SCOPE
Scope of study in privatization in Indian banking sector
The scope of this study is that it will help the further researchers to gain an
insight into the customers minds that what are their perception about private
sector banks and how it affects the banking sector. The purpose of this study is
to identify those parameters and policy issues to be considered in connection
with proposals to transfer federal state or local government service, asset and
function to the private sector. It will review the stated goals and identify
strategies to ensure transparency, accountability and preservation of common
good.
LIMITATION
In spite of best of efforts to minimize all limitation that might creep in
course of the research, there were certain constraints within which the research
was completed.
1) The research was based on secondary as well as primary data. The primary
data require for research objective was collected from the sample based in
Guwahati city. Although Guwahati is one of the most important cities of the
country and a commercial hub of north east India, sample selected from the city
cannot be considered as a proper representation of the population of the country.
2) The objective of the survey was to check the perception of the bank managers
as well as customers of the bank.
3) For primary data, non response error cannot be ruled out.
4) This study is related to selected Public Sector Banks and Private Sector
Banks only.
5) The secondary data, which used for this study is based on annual reports of
the bank. The quality of this research depends on quality and reliability of data
published in annual reports of banks.
6) There are different methods to measure the profitability of the banks. View
of expert can be different in this matter from one another.
7) The present study is largely based on ratio analysis; such analysis has its
own limitations, which also applies to the study.
RESEARCH METHOIDOLOGY
Meaning word "research" is derived from the French word "Research" using to
some broadly Research refer to a search for knowledge research is an attempt to
find answer to problem both theoretical and practical through the application of
scientific methods.
Primary data:Constitute first hand information which is collected for the first time in
order to solve research problem. It is the data collected from primary sources
which are original sources. The method used for the collection of primary data
are:
Interview method
Questionnaire method
Secondary data
Secondary data are next to primary data. This data is already collected and
complied for sources other purpose by source other than the research himself.
Website, internet
Reference Book
seen the economic crisis of US in 2008-09 and now the European crisis. The
general scenario of the world economy is very critical. It is the banking rules
and regulation framework of India which has prevented it from the world
economic crisis. In order to understand the challenges and opportunities of
Indian Banking Industry, first of all, we need to understand the general scenario
and structure of Indian Banking Industry.
The banks, which were not nationalized at the time of bank nationalization that
took place during 1969 and 1980 are known to be the old private-sector banks.
These were not nationalized, because of their small size and regional
focus. Most of the old private-sector banks are closely held by certain
communities their operations are mostly restricted to the areas in and around
their place of origin. Their Board of directors mainly consist of locally
prominent personalities from trade and business circles. One of the positive
points of these banks is that, they lean heavily on service and technology and as
such, they are likely to attract more business in days to come with the
restructuring of the industry round the corner.
Private Banks are banks owned by either an individual or a general partner with
limited partner(s). Private banks are not incorporated. In any such case, the
creditors can look to both the "entirety of the bank's assets" as well as the
entirety of the sole-proprietor's/general-partners' assets.
These banks have a long tradition in Switzerland, dating back to at least
the Revocation of the Edict of Nantes (1685). Private banks also have a long
tradition in the UK where C. Hoare & Co. has been in business since 1672.
There were many private banks in Europe, but most have now become
incorporated companies, so the term is rarely true any more. Today, the term
"private bank" can also refer to the financial institution specializing in financial
advice and services for high-net-worth individuals (private banking).
"Private banks" can also refer to non-government owned banks in general, in
contrast to government-owned (or nationalized) banks, which were prevalent
in communist, socialist and some social democratic states in the 20th century.
10
CHAPTER 1
GLOBAL VIEW
Private banking is the way banking originated. The first banks in venice were
focused on managing personal finance for wealthy families. Private banks
became known as Private to stand out from the retail banking & savings banks
aimed at the new middle class. Traditionally, Private Banks were linked to
families for several generations. They often advised and performed all financial
& banking services for families. Historically, private banking has developed in
Europe (see the List of private banks). Some banks in Europe are known for
managing assets of some royal families. The assets of the Princely Family of
Liechtenstein are managed by LGT Group (founded in 1920 and originally
known as The Liechtenstein Global Trust). The assets of the Dutch royal
family are managed by Mees Pierson (founded in 1720). The assets of
the British Royal Family are managed by Coutts (founded in 1692).
