May 1 June
2016 Doctoral
Conference
Table of Contents
Welcome Message ...................................................................................................................................... 3
Acknowledgements .................................................................................................................................... 4
Keynote Speakers and Addresses ................................................................................................................ 5
Day 1 Tuesday May 31st 2016 ................................................................................................................... 7
Session 1: Educational Systems (Room 2.26) ...................................................................................................... 7
1. School Processes in Rural Mexico: CONAFE ................................................................................................ 7
2. The Brazilian Education System: A Path Full of Ups and Downs ................................................................. 7
3. An Exploratory Study of Context Realities and Stakeholders Perceptions: Given Student-centred
Recommendations in Nigerian Secondary Schools. ........................................................................................ 8
Session 2: ESOL Research (Room 1.21) ................................................................................................................ 8
1. Curriculum Prescription and Teacher Identity ............................................................................................ 8
2. How my Action Research was Conducted in Assisting Taiwanese English Teachers in Transforming their
Teaching Approaches ...................................................................................................................................... 9
3. An Investigation into Experienced EFL Teachers Selection and Use of Grammar Teaching Techniques:
A Belief Perspective ......................................................................................................................................... 9
Session 3: Challenges in Research Methods (Room 1.20) ................................................................................. 10
1. Getting Lost Along the Way? Some Challenges and Emerging Solutions in the Holistic Analysis of
Qualitative Data. ........................................................................................................................................... 10
2. How Flexible can a Research Design be and who Decides? ...................................................................... 10
3. Knowledge of and Attitude Towards Multimodality: Correlations, Influence and Predictions Based
upon Teaching Experiences and Age ............................................................................................................. 11
Session 4: Technology (Room 2.26) ................................................................................................................... 11
1. Learning by Researching: the Challenges of Using Assemblage Ethnography in a Study about
Information and Communication Technology (ICT) in Education. ................................................................ 11
2. Bridging the Intergenerational Gap Using Technology to Learn about Bristol .......................................... 12
3. Research through Engagement ................................................................................................................. 12
Session 5: Engagement and Learning (Room 1.20) ........................................................................................... 13
1. Influence of Learner Identity on Classroom Learning Engagement: Using a Freirean Popular Education
Approach to Support Low-Engaging Year Eight Pupils .................................................................................. 13
2. Self-control and Grit in School-age Children ............................................................................................. 13
3. Equality, Trust and Student Agency: a Multi-method Study of Quaker Schooling .................................... 14
Session 6: Research Roundtable (Room 1.21) ................................................................................................... 14
Session 7: International Students in the UK (Room 2.26) ................................................................................. 14
1. Lived Experiences of Adapting to a UK University's Pedagogic System ..................................................... 14
2. Integrating the Teaching of Logic and Coherence to International Students ............................................ 15
3. EU/International Doctoral Students' Psychological Wellbeing during their Cross-cultural Transition in
the UK ............................................................................................................................................................ 15
Session 8: Higher Education Research (Room 1.20) .......................................................................................... 16
1. Cultural Political Economy of Mercosurs Higher Education Sectoral Project ........................................... 16
2. Service Learning: Challenging, and Challenged by, the Academy ............................................................. 16
3. Chinese Students Perceptions of, and Responses to Teacher Written Feedback in the UK Higher
Education ....................................................................................................................................................... 17
Session 9: By the Fireplace Life after the PhD: Securing a Post-doc Fellowship and Roles within the
University (Room 1.21) ...................................................................................................................................... 17
1
Welcome Message
Dear Doctoral Conference Delegate,
Welcome to the 2016 Doctoral Student Conference held here at the Graduate School of Education,
University of Bristol. This is an annual event which goes from strength to strength each year and as PhD
programme director, I am delighted to see how the doctoral conference develops in exciting new ways each
year.
This year the theme is Transforming Research in Education and the programme again looks very innovative
and engaging. We are lucky to have four leading academics who have agreed to be keynote speakers.
However, the main aim is to provide a platform for current doctoral researchers, from Bristol and SWDTC
partner institutions Bath and Exeter and elsewhere, to present their ongoing work in an enjoyable and
supportive context. This is an important event for the Graduate School of Education and we extend best
wishes to all presenters, and particular thanks to the organisers for their hard work and creative ideas in
making these two days possible.
We hope you are able to capitalise on these opportunities to learn from others and to develop your
confidence in sharing your research ideas. The networking that such events facilitate is of course very
valuable in its own right, as is the chance to enjoy some socialising and spending time in the beautiful city of
Bristol!
Unfortunately, this year I will be away teaching in Hong Kong when the conference is held and so I cant be
with you. However, I am sending you all my best wishes for another successful and stimulating conference.
Very best wishes
Dr Sue Timmis
Director PhD Programme
Graduate School of Education
University of Bristol
Acknowledgements
On behalf of the Doctoral Conference Committee, we warmly welcome you to our conference at the
Graduate School of Education, University of Bristol. This years conference is themed Transforming Research
in Education, and will provide an open, friendly and thought-provoking environment for graduate students
to present and discuss their ongoing research in education and other related social sciences.
