COMMON LAW SYSTEMS VS.

CIVIL
LAW SYSTEMS
THE SOURCES OF ENGLISH LAW

COMMON LAW SYSTEMS VS. CIVIL LAW

SYSTEMS. SOURCES OF ENGLISH LAW

Ingls Profesional y
Acadmico

Law systems
(Source: Wikipedia. Author: Javitomad. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_law_%28legal_system%29)

Common law systems

(Source: Wikimedia. http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Common_law_world.png#file)

Common law systems vs. civil law systems

List of country legal systems:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cou
ntry_legal_systems#Civil_law_and_co
mmon_law

Common law systems

- Common law is law developed by judges through decisions of courts and/or
tribunals. It is very pragmatic: the law can be developed on a case-by-case
basis and it is not necessary to wait for Parliament to pass an Act.

- Court decisions are considered law (case law) and have the same force as any
law passed by Parliament (statutory law).

Law passed by Parliament

- Leading cases set a precedent which is binding (=obligatory): the precedent

binds future decision on the principle of stare decisis (similar cases should be
decided in such a way they reach similar results it would be unfair to treat
similar facts differently on different occasions.

- Decisions by appelate courts are binding on lower courts and on future

decisions of the same appellate court, but decisions of lower courts are
persuasive authority.

Not binding
Adapted from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_law

Civil law systems

- Civil law systems are also called code systems or codified
systems. They write (=codify) law) and apply it.

- There is generally a written constitution as well as specific codes

(e.g., civil code, criminal code, commercial code, etc.).

- There is little scope for case law (in practice judges tend to follow
previous judicial decisions of the higher courts).

- Constitutional and administrative courts can annul laws and

regulations.
Adapted from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_law_%28legal_system%29

The sources of English law

1. COMMON LAW (custom + case law).
2. EQUITY: formerly administered by the Lord Chancellor. Based on
basic principles of fairness and justice.
3. STATUTE LAW: law passed by Parliament (acts/statutes;
statutory instruments or SIs).
4. EU LEGISLATION + INTERNATIONAL AGREEMENTS (must
be formally incorporated into English law before courts are
obliged to apply them; e.g. European Convention on Human
Rights and Fundamental Freedoms ECHR-, 1950 Human
Rights Act 1998).

COMMON LAW

Common law
THERE IS NO STATUTE MAKING MURDER
ILLEGAL. It is a common law crime, so there is no
written Act of Parliament making murder illegal.

Common law, however, can be amended by

Parliament.
Example: murder carries a mandatory life sentence today, but
previously allowed the death penalty.

STATUTE LAW

10

Statute law
Also enacted law

Written laws or legislation passed by Parliament.

Types:
(1) Acts of Parliament (statutes)
(2) Delegated legislation (Statutory Instruments or
SIs: ministerial orders, regulations, rules, local byelaws, etc.). Approx.3,000 each year.

On the increase the last few years.

11

Statute law
Legislation since devolution (the moving
of power or responsibility from a central
government to a local government) forms
several separate entities:
United Kingdom legislation: applies to the
whole UK.
Scottish legislation.
Welsh legislation (Statutory Instruments only).
Northern Irish legislation.
12

Statute law

STAGES OF AN ACT:
draft (bill) bill act / statute

13

CASE LAW

14

Case law
Body of law created by judges
decisions on individual cases.
Also called judge-made law

15

Case law
CONTINENTAL SYSTEM: judges apply the law.
ENGLISH SYSTEM: judges apply the law BUT
also make the law.
- Judges apply their KNOWLEDGE OF LEGAL
PRECEDENT to the facts before them (+ statute
law, of course).

16