BETHANY SALMON
University of Illinois at Chicago | Department of Urban Planning & Policy
Community Development | Advisor: Kheir Al-Kodmany | Summer 2016
II
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1) Executive Summary
13
69
5) Recommendations
117
6) Conclusion
155
7) References
157
III
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Historic preservation generally conjures images of unique,
grand buildings and distinct old neighborhoods in cities, urban
areas, and main street communities. Yet, historic assets within
suburban environments are often less well known, less visible,
and underappreciated. While perceptions of postwar suburbia are
changing alongside new ways of planning, they are still viewed
as merely artifact of the automobile age characterized by sprawl,
parking lots, expansive subdivisions, strip malls, and highways.
Consequently, in many suburbs, preservation has received less
attention and efforts to save historic buildings from the wrecking
ball floundered with unprecedented growth in the postwar years.
Unfortunately, the result is the loss of countless buildings and
structures that represent unique regional or local patterns of
development that occurred before the postwar suburban trend.
Despite being known for its post-war suburban development,
the Village of Orland Park possesses a small Historic District
with a variety of late 19th and early 20th century buildings
that highlight the Villages early beginnings and contribute to
its sense of place. Amid the Villages suburban character and
Many neighborhoods and suburbs in the Chicago region can trace their history
back to the growth of the rail network. The arrival of the railroad in 1848
created an economic foundation for newly developing towns and an efficient
way for farmers and businesses in outlying areas to trade and sell products in
Chicago.1 Around newly laid railroads and depot stations, farmers, residents,
workers, commuters, and developers built settlements that would eventually
evolve into new towns and suburbs. Similar to other communities, Orland
Parks pattern of development that originated during the railroad age is still
somewhat visible today. The original town formed closely to the rail line and
its depot. Although the area was primarily developed with single family homes,
it also includes early multi-family, commercial, restaurant, church, office, and
mixed-use buildings.
While the Village has led various efforts to improve Old Orland and promote
the restoration of its historic buildings, the District faces several challenges
that restrain its future and the preservation of remaining historic buildings. Of
note, the combination of outdated zoning and land development policies, the
recent dismantling of the Historic Preservation Review Commission, increasing
market pressures for redevelopment and the demolition of historic buildings
threatens to undermine Old Orlands character and integrity. Addressing these
challenges will create new opportunities for improvement and will help to
transform the District into a vibrant, dynamic neighborhood that preserves the
past while leaving room for future change.
Old Orland remains a marker of the Villages early history despite the postwar suburban development that virtually surrounds it. Careful planning
and implementation of revised Village policies can ensure that contributing
buildings with historic significance are not destroyed and are protected against
demolition, new construction is compatible with the existing neighborhood
character, and the neighborhood is an economically vibrant and beneficial
resource for the future.
Given the extensive redevelopment occurring in and around Old Orland,
primarily within Orland Parks Main Street downtown area, a renewed
attention, neighborhood planning and historic preservation considerations
should take place in Old Orland. Although the District no longer serves as
the original downtown, Old Orland stands as one of the few places left that
commemorates the Villages growth in the early 20th century.
The overall goal of this plan is to identify Old Orlands meaningful past and
contributions to the Village over time, up to the present. The developmental
history of the Village and key planning considerations for Old Orland are
intended to highlight the urgency for preserving what remains of the District,
as well as strategies to improve the neighborhood. A strategic plan for the
future will help ensure that the Historic District will stand as a living community
and remain a memorable, beneficial resource for the future.
Reconsidering Orland Parks policies and design guidelines that impact the
area can provide opportunities to improve Old Orlands underlying value and
support the maintenance of existing historic buildings. Despite an increase in
teardowns over the past decade, adopting an updated historic preservation
ordinance, effective strategy, and new policies or programs will help
strengthen, preserve, and protect Old Orlands historic sense of place and
simultaneously encourage future stability. The recommendations will highlight
the need for the Village to protect its historic resources and include a range of
possible planning initiatives, including new construction and design guidelines.
The prospects for Old Orland are yet to be fully explored but may be great in
themselves. Building on the momentum of Orland Parks new downtown, the
future for Old Orland holds a range of possibilities.