Firstly, we extend a very special thank you to our keynote speakers for accepting our invitation and
reflecting on the main challenges of the research process: Dr Peter Etchells, Debbie Watson, Jane Seale and
Professor Alis Oancea. We would also like to thank all the Graduate School of Education academic staff for
their invaluable participation in both the workshop and the By the Fireplace sessions: Professors Justin
Dillon and Ros Sutherland, Drs Shelley McKeown Jones, Amanda Williams, George Leckie and Jo Rose.
We would also like to thank the individuals whose administrative and managerial support have assisted us
throughout the whole organisational process: Dr. Sue Timmis for her sage and pertinent contributions, Liz
Roberts for her practical and level-headed support, Duncan Coutts for his IT expertise and, last but certainly
not least, Mark Davey from the Alumni Foundation, for his help with our funding application and, of
course, the Foundation themselves, whose generous donation have helped make this event possible.
Finally, no conference would be complete without the presenters and participants themselves. Your interest
in and contributions to the programme are most greatly appreciated we extend our warmest thanks to all
of you.
We do hope you enjoy the conference and find it stimulating, and enjoy your stay with us here in Bristol.
Best wishes,
About Alis
Professor Alis Oancea is Pro-Proctor at the University of Oxford, Associate
Professor in the Philosophy of Education, and, from next term, Director for
Research at the Oxford University Department of Education. She has
learned about the challenges and rewards of the doctoral journey not only from her own two PhDs, but
most importantly from her fantastic doctoral students, who have become accomplished professionals while
remaining firm friends. Her research addresses questions about research policy and governance, including
research impact, quality, assessment and public discourses about research, as well as philosophical
questions about research methodology. In her writing, she has challenged divisive interpretations of
research methodologies and of research governance and conceptually underdeveloped metrics for research,
while arguing for the importance of a tight relationship between philosophical, theoretical and empirical
inquiry in the social sciences and the humanities. Books include "Introduction to Research Methods in
Education" (Sage), "Assessing Quality in Applied and Practice-Based Research" (Routledge), and 'Education
for All' (Routledge). Her most recent publications are "The ecologies and economy of cultural value from
research" (2015) and "The aims and claims of educational research" (2016).
http://www.education.ox.ac.uk/about-us/directory/alis-oancea/
Dr Jane Seale, the Open University
Title of keynote address: Can Inclusive Methods Transform
Educational Research: Opportunities and Challenges?*
About Jane
Jane Seale is a Professor of Education in the Faculty of Education and
Language Studies at the Open University. Janes teaching and research interests lie at the intersections
between disability, technology and inclusion. Her work focuses in particular on the role that technologies
play in the lives of people with learning disabilities and the factors that influence or sustain the digital
exclusion of disabled learners. Her recent work has also focused on how the inclusive practices of teachers
and support workers might be enhanced through the development of 'positive risk taking'. Jane has
developed a national and international profile in the field through key roles such as President of the
Association for Learning Technology (2006-7) and Digital Inclusion consultant to the ESRC funded
Technology Enhanced Learning (TEL) Programme in the UK (2009-2012).
Janes methodological interest is the development and evaluation of participatory research methods that
promote voice and empowerment for disabled research partners. Jane has recently completed a research
study entitled Towards equal and active citizenship: pushing the boundaries of participatory research with
people with learning disabilities. Between 2007 and 2010 Jane was Co-Director of the ESRC National Centre
for Research Methods. She has recently served on the REF 2014 Education panel in the UK which had the
responsibility for assessing the quality of educational research conducted in UK universities.
*These sessions will be audio recorded
3. An Exploratory Study of Context Realities and Stakeholders Perceptions: Given Studentcentred Recommendations in Nigerian Secondary Schools.
Abi'odun Oyewole, University of Bristol
My doctoral research explores recent attempts to introduce student-centred instruction to secondary
school classrooms in Nigeria. The conduct of this research was informed by the advised need to be critical of
learner-centred policy transfer to developing countries (Guthrie, 1986). Especially in view of the many and
persistent reports of implementation failures in developing countries (Schweisfurth, 2011). Secondly, the
argument that cultural and contextual differences have significant influence on the implementation of
learner-centred education reform, has maintained its credibility over the years (Guthrie et al., 2015;
O'Donoghue, 1994; OSullivan, 2004).
The aim of this presentation is to highlight assumptions and gaps in the process of recommending and
introducing learner-centred reform in my country. The presentation will focus on the use of a qualitative
research design to address questions about context realities and perspectives of those involved, especially
teachers and students. The research findings will also be reported with an account of the inferences drawn
from the key themes. My hope is that my research can challenge widespread notions about instructional
practice in Nigerian secondary schools and question the trending appeal of learner-centred reform, within
the context. Perhaps this attempt to change perspectives can then transform educational practice in my
country.
