Quality Management
Issue/revision
Issue 1
Revision 1
Remarks
Tender
Tender Addendum
Date
24 September 2013
19 October 2013
Prepared by
Alex Castellanos
Alex Castellanos
Revision 2
Revision 3
24/09/2013
Signature
Client
Emaar Properties PJSC
Checked by
Adam Olomon
James Evans
Signature
Authorised by
Consultant
Eugene Olivier
Eugene Olivier
Project number
37441950
37441950
Report number
051
051
File reference
37441950-051-AC-RA
37441950-051-AC-IR
Signature
WSP Contacts
Eugene Olivier Project Manager
Eugene.Olivier@wspgroup.ae
Alexander Castellanos
Alexander.castellanos@wspgroup.ae
5.7
Retail Scenario 1 Unit spill with Smoke Extraction from
Mall. 32
5.8
Retail Scenario 2 Unit Fire with Smoke with In Unit
Extraction. .......................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
Table of Contents
1
1.1
1.1.1
1.1.2
1.1.3
1.1.4
1.1.5
1.1.6
1.1.7
1.1.8
1.1.9
1.1.10
1.1.11
1.1.12
Introduction...........................................................................23
Scope ...................................................................................23
Objectives .............................................................................23
Acceptance Criteria ..............................................................23
3
3.1
3.1.1
3.1.2
3.1.3
3.1.4
3.2
4
4.1
4.1.1
4.1.2
4.1.3
4.1.4
4.1.5
4.2
4.2.1
4.3
4.3.1
4.3.2
Modelling Methodology.........................................................24
Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) ..................................24
Hydrodynamic Model ............................................................24
Combustion Model................................................................24
Radiation Model ...................................................................24
Turbulence Model .................................................................24
Verification & Validation Studies ...........................................24
FDS Model ...........................................................................25
Computational Domain .........................................................25
Modelled Scenarios ..............................................................25
Mall Smoke Extraction Scenarios .........................................25
Retail Tenancy Smoke Extraction Scenarios ........................26
5
5.1
5.2
5.3
5.4
5.5
5.6
Results .................................................................................26
Mall Scenarios ......................................................................26
Retail Unit Scenarios ............................................................26
Mall Scenario 1 10MW Boulevard Kiosk Fire ....................27
Mall Scenario 2 10MW Mall Kiosk Fire ..............................28
Mall Scenario 3 1.5MW Mall level Caf FireError! Bookmark not defined.
Mall Scenario 4 1.5MW Third Floor Food Court Fire .........30
1.1
1.1.1
DCD enforces the 2011 Edition of the UAE Fire and Life Safety Code of Practice [UFC], supported by the
National Fire Protection Association [NFPA] suite of documents. At present neither the UFC nor NFPA are
applied in their entirety by DCD.
Where guidance is missing, unclear, or contradictory, the NFPA suite of codes is to be referred to. Such case is
the design of the mall smoke control system.
In addition to the above mentioned codes, local requirements not supported by the aforementioned codes are
often requested verbally during meetings. In view of this, the contents of this report is based on the UFC, NFPA
requirements and verbal DCD comments known to WSP from our experience of operating in Dubai..
Introduction
It should be noted that whilst the contents of the Fire Strategy Report is based upon our previous DCD design
experience, meetings held with DCD with respect to the mall expansion, the contents of this report is subject to
change until such time as the design is formally approved by DCD.
1.1.1.1 Scope
WSP Middle East has been commissioned by EMAAR to provide Fire and Life Safety consultancy services for
the Dubai Mall Expansion project located in Dubai.
This report addresses the following key fire and life safety issues associated with the Dubai Mall Expansion.
Furthermore, in coordination with DCD and the design team and in accordance with the Existing Mall Fire and
Life Safety Strategy a number of alternative design solutions are being proposed which are not in accordance
with prescriptive codes, these are summarised as follows:
Means of egress
Smoke reservoir plan area in excess of the UAE Fire Code permitted 2,600m .
The strategy for the Dubai Mall Expansion is developed to ensure compliance with the prescriptive
requirements in accordance with the applicable codes and standards. It is also intended to follow the principles
developed for the existing mall fire strategy and regulatory requirements in support of the formal approval
process as defined by Dubai Civil Defence (DCD).
The aforementioned alternative solutions has been justified using Performance Based Design (PBD) and/ or
equivalence analysis. The strategy was presented during consultation meetings with DCD during the early
stages of the DD phase in which they have not raised objections to the above proposals. Codes and Standards
Below is a list of the primary reference documents for the Dubai Mall Expansion. These are the most recent
editions of these codes and standards unless otherwise stated. The list is not exhaustive:
This strategy must be read in conjunction with the Fire and Life Safety Drawings.
DCD have full mandate to interpret the requirements detailed in the fire and life safety design codes and
standards; the approval of the fire and life safety design provisions outlined in this report remains at the sole
discretion of DCD.
This report is for the sole use of the client, design team, and contractor for the Dubai Mall Expansion. It should
not be used in full or in part to support any other scheme. Changes in the design of the building may invalidate
the proposals for the scheme as stated herein and / or necessitate a revisit to the design.
1.1.1.2 Stakeholders
This document is to be discussed with the relevant project stakeholders for an in principle acceptance of the
proposed design. Input and feedback from stakeholders is an essential part of the design process. The relevant
stakeholders for the project are identified as follows:
Table 1: Project Stakeholders
UAE Fire and Life Safety Code of Practice, 2011 Edition [UFC]
NFPA 14, Standard for the Installation of Standpipe and Hose Systems
NFPA 20, Standard for the Installation of Stationary Pumps for Fire Protection
NFPA 22, Standard for Water Tanks for Private Fire Protection
NFPA 24, Standard for the Installation of Private Fire Service Mains and Their Appurtenances
Discipline
Organisation
Client
EMAAR
NFPA 80, Standard for Fire Doors and Other Opening Protectives
Design Architect
DP Architects
NFPA 90A, Standard for the Installation of Air-conditioning and Ventilating Systems
Architect of Record
MEP Consultant
Structural Consultant
NFPA 105, Standard for Smoke Door Assemblies and Other Opening Protectives
Security Consultant
SKM
NFPA 241, Standard for Safeguarding Construction, Alteration, and Demolition Operations
NFPA 255, Standard Method of Test of Surface Burning Characteristics of Building Materials
ICC/ANSI A117.1, American National Standards for Accessible and Usable Buildings and Facilities
The use, height, and area of the project form the basis for classifying the building into its construction type and
hence its structural fire performance requirements.
The table below summarizes the height and area characteristics of the building and the associated
requirements for structural fire resistance for the Mall Expansion as set out in UFC Table 1.6:
Table 3: Structural Fire Resistance
Structural Fire Resistance
Building Area
Occupancy
Classification
Height of
Building
Max Floor
Area (m2)
Construction Type
Type B
Permitted Area
Type B
Maximum
Permitted
Height
Mall Building
Mercantile
~26m
~21,000
Type B
Unlimited
55m
Space/Area
Occupancy Classification
Mall Building
Mercantile
Parking Structure
Storage
Assembly
Exterior and interior load bearing walls, columns, beams girders trusses, arches, and floors 120 minutes
fire resistance
Smoke control
Travel distances
Glass roof will not be occupied or utilized for fire fighting purposes.
The glazed portion of the roof can be classified as a skylight which is exempt from requirements of fire
resistance per NFPA 5000, Section 8.2.2.3.3.1. This is inclusive of the frame structure that supports the
glazed elements.
All other structural and non-glazed portions of the roof that do not form part of the skylight will meet the fire
resistance rating requirements of the UFC.
