In 2003, a Malaysian venture capitalist group entered into the picture promising
S$2.5 mn cash injection. The focus of operation was to produce products for
institutional usage, principally a box that would control (1) a server engine, and
(2) a tool kit to design and drive applications driven by Java. The problem,
however, was that they were trying to sell a product that had not yet been
developed.
Its customer base was mostly from ITI where the principals had worked with the
projects. The National Archives of Singapore project had been one of the
contacts that had been passed on to Nexus. This was for a user interface to
overcome the limitations caused by the browser environment. Its difficulty was
making available its vast records, much of which were physical in nature,
available to the general public.
The partnership between the Malaysian venture capitalists and the Singaporean
professionals started to become more and more fractious as the lack of a
finished product at the time meant that there was great difficulty with generating
revenue. The friction by then grew to the extent that Winson decided that he
would quit the organisation. At the same time, the National Archives had become
nervous about allowing the work being done on their records by a nonSingaporean controlled company.
The congruence of events resulted in the formation of Reachfield IT Solutions.
The Early Years for Reachfield
Formed firstly by his wife and his sister in law, Reachfield soon had Winson as an
employee director (although he still carries the job-title of Vice-president today
because he claims that customers are less intimidated by that title than by a
more senior sounding title).
Its first customer was the National Archives of Singapore, but Reachifield was
able to add, between 2004 and 2006, the Singapore Tourism Board, the Ministry
of Foreign Affairs, the Building Control Authority, and NUS High School as
customers. Each of them had similar problems, the issue of making available
audio and video records, and other records (like a PDF file) to end users
because of the difficulty that existing systems had, and still have, with enabling
the end user downloading of files expeditiously.
This was the problem that Winson has solved, initially using part time assistance
of other professionals in the market who he supervised. Some of these early
assistants were eventually to join the company as full time employees.
The success that the company achieved is very well illustrated by the attached
financial summary from its founding to the end of 2011. The problem however, is
that once a solution had been found for the end user, there is relatively little
continuing fee income for doing maintenance and trouble shooting of the system
software and hardware.
The Partnership with A*STAR
Reachfield IT has an agreement with Exploit Technologies, which is the
commercialisation arm of A*STAR. This enables it to develop and market the
Scalable Multimedia Platform (SMP) technology. SMP simplifies the current
media transcoding process, and benefits video hosting service providers,
Most products now require the creation of multiple files to cater to a range of
bandwidths and device solutions. SMP technology, on the other hand, creates
just a single layered source file that can automatically adapt to the device and
to the bandwidth of end users. The solution therefore means a substantial
savings in reduced storage space, and minimises the man-hours needed for file
transcoding.
This technology was developed under A*STAR I 2R organisation. Under the
licence arrangements Reachfield pays a one time fee for each new customer it
uses the SMP technology for.
The Situation in 2012
Reachfield is now seeking appointment as an approved vendor for video storage
and retrieval processes by the Infocomm Development Authority of Singapore.
The nature of this approval will allow government departments intending to
engage a vendor for video hosting and portal related work to do so without
entering into a tendering process.
The last IDA approval process was called two years ago. A call for collaboration
tender has been initiated. IDA will specify the requirements and deliverables so
that participants are aware, and also to ensure that vendors selected will be able
to meet their stringent and careful evaluation of the submission.
Envision and Servtouch currently are the two companies appointed by IDA to
supply video related product and services to the government agencies. It is an
optional consideration for government agencies to engage their services. Their
engagement merely reduces the paperwork and procurement process for the
agencies.
Reachfield IT will participate in the next IDA call for collaboration. The current
tenure will expire by end of 2012. IDA is expected to invite all potential
participants to be qualified for the next period by Q4 2012.