DOCUMENT OVERVIEW
The remainder of this document will contain the following chapters:
2) Overview of the Old Orland Historic District & Surrounding Areas
This chapter will provide a brief background of the Historic District, introducing
its general characteristics today, the location, and surrounding areas.
3) The Development of A Suburb - A History Of Orland Park's Growth
The history and development of Orland Park will be discussed, including the
Village's rural history, its start as a small railroad town, unprecedented post-
ABOVE: Images of the Old Orland Historic District today (Bethany Salmon).
ABOVE: Images of the Old Orland Historic District today (Bethany Salmon).
REGIONAL MAP
LAKE
MCHENRY
LAKE
MICHIGAN
294
COOK
90
94
290
290
KANE
DUPAGE
90
355
290
88
COOK
Chicago
88
90
294
55
Orland
Park
KENDALL
94
80
80
55
WILL
57
GRUNDY
SO
UT
HW
ES
T
HW
NEIGHBORING DISTRICTS
MAIN
STREET
143RD STREET
OLD
ORLAND
NEARBY NEIGHBORHOODS
ORLAND
CROSSING
VILLAGE
CAMPUS
LAGRANGE ROAD
LEGEND
RAVINIA A
VE
NU
WEST AVENUE
T
OU
TH
W
ES
ME
TR
AS
Old Orland
Historic District
Village Boundary
Metra Station
1/2 MILE
1/4
10
Cook County
Orland Grove
Forest Preserve
McGinnis
Slough
143RD STREET
METRA STATION
142ND STREET
UT
HW
ES
T
LI
NE
Crescent
Park
SO
Ninety7Fifty
M
ET
RA
Orland Park
Elementary
LAGRANGE ROAD
SO
UT
H
ES
T
H
W
Y
Orland
Crossing
University of
Chicago
Medicine Center
& Parking Deck
143RD STREET
VE
UE
143RD STREET
11
Humphrey
House
Frontier
Park
SO
RA
145TH PLACE
Humphrey
Woods
Humphrey
Sports
Complex
Orland
Park
Recreation
Franklin
Loebe
Center
147TH STREET
Village
Hall
Civic
Center
LEGEND
Old Orland Historic District
Village Boundary
Orland
Township
Orland Park
Library
Orland Square
Mall
LAGRANGE ROAD
K
OL
RF
RAVINIA AVENUE
ER
H
UT
JOHN HUMP
HRE
YD
RIV
E
LR
O
AD
RAVINIA AVENUE
144TH PLACE
94TH AVENUE
Twin
Towers
Church
WEST AVENUE
BEACON AVENUE
UNIO N A
NINETY7FIFTY
VILLAGE CENTER
12
13
14
15
16
17
Accelerated growth patterns that had affected the north and west suburbs
found its way to southwestern areas of Cook County. New single family
homes were constructed at unprecedented rates due to plentiful undeveloped
land and cheaper prices. As land values rose, it became more profitable for
farmers to sell their land than to continue cultivating it.
By the early 1980s, it was clear that Orland was no longer a small farming
community, but a burgeoning suburb. Following trends of suburbanization,
rapid residential and commercial development expanded the original
boundaries as land was annexed into the Village. Subdivisions replaced
farm fields and the town evolved into a suburban center. An expanded water
and sewer system, roads, schools, parks and recreational areas helped to
attract new development. New public facilities were added, including a new
Village Center, library, police station, aquatic center, sports complex, parks,
train stations, and bike paths.
ORLAND PARK TODAY
Orland Parks growth over the past century epitomizes the economic and
population booms that engulfed Chicagos southwest suburbs. Today, its past
rural landscape is barely visible among its subdivisions and shopping malls.
Orland Park has become one of the most attractive suburban communities
southwest of Chicago. It has maintained its status as a regional commercial
center with a variety of shopping, dining and entertainment options. As an
upscale suburb, Orland Park embraces a strong suburban character with a
variety of housing options, a well-connected transportation system, and an
abundance of recreational activities.