3. An Investigation into Experienced EFL Teachers Selection and Use of Grammar Teaching
Techniques: A Belief Perspective
Anna Csernus, University of Bath
Teacher cognition in grammar teaching has been widely researched in the last few decades. A significant
number of studies have been conducted on teachers beliefs and their overall approach to grammar
teaching. The impact of experiential, cognitive and contextual factors on teachers grammar teaching
practices has also received some attention. However, teachers choice and use of pedagogical techniques in
grammar teaching seems to be an under-explored area within teacher cognition research and, therefore,
requires further research in a range of contexts and from different perspectives. The present study sets out
to investigate the relationship between teachers grammar teaching beliefs and their selection and use of
pedagogical techniques, with particular attention to the bidirectional relationship between beliefs and
practice. As I am in the process of collecting data the aim of this presentation is to discuss 1) how piloting
the study helped to prepare for my data collection and 2) challenges (both practical and ethical) that I am
facing with during data collection.
go beyond the common understandings of the everyday context (Pike, 1954) alongside training in data
analysis pointed in this project to greater levels of responsibility for this researcher, while benefits may
follow if we invest in enabling others in these endeavours.
This paper argues that while lines need not be drawn permanently in any given research project, there is
however a strong case for transparent reporting. Audiences can then decide for themselves whether such
power boundaries are drawn or negotiated for the right reasons for all involved.
12
13
Three studies will be conducted to address the aims of this investigation. Studies 1 and 2 will explore the
possible relationship of cognitive skills with self-control and grit, using quantitative methods. In study 3,
mixed methods will be used to build a more comprehensive picture of self-control and grit in specific
domains. This study will explore both within participant, as well as between participant differences in selfcontrol and grit.
these encounters. In a Qualitative research which adopted descriptive phenomenology, the lived
experiences of six Nigerian students studying for a Masters degree in a UK university indicates that the
pedagogic practices they encountered in their UK University was mostly novel in terms of the teaching
methods, classroom engagement requirement, independent learning expectations and demands for
criticality in reading and writing. Consequently, these students had to promptly adapt in ways that would
enable them maximise the learning opportunities in the new pedagogic system. However, the students
major challenge in adapting to the UK Universitys system revolved around the self-regulation of their
learning. Self-regulation encompasses the processes required for students to take personal responsibility for
their learning. This paper highlights the different ways through which these students navigated the
challenges associated with self-regulation in order to successfully adapt to their UK Universitys pedagogic
system.
capture their own transition). The data will be collected longitudinally over the period of one year, and
questionnaires and interviews will happen at three different time points.
Analysis will focus on answering two main research questions,
1. In terms of wellbeing,
a. How do SCA wellbeing scores changes over time?
b. How are wellbeing scores related to the cultural scores over time?
2. In terms of the cross-cultural transition,
a. How is the transition experienced on an individual level?
b. What kind of impact can the doctoral experience have on the transition?
The pilot of three questionnaires, two interviews, and one journal (over the period of a month) raises
consideration about the language and content of the questionnaire, how the interview should be further
developed in a more creative manner, and how the multi-media platform for the online journal can better
accommodate the participants sharing of information. Furthermore, the pilot also allows a clearer picture
of what type of analysis will be used to best answer the questions.
suggested that this academic culture is one of critical discourse rooted in a separateness of the academy
from society. This is the discourse with which service learning must contend if it is to be legitimised.
The social process of legitimisation is examined with recognition that faculty have the power to confer
legitimacy on service learning, often prioritising models where learning is emphasised at the expense of
service.
In addition, tensions exist between academic and service learning cultures that might mitigate conferral.
These tensions include: a decentring of traditional academic conceptions of knowledge by service learning;
boutique multiculturalism (Fish, 1999) where academy values trump those of the community; and
tensions between hard and soft disciplines where the latters conceptions of knowledge and disciplinary
practices align more naturally with service learning than the formers.
Using Michael Burawoys (2011) four functions of a public university as a frame, the paper argues for a
particular model of service learning one equally both academically rigorous and democratically driven
that reasserts reflexive knowledge in the academy through the disciplining of service learning alongside the
advancement of civic (democratic) knowledge.
3. Chinese Students Perceptions of, and Responses to Teacher Written Feedback in the UK
Higher Education
Fangfei Li, University of Bath
Teacher written feedback (TWF) is an interaction, between teachers and students, where linguistic,
communicative and affective factors are at play. Studies on teacher written feedback have produced a wide
range of findings in aspects of characteristics of good feedback (Quinton and Smallbone, 2010), factors
influencing the quality of feedback (Gibbs and Simpson, 2004), the current situation of teacher written
feedback in higher education (Tsutsui, 2004) and reasons for Chinese students different responses to
feedback (Poverjuc, 2011). Instead of re-examining the quality and characteristics of current teacher written
feedback, my research goes beyond these works and probes into how Chinese students, who come from a
feedback-sparse background of China HE, deal with written feedback in courses of UK higher education.
Research questions of this study are 1) what are Chinese overseas students perceptions of teacher written
feedback in courses of the UK higher education? 2) how do they respond to teacher feedback in courses of
the UK HE? 3) what possible factors might influence their responses to feedback? I will conduct qualitative
case studies of six Chinese postgraduate students in a UK university. In-depth interviews, text analysis and
stimulated recall interviews will be employed to find out Chinese participants perceptions of teacher
written feedback, teachers comments on drafts of their essays, participants responses to these comments,
rationales for participants responses to feedback. In this presentation therefore, I will talk about the early
stages of my PhD research in relation to my literature background, research methodology and pilot study as
well as practical significance of my study on current feedback provision contexts in both UK and China
higher education.
