Anda di halaman 1dari 9

International Journal of Digital Information and Wireless Communications (IJDIWC) 2(1): 66-74

The Society of Digital Information and Wireless Communications, 2012(ISSN 2225-658X)

High performance OFDM systems for digital video broadcasting-terrestrial


(DVB-T)
Mr Y. A. LAFTA 1 and Dr. P. JOHNSON2
School of engineering, Liverpool John Moores University, Byrom Street, Liverpool, L3 3AF,
UK

Y.Lafta@2008.ljmu.ac.uk
1 Introduction
Abstract
Digital wireless communication has
become one of the most exciting research
topics in the electrical and electronic
engineering field due to the explosive
demands for high-speed wireless services,
such as cellular video conferencing.
Digital video broadcasting-terrestrialsecond generation (DVB-T2) has been
demonstrated to provide services with very
high spectral efficiency and improved
performance. Also, OFDM systems have
been deployed in mobile networks for their
spectral efficiency and optimum bit error
rate. Among the OFDM systems, wavelet
based systems have been demonstrated to
have improved bandwidth and channel
performance. In this paper the authors
demonstrate that very high spectral
efficiency, BER and PAPR can be
achieved by employing DWT-DAPSK
scheme with the DVTB-T2 system. It is
demonstrated in this paper that including
companding with this system results in
further reduction of PAPR.

Correspondence should be addressed to YHYA LAFTA on


Y.Lafta@2008.ljmu.ac.uk

1.1 Orthogonal Frequency


Modulation (OFDM) Systems

Division

The layered transmission technology that


is used to support the multi-service in
DVB-T (Digital Video BroadcastingTerrestrial) with different priorities is not
suitable for mobile applications because of
its low mobility and high-power
consumption. DVB-H (Digital Video
Broadcasting-Handheld) system addresses
those issues, which is especially developed
for mobile services and provides highspeed.
Recent research investigations identify the
OFDM to be suitable for the upcoming
DVB-H
system
and
wireless
communication systems due to its
excellent robustness to frequency-selective
fading channels [4] - [6].
The OFDM scheme provides an efficient
means to handle high-speed data streams.
This is because the OFDM system uses
multi-carrier
modulation
(MCM)
technique which divides the entire data
stream into several small numbers of lower
data-rate subcarrier data streams, thus
reducing the frequency selective fading
[15].
Service providers working towards 4G
communication systems are continuously
66

International Journal of Digital Information and Wireless Communications (IJDIWC) 2(1): 66-74
The Society of Digital Information and Wireless Communications, 2012(ISSN 2225-658X)

met with the challenge of accommodating


more and more users within a limited
available bandwidth [8]. The main
advantage of the OFDM systems is that
they are immune to multi path fading [11].
However, their major disadvantage is that
the transmitted signal has a high peak-toaverage power ratio (PAPR). Many
research investigations have led to the
conclusion that the wavelet based OFDM
is more advantageous than the Fourier
based OFDM [1][3] [21]. One of the main
reasons being Fourier based OFDM
systems require allocation of guard bands
between subcarrier frequencies to avoid
inter symbol interference, however
wavelet based OFDM systems do not
require such guard bands and therefore the
overall system bandwidth is increased.

anticipation that this system should have


reduced PAPR compared to the other
Fourier based OFDM systems.

The discrete wavelet transform (DWT) is


represented by a function of a countable
set of wavelet coefficients, i.e. individual
wavelet functions localized in space [28].
The wavelets are a family of functions
constructed from the translation and
dilation of signal function called the
mother wavelet. Due to an extremely high
spectral containment property of the
wavelet filters and the fact that extremely
less energy is contained in the side lobes,
the amount of interference between
carriers in wavelet systems is much lower
than that in Fourier systems [21].
Therefore, even in the absence of guard
bands,
DWT-OFDM
can
combat
narrowband interference better than the
traditional discrete Fourier transform
systems and is inherently more robust in
terms of inter carrier interference (ICI)
which is the most detrimental feature in
DFT-OFDM systems [2]. This research
work proposes a combination of DWT
with DAPSK modulation scheme in

DVB-T could be used to provide portable


and mobile services over the 8 MHz
channel at the date rate ranging from 4.98
to 31.67 Mb/s, as well as support indoor
and outdoor fixed reception.

