Anda di halaman 1dari 15

IPASJ International Journal of Management (IIJM)

Web Site: http://www.ipasj.org/IIJM/IIJM.htm


Email:editoriijit@ipasj.org
ISSN 2321-645X

A Publisher for Research Motivation ........

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Integrated Building Information Modeling (BIM)


System for Multi-dimensional Framework
Application on Marine Projects
M.A.E.M Khalil 1, M.A.Mohamedien 2, H.M.H.Ibrahim 3, I.M.Mahdi 4
1

Civil Engineering Department, Faculty of engineering, Port Said University, Port Said, Egypt

Professor, Civil Engineering Department, Faculty of engineering, Suez Canal University, Ismailia, Egypt

Professor, Civil Engineering Department, Faculty of engineering, Port Said University, Port Said, Egypt

Assoc.Professor Str. Eng. & Constr. Management Department, Faculty of engineering, Future University, Cairo, Egypt

ABSTRACT
One of the major challenges facing project stakeholders, especially in marine projects, is the information islands
phenomenon. This phenomenon arises from using different software by each stakeholder, transformation of large amount of
data and reuse of these data to match stakeholders management approach. This creates gaps, losses and duplication of data at
almost all project stages. Implementing of Building Information Modeling (BIM) may provide stakeholders with many
advantages and benefits that can achieve their projects objectives. Literature review of latest BIM in construction showed that
the development of interoperability as it is the only way to close information gaps. This development included additional areas
such as; schedule (4th D), cost estimation (5th D) and sustainability (6th D) as well as using higher level of detail (LOD),
Decomposition of elements and interoperability. etc. In this research interoperability is developed as the main approach to
close information gaps. This development is carried on via handling of interoperability with two approaches. One approach is
the Industry Foundation Classes (IFC) which is an open-data format developed by building SMART. In which, the IFC is
facilitating of information transfer among BIM programs. The main obstacle of transferring data from modeling to schedule
or cost estimation software is the disability of breaking down element. The second approach of interoperability development is
by integrating the information systems which can provide a unique environment to facilitate successful information exchange.
A comparison among three approaches of management approaches in marine projects to illustrate how each approach may be
able to overcome information gaps. This include (1) the current traditional two-dimensional (2D) way of transferring data; (2)
Available BIM software with help of IFC; and (3) the integrated information system developed to adopt almost all BIM feature.

Keywords: Building Information Modeling, Marine projects, Schedule, Cost estimation and Integration

1-INTRODUTION
It has long been criticized that the construction sector in Egypt associated with a great amount of inefficiency,
unsatisfactory performance, inappropriate design, poor construction planning, and lack of communication between
stakeholders. BIM created effective ways to develop and prefer between construction sequences to ensure continuous
flow of resources by reducing space clashes between activities.
Previous work on this research reveals how marine industry is surrounded by many obstacles which hinder industry
progress. BIM was introduced as a promising solution to narrow and close information gaps between stakeholders.
Many hot areas were recommended for future development of BIM. In this research interoperability is developed as
main approach to close information gaps.
1.1 Background of Research
BIM is the newest technology in construction industry which is intended to overcome all associated barriers which
hinder industry development.
Qinghua [1] conducted analysis shows the distribution and structure of BIM research themes during the period of
20062015 in China which prove growing attention for BIM as shown in the following figure.

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Page 20

IPASJ International Journal of Management (IIJM)


A Publisher for Research Motivation ........

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Web Site: http://www.ipasj.org/IIJM/IIJM.htm


