TABLE OF

CONTENTS
Book I: Part I

JURISDICTION
1. Zamora v. CA, 183 SCRA 279 [1990]
2. Mercado v. Uban, et.al., Gr. No. 35830, July 24,1990
3. Serdoncillo v. Benorillao, Gr. No. 118328, Oct. 8, 1998
4. Citibank, N.A. v. CA, Gr. No. 108961, Nov. 27, 1998
5. Isidro v. CA, et. al. , Gr. No. 105586, Dec. 15, 1993
6. Ratilla v. Tapucar, et. al. , Gr. No. L-45018, Jan. 24,1997
7. Fernandez v. International Corporate Bank, et. al., 31
SCRA 326
8. Singson v. Isabela Sawmill, Gr. No. L-27343, Feb. 28,
1979
9. Cruz v. Tan, 87 Phil. 627 [1950]
10. Mendoza v. The, et. al., Gr. No. 122646, March 14, 1997
11. Firestone Ceramics v. CA, Gr. No. 127245, June 28, 2000
12. Republic v. CA, Gr. No. 127245, June 28, 2000
RULE 1. GENERAL PROVISIONS
13. Pacific Banking Corporation Employees Organization, et.
al v. CA, et.al, Gr. No. 109373, March 20, 1995
14. Cojuangco Jr. v. Palma, Admn. Case No. 2474, Sept. 15,
2004
15. Magaspi, et. al, v. Ramoleta, 115 SCRA 193
16. Cabrera v. Tiana, 8 SCRA 542
17. Barco v. CA, et. al., Gr. No. 120587, Jan. 20, 2004
18. BA Finance Corp. v. CA, Gr. No. 102998, July 5, 1996
19. Domagas v. Jensen, Gr. No. 158407, Jan. 17, 2005
20. Fortich v. Corona, Gr. No. 131457, April 24, 1998
RULE 2. CAUSE OF ACTION
21. Navoa v. CA, Gr. No. 59255, Dec. 29, 1995 [251 SCRA
545]
22. Joseph v. Bautista, et. al., Gr. No. L-41423, Feb. 28, 1962
23. De Guzman v. CA, 192 SCRA 507
24. Quiogue, et. al. v. Bautista, et. al., Gr. No. L-13159, Feb
28, 1962
25. Caltex Phil. , Inc. v. IAC, et. al., Gr. No. 74730, Aug. 25,
1989
26. Danilo and Cristina Decena v Pedro and Valeria Piquero,
Gr. No. 155736, March 31, 2005
RULE 3. PARTIES TO CIVIL ACTION
27. Yao Ka Sin Trading v. CA, et. al., Gr. No. 53820, June 15,
1992
28. Commissioner of Customs v. KMK Gani, Indrapal & Co.,
Gr. No. 73722, Feb. 26, 1990
29. Lorenzo Shippine Co. v. Chubb & Sons, Inc., et. al., Gr.
No. 147724, June 8, 2004
30. Pascual v. Secretary of Public Works, L-10405, Dec. 29,
1960
31. Agan Jr., et. al. v. Phil. Int.l Air Terminals Co., et. al., Gr.
Nos. 155001/15547/155661, Jan. 21,2004
32. Tangpingco v. IAC, Gr. No. 76225, March 31, 1992 [207
SCRA 652]
33. Travel Wide Assoc. Sales Phi., et. al., v. CA, et. al., Gr. No.
77356, July 15, 1991
34. Tancutian, et. al. v. Gempesaw, et. al., Gr. No. 149097,
Oct, 18, 2004
35. Salvador v. CA, et.al., Gr, No. 109910, April 5, 1995
36. The Leyte-Samar Sales Co., et. al. v. CEA, et. al., Gr. No.
5963, May 20, 1953

Page
No.
3-5
7-9
11
13
15
17
19-21
23-25
27-20
31-33
35-37
39-41
43-45
47-49
51-53
55-57
59-61
63-65
67-69
71-73
75-77
79-81
83
85
87
89