A set of cosinusoidal functions


cos(2nF_
t),
n=0,1,..,
N-1
representing the signal can be used on
orthogonal basis to achieve the multi
carrier modulation (MCM) scheme that
can be synthesized using a discrete cosine
transform (DCT) [23]. The minimum
frequency spacing_ required to satisfy
the DCT based OFDM is 12T Hz [25].
The baseband DCT-OFDM signal x (t) is
still a real value when the data symbols
d_n are obtained using real valued
modulation formats, such as pulse
amplitude modulation (PAM) and binary
phase shift keying ( BPSK).

1.2

Organization of the paper

The organization of this paper is as


follows: section 1.3 reviews the QAM
modulation scheme and 1.4 reviews related
work in the area of DCT (DWT) OFDM
systems with QAM modulation for high
data rate next generation communication
networks. Finally, section 2 presents the
simulation and the results of the proposed
DWT system with DAPSK and QAM
modulation schemes. The performance
from the system is evaluated against
metrics such as Eb/No, ISI and PAPR and
compared with that of DCT system.
1.3

Modulation Schemes

Quadrature amplitude modulation


(QAM) is more attractive for the highly
67

International Journal of Digital Information and Wireless Communications (IJDIWC) 2(1): 66-74
The Society of Digital Information and Wireless Communications, 2012(ISSN 2225-658X)

mobile radio environment (e.g., in a car or


a train), which is a high-order and noncoherent modulation scheme, employed as
a potential means to give further
improvement to the spectral efficiency.

cosine IDCT will be used to modulate


spread data symbol on the orthogonal
carriers, as in conventional OFDM.

scheme does not require


complicated channel estimation and
equalization to be detected by the receiver.
Use of pilot symbol can be avoided to
more efficiently transmit the informationbearing data. Moreover, the non-coherent
modulation can preferably withstand the
Doppler Effect caused by the high mobility
between the transmitter and receiver [18].
The 16QAM has a more efficient signal
distribution than the 16DAPSK, in terms
of the relative power saving in an AWGN
channel [22]. Since highly accurate carrier
recovery and phase tracking are required in
the receiver, applying coherent detection in
the mobile radio environment is a very
difficult task. It is also important to
accurately track the fading envelope for
systems such as 16QAM.

As a candidate for next-generation


digital television terrestrial broadcasting
systems (DTTB) and the 4th generation
mobile receivers, the OFDM systems have
attracted considerable research attention.
The OFDM system has been successfully
implemented by [12] [17] and [13] in the
wireless broadcasting applications such as
Digital Video Broadcasting (DVB) and
Digital Audio Broadcasting (DAB). The
above mentioned systems use data rates in
the range of 40Mbits/s and with DTTB
system could deliver 40 GB contents to
unlimited number of local servers. The
ETSI-BRAN system employs
this
transmission technique for HIPERLAN 2
(high performance local area networks),
and also for the extension of the IEEE
802.11 standard for the 5-GHz frequency
range. A DVB-T system supports
networks covering portable mobile
receivers in buses, cars, and receivers
indoor [14] [19]. The digital dividend has
been designated such as a matter of
controversy between broadcasters and
mobile communications operators which
occupy part of it as desired [9]. Future
mobile communication systems with data
rates far beyond the Universal Mobile
Telecommunication system (UMTS) can
be realized using OFDM as a suitable
transmission technique.

QAM

The coded bits are mapped to form


symbols which use gray coding in the
constellation map. The coding rate is (1/2)
for the 16QAM modulation scheme. When
the symbol is normalized, the average
power is unity irrespective of the
modulation scheme used. The data are
converted by the process to corresponding
value of M-ary constellation, which is a
complex word, constituting real and
imaginary parts. The bandwidth B =1/ is
divided into N equally spaced subcarriers
at frequencies (kf), k=0, 1, 2 N-1 with
f=B/N and
as the sampling interval.
Grouping and mapping information bits
into complex symbols will be carried out
at the transmitter. Inverse wavelet
Transform IDWT or inverse discrete

1.4

Related work

Simulation and Analysis


In this section, the simulations results
for the DWT and DCT-OFDM systems
with
64DAPSK/64QAM
modulation
schemes and for two different input types
are presented. The input types considered
68

