QUALITY AWARD
Case Study
ABC SERVICES LTD
2015
Table of Contents
Criteria
No
Criteria Topic
Page
No.
P.1
P.2
i to v
i
iii
vi
1
1.1
1.2
Leadership
Senior Leadership
Governance and Societal Responsibilities
1 to 7
1
4
2
2.1
2.2
Strategic Planning
Strategy Development
Strategy Implementation
8 to 10
8
9
3
3.1
3.2
Customer Focus
Voice of the Customer
Customer Engagement
11 to 15
11
13
4
4.1
4.2
16 to 21
16
19
5
5.1
5.2
Workforce Focus
Workforce Environment
Workforce Engagement
22 to 27
22
24
6
6.1
6.2
Operations Focus
Work Systems
Work Processes
28 to 32
28
30
7
7.1
7.2
7.3
7.4
7.5
Results
Product and Process Outcomes
Customer-Focused Outcomes
Workforce-Focused Outcomes
Leadership and Governance Outcomes
Financial and Market Outcomes
33 to 44
33
36
38
41
43
Applicant
Official Name_ABC SERVICES LTD_____________________________________________________________________________
Other Name______________________________________________________________________________________________
Headquarters Address
XXXXXXXXXXX_____________________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
2.
Highest-Ranking Official
Mr._______
Mrs. _______
Ms. _______
Dr. _______
Mrs. _______
Ms. _______
Dr. _______
Name_S Quest_________________________________________Title________________________________________________
Address__________________________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Telephone____________________________________________ Fax________________________________________________
Mobile_______________________________________________E-mail______________________________________________
4.
5.
_______Education (For-Profit)
b.
Total number of
Employees (business)
__800+_____
Faculty/staff (education)
_______
_______
Check amount:
1.
Applicant
Official Name__ABC SERVICES LTD__________________________________________________________________________
Other Name______________________________________________________________________________________________
Headquarters Address xxxxxxxxxxx
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
2.
Highest-Ranking Official
Mr._______
Mrs. _______
Ms. _______
Dr. _______
Name_____Mr. S. Narayanan_____________________________Title_____CEO_______________________________________
Address__As above____________________________________________________________________
Telephone____________________________________________ Fax________________________________________________
Mobile_______________________________________________E-mail______________________________________________
3.
Mrs. _______
Ms. _______
Dr. _______
4.
5.
_______Education (For-Profit)
Values
P.1a(1) ABC delivers custom development,
application maintenance services and BPO services
using telecommunication networks with IT as their
main backbone. From a small team of 25 members
servicing their parent organization, the company today
has over 800+ employees and provides a
comprehensive suite of services to its customers.
Primary operations are from the two locations Mumbai
and Chennai.
An integrated delivery model
comprising of on site, on-shore and off-shore
mechanism is deployed to deliver the companys
products / services. Table P1.1-1 highlights the
services and the delivery mechanisms.
Table P.1-1: Services & Delivery Mechanism
Table P.1-1
Service Offering
Delivery Mechanism
Custom Development:
Mostly off-shore
Deployment and support
and on site during
applications ranging from
deployment & pilot
global applications to small
run
department based apps.
Application Maintenance
Services: To provide worldclass maintenance and support
to IT applications deployed at
customer locations
off-shore with on
shore
manager/support
personnel if
customer requires it
off-shore with on
shore
manager/support
personnel if
customer requires it
Page i
35%
Graduates
Post Graduates
Engineers
MBA
33%
MCA
15%
Page ii
Partners
Table P.1-3
Security Services
Housekeeping Services
Canteen Services
Technology service providers
Staffing companies
Business Associates
Page iii
Internal BE team
Third Party
Third Party
Staffing companies
Business associates
Technology Partner
Annual
Conducted once
Conducted once
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Strategic Advantages
Robust governance processes, including daily
dashboards, monthly performance reviews by
senior leadership, quarterly Board reviews
Ability to work across cross-vertical platforms
such as retail, manufacturing, media, banking,
insurance, etc.
