com
Seminar Topics
www.albemarle.com
Chemistry / Kinetics
Diesel Sulfur Chemistry
Feed Effects
endpoint
cracked stocks (LCO & Coker Diesel)
Catalyst Inhibition
Diesel Color
Aromatics Saturation
H2 Consumption
Maximizing Hydrotreater Performance
Feed Management
Catalyst Selection
ULSD Catalyst Selection Guidelines
Commercial Example
www.albemarle.com
Sulfur
Compound
Structure
Name
Relative D-86 EP
Reaction
When
Rate
Observed
dibenzothiophene
6 - 12
590F
4-methyldibenzothiophene
2-4
600-620F
4,6-dimethyldibenzothiophene
630-650F
3,4,6-trimethyldibenzothiophene
660-680F
H3C
H3C
CH3
CH3
H3C
CH3
SH-DBT Source/Origin
www.albemarle.com
Sulfur Speciation
www.albemarle.com
counts
300000
Feed: ~5000 wppm S
250000
200000
150000
100000
50000
0
5
10
15
20
25
30 min
Sulfur Speciation
www.albemarle.com
counts
300000
250000
Feed:~5000 wppm S
Product: ~100 wppm S
200000
150000
100000
50000
0
5
10
15
20
25
30 min
www.albemarle.com
4,6-Dimethyl-Dibenzothiophene
H3C
CH3
S
H3C
CH3
CH3
H3C
CH3
Steric Hindrance
www.albemarle.com
DMDBT has all sulfur and carbon atoms in the same plane
Direct hydrogenolysis route inhibited by steric hindrance of
alkyl groups on 4,6 position in the adsorbed sulfur
compound
DBT
4,6-DM-DBT
Hydrogenation Route
www.albemarle.com
10
www.albemarle.com
100
Product S (wppm)
90
80
70
Aromatic
saturation
equilibrium
limited
60
50
40
Kinetic
control
30
20
10
0
620
630
640
650
660
670
WABT (F)
www.albemarle.com
10
9
N
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
450
500
550
600
650
700
750
800
850
Aromatic
structure
13
Name
MW
True
Boiling
Point
D-86 FBP
When
Observed
Naphthalene
128.2
424F
~ 400F
Anthracene
178.2
644F
~ 605F
Phenanthrene
178.2
644F
~ 605F
Fluoranthene
202.3
707F
~ 665F
Pyrene
202.3
739F
~ 695F
0.5
100
0.0
14
www.albemarle.com
S (wt%)
N (ppm)
N (ppm)
200
F-12
1.0
F-11
300
F-10
1.5
F-9
400
F-8
2.0
F-7
500
F-6
2.5
F-5
600
F-4
3.0
F-3
700
F-2
3.5
F-1
S (wt%)
TBP Basis
F-1: 360-390F
F-2: 390-410F
F-3: 410-445F
F-4: 445-480F
F-5: 480-505F
F-6: 505-535F
F-7: 535-560F
F-8: 560-600F
F-9: 600-640F
F-10: 640-665F
F-11: 665-695F
F-12: 695-725F
www.albemarle.com
200
2.5
180
S (wt%)
160
N (ppm)
140
120
1.5
100
1.0
80
60
0.5
40
20
0.0
350
0
400
450
500
550
600
650
700
750
2.0
32.0
API Gravity
46.0
44.0
30.0
42.0
29.0
40.0
28.0
38.0
27.0
36.0
26.0
34.0
25.0
32.0
24.0
30.0
350
16
48.0
400
450
500
550
600
650
TBP Endpoint Temperature (F)
700
750
API Gravity ()
33.0
www.albemarle.com
17
www.albemarle.com
Total
API
Aromatics
Gravity ()
(vol%)
Feed TBP
EP (F)
Feed D-86
EP (F)
S (wt%)
N (ppm)
670
630
1.75
56
30.6
33.7
680
640
1.80
67
31.0
33.4
690
650
1.85
79
31.3
33.0
700
660
1.90
92
31.7
32.7
710
670
1.95
105
32.1
32.4
720
680
2.00
119
32.5
32.1
25
Model Projections
15
10
5
1.5
0
-5
1.0
-10
-15
0.5
-20
-25
-30
0.0
630
18
640
650
660
670
Feed D-86 Endpoint (oF)
680
Process Conditions:
Relative SOR WABT (F)
20
2.0
www.albemarle.com
Cycle Length
WABT
+30F LCO EP
+20F LCO EP
+10F LCO EP
Base LCO EP
www.albemarle.com
20
www.albemarle.com
SRD
LCO
CGO
1.00
2.91
2.27
Nitrogen (ppm)
92
551
945
API Gravity ()
36.4
15.6
32.0
1.3
6.6
26.0
IBP
325
355
356
10 vol%
407
451
406
50 vol%
493
527
519
90 vol%
598
635
635
FBP
629
717
674
20.2
66.6
27.9
mono-
15.6
52.6
21.7
di-
4.6
13.5
6.0
tri-
0.1
0.5
0.2
Sulfur (wt%)
D-86 (F)
Aromatics (vol%)