Email:editoriijit@ipasj.org
ISSN 2321-645X

Figure 1 Number of BIM-related papers published yearly from 2006 to 2014 in china. Qinghua [1].
Previous research showed that current BIM related researches concentrates on clash detection, data management and
visualization, scheduling, and quantity takeoff compared with expert functionalities attached to BIM, such as jobsite
safety, risk scenario planning, or recycling management.
Dr. Lieyun Ding [2] summarized the development of BIM from 3-D to nD. The first step was by combining the fourth
dimension (4-D) of time to demonstrate schedule and the fifth dimension (5-D) of cost to demonstrate cost estimation
and cash flows. nD modeling contains various technical features such as; quality, safety, environmental protection, etc.,
Yaling Deng [3] used information visualization software CiteSpace to collect and analyze 290 BIM-related papers in
the core database of Web of Science from 1990 to 2014. Four hot research fields of BIM were got: related concepts of
BIM; interactivity; GIS; application function of BIM. Finally by detecting burst words it got the future research trend of
BIM, they respectively are cost estimation, GIS, the IFC standard; topology information; computer aided.
1.2 Problem Statement
During the development of BIM system, many recommendations were observed for future research. One of BIM
challenges is what is called information islands. This expression arises from using different software by each
stakeholder, transformation of large amount of data and reentering of these data to fit different software used by
stakeholder. This creates gaps, loss and duplication of data at almost all project stages. BIM experts suggested
interoperability as solution to close information gaps. Interoperability was discussed from two perspectives. The first,
Industry Foundation Classes (IFC) which is an open-data format developed by buildingSMART. The goal of IFC is to
facilitate transferring information between different programs developed by various BIM vendors. Disability of
breaking down element was the main obstacle when transferring data from modeling to schedule or cost estimation
software. The second way for interoperability is by developing integrated information system which provides a unique
environment to facilitate successful information exchange. But adding various BIM feature like modeling, structural
design, schedule, cost estimation.etc. to be handled in one manner was a complicated area for development.
Xinan Jiang [4] holds comparison between parametric models in CAD and object-based parametric models in BIM.
Presenting objects by both physical and functional parameters is one of BIM features. Three hot area were
recommended for future development: i) develop BIM technology with higher levels of detail (LOD), ii) obtaining a
scheduled financial analysis by associating time and cost parameters simultaneously with BIM components, iii)
allocation and simulation of resources on 4-D BIM model to manage resource utilization according to the most updated
design.
Masha Ghaznavi [5] developed an integrated project system framework for tunneling construction projects. It was
claimed that there are numerous IFC-compatible applications for building construction projects which facilitate
management roles of the project life cycle. On the other side, no tunnel design application based on a universal data
model is available in the market. These findings reveal marine projects needs to gain BIM benefits as there is no
application specified in this field.
Eastman [6] suggested decomposition and aggregation for future development. Because objects shown as a single entity
may need to be broken into parts to show construction procedure or how they will be constructed. Another challenge
faces planners is how to break up specific components, such as walls or roofs, that a designer or engineer would model

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Page 21

IPASJ International Journal of Management (IIJM)


A Publisher for Research Motivation ........

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Web Site: http://www.ipasj.org/IIJM/IIJM.htm


Email:editoriijit@ipasj.org
ISSN 2321-645X

as a single component but the planner would divide or break - up into zones. This capability is not offered by most
specialized tools, and the planner must perform these break - ups within the 3-D/BIM tool.
Bhargav DAVE [7] discussed integration of information sources to production management systems in real-time to
enable accurate decision making. Information such as material procurement and delivery, equipment hire and
availability, labor availability, space availability, etc. Again, none of the commercial systems can deal with dynamic
integration of such information sources
It could be noted from this discussion that while the current systems offer a significant improvement compared to the
traditional 2D CAD and 3-D CAD systems, there is still potential for improvement and a gap in the current system.

1.3 Objectives of the Study


The objectives of this paper could be drawn as:
(1) To show how current available BIM software could support efficiency of construction industry.
(2) Develop integrated information system supported with visualized software to help project parties to close
information gaps.
1.4 Scope of Study
At primary stages of this research recommended BIM as a cutting edge solution for current problems in marine
industry. This paper aims to support interoperability by developing integrated information system to close information
gabs which will enhance BIM capabilities.

2. LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 BIM Definition
BIM is viewed according to the following definition from the National Building Information Modeling Standards[8]:
A digital representation of physical and functional characteristics of a facility. A BIM is a shared knowledge
resource for information about a facility forming a reliable basis for decisions during its life-cycle; defined as existing
from earliest conception to demolition. A basic premise of BIM is collaboration by different stakeholders at different
phases of the life cycle of a facility to insert, extract, update or modify information in the BIM to support and reflect
the roles of that stakeholder (NBIMS, 2007, p. 21).
Eastman [6] defines BIM as a verb or adjective phrase to describe tools, processes, and technologies that are facilitated
by digital machine-readable documentation about a building, its performance, its planning, its construction, and later
its operation.
2.2 BIM Techniques-State-of-Art
Bhargav DAVE [7] studied the importance to identify what are the current systems in the market that support the
construction management/production management activities. Also, to avoid duplicating the features available with the
current commercial systems, their main limitations and available features should also be identified. These features may
include, but are not limited to:
i. Construction sequencing known as 4-D simulation
ii. Clash detection analyzing clashes between various designs (such as architectural, structural and MEP)
iii. Visualization of design during construction
iv. Communication, including marking up of design for clarification
v. Quantity and cost take--off
vi. Constraints analysis
vii. Evaluation of what--if scenarios
viii. Visual tracking of progress