91- 93
95-97
99-101
103105
107109
111113
115117
119121
123
125

RULE 4. VENUE
37. Lizares, Inc. v. Caluag, et. al., Gr. No. L-17699, March 30,
1962
38. Infante v. Aran Bauilders, Inc., Gr. No. 156596, Aug.
24,2007
39. Dimo Realty & Dev., Inc., et. al. v. Dimaculangan, Gr. No.
1300991, March 11, 2004
40. Gesmundo v. JRB Realty Corp., et. al., Gr. No. 111077,
July 14, 1994
41. Uniwide Holdings, Inc. v. Cruz, Gr. No. 171456, Aug. 9,
2007
RULE 6. KINDS OF PLEADINGS
42. Samala v. Victoe, Gr. No. 53969, Feb. 21, 1989
43. Halimao v. Villanueva, Adm. Case No. 3825, Feb. 1, 1996
44. Cruz-Agana v. Santiago-Lagman, Gr. No. 139018, April
11, 2005
45. Ballecer v. Bernardo, Gr. No. L-21766, Sept. 30, 1996 [18
SCRA 291]
46. Lascano v. Universal Steel Smelting Co., Inc., et. al., Gr.
No. 146019, June 8, 2004
RULE 7. PARTS OF PLEADINGS
47. Villanueva v. Andre, Gr. No. 80863, April 27, 1989 [172
SCRA 876]
48. Beneco Inc. v. NEA, Gr. No. 93924, Jan. 23, 1991 [193
SCRA 250]
49. Joymart Corp. v. CA, Gr. No. 88705, June 11, 1992
50. Sevilla v. Laggui, AM. No. RTJ-01-1612, Aug. 14, 2001
51. Savage v. Taypin, Gr. No. 134217, May 11, 2000
RULE 8. MANNER OF MAKING ALLEGATIONS IN PLEADINGS
52. Tantuico Jr. v. Republic, Gr. No. 89114, Dec. 2, 1991
53. Imperial Textile Mills, Inc. v. CA, Gr. No. 86568, March 22,
1990
54. Phi. Amercican Gen. Insurance Co., Inc., et. al. v. Sweet
Lines, Inc., et. al., Gr. No. 87434, Aug. 5, 1992
55. Morales v. CA, et. al., Gr. No. 91003, May 23, 1991
RULE 9. EFFECT OF FAILURE TO PLEAD
56. Rudolf Lietz Holdings, Inc. v. The Registry of Deeds of
Paranaque City,
Gr. No. 133240, Nov. 15, 2000
57. Talsan Enterprises, Inc. v. Baliwag Transit, Inc., Gr. No.
126258, July 8, 1999
58. Rep. of the Phil. v. Sandiganbayan, et. al., Gr. No.
148154, Dec. 17, 2000
59. Rural Bank of Sta. Catalina, Inc., etc. v. Land Bank of the
Phils., Gr. No. 148019
RULE 10. AMENDED AND SUPPLEMENTAL PLEADINGS
60. Valenzuela v. CA, Gr. No. 131175, Feb. 15, 1999
61. Siasoco, et. al. v. CA, et. al., Gr. No. 132753, Feb. 15,
1999
62. Solid Homes, Inc. v. Payawal, Gr. No. 848111, Aug. 29,
1989 [177 SCRA 72]
63. Delbros Hotel Corp. v. IAC, et. al., Gr. No. L-72566, April
12, 1988
RULE 12. BILL OF PARTICULARS
64. Republic v. Sandiganbayan, Gr. No. 90478, Nov. 21, 1991

127
129
131
133
135

137139
141143
145147
149151
153155
157
159161
163165
167
169171
173175
177179
181183
185187
189191
193195
197199
201203
205207
209211
213
215217
219221

RULE 13. FILING AND SERVICE OF PLEADINGS,

JUDGEMENTS, AND OTHER PAPERS
65. Uy v. Medina, AM No. MTJ-00-1247, Oct. 10, 2000
66. Viewmaster Construction Corp. v. Maulit, Gr. No. 136283,
Feb. 29, 2000
67. Atlantic Erectors, Inc. v. Herbal Cove Realty Corp., Gr. No.
148568, March 20, 2003
RULE 14. SUMMONS
68. Francisco Motors v. CA, Gr. No. 100812, June 25, 1999
69. Hamilton v. Rey, et. al., Gr. No. 139283, Nov. 15, 2000
70. Patrick Jose et. al. v. Helen Boyon et. al., Gr. No. 147369,
Oct. 23, 2003
71. Oaminal v. Castillo et. al, Gr. No. 152776, Oct. 8, 2003
72. Asiavest Ltd. v. CA et. al., Gr. No. 128803, Sept. 25, 1998
RULE 16. MOTION TO DISMISS
73. Victronics Computers, Inc. v. RTC, Branch 63, Makati, 217
SCRA 517
74. Agilent Technologies Singapore (PTE) Ltd. v. Integrated
Silicon Technology Phil. Corp. et. al., Gr. No. 154618,
April 14, 2004
75. Intramuros Administration v. Contacto et. al., Gr. No.
15256, May 5, 2003
76. Silangan Textile Manufacturing Corp., et. al. v. Demetria,
et. al., Gr. No. 166719, March 12, 2007
77. Ramos v. Peralta, Gr. No. 45107, No. 11, 1991
78. Roa-Magsaysay v. Magsaysay, Gr. No. L-49847, July 17,
1980
79. Teodoro Jr. v. Mirasol, 99 Phil. 150
80. Gardose v. Tarroza, Gr. No. 13057, May 19, 1998
81. De Asis v. CA, 303 SCRA 176
82. Mallion v. Alcantara, Gr. No. 141528, Oct. 31, 2006
RULE 18. PRE-TRIAL
83. Interling Corp. et. al. v. Philippine Trust Co., Gr. No.
44190, March 6, 2002
84. Paredes et. al. v. Verano et. al., Gr. No. 164375, Oct. 12,
2006
85. Saguid v. CA et. al., Gr. No. 150611, June 10, 2003
86. Ruiz, Jr. v. CA, Gr. No. 101566, Aug. 17, 1992 [212 SCRA
660]
87. Young v. CA, Gr. No. 81239, Dec. 4, 1991
RULE 19. INTERVENTION
88. Dolfo v. Register of Deeds of the Province of Cavite et.
al., Gr. No. 133465, Sept. 25, 2000
89. Gonzales v. PAGCOR et. al., Gr. No. 144591, May 27,
2004
RULE 21. SUBPOENA
90. People v. Montejo, Gr. No. L-24154, Oct. 31, 1991
RULES 23,24,25,26,27,28 AND 29. MODES OF RECOVERY
91. Republic v. Sandiganbayan, Gr. No. 90478, Nov. 21, 1991
92. Producers Bank of the Phil. CA, et. al., Gr. No. 110495,

