231240
School of En ironmental Sciences, Department of Ecosystem Studies, The Uni ersity of Shiga Prefecture, 2500 Hassaka,
Hikone 522-8533, Japan
b
International Graduate School (IHI) Zittau, Markt 23, 02763 Zittau, Germany
c
Federal Institute for Geosciences and Natural Resources, Stilleweg 2, 30655 Hanno er, Germany
d
Department of Forest Science, Faculty of Agriculture, Utsunomiya Uni ersity, Utsunomia 321-8505, Japan
Received 3 September 1998; accepted 12 October 1998
Abstract
Leaves of Dipterocarpaceae, a major canopy component tree, and Euphorbiaceae, predominantly occurring in the
second layer, were analysed for 43 chemical elements. The comparison between the two families revealed significantly lower concentrations for the vast majority of elements in Dipterocarpaceae. All elements except Cu, Cs and
Ce were found in higher concentrations in Euphorbiaceae. Furthermore, Euphorbiaceae showed a higher biological
variation for most elements indicated through higher coefficient of variances CV. values. The fingerprints revealed a
general tendency in both families investigated to exhibit rather low element concentrations compared to the
reference plant proposed by Markert 1996.. Out of the 43 chemical elements only Ni showed remarkable positive
deviations in both families, while the deviation of 6700% found for Co in Euphorbiaceae was striking. In
Dipterocarpaceae the elements N, Co, Cu, Mn, Li, Cs, Mg and Th were found in concentrations similar to the
reference plant while all other elements exhibited rather high negative deviations. In Euphorbiaceae more elements
occurred similar to the reference plant, however, the general tendency of negative deviations was obvious. Due to
their specific environment, trees from tropical forest might have a rather different chemistry from trees in the
Northern Hemisphere. 1999 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Multi-element analysis; Dipterocarpaceae; Euphorbiaceae; Tropical rain forest; Trace elements; Plants;
Fingerprinting
Corresponding author.
0048-9697r99r$ - see front matter 1999 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
P I I: S 0 0 4 8 - 9 6 9 7 9 8 . 0 0 3 6 9 - 6
232
G. Breulmann et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 225 (1999) 231240
1. Introduction
G. Breulmann et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 225 (1999) 231240
233
atomic absorption spectrophotometry AAS., Shimadzu AA-640-12, for Ca, Mg, Na and K at the
College of Agriculture, Kyoto University.
The samples collected during the second visit
were digested in a mixture of H 2 SO4 and H 2 O 2
Fentons reaction. using a sandbath. The instrumental measurement was performed by
ICPrAES, Shimadzu ICPS-1000 IV, for Zn, Fe,
Cu, Sr, Al at the Faculty of Agriculture, Kochi
University. K was analyzed by AAS, Shimadzu
AA-630-02 at the Faculty of Agriculture, Ehime
University.
All samples were digested again in HNO3 using
high pressure Teflon vessels with quartz glass
inserts. The instrumental measurement was performed by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry ICPrMS., Perkin Elmer Elan 5000 for
approximately 80 chemical elements at the International Graduate School Zittau, Germany. Several elements were excluded from this paper as
the results were either always below the detection
limit or showed rather erratic values.
The N content was measured by an automatic
Kjeldahl device, Gerhardt Vapodest-6, at University of Osnabruck,
Germany.
The accuracy of the digestion procedures was
checked by use of Standard Reference Material
NIST 1571, Orchard Leaves, and NIST 1572, Citrus Leaves, from the National Bureau of Standards, Washington. The certified values and the
values obtained for the respective measurement
are shown in Table 1. The elements not included
in this table are not certified.
For several elements we performed two measurements for the same sample. These values we
averaged if the deviation between the values obtained was less than 10%. In case the deviation
exceeded 10%, one value was selected on the
basis of the Standard Reference Material for the
respective measurement.
The data presented in this paper are based on
the taxonomical level of the family and represent
the mean concentration of the leaf samples for
Dipterocarpaceae 18 species. and Euphorbiaceae 5 species.. Species differences were not
considered. The comparison on the basis of
species for the respective family can be found in
Breulmann et al. 1997, 1998..
234
G. Breulmann et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 225 (1999) 231240
Table 1
Comparison of certified values and values obtained for the Standard Reference Materials
Certified values
Obtained values at
Zittau
Kyoto
Kochi
3.15" 0.10
1.82" 0.06
0.58" 0.03
160 " 20
100 " 2
92 " 15
90 " 10
29 " 2
23 " 2
21 " 3
16.5" 1
13.3" 2.4
4.84" 0.06
3.10" 0.30
0.8" 0.2
0.6" 0.3
0.17" 0.09
3.04
1.77
0.45
139.34
87.48
62.31
90.68
25.30
20.34
17.79
13.86
11.21
4.44
2.90
1.08
0.65
0.12
2.55
1.42
0.44
128.47
89.68
74.00
82.00
26.93
19.03
23.01
13.61
n.d.
n.d.
n.d.
n.d.
n.d.
n.d.
n.d.
n.d.
n.d.
n.d.