21
www.albemarle.com
SRD
LCO
CGO
Sulfur (wt%)
1.78
1.01
2.66
Nitrogen (ppm)
379
875
1028
API Gravity ()
31.7
14.3
30.1
1.9
2.9
22
IBP
417
396
438
10 vol%
503
476
458
50 vol%
568
540
518
90 vol%
631
638
596
FBP
661
685
636
36.0
84.8
40.2
mono-
19.5
16.6
21.2
di-
15.2
59.1
17.4
tri-
1.3
9.1
1.6
D-86 (F)
Aromatics (wt%)
22
www.albemarle.com
100/0/0
0/100/0
0/0/100
50/25/25
Sulfur (wt%)
1.78
1.01
2.66
1.78
Nitrogen (ppm)
379
875
1028
672
API Gravity ()
31.7
14.3
30.1
26.5
1.9
2.9
22
7.0
IBP
417
396
438
396
10 vol%
503
476
458
472
50 vol%
568
540
518
550
90 vol%
631
638
596
628
FBP
661
685
636
685
36.0
81.8
40.2
50.5
mono-
19.5
16.6
21.2
19.1
di-
15.2
59.1
17.4
27.9
tri-
1.3
9.1
1.6
3.5
D-86 (F)
Aromatics (wt%)
23
www.albemarle.com
Organic Nitrogen
Polynuclear Aromatics
Olefins
SH-DBT Species
H2 /OilInlet (SCFB)
H2 Availabil ity =
H2 Consumed (SCFB)
Hydrogen Availability
> 4 Recommended
Maximize ppH2
Reduce Cracked Stock Endpoint
26
www.albemarle.com
Catalyst Inhibitors
Organic Nitrogen
Basic
Non-Basic / Neutral
Aromatics
Organic Sulfur
H2S
NH3
Experimental
Catalyst: CoMo/Al2O3
Fixed Bed Flow Reactor
Identical Parallel Rxrs
Common Furnace
Data
4,6 DE-DBT HDS
Inhibitor Effects
Transient
Steady State
Inhibitor
MW
195.3
705 - 710
128.2
424
C2H5
N
H
3-Ethylcarbazole
Naphthalene
29
Composition (wt%)
Feed
0.8
0.8
0.8
3-Ethylcarbazole
0.112
(80 wppm N)
Naphthalene
10
N-Dodecane
99.2
99.09
89.2
4,6-DE-DBT
80
Feed B
Feed C
Feed A (after B)
Feed A (after C)
% HDS
60
40
20
Feed A used
before 400 hr TOS
0
400
450
500
550
TOS (hr)
31
600
650
HDS (%)
Product N (ppm)
80
TOS < 0:
TOS > 0:
60
40
20
0
0
20
40
TOS (hr)
32
Feed A
Feed B
60
80
Color Bodies
Low Concentrations
Significant
Identification Difficult
33
Feed Handling
exposure to oxygen
exposure to light
Relative
Fluorescence
Intensity
Partially Saturated
Species
www.albemarle.com
Relative
Fluorescence
Intensity
22.5
0.0
1,2,3,10btetrahydrofluoranthrene
fluoranthrene
7.0
anthracene
0.0
9,10-dihydroanthracene
Aromatic Species
MW
Relative
Fluorescence
Intensity
178.2
7.0
178.2
0.0
anthracene
phenanthrene
Aromatic Species
MW
Relative
Fluorescence
Intensity
228.3
1.3
228.3
2.0
228.3
0.0
202.3
0.3
naphthacene
2,3-benzophenanthrene
chrysene
pyrene
Reference: X. Ma, et.al., Energy & Fuels, 10 (1996) 91
36
40
PNA (wt%)
Color (RFI)
35
F-1
F-2
F-3
F-4
F-5
30
25
20
15
< 535F
535-575F
575-610F
610-645F
> 645F
10
5
0
Feed
F-1
F-2
F-3
F-4
F-5
Maximize ppH2
Maintain Hydrogen Availability > 4
Reduce Dehydrogenation
Reduce Polymerization / Condensation Reactions
Aromatics
Organic Nitrogen
38
39
40
www.albemarle.com
KF-757
KF-757
475
15
WABT (F)
592
664
ppH2 (psia)
400
400
H2/oil (SCFB)
750
750
LHSV (hr-1)
1.4
1.4
Feed Properties
SRD
Sulfur (wt%)
0.45
Nitrogen (ppm)
130
0.6
Aromatics (wt%)
31.3
685
Feed
KF-757
KF-848
Sulfur (ppm)
4500
475
15
Nitrogen (ppm)
127
57
11
0.6
API Gravity ()
33.3
34.6
35.3
Aromatics (wt%)
31.3
31.4
28.3
mono-
19.1
26.5
23.7
di-
11.1
4.7
4.4
tri+
1.1
0.2
0.2
150
190
H2 Consumption (SCFB)
41
www.albemarle.com
KF-757
KF-848
WABT (F)
685
665
ppH2 (psia)
650
650
H2/oil (SCFB)
2200
2200
1.5
1.5
LHSV (hr-1)
LCO/CGO/SRD (vol%)
42
www.albemarle.com
25/25/50
Sulfur (wt%)
1.84
Nitrogen (ppm)
323
8.5
Aromatics (wt%)
44.1
690
FEED
KF-757
KF-848
Sulfur (ppm)
18400
Nitrogen (ppm)
323
8.5
API Gravity ()
