Anda di halaman 1dari 1

Scientific Method Peer Review

Scientist:______________________________ Reviewer: _____________________________


Review the work of your fellow scientist by using the rubric below. Remember to be fair, honest,
and polite.
Inquiry Components

Score

Is their question testable?


Does their hypothesis clearly state a prediction based on general knowledge
and is it written correctly?
Do they provide evidence of meaningful research?
Are their procedures clear and precise enough for another scientist to
follow?

Are their data tables/graphs/observations well organized? (data tables,


charts, and graphs in the right format for data collected) Do their details tie
in to their question and hypothesis?
Does their conclusion include a detailed explanation of their results and
whether their hypothesis was supported or not? Did they explain what they
have learned from the investigation?
Total

Scientific Method Peer Review


Scientist:______________________________ Reviewer: _____________________________
Review the work of your fellow scientist by using the rubric below. Remember to be fair, honest,
and polite.
Inquiry Components

Score

Is their question testable?


Does their hypothesis clearly state a prediction based on general knowledge
and is it written correctly?
Do they provide evidence of meaningful research?
Are their procedures clear and precise enough for another scientist to
follow?

Are their data tables/graphs/observations well organized? (data tables,


charts, and graphs in the right format for data collected) Do their details tie
in to their question and hypothesis?
Does their conclusion include a detailed explanation of their results and
whether their hypothesis was supported or not? Did they explain what they
have learned from the investigation?
Total