Historically, private banking has been viewed as a very exclusive niche that
only caters to high-net-worth individuals (HNWIs) with liquidity over $2
million, though it is now possible to open private banking accounts with as little
as $250,000 for private investors. An institution's private banking division
provides services such as wealth management, savings, inheritance, and tax
planning for their clients. For private banking services clients pay either based
on the number of transactions, the annual portfolio performance or a "flat-fee",
usually calculated as a yearly percentage of the total investment amount.
"Private" also alludes to bank secrecy and minimizing taxes through careful
allocation of assets, or by hiding assets from the taxing authorities. Swiss and
certain offshore banks have been criticized for such cooperation with
11
12
The U.S. capital markets have long been a favored destination for foreign
companies wishing to raise capital or establish a trading presence for their
securities. The following information provides a general overview of the
relevant laws and regulations governing the U.S. securities markets with which
foreign companies wishing to access the U.S. capital markets should be familiar.
Two of the most important laws applicable to companies wishing to access the
U.S. capital markets are the Securities Act of 1933 (the Securities Act) and
the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (the Exchange Act). In very broad
overview, the Securities Act requires companies wishing to offer and sell
securities in the United States to register the transaction with the Commission or
to follow the requirements of an exemption from the registration requirements.
The Exchange Act requires companies to register classes of equity securities in
order to list these securities on a national securities exchange in the United
States, or if certain asset and shareholder thresholds are exceeded. The
Exchange Act also requires companies to make periodic filings with the
Commission to disclose information about their business operations, financial
condition, and management.
CHAPTER 2
13
INDIAN VIEW
The main objective of the Indian Banking Sector reforms of the 1990s was to
have a good and efficient financial system. As the new economy now continues
to grow much higher, new demands are placed on the Banking industry. Higher
growth is contributing to increase in higher income categories households and
this has led to higher consumption thus ultimately leading to more demand for
financial savings. On the production side, industrial production has accelerated,
trade has increased in terms of exports thus leading to a lot of investment
demand in this area. Thus higher consumer demand and production demand has
led banks to bring new and new products and innovate continuously and
produce more customized products thereby increasing competition in the sector.
If Indian banks have to sustain such high demand pressures it has to expand
both organically and inorganically. Looking at the global banking scenario only
22 banks figure in the top list of top 1000 banks and only 5 in the top list of 500
banks. Though banking in India has changed a lot, it has shown signs of
transformation whereby it can feature in the top rung of banks. The loan book of
the banks has increased tremendously and also the credit has exceeded the
deposit growth. Indian banks have also realized that with organic growth there
is a need to grow inorganically as well, to be competitive with other players in
the market. For e.g. State Bank if India, Indias largest bank has acquired 76%
stake in the Keynian Bank, Giro Commercial Bank. ICICI Bank, Bank of India,
Bank of Baroda also followed the same route. Even nationally banks like Bank
of Punjab has been merged with Centurion Bank to form Centurion Bank of
Punjab Ltd, Many such instances have started growing in the Indian banking
industry thereby giving signals that inorganic growth is important to compete
and sustain in the Indian banking industry. To meet 47 these challenges of
growing through inorganic growth and Indian banks going global, banks have
started following international norms. There has been increased transparency in
14
the system. The use of technology in the banking industry has changed things a
lot, thus creating faster processes, addressing customer problems in a more
efficient way etc. India has also compiled with all the Core Principles of
Effective Banking Supervision of the Basel Committee. Currently, India has 96
scheduled commercial banks (SCBs) - 27 public sector banks (that is with the
Government of India holding a stake), 31 private banks (these do not have
government stake; they may be publicly listed and traded on stock exchanges)
and 38 foreign banks. They have a combined network of over 53,000 branches
and 49,000 ATMs. According to researches carried out by the Reserve Bank of
India (RBI), on an all India basis, 59 per cent of the adult population in the
country has bank accounts and 41 per cent dont. In rural areas, the coverage of
banks is 39 per cent, against 60 per cent in urban areas. There is only one bank
for a population of 13000. Banking sector in India has been transformed
completely. Presently the latest inclusions such as Internet banking and Core
banking have made banking operations more user friendly and easy. At present
there are 20 public sector banks, State Bank of India and its associate group.
