Jan
Ader
Please dont leave me
Contents
Foreword
25
29
31
34
74
86
88
106
114
132
136
143
149
157
Biography
171
Authors
173
Colophon
174
Foreword
Thirty years after Bas Jan Ader failed to return from a solo crossing of the Atlantic, the interest in his work
continues to grow. In less than ten years he created some thirty-five works of art in which falling, physical and
emotional vulnerability and mortality are the central themes. Aders early work could be comic. For his graduation in 1967 he produced a poster showing him sitting in a wicker chair on the roof of his house in Los Angeles
smoking a cigar, surrounded by cartoon depictions of clouds. The serious films and photo works he made
several years later, in which he bursts into tears, or falls off his roof or out of a tree, are harrowing, moving and
unforgettable. Bas Jan Ader left behind a small, intriguing and important oeuvre.
A premature death, a small oeuvre, a good deal of travelling and many years spent abroad these are not generally the conditions whereby an artist makes his name. However, through the eloquence of his work and the
impression Ader made on his contemporaries; the efforts of Paul Andriesse, who began to publish on Ader in
1986, and Christopher Mller, whose catalogue appeared in 2000, Aders oeuvre is more tangible and better
known than ever. Bas Jan Ader may not have proved immortal, his work is proving otherwise.
In 1992 Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen bought eight photo works from the period spanning 1969-1972
from his estate. This was one of the museums most important acquisitions of the decade and one that fits
beautifully amongst the museums Surrealist collection. There are frequent requests to borrow the works. To
coincide with his retrospective exhibition at Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen we are proud to publish this
book as a contribution to the ongoing research into Bas Jan Aders work. In order to underline his significance
in 2006 we have invited an artist, two critics and two curators to write about the artist. In addition each work
has been meticulously described and contextualised with the help of information gleaned from conversations,
correspondence, new biographical and bibliographical research and archives that have until now remained
inaccessible or unknown.
I would like to extend my thanks to the Camden Arts Centre for its collaboration and to Mary Sue AderAndersen, Erik Ader, Adriaan van Ravesteijn of Galerie Art & Project, Ger van Elk, Rene Daalder and Daniel
Congdon of Patrick Painter Editions for their unstinting support in this project.
Sjarel Ex
Director Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen
It was to be an adventurous voyage and the middle section of a grand trilogy of works entitled In search of the
miraculous. For Bas Jan Ader (Winschoten, 1942) it was also to be an attempt at breaking the world record for
a single-handed crossing of the Atlantic in the smallest craft to date, a mere four metres in length; sponsors
1
for the project, however, had not been forthcoming. Was this hubris? He was to depart from Cape Cod,
which sounds not too dissimilar to God.
2
At two o clock in the afternoon on 9 July 1975 he sailed out of the harbour. His wife Mary Sue remained
ashore to photograph the boat until it disappeared on the horizon. One of the photographs appeared in
Bulletin no.89, designed by Bas Jan, issued by the Amsterdam-based gallery Art & Project. A day before his
departure he had sent a card to the gallerys owners Geert van Beijeren and Adriaan van Ravesteijn: See
3
you in 8-10 weeks. Bas Jan. This was his final message. He was spotted by fishermen sixty miles out to sea
4
and was later sighted again near the Azores. He was never seen again.
1. Guppy pocket cruiser measuring 12 feet and 6 inches, without motor.
(Bas Jan Ader dossier), Netherlands Institute for Art History/Rijksbureau voor
2. The postcard that Ader wrote to Art & Project the day before his departure is dated:
8 June 1975. One day later Mary Sue added that he had left at 2.00 p.m. on 9 June.
3. idem
There must be a mistake, which Mary Sue later confirmed. Art & Project archive
He was awaited at the Groninger Museum. An exhibition of the second and third parts of In search of the mirac5
ulous was due to open on 6 December. The first part had been shown earlier that year at the Claire S. Copley
Gallery in Los Angeles, during which a student choir had sung sea shanties to a piano accompaniment, with the
6
lyrics of A life on the ocean wave shown on the wall. There were also eighteen photographs of a nocturnal, flashlit
search that Ader had undertaken in 1973 through Los Angeles, his home since 1963. The search began in a
canyon on the eastern edge of the city and ended at the ocean. Ader had handwritten the lyrics of the
Coasters 1957 hit Searchin in white ink on the black and white photographs. He intended to complete the
trilogy with a night time search through Amsterdam and to present it in Groningen together with the second part
the sea crossing. Once again a student choir would sing shanties against the backdrop of A life on the ocean wave.
Ocean Wave was also the name of his sailing boat, which had been adapted for the cross-Atlantic trip. He
fully expected to arrive safely. The boat was unsinkable and Ader was attached to it by a lifeline.
Furthermore, he was an experienced sailor. In 1962-63 he had already crossed the ocean from Morocco to
7
California on a 15-metre yacht in the company of the crafts owner. It had taken them months and they were
beset with misfortunes; they had withstood a hurricane and endured the doldrums for weeks on end leaving
them with scarcely any food or water. Now Ader was prepared for any eventuality and had stocked the boat
with sufficient provisions for 180 days. No, this did not look like a suicide attempt, as some assumed, or an
extreme form of tempting fate.
What is strange is that Ader would not allow Mary Sue to read any of the accounts of earlier solo crossings
such as that of the American Robert Manry, who sailed from Falmouth, Massachusetts to Falmouth,
8
Cornwall in 1965 in his yacht Tinkerbelle. Ader intended to complete the voyage in an even smaller boat.
Mary Sue was thus oblivious to the hardships that Manry described, such as frequently being thrown overboard
and suffering terrible hallucinations.
Later a book about Donald Crowhurst, who participated in the Sunday Times Golden Globe Race, a non-stop,
9
single-handed, round-the-world yacht race in 1968, was found in Aders locker at the art school where he taught.
During the race Crowhurst had radioed false positions and had in fact never left the Atlantic Ocean. On the
home run he learned that he stood to come second and therefore ran the risk of his fraudulent logbooks
being scrutinised by the judges. Fearing his deceit would be made public, and losing his sanity, he wrote an
incoherent book-length apologia and jumped overboard. The logbooks were later found on his abandoned
yacht. What are we to read into the discovery of the Crowhurst story amongst Aders effects? An omen that
Bas Jan Ader planned to disappear at sea and thus enter mythology?
Mary Sue, now in the Netherlands, waited in vain. The exhibition was cancelled; there was no trace of Ader.
His younger brother Erik, also a passionate yachtsman who would later sail around the world, attempted to track
4. This essay makes use of information from an as yet unpublished manuscript about
the exhibition slides of the performance were projected and a recording of the singers
Bas Jan Ader by Koos Dalstra & Marion van Wijk, which will be published in the two
was played.
following books: Dalstar & Van Wijk, TMC/14-76, Veenman Publishers, April 2006
7. On 26 October 1962 the newspaper Nieuwsblad van het Noorden published a travel
and Dalstar & Van Wijk, Ocean wave, Bas Jan Ader, Veenman Publishers, July 2006.
report that Ader sent on 15 September from the Panama Canal. On 6 January 1963
We are grateful to be able to refer to the following chapters and page numbers in the
the Los Angeles Times reported that the yacht was towed into San Diego harbour by a
manuscript: I p. 11, II p. 22, III p. 40, p. 41, V p. 59, VII p. 101, p. 103, p. 117, p. 118,
naval ship.
5. The exhibition was originally planned for the autumn. Finally it was to take place in
9. Nicholas Tomalin and Ron Hall, The strange last voyage of Donald Crowhurst,
London, 1970.
6. The choir performed at the opening of the exhibition. Throughout the duration of
10
him down. But to no avail. Mary Sue informed Aders mother, concerned about her sons fate, that in the region
11
where Bas Jan had been sailing that summer there was talk of a complete lack of winds for some eighty days.
On 18 April 1976 Spanish fishermen came across Aders boat, largely under water, 150 miles west south west
of Ireland. The mast, handrails, the self-steering mechanism and a hatch that had been specially sealed for
the journey, were all missing. The lifeline, by which Ader was secured to the boat, appeared to have been
roughly yanked free. The algae growth and barnacles on the boat suggest that it had lain in this position for
approximately six months, so that it must have capsized mid-October. The fishermen took the boat back to
12
their homeport, La Corua, where a local newspaper published an article with a photograph of the wreck.
Mary Sue was informed and travelled to La Corua with the artists brother. The harbour authorities concluded
that there had been an explosion on board, but Erik Ader doubted this. Based on the information they supplied,
he surmised that the boat had been hit sidelong by a wave that had carried Bas Jan, lifeline and all, overboard. He knew that this could have happened because of a construction fault he had noticed when the boat
was being made seaworthy. However, he could not prove it since, in the meantime, the boat too had been
lost. All that remained were Aders soaked identity papers, a plastic sextant, a pair of sunglasses and a waterdamaged camera. What had happened on board remains a mystery.
Following the discovery, and subsequent loss, of the wreck, Bas Jans mother a religious minister and writer
wrote in a pastoral letter to her parish: I sensed it already on an early Sunday morning in October when I
received a telepathic message and a poem welled up in me, in English, the language that I often used with
13
Basjan and in which we corresponded, so that Mary Sue could read it too. I shall give it to you, but you
must be satisfied that this shall be the only mention I make of it. I cannot talk about it. This is the poem that
came to her on Sunday 12 October 1975:
From the deep waters of sleep
From the deep waters of sleep I wake up to consciousness.
In the distance I hear a train rumbling in the early morning.
It is going East and passes the border. Then it will stop.
I feel my heart beating too. It will go on beating for some time.
Then it will stop.
I wonder if the little heart that has beaten with mine, has stopped.
When he passed the border of birth, I laid him at my breast,
Rocked him in my arms.
He was very small then.
10. Erik Ader was a crewmember on a boat that participated in the Whitbread Round
lifejacket was found. All evidence points to the Ocean Wave having only a single
crewmember, who wished to cross the Atlantic Ocean, was surprised by a storm and
11. Moeder Ader in Drieborg bezorgd over haar zoon. Kunstenaar spoorloos op
12. La Voz de Galicia, 29 April 1976: A torn US flag was found in the cabin, but no
falling but also the historical dispute between Mondrian, who worked only with
vertical and horizontal lines, and Theo van Doesburg, who admitted the dynamic
of the diagonal in his work.
In fact most of the works concern falling, even those where this is not immediately
obvious such as the film and photograph Im too sad to tell you, 1970 in which Ader
is seen crying. Is this a reference to the Man of sorrows the weeping Christ
a common theme in mediaeval painting? Nonetheless, falling is also the central
theme here, as Ader himself admitted, for the tears stream down his face.
Ader plays with the phonetic and conceptual similarities of the words fall and fail.
The comic aspect of the fall is central to slapstick, circus clowning and commercial televisions obsession with
pratfalls in home movies. The laughter response to the fall is one of relief. From the moment we learn to walk,
the possibility of falling is humiliating. But is also a primal fear of giving in unwillingly to the force of gravity.
It was not for nothing that the images of people falling from the burning twin towers of the World Trade Center
were so heart stopping. In history, mythology and the Bible, the fall is often synonymous with ruination, the
end: pride comes before a fall, kingdoms and empires fall, cities fall, the fall of Icarus, the Fall of Lucifer, the
Fall of Man.
As the son of preachers, Ader would have been fully conversant with the biblical significance of the Fall. In one
15
of his notebooks from 1968 there is a scribbled note about the fall of the walls of Jericho. But falling must
also have had a traumatic personal meaning for him. He was two and a half years old when his father, a key figure
in a network of resistance fighters helping to hide Jewish families, was arrested. A day before the resistance
had planned to set him free he was transferred to a notorious prison in Amsterdam, where he was interrogated
and severely mistreated. Soon afterwards the resistance attacked a group of German soldiers and in retaliation
six prisoners, including Bas Jan Aders father, were shot dead by a firing squad. Ader, who was named after his
father and who was supposed to follow in his footsteps as a preacher, must often have recalled his fathers
death, particularly during the official two minutes silence each year on 4 May for those who lost their lives in
16
the Second World War.
In 1972, in an interview about falling and his fathers death, he said: I have always been fascinated by the tragic.
15. The fall of Jericho quite literally 'Jericho' painted or in letters falling (en) off a wall...
Note in one of Aders notebooks, quoted by Brad Spence in the catalogue for Aders
exhibition at the Art Gallery, University of California, Irvine (25 February 20 March
1999). Other noteworthy remarks are: Greeting from beautiful Ader Falls;
All is Falling; Rolling into a freshly dug grave; I can think around corners; Whole series
of photographs on dead in ocean, being washed ashore. My body practicing having
been drowned; The sea, the land, the artist has with great sadness known they too
will be no more.
16. Bastiaan Jan Ader was shot by firing squad on 20 November 1944 in the Schupse
Bos near Rhenen. He was arrested together with two German deserters and a Jew on
their way to a new hiding place. (Johanna Adriana Ader-Appels, Een Groninger pastorie
in de storm, Amsterdam 1945).
That is also contained in the act of falling; the fall is failure. Someone once said to me: I can well imagine
that you are so obsessed with the fall; thats because your father was shot. That is obviously a far too anecdotal
interpretation. Everything is tragic because people always lose control of processes, of matter, of their feelings.
17
That is a much more universal tragedy, and that cannot be visualised from an anecdote. Ader later distanced
18
himself from this interview: so many misunderstandings and factual inaccuracies. Nonetheless the passage
gives some insight into his motifs and reinforces statements in earlier interviews. The constant in his work is
his striving for universal images, which communicate directly and which transcend their physical form. Even
if formally his work was very diverse, this was always his aim.
In 1961 the 19-year-old Ader exhibited an ink drawing in Washington DC and was given a glowing review in
19
The Washington Post. He was interviewed by The Voice of America and some of his works were sold;
Jacqueline Kennedy is said to have bought a drawing. He was a sensation. The Dutch press reported the story
and back in Holland Ader was interviewed by reporters. He told one journalist, in English: Painting is like
making love, and then continued in Dutch, Dont translate that with sex because that has too cheap a connotation. The journalist found him unbearable: And who could blame this 19-year-old youngster with his
short hair combed forward and his seamans jumper and jeans for being so full of himself? He is so selfassured as to be almost conceited. In his Groninger Dutch, but with an American accent, he makes severe
statements such as: I am not a Groninger and I am not a Dutchman, but neither am I an American or anything else. I am Basjan. I dont want to be anything except Basjan myself. He paints exclusively in black,
white and grey because: I dont like that trickery with pretty colours. I want to be as honest as possible and do
20
not need colours to represent my ideas. He came across as a disarming braggart, but was very serious about
21
his work: I believe that limiting my materials spurs me on to a more honest expression. Even then he was
aiming for the essence of things. With the money from his sales he planned to spend a year in isolation studying
and painting. Had the search for the miraculous already begun?
But how had he actually come to be in Washington D.C. in the first place? Before that Ader lived with his
mother and younger brother Erik in Nieuw-Beerta in a remote corner of eastern Groningen. They were close
to Drieborg (where they would later relocate), the neighbourhood of Hongerige Wolf (literally Hungry Wolf),
five kilometres or so from the harbour town of Statenzijl aan de Dollard (which discharges into the North Sea)
and not far from the German border. He frequently played truant, preferring to accompany the prawn fishers
on the Waddenzee.
