Anda di halaman 1dari 4

Pakistan knows India is on a different level with the US - Ind...

1 of 4


rediff NewsApp


SHOP FOR: Men's Lifestyle Women's Lifestyle Mobiles Electronics Watches Home & Decor Personal Care Health & Fitness Books All Categories

Search for over 22,00,000+ products

Ashutosh Sachan | Sign out

Close x News Pakistan knows India is on a different level with the US

Pakistan knows India is on a different level

with the US


To get such articles in your inbox

Text size: A A

February 03, 2016 01:09 IST

'Both India and Pakistan are now, for the first time in history, very closely allied
and connected with the US -- economically and politically.'
South Asia expert Shuja Nawaz speaks to Aziz Haniffa/ in Washington,

Latest from

Late Costa strike
helps Chelsea
hold Man United
to a draw

Arsenal back in
EPL title race with
win at

HIL: Punjab
Warriors end
Lancers' winning

Strike hits Pak

national carrier,
600 flights

IMAGE: Pakistan army chief General Raheel Sharif, third from left, introduces US Secretary of State John Kerry
to some of his top generals before a military briefing during his visit to Pakistan's army headquarters in

India to host
first-ever global
maritime summit,
announces PM

Rawalpindi, January 13, 2015. Photograph: US State Department

erhaps no South Asian strategic analyst in Washington, DC, is as well plugged in with the
Pakistani government and its military as Shuja Nawaz, till recently the Atlantic Council's first
Director of the think-tank's South Asia Centre.
Nawaz, currently a Distinguished Fellow at the Council's South Asia Centre, diving into the
controversy that the office of the US Special Representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan
(SRAP) would shortly be folded back into the South and Central Asian Affairs (SCA) bureau,
said while it was unlikely, debunked concerns in New Delhi that if it happens it would
necessarily lead to re-hyphenation of US policy toward India and Pakistan.
In an interview with, Nawaz acknowledged that he is a strong proponent for a
merger between SRAP and SCA, and said, "I believe (Secretary of State) John Kerry was
inclined to change the situation last year, but he did not calculate the power of the bureaucracy
to slow things down and so it's not a fight he wanted to get involved in."
"Also, with the transition in Afghanistan, I believe they wanted to continue the Af-Pak position
through 2016," Nawaz said, and noted, "The appointment of Rick Olson (as SRAP) was an
indication that they wanted somebody who knew both countries."
"If you recall," Nawaz said, "he had served with the rank of ambassador in charge of economics
in Kabul, then he had also served as ambassador in the UAE, so he knew the region, and then,
of course, his most recent posting was in Pakistan (as US ambassador)."
"So the Af-Pak position for him was a kind of a natural progression, giving the administration a
little time to change over."

Tour operators
seek service tax
e-tourist visas at

wrestlers shine as
India's gold rush
continues at
South Asian
DCW threatens to
sue Delhi police if
crime data not

States demand
more money from
Centre ahead of

Why not forming

government if
alliance intact,
Omar asks

08-Feb-16 2:57 AM

Pakistan knows India is on a different level with the US - Ind...

2 of 4

"I've been following the debate on why to hyphenate or why de-hyphenate and the
hyphenation, at least from my point of view, is not simply between Pakistan and India, but
putting both of them in he same wider regional grouping," Nawaz said.
"It would allow regional decision-making to take place," he argued, "and so, the US could work
with countries as a region rather than dealing bilaterally with four or five."

Stars spotted!

What's this?

Spotted: Sunny-Bobby Deol in Dubai

Reader Jeelani Ahmed Shaikh has sent
More stars spotted

Met a celebrity?
Email us photos & videos

t the same time," Nawaz said, "I don't think this will downgrade the growing US-India
relationship because that has its own trajectory and its own objectives, which extend beyond
the region."
"Both the US and India have a powerful interest in the East and apart from the rebalancing of
the US -- from the Middle East to the Pacific -- India also has a very powerful interest in the
Pacific and in the South China Sea."
Nawaz reiterated that he was a strong supporter for the merger between the SRAP and SCA
"because I believe it will force many of the bureaucrats to work together and work with their
regional partners -- US bureaucrats in India and US bureaucrats in Pakistan and Afghanistan
to work together in finding more regional solutions to problems."
"Now this will not change some of the other boundaries that exist for the US government and I
believe it's worth pointing them out. The Pentagon still has the very rigid boundary with
PACCOM (Pacific Command) and CENTCOM (Central Command)."
"I've met some retired senior military people who have said they regretted this strict boundary
because it did not allow India to participate in a lot of the task forces and activities in the
Indian Ocean because it involved moving into the Red Sea and the Arabian Sea and so on,"
Nawaz said.

