CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
The apprehensions of media communication, as well as evidence for its effects, are as old
as the history of the subject itself. People have always wondered how media messages are
affecting them by bringing about an imperceptible change in their culture, values and
behavioural patterns. They have always been concerned for the negative influence of a
particular message or message system and have been curious about the potential prosocial effects of others. Wimmer (1993) has mentioned that the concern over the social
impact of mediated messages was evident as far back as the 1920s when many critics
charged that the motion pictures had a negative influence on children. The study of the
anti-social effects of viewing television and motion picture is one of the intensely
researched areas of mass media. The impact of pro-social content is a newer area and
grew out of recognition that the same principles underlining the learning of anti-social
activities ought to apply to more positive behaviour.
Keeping in view the above-cited concern, this study analyses the Effects of cable
television in Pakistan. It is a comprehensive study of effects on women in Lahore,
Pakistan and provides results by comparing life patterns of heavy, moderate and
light viewers.
In 2003, this researcher had conducted an M. Phil study on cable television titled
Cable Television Network in Pakistan: Introduction, Development, Prospects and
Dilemmas. The outcome of the study (M. Phil) has now been used in this research,
leading to the effects of cable television.
Zia (2003) quotes In Pakistan, cable television network was initiated in Karachi
in early 1980s and by 1998 was introduced in almost all the big cities of the country but
functioned without rules and regulations. The year 2000 witnessed a mushroom growth of
cable television network all over Pakistan after the government legalized cable television
network. According to Aziz (2003) in 2002 almost four million households were
enjoying its services in the country.
Cable television viewership is no more restricted to the upper-middle class only;
with the availability of low-priced television and cable connection, it has become a
common household facility for the lower class as well. Viewers have access to a variety
of channels from local to foreign, which provide them an opportunity to watch all types of
programmes. Zia (2003) quotes, The reasons for this rapid growth of cable television
included easy access, low cost, access to satellite channels and a huge television viewership interested in entertainment only.
According to Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (PEMRA) regional
office, Punjab, the subscription of cable television in Lahore has increased from 0.2
million in 2003 to 0.35 million in 2006. Cable television subscription to 0.35 million
households in Lahore increases the chances of its effect/influence on the viewers as
findings of a pilot study with 1200 sample size, conducted by the researcher showed that
majority of them (60 percent) are spending 2-3 hours daily to watch cable television.
reports that growth of cable television has resulted into a spill over of the Indian and
western channels to Pakistani audience. The primary beneficiaries were the ZEE TV,
Sony, Star Plus, HBO, sports channels etc.
These western and Indian channels have grabbed attention of viewers in Pakistan
and exposed its audience to programmes that were vividly different to the usual available
programmes on local television channels. There was an apprehension among the public
that these Indian and western channels may adversely affecting viewers minds and
activities. Therefore, it was high time to conduct a study on cable television effects. So
this research has been conducted to find out the effects of cable television in Pakistan.
General aim of this study was to ascertain effects of cable television on women in
Lahore, Pakistan. This study tried to record the demographic characteristics of cable
television subscribers (women only) and measured their level of viewership. The study
also tends to find out respondents preferred channels and programmes. It also tried to
find out whether or not there existed any gender difference in cable television viewing.
Following were the specific objectives of the study to:
Explore how viewing of cable television was affecting their household chores and
other activities;
Gauge association between viewing of cable television and change in family and
social interaction patterns of women (18-40 years) in Lahore, Pakistan;
Find out relationship between viewing of cable television and its effects on
personal appearance and style of women;
Examine association between viewing of cable television and its effect on house
and personal expenditure of women in Lahore, Pakistan;
1.3 Hypothesis
The hypothesis designed for the study was as follows:
The core purpose of this study was to dig out the influence of foreign channels
and Pakistani channels with foreign contents on social life, values and behaviour patterns
of female viewers through cable television. The researcher was interested to examine if
the cable television has any affects on women in Pakistan and if yes, to what extent has
it effected the women at basic level in terms of the following factors:
after reviewing the relevant literature i.e., most of the researchers were of the view that
television viewing generates socio-economic and cultural changes. The following subhypotheses were formed on the basis of above-mentioned factors.
1.4 Rationale
This study was aimed at finding out effects of cable television on Pakistani women with
emphasis on measuring these effects on women belonging to Lahore and viewing cable
television for a minimum of two years. The study was important as there was a general
concern in the society about cable television and their impact/effects on women
particularly if they were heavy viewers of cable television. But little or no attention had
been paid in the past to the actual consumption of cable television and its impact on
audience, particularly on women of reproductive age in Lahore, Pakistan.
on screen. Hence, with such concern in the back of her mind, it was very necessary to
measure those implicit and explicit effects that (might) affect the behaviour and attitudes
of the female-audience.