15
CHAPTER 3
Definition 'Private Banking'
Personalized financial and banking services that are traditionally offered to a
bank's rich, high net worth individuals (HNWI). For wealth management
purposes, HNWIs have accrued far more wealth than the average person, and
therefore have the means to access a larger variety of conventional and
alternative investments. Private banks aim to match such individuals with the
most appropriate options.
1786. From 1786 till today, the journey of Indian Banking System can be
segregated into three distinct phases. They are as mentioned below:
Early phase from 1786 to 1969 of Indian Banks
Nationalization of Indian Banks and up to 1991 prior to Indian banking sector
Reforms.
New phase of Indian Banking System with the advent of Indian Financial &
Banking Sector Reforms after 1991.
4/7 account access: Access your money, when and where you want it,
anywhere in the world.
Online tools: Check your account balances online, change your contact
details, pay your BPAY bills, transfer money overseas, replace and activate your
cards and much more.
ANZ Shield: The peace of mind of an extra layer of security for your
online payments and activities with ANZ Shield.
The private sector banks play a vital role in the Indian economy. They indirectly
motivate the public sector banks by offering a healthy competition to them. The
following are their importance:
18
The private sector banks are always trying to Innovate new products avenues
(new schemes, services, etc.) and make the industries to achieve expertise in
their respective fields by offering quality service and guidance.
They introduce new technology in the banking service. Thus, they lead the other
banks in various new fields. For example, introduction of computerized
operations, credit card business, ATM service, etc.
Privatization in bank
ICICI Bank
of banking products and financial services for corporate and retail customers
through a variety of delivery channels and specialized subsidiaries in the areas
of investment
insurance, venture
management. The Bank has a network of 4,050 branches and 12,919 ATMs in
India, and has a presence in 17 countries including India.
ICICI Bank is one of the Big Four banks of India, along with State Bank of
India, Punjab National Bank and Bank of Baroda. The bank has subsidiaries in
the United Kingdom and Canada; branches in United States, Singapore,
Bahrain, Hong Kong, Sri Lanka, Qatar, Oman, Dubai International Finance
Centre and China; and representative offices in United Arab Emirates, South
Africa, Bangladesh, Malaysia and Indonesia. The company's UK subsidiary has
also established branches in Belgium and Germany.
ICICI Bank has been at the forefront when it comes to technology adoption in
banking sector in India. Business intelligence has been a long journey for the
company with 12 million terabyte of data currently. And the reason why ICICI
Bank is spending so much on technology is primarily because of two reasons customer expectations and behavior is changing rapidly in India and second, the
diversified customer base in India.
There are so many business units like banking, mutual funds and insurance
within the ICICI group and it is very important for the group to seamlessly
integrate these units. This is because there is an overlap of the customer base
among these business units.
20
Deposits
Get full safety for your investments along with steady growth for your portfolio
with competitively priced deposit products from ICICI Bank Wealth
Management. We have designed a gamut of deposits to cater to your unique
banking needs. Now, earn attractive interest for various tenures on your
deposits.
Banking product
21
Savings Account
Home loans
22
Simplified documentation
At least one of the members in your family should hold a Wealth Management
account with ICICI Bank and this premium service will be extended to all the
members in the family*. Earn PAYBACK points under My Savings Rewards for
adding members to Family Wealth Account.
Car loans
23
The Car Loans from ICICI Bank are designed to finance your dream car that
suits your status and taste. Enjoy the following benefits when you choose a Car
Loan from us and be rest assured of a pleasant journey.
Our Car Loans offer attractive interest rates to ensure you have a smooth
drive
New car loans are offered with fixed interest rates during the tenure of the
loan
Demat account
Enjoy 24x7 access to transfer securities through the Internet and Interactive
Voice Response (IVR). Now you can receive your account statement and bill by
24
e-mail, and track your dividend, interest and bonus through the account
statement.
You also can seamlessly access your Demat Account by sending an SMS to
enquire about your Holdings, Transactions, Bill and ISIN details. Also receive
SMS alerts for all debits/credits and benefit from our competitive service
charges that offer you value for money.
Axis bank
25
Axis Bank Limited (formerly UTI Bank) is the third largest private sector bank
in India. Although classified as a private sector bank, Axis Bank's promoters
( UTI, LIC and GIC, which collectively held approx. 34% of the shares as at 31
December 2013), are all entities owned and controlled by the Government of
India.