International Journal of Digital Information and Wireless Communications (IJDIWC) 2(1): 66-74
The Society of Digital Information and Wireless Communications, 2012(ISSN 2225-658X)

for the simulations are uncoded random


binary system and coded signal DVB-T.
This simulation also considered AWGN
and Rayleigh transmission channels within
the system. The results are presented in
figures 1 to 4. The simulation parameters
for the number of sub carriers N is 64, and
the number of samples for the symbols is
1000. If the number of the sub carriers and
symbols were larger, the time for running
the simulations will be longer. The
simulation has been run for a larger set of
system parameters and no significant
difference to the results was noticed. The
figures 1a to 1c represent the power
spectral density of the received signal for
DWT (and DCT)-OFDM systems with
64QAM modulation scheme using AWGN
channel with Gaussian spectrum and
Rayleigh channel with Jakes spectrum.

higher signal power than that for the DCT


based OFDM system using the same
modulation scheme. It is also clearly seen
that the power spectral density (PSD) for
DWT-OFDM
is
20-40dB/rad/sample
better than the DCT-OFDM system when
using the 64QAM scheme modulation via
AWGN transmission channel type. This
huge difference in PSD between the
received signals which were transmitted
with the same input power leads to the
observation that DWT system has much
better signal to noise ratio. Whereas, the
DWT-OFDM system with 64QAM using
Rayleigh
with
Jakes
spectrum
demonstrates to have higher bandwidth
efficiency
when compared to the DCT
OFDM system under exactly the same
conditions. The DCT-OFDM seems to
have better
than PSD signal using the
AWGN and Rayleigh with Gaussian
spectrum. This means that for binary input
stream, the spectrum for this system will
have smaller side-lobes and so will be
immune to inter-symbol interference (ISI).

Fig1a Power spectral densities for DWT and DCT


systems with 64QAM modulation schemes via A

Fig1d Power spectral densities for DWT system


with 64DAPSK modulation schemes via AWGN
channel

Fig1b Power spectral densities for DWT and DCT


systems with 64QAM modulation schemes via
Rayleigh (Gaussian) channel

The simulation results indicate that the


DWT-OFDM with 64QAM scheme has

The figures 1d to 1f represent the power


spectral density of the received signal for
DWT -OFDM systems with 64DAPSK
modulation scheme using AWGN or
Rayleigh channels with Gaussian and
Jakes spectrum respectively. The DWTOFDM system with 64DAPSK has 75dB
69

International Journal of Digital Information and Wireless Communications (IJDIWC) 2(1): 66-74
The Society of Digital Information and Wireless Communications, 2012(ISSN 2225-658X)

higher PSD than that of the DWT-OFDM


system with 64QAM scheme, though with
less bandwidth efficiency .

using Rayleigh Channel and AWGN


channels, the DCT-64QAM is shown to
have at least 15dB lower PSD with
exponential transform when compared to
that with or without companding.

Fig1e Power spectral densities for DWT system


with 64DAPSK modulation schemes via Rayleigh
(Jakes) channel

The PSD of the DWT and DCT OFDM


systems were also simulated with and
without
-law companding, and
exponential transforms. The results are
shown in figures 2a and 2b. Figure 2a
representing the DWT-OFDM system with
64DAPSK scheme using Rayleigh
Channel shows that the signal with nocompanding suffers from out-of-band
interference (OBI) compared to the signal
that has gone through companding or
exponential transforms.

Fig.2b PSD for DWT with 64DAPSK channel


AWGN

Fig.3 PSD for DCT with 64QAM Rayleighs


channel (Jakes and Gaussian) and AWGN

Fig.2a PSD for DWT with 64DAPSK channel


Raleigh ( Jakes and Gaussian)

The DWT-64DAPSK system in Fig.2a


using Rayleigh channel with Jakes or
Gaussian spectrum is shown to have at
least 32dB lower PSD with or without
companding when compared to that with
exponential transform. Fig.3 represents
DCT-OFDM system with 64QAM scheme

Fig.4
CCDF
for
DWT/DCT
with
64DAPSK/64QAM
for
no
companding,
companding and exponential signals

In figure 4, the continuous line graphs


represent the complementary cumulative
distribution
(CCDF)
vs.
PAPR
performance for DWT systems, whereas
the dashed lines represent the same for
DCT systems. It can be observed from the
70

International Journal of Digital Information and Wireless Communications (IJDIWC) 2(1): 66-74
The Society of Digital Information and Wireless Communications, 2012(ISSN 2225-658X)

When the input data is changed to that of


DVB-T, created by using a trellis code
with length = 256 and Fs=1000, the DWT
based systems seem to possess better
bandwidth efficiency and PAPR than the
DCT based systems. This effect is depicted
in the simulation results shown in figure 5a
to 5d.