2010
336,28
9
5,00
0
341,28
9
261,21
7
21
6
261,43
3
40,31
1
74,39
6
162,34
0
4,29
8
133,17
2
340,12
1
1,16
8
1,12
3
2,29
1
153,56
3
4,88
6
55,61
8
288,46
3
(27,030
)
(2,595
)
(29,625
)
2,29
1
(29,625
)
2009
2008
2007
608,711
318,94
4
391,192
2006
2005
2004
419,56
7
5,07
9
424,64
6
165,88
3
15,60
8
181,49
1
82,69
3
8,60
0
91,29
3
61,38
0
34,02
1
Revenue
Service Income
Government Grant
345
609,056
318,94
4
5,767
396,959
Total Costs
Profit/(loss) before tax
Taxation
Net profit/(loss) for year
Dividend declared
185,821
221,862
119,969
527,652
81,404
(6,342
)
75,062
(150,000
)
(74,938
)
32,01
4
165,67
2
3,38
4
56,18
7
257,25
7
61,68
7
(6,580
)
55,10
7
55,10
7
63,732
135,820
3,200
37,266
240,018
156,941
(13,849
)
143,092
(200,000
)
(56,908
)
114,24
1
15,27
0
156,01
6
2,28
5
63,25
5
351,06
7
73,57
9
81,74
2
6,64
3
10,60
7
160,37
2
21,11
9
50,03
7
2,07
3
6,72
3
92,85
4
(1,561
)
73,57
9
21,11
9
(1,561
)
73,57
9
21,11
9
(1,561
)
Note:
The government grants received in every year except one were for feasibility studies conducted
with government institutions, as well grants given by a government entity for working on projects
using the assistance of A*STAR researchers.
Exhibit 2
Reachfield IT Solutions Pte Ltd
Balance Sheets (in S$)
For Year Ended December 31
2011
-
2004
80
3
46,68
8
62,76
3
7,35
0
24,30
1
6,35
2
18,20
1
21,40
0
30,91
8
82,97
9
10,70
0
Prepayments
86,56
1
72,26
0
98,63
4
187,89
5
168,61
0
110,12
1
78,27
9
13
5
118,83
2
124,43
8
133,24
9
135,02
3
192,31
3
227,49
6
199,52
8
195,75
0
143,13
3
131,72
8
44,18
4
25,55
7
2,61
3
14,86
2
2,86
6
8,48
3
51,95
0
2,90
1
6,42
0
55
0
12,28
6
6,14
6
40,96
7
13,84
9
1,00
1
70
0
1,81
6
29,77
2
Fixed Assets
Current Assets
Trade Debtors
Total Assets
2010
2009
2008
2007
2006
2005
Current Liabilities
Trade Creditors
Accrued Expenses
Other Creditors
Amount due to Director
22,69
3
14,71
1
6,35
3
44,18
5
48,25
0
75,91
5
36,16
0
89,06
4
86,77
3
116,39
8
100,00
0
(10,93
6)
100,00
0
(13,22
7)
89,06
4
86,77
3
Total Liabilities
NET ASSETS
Share Capital
Accumulated Profit/(Loss)
TOTAL LIABILITIES &
SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY
16,60
5
63,29
9
2,61
3
23,57
5
33,28
9
191,33
6
136,22
9
193,13
7
119,55
8
98,43
9
100,00
0
16,39
8
100,00
0
91,33
6
100,00
0
36,22
9
100,00
0
93,13
7
100,00
0
19,55
8
100,00
0
(1,561
)
116,39
8
191,33
6
136,22
9
193,13
7
119,55
8
98,43
9
A recent innovation has been the addition of NUS High School as a customer.
NUS High is a secondary school linked to the National University of Singapore,
where classes at the higher levels are recorded and made available to students
for retrieval via a audio-visual format. Again there are the issues of capacity, end
user equipment characteristics, and rapid retrieval for the student to access, are
the problems that need to be resolved.
The Role Played by I2R
I2R was set up in 2002 and has as its mission to be the globally preferred source
of innovations in Interactive Secured Information, Content and Services Anytime
Anywhere. Research is conducted in Singapore and is done in the areas of
information, communications, and media (ICM) technologies to develop holistic
solutions across the ICM value chain.
In I2R's latest report, it discloses that it employs 574 research staff number, of
which 52% (or 299) hold doctoral degrees, 29% (or 157) hold master degrees. It
also reports that between 2003 and 2012, it had published 1,272 articles in
Research Journals, and contributed 3,693 conference papers. It has won a fair
number of prestigious best paper awards for some presented at these
conferences,
Some of their staff hold editorial positions with some of the
publications of the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers.