The circulation area of the mall building, exclusive of retail units, will be classified as the Mall Pedestrian Way,
which per NFPA 101, Section 36.4.4.2.2 requires a minimum dimension of 6100mm at its narrowest point, with
each side of the pedestrian way providing exit access of at least 3050mm in width. Exit access must lead to an
exit width of no less than 1675mm.
Retail units are sub classified by NFPA 101, Section 36.1.2.2.1 as follows:
2
Class A Retail unit with an area greater than 2,800m or occupying more than 3 stories for sales
purposes.
Class B Retail unit with an area ranging between 280m and 2,800m and occupying not more than 3
2
stories for sales purposes or an area greater than 280m and occupying 2 or 3 stories.
Class C Retail unit with an area less than 280m and occupying only a single storey for sales purposes.
1.1.2
Structural elements, floors, and bearing walls will have a fire resistance rating not less than the fire resistance
rating required for the structural element, bearing or non-bearing wall, floor, or roof they support. UFC C1 4.1
In addition it should be noted that the proposal is in accordance with the existing mall strategy in which glazed
roofing structures are not provided with a fire resistance rating.
The mall and car park will be separated by 2 hour fire rated construction throughout, with the exception of
welcome courts.
The welcome courts serve as access from the car park into the mall, NFPA 101 recognizes this condition in
Section 36.1.3.2.2(1) by allowing up to 25% of openings to be unprotected in the 2 hour fire rated wall
separating the mall from car park on the basis that the following conditions are met:-
To mitigate the risk of external fire spread between buildings in close proximity, the UFC prescribes
requirements for fire rating of external walls and limits on the amount of openings based on the physical
separation distances between buildings (UFC C1 5.1).
The UFC states that any faade that is closer than 6m from any faade of an adjacent building must be rated
with 1 hour fire rated construction.
The separation distance between The Mall Expansion and the adjacent office annex building will be a minimum
of 7.5m. Therefore, the facades of the buildings are not required to be fire rated and the number of unprotected
openings in the faade can be unlimited.
Lower Ground Floor car park entrance to mall near At The Top
Boulevard level car park entrance to mall near the Concierge Area
Level 01, Level 1M, Level 2, Level 2M, level 3 car park entrance adjacent to Welcome Court
2 Hours
Ducts and air-transfer openings in walls or partitions with a fire resistance rating of 2 hour or more.
90 min
Ducts and air transfer openings in shafts rated for 1 hour or more
2 Hours
90 min
Ducts and air transfer openings in floor penetrations which are not enclosed in a shaft
2 Hours
90 min
1 Hour
60 min
1 hour
60 min
Fire dampers will be required to comply with the requirements of UL 555, Standard for Fire Dampers, and will
be required to have the minimum fire protection rating of not less than 90 minutes for any fire separation that
has a fire-resistance rating of less than 3-hours, and 3 hour for barriers rated 3 hours or more as specified in
Table 1.11 of UFC C1.
2 Hours
90 min
1 hour
60 min
Generator room
2 Hours
90 min
2 Hours
90 min
1 Hour
60 min
Kitchens
1 Hour*
60 min
1 Hour**
60 min
2 hours
90 min
Horizontal Exit
2 Hours***
90 min
Elevator Lobbies
60 min
In a duct system serving only one floor and used only for exhaust of air to the outside and not penetrating a
wall or partition having a required fire resistance rating of 2 hours or more or passing entirely through the
system and contained within its own dedicated shaft.
Where branch ducts connect to enclosed exhaust risers, and in which the airflow is upward and steel subducts at least 560 mm in length are carried up inside the riser at each inlet.
Smoke dampers will be provided where required as part of the smoke control system and for penetrations
through smoke barriers.
All levels that form part of the atrium connection will be considered a single volume.
Smoke control will be provided as required by code to maintain tenable conditions for all levels during a
potential fire scenario as determined by an engineering analysis. Tenable conditions will be assessed at a
minimum of1830mm above the highest occupied level of exit access open to the atrium for a minimum
period of 20 minutes.
Occupancy
Exits
Other Spaces
Mercantile
A or B
A or B
A or B
The base engineering analysis for the mall pedestrian way and associated retail units are in accordance
with the methodology of UFC C10 29.8 for smoke control.
A or B
A, B, or C
A or B
A or B
A performance based design analysis utilizing computational fluid dynamics will be utilized for finalizing the
smoke control design. This has been discussed in principle with DCD.
The classifications shall be interpreted as follows:
Table 6: Finish Classifications
A draft curtain/downstand, protected with sprinklers, measuring a minimum 455mm in depth is provided
around the opening
Sprinklers protecting the draft curtain are installed a maximum 1830mm on centre around the draft curtain
and spaced between 150mm and 305mm from the draft curtain.
Finish
Class A
0-25
0-450
N/A
Class B
26-75
0-450
N/A
Class C
76-200
0-450
N/A
All internal linings require test evidence or certification that demonstrates that they comply with the above
tables.
Wherever the use of Class C interior wall and ceiling is required Class A or Class B shall be permitted. Where
Class B interior wall and ceiling finish is required Class A shall be permitted.
This strategy accounts for the building being protected by a fire sprinkler system throughout, in conjunction with
the exclusion of sprinkler protection for the glass roof.
Where the service opening is within the mall atrium volume, the service opening protection is not required.
1.1.3
Means of Egress
Means of egress for the mall expansion will be in accordance with the following section. The strategy also
addresses areas where the mall expansion interfaces with the existing mall and the impact on the existing
malls means of egress.
Net occupiable area for assembly spaces, gross area for all other spaces.
Occupant load factors are selected based on the characteristic use of the space, and not the occupancy
classification of the space. The occupant load factors are summarised in the table below which reflects the
uses of the mall expansion.
For the purpose of determining the occupant load of the mall and associate required exit capacity, NFPA 101
2
Figure 7.3.1.2(b) has been utilized. An occupant load factor of 5.1m /person is applicable based on the total
2
Gross Leasable Area (GLA) being approximately 61,000m
Table 7: Summary of occupant load factors
Usage
Factor (m2/person)
Prayer rooms
0.65 (net)
0.65 (net)
1.4 (net)
The interior finishes provided within the building will have a minimum classification as identifies in the following
locations:
2.8
5.6
Figure 2: Sprinkler and downstand method for protecting circulation stairs and escalators.
Usage
Factor (m2/person)
Mall Building
5.1
9.3
Storage, Parking
27.9
Detailed calculations of available capacity and occupant load will be provided as part of the Fire Strategy
Drawings.
Figure 3: Existing mall lower ground floor exit relocation to mall expansion.
The existing Level 01 exit from the Fashion Avenue Atrium currently discharges to the exterior at the Fashion
Avenue drop-off, following completion of the expansion this exit to the exterior will no longer be available, as
illustrated in Figure 4 below. Consequently, the egress requirements from the Mall Expansion have been
designed to cater for the occupants from the existing mall who were originally served by this exit (3600mm is
the total width of the exits per the original as built drawings of the existing mall) in addition to the occupant load
calculated for the expansion.
Three key locations of the mall expansion interface with the means of egress of the existing mall. These
locations are as follows:
Lower Ground Floor exit, adjacent to current More Caf, to the promenade of existing mall to be converted
to new retail unit.
Stairs 36 and 37 serving the car park/medical centre that currently discharge to the exterior.
The existing Lower Ground Floor egress route, highlighted in Figure 3, has been replaced by a retail unit, and
as a consequence the egress requirements from the mall expansion will cater for occupants from the mall
expansion in addition to occupants from the existing mall who were originally served by this exit.
The exact number of occupants utilizing those doors could not be determined based on the current fire
strategy. Therefore, the mall expansion will cater for the exit width provided in the original mall as built
drawings, which are a total 2400mm of door exit width. The exit width has been distributed throughout the mall
expansion exits.
