COMSOL MULTIPHYSICS
APPLICATION BUILDER
APPLICATION
comsol.com/application-builder
Copyright 2016 COMSOL. COMSOL, COMSOL Multiphysics, Capture the Concept, COMSOL Desktop, COMSOL Server, LiveLink, and Simulation for Everyone are either registered trademarks or
trademarks of COMSOL AB. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners, and COMSOL AB and its subsidiaries and products are not aliated with, endorsed by, sponsored by, or
supported by those trademark owners. For a list of such trademark owners, see www.comsol.com/trademarks
AUTOMOTIVE
ENGINEERING
EXCLUSIVE
PLUS:
NHTSA and
Euro NCAP
face the
Autonomous
future
Yoshiyuki
Matsumoto
and Clarity FCV
May 2016
magazine.sae.org/auto
are good business!
Brock Miller
Caster Operator
Gerdau is steel. For nearly half a century Gerdau has been a singular
source of excellence for all your SBQ needs. And were getting better
every day. More capacity, new capabilities, a renewed focus on
service and delivery - all centered on adding value for our customers.
All of our people are aware that our success depends on your
success, and we thrive on accepting tough challenges head-on.
www.gerdau.com/northamerica
CONTENTS
FEATURES
REGULARS
REGULATIONS | STANDARDS
ON THE COVER
AEs veteran Asia correspondent Jack Yamaguchiknown as the
dean of Japanese auto writerswas the first journalist to get a
sit-down interview with Yoshiyuki Matsumoto in his new role as
Honda R&D President. Matsumoto said he intends to re-invigorate
Hondas technology and product-development organization.
@SAEAutoMag
@saeaei
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
SAE Magazines
28 Global Vehicles
28 Teslas highly-anticipated Model 3 brings
technology questions
30 Mazda reveals retractable-hardtop MX-5 RF
30 Enter two new plug-ins: 2017 Mitsubishi
Outlander PHEV and Toyota Prius Prime
32 Lincoln unveils big-SUV future with Navigator
concept
33 Nissan targets cabin NVH with big investment
in Sentra upgrade
34 Product Briefs
Spotlight: Test equipment & software
Audited by
May 2016 1
EDITORIAL
Bill Visnic
Editorial Director
bvisnic@sae.org
EDITORIAL
Yamaguchi
(at right)
talks NSX
with Ted
Klaus.
When Kyoichi Jack Yamaguchi
talks, industry engineers listen because
theyre hearing the dean of Japans
automotive journalists. Over a career
spanning 50 years, Jack has conducted
hundreds of interviews with experts at
the OEMs and suppliers. Doors open
when Jack visits and top executives
return his calls. Hes reported on new
technologies and driven prototypes and
production vehicleson two wheels
and fourwell ahead of launch.
Jack filed his first English-language
articles in 1967, and went on to become
the Japan correspondent for Road &
Track and Cycle World in the U.S. SAE
International was smart to hire him in
the early 1980s to be Automotive
Engineerings Asia Editor, a post he still
holds today while penning monthly columns in four Japanese car magazines.
And students of Mazdas sports cars
know Jack as the author of books on
the RX-7, RX-8, and MX-5 Miata.
2 May 2016
Midwest/Great Lakes:
IN, MI, WI, IA, IL, MN
Chris Kennedy
+1.847.498.4520, x3008
ckennedy@techbriefs.com
Ryan Gehm
Associate Editor
rgehm@sae.org
Patrick Ponticel
Membership Editor
ponticel@sae.org
Send in Yamaguchi!
Ted Klaus is not given to hyperbole. So
when the Chief Engineer of Hondas
2017 NSX says something is the best,
he means it. And thats how Klaus described hearing Jack Yamaguchis first
impressions of the all-new supercar,
during a pre-production drive event last
winter at the Tochigi Proving Ground.
Jack got out of the car, looked me in
the eye and said, Its still an NSX! Then
he smiled. Coming from Jack, that was
the best comment Ive heard about this
vehicle, Klaus proudly recounted to
me in early March at the NSXs global
media launch.
PA/DE:
Desiree Stygar
+1.908.300.2539
dstygar@techbriefs.com
Lindsay Brooke
Editor-in-Chief
abrooke@sae.org
How did a kid living among the devastation of post-WWII Japan, who was
crazy for bikes and cars, get started as
a renowned industry journalist?
I mostly learned English by watching
movies and listening to Armed Forces
Radio at home, Jack told me during
the 2016 SAE Congress. He learned the
nuts-and-bolts of machines while working for Japans BMW and BSA motorcycle importer and going to races.
Jacks coverage of the industry in major publications soon got the attention
of top management within Japans
OEMs. Three senior engineers became
my mentors and helped me get started
in this business: Yoshio Nakamura at
Honda, Jiro Kawano at Toyota, and
Shinichiro Sakurai at Nissan, Jack said.
Each of the three are iconsNakamura
was Soichiro Hondas R&D director;
Kawano led development of the 2000GT
and Toyotas Group 7 racecar; and
Sakurai headed Nissan GTR engineering,
among many other projects by each.
It was Nakamura, then president of
Japan SAE, who approached Jack with
a proposal: Would he be interested in
writing for SAEs flagship magazine?
My first reaction was, No way! The
standards of a professional engineering
publication are much higher than those
for enthusiast magazines, Jack recalled. But his mentors encouragement
prevailed. I told Nakamura that I would
write for AE for one year...and 40 years
later Im still doing it!
So when the grapevine told me that
Honda was about to promote Yoshiyuki
Matsumoto to head Honda R&D earlier
this year, my immediate reaction was,
better send in Yamaguchi! Jack, who
lives in Tokyo, just happened to have a
lunch scheduled with his R&D contacts at
Tochigi. His request for a sit-down interview with Matsumoto-santhe first for
an industry magazineresulted in this
months cover story. Our domo arigatou
gozaimasu to Honda for making it happenand to Jack for being the dean.
