s u m m a r y
Keywords:
Electronic fetal monitoring
Category I, II and III fetal tracings
Late decelerations
Variable decelerations
Sinusoidal
Electronic fetal heart rate monitoring is a widely utilized means of assessment of fetal status during labor.
Whereas little evidence exists regarding efcacy, this modality continues to be used extensively in every
modern labor and delivery unit in developed countries. It is of importance that all providers of health
care to the woman in labor and her newborn have a clear understanding of the basic pathophysiology of
fetal heart rate monitoring and an appreciation for labor course and concerns as they arise in order to
optimize outcomes and patient safety.
2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Electronic fetal heart rate monitoring (EFM) is widely used in
nearly every modern labor and delivery unit in the developed
world, and was initially introduced for clinical use in the late 1960s
as an alternative to the very labor-intensive auscultation of the fetal
heart. EFM uses either the direct electrical signal of the fetal heart
rate captured through a fetal electrode (direct) or more usually
employs ultrasound technology and Doppler physics to interpret
the changes in frequency of sound waves reected from pulsations
within fetal vessels (indirect). The aim of such monitoring, which is
generally continuous, is to enable clinicians to accurately identify
hypoxic fetuses at risk for deterioration and who might benet
from expedited or immediate delivery either vaginally or by Cesarean section. Whereas EFM remains an accepted component of
labor management and fetal assessment, the true positive predictive value for metabolic acidosis is low. Unfortunately, this often
results in unnecessary interventions and a signicant increase in
the Cesarean section rate for concerns regarding fetal intolerance of
labor. Such an observation may be the result of appropriate early
intervention before worsening of metabolic condition occurs or
inappropriate early intervention from a misreading of the information generated from the fetal monitor. Whereas the negative
predictive value is exceptionally high (a normal fetal heart rate is
associated with a normally oxygenated and non-acidotic fetus) and
the rate of unexpected intrapartum stillbirth approaches zero,
nonetheless, despite the wide usage of EFM, unfortunately there
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.siny.2015.02.002
1744-165X/ 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Please cite this article in press as: Nageotte MP, Fetal heart rate monitoring, Seminars in Fetal & Neonatal Medicine (2015), http://dx.doi.org/
10.1016/j.siny.2015.02.002
M.P. Nageotte / Seminars in Fetal & Neonatal Medicine xxx (2015) 1e5
4. Early decelerations
An early deceleration is a uniformly shaped deceleration of
gradual onset and gradual return to baseline associated with a
uterine contraction. The degree of slowing generally is proportional
to the strength of the associated uterine contraction, and the timing
of the deceleration accompanying the uterine contraction generally
mirrors the contraction with the early deceleration nadir at the
peak of the contraction. Early decelerations are thought to result
from fetal head compression altering cerebral blood ow and
leading to cardiac slowing through a vagal reex. This is supported
by the experimental nding that early decelerations can be abolished or altered by the administration of atropine. Early decelerations are generally seen in active labor and are a pattern not
associated with fetal hypoxia, acidosis, or subsequent depressed
Apgar scores.
Please cite this article in press as: Nageotte MP, Fetal heart rate monitoring, Seminars in Fetal & Neonatal Medicine (2015), http://dx.doi.org/
10.1016/j.siny.2015.02.002
M.P. Nageotte / Seminars in Fetal & Neonatal Medicine xxx (2015) 1e5
5. Variable decelerations
The most common deceleration of the fetal heart rate is the
variable deceleration. Variable decelerations frequently occur in
both the rst and second stages of labor and are usually indicative
of some degree of obstruction to fetal blood ow through the
umbilical cord or compression of the vessels within the cord. Again,
the mechanism of such deceleration is thought to be mediated
through the vagus nerve and often bears no temporal relationship
to uterine contractions. Hypoxia is clearly not required to produce
variable decelerations, as changes in fetal blood pressure associated
with umbilical cord compression alone can produce such patterns.
Data from studies using continuous fetal pulse oximetry also have
demonstrated that deep and relatively prolonged variable decelerations occur often without any change in fetal oxygen saturation. Pregnancies complicated with decreased amniotic uid
(oligohydramnios) are associated with more frequent patterns of
variable decelerations, and this is thought to be related to the loss of
the protective effect of the amniotic uid on the fetal umbilical
cord. Such a relationship is further supported by the fact that, in
cases with diminished amniotic uid in labor treated with saline
amnio-infusion via a transcervical catheter, there is a reduction in
the frequency of variable decelerations in both preterm and term
fetuses compared to controls [2].
