Not to Worry About the Unproven Pluto Effect

by tw853@yahoo.com
(courtesy of KPE-zine, August 2011 issue)
Intention
1. The purpose of this article is to provide the convincing evidence of practical example
charts not to worry about the experimental predictions of unproven Pluto destructive
effect floating in some circles without support of any reliable research of the sufficient
number of cases.
No Origin of Pluto Effect

2. There is any single website, any single reputable astrologer, West and East, or any
single Pluto or outer planet book saying: "Pluto is always destructive and supersedes the
results of normal inner planets."
No Pluto Effect on Unmarried Charts
3. Out of 15 unmarried charts in message #23786 of the Yahoo KP group, the Pluto
negative effect on the 7th cusp is found in 1 chart (6.7%) only , i.e. chart no. 1: 7th cspal
sub lord (CSL) is in the sub of Ke being in the star of Mercury, which aspects Pluto
within 3 20 orb in the 4th step.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/k_p_system/message/23786
4. Out of 10 unmarried charts in the Umang Taneja: Marriage and relationships book,
2006, pp 142-153, the Pluto negative effect on the 7th cusp is found in 2 charts (20%)
only, i.e.
1) Chart no.1 (p 142): 7th CSL Me is in the star of Sun, which is conj. with Pluto
within 3 20 orb in 2nd step;
2) Chart no. 3 (p 144): 7th CSL Ra is in the sub of Sun being in the star of Moon,
which is conj. with Pluto within 3 20 orb in 4th step.
5. Out of the Astro-Databank (ADB) AA 100 unmarried charts compiled by using the
filters, the negative Pluto effect on 7th cusp is found in 10 charts (10%) only, as shown
under: (Courtesy of Astro-Databank 4.0/ www.astro.com and calculated by KPAstro 4.0
using the KP New Ayanamsa 2003) Note: Conj & Aspect within 3 20 orb
1) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Bausch%2C_Pina
7th CSL Ke in sub Su+, having no planet in its stars, which is Conj with Pl (in 3rd
step).
2) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Gorey%2C_Edward_St.John
7th CSL Sa is in star Ju, which Aspects Pl (in 2nd step).
3) ADB Rcd ID #45903: Kathleen Hogan, 18-09-1965, 17:37 DST, TZ hr5w, Holyoke,
MA, USA, 42n12, 72w37
7th CSL Ve is in sub Me+, which is Conj with Pl (in 3rd step)
4) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Lorca%2C_Federico_Garcia

7th CSL Sa is in sub Ju being in star Su, Conj Pl (in 4th step).
5) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Penfield%2C_Marc
7th CSL Ma in sub Sa+, having no planet in its stars, Aspt Pl (in 3rd step)
6) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Pio%2C_Padre
7th CSL Mo is in sub Me+, having no planet in its stars, Conj Pl (in 3rd step)
7) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Pope_John_XXIII
Pl Conj 7th cusp
8) ADB Rcd ID #49114: John Sutton, 07-11-1955, 21:13 pm, hr5w, Milton, MA, USA,
42n15, 71w04
7th CSL Sa is in star Ju, Conj Pl (in 2nd step)
9) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Baudelaire%2C_Charles
7th CSL Ma in sub Ma+, having no planet in its stars, Conj Pl (in 3rd step)
10) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Muller%2C_Ludwig
7th CSL Sa+, having no planet in its stars, Conj. Pl
6. Out of the above 125 (15+10+100) unmarried charts, the Pluto negative effect on 7th
cusp is found in 13 (1+2+10) charts (10.4%) only, which clearly shows that Pluto
negative effect on 7th cusp is not much to do with no marriage.
No Pluto Effect on Married Charts
7. From the other side, the ADB AA 40 married charts with the Pluto effect on 7th cusp
are provided below from the research records to show not to worry about Pluto negative
effect on marriage: (Courtesy of Astro-Databank 4.0/ www.astro.com and calculated by
KPAstro 4.0 using the KP New Ayanamsa - 2003) Note: Conj & Aspect within 3 20 orb
1) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Astaire%2C_Fred
Pl Conj 7th cusp
2) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Baudelaire%2C_Charles
7th CSL Mo in sub Ma+, having no planet in it's stars, Conj Pl (3rd step)
3) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Baxter%2C_Meredith
7th CSL Ve in star Mo, Conj Pl (in 2nd step)
4) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Berdella%2C_Bob
7th CSL Ju in sub Me+ ,having no planet in it's stars, Aspt Pl
5) ADBRcdID#37302:Bruno Caloone, 10101959,22:15pm,hr1east,Bourbourg,
France,50n57,02e12
7thCSLMoinstarMo,AsptPl(in2ndstep)
6) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Crosby%2C_Gary
Pl Conj 7th cusp
7)http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Coe%2C_Frederick
7thCSLSuinstarMa,ConjPl(in2ndstep)
8)http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Coe%2C_Ruth
7thCSLSainstarVe,ConjPl(in2ndstep)
9) ADB Rcd ID #43215: Ann Cook, 30-08-1950, 04:03 am DST, hr 5 west, Cleveland,
OH, USA, 42n19, 81w41
7th CSL Ve+, having np planet in its stars, Conj Pl (in 1st step)

10) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Daumier%2C_Honore
7th CSL Ju in sub Mo+, having no planet in its stars, Conj Pl (in 3rd step)
11) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Della_Corte%2C_Rosanna
Pl Conj 7th cusp
12) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/De_Palma%2C_Brian
7th CSL Ju in star Ve, Conj Pl (in 2nd step)
13) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Fonda%2C_Jane
Pl Conj 7th cusp
14) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Franco%2C_Fulvia
7th CSL Mo in star Ju, Conj Pl (in 2nd step)
7th CSL Mo in sub Ke in star Mo, Conj Pl (in 4th step)
15) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Gable%2C_John_Clark
7thCSLVeinstarKe,OppositePl(in2ndstep)
16)http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Getty%2C_Gordon
7thCSLRainstarMa,AsptPl(in2ndstep)
PlConj7thcusp
17)http://www.astro.com/astrodatabank/Grant%2C_Jennifer
7thCSLVeinsubKeinstarSa,AsptPl(in4thstep)
18)http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Gucci%2C_Grimalda
7thCSLJuinsubJu+,havingnoplanetinit'sstars,AsptPl
19)http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Gucci%2C_Maurizio
7thCSLRainstarVe,ConjPl
20)http://www.astro.com/astrodatabank/Gucci%2C_Paolo
PlConj7thcusp
21)http://www.astro.com/astrodatabank/Gucci%2C_Rodolfo
PlConj7thcusp
22)ADBRcdID39849:DebraHoule,21011965,19:13pm,hr5west,Southbridge,
Massachusetts,USA,42n04,72w02
7thCSLRainsubJu+,havingnoplanetinit'sstars,AsptPl
23)http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Houston%2C_Whitney
7thCSLVeinstarMe,ConjPl
PlConj7thcusp
24) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Johnson%2C_Virginia
7th CSL Ma in sub Sa in star Ju, Aspt Pl (in 4th step)
25) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Johnson%2C_Virginia
7th CSL Su in sub Mo in star Ju, Conj Pl (in 4th step)
26) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Jurkowski%2C_Suzanne
7th CSL Ma in star Ra, Conj Pl
27) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Kerr%2C_Jim
7th CSL Me in sub Ve+, having no planet in its stars, Conj Pl
28) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Kinski%2C_Natassja
7th CSL Ju in sub Ke in star Ra, Conj Pl (in 4th step)
29) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Kissinger%2C_Henry
7th CSL Ke in star Ju, Aspt Pl
30) ADB Rcd ID #1448: ShirleyMay, 26-07-1952, 4:10 am DST, hr 5 west, Cambridge,

MA, USA, 42n22, 71w06

7th CSL Ju in sub Me in star Ke Conj Pl (in 4th step)
31) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Moore%2C_Julianne
7th CSL Ve in sub Ma in star Ju, Aspt Pl (in 4th step)
32) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Moore%2C_Terry
7th CSL Me in star Su, Aspt Pl
33) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Munkasey%2C_Michael
7th CSL Mo+, having no planet in its stars, Aspt Pl (in 1st step)
34)http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Newman%2C_Paul
7thCSLJuinstarVe,AsptPl
PlConj7thcusp
35) ADB Rcd ID #24978: Jeanie Stevenson, 15-07-1954, 19:49 pm, hr 6 west,
Minneapolis, MN, 44n58, 93w15
7th CSL Su in sub Mo+, having no planet in its stars, Aspt Pl
36) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Simpson%2C_O.J.
7th CSL Sa in star Sa, Conj Pl
37) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Gucci%2C_Rodolfo
Pl Conj 7th cusp
38)http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Vilbert%2C_Melody
7thCSLRainsubSa+,havingnoplanetinit'sstars,AsptPl
39) ADB Rcd #45863: Judi Vitale, 13-07-1956, 23:37 pm DST, hr 0 west, Pittsburgh,
PA, USA, 40n26, 79w59
7th CSL Ra in star Sa, Aspt Pl
40) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Wood%2C_Natalie
7th CSL Ke in star Su, Conj Pl
8. Marriage is not denied by Pluto on 1st cusp aspecting on 7th cusp in the following
ADB AA charts, [Click on natal chart (Placidus) to see the positions of Ascendant and
Pluto.] (Courtesy of Astro-Databank 4.0/ www.astro.com )
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
7)
8)

http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Bush%2C_George_H._W.
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Crichton%2C_Michael
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Debord%2C_Guy_Louis
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Griffin%2C_Mer
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Martin%2C_Steve
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/McNamara%2C_Robert_S.
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Sheline%2C_Raymond
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Verlaque%2C_Andre_Pau