Because it is concentrated on research, the institute has actively been spinning
off small companies, often with the original researchers forming part of the new
companies as founding shareholders. This is how NexusEdge Technologies was
established, and was how Winson Wee embarked on his entrepreneurial career.
As mentioned in the case, I2R retained a stake in this entity in exchange for
permitting the use of the research results already achieved up till that time.
Exploit Technologies (ET)
ET is involved with bridging R&D and industry, and to maximise the commercial
potential of A*STAR. This is done through IP awareness and protection, and
incubation of both technologies and businesses by licensing A*STAR's
intellectual property, spinning off high potential companies.
It now has a portfolio of some 3000 active patents, and has granted more than
250 licences for proprietary technologies as well as spinning off 24 companies.
One such licence is the agreement with Reachfield to develop and market SMP
technology. For 2012 I2R expects to generate some S$500 mn in revenue by its
licensees from sale of products, and provision of services. It also believes that
the total market value, some realised, that has been created by its start-ups have
reached some S$75 mn.
10
Industry players and businesses can benefit from collaborating with ET using its
technologies, through research collaboration, through commercialisation of
technology funding, as well as through licensing of technologies. This enables
companies to save significant costs on their own R&D, as well as reducing its
risks from such investment.
References
Annual Reports of the Institute for Infocomm Research from 2003
11
12
guarantee for the foreign investor to hire a proportion of the graduates from the
program so that they would have workers with the right skill sets in a tight labour
market. The first targets were actually companies that included the former RolleiWerke of Germany, Phillips of the Netherlands, and the Tata Group from India.
Incentives given to the foreign corporations varied. In the case of Rollei, it was
given the right of refusal, for a period of ten years. This meant that a whole range
of products that it could manufacture was placed on a control of manufacture
ordinance.
This meant that any other potential manufacturer of the same
products would require a licence to produce them in Singapore and would only
be granted such a license if Rollei declined to manufacture the product here. In
the case of Tata, loans were provided, as well as land at reasonable rent. In
addition, the government paid for training equipment, materials, as well as
picking up 70% of the operating costs of the training institute.
It was in the early 1980s that Singapore's Economic Development Board (EDB)
began to expand its focus to create training centres funded jointly with other
governments. The logic was that if the foreign government could be persuaded
to invest in skills development in Singapore that would give an important
incentive for firms from that country to also invest in the country. This was when
the JSTC was first formed, followed by the German Singapore Institute for
Production Technology, the French Singapore Institute for Electro-technology,
and eventually the JSIST.
The Japan Singapore Insittute for Software Technology
The project was a technical cooperation project was led by the Japan
International Cooperation Agency (JICA) and was run over 10 years over two
phases of five years each. This involved the training of programmers, system
analysts, and system programmers, and offered training in Japan for the
Singapore instructors who taught in the program. A more sophisticated Artificial
Intelligence (AI) Centre cooperation project was also set up for an additional two
years. In the second half of the program, until 1998, third country training
programs were run in order to train computer engineers from the Asean nations.
In 1991, the JSIST was absorbed within the Singapore tertiary education system.
It was placed under the jurisdiction of the National Computer Board, and was
eventually to become a department of the Singapore Polytechnic, the first of the
four technical colleges that currently operate in Singapore. The JSIST name
remains to this day, at the entrance hall of the present Software Engineering
Department at the Polytechnic, acknowledging both its history and the
involvement of Japan in its establishment.
13
14
knowledge and skill intensive industries to make its products and services more
competitive internationally. A cabinet committee on national computerisation was
formed in March 1980, and its first study completed by October that year. One of
the conclusions was that a big obstacle holding back development of the
software industry was the lack of trained personnel. That was when it was
decided that attention be given to develop opportunities for training computer
personnel, and plans made for enabling this to be encouraged.. And in 1981, the
National Computer Board (NCB) was established.
Three institutes were set up under the NCB. This included the Institute of
Systems Science, the Japan-Singapore Institute of Software Technology, and the
Centre for Computer Studies between December 1981 and December 1982.
The NCB is represented on the advisory committees of each of these institutions.