Agile processes and transparency of operations
Technology adoption: Keeping pace with
technology and agility in maintaining and
updating changes;
Constantly innovating and finding a better way
to do things
Trust relationships with existing customers
Page iv
Page v
BOD
Chairman
CEO
CFO
Chief
Accou
ntant
MIS
Team
CMO
Co Sec
&
Legal
Sales
Head
Marketing
Head
BU1
Head
Produc
t Team
Head
BU2
Head
CRMs
BU3
Head
HR
Head
Recruitment
L&D
Page vi
IT
Head
Suppor
t
Administra
tion
Page 1
CEO / CMO /
Business Heads /
HR / Head Quality
& BE
Improved customer
relationship and
increased customer
satisfaction
Succession
planning, trained
future leaders
Learning
organization
CEO / Business
Heads / HODs /
HR Head / IT Head
/ Senior Managers
Page 2
Communication
Mechanism
Daily Huddles
CEO Talks
BU Town Hall
Newsletter
Frequency
Daily
Team Leads
HODs
Monthly
CEO
Monthly
BU Head
Monthly
Head
Corporate
Communication
HR Head & team
HR Open House
All
BOD Meeting
Provide
oversight
of
the
organization / review performance
BOD
Once a
quarter for
each team
Quarterly
Chairmans Meet
Annual Day
SLT
All
Annual
Annual
All
As required
Responsibility
/
Company
Secretary
/
Chairman / CEO
Chairman
Head HR, SLT
Head
Corporate
Communication
Page 3
Page 4
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Water
Conservation
1.
Paper
1.
2.
3.
4.
Disposal
1.
Co2 Emissions
1.
FTE
Engagement
Survey
Internal
Audit
Measures /
Indicators
% compliance
Deployment
Management
integrity score
Throughout the
governance
structure,
organization and
in external
interactions
Throughout the
organization
No. of findings
related to ethics
Throughout the
organization
Page 5
Page 6
Program
Knowledge
Program
Education
Evening Adult
Training Centers
Health
Blood Donation
Drives
Health Camps
Special Aids
Empowerment
Computer
Education Program
Table 1.2-4
Benefit area
Funding / Scholarships to staff
and meritorious economically
challenged candidates
recommended by local social
organizations
Creation of infrastructure,
supporting English language
skills
Bi-annual program wherein staff
donate blood and support the
local hospital
Free health checkups organized
in the rural communities around
Mumbai & Chennai
Provide differently-abled
persons with special aids,
specially computers and provide
a means of livelihood
Vocational training to youth and
women, facilitating the courses,
computers supporting software
and computer books
Stakeholders Involved
BOD / Senior
Leaders/Management team of ABC
provides mentoring/guidance
towards academic project work
undertaken by its employees.
BOD, Senior Leaders /
Management Team
Entire organization staff
Page 7
VMV
Industry & Market Trends
VOC
Focus Group
Recommendations
Workforce Feedback
Step 2: Analysis
SWOT
Strategic Challenges &
Strategic Advantages
Blind Spot Identification
Communication
Effectiveness
IT Update
Step 3: Develop
Strategy
Page 8
SWOT
Shift in industry,
technology
Customers,
Markets &
Products
Workforce
Business
Performance
Projected
Performance
100 Crores
7 Crores
6.5
6.5
2%
100%
100%
100%
Page 9
Strategic
targets
Annual
Review &
input to
SPP
Indvidual
business
unit /
function
targets
Monthly
Review &
30-60-90
day plan
KRA / KPI
develop
ment
Resource
allocation
& Risk
assessme
nt
Page 10
Scale
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Table 3.1-2
Rating
Extremely dissatisfied
Very dissatisfied
Dissatisfied
Neutral
Satisfied
Very satisfied
Extremely satisfied
Page 11
SLA
Finalization
During
Execution
Other listening
& support
mechanisms
Listening Method
Sales, CMO, BU
personnel meetings
with potential
customers / Customer
visit to ABC offices
Discussions with
customer sponsor /
project teams
Status calls / visit to
customers offices /
complaint resolution
Frequency
Actionable Information
Visits: as required
Complaint resolution:
acknowledgement
within 24 hours and
closure within
provided deadline
