www.elsevier.com/locate/ijporl
KEYWORDS
Recurrent upper respiratory tract infections;
Tonsillar hypertrophy;
Granulocyte chemiluminescence
Summary Granulocytes play a key role in the defence against bacterial infections.
Their dysfunction may both predispose to and result from infections. The oxidative
metabolism of peripheral blood granulocytes was studied in 50 children aged from 1
to 10 years, with recurrent upper respiratory tract infections and/or tonsillar
hypertrophy. Four groups of patients were recruited: 15 healthy controls, seven
patients with idiopathic tonsillar hypertrophy, 12 patients with upper respiratory tract
infections and 16 patients with upper respiratory tract infections with concurrent
tonsillar hypertrophy. The ability of granulocytes to produce reactive oxygen species
was assessed by nFMLP-induced chemiluminescence. Both increased and depressed
granulocyte activity was observed in all studied groups, with the exception of
controls. Altered granulocyte function was observed in 30% of patients in the
idiopathic tonsillar hypertrophy group. In children with recurrent infections abnormal
chemiluminescence results were found in from 75% to nearly 90% of patients. This
preliminary study demonstrates the possible relationship between recurrent upper
respiratory tract infections, tonsillar hypertrophy and impaired peripheral blood
granulocyte chemiluminescence.
2003 Elsevier Science Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Upper respiratory tract infections are among the
most common problems encountered in paediatric
practice [1,2]. Mild and rapidly reducing infections
do not arouse concern; those that recur despite
*Corresponding author.
E-mail address: wasik@litewska.edu.pl (M. Kowalska).
0165-5876/03/$ - see front matter 2003 Elsevier Science Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/S0165-5876(02)00402-0
366
M. Kowalska et al.
Based on disease history and physical examination, the children were divided into the following
groups:
1) Controls (C; n/15) */healthy children with
negative history of recurrent upper respiratory
tract infections and tonsils size 0, /1.
2) Children with idiopathic tonsillar hypertrophy
(T; n /7) */patients qualified for adenotonsillotomy due to important airway obstruction
(tonsils size /3, /4) with negative history of
recurrent upper respiratory tract infections.
3) Children with recurrent upper respiratory tract
infections without tonsillar hypertrophy (I; n /
12) */patient with tonsils size 0, /1 and
positive history of recurrent upper respiratory
tract infections.
4) Children with recurrent upper respiratory tract
infections and concurrent tonsillar hypertrophy
(TI; n /16) */patient with tonsils size /2, /
3, /4 admitted to the hospital for adenotonsillectomy, with positive history of recurrent
upper respiratory tract infections.
The age and sex distribution was similar in all
groups. The children in the control group were
healthy pupils of nursery and a sports-oriented
primary school. The children in the studied groups
had no other diseases except those on the basis of
which they were qualified for the above groups.
During the study, all of the children had no signs
of infection and the results of carried out basic
laboratory tests (blood count and smear, erythrocyte sedimentation rate, urinalysis) were all within
the normal range. None of the children received
any medications and the time from their last
infection, antibiotictherapy and vaccination was
at least 4 weeks before material was sampled for
the study.
Two millimetres of blood were taken from the
ulnar vein to a tube containing heparin (10 u/ml).
The blood count was determined using a Coulter
Micro Diff II analyser, nucleated blood cells being
identified microscopically after haematological
staining. Urinalysis was conducted using a Clinitec
100 (Bayer) analyser. Erythrocyte sedimentation
rate was determined using an automatic instrument, Monitor 20E (Oxford).
The chemiluminescence test based on measuring
the light emitted spontaneously and after stimulation was performed in the presence of luminol in a
Wallac 1409 scintillation counter (Wallac, Finland).
Chemiluminescence was measured in every blood
sample, before and after stimulation, with nFMLP
peptide, prepared at a concentration of 10 5 M.
Samples and reagents were prepared as described
3. Results
The average leukocyte counts, absolute number
of granulocytes and their percentages are given in
Table 1. Both the leukocyte count and number of
367
Leukocytosis in 1 ml blood
Granulocytes (%)
Controls (n/15)
T (n /7)
I (n /12)
TI (n/16)
62269/1222
76289/2951
72009/2697
64169/1317
61.99/5.30
55.69/13.75
46.19/10.60
55.09/7.04
38999/881
45089/3108
33459/1768
34399/818
The results are expressed as mean value9/standard deviation (SD). Group T: children with idiopathic tonsillar
hypertrophy (without recurrent upper respiratory tract infection), group I: children without tonsillar hypertrophy
but with recurrent upper respiratory tract infection, group TI: children with tonsillar hypertrophy and with
recurrent upper respiratory tract infection.