17
students to ask frank questions, in a safe, non-judgmental environment. In this first session, some of our
lecturers will be thinking back to the end of their PhD and sharing their personal experiences with you.
What advice they would give their old selves?
What resources would they have wished they had known about?
What were some of the factors that helped them in their decision making process?
When and how to start the process?
What were the positives and negatives of their current position?
And anything else that they deem important.
You will have the opportunity to engage in conversation with them and find out anything you wish to know
about life after the PhD.
Poster Session 1
1. Online Exploratory Talk for Writing
Aireen Aina Bahari, University of Exeter
In Malaysian Certificate of Education (MCE), equivalent to GCE O-Level, secondary school students English
language ability is mostly determined by their writing skill. My assumption is, in order to write a better
argumentative essay writing, students must practice doing argumentative discussion with other friends
before they write their own piece of writing. My overarching aim is to help them to improve their writing
skill. I wanted to explore student-led online discussion using mobile assisted language learning (MALL) and
investigate its impact on individual written argument in order to design an online intervention rich in
discussion that would help future ESL students write better essays. In the context studied, classroom
activities were exclusively teacher-led where student-led group discussion is sporadic. Hence, online
Thinking Together appears more appropriate in this context in order to teach
Exploratory talk techniques. This study will be conducted based on the principle of design-based research
(DBR) in four main phases involving 15 ESL students. In the first phase, students essay will be analysed for
their grade and quality of argumentation. Online interview will be conducted to investigate the difficulties
they had when producing the essay. The online intervention will be executed in the second phase where
students will be exposed to online Thinking Together approach using their mobile phones. The quality of
their essay will be analysed in the post-intervention (third stage) to find any improvement as the impact
from the intervention. Another online interview will be conducted to examine their perspectives on the
impact of the intervention on their writing. This study also will have larger implications on how Thinking
Together approach is attainable in the scope of mobile assisted language learning (MALL) and subsequently
improve ESL students argumentative essay.
2. Korean students' knowledge creation through digital technologies and digital media
Eunjoo Kim, University of Bristol
This research study aims to investigate how South Korean middle school students and a teacher engage in a
knowledge-creation oriented, classroom-based activity in the context of collaborative learning using digital
technologies and digital media in and out of school. This activity involves collaboratively producing a tenminute digital media product in the form of a video clip. This study takes a design-based research approach
and a qualitative case study approach. Based on three iterative cycles of design-based research, this study
will implement a series of interventions in order to analyse a knowledge-creation related activity in
18
classroom. Thirty-five Korean middle school students and their teacher will participate in the knowledgecreation activity in the Free Semester System class.
Ever since formal education began, educators have been motivated to teach thinking, aspiring to offer
learners a program focused not only on the transference of current knowledge, but which also equipped
them with the dispositions and skills that they would require to face novel challenges in the future.
This study aims to explore and evaluate primary school teachers perceptions of teaching thinking skills. The
foundation for the research design is based on a pragmatic worldview and uses structured mixed methods
to explore teachers perceptions about their practices of teaching thinking in primary classrooms, and to
examine their practice. Convenience sampling is used in this research. The sample will consist of
approximately 30 Key stage 1 and 2 teachers representing UK primary schools. The teachers will be
volunteers. An information sheet for the interviews and focus group will be given to them before their
participation. Head teachers will receive an information sheet outlining the ethical and practical implications
of their teachers participating in the study.
Eventually, the data will be analysed through the lens of a computational thinking framework. This study
meets the need for academic reflection of this framework. This will enable the framework to be assessed for
its suitability as a tool for teachers to evaluate their own practices in teaching thinking skills. Additionally,
the existing model can be refined in accordance with the findings from the study. Directions for further
research will be discussed, focusing on teachers practice evolution, thinking-based learning frameworks
and teaching value criteria using a computational thinking model.
19
Poster Session 2
1. How Can We Contribute to Improving Basic Mathematics Education in St. Lucia?
Takuya Numajiri, University of Edinburgh
Although measuring quality of education is difficult, a number of research on assessing the quality of
primary education utilise the results of academic achievement. The reason is straightforward: acquiring
basic skills, especially in the areas of literacy and numeracy, underpins successful learning. Many countries,
therefore, administer either an examination or a standardised assessment during the primary school years
to identify and ensure the quality of basic education. On the other hand, growing evidence indicates that
many developing countries including St. Lucia need to improve the quality of education and students
achievement, especially in mathematics. The results from national examinations in St. Lucia suggest that
many students and even teachers had not mastered the basic skills in early mathematics which they should
have. Nevertheless, there is little information available on factors affecting students academic performance
in mathematics in the country due to insufficient operating budgets and an inadequate number of staff
members. More research is, thus, needed to extend our understanding of why and how to improve the low
achievement of mathematics, since quality of education is a far difficult concept to define. The current
study aims not only to identify factors associated with low mathematics achievement of students in basic
schools, but also to contribute a deeper understanding of the development of a conceptual framework for
understanding quality of education in St. Lucia. Based on previous research and the countrys context, the
current study selects five kinds of factors that have been considered as key elements for mathematics
education in St. Lucia: learning and teaching dimension, enabling inputs dimension, learner characteristics
dimension, contextual dimension and outcomes dimension. The findings of this study could be potentially
useful for designing more effective programmes and policies to improve the quality of mathematics
education in the country.