It is a general observation that females in Pakistan are the housewives. A very
small segment of the female population professionally works. Hence their exposure to
outside world is limited. Thus, their perception falls back upon the mediated and
glamorised reality via television. This also directed attention towards an important issue:
the weak analytical and expressive powers of female population in general. Even if the
women possess communicative skills, they are not provided with a proper platform to get
themselves heard. Further, in Pakistans male-dominated society, women are not
encouraged to come forward and speak-out their minds. Such observations developed the
need of this study.
In Pakistan, a woman is supposed to perform an important responsibility of
bringing up their children. She is considered as the first institution of the society from
where the child learns. Moreover, woman is also the one who is responsible for keeping
intact the value system of the family unit and thus the women population holds the key to
value system of the society in general. Hence, this study had a strong rationale for
analyzing the effects women are receiving through the cable television.
Zia (2003) mentioned that cable television channels have been immensely popular
among viewers, particularly among women folk in Pakistan. Public concern over the ill
effects of media violence and sexuality, explicit content, obscenity and vulgar language
shown through cable television channels is evident and important. This caused many to
criticize the channels and express concern over the effects of such material on an innocent
and expanding viewership. It was reported in the national dailies several times that angry
viewers physically attacked the cable operators. On the other hand, the PEMRA does not
have any proper system of check and balance and monitoring cable networks. Thus, this
study was deemed significant for the public and the policy makers.
A study by Zia (2004) concluded that entertainment was the primary purpose of
viewing cable television and 70 percent female cable viewers were interested in watching
only two kinds of programmes: films and dramas. Only 17.3 percent of the women used
cable television for information and awareness purpose. Therefore, this study focused on
women only and analysed the affects of these programmes on them. The study has
provided certain recommendations on the bases of these affects.
Thompson and Bryant (2002) expressed that new media enabled users to become
more active in communication process and to be more selective with regard to messages
they receive. They were active agents rather than passive receivers of information. They
may be called addressable users of micro multimedia television. Bellour (1975)
considered women as passive audience but was converting them into an active audience.
Hence, with all these aspects in mind, the study explored the area of cable
watching and its effects with special reference to women residing in Lahore, Pakistan.
10
were few limitations. But for those living some distance away, reception could be poor,
the picture was often fuzzy, distorted or faint. Even a passing car could create electrical
interference and fill the screen with snow or cause the picture to roll. In addition, the
fact that television signals travel in a straight line reduced the quality of reception or even
made it impossible behind large buildings on the back side of hills or mountains and in
similar positions.
To solve his problem, Mr. Walson put an antenna on the top of a large utility pole
and installed it on the top of a nearby mountain. Television signals were received and
transported over twin lead antenna wire down to his store. Once people saw these early
results, television sales soared. It became his responsibility to improve the picture quality
by using coaxial cable and self- manufactured boosters (amplifiers to bring cable
television to the homes of customers who bought television sets. And as such the cable
television was born in June 1948.
In the early 1950s, television was fairly new. Though it had not yet become
popular, city department stores displayed many different models for sale. And, like an
apartment house where every resident had his/her own television, the rooftops of stores
were beginning to resemble forests of television antennas. Milton Jerrold Shapp, who
later became governor of Pennsylvania, developed a system to consolidate the forest of
antennas for city department stores and apartment buildings. Under this new system, one
master antenna (MATV) could be used for all television in the building. His secret: the
coaxial cable and signal boosters (amplifiers) capable of carrying multiple signals at once.
At about the same time, in the nearby town of Lansford, another appliance
salesman named Robert (Bob) Tarlton experienced similar problems as those faced by
Mr. Walson. He read about Mr. Shapps new system and though it worked for apartment
houses and department stores, it could work for his own town as well. While the
community was only 65 miles from Philadelphia, it was behind a mountain that interfered
with signals. Tarlton decided to try a new approach. He put up a big antenna and for a
monthly fee he provided a cable hook-up to each subscribers home. He called his new
business the Panther Valley Television Company, and he was able to supply excellent
signals to people who could not otherwise operate a receiver. He did not originate any
new programming. All he did was to capture network broadcasts with his community
antenna and relay them to homes on his system.
11
12
broadcasting, commercial telecast was also permitted but no license fee was charged on
television set at that time.
13
1.7.5 AJK TV
AJK television is a Kashmiri Channel providing different programmes for local viewers
and Kashmiri and Gojrati news.