Lindsay Brooke, Editor-in-Chief
Midwest/Central Canada:
KS, KY, MO, NE, ND, SD, ON, MB
Bob Casey
+1.847.223.5225
bobc@techbriefs.com
Lisa Arrigo
Custom Electronic
Products Editor
larrigo@sae.org
Contributors
Kami Buchholz
Detroit Editor
Stuart Birch
European Editor
Jack Yamaguchi
Asia Editor
Steven Ashley, Dan Carney,
Terry Costlow, Richard Gardner,
John Kendall, Bruce Morey,
Jennifer Shuttleworth, Linda Trego,
Paul Weissler
DESIGN
International
Europe Central & Eastern:
Sven Anacker
Britta Steinberg
+49.202.27169.11
sa@intermediapartners.de
steinberg@intermediapartners.de
Lois Erlacher
Creative Director
Ray Carlson
Associate Art Director
Europe Western:
Chris Shaw
+44.1270.522130
chris.shaw@chrisshawmedia.co.uk
SALES &
MARKETING
China:
Alan Ao
+86.21.6140.8920
alan.ao@sae.org
Joe Pramberger
Publisher
joe@techbriefs.com
Japan:
Shigenori Nagatomo
+81.3.3661.6138
Nagatomo-pbi@gol.com
Marcie L. Hineman
Global Field Sales Manager
hineman@sae.org
Debbie Rothwell
Marketing Director
drothwell@techbriefs.com
South Korea:
Eun-Tae Kim
+82-2-564-3971/2
ksae1@ksae.org
Martha Schanno
Recruitment Sales Manager
+1.724.772.7155
mschanno@sae.org
Integrated Media
Consultants
REGIONAL
SALES
Angelo Danza
+1.973.874.0271
adanza@techbriefs.com
North America
New England/Eastern Canada:
ME, VT, NH, MA, RI, QC
Ed Marecki
+1.401.351.0274
emarecki@techbriefs.com
Patrick Harvey
+1.973.409.4686
pharvey@techbriefs.com
Todd Holtz
+1.973.545.2566
tholtz@techbriefs.com
Rick Rosenberg
+1.973.545.2565
rrosenberg@techbriefs.com
CT:
Stan Greenfield
+1.203.938.2418
greenco@optonline.net
Mid-Atlantic/Southeast/TX:
MD, DC, VA, WV, KY, TN, NC, SC,
GA, FL, AL, MS, LA, AR, OK, TX
Ray Tompkins
+1.281.313.1004
rayt@techbriefs.com
Scott Williams
+1.973.545.2464
swilliams@techbriefs.com
SUBSCRIPTIONS
+1.800.869.6882
AEI@kmpsgroup.com
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
TECHNOLOGY
REPORT
ELECTRONICS
Cuneyt L. Oge
President
Richard W. Greaves, FREng
2015 President
Douglas Patton
2017 President Elect
Robert L. Ireland
Vice President Aerospace
Carla Bailo
Vice President Automotive
Thomas Stover
Vice President
Commercial Vehicle
4 May 2016
SAE INTERNATIONAL
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Pierre Alegre
Treasurer
David L. Schutt, PhD
Chief Executive Officer
Gregory L. Bradley, Esq.
Secretary
Daniel Basch
Alba Colon
Haoran Hu, PhD
Alain P. Jablonowski
James R. Keller
Jay Meldrum
Christopher Myers
Eric Tech
Gareth Williams, PhD
Todd Zarfos
SAE Sections
and Affiliate Activities
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
www.dspace.com
www.dspace.com
TECHNOLOGY REPORT
6 May 2016
POWERTRAIN
issues with cold-start operation and difficulty in addressing the entire automotive rpm range suppressing introduction
for production-vehicle application.
Nautilus, however, said its approach
to the issue was not to layer on yet
more levels of costly engine software
control. Instead the engines defining
featurea novel piston design that creates a small primary combustion
chamber that propagates the air/fuel
detonation to the larger secondary cylinder for full and controlled expansion
and an equally unique approach to
dealing with the intake and exhaust
paths of the two-stroke cycle create an
architecture conducive to relatively simple control of full-range HCCI operation.
Everybodys always tried to take a
spark-ignition engine and make it
HCCI, Riley said at the 2016 SAE World
Congress. Bad idea.
On its website, Nautilus said, With
this new technology, weve achieved full
control over the HCCI cycle in all conventional rpm ranges, loads and temperatures. This may be rapidly implemented into existing platforms and will
meet and even exceed 2025 EPA (emissions) regs.
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
Full
Fu
ull SSpectrum
pectrum Monitor
Monitoring
ring
430
30 466 502 538 574 610 646 68
FSM
WXView
An integrated full
spectrum monitoring
system that
continuously verifies
compliance with
performance based
test methods
WeatherView, an innovative
data acquisition software that
provides remote access to
view all test parameters
S3T
An online measurement
system that provides
specific specimen surface
temperatures of test
samples on exposure
Weve perfected
the time machine.
Atlas can give you a glimpse into the future of your products
performance. With the introduction of four new innovations to its
Ci Series Weather-Ometers, that future can become more clear.
For more information on Ci Series Weather-Ometers visit
www.atlas-mts.com
Visit Atlas at:
June 29 - July 01
Nagoya, Japan
Booth 165
TECHNOLOGY REPORT
check valve, the company said, to minimize the typical two-stroke engines
exposure of the intake and exhaust
streams to engine lubricating oil.
The Nautilus Cycle engine will run air/
fuel ratios approximately ranging from
24:1 to 31:1, as the engine design means
the air/fuel ratio is determined strictly by
engine load. As for a projected noise, vibration and harshness signature for the
engine, Were not sure yet, Riley admits.
He seemed to indicate an ideal configuration for the Nautilus engine could be an
opposed-cylinder boxer layout. And he
would not rule out the likelihood that an
automotive application might require
some kind of supercharging to aid cylinder filling and scavengingparticularly if
the Nautilus Cycle engine is adapted to
operate under Miller or Atkinson cycles.
Riley said combustion temperatures
are expected to be around 1200F
(649C) for an engine that for the moment exists only in computer design: no
running prototype yet exists. He said the
company plans to have a running version
in eight to ten weeks and a prototype
engine up and functional within six
months. After a year of prototype development, he sees a window of two to
three years for major streamlining of
automotive applications.
Drone duty?
Given some past experiences, the timeline seems uncharacteristically cautious
for a new-engine promoterbut the
Nautilus Engineering CEO is openly bullish about the engine designs intrinsic
appeal: Somebodys probably going to
come to us by the end of the week with a
development contract, Riley predicted.
He said the immediate goal for
Kansas-based Nautilus Engineering is to
work with academic partner Kansas
State University to develop a version of
the engine suitable for an unmanned
aerial vehicle (UAV) drone.