For swinging doors, between the face of the door and the stop
Side-hinged or pivoted-swinging type doors shall swing in the direction of egress travel in the following cases:
Where serving a room or an area with an occupant load of 50 or more (UFC C3 3.7.3)
Revolving doors are not permitted as a component in the means of egress (UFC C3 3.12.1)
Stairs 36 and 37 that currently serve the car park areas and the medical centre will not be accounted for
capacity since the mall expansion has been provided with its own capacity. However, the existing stairs will be
accounted for to meet travel distance requirements. The stairs will discharge to a separate compartment at
Ground Level and such compartment will serve as an exit passageway and lead to the exterior.
Doors will be designed to meet the limits of encroachment/projection into the required exit width within stairs as
follows:
1.1.3.4 Doors
Minimum door dimensions will be provided as follows:
Table 8: Door dimensional criteria
Feature
Minimum Door Width
Maximum Required Door Width Capacity
Dimensional Criteria
915mm
5mm per person
13mm
13mm
915mm
180mm
Every door and every principal entrance that is required to serve as an exit shall be designed and constructed
so that the path of egress travel is obvious and direct.
A doors clear width shall be measured as follows:
1.1.3.5 Stairs
Minimum stair dimension will be provided as follows:
Table 9: Stair dimensional criteria
Feature
Dimensional Criteria
1200mm
3660mm
Riser height
Tread Depth
280mm
Headroom
2030mm
1.1.3.7 Corridors
Exit access corridors are sized to accommodate the largest calculated occupant load when applying 5mm per
person or a minimum width as follows:
1200mm
General - 1200mm
The required capacity of a corridor shall be the occupant load that utilises the corridor for exit access divided by
the number of exits to which the corridor connects. However, the corridor capacity shall not be less than the
required capacity of the exit to which the corridor leads.
Handrails are provided on each side of stairs and ramps in accordance with the dimensional criteria shown in
Figure 7
Rooms with service equipment, janitor closets, and service elevators are permitted to open into the exit
passageway
In addition, where multiple stairs converge into an exit passageway to discharge to the exterior, the exit
passageway will be sized to accommodate the aggregate occupant load of all stairs discharging into it.
Furthermore, where the exit passageway serves a stair that has occupant flow from both below and above the
discharge level, the passageway is to be sized to serve the converging number of occupants from both
directions (UFC C3 11.6.3.1).
1.1.3.9 Ramps
Minimum stair dimensions will be provided in accordance with the table below:
Feature
Where stairs serve above grade and basement levels, a fire rated separation is required at the level of exit
discharge where the flows from above and below converge, Figure 9 refers
1200mm
Scissor or interlocking stairs count as a single exit and shall be separated from each other by a 2 hour fire
resistance rating. Openings or penetrations between the stairs will be required to be provided to achieve the
stair pressurization requirements.
114mm
1 in 12
10
Dimensional Criteria
Feature
Dimensional Criteria
Occupancy
1 in 48
760mm
1220mm
1.1.3.13
1.1.3.10
Common Path of
Travel (m)
The number of exits required is dependent on the design occupant load. The mall pedestrian way provides the
required number of exits based on occupants. In addition, each tenant unit will meet the following requirements:
91
30
30
122
Exit Discharge
Stairs that continue more than one-half story beyond the level of exit discharge shall be interrupted at the level
of exit discharge by partitions, doors, or other effective means (UFC C3 6.5.2) to help prevent occupants
escaping from floors above the level of exit discharge continuing down into the basement levels and vice versa.
Figure 9 illustrates the acceptable separation method to meet this requirement.
Number of Exits
1
15
This option of interior stair discharge is being considered for Stair 36 or Stair 37 if the exit passageway to the
exterior is unfeasible.
Class C units where distance to exit or mall not in excess of 30m and
occupant load not exceeding 100
30
Stair discharge to the interior (such as mall exits into Lower Ground) of the building is not permitted per the
UFC due to the pressurization of stairs and the requirement for pressurized stairs to discharge directly to the
exterior (UFC C3 5.2.19.3). NFPA 101 allows up to 50% of stairs to discharge to the interior of the building,
which must be noted to be a fundamental strategy of the existing mall fire strategy.
Number of Exits
Feature
Business
Occupant load more than 500 but not more than 1000
1.1.3.11
Exit Separation
Where two exits or exit access doors are required, they shall be located at a distance from one another not less
than one-third of the maximum overall diagonal dimension of the building or area to be served, measured in a
straight line between the nearest edge of the exit doors or exit access doors (UFC C3 7.4.1).
Figure 9: Stair separation at exit discharge level
Where more than two exits or exit access doors are required, at least two of the required exits or exit access
doors shall be arranged to comply with the minimum separation distance requirement.
1.1.3.14
1.1.3.12
Illumination of means of egress should be provided in accordance with the requirements contained in NFPA
101 section 7.8.
Travel Distance
The maximum allowable travel distance limit from any point of the building to an exit is as follows:
Table 12: Travel distance requirements per occupancy
Occupancy
Common Path of
Travel (m)
Emergency Lighting
Emergency lighting systems will be designed and installed in accordance with Chapter 6 of the UFC.
Assembly 50 People
23
15
76
Assembly 50 People
6.1
6.1
76
6.1
6.1
76
30
15
76
30
15
61
1.1.3.15
The emergency lighting facilities will be required to be arranged to provide initial illumination that is not less
than an average of 10.8 lux and at any point not less than 1.1 lux, measured along the path of egress at floor
level. Illumination levels will be permitted to decline to not less than an average of 6.5 lux and at any point not
less than 0.65 lux at the end of the 90 minutes. A maximum-to-minimum illumination uniformity ratio of 40 to 1
will not be required to be exceeded (UFC C6 4).
11
The fire alarm will broadcast an alert signal throughout the unit of fire origin. No alarm will sound in the mall
or adjacent units;
Nominated staff within the tenancy will begin to investigate the alarm. A grace period of 3 minutes (subject
to confirmation by the management of the tenancy) will be allocated to determine whether or not the fire
alarm is false;
An alert signal will be sent to the ECC to alert the building management that an incident has occurred;
Means of egress for limited mobility occupants will be provided in accordance with the UFC which directly
references NFPA 101 as the applicable code (UFC C14)
If the management of the tenancy confirm a false alarm, then the signal can be cancelled in the unit;
As per Appendix note A3.3.22 of NFPA 101, the American National Standard for Accessible and Usable
Buildings and Facilities any floor in a building protected throughout by an approved, supervised automatic
sprinkler system can be considered as an area of refuge. This recognition acknowledges the ability of a
properly designed and functioning automatic sprinkler system to control a fire at its point of origin and to limit
the production of toxic products to a level that is not life threatening.
If the building management confirm a false alarm, then the alarm can be cancelled by them at the main fire
alarm control panel (MFAP) located in the ECC Smoke control system to be reset;
Should any additional detector activate in the unit, alarm will sound for unit to evacuate. This will also
happen if the management investigation period expires;
Based on the above, areas of refuge within stairs will not be provided.
If two means of smoke detection activate in the mall evacuation zone then the smoke control systems will
activate in the zone, including the opening of entrance doors for the supply of inlet air, as required.
Elevators will return to discharge level where the doors will open, unless a fire is detected at discharge
level in the evacuation zone in which the elevator is located, under this scenario the elevator will home to
the level above and the doors will open;
1.1.3.16
Exit Signage
Means of Egress shall be provided with signs in accordance with UFC Chapter 5. Exits other than main exterior
exits clearly identifiable as exits, shall be marked by an approved sign that is readily visible from any direction
of exit access.