14
decoders, which were a lot more expensive and the annual subscription was also beyond
the reach of a common man. A man once setup this satellite system for his own personal
use and then started providing this service to neighbouring areas against a small fee.
Thus, this gave way to the business of cable television networking which established and
flourished in a short period.
The government took notice of this illegal operation in the late 1998. The Nawaz
Sharif headed government came to conclusion that cable operation be made legal in
Pakistan. But before any action could be taken, the Nawaz Sharif government was
toppled and the armed forces took command of the nations destiny and started
considering legalization of the cable television. The army regime headed by General
Musharraf legalized cable television operations in January 2000.
The Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) started the procedure of
issuing licenses to the cable operators in January 2000. The following is the data for the
number of issued application forms and responses received till June 2000. PTA chairman
Mian Muhammad Javed explained that cable television had now emerged as one of the
most inexpensive means of entertainment in the country which government wanted to
make more popular among users and viewers by framing policies and proper rules and
regulations to ensure transmission of good programmes through their channels.
The legalization process of cable television networks started in November 1998
and completed in 2000.
functioning legally which initiated a new era of electronic media in Pakistan. This raised
a number of new queries and gave an opportunity to people to discuss this new system of
communication in Pakistan.
15
PTA issued nationwide licenses to the cable operators and the issuance of the
license to an eligible firm(s)/company may take seven days on the receipt of the
application.
Table 1.1: Licenses Issued to Cable Operators from June 2000 to Dec. 2001 by PTA
Category
Islamabad/
NWFP
Punjab/
Lahore
Karachi
Total
B-1
110
328
333
771
B-2
42
52
B-3
B-4
B-5
B-6
B-7
B-8
Total
119
338
380
837
It can be seen from the above table that maximum licenses were issued in Karachi
i.e. 380 and minimum were issued in Islamabad/NWFP i.e. 119 whereas Lahore issued
338 licenses throughout Punjab. This shows that the growth of cable television network is
at its peak in Karachi and in Punjab including that cable television was warmly welcomed
in these areas and people accepted it with pleasure.
Cable television has been growing rapidly in major cities of the country since the
government authorised PTA to issue licences to cable operators in early 2000. The
number of households using this service has crossed 2.5 million. In the densely populated
cities, like Karachi and Lahore, the growth of cable television is rapid as the operators do
not have to face high installation cost. Secondly, houses are close to each other, making
16
supplying of connections easier than in cities like Islamabad where the houses are not so
close. Therefore, in the federal capital, cable television system is far from being a
thriving trend as cable operators see dim business prospects in the field.
According to a study in which three thousand people were interviewed in different
areas of town, cable network has expanded 25 percent in just one year. (Zia, 2003: 89).
Exploit indigenous human and financial resources in the broadcasting field to gain
competitive advantage and become a leading player in the region
17
To avoid massive larceny of government revenue in the form of taxes and tariffs
caused due to concealing of facts about actual income by cable television
operators
domain of electronic media in the country. PTA has evolved a comprehensive policy to
grant licenses for establishing cable television networks, identifying for them baskets of
television channels and introducing them to new media technologies.
PEMRA has issued cable television regulations, developed a code of ethics for
operators selected 54 eligible television channels for distribution detected over 2,000
illegal cable television operators/loop line holders and regularized rural areas cable
television operators. Till February 2004, there were 1,105 licensed cable television
operators in the country, whereas many more are being licensed and almost double the
number are under process for regularization. As per Sedat and Murshad Associates survey
and study, an estimated investment in this segment is over Rs. 7.28 billion with annual
growth rate of 132 percent for the last three years. It covers over 5-6 million households
with approximately 30,000 personnel working on self-employment basis. Other surveys
have revealed that cable and satellite penetration has grown from 5 percent in 1998 to
approximately 45 percent in 2006 in the country (Report 2003- 06: PEMRA).