Riley also said the Nautilus engine could
easily run a conventional four-stroke cycle.
One of its chief attributes, he insisted, is
scalability to accompany its easy adaptability for a range of mobility applications.
Bill Visnic
ELECTRONICS
TECHNOLOGY REPORT
OMEGA Introduces
Technical Learning
Visit omega.com/technical-learning
Contact Us Today
1.888.826.6342 | omega.com
Though 220-V chargers are faster, most owners of GMs plug-in vehicles
are using 110-V chargers. Shown is the SAE J1772 combo (Levels 1 and 2)
connection for the 2017 Chevrolet Bolt EV.
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
Prices listed are those in effect at the time of publication and are subject to change without notice.
Please contact OMEGAs sales department for current prices.
Note: Models with wireless option are approved for use in the US, Canada and Europe only.
COPYRIGHT 2016 OMEGA ENGINEERING, INC ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
May 2016 9
TECHNOLOGY REPORT
10 May 2016
INTERIORS
TECHNOLOGY REPORT
Manager. Therefore, it is critical to reduce losses in the IC and other electronic components and use proper layout
techniques, to minimize power waste
and assure proper heat dissipation.
Terry Costlow
HOW DO I KNOW
IF IM TALKING TO
AN ENGINEER OR
A SALESMAN?
38139_Smalley_BrandAd_NASATechBrief_r4.indd 1
Smalley
Wave Spring
Coil Spring
May 2016 11
9/8/15 1:29 PM
EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW
New dawn
at Honda
R&D
ondas new 10-speed automatic has not yet entered production, but it is already among the technologies that competitors are clamoring to benchmark when it enters the market.
Designed and built in house, the new planetary transmission
for front-drive vehicles, equipped with a torque converter, is as compact as Hondas incumbent 6-speed transaxle and is claimed to shift
30% faster and deliver a 14% improvement in acceleration.
Its an impressive piece of engineering, but the new 10-speeds
greatest attribute may be that it exists at all.
It wondrously escaped the corporate maze, noted Yoshiyuki
Matsumoto, who last month officially became President of Honda
R&D, the automakers integrated research and product development
organization. A 35-year Honda engineering veteran, he candidly
agrees with critics and even some Honda fans who say the company
that once dazzled the world with 22,000-rpm Grand Prix-winning
engines, beat everyone to U.S. Clean Air Act compliance, and set the
pace in innovative, efficient mobility for generations, had lost its
edge in recent years.
Business plans and strategy had prevailed, discouraging those
who challenged, Matsumoto told Automotive Engineering in an exclusive interview (his first with media) at Hondas Tokyo headquarters. He explained that often during this lackluster period, technologies that were novel and untried were often disregarded as prohibitive in cost for implementation.
The straight-talking Matsumoto aims to reverse that approach. He
and his R&D team are charged with invigorating their companys
product groups, with the kind of boldness that put the motora
term that now includes electric and chemical, as well as internal combustioninto Honda Motor Co.
12 May 2016
Yoshiyuki Matsumoto:
We will no longer limit ourselves to
building and marketing automotive and
related products, but expand to yonder.
Honda R&D will apply aero and materials learnings from the 2017
NSXs 9-year development to mainstream vehicle programs.
New dawn
at Honda
R&D
Might Honda make the jump beyond midsized
trucks like the 2017 Ridgeline (shown) and into
the true full-size segment? Matsumoto says
Never say never!
14 May 2016
Jack Yamaguchi
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
Automated-driving
systems will prevent
millions of accidents and
injuries and save thousands
of livesbut they will not
be perfect from the outset.
The challenges and opportunities on the road to zero deaths demand a new
level of federal automotive safety technical standards, and a new safety-defect
reporting and recall system. NHTSA and the U.S. Congress must act boldly and
quickly to make it happen.
Editors note: This article is based on a longer technical paper (201601-7000) by the authors and published by SAE International in April. It
can be accessed here: http://papers.sae.org/2016-01-7000/.
nationwide standards. NHTSA leadership can guide reform of the safety-defects system to better protect the public welfare. But only
Congress can enable NHTSA to fulfill its mission.
The challenges and opportunities on the road to zero deaths demand a coherent, national (and even international) response.
Solutions must be found quickly, but not hastily, through greater
transparency and collaboration among stakeholders. We are entering
what is arguably the final frontier in road safety, one in which traffic
and vehicle safety merge. The U.S. regulatory system needs to move
with it and Congress needs to make this happen.
Rulemaking in this new era needs to more closely resemble standards-setting within SAE International. Rather than focusing on mandatory vehicle performance, a new level of federal automotive safety
technical standard should focus on ensuring that systems installed on
vehicles are safe in the hands of the average driver. These standards
should set uniform minimum requirements for safety, privacy, security and other aspects in the public interest.
Unlike the FMVSS, however, these technical standards would not mandate vehicle performance. Rather, they would set performance requirements for automated systems. A vehicle would be required to meet these
requirements only if fitted with the given system; the FMVSS still could be
used to mandate their use, but these federal automotive safety technical
standards would leave use of the systems up to each automaker.
As such, NHTSA should be enabled to establish the standards more
quickly, without the extensive cost-benefit justifications required of
FMVSS. For this to happen, NHTSA needs to collaborate with stakeholders in road safety and NHTSA is absolutely correct to be reaching
out to automakers for support in developing standards. However, within a regulatory context, collaboration needs to go beyond agreements
May 2016 17
TRUST IS UNYIELDING
Roads can be a dangerous place for drivers, passengers
and pedestrians. Control of the cars ability to stop is a
fundamental necessity for safe passage. As cars become
more autonomous, ZF TRWs camera, radar and braking
technologies are enhancing stopping ability in the event
of driver lapse.
18 May 2016
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
For the promise of automated driving as depicted here to become reality, the
challenges cannot be met under a system designed in the 1960s, based on
assumptions from the 1950s and technologies from the 1970s, the authors argue.
May 2016 19
Euro NCAPS president warns that without coherent policies, the growing
availability of automated technologies may result in piecemeal technology
developmentand unintentional consequences.
by Stuart Birch
SAFETY FEATURE
Keeping secrets
Such a complex traffic landscape requires clear leadership and coherent policies if the growing availability of
automated technologies is not to result in piecemeal
development and unintentional consequences, he said:
Legislators tend to lag behind the technology, especially at the rate of progress common with electronics
and software, while individual vehicle manufacturers are
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
SAFETY FEATURE
The big
challenge of
autonomous
driving, said
Thatchams
Matthew Avery,
is the stepchange from
hands off to
eyes off.