1.1.3.17
1.1.4
The mall expansion is segregated into the following smoke zones which will coincide with the evacuation
strategy:
Activation of an additional detector in any mall zone/tenant unit or parking zone will result in simultaneous
evacuation of the entire mall and parking structure.
(b)
Sprinkler activation in a tenancy and mall: The fire alarm will broadcast an evacuation signal throughout the evacuation zone [mall and units
connected to the evacuation zone];
An alert signal will be sent to the ECC to alert building management that an incident has occurred;
A confirmed fire for the mall expansion and parking structure is defined as follows:-
Mall Building
Mall smoke control systems will activate, including the opening of entrance doors for the supply of inlet air,
as required, unless a tenant unit fire has activated first.
Elevators will return to ground floor level where the doors will open, unless a fire is detected at ground floor
level in the evacuation zone in which the elevator is located, under this scenario the elevator will home to
the level above and the doors will open;
Activation of an additional sprinkler zone in any mall zone/tenant unit or parking zone will result in
simultaneous evacuation of the entire mall and parking structure.
Activation of a sprinkler
Parking Structure
A confirmed fire in the parking structure will be instigated by the following:
Activation of a sprinkler
An alert signal will be sent to the ECC to alert building management that an incident has occurred;
Elevators will return to exit discharge level where the doors will open, unless a fire is detected at the
discharge level in the evacuation zone in which the elevator is located, under this scenario the elevator will
home to the level above and the doors will open;
12
Activation of an additional manual call point in any mall zone/tenant unit or parking zone will result in
simultaneous evacuation of the entire mall and parking structure.
(d)
Smoke detection activation in the mall: A supervisory signal will be sent to the ECC to alert the building management that an incident has
occurred. No alarm will sound in the evacuation zone;
If the building management confirm a false alarm, then the signal can be cancelled by them at the MFAP
located in the ECC;
Should any additional detector activate in the evacuation zone then the mall and all units connected to the
evacuation zone will evacuate. This will also happen if the management investigation period runs out;
Smoke control systems will activate in the relevant zone, including the opening of entrance doors for the
supply of inlet air.
Elevators will return to exit discharge level where the doors will open, unless a fire is detected at exit
discharge level in the evacuation zone in which the elevator is located, under this scenario the elevator will
home to the level above and the doors will open;
Activation of an additional smoke detector in another mall zone/tenant unit or parking zone will result in
simultaneous evacuation of the entire mall and parking structure.
(e)
Manual Alarm Call Point activation in the mall: The fire alarm will broadcast an evacuation signal throughout the evacuation zone, including the units and
mall area;
An alert signal will be sent to the ECC to warn the building management that an incident has occurred;
Smoke control systems will activate in the relevant zone, including the opening of entrance doors for the
supply of inlet air.
Elevators will return to exit discharge level where the doors will open, unless a fire is detected at exit
discharge level in the evacuation zone in which the elevator is located, under this scenario the elevator will
home to the level above and the doors will open;
Activation of an additional manual call point in any mall zone/tenant unit or parking zone will result in
simultaneous evacuation of the entire mall and parking structure.
13
LGF
At The Top
Zone 3
Zone 4
BV-L03
Zone 4
Zone 5
BV
BV Individual Units
Zone 5
Zone 6
GF
GF Individual Units
Zone 6
Zone 7
L01
Zone 7
Zone 8
L02
L02Individual Units
Zone 8
Zone 9
L03
Zone 9
Carpark Zone 1
P1
Carpark
Carpark Zone 2
P2
Carpark
Carpark Zone 3
P3
Carpark
Carpark Zone 4
P4
Carpark
Carpark Zone 5
P5
Carpark
Carpark Zone 6
P6
Carpark
Carpark Zone 7
P7
Carpark
Carpark Zone 8
P8
Carpark
Carpark Zone 9
P9
Carpark
Carpark Zone 10
P10
Carpark
Carpark Zone 11
P11
Carpark
LGF
Adjacent Property
Existing Mall
BV-L02
Adjacent Property
Existing Mall
Metro Link
P7
Adjacent Property
Metro Link
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
14
Figure 10: Evacuation matrix based on confirmed fire, where X is a confirmed alarm and O denotes alert
Metro Link
Zone 3
Carpark Zone 11
Carpark Zone 10
Zone 2
Carpark Zone 9
Mall
Carpark Zone 8
LGF
Carpark Zone 7
Carpark Zone 6
Zone 2
Carpark Zone 5
Zone 5
O
Carpark Zone 4
Zone 4
O
Carpark Zone 3
Zone 3
X
Carpark Zone 2
Zone 2
X
Carpark Zone 1
Zone 1
X
Zone 9
FAZ
Zone 1
Zone 8
Reference Name
Food Court
Zone 7
Floors Connected
LGF
Zone 6
X
X
1.1.5
pressure according to the hydraulic calculation to supply fire water demand of the system as detailed in section
6.1.4.3 above.
The fire pumps shall be of Centrifugal type and will be dedicated and reliable as described in NFPA 20. The fire
pumps shall be located in dedicated sprinkler protected rooms enclosed with 1 hour fire rated barriers.
A fire alarm system will be provided for the project which includes smoke detection and manual call points
throughout (UFC C8 1.1).
The fire pumps and their associated piping and electrical systems shall be in accordance with the UFC, NFPA
20, NFPA 70 and NFPA 72.
Activation of the mall pedestrian way smoke control system will be achieved by a combination of beam
detection and aspiration smoke detection system.
The area of the project classifies it as Category 5 with respect to alarm monitoring and notification. Civil
Defence provides a remote monitoring service (RMS) in which they are notified in the event of an alarm. This
will require a special Civil Defence Alarm Panel to be installed for the mall and dedicated panel for each
tenancy unit.
Common
Design Criteria/Parameters
Reference
Elevator lobbies, hoist ways, and elevator machine rooms will be provided with smoke or heat detection to
initiate fire fighter elevator recall (UFC C8 28). Recall is to follow procedures of UFC Chapter 2 Section 15.
Fire hydrants shall comply with the UFC requirements as outlined below.
A Class III Standpipe/Wet Riser System, installed in accordance with NFPA14, is required for the mall
expansion (UFC C9 4.9.1). The hose stations for the Class III system include a 65 mm hose landing valve and
25mm fire hose rack, which are to be located within exit stair shafts near the entrance to each storey and roof
areas or inside a 2-hour rated protected shaft. NFPA recommends that landing valves are provided at the midlanding inside the exit staircases.
The existing public fire hydrant provision has been determined to provide for the required coverage; however
some minor relocation is required.
Spacing between the public fire hydrants shall be maintained at a maximum of 120m after relocations have
been completed (UFC C2 5.2(i))
The hose stations will be required to be installed such that all portions of each floor level will be within 30
meters of a hose connection (UFC C9 4.9.2). Additional hose reels will be required to be provided by the tenant
in cases where the 30m coverage of the provided hose reels is exceeded due to the retail unit fit out.
Every part of the fire engine access road shall be within an unobstructed distance of 60m away from a fire
hydrant (UFC C2 6.4(iv)).
The fire water storage will be located at the lowest level (Basement) in a combined potable and fire water
storage tank. The design will be in accordance with NFPA 22 and will be constructed from RCC complete with
two (2) equal compartments and supplied with appropriate isolation facilities and segregation to allow periodic
cleaning and maintenance works. The suction connections shall be arranged as such that the minimum fire
water reserve shall always be available for use irrespective of the potable water demand.
Portable Fire Extinguishers 1x DCP and 1x CO2 types each with 4.5 kg capacity
A 2 (65mm ) landing valve / hose connection (standpipe) shall also be provided at full landing level
inside each exit stair enclosure for fire department use. A separate system riser, connected from the fire pump
manifold (with control/alarm check valve assembly) shall be provided to supply thewet standpipe system.