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Page 22

IPASJ International Journal of Management (IIJM)


A Publisher for Research Motivation ........

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Web Site: http://www.ipasj.org/IIJM/IIJM.htm


Email:editoriijit@ipasj.org
ISSN 2321-645X

Eastman [6] holds a comparison between various systems from their construction management capability viewpoint.
Autodesk Navisworks, Synchro, Vico constructor, Tekla CM and Solilbri are samples of current BIM software systems
which have features in different ways. These tools offer important benefit over the traditional CAD systems where
construction users have to use imagination to gain a deeper understanding and yet some of the functions such as clash
detection or 4-D simulation would not be possible to achieve. A wide range of case examples of benefits is emerging
from the use of such systems in the industry. On some of the complex projects such as a hospital, multi-story
commercial building, stadiums, etc. it is not uncommon to identify several hundred if not thousand clashes during
design and early construction stages.
However, in terms of detailed production planning, scheduling and control capabilities, and the capability of BIM tools
still remains limited. Barring Vico and Synchro, none of the tools offer detailed production planning and resource
linkage to the production plans, and mostly offer 4-D planning capability which let the users simulate the project only
at the master plan level.
Both Synchro and Vico demonstrate some capability to provide a detailed production planning by enabling the
development of detailed plans and links to the model. Also, neither Synchro nor Vico offer the pull production
management capability, however Vico has partially implemented the Look ahead scheduling workflow. Also, Vico is
predominantly based on the Line of Balance scheduling method and for projects which are not using this method or the
teams which are not familiar with the method, the usability remains somewhat limited. On the other side, many users
claimed that both Vico and Synchro are of complex nature and prior training and experience is required before the
users can start to use them to its full potential. This remains one of the critical issues for software being used for
production planning and control. For such a complex system, it may not be possible to train the whole supply chain and
site team in using the system on daily or weekly basis, hence it remains a tool to be Used by a selected few users
located at the head-office or a central BIM team. This somewhat limits the usability of the system to be used on site.
Bhargav DAVE[7].
Previous research observed that neither of the system provides detailed constraints analysis at task level or assignment
of responsibility and real-time task status updates to enable accurate production planning. As it was observed, one of
the cornerstone principles of pull planning is to carry out detailed constrains analysis at the look-ahead and weekly
planning level and to assign responsibility to task/trade leaders/managers to ensure the constraints are removed before
the tasks are considered for production. However, such level of production planning is not yet available in any of the
commercially available systems. Table 1 shows a comparison between Construction Management capabilities of BIM
systems.
Table 1: Comparison between Construction Management Capabilities of BIM Systems. Bhargav DAVE[7].

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Page 23

IPASJ International Journal of Management (IIJM)


A Publisher for Research Motivation ........

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Web Site: http://www.ipasj.org/IIJM/IIJM.htm


Email:editoriijit@ipasj.org
ISSN 2321-645X

3. INTEGRATED INFORMATION SYSTEM


3.1 Proposed Framework
This research aims to develop integrated information system to overcome barriers which hinder development of
interoperability in marine projects. This system is mainly consists of framework and software to validate the
framework. The framework of this system goes through many steps which are:
1- Project modeling
2- Simulating operation phase
3- Entering soil properties
4- Structural design
5- Construction logistics
6- Developing multi-dimensions plans
7- Monitoring and controlling
3.1.1 Project modeling
Because the owner may not be as proficient as the engineers at visualizing the building design in two dimensions, the
first step in the framework is to create a three-dimensional model as a tool for discussion with the owner to ensure that
the design requirements of the structure are satisfied. The 3-D model can help the owner to become more involved in
the conceptual design processes. The collaboration between the designers and the owner can reduce costly and time
consuming and also change orders during the construction process. Christopher M.Hostetler [9].
3.1.2