Over the past decade, the Village has continued to change with redevelopment
and new construction. Recent efforts have culminated in a new transitoriented downtown. The Main Street Downtown District is currently under
construction and highlights efforts to transform Orland Park from its classic
automobile-dependent suburb into an adaptive, modern Village.
1970
1995
1978
2016
18
"Orland Park was shaped by the people who came, immigrants who despaired
of having a good life in the old country and looked to the new land for freedom
from want and for their share of happiness. They come to a rolling countryside
where birds of a hundred species gathered at the slough on migratory flights,
a land of tall prairie grasses, woods and fields, marsh and creek. The land was
there, a reward and a challenge. It would be a hard fight but it would lead to a
satisfying life and a new beginning."
Over the next few decades, additional European settlers arrived in search
of land for farming.3 Immigrants, largely from England and Germany,
constructed small log cabins on farm land and established what was then
known as the English Settlement. Farmhouses dotted the rural landscape
and new institutions were built to support the small rural community. In
1848, the first post office was established and the first school was built in
the following year. In later years, as new settlers purchased land in the area,
additional small schools were constructed and a road was established.
By 1850, Orland Township was formed. With a population of 504, there were
approximately 78 small farms that covered 15% of the entire township.4
James H. Rees map of 1851, to the right, showcases the rural nature of
the township as well as the primacy of the entire Chicago region prior to
the construction of the railroad. Groves, marshes, and creeks dominated
the landscape and a few roads traversed the area, providing the only
connections to the nearby communities. Farms dotted the township and
typically included a small number of livestock and produced a mix of grain
crops, potatoes, and butter.
Over the next decade, the agricultural community nearly doubled. In
1860 The Townships population grew to 1,049 people and the number of
farms increased to 30% of land area. While the size of the farms generally
remained small, Orland was showing small signs of growth.
19
LEFT: Orland Township Map in 1851 showing the locations of farms, groves, marshes, and few
roads traversing the area (Rees, 1851); RIGHT: Hostert Cabins, built by two of the first settlers to
the area (Village of Orland Park Archives).
had to travel long distances by wagon over mud and dirt roads to trade areas
such as Lockport, approximately 12 miles away. The Illinois and Michigan Canal
traversed Lockport and provided an established water transportation corridor
from Chicago to the Illinois River and Mississippi River.
But with the construction of the Wabash Railroad, which traveled from Chicago
to St. Louis, Orland transformed into a farm center. It triggered the development
of a small town that served as a commercial and transportation hub for the
surrounding farm community. Farmers and businesses obtained a new way to
directly and conveniently ship diary products and livestock to Chicago.9 With its
new access to the city center, Orland became a rural market town, spurring
a shift in agricultural production from grains to dairy products and livestock:
Orland became the starting point for cattle, arriving from the Chicago Union
Stock Yards, would be unloaded at Orland, then moved by the cattle drive out
to the farms to be fattened for market. After fattening, the cattle were returned
to Chicago for slaughter by way of the Wabash. 10,11 In addition to the cattle
and milk trains, the Wabash railroad accommodated passenger trains. By 1911,
eight daily trains ran from Orland to Chicago.12
20
21
TOP LEFT: Krupes Saloon on 143rd Place; TOP RIGHT: United Methodist Church & Twin
Towers on 144th Place circa 1900; BOTTOM LEFT: Orland Park Hotel on Union Avenue;
BOTTOM RIGHT: German Lutheran Church in 1898 at 143rd Street and West Avenue (Village
of Orland Park Archives, Orland Historical Society).
For the small size of the downtown, there were a large number of saloons. A
description of Orland Park in 1884 highlights the character of the town at that
time: "It may be mentioned in passing, and as showing the extreme temperance
proclivities of the citizens here, that in 1883, at the spring election, the question
of permitting a saloon to be established within the Village limits, was decided in
the affirmative, by the exceedingly popular vote of 98 to 1. As the place has a
population considerably less than two hundred, and now has two saloons, the
above vote indicates the unanimity of opinion in regard to the beneficial influence,
which their institutions wield over the morals of a community."18
There was a fierce struggle between the wets and the drys during the
towns early history.19 While travelers and residents were attracted to the
saloons, new churches were constructed to serve the local congregations. In
particular, the farming community as well as town residents attended the Christ
Lutheran Church and Orland Methodist Church, both of which still are located
in the Old Orland Historic District. Yet, any early efforts to reform the town
LEFT: Orlands developing town in 1886. (L.M. Snyder & Co., 1886); MIDDLE: Original Village Hall on Beacon Avenue in the late 1800s; RIGHT: Post office located at Beacon Avenue and 143rd
Street (Village archives, Orland Historical Society).