The following fire water supplies will be provided to serve all the fire fighting systems within the Dubai Mall
Expansion:
Building/Area
60 minutes
The design criteria for the standpipe and hose reel system shall be as follows:
Type of Standpipe
Reference
NFPA 14
All areas
Class III
UFC C9 4.9.1
15
Where the static pressure at a hose connection exceeds 12.1 bar, an approved
pressure regulating device will be provided to limit static and residual pressures
at the outlet of the hose connection to 12.1 bar (175 psi)
Rooms /
Refuse
Group 1
79C
Sprinkler system zone control valve (AZCV) provision: On each zone (and each floor within zone)
NFPA 13: C8
Sprinkler system components will be rated for the maximum system working pressure to
NFPA 13: C6
which they are exposed but will not be rated at less than 12.1 bar for aboveground components
The sprinkler pipe network is to be designed and zoned such that the tenant supply can be maintained, tested,
and interrupted without interrupting the supply to the rest of the mall.
The main sprinkler system will be a wet pipe system wherein a dedicated sprinkler riser (with control/alarm
check valve assembly) will be provided to cover each individual fire zone in the building (ten zones in total). All
control valves and system risers will be supplied and connected from a common manifold within the fire pump
room. In addition, fire zones on all levels will be provided with an Automatic Zone Control Valve assembly
(AZCV) that comprises of a supervised control valve, water flow alarm switch, pressure gauges and test/drain
valve connection.
The roof skylight of the mall pedestrian way is not exempt from sprinkler protection per neither UFC nor NFPA.
However, sprinkler protection from the skylight has been omitted based on the following:
Undetermined sprinkler activation time and efficiency due to the height of the skylight,
WSP in conjunction with the design team discussed with DCD adopting a performance based design
approach
Normal glass failure is expected between 150 and 200 degrees Celsius, of which computer model show a
maximum exposure of approximately 75 degrees Celsius due to smoke control exhausting hot gases
Concealed Pendent Sprinkler installed in areas where false ceiling is available (i.e. Mall front of house
areas, corridor, lobby, other light hazard occupancy areas).
Upright Sprinkler installed in areas where false ceiling is not available (i.e. car parks, storage and
mechanical plant rooms).
Sidewall Sprinkler installed in areas where piping across the ceiling is not desirable due to aesthetics or
building construction considerations (i.e. elevator shafts)
1.1.5.8 Manual Suppression
The sprinkler system including system valves/gauges should have access provision (i.e. removable / access
panels, doors, etc.) for operation, inspection, test and maintenance activities in accordance with NFPA 13:
8.1.2. The tenant is required to provide a visible sign indication the location of the unit sprinkler valve.
Hand held / portable fire extinguishers shall be provided throughout the Mall Expansion area in accordance
with UFC Chapter 4 and NFPA 10. Portable fire extinguishers, complete with monthly inspection tags, shall be
kept in a fully charged condition.
A pre-action sprinkler system will be provided to serve the lift machine rooms (UFC C9 Table 9.2). From the
fire pump system manifold, a separate connection will be provided to supply the pre-action sprinkler system
Occupancy
Classification
Design
Density
(lpm/m2)
Area of
Operati
on (m2)
Max.
Sprinkler
Coverage
Sprinkler Types
Standards Reference
DCP and CO2 types, each with a capacity of 4.5 kg Installed in retail units, back of house areas, plant
rooms, light and ordinary hazard occupancy areas.
Wet chemical type, each with a capacity of 6.0 L - Installed in kitchen areas
(m2)
Common
Design Criteria/Parameters
Reference
NFPA 10.6.2
Mall
Pedestrian
Way
Ordinary Hazard
Group 1
Entrance
Lobbies
Light Hazard
4.1
139
20.9
Shop Units
Ordinary Hazard
Group 2
8.1
139
12.1
Offices
Light Hazard
4.1
139
20.9
1.1.5.9
Carpark /
Loading
Docks
Ordinary Hazard
Group 1
6.1
139
12.1
In areas where water based suppression is considered undesirable by the UFC due to potential of damage to
equipment, i.e. main electrical rooms and telecom rooms, a clean agent gas suppression system shall be
provided. The system shall be an engineered total flooding system; the design and installation shall be in
accordance with the UFC and NFPA 2001.
Server
Room
Ordinary Hazard
Group 1
6.1
139
12.1
Storage
Ordinary Hazard
Group 2
8.1
139
12.1
Prayer
Rooms
Light Hazard
4.1
139
20.9
Toilets
Light Hazard
4.1
139
20.9
Plant / MEP
Ordinary Hazard
6.1
139
12.1
6.1
139
12.1
Common
All rooms with un-closable openings, louvers, etc. shall be provided with listed and approved fire dampers and
shutters to ensure the integrity of the system.
The rooms to be served by the clean agent fire suppression system have been identified as part of the fire
protection drawings and the system will be designed by a specialist contractor.
UFC C9
16
The proposed strategy is a performance based design approach that has been discussed with DCD and in
principle they have no objection to.
A foam-water suppression system shall be provided in generator rooms and where large quantities of diesel
fuel are to be stored. The system shall be designed in accordance with the UFC, NFPA 11, 11A, 15 and NFPA
16.
From the fire pump system manifold, a separate connection will be provided to supply the foam-water
suppression system. Dedicated control valves (Electric Actuation type) including foam equipment and
accessories (i.e. foam bladder tank, foam proportioner, etc.) shall be provided and shall be located within the
fire pump room.
1.1.6
Smoke Control
Various smoke control systems will be provided as required by the UAE Fire Code, Civil Defence
Requirements, and NFPA 101. A summary of the required systems is provided below:
Table 13: Smoke Control Requirements
Area
Requirement Reference
3
NFPA 101/NFPA 92
Stairs
Pressurisation
Corridors
UFC C10
UFC C10
1.1.7
UFC C10
3
UFC C10
The UFC provides specific requirements with respect to smoke control for large volume and atria which is not
specific to malls. However, NFPA 101 provides a comprehensive set of requirements for malls which includes
smoke control. Therefore, a strategy has been developed for the design of the mall smoke control in
accordance with NFPA 101 36.4.4 in addition to the minimum atrium requirements of the UFC. In addition, the
strategy is per the 19 September 2013 smoke control strategy presentation to Emaar.
The system will provide:
A mechanical smoke control system will be designed with the intent to maintain tenable conditions 1.83m
above the highest occupied floor served by the specific smoke control system.
Base exhaust rates calculated in accordance with the methodology of NFPA 92 and further developed by a
computer fire and smoke model analysis.
The following smoke control strategy has been developed for the Mall Pedestrian Way Smoke Zone:
A single dedicated zone for the mall pedestrian way from Boulevard Level to Level 03.
Goal is to control smoke for fires from Boulevard Level to Level 03.
In order to mitigate smoke spill from any of the individual retail units into the mall, a dedicated smoke
3
control system will be provided for each unit at a rate of 15m /s. Smoke spill into the mall from these units
would increase mall smoke exhaust volumes by a factor of 3.
The preliminary smoke control design calculations per NPA 92 and further developed with the aid of a
Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) study. 10,000 kilowatt fire within the mall pedestrian way
Single smoke zone with extract distributed over 20 locations at high level calculated at 176m /s
The smoke control strategy for Level 3 is based on permitting spill into the main mall pedestrian way smoke
control system.
17
Make-up air will be provided passively via exit doors (4 x 3400mm door openings at Boulevard Level and 4
x 1800mm wide doors at LGF Lakeside) operating upon alarm. The remaining make-up air requirements
will be provided from the connections to the interior of the adjacent mall.