Variable decelerations characteristically are very abrupt in onset
and return to baseline. They may be associated with fetal movement or uterine contractions and are most commonly seen in the
second stage of labor associated with maternal Valsalva and
pushing efforts. Variable decelerations have different degrees of
decrease of heart rate, time below baseline, and rate of return to
baseline. The vast majority of variable decelerations are not associated with signicant hypoxia or acidosis. Because of their frequency and unpredictability, variable decelerations must be
evaluated and managed closely. With cord compression that is
prolonged and repetitive, there may be the development of progressive fetal hypoxia and respiratory acidosis. Thus, variable decelerations have been graded as mild, moderate, and severe. Mild
variable decelerations last for <30 s regardless of level or a deceleration not <70e80 bpm of any duration. Moderate variable decelerations have a nadir of <80 bpm regardless of duration. Severe
variable decelerations are both <70 bpm and have a duration of
>60 s. More recently, variable decelerations are no longer subclassied as mild, moderate, or severe, but must be a decrease of
15 bpm lasting 15 s and <2 min in individual duration. Variable
decelerations that are recurrent (occurring with >50% of contractions) and that progress to greater depth and longer duration are
moderate variability of the baseline heart rate, or the occurrence of
spontaneous or induced accelerations strongly support the fact that
the fetus is not acidotic. Management should be directed at
attempting to relieve umbilical cord compression with repositioning of the patient or consideration of amnio-infusion.
described a slowing of the fetal heart rate related to uterine contractions with gradual onset usually following the peak of the
uterine contraction and delayed return of the deceleration to the
baseline, usually following the contraction. The gradual decrease in
fetal heart rate is symmetrical and dened from the onset to the
nadir of 30 s in duration. The fetal heart rate rarely falls
>30e40 bpm below baseline and usually not >10e20 bpm. In most
cases, the onset, nadir, and recovery occur following contraction
beginning, peak, and ending. This late deceleration is thought to
have both a fetal reex and hypoxic component. In most instances,
late deceleration is primarily a reex change associated with nonacidotic hypoxia. However, when hypoxia is associated with
acidosis, the mechanism of late deceleration is more concerning,
because of direct myocardial depression, and is not reex.
Late decelerations are signicant and concerning when they are
persistent and not amenable to corrective measures. Variability
often increases during the contraction and is not a reassuring sign.
Most ususally, late decelerations appear before the loss of variability and are reex in nature from transient fetal hypoxia most
often related to uterine activity, frequency and strength, or
maternal hypotension. The presence of persistent late decelerations
with the loss of variability and elevation of the fetal baseline heart
rate is far more signicant than the presence of the decelerations
alone and strongly suggest fetal intolerance to the hypoxic stress of
uterine contractions. Such associations strongly correlate with
neonatal depression.
7. Prolonged decelerations
Prolonged decelerations are generally isolated decelerations
lasting >2 min. Such a decrease must be 15 bpm below baseline
and last <10 min. If a deceleration lasts 10 min, it is termed a
baseline change and considered a bradycardia. Such decelerations
are difcult to classify by pathophysiologic cause, as they appear in
any number of clinical situations. Cord compression is a frequent
etiology for prolonged decelerations. Profound placental insufciency, hypertonic uterine contractions, or severe maternal
compromise (such as seizures, profound hypoxia, cardiac decompensation, trauma) and certain types of drug overdosage may be
associated with prolonged fetal heart rate decelerations. In most
instances, as long as the original insult thought to be responsible for
the prolonged deceleration is corrected, the placenta is a very
effective organ to adequately resuscitate the fetus. Clinical decisions regarding recurrent prolonged decelerations must be individualized and are the most difcult of all patterns to manage.
Gestational age, presumed etiology, course of labor, and other
factors must be considered. Although generally isolated and unpredictable, prolonged decelerations represent a clinical challenge
in both the antepartum and intrapartum management of certain
pregnancies.
8. Sinusoidal pattern
6. Late decelerations
When the blood ow through the intervillous space is decreased
to a degree that causes fetal hypoxia, uteroplacental insufciency
is said to exist. This may be the result of fetal or maternal factors
and can manifest itself in the chronic form with intrauterine
growth restriction, antepartum fetal compromise, or stillbirth. In
the acute form, with the presence of prolonged and deteriorating
fetal intolerance to labor, intrapartum asphyxia or e in the extreme
e intrapartum fetal death, may occur. Associations between certain
characteristic changes in the fetal heart rate associated with uteroplacental insufciency have been established through the early
work of Hon, Caldeyro-Barcia, and many others [3,4]. They
Please cite this article in press as: Nageotte MP, Fetal heart rate monitoring, Seminars in Fetal & Neonatal Medicine (2015), http://dx.doi.org/
10.1016/j.siny.2015.02.002
M.P. Nageotte / Seminars in Fetal & Neonatal Medicine xxx (2015) 1e5
pattern is not clearly understood, an association between sinusoidal heart rate and fetal plasma arginine vasopressin concentration
in response to the anemia has been reported [5].
