ABSTRACT
Since the majority of the innovative trends in automotive
industry today are based in advanced electronics
technology, mastering the EMI (Electromagnetic
Interference) between embedded electronic subsystem and
the EMC (Electromagnetic Compatibility) features of a
vehicle in its early design phase becomes one of the crucial
technical challenges faced by all automotive manufacturers.
Even if all electronic subsystems in a vehicle are validated
under the EMC standards, the integration between them
may create numerous points of potential hazards that affects
the total electromagnetic behavior of the entire system,
hazards that can be detected only once the first complete
prototype is available, and whose resolution at this phase of
the process is very time consuming and expensive. This
paper presents the state of the art regarding electromagnetic
numerical analysis using Ansoft HFSS (High Frequency
Structure Simulator) tool and a parallel HPC (High
Performance Computing) consisting of numerous computer
nodes connected to a network. An application of this
approach to a vehicle modeling is presented. Adaptations to
CAD (Computer Aided Design) models are proposed in
order to improve CAE (Computer Aided Engineering)
analysis and save computer effort with the objective to
reach a correct level of industrial efficiency. EMI between
subsystems are investigated using field solvers and a SI
(Signal Integrity) analysis is performed in a wiring harness
transmitting a random CAN J1939 standard signal. A
complete analysis on EMI and EMC properties is
performed, and a conclusion concerning the practical use of
INTRODUCTION
The amount of electronics content in vehicles has been
increasing significantly during the last years, and the
prevision is to keep rising in the future specially with the
development of hybrid vehicles. The economical emergent
market largely mentioned in the media today (comprised by
Brazil, Russia, India and China - BRIC) is the main target
for almost all automotive companies. It is expected that the
BRIC countries will be responsible for approximately 72%
of total automotive global share by 2013. Although the
vehicles of such countries are classified as A and/or B entry
cars, their EEA (Electrical and Electronic Architecture) is
becoming more complex due to the increasing customer
demand for advanced multimedia and infotainment features.
Today the value of electronics in a medium sized vehicle
represents about 35% of the total vehicle cost. The increase
in vehicle electronic components and modules has occurred
not only in ECU (Electronic Control Units) and operational
systems for the vehicle itself, but also in mobile
communications, navigation, information, security and
entertainment devices.
In light of this automotive electronic expansion it is crucial
that the multiple ECUs in a vehicle are electromagnetically
compatible and do not interfere in external devices [1-8].
The EMC of vehicles has been a global consideration for
much longer than most commercial EMC standards have
existed. Unfortunately, the electromagnetic behavior of the
x y z
u u u
x y z
J=
x y z
w w w
(1)
ELECTROMAGNETIC ANALYSIS
The finite element method (FEM) is a very well established
numerical technique employed to solve electromagnetic
problems [10-16]. The application of this method is for a
general purpose and does not restrict any geometry or
material. Using the FEM model displayed in figure 2, one
jr H tan G + Etan G +
ds (3)
E ( x, y, z ) =
S Enormal G
G=
exp( jk r r ) r r
4 r r
(4)
Figure 4. 3106 Horn antenna gain pattern. Inset graph shows the
3D radiation pattern.
(5)
Where Aii, xi and bi, i=1,2 are the matrix system, the
solution vector and the right hand solution for domain i,
respectively; and A12, A21 are the coupling matrices
between the two domains. To solve in parallel sub-domain
problems, one popular domain decomposition algorithm is
of Jacobi type:
A11 A12 A11 0 0 A12
A
=
+
(6)
A11 0 x1
b1 0 A12 x1
0 A x = b A
22 2
2 21 0 x 2
(7)
( )
= b1 A12 x 2
( 1 )
A22 x 2
( )
= b2 A21 x1
( 1 )
(8)
-1
Figure 12. Eye diagrams for the cases: a) cell phone on; and b) cell
phone on and the output power multiplied by 5.
SUMMARY
We have addressed a detailed numerical methodology
capable of simulating very large field problems with the use
of domain decomposition technique supported by high
performance computing.
An anechoic chamber
environment with a real horn antenna and a Fiat Punto door
have been simulated at 200MHz and 1GHz using HPC and
DDM by having the entire model spit into four subdomains, which in turn was calculated on four different
computers connected to a high speed network. It has also
been shown a methodology that enables design engineers to
proactively reduce EMI issues on automotive embedded
system. A dynamic link between electromagnetics, PCB and
circuit simulation, allows a complete analysis, with actual
signals that are used by automotive protocols, leading to
very accurate results, independently of the complexity and
size of the geometries being evaluated. The interference of
the cell phone in a wiring harness carrying a CAN J1939
signal was also evaluated. Through the use of statistical
tools, it is possible to verify that the cell phone radiation
reduces the signal integrity, leading to an increase in the bit
detection error probability. The numerical methodology
presented herein can be employed to predict any intrasystem
interactions, optimizing test time and reducing costs through
virtual prototyping and above all, increasing the safety of
vehicles.
