ed. S. Huerta, Madrid: I. Juan de Herrera, SEdHC, ETSAM, A. E. Benvenuto, COAM, F. Dragados, 2003.
f~
/
bC*
tw/
/
/
1:
/ ,
,u
-c::: -c:::l.>
'
-,
"-
~- ~,
-<::
.
lO'
o)
l.
lO'
b=b,
Cy
\z
-,
Iz
b)
b
~.
d)
d
i"""
_.
y
e)
Figure 1
Types of Composite
4.9)
f)
~z
Columns
Iz
Fig.
788
H. Eggemann
(1862-1942)
This paragraph
is based on a curriculum
by
Kleinlogel, dedicated to Emperger's 70th birthday
(Kleinlogel 1932). Emperger was born on January
11th, 1862 in Beroun (at that time Austria, today
Czech Republic).When he began his studies in Prague
in 1879, the first effects of Monier' s patents had
become visible in France and evoked Emperger's
interest in the new technology. His first professional
activities were in the field of railway and bridge
construction. In 1890 he settled down in Chicago as a
consultant engineer, where he worked on the planning
of New York's and Boston's subways, built the first
American concrete bridge in Cincinatti, Ohio and
designed high-rise buildings.
COLUMNS
First steps
In the winter of 1901/1902 Emperger started research
on concrete
columns
mostly
reinforced
with
structural steel. For several reasons he had to wait
until 1908 to have the specimens tested in Stuttgart
with Bach. AJthough Emperger didn't give explicit
evidence for the problems, it can be supposed that
there had been internal rivalry with his colleagues in
Vienna (Emperger
1908b, Foreword).
In 1907,
Emperger tested three steel columns to determine
their buckling loads (Emperger 1907a). After testing,
one of those specimens, Figure 3, was bent back to its
original shape by Emperger himself and filled with
concrete (Emperger 1907b, 172). Emperger wanted to
give evidence for the importance of concrete filling
for steel columns. He estimated that the design
formula
P
Figure 2
Medal of Honour to Emperger's 70th Birthday (Beton u.
Eisen 1932,50)
= O'h (Fb +
15 F)
Developrnent
789
effort
Emperger's
= Fb0h
+ Feo,
Patent 1911
Figure 3
Steel Colurnn filled with Concrete (Emperger 1907b, 173)
Emperger's
addition-law
= Fb0b + Feo,
+ Fpg
where
is the compres sive strength of the cast-iron
"
in consicteration
of buckling of the complete section,
is the yield point of the mi Id steel and 0b is the
e
cornpressive
strength of the concrete (Ernperger
1913, 34). In the sarne book Ernperger reported
various test results of encased cast-iron colurnns. The
colurnn sections were varied in rnany ways, and solid
cores were tested too, Figure 5. During the following
years, nurnerous buildings in Austria, Czechoslovakia
and the United States had been built with EmpergerColurnns, but not in Gerrnany (Kleinlogel 1928, 53).
For Kleinlogel the reason had been that Gerrnany's
building authorities
rejected the application
of
Ernperger-Colurnns
because of missing regulations,
and official tests had been refused because of
Ernperger' s patent clairn. So in 1928 Ernperger
decided to give up his clairns (Kleinlogel 1928, 53).
Emperger-columns
in the United
States
790
H. Eggemann
p2mmna#mm
Fig.2.
Figure 5
Emperger-Columns
]913,53,56)
in San Francisco, USA. He presented his AdditionLaw and pointed out that the strength of the core
material was not of great importance, both cast-iron
and mild steel were possible. In 1920, EmpergerColumns
were regulated
in the US Standard
Specifications No. 23, Standard Building Regulations
for the Use of Reinforced Concrete (ACI 1920).
Paragraph 50 stated:
Composite columns having a cast -iron core or center
surrounded by concrete which is enclosed in a spiral of
not less than one-half of ] per cent of the core area, and
with a pitch of not more than three inches, may be figured
for a stress of 12,000 - 60 L/R, but not over 10,000 lb. per
sq. in. [69 N/mm~] on the cast-iron
"'!T
Figure 4
Emperger-Column (Pat. 291068, Fig. 2)
Emperger's
Addition-Law
was applied
in a
modified form, using a specified Tetmajer-Formula.
This was the first official building regulation for
Emperger-CoIumns.