Simulating operation phase

The second step which is intended to assure that the owner will receive the building as envisioned is simulating. The
value of simulating is to test the consequences of what will happen if a project is implemented which asset in reaching
and making the right decisions. The value of the decisions lies in screening different alternatives and quantifying cost
versus performance. Simulations also provide an opportunity to experience the planned future in real-time and therefore
a clear picture of the results. Force Technology [10].
3.1.3 Entering soil properties
The most important factor to be considered in any project is soil properties. To obtain clear vision of soil nature, it is
essential to get information as possible be obtained regarding strata, ground water, tidal water, embankments, existing
foundation, buried services and the like in order to design the most suitable piling in terms of strength stability and
economy. These data should be incorporated into the framework to assure that client demands planned in previous two
steps could be safely constructed.

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Page 24

IPASJ International Journal of Management (IIJM)


Web Site: http://www.ipasj.org/IIJM/IIJM.htm
Email:editoriijit@ipasj.org
ISSN 2321-645X

A Publisher for Research Motivation ........

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016


Creating
3-D model
of project

Proposed Framework
(1)
Testing
operation

Detecting client
demand

Conceptual
design

Importing form library


Importing Models
of marine objects

Creating 3-D object

Design of second life simulation


system
(Adding controlling features)

Soil Properties
(2)
Structural
design

Site geometry

Plan and sections of roads &


existing building ..etc.

Procurement
Resources

Construction
logistics

Sheet piles

Reinforcement

Bollards

Ready mix
concrete

Labor
Equipment

Construction
scenarios

Fenders

Rented
n-D

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Page 25

IPASJ International Journal of Management (IIJM)


A Publisher for Research Motivation ........

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Web Site: http://www.ipasj.org/IIJM/IIJM.htm


Email:editoriijit@ipasj.org
ISSN 2321-645X

3.2 Proposed software


The proposed software is the second step of this section. It aims to test validity of previous framework. It is a
complicated process to gather all previous BIM features to be programmed in one manner. This research will use unity
game engine to achieve its objectives. Unity has different features like rendering, scripting, asset tracking and physics.
Above features could strongly support creating construction scenarios. The software is now under development and this
paper will show some its interfaces and features.
The following figure 2 shows the software structure. It consists of eight locations which takes part in any marine work
which are; resource, storage, landfill, stone pit, supplier, patching plant, transportation area and finally offshore and
onshore construction site.

Figure 2 Software Structure


First, the user could model the project using modeling tools contained in the software. Then, the end user could test
operation by simulating the project to assure client satisfaction as shown in the following figure 3

Figure 3 Operation Phase


The next step is to enter soil properties to perform structural design. The required input data are angle of internal
friction, cohesion and standard penetration test for each soil layer. The user also should enter the applied loads and
allowable stresses of each element. The output data are dimensions and required check for structure safety. The software
automatically will calculate quantities and model each element to be exported to construction logistic stage.
The user could move any equipment or labor to perform construction activities. A list of each equipment capabilities has
been programed to help site engineer for choosing best scenario. The following figures 4 and 5 shows initial edition of
resources available.

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Page 26

IPASJ International Journal of Management (IIJM)


A Publisher for Research Motivation ........

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Web Site: http://www.ipasj.org/IIJM/IIJM.htm


Email:editoriijit@ipasj.org
ISSN 2321-645X

Figure 4 Resource Area

Figure 5 Patching Plant


The software will give the user the corresponding time and cost for each construction scenario to facilitate choosing
optimal scenario. In addition to cost and time a scale showing predicted risk, waste and sustainability has been
developed. It is intended to add a vital feature to the software which support monitoring and controlling during
construction. Adding real time data to construction resource will assure that construction procedure is going as planned.