As an unmanageable 14-year-old he was sent to a foster home and then to a boarding school. He had to repeat
several years and did not complete his secondary education. Nonetheless he was admitted to the Instituut
voor Kunstnijverheidsonderwijs in Amsterdam (since 1967 the Gerrit Rietveld Academie). The artist Ger van
Elk, who made Aders acquaintance at the college and remained a good friend, has said that Ader did curious
22
things. For example, he used the same sheet of paper for all his drawing assignments, simply erasing one
17. Betty van Garrel, Bas Jan Aders tragiek schuilt in een pure val, Haagse Post, 5
president..., The Washington Post, 23 April 1961, p. 6. The Dutch press was informed
via a cultural bulletin from the United States Information Service on 19 April 1961.
18. Letter from Bas Jan Ader to Poul ter Hofstede, 20 August 1974, Groninger
20. Bob Nahuisen, Amerika bracht Basjan (19) uit Groningen onverwacht succes, Het
19. Stephen S. Rosenfeld, Dutch artist, 18, molds philosophy and jazz, The
21. Bas Jan Ader exposeert in Verenigde Staten. Zoon van het Groningse land,
Washington Post, 22 April 1961, p. 34; Leslie Judd Ahlander, If an art critic were
drawing and starting another. After some time the paper was wafer thin. In response to a project to make a threedimensional object, Ader stuck one brick on top of another with some mortar. At the presentation he lifted
the top brick, allowing the lower one to fall to the floor. He did not complete the course.
In 1961, back from Washington, he told a journalist with some self-assurance: I found the course too slow.
23
I had the feeling that I had more to offer and so I sought a different route. But in fact he had been unlucky
in everything until now and so sought a way out. He contacted an American student exchange programme,
the International Christian Youth Exchange, which placed him with a guest family (the family of one of the
24
sons of the architect Frank Lloyd Wright) in Bethesda, Maryland, a suburb of Washington D.C. He attended
the Walter Johnson High School where he mainly followed art classes. One of his teachers was so impressed
with his talent for drawing that he arranged for Ader to have his own studio and also for him to exhibit at
Galerie Realit and the Capitol Hill Community for Fine Arts.
In 1961 instead of painting and drawing in isolation, as he had proposed to do, he travelled to Spain and
Morocco. From there he set sail for California at the beginning of 1962 with Neil Tucker Burcket on the latters
yacht Felicidad. After a journey of eleven months they arrived in California, in January 1963. Ader was reacquainted with Ger van Elk, who was studying art history at the Immaculate Heart College, where Ader also took
some classes. After passing some supplementary exams he was accepted at the Otis Art Institute in Los Angeles.
In 1965 he earned his Bachelor of Fine Arts and then continued his studies at the Claremont Graduate School.
He seemed to have found his stride. In the same year he married his girlfriend Mary Sue Andersen in Las Vegas
and walked on crutches during the ceremony as a joke. Was this to signify that he had sustained an injury
whilst falling for Mary Sue?
In 1967 he gained his Master of Fine Arts with his project Implosion. Although the work was visually very distinct
from his later work, falling was already the central theme even if subsidiary themes such as spatial relationships also played a part. The presentation consisted of three components: two large constructions of wood,
linen and paint that almost entirely filled the exhibition space; six smaller works and a book with spreads
25
comprising stories or poems on one page and offsett lithographic drawings on the facing page. On the cover
in large letters is written: What does it mean? Cheep Cheep and above that in smaller letters, What Makes
me so pure, Almost holy? And more. Above the text is a self-portrait of Ader. Is this ironic self-canonisation?
The drawings were made in a loose figurative style, fashionable at the time. Stars and stripes suggest the
26
influence of Pop Art. In his masters thesis Ader described the exhibition as an environment. In it he wished to
investigate the meanings of fall and its complement rise, purely visually and formally as well as intrinsically
and thematically. He made the following subdivision: Rise and fall; Part and whole; Real and illusionary.
The categories for Rise and fall were:
1 Humpty Dumpty fall guy the egg suspended above the sky, and the use of the
bicycle before and after its unexplained misfortune.
2 Sue Falls table your feelings the congratulatory letter to the Eiffel Tower
and the leaning table, about to be sawed through, which contains this letter.
22. Rene Daalder, Here is always somewhere else, documentary film, VPRO, Hilversum
2006.
25. Published by Claremont Colleges Printing Service, Claremont Graduate School and
23. Bob Nahuisen, Amerika bracht Basjan (19) uit Groningen onverwacht succes, Het
26. Aders masters thesis, 1967, Claremont Graduate University archive, Claremont,
24. Information from correspondence with Emil Hrebenach, who taught Ader at the
California.
3 Plan for a dangerous journey and Niagara Falls both pieces partly laid out
on the floor, but the canvas in Plan for a dangerous journey becoming sucked up in
the construction while the canvas in Niagara Falls spills out from it.
These are complex statements, with the same surreal tone as the texts (poems) in the book. Thematically the
works, such as Plan for a dangerous journey and Niagara Falls, share Aders later preoccupations. Visually the
works are quite different: paintings, objects, linen and paint become performances; films and photographs
are condensed (or is imploded a better term?) into handwritten statements.
The project also included a poster with a photograph of Ader sitting on a chair on the ridge of the roof of his
house in Claremont. He smokes a thick cigar. Behind him and to his right are painted clouds. It is a little
comic, like Pop Art. The title is The artist contemplating the forces of nature. Three years later, in 1970, this
contemplation would lead to his taking up position once again on his roof, seating himself in his chair and
then giving himself up to the forces of nature and falling, chair and all, from the roof. His first fall film. What
had happened since 1967 that his style should alter so radically?
The artist contemplating the forces of nature is a title that Ader took very seriously. After his masters he did not
immediately continue to make art, but decided to think about it and opted to study philosophy from 1967 to
1969. He fell under the influence of the German philosopher Georg Hegel (17701831), whose 1807 book The
phenomenology of mind Ader later took with him on his final voyage. Perhaps the riddle of his disappearance, if
this was intentional, lies hidden in this book. It is a complex discussion of the development from soul to mind
and discovery of the absolute and true knowledge with the aim of becoming at one with it, which corresponds
with the notion that that which someone attempts to know is actually himself, in which the I frees him from
his natural limitations and elevates him to the realms of the universal.
Is this comparable with his giving himself up to the forces of nature, to which Ader aspires in his fall works?
Perhaps it explains his mysterious descriptions of these works: Like gravity, the artists body makes itself its
own master. His sea voyage, which his brother characterised as the ultimate search for the metaphysical
was also a surrender to the elements. The insignificance he felt in relation to nature fascinated him. In an
undated text fragment he wrote: I really love Los Angeles. I love the surrounding wilderness of ocean, desert
and mountains. I feel belittled by its enormous scale, I value more than anyone the solitary beauty of the
Freeways by night. Even disasters, enormous bushfires and earthquakes have strengthened my attachment to
the city rather than chased me away. I must admit to being fascinated by the constant threat that nature has over
27
us here. I love this wild romantic metropolis of extremes. Could this feeling of insignificance and sense
of threat have lain at the basis of his mysterious performance Light vulnerable objects threatened by eight
cement bricks in 1970? Breezeblocks hang from ropes above vulnerable objects including eggs, light bulbs, a
boxed birthday cake and a portrait. Ader systematically cuts through each of the ropes with a Stanley knife,
flattening the objects below. Ader shares this sense of mans fragility in relation to the overwhelming
grandeur of the forces of nature with the German landscape painter and Hegels contemporary Caspar David
Friedrich (17741840). Some of Aders works are similar to those of Friedrich, even if they employ different
media. One such work is a colour photograph from 1971 in which Ader stands alone at sunset on a bay. The
composition clearly refers to Friedrichs work, but Ader intensifies the emotion with the text: Farewell to
faraway friends.
27. Text fragment by Bas Jan Ader, probably autumn 1974. See: Paul Andriesse, Bas Jan
Ader, een persoonlijke ontwikkeling, Jong Holland, vol. 2, no. 1, March 1986, pp. 20-21.
Hegel also discusses the limitations of language. This became a hot topic in the Conceptual Art of the 1960s,
in which language often had equal weight with the image or replaced it entirely. Between 1967 and 1970
Ader developed into a conceptual artist and immersed himself in the philosophical linguistics of Ludwig
Wittgenstein (1889-1951). Is there a relationship between Aders fall works and Wittgensteins opening proposition from the Tractatus Logico Philosophicus: Die Welt ist alles was der Fall ist (The world is everything
that is the case)? Aders interest in the many different meanings of the word fall was fed by many sources,
such as the 1957 play All that fall by Samuel Beckett (1906-1989) and another existentialist work La chute
(The fall) of 1956 by Albert Camus (1913-1960). That this latter book is set in Amsterdam possibly furnished
the inspiration to complete In search of the miraculous in the Dutch capital. And then there is the 1960s
Californian scene with its penchant for the occult and the cosmic. Ader was certainly no hippy, but he did
read the books of their favourite philosopher, the Russian mystic Petyr Demianovich Ouspensky (1878-1947),
possibly to test his metaphysical thought against that of Hegel. In any case the title In search of the miraculous
is borrowed from Ouspenskys book about his conversations with his guru Georges Ivanovich Gurdjieff
28
(1872?-1949).
In 1969 Ader began to teach art history, bringing about a change in his work; his wife Mary Sue was also a
lecturer in art history. Ader now positioned himself in relation to other artists. He immersed himself in the work
of Marcel Duchamp (1887-1968) and concluded that each conceptual art work should be an improvement on
29
Duchamp. It was typical of Aders ambitions for a new art that he believed that it should surpass Duchamp.
It is also a crying shame that he was unable to complete In search of the miraculous and that his experiments
30
with computers and dancers, on which he was working before his departure, remained at this stage. The
influence of Yves Klein (1928-62) is also unmistakeable in Aders work. In 1960 Klein launched himself from a
high wall and had his balletic flight captured in a photograph. It seems like a source of inspiration for Aders
fall works. Klein believed ultramarine to be the purest colour and produced monochrome works in his patented
International Klein Blue that represented infinity and the immaterial. This too spoke to Ader; mankind as an
insignificant being against the infinity of nature is a theme in his work that, he too, often gave an immaterial
and fleeting form.
Although he never used Kleins blue in his work he rarely worked with colour he wore blue in homage to
him. He even re-sprayed his cars blue, both the Mercedes that he bought with Mary Sue and the (originally red)
Porsche that he drove around Sunset Boulevard, where he had his studio, like a playboy. This was the period just
before his ocean crossing when he had several girlfriends and speculated in natural resources, often losing
31
large sums of money. His friend Ger van Elk is convinced that his risky journey in a small boat across the ocean
32
was connected with this desperate lifestyle. And indeed it cannot be denied that Ader sought danger and
gave himself over to it just as he gave himself over to gravity. With his sea voyage he put his fate in the
33
hands of the overwhelming forces of nature, possibly in a religious longing to be swallowed up by infinity.
28. P. D. Ouspensky, In search of the miraculous, New York 1949.
and have now leased out the Mercedes. In English this business is known as
commodities futures speculation. You buy, for example 100 tons of soybean against
30. Letter from Bas Jan Ader to Poul ter Hofstede, 20 augustus 1974 (Groninger
10-15% of your own money. If the price per pound rises by 50% you double your
money. Art & Project archive (Bas Jan Ader dossier), Netherlands Institute for Art
31. On 29 October 1972 Ader wrote to Geert van Beijeren and Adriaan van
32. Arjen Hoekstra, Het verlangen naar de zee als zienswijze, Zeilen, no. 10, October
metals etc. I have been occupied by this almost day and night for the last few weeks
2000.
Despite having settled in Los Angeles, Ader recognised his position within the Dutch tradition. In 1974 he
wrote the following: To begin at the beginning, I write these words in Dutch, my mother tongue, the language
34
of Rembrandt and Vermeer, Van Gogh and Mondrian. And on a postcard to Art & Project he wrote: I make
modest work. In the films I silently elucidate everything concerning falling. It is a great task, which demands
35
much difficult thought. It becomes poignant, which pleases me. I am a Dutch Master.
His work demonstrates a particular connection with the works of Piet Mondrian (1872-1944). In 1971 he
staged several photo pieces and a film on a lane in Westkapelle, with its famous lighthouse in the background. This is a place loaded with art history. Around 1909, in his paintings of this lighthouse, Mondrian
had separated the primary colours for the first time and so had taken his first steps towards De Stijl and Neo
Plasticism. Ader satirises these first wobbly steps in a series of colour photographs. In the single image Pitfall
on the road to a new Neo Plasticism he falls to the ground carrying a blue blanket and various primary
coloured objects. In the sequence of four photographs On the road to a new Neo Plasticism he lies on the
ground in a position that approximates Mondrians harmony of vertical and horizontal lines. In stages, the
blue blanket appears beneath him like a canvas and then the coloured objects take their places around him.
Aders love of art-historical references resurfaces in a series of watercolours from 1974 whose title Piet niet
(literally Not Piet) refers to Salvador Dal (1904-1989) who, known for his dislike of Piet Mondrian, once
played a word association on his name until he arrived at the negative nomenclature Piet Niet. Another
Mondrian reference is the 21-part photo series Untitled (Flower work) from 1974 showing a vase containing a
mixed bouquet of red, yellow and blue flowers. In three separate sequences of seven photographs Ader adds
and removes flowers until the vase contains only flowers of a single colour.
More light-hearted is the sequence of six photographs from the performance Untitled (Tea party), 1972 in
which Ader is seen in a woodland clearing wearing a smart suit and tie. He crawls under a box, propped up
with a stick, where tea is laid out. When he has drunk his cup of tea, the stick is yanked away and Ader is
trapped under the box. There was more light relief in the 1970 installation, which comprised a compost heap
of earth and 473 copies of the magazine Readers Digest, with the literal title 473 Readers Digests digested.
This is similar to the visual world play of Sawing from 1971 in which Ader saws through the blade of a handsaw
with a circular saw.
During this period Ader also made much more powerful statements such as Nightfall, 1971, a film in which
he holds a heavy concrete paver in one hand and throws it, crushing an illuminated light bulb on the floor.
He repeats the process with the other hand, extinguishing a second light bulb: lights out, fin. This film is
amongst his best works: the bare, unadorned, seemingly negligent, almost casually made grimy black and
white fall films in which the tragic enacts its silent fate; or the photographs of heartrending statements
scrawled on blank white walls, each a cry for help that seems to have been directly inscribed on the retina.
In Germany in 1966 Jrg Immendorff painted Hrt auf zu malen! (literally Stop painting!); his peer Ader,
far away in California, drew the same conclusion and turned to photography and film. He was not alone.
This went hand in hand with the new forms of expression such as performances, Body Art and Land Art;
fleeting and immaterial forms that were captured and immortalised by photography and film, taking the
33. In the middle ages the highest form of pilgrimage was to go to sea in a small boat
35. Postcard from Bas Jan Ader to Geert van Beijeren and Adriaan van Ravesteijn,
and give yourself over to the wind and the waves, thus placing yourself literally in
undated but probably December 1970, Art & Project archive (Bas Jan Ader dossier),
Gods hands. Paul Andriesse, Bas Jan Ader: kunstenaar - artist, Amsterdam 1988, p. 63.
place of the actual work of art. This was the heyday of Conceptual Art,
which in its purest form was expressed simply by means of a text or an idea
and did not require material visualisation. Ader also worked conceptually in
his installation/performance in the Mezzanine Art Gallery at the Nova
Scotia College of Art and Design in Halifax. From California he sent
instructions to the students on how to perform the work and received a
polaroid of the results in return. Thoughts unsaid, then forgotten from 1973
began with a vase of flowers on the floor in front of a wall bearing the
inscription: Thoughts unsaid, then forgotten, illuminated by a lamp. After
a few days the students repainted the wall, obliterating the text. The lamp remained lit for the remainder of
the week, at the end of which the flowers had withered. This decay and the text about forgetting gave the
installation the character of a vanitas work. Text installations are typical of the emphasis on language as a
visual medium within Conceptual Art. Ed Ruscha on the West Coast and Lawrence Weiner on the East Coast
are the most important exponents of this tendency.