29.7
35.4
36.1
Aromatics (wt%)
44.1
36.6
32.7
mono-
21.2
31.9
29.5
di-
20.2
4.2
2.9
tri+
2.7
0.5
0.3
690
780
38
44
45
H2 Consumption (SCFB)
Cetane Index
43
www.albemarle.com
www.albemarle.com
44
40
[240]
20
[120]
0
1
45
www.albemarle.com
10
100
Sulfur (wppm)
1000
10000
46
www.albemarle.com
Avoid Over-Treating
Feed Management
Avoid Overtreating
www.albemarle.com
Example:
KF-757, 800 psig inlet pressure
1.4 LHSV, 0.22% feed S, 2000 scf/B H2/oil
Example is based on a commercial unit that treated ULSD to
4 ppm S instead of 7 ppm S
47
Overtreating Example
www.albemarle.com
WABT Required, F
720
700
680
660
640
0.0
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
10.0
12.0
10.0
12.0
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
36
30
24
18
12
6
0
0.0
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
10.0
12.0
49
Feed Management
www.albemarle.com
Endpoint Effects
Concentrations of SH-DBT species, organic nitrogen, and aromatics
increases with diesel endpoint
Higher Processing Severity
Catalyst Inhibition
H2 Consumption
Feed Composition
Cracked Feeds (coker distillate/LCO) have high refractory sulfur (SHDBT), organic nitrogen, and aromatics contents.
Higher Processing Severity
Catalyst Inhibition
H2 Consumption
Feed Selection
Balance feed properties (treating requirements) and unit capabilities
Endpoint Reduction
Reduce Organic Nitrogen & Aromatics Contents
Control SH-DBT Content
50
www.albemarle.com
STARS
Super Type II Active Reaction Sites with very high intrinsic
activity for HDS, HDN and Hydrogenation
KF-757 - CoMo
KF-767 - CoMo
KF-848 NiMo
Combined NiMo/CoMo Loads
NEBULA
Bulk metal catalyst
Highest active site density of any hydrotreating catalyst
technology
52
53
Catalyst
HDS RVA
HDN RVA
Relative H2
Consumption
KF-757 (CoMo)
100
100
100
KF-767 (CoMo)
150
130
105
KF-848 (NiMo)
190
150
135
NEBULA
> 250
> 200
> 175
54
www.albemarle.com
Aromatics reduction
Color control/improvement
Cetane improvement
Application Constraints
High H2 consumption in ULSD service
H2 consumption management necessary
55
www.albemarle.com
www.albemarle.com
56
www.albemarle.com
57
Poison
As
Na
Si
58
Relative Toxicity
10
0.3 1.0
< 0.1
www.albemarle.com
59
www.albemarle.com
As
Na
Caustic
Seawater
Crude
Present in All Fractions
Major Impact: Catalyst Regenerability
Si
Guard
Catalysts
0.8
60
High
Activity
Guard
Catalysts
High Activity
Catalysts
Si
As
0.6
0.4
0.2
KF-757
KF-901
KF-841
KF-844
KF-859
KG-6
0.0
KF-647
www.albemarle.com
Feed effects
Endpoint
Cracked stocks
SH-DBT species
Organic nitrogen
Catalyst inhibition
Influencing factors:
Inhibitor molecule
Reactant molecule
Feed oil matrix
Color
Complex
Aromatics, Nitrogen Species
Feed Endpoint
High T / Low ppH2 Operation
Aromatics Saturation
Conventional Diesel Hydrotreating
PNAs saturated to mono-aromatics
mono-aromatics not saturated
minimal net reduction of total aromatics
ULSD
PNAs saturated
mono-aromatics saturated
significant net reduction of total aromatics
62
H2 Consumption
30% - 75% higher
Influences:
Product S level
Catalyst type
Process conditions
Feed characteristics
Avoid Overtreating
Feed Management
Endpoint effects
Cracked stock effects
Match feed properties / unit capabilities
63
Maximizing Performance
ppH2
H2 Availability
H2 Purity
Feed distribution
Catalyst activity
64