Other efforts put in by the NCB was to help computer software companies by
jointly developing JTC Accommodation for Selected Service Industries which
enables approved computer software companies to be located in JTC (Jurong
Town Corporation which was at that time the principal builder of industrial
properties for companies manufacturing in Singapore) flatted factories at low
costs but one key condition was that the applicant had to show current export
activity, or plans for the export of its services or products.
References
Kuruvilla, Sarosh, Erickson, Christopher L., and Hwang, Alvin. An Assessment of Singapore Skills
Development: Does it Constitute a Viable Model for Other Developing Countries? World
Development Vol 30, pp 1461-1476, 2002
Yeo, Kee Leng, Loh, Chee Meng; Thong, Pao Yi & Koh, Pia Chin. Information Technology and
the Singapore Experience. AMIC-EWC Research Workshop on the Computer and Information
Development in Asean: Singapore March 27-30, 1984. Singapore: Asia Mass Communication
Research
&
Information
Centre.
Pek Hooi, Soh & James Ang.
The Role of the Singapore Government in National
Computerisation. Paper. Departement of Decision Sciences, Faculty of Business Adminsitration,
National University of Singapore (undated paper)
Hiroshi Aoki Third Party Evaluation of Singapore and Malaysian Industrial Projects. JICA Annual
Evaluation Report 2000. Chapter 3 Section III. Pp299-307
Fong, Aik Meng Japan Singapore Technical Institute A International Cooperation in Human
Resource Development for Inclusive Growth.
Paper presented at Nanyang Polytechnic
International. 2010.
15
DRAMS 2.0 has solved issues like the consolidation of digital assets from various
resources for companies or institutions that have massive records, very often in
different media forms, that do not lend themselves firstly to easy retrieval, and
more importantly from being downloaded by an authorised end-user.
The Market
Right now the market comprises broadcasters, educational institutions, libraries,
government agencies, media and advertising companies, architectural and
design providers, as well as museums.
To date, Reachfield counts on the Singapore National Archives, the Singapore
Building Control Authority, the Singapore Tourist Promotion Board, and the NUS
High School, as customers. Each had unique needs of storage, the first two in
particular having difficulty with making the digitalised records that are in original
print format conveniently readable from an approved on-line investigator.
It is difficult to estimate an industry size for this business because the case writer
considers DRAMS 2.0 as the equivalent of the fax machine during the era when
information transmission was via telex, if not telegram.
16
The Parallels of the Telegram, Telex, and Fax evolution to DRAMS 2.0
Going back some 40 years to before the 1970s, office machines then invariably
included a typewriter and a telephone only. Urgent messages then had to be
transmitted via telegram which brought up the issue of security, and brevity in
writing.
The first was because telegrams were sent through telephone
companies or post offices, and the operator if not some someone else, could
read what was being transmitted. Brevity brought about the problems of being
misunderstood at the expense of a more expensive transmission.
It was only around 1970 that telex machines were introduced. And what that did
was to improve the security side of the problem because companies with
sufficient traffic could install a machine in its own office and there was less of an
issue with brevity. But there was invariably the need to employ a suitable person
to work as telex operator as invariably few senior executives were competent on
the machines.
Then the fax machine came into vogue in the 1980s. Now entire documents,
shrunk down to the right size to suit the machine, could be transmitted as a
virtual photocopy. This was especially revolutionary as it now truly expanded the
amount of information being transmitted across the seas.
What DRAMS 2.0 does in this day and age of the internet, and ultra fast data and
information transmission is to make it possible for a large library to become
readily accessible to an authorised end-user using the search and cataloguing
functions; then the retrieval of the information. Next is the question of the ability
to properly download the data or information at the user end. This had caused
issues because users did not necessarily have universally the same programs for
viewing, something that DRAMS 2.0 can accommodate.
And most of all DRAMS 2.0 is able to handle audio-visual media, making it
possible for some educational institutions to make available, for their selected
period of time, to properly authorised end users, items like a lecture that can be
transmitted across continents, in its recorded form. Certainly one of the key
issues that DRAMS 2.0 solves is that of storage and transmission of some files,
those using TIFF or PDF, for example, that would otherwise be too huge to
readily transmit via the internet.