(see service ticket
management system
below)
Customer Satisfaction
Survey
Conducted annually
for the transactional
services or upon
completion of a
project/program
Service ticket
management system
Online status
dashboard
Page 12
Page 13
Page 14
Page 15
Finance
Revenue
Revenue by BU / Geography
EBIDTA, PAT
Audit Compliance
Legal & Regulatory compliance
Customer
Revenue per Customer
No. of projects / processes per
customer
New Customers added /
additional process per customer /
Customers Lost
CSAT
Operations
SLA compliance score
Cost Effectiveness
Efficiency / Productivity
No. of customer complaints /
issues
Improvements/Innovation
Workforce
FTE Engagement / Satisfaction
Recruitment Status / Attrition
Code of Conduct / Ethical
breaches
IT
System Uptime
Help Desk Support TAT
BE Team
External audit compliances
Means of
Analysis
Table 4.1-1
Review
Frequency
Owner /
Process
Comparative
Data Source or
Benchmark
Category 7
Reference
Internal targets as
per SPP
Comparison with
competitors / bestin-class
Fig. 7.5-1
Fig. 7.5-3
FinPlus
M, Q, A
Finance / CFO
FinPlus,
Research
Finance / CFO
Audit Findings
Compliance
Report
Q, A
Q, A
Finance / CFO
Company
Secretary / CFO
M, Q, A
S&M / CMO
Internal targets as
per SPP
Will provide
during the
site visit
Dosti /
Pegasus
A / Once in
3 years
BE Team /
Third Party
Internal
7.2-1
PRB reports,
Monthly
Review
W, M, Q, A
Business Teams
/ BU Heads
Internal
7.1-3
7.1-4
7.1-5
Zero noncompliance
FinPlus
Dosti
URView
W, M, Q, A
BE Team
7.2-7
7.1-6
Pegasus
M, Q, A
BE Team
Annual Survey
Third party / HR
HR Mantra
Incident Report
M, A
HR Team
Legal &
Compliance
team
M, A
Downtime
report
TAT Tracker
Audit Reports
D, W, M, A
M, A
Q, A
IT infrastructure
Team
BE Team
Internal
benchmarks
7.3-4
Table 7.4-2
Internal
benchmarks
Internal
7.1-7
7.1-8
Table 7.4-2
Page 16
Page 17
Audit Committee
Meeting Quarterly
Table 4.1-2
Key Performance Measures, Variance & Trend
Analysis
Financial results and variance analysis, operational
performance, status on strategy implementation
projects, treasury performance, statutory & legal
compliances
Financial results and variance analysis vis--vis
previous year / Quarter performance, audit reports,
review of compliance, code of conduct
Operational Review
Monthly
Sales Review
Weekly
PRB Meeting
Weekly
Morning Huddles
Daily
Participants
Outcomes
BOD, CEO,
CFO,
Company
Secretary
CEO, CFO,
Company
Secretary,
Auditors
CEO, CFO,
BU /
Functional
Heads & their
direct reports
CMO & sales
team,
marketing
team, Product
Managers,
CRMs
BE process
teams /
delivery team
leads,
managers
All members at
team / project
level
Technical
Improvements/
Innovation
Process
Improvements /
Innovation
Table 4.1-3
Integrated workflow using
technology and
telecommunication networks
and information security to
process tax returns of foreign
nationals
Test Utility
Page 18
Accuracy
Integrity
Reliability
Timeliness
Table 4.2-1
Detailed FTE Training for transaction process, data entry processes
Application / system based validation and rules
Established tolerances for variation in data sets
Data audits
Security
Confidentiality
Standard desktop configuration with regularly updated virus and malware protection
Separate servers for the various business operations
Access to data and systems provided only after appropriate sign-offs as per Security Policy,
mandatory password changes, system lock-out after failed attempts
Security firewalls and intrusion prevention systems
Redundant system design with automatic server scans to identify possible security failure
Device hardening and access restrictions
VAPT testing of critical business applications
IT Security audit conducted by external agencies
Page 19
Table 4.2-2
The QMS and SOPs contain the first level of information about
the projects, processes. The work instructions provide specific
and detailed instructions about the various tasks in a process.