The bank offers financial services to customer segments covering Large and
Mid-Sized corporates, MSME, Agriculture and Retail Businesses. Axis Bank
has its registered office at Ahmedabad.
Home loan
26
Axis Bank has opened a new front in the fast-growing home loan market by
promising to waive the last 12 equated monthly installments, or EMIs, if
repayments are done on time, a move that could prevent customers from
shifting to rivals offering lower rates and help the bank grab market share from
them.
The bank, which aims to raise its retail loan portfolio to about 30 per cent of
total from less than a fifth now, said this offer is available for those who borrow
under floating rate of interest and where payments are on time. "The idea is also
to check the churn in the home loan portfolio," said Jairam Sridharan, head
consumer lending and payments at Axis Bank. "With no pre-payment penalty,
customers are shifting loans to take advantage of the interest rate arbitrage
between banks. This product will also help us retain customers."
HDFC Bank
Housing
Development
Finance
Corporation
Limited or HDFC is
28
Yes bank
Yes Bank, is India's fifth largest private sector Bank, co-founded by Rana
Kapoor in 2004 Yes Bank is the only Greenfield Bank license awarded by the
RBI in the last two decades. Yes Bank is a Full Service Commercial Bank,
has steadily built a Corporate, Retail & SME Banking franchise, Financial
Markets, Investment Banking, Corporate Finance, Branch Banking, Business
and Transaction Banking, and Wealth Management business lines across the
country.
All parts of the Bank use IT to deliver superior products and services to the
customer. Innovations like Money Monitor, Mobile payments, Dual factor
authentication, Mobile Banking, RFID in branches, one-view of customer
relationship, most advanced speech enabled IVR enable products and sales
teams to offer superior customer offerings. Additionally, YES BANK continues
to strengthen its strategic partnerships with some of the best known IT majors
globally to develop innovative system features in order to improve process
efficiencies and create sector-specific banking solutions. Further, the
development of a robust Business Continuity plan within the Bank addresses
risks and secures systems that are vital to business operations.
YES BANK entered into a strategic partnership with Cordys for implementation
of a Business Process Management Suite to further help automation of
processes, straight through processing, robust audit mechanisms and flexibility
to quickly launch new customer products.
YES BANK entered into a partnership with First Data Corporation for its ATM
outsourcing in line with the Banks strategy to partner with best in class service
providers. This move has given the Bank a substantial cost advantage viz. ATM
management on one side, and ability to scale up much faster at the other.
30
31
Structured products
Foreign exchange
Commodities including precious metals
Deposits
Cash management
Real estate investments
Banks can offer either proprietary products or third-party products. To
distinguish between the two options, two types of product platforms are used:
Open architecture product platform is where a private bank distributes
all the third party products and is not restricted to selling only its
proprietary products.
Closed architecture product platform is where the bank sells only its
proprietary products and does not entertain any third party product.
Because of the diversity of clients' investment goals and existing private
banking products, a bank cannot meet the needs of the clients by offering solely
proprietary products. That is why most of the banks now follow an open
architecture product platform.
32
Financial Advising
investment
counseling
asset allocation
market analysis
risk management
tax counseling
fiduciary solutions
protecting
estate planning
and
growing
retirement planning
inheritance planning
sector banks were allowed to procure financial resources from the stock market
up to 49%of their paid-up capital. The state of affairs began to change after
2000.The government adopted a policy of converting development financial
institutions into banks, and ICICI became a bank in 2001, followed by IDBI in
2004. During this period, one public sector bank and four private sector banks
were established, and 16 foreign banks entered the market. In March 1991,
foreign banks had 151 branches. This had increased to 205 by March 2001, and
to 295 by March 2009.
Growth of Advances:
The credit from the bank is an important input in the production function of the
agriculture, industry, commerce and allied productive activities for socio
economic development of the country. The bank credits, its development,
composition and direction are equally important in realizing the countrys
various macroeconomic goals. The channelization of bank credit in proper
direction, otherwise, there will be the adverse effect on the economy of the
country.
34
The percentage share of state bank of India and its associate banks registered a
growth of 5.6 during 2010-2011. The nationalized banks of India registered an
increase of 26.4 per cent during 2010-11. During 2010-11 Indias public sector
banks, old private sector banks, new private sector banks, private sector banks
and foreign banks registered a growth 19.0, 15.3, 15.6, 15.5 and 22.1 per cent
during 2010-2011. The all scheduled commercial banks registered a growth 18.6
per cent during 2010-2011.
TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENT IN BANKING:Indian banking has changed terrifically in the past few years. The changes are
multiple and at a fast pace in the term of transformation of technology
advancement. It has become completely dependent on technology as the
service/ product channel. Up gradation of technology, innovation and
modernization are the key factors of having excellence in banking sector. It
becomes necessary for a bank to differentiate its products from others. The
differentiation can be in terms of specialization, new products, increasing added
value by technology convergence. Technology in banking sector is one of the
focus areas of banks. The banks in India are using Information Technology (IT)
not only to improve their own internal processes but also to increase facilities
and services to their customers. Technological innovation not only enables a
broader reach for consumer banking and financial services, but also enhances its
capacity for continued and inclusive growth. IT improves the front end
operations with back end and helps in bringing down the transaction costs for
the customers.
Privatization has become a popular measure for solving the Banking problems
of governments by reducing the role of the state and encouraging the growth of
the private sector Bank. However, privatization takes a number of forms and has
been approached in various ways during the move away from government
control to other forms of ownership in developing countries.
In the course of banking liberalization, Reserve Bank has so far granted licenses
to 9 private sector banks up to March 2003. This apart, many foreign banks are
allowed to set up branches / offices in India. Simultaneously banks were
encouraged to go for mergers as in the case with Times Bank Ltd with HDFC
bank and Bank of Madura Ltd with ICICI Bank Ltd.
36
ADVANTAGES OF PRIVATIZATION
Privatization indeed is beneficial for the growth and sustainability of the
state-owned enterprises. The advantages of privatization can be perceived
from both microeconomic and macroeconomic impacts that privatization
exerts.
A. Microeconomic advantages:
37
B. Macroeconomic advantages:
Privatization has a positive impact on the financial health of the sector
which was previously state dominated by way of reducing the deficits and
debts.
The net transfer to the State owned Enterprises is lowered through
Privatization .
Helps in escalating the performance benchmarks of the industry in general.
Can initially have an undesirable impact on the employees but gradually in
the long term, shall prove beneficial for the growth and prosperity of the
employees
Privatized enterprises provide better and prompt services to the customers
and help in improving the overall infrastructure of the country. .
38
the private sector banks played a crucial role in the growth of joint stock
banking in India. The first half of the 20th century witnessed phenomenal
growth of private sector banks. As a result in 1951, there were 566 private banks
of which 474 were non-scheduled and 92 scheduled classified on the basis of
their capital size. The role of private sector banking started declining when the
Government of India entered banking business with the establishment of State
Bank of India in 1955 and subsequently two rounds of bank nationalization one
in July 1969 (14 major banks), another in April 1980 (takeover of 6 banks).
Consequently, the presence of public sector banks has increased. At present,
there are 32 private banks comprising of 24 old banks, which existed prior to
1993-94 and eight new private banks, which were established during 1993-94
and onwards after the RBI announced guidelines in January 1993 for
establishment of new banks in private sector following the recommendations of
Narasimham Committee-I (1991). Compared to New private sector banks, the
old banks are smaller in size. For example, at end March 2000, the average net
worth of the 24 Old Private Banks (OPBs) was Rs.179.67 Crore per OPB
compared to that of the New Private Bank (NPB) at Rs. 479.88 Crore per NPB.
The OPBs are essentially regional in character although some of them have
scattered presence in areas other than in and around the areas of their origin.
The number of branches of the NPBs was 999 at end March 2003, while those
of OPBs 3491. The NPBs are extremely cautious in expanding their branch
network and business because their managers.
The Narasimham Committee-I, that advocated competition in the banking
industry, made unequivocal recommendation to allow private and foreign banks
into the industry. Acting on the recommendations of the committee, the RBI laid
down guidelines for the establishment of the private 191 sector banks on
January 1993.
40
41
42
The Reserve Bank of India is slowly opening the doors for corporate to enter the
highly regulated industry i.e. the banking industry.
New Banking Law [The Banking Laws (Amendment) Bill 2012]
Some Features of the Bill are as Follows
The new regulation increases the shareholders voting rights from 10 per
cent to 26 per cent in private sector banks, making investment attractive
to foreign players. This will make the Indian banking sector attractive for
the overseas investors and is expected to lead to consolidation in the
industry.