4. CASE STUDY
The main objective of this study is to compare the current 2D-delivery system with Integrated BIM system. BIM offer
many features which could overcome current problems of 2D-system. To achieve this goal a case study will be presented
to reveal causes of information gabs. The effect of each problem on various dimensions will be estimated. Then, these
problems will be studied to evaluate if BIM could enhance it or not.
4.1 Project Description
The project is developing existing quay wall which consists of steel sheet piles supporting reinforced concrete beams to
facilitate barges loading. The existing quay walls are approximately 50 years old, so it is near the end of its design life
and sheet piles adversely affected by corrosion and it is risky to use it for loading barges. In order to load barges of 3M
draught, an extension to the existing quay wall has been studied.
After investigating soil properties, rocky strata push the planner to change existing structure system from using sheet
piles to use gravity wall. The main cause of choosing gravity wall was for two reasons. First, high tidal range cause
rapid deterioration of steel sheet piles. Second, the rocky strata need special technique and equipment to drive sheet
piles which considered time consuming in addition to cost overrun. So, it is proposed to construct a new gravity wall
seaward of the existing quay wall over the length of the existing berths. Granular fill material or crushed concrete will
be used to infill the space between the new gravity wall and the existing quay wall. The following figure shows the
cross section of the proposed gravity wall system.

Figure 6 Cross section of new gravity wall

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Page 27

IPASJ International Journal of Management (IIJM)


A Publisher for Research Motivation ........

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Web Site: http://www.ipasj.org/IIJM/IIJM.htm


Email:editoriijit@ipasj.org
ISSN 2321-645X

4.2 Project Problems


The current problems facing the project considered in this case study are deducted from the projects daily reports, and
are summarized in Table 1.
Table 1: Project problems
Effect on Multi-Dimensions
Health &
No.
Problems
Time
Cost
Safety
Sustainability Waste
days
EGP
(No. of
Cost/ lifetime EGP
accidents)
After arranging blocks of corner support and during
1
loading test, the measured settlement exceeded the
70
80000
permissible limits in Egyptian code.
The client took a lot of time to approve the submitted 2D
drawings. As the client is not proficient as engineers he
wasnt able to imagine or judge the operation of loading
2
28
barges. 2D drawing didnt dissipate client fears of clash
between barge and cant leaver beam when the barge is
empty.
3
Bad climate conditions
60
The contractor faced many problems for performing
4
workshop drawing of block arrangement in corner
24
supports.
During excavation the contractor found massive concrete
5
32
section conflicting with the new gravity wall.
The crane driver put a huge concrete block tons over the
6
cant leaver beams which immediately caused failure
45
50000
1 *1
cracks
7
Using unsustainable materials
20000
18.26 *2
*1 The main cause of the sixth problem was lack of attention given for health and safety precautions.
*2 The main cause of the seventh problem were choosing materials which required rapid periodic maintenance.
To get a better understanding , the figure in the cell above describes sustainability by dividing activity cost (EGP) on
time of first periodic maintenance(day).
In the following section, it will be illustrated to which extent the system developed on the basis of BIM technology may
overcome the problems considered in Table 1.
4.3 Application of Real Time Strategy Management (RTSM) software
The main objective of the framework developed is to demonstrate the benefits of utilizing BIM technique in narrowing
the information gabs. RTSM software is computerized application of the proposed framework to evaluate its capabilities
of solving tradition problems of 2D delivery system. The RTSM software is implemented for this case study project to
demonstrate its applicability in enhancing and integrating the information system aspects.
4.3.1 Simulating operational phase
In this stage loading barges with crushed stones is tested by barges, Lorries and loader. The main goal of this step is to
make sure that design will achieve client requirement. Barges drivers were afraid of mooring on the berth beneath the
cant leaver beam during high water tide when barge is empty. It is very easy to change design in planning phase
otherwise it will be very expensive to apply this change in construction phase. The only way to dissipate the client fears
mentioned above was by two approaches. The first, to create 3-D model of loading system. The second, to simulate and
animate the whole system equipment to test maneuvering and clashes. The following figure shows the loader and an
excavator filling stone in barge and the barge is mooring on berth beneath cant leaver beam safely.

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Page 28

IPASJ International Journal of Management (IIJM)


A Publisher for Research Motivation ........

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Web Site: http://www.ipasj.org/IIJM/IIJM.htm


Email:editoriijit@ipasj.org
ISSN 2321-645X

The client took 28 days to approve the submitted 2D drawings. As the client is not proficient as engineers he wasnt
able to imagine or judge the operation of loading barges. 2D drawing didnt dissipate client fears of clash between
barge and cant leaver beam when the barge is empty. Using RTSM it took only 20 mints to model and simulate all
critical operations. Finally, RTSM saved this period which equal (3.83%) of time losses.

