145
Wogelius et al.
opacidades pueden romperse debido a las fuerzas de la
masticacin, lo que resultar en la prdida macroscpica
de la sustancia dental (1-3).
La condicin es comn y estudios previos han reportado
tasas de prevalencia del 3-37% en perma- nente primer
molar (4-11). La mayor parte de los defectos son
opacidades demarcadas de color blanco cremoso, pero
opacity- relacionados con la prdida macroscpica de la
sustancia dental en primeros molares permanentes se han
notificado a ocurrir hasta en un 8% de los nios (7).
Los sntomas frecuentes despus de la prdida de esmalte
macroscpica incluyen la sensibilidad de los dientes
afectados aumentaron, el rpido desarrollo de la caries en
los dientes afectados y la ruptura repetida de las
restauraciones que ya estn incluidas (1, 12). Por lo tanto,
el manejo clnico de la enfermedad se ve obstaculizada.
A pesar de su alta prevalencia y complicaciones clnicas
integrales, la etiologa de esta condicin requiere
aclaracin. Estudios anteriores han indicado que los
factores sistmicos, tales como las infecciones del tracto
urinario maternas durante el ltimo perodo del embarazo,
parto prematuro, la ingesta prolongada de la leche
materna, con especial referencia a la dioxinacontaminacin, la mala salud general en los primeros 3
aos, o la falta de calcio fosfato puede causar opacidades
demarcadas (1).
Otra causa sistmica se sospecha es el asma y su
tratamiento (13, 14). Esta cuestin se examin en un
estudio poblacional, transversal que incluy 696 nios de
9 aos de edad, de Nueva Zelanda que tenan un examen
mdico y dental (13). Entre los 121 nios con asma en el
momento del examen, se ha demostrado un aumento del
riesgo de opacidades CATed demarcacin. La formacin
del esmalte de los primeros molares se lleva a cabo
durante la ltima parte del embarazo y el primer
3 aos despus del nacimiento, lo que nos hizo considerar
este perodo sera el momento en el que el esmalte del
primer molar permanente era ms vulnerables a la
exposicin sistmica. Tomarse el tiempo correspondiente
ventana en consideracin, Jalevik et al. realizado un
estudio transversal basado en la poblacin de 516
8 aos de edad. Utilizaron informaron sus padres en la
informacin sobre los factores de embarazo y la salud del
nio durante los 3 primeros aos de vida (14). Entre cinco
nios con asma durante el primer ao de vida, cuatro
haban demarcado opacidades en primer molar
permanente en comparacin con 73 entre los 511 nios
sin asma, lo que result en un odds ratio de (IC del 95%:
5,2 a 110,0) 24.
Los dos estudios que examinaron la asociacin entre el
asma y opacidades delimitadas en los dientes permanente
no incluan informacin sobre los medicamentos para el
asma. Por lo tanto, se realiz un estudio
para comparar la prevalencia de opacidades demarcadas
de los primeros molares permanentes entre los nios con y
sin la informacin del registro en el consumo de drogas
asma desde su nacimiento.
146
Material y mtodos
poblacin de estudio
El estudio se realiz en los municipios anteriores Stovring
y Nibe en la Regin Norte (ex Jutlandia del Norte del
Condado), Dinamarca. El grupo de estudio consisti de
todos los nios en los dos municipios (n = 891) que
estaban 6-8 aos de edad durante el perodo de estudio
desde enero 1, 2005 hasta diciembre 31, 2005.
En Dinamarca, el cuidado dental es gratis para los nios
hasta la edad de 18 aos. Todos los nios se ofrecen
regularmente examen dental, y la mayora de los nios son
examinados rutinariamente cada ao. En los dos
municipios de estudio, el servicio dental fue ofrecida por
tres clnicas dentales infantiles municipales que decidieron
realizar la grabacin de las opacidades CATed
demarcacin una parte del examen clnico regular. Para
ms detalles, vase Wogelius et al. (11). El estudio fue
aprobado por la Agencia de Proteccin de Datos de
Dinamarca (File # 2007-41-0178). Ing de acuerdo a la
legislacin danesa el consentimiento informado de los
padres no es necesario cuando la aprobacin de la
se obtiene Agencia Danesa de Proteccin de Datos.