These work instructions are continuously updated by the
workforce based upon their experience in undertaking the various
tasks, thereby also capturing the knowledge gained during
execution.
Criteria 2.1 outline all the reports and information that is used
during the SPP. The various information systems deployed at
ABC including the KM portal Pegasus assist in securing trend
data for operations, CSAT, market and customer updates from
the CRM platform Dosti and workforce data from HR Mantra.
Page 20
Page 21
Page 22
SPP
Action
Plan
CMPF
IP
Page 23
Policy
1.
2.
Work-life
Balance
1.
2.
3.
4.
Employee
Benefits
Employee Education
Assistance Policy
Professional / Executive
Development Education
Policy
Leave Policy
Compensatory Off Policy
Flexible Working, Part-time
Working Policy
Sabbatical Policy
1.
2.
3.
4.
Prevention of Sexual
Harassment Policy
Grievance Redressal Policy
Physical & Environmental
Security Policy
Whistle Blower Policy
Page 24
Engagement
Determination
Mechanism
Annual workforce
satisfaction and
climate survey
Townhall, BU /
FH Meetings,
Morning Huddles
Josh activities
Target
Employees
All
All
All
Focus Area
Organization
Feedback
Organization /
Business Unit /
Function feedback
Fun@work
Team sentiments /
grievances
Understanding
and getting to
know next-level
leaders
Measures to be
taken to curb
attrition
HR Open House
All
Even-in
Senior
Managers
Attrition Analysis
All
Absenteeism
Analysis
FTE,
Developers,
Junior
Managers
Measures to be
taken to curb
absenteeism
All
No holds barred
feedback provides
deep insights into
the reasons for
dissatisfaction
Exit Interviews
Page 25
4.
5.
L&D Requirements
Organizational performance
improvement & innovation
Customer Focus
Training interventions
Reinforcement of new
knowledge and skills on the job
Table 5.2-2
Approach
Organizational objectives linked to individual
goals
Idea bank on the KM portal and R&R for the
best idea generation / transformational changes
recommended
Code of conduct and ethics training during
induction
Take four to eight on-line courses annually on
ethics and security
Role based customer sensitivity training
Various communication by senior leaders on
customer focus
Outcome
Process Improvement
Ideas generated and
implemented (see Fig.
7.3-7)
Zero code of conduct /
ethical breaches for 2
years (Fig. 7.4-3)
Training record and
skills chart for every
employee
Training record and
skills chart for every
employee
Lessons learned
database / Best
Practices database on
the KM Portal
Updated CMPF /
Training record and
skills chart for every
employee
Page 26
Page 27
Page 28
1: Design
the
Process
2: Establish
Metrics
3:
Determine
Performance
4: Stabilize
the
Process
5: Set
Goals
6: Develop
Improvement Plan
7:
Implement
Improvement
Page 29
DR Area
Power
Failure
IT
Infrastructure
People
Table 6.1-1
Precautions
1. Dual power sources
2. Full DG backup
3. UPS for critical systems
1. Redundant telecommunication
infrastructure
2. Off site backup
3. VPN connectivity to senior
leaders and critical resources
1. Critical services operated from
both Mumbai & Chennai locations
2. Multiple entry and exit points at
both offices
3. Fire equipment such as smoke
detectors, fire alarms, sprinklers
and fire extinguishers deployed
4. Signs for directions and
identification of safety
infrastructure
5. Fire wardens identified and
trained in evacuation & first-aid
Page 30
Page 31
Key
Work
System
Sales &
Marketing
Table 6.2-2
Key Requirements
Performance Metric
1.
2.
Lead Generation
Sales Process
1.
2.
Service Delivery
1.
2.
HR
1.
2.
Service Design
Project / Process
Management
Recruitment
L&D
1.
2.
3.
1.
Customer retention
Customer growth
SLA compliance
Number of open positions
and average time to
onboard
Workforce engagement &
satisfaction
System downtime
Time to respond to
incidents/requests
IT
1.