223225
227229
231233
235237
239241
243245
247249
251253
255257
259261
263265
267
269271
273275
277279
281283
285287
289291
293295
297299
301303
305307
309311
313
315

317
319
321

Jan. 29, 1998

93. Jonathan Landoil International Co. Inc. v. Magundadatu,
Gr. No. 155010, Aug. 16, 2004
94. Republic of the Phil. v. Sandiganbayan, et. al., Gr. No.
112710, May 30, 2001
95. Dasmarinas Garments Inc. v. Reyes, et. al., Gr. No.
108229, Aug 24, 1993
96. Lanada v. CA et. al., Gr. No. 102390, Feb 1, 2002
RULE 31. CONSOLIDATION OF SEVERANCE
97. Cojuangco et. al. v. CA et. al., Gr. No. L-37404, No. 18,
1991
RULE 33. DEMURRER TO EVIDENCE
98. Casent Realty Dev. Corp. v. Philbanking Corp., Gr. No.
150731, Sept. 14, 2007
99. Radiowealth Fianance Co. v. Del Rosario, Gr. No. 138739,
July 6, 2000
100.
Hun Hyung Park v. Eung Won Choi, Gr. No.
165496, Feb 12, 2007
RULE 34. JUDGEMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
101.
Kho v. Camacho, Gr. No. 82789, Nov. 21, 1991
102.

Aurelio v. Baquiran, Gr. No. L-9316, Oct. 31, 1956

103.
Verga v. Suelto, et. al., Gr. No. 74766, Dec. 21,
1987
104.
Hontiveros v. RTC, Gr. No. 125465, June 9, 1999
RULE 35. SUMMARY JUDGEMENTS
105.
Excelsa Industries Inc. v. CA et. al., Gr. No.
105455, Aug. 23, 1995
106.
Estrada v. Hon. Consolacion et. al., 71 SCRA 523
107.
Paz Mercado et. al. v. CA, Gr. No. L-44001, June
10, 1988
108.
Pineda v. Heirs of Eliseao Guevara, etc., Gr. No.
143188, Feb. 14, 2007
109.
Province of Pangasinan v. CA, Gr. No. 104266,
March 31, 1993
RULE 36. JUFGEMENTS, FINAL ORDERS AND ENTRY
THEREOF
110.
Estoya et. al. v. Singson, Adm. Matter No RTJ-91758, Sept. 28, 1994
111.
Oil and Natural Gas Commission v. CA, Gr. No.
114323, July 23, 1998
112.
Velarde v. Social Justice Society, Gr. No. 159357,
April 28, 2004
113.
Dizon v. Judge Lopez, Adm. Matter No. RTJ-961338, Sept. 5, 1997
114.
Baguio v. Bandal, Gr. No. 126442, Dec. 29, 1998
RULE 37. NEW TRIAL AND RECONSIDERATION
115.
Commissioner on Internal Revenue v. A. Soriano
Corp. et. al., Gr. No. 113703, Jan. 31, 1997
116.
Dizon v. CA, Gr. No. 96296, June 18, 1992
117.
Dapin et. al. v. Dionaldo, et. al., Gr. No. 55488,
May 15, 1992
118.
Manila Electric Co. v. La Campana Food Products
Inc., Gr. No. 97535, Aug. 4, 1995
119.
Cledera v. Samiento, 39 SCRA 552
RULE 38. RELIEF, JUDGEMENTS, ORDERS OR OTHER
PROCEEDINGS
120.
Domingo Realty Inc. et. al. v. CA et. al., Gr. No.