It allows nationalized banks to issue bonus shares and rights to give them
flexibility to raise capital.
Now, Reserve Bank of India (RBI) could issue new bank licenses to
business houses.
It gives the RBI powers to inspect the books of any associate enterprise of
a bank
RBI will have powers to impose penalty if banks fail to maintain
adequate CRR
Bill also enables the government to raise voting rights in state banks such
as the State Bank of India to 10 per cent from the current one per cent.
Bill allows foreign banks to convert their Indian operations into local
subsidiaries or transfer shareholding to a holding company of the bank
without paying stamp duty
43
44
1. Axis Bank
2. Development Credit Bank
3. HDFC Bank
4. ICICI Bank
5. IndusInd Bank
6. Yes Bank
7. Bandhan Bank
8. IDFC
9. Kotak Mahindra Bank[
CHAPTER 4
The Indian banking sector is a mixture of public, private and foreign
ownerships. The below table highlights top 10 banks which contributed 58%
share of the total credit as on March 31, 2011. The State bank of India has
recorded highest market share. The Net Interest Margin of HDFC Banks is 4.2%
which is highest among others.
Name
of bank
State
bank of
India
Punjab
national
Bank
Bank of
Baroda
ICICI
Bank
Canara
Bank
HDFC
Bank
IDBI
Bank
Credit
portfolio
(Rs.Bn)
-Mar
2011
7565
Market NIM
shares Mar(%)
2011
Tier
I RONW
capital( (%)
%)
Mar2011
18
2.9
7.8
13
Gross
NPA
(%)
Mar2011
3.3
2421
3.5
8.4
24
1.8
2287
2.8
10.0
24
1.4
2164
2.3
13.2
10
4.5
2125
2.6
10.9
26
1.5
1600
4.2
12.2
17
1.1
1571
1.8
8.1
16
1.8
46
Axis
1424
Bank
Central 1297
Bank of
India
Bank of 2131
India
3.1
9.4
19
1.1
2.7
6.4
18
2.2
2.5
8.3
17
2.2
Composition of deposit
120
100
80
Term deposit
CASA
60
40
20
0
PSBs
OPRBs
NPRBs
Deposits of Borrowings
47
FBs
120
100
80
borrowings
deposits
60
40
20
0
PSBs
OPRBs
NPRBs
FBs
800
600
400
200
0
FY06
FY07
FY08
FY09
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
48
Sales
Foreign Banks
Private sector bank
Government Controlled bank
49
CHAPTER 5
SUGGESTIONS:
There are some suggestions derived from the doing the analytical study of the
financial performance of the selected banks. As such this chapter offer new
suggestions for the increasing profitability and proper capital structure decision
of banking industry in India.
The return on equity for private sector banks is less than that of public
sector banks. So, researcher may suggest to private sector banks to
improve their profitability. Thus private sector banks are required to
increase their profit after tax to satisfy the share holders with adequate
return.
In private sector banks return on long term fund found poor as compared
to public sector banks. It is necessary for the private sector banks to
50
utilize their long term fund very effectively to generate enough return. So,
as they can compete to public sector banks.
An appropriate mix of capital structure should be adopted in order to
increase the profitability of banks.
In the case of higher debt, profitability will tend to decline. The reason
behind this may be due to the high interest bearing securities engaged in
the total debt.
Banks should concern much on internal sources of financing in order to
increase their profitability.
51
Asset Reconstruction Fund to take over from banks the bad and doubtful
debts at a discount deserves to be implemented
The attitudes of bankers should be more customers oriented than
procedure oriented. More flexible business hours, evening counters,
bright and comfortable banking halls and well informed staff, information
brochures and regular contacts, all of which will have to be given due
attention to improve customer services.
Appropriate use of technology for improvement the quality of customer
service and ensuring efficiency in operations is crucial for the effective
functioning of banks in emerging competitive environment. There is a
need for improving and upgrading work technology to cope up with the
growing volume of business transactions. The present program of branch
computerization is largely confined to metropolitan and urban branches
only. The feasibility of extending this facility to other growing banking
centers has to be explored.
The process of any reforms in banking system cannot gather momentum
without evolving reforms in the area of Human Resource Development.