Please dont leave me from 1969 was one of Aders first statement pieces. The first of two versions was presented
to several friends and colleagues in Aders studio. His statement pieces were usually presented a single time
and then dismantled and painted over. The only tangible evidence of their short-lived existence were the
photographs Ader made of them, which he published in very limited editions, or which he sent as postcards.
Ader never suggested that reconstructing the original work itself was a legitimate way of representing the work
and this also begs the question whether he saw them as installations at all, or as one-off events. In this respect it
is certainly with some irony that Ader once published carefully written instructions for a do-it-yourself36
happening in the magazine Landslide (1969-70) that he published together with his friend William Leavitt.
Ader received greater recognition in the early 1970s in the Netherlands than he did in California, albeit within
a relatively limited group of art aficionados around the Amsterdam-based gallery Art & Project. This gallery,
to which Ger van Elk introduced him, furnished him with a podium and his work began to be noticed. His
films were included in the travelling exhibition Film als beeldend medium (Film as an artistic medium)
organised by the now defunct Nederlandse Kunst Stichting (Dutch Arts Council). However, he was still to
make his international breakthrough; he was included in the Dutch manifestation Sonsbeek buiten de perken
(Beyond the limits) in 1971, but not in Harald Szeemanns Documenta 5 in 1972. However, the solo exhibition
at the Groninger Museum was on the books and Art & Project also secured him an exhibition in 1972 in
37
Bremerhaven, Germany. Here he delivered a second performance of The boy who fell over Niagara Falls the
38
first was at Art & Project a dramatic story that he read aloud from the magazine Readers Digest. At precisely
determined moments during the reading Ader sipped from a glass of water. The performance ended when
the glass was emptied.
Unlike Ger van Elk, who already had a considerable reputation and had participated in international exhibitions
and manifestations, Ader was still a relatively unknown figure within the Dutch avant-garde of the early
36. At least seven issues of Landslide were published in 1969 and 1970. The DIY
38. The first performance took place at Art & Project in Amsterdam from 15-21 April
1972. Twice per day, at 2.00 pm and 5.00 pm, Ader read the story The boy who
37. In 1972 Ader was the first artist to exhibit at the Kabinett fr Aktuelle Kunst in
plunged over Niagara from the March 1972 edition of Readers Digest. It is the story
Bremerhaven. The director Jrgen Wesseler had seen Aders work at Art & Projects
1970s. Neither did Aders work really fit within the ironising and general arsing around typical of the dynamic
Provo or Neo-Dada art of Wim T. Schippers and Willem de Ridder. His modest films are more closely akin to
the works of the Nul (Zero) group of artists Armando, Jan Hendrikse, Henk Peeters and Jan Schoonhoven
but even amongst them he would have to be considered a loner, the black sheep. Who at the time would have
tipped him as one of the most important artists of his generation? He was just one of many artists making short
films and for many people they were all much of a muchness. That he made them from a very different
philosophical background would be realised only much later; to the early 1970s Dutch mindset, films of
falling into a canal or hanging from a tree could only be, mistakenly, read as ironic. Now we know better.
His falls are of an existential nature, his surrender to gravity is philosophically underpinned and stems
from his personal experience. It is, as such, not simply an artistic statement, but an intrinsic and deeply
felt urge.
Alongside the historical and parallel developments within the visual arts that had an influence on Aders
development, there were also other important sources of inspiration. The motifs in several of Aders work seem
to have been lifted directly from the book his mother wrote about the war years, Een Groninger pastorie in de
39
storm (A Groninger parsonage in the storm). She tells of her life on the parsonage, which was a haven for those
hiding from the Nazis during the occupation, of how her husband was arrested, tortured and then executed,
but also about the infancy of her sons Bas Jan and Erik. The book a bestseller is the key to a better insight
into Aders work. The fall works are related to the fall of his father and to the fact that his mother wished
him to follow in his fathers footsteps, which in a certain sense he did with his impossible journey across the
ocean. But Ader was also influenced by his mother, her love of language, her interest in the spiritual and the
mystic and her preference for the colour blue.
On the very first page of her book, when she is on a train journey to eastern Groningen daydreaming about the
parsonage where she will live, she suddenly says: The kitchen must be blue. Yes, the kitchen must be blue.
Another remarkable passage describes her husbands state of unrest. When she asks what is wrong, he replies
quite simply that he wants to go away. Far away. Where? To Palestine, to Jerusalem. And he went. On his
40
bicycle, even though people thought him mad. Before departing he gave a concert on the church organ, as
his son would later have a student choir to sing before his mad journey. And when his father returned and
was depressed about what he had seen in Nazi Germany, he suggested that they immigrate to America. But
41
she didnt want to. Later, in one of his letters from prison he implored her again to flee to America. She did
not go, but her son did.
Untitled (Sweden), 1971 consists of two slides that Ader made in Sweden. In one Ader stands beside a tree, in
the other he lies on the ground. His father was shot dead in a forest and his mothers book reads: The trees
39. Johanna Adriana Ader-Appels, Een Groninger pastorie in de storm was first
afternoons, he sat at the office of the A.N.W.B. (The Dutch national tourist board).
published in 1945. The sixth edition (1974 published by T. Wever b.v. Franeker)
I want to got to Palestine, he suddenly told me one day. How will you get there?
includes a photograph of the young Bas Jan playing with his father. Mrs Aders
On my bike. He told me his plans with great enthusiasm. I could see half a year of
revenue from book sales was placed in a fund in memory of her husband and was
loneliness before me, but in any case it was wonderful that he dared to undertake
such a journey and he would succeed too even if people said that it was an
40. Idem, p. 336: ...What do you want then? I asked him. But the birds foreign
insane undertaking. Aders father left in 1937 and after visiting Jerusalem returned
migration seems to have entered his veins. I want to go away, far away, he said.
Where then? I dont know. Czechoslovakia or somewhere, but in any case far away.
41. Idem, p. 315: Should I not return, and should Europes prospects remain as dark
Maps were dug out, new maps were bought. Whole mornings, sometimes also whole
42
of the forest stood impassive like the pillars of a cathedral. And when she was
suddenly forced out of her home by the Nazis with barely time to pack anything
she threw as many clothes as possible outside to collect later. It is obvious that
Aders work All my clothes, 1970, in which he photographed all his clothes laid
out on the roof of his house in Claremont, is in some way related to this incident.
There are also countless references to falling and sailing. In the hymnbook that
Aders father was carrying when he was shot, the corner of a page was folded
down; the text read:
Valt hier op aarde
geen mus dan met Uw wille
Heer, dat mijn hart zich met de troost dan stille
Dat Uwe zorg ook mij bewaart.
If here on earth
No sparrow falls, then with Your will
Lord, my heart be comforted and still
That your hand protects me too.
And then the layered lines of his farewell poem:
This must certainly have influenced Ader, particularly because, whilst in California, he was translating his
mothers book into English. He saw his traumatic youth in front of him again. He never finished the translation
and the manuscript has been lost. His mother wrote in her book that when Ader realised that his father
would never return and feared that his mother too would disappear from his life, he asked: Mamma, ga je
44
niet weg?, which he could easily have translated as: Please, dont leave me.
Do these kinds of associations reduce the works to anecdotes or illustrations? No, they are too layered, too
complex for that. Ader managed to sublimate his personal tragedy into images with a universal appeal; and
furthermore it is not only their content but also their form that is so intriguing and so convincing.
Even if Ader is supposed once to have said about Im too sad to tell you that the face is the canvas and the
45
tears the paint, he did not wish his works to be regarded as Body Art. And he was right. He employed his
body as a means to an end and not as a means in itself. He was not a living sculpture but a conceptual artist.
The idea surpasses the form. Even though he committed himself physically, he pointed to an inherent significance that exceeds the merely physical appearance.
42. Idem, p. 330.
The baby sleeps audibly in the cradle. Everything belongs together. It is dear to me.
But that young man, for whom alongside other feelings I nurtured a deep motherly
44. Idem, p. 339: ...Mamma, please dont leave me. (Our constant moving had made
love, has left me. Forever? *Ader was known as Hans as a child.
Hans* fearful of this). No, my angel, Im staying with you. Forever? Yes, forever.
45. In one of Aders notebooks, quoted by Brad Spence in 1999, he wrote: I do not
Satisfied, the little chap nestles in my arms. I pull the blanket over us. Nothing
make body sculpture, body art or physical work. When I fall from the roof of my house
connects us to life more strongly than the helplessness of a small child. Paw comes
the little voice again. I take his foot in my hand. This is after all flesh of my flesh.
In what was to have been his masterpiece, In search of the miraculous, the physical setup he selected to link
America and Europe is similar in scale to a drawing that the American artist Walter de Maria was contemplating in 1969: a drawing that would start in India, continue in the Sahara Desert and finish in a desert in
46
America, and which would be visible only by satellite. In the light of such grandiose artistic concepts (this
is the period of the first lunar landing) Aders disappearance whilst executing his trilogy is, viewed soberly,
nothing more than an occupational hazard. It was the risk attached to the scale at which artists were then
working and comparable to the plane crash in which the American Land Art sculptor Robert Smithson died
47
whilst undertaking reconnaissance for a new location.
Ader and tragedy are indivisibly bound together. It would not be surprising if he were to return to Hollywood,
close to where he lived, as the subject of a real Hollywood movie. His life makes an exciting script. The father,
a preacher, who once cycled from Holland to Jerusalem and was shot dead as a resistance fighter. The mother
with telepathic powers who wrote a book full of references to falling and sailing. The brother, a successful
diplomat, who sailed around the world (but not alone) and came back in one piece. And Bas Jan Ader himself,
his dramatic childhood, his love of adventure and risky activities, which he managed to incorporate into his art,
and his disappearance at sea whilst carrying out a work of art.
Aders work is probably more autobiographical than was initially supposed and his mothers book is an important
source in this respect. That this information was not considered in earlier publications on Ader was not due
only to the lack of an English translation of her book. It was also because art history was long viewed from
within a strict, formal frame of reference. But art is not only about art, but also about life, and in this respect
there has been a clear change in the perception of Aders work in recent years.
Whilst in the early 1970s his work was discussed in formal, almost technical terms, there is now a greater concern
for the works tragic element. The first major publication on Ader, Paul Andriesses book published in 1988,
did deal with his mothers book and its possible connection with Aders work, but in a very aloof manner. The
German exhibition catalogue of 2000 by Christopher Mller certainly paid greater attention to this aspect.
And this is by no means restricted to publications, as is evinced from Aders recent inclusion in an exhibition
48
on the subject of grief. In the work of a new generation of artists whom Ader has inspired, the emphasis is
also placed on the tragic aspect of his life and work.
Does it demean Aders work that interpretations of his oeuvre focus on its tragic element and that his mothers
book is recognised as a source for certain images? Does this make his work anecdotal, illustrative or even flat?
Not everyone will be pleased with this development, but it looks as though his work can cope and that its
mysterious complexity will grow and not diminish. His works significance appears to be reaching beyond the
domain of art and even beyond Aders own intentions. His work seems to have become an icon for a particular
attitude to life and a particular time.
Of course the disappearance at sea speaks to the imagination, retrospectively puts everything into tragic per46. Walter de Maria, 1969: Three continent project consists of a mile-long bulldozer
cut in a desert east to west in India, a mile-long cut north to south in Africa, and a mile
47. Robert Smithson (1938-1973) died on 20 July 1973 in a plane crash whilst
square line cut north, south, east and west in the U.S.A. The lines would be photo-
graphed from a satellite and superimposed to create the image of a cross within a square.
The north-south was made in the Sahara Desert, Algeria. Work in progress. Exhib. cat.
spective, overshadows his work and forms a compelling framework for its interpretation. In a certain sense
that is a shame, for it loses its original innocence and purity. But it cannot be left out of the picture. Just as it
is legitimate to set his work alongside that of his contemporaries and within an art-historical framework, so it
is equally legitimate to examine the sources that fed him and from which he drew.
There are clear narrative aspects to his work. He loved to teach because he loved to tell stories. But in this
respect, and from very early on, he sought the essence in things; images and statements that would surpass
the immediate pretext, the anecdote, and the temporary. Why else would he have studied philosophy? And
why does his most important work date from after this period?
Bas Jan Ader left behind a very small oeuvre, created within an equally brief period, between 1969 and 1975.
He managed to transform images that were heavily laden with personal significance into lucid statements
with universal appeal. This explains the ever-growing international interest in his work. And that is no coincidence, since Ader allotted himself an important role as an artist and set himself, like a modern Icarus, very
high goals. In an interview in the journal Avalanche in 1976 Mary Sue said: Bas Jan Ader believed that art was
in a transitional phase and he wanted to break through to the next stage. And Erik Ader said of his brother:
49
He wanted to look beyond the horizon.
Perhaps he discovered that the Earth is flat after all and simply fell over the edge.
49. Rene Daalder, Here is always somewhere else, Documentary film, VPRO, Hilversum
fragility of the undertaking, the cutting back of existence to the core: all this was part
2006. In a letter Erik Ader wrote: I surely do not see him as some nutty mystic. But
of the search for the essence, rising above banality, the ultimate search for the
what I am sure of is that he was always concerned with quality. Quality in art, the
metaphysical.
quality of existence. That entire sea voyage, the unsteady balance in that tiny boat, the
Some of Bas Jan Aders most memorable works recall early slapstick comedy. Particularly in the silent films
in which we see him falling in one way or another, he employed the simple means of this earlier tradition
to reformulate and to some extent parody conceptual performance and its documentation, and the
Modernist abstraction it had grown out of. In Fall 1, Los Angeles, 1970, for example, we see the artist falling off
the roof of his single-storey house in Claremont; in Fall 2, Amsterdam, 1970, he loses control of his bicycle
and plunges into one of Amsterdams canals. In Nightfall, 1971, he throws a heavy concrete paving slab from each
hand in turn, smashing and extinguishing two illuminated light bulbs on the floor. Broken fall (geometric),
Westkapelle, Holland, 1971, shows the artist falling sideways onto a sawhorse and into the bushes on a path
leading to the Westkapelle lighthouse, which had been the subject of an early series of Mondrian paintings.
The act recalls the comedians classic visual gag of feigning drunkenness or trying to stand on an imaginary
ship; but it also refers to Mondrians rejection of the diagonal, which led to his falling out with his friend
and fellow De Stijl member Theo van Doesburg. Ader makes the reference to Mondrian whom he had
studied closely even more explicitly and comically in his series of photographs taken at the same spot, entitled
On the road to a new Neo Plasticism, Westkapelle, Holland, 1971, in which he is sprawled on the ground in a
black outfit mimicking the grid of a Mondrian painting with primary-coloured objects positioned around
him: a blue blanket, a warning triangle in its rectangular red plastic box, and a yellow petrol can.