22
23
ABOVE: Birdseye aerial image of the Old Orland area, Orland Park's original downtown circa 1930 (Village Archives).
24
a train depot, a bank, a creamery, a lumber yard, a combination Village hall and
firehouse, a barber shop, a post office, a doctor, a dentist, and a baseball
diamond.28 Although businesses came and went, the town was deemed a
worthwhile shopping trip due to the concentration of goods and services
provided. Local shopkeepers all contributed to the community beyond the
mere marketing of essential goods. Their stores attracted outsiders to Orland
and served as gathering places to meet neighbors and friends and to exchange
news. In return, this friendly group of proprietors served the town as community
leaders.29 The end of Prohibition in 1933 restarted Orlands saloon economy.30
Immediately after Prohibition was repealed, three new saloons opened in town.
At the same time, new businesses opened or expanded with the town beginning
to show signs of the spirit of perseverance and commercial enterprise that led
to later expansion.31
"Change came slowly to Orland Park. At the turn of the century more
people lived outside of the village limits than within them, confirming the
agricultural character of the area. Although farm development peaked in
the 1880s it remained constant for many decades thereafter."
McGuire, Igleski & Associates, 2008, 18
25
TOP: Middle Street, now 143rd Place, circa 1900 looking east. Middle Street featured wooden
sidewalks, a bakery, and general store; BOTTOM: View of the town in the 1900s, with the
German Lutheran Church to the left and Twin Towers on the right (Village archives, Orland
Historical Society).
"Perhaps a visiting writer with only a brief time to observe ... might
come to believe that Orland was not moving forward. But from 1920 to
1945 the people of Orland Park worked together to pull through three
successive periods of great difficulty and avoided many of the calamites
that befell similar communities across the country. With its young men
returning from the war and its sense of pride and mutual respect intact,
Orland Park was well-positioned to prosper in the post-war boom years."
Orland Heritage Book Association, 1991, 11
MCGINNIS
SLOUGH
LAGRANGE ROAD
143RD STREET
1938
26
27
"In 1920, Orland had no electricity, no paved roads, few automobiles, and a
few farm tractors. It was still the age of horse and wagon, kerosene lamps, and
traveling medicine shows. The village had about three blacksmith shops and a
livery stable. The train was the easiest was out of town. The train service was, in
fact, as good or better than it is today. The Orland State Bank had one employee
and was located at the corner of a meat market on Beacon Avenue."
Orland Heritage Book Association, 1991, 88
LEFT: The construction of 144th Place circa 1945; RIGHT: A rural road in the Village (Village of Orland Park Archives).
2,592
2,500
2,000
1,500
1,000
500
0
788
366
1900
369
1910
343
1920
571
631
1930
1940
1950
1960
28
While new retail and services accommodated a growing demand, Of the surrounding Villages,
only Palos Heights and Tinley Park have shopping facilities adequate to supplement those of
Orland Park. In these towns are found hardware stores, large food Supermarkets, 5-and-10
stores, clothing stores, bakeries, and drug stores.50
Orland Park began to slowly follow suburban development patterns, with new development
spatially dispersed throughout the Village along roads and highway routes.51 The pattern
of development resulted in new shopping centers and the shift from the original downtown
to outlying areas. Growth was no longer base on the Wabash railroad but on the rise of the
automobile. During this period, farmland was slowly converted into larger subdivisions and
commercial establishments to support the increasing number of residents.