Periodogram Power Spectral Density Estimate


-1.4
-1.6
-1.8
Power/frequency (dB/Hz)

graph that both DCT and DWT systems


with companding have at least 1.9 dB less
PAPR than the systems without
companding and the systems with
exponential transform have 1.3 dB less
PAPR than that without any transform.

-2
-2.2
-2.4
-2.6
-2.8
-3

-400

-300

-200

-100
0
100
Frequency (Hz)

200

300

400

500

Fig.5b Power spectral densities for DCT systems


with 64QAM modulation via AWGN using trellis
code

Periodogram Power Spectral Density Estimate

Periodogram Power Spectral Density Estimate

30

25
20

20
15

Power/frequency (dB/Hz)

Power/frequency (dB/Hz)

10

-10

-20

-30

10
5
0
-5
-10

-40

-15
-50

-400

-200

0
Frequency (Hz)

200

400

-20
-25

Fig.5a Power spectral densities for DWT systems


with 64QAM modulation via AWGN using trellis
code
Periodogram Power Spectral Density Estimate
-1.4

-400

-200

0
200
Frequency (Hz)

400

Fig.5c Power spectral densities for DWT systems


with 64DAPSK modulation via AWGN using
trellis code

-1.6

Periodogram Power Spectral Density Estimate


30
20
10

-2
Power/frequency (dB/Hz)

Power/frequency (dB/Hz)

-1.8

-2.2
-2.4
-2.6

0
-10
-20
-30
-40

-2.8
-50

-3

-400

-300

-200

-100
0
100
Frequency (Hz)

200

300

400

500

Fig.5b Power spectral densities for DCT systems


with 64QAM modulation via AWGN using trellis
code

-60

-400

-300

-200

-100
0
100
Frequency (Hz)

200

300

400

500

Fig.5d Power spectral densities for DCT systems


with 64DAPSK modulation via AWGN using
trellis code

71

International Journal of Digital Information and Wireless Communications (IJDIWC) 2(1): 66-74
The Society of Digital Information and Wireless Communications, 2012(ISSN 2225-658X)

This means that the DWT system presents


at least 7 times better BW efficiency than
the DCT system. This high BW efficiency
ensures
immunity
to
inter-carrier
interference (ICI) in the receiver but the
DCT has very small side lobs than the
DWT system, which means immunity to
inter-symbol interference (ISI).

PSD of orginal & companded signals


Orginal
20

Proposed
Exponential

PSD(db/rad/sample)

0
-20
-40
-60
-80
-100
0

0.1

This means the DWT system possesses


two times better BW efficiency than the
DCT system. This high BW efficiency
ensures
immunity
to
inter-carrier
interference (ICI) in the receiver but the
DWT also has very small sidelobs in its
spectral density than DCT. This means that
the DWT system has better immunity to
inter-symbol-interference (ISI) as well.

0.3

0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
Normalized frequency(pi rad/sample)

0.8

0.9

PSD of orginal & companded signals


Orginal
20

Proposed
Exponential

0
-20
-40
-60
-80
-100
0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4
0.5
0.6
Normalized frequency(pi rad/sample)

0.7

0.8

0.9

Fig.6b PSD for DCT with QAM via AWGN using


trellis code
PSD of orginal & companded signals
60
No-Companding
40

Companding
Exponential

20
PSD(db/rad/sample)

From figures 5c and 5d, it can be seen that


the DWT-64DAPSK system occupies less
than 2.69 times the bandwidth (700Hz) the
DCT-64DAPSK system (260Hz). The
power spectral density per subband of
DWT-64DAPSK is 48dB/Hz and also of
DCT-64DAPSK is 88dB/Hz. Therefore,
the BW efficiency of the DWT system is 3
times better the DCT system with their
DAPSK modulation.

0.2

Fig.6a PSD for DWT with QAM via AWGN using


trellis code

PSD(db/rad/sample)

The figures 5a to 5d, depict the power


spectral density of the received signal for
DWT (and DCT)-OFDM systems with
64DAPSK and 64QAM modulation
schemes
using
AWGN
channel
transmission for DVB-T input data types.
From figures 5a and 5b, it can be seen that
the DWT-64QAM system occupies less
than half the bandwidth (369Hz) of the
DCT-64QAM system (800Hz), while
having a superior power spectral density
per subband of 65dB/Hz compared to the
negligible 4.5 dB/Hz for DCT.