Los datos sobre los medicamentos para el asma
Todas las farmacias de la Regin Norte estn equipadas
con un sistema de contabilidad computarizado mediante el
cual los datos se envan al Servicio de Salud Nacional de
Dinamarca como parte de un programa de salud apoyado
impuesto nacional. La parte del programa de reembolsos
de los costos asociados con la compra de los
medicamentos recetados, incluyendo medicamentos para
el asma. En la Regin Norte, el sistema de contabilidad
tambin proporciona datos clave sobre las recetas de
medicamentos reembolsables a la base de datos de la
prescripcin farmacolgica (15). Esta base de datos
incluye informacin sobre: (i) el tipo de frmaco de
acuerdo con el sistema anatmico-teraputica-qumica
clasificacin cin (16), (ii) dispersin al del frmaco, (iii)
los cdigos municipio, (iv) la fecha de compra de la
prescripcin drogas y (v) y nmero de registro civil del
paciente, un nmero que se ha asignado a todos los
residentes en Dinamarca desde 1968 y que codifica sexo y
fecha de nacimiento. medicamentos para el asma se
clasifican en: (a) inhalados b2-agonistas, (b) los agonistas
b2 orales y (c) los corticosteroides inhalados. Un historial
de recetas com- pleta se puede establecer para todos los
nios nacidos durante el ao 1996 y en adelante.
Gestational age
To elucidate whether preterm birth is a confounder
we included information on gestational age from
the Danish Medical Birth Registry (17).
Data analysis
The unit of analysis is individuals, and the analysis
was restricted to children with four fully erupted
permanent molars in order to avoid misclassification of individuals.
Results
Among the 891 children included, 745 (83.6%) were
examined. The remaining 146 children were not
examined for various reasons: withdrawn from the
municipal clinic (n = 4), moved outside the municipality (n = 28), missed the appointment (n = 13),
not invited because the individual interval between
two routine examinations was longer than 1 year
(n = 3) and, finally, the staff forgot to examine
some children for opacities during the routine
examinations (n = 98).
The proportions of children with fully erupted
permanent first molars were 90.9% among girls,
83.2% among boys, 89.2% among individuals
without asthma drug prescriptions, 79.3% among
individuals with prescriptions for both inhaled
b2-agonists and inhaled corticosteroids anytime,
and 79.7% among individuals with prescriptions
for both inhaled b2-agonists and inhaled corticosteroids during the first 3 years of life.
Among the 647 children with fully erupted
permanent first molars, 264 (40.8%) received no
asthma drug prescriptions from birth until the time
of the dental examination (Table 1). The remaining
Table 1. Distribution of children according to type of demarcated opacities and prescriptions of asthma drugs (inhaled
b2-agonists, inhaled corticosteroids, and oral b2-agonists)
Inhaled b2agonists and
steroids
Inhaled
b2-agonists
Before
Before
Anytime third year Anytime third year Anytime
N (%)
N (%)
N (%)
N (%)
N (%)
Number of children
65
47
Category of opacity Creamy-white
16 (24.6) 11 (23.4)
Yellowish-brown 5 (7.7)
5 (10.6)
Opacity-related
5 (7.7)
6 (12.9)
loss of tooth
substance
Any
20 (30.8) 15 (31.9)
No asthma
drug
prescriptions
Oral
b2-agonists
Before
third year Anytime
N (%)
N (%)
50
34
14 (28.0) 10 (29.4)
3 (6.0)
2 (5.9)
3 (6.0)
3 (8.8)
254
257
264
98 (38.6) 95 (37.0) 83 (31.4)
25 (9.8)
23 (8.9)
26 (9.8)
19 (7.5)
18 (7.0)
13 (4.9)
15 (30.0) 10 (29.4)
96 (36.4)
Some children who used oral b2-agonists during the first three years were prescribed inhaled asthma drugs later in life.
Table 2. Distribution of children according to demarcated opacities in permanent first molars and use of asthma drugs
(both inhaled b2-agonists and inhaled corticosteroids) the first 3 years of life compared with children with no
prescriptions of asthma drugs
Type of demarcated opacity
Number of children
Creamy-white
Yellowish-brown
Opacity-related
loss of tooth substance
Any
None
11
83
0.70
(0.301.50)
5
24
1.09
(0.303.23)
6
13
2.42
(0.707.43)
15
96
0.82
(0.391.65)
32
168
Prevalence odds ratio (OR) with 95% confidence interval (95% CI).
opacities of any type, and none (0%) had opacityrelated loss of tooth substance. The remaining 594
children were at term and among these 220 (37.0%)
had demarcated opacities of any type and 41 (6.9%)
children had opacity-related loss of tooth substance.
Among children with prescriptions for both
inhaled b2-agonists and inhaled corticosteroids
during the first 3 years of life, the proportion with
yellowish-brown opacities or opacity-related loss
of tooth substance was higher than in children
without asthma drug prescriptions and in children
with prescriptions of only inhaled or oral
b2-agonists (Table 1).
The ORs of demarcated opacities are presented
in Table 2, which compares children with prescriptions for both inhaled b2-agonists and inhaled
corticosteroids during the first 3 years of life with
children without prescriptions for asthma drugs.
Overall, we found no increased risk of demarcated
opacities in children with use of asthma drugs.
However, the risk of opacity-related loss of tooth
substance may show a tendency to be increased.
Discussion
This population-based study among 6-to-8-year-old
Danish children showed no association between use
of inhaled asthma drugs during the first 3 years of
life and an increased risk of demarcated opacities.