Figure 7 Testing operational phase


4.3.2 Structural Design
The concrete gravity wall consists of 11 supports each support consists of hundreds of blocks. After arrangement of
block in corner support and during loading test, the measured settlement exceeded the permissible limits of Egyptian
code. A gravity wall resists the overturning and sliding forces generated by the retained material by depending on its
own weight. The bearing pressures beneath the toe of the structure mustnt exceed the safe bearing capacity of the subsoil.
By entering soil properties in the software and applying loads on berth, it was easily found that the structural design is
safe. The main cause of settlement was due to inaccurate bearing capacity obtained during site investigation phase. The
contract mention that the contractor is the main responsible for assuring soil properties and overall stability of the
gravity wall. So, the contractor spent 80000 EGP for making new bore holes, removing blocks, increasing the depth of
sub-base, rearrangement of blocks and finally performing loading test again which cause project delay for 70 days. The
percent of time and cost losses are 9.58 % and 1.77 % respectively. Also due to lack of site investigation, the contractor
faced massive concrete blocks during dredging. The contractor took 32 days to bring divers trying to estimate its
weight. Then, to bring the required floating crane to lift it. BIM approach is not design to gather information but to
manage it. So, the software has limited role due to poor site investigation.

Figure 8 Structural design

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Page 29

IPASJ International Journal of Management (IIJM)


A Publisher for Research Motivation ........

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Web Site: http://www.ipasj.org/IIJM/IIJM.htm


Email:editoriijit@ipasj.org
ISSN 2321-645X

4.3.3 Construction Logistics


Arrangement of block in gravity wall is so complicated process. The overlap between two blocks should not be less than
.25 of the smaller block. In addition, it is more difficult to arrange block in corner supports. This exactly happened in
this project.
Creating 3-D-model of blocks gives the planner the ability to perform this job in very short time comparing with the
tradition way of 2D- delivery system. The contractor spent 18 days to prepare workshop drawing of block arrangement
in corner support and the consultant took 6 days for approval. The percent of time lose saved by RTSM software is 3.28
%. The following figure shows floating crane arranging blocks of corner support.

Figure 9 Construction logistic- Blocks arrangement of corner support


4.3.4 Schedule & Cost Estimation
The project duration is 2 years but due to the previous problems it exceeded finishing time. In this case, the owner has
the right to discount 10% of total project cost from the contractor. Many construction scenarios were obtained using
RTSM software. In each scenario, using various resources and without exceeding project budget the user could achieve
optimum schedule with reasonable budget. The following figures show the schedule performed by the software and also
cost estimation.

Figure 10 Developing Schedule

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Page 30

IPASJ International Journal of Management (IIJM)


A Publisher for Research Motivation ........

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Web Site: http://www.ipasj.org/IIJM/IIJM.htm


Email:editoriijit@ipasj.org
ISSN 2321-645X

Figure 11 Resource allocation + Cost estimation


4.3.5 Health & Safety Plans
During construction and exactly during block arrangement the crane driver moved a massive block over the cant leaver
reinforced beam which immediately caused cracks in this element. This problem caused rework of this element.
Demolishing the cracked beam, moving the demolished concrete to landfill and reconstruction of new beam took 45
days and cost 50000 EGP. The software offer all required health and safety tools which capable the planner to perform
health and safety plane. The cost of this plan could save life in addition to cost and time as shown in this case. The total
savings using RTSM software in this case are 6.16 % and 1.11% for time and cost respectively.
4.3.6 Sustainability & Waste Plans
For both sustainability and waste the RTSM software provide a checklist to help not only to achieve minimum budget
with reasonable time, but also to gain waste minimization costs and long term sustainability benefit.
The owner needs light columns manufactured from steel tubes to maintain light during night loading. And also, a hand
rail for stairs from steel angles for safety precautions. By entering the material of each element in the software and by
answering checklist questions, the software advices were to use fiber light columns and stainless steel hand rail. The
biggest figure of maintenance costs in marine projects is for repainting steel elements which it adversely affected by
corrosion. The ratio of cost to lifetime of unsustainable materials 18.26 reduced to 10.95 for sustainable materials by
following RTSM software advices.
4.3.7 Summary of Case Study
In this case seven problems reveals current situation of 2D delivery system. Problems could be classified into four main
categories which are; insufficient site investigation data, bad climate conditions, inadequate planning and Low
consideration given for health and safety. BIM could offer benefits related to information management. However, BIM
has limited role regarding enhancing the first two categories listed above which could be considered as data entry.