88.35
67.80
72.08
32.66
n.d.
n.d.
12.62
n.d.
n.d.
n.d.
n.d.
n.d.
n.d.
2.76" 0.05
Osnabruck
2.58
All data are in mgrkg dry wt. with exception of Ca, K, Mg and N given in %.
n.d.s not determined.
trations 1.86 mgrkg dry wt.. in Allophylus arians Sapindaceae., a densitydominant tree
species from a montane rain forest in Sri Lanka.
The Co concentrations in two out of the investigated species of Euphorbiaceae, i.e. Koilodepas
lae igatum and Trigonostemon sp. no . aff. ionthocarpus, were substantially higher with 15.35 mgrkg
dry wt. and 18.94 mgrkg dry wt., respectively
Breulmann et al., 1997.. The status of Co as a
micro-nutrient is not yet certain, however, it has
been shown that deficiency of Co can lead to
chlorosis and leaf-drop Berrie et al., 1987.. Co is
essential for the nitrogen fixing system of Rhizobium bacteria in symbiosis with Leguminosae
Epstein, 1972; Markert, 1998.. Non-nodule nitrogen fixing bacteria living on and in the leaves
have been reported for several non-Leguminosae
Jones, 1982; Whitmore, 1985.. Higher Co concentrations could therefor be beneficial for the N
fixation.
G. Breulmann et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 225 (1999) 231240
Fig. 1. Comparison of the mean concentrations in Dipterocarpaceae and Euphorbiaceae. The total concentration of both families represents 100%.
235
G. Breulmann et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 225 (1999) 231240
236
Table 2
Mean concentrations in leaves of Dipterocarpaceae and Euphorbiaceae
Dipterocarpaceae
Euphorbiaceae
Dipterocarpaceae
Euphorbiaceae
Dipterocarpaceae
Euphorbiaceae
Dipterocarpaceae
Euphorbiaceae
NU
SiU
CoU
Cr
CuU
Fe
MnU
MoU
NiU
VU
ZnU
1.41
13.
1.61
17.
217.33
123.
532.68
49.
0.11
78.
13.61
84.
0.47
24.
0.53
47.
5.96
28.
4.72
29.
38.44
30.
45.04
36.
204.04
79.
600.73
57.
0.0097
89.
0.0261
77.
3.26
57.
9.88
100.
0.0191
43.
0.0351
65.
11.44
31.
15.97
29.
Li
Na
KU
Rb
CsU
MgU
CaU
SrU
Ba
AlU
0.11
83.
0.22
160.
67.64
35.
172.61
218.
0.92
29.
2.02
71.
13.06
30.
15.19
67.
0.11
75.
0.06
113.
0.17
33.
0.26
58.
0.30
52.
0.64
48.
15.13
51.
37.43
45.
17.18
52.
22.43
60.
18.82
33.
23.34
51.
22.38
26.
40.19
69.
GaU
In
TlU
Sn
PbU
AsU
SbU
Bi
IU
YU
LaU
0.01
91.
0.05
205.
0.0002
59.
0.0002
90.
0.0025
90.
0.0100
126.
0.0365
30.
0.0381
27.
0.28
57.
0.48
100.
0.0327
57.
0.2326
184.
0.0002
141.
0.0005
102.
0.0012
65.
0.0014
207.
0.17
81.
0.25
53.
0.0089
89.
0.0161
69.
0.0050
61.
0.0082
76.
CeU
Pr
Nd
EuU
Tb
Th
TiU
ZrU
NbU
0.0851
163.
0.0238
75.
0.0011
70.
0.0015
80.
0.0028
83.
0.0039
75.
0.0006
62.
0.0008
62.
0.0001
92.
0.0001
96.
0.0026
99.
0.0040
86.
0.0012
97.
0.0018
69.
2.02
22.
3.13
25.
0.0052
37.
0.0100
75.
0.0003
114.
0.0011
93.
The values are given in mgrkg dry wt. except for N, K, Mg and Ca in %..
An asterisk indicates significance of t values at 0.01 probability level.
Values in parentheses indicate the coefficient of variance in %..
G. Breulmann et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 225 (1999) 231240
237
238
G. Breulmann et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 225 (1999) 231240
G. Breulmann et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 225 (1999) 231240
References
239
240
G. Breulmann et al. r The Science of the Total En ironment 225 (1999) 231240