DESIGNER YIN
MEETS
ENGINEER YANG
DESIGN | STYLING FEATURE
by Dan Carney
DESIGNER YIN
MEETS
ENGINEER YANG
one used by the factory racing team to cool the transaxle and rear
brakes. But the race teams [aesthetically] brutal solution wouldnt
fly in production, which demanded beautiful, said Juechter.
The aerodynamic challenge, however, was so tough that the engineering team couldnt devise a solution that looked good. So a designer asked to try to produce an asymmetric vent that was half conventional vent, half NACA duct.
I was mocking them, Juechter admitted. Until the design worked
in practice. Now it is studied physics, he said.
The GMC Acadias grille, on the other hand, was produced by sheer
number crunching, according to Paul Spadafora, Vehicle Chief
Engineer for the Cadillac XT5 and Acadia. While a bold, heavily
sculpted design with a lot of depth and surface interest was desired,
the Acadia is an SUV and, as such, it needs surplus cooling capacity
for towing, he pointed out.
The carefully developed result is a grille that flows more air through
the Acadias radiator than does an empty opening, because it tailors the
airflow for the space it is entering. Bring into play some advanced rapidprototyping technology and test it in the wind tunnel early and often.
To verify their computational fluid dynamics (CFD) models, GM
used additive manufacturing (3D printing) to produce prototypes for
wind tunnel testing early in the process. Getting these rapid prototype parts into our wind tunnel, we were able to confirm [the CFD
analysis] very quickly, Spadafora said. It was no small feat, no lack
of hours to come up with that.
Other parts are tougher to produce because they arent bolt-on trim.
In the case of the Cadillac XT5, Spadafora points to the sharply
creased body side panel. Getting that depth of draw is very challenging, he said. To achieve that, You want to have consistent die quality.
For the XT5, that meant plenty of analysis. You have the advantage
of the latest analytical tools to predict the stress strain on the panel,
said Spadofora. We used a lot of work and math, a lot of experience,
and we brought in the die experts. This was all before we could ever
produce a panel. That is upfront work in the studio.
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
For the sleek 2017 Lexus LC500, engineers were able to revise the
suspension to permit a very low hoodline. The solution required six
months of refinement work on the upper control arm and location
of the ball joint. (Image of cutaway by Lindsay Brooke)
LC500s hoodline above the wheel is several inches lower. That space normally contains suspension components, and Sato admitted that a higher upper arm is
better for ride compliance. The solution meant six
months of refining the design of the upper control arm
and the precise location of the ball joint. Ultimately this
permitted the ultra-low hoodline.
Once the car was mechanically possible, then it was
time to address legal requirements, in the form of pedestrian protection. The solution for the LC500 is one that
engineers try to avoid because its complex and expensive: a hood that pops up at all four corners using pyrotechnic charges in the event of a pedestrian-protection
collision, providing crucial impact-mitigating crush space
between the hood and the top of the engine.
In this instance, the engineers ability to support their
design colleagues desires with technology that overcomes a regulatory obstacle shows the value of close
cooperation between the groups. And maybe earns the
engineers a little goodwill in the next tussle with design.
May 2016 25
The e-LSD
alternative
to AWD
Eatons new-for-2018 electronic
limited-slip differential offers
mass, fuel-consumption,
and packaging benefits over
typical AWD while enhancing
vehicle dynamic control.
by Lindsay Brooke
POWERTRAIN FEATURE
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
Rick Kukucka:
The systems faster time to
peak pressure makes all the
difference in how much we
assist stability-control events
before any brake or throttle
interactions come into play,
pressure slightly faster than a brushed motor, but at
higher cost. The motor in turn drives a piston pump
that can work to peak performance across all temperature extremes, the company said.
The pump builds line pressure either directly or to
an accumulator when its not needed. An accumulator
is used because when there is a sudden need for intervention, the stored energy is what gives us that 100ms response time, guaranteed, Kukucka said. There is a
differential clutch for controlling torque slip, as well as
temperature and pressure sensors in the HCU and a
feedback loop to ensure precise pressure and intervention control. A plenum located downstream of the HCU
actuates the clutch discs. Operating pressures are 750
psi (5171 kPa) at the HCU, and 400 psi (2757 kPa) at
the clutch.
Eatons new e-LSD is compatible with any powertrain layout and is scalable according to vehicle segment and power.
You could add clutch discs, or increase/decrease
diameter of the clutch discs, or do both, Kukucka explained. Thats one of the advantages of the electrohydraulic approach: we can go from very low-torque demands, say 1200 Nm, to very high, like 4000 Nm and
towing a 9000-lb trailer. Eatons electronic controls engineers can supply either an entire ECU with calibration
tuned internally or support integrating the software into a
powertrain controller ECU.
May 2016 27
GLOBAL
VEHICLES
Teslas highly-anticipated Model 3 brings technology questions
Baby Model S? Model 3s styling with blunt, sans-grill nose fits nicely into
Teslas growing portfolio. (Photo by Tod Mesirow)
The ravenous feeding habits of the 24-hour news cycle rarely
turn toward automotive transportation, and usually only when
a disaster has happened, such as Toyotas acceleration mess
or Volkswagens diesel cheating. Recently it was Tesla Motors
turn to feed the beast with the unveiling of its long-anticipated Model 3, the battery-electric compact sedan which had
successfully remained under cover because Job One still is
almost two years away.
Traditional automakers dont normally lift their skirts quite
so early in the development process, when the mules are still
circulating as taped-together Frankensteins with shear-cut
holes. But here were three glossy Model 3s, perhaps the only
driveable examples in existence, giving rides to the 650 or so
attendees at a boisterous launch party behind the headquarters of SpaceX, Teslas sister company in Hawthorne, CA.
The car that Tesla CEO Elon Musk promised will arrive late
in 2017 as the companys volume play looks like a blunted and
bob-tailed version of Teslas larger Model S. It offers five seats
and both a conventional trunk and a frunk (front trunk) situated above a choice of battery packs that will deliver, said
Musk, at least 215 mi (346 km) of range on the EPA cycle.