Pass/fail criteria based on visibility and exposure to heat measured 1.83m above highest occupied level for
20 minutes.
(b)
F&B and Retail Units
The following smoke control strategy has been developed for the Lower Ground Floor (LGF) Smoke Zone:
Goal is to mitigate smoke spill into adjacent existing mall, food court zone, and upper levels of the mall
expansion.
The design fire for the mall circulation area (code compliant value of 5,000 kilowatts) accounts for unit
design fires. Smoke from individual units will be controlled by the LGF zone smoke control system.
Units will be separated from each other by 1 hour fire rating to prevent fire and smoke spread between
units. Partition to extend full height of the unit from finished floor to underside of ceiling slab).
LGF Zone to be considered a single smoke zone with an exhaust rate of 21m /s accounting for F&B units.
(c)
At The Top
3
The At The Top space will also have a dedicated smoke control system capable of exhausting 21m /s.
1.1.7.3 Retail Units Boulevard Level, Ground, Level 01, and Level 02
All retail and F&B units located on Boulevard to Level 2, regardless of size or use, will be required to be
provided with dedicated mechanical exhaust. Smoke control requirements for the different units, based on:
Figure 12: Mall atrium model showing exhaust points at high level.
Kitchens will be provided with the Mall Regulations required 1 hour fire rated enclosure and therefore
dedicated unit smoke control is not required.
The design fire for the Food court to calculate the required exhaust (code compliant value of 5,000
kilowatts) accounts for F&B unit design fires. Smoke from individual units will be controlled by the Lower
Food Court zone smoke control system.
F&B unit frontage will not require smoke downstand or separation for smoke control due to opening
frontage area.
F&B Units will be separated from each other by 1 hour fire rating to prevent fire and smoke spread between
units. Partition to extend full height of the unit from finished floor to underside of ceiling slab).
The 5.5m clear height from floor to finished ceiling interface between the Food Court Smoke Zone, mall
expansion, and existing mall will be provided with downstands to create the Food Court Smoke Zone
reservoir which separates it from adjacent zones. A non-rated partition will also be provided within the
ceiling void to prevent spread to adjacent zones via the void.
Food court to be considered a single smoke zone with an exhaust rate of 21m /s, which accounts F&B
units.
Exhaust air per unit of 15m /s, where a single fan will serve multiple units and activates in unit of fire origin
only
60% make up air is provided mechanically, via leakage from frontage, and from the normal frontage door
openings (if provided)
If unit to mall interface frontage is designed to be open, the following criteria must be met:
(a)
Food Court Zone
The following smoke control strategy has been developed for the Food Court Smoke Zone:
Goal is to mitigate smoke spill into adjacent existing mall and mall expansion
The openness of the frontage is flexible and dependant of the design intent of the tenant. However, in order for
the dedicated retail unit smoke control to function as intended.
The Lower Ground Floor will be divided into 3 smoke control zones; Food Court Smoke Zone, Retail Smoke
Zone, and At The Top Smoke Control Zone.
Where the unit has a total height of more than 5m, the maximum opening permitted is a height of 4m. Such
maximum opening can be achieved implementing fixed or descending smoke downstand from the finished
ceiling level for the remainder of the frontage in excess of 4m.
Where the unit has a total height of 5m or less, a fixed or descending smoke downstand with a minimum
1m depth will be required.
The frontage section above the downstands will be provided by the tenant with a non-combustible
separation to the mall in order to restrict smoke spread from the ceiling void.
18
Figure 13: Section of retail units depicting frontage design criteria for units with floor to ceiling heights 5m or
greater
Figure 14: Section of retail units depicting frontage design criteria for units with floor to ceiling heights less than
5m
Figure 15: Indicative strategy for separation between retail and F&B units
19
The downstands can be permanent architectural features of the frontage such as glass, incorporated into the
door frame, solid construction or alternatively, downstands can be temporary. Temporary solutions include
smoke curtains that activate on fire alarm only and are normally retracted.
units), it is anticipated to be evacuated before the visibility limit decreases below 10m, travel distances are
compliant with code,
Figure 16: Options for temporary (smoke curtain) and permanent (fixed glass) smoke downstands.
1.1.8
The following is a summary of the inputs and results of the CFD analysis.
1.1.8.4 Connection to the Existing Mall
The mall expansion is being designed as a separate smoke zone from the existing mall. The CFD analysis has
shown that smoke spread between the existing mall and the expansion will be mitigated by the resulting
opposing airflows to smoke caused by activating the mall smoke exhaust system.
1.1.8.1 Objectives
The goal of the smoke management is to maintain safe conditions a minimum of 1.83m above the highest
unprotected opening for a period of 1.5 x egress time or 20 minutes (whichever is greater). Safe conditions will
be evaluated as a Pass/fail tenability criteria of maintaining a minimum 10m visibility and maximum 60 degrees
Celsius exposure to heat.
1.1.9
The enclosed car park will be provided with a smoke purge system, independent from other building smoke
control, capable of exhausting a minimum of 9 air changes per hour. System is to operate automatically upon
fire alarm activation and have the capability of manual override (UFC 10 28.7.1.i/ii and UFC 10 31.1).
Building geometry
10,000kW design fire size, located at Boulevard Level and one at Ground Level
186m /s smoke exhaust vent distribution locations per MEP and architecture proposed design
Temporary or permanent kiosks will not be considered tenant spaces and will meet the following:
4 sets of 1800mm doors at Lower Ground (promenade) Level for passive make up air
2 sets of 1200mm doors at Lower Ground (promenade) Level for passive make up air
Constructed of fire-retardant-treated wood, code compliant light transmitting plastics, UL 1975 rated
foamed plastic with a maximum heat release rate of 100kW, metal composite materials, or NFPA 701
compliant textiles and films.
The new car park portions will be provided with a new ducted system.
Existing car park sections that are being refurbished and currently equipped with a jet or impulse fan system
will be provided with an upgraded replace in kind impulse fan system.
20
Fire pump
Smoke control systems, inclusive of all equipment such as fan motors and motorized dampers.
1.1.12
1.1.12.1
Breeching Inlets
Breeching inlets shall be located on the external wall above ground level nearest to the vertical run of the
standpipe and should be visible and recognisable from the nearest point of fire department access.
The breeching inlets shall not be sited more than 18m away from the fire engine access road (UFC C2 4.1)
The breeching inlets shall be located not more than 100 ft (30.5 m) from the nearest fire hydrant connected to
an approved water supply. (NFPA 14 6.4.5.4)
2 sets of breeching inlets have been provided for the mall expansion. One set of breeching inlets is provided at
the Boulevard side at the Northeast corner of the building and the other set of inlets is provided at the
promenade side at the Southeast side of the building (UFC C9 4.19.2 and 4.19.3).
The Figures above outline the turning provisions required for the fire vehicle access road around the Dubai
Expansion Mall. These shall be implemented for existing or potentially new roads in order for the fire vehicle to
have sufficient turning spaces in the event of a fire scenario.
Each set of breeching inlets will consist of two (2). four-way (4) type complete with listed non return/check
valves. One breeching inlet in each set will connect to the sprinkler / standpipe manifold (marked
SPRINKLER/STANDPIPE), with the other feeding into the fire water tank (marked FIRE TANK) (UFC C9
Figure 9.6 & NFPA 13 8.6.1.1)
1.1.12.3
1.1.12.2
Fire Department vehicular access roads are required to extend a certain distance around the perimeter of the
building so the necessary access required for Civil Defence is achievable by making use of the existing and
approved access paths. Any proposed changes to the access has been coordinated with DCD.