REFERENCES
1. L. Alvarenga et al., "Correlation between EMC
Measurements of vehicle tests made in: Standard Semianechoic Chamber and of Reduced Dimensions.", SAE
Technical Paper 2007-01-2598, 2007.
2. J. Mologni et al., "A Time-Frequency Domain Analysis
of Crosstalk Phenomenon on LIN / CAN Based
Architectures", SAE Technical Paper 2008-36-0046,
2008.
3. A. Rubinstein, F. Rachidi and M. Rubinstein, "On wiregrid representation of solid metallic surfaces", IEEE
Transactions on EMC, Vol. 47, No. 1, February 2005,
pp. 192-195.
4. A.R. Ruddle, X. Ferrires, J.P. Parmantier and D.D.
Ward, " Experimental validation of time-domain
electromagnetic models for field coupling into the
interior of a vehicle from a nearby broadband antenna",
Special Issue on Computational Electromagnetics, Vol.
156, No. 6, November 2004, pp. 430-433.
5. X. Ferrires, J.P. Parmantier, S. Bertuol and A.R.
Ruddle, "Application of a hybrid finite difference/finite
volume method to solve an automotive EMC problem";
IEEE Transactions on EMC, Vol. 46, No. 4, November
2004, pp. 624-634.
6. A.R. Ruddle, J.P. Parmantier, X. Ferrires and D.D.
Ward, "Experimental validation of time-domain
electromagnetic models for field coupling into the
interior of a vehicle from a nearby broadband antenna",
IEE International Conference on Computation in
Electromagnetics CEM2004, Stratford-upon-Avon,
September 2004, Proceedings pp. 133-134.
7. A. Gnsaya, D. Smythe and A.R. Ruddle, "Whole
vehicle electromagnetic modeling: developments and
applications", ERA Conference on Vehicle Electronic
Systems, Birmingham, UK, September 2003.
8. A. Rubinstein, F. Rachidi, M. Rubinstein and B.
Reusser, "A parallel implementation of NEC for the
analysis of large structures", IEEE Transactions on
EMC, Special Issue on Numerical Modeling, Vol. 45,
No. 2, May 2003, pp. 177-188.
9. J. F. Mologni, M. A. R. Alves and E. S. Braga,
Numerical study on performance of pyramidal and
conical isotropic etched single emitters; Microelec.
Journal; vol. 37, 2006; pp. 152-157.
10. A.M. Winslow, Numerical Calculation of
StaticMagnetic Fields in an irregular triangle mesh,
University of California Report, UCRL- 7784, 1964, J.
Comput. Phys. 1, p. 149, 1966
11. P.P. Silvester, High-order polynomial triangular finite
elements for potential problems,, Int. J. Engineering
Science, 7, 849-861, 1969
12. M.V.K. Chari, and P.P. Silvester, Finite Element
Analysis of magnetically saturated dc machines", IEEE
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
CONTACT INFORMATION
Corresponding author:
Juliano Fujioka Mologni
ESSS - Engineering Simulation & Scientific Software
Rua do Rocio 423 Suite 1001, 04552-000, Vila Olmpia,
So Paulo - SP, Brazil
juliano.mologni@esss.com.br
Leonardo Alvarenga Lopes Santos
Fiat Automveis S.A.
Rodovia Ferno Dias, km 429, CEP 32530-000 Betim
MG
leonardo.alvarenga@fiat.com.br
DEFINITIONS/ABBREVIATIONS
3D
THREE DIMENSION
AM
AMPLITUDE MODULATION
BRIC
BRASIL, RUSSIA, INDIA AND CHINA
CAD
COMPUTER AIDED DESIGN
CAE
COMPUTER AIDED ENGINEERING
CAN
CONTROLLER AREA NETWORK
DDM
DOMAIN DECOMPOSITION METHOD
EEA
ELECTRICAL ELECTRONIC ARCHITECTURE
ECU
ELECTRONIC CONTROL UNIT
EMC
ELECTROMAGNETIC COMPATIBILITY
EMI
ELECTROMAGNETIC INTERFERENCE
FM
FREQUENCY MODULATION
GPS
GLOBAL POSITIONING SYSTEM
HFSS
HIGH FREQUENCY STRUCTURE SIMULATOR
HPC
HIGH PERFORMANCE COMPUTING
RAM
RANDOM ACCESS MEMORY
SI
SIGNAL INTEGRITY
PCB
PRINTED CIRCUIT BOARD