323
325
327329
331333
335

339341
343345
347349
351353
355357
359361
363
365
367369
371
378
375377

379
381383
389391
393395
397
399401
403405
407
409411
413

415-

126236, Jan. 26, 2007

121.
Mesina v. Meer, Gr. No. 146854, July 2, 2002
RULE 39. EXECUTION, SATISFACTION, AND EFFECT OF
JUDGEMENTS
122.
De Ocampo v. Republic, Gr. No. L-19533, Oct. 31,
1963 [9 SCRA 44457-4590]
123.
Investments Inc. v. CA, Gr. No. 60036, Jan. 27,
1987
124.
Lu v. Siapno et. al., AM No. MTJ-99-1199, July 6,
2000
125.
Lumapas v. Tamin, AM No. RTJ-99-1519, June 27,
2000
126.
Camacho v. CA et. al., Gr. No. 118339, March 19,
1998
127.
Baclayon v. CA, Gr. No. 89132, Feb. 26, 1990
128.
Macias et. al. v. Lim et. al., Gr. No. L-139284,
June 4, 2004
129.
Rodil et. al. v. Benedicto et. al., Gr. No. L-28616,
Jan 22, 1980
130.
Caina v. CA et. al., Gr. No. 114393, Dec 15, 1994
131.
Fortune Guarantee and Insurance Corp. v. CA et.
al., Gr. No 110701, May 12, 2002
132.
Marcopper Mining Corp. v. Solidbank Corp. et.
al., Gr. No. 134049, June 17, 2004
133.
Bell Carpets International Trading Corp. v. CA,
185 SCRA 35
134.
Shuhei Yasuda v. CA et. al., Gr. No. 112569, April
12, 2000
135.
Borja v. Encarnacion, Gr. No. L- 1479, May 30,
1951
136.
Viray v. CA, Gr. No. 120760, Feb. 24, 1998
137.
Naguit v. CA, et. al. , Gr. No. 137675, Dec. 5,
2000
RULE 40 TO RULE 56. APPEALS
138.
Ortiz v. CA, Gr. No. 127393, Dec. 4, 1998
139.
Manila Memorial Park Cemetery Inc. v. CA et. al.,
Gr.No.137122, Nov.15, 2000
140.
GSIS v. Philippine Village Hotel Inc., Gr. No.
150922, Sept. 21, 2004
141.
De Leon v. CA et. al., Gr. No. 138884, June 6,
2002
142.
GSIS v. Olisa, Gr. No. 126874, March 10, 1999
143.
De Dios v. Balagot, Gr. No. L-24103, Aug. 10,
1967
144.
Pahang v. Vestil, et. al., Gr. No. 148595, July 12,
2004
145.
Cortez v. Judge Felino Bangalan, AM No. MTJ-97,
Jan 19, 2000
146.
Phil. Commercial and Industrial Bank v. Ortiz, Gr.
No. L-49223, May 29, 1987
147.
Fukuzumi v. Sanritsu Great International Corp. et.
al., Gr. No. 140630, Aug. 12, 2004
RULE 57. PRELIMINARY ATTACHMENT
148.
Virata v. Aquino, Gr. No. L-35027, Sept. 20, 1973
149.
Cebu International Finance Corp. v. CA et. al., Gr.
No. 123031, Oct, 12, 1999
150.
Caja v. Nanquil, AM No. P-04-1885, Sept. 13,
2004
151.
Perla Compania de Seguros Inc. v. Ramolete et.

417
419

421423
425
427
429
431
433
437
439441
443445
447449
453455
457459
461463
465
467469
471473
475477
479
481
483
485
487
489
491
493
495

497
499
501
503

al., Gr. No. 60887, Nov. 13, 1991

152.
Solidbank v. CA, 197 SCRA 663

503505

RULE 58. PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

153.
Lopez v. CA 322 SCRA 686

511

TABLE OF
CONTENTS
Book II: Part I
RULE 58. PRILIMINARY INJUNCTION (Continuation)
154.
Ilaw at Buklod ng Manggagawa v. NLRC, 198
SCRA 586
155.
Marcos-Manotoc v. Judge Agcoili, AM No. RTJ-981405, April 22, 2000
156.
Bank of the Phil. Islands v. CA et. al., Gr. No.
142731, June 8, 2006
157.
Santiago v. Ombudsman, Gr. Nos. 99289-90, Jan.
27, 1993
RULE 59. RECEIVERSHIP
158.
Salientes v. IAC, Gr. No. 110929, Jan. 20, 2000
159.
Arranza v. BF Homes Inc., Gr. No. 131683, June
19, 2000
RULE 60. REPLEVIN
160.
BA Finance v. CA, Gr. No. 102998, July 5, 1996
161.
Chua v. CA, Gr. No. 79021, May 17, 1993
162.
Sergs Products Inc. v. PCI Leasing and Financing
Inc., Gr. No. 137705, Aug. 22, 2000
163.
Pardo v. Velasco, Adm. Matter, P-9408, Aug. 7,
1992
164.
Citi Bank v. CA, Gr. No. 61508, March 17, 1999
RULE 61. SUPPORT PENDENTE LITE
165.
San Juan v. Valenzuela et. al., Gr. No. L-59906,
Oct. 23, 1982
RULE 62. INTERPLEADER
166.
Mesina v. IAC, et. al., Gr. No. 70145, Nov. 13,
1986
RULE 63. DECLARATORY RELIEF AND SIMILAR REMEDIES
167.
Velarde v. Social Justice Society, Gr. No. 159357,
April 28, 2004
168.
Atlas Consolidated Mining and Dev. Corp. v. CA
et. al., Gr. No. L-54305, Feb. 14, 1990
169.
Bayan Telecomunications, Inc. v. Republic of Phil.
et. al., Gr. No. 161140, Jan 31, 2007
170.
The Visayan Packing Corp. v. The Reparation
Commission et. al., Gr. No. L-29673, Nov. 12, 1987
171.
Bentir et. al v. Leanda, Gr. No. 128991, April 12,
2000
RULE 64. REVIEW OF JUDGEMENTS & FINAL ORDERS OF
THE COE AND THE COA
172.
Ambil Jr. v. COMELEC, etc., et. al., Gr. No.
143398, Oct. 25, 2000
RULE 65. CERTORARI, PROHIBITIONA AND MANDAMUS
173.
Rodson Phil. Inc. et. al. v. CA et. al., Gr. No.
141857, June 9, 2004
174.
Air Philippines Corp. v. Zamora, Gr. No. 148247,
Aug. 6, 2006
175.
Arturo Condes et. al. v. CA et. al., Gr. No.
161304, July 27, 2007