368
M. Kowalska et al.
Table 2 The individual results obtained in studied groups of patients, presented as the mean value of the number
of light impulses emitted by a single cell before (sp, spontaneous chemiluminescence) and after stimulation (st,
stimulated chemiluminescence)
Chemiluminescence (impulse9/SD/min/cell)
Controls
TI
sp
st
ix
sp
St
ix
sp
st
ix
sp
st
ix
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
2.190
1.550
1.060
1.160
0.68
1.400
0.860
1.190
1.250
2.460
0.760
1.290
1.170
2.020
1.410
9.070
7.030
4.960
5.760
3.47
5.900
4.730
6.560
7.330
14.490
5.440
9.320
12.750
24.100
19.65
3.14
3.53
3.67
3.96
4.10
4.17
4.50
4.51
4.86
4.89
6.15
6.22
9.89
10.93
12.94
13.560
3.660
0.470
1.970
0.690
10.970
0.630
12.240
19.260
2.640
16.130
48.970
361.0
4.690
0
4.28
4.61
7.18
69.97
31.9
6.44
0.970
8.760
8.450
7.740
44.190
2.330
1.060
0.950
2.850
2.470
5.890
1.850
0.650
10.900
10.660
10.420
83.540
10.010
6.150
6.01
38.300
52.000
138.40
85.600
0
0.24
0.26
0.34
0.89
3.33
4.8
5.33
13.4
20.0
22.6
45.5
3.25
0.380
0.620
7.510
5.970
4.310
13.440
1.200
1.640
1.290
23.200
1.630
0.970
1.040
0.600
0.740
4.01
3.820
6.710
8.100
10.530
9.010
37.600
2.860
13.410
22.200
55.600
56.100
34.00
38.4
36.300
79.400
0.23
0.38
0.62
0.7
0.76
1.09
1.8
2.33
7.15
16.2
23.2
32.0
33.9
35.9
59.5
106
Mean
SD
1.35
0.51
9.37
5.95
5.73
2.77
4.56
5.42
66.41
130.79
17.67
25.36
7.30
12.02
37.72
43.76
9.54
13.97
3.29
3.36
26.07
22.84
20.16
29.05
Table 3 Comparison of the peripheral blood granulocyte ability to generate light impulses
Groups
Controls
T
I
TI
Chemiluminescence (impulse9/SD/cell)
Index st/sp9/SD
Spontaneous (sp)
Stimulated (st)
1.359/0.51
4.569/5.43
7.309/12.02
3.299/3.36
0.72
0.01
0.06
9.379/5.95
66.419/130.79
37.729/43.76
26.079/22.84
0.146
0.04
0.048
5.749/2.77
17.679/25.36
9.549/13.97
20.169/29.05
Results are presented as the mean value of the number of light impulses emitted by a single cell before (sp) and
after (st) stimulation. The index of chemiluminescence is calculated by dividing st by sp chemiluminescence value.
The study was performed in the following groups: control, healthy children; group T, patients with tonsillar
hypertrophy but without recurrent infections; group I, patients with recurrent infections without tonsillar
hypertrophy; group TI, patients with tonsillar hypertrophy and recurrent infections.
369
Table 4 The number of low, normal, and high chemiluminescence indexes in the studied groups
Groups
Index of chemiluminescence
Controls
T
I
TI
Total
Below 2
Between 2 and 13
Over 13
Total number
0
1
5
7
13
15
4
3
2
24
0
2
4
7
13
15
7
12
16
50
Characteristics of patient populations: controls, healthy children; T, patients with idiopathic tonsillar
hypertrophy; I group, patients with recurrent upper tract infections without tonsillar hypertrophy; and TI group,
patients with recurrent upper tract infections and tonsillar hypertrophy.
4. Discussion
Granulocytes play an exceptionally important
role in inducing the non-specific immune response.
By acting in synergy with antibodies and complement, granulocytes participate in protecting the
body from harmful microorganisms. The role of the
particular types of granulocytes (neutrophils, eosinophils, basophils) in the elimination of pathogens
Fig. 1 Frequency of low, normal and high indexes observed in studied group of children.
370
M. Kowalska et al.
Table 5 Observed frequency of the potentially pathogenic strains of bacteria, cultured from the surface and the
core of the tonsils in patients with idiopathic tonsillar hypertrophy (T) and children with recurrent upper tract
infections and tonsillar hypertrophy (TI)
Bacteria
Staphylococcus aureus
Haemophilus influensae
Moraxella catharalis
Streptococcus pyogenes
Staphylococcus pneumoniae
Pseudomonas aureginosa
TI (n/12)
T (n/5)
surface
core
surface
core
2
1
2
1
1
0
4
3
2
2
2
1
2
1
2
1
[8]
[9]
[10]
[11]
[12]
References
[13]
[1] J.E. Arnold, Infections of upper respiratory tract, in: R.E.
Behrman, R.M. Kliegman, W.E. Nelson, V.C. Vaughan (Eds.),
Nelson Textbook of Pediatrics, III-14th ed., WB Sauders
Company, 1993.
[2] P.B. van Cauwenberge, M.J. van Kempen, C. Bachert, The
common cold, Acta Oto-Rhino-Laryngol. Belgica 54 (3)
(2000) 397 /401.
[3] R.M. Stock, J.W. Tompson, J.A. Church, S. Kun, E. Simms,
Severe combined immunodeficiency: otolaryngological presentation and management, Ann. Otol. Rhinol. Laryngol.
108 (1999) 403 /407.
[4] L. Brodsky, L. Moore, J.F. Stanievich, P.L. Ogra, The
immunology of tonsils in children: the effect of bacterial
load on the presence of B- and T-cell subsets, Laryngoscope
98 (1) (1988) 93 /98.
[5] R.J. Koch, L. Brodsky, Effects of specific bacteria on
lymphocyte proliferation in diseased and nondiseased
tonsils, Laryngoscope 103 (9) (1993) 1020 /1026.
[6] M.P. Pizzuto, M.S. Volk, L.M. Kingston, Common topics in
pediatric otolaryngology, Ped. Clin. North Am. 45 (4) (1998)
973 /991.
[7] Y. Harabuchi, M. Hamamoto, H. Kodoma, A. Kataura,
Spontaneous immunoglobulin production by adenoidal and
tonsillar lymphocytes in relation to age and otitis media
[14]
[15]
[16]
[17]
[18]
[19]
371