29
In particular, shopping centers became the engine of Orland Parks growth, transforming it
from a quite farm town into one of Chicagos fastest growing suburbs. In 1956, Orland Plaza,
at 143rd Street was constructed, effectively leading to the relocation of Orland State Bank
from Old Orland to LaGrange Road. The following year the post office relocated as well. A
new grocery store and drug store were opened to increase shopping and services.52 In 1963,
Orland Parks number of businesses grew to 27 and by 1967, that number had grown to 36.53
Through the 1960s, retail sales generally lagged rather substantially behind the potential
retail sales by people in the area.54 Although retail sales grew alongside the increase in
population, retail facilities catering to the consumer needs of the community at present will
be through the future given the size of the future population living in and around the present
boundaries of Orland Park.55
30
Although businesses were moving out of the original downtown, the Old Orland
area continued to contribute to Orland Parks economic base. As noted in the
1969 Comprehensive Plan, overall buildings remained in generally sound structural
condition with only a handful of dwellings in need of repairs or were dilapidated. Yet,
the future role of the original downtown was correctly projected: The traditional
central business district of the Village has been replaced by the Orland Plaza Shopping
Center. The Plaza is a neighborhood size center and has served the community well.
With the population expected to reach some 27,000 to 30,000 by 1985 in the Village
alone, a suitable location should be chosen for a regional shopping center.56
THE BEGINNINGS OF A RESIDENTIAL BOOM
A huge surge in new residential construction occurred in the Chicago Metropolitan
area in the post-war years.57 The housing market shifted to larger, more expensive
single family homes in outlying areas of the city.58 Similar to the location of industry
LEFT: Orland Plaza on 143rd Street and LaGrange Road (Wm. S. Lawrence and Associates & Orland Park Plan Commission, A Comprehensive Plan for Orland Park, Illinois, G-7.5);
RIGHT: Photograph of Orland Plaza and Marquette Bank in 2014 (BRC Photography. Marquette Bank, Orland Park, ILL. Flickr. June 16, 2014. https://www.flickr.com/photos/9385421@
N08/14438110972/)
31
From roughly 19601970, Orland Parks housing doubled. According to the 1960
Census, there were 696 dwelling units in the Village and by 1968 there were 1,407.61
Of the 711 new housing units, 92% were predominately single family homes. During
that same period the median value of owner occupied units rose almost 23%.
As new housing dotted the Village, new types of residents moved in. In 1960, the
Village included a larger portion of younger residents between 25-34, had one of the
highest education levels compared to the surrounding communities according to the
percentage of the population with high school degrees, and contained a relatively
stable median family income.62 Residents primarily worked in professional and
technical jobs as well as craftsmen, foremen, and clerical workers. Very few non-white
families lived in the area. The wave of new housing would soon turn the Village into a
strong middle and upper class community.
Some residents showed concern over new development and the influx of residents.
Concerns over growth would continue over the next few decades. According to one
resident, At one point, you had this competition between Old Orland and Orland
Park Hills. Then a new area, Fairway, came along and Old Orland and Orland Park
1960
1961
1962
Orland Park
1963
Oak Forest
1964
1965
Palos Heights
1966
1967
1968
Tinley Park
TOP: Housing construction in Orland Park and nearby suburbs from 1960-1968 (Wm. S. Lawrence and Associates & Orland Park Plan Commission, A Comprehensive Plan for Orland Park, Illinois,
B-23 - B-24); BOTTOM LEFT AND MIDDLE: Orland Hills Subdivision (Wm. S. Lawrence and Associates & Orland Park Plan Commission, A Comprehensive Plan for Orland Park, Illinois, H-9); BOTTOM RIGHT: Model homes in 1950s circa 1950s (Orland Heritage Book Association, 1991, 124; Village Archives).
32
Hills joined forces to keep these newcomers out of office.63 The University of Chicago's Plan
for the Andrew Corporation and Orland Park in 1951 also highlights some of concerns over new
development: The only interest in local affairs which most of the people of Orland Park feel
appears to be an interest in keeping taxes low. Because they believe that further development of
the community would result in higher taxes, most of the are apparently opposed to it.64
INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS
Municipal improvements were necessary to make way for new subdivisions and development
projects. During the mid 1950s, water and sewage systems were constructed and expanded to
serve newly incorporated areas. Additionally, transportation improvements and the construction of
new roads were initiated. Major thoroughfares included LaGrange Road, Harlem Avenue, Wolf Road,
151st Street, 159th Street, and 143rd Street, which remain major streets today. These improvements
were vital in attracting prominent residential, commercial and manufacturing projects.