The
maximum
allowed
compressive strength of the concrete was 3000 lb. per
sq. in. (20.7 N/mm"'), so a column could be calculated
with a maximum stress on the concrete of 4. I N/m m"'.
In 1928 the paragraph was amended and cores of mild
steel were permitted too (ACI 1928, 824). This
building regulations made it possible to use EmpergerColumns in the design of many high-rise buildings in
the United States, above all in Chicago:
Buildings having the Emperger typc of column,
include the following:
Surf-Hotel,
Chicago,
eleven
storeys;
two sixteen-storey
apartment
buildings
at
Development
3730-40
Sheridan
Road, Chicago;
Aragon
Hotel,
Chicago, twelve storeys; Krolick Department
Store,
Detroit, 150"200 ft. [46"61 m], twelve storeys, with
co1umn loads of 2,000,000 lb. [9 MN], and a building of
the same size for the Detroit Pressed Steel Company. Of
these, the Surf Hotel and the Krolick Store have hollow
cast-iron cores (ENR 1930, 278).
Composite
Columns
in Europe
today.
791
Type 1.
TypellI
''1
<~/"
.T)]~
IL
T"eI\
Figure 6
Composite Columns 1932 (Emperger 1932, 596)
792
H. Eggemann
,,
.....
~.
;1Zmm,Sfmb
,,
~'
,'
,
,
,
,,
,
I,
I~,
,,
"
I
I
"
VI
SO.JS'lNS
Sp.SQ.Z,S./,Smm
;1Zmm,sfmb
I
I,
I
I,
I
I
I
I
~
Al
'
mm
J'lo/llrern
;ZZOmm,SIJ7
tlMIIlllet"
tkiget
',
I
I
8oW!oJfgewebe
8aula/lgewe/;e Ng.
I
I
I,
Rippenloflahj
OZmm
'
Figure 7
Concrete Columns reinforced with Structural Steel (DIN
1045-1943, Fig. 23)
Figure 8
Composite
1969,260)
4 for
= A/Yd + Aca/cd
+ A/'d
793
etfort
McGraw-Hill
Building, Chicago 1929
Architect: Thielbar & Fugard, Chicago
Engineer: James B. Black, Chicago
BUILDING
CASE
HISTORIES
'1
~---.~'.
TI
1,11 ~\'
r~ .,.~',
~I
,
'."
'
~C
''
, ,,
',
'
:
'
"',1 ..
,
'
45
">,,,,
,
.'
.9
~
'"
43
~,
'"'!
1
I
: L'
:
.-
'
.,
,,
,; H
"
". 'C~l"
1
39
'.
,d
32
:;]
46 "
-".-
Court
Above Jrd Floor
~1
I~~ ~f "p
:~~..-~ -. --4S19f'.
LOflme-"
,< i
,,!If~.
t~
",
"
'
..,' ..28',"
Corridor
'.J
"tU.I
1111::,,<1"
.10
1118
18
17
Mic.higan
Figure
Typical
"
IIJII
34
26
25
41
Space
Offce
Figure 9
McGraw-Hill Building, Chicago 1929 (ENR 1929, 129)
33
4Q
Ave.
10
Floor
Plan, McGraw-Hill
Building
(ENR
1929,
130)
794
H. Eggemann
Figure 11
Detail of Column-Joint in McGraw-Hill Building (ENR
1929, 130)
Figure 12
View in First Floor of Telephone-Factory, Budapest (Enyedi
1931,244)
Telephone-Factory,
Budapest 1930
Architect: N. N.
Engineer: Bla Enyedi, Budapest
o;
C'Ji
2Q....
! i
Schnitt mz-m2
',1Qi'.1M
wr;
~..
The Telephone-Factory
in Budapest, Hungary, is one
of the few documented buildings in Europe designed
with Emperger-Columns.
Built in 1930, it has got a
framed structure with a column spacing of about 5,60
m square. For the reason of transparency and cable
assembly, the structure was built 'without floorbeams, using flared heads instead, Figure 12. To
achieve the smallest possible column proportionsthe company wanted columns of less than 40 cm
square with the option of adding another storey-the
columns were designed according to the Emperger
type, but with a core of mild steel instead of cast-iron:
[Es] wurden umschnrte
Sttzen mit steifen
FluBeiseneinlagen,
System Dr. Emperger, gewahlt
(Enyedi 1931, 242). The columns were made of
octagonal sections, 39 cm in view, and with a strong
hooping (spiral reinforcement). The columns on the
basement, made of ordinary reinforced concrete, 66
cm square, had more than double the cross-section
area, Figure 13.