View from the backseat shows the minimalist IP and large touchscreen
display that replaces all buttons and knobs. The Model 3 is wide for a
C-segment vehicle, but rear seat legroom is in short supply. (Tod Mesirow)
body materials described as a mix of aluminum and steel.
During the brief test ride, in which patrons were rocketed
up and down a nearby street that was sealed off by the police, Automotive Engineering touched a magnet to various
places on the car, including the structural B-pillar, and got no
stickeither these early prototypes were made of fiberglass
or theres very little steel in the body top-hat.
While Tesla engineers have previously talked about a potential mixed-materials strategy as they push future product
development down the retail-price ladder, the prospect of an
aluminum-intensive Model 3 raises the question of how profitable a $35,000 EV will be when it carries 60-80% of the battery capacity of the basic $71,200 Model S 70.
And yet to be confirmed is the cars battery-cell form factor. Will Model 3 be the first Tesla to abandon the 18650-type
laptop lithium battery cells used in Model S and X packs, in
favor of the prismatic or pouch-type form factors that are
increasingly becoming the automotive standard?
Musk promises a car that will have more cabin and cargo
space than anything its size, which is roughly that of a Mazda3.
The Model 3 is indeed wide, but the high, flat floor and the imposing front seat shells create a shortage of legroom in back.
Launch party crowd outside the SpaceX facility check out the Model 3s
enormous rear window-cum-roof panel. (Tod Mesirow)
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
GLOBAL VEHICLES
Arena rock and religious evangelism meet the auto industry: The Model 3 (at left on the stage)
debuted inside a hangar-sized SpaceX building in front of 650 Tesla true believers. (Tod Mesirow)
Riding on charisma
The Model 3, asserted Musk, is the affordable electric car that
he got into the car business to build. For all those who bought
an S or an X, he told the Hawthorne crowd, thank you for
paying for the 3. Tesla marches to its own beat, and unlike the
Model S and X unveilings which have been chaotic cheer-fests
attended by thousands, the head-count at Hawthorne was limited and the security was airtight. As usual, Musk had gathered
his acolytes to both dazzle them with another product leap
and also warn about the perils of climate change and the need
to reform carbon-based transportation.
Teslas CEO spoke for barely 20 minutes, without a prompter
Tesla engineers have dubbed the Model 3s front cargo trunk the frunk.
A magnet probe of the cars exterior panels during the launch showed
no indication of ferrous metals. Number on the back wall indicates how
many customers had plunked down a $1000 deposit on the car, sight
unseen, when this photo was taken. (Tod Mesirow)
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May 2016 29
GLOBAL VEHICLES
The Mazda MX-5 RF roof folds in three sections when retracted, but
the side buttresses remain, fastback-style.
Moving quickly to expand the appeal of the all-new, fourthgeneration MX-5 Miata roadster introduced last year, Mazda
revealed prior to the 2016 New York auto show a folding hardtop version of the car called MX-5 RF, for retractable fastback.
Mazda invokes the fastback descriptor because, unlike the
prior-generation MX-5s power retractable hardtop (PRHT)
that folded the entire roof assembly in a storage area behind
the seats, the 2017 MX-5 RF effectively is more of a targa
design: only the roofs center section and the rear glass are
removed, leaving buttresses on either side. When the roofretraction process begins (no exact figure yet from Mazda
regarding how long it takes), the one-piece side-buttress section briefly unlatches to release the retractable roof section
but then somewhat disappointingly reattaches instead of disappearing; video can be seen at: (http://insidemazda.mazdausa.com/newsroom/#assets_68).
The company did say the roof achieves one of the fastest
opening/closing times of any retractable hardtop. An acrylic wind
deflector can be erected in place of the retracted rear glass.
Mazda said the roof section can be retracted at speeds up
to 6 mph (10 km/h), but also has yet to detail how much
weight the folding-hardtop hardware adds. The new hardtop
does add 0.2 in (5 mm) in height compared with the standard
MX-5 roadster. The roadsters trunk capacity of 4.6 ft3 is not
reduced by the new folding-top hardware.
And perhaps in acknowledgement of the roadsters notinconsiderable top-up interior noise levels, the new MX-5 RFs
roof panels have sound-attenuation insulation and engineers
added extra sound-deadening measures around the rear
wheelwell area. The suspension and electric power-steering
have been slightly retuned for the MX-5 RF.
Mazda also said the 2017 MX-5 RF, which goes on sale later
in 2016, continues for the U.S. market with a 155-hp 2.0-liter
four-cylinder and a choice of 6-speed manual or automatic
transmissions. The MX-5 RF will offer an exclusive new color,
Machine Grey, that infuses aluminum flakes in the paints reflective layer to impart a unique sheen. With strong contrast
between light and shadow and a sleek, high-density finish,
(Machine Grey) gives the impression that the vehicles body
has been sculpted from a solid steel ingot, the company said.
Bill Visnic
30 May 2016
GLOBAL VEHICLES
many buyers will be able to charge during working hours. Toyota has an arrangement with ChargePoint, a company
with some 27,000 locations, mostly in
the U.S. More than half will be free to
Prime drivers. (For more on the Prius
Prime, see http://articles.sae.org/14700/.)
The engine in all Prius models is the
1.8-L Atkinson-cycle I4, for which Toyota
now claims 40% brake thermal efficiency, more than 30% higher than a modern
but conventional Otto cycle engine. The
contemporary interpretation of the
Atkinson cycle increases efficiency by
using infinitely-variable valve timing to
effectively increase the length of the
power stroke. Use of more of whats left
in the expansion stroke normally would
lead to performance weaknesses, but
the electric assist of the battery hybrid
fills in any gaps. The ICE also has a more
efficient electric water pump, new
cooled-EGR and exhaust-heat recovery
to speed engine warm-up.
Paul Weissler
Automotive Engine
Testing Sensors
Measure Engine Dynamics to 50 KHz at up to
10000F with better than 1 micron accuracy.