IT infrastructure
management
Target Achievement
Effective lead management &
conversion
Provide value to customer
Meet / exceed SLAs
Timely recruitment of right
candidates
Upgrading, cross-skilling and
motivating employees
Availability of systems,
networks
Help Desk
2.
1.
2.
Page 32
1.00
0.90
0.80
0.9
0.81
0.75
0.70
0.60
0.50
0.46
0.40
0.30
0.20
0.25
0.25
0.16
0.10
0.00
Jan-14
Feb-14
Mar-14
Defect Rate
Apr-14
UCL
May-14
LCL
30
25
100%
25
23
22
Hours
20
19
22
95%
21.5
90%
85%
15
80%
75%
10
Custom Development
Application Maintenance
Mon Tue Wed Thu
TAT
UCL
Fri
Last
week
LCL
Transaction Processing
7.1-3: ABC SLA Compliance Dashboard
7.1b(1) Effort variance, cost variance, size variance,
productivity are the internal measures used to indicate
effectiveness of operational performance.
These
measures are also tracked on a weekly basis, similar to
the schedule and quality parameters.
All these
measures are generated from TrackOn and available
for review in real-time. Costs are tracked at the project
level as well as the business unit level.
Page 33
30
25
Custom Development
Application Maintenance
Transaction Processing
120%
10
100%
80%
60%
40%
FY08
20%
0%
FY09
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
125
120
118
117
92
100.20%
100.00%
99.80%
99.60%
99.40%
99.20%
99.00%
98.80%
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
98.60%
98.40%
FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13
7.1-7: System Uptime
Page 34
Logged issues
FY08
FY09
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
120
165
183
205
200
193
2.5
1.5
TAT
Q3 FY10
Q2 FY11
Q4 FY11
Q1 FY12
Q3 FY12
Q2 FY13
Q4 FY13
Fire Drills
Amber
Green
Green
Amber
Green
Green
Green
Green
DR Drills
Amber
Amber
Green
Amber
Green
Green
Green
Green
Page 35
Competition Survey
Target
PRODUCT /
SERVICE FEATURES
6.2
6
5.8
5.6
5.4
5.2
OVERALL
SATISFACTION
6.5
QUALITY
Scale
5
4
4.49
4.85
5.41
5.19
5.78
5.67
PRICE
COMMUNICATION
3
2
1
ABC
Best-in class
0
FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13
Percentage Dissatisfied
6
5
0.2
18%
0.15
Application
Maintenance
3
2
9%
5%
1%
FY13
0
FY12
6%
FY11
0.05
Transaction
Processing
1
FY10
7%
FY09
0.1
FY08
Scale
Custom
Development
Page 36
Note:
Engagement scores for
each business unit are
also available, and will
be presented during the
site visit.
FY13
16%
76%
FY12
24%
70%
FY11
29%
61%
FY10
35%
71%
FY08
1%
36%
55%
FY09
Fully Engaged
3%
10%
28%
Partial Engaged
Not Engaged
1%
Scale
4.61
11
6.5
Target
5.38
No. of Days
5.76
5.13
5.11
8
4
6
3
1
0
FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13
Figure 7.2-6: Customer Satisfaction Index
FY08
FY09
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
Page 37
18%
14%
12%
10%
8%
6%
4%
2%
Actual
815
786
Required
16%
0%
FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13
ABC Manf.