0
-20
-40
-60
-80
0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
Normalized frequency(pi rad/sample)

0.8

0.9

Fig.6cPSD for DCT with 64DAPSK via AWGN


using trellis code

Figures 6a through 6c compare the BW


efficiency performance of the DWT &
DCT systems with and without
72

International Journal of Digital Information and Wireless Communications (IJDIWC) 2(1): 66-74
The Society of Digital Information and Wireless Communications, 2012(ISSN 2225-658X)

companding to that of with exponential


transform.
In figures 6a and 6b, it is shown that
DWT-QAM system with exponential
transform has 2 times BW efficiency
compared with the same system but with
no companding. It also has 5 times BW
efficiency compared to the system having
companding. However, the performance of
the DCT with QAM modulation is not as
good as the DWT system. It shows 3 times
better BW efficiency difference from both
nocompanding & companding processes.
In fig.6c, it is shown DCT-DAPSK with
exponential transform has 4 times BW
efficiency compared companding and no
companding processes.

the signal. For example, from the


simulation results shown above, a
reduction of PAPR by 1.9 dB has been
achieved by the DWT system compared to
without companding. With the exponential
transform, a reduction of 1.3 dB in PAPR
has been demonstrated. Hence, in this
paper it has been demonstrated that the
DWT-OFDM system with 64DAPSK
modulation scheme is very suitable for the
DVB-T system.
References
1.

2.

Abdullah, K., and Hussain, Z. M. (2007)


Performance of Fourier-Based and Wavelet-Based
OFDM for DVB-T Systems, Australasian
Telecommunication Networks and Applications
Conference, pp. 475-479.
Ahmed, N. (2000) Joint Detection Strategies for
Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing, Master
thesis, Houston, Texas.

3 Conclusions
The BW efficiency of the DWT-OFDM
system with both 64QAM and 64DAPSK
modulation
schemes
via
AWGN
transmission channel is shown to be better
than the DCT-OFDM system under similar
conditions. The DWT system with QAM
shows 7 times better BW efficiency than
the DCT with QAM modulation. The
DWT with DAPSK modulation has two
times better BW efficiency than the DCT
system with DAPSK. The better BW
efficiency possessed by the DWT with
DAPSK is an indicator of the systems
immunity to inter-carrier interference (ICI)
which in turn guarantees high bitrate, high
quality data transmission. The DWT
system also displays minimal side-lobes
which contribute to its immunity to intersymbol interference (ISI).

Furthermore, a considerable reduction in


PAPR is obtained through companding of

3.

Akansu, A.N.,and Xueming, L. (1998) A comparative


performance evaluation of DMT
(OFDM) and
DWMT (DSBMT) based DSL communications
systems for single and multitone interference,
Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on
Acoustics, Speech and Signal Processing.

4.

C. yen Ong et al., (2010), Technology and Standards


of Digital Television Terrestrial Multimedia
Broadcasting System (DVB-T2). ETSI Standard, EN
302 755, IEEE Commun. Mag., vol. 48, no. 5, pp.
119-27.

5.

Digital Video Broadcasting (DVB), (2012), Frame


Structure, Channel Coding and Modulation for a
Second Generation Digital Terrestrial Television
Broadcasting System (DVB-T2), EN
3.1.

302 755,

V1.

6.

Error-Correction, (2010), Data Framing, Modulation


and Estimation Methods for Second Generation
Digital Terrestrial Television Broadcasting System
Recommendation ITU-R BT, 1877.

7.

ETSI ES 201 980 v1.2.2 (2003-04) ETSI standard:


digital radio mondiale (DRM); system specication.

8.

Gupta, D., Vats, B. V., Garg, K. (2008) Performance


Analysis of DFT-OFDM, DCT-OFDM, and DWTOFDM Systems in AWGN Channel, IEEE, The
Fourth International Conference on Wireless and
Mobile Communications, pp. 214-216.

9.