Page
No.
5-7
9-11
13
15

17
19

21
23-25
27
29
31
33

35

37-39
41
43
45
47

49

51-53
55
57

176.
People v. Nano, 205 SCRA 155
177.
Dela Rosa v. CA et. al., Gr. No. 116945, Feb. 9,
1996
RULE 66. QUO WARRANTO
178.
Palma-Fernandez v. De La Paz et. al., Gr. No. L78946, April 15, 1988
179.
Palma et. al. v. Mandocdoc et. al., Gr. No. L17393, Nov. 28, 1962
180.
Luison v. Garcia, Gr. No. L-10981, April 25, 1958
181.
Nuval v. Guray, et. al., Gr. No. 30241, Dec. 29,
1928
182.
Mendoza v. Allas, Gr. No. 131977, Feb. 4, 1999
RULE 67. EXPROPRIATION
183.
Biglang-awa v. Bacalla, et. al., Gr. No. 13992736, Nov. 22, 2000
184.
Manila Electric Co. v. Hon. Gregorio, Gr. No. L59791, Feb. 13, 1992
185.
Manila Electric Co. v. Hon. Pineda, Gr. No. 59791,
Feb 13, 1992
186.
Heris of Alberto Suguitan v. City of Mandaluyong,
Gr. No. 135087, March 14, 2000
RULE 68. FORCLOSURE OF REAL ESTATE MORTGAGE
187.
Caltex Phil. Inc. v. IAC et. al., Gr. No. 74730, Aug.
25, 1989
188.
Movido v RFC, L-11990, May 29, 1959
189.
Maglague v. Planters Dev. Bank, Gr. No.
1094272, May 18, 1999
190.
Cruz et. al. v. IAC et. al., Gr. No. 7286, Jan. 9,
1989
191.
Rural Bank of Oroquieta [Miss.Occ]Inc. v. CA et.
al., Gr. No. 53466, Nov. 10, 1980
192.
Rosales v. CA et. al., Gr. No. 137566,Feb. 28,
2001
193.
Huerta Alba Resort Inc. v. CA et. al., Gr. No.
128567, Sept. 1, 2000
194.
Mirasol et. al v. IAC, et. al., Gr. No. L-67588, June
20, 1988
195.
De Mesa v. CA, Gr. No. 109387, April 25, 1994
RULE 69. PARTITION
196.
Gabila v. Perez et. al., Gr. No. L-29542, Jan. 27,
1989
197.
Bicarme v. CA, et. al., Gr. No. L-51914, June 6,
1990
198.
De Mesa v. CA, Gr. No. 109387, April 25, 1994
RULE 70. FORCIBLE ENTRY AND UNLAWFUL DETAINER
AND THE 1991 REVISED RULE ON SUMMARY PROCEDURE
199.
Lucas v. Fabros, AM No. MTJ-99-1226, Jan. 31,
2000
200.
Lesaca v. CA, Gr. No. 96432, Oct. 21, 1992
201.
Dy v. CA, 195 SCRA 585
202.
Francisco Realty & Dev. Corp. v. CA et. al., Gr.
No. 125055, Oct. 30, 1998
203.
Ganadin v. Ramos et. al, Gr. No. L-23547, Sept.
11, 1980
204.
Munoz et. al v. CA et. al., Gr. No. 102693, Sept.
23, 1992
205.
Caniza etc. v. CA et. al., Gr. No. 110427, Feb. 27,
1997
206.
Salud Lopez et. al. v. David Jr. et. al., Gr. No.
152145, March 30, 2004
207.
Javelosa v. CA, et. al., Gr. No. 124292, Dec. 10,
1996
208.
Benitez v. CA, Gr. No. 104828, Jan. 16, 1997

59
61

63
65
67
69
71
73
75
77
79

81-83
85
87
89
91
93
95
97
99
101
103
105

107
109
111
113
115
117
123125
127129
131
133

RULE 71. CONTEMPT

209.
Montenegro v. Montenegro, Gr. No. 156829, June
8, 2004
210.
Chan v. CA, Gr. No. 138758, July 6, 2000
211.
Morta Sr. et. al. v. Sanez et. al., AM. No. RTJ-001593, Oct. 16, 2000
212.
Espinosa v. CA, et. al., Gr. No. 128686, May 28,
2004
THE REVISED KATARUNGANG PAMBARANGAY LAW
213.
De Borromeo v. Pogoy et. al., Gr. No. L-63277,
Nov. 29, 1983
214.
Peregrina v. Panis, et.al., Gr. No. 56011, Oct. 31,
1984
215.
Chavez v. CA et. al., Gr. No. 159411, March 18,
2005