KD-1975
Kamans Non-Contact
Eddy Current
Sensors Measure:
Rocker arm movement / lifter leakdown
Axial camshaft / crankshaft run-out / balancing
Pushrod deection
Valve lift and valve oat investigation
Piston slap and skirt clearance
Static bearing clearance on crank journal
Engine mount deection
Dynamic/head gasket clearance
Fuel injection needle lift (not shown)
Turbo shaft runout (not shown)
800-552-6276
measuring@kaman.com
kamansensors.com
Visit our
Applications
Notes page
May 2016 31
GLOBAL VEHICLES
Lincoln unveils Big-SUV future with Navigator concept
Intent on staying on its message of reinvigorating its brand
under the banner of quiet luxury, Fords premium-vehicle
unit, Lincoln, used the 2016 New York auto show to reveal
what almost certainly will be remembered as one of the most
audacious concept cars ever, the Lincoln Navigator Concept.
Two stupendously-sized gullwing doors lift to allow full access
to the SUVs first and second seating rows, with 30-position adjustable seats floating on pedestal attachments that eliminate
traditional seat tracks, full-length concertina steps are powerdeployed to create a waterfall of steps for entry and exit, and a
wardrobe management system in the cargo area looks like
something Tony Stark dreamed up to secure his Iron Man gear.
The all-new Navigator Concept reinforces our commitment
to give every Lincoln client what we call quiet luxuryvehicles
and experiences that are elegant, effortlessly powerful and serene, said Kumar Galhotra, president of Lincoln, in a statement.
This kind of quiet luxury sets Lincoln apart. Now, were showing fans of large SUVs how we can exceed their expectations,
without being the loudest statement on the road.
At a media event prior to the Navigator Concepts public
unveiling at the New York auto show, neither Galhotra or other Lincoln officials would commit to whichif anyof the
concept SUVs most outlandish and ostentatious features
would end up on the production version of the fullsize SUV
expected next year, but it was quietly conceded the gullwing
doors are purely a flight of fancy, serving the purpose, for
now, of allowing a totally unfettered view of the Navigator
Concepts brilliantly detailed interior.
But one Lincoln source said that while the power-deployed
Outsized
display
screen for all
occupants in
the Navigator
Concept
interior.
32 May 2016
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
GLOBAL VEHICLES
Nissan targets cabin NVH with big investment in Sentra upgrade
Significant updates to the seventh generation Sentra make the 2016 model
Nissans quietest and most dynamicdriving compact sedan to date. The automaker invested more than three times
its typical outlay for a mid-cycle refresh
on Sentra, according to Chris
Schwerkoske, senior product planner.
The 2016 model contains more than
550 new parts involving the exterior,
interior, suspension, and steering systems, Schwerkoske told Automotive
Engineering.
With the Sentra revamp, Nissan aims
to remain a leader in the highly competitive compact car segment, said
Robert Mank, an engineer with Nissan
Technical Center North Americas
Marketability Engineering group.
He said the current-generation Sentra
was fully redesigned in 2013MY. Since
that time, compact-sedan makeovers
have included full redesigns of the
Mazda3 and Toyota Corolla in 2014MY,
as well as the 2016MY debut of the
10th-generation Honda Civic.
Sentras cabin noise was reduced
through various upgrades, including
replacing the prior non-laminated windshield with an acoustic windshield, and
adding sound-reduction materials under the dash, inside the door trim, and
underneath the floor carpet.
Explained Mank, In specific cabin
areas, material was added where there
was no sound-absorption material before, and in other areas we replaced
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May 2016 33
PRODUCT
BRIEFS
34 May 2016
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
ADVERTISEMENT
Company Description
Since 1915, Atlas has pioneered the way companies
test the durability of their
products. From the advanced technology of our
accelerated weathering
equipment and services to
the consultative services of
our expert weathering scientists, our approach to the
market is clear: Provide our
customers with sophisticated technology and advanced testing solutions to determine how long their products will last.
When predicting how components of a car will stand up
to the elements, it isnt enough to guess. You need to
know. Atlas works with every major automotive manufacturer on the market today to develop comprehensive testing programs that deliver reliable results.
Atlas has the widest range of accelerated laboratory
instruments, from tabletop to the largest rotating rack xenon arc chambers. Atlas fluorescent UV instrument, corrosion cabinets, flammability chambers, full vehicle solar
simulation and high-speed lighting systems for crash testing set the standard for a wide range of automotive materials testing needs.
Products/Services Offered
Similar to its testing instruments, Atlas Weathering
Services Group has the
same goal for innovation
and quality; its new UltraAccelerated EMMAQUA
technology provides faster
test results than standard
ASTM G90 devices.
With its outdoor and accelerated laboratory testing
services, AWSG is the first
weathering organization to
receive accreditation to ISO 17025. Additionally, Atlas is
fully accredited by the Automotive Manufacturers
Equipment Compliance Agency, Inc. (AMECA).
Atlas products are designed and manufactured to conform
to international, national and industry standard test methods
including SAE, ISO, ASTM, DIN, JIS and numerous others.
Atlas offers:
Weathering, corrosion and flammability instruments
Outdoor and accelerated laboratory weathering
testing services
Evaluation services
Full vehicle systems and crash test lighting
Test methodology and standards development
Material performance tests for plastics, coatings, textiles,
rubber and glass
Consultation and client education services
www.atlas-mts.com
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May 2016 35
ADVERTISEMENT
COMSOL, INC.
100 District Ave.
Burlington, MA 01803
Phone: 781-273-3322
E-mail: info@comsol.com
www.comsol.com
Company Description
COMSOL is a global provider of simulation software for
product design and research to technical enterprises, research labs, and universities. Its COMSOL Multiphysics product is an integrated software environment for creating physics-based models and simulation apps. Founded in 1986,
COMSOL employs more than 400 people in 22 offices worldwide and extends its reach with a network of distributors.
Products/Services Offered
With the COMSOL Multiphysics software, you can accurately model any physics-based problem. Engineers and
researchers use our software for a wide variety of applications, ranging from developing energy-efficient vehicles to
educating physics and engineering students. Simulation
experts rely on the COMSOL Server product to deploy
apps to their design teams, manufacturing departments,
test laboratories, and customers throughout the world.
Customized simulation apps enable the wider technical
community to utilize the power of multiphysics simulation by providing access to a detailed model through an
easy-to-use interface.
www.comsol.com
36 May 2016
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
www.dspaceinc.com
www.dspaceinc.com
www.dspaceinc.com
System Architecture
ECU Autocoding
HIL Testing
Virtual Validation
Data Management
ADVERTISEMENT
Company Description
Gerdau history dates back to 1901 when it started as a nail
factory in Porto Alegre, Brazil. Today Gerdau products are
present in the daily lives of millions of people. With more than
45,000 employees and operations in 14 countries, including
the Americas, Europe and Asia, Gerdau has an installed capacity of over 25 million metric tons of steel annually.