2. The Use of Creative Drama for Teaching Thinking Skills to Children with Moderate Learning
Difficulties (MLD)
Arwa Mesfer Alharthi, University of Exeter
The literature shows the power of thinking skills. The aim behind this proposal is to explore the value of
creative drama as a method in enhancing the thinking skills of children with moderate learning difficulties
(MLD) in Saudi Arabia. Additionally, this proposal aims to understand the impact of drama on teaching
thinking skills among children with MLD. The goal is to propose a clear overview of the creative drama
approach as a creative pedagogy for fostring thinking skills to children with MLD at primary inclusive school
level. Design Based Research (DBR) research will be employed as the research methodology in this study.
This DBR project will be conducted during the 2017-2018 academic year in two different schools
consecutively. The initial design includes three cycles; the duration of each cycle will be one week, with one
creative drama session apiece. The participants in this project will be the special education teacher as coresearcher, and the children with MLD. Data collection methods will include observation as a main source of
data; it will also include pre- and post-test, meetings and focus groups. All data will be analysed both
quantitatively and qualitatively in order to answer the research question and achieve this proposals aim.
narrative stories that are told. I will explore the impact it has on teachers, pupils, parents and ways to
develop practice. It also aims to examine the extent to which Teacher Education Institutions and schools
prepare teachers to implement a Multicultural Curriculum. The importance of this research is to have an
impact on policy and practice in schools and Teacher Education Institutions. Importantly, for Qualified
Teacher Status(QTS) to be achieved, those intending to teach are required to maintain high expectations of
all pupils, raise their educational achievement, challenge stereotypical views and encourage the effective
teaching and learning of pupils from all ethnic, social, cultural, linguistic and religious backgrounds.(Maylor
et al. 2006: p39)
4. How can reflective and collaborative strategies improve the impact and process of your
research?
Miguel Angel Cerna Caceres, University of Bristol
This presentation describes the challenges a group of eleven Chilean teachers from different school realities
faced in an on-line action research professional development project, and how these challenges collated
into possibilities through reflective and collaborative strategies in the research. This research promoted that
eleven teachers from different schools supported each other when facing problems and daily practices in a
four-month on-line action research project. This project involved both face-to-face and an on-line
components. The Online component integrated the support of Wikis, emails and on-line conversations.
However, during the implementation, several challenges emerged, such as lack of participation and
commitment towards the study, lack of technical skills or resources and schools strikes, which generated
barriers for the professional development of teachers. My researcher reflexivity was critical to understand
these challenges and shape them into possibilities through a set of strategies that maximized the reflective
process of the participants and inspire them to collaborate. These strategies were twofold; they involved a
critical evaluation of the action research stages by following (a) Gibbs reflective cycle (1988) and (b)
Brydon-Millers et al. (2010) structured ethical reflection to identify problematic areas, potentiate strengths
and inspire participation, respect and commitment. These two approaches promoted practical strategies
leading to collaborative and reflective behaviours in the participants which shared educational material,
helped each other to understand educational concepts, wrote academic contributions in school magazines,
discussed educational policies, etc. The support provided by these teachers put in the spotlight the
relationship researcher-participants and participants-participants to trigger motivation, engagement and
commitments in action research projects. Practical examples on how these frameworks were applied and
the implication for the participants are included in this presentation.
21
22
2. Cultural Issues in Higher Education: Lessons to Learn from Researching Omani Undergraduate
Students Cultural Universalities and Peculiarities
Jamila Al Siyabi, University of Exeter
The paper session is based on a case study that looked into students practices and perceptions from their
teachers point of views in the field of higher education in Oman. The study is based on classroom
observational data, and self-reported data and anecdotes of various expatriate instructors coming from
different cultural backgrounds working in Sultan Qaboos University in Oman. The study investigates some
concepts in the area of culture and intercultural communication that teachers in higher education deal with
on a daily basis. My paper session will briefly touch on relevant issues like cultural awareness, universality
versus peculiarity and the cultural setting of expatriate teachers working in higher education in Oman. The
concepts that the session will specifically explore are related to students assertiveness, greeting each other
and/or the teacher, perception of time, oral traditions and face saving strategies. Teachers received an
open-ended questionnaire that required them to reflect on their classroom experiences in Omani university
by sharing their observations, anecdotes and/or opinions related to these cultural issues which the
questionnaire asked them about (i.e. students assertiveness, greeting each other and/or the teacher,
perception of time, oral traditions and face saving strategies). The data show interesting and valid cultural
dimensions about Omani students in higher education who may differ from or resemble students from
other cultures in the world. The session aims to provide informative and reliable insights on some of the
prominent features about students cultural universalities and peculiarities. Exploring these cultural
concepts can help improve teachers teaching and learning practices through appreciating students related
cultural aspects. It can also help better understand students attitudes, practices and expectations and
student-teacher relations. Appreciating such cultural dimensions can make a difference in how teachers
perceive teaching and learning in any culture and/or context in the field of higher education.