No Pluto Effect on Divorce Charts

9. When the Pluto effect of no marriage is not so sure that another circulated view is that
there is no marriage by Pluto effect or if there is marriage with Pluto effect, then divorce
is imminent. In this regards, some example charts are given under: (Courtesy of Astro-

Databank 4.0/ www.astro.com and calculated by KPAstro 4.0 using the KP New
Ayanamsa - 2003) Note: Conj & Aspect within 3 20 orb
1) Guruji K.S.K.'s (01-11-1908,12:11pm IST, Thanjavur, TN) 7th CSL
Su is in the star of Ra (primary significator as star lord in 2nd step), which is
conj with Pl within within 3 20' orb. Thus 7th CSL is affected by Pl, whose
negative result is supposed to be no marriage or if married, then divorce but the
fact is entirely different.
2) Chart no. 4 in the study on child gender, Male, 27-10-1955, 11:50 pm IST, 15n46,
77e31, 7th CSL (marriage), 11th CSL (child for male) and also 5th
CSL is Ve in the star of Ju (primary significator as star lord in 2nd step)
conj. with Pl within 3 20' orb to give negative effect of no marriage or if
married then divorce and no child or if child is got, then what would happen? In fact
the native is married with children.
3) In Prince Bernhard's chart, Pl is conj. with Pl within 3 20' orb. Mo, Ma & Ve are in
the star of Me (primary significator as star lord in 2nd step). So Mo, Ma & Ve are
effected by Pl through Me and these Mo, Ma & Ve are to give Pl negative effect of no
marriage, no child, no success etc. as CSL or dasa period lord. 7th CSL is Ma, 11th
CSL & 5th CSL is Ve but during Ju Dasa period he was married, got children and
spouse became Queen.
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Bernhard%2C_Prince
10. Out of 12 divorce charts in the Umang Taneja: Marriage and relationships book,
2006, pp 125-139, the Pluto negative effect on the 7th cusp is found in 3 charts (25%)
only, i.e. chart no. 2 (p 126), 9 (p 135) and 11 (p 137).
11. Out of 100 AA divorce charts from the ADB 4.0 compiled by using the filters, only 19
charts (19%) below are found with Pluto negative effect: (Courtesy of Astro-Databank
4.0/ www.astro.com and calculated by KPAstro 4.0 using the KP New Ayanamsa - 2003)
Note: Conj & Aspect within 3 20 orb
1) Rosalba Anderini
2) Meredith Baxter
3) Gary Evan Crosby
4) Jane Fonda
5) Fulvia Franco
6) Virginia Johnson
7) Jennifer Jones
8) Suzanne Jurkowski
9) Jim Kerr
10) Natassja Kinski
11) Julianne Moore
12) Terry Moore
13) Michael P. Munkasey
14) Brian De Palma
15) Zane Stein

16) Jeanie Stevenson

17) OJ Simpson
18) Judi Vitale
19) Natalie Wood
12. Out of the above 112 (12+100) divorce charts, the Pluto negative effect on 7th cusp
is found in 22 (3+19) charts (19.6%) only, which clearly shows that Pluto negative effect
on 7th cusp is not sufficiently significant for divorce.
No Pluto Effect on Dasa Period Lords
13. The DBA lords give whatever they have to provide irrespective of Pluto effect in the
following charts: (Courtesy of Astro-Databank 4.0/ www.astro.com and calculated by
KPAstro 4.0 using the KP New Ayanamsa - 2003) Note: Conj & Aspect within 3 20 orb
1) Mahatma Gandhi's carrier started in Mars Dasa, most success in Rahu Dasa and
ended in Jupiter Dasa, where Ma is in the star of Ju conj. with Pl within 3 20'
orb, and Ra is in the sub of Ma, having no planet in its stars, aspecting Pl
within 3 20' orb and Ra's sub Ma is in the star of Ju.
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Gandhi%2C_Mohandas
2) Richard Nixon's Mercury and Jupiter, having no planet in their stars, and
Mars aspect Pluto within 3 20' orb. But he became a congressman on 04-11-1946
(Ju-Su), then a senator on 06-11-1950 (Ju-Ra), won presidential election on
05-11-1968 (Sa-Ju) and reelected on 11-11-1972 (Me-Me).
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Nixon%2C_Richard_M.
3) Al Gore's Saturn is in conj. with Pl within 3 20' orb. No planet is in the
star of Saturn. Rahu is in the star of Saturn. But he became Vice President on
20-01-1993 (Ra-Ra-Ra) and won Nobel Peace Prize on 10-12-2007 (Ra-Su-Sa).
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Gore%2C_Al
4) Bjorn Borg's successful period is from 1974 (Ma-Ju/ Australian, French open
win) to 1980 (Ra-Ra/ Wimbleton win), though Ma is in the sub of Ju, having no
planet in its stars, conj. with Pl within 3 20' orb, and Ra and its own sub Ra
are in the star of Saturn, aspecting Pl within 3 20' orb.
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Borg%2C_Bjorn
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bjorn_Borg
5) Anne Morrow Lindbergh had written a dozen books including the 1955 bestseller
"Gift From the Sea" during Dasa period of Mercury, which self and its sub Saturn
is in the star of Jupiter, conj Pl within 3 20' orb.
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Lindbergh%2C_Anne_Morrow
No Pluto Effect on Getting Children
14. Getting children are not denied by Pluto effect in the following charts: (Courtesy of
Astro-Databank 4.0/ www.astro.com )
1) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Cole%2C_Natalie (5CSL Su aspt Pl)

2) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Lindbergh%2C_Anne_Morrow (5 CSL Ju
conj Pl)
3) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Blair%2C_Tony (11&5 CSLs Ra opp Pl)
4) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Gore%2C_Al (11&5 CSL Sa conj Pl)
5) Male,27Oct1955,23:50PMIST,15N46,77E31,from Child Gender study (11&5
CSL Ve in star Ju conj Pl)

No Pluto Effect on Conversion of Religion

15. Two AA charts of Muhammad Ali and Julia Roberts of religion conversion have
nothing to do with thw view of conversion of religion by Pluto effect on 9th cusp and 1st
cuspal sub lords connection to Mars for courage: (Courtesy of Astro-Databank 4.0/
www.astro.com and calculated by KPAstro 4.0 using the KP New Ayanamsa - 2003)
Note: Conj & Aspect within 3 20 orb
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Ali%2C_Muhammad
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Roberts%2C_Julia
16. By using filters 25 AA charts of religion conversion are available in the
Astro-Databank 4.0 and the first 5 charts are found as follows:
1) Susan Atkins is satisfied both conditions of the rule but a little bit out of orb.
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Atkins%2C_Susan
2) Christophe Caze: 9th CSL has Pluto effect but 1st CSL is not connected with
Mars.
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Caze%2C_Christophe
3) Lauren Chapin: only 1st CSL is connected with Mars.
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Chapin%2C_Lauren
4) Paul Claudel: only 9th CSL has Neptune effect.
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Claudel%2C_Paul
5) Eldridge Cleaver: only 1st CSL is Mars.
http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Cleaver%2C_Eldridge
17. In the following charts, there is no conversion of religion although both conditions of
the rule are satisfied:
1) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Christina%2C_Princess_Netherland
(Pl conj. 9th cusp, opposite to 3rd cusp may be damaging courage.)
2) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Moore%2C_Mary_Tyler
3) http://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Papandreou%2C_Andreas

Finding
18. No ground is not yet found to worry about the experimental predictions of Pluto
destructive effect.

References
Stephen Arroyo: Astrology, Karma & Transfornation, 1978
Donna Cunningham: Healing PLUTO Problems, 1986, Sixth Printing 1992
Ronald Davison: SYNASTRY, Understanding Human Relations through
Astrology, 1983
Steven Forest: The Book of PLUTO, Turning Darkness to Wisdom with
Astrology, 1994, Fifth Printing 2002
Jeff Green: PLUTO, the Evolutionary Journey of the Soul, Vol I, 1985, Tenth
Printing 1993
Jeff Green: PLUTO: Vol 2: The Soul's Evolution Through Relationships, 1997,
Third Printing 2002
Deva Green: PLUTO and Your Karmic Mission, Evolutionary Astrology, March
2009
Liz Greene: the Astrological NEPTUNE and the Quest for Redemption, 1996
Robert Hand: Essays on Astrology, 1982
Robert Hand: Planets in Transit, 1976
Robert Hand: Planets in Composite, Analyzing Human RELATIONSHIPS, 1975
Judith Hill: Medical Astrology, A Guide to Planetary Pathology, 2004
Marion D. March & Joan McEvers: The only Way toLearn about
RELATIONSHIPS, Volume V, SYNASTRY Techniques, 1992, Third Printing
1996ond Printing
John Townley: Composite Charts, The Astrology of RELATIONSHIPS, 2000,
Second Printing 2004
John Townley: Planets in Love, Exploring Your Emotional and Sexual Needs,
1978
Noel Tyl: Solar Arc, Astrology's Most Successful Predictive System, 2001
Ernst Wilhelm:The Outer Planets in Vedic Astrology Course
A Review on Effect of Pluto in the KPAF Journal, Jul-Dec 2008
Pluto is Not Always Malefic (KPE-zine Aug 2009 free download @
www.kpastrologer.com )