The slapstick almost silly element is all the more remarkable because Ader has been mythologised as
the ultimate tragic artist because of his disappearance at sea while attempting a solo crossing of the Atlantic
for the central element of his uncompleted trilogy In search of the miraculous, 1975. And admittedly there is
nothing very humorous about the silent black and white film Im too sad to tell you, 1971 more melodrama
than slapstick in which we see the artist weeping, apparently so inconsolable with grief that he cannot even
tell us why. In fact, a preparatory note for the work reveals that Ader considered including the following line
1
in the film: The thoughts of our inevitable and separate deaths fills my heart with intolerable grief.
1. Christopher Mller, Bas Jan Ader. Filme, Fotografien, Projektionen, Videos und
book p. 24.
Of course there is a peculiar relationship between the tragic and the comic. Ader himself pointed out that
2
his concern with falling was connected to failure and tragedy. And seminal figures such as Charlie Chaplin
and Buster Keaton have always played on the tension between comic incident and tragic fate. In his book on
the artist, Jan Verwoert argues that Ader ultimately takes recourse to the classical Greek model of the tragic
3
hero who, takes the conscious decision to carry out a plan that will inevitably lead to his fall. He refers to
Aders silent film Broken fall (organic), Amsterdamse Bos, Holland, 1971, as a condensation of this paradigm: we
see the artist hanging from the branch of a tree until his strength fails him and he falls into the narrow ditch
beneath. In other words: the artist has knowingly put himself at risk by climbing up the tree and dangling
over the water.
The question remains whether there isnt a crucial difference between Aders act and that of the tragic hero.
For what we see is not really an existential threat, quite the opposite apart from maybe a bruised ankle, Ader
escapes unharmed. Interestingly, we do not see Ader clamber up the tree; the film starts with him hanging in
mid-air and ends with him crawling out of the ditch. Basically he has enacted the childrens game, which
appears, for example, in Maurice Sendaks famous picture book Where the wild things are published in 1963,
in which little Max, dressed in a wolfs suit, sails in a little boat to the island of monstrous creatures, tames
them by staring them down, is crowned their king, and proclaims that a wild rumpus shall begin which
climaxes in all the monsters merrily dangling from the trees.
Even though Bas Jan Aders more solitary act inevitably takes on a certain existential gravitas by being
isolated and captured on film, it nevertheless relies on the consoling knowledge that the artists life has never
actually been at risk. This is in stark contrast to the performances of Aders Los Angeles contemporary Chris
Burden who had himself shot in the arm (Shoot, 1971), or pushed live electric wires into his chest (Doorway
to Heaven, November 15, 1973). With regard to Aders fatal attempt to cross the Atlantic, it should be stressed
that his widow stated some months after his disappearance that Ader was convinced and had convinced
other sailors that he was sufficiently experienced and well equipped to make the crossing unharmed;
indeed Ader had already sailed from Morocco to Los Angeles in 1962, albeit in a larger boat and with ano4
ther crew member. Other works by Ader support the assumption that he was interested less in testing the
limits of his body i.e. putting it at risk than in what is, according to Alan Dale, author of the book Comedy
5
is a man in trouble, the essence of slapstick: a physical assault on, or collapse of, the heros dignity.
Nevertheless, Jan Verwoerts reference to the classical tragic hero helpfully leads us straight to the crucial issue of the relationship between intention, act and effect: the classical tragic hero acts purposefully and
forcefully, and ultimately sacrifices himself in order to enforce a resolution. The religious martyr does so for
the love of God, while the secular figure of the knight does so for the love of his country, or the lady he
courts. One strain of comedy since the Enlightenment from Don Quixote to Monty Python thrives on the
comic mishaps brought about by these worthy intentions. Another strain that of Chaplins slapstick for
example reverses this logic by relying on comic mishaps that inadvertently result in heroic deeds. In Chaplins
The tramp, 1915, the title character is charmed by the farmers daughter who has just escaped from a trio of
robbers. As he flirts awkwardly with her, he swings his ragbag containing a brick and, one by one, inadvertently
hits each of her assailants over the head. Increasingly aware of his unintentional bravery, he rises to the chal2. Betty van Garrel, Bas Jan Aders tragiek schuilt in een pure val, in Haagse Post
Los Angeles, May 28th, 1976, Avalanche, no. 13, summer 1976.
3. Jan Verwoert, Bas Jan Ader: In Search of the Miraculous, Cambridge, Mass., 2006.
4. Lizy Bear and Willoughby Sharp, A telephone conversation with Mary Sue Ader,
lenge and bluffs until even the strongest of the three is sent packing in the belief that he has encountered an
undefeatable strongman. Another classic example of the accidental tragicomic hero is the famous scene in
Modern times from 1936, in which Chaplins character sees a red flag fall from a truck and picks it up.
He pursues the vehicle waving the red flag to catch the drivers attention, all the while unaware that he is involuntarily heading a march of angry, striking proletarians. Chaplins accidental revolutionary leader is eventually thrown in jail.
In Buster Keatons films, the comic effect is triggered by the seemingly insurmountable forces his character
faces. In Steamboat Bill Jr., 1928, Keaton is cast as the weakling Willie who inadvertently saves the day when a
cyclone and flood hit a small town. The film climaxes with the famous scene in which Keaton avoids certain
death when the facade of a house falls on him because he fits neatly through an open window frame; the British
artist Steve McQueen re-enacted the scene for his 1997 video Deadpan.
Bas Jan Ader turns the mishap itself into the ultimate and intentional performative act. On one level this
simply highlights, as Verwoert observes, the existential adversity of the everyday much in the vein of Chaplin
and Keatons slapstick. On another level, however, it is neither an existential heroic act nor simply its parody,
but precisely the short-circuiting of the two. While the classical tragic hero consciously decides to carry out
the task at all costs, the slapstick hero either quixotically fails to complete it, or inadvertently succeeds
through his hesitations and failures. Ader in turn accomplishes the comical act itself with the solemn purposefulness of a self-endangering act. While the conventional slapstick gag relies, according to Alan Dale,
6
on a rupture in the expected link between physical effort and result, Aders pieces make it very clear that
they are executed according to plan and that their outcome holds no surprise.
Aders gentle rejection of the confrontation between the heros dignity versus its parodist collapse can be
read closely in relation to his artistic peers in Los Angeles around 1970. While Chris Burden was the ultimate
hero of the risky performative act, John Baldessari was the ultimate parodist of heroics in video performances
such as I am making art, 1971, in which he performs a series of small mechanical movements exclaiming I am
making art in sardonic reference to the weighty significance attached to physical movement in much Body
Art and performance. Ader certainly didnt aim to discredit either of these artistic approaches (and might not
even have had them in mind when making his pieces), but he nevertheless bypassed both the heightened
sense of pathos and irony they represented.
Aders use of slapstick also resonates with the undertones of class difference typical of the genre. His 1967
poster piece Implosion / The artist contemplating the forces of nature shows a photograph of Ader sitting in
an armchair on the roof of his house (the same roof he will fall off in Fall 1, Los Angeles three years later),
smoking a cigar, against a background of an actual sky plus fake cartoon clouds. The artistic hero who is, in the
words of Lukacs, transcendentally homeless (i.e. sitting on the roof like a bird), is fused with the idle armchair
dandy: The artist as consumer of extreme comfort, 1968, is a photograph of Ader in front of a fire place that
illustrates precisely that snug role. The photo series Untitled (Tea party) of 1972 and the eponymous (but
unauthorised and posthumously released) film could have come straight from one of P.G. Wodehouses satirical stories, as the artist, wearing a suit and tie, crawls on all fours like a silly member of Bertie Woosters
Drone Club. He then drinks tea from a tea set placed under a large box, propped up with a wooden stick
like an animal trap, which eventually falls over him: the refined gentleman trapped in a Minimalist box.
But Aders enquiry into the bohemian bourgeois steers clear of overt comic effect there is no acrobatic
grotesqueness in his movements or facial expressions, quite the opposite: there is seriousness in his actions,
6. Alan Dale, op. cit., p. 4.
isolating and exposing the romanticist strain in the comical mishap as a means to isolate and expose the relation
between failure and empathy. In this respect, the slapstick works are intricately linked to, rather than separated from, Aders evocations of melodrama: both employ the genre traditions of an outmoded medium
silent film as a means to destabilise the (then relatively new) stereotype of the Conceptual artist as a stern
hero of critique who never embarrasses himself. But again, Ader is not simply a parodist. Rather, as a Dutch
artist based in Los Angeles, this chasm between romanticism and slapstick at the heart of his work echoes
the chasm between Europe and America: between the European school of thought leading from nineteenthcentury romanticism via Freud to auteur cinema the concept of psychological depth and singularity and
the American deadpan concern for repetition and social interaction that connects early slapstick with late
Modernism.
Of course the Atlantic can be crossed: there are strong auteur strands in American cinema (Welles,
Kubrick), and there are European slapstick comedians such as Karl Valentin and Jacques Tati. But these
cross-relations are actually triggered not least of all by the mutual relationship in the first place: for example, in
Tatis Jour de fte of 1947, a French village postman sees a news reel hailing the efficient mechanised delivery
methods of the US postal system, and the next day tries to compete using his bicycle (upon which he ends
7
up in the water ditto Ader).
Viewed against this background, Aders crossing the Atlantic as the central part of In search of the miraculous thus becomes not least of all an attempt to traverse the chasm of traditions. The tragedy is that his disappearance at sea was certainly not an intended kind of failure. For it seems that the miraculous that Ader
sought was the impossibility of being simultaneously the ultimate rationalist and the ultimate romanticist.
pear. He wanted to cross the ocean alone, in answer to the journey that had brought him to California in the
first place. He had sailed there as a deckhand and wanted to sail back: to arrive and leave by sea a romantic
equation and obvious apotheosis. His audacity lay only in his desire (casual but nonetheless mindful) also to
break the world record by making the trip in the smallest ever boat: 2 feet and 2 inches smaller than the last
successful passage. Ocean Wave was probably not even double his bodys length.
Ader was a master of gravity. But when he fell, all he would say was that, it was because gravity made itself
master over him. He understood the necessary surrender and decisiveness of purpose needed to make gravity
his companion, unlike the prosaic James Honeycutt in The boy who fell over Niagara Falls, whose misjudgement of the supremacy of water left him trying desperately to reverse his ineffective outboard motor on the
brink of the Niagara Falls. It is a bad sailor who trusts his engine. Bas Jan Ader probably felt closer to the boy
whose very lightness would be his protector as he fell the 161 feet to certain death.
Did Ader feel protected because he was making a work of art? Protected in his pursuit of the sublime, which
suspends all truth and postpones the realisation that we are, in fact, dully mortal? More than anyone, he played
with this engagement laid himself open to the possibility of death. Taunted it. Provoked it. Fell for it. Sadly
we can only glimpse at the enormity of Bas Jan Aders feat because he failed. Had he completed his Part Two,
we would never think enough of what it takes to sail alone across the Atlantic in a boat barely bigger than most
sailors dinghies.
It is perhaps the most unsettling fact of all to learn that The strange last voyage of Donald Crowhurst was found
in Aders faculty locker in Irvine some time after he had disappeared. We have to suppose he read it. We have
to suppose he imagined Crowhursts anguished journey in the light of his own incipient one, even if it was only
to dismiss it. We have to suppose he knew, as he set out, that there were many ways to fail as there were many
ways to succeed.
Icarus, blinded by the elation of his ascent, failed and fell: fell to fail. His was a journey up that came down.
Crowhursts was a journey along: flat, doomed and sorrily human. His fall was wretched, unimagined, unannounced and wholly practical. But for Bas Jan Ader to fall was to make a work of art. Whatever we believe or
whatever we imagine, on a deep deep level, not to have fallen would have meant failure.
List of works
Cataloguing Bas Jan Aders small oeuvre is far from simple and requires careful navigation amongst various
pitfalls. Given that the artist is no longer with us, the question of authorisation is more than a little problematic
and naturally, the Estate plays an essential role in this respect. However, the matter is complicated by the
radical change in the composition of the Estates representatives since May 1993, with an attendant change in
how the oeuvre is viewed. That is a normal process. In the case of Bas Jan Ader the Estate was administered
from 1979 by the so-called Committee of Four Ger van Elk, Adriaan van Ravesteijn, Martijn Sanders and
Erik Ader. Initially the Estate was represented by Adriaan van Ravesteijn of Galerie Art & Project; from 1988
the Estate was represented by Paul Andriesse who had concluded his in-depth research into Aders work with
the first published monograph on the artist. In 1993 the committee and Andriesse were replaced by a new
representative for the Estate: the collection of Mary Sue Ader-Andersen Bas Jan Ader Estate, courtesy of
Patrick Painter Editions.
During the research into this list we have spoken frequently and corresponded extensively with Mary Sue
Ader-Andersen and Daniel Congdon, the Estates representative at Patrick Painter Editions. There was also
contact with Erik Ader. Doede Hardeman has consulted several archives during his research, including the
Sonsbeek archive, housed at the Krller-Mller Museum; the Groninger Museum exhibitions archive, housed
at The RHC Groninger Archieven and the Art & Project archive (Bas Jan Ader dossier) at the Netherlands
Institute for Art History/Rijksbureau voor Kunsthistorische Documentatie (RKD) in The Hague. The Art & Project
archive has yet to be catalogued and is still inaccessible to researchers; a sole exception has been made to make
the Bas Jan Ader dossier accessible exclusively for this publication. Otherwise the basis for the research has
remained the monograph on Ader by Paul Andriesse published in 1988 and the catalogue for the exhibition at
the Kunstverein Braunschweig in 2000 by Christopher Mller. An additional important source of information
was the article by Wade Saunders published in Art in America in February 2004.
Many individuals have also provided invaluable information including Poul ter Hofstede, the former curator
at the Groninger Museum; Gifford Myers, Aders former assistant; the filmmaker Rene Daalder; Wade
Saunders; Dennis Parks, a friend of Aders who ran the Upstairs Gallery; Steven Leiber; Jrgen Wesseler, the
director of the Kabinett fr Aktuelle Kunst in Bremerhaven; Helene Winer, curator of Aders exhibition at
the Pomona Gallery in Claremont and Ida Gianelli, the then director of the Saman Gallery in Genoa. Aders
works in the collection of Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen were also re-examined and carefully studied.
The result is a new list of works, a list more extensive than any previous list of Aders works. This is partly on
account of the recently discovered juvenilia. These early works are quite distinct from the artists mature
work in terms of quality. Nonetheless we considered it important to include them here in order to facilitate
future research and to give a broader understanding of Aders development.
The list has also grown because the Estate has recently authorised more works. Some of these works raise
certain issues for discussion, and these are mentioned in the list that follows. Other works that have been
issued posthumously, have been arranged in a separate list of Posthumously published works. The film footage
that cannot be considered as authorised is dealt with in detail in Elbrig de Groots essay.
Since the artists disappearance, authorisation of Aders works has been the responsibility of Mary Sue AderAndersen, the representative of the Estate. Where the term authorised is used in the list, it refers to this form
of authorisation. In several cases the list mentions the completion of editions. Bas Jan Ader normally produced
three copies of his photo works. In some cases where less than three copies had been printed before his disappearance the Estate has chosen to print and publish the outstanding copies. This is in some cases referred to
as completing the edition. In his monograph published in 1988, Paul Andriesse chose to mention only those
prints that had been realised before Aders disappearance. A part of the editions were completed in the 1980s
under the auspices of the Committee of Four, with the agreement of Mary Sue Ader-Andersen and under the
supervision of Paul Andriesse (Wade Saunders, In dreams begin responsibilities, Art in America, February 2004,
pp. 54-65). In the following list we have chosen to give the original year of the work for these posthumously
completed editions.