Kalogirou, V. P., Nanou, E. D., Capsalis, N. C.,


Velivasaki, T-H. N., Capsalis, C. N. (2009),
Compatibility of DVB-T Services and IMT-2000
Compliant Mobile Telecommunications in the UHF

73

International Journal of Digital Information and Wireless Communications (IJDIWC) 2(1): 66-74
The Society of Digital Information and Wireless Communications, 2012(ISSN 2225-658X)
Band of 470-862 MHz, IEEE TELSIKS 2009, pp.
247-254.
10.

Khalid, S., and Shah, S. I. (2006) PAPR Reduction


by using discrete wavelet transform, IEEE-ICET, PP.

Communication Engineering Journal, Vol. 13, No. 4,


pp. 166172.
23.

Schucher, A., Hasholzner, R. and Antoine, P. (2001)


A novel IQ imbalance Compensation Scheme for the
reception of OFDM signals IEEE Trans. Electron.,
vol. 47, no. 8, pp. 313-318.

24.

Steren, H., P., E. and Mahmoud, S. A.,


Communication Systems Analysis and Design,
International Edition, Prentice Hall.

25.

Tan, P. (2006) A Comparison of DCT-Based OFDM


and DFT-Based OFDM in Frequency Offset and
Fading
Channels,
IEEE
Transactions
on
Communications, vol. 54, No. 11, pp. 2113-2125.

26.

Tellambura, C. (2001) Computation of the continuoustime PAPR of an OFDM signal with BPSK sub
carriers, IEEE Commun. Lett, vol. 5, no. 5, pp. 185187.

27.

Wong, K. D. (2008) The continuous-time peak-toaverage power ratio of OFDM signal using
modulation scheme, IEEE Transaction on
communications, vol. 56, no. 9, pp. 1390-1393.

28.

Zhang, H., Yuan, D., Wang, C-X. (2007a) A study on


the PAPRs in multicarrier modulation systems with
different orthogonal bases, Wireless Commun.
Mobile Compute. 7(3), pp. 311- 318.

. 179-182.
11.

Kumbasar, V., and Kucur, O. (2008) Better wavelet


packet tree structures for PARP reduction in
WOFDM systems, Digital Signal Processing, 18, pp.
885-891.

12.

Dai, Z. Wang, and Z. Yang, (2012),


Time-frequency Training OFDM with
High Spectral Efficiency and Reliable
Performance in High Speed Environments,
IEEE JSAC, vol. 30, no. 4, pp. 695-707.

13.

14.

L.

L. Dai et al, (2012), Wireless Positioning


Using TDS-OFDM Signals in Signalfrequency
Network,
IEEE
Trans.
Broadcast., vol. 58, no. 2.
Ladebusch, U., and Liss, C. A., Terrestrial BVB
(DVB-T): A Broadcast Technology for Stationary
Portable and Mobile Use, IEEE, vol. 94, no. 1, pp.
183-193.

15.

Latef, A., and Goher, N., D. (2006) BER Performance


Evaluation PSD Analysis of Non- Coherent Hybrid
MCM-LFSK OFDM Transmission system, IEEEEICEI 2nd International on Energy Technologies,
Pakistan.

17.

Martoyo, H. S., and Jondral, F. (2002) CDMA versus


OFDM, a performance comparison in selective
fading channels. Proceeding of the IEEE Seventh
International Symposium on Spread Spectrum
Techniques and Applications, Sept. 2002, IEEE
Xplore Press, Prague, Czech Republic, pp: 139-143.
DOI: 10.1109/ISSSTA.2002.1049302

18.

Min, G., Yusheng, J., Han, H., and Xiaokang, L.


(2010) Tow-Dimensional Demodulation for 64DAPSK Modulated OFDM Signal, IEEE CCNC,
proceedings.

19.

Modellversuch DVB-T Norddeutschland (Interim


Report) (2001), Braunchweig, Germany.

20.

Jiang, Y. (2010), New companding transform PAPR


reduction in OFDM, IEEE Transaction on
communications, vol. 14, no. 4, pp. 282-284.

21.

Sandberg, S. D. and Tzannes, M., A. (1995)


Overlapped discrete multi tone modulation for high
speed copper wire communications, IEEE Journal on
Selected Areas on Communications, vol. 13, pp.
1571 -1585.

22.

Sayhood, K. H., Ling, Z. G. and Nan, W. L. (2001)


Performance Analysis of Punctured Convolution
Codes and TurboCodes,
Electronics and

74

Anda mungkin juga menyukai