380
Submitted 13 February 2012, sent back for revisions 4 April 2012; accepted for publication following double-blind peer
review 9 May 2012
27/06/2012 14:52
Methodology
A longitudinal randomised controlled trial with
concealed allocation was used for this study.
The study comprised of two groups, a control
and experimental group each with 100 patients
with first time ischaemic stroke and their carers.
Stroke survivors from Chris Hani Baragwanath
Academic Hospital (CHBH) participated in the
study. The hospital caters mainly for the surrounding largely black population of Soweto,
in Johannesburg, South Africa. The allocation
into groups and training of the informal carers
was done with blinding of the researcher. The
second training of carers, which was provided
at the three months follow up depending on
the needs of the carer, was done with blinding
of the researcher. The research assistants were
trained by the researcher on the protocols to be
covered during data collection, that is recruitment of the patients and carers, and training
of the carers. The research assistants were a
qualified physiotherapist and an occupational
therapist.
From a statistical calculation, a sample of 200
patients with stroke and carers (100 per group)
had 80% power to detect a difference in means
of 1.0 assuming that the common standard
deviation was 2.5 using a two-group t-test with
a 0.05 two-sided significance level using the
Barthel Index (BI) as the main outcome measure. However, for the Rivermead Mobility Index
(RMI) this sample size yielded power in excess
of 90%.
To attain the required sample size for the
study, all consecutive patients with first time
ischaemic stroke and their informal carers fitting the inclusion criteria were approached by
either the researcher or the research assistant
for their permission and initial screening for
inclusion into the study until the sample size
was reached. For inclusion into the study, both
the patient and the carer needed to agree to
participate in the study and ethical clearance
was applied for and granted by the University
of the Witwatersrand Human Research Ethics
Committee.
The BI and the RMI were administered to
the patients before discharge. In the event of
the patient having speech problems and not
being able to provide some of the information required for the data collection process,
the carer was asked to provide the information
(Sneeuw et al, 1997).
All the patients and informal carers in the
control and experimental groups received the
standard existing rehabilitation stroke care as
was currently being undertaken at CHBH at
the time of the study. In addition to the standard and existing rehabilitation stroke care, all
the carers in the experimental group received
individualised hands-on training in lifting
and handling techniques, back care, facilitation
of mobility and transfers, continence, assistance with ADLs, and communication. Included
were information on stroke related problems
and their prevention, management/prevention
of pressure sores, continence, positioning, gait
facilitation and sexuality as was indicated by
the condition of the patient they would be looking after post discharge.
This training was given as a 45-minute to
an hour training session just before discharge
home of the patient. The training was specific to
the individual patient needs for which the carer
would be responsible. It involved a practical
component where the carers were expected to
demonstrate the taught exercises. Subsequent
carer training was given at the three months follow up depending on the need of the carer and
the patient. Follow up assessments were done
at three, six and 12 months post discharge. Data
collection was done from 2006 to 2010.
Descriptive statistics were used to analyse
the data for the demographic information and
functional level of patients. The means and
standard deviations of the various data catego-
381
27/06/2012 14:52
Research
Total Barthel
Index Score
Control
Experimental
Group n(%) Group n(%)
Total
n(%)
Mean
Mean
Mean
Experimental Control difference
Group
Group
St.
Error
95% CI
P value
-1.8(-0.5) 0.01
-1.30.2 0.08
-1.50.1 0.05
16
14
13.3
11.3
Mean change
12
9.7
10
8
6
12.6
10.8
8.7
6.2
6.1
Control group
Experimental group
2
0
382
Baseline
3 months
6 months
Time period of measurement
12 months
Results
Demographic details
There were more female patients (56.5%) than
male with more than 78% of the sample having
attained less than or equal to Grade 11 level of
education. There were also more female carers (70%) than males. The majority of the carers (61.5%) were available all the time for
caregiving duties. The mean age of the male
patients was 52.111.4 years while that for the
female patients was 54.111.4 years. For the
carers, the male mean age was 42.815.4 while
that for females was 37.410.8 years.
27/06/2012 14:52
Figure 2. Mean RMI scores over the 12 months period. There was a general increase
in the patients RMI scores over the 12 months but they were still low. Overall, the
experimental group patients had better mean mobility scores than those in the control
group (P=0.001).
