August 2006
Volume - 1
Issue - 4
Editor :
Hariprasad R.C.
C O N T E N T S
REALITY CHECK
National Insecurity
REALITY CHECK
Reservation Issue
RTI CORNER
RTI Report
PUBLIC EYE
Another Story
RTI CORNER
RTI Report
TEA TIME CHAT
Centre for Public
Policy Research
Vaikom Road, Cochin
Kerala, India - 682 301
www.cpprindia.org
E-mail : program@cpprindia.org CPPR is not responsible for the views expressed in this journel. Authors own resposibility for their articles
EDITORIAL
INDEPENDENT OR ‘IN-DEPENDENCE’?
Independent
or
‘In-dependence’?
“If you really want something in life, then the entire
world will conspire with you to achieve that,” declares
Paulo Coelho in his book ‘The Alchemist.’ We can see
numerous achievements in the course of history which
has asserted the truth in these words. One such glorious
moment was when India became independent on August
15, 1947. It was the final outcome of innumerable
sacrifices by millions of people.
Editor
National (In)Security
!" HARIPRASAD R C !
From Mumbai bomb blasts to security breach at PM’s Residence, it has been a
tough time for the intelligence agencies and our cops for the past several weeks. And
to add some spice to the real threats were many hoax bomb calls which included bomb
scares at the India Gate and AIIMS and even a threat e-mail to our Prez. This was
followed by a revelation by our National Security Advisor of the possibility of two LeT
militants in the Indian Air Force. The country is now on a high alert with possible
terrorist strikes at the wake of Independence Day. The simple question that rises in the
mind of a commoner who reads through these facts is how secure is our nation after all.
The government may pat on our shoulders and tell us that all possible measures are
taken to ensure the safety of the citizens and the usual blah-blah about its past
achievements. But words are of little use when actions contradict them.
NO EXCUSES, PLEASE!
Isn’t it a great irony to know that millions of dollars are spent annually for defense
purposes and still the lives of the people in the nation are ever under threat. Okay, one
can argue that little can be done to ensure the lives of all the people in the country all
the time. But repeated terror strikes from the same militant organizations leave little
space for finding excuses. The fact that they are able to strike and strike repeatedly
simply reflects the fact that they are better organized and skillful and ever alert to the
strategies employed by the intelligence agencies. It is in a way pointing out the
insufficiencies in our system. Hence, we have no room for any excuses.
1. 11/7 – Mumbai Bomb blast
2. 16/7 – bomb hoax call at India Gate, ND
3. 20/7 – bomb scare at AIIMS
4. 20/7 – threat e-mail to Kalam
5. 27/7 – security breach at PM’s residence
The incident at the PM’s residence was a result of the callous indifference on the
part of the security guards. And if the media persons outside the PM’s residence had
not noticed the incident it would never have come out. This was clearly evident in the
statement issued later which said that no serious security breach had taken place.
Possibilities of terrorists sneaking in with bombs in the place of those three youngsters
seem a far fetched horror story for our government and security agencies. Constant
vigil and skillful planning must be ingrained into our system to beef up the security in
the country.
THE GREAT IRONY
India was ranked at 9th position in the National Security Index (1994) ahead of
countries like Israel, U K, France and Germany. If this is the state of affairs with
regard to security in India, imagine the possibilities lie in these countries. Yet none of
them suffer from terrorist strikes as frequently as we do. This is the great irony that is
facing us today.
SECURITY IN US
Take a look at the number of instances when there was an intrusion into the White
House. May be we need to emulate US in this issue. The table plainly puts forth the
fact that not only does US place a very high priority when it comes to security matters
but it succeeds in efficiently implementing them.
YOUTH – EASY TARGETS
A major threat to the nation at present is the growth of extremist activities within
India. We can no longer put the blame on Pakisthani militants every time a terrorist
strike hits India though they might be sponsored by ISI or other terrorist groups.
Today youth, particularly Muslim youth, in India are increasingly targeted by the
underworld to carry out their operations in India. This was fact was further
substantiated by a statement of a former Students Islamic Movement of India (SIMI)
activist in Mumbai, who said that terrorist organizations were making youth their
tools to carry out terrorist operations. The rising strength of the naksal movement and
the sprouting of extremist groups like People’s War Group (PWG) and others are also
a major concern.
BE ALERT!!!
A practical solution seems to be maintaining a state of constant alertness both by
the security agencies, government and the public. Public awareness about the seriousness
of the issue needs to be heightened. Public needs to be trained in detecting a possible
danger and a well coordinated system of intelligence agencies and police should be
able to take the necessary actions promptly.
Recent Trespassers to the White House Complex
Year Ran Through Open Gate Entered With Passholders
1989 0 0
1990 1 1
1991 0 0
1992 0 0
1993 1 0
1994 0 3
Reservation Issue
! ABIN !
Central government policy on reservation has started fresh debates all over the
country. Union HRD Minister Sri.Arjun Singh proposed 27% reservation for OBCs
in central education institutions citing the need to satisfy the interests of all sections of
the society. The response to the bill was mixed. Doctors and medical students of
AIIMS spearheaded the agitation against the bill. They raised slogans, staged protest
marches and fasted. Their argument is that the reservation of seats in premier institutes
of the country like theirs would greatly affect the quality of education provided there.