THE ANDREW CORPORATION
Alongside the development of new housing, retail establishments, and shopping plazas, new
industries emerged. In 1953, the Andrew Corporation constructed a telecommunications
manufacturing facility in Orland Park.66 By 1960, the company relocated their company headquarters
and all of their Chicago-based operations to Orland Park. In many ways, the Andrew Corporation was
crucial to the Village's development, not only through providing steady employment opportunities,
but also from civic involvement. As they grew into a global communications equipment industry,
the company assisted with a number of buildings and contributions to projects including churches,
schools and recreation, and the library.67 The Andrew Corporation became the largest employer in
Orland Park over the following decades. After about five decades of manufacturing communications
equipment, the facility closed in 2007.
LAND USES
In 1951, commercial development existed almost exclusively on 143rd Street near the original
downtown. By 1969, retail establishments extended outward along LaGrange Road. Industrial
development was still rather limited. By the end of the 1960s, the predominant land use was
single family with a major portion of the Village dedicated to open space and Cook County Forest
Preserves.65 The following land use maps highlights changes in development patterns between
1951 and 1969.
33
LAND USE
ACRES
Single Family
Farmsteads
Multifamily
Retail
Manufacturing (Light)
Manufacturing (Heavy)
Auto
Quasi Public
Parks
Forest Preserve
Railroads
Streets
Water
275.93
2.06
1.80
25.96
6.65
59.76
5.98
14.67
13.21
228.36
22.65
153.62
92.66
903.65
2020.18
1116.53
34
As Orland Park began to show its first signs of growth, a handful of comprehensive
plans were developed to manage change over the next decades. Early plans
highlight the ways in which Orland Park began transforming into a suburb.
Toward a Plan for the Andrew Corporation and the Orland Park Community (1951)
With the assistance of the University of Chicago, the Andrew Corporation may
have created one of Orland Parks first attempts at a master plan. In 1951,
Toward a Plan for the Andrew Corporation and the Orland Park Community: A
Pre-Planning Report introduced a proposal to locate the Andrew Corporations
new manufacturing facility in Orland Park as well as concepts for development
surrounding the site. The document not only focuses on a proposed 420-acre
site for a modern manufacturing facility and alternative options for a planned
community of residential and civic uses surrounding the plant, but also on broader
recommendations for future of Orland Park.
Recognizing future trends and foreseeing the next twenty years will be crucial
in the growth of the Orland Park area, the plan aimed to assist with guiding future
policy decisions and land uses for the Village as a whole.68 It repeatedly declared
that steps needed to be made to ensure that the pattern of future development
would not be unplanned or uncontrolled. According to the report,
unplanned and uncontrolled development may bring Orland Park within
the typical suburban sprawl pattern of the metropolitan region, a pattern
sometimes known as rurbanization. This pattern is characterized by
elements of both urban and rural development, but lacks some of the
major advantages of each. Population densities are usually too low to
permit economic provision of the amenities and services offered by the
urban community. At the same time most of the spacious charm of country
living is also lacking, or at least threated by the imminent encroachment
of an indiscriminate mixture of uncontrolled land uses such as roadside
stores and taverns, factories, country clubs, airports, and speculative
residential constructionModern development in the field of cooperative
community action have proved that positive steps can be taken to prevent
indiscriminate ruban growth. Community planning, with its tools of
35
LEFT: Proposed Land Use Plan in 1951 (University of Chicago & Andrew Corporation,
Toward a Plan for the Andrew Corporation and the Orland Park Community, 85).