Gerdau is the leading producer of long steel in the
Americas, and one of the largest suppliers of special long steel
in the world. Additionally, Gerdau is the largest special bar
quality steel supplier to the automotive industry in the world.
Products/Services Offered
Gerdaus innovative steel technologies have led to recent
new product developments such as MECAMAX and
NANOCEM steels. Gerdaus MECAMAX steels were developed to reduce customers steel machining costs by up to
50 percent for both conventional and complex machining
applications. This is achieved by making an addition of the
non-toxic element bismuth. The benefits of MECAMAX
steels include self-lubrication, shorter chips, reduced cutting
forces, and longer tool life during the machining process.
NANOCEM steels were developed by Gerdau Special
Steel as a way to reduce customers cost for carburizing
forged gears and other transmission components using
low carbon alloy steel grades. NANOCEM steels are produced by micro-alloying aluminum, niobium, nitrogen and
titanium in steels for forming precipitates to suppress austentite grain coarsening at elevated temperatures during
carburizing, which allows for a significantly shortened carburizing or case hardening time (up to 3 4 times less).
www.gerdau.com/northamerica
38 May 2016
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
ADVERTISEMENT
PROTO LABS
5540 Pioneer Creek Drive
Maple Plain, MN 55359
Phone: 763-479-3680
Fax: 763-479-2679
E-mail: customerservice@protolabs.com
www.protolabs.com
Company Description
Proto Labs is the worlds fastest digital manufacturing
source for custom prototypes and low-volume production
parts. Its a technology-enabled company that uses advanced 3D printing, CNC machining and injection molding
technologies to produce parts within days. The result is an
unprecedented speed-to-market value for designers and
engineers and an on-demand manufacturing resource
throughout a products life cycle.
Why Proto Labs?
Proto Labs has radically changed the economics and lead
times traditionally associated with manufactured parts.
The rapid manufacturer provides a fast, easy and costeffective way to obtain 1 to 10,000 parts within days,
routinely shipping parts before conventional suppliers
can even quote them. These quick delivery times are possible because it has automated the manual process of
mold design and toolpath generation through the use of
proprietary software.
Products/Services Offered
3D Printing
Proto Labs uses the latest 3D printing technologies to provide precision accuracy to plastic and metal part production
from small pieces with complex geometries to large, highly detailed patterns. 3D printing is ideal for 1 to 50 parts and
works well for form and fit testing, reducing multipart assemblies and as fully functional components in some cases.
CNC Machining
The companys CNC machining service uses three-axis
milling and turning with live tooling to machine up to 200
parts from more than 30 stocked plastic and metal materials. The result is functional parts made from engineeringgrade materials for prototype testing, jigs and fixtures, and
end-use applications.
Injection Molding
For those who need low-volume production, bridge tooling or on-demand parts throughout a products life cycle,
rapid injection molding can manufacture up to 10,000
parts from hundreds of different engineering-grade plastic
and liquid silicone rubber materials.
www.protolabs.com
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May 2016 39
ADVERTISEMENT
Products/Services Offered
The company supplies flexible, durable, high performing simulators and their modular components: hardware, software, vehicle
models, content, and on- and off-board projection systems.
Crudens simulators andstand-alone, open architecture
Panthera Software Suiteare designed to slot
into customers existing tool chains so their
engineers can be up and running quickly with
a future-proofsystem that does not tie them
to any one supplier. Their features allow:
CRUDEN
Pedro de Medinalaan 25
1086 XP Amsterdam
The Netherlands
Phone: +31 20 707 4668
E-mail: info@cruden.com
www.cruden.com
Company Description
Cruden is the worlds leading designer,
manufacturer and integrator of open architecture driving simulators for the automotive, motorsport andmarine industries.
Having recognised the potential of driving
simulators to save time and money
throughdriver-in-the-loop (DIL)testing
since the 1990s, Cruden has installed over 100 simulators
globally. Many automotive OEMs and research institutions rely on Cruden simulators as an engineering tool
for vehicle dynamics, autonomous driving, ride & comfort, driver training, HMI, ADAS, NVH and audio development and testing.
www.cruden.com
ADVERTISEMENT
Company Description
Your One-Stop Source for Process
Measurement and Control
Founded in 1962, OMEGA
Engineering Inc. has grown from
manufacturing thermocouples to a
global technology leader, with more
than 100,000 innovative products for measuring and controlling temperature, humidity, pressure, strain, force, flow,
level, pH, and conductivity. OMEGA also offers a complete
line of data acquisition, automation, electric heating, and
custom engineered products for use in manufacturing, test
and research environments.
Exceptional Customer Experience
Our highly trained, degreed engineers provide free unlimited
40 May 2016
Products/Services Offered
Easy One-Stop Shopping
We offer the latest technology and competitive pricing so customers dont have to shop anywhere else. Our website offers
user-friendly search tools, easy ordering
options and online support. Customer
service, sales and technical assistance
are free, professional and prompt.
World Class Manufacturing and
Distribution
OMEGA products are used in many critical applications in manufacturing, food
processing, medicine, aerospace, and
science, to name a few. OMEGA manufactures many individual components with the balance meeting
OMEGAs rigid quality specifications. With manufacturing centers located in the United States, Europe and China and worldwide warehousing, OMEGA can service customers daily needs.
The OMEGA credo: We provide you the products that
you need, when and where you need them.
www.omega.com
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
ADVERTISEMENT
Products/Services Offered
Smalley prides itself in providing more than just a part
number. Whether you need space saving Wave Springs or
strong retaining rings, our engineers work directly with
you to determine what product meets your application
requirements. Smalley Wave springs reduce spring heights
by up to 50% compared to conventional springs. When
using a retaining ring, engineers choose Smalleys Spirolox
Rings because they have No-Ears to interfere in an assembly and can fit stamped ring grooves. For impact-loading
applications, turn to Smalleys constant section rings. From
stainless steel, to exotic alloys, we have the right materials
and capabilities to provide you with the right solution.