23
their similarity, as ethnically and economically diverse dreamscapes that symbolize aspiration and
opportunity, cheek-by-jowl with severe inequality. Accordingly, it is important to address the range of
cultural and financial backgrounds of university graduates and to appreciate how their differing social
contexts, relationships with the city, and experiences of higher education, may translate differentially into a
spectrum of future prospects. This conference provides an opportunity to test and develop the research
themes, prior to empirical ethnographic research in each of the cities. Coming from an anthropological
perspective, this will focus on the cultural changes in young peoples lives following their graduation, and on
the affective dimensions of imagining and engineering ones life course. This period has been shown to be
one of existential dilemma, in which graduates negotiate multiple expectations, responsibilities, dreams and
uncertainties (Bregnbaek, 2016). The contemporary societal role of higher education will therefore be called
into question, in terms of how graduates reflect on their university and post-university experiences. The talk
will explore how one can best articulate the multiple possible and preferable pathways of university
graduates, as they assess the implications of their degree, including debts incurred, upon their immediate
and imagined futures. It is hoped that discussion of the research themes may help to clarify the kind of
tone to take and direct how the findings may be applied.
2. Teachers and Students Attitudes Toward Disruptive Behaviour and Disciplinary Styles: A
Comparative Analysis of England and Nigeria
Ocheho ThankGod Ugbede, Lancaster University
The issue of disruptive behaviour in schools has become a major stress and concern to teachers. However,
in order to minimize these behaviours, teachers are utilizing various disciplinary styles. The aim of this study
was to examine students and teachers attitudes toward disruptive behaviour and disciplinary styles and to
compare the views of the participants from Nigeria and England. 285 students and 41 teachers from high
school completed the disruptive behaviour and disciplinary styles questionnaires which contain behaviours
and intervention methods commonly reported in high schools. These questionnaires measure individuals
attitudes toward behaviour problems and the strategies used to regulate such behaviour. The results depict
that there is a relationship between disruptive behaviour and disciplinary styles. Significant difference was
found among nationality, gender, student and teacher attitudes toward disruptive behaviour and
disciplinary styles. Nationality also significantly predicted disruptive behaviour, while aggressive style and
relationship based style of discipline predicted juvenile delinquency and school misconduct respectively. In
conclusion, the style of discipline adopted in school is associated with students judgement of behaviour.
The implications of the findings to disciplinary styles that may be most effective at regulating disruptive
behaviour are discussed.
that professional lectures with experience in the area of their studies will be teaching them. However, this is
also a weakness because there is not an established process for hiring these professionals from industry,
who have little or no teaching experience.
Based on a case study in Mexico, this research is looking in depth at the professional development, and
needs of academic staff at The Technological University of San Juan del Rio (UTSJR). Opinions, expectations
and attitudes from Mexican lecturers working at the UTSJR will be gathered by conducting surveys.
Investigation, identification and assessment of national (Mexican) and global models implemented in higher
educational systems are providing new perspectives of professional development. The main aim of this case
study is to develop a holistic academic model to be applied in a Mexican context, specifically at the UTSJ
2. Journeys from the Worst School in Britain to University: A Fight for the Oppressed Past
Denise Rogers, University of Bristol
Blakelaw Comprehensive School, which closed in 2002, was situated in one of the most deprived
neighbourhoods in Newcastle upon Tyne. During the 1990s Blakelaw caught the attention of the national
media, one of 18 schools named and shamed by the Labour Government as the worst in Britain. The school
and the area in which it was located and drew its pupils embodied the socio-economic indicators associated
with predicted low academic performance and participation (e.g. Chowdry et al. 2010).
My study asks how this defunct, apparently failed school might be understood to have impacted on the
educational journeys of a group of former pupils who ended up going to university against the odds. I
consider how recollections and artefacts shared by former pupils, family members and teachers complicate
and challenge versions of bad school, troubled pupils, disengaged families and poor teachers captured
within publically available archives.
My project is positioned within a poststructuralist theoretical framework that embraces the non-linear and
the fragmented. My main methodological driver is thinking with theory (Jackson & Mazzei 2012) which
involves the viewing of data through multiple theoretical lenses to show how knowledge can be opened up
and proliferated rather than foreclosed and simplified (ibid, p.vii).
What kind of transformational ambition makes sense within a poststructurally positioned research project
like mine? I explore this question by 'plugging in' a selection of my data to a number of concepts, including
Walter Benjamins notion of a fight for the oppressed past, to produce some transformational accounts of
school, selves and neighbourhood.
26
2. Investigating Early Career Science Teachers Experience of Subject Knowledge Development
Jon James, University of Bristol
Pedagogical content knowledge (PCK) is deemed to be of particular importance for effective teaching of
science in schools. Hence developing PCK is a key focus of pre-service teacher education courses and it is the
object of substantial research by the science education community. However the PCK construct rarely
appears in guidance documents for in-service science teachers. This is in part because PCK research tends to
focus on the establishment of a stable, teacher knowledge structure, without regard for the complexities of
the classroom context. Little research has examined how science teachers work with subject matter in the
classroom or chartered the complex evolution of knowledge for science teaching.