During the years 2003 - 2006, PEMRA has issued 788 licenses in various
categories for launching cable television networks in various parts of the country that is in
addition to the licenses inherited by the PEMRA from PTA. Province-wise number of
licenses issued is as follows:
18
Punjab -------------------235
NWFP------------------- 52
Balochistan ------------- 70
Islamabad
Region
Punjab
region
NWFP
Region
Sindh
Region
Balochistan
Region
Total
B(LH)
09
99
12
00
08
125
B-1
90
236
50
219
28
622
B-2
18
07
03
71
03
94
B-3
02
01
00
24
01
25
B-4
00
01
00
03
00
05
B-5
00
01
00
03
01
04
B-6
00
00
00
00
00
00
B-7
00
00
00
00
00
00
B-8
00
00
00
02
00
02
B-9
00
00
00
00
00
00
B-10
00
00
00
01
00
01
Rural (R)
63
60
17
217
43
365
Hotel (H)
00
03
00
04
01
08
Total
182
408
82
544
85
1301
19
The authority retains the approved list of satellite television channels under
constant review, periodically revising it to cater to public taste, needs and demands. Its
current list has on it 49 satellite television channels excluding the Pakistani ones. The list
is enclosed at:
News Channels
Entertainment Channels-----------------------06
Sports Channels
Entertainment Channels-----------------------15
----------------------------11
--------------------------06
The list is widely circulated among cable television operators for their information
and compliance.
The number of connections has been increased from 2.9 million in 2003 to more 4
million homes in 2006 in Pakistan. However, cable operators do not have any device to
censor whatever the channels are broadcasting. In addition to this PEMRA does not have
any system to monitor the channels which are being transferred to the connection holders
by the cable operators.
Declared subscribers by
cable television operators
Implemented
subscribers through
enforcement so far
Islamabad
40,244
223,000
Sindh
88,332
1,497,905
Punjab
22,356
1,011,000
NWFP
17,037
499,017
Balochistan
8,434
40,000
Grand total
176,392
3,270,922
20
Monthly subscription
(in Rs)
Cable Television
500 2000
225 350
MMDS
1500 2000
200- 350
DTH
10,000 12000
250 350
The growth in subscription of above technologies is correlated with the cost effectiveness
that is offered to end-users.
Table 1.5 portrays a survey of the television viewership in the country by
household income group.
Viewers percentage
Estimated numbers
Up to 4,000
35
14,843,000
4001-7000
51
17,107,000
7001-15000
72
11,845,000
15000+
81
7,843,000
Cable television operators all over the country have been relaying programmes
and advertisements on self-generated CD channels in explicit violation of the provisions
21
of PEMRA regulations. By doing so they were causing damage to the satellite television
channel operators by fetching advertisements at a very cheaper cost. Moreover, content
and quantity of such private channels was also devoid of PEMRA rules.
On the other hand, cable television operators of the country have persistently
demanded PEMRA for granting permission for in-house channels and advertising on
cable television networks. PEMRA has therefore devised a policy for registration of inhouse channels for cable television operators. The very purpose of this policy is to ensure
the level playing field for stakeholders by regulating illegal transpiration of in-house
channels.
The number of such channels is now restricted to five (maximum) according to
categories of cable television licenses. Whereas, in past they were showing 15 to 20 such
channels by flouting all the regulations and norms. No operator is allowed to transmit
their local channels or to insert ads without prior permission/license of the Authority. The
license for in-house channel and its fee is in addition to the license for cable television
operation.
Moreover, the sector had over the time come to be lighted massively by the
courage of loopline connections. Instead of going for rather impracticable punitive
actions, the Authority thought it more prudent and practicable to bring the operators of
these illegal connections in its net by offering them concessions. To this end, it introduced
for operators running their cable operations on loopline from any licensed cable television
head-end operators, a category marked as cable television license of loop-line holders
(LH Category). It provides two options to such loop holders. They can either obtain an
independent license in LH Category maintaining their independent status or they may
become an agent to the licensed cable television operator. Both options were evolved in
consultation with various representatives of cable television operators associations and
stakeholders (PEMRA: Annual Report 2002-2003). As such, some good results were
obtained and PEMRA issued 640 head-end licenses till 2006 in Punjab. In Lahore,
PEMRA has issued 83 head-end licensees till 2006, out of which 68 are active and 276
loop holders are successfully handling cable perorations and serving 0.35 million
subscribers. Every cable operator/loop holder provides more than 100 channels to
connection holder.
22
AJK
Geo TV
Indus Music
Indus News
Indus Plus
Indus Vision
KTN
Ptv 1
Ptv Channel 3
Ptv National
QTV
The Music
UNI Plus
Geo News
Apna Channel
The present situation in Pakistan shows dominance both by public sector and
private/commercial media, with PTV having an extensive reach because of its extensive
network of stations and boosters. It has a greater acceptability and credibility of people in
areas where it can be watched through cable network and satellite dish antennas.