~"'
.39
""'"''
@
"-
rI}-
_.r!1.L
.
..
60,60
8i./ :
""'S"
\.1Q~
1o.f/
,66
_.-I!1L
j6.~~Qf
_r:!!L
y<
..M
39""[
Schnitt
.:
~;
''
'
m,-m,
~'
1~:'J~~
t:::J"f.,
<_..6.L
~_LOQ~
Figure 13
Column Section
1931, 243)
of Telephone-FactOry,
Budapest
(Enyedi
Development
795
Millenium-Tower,
Vienna 1999
Architect: Peichl, Podrecca and Weber, Innsbruck
Engineer: Tschemmernegg,
Obholzer and Baumann,
Innsbruck
The 50-storey Millenium Tower in Vienna is the
tallest building in Austria, with a height of 202 m,
Figure 14. After construction had been started in
1998, it took less than one year until its completion in
1999. The structure consists of a reinforced concrete
core, while composite construction was used for the
ceilings
and columns
in the office
areas
(Tschemmernegg
1999, 607). The exterior columns
are made of comete filled hollow sections with solid
steel cores, Figure 15. The columns themselves have
a diameter of 406.4 mm fram first to 14th floor and
323.9 mm above. The cores were gradually reduced
Figure 15
Composite Column with Solid Steel Core, Millenium Tower
(Angerer, Rubin and Taus 1999,642)
Figure 14
Millenium Tower under Construction 1999 (Tschemmemegg
1999,610)
796
H. Eggemann
REFERENCE LIST
ACI.
1920. American
Concrete
Institute.
Standard
Specifications No. 23. Standard Building Regulations for
the Use of Reinforced Concrete. in: Proceedings. ACI.
Vol. 16: 283-302.
ACI. 1928. American Concrete Institute. Tentative Building
Regulations
for Reinforced Concrete (E-IA-28T).
in:
Proceedings. ACI. Vol. 24: 791-828.
Angerer. T.. D. Rubin. and M. Taus. 1999. Verbundsttzen
und Querkraftanschlsse
beim Millenium
Tower.
Stahlbau 68: 641-46.
Bauer. Bruno.
1930. Eine neuartige
Herstellung
von
Eisenbetonbauten.
Beton u. Eisen 29: 3] 2-15.
BolI. K.. and U. Vogel. 1969. Die Stahlkernsttze und ihre
Bemessung. Bautechnik 46: 253-62, 303-09.
Bonzel. J.. H. Bub. and P. Funk. 1972. ErHiuterungen zu den
Stahlbetonbestimmungen.
Band. I, 7. Auflage. Berlin,
Mnchen. Dsseldorf: Wilhelm Ernst & Sohn.
DlN 1045. 1943. A. Bestimmungen fr die Ausfhrung von
Bauwerken aus Stahlbeton. 4. Ausg. 1943. Berlin: Beuth
1943.
-.
-.
1913. Neuere
Bogenbrcken
aus umschnrtem
GuBeisen, System Dr. Ing. Fritz Edler von Emperger.
Berlin: Wilhelm Ernst & Sohn.
-. ]930. Der Wettbewerb zwischen Eisen und Eisenbeton
im Hochbau.
Zentralblatt
der Bauverwaltung
50.
Supplement Konstruktion und Ausfhrung: K81-84.
-.
Hochhausbau.
-.
-.
Development
Offenlegungsschrift
Nr. 1559482. DeUtsches Patentamt.
Dipl.-Ing.
Kuno Bol1, Stuttgart.
Stahlkernsttzen.
Offenlegungstag:
5. Marz 1970.
Patentschrift Nr. 291068. Kaiserliches Patentamt. Dr.-Ing.
Fritz von Emperger in Wien. Hohle GuBeisensaule mit
einem Mantel aus umschnrtem
Beton. Patentiert im
Deutschen Reiche vom 24. Ianuar 1911 ab.
Roik, K., R. Bergmann, H. Bode, and G. Wagenknecht.
1976. Tragfahigkeit
von einbetonierten
Stahlsttzen.
lnstitut
fr konstruktiven
lngenieurbau,
Bochum
University, Mitteilung 76-4.
797