The project is seeking to represent early-career science teachers experience in relation to subject
knowledge and its enactment in the classroom, and shed light on the complexities of its longitudinal
development. Given the need for direct engagement with experience, and the emphasis on interpretation,
the research adopts a phenomenological approach and positions itself within a situated cognition
framework.
This paper describes the challenges of getting close to individual teachers experiences and exploring
knowledge application in the complex environment of the classroom. Stimulated recall interviewing has
been employed to probe perception of activity within the practice context; science lessons have been filmed
and the recordings used with teachers in follow-up interviews. Transcripts have then been subject to
interpretive phenomenological analysis to help represent the dynamic nature of knowledge development. A
particular focus of the project has been on teachers responses to students conceptual questions, as this
requires contingent enactment of teachers subject knowledge, and this paper presents several vignettes
27
from the classroom. Early findings indicate the importance of teachers making connections between
students critical questions and previous experiences or educational theory, highlighting the role of
experienced colleagues in helping teachers to reason about their enactment of subject knowledge.
the research and present their research findings to staff and students. The aim was to engage the children
with the research process and also to inspire them to aspire to attend University.
Session 18: By the Fireplace Getting the Most out of your Supervision
(Room: 1.21)
Run by: Dr Jo Rose and Professor Ros Sutherland
In the second of our By the Fireplace sessions, two seasoned supervisors with different styles will answers
your questions about how to invest in this most important of relationships during your PhD. There are a
great number of factors that affect success in your PhD, but perhaps the most influential factor is having a
positive relationship with your supervisor. So, to find out more, feel free to come along and join in the
discussion.
29
Conference Programme
Day 1 31st May
Time
8:30
9:00
9:00
9:15
9:15
10:15
Registration
Welcome Address
Transforming Research in Education
Professor Justin Dillon, Head of Graduate School of Education
Helen Wodehouse Lecture Theatre
Keynote Address
Raising Your Profile as a Researcher
Dr. Peter Etchells, Bath Spa University
Chair: Pooneh Roney
10:15
10:30
10:30
Session 1
Session 2
Session 3
12:00
Educational Systems
ESOL Research
Challenges in Research
Methods
Room 2.26
Room 1.21
Room 1.20
Chair: Zibah Nwako
Chair: James Sumner
Chair: Aliandra Barlete
1. School Processes in Rural
1. Curriculum Prescription and
1. Getting Lost along the Way?
Mexico: CONAFE
Teacher Identity
Some Challenges and Emerging
Solutions in the Holistic Analysis
of Qualitative Data.
Rosa Maria Cruz Avendano,
Fawziya Hamdan Al Zadjali,
Paulina Ruiz,
University of Southampton
Leeds Beckett University
University of Bristol
2. The Brazilian Education
2. How my Action Research was 2. How Flexible can a Research
System: A Path Full of Ups and
Conducted in Assisting
Design be and Who Decides?
Downs
Taiwanese English Teachers in
Transforming their Teaching
Approaches
Georgia Sobreira dos Santos
Yi-Mei Chen,
Steven Peters,
Ca, University of Bristol
University of Exeter
University of Bristol
3. An Exploratory Study of
3. An Investigation into
3. Knowledge of and Attitude
Context Realities and
Experienced EFL Teachers
Towards Multimodality:
Stakeholders Perceptions: Given Selection and Use of Grammar
Correlations, Influence and
Student-centred
Teaching Techniques: A Belief
Predictions Based upon
Recommendations in Nigerian
Perspective
Teaching Experiences and Age
Secondary Schools.
Abi'odun Oyewole,
Anna Csernus,
Henry Nicholas,
University of Bristol
University of Bath
University of Exeter
12:00
Keynote Address
12:50
Creative and Arts-based Research Methods with Children: Challenges and Opportunities
Dr Debbie Watson, University of Bristol
Chair: Pooneh Roney
Helen Wodehouse Lecture Theatre
1:00
2:00
Lunch
Room 4.10
30
2:00
3:30
Session 4
Technology
Room 2.26
Chair: Carolina Gordillo
1. Learning by Researching: the
Challenges of Using Assemblage
Ethnography in a Study about
Information and Communication
Technology (ICT) in Education.
Paula Lameu,
University of Birmingham
2. Bridging the Intergenerational
Gap Using Technology to Learn
about Bristol
Diana Erandi Barrera Moreno,
University of Bristol
Session 5
Engagement and Learning
Room 1.20
Chair: James Sumner
1. Influence of Learner Identity on
Classroom Learning Engagement:
Using a Freirean Popular Education
Approach to Support Low-Engaging
Year Eight Pupils.