125
119
215
212
420
400
ABC Services
No of Days
45
30
21
14
7
FY08 FY09
FY10 FY11
FY12 FY13
Page 38
4
3
2
1
FY13
0
FY10
FY11
FY12
52
FY12
FY13
36
FY11
34
FY10
20
0
20
40
60
No. of Referrals
In Rs. Lakhs
70
45
FY13
25
6
FY09
10
FY12
FY11
FY10
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
8
0
10
Page 39
Ideas
0
FY08
1
FY09
750
700
600
500
432
400
300
200
100
0
200
108
12
FY10
20
36
FY11
FY12
Total No. of Programs
50
FY13
15
6
FY10
FY11
27
29
FY12
FY13
Page 40
Management Integrity
Score
98
98
95
92
92
Internal
Controls
Account
reconciliation
Performance
Parameter
100%
reconciled
accounts
Internal Audit
100%
adherence to the
requirement
89
98%
98%
98%
97%
97%
97%
Statutory
Audit
99%
99%
95%
Tax audit
FY09
FY10
FY11
BU Town Hall
FY12
FY13
HR Open House
Exceptions to
be signed off by
the Directors
100% true and
fair view of
financial
performance
and no
qualifications in
the audit report
Correct &
accurate
computation of
income tax ,
liability and its
payments
Actual
Performance
100%
reconciled
accounts on a
quarterly basis
100%
adherence to the
process
Exceptions preapproved by the
Directors
100% true and
fair view of
financial
performance
and no
qualification in
the audit report
since 2007
No issues
reported in
audit report
since 2007
Page 41
FY09
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
94%
98%
100%
97%
100%
100%
No of employee dismissals
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
% of Legal compliances
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
FY08
FY09
37
35
25
25
FY10
48
FY11
38
42
56
65
FY12
FY13
152
FY08
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
350
375
FY09
300
350
319
300
300
472
175
250
419
150
200
407
250
300
CSR Beneficiaries
207
FY09
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
Special Aids
55
40
20
22
45
15
25
10
25
2
No of Beneficiaries
Page 42
13
FY13
11
FY12
120
100
100
FY08
42
40
23
Asia
5
2
0
65
60
Rs Crore
FY09
82
80
20
Target
Europe
FY10
Revenue
USA
FY11
50
100
28
International
11
0
FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13 FY 14
FY13
India
79
FY12
62
FY11
40
Revenue by
Business Unit
FY08
26
FY09
2
22
10
85%
90%
95%
100%
40
Rs Crore
FY10
30
20
79.24%
10
47.56%
0
FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13
55.46%
62.45%
34.10%
24.40%
Custom Developent
Application Developent
FY08
FY09
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
Transaction Processing
Figure 7.5-2: Revenue by Business Unit
Page 43
38.90%
38.27%
33.45%
25.60%
28.99%
28.80%
25.25%
27.76%
25.78%
27.45%
FY08
FY09
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
30.45%
28.58%
23.25%
22.55%
20.28%
23.32%
18.58%
22.37%
FY08
FY09
18.90%
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
Page 44
Glossary of Abbreviations
BCP
BE
BI
BOD
BPO
BU
CAPEX
CEO
CFO
CFT
CMO
CMPF
CRM
CSAT
DR
B
Business Continuity Plan
Business Excellence
Business Intelligence
Board of Directors
Business Process Outsourcing
Business Unit
C
Capital Expense
Chief Executive Officer
Chief Financial Officer
Cross Function Tea
Chief Marketing Officer
Competency Management &
Performance Framework
Customer Relationship Manager
Customer Satisfaction
D
Disaster Recovery
EBIT
E
Expense before Income Tax
FTE
F
Full Time Employee
HOD
HR
H
Head of Department
Human Resources
IIM
IP
IT
I
Indian Institute of Management
Individual Plan
Information Technology
ITES
JD
KM
KPI
KRA
K
Knowledge Management
Key Performance Indicator
Key Result Area
L&D
LOB
L
Learning & Development
Line of Business
MDP
M
Management Development Program
OJT
OPEX
O
On the Job Training
Operating Expense
PAT
PIP
P
Profit after Tax
Performance Improvement Plan
Q&A
QMS
Q
Question & Answer
Quality Management System
R&R
RFP
RFQ
R
Reward & Recognition
Request for Proposal
Request for Quote
S&M
SLA
SLT
SPP
STPI
S
Sales & Marketing
Service Level Agreement
Senior Leadership Team
Strategic Planning Process
Software Technology Park of India
TAT
T
Turnaround Time
UK
U
United Kingdom
VMV
V
Vulnerability Assessment &
PenetrationTesting
Vision Mission Values
VOC
Voice of Customer
VAPT