135
137
139
141143
145
147
149

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Book III: Part II

216.
Partido ng Manggagawa v. Comelec, Gr. No.
164702, March 15, 2006
217.
Racaza v. Gozum, Gr. 490 SCRA 313
218.
Reyes v. Solemar, Gr. No. 129247, March 3, 2006
219.
MERALCO v. ERB, 485 SCRA 19
220.
Evangelista v. Santiago, 457 SCRA 744
221.
Domingo v. Carague, 456 SCRA 450
222.
Uy v. CA, 494 SCRA 535
223.
Alfelor v. Halasan, March 31, 2006
224.
Perez v. CA, January 27, 2006
225.
Hinog v. Melicor, 455 SCRA 460
226.
Dela Cruz v. Joaquin, July 28, 2005
227.
Limbanan v. Acosta, June 30, 2008
228.
Ao-as v. CA, 491 SCRA 353
229.
PAL v. FASAP, January 24, 2006
230.
International Construction v. FEB Leasing,
April22, 2005
231.
SPS. Arquiza v. CA, Gr. No. 160479, June 8, 2005
232.
ASAPHIL Construction v. Tuason, 58 SCRA 583
233.
Saludo Jr. v. American Express International, Inc.,
Gr. No. 159507, April 19, 2006
234.
Solmayor v. Arroyo, 486 SCRA 326
235.
Citibank N.A. v. Sabeniano, 504 SCRA 378
236.
Yu v. PCIB, March 17, 2006
237.
Carpio v. Rural Bank, May 4, 2006
238.
Korea Exchange v. Hon. Gonzales, April 15, 2005
239.
Republic v. Sandiganbayan, June 26, 2006
240.
Robinson v. Miralles, December 12, 2006
241.
Miranda v. Tuliao, March 31, 2006
242.
Cezar v. Ricafort, October 31, 2006
243.
O.B. Jovenir v. Macamir Realty, March 28, 2006
244.
245.
Cruz v. CA, February 13, 2006
246.
CA v. Alvarez, Gr. No. 142439, December 3, 2006
247.
Pinga v. Santiago, June 30, 2000
248.
Perkin Elmer v. Dakila Trading, August 14, 2007
249.
Gatudo v. Traders Royal Bank, March 21, 2006
250.
Martinez v. Republic, October 30, 2006
251.
Ong v. Mazo, 431 SCRA 56
252.
Republic v. Sandiganbayan, 204 SCRA 212,200
253.
Marcelo v. Sandiganbayan, Gr. No. 156605,

Page
No.
3
5-7
9-11
13
15
17
19
21
23
25
27
29
31-33
35
37
39
41
43-45
47-49
51-53
55
57
59
61
63-65
67
69
71
72
73
75-77
79
81
83
85-87
89
91
93-95

August 28, 2007

254.
Landa v. CA, 375 SCRA 543 / Gr. No. 102590,
February 1, 2002
255.
Ayala Land v. Tagle, Gr. No. 153667, August 11,
2005
256.
Hyatt Industrial v. Ley Construction, March 10,
2006
257.
Cariaga v. CA, June 6, 2001
258.
Veron v. CA,157 SCRA438
259.
Dulay v. Dulay, November 11, 2005
260.
Hanil Dev. V. CA, Gr. No. 113176, July 30, 2001
261.
American Airlines v. CA, March 9, 2000
262.
Sales v. Sabino, December 9, 2005
263.
Bembo v. CA, 250 SCRA 404
264.
Cathay Pacific v. Spouses Fuentebella, December
15, 2005
265.
Heirs of Pedro Pasas v. Spouses Parocha, April
27, 2007
266.
Locsin v. Sandiganbayan, August 9, 2007
267.
Gerochi v. Department of Energy, April 5, 2005
268.
Briboneria v. CA, 216 SCRA 67
269.
270.
271.
272.
273.
2008
274.
2000
275.
17217,
276.

Duque v. CA, July 2, 2002

PO v. CA, 164 SCRA 668
DBP v. CA, Gr. No. 153034, September 20, 2005
Bay View v. Ker and Co, 116 SCRA 327
Solidbank (Metrobank) v. Gate Way, April 30,
Security Bank v. CA, Gr. No. 135874, January 25,
Spouses Zepeda v. China Banking, Gr. No.
October 9, 2006
Lanada v. CA, Gr. No. 102390, February 1, 2002

277.
Nestle Philippines v. CA, Gr. No. 102404,
February 1, 2002
278.
Teresita Monzon v. Spouses James and Maria, Gr.
No. 171827, September 17, 2008
279.
Frisco F. San Juan v. The Sandiganbayan, Gr. No.
173956, August 6, 2008
280.
RN Development v. A.I.I. System, Gr. No. 166104,
June 26, 2008
281.
J.R. Daan v. The Hon. Sandiganbayan, Gr. Nos.
163972-77, March 28, 2008
282.
Estanislao v. Alviola v. Judge Henry, February 29,
2008
283.
LCK Industries v. Planters, 538 SCRA 634
284.
Mercury Drug v. Rep. Surety and Insurance Co.,
538 SCRA 464
285.
Republic v. Ildefonso Oleta, 530 SCRA 534
286.
Dr. Emmanuel Vera v. Ernesto F. Rigor, 529 SCRA
729
287.
Vivian Y. Locsin v. The Hon. Sandiganbayan, 529
SCRA 572
288.
Heirs of Vicente Reyes v. The Hon. CA, 519 SCRA
250
289.
People v. Nicolas Guzman, 513 SCRA 156
290.
371
291.