9. Uterine contractions
A key component of electronic fetal monitoring is the assessment of uterine activity. Generally, uterine activity is deemed
adequate if there is progress in labor with cervical dilation and
descent of the fetal presenting part. Failure of such progress may
result from inadequate uterine activity, and augmentation of labor
is often necessary. However, excessive uterine activity resulting
from pathology such as abruptio placenta or overstimulation of the
uterus with various medications may result in fetal compromise in
the form of hypoxia and acidosis. In labor, uterine contraction frequency is the number of contractions in a 10 min window averaged
over 30 consecutive minutes. Uterine contraction intensity, duration, and relaxation time are also clinically important assessments.
Normal uterine activity is ve or fewer contractions in 10 min
averaged over a 30 min window of time. Tachysystole or increased
uterine activity is greater than ve contractions in 10 min averaged
over a 30 min window. When present, tachysystole should always
be assessed for the presence or absence of decelerations of the fetal
heart rate. When associated with decelerations, tachysystole requires evaluation and treatment. In active labor, patients with
tachysystole thought secondary to the supplemental usage of
oxytocin should be considered as candidates to have the oxytocin
reduced or discontinued to reduce the uterine activity and minimize the risk of suspected evolving fetal hypoxia and potentially
acidosis. Rarely, if efforts to reduce uterine activity are unsuccessful
and the decelerations of the fetal heart rate are concerning (e.g.,
prolonged or recurrent late decelerations), tocolytic agents such as
terbutaline may be indicated to attempt in-utero resuscitation of
the fetus.
10. Three-tier fetal heart rate interpretation system
In 2008, a Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child
Health and Human Development (NICHD) consensus panel developed a uniform system of denitions and terminology in the
interpretation of fetal heart rate patterns [6]. This resulted from
concerns relating to lack of consistency in the management and
interpretation of intrapartum fetal heart rate patterns. The goal of
such denitions was to allow the meaningful assessment of the
predictive value of, and to develop evidence-based clinical management protocols for, the clinical management of fetal compromise during labor. This report emphasized that fetal heart rate
tracings need to be evaluated in the context of several different
clinical conditions, which include gestational age, medications,
maternal health status, prior fetal assessments, and suspected
concerning fetal conditions including anemia, arrhythmias, and
growth restriction. Complete assessment of the fetal heart tracing
requires both a qualitative and quantitative description of the
uterine activity, baseline fetal heart rate and variability, presence of
accelerations, periodic or episodic decelerations, and changes or
trends of the pattern over time. Decelerations are dened as
recurrent if they occur with more than half of the uterine contractions in any 20 min window. When decelerations occur with
less frequency they are dened as intermittent. The fetal heart rate
tracing needs to be interpreted in the context of the clinical situation, which is often very dynamic. Consequently, the interpretation
and assignment of certain patterns to certain categories is also
dynamic and likely to change during labor. The presence of either
spontaneous or stimulated accelerations of the fetal heart rate
predicts the absence of fetal metabolic acidosis. However, the
Practice points
EFM is a highly reliable assessment of normal fetal
oxygenation when it is Category I.
Over the course of labor, the fetal heart rate will often
change between Categories I and II and does not necessarily suggest any significant worsening of fetal status.
Category III fetal heart rate patterns are most concerning,
correlate highly with need for neonatal resuscitation, and
need to be acted upon with either improvement or delivery of the fetus.
Please cite this article in press as: Nageotte MP, Fetal heart rate monitoring, Seminars in Fetal & Neonatal Medicine (2015), http://dx.doi.org/
10.1016/j.siny.2015.02.002
M.P. Nageotte / Seminars in Fetal & Neonatal Medicine xxx (2015) 1e5
References
Research directions
There needs to be ongoing research into new technologies
that may serve as adjuncts to EFM for fetal assessment.
Studies utilizing proposed management strategies for
Category II tracing must be done to provide evidence that
such strategies are appropriate.
Use of a common language and intrapartum management
approach must be stressed for each institution providing
labor and delivery services, as well as monitoring to insure
patient safety and improved perinatal outcomes.
None.
Please cite this article in press as: Nageotte MP, Fetal heart rate monitoring, Seminars in Fetal & Neonatal Medicine (2015), http://dx.doi.org/
10.1016/j.siny.2015.02.002