Currently, in Pakistan we can differentiate three kinds of television channels:
1. State-owned television channels
23
24
Name/Title of licensee
Name of channel
[Two Channels]
VTV 1
VTV 2
VTV 3
VTV 4
[Two Channels]
Indus Music
Indus Vision
[Two Channels]
Licence Issued
Licence Issued
"Hum TV"
Licence Issued
10
Licence Issued
11
Licence Issued
Number of Licenses 16
Gone on-air 10
25
26
Ptv Channel 1
Ptv Channel 3
Rung TV
Sun Biz TV
Ravi TV
27
Star World
Star Plus
Star Gold
Star Movies
Star Sports
Sahara One
Sur Sangeet
Super Sports
Ten sports
Zee Movies
Zee Tv
Zee Smile
ZOOM
HBO
HallMark
AXN
Balle Balle
BBC Prime
Bloom Berg
Cartoon Network
ESPN
VOX
Fashion TV
ESPN
FOX
Reality TV
MTV
Channel V
CNN
Discovery channel
National Geographic
History
SONY
Saharay samay
Saudi Tv
LBC
B4u music
B4u movies
S Max
Sky sports
Zee cinema
28
Star one
CNBC
MTV HITS
MTV UK
Nickelodeon
Sky Movies
Sky News
The Hits
Animal Planet
29
came out of the stagnant state of Ptv which monopolised the electronic media field for a
long time. Viewers may have the cable connection by paying nominal amount and can
watch a variety of channels which provide them unlimited number of films, drama, music,
international programmes, sports programmes etc. With the introduction of cable
television, viewers of different age groups and different income groups can now approach
different kinds of local and foreign channels. Another reason for its acceptability and
popularity among the viewers is the leisure and entertainment at their doorstep.
For instance, if a family visits a cinema hall, they have to spend on their
travelling, food stuff and tickets, obviously being expensive to a middle class family.
Now, with the ultimate number of channels on cable television, inexpensive and round
the clock entertainment is available at their home for the entire family. At the same time
they may avoid the programmes on Ptv which lack variety, are unattractive and with a lot
of coverage to the govt activities. As a result these programmes are quite often
monotonous and uninteresting. In contrast, foreign channels provide a variety of
programmes, non-stop entertainment and a choice to all the members of the family.
Moreover, their uncensored presentation is found to be bold and attractive for them.
One of the reasons for the attraction of cable television channels is the live
coverage of international audience hitherto ignored by Ptv in the past. The Ptv news and
current affairs programmes gave more coverage to government activities and most of the
time full of statements and speeches of the VIPs, political leaders and ministers were
telecast. It lacked coverage to social and other issue of common mans interests.
Therefore, viewers were glad when they received news of events of their interests and
interviews with personalities on BBC, CNN and other private channels rather than
statements by the government officials and celebrities. They were also amazed by visiting
foreign lands by watching programmes on cable television foreign channels and were also
exposed to the behaviour and lifestyle of other nations.
Apart from live coverage of major happenings, interviews with personalities on
news channels, music channels, dramas on Geo, Star Plus, ARY and Sports channels
attracted both viewers and advertisers which posed a serious threat to Ptv. The soap
operas, talk shows, chat shows and other programmes have become quite popular among
viewers of all income status groups, though these programmes promote a very different
values system from that of Pakistanis. As a result, rapid growth of cable television in
Pakistan has not only broken the monopoly of Ptv in the country but also possessed a
challenge to the behaviour and values system of our nation. Further, with the advent of
30
satellite transmission and growth of cable television has enhanced the element of
competition among the television channels. Consequently, local and state-owned
television channels are following the production patterns of foreign channels, particularly
Star Plus owned by Star TV Network. Star plus is projecting and promoting the Indian
traditions, values and culture in Hindi language.
In Pakistan, no other technology has been accepted and ever made a so sudden
impact on minds of peoples as the cable television network has made. With emergence of
private satellite channels, the whole broadcasting industry has been commercialized. The
expansion of commercial broadcasting has created a consumer-oriented market which
further expanded the marketing and advertising infrastructure of Pakistans economy.
This was required for the success of the governments liberal media policy.
One of the important and clear trends observed in Pakistani broadcasting industry
is the shifting of senior, famous and creative directors, producers and broadcasters from
Ptv to the new private television channels. There might be the following reasons for this
act:
Private television channels are paying heavily to the media professionals i.e.
producers, directors, editors, etc.
Another important result of the media expansion is the fragmentation of audience. These
channels provide diversity in content and theme targeting a specific group. There are
separate dedicated channels for sports, movies, music, drama, news, religion etc.
Similarly, there are separate channels for different languages i.e. national, international
and regional. Many indigenous programmes are just replicas of the western and Indian
programmes. Most of the channels show clichs of similar programmes having a few
innovative ideas. This shows that a variety of programmes are available but the content is
almost the same.