The Costs of Using DRAMS 2.0
One of the key selling points for the product is that the information provider only
needs to purchase a server, install a customised solution, and store its
information, to enable this system to work. The costs are not excessive. But the
question is who could be the possible parties that would use this system?
17
No one customer of Reachfield has had to spend more than S$500,000 to install
the system, and that amount applies only to the largest of its customers. Others
have spent considerably less.
The Possible Market
The most likely Singapore government agencies are already customers of
Reachfield. And its total income since it started this business has only reached
just over S$2.5 million.
Singapore not having a big distance learning education industry possibly has
fairly limited further growth potential.
It is within the region, and internationally, that the prospects start to get more
interesting. Nonetheless it would prove to be a major surprise if the market for
this service has a total value of more than S$100 million on a Asia Pacific wide
basis.
18
DRAMS 2.0 has solved issues like the consolidation of digital assets from various
resources for companies or institutions that have massive records, very often in
different media forms, that do not lend themselves firstly to easy retrieval, and
more importantly from being downloaded by an authorised end-user.
The Market
Right now the market comprises broadcasters, educational institutions, libraries,
government agencies, media and advertising companies, architectural and
design providers, as well as museums.
To date, Reachfield counts on the Singapore National Archives, the Singapore
Building Control Authority, the Singapore Tourist Promotion Board, and the NUS
High School, as customers. Each had unique needs of storage, the first two in
particular having difficulty with making the digitalised records that are in original
print format conveniently readable from an approved on-line investigator.
It is difficult to estimate an industry size for this business because the case writer
considers DRAMS 2.0 as the equivalent of the fax machine during the era when
information transmission was via telex, if not telegram.
19
The Parallels of the Telegram, Telex, and Fax evolution to DRAMS 2.0
Going back some 40 years to before the 1970s, office machines then invariably
included a typewriter, and a telephone only. Urgent messages then had to be
transmitted via telegram which brought up the issue of security, and brevity in
writing.
The first was because telegrams were sent through telephone
companies or post offices, and the operator if not some someone else, could
read what was being transmitted. Brevity brought about the problems of being
misunderstood at the expense of a more expensive transmission.
It was only around 1970 that telex machines were introduced. And what that did
was to improve the security side of the problem because companies with
sufficient traffic could install a machine in its own office and there was less of an
issue with brevity. But there was invariably the need to employ a suitable person
to work as telex operator as invariably few senior executives were competent on
the machines.
Then the fax machine came into vogue in the 1980s. Now entire documents,
shrunk down to the right size to suit the machine, could be transmitted as a
virtual photocopy. This was especially revolutionary as it now truly expanded the
amount of information being transmitted across the seas.
What DRAMS 2.0 does in this day and age of the internet, and ultra fast data and
information transmission is to make it possible for a large library to become
readily accessible to an authorised end-user using the search and cataloguing
functions; then the retrieval of the information. Next is the question of the ability
to properly download the data or information at the user end. This had caused
issues because users did not necessarily have universally the same programs for
viewing, something that DRAMS 2.0 can accommodate.
And most of all DRAMS 2.0 is able to handle audio-visual media, making it
possible for some educational institutions to make available, for their selected
period of time, to properly authorised end users, items like a lecture that can be
transmitted across continents, in its recorded form. Certainly one of the key
issues that DRAMS 2.0 solves is that of storage as some files using TIFF or PDF
for example, could be too huge to readily transmit via the internet.
The Costs of Using DRAMS 2.0
One of the key selling points is that the information provider only requires to
purchase a server, install a customised solution, and store its information, to
enable this system to work. The costs are not excessive. But the question is
who are the possible parties that could use this system.
20
No one customer of Reachfield has had to spend more than S$500,000 to install
the system, and that amount applies only to the largest of its customers. Others
have spent considerably less.
The Possible Market
The most likely Singapore government agencies are already customers of
Reachfield. And its total income since it started this business has only totalled
just over S$2.5 million.
Singapore not having a big distance learning education industry possibly has
fairly limited further growth potential.
It is within the region, and internationally, that the prospects start to get more
interesting. Nonetheless it would prove to be a major surprise if the market for
this service has a total value of more than S$100 million on a Asia Pacific wide
basis.