SMALLEY
555 Oakwood Road
Lake Zurich, IL 60047
Phone: 847-719-5900
Fax: 847-719-5999
E-mail: info@smalley.com
www.smalley.com
Company Description
Smalley is the exclusive manufacturer of the industry-leading Spirolox Retaining Rings and the originator of Crestto-Crest Wave Springs. Smalley prides itself in being the
industry leader in steel ring and spring customization due
to our ability to control the design and manufacturing process from the production of raw materials to the finished
product. With locations globally, we are certified toISO
9001,ISO/TS 16949,AS 9100CandISO 14001. Smalley offers customers unprecedented service and quality. We
welcome your comments and your design challenges.
Smalley will work hard to become your preferred source
for retaining rings and wave springs.
www.smalley.com
ADVERTISEMENT
Products/Services Offered
ZF TRW designs, develops and manufactures the widest
array of safety systems in the industry:
Driver assist systems including radar and camera sensors
Company Description
ZF TRW is the Active and Passive Safety Division of ZF
Friedrichshafen AG. We are uniquely positioned to deliver
integrated systems that form the building blocks for tomorrows automated vehicles.
http://safety.trw.com
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May 2016 41
COMPANIES MENTIONED
Company
Page
Acura .......................................................................................................12
GlobalAutoRegs.com ............................................................................19
GMC ........................................................................................................ 23
AirFuel Alliance......................................................................................10
GS Yuasa .................................................................................................31
Audi ........................................................................................................20
HBM ........................................................................................................34
Smalley ..................................................................................................34
BMW ......................................................................................................... 2
SpaceX ...................................................................................................28
Bosch ......................................................................................................20
IHS ...........................................................................................................10
BSA ........................................................................................................... 2
STMicroelectonics...................................................................................11
Jeep ........................................................................................................ 27
Cadillac................................................................................................... 32
Tesla........................................................................................................ 32
Carfax ......................................................................................................17
Lexus ...................................................................................................... 23
Lincoln .................................................................................................... 32
Chevrolet ..........................................................................................23, 31
Continental AG........................................................................................4
Mitsubishi ..............................................................................................30
Eaton ......................................................................................................26
nCode .....................................................................................................34
NHTSA .....................................................................................................16
Volkswagen ...........................................................................................28
FEDITC ......................................................................................................6
NXP Semiconductor..............................................................................10
S. Himmelstein Final Auto Eng ad_S. Himmelstein Small Space ad SAE 1/5
AD INDEX
Advertiser
S. HIMMELSTEIN
AND
www.himmelstein.com
COMPANY
800-632-7873
Page
Web Link
Executive Leadership
Provided by:
ON-HIGHWAYOFF-HIGHWAYDEFENSE
sae.org/comvec
P1611538
42 May 2016
P1611538_2016_Comvec_3.375x2.125.indd 1
3/30/16 4:07 PM
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
Speakers:
Sandeep
Sovani, Ph.D.
Director, Global
Automotive
Industry,
ANSYS Inc.
Markus Kopp
Margaret
Xavier
Fornari, Ph.D.
Lisa Arrigo
SAE International
Product Manager,
Embedded Software,
ANSYS France
Registration:
www.sae.org/magazines/webcasts
Sponsored by:
Hosted by:
Speakers:
Garry Grant
Manager,
Substrate Protection
Technology,
PPG
Peter Votruba-Drzal
Research Manager,
Electrocoat,
Physical Chemistry &
Insight, PPG
Lisa Arrigo
SAE International
Registration:
www.sae.org/magazines/webcasts
Sponsored by:
Hosted by:
Q&A
You think there is good potential, then, to meld the aspects
of performance and autonomous? That the two worlds are
not mutually exclusive?
Making the decision to use autonomous technology for the
GT-R would (actually) help a lot. Why? Because performance
cars have no space, (autonomous hardware) is heavy, system
response (is critical)putting that technology in any performance car is helpful (to speed development for mainstream
models). Packaging is really the key.
Keno Kato:
The GT-R is a symbol of
our technical capability.
Supercars and
character are critical in
the autonomous future
At the recent New York auto show, Automotive Engineering
spoke with Keno Kato, Nissans Corporate Vice President for
Global Product Strategy & Product Planning. Kato, an enthusiast of mobility in just about any form, was in town to support
Nissans unveiling of the heavily revised 2017 GT-R supercar.
Everyone knows the GT-R is a halo car. But the GT-R almost
transcends that description in your home market, doesnt it?
I raised the question about this car to check awareness. Nearly
100% of people know it; awareness is unbelievable. For my
generationand a bit younger as well as much olderthis (GTR) brand is significant. Maybe like Corvette in the U.S. This is
truly the icon of high-performance (in Japan) for my generation. For the future, we have to continue to demonstrate our
technology and our performance through this brand.
So one way you see the GT-R is as a demonstration of
Nissans ability to solve problems?
Its a symbol of our technical capability. Plus, respect for the
customer. If we start to make excuses, thats really bad. (Nissan
can cope) with any new requirement, regulation, anything
that message is very important.
What does this mean when the talk almost every day is
about how cars are going to drive us? Will there always be a
place for a GT-R? Will someday even a GT-R be autonomous?
Theres zero mismatch (between performance cars and autonomous technology). Theres an easy example: in the city, in
traffic, the driver can reduce effort. After leaving the city and
getting to the destination, say the racetrack, the driver resumes
control. This is quite a straightforward story for even the GT-R
or any car: reduce effort for the driver in unfavorable traffic
situations. Thats most valuable. Ive tested an (autonomous)
prototype, by the way, and I was excited. I am a car guy and I
was excited by the thought of the autonomous technology.
44 May 2016
AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
CREATE IT.
ABRAHAM LINCOLN
Making Inroads
2013 BEST STUDENT ENTRY
SELF-DRIVING CAR
www.createthefuturecontest.com
P R I N C I P A L
S P O N S O R S
C A T E G O R Y
S P O N S O R S
P R I Z E
S P O N S O R S
COMSOL MULTIPHYSICS
APPLICATION BUILDER
APPLICATION
comsol.com/application-builder
Copyright 2016 COMSOL. COMSOL, COMSOL Multiphysics, Capture the Concept, COMSOL Desktop, COMSOL Server, LiveLink, and Simulation for Everyone are either registered trademarks or
trademarks of COMSOL AB. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners, and COMSOL AB and its subsidiaries and products are not aliated with, endorsed by, sponsored by, or
supported by those trademark owners. For a list of such trademark owners, see www.comsol.com/trademarks