Automatic Electric Roti / Chapati

Maker With Non Stic Coating

Aquafresh 5 Stage Uv Water


Rs. 2,999 Rs. 719

Rs. 4,700 Rs. 1,399

Provogue Grey And Red Sports

Shoes For Men
Rs. 499

Add to cart

Add to cart

Add to cart

Thus, he believed, "the Pentagon will probably need to think about either making these
boundaries more porous or eliminating them and reshaping its relationship, because now a
guy sitting in Hawaii is essentially dealing with India -- that's a long way -- and CENTCOM is
next door in the Gulf and they have regional headquarters there."
sked if the powers that be in Islamabad were for a merger or if it really does matter to
them at all, Nawaz said, "My understanding from very senior foreign affairs persons in
Islamabad last year was that they were for it and they had understood that Kerry was ready to
make a change rapidly."
"At that time, I advised them that I didn't think that Kerry would be able to make such a rapid
transition because there were enrenched interests and there is an active debate going on within
the system," Nawaz said.
Asked if Islamabad would like a merger because at some level they may perceive that this puts
them on par with India, he said, "There is no question that India and Pakistan are on different
levels and that's a reality that is understood."
But he reiterated that a merger makes it easier to communicate, to bring the US into the
discussions, which Pakistan has favoured and India has not -- "India doesn't want the US to be
the third person in the room."
Nawaz believes that a consequence of this led to "Prime Minister Modi's recent turnabout and
warming of the relationship, or thawing of the relationship rather than warming with
"So, these are things that will have to be addressed within South Asia, but the point is both
India and Pakistan are now, for the first time in history, very closely allied and connected with
the US -- economically and politically."
ince Olson comes with a wide swath of connections in Pakistan and Afghanistan and his
decades of experience, technically since he would erport to Assistant Secretary of State Nisha
Desai Biswal in the case of a merger, Nawaz said, it would have been a difficult scenario.
"This is probably one of the reasons why it (a merger) is likely to be delayed till the end of this
year, because then, whatever change that occurs will be under a new administration come
"The other critical thing," Nawaz said, "is that they would want to maintain the focus on
Afghanistan and Pakistan, while Afghanistan is going through a very difficult political and
military transition itself."
"By the end of the year, there should be a little more clarity about the future of US forces in

08-Feb-16 2:57 AM

Pakistan knows India is on a different level with the US - Ind...

3 of 4

Afghanistan -- will they go down to zero or will it remain at the current levels?"
Unlike the first turbo-charged SRAP Richard Holbrooke -- who at one time was asked not to
come to Kabul by then Afghan president Hamid Karzai -- Olson "has a very good equation with
(Afghan President) Ashraf Ghani and in Islamabad," Nawaz said.
"He knows everyone and he understands them. He has a good relationship with the army in
Pakistan also and that's what makes any ambassador effective on a regional basis."
nother element in this is Iran," Nawaz said and argued, "with the sanctions being lifted,
that will likely change Iran's regional participation in Afghanistan on the one hand and with
Pakistan and India because trade is going to start in an unfettered mode."
"And with the sanctions removed, who knows, it might be possible for India to participate in
the reopening of the IPI -- India, Pakistan, Iran pipeline -- and maybe even an oil pipeline
because remember, the Ambanis have a very big refinery near the Pakistani border, which I am
told is specifically designed among other things to deal with Iranian crude."
"These kinds of second and third tier effects," Nawaz predicted, "are likely to be quite
important on a regional basis."
Aziz Haniffa in Washington, DC

Related News: Nawaz, SRAP, Pakistan, India, SCA


Print this article


More from rediff

No putting India, Pak in same basket: US
Who is afraid of 'hyphenated' US policies?
'Our people are disillusioned over peace with Pakistan'
'By 2012, we brought China boundary row to point of solution'
'Terrorism is something you have to deal with. But that is a political call'
Better ties with Pak depends on this Sharif, not the other one

It's free!

To get such articles in your inbox

ashutoshsachan@rediffmail. SUBSCRIBE >

Sponsored Content You May Like

Sponsored Links by Taboola

Why a Career in Data Science Could Lead to Casting Netfli

Beginner's Guide to Analytics E- book

She Likes You, But Before You Ask Her Out


Calculate: The Amount of Money You Need At 60

Big decisions

Auto Expo 2016: Maruti Vitara Brezza Unveiled in India

An Uncommon Friendship

Investing Rs.1000 Per Month Can Lead to Long Term Weal


08-Feb-16 2:57 AM

Pakistan knows India is on a different level with the US - Ind...

4 of 4

on F
will become irrevalent once financial umbrella of
WEATHER OF REASONING.Let us all work to improve well being of mass humanity in India/Afghnaisan and ndia.

A car that's also a feast

Liven up Your Space this
for the senses
Forward | Report Diwali!
Tata Motors


Re: Pakistan
by H K Gupta (View MyPage) on Feb 03, 2016 02:32 AM
Pakistan instead of ndia.

Stylish Handbag, Sling

Bag & Clutch Combos Starting @ Rs 299
Rediff Shopping

Forward | Report abuse

Message(s) deleted by moderator not displayed on this page

Total 3 messages

Pages: | 1

Write a message

Terms of use | Disclaimer

Business email Office email App Domain registration Website Rediffmail Money Company email Online Shopping Books





2016 - Investor Information - Advertise with us - Disclaimer - Privacy Policy - Careers - Feedback - Terms of use

08-Feb-16 2:57 AM