For Midrise to Highrise buildings for mercantile occupancies exceeding the habitable height of 15 m, an
accessway shall be provided. Accessway shall be provided based on the gross floor area (including toilets,
stores, circulation areas, etc.) of the largest floor in the building as shown in UFC C2 13.6
All fire vehicle access roads shall have a minimum unobstructed width between curbs of 6m.
For buildings with a gross area greater than 32,000m , the UAE fire code requires full perimeter access.
Therefore, the fire service access road will be designed such that it provides full perimeter access to the entire
building, inclusive of the existing and expansion portions of the mall.
Vertical Clearance
Access roads shall have an unobstructed vertical clearance of not less than 4.5m.
The service road adjacent to the office annex will form part of the full perimeter fire service access road which
will be linked to the promenade perimeter access. Figure 19 shows the proposed access route. The route will
be further developed as necessary based on the landscape architectural requirements.
Maximum 15m
Grade
The angle of approach and departure for any fire vehicle access road shall not exceed 10%
Dead-end fire vehicle access roads in excess of 45m in length shall be provided with turning provisions.
Turning Radius
The inner radius of a turning facility on the fire vehicle access road shall be minimum of 7m as illustrated in
Figure 18
Stationery Load
The fire vehicle access road shall be designed to sustain the stationary load of a 41-ton standard fire appliance
and 81 tons for a high reach appliance.
21
Figure 19: Service road which will function as service access road with connection to the promenade
1.1.12.4
An Emergency Command Centre is provided within the existing mall and will be provided with communication
to a new command centre in the expansion. The mall expansion fire command centre will be located adjacent
to the fire fighting core (Stair 6) on the Boulevard Level and will be in accordance with UFC C2 15.7
2
A minimum area of 20m will be provided with no dimension measuring less than 2440mm.
The Emergency Command Centre shall include the following:
Communication system to fire fighting lobby, elevator machine room, areas of refuge, and air-handling
control rooms.
1.1.12.5
The mall is classified as a high rise building in accordance with the UFC, therefore, a fighting core will be
required consisting of a fire fighting elevator and protected stair which are connected via a common fire fighting
lobby per UFC C2 15.1.
2
The fire fighting lobby shall have a clear floor area of not less than 5 m .
The clear floor area should not exceed 20 m for spaces serving up to four lifts or 5 m per lift for spaces
serving more than four lifts per UFC C2 15.5. The core on the Boulevard end which contains Elevator SE-05
and Stair 06 will serve as the fire fighting core.
22
3
Appendix A - CFD Report
2
The UAE fire code limits smoke zones to a maximum plan area of 2600m2. However, it was discussed with
Dubai Civil Defence on a meeting held 7 July 2013 that the intent of the expansion was to follow the strategy of
the current mall in which zones depend on architecture and feasibility of smoke management. Civil Defence
had no objection to the proposed strategy.
Introduction
2.1
Scope
WSP UK have been appointed to provide computer modelling support to WSP Middle East on the Dubai Mall
Expansion project in Dubai, UAE. WSP UK have undertaken a Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) analysis
to support the WSP Fire Strategy and demonstrate adequate performance of the proposed smoke control
solution.
The project is an expansion to the existing Dubai Mall designed and built in accordance with NFPA 101, 2002
Edition for Performance Based Design. The Dubai Mall Expansion is designed in accordance with the existing
mall fire strategy with reference to NFPA 101 2012 edition and the UAE Fire & Life Safety Code of Practice
2011.
A single smoke control zone and smoke extract system will be provided to manage smoke from fires in
the mall pedestrian way (ie. Kiosk fires);
Dedicated smoke control for tenant units to mitigate spill into the mall;
Interface to the existing mall (Fashion Avenue Atrium) to mitigate smoke spread via opposed air flow to
smoke induced as a source for make up air when smoke control system activates;
High level smoke extraction is distributed evenly at roof level around the perimeter of the expansion zone
across 22 smoke exhaust points.
3
Objectives
Demonstrate the required volumetric smoke exhaust rate to maintain tenable conditions at a minimum of
2m above the highest occupied floor (Level 3),
Determine the impact of smoke conditions to the existing mall at the interface locations.
2.3
3.1
As required by NFPA 101 Section 36.4.4.9, smoke control will be provided for the mall since it connects more
than 2 floors, the objective of the CFD analysis is to demonstrate the required volumetric exhaust rates
required to maintain tenability in the mall pedestrian way.
2.2
8 m /s at each vent
Acceptance Criteria
The design is based on standard performance criteria for human tenability, the design is deemed acceptable
provided tenable conditions are maintained at least 1.83m (2.0m maintained for this analysis) above the
highest occupied level open to the mall for occupant escape. Tenability criteria for visibility distance and
temperature will be used to assess performance.
The following tenability criteria will be applied:
Temperatures no greater than 60C in occupied zone (due to vapour from sprinkler suppression systems)
These values are common to IFEG, SFPE and British Standards and can be used to define the smoke layer
tenability limits for occupant escape. CFD results will assess the tenability criteria at 2m above each storey
level as an effective head height.
Radiation and smoke layer temperature will not be considered as due to the presence of a sprinkler system to
cool the smoke, the heat radiation is not considered as significant criteria when compared to the spread of cool,
visibility obscuring smoke as a predictor of untenable conditions within a zone.
Results will be presented as a visual timeline as well as graphed for the full simulation period of 20 minutes.
23
Replacement air is to be provided from exits to external air on the boulevard and lake side, and from the
adjacent existing Fashion Atrium mall. No mechanical supply air is to be specified. All replacement air is
supplied from below the smoke layer.
FDS solves numerically a form of the Navier-Stokes equations appropriate for low-speed, thermally-driven ow
with an emphasis on smoke and heat transport from res. The core algorithm is an explicit predictor-corrector
scheme that is second order accurate in space and time.
All units in Ground Level, Level 01, and Level 02 will be provided with dedicated in unit smoke control.
Turbulence is treated by means of the Smagorinsky form of Large Eddy Simulation (LES).
The mall expansion smoke zone will be connected to the existing fashion avenue atrium by walkways. Smoke
spread from a fire in the mall expansion is mitigated during the mall expansion smoke control system activation
by mean of the induced airflow by the make-up air.
Two referenced documents are available from the NIST website which detail all relevant verification and
validation studies for FDS.
The latest version of the software has been used in this study, version 5.5.3.
3.2
Suppression
Retail units are equipped with sprinkler suppression. Sprinklers are designed to activate at a temperature of
0.5
68C with an RTI of 50(m/s) . Sprinklers will be in accordance with NFPA 13.
Modelling Methodology
4.1
The Fire Dynamics Simulator (FDS) is used for this modelling study. FDS is a Computational Fluid Dynamics
(CFD) model of re-driven uid ow. The model solves numerically a form of the Navier-Stokes equations
appropriate for low-speed, thermally-driven ow with an emphasis on smoke and heat transport from res. The
partial derivatives of the conservation equations of mass, momentum and energy are approximated as nite
differences, and the solution is updated in time on a three-dimensional, rectilinear grid. Thermal radiation is
computed using a nite volume technique on the same grid as the ow solver. Lagrangian particles are used to
simulate smoke movement, sprinkler discharge, and fuel sprays.
24
4.2
FDS Model
Computational mesh is constructed of 17 synchronised meshes based on a minimum size of 0.25m x 0.25m x
0.25m with a total count of 7,186,046 cells.
All solutions are simulated until stable conditions are demonstrated, with a maximum simulation time of 1200 s.
4.3
Modelled Scenarios
Multiple fire scenarios have been investigated to ensure a robust analysis. The modelled scenarios are all
based on credible severe case design fires, accounting for the mall architecture, use, and UAE Fire Code
requirements.