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Page 31

IPASJ International Journal of Management (IIJM)


Web Site: http://www.ipasj.org/IIJM/IIJM.htm
Email:editoriijit@ipasj.org
ISSN 2321-645X

A Publisher for Research Motivation ........

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Table 2: Problems classification


Problem
No.
1

3
4
5
6
7

Category

Problem description
After arranging blocks of corner support and during loading test, the
measured settlement exceeded the permissible limits in Egyptian code.
The client took a lot of time to approve the submitted 2D drawings.
As the client is not proficient as engineers he wasnt able to imagine
or judge the operation of loading barges. 2D drawing didnt dissipate
client fears of clash between barge and cant leaver beam when the
barge is empty.
Bad climate conditions
The contractor faced many problems for performing workshop
drawing of block arrangement in corner supports.
During excavation the contractor found massive concrete section
conflicting with the new gravity wall.
The crane driver put a huge concrete block tons over the cant leaver
beams which immediately caused failure cracks
Using unsustainable materials

Code

Category description

insufficient site investigation


data

Inadequate planning

Bad climate conditions

Inadequate planning

A
D
C

insufficient site investigation


data
Low consideration given for
health and safety
Inadequate planning

Waste

Sustainability

A
C
B
C
A
D
C
Total losses using 2D delivery system
losses using proposed framework will be
Efficiency using proposed framework

BIM
role

Health &
Safety

1
2
3
4
5
6
7

Category

Cost
%

Problem
No.

Time
%

Table 3: Efficiency of using proposed integrated information system


Effect on Multi-Dimensions

9.58
3.83
8.21
3.28
4.38
6.16
35.47
22.87
35.52

1.77
1.11
0.44
3.33
1.55
53.33

1
1
0
1

18.26
18.26
10.95
40

Figure 12 Efficiency of using proposed integrated information system

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Page 32

IPASJ International Journal of Management (IIJM)


A Publisher for Research Motivation ........

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Web Site: http://www.ipasj.org/IIJM/IIJM.htm


Email:editoriijit@ipasj.org
ISSN 2321-645X

5. CONCLUSION
BIM is the newest technology in construction management which is intended to give momentum to various construction
industry branches. The first part of this research investigated seven marine projects to find out the most repetitive and
influential factors causing inefficiency. The investigation showed that the main factors are; insufficient site investigation
data, change orders, security precautions, bad climate conditions, uneconomic design, poor supply, low consideration
given for health and safety and finally inadequate planning. BIM was introduced as a cutting edge solution for different
marine industry problems.
Development of BIM was surrounded by many hot areas recommended for study. One of the major challenges facing
project stakeholders, especially in marine projects, is the information islands phenomenon. This phenomenon arises
from using different software by each stakeholder, transformation of large amount of data and reuse of these data to
match stakeholders management approach. Interoperability was recommended as the main approach to close
information gaps. But development of interoperability was surrounded by two main obstacles. The first is the disability
of breaking down element when using IFC approach. The second, the difficulty of gathering and managing information
related to all stakeholders to be managed in one manner.
This research developed integrated information system to overcome barriers which hinder development of
interoperability in marine projects. This system is mainly consists of framework and software to validate the
framework. By applying the software to a real case study it was found the RTSM software enhanced project parties
capabilities to gain BIM benefits and to overcome the traditional problems of current 2D delivery system.