Reuben Shekwonyadu Katai,
University of Bristol
2. Self-control and Grit in Schoolage Children
Pooneh Roney,
University of Bristol
Session 6
Research Round Table
Room 1.21
Chair: Aliandra Barlete
Teacher Well-being,
and the Role of the
Teacher and
Researcher
5:30
7.00
Session 7
International Students in the
UK
Session 8
Higher Education Research
Room 1.20
Room 2.26
Chair: Zibah Nwako
Chair: Mike Nandu
1. Lived Experiences of Adapting to 1. Cultural Political Economy of
a UK University's Pedagogic
Mercosurs Higher Education
System
Sectoral Project
Jane Nebe,
Aliandra Barlete,
University of Bristol
University of Bristol
2. Integrating the Teaching of Logic 2. Service Learning: Challenging,
and Coherence to International
and Challenged by, the Academy
Students
Abby Ping Wang,
Ed Stevens,
University of York
University of Bath
3. EU/International Doctoral
3. Chinese Students Perceptions
Students' Psychological Wellbeing of, and Responses to Teacher
during their Cross-cultural
Written Feedback in the UK Higher
Transition in the UK
Education
Trang Mai Tran,
Fangfei Li,
University of Bristol
University of Bath
Session 9
By the Fireplace
Room 1.21
Chair: Pooneh Roney
Life after the PhD
Securing a Post-doc
Fellowship and Roles
within the University
Run by Drs. Shelley
McKeown Jones,
Amanda Williams and
George Leckie
31
Time
9:00
9.30
9.30
10:30
Registration
Ground Floor Foyer
Keynote Address
The impacts of impact: on the rise of impact in research policy and governance
Professor Alis Oancea, University of Oxford
Chair: Pooneh Roney
10:30
11:00
11:00
12:00
12:00
1:00
Session 10
Neuroscience and Education
Room 1.20
Chair: Miguel Cerna
1. Latin American Teachers'
Perception of Brain Function.
Adriana Soni Garcia,
University of Bristol
2. Bridge the Gap: Challenges in
Research in Neuroscience and
Education
Carolina Gordillo,
University of Bristol
Session 13
Comparative Education
Room 2.26
Chair: Adnan Mukhrib
1. Debt and Desire after
Graduation
John Loewenthal,
Oxford Brookes University
2. Teachers and Students
Attitudes toward Disruptive
Behaviour and Disciplinary
Styles: A Comparative Analysis
of England and Nigeria.
Ocheho ThankGod Ugbede,
Lancaster University
Session 11
Multicultural Education
Room 2.26
Chair: Zibah Nwako
1. South Korean Students'
National Identity and
Perceptions towards Migrants
and its Implications on Korean
Multicultural Education
Yurim Kim,
University of Bristol
2. Cultural Issues in Higher
Education: Lessons to Learn
from Researching Omani
Undergraduate Students
Cultural Universalities and
Peculiarities
Jamila Al Siyabi,
University of Exeter
Session 14
Changing Perspectives
Room: 1.21
Chair: Jane Nebe
1. A holistic academic model for
professional development
towards lecturers at the
Technological University of San
Juan del Rio
Myrna Escalona Sibaja,
University of Bristol
2. Journeys from the Worst
School in Britain to University:
a Fight for the Oppressed Past
Denise Rogers,
University of Bristol
Poster Session 2
4th Floor Foyer
Session 12
Innovative teaching: pushing
the boundaries
Room 1.21
Chair: Duygu Cavdar
1. The ELF Method: how the ELT
classroom can imitate the realworld ELF context
James Sumner,
University of Bristol
2. Exploring Mathematics
Examples from a Teacher and
Student Perspective
Paola Ramirez,
University of Bristol
Session 15
Workshop
Room 1.20
Chair: Pooneh Roney
Writing to Publish
Run by Professor Justin
Dillon
32
1:00
2:00
2:00
3:00
Lunch
Room 4.10
Keynote Address
Can Inclusive Methods Transform Educational Research: Opportunities and Challenges?
Professor Jane Seale, The Open University
Chair: Pooneh Roney
3:00
3:30
3:30
4:30
4:30
5:00
Session 16
Teacher Development
Session 17
Creativity in Education
Room 2.26
Chair: Paola Ramirez
Room 1.20
Chair: Sian Ephgrave
1. Professional Learning
Communities in Chilean Schools:
Local realities of Teachers'
Collaboration.
Daniela Figueroa Moya,
UCL Institute of Education
Session 18
By the Fireplace
Room: 1.21
Chair: Pooneh Roney
Getting the most out of
your supervision
Run by: Dr Jo Rose and
Professor Ros Sutherland
33
Poster Sessions
4th Floor Foyer
Day 1 31st May
3.30 4.00
1. Online Exploratory Talk for Writing
2. Korean students' knowledge creation through digital technologies and digital media
Eunjoo Kim, University of Bristol
Day 2 1st June
10.30 11.00
1. How Can We Contribute to Improving Basic Mathematics Education in St. Lucia?
Takuya Numajiri, University of Edinburgh
2. The Use of Creative Drama for Teaching Thinking Skills to Children with Moderate
Learning Difficulties (MLD)
Arwa Mesfer Alharthi, University of Exeter
4. How can reflective and collaborative strategies improve the impact and process of your
research?
Miguel Angel Cerna Caceres, University of Bristol
34