NATURE
PETITIONERS
RESPONDENTS
SUMMARY. Petitioner failed the CPA Board Exams. Believing she passed,
she is now invoking her right to information to to get hold of the
questionnaire, her answer documents, the answer key, and explanation of
the grading system. The Supreme Court held that there are valid reasons
with regard to the limited access to the Examination Papers.
DOCTRINE. Like all the constitutional guarantees, the right to information
is not absolute. The people's right to information is limited to "matters of
public concern," and is further "subject to such limitations as may be
provided by law." Similarly, the State's policy of full disclosure is limited to
"transactions involving public interest," and is "subject to reasonable
conditions prescribed by law".
FACTS.
Believing she passed, she wrote to the Board to request for the
following documents: (a) the questionnaire in each of the seven
subjects (b) her answer sheets; (c) the answer keys to the
questionnaires, and (d) an explanation of the grading system used in
each subject (collectively, the Examination Papers).