REFERENCE
[1]. Qinghua He1, Ge Wang, Qian Shi, and Yaxian Zhou. Application of Building Information Modeling (BIM) in
Chinas Megaprojects: Bibliographic Analysis, International Conference on Innovative Production and
Construction 2015 (IPC 2015), 28-31 July 2015, Perth, Australia, pp. 61-64, 2015.
[2]. Dr. Lieyun Ding, BIM Applications: From 3-D to n-D. Proceedings of 2012 Australasian Conference on
Innovative Technologies in Construction ,Wuhan, China, 6-7 December 2012, pp. 7-8, 2012.
[3]. Yaling Deng , Bo Xu, Xiao Li, Development and Frontier of Building Information Model Visualization Analysis
Based on Science Knowledge Map. International Conference on Innovative Production and Construction 2015
(IPC 2015), 28-31 July 2015, Perth, Australia, pp. 15-18, 2015.
[4]. Xinan Jiang, Developments in Cost Estimation and Scheduling in BIM Technology, Master of Science,
Northeastern University Boston, Massachusetts, 2011.
[5]. Masha Ghaznavi, Developing an Information Modeling Framework for Tunnel Construction Projects, Master of
science, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada, 2013.
[6]. Eastman, C., Teicholz, P., Sacks, R., and Liston, K. BIM Handbook, 2nd ed. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2011.
[7]. Bhargav Dave, Developing a Construction Management System Based on Lean Construction and Building
Information Modeling, PhD Thesis, University of Aalto, Finland, 2013.
[8]. NBIMS, National Building Information Modeling Standards: Overview Principles, and Methodologies. National
Institute of Building Sciences, United States (Version 1: Part 1, p. 21), 2007.
[9]. Christopher M.Hostetler, Building Information Modeling (BIM) and its Potential Impacts on Sustainable Building
Project Delivery, Master of Science, University of Florida, USA, 2009.
[10]. Force Technology, Virtual world replicating future reality, http://forcetechnology.com/en/maritimeindustry/cargo -vessels/simulation-studies-for-maritime-operations, [access date; May 2016].
[11]. Esri, Make Better Decisions the Moment Something Happens, Available: http://www.esri.com/products/arcgiscapabilities/real-time-gis , [access date; October 2016].

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Page 33

IPASJ International Journal of Management (IIJM)


A Publisher for Research Motivation ........

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Web Site: http://www.ipasj.org/IIJM/IIJM.htm


Email:editoriijit@ipasj.org
ISSN 2321-645X

AUTHOR
Eng. Mohamed Abd Elmoty Mohamed Khalil received the B.S. degree in Civil Engineering
from Suez Canal University , Egypt in 2007, I received the M.S. degree in Construction
Engineering from Port Said University in 2013 ,worked as site engineering in Arab Contractors
Company, Egypt from(2007-2010), currently I am designer of marine structures in Suez Canal
Authority.

Prof. Mohamed Ahmed Mohamadien is Professor of Steel Structure, Faculty of Engineering ,


Suez Canal University, I received the M.S. degree in Construction Engineering from Suez Canal
University in 1983 and PhD in Construction Engineering from Bath University, England 1990, I
am the Former president of Port Said University from (2010-2011) and the Former president of
Suez Canal University-Egypt from (2011-2015),. I am Member of Several committees for the
Egyptian Code for Design and maintenance of bridges. Involved in conducting research work in
the areas of steel structure, Bridge Maintenance and Management Systems.
Prof. Hassan Mohamed Hassan Ibrahim is Professor of Concrete Structures, Faculty of
Engineering, Port Said University, I received the M.S. degree in Construction Engineering from
Suez Canal University in 1991 and PhD in Construction Engineering from Suez Canal/EgyptOttawa/Canada University in 1996, I am the Ex-Head of Civil Engineering Department of Port
Said University from (2012-2014) and the Vice Dean of Educational and Student Affairs of
faculty of Engineering of Port Said University-Egypt from (2015-.). My research areas are
Design/ Numerical Analysis of Concrete Structures and Construction Projects Management.
Assoc. Prof. Ibrahim M. Mahdi is associated professor of project management at Future
University of Egypt. Mahdi has over 30 years of professional experience in all phases of project
management including Planning, Cost a, Risk management and Project Control. He has been
responsible for many assignments of highly technical projects in Egypt and Kuwait. His
experience includes Preparing tenders packages; receiving and analyzing tenders, making
consultant and contractor recommendations, issuing, executing and administering contracts; and
finally, supervising the construction to insure quality and schedule requirements are met.
Specialties: Assoc. Prof. Project Management and Project management Consultant

Volume 4, Issue 10, October 2016

Page 34

Anda mungkin juga menyukai