The works have been arranged by medium. Within each medium the works are listed chronologically by the
date of their production. We have decided to place the most important body of works the photographs and
films at the head of the list in order to highlight their qualitative weight. In this respect the list of works is
also a definite attempt to create a critical ordering of the works.
In the list of works we have chosen to standardise the spelling of the artists name and the titles of the works.
Thus he is referred to here throughout as Bas Jan Ader or with the abbreviation BJA, and not Basjan or Bas
jan Ader spellings that were frequently adopted by himself and others. We have chosen to give all titles of
work in English because nearly all the works were made whilst he was living in America. Indeed, when Ader
was invited to participate in the Sonsbeek exhibition he explicitly referred to himself as an international
artist, not a Dutch one. In the titles of all works capital letters are used only for the principal word and for
proper nouns. Place names such as Westkapelle have been corrected where inaccurate or inconsistent
spellings were originally used and irregular punctuation has also been corrected. Consistent spelling was not
one of Aders strong points, a feature that we see no justification for idealising.
Dimensions are given in centimetres, using the international standard of height followed by width followed by
depth. Where the locations of works are known, the collection (or collections in the case of editions) is named.
Unfortunately this has not always been possible.
The descriptions of the works are based on a comparison of the available literature, our own observations and
the result of research carried out by Doede Hardeman. The two most important catalogues were consulted
extensively, and are referred to by the authors surnames and date of publication: Andriesse, 1988 for Paul
Andriesse, Bas Jan Ader: kunstenaar/artist, Amsterdam, 1988 and Mller, 2000 for Christopher Mller, Bas
Jan Ader, Filme, Fotografien, Projektionen, Videos und Zeichnungen aus den Jahren 1967-1975, Cologne, 2000).
Each description is supplemented with references to the literature and exhibitions until 1975, the year of Bas
Jan Aders disappearance.
The following list is in our opinion an important step in the research into the art of Bas Jan Ader. More research
will certainly be required, which can only help to clarify and strengthen our understanding of the work.
35
37
3. All my clothes
1970 Gelatin silver print 28 x 35.5 cm Edition: 3
Collections: Mary Sue Ader-Andersen - Bas Jan Ader Estate, courtesy
of Patrick Painter Editions / Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen Rotterdam,
inv. no. 3276 (MK) / Patrick Painter collection.
39
41
43
45
47
49
51
53
55
57
13. Sawing
1971 Gelatin silver print 28.2 x 35.5 cm Edition: 3
Collection: Mary Sue Ader-Andersen - Bas Jan Ader Estate, courtesy
of Patrick Painter Editions.
59
14. Sawing
1971/2003 3 gelatin silver prints 12.7 x 17.9 cm each Edition: 3
Collection: Mary Sue Ader-Andersen - Bas Jan Ader Estate, courtesy
of Patrick Painter Editions.
61
63
Well now if I have to swim a river / you know I will / and if I have
to climb a mountain / you know I will / and if she is hiding up on
blueberry hill / am I gonna find her child / you know I will cause
Ive been searchin / Oh yeh searchin my goodness / searchin
everywhich way, but Im like that / Northwest Mounty / you know
Ill bring her in someday.
Comments: The negatives no longer exist. In addition to this
edition there is a series of eighteen photographs (cat. no. 17).
According to Mary Sue Ader-Andersen, the less extensive
series was due to lack of funds. (Mary Sue Ader-Andersen,
conversation on 25 February 2006).
The photographs were taken by Mary Sue Ader-Andersen in
Los Angeles from nightfall to sunrise. (Mary Sue Ader-Andersen,
correspondence 2 March 2006).
It is remarkable the extent to which the two series differ: the
series of eighteen photographs has a very different sequence;
identical photographs from each series have different lyrics;
and finally some words in the two series have been spelt in
different ways (compare mountie/mounty, the inconsistent use
of apostrophes and the inconsistent use of upper and lower
case). The handwriting, however, is the same.
The work was to be part of a trilogy BJA was working on, but
never completed (cat. no. 33).
Literature: Hannelore Ahorn, Kunstwerk ist Vorgang. Fotos des Amerikaners
Bas Jan Ader beim Kabinett fr Aktuelle Kunst, Nordsee-Zeitung Bremerhaven,
14 November, 1974.
Henry J. Seldis and William Wilson, A Critical Guide to the GALLERIES, Los
Angeles Times, 2 May, 1975, p. 8.
66
67
70
71
voor
Kunsthistorische
Documentatie
73
Description:
(in block letters)
BAS JAN ADER
FALL 1
LOS ANGELES 1970
Duration: 6
The camera is fixed on the facade of BJAs house in Claremont,
California, showing the roof and veranda. BJA is seated on a
chair on the roof ridge. He falls and rolls, chair and all, off the
roof. One of his shoes comes loose. The chair falls to the left and
comes to a standstill on the roof. BJA lands in the bushes in
front of the house, out of view.
Duration: 18
Comments: There are a number of screen tests in which BJA
drops the chair off the roof several times, whilst William Leavitt
took photographs that appear never to have been used.
For the book Fall (cat. no. 43) BJA used film stills from Fall 1
and Fall 2, which he included in his exhibition in Claremont in
1972.
Exhibitions: 19 June15 August 1971, Sonsbeek buiten de perken, in the film
tent in the garden of the Gemeentemuseum Arnhem, Arnhem (cat.).
Filmprogramma van Sonsbeek 71, Vestzaktheater, Groningen.
8 October17 October, Prospekt 71: Projektion, Stdtische Kunsthalle,
Dsseldorf (cat.).
17 June2 July 1972, Bas Jan Ader, Broken Fall (Organic), Kabinett fr
Aktuelle Kunst, Bremerhaven (inv.).
19 November 1974 , Film als beeldend medium, travelling exhibition
Nederlandse Kunststichting.
Literature: Cor Blok, Gaat Sonsbeek buiten de perken?, Museumjournaal vol. 16,
no. 4, 1971, p. 174.
Peter Kress, Aktiviteit Sonsbeek buiten de perken, Das Kunstwerk, 5 XXIV,
September 1971, p. 77.
Willoughby Sharp, Rumbles, Avalanche, winter 1971, p. 2.
Betty van Garrel, Bas Jan Aders tragiek schuilt in een pure val, Haagse Post, 5
January11 January 1972, p. 48.
Exhib.cat. Claremont, California, Pomona College Gallery, Bas Jan Ader, William
Leavitt, Ger van Elk, 1972, p. 1.
William Wilson, Photo-Sculpture Show at Otis, Los Angeles Times, 14 February,
1972, p. 8.
Hannelore Ahorn, Es geht Bas Jan Ader nicht um das Filmen. Hollnder
prsentiert sich im ,,Kabinett fr aktuelle Kunst, Nordsee-Zeitung Bremerhaven,
20 June, 1972.
Exhib.cat. various venues, Nederlandse Kunststichting, Film als beeldend medium, 1974, p. 8 and p. 32.
Benjamin H.D. Buchloh (ed.), Filmographie von Knstlerfilmen, Interfunktionen,
no. 12, Cologne 1975, p. 85.
Erik Beenker, Bas Jan Ader op zoek naar het miraculeuze, Nieuwsblad van het
Noorden, 11 November, 1975.
75
Description:
(in block letters)
BAS JAN ADER
FALL 2
AMSTERDAM 1970
Duration: 6
BJA appears from a side street on a bicycle and cycles along
the Reguliersgracht in Amsterdam. The static camera records
his progress from the other side of the canal. B J A grips a bunch
of flowers in one hand. He steers straight towards the canal
and plunges into the water, bike and all. The saddle cover
springs up on impact.
Duration: 13
Comments: There are several screen tests showing the location with pedestrians and traffic. In the definitive shot only
B J A is in view. Another scene shows B J A being fished out of
the water at the end of a rope.
Ger van Elk and William Leavitt were on site to take photographs.
For the book Fall (cat. no. 43) B J A used film stills from Fall 1
and Fall 2, which he included in his exhibition in Claremont in
1972.
Exhibitions: 19 June15 August 1971, Sonsbeek buiten de perken, in the
film tent in the garden of the Arnhem Gemeentemuseum, Arnhem (cat.).
Filmprogramma van Sonsbeek 71, Vestzaktheater, Groningen.
8 October17 October, Prospekt 71: Projektion, Stdtische Kunsthalle,
Dsseldorf (cat.).
17 June2 July 1972, Bas Jan Ader, Broken Fall (Organic), Kabinett fr
Aktuelle Kunst, Bremerhaven (inv.).
19 November 1974 , Film als beeldend medium, travelling exhibition
Nederlandse Kunststichting.
Literature: Peter Kress, Aktiviteit Sonsbeek buiten de perken, Das Kunstwerk,
5 XXIV, September 1971, p. 77.
Willoughby Sharp, Rumbles, Avalanche, winter 1971, p. 2.
Betty van Garrel, Bas Jan Aders tragiek schuilt in een pure val, Haagse Post,
5 January11 January 1972, p. 48.
Exhib.cat. Claremont, California, Pomona College Gallery, Bas Jan Ader, William
Leavitt, Ger van Elk, 1972, p. 1.
William Wilson, Photo-Sculpture Show at Otis, Los Angeles Times, 14 February,
1972, p. 8.
Hannelore Ahorn, Es geht Bas Jan Ader nicht um das Filmen. Hollnder prsentiert sich im ,,Kabinett fr aktuelle Kunst, Nordsee-Zeitung Bremerhaven, 20
June, 1972.
Exhib.cat. various venues, Nederlandse Kunststichting, Film als beeldend medium,
1974, p. 8 and p. 32.
Benjamin H.D. Buchloh (ed.), Filmographie von Knstlerfilmen, Interfunktionen,
no. 12, Cologne 1975, p. 85.
Erik Beenker, Bas Jan Ader op zoek naar het miraculeuze, Nieuwsblad van het
Noorden, 11 November, 1975.
77
Description:
Bas Jan Ader
71
Duration: 6
Im too sad
To tell you
Duration: 10
BJA is filmed frontally. His face, full of emotion, fills the screen.
He pulls his hair and rubs his face. He snivels and tears show.
He opens his mouth, rubs his eyes, lifts his head, blinks his eyes,
grins, bends his head, curls his lip inward, bursts into tears,
regains control, moves his tongue over his lips, keeps his
head still, bends his head again, cant hold back his tears,
turns his head to the left, shakes his head, curls his lip inward,
puts a hand on his face and flicks his hair out of the way, nods,
keeps his eyes closed and bursts into tears again.
Duration: 318
Comments: BJA made three different versions of Im too sad to
tell you. One American version, with BJA sitting in front of a fence
(Cry Claremont, 1970) and two versions in Amsterdam, shot in
a neutral space (1971). Compare the text by Elbrig de Groot.
Exhibitions: 4 April24 April 1971, Studio show, together with Paul Drake,
Ger van Elk, Jack Goldstein, William Leavitt, Allen Ruppersberg, Stephen Sher,
Wolfgang Stoerchle, the exhibition took place in a loft of Jack Goldstein, Los
Angeles. Presumably it was the first version Cry Claremont that was shown
here (for a discussion of the various see the text by Elbrig de Groot).
18 January20 February 1972, Bas Jan Ader, William Leavitt, Ger van Elk,
Pomona College Gallery, Montgomery Art Center, Claremont, California (cat.).
4 June 21 July 1972, listahtd reykjavk, Galerie Sm, Reykyavik (cat.).
17 June2 July 1972, Bas Jan Ader, Broken Fall (Organic), Kabinett fr
Aktuelle Kunst, Bremerhaven (inv.).
11 March6 April 1973, Werken van Bas Jan Ader, Ger van Elk, Gilbert &
George en William Leavitt, Galerie Waalkens, Finsterwolde (inv.). (It is not
entirely clear whether the film or the photo work was shown at this exhibition).
19 November 1974 , Film als beeldend medium, travelling exhibition
Nederlandse Kunststichting.
Literature: Betty van Garrel, Bas Jan Aders tragiek schuilt in een pure val,
Haagse Post, 5 January11 January 1972, pp. 48-49.
Exhib.cat. Claremont, California, Pomona College Gallery, Bas Jan Ader, William
Leavitt, Ger van Elk, 1972, p. 1 and pp. 4-5.
Exhib.cat. Reykjavik, Galerie Sm, listahtd reykjavk, 1972, p. 1 and p. 119.
Hannelore Ahorn, Es geht Bas Jan Ader nicht um das Filmen. Hollnder prsentiert sich im ,,Kabinett fr aktuelle Kunst, Nordsee-Zeitung Bremerhaven,
20 June, 1972.
H.A. (Hannelore Ahorn), Elementare Erfahrungen. Bas Jan Ader im Kabinett
fr aktuelle Kunst, Bremerhaven, Bremer Nachrichten, 28 June, 1972.
Exhib.cat. various places, Nederlandse Kunststichting, Film als beeldend medium,
1974, p. 9 and p. 32.
Erik Beenker, Bas Jan Ader op zoek naar het miraculeuze, Nieuwsblad van het
Noorden, 11 November, 1975.
79
Description:
(hand-written)
Bas Jan Ader
71
Duration: 6
Broken Fall
(geometric)
West-Kapelle, Holland
Duration: 11
BJA is standing on a brick-paved country lane bordered by
shrubs on each side, next to a wooden sawhorse. In the background is the Westkapelle lighthouse in Zeeland. BJA staggers
for a moment and falls sideways against the sawhorse and onto
the ground at the side of the road. His hands continue to move
for a while.
Duration 132
Comments: Both the location and the subject refer to Piet
Mondrian, an artist that fascinated BJA. Mondrian painted the
lighthouse on several occasions. The lighthouse and the sawhorse
represent Mondrians disagreement with Theo van Doesburg
over his controversial use of the diagonal line; Mondrian
sought a perfect harmony of horizontals and verticals only.
BJA attempts to intervene in this theoretical conflict, but fails
whilst trying to replicate the angle of the sawhorse. At the
same location but at a different time, Mary Sue Ader-Andersen
took photographs for various Westkapelle photo works. Ger
van Elk also took photographs at Westkapelle (conversation
with Ger van Elk, 13 March 2006). There are many screen tests
for this film. In one piece of footage a car appears, spoiling the
shot, much to BJAs annoyance.
Exhibitions: 18 January20 February 1972, Bas Jan Ader, William Leavitt, Ger van
Elk, Pomona College Gallery, Montgomery Art Center, Claremont, California (cat.).
17 June2 July 1972, Bas Jan Ader, Broken Fall (Organic), Kabinett fr Aktuelle
Kunst, Bremerhaven (inv.).
Literature: Betty van Garrel, Bas Jan Aders tragiek schuilt in een pure val,
Haagse Post, 5 January11 January 1972, p. 48.
Exhib.cat. Claremont, California, Pomona College Gallery, Bas Jan Ader, William
Leavitt, Ger van Elk, 1972, p. 1 and p. 4.
Hannelore Ahorn, Es geht Bas Jan Ader nicht um das Filmen. Hollnder prsentiert sich im ,,Kabinett fr aktuelle Kunst, Nordsee-Zeitung Bremerhaven,
20 June, 1972.
H.A. (Hannelore Ahorn), Elementare Erfahrungen. Bas Jan Ader im Kabinett fr
aktuelle Kunst, Bremerhaven, Bremer Nachrichten, 28 June, 1972.
