English 360 Portfolio Rubric for Revised Documents

Absent or
Below Basic

Developing

Proficient

Advanced

Form: Design

Figures or formatting do not

match the papers purpose or
are not explained by author.

Some figures and formatting help

author achieve purpose.

Designincluding figures and

formathelps author achieve
purpose.

Designincluding figures and

formathelps author achieve
purpose with style.

Form: Genre

Generic conventions are not

employed.

Follows most generic conventions

(whether for instruction manual,
cover letter, etc.)

Follows generic conventions

(whether for instruction manual,
cover letter, etc.).

Follows generic conventions

(whether for instruction
manual, cover letter, etc.)
consistently and with
sophistication.

Content:
Information

Fails to provide most of the

required information.

Supplies some necessary

information.

Supplies all necessary

information.

Supplies all necessary

information with
sophistication.

Content:
Support

Typically does not support

claims with evidence.
Sometimes tries to support
claims with additional claims or
personal opinion.

Supports a few claims with

evidence, although the evidence
could at times be more specific or
relevant.

Supports most claims with

specific, relevant details and/or
evidence.

Supports all claims with

specific, relevant details and/or
evidence. Employs different
types of evidence.

Content:
Organization

Frequently unorganized:
difficult to find a clear
relationship between
paragraphs or sentences.
Headings are inappropriate,
unclear or absent.

Demonstrates some signs of

organization, but occasionally
includes abrupt or illogical shifts
and ineffective sequence of ideas.
Headings may not be appropriate
or clear.

Effectively ordered paragraphs

generally cover only one topic
each and are linked with useful
transitions. Headings are usually
appropriate and clear.
Sentences typically flow
logically.

Effectively ordered paragraphs

cover only one topic each and
are generally linked with
useful transitions. Headings
are appropriate and clear.
Sentences flow logically to
persuade reader.

English 360 Portfolio Rubric for Revised Documents

Citations:

Omits or uses incorrectly

MLA- or APA-style
parenthetical citations,
quotation marks, and works
cited list. Drops quotations and
ideas into text without
introducing source.

A few errors in MLA- or APAstyle parenthetical citations,

quotation marks, and works cited
list. Often includes sources names
without introduction.

Correctly uses MLA- or APAstyle parenthetical citations,

quotation marks, and works cited
list. Usually introduces each
source fullyyou know who did
the research or talking, for
whom, and why.

Correctly uses MLA- or APAstyle parenthetical citations,

quotation marks, and works
cited list. Introduces each
source fullyyou know who
did the research or talking, for
whom, and why.

Readability:

Spelling, syntax, diction, or

punctuation errors impede
readability.

Spelling, syntax, diction, or

punctuation errors impede
readability or otherwise distract
from meaning.

Spelling, syntax, diction, or

punctuation errors are few and
do not distract from meaning.

Outstanding control of
language, including effective
diction and sentence variety.

Comments: On what two or three areas do you think this writer needs to focus before submitting this document
Grammar at the end of Fan Needs to be Replaced section is inconsistent. Consider making all examples the same type.
Long paragraph under Loose Headphone Jack. Consider simplifying sentences, or dividing section into different sections for driver not working and
physical damage to headphone jack, to provide two separate solutions for the issue.