Malayan Insurance v. Ipil International, 500 SCRA

Crisostomo Alcaraz v. CA, 497 SCRA 75

97-99
101
103
105
107
109
111113
115
117
119
121
123
125
127
129133
135
137
139
141
143
145147
149151
153155
157
159161
163
165
167
169171
173
175
177179
181183
185187
189
191193
195197
199-

292.
Advance Textile v. Willy C. Tan, 464 SCRA 431
293.
Elenterio Olave v. Teodulo Mistas, 444 SCRA 625
294.
Jonathan Landoil, v. Spouses Suharto
Mangundadatu, 436 SCRA 559
295.
United Coconut v. Miguel Magpayo, 429 SCRA
669
296.
Procopio Villanueva v. CA, 427 SCRA 439
297.
Sixto M. Bayas v. The Sandiganbayan, 391 SCRA
415
298.
Spouses Mondedo v. CA, Gr. No. 113349, January
18, 1996
299.
Silvestre Tiu v. Daniel Middleton, Gr. No. 134998,
July 19, 1999
300.
Air Philippines v. International Bus. Aviation, Gr.
NO. 151963, September 9, 2004
301.
In Re: Republic v. Tuvera, Gr. No. 148246,
February 2007
302.
In Re: Manila Banking Corp. v. University of
Baguio, Gr. No. 159189, February 21, 2007
303.
Swagman Hotels v. CA, Gr. No. 161135, April 8,
2008
304.
Meneses v. Secretary of Agrarian Reform,
October 23, 2006
305.
Ontimare v. Elep, Gr. No. 159224, January 20,
2006
306.
Asian Construction v. PCIB, April 25, 2006

201
203
205
207209
211213
215
217
219
221
223
225227
229231
233235
237

307.
2007
308.
309.
2004
310.
2006
311.

Pineda v. Guevara, Gr. No. 143188, February 14,

239243
245247
249

Fabian v. Desierto, September 16, 1998

Perez v. Ombudsman, Gr. No. 131445, May 27,

251
253

Grande v. UP, Gr. No. 148456, September 15,

255

People v. Bitanga

312.
2004
313.

Santander Consn v. Villanueva, November 30,

257259
261

Pilipinas Shell v. Gobonseng, July 21, 2006

314.
Tagabi v. Tangue, July 27, 2006
315.
Villanueva v. CA, July 20, 2006
316.
Jaramillo v. CA, Gr. No. 122317, July 14, 2005
317.
Madriaga v. CA, Gr. NO. 142001
318.
Santander Construction v. Villanueva, November
20, 2004
319.
Remulla v. Manlongat, November 11, 2004
320.
KLR Fruits v. WSR Fruits, November 23, 2007
321.
Cucueco v. CA, October 25, 2004
322.
Neypes v. CA, September 14, 2005
323.
Santos v. People, August 26, 2008
324.
Fil-Astate Properties v. Hon. Homena-Valencia,
October 15, 2007
325.
Jabaluyas v. Japson, 142 SCRA 2008
326.
Tolentino v. Natanauan, November 20, 2003
327.
Republic v. Luriz
328.
Asian Construction v. Tulabot
329.
In Provost v. CA and Encarnacion v. Amigo
330.
Provosi v CA, June 26, 2006
331.
Ross Rica v. Ong, August 16, 2005
332.
Escueta v. Lim, Gr. No. 137162, Jan 24, 2007
333.
Encarnacion v. Amigo, Gr. No. 169793, Sept. 15,

263265
267
269
271
273
275
277
279
281
283
285
287
289
291
293
295
297
299
301
303
305-

2006
334.
335.
336.
337.
338.
339.
340.
341.
342.
343.
344.
2011
345.
346.

Serrano v. Gutierrez, November 10, 2006

Balajonda v. COMELEC
DBP v. Spouses Gatal
Dagooc v. Erlina
Springfield Dev. Corp. v. Presiding RTC Judge
Holy Spirit Homeowners Assoc. v. Defensor
Henares Jr. v. LTFRB
Republic v. De castro
Veran v. CA, 157 SCRA 438
Go v. Sunnanun, 642 SCRA 367
Yu v. Samson-Tadtad, Gr. No. 170979, Feb 9,
Calleja v. Panday
Republic v. Guingoyon

307
309
311
313
315
317
319
321
320
318
322
324
323
325327
329
331
333
335
337
339341
343
345
347
349
351
353
355357
359
336
338
340
342
344
346
348
350
352
361
363
365

347.
348.
349.
350.
351.
352.

Masikip v. City of Pasig

PNB v. Sanao
Selegna Management v. UCPB
Sps. Arquiza v. CA, Gr. No. 160479, June 2, 2005
Dumo v. Espinas, January 25, 2006
Roberts v. Papio, February 9, 2007

353.
354.
355.
356.
357.
358.
359.