Overstaffing, over unionization and rigid frame work of promotions and
transfers, also lack of effective leadership are the principal contributory
factors to the disquieting trend in Personal Management. Thus, the policy
should be redefined to making the employees committed to the
organization and to the changes that are taking place and to face the
future challenges as a cohesive team.
Considering pros and cons of privatization, the case for privatizing
Indian Banking seems to be strong. While privatization is theoretically
the desired policy option. In reality, privatization of banks has proven to
be difficult, making the end point unclear. The problem of political
opposition of privatization has no short cut solution in a democracy and
can only be solved over time through consensus building.
52
CONCLUSION
This study examines the impact of privatization on bank performance and
efficiency using data of banks in India for the five-year period 1998-2002.
Statistical analysis was performed using the difference of means test for three
groups of banks partially privatized, fully state14 owned, and those already in
the private sector. Partially privatized banks have performed better as compared
to the fully public sector banks in respect of certain financial performance and
efficiency parameters. Partially privatized banks also seem to be catching up
with the banks already in the private sector. No significant performance or
efficiency difference was seen in these two cohorts of banks. Overall, going by
the results of this study, partially privatized banks have continued to show
improved performance and efficiency in the years after privatization. In several
countries, post-privatization outcomes were far from satisfactory. However,
Indias partial privatization, as shown by this study, appears to have resulted in
positive outcomes. Prior studies suggested that partial privatization fails to
produce any improvement in performance and that mixed state private firms
often do worse than fully state-owned companies (Boardman and Vining, 1989).
The results of this study, like those of fundamental. (1997), contrast with these
findings and could be of interest to researchers. The Government of India is
53
already considering a measure to bring down its stake further to 33 per cent.
Given the positive outcome of partial privatization so far, further dilution of the
stakes may help. When compared with the privatization strategies worldwide, it
seems that the Indian strategy of gradual privatization has succeeded. It is
different from some other countries like Mexico where hasty privatization led to
serious problems. Also, while IPOs, as a means to privatization, succeeded in
India due to a well developed capital market, it did not in Polands case of Bank
Slaski. Appropriate changes in the regulatory and supervisory regimes also
helped a smoother transition and avoided financial crisis in India that some
other countries had to face.
1) Private Sector Banks profitability is much higher than that of Public Sector
Banks.
2) The economic liberalization measures introduced by the Indian government
coupled with trends towards globalization have substantially altered the banking
sector and the profitability of public sector banks has declined to a large extent.
So Public Sector Banks will have to introduce new financial instruments and
innovations in order to remain in business.
3) It is clear from the analysis that the public sector banks are less profitable
than the private sector banks in terms of overall profitability.
4) All these developments in Indian banking are says that, the Indian banks are
moving towards modern banking changing a face of traditional banking of
Indian economy .It is grate change of banking industry. They having a installing
an information technology for 191 banking business and they trying to provide
technology based banking products and services to their customers.
5) Indian banks also trying to Universalization of banking products and services
to one top banking shop for customer delight, but comparatively private and
foreign banks existing in Indian economy are having a higher level of
54
55
QUESTIONNAIRE
QUESTIONNAIRE CUSTOMERS PREFERENCE FOR PUBLIC
AND PRIVATE SECTOR BANK
Sex (M/F):
Area (Rural/Urban):
Age:
15-30 years:
30-45 years:
45-60 years:
Above 65 years:
a) Yes
b) No
Q4. How often do you visit your bank?
a) Weekly
b) 2-3 times in a week
c) Monthly
d) Any other
Q5. Which banking sector services do you avail?
a) Public sector
b) Private sector
c) Both
Q6. Which type of account do you have in public and private sector banks?
a) Savings account
b) Current account
c) Fixed deposits
d) Any other
Q7. Have you ever availed loan facility from your bank?
a) Yes
b) No
If Yes, then answer following questions:
57
a) Oneself
b) Broker
c) Market Research
d) Friends/ Relatives
e) An Other
Q. 12 Are you using mobile Banking service offered by Bank?
a) Yes
b) No
Q.13 Are you aware of all the accounts provided by your Bank?
a) Yes
b) No
Q.14 Can you tend to buy gold form your bank by the way of pure gold
investment opportunity?
a) Yes
b) No
Q.15 Are you aware of home insurance facilities provide by our bank?
a) Yes
b) No
Webliography
59
www.google.com
www.scribd.com
60