Exhib.cat. various places, Nederlandse Kunststichting, Film als beeldend medium,
1974, p. 32.
81
Description:
(hand-written)
Bas Jan Ader
71
Duration: 7
Broken Fall
(organic)
Amsterdamse Bos, Holland
Duration: 11
BJA dangles from a tree branch, several metres above a ditch.
He swings, repositions his hands, spreads his legs, hangs still,
kicks his legs, loses his grip until and falls into the water,
close to the bank.
Duration: 126
Comments: BJAs original intention was also to publish this work
as a photographic print, as in the poster for the Kabinett fr
Aktuelle Kunst, Bremerhaven (cat. no. 45) (Andriesse, 1988). A
crop of the image was used for the exhibition invitation.
Footage exists, probably shot in California, in which BJA - nimbly
climbs a tree and roughly shakes the foliage.
Exhibitions: 18 January20 February 1972, Bas Jan Ader, William Leavitt, Ger
van Elk, Pomona College Gallery, Montgomery Art Center, Claremont, California
(cat.).
17 June2 July 1972, Bas Jan Ader, Broken Fall (Organic), Kabinett fr Aktuelle
Kunst, Bremerhaven (inv.).
Literature: Betty van Garrel, Bas Jan Aders tragiek schuilt in een pure val,
Haagse Post, 5 January11 January 1972, p. 48.
Exhib.cat. Claremont, California, Pomona College Gallery, Bas Jan Ader, William
Leavitt, Ger van Elk, 1972, p. 1 and pp. 4-5.
William Wilson, Photo-Sculpture Show at Otis, Los Angeles Times, 14 February,
1972, p. 8.
Hannelore Ahorn, Es geht Bas Jan Ader nicht um das Filmen. Hollnder prsentiert sich im ,,Kabinett fr aktuelle Kunst, Nordsee-Zeitung Bremerhaven,
20 June, 1972.
H.A. (Hannelore Ahorn), Elementare Erfahrungen. Bas Jan Ader im Kabinett fr
aktuelle Kunst, Bremerhaven, Bremer Nachrichten, 28 June, 1972.
Exhib.cat. various venues, Nederlandse Kunststichting, Film als beeldend medium,
1974, p. 32.
83
24. Nightfall
1971 Black and white film 16mm, silent Total duration: 416
(title 8, film 48), Camera: Peter Bakker
Collection: Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam, inv. no. FKI 47 (MK).
Description:
(in block letters)
BAS JAN ADER
NIGHTFALL
1971
Duration: 8
BJA stands in a garage behind a concrete paving slab. On the
floor to his left and right are illuminated light bulbs. The camera
records BJA frontally from a fixed position. After approximately one minute BJA picks up the heavy concrete slab and raises
it onto his left shoulder. He then shifts the block onto his left
palm and holds it like a serving tray. All of this is accomplished
with great difficulty due to the weight of the slab. He throws
the slab onto the light bulb on his left, smashing and extinguishing it. He remains standing in the middle for a while,
picks up the slab again and repeats the entire process on his
right-hand side. As the second light bulb is extinguished the
scene turns black.
Duration: 48
Exhibitions: 18 January20 February 1972, Bas Jan Ader, William Leavitt, Ger
van Elk, Pomona College Gallery, Montgomery Art Center, Claremont, California
(cat.).
17 June2 July 1972, Bas Jan Ader, Broken Fall (Organic), Kabinett fr Aktuelle
Kunst, Bremerhaven (inv.).
Literature: Betty van Garrel, Bas Jan Aders tragiek schuilt in een pure val,
Haagse Post, 5 January11 January 1972, p. 49.
Exhib.cat. Claremont, California, Pomona College Gallery, Bas Jan Ader, William
Leavitt, Ger van Elk, 1972, p. 4.
Hannelore Ahorn, Es geht Bas Jan Ader nicht um das Filmen. Hollnder prsentiert sich im ,,Kabinett fr aktuelle Kunst, Nordsee-Zeitung Bremerhaven,
20 June, 1972.
H.A. (Hannelore Ahorn), Elementare Erfahrungen. Bas Jan Ader im Kabinett fr
aktuelle Kunst, Bremerhaven, Bremer Nachrichten, 28 June, 1972.
Exhib.cat. various venues, Nederlandse Kunststichting, Film als beeldend medium, 1974, p. 32.
85
Description:
(hand-written)
Primary Time
Bas jan Ader 74
The video begins with only a vase holding a bouquet of red,
yellow and blue carnations. After a few seconds BJA appears
and stands behind the vase of flowers. He adds and removes
flowers until he has arranged, in turn, an exclusively red, then
yellow and finally a blue bouquet. Between arranging each
monochrome bouquet he disappears briefly. Unlike the photo
series, which ends with the monochrome blue bouquet, the
video returns to the three-coloured bouquet.
Comments: The video was shot at Irvine University. In addition
to the video work there is also a series of 21 c-type prints (cat.
no. 18).
87
Description: BJA produced two versions of this studio installation in his studio in Claremont, California. In one version a lamp
attached to a ladder illuminated the text PLEASE DONT
LEAVE ME written in dark paint on the back wall. This installation was the basis for the photo work, a copy of which is in
the collection of Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen (cat. no. 2).
In the second version a tangle of light bulbs was attached to
the same wall, brightly illuminating the text. There were no other
artificial light sources. There is an authorised photo work of
this version, signed, dated and inscribed Studio Installation
on the verso. There are also documentary photographs of this
installation.
Documentary photographs also exist of a third, outdoor, version
of the work: the texts is traced in white powder, possibly
plaster, partially on a path and partially over grass and soil.
Comments: The Estate offers the second version as an installation: Please dont leave me, 1969 / Paint, light bulbs, wire /
Installation: dimensions variable.
It seems clear that BJA made the work in 1969 as an installation. In a notation on the verso of the eponymous photo work
(cat. no. 2) he calls it a studio installation, an installation with
a certain intimate and limited reach. In order to be able to
identify the work on this list as installation, 1969, various versions we must first establish BJAs original intentions. These
appear to be clear, from his additional description of studio
installation and from the mainly documentary character of most
photographs. As such any posthumous reconstruction of the
installation should be referred to as a posthumously produced
installation.
For a discussion of this work see also: Wade Saunders, In
dreams begin responsibilities, Art in America, February 2004,
pp. 54-65.
89
91
93
Description: The image shows a tangle of light bulbs illuminating grass, fencing and rocks.
Comments: BJA also used the tangle of light bulbs in one of
the known versions of Please dont leave me (cat. no. 26). 473
Readers Digests digested (cat. no. 30) has similar lighting and
other formal similarities with Two kinds of grass, two kinds of
fences, illuminated by two kinds of light.
95
97
99
101
104
105
107
109
111
113
115
117
119
41. Landslide.
Quarterly journal of underground art
[No. 3]:
NO.3. Expandable sculpture. untitled
cm; sculpture: approx. 8.9 x 10.2 cm; envelope: 13.3 x 18.4 cm.
[No. 4]:
cal content.
Landslide
[Landslide #5]
acetate cover. The sheets have the title, edition number, sig-
17.8 cm; letter: 21.6 x 16.5 cm; envelope: 22.9 x 19.7 cm.
Print and letter in an envelope. Colour and black and white. The
22.9 x 21.6 cm; letter: 22.2 x 21.6 cm; envelope: 29.2 x 22.9 cm.
[No.7]:
Landslide #7
[No. 2]:
Landslide number 2
1971, p. 195.
Betty van Garrel, Bas Jan Aders tragiek schuilt in een pure val, Haagse Post, 5
and white. The publication has two parts. Part 1 comprises two
sheets, stapled with a wrapper; part 2 comprises four sheets in
121
123
43. Fall
1970 Booklet (offset lithography on paper) Published by
Bas Jan Ader 19.1 x 19.1 cm 48 pages Stapled Edition: unknown
Collections: Mary Sue Ader-Andersen - Bas Jan Ader Estate,
courtesy of Patrick Painter Editions / Private collection, Cologne.
125
127
129
131
47. Sculpture
c. 1961 Painted plaster 19 x 22 x 24 cm
Collection: Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam,
inv. no. 3465 (MK)/donation 2000.
48. Untitled
c. 1961 Oil on canvas 71.5 x 30.5 cm
Collection: Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam,
inv. no. 3469 (MK)/donation 2000.
56. Eat
1963 Oil on chipboard on a wooden frame 121.9 x 91.4 x 8.9 cm
Signed: Bas Jan Ader 63
Collection: Dennis Parks.
59. Numbers
1963 Synthetic polymer paint on paper 61 x 48.3 cm
Signed, dated and dedicated lower right in pencil: Bas Jan Ader 63;
To Dennis and Julie
Dennis Parks Collection.
134
135
137
Description: Untitled Swedish fall comprises two colour photographs, of identical dimensions, placed side by side. The two
images show almost identical views of a pine forest. In the
left-hand image BJA stands beside a tree, in the right-hand
image he lies stretched out beside the same tree; a few felled
trees lie alongside him. As such a sequence is suggested. In both
prints BJAs position is identical to that of the trees, erect and
prone respectively. In the right-hand image he simulates a felled
tree; a touching depiction of the fall theme.
Comments: This work was produced during BJAs trip to Sweden
where he also made Farewell to faraway friends (cat. no. 12).
The two colour photographs were published posthumously by
the Estate in 2003. In 1972 BJA presented this work as a slide
projection in the exhibition Bas Jan Ader, William Leavitt, Ger
van Elk at the Pomona College Gallery, Montgomery Art Center,
Claremont, California. The film stills of Fall 1 and Fall 2 were
shown at the same exhibition. This emphasised the thematic
continuity.
According to Mary Sue Ader-Andersen, the work was originally
intended as a photo work (Mary Sue Ader-Andersen, conversation on 25 February 2006).
139
141
Elbrig de Groot
In his short films Bas Jan Ader defies gravity. He attempts, both literally and figuratively, to free himself from
the limits of existence inscribed by the laws of science, personal history, art history and the elements.
In 1992 Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen purchased a large part of Bas Jan Aders modest oeuvre from his
estate, represented by Galerie Paul Andriesse. In addition to eight photo pieces, a poster and videotape, the
museum also acquired almost all the film material that Ader had left behind. This extraordinary acquisition
was first exhibited in the summer of 1993 together with two loans from the then Rijksdienst Beeldende Kunst.
The films were shown on video.
In 1975 Bas Jan Ader departed from Cape Cod on a lone voyage to Lands End. The crossing from America to
England in a small yacht was to form the second part of his planned trilogy of works In search of the miraculous. Although he was an experienced sailor, his journey did not go as planned and his unmanned boat was
brought ashore six months later by fishermen at La Corua in Spain. When it became clear that Bas Jan
Ader would never return, his brother, Erik Ader, and one of the partners of Aders Dutch gallery Art &
Project, Adriaan van Ravesteijn, took charge of the estate, assisted by the artist Ger van Elk and the arts
2
administrator and collector Martijn Sanders. They asked the art historian and dealer Paul Andriesse to catalogue the estate and to write a monograph on the artist, which was eventually published to coincide with the
3
Bas Jan Ader exhibition at the Stedelijk Museum in Amsterdam in 1988. The transfer of the works to
Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen was affected in consultation with the artists widow Mary Sue AderAndersen. The museum was granted the screening rights for all Bas Jan Aders films on the understanding
that the film material would be conserved and made accessible. Concurrently Mary Sue transferred the
1. Postcard from Bas Jan Ader to Geert van Beijeren & Adriaan van Ravesteijn,
Martijn Sanders was the Managing Director of Jogchem's Theaters before becoming
undated, probably December 1970. Art & Project archive (Bas Jan Ader dossier),
of the Dutch public radio and television network AVRO and is a member of the Advisory
Committee for the Stedelijk Museum in Amsterdam. Both he and his father have
2. Ger van Elk (b.1941) was one of Aders closest friends. They studied together in
Amsterdam and Los Angeles and exhibited together in California in 1971 and 1972.
administration of the estate from Paul Andriesse to the American art dealer Patrick Painter.
On 1 November 1999 all the film material was examined at Cineco Amsterdam by Paul Andriesse, the artist
and filmmaker Gerard Holthuis and myself. The film material comprises originals, copies, test rolls, rejected
shots, authorised films and uncompleted projects. The condition of the films varied enormously; some original film material appeared to have been projected and the copies existed in various versions.
For the conservation and reconstruction of the films, which was supervised by Holthuis, the material was separated into presentation and documentary material. The six authorised films were edited and restored. Technically
and in terms of content every effort was made to adhere as closely as possible to Aders original intentions.
The editing was carried out on the basis of technical information in consultation with Gerard Holthuis. All the
film material was cleaned and, where necessary, restored: perforations were repaired and joins were re-spliced.
Where no original negative had survived, a new negative was made from the restored positive to serve as the
basis for screening copies. The original titles either handwritten or stencilled were restored and finally all
the material was cleaned ultrasonically.
For many years the copy of the films used during the
Bas Jan Ader exhibition at the Stedelijk Museum in
Amsterdam (1988) was believed to be the definitive set
of Aders complete authorised film production: Fall 1,
Los Angeles, 1970; Fall 2, Amsterdam, 1970; Im too sad
to tell you, 1971; Broken fall (geometric), Westkapelle,
Holland, 1971; Broken fall (organic), Amsterdamse Bos,
Holland, 1971 and Nightfall, 1971. Although the films
had had extremely limited distribution, various copies
had accumulated on film and/or video with quite noticeable variations. This gave cause to doubt the authenticity of the copies of the films shown at the Stedelijk
Museum (SM copy). In particular Im too sad to tell
you turned out to be considerably longer in compariBas Jan Ader during the filming of Im too sad to tell you, Amsterdam, 1971
son with material from other sources. Im too sad to
tell you; Fall 1, Los Angeles and Fall 2, Amsterdam had been included in the exhibition Film als beeldend
4
medium (Film as a plastic medium) organised by the Nederlandse Kunststichting in 1974. The composite
film, comprising the submissions of twelve Dutch visual artists, is now in the collection of the Netherlands
Institute for Cultural Heritage. The accompanying catalogue lists the duration of Im too sad to tell you as a
mere two minutes and five seconds, while Aders sorrow lasts for more than six minutes on the SM copy. In
order to establish a definitive version of each of Aders films we have taken Film als beeldend medium as a
point of comparison. Ader had submitted Im too sad to tell you; Fall 1, Los Angeles and Fall 2, Amsterdam to
the exhibition personally. These three films have been shown more frequently than the others, which is probably why varying versions have come into circulation.
In total Ader made three versions of Im too sad to tell you: one version in California, in which the artist sits
4. The exhibition and catalogue Film als beeldend medium was initiated in 1974 by the
in front of a fence (Cry Claremont, 1970) and two versions in Amsterdam filmed in a neutral space (1971).
Ader rejected the American version. Part of one of the Amsterdam versions (which I will call Amsterdam I)
was added to the other complete Amsterdam version (Amsterdam II). This combined version is the one
shown at the Stedelijk Museum in 1988. The length alone set alarm bells ringing.
Its duration differs substantially from the version on videotape in Museum
Boijmans Van Beuningens collection and that used in Film als beeldend medium.
The latter corresponds to only a small segment of the SM copy. The description in
the catalogue Film als beeldend medium provides no definite answer; in any case the
duration has been incorrectly stated here.