However, our data indicated a tendency of an
association between use of inhaled asthma drugs
during the first 3 years of life and the more severe
types of lesions (opacity-related loss of tooth substance). Demarcated opacities in permanent teeth
are commonly considered to be caused by local
trauma and infection during the period of tooth
development. However, in a previous detailed
description of the present study-population (11),
children with permanent first molars with demarcated opacities were shown to have affected permanent incisors 2.5 times more frequently than children
without affected permanent first molars, thus indicating a systemic origin. Furthermore, our analyses
were based on permanent first molars in which local
infection or traumatic damage is unlikely to occur.
The classification of demarcated opacities was
done using the criteria recommended for epidemiological studies of this condition (1820). We did
not register hypoplasia and the examiners were
carefully trained in the difference between hypoplasia and demarcated opacities with loss of tooth
substance. Among the strengths of the diagnostic
criteria used are their simplicity and the classification of the demarcated opacities according to
severity, which includes sequelae of demarcated
opacities. The creamy-white demarcated opacities
represent defects with less mineral deficiency than
the yellowish-brown ones (3). Thereby, the recording of the color of the opacities is a reflection of the
severity of the enamel lesions.
The data were collected by the dental staff in three
municipal clinics in connection with routine dental
examinations. All of the examiners were exclusively
treating children, which has given all of them
comprehensive clinical experience with pediatric
dentistry. The registrations were considered to be
valid, especially with regards to the yellowishbrown opacities or opacity-related loss of tooth
substance (11). Any misclassification of children
according to demarcated opacities will most likely
occur with equal frequency among children with use
of asthma drugs and healthy children and thus
cause bias toward no difference between children
with use of asthma drugs and healthy children. A
considerable proportion of the included children
were not examined for different reasons, which
included ignored registration of demarcated opacities during the routine dental examination. The
prevalence of demarcated opacities recorded may
have been affected by a potential higher propensity
of dental staff to overlook children without demarcated opacities than children with such opacities.
The relative estimates will, however, hardly be
influenced by this drop-out, since the drop-out very
unlikely was associated with the use of asthma
drugs. The examiners were not aware of the purpose
of the present study, nor were they aware of the
childrens history of asthma drug use (11), and thus
bias of the relative estimates was avoided.
We used registry data on asthma drug use from
the time of tooth formation. In the present study,
we were unable to establish precise measures of the
compliance. However, a previous validation study
on a population similar to the present study
population showed that more than 90% of children
with parentally reported asthma drug use had
received asthma drug prescriptions according to
registry information. Therefore, we believe that the
compliance was high (21).
Childhood asthma is, among other factors, associated with preterm birth (22,23). Aine et al. compared the prevalence of enamel defects in 32
preterm and 64 full-term born children and found
that demarcated opacities occurred in 47% of the
preterm and 25% of the full-term born children
(24). We retrieved information on preterm birth
from the Danish Medical Birth Registry (17) and
found that demarcated opacity was not associated
with gestational age.
The availability of information about the exact
date of drug prescription allowed us to study
specific time windows and hence allowed evaluation of the drug use effect during the period most
vulnerable with regards to enamel developmental
disturbances. In the present study, 65 children had
prescriptions for both inhaled corticosteroids and
inhaled b2-agonists some time from birth until the
date of dental examination, while a smaller group
received their asthma drug prescriptions during
the first 3 years after birth. In the latter group, we
found a tendency of an increased prevalence of
opacity-related loss of tooth substance, which may
be consistent with a causal effect. On the other
hand, posteruptive breakdown of the enamel may
be accelerated or complicated in an acidic environment caused by the use of asthma drugs, some of
which have low pH-values (25). If such an effect,
the vulnerable period for opacity-related loss of
tooth substance may be after tooth eruption.
Conclusion
In conclusion, children with prescriptions for
inhaled asthma drugs before the age of 3 years
did not have an overall increased risk of demarcated opacities in first permanent molar but they
seemed to have an increased risk of the more
severe demarcated opacities, i.e. opacities resulting
in macroscopic loss of tooth substance, and possibly a need for restorative care.
Acknowledgments
We wish to thank the Chief of the municipal dental
service in Stvring and Nibe, Gerd Bangsbo, and the
dental staff for permission and practical help with the
data collection. The study received financial support
from the Augustinus Foundation, The Western Danish
Research Forum for Health Sciences, The Danish Dental
Association, The New Dentists Association, The Research
Foundation of the University of Aarhus, Danish Lung
Association, and The Asthma and Allergy Association,
Denmark.
References
1. William V, Messer LB, Burrow MF. Molar incisor
hypomineralization: review and recommendations
for clinical management. Pediatr Dent 2006;28:22432.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
This document is a scanned copy of a printed document. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the copy.
Users should refer to the original published version of the material.