16
14
Mean RMI change
12
10
9.1
8.1
8
5.7
6
4
2
0
8.5
7.5
3.7
5.0
3.3
Baseline
Control group
Experimental group
3 months
6 months
Time period of measurement
12 months
Discussion
The patients in this study sample had very low
mobility levels at discharge from hospital as
indicated by their low RMI scores at the baseline assessment. This is despite the fact that one
of the most important aims of rehabilitation following stroke is to improve patients functional
ability. A major contributor towards the realisation of this important rehabilitation goal is
improved patient mobility (van Peppen et al,
2004; Langhorne et al, 2009). The low scores
that persisted in this cohort of patients signify a
high degree of dependency. The higher the RMI
scores, the higher the mobility of the patient
and the reverse is true (Collen et al, 1990).
The patients who belonged to the experimental group improved their RMI scores by an
average score of 0.7, which was moderately
clinically significant. One can only postulate
that maybe the patients cared for by the trained
carers were exercised a little more than those
who were cared for by untrained carers and
hence the slightly better outcome. This outcome
could also be attributed to increased confidence
with the mobilisation process by the carers.
The poor RMI mobility scores of the patients
also agree with the finding of low BI mobility scores. The lack of clinically significant
changes in the two groups mobility abilities
could be attributed to the low scores they had at
discharge and lack of ongoing outpatient rehabilitation. Though it was not part of this study, it
was noted during the follow up interviews that
If the patients had gone for rehabilitation after their early discharge from hospital,
they would have benefited. Training and exercise programmes have value in stroke rehabilitation (Ramas et al, 2007). They have been
shown to result in improved patient functional
abilities and quality of life (Kalra et al, 2004;
McNaughton et al, 2005; Aprile et al, 2008).
The finding of patient inability to attend outpatient rehabilitation agrees with Kengne and
Anderson (2006)s statement that,
there is poor access of patients
to rehabilitation services and little
information available on functional
recovery of patients after stroke in subSaharan Africa.
383
27/06/2012 14:52
Research
of daily living ability over the one-year period
were not enough to allow patients to function
independently in the community. The patient
dependency on outside help can be explained by
the poor functional levels that the patients exhibited throughout the study period. A score of 60%
on the BI is the cut off between independence and
more marked dependence, 40% or below indicates
severe dependence while 20% or below reflects
total dependence (Granger et al, 1979; Finch et
al, 2002). The mean BI scores at 12 months for
the patients in this study were 63% and 67% for
the control and experimental groups respectively
and they were 54% and 57% respectively at the
six months follow up period. At six months follow
up, 92% of the patients were dependent according
to the BI scores while 78% were dependent at 12
months. It is quite clear from these figures that the
majority of the patients had dependence scores
for most of the study period. Low BI scores negatively affect patients ability to do activities and
participate in the community (Wee and Lysaght,
2009). The poor BI scores can be attributed to
stroke severity as well as the early discharge from
hospital, which meant that the patients received
little to no rehabilitation before discharge. The
lack of out-patient rehabilitation, physiotherapy
included also meant that patients had to rely solely
on carers and natural recovery for any functional
improvements. This is despite the fact that rehabilitation has been shown to improve not only the
quality of life of the carers, but that of the stroke
survivors as well (Kalra et al, 2004; Patel et al,
2004).
Walking exercises are very physically demanding and as such the carers may not have let the
patients practice enough when at home, resulting in some clinically insignificant differences
between the two groups. Despite the general
increase in mobility among the patients over the
year, they still struggled with higher mobility tasks
such as stair climbing and running, with none of
the participants being able to do the latter. The
Key points
n Carers are integral to survival of stroke survivors
n Patients are discharged with low functional abilities
n Carer education alone does not significantly improve patient functional
ability
n There is need to strengthen outpatient rehabilitation services
n Carers of stroke survivors need more structured support
384
27/06/2012 14:52
Conclusion
Though patient functional ability generally
improves over time, it does not improve to satisfactory levels. Carer training alone does not
result in significant improvements in patient
functional ability. The low levels of carer training intensity could also have contributed towards
this finding. The majority of patients are being
discharged home with very low functional levels
to unprepared carers resulting in them being very
low functioning one-year post-stroke. Community
physiotherapy including domiciliary visits needs
to be strengthened to ensure continuation of rehabilitation post discharge from the hospital. Though
there is no agreement in the literature on the best
method for carer education at the moment, it
would be important to try out the effectiveness of
different methods of carer training and see which
one would best suit our country. IJTR
Funding acknowledgements:
1. University of the Witwatersrand
2. Medical Research Council of South Africa
Declaration of Interest Statement: The authors report no
conflict of interest.
385
27/06/2012 14:52
Copyright of International Journal of Therapy & Rehabilitation is the property of Mark Allen Publishing Ltd
and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright
holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.