Given that Film als beeldend medium contains Amsterdam I, which is much less
theatrical and agitated than Amsterdam II (used for the overly long SM copy), I am
convinced that this is the sole authentic version. Bearing in mind the balance and
precision within Aders work as a whole, the combination of parts of Amsterdam I
and Amsterdam II is not convincing. The correspondence between Ader and Art & Project also makes clear
that only a fraction of the footage filmed in Amsterdam for Im too sad to tell you was actually used in Film als
5
beeldend medium.
Fall 1, Los Angeles and Fall 2, Amsterdam also exist in differing versions. On the SM copy of Fall 1, Los Angeles
the camera continues to run for a few seconds after Ader lands in the bushes, but in Fall 2, Amsterdam the
camera stops immediately after Ader falls in the ditch. In the versions in Film als beeldend medium both films
6
end directly after the fall. The film material includes a variety of footage filmed before and after the actual
falls. This has probably contributed to the confusion. For Fall 1, Los Angeles there is footage showing Ader
climbing a ladder onto the roof and performing a number of tests by allowing the chair to fall in various ways
from the roof. Likewise for Fall 2, Amsterdam there are different shots showing the Reguliersgracht with traffic
and passers-by and a fragment in which Ader is fished out of the water. The versions that show only the fall
itself appear most authentic and convincing given Aders preference for clarity and brevity. The same is true of
Broken fall (organic) and Broken fall (geometric). Here too, there are various versions showing the preparations
for and aftermath of the fall. In one variant of Broken fall (geometric) filming had to be stopped, to Aders
considerable fury, because a car drove into shot. In another we see him getting ready in the verge and walking
slowly towards the sawhorse and positioning himself beside it. The most compact version from the moment
at which he has readied himself alongside the sawhorse until he falls in the verge is the most convincing.
Nightfall poses no such problems. The available material on film and video is virtually identical, although
there is one version preformed with slightly less conviction than in the definitive version.
Since the films have been made available, interest in Aders work has grown enormously. Due to the number
of contaminated copies circulating on film and video, in principle the museum lends out only the edited
copies on 16 mm film format because it is often assumed that the works are videos or DVDs. Some institutions
offer old-fashioned monitors for authenticity, others mistakenly assume that the films should be shown as
installations with droning projectors. Plasma screens have also been installed, leading to bizarre distortions of
the image. All these assumptions are the consequence of the film mediums inclusion within exhibitions and
5. Art & Project archive (Bas Jan Ader dossier), Netherlands Institute for Art
museum collections since the 1960s. Exhibitions are not one-off events, but last on average six weeks. It is
understandable that films by visual artists are shown within the gallery context alongside two-dimensional or
three-dimensional works. Screenings in the cinema, on television and on the internet are governed by yet other
rules. In conserving and presenting artists films it is important to retain the original medium: film. Over the
years our vision has been muddied by considering copies of copies as to be work itself.
The remaining film material has also been organised and made accessible to visitors. The various test footage
and unauthorised films are not lent out and are available for consultation on video or DVD by appointment.
In addition to all the aforementioned trials for and versions of the authorised films there are also several
unfinished, rejected films or try-outs.
Cry Claremont, 1970; Light vulnerable objects threatened by eight cement bricks, 1970; Untitled (Daybreak), 1971;
Untitled (Tea party), 1972 and Primary colors (Red, yellow and blue glasses), 1973, are relatively complete
films, which for one reason or another Ader did not approve. Untitled (Tea party) was completed but contains
sections that are out of focus. The camera was operated by Aders friend the American artist William Leavitt.
The film begins in a wooded landscape. Ader, dressed in a dark suit and tie, crawls
from camera right towards a large cardboard box extreme left. The box is held
aloft on one side by a stick, creating a sort of tent. In this improvised tea pavilion a
tea service has been neatly laid out on a small tablecloth. Ader takes up position
beneath the box, pours himself a cup of tea and drinks it. The camera zooms out
and the box falls to the ground, trapping Ader inside. One can clearly see the cord
that is activated off camera to pull the stick away.
The idyllic location for this film is similar to that in the untitled film (Sussex, 1970)
by Gilbert & George included in Identifications, compiled and produced in 1970 by
Gerry Schum. Both Identifications and Schums 1969 production Land art provide
7
a context that helps to clarify Aders films.
Other material that presumably relates to the shooting of Untitled (Tea party) includes a fragment of a child playing with a cardboard box and footage showing Ader
eating and drinking. There is a series of photographs bearing the same title, which
was issued in an edition of three, one of which is in the collection of Museum
Boijmans Van Beuningen. Ader mentioned this film in his correspondence with Poul
ter Hofstede, the curator at the Groninger Museum responsible for preparing Aders
aborted show in 1975, but he never made a definitive edit of the film.
The hand-written title Daybreak refers to an incomplete film dealing with the four
elements. Bas Jan Ader stands on a rocky coast with his back to the crashing waves
and holds up a large sheet of paper bearing the inscription water. The camera
zooms out and then back in again. Ader now holds up a sheet with the word
earth written on it. Fighting against the wind, Ader completes the process with
7. See: exhib. cat. Ready to shoot: Fernsehgalerie Gerry Schum: Videogalerie Schum, Kunsthalle Dsseldorf, 2003.
air and fire. The film is clearly a try-out and is not edited.
Light vulnerable objects threatened by eight cement bricks is the record of a performance at the Chouinard Art Institute, where Ader taught. Various objects are
scattered throughout a large gallery with breezeblocks hanging from ropes directly
above them. Ader carefully cuts each of the ropes in turn, crushing the vulnerable
objects below: eggs, flowers, a transistor radio, a boxed birthday cake, a portrait, two
pillows and a string of illuminated light bulbs. The footage ends with a broad shot
of the entire space showing the crushed objects, followed by a text giving the location of the performance. There are various related pieces of footage, including one
showing Mary Sue. They are all undoubtedly documentary in nature.
Aders interest in light fall is explored further in a short fragment showing a closed set
of a Venetian blinds bound together with a string of illuminated light bulbs, which
he allows to drop in various stages: hanging, falling, lying.
Untitled (Waving), which was included ex-catalogue by Christopher Mller, is un8
edited. Ader is seen upside down and from behind, sitting on a chair on a hill,
waving a handkerchief, which, in the following piece of footage has changed appearance. Two other fragments show Ader in the same position without the handkerchief
and walking towards the camera carrying the chair. This is the world turned upside
down or as Piero Manzoni called his similar inversion, Socle du monde, 1961: the
art work as plinth for the globe. By turning the film on its head Ader has cheated
gravity once again.
Primary colors (Red, yellow and blue glasses) comprises numerous different reels and
can be considered a variant of Light vulnerable objects threatened by eight cement
bricks. Ader holds a breezeblock above a glass, filled in turn with yellow, red and
blue liquids. The camera zooms in on the glass until the colour fills the screen.
There are various different shots of the block, which has fallen and broken the glass.
The red glass was filmed most extensively. These are undoubtedly try-outs and are
amongst Aders first experiments with colour film; the colours are not always optimal.
In addition to making films Ader, like many artists at the time, also made works on
video, which was a much simpler medium to use than film. The equipment was
more user-friendly and there was no need to send the footage to be developed. The
medium had one drawback in this period in that it was not possible to montage the
material. Nonetheless, video was ideally suited to recording performances, environments or situations and all that was needed to present the work was a monitor.
Ader recorded two performances on video, one with an audience and one without.
8. Christopher Mller (ed.), Bas Jan Ader. Filme, Fotografien, Projektionen, Videos und
Zeichnungen aus den Jahren 19671975, Cologne 2000. Published to coincide with the
exhibition at the Kunstverein Braunschweig, Bonner Kunstverein and Kunstverein Mnchen.
In Primary time Ader re-arranges a mixed bouquet of red, yellow and blue flowers three times, adding and
removing flowers until the vase is filled exclusively with flowers of a single colour. The vase and flowers fill
the screen. Ader stands behind the vase, but we see only his hands at work. The camera follows the flower
arranging closely; the performance and the film have the same duration: 25 48. There is also a photo work
of this performance, comprising 21 stills arranged into three sequences of seven shots (Untitled, also known
as Flower work).
The boy who fell over Niagara Falls is a black and white recording of a performance that Ader performed several times. The video, whose duration is 1656, was made at Art & Project in Amsterdam in 1972. Ader sits on
a chair next to a table on which there is a reading lamp and a full glass of water. He produces a copy of the
popular scientific magazine Readers Digest and reads, in English, the adventure of a young boy who survived a fall over the Niagara Falls. At given points (marked with crosses in the article) he takes a sip of water
9
from the glass. When the glass is empty he falls silent and the performance is finished.
Bas Jan Aders unique film oeuvre deserves the viewers full attention; his short films should be shown alone
without other works to distract from them. However, full justice can be done to the videos by showing them
on monitors; they do not need to be projected in an auditorium or blown up to huge proportions. The two
media are quite distinct as Bruce Nauman once said: "Video is much more 'private' kind of communication.
Generally, it's what one person does. You sit and have contact with a television set, as opposed to a film, where
10
generally a lot of people go and the image is very large; it's more of a common experience."
Art & Project archive (Bas Jan Ader dossier), Netherlands Institute for Art
a letter from Ader to Geert van Beijeren and Adriaan van Ravesteijn dated 24 April
10. Bruce Nauman interviewed by Chris Dercon on video, Basel, July 1986, quoted in:
1973, the video was shown in the exhibition Bas Jan Ader, William Leavitt at the
Janet Kraynak (ed.), Please pay attention please: Bruce Naumans words: writings and
Mezzanine Art Gallery, Nova Scotia College of Art and Design, Halifax, 1-7 April 1973,
The following essay presents some of the findings of research carried out on behalf of Museum Boijmans
Van Beuningen and is an attempt to fill some of the gaps in our understanding of Bas Jan Aders work and philosophy.
Until recently little was known about Bas Jan Aders work from the early 1960s. Many works had been lost or
their location was unknown. However, in 2000 Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen acquired a painting on canvas,
a work on chipboard, five works on paper and a small painted plaster sculpture that the artist had made in
America in 1961. The works were donated by Emil Hrebenach who had taught Ader art in the early 1960s at the
Walter Johnson High School in Bethesda, Maryland. Ader was studying here as part of an exchange programme and had a studio in the schools basement, where he worked on paintings, sculptures and other spatial
1
works. Aders growing interest in visual art brought him into contact with the American artist Dennis Parks,
who at that time ran an exhibition space in Washington D.C.s old city centre called the Upstairs Gallery.
Here Ader was given his first opportunity to exhibit his work. Parks introduced Ader to Jos Nunez, who was
about to open a space called Galerie Realit and who invited Ader to show his works in the inaugural exhibi2
tion in 1961. The exhibition was reviewed in several newspapers, including the Washington Post of 23 April:
Basjan shows drawings which he would like to have seen as a creative play of lines, forms and accidents
3
rather than people or beasts. This exhibition led in turn to an invitation for Ader to show his work at the
4
Capitol Hill Community for Fine Arts in Washington, before he returned to the Netherlands. Although these
juvenilia should be viewed apart from his mature oeuvre, these works and indeed his time spent in America
in 1961 illustrate the extent of the 19-year old artists ambition.
1. Bob Nahuisen, Amerika bracht Basjan (19) uit Groningen onverwacht succes,
3. Leslie Judd Ahlander, If an art critic were president..., The Washington Post,
23 April 1961, p. 6.
Bas Jan Ader, thesis accompanying his MFA final show, 1967
(Claremont Graduate University archive, Claremont, California).
As stated, Aders early work should be seen as distinct from his later oeuvre, which for Ader should form an
integrated whole. Paul Andriesse discussed this point in 1988: Bas Jan Ader envisioned a total oeuvre that
would come together over a long period of time. When all the work was done, it would have a meaning that
for him was complete. When you looked at a part of it, it would tell you something about his work as a whole.
5
This is an idea that could have originated during his philosophy studies in 1967-1969. This idea may have
occurred to Ader already during his studies at the Claremont Graduate School in California, which he completed in 1967 with his final show Implosion. Ader made extensive photographic documentation of the exhi6
bition and it has been discussed in several publications on the artist. The exhibition was accompanied by
a 44-page book What makes me so pure, almost holy? And more + What does it mean? Cheep cheep, which
Ader published in an edition of one hundred.
Aders MFA thesis entitled Implosions Paintings and Constructions discusses his final show in a concrete,
7
rational manner: the notions of fall and rise were to be explored. He describes the exhibited works, whose
titles such as Humpty Dumpty fall guy, Plan for a dangerous journey and Niagara Falls show a remarkable
continuity with the later works of the 1970s. The text makes clear that Ader already placed great importance
on the cohesion between his works as a whole: Distinctions as to separate pieces can be made, but the interfusion of all pieces into one greater entity is also an objective (as in a family or nation). In all of this, relationships become of primary importance I like to call this spanning of a vacuum (of spatial or mental order) as
8
it takes place in the spectators mind: implosion.
The photographic documentation of Aders final show and his MFA thesis provide an insight into his artistic
oeuvre and particularly his early fascination with the concept fall that would take on such a central role in
the films he made some three years later: Fall 1, Los Angeles and Fall 2, Amsterdam.
Sonsbeek 71 correspondence
Approximately a year after Ader made the films Fall 1, Los Angeles and Fall 2, Amsterdam he was approached
in March 1971 by Rudi Oxenaar, the then director of the Krller-Mller Museum, to participate in the film
9
programme of the exposition Sonsbeek buiten de perken (Sonsbeek beyond the limits). In a letter he asked
10
Ader if he might show the films Dakval (Roof fall) and Fiets (Bicycle). Replying in English, Ader accepted,
but with certain reservations about Oxenaars planned presentation methods: I hereby accept your invitation to
exhibit two works at the Sonsbeek 71 manifestation; though I nourish the fervent wish you can find a less
avant-garde way than simultaneous projection on four sides to show these works Most of the works on film
by better artists are difficult enough to comprehend properly when shown by themselves in surroundings
5. Paul Andriesse, Bas Jan Ader: kunstenaar/artist, Amsterdam 1988, p. 91.
9. This contact came about through Art & Project and Frans Haks. In a letter from Ader
6. Paul Andriesse, op. cit., pp. 9-14 and 16-17 and Christopher Mller (ed.), Bas Jan Ader.
to Geert van Beijeren and Adriaan van Ravesteijn, 27 May 1971: Firstly my sincere
Filme, Fotografien, Projektionen, Videos und Zeichnungen aus den Jahren 19671975,
thanks for placing my 2 fall films in the Sonsbeek show. This was a most pleasant
surprise. (Art & Project archive (dossier Bas Jan Ader), Netherlands Institute for Art
7. Project description Bas Jan Ader (MFA thesis), 1967. (Claremont Graduate
10. Letter from R.W.D. Oxenaar to Bas Jan Ader, 25 March 1971 (Sonsbeek archive,
8. ibid.
11
conducive to thought and contemplation. Ader was clearly concerned that his films should not be shown
together with the works of other artists, so that the viewers attention should not be diluted.
Ader was also critical of the selection of films by Dutch artists; in the same letter he wrote: In view of the fact
that I have resided in the U.S. for the last 10 years and the list of Dutch artists already appears to be inflated with
too many names, most of whose work appears to be of questionable international merit, I wish to be included
amongst the U.S. contributors. It is noteworthy that Ader already considers himself an American artist and
12
has a clear idea of his position within the international art world.