Now, reservation is a very sensitive issue. The main aim of this proposal is supposed
to be establishing social justice. But the question is, even after 58 years of independence,
why haven’t we met the objectives of reservation which was proposed to be removed in
a time bound manner. Now, poor has become poorer and the rich, richer. Lack of
professional planning and mismanagement made the system unduly complicated.
There are numerous other factors which have undermined the purpose of reservation.
The political aftermath is an unavoidable aspect in such a sensitive case. Each and
every party aims the vote bank when it comes to issues that matter the most. Recently
some of them expressed concern over the impact of this complicated issue. At the same
time they are saying that they are not against reservation. This is clearly double
standards. Politics has become the field of opportunists and criminals where corruption
has penetrated just too deeply. Political leaders say about setting an alternative, a
road map for the future, which might never happen.
Studies give reservation “intentionally” to counter the perspectives of am admi.
Kerala provided reservation for muslim community and Latin Catholics, even right
from 1950s. Andhra Pradesh recently made a legislation concerning reservation. A
mahapanchayat was organized in Delhi by politicians to demand reservation. But
they are not ready to resolve the primary needs of common man. They only like to
make news. Education should be separated from politics, because most of the states in
India have already reached the constitutional limits beyond which no reservation is
permissible.
ANOTHER STORY
! RIYA GEORGE !
Riya George - IIIrd year BA Literature Student, St. Teresas College, Kochi
RTI - REPORT
! JITHIN PAUL !
The Right to Information Act was passed by the union parliament on 15th June,
2005 and came into force on 12th October, 2005 thereby making sure that the nation
achieved another mile stone in its way forward. The Act provides the citizens the right
to gain information on virtually everything related to “public authorities”.
We in Centre for Public Policy Research (CPPR) believe that if properly
implemented unlike many other laws Right to Information Act, 2005 can be a
very effective tool in speeding up the process of national progress, because it
brings the “power” back to people which ultimately is what democracy aims
at. Moreover RTI ensures that the ultimate decision makers are going to be
people of the respective area’s which indirectly means that the “Public Choice”
is going to prevail, over the will over of bureaucrats thereby making sure that
meeting another objective of our organization. We believe that this act is
certainly going to make difference because it is already working. Also it is for the
first time in the history of independent India, there is a law, which casts a direct
accountability on the officer for non-performance. If concerned officer does not provide
information in time, a penalty of Rs 250 per day of delay can be imposed by the
Information Commissioner. If the information provided is false, a penalty of a
maximum of Rs 25000 can be imposed. A penalty can also be imposed for providing
incomplete or for rejecting your application for malafide reasons. This fine is deducted
from the officer’s personal salary. However, it made clear that there have nothing
similar in the history of this country were the administrators has shown such will to
and Mr. Jacob Joseph(Faculty, team to the campaign sites and the
NUALS).Later, the members of the Centre program is scheduled like 45 minutes
tried to learn more about the Act, and presentation and remaining time is spent
various reading materials were for interaction and clarifying doubts. We
distributed among the members as well as have come to a situation where the demand
the local men. for frequent campaign and visits to
various places is on the rise. The Centre is
RTI coordinators of the Centre Mr. planning to train volunteers in order to
Jithin Paul and Ms. Malathy participated meet this demand. Already many college
in a training session on the topic at S.H going students have shown interest in RTI
College Thevara and had a meaningful Campaigns. The Centre aims to conduct
and informative discussion with the at least 100 workshops and campaigns in
faculty members of the college. the next six months. In order to achieve
Since March 2006, we have been into this target, simultaneous workshops have
rigorous campaigning at various places to be conducted and this requires more
in Kerala were the locals were given a trained man power into
clear-cut idea into the topic and Centre campaigns. These campaigns are
was also instrumental in sorting out many conducted at free of cost and the Centre
local issues and also finding solution for funds the team members for the
many of them. campaigns. Since this is a visible and
deliverable mechanism, the interest
MIND TEXT 10 AUGUST 2006
parties are many. invocation and how serious they are to public it would end up like any other law.
the procedures. In a highly literate state Using RTI, the Centre plans to take the
FUTURE PLANS
like Kerala, the awareness campaign is the initiative to find the
Along with the research papers most demanding one. We will evaluate the rules and regulations governing each
planned under RTI, the Centre is campaigns on the basis of the number of Government Department and compile it
planning to engage in Duty To Publish applications the participants file. in the form of a book. This would be an
(DTP) awareness campaign. According to Another area of focus is the compilation asset to the Kerala society at large.
a study conducted by Centre for Civil of contact addresses of Public Information
Society, Kerala ranks 14th in the DTP offices under various departments and to Jithin Paul Varghese - Co-ordinates RTI
index with regard to education publish it. Still, there are gray areas in Act campaign for CPPR. He can be
department. It shows how the bureaucracy Kerala as far as the implementation part reached at rti@cpprindia.org
and the political leadership look at RTI is concerned. Without demand from the
Dr. Henri Austin former Union Minister addressess NCC wing of S.H. College, Kochi organised by CPPR