Atuel v. Valdez, July 10, 2003

Aliabo v. Carampatan, March 16, 2001
Hilario v. Salvador, April 29, 2005
Barangay Piapi v. Talip, 469 SCRA 409
Laresman v. Abellana, 442 SCRA 156
Valdez v. CA, May 4, 2006
Santos v. Sps. Ayon, May 6, 2005

360.
361.
362.
363.
364.
365.
366.
367.
368.
369.
370.
371.
372.
645
373.
374.
375.

Racaza v. Gozum, June 8 2006

Pena v. Tolentino, 642 SCRA 310
Calanunan v. Madolaria, 642 SCRA 01
Reyna v. COA, 642 SCRA 210
Bayan Muna v. Romulo, 641 SCRA 244
Mendoza v. United, 641 SCRA 333
Del Monte v. Sangunay, 641 SCRA 87
MIAA v. Avila, 641 SCRA 138
Catindig v. Vda De Meneses, 641 SCRA 350
Fernando v. Fernando, 641 SCRA 202
Benedicto v. CA, October 19, 2005
Lores Realty v. Pacia, 121 SCRA 645
Filipinas Synthetic v. De Los Santos, 463 SCRA

376.
377.
378.
379.
380.
381.
382.

Alagar v. PNB, 559 SCRA 645

Home Guaranty v. R-II Builders, 219 SCRA 645
Davao Furits v. LBP, 167 SCRA 645
PNB v. Valenzuela, 66 SCRA 645
People v. Salak, 269 SCRA 645
Bacolot v. Pano, 17 SCRA 645
Rodriguez v. Blancaflor, 286 SCRA 645

383.
384.
645
385.
386.
387.
388.

Asia United v. Goodland, 205 SCRA 645

Buklod ng Magbubukid v. E.M. Ramos, 401 SCRA

367
369
371373
375
377
379
381
383
385
387391
393
395

Givero v. Givero, 479 SCRA 645

Dionisio v. Linsangan, 424 SCRA 644
LBP v. Pagayatan, 133 SCRA 644
Andrada v. Pilhino Sales, 01 SCRA 644

397
399
401
403

MetroBank v. Custodio, 697 SCRA 645

Chant Kent v. Micarez, 176 SCRA 645
Heirsof Santiago v. Aguila, 130 SCRA 645

389.
390.
391.
392.

Heirs of Simon v. Chan, 13 SCRA 644

FGU Insurance v. RTC Makati, 50 SCRA 644
Tan v. Antiazo, 644 SCRA 337
Mendoza v. Villas, 347 SCRA 644

393.

Central Luzon Drug v. CIR, 436 SCRA 644

394.

Parel v. Prudencio, 496 SCRA 644

395.

Verzosa Jr. v. Carague, 679 SCRA 644

396.

Pimentel v. Senate, 741 SCRA 644

397.
398.
399.
400.
401.

Gonzales v. COMELEC, 761 SCRA 644

Gutierrez v. House of Rep., 804 SCRA 644
Milestone v. Office of the Pres., 217 SCRA 644
Lu v. Lu Ym Sr., 23 SCRA 643
Ando v. Campo, 513 SCRA 643

402.
403.

Gutierrez v. House of Rep., 198 SCRA 643

Facura v. CA, 427 SCRA 643

404.

Univ. of Mindanao v. CA, 562 SCRA 643

405.

Galang Jr. v. Geronimo, 631 SCRA 643

406.
Alcaraz v. Gonzales, 417 SCRA 643
407.
MMDA v. Concerned Res., 90 SCRA 643
408.
LCP v. COMELEC, 149 SCRA 643
409.
Tan v. Usman, 13 SCRA 643
410.
Plastimer v. Gopo, 502 SCRA 543
411.
Philippine Bank v. Go, 693 SCRA 642
412.
United Overseas Bank v. Rosemoore Mining,
March 12, 2007
413.
Anson Trade Center v. Pacific Banking, Gr. No.
179999, March 17, 2009
414.
AFP Mutual v. RTC Manila, 642 SCRA 720
415.
VDA. De Quano v. Republic, 642 SCRA 384
416.
Mactan-Cebu v. Heirs of Minoza, 641 SCRA 520
417.
So v. Food Fest, 642 SCRA 592
418.
South Pacific v. CA, 642 SCRA 557
419.
Beatingo v. Gasis, 642 SCRA 539
420.
Lee v. Bankok Bank, 642 SCRA 447
421.
Atienza v. Board of ABC, 642 SCRA 523
422.
Vda de Quano v. Republic, 642 SCRA 384
423.
AFP Mutual v. RTC Manila, 642 SCRA 720

405
407
409
411413
415417
419421
423425
427429
431
433
435
437
439441
443
445447
449451
453455
457
459
461
463
465
467
469
471
473
475
479
481
483
485
487
489
491
493

Civil Procedure

Case Digest
Book I-III; Part I & II

Submitted to:
JUDGE RUFUS G. MALECDAN JR.

Submitted by:
WINDY SACKI CAPUYAN