The design fires to be tested within the mall pedestrian way will be a minimum 10 MW which allows for
flexibility of the use of the space, aligns with the strategy of the current mall, and encompasses the minimum
5MW design fire required by the UAE Fire code. Additional locations and fire sizes are tested as part of a
sensitivity analysis.
All fire scenarios based sprinkler controlled fire growth. The fire size simulated represents the peak steady
state fire size with sprinkler suppression; ie. a shielded, sustained fire. A fuel load based on a plastic / wood
mix is assumed with a 5% soot yield.
Boulevard Level mall: Pedestrian way fire scenario for which smoke plume traverses all mall levels with
maximum height of rise for smoke plume
Ground Level: Kiosk fire which has the potential of spilling from under two bridges on different levels
within the mall (maximum smoke entrainment)
Third level: Food court area fire close to existing Fashion Atrium entrance
st
1 floor level
Design
Scenarios
Fire location
2 floor level
rd
3 floor level
25
Extract
3
rate (m /s)
Extract design
10
176
10
176
1.5
176
Fire size
(MW)
Design
Scenarios
Two scenarios are simulated to demonstrate the conditions within the mall from a fire within a retail unit served
2
by the mall. The retail units are modelled as approx. 530 m total floor are, with 4 extract points within the unit
distributed at ceiling level.
Mall 1
Based on the results of the mall fire scenarios, a fire in the boulevard entrance end of the mall represents the
worst case in terms of smoke logging at high level. Therefore retail unit locations simulated are all located in
this area.
Large kiosk
Boulevard Level
Fire size
(MW)
Extract rate
3
(m /s)
10
176
Mall 2
10
176
Second floor level: demonstrates the performance of the proposed in unit smoke extract solution with no
reliance on smoke extraction within the mall space.
Fire location
Fire size
(MW)
Sprinkler
controlled
peak HRR+
margin of
safety
Extract
3
rate (m /s)
15
Extract design
Mall 3
Retail 1
Retail unit on
Second Level
Mall Scenarios
Results demonstrate that no smoke spreads to the existing Fashion Atrium mall from fire scenarios within the
mall expansion. This is due to the high volumetric extract rate maintaining a high smoke layer and drawing
sufficient inlet air from the existing atrium to impede the ingress of smoke.
Conditions are tenable on levels Ground to Second for scenarios 1 3. Conditions are tenable on Third level
for scenarios 1 2 (as fire is located in only occupied area on Third floor in scenario 3)
Short regions of untenable smoke are observed in the mall expansion entrance area at the second floor level.
These regions are limited in extent and develop after 15 minutes of steady state fire development. The smoke
in these regions is not considered to affect safe means of escape from the second floor.
This is deemed acceptable based on the means of egress configuration and anticipated evacuation prior to
reaching untenable conditions.
5.2
The intent of the in unit smoke extraction is to mitigate smoke spread into the mall and not to assess tenability
conditions within the retail unit as a function of the smoke control system activation.
When considering smoke from a retail unit fire spilling into the mall space, the mall extract system controls the
smoke and prevents the build up of untenable regions that may compromise escape.
176
1.2 MW
15 in unit
5.1
Sprinkler
controlled
peak HRR
@ 1.5MW
Results
1.2 MW
Results Summary
To ensure a worst case scenario for a robust analysis, the retail unit scenario is modelled with a notional
maximum spill width. This is based on an 18m wide and 4m high shop front opening.
Fire location
26
5.3
This scenario represents a worst case scenario in terms of smoke control within the mall. A sprinklered 10MW
kiosk fire located at Boulevard level ensures the highest height of rise within the smoke plume.
Existing Mall
Based on 176 m /s of high level smoke extraction distributed across 22 smoke extract grilles at roof level; the
following is observed;
Tenable conditions can be maintained for escape on Ground, First and Second levels within the mall, as
well as the Third level food court area (although this does not exit via the mall).
nd
floor
rd
Figure 27 Visibility Distance at head height above the 3 floor (Food court level)
Figure 25 Visibility Distance section through interface between expansion and existing mall.
27
5.4
This scenario represents a worst case scenario in terms of smoke control within the mall. A sprinklered 10MW
kiosk fire located at First floor level underneath a mall bridge allows for the generation of multiple spill plumes,
increasing the overall air entrainment and thereby volume of smoke.
Figure 28 Temperature profile at head height above the 3 floor (Food court level)
Based on 176 m /s of high level smoke extraction distributed across 22 smoke extract grilles at roof level; the
following is observed;
Temperatures are generally tenable throughout the mall due to the action of sprinklers to cool smoke outside of
the immediate plume region.
Tenable conditions can be maintained for escape on Ground, First and Second levels within the mall, as
well as the Third level food court area (although this does not exit via the mall).
Some small regions in entrance area on Third floor are showing untenable conditions, however this is
isolated to a small region and will not affect means of escape in the area. This is related to the mall zone
shape in this region increasing in volume and the influence of deep beams at glass ceiling level.
The action of the extract fans draws sufficient volume of replacement air across all levels from the existing
fashion mall atrium to prevent the ingress of any smoke.
Figure 31 Visibility Distance section through interface between expansion and existing mall.
28
Existing Mall
nd
rd
floor
Figure 34 Temperature at head height above the 3 floor (Food court level)
Temperatures are generally tenable throughout the mall due to the action of sprinklers to cool smoke outside of
the immediate plume region.
Velocity Profile
Existing Mall
The action of the extract fans draws sufficient volume of replacement air across all levels from the existing
fashion mall atrium to prevent the ingress of any smoke.
rd
Figure 33 Visibility Distance at head height above the 3 floor (Food court level)
29
5.5
This scenario demonstrates the impact of a sprinkler controlled fire size within food court, which is the only
occupied area open to the mall space at this level. An initial simulation determined a conservative fire size of
1.5 MW as suitable for this sprinkler controlled scenario.
Existing Mall
nd
floor
Figure 36 Third floor caf fire adjacent to the fashion atrium interface
3
Based on 176 m /s of high level smoke extraction distributed across 22 smoke extract grilles at roof level; the
following is observed;
Tenable conditions can be maintained for escape on Ground, First and Second levels within the mall, the
only occupied area on the Third floor is the food court, which does become untenable.
Existing Mall
rd
Figure 37 Visibility Distance section through interface between expansion and existing mall.
30
rd
Figure 40 Temperature at head height above the 3 floor (Food court level)
Temperatures are tenable throughout the mall due to the action of sprinklers to cool smoke outside of the
immediate plume region.
Velocity Profile
The action of the extract fans draws sufficient volume of replacement air across all levels from the existing
fashion mall atrium to prevent the ingress of any smoke.
31
5.6
This scenario represents a worst case spill plume scenario from a unit served by the mall. The unit is modelled
with a frontage opening of 18m x 4m for its potential spill width. Its location on the Ground level ensures
maximum height of rise within the smoke plume to provide maximum entrainment to the plume.
Existing Mall
Based on 176 m /s of high level smoke extraction distributed across 22 smoke extract grilles at roof level; the
following is observed;
Tenable conditions can be maintained for escape on Ground, First and Second levels within the mall, as
well as the Third level food court area (although this does not exit via the mall).
Visibility Distance
rd
Existing Mall
Figure 42 Visibility section through unit and mall
32
nd
floor
rd
Figure 45 Temperature at head height above the 3 floor (Food court level)
Temperatures are tenable throughout the mall due to the action of sprinklers to cool smoke outside of the
immediate plume region.
Velocity Profile
Existing Mall
The action of the extract fans draws sufficient volume of replacement air across all levels from the existing
fashion mall atrium to prevent the ingress of any smoke.
33