16

, 21-23/10/ 2009,

(ASTM D 2419-02 & EN 933 8)

(
933.09)
Determination of argil in concrete sand via the tests of sand
equivalent value (ASTM D 2419-02 & EN 933 8) and blue
of methylene (
933.09) - Results comparison
1

/
:

ASTM D 2419-02
933.08
933.09
.
(
.
(

).

,
( EKET ) email:rouvelasg@aget.gr

email:xintarask@aget.gr
( EKET )

. . .,

email:alafouzosc@aget.gr

16

, 21-23/10/ 2009,

ABSTRACT
In this study, we examine the results that arose after the trial tests of the
assessment of conciseness in argil or plastic thin grains on sand sample. We
compare the results of the following trial tests:
Definition of sand equivalent value (ASTM D 2419-02)
Definition of sand equivalent value (
933.08)
Trial of methylene blue (
933.09)
The purpose of the study is to examine and analyze the differences among the
results of the above trial tests concerning the definition of conciseness in argil.
Furthermore, another purpose is to verify the possibility of recognition of
argicaleous and grains that are < 0,075 mm via the test of definition of sand
equivalent value.
The experiments of the study were carried out in the laboratory of Hellenic Center
of Research Cement (HCRC LTD).

,
.
ASTM D 2419-02 ,
933.09
.

,
.
933.08 &

:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

AST
11-1995 Standard Specigication for Wire Cloth and
Sieves for Testing Purposes.
933.01, 1997 / 1 Tests for geometrical properties of
aggregates Part 1:Determination of particle size distribution Sieving
method.
ASTM D 2419- 2002 Standard Test Method for Sand Equivalent
Value Of Soils and Fine Aggragate.
933.08, 1999 Tests for geometrical properties of aggregates
Part 8: Assessment of fines Sand Equivalent test.
933.09, 1998 Tests for geometrical properties of aggregates
Part 9: Assessment of fines Methylene blue test.

16

, 21-23/10/ 2009,

- ASTM D 2419-02,

933.08,

933.09

:
4
:
1
,

20%
.
5 %
.
10 %

15 %.

2
15 %

15 %
3

(5 %)

.
10 %

5%

1.
1:

(%)

(%)

20
15
10
5

0
5
10
15

15
10
5
0

0
5
10
15

(%)
1
20+0
15+5
10+10
5+15
2
15+0
10+5
5+10
0+15
3

16

, 21-23/10/ 2009,

10
5
0

0
5
10

5
0

0
5

10+0
5+5
0+10
4

20%, 15%, 10%

2.

5+0
0+5

5%.

2:

mm
4,75
4
2,36
2
1,18
0,6
0,3
0,25
0,075

20%

15%

10%

5%

%
99,6
97,3
79,5
71,7
54,2
41,5
33,7
32
20,8

%
99,6
97,1
78,2
69,9
51,3
37,8
29,5
27,7
14,8

%
99,6
97,0
77,1
68,5
48,9
34,8
26,1
24,2
10,5

%
99,5
96,8
75,6
66,3
45,5
30,4
21,2
19,1
4,9

,
,
3.

16

, 21-23/10/ 2009,

3:
ASTM
D 2419

EN 933.08 0/4

Blue of
Methylene

EN 933.08 0/2

+
(%)
20+0
15+5
10+10
5+15

.
78
68
45
36

.
74
65
40
34

76
66
44
35

.
61
50
34
28

56
49
32
26

0,43
2,72
5,37
6,5

15+0
10+5
5+10
0+15

82
70
57
51

78
66
53
41

80
68
55
50

67
53
39
35

57
49
40
36

0,36
2,53
3,88
4,77

10+0
5+5
0+10

85
72
53

80
67
46

82
70
51

63
54
39

58
49
36

0,33
2,51
4,38

5+0
0+5

90
81

87
76

87
78

69
54

87
54

0,25
2,48

3
. .

. .

933.08 0/4:
ASTM D 2419 *
(
.+
.

4mm (%)
: 20+0): 78 * 97,3% = 76

933.08 0/2:
ASTM D 2419 *
(
.+
.

2mm (%)
: 20+0): 78 * 71,7% = 56

,
,

ASTM D 2419-02,
933.08 0/4 & 0/2
0-20 %, 0-15 %, 0-10 %
0-5 %.
5
.
.

16

, 21-23/10/ 2009,

100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0

y = 2,945x + 19,975
R2 = 0,965
y = 2,9x + 17
2
R = 0,943

y = 2,3x + 14,5
R2 = 0,9742
0

10

11

12

13

14

.
ASTM

EN 0/4

EN 0/2

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

(ASTM)

(EN 0/4)

(EN 0/2)

1:

5-20%.

100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0

y = 2,12x + 49,1
2
R = 0,9787

y = 2,480x + 40,900
R2 = 1,000
y = 2,213x + 31,84
R2 = 0,9499

-2

-1

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

(%)
ASTM

EN 0/4

EN 0/2

(ASTM)

(EN 0/4)

2:
0-15 %.

(EN 0/2)

17

18

19

20

16

, 21-23/10/ 2009,

100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0

y = 3,200x + 54,000
2
R = 0,988
y = 3,400x + 47,333
2
R = 0,982
y = 2,400x + 40,000
2
R = 0,980

-2

-1

7
.

ASTM

EN 0/4

EN 0/2

10

11

12

13

14

15

%
(ASTM)

(EN 0/4)

(EN 0/2)

3:

0-10%.

100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0

y = 1,800x + 81,000
2
R = 1,000
y = 2,200x + 76,000
2
R = 1,000
y = 3,000x + 54,000
2
R = 1,000

-2

-1

(%)
ASTM

EN 0/4

EN 0/2

(ASTM)

(EN 0/4)

4:
0-5%.

(EN 0/2)

10

16

, 21-23/10/ 2009,

5,6
.

6
5
4
3
2

y = 0,229x + 1,4867
R2 = 0,95

1
0
0

10

15

20

5:
5-15%.

0,5
0,45
0,4
0,35
0,3
0,25

y = 0,0114x + 0,2
R2 = 0,9742

0,2
0,15
0,1
0,05
0
0

10

15

20
%

6:
5-15%.

7)
ASTM D 2419-02
.

25

16

, 21-23/10/ 2009,

ASTM

MB

ASTM(%)

90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20

y = -9,589x + 96,701
R2 = 0,9449

10
0
0

7:

3
:
o

,
.
933.08

o
STM D 2419

ASTM

7,

o
.

16

, 21-23/10/ 2009,

o
),

(
.

AST
11-1995 Standard Specigication for Wire Cloth and Sieves for
Testing Purposes.
933.01, 1997 / 1 Tests for geometrical properties of aggregates
Part 1:Determination of particle size distribution Sieving method.
ASTM D 2419- 2002 Standard Test Method for Sand Equivalent Value
Of Soils and Fine Aggragate.
933.08, 1999 Tests for geometrical properties of aggregates Part 8:
Assessment of fines Sand Equivalent test.
933.09, 1998 Tests for geometrical properties of aggregates Part 9:
Assessment of fines Methylene blue test.

10