It is also noteworthy that Oxenaar referred to the two valfilms as Dakval and Fiets, because Ader was initially
uncertain as to their definitive titles. Indeed he described them in a letter to Art & Project as, two films
13
about falling and Art and Project referred to the films shortly before Sonsbeek 71 as, fall from roof and
fall in canal. It was only when he came to complete the forms for the works inclusion in the Sonsbeek
buiten de perken catalogue that Ader gives them concrete titles. In his reply to Oxenaar he wrote: (dakval)
properly titled Fall, Los Angeles, 1970 and (fiets) Fall, Amsterdam 1970. Here the films did not yet have the
numbers by which they are now known. At Sonsbeek buiten de perken the films were shown in the wrong order,
14
which is probably the reason that Ader gave them numbers for the catalogue of Prospekt 71 However, Ader left
no doubt as to the date of the works. On the forms he dated them as follows: Fall, Los Angeles, 1970 in April
1970, and Fall, Amsterdam, 1970 in July 1970. He also added the following text: The artists body as gravity
makes itself its master.
The Amsterdam-based gallery Art & Project played an important role in Aders participation in Sonsbeek
15
buiten de perken in Arnhem and Prospekt 71 in Dsseldorf. The gallery represented his work in Europe and
16
was responsible for securing the purchase of three of Aders films by the Dutch State in 1974. The films Fall 1,
Los Angeles; Fall 2, Amsterdam and Im too sad to tell you were acquired by the Nederlandse Kunststichting
(Dutch Arts Council) as part of the exhibition Film als beeldend medium. This travelling exhibition was organised in 1974 for the Nederlandse Kunststichting by a project group at the University of Groningen led by
17
Wim Beeren. Aders entry in the catalogue was compiled by Poul ter Hofstede, a member of the project group
and curator at the Groninger Museum. In his correspondence with Ader, in addition to soliciting information
11. Letter from Bas Jan Ader to R.W.D. Oxenaar, 28 April 1971 (Sonsbeek archive,
Art & Projects intervention, Ader was eventually allowed to show his films at the
exhibition. Letter from Geert van Beijeren and Adriaan van Ravesteijn to Ader, 2 June
12. Eventually no distinction was drawn between Dutch and foreign artists in the
1971, Art & Project archive (Bas Jan Ader dossier), Netherlands Institute for Art
13. Letter from Bas Jan Ader to Geert van Beijeren and Adriaan van Ravesteijn,
16. Letter from Adriaan van Ravesteijn to Bas Jan Ader, 13 February 1974: Sure
16 February 1971, Art & Project archive (Bas Jan Ader dossier), Netherlands Institute
enough Her Majesty Minister of Culture has agreed to acquire three films from you!
Fall 1 and 2 + Im too sad..., Art & Project archive (Bas Jan Ader dossier),
14. In the catalogue for Prospekt 71 the films were given as Fall I (Los Angeles) and
Fall II (Amsterdam). The title sequences of the actual films read as follows: Fall 1 Los
17. Beeren later served as director of both Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen and
15. Ader was not initially invited to contribute to Prospekt 71. However, through
for the catalogue, Ter Hofstede asked if he would be willing to prepare a solo exhibition at the Groninger
Museum in the autumn of 1975. Ader responded positively to this invitation and proposed to exhibit the
18
planned conclusion to his trilogy: In search of the miraculous. However, Ader had already planned to complete
the trilogy with an exhibition at the Situation Gallery in London. In the autumn of 1973, though, the Situation
19
Gallery went bankrupt, forcing Ader to seek a new location. The exhibition at the Groninger Museum fitted
with his plan to make a European section of In search of the miraculous. To be certain that he would be able
to realise this plan, he wrote to Geert van Beijeren and Adriaan van Ravesteijn a few weeks before his departure
from America: Whats the situation with the Groninger Museum? If its nothing, let me know soon. I want to
confirm the European exhibition now and, since you are booked up already, if Groningen turns out not to be
20
interested, Ill have to make enquiries in Italy or France.
But the Groninger Museum was interested. The exhibition was reserved for the period 6 December 1975 to
21
4 January 1976. As at the opening of the first part of In search of the miraculous in May 1975 at the Claire
S. Copley Gallery in Los Angeles, a choir would sing sea shanties. Three months after Aders departure, his wife
Mary Sue dispatched the following pieces of sheet music to the Groninger Museum: A life on the ocean wave;
A wet sheet and a flowing sea; A Yankee ship and a Yankee crew; Beautiful sea; Good-bye, my lover, good-bye and
What are the wild waves saying? The Bragi students music society rehearsed the songs during Aders crossing,
but alas the performance never took place.
18. Ader asked the Groninger Museum to make a financial contribution to the exhibition
van Ravesteijn, 20 August 1974, Art & Project archive (Bas Jan Ader dossier),
in the form of an acquisition. The Museum agreed and proposed to purchase a work for
approximately 3,000.00 guilders. (Letter from Poul ter Hofstede to Bas Jan Ader,
12 November 1974. A copy of this letter is in the Poul ter Hofstede archive).
20. Letter from Ader to Geert van Beijeren and Adriaan van Ravesteijn, undated
19. Ader wrote about the Situation Gallerys closure: I was very sorry about
(probably May or June 1975), Art & Project archive (Bas Jan Ader dossier),
Situations closure last autumn. I was going to complete a work there that comprises
an American and a European part: In search of the miraculous. (The American part
was already finished and Anthony saw it and thought it was beautiful). They would
21. Note in Poul ter Hofstedes notebook during the organisation of the exhibition:
then publish it as a book (after I had made the European part there) and publish it
exhib. period: 6 Dec 1975 4 Jan 1976, Poul ter Hofstede archive.
to coincide with the exhibition. Letter from Ader to Geert van Beijeren and Adriaan
Letter from Bas Jan Ader to Poul ter Hofstede, 20 August 1974 (Groninger Museum exhibitions archive, housed in the RHC Groninger Archieven, Groningen).
Ter Hofstede used this information in the catalogue for Film als beeldend medium, 1974.
155
Aug 20 74
a work that I was indeed
Dear Mr Ter Hofstede.
letter writer.
sure.
sence?
finished is entitled:
(purchase, or something).
My position here at the University
Kind regards
This research has shown that in 1961 Ader exhibited several times in Washington D.C. rather than the single
instance that had previously been believed. Because no primary documentation has surfaced to support this
information, these newly added exhibitions are explained by a footnote. Another exhibition that has never been
mentioned in the Ader literature is the travelling educational exhibition Mooi alleen hoeft niet (It doesnt have
22
to be beautiful) organised by the Nederlandse Kunststichting in 19761977. This exhibition included Aders
23
films Fall 1, Los Angeles and Fall 2, Amsterdam. Like Film als beeldend medium in 1974, Mooi alleen hoeft
niet was a touring exhibition and was shown at no less than eighty different institutions in the Netherlands
24
between 1976 and 1979.
The list of exhibitions is as complete as possible for the period 19611975. Where there is a known invitation
card for the exhibition it is noted as follows: (inv.). Where a substantial catalogue was published, it is noted as
(cat.). The catalogue details can be found in the bibliography. The list of exhibitions since 1976 is selected.
The bibliography
This research into Bas Jan Aders oeuvre has uncovered many additional documents on Ader published in his
lifetime. I have attempted to provide as complete a bibliography as possible for the period 19611975. I have
supplemented the bibliography compiled by Paul Andriesse in 1988 with additional items discovered during
this research. I have provided a selected bibliography from 1976 to the present day. The bibliographical information has been split between two distinct lists, one for exhibition catalogues and books and one for newspaper and magazine articles.
23. Een andere kijk op de natuur in Mooi alleen hoeft niet, Amsterdam, 1977, p. 1.
1988
1963
1993
1967
1994
1970
1995
1973
1999
1974
2000
1975
2001
1. This emerged during a conversation I had with Dennis Parks, who owned
The Upstairs Gallery in Washington in 1961 (telephone conversation Doede
2002
2003
1972
2004
1974
2006
1976
1971
1977
1979
1992
1980
19921993
1981
1993
1982
1994
19871988
1995
1988
19951996
1996
Reel Work: Artists Films and Videos from the 1960s and
1970s, Museum of Contemporary Art, Miami.
January25 February, More Than Real, Palazzo Reale
di Caserta, Naples.
1 June27 July, Dites-le avec des fleurs, Galerie Chantal
Crousel, Paris.
23 JuneSeptember, Autoreverse 2, Centre National dArt
Contemporain, Grenoble.
19961997
20012002
19971998
20022003
2003
20042005
20032004
20052006
Bibliography 19611975
Exhibition catalogues and books
1971
1972
1962
1963
1973
1971
1974
1972
Betty van Garrel, Bas Jan Aders tragiek schuilt in een pure
val, Haagse Post, 5 January11 January 1972, pp. 48-49.
William Wilson, Photo-Sculpture Show at Otis,
Los Angeles Times, 14 February, 1972, p. 8.
1961
1973
1974
1976
1977
1978
1975
1979
1980
1986
1998
1987
1988
2000
1991
2001
2002
1993
1994
2003
1995
1996
2004
1997
2005
1986
1988
2006
1976
1978
1980
1981
1989
1982
1991
1984
1993
1985
Thea Figee, Klein maar kloppend oeuvre van Bas Jan Ader,
Kunstbeeld, July-August 1993.
1998
1999
1994
James Roberts, Bas Jan Ader: the artist who fell from grace
with the sea, Frieze, no. 17, June-August 1994.
2000
Carel Blotkamp, The End, De Witte Raaf, no. 83, JanuaryFebruary 2000.
1995
Cindy Loehr, Bas Jan Ader, New Art Examiner, March 2000.
1996
1997
, Verschollen auf hoher See, Der Spiegel, no. 18, May 2000.
Peter Herbstreuth, Bas Jan Ader, Flash Art, vol. 36, no. 229,
MarchApril 2003.
2003
2001
Hilde van Gelder, Bas Jan Ader, De Witte Raaf, vol. 15, no.
90, MarchApril 2001.
2004
2002
2006
Others
1994
2005
1996
2004
Marcus Field, Lots of fun and games for all the family,
The Independant, 5 June, 2005.
2006
Biography
1956
19 April 1942
19591960
4 November 1944
1960
20 November 1944
1961
November 1947
1962
1971
1963
1972
19631965
1973
June 1965
1974
1967
1975
19671969
1976
Authors
Erik Beenker is a free-lance arts journalist. He worked at Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen from 1986-2005,
latterly as head of the education department.
Alexandra Blttler is programme director of the CoalMine Fotogalerie in Winterthur and works as an academic researcher
at the Fotomuseum Winterthur, cataloguing the estate of Mark Morrisroe.
Tacita Dean is a visual artist. Born in Canterbury (UK), she works in a variety of media, including drawing,
photography, sound and 16mm film. She currently lives and works in Berlin.
Elbrig de Groot is an art historian. She has been a curator of modern and contemporary Art at Museum Boijmans
Van Beuningen in Rotterdam since 1979.
Doede Hardeman is an art historian. He undertakes free-lance research and publishes on twentieth-century art.
He lives and works in Utrecht.
Jrg Heiser is a curator and writer. He is co-editor of Frieze magazine and also writes for the Sddeutsche Zeitung.
He is preparing a touring exhibition for 2007-2008 entitled Romantic Conceptualism, to include work by among others
Andy Warhol, Robert Barry, Susan Hiller, Mathilde ter Heijne and Bas Jan Ader. He lives and works in Berlin.
Rein Wolfs is a curator and writer. He has been chief curator at Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen in Rotterdam since 2001.
Colophon
Thanks to: Mary Sue Ader-Andersen, Erik Ader, Peter van Beveren, Claire Copley,
Daniel Congdon (Patrick Painter Editions), Rene Daalder, Koos Dalstra & Marion
van Wijk, Peter Dykhuis (Nova Scotia College of Art and Design), Marianne Elder
(Claremont Graduate University, Claremont, California), Jim Foster, Ida Gianelli,
Hal Glicksman, Frans Haks, Poul ter Hofstede, Anita Hopmans (Netherlands
Emil Hrebenach, Maartje de Jong, Eddy de Jonge (The RHC Groninger Archieven),
Jrg Heiser
Bas Jan Ader Estate, courtesy of Patrick Painter Editions; Koninklijke Bibliotheek,
Archieven, Groningen; Poul ter Hofstede archive; Art & Project archive
51/53 (photography Tom Haartsen), 55, 59, 61, 89, 93, 95, 97, 101 (top),
104 (top), 107, 109, 111, 113, 115, 119, 137, 139, 141, 144, 151, 171.
archive, Sittard; Steven Leiber archive, San Francisco; Museum Boijmans Van
Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam: pp. 9, 12, 13 (top), 21, 23, 37,
39, 41, 43, 45, 47, 57, 63, 73, 75, 77, 79, 81, 83, 85, 87, 99, 127, 129,
131, 134, 135 (cat. no. 52, 53, 54) 145, 146, 147.
California; Archives of the Nova Scotia College of Art and Design, Halifax.
Poul ter Hofstede archive (photography John Stoel): pp. 104 (bottom), 117.
Museumpark 18/20
3015 CX Rotterdam
Dennis Parks collection: p. 135 (cat. no. 55, 56, 57, 58, 59).
Jim Foster collection, Fort Collins, CO: p. 135 (cat. no. 60).
info@boijmans.rotterdam.nl
www.boijmans.nl
Courtesy of the Archives of the Nova Scotia College of Art and Design: p. 101
(bottom).
www.ideabooks.nl
Groningen: p. 155.
Claremont Graduate University archive, Claremont, California: pp. 150, 151.
Cover images: Telegram from Poul ter Hofstede to Mary Sue Ader-Andersen,
Letter from Mary Sue Ader-Andersen to Poul ter Hofstede, 18 October 1975.
Poul ter Hofstede archive (photography John Stoel).
This publication accompanies the exhibition Bas Jan Ader, All is Falling held
from 28 April until 2 July 2006 at Camden Arts Centre, London. The exhibition
ABN AMRO
CALDIC
Rotterdam.
Imtech N.V.
DURA VERMEER GROEP N.V.
Arkwright Road
Unilever
Fortis Bank
www.camdenartscentre.org
NautaDutilh
KPMG
Stichting Organisatie van Effectenhandelaren te Rotterdam
Nidera Handelscompagnie b.v.
KOEN VISSER GROEP
Stad Rotterdam Verzekeringen
Gebrs. Coster Beheer B.V.
Gemeente Rotterdam, Afdeling Externe Betrekkingen
De Brauw Blackstone Westbroek
Rendra
Baris Group
SV Projektinrichters
Thony en Melanie Ruys
PricewaterhouseCoopers
ING Bank Rotterdam
TDS printmaildata
Hotel New York Groep
Hollandsche Bank-Unie N.V.
OC&C Strategy Consultants
WEMAR Marketingstrategie en Onderzoek B.V.
Van Uden Group B.V.
Breeman Automotive Groep
Fortress Groep
Rabobank Rotterdam
Schipper Van der Mersch Advocaten
Korbel
Familie R.P.R. von Weiler, Rotterdam
Faasen & Partners
M&R De Monchy N.V.
ENECO Energie
Port of Rotterdam
D. Berghout B.V.
RoyalBurgerGroup
TBI Holdings
Anthony Veder Group NV
Van Agt + Dussel Notarissen
Burgers Ergon
De heer en mevrouw C. Zachariasse