would a small downtown and limited housing suffice: Orland Parks outlook
should be pointed to the future to achieve the greatest balanced developmental
growth. The potential in this area is so great in relation to what has happened
in the past that any discussion of the economic factors in planning would be
seriously remiss if it was limited to merely a projection of what has already
occurred in the community, but it is necessary to start the discussion at that
point.72
The 1969 Plan suggested major projects that would never materialized, but
if implemented, would have dramatically changed the course of the Villages
development. These proposed projects also highlighted the planning mentalities
during the beginnings of suburbanization in which they were proposed. For
example, two major highways were proposed through the center of Orland
Park. The two proposed highways were intended to connect to nearby existing
highways, including I-80, I-295, I-55, I-57, I-94. Interchanges were recommended
on LaGrange Road and just south of 151st Street or at 147th Street, as well as on
151st Street just west of Wolf Road, and 131st and Southwest Highway. It was
believed that transportation was vital to economic development as one of the
more important needs of our society is the effective and expedient movement
of people and commodities. This need has been met with the development of
a highly complex system of transportation which is literally the lifeline of this
nation.With the rapid growth predicted for the Orland Park area and the plans
for two new expressway locations closely connected to the Village, considerable
additions and improvements will be needed to the local street systems.73
According to the plan, the lack of highway transportation connecting to adjacent
communities and Chicago was marked as a major reason for lack of previous
development in the area.74 New highways and major roads were necessary
to link Orland Park to Chicago and outlying areas: Transportation has had a
fundamental impact of the development of Orland Park. This will continue to be
the case in the years to come, but the extent of this impact will depend on the
communitys ability to meet modern traffic requirements.75
Access through effective transportation was crucial to connecting urban centers,
places of employment, commerce, and social, educational, and recreational
activities. New highways would allow employees to live farther away from
36
their work place and commute between Chicago, nearby suburbs, and Orland
Park. They would also attract new industry, a rising population, and economic
development bolstered by an increase in automobile traffic into and out of town:
With the construction of two interstate highways close to and possibly through
the Village of Orland Park will provide the means of linking Orland Park directly
with central Chicago and outlying businesses and residential areas. These
centers will continue to spin off old industries and to promote new ones and
people continue to be attracted to the suburbs for residence.76
In addition to highway and road improvements, the 1969 Plan also called for
connectivity and transportation improvements by locating a new major airport
in the southwest Chicago near Orland Park. As Chicagolands third airport, in
addition to Midway and OHare, the new airport would further promote future
growth and secure Orland Park as a major town in the south and southwest
suburbs.
In the late 1960s, residential construction was beginning to emerge in Orland Park.
As such, the 1969 Comprehensive Plan focused on new housing construction
as one of the primary factors in the Villages future growth. Alongside new
transportation and infrastructure improvements, Orland Park and the southwest
suburbs were next in line for the coming residential boom: The housing market
looks good through the planning period particularly in the southwest portion of
37
Cook County due to the availability of large tracts of land suitable for residential
division development at relatively low cost and due to the proposed highways,
which will be built through this area which will open up this section of the
Chicago SMSA, previously lacking expressway accessibility.77 People would
undoubtedly be attracted to the Village: the desire of people to want to live in
Orland Park will be very great.The most important piece of information above
all to be remembered is that there will be a high demand through the immediate
future and beyond for developers to build here, for businesses to establish
plants here, and for people to live here.78
Comprehensive planning was considered necessary to ensure the community
formed in a proper and balanced manner. The increase in new homes created
a need for new schools, churchs, shopping centers, recreational area, and
commercial and office buildings. As such, recreational needs, open spaces,
schools, public buildings, and utilities were also a major focus of improvements
needed to meet the growing populations needs and manage growth. The new
sewage treatment facility, attractiveness of the community in relation to the
amenities provided for suburban living (good schools, open spaces, clean air
and environment, broad housing market, decentralized political institutions,
good employment opportunities, etc.) and the annexation of surrounding
unincorporated land were all touted as major forces that would aid growth in
Orland Park.79
38
39
788
1900
1920 Heritage
1930
1940 1991, 230
1950
Orland
Book Association,
1910
56,767
51,077
50,000
40,000
34,391
30,000
23,045
20,000
10,000
788
1950
2,592
6,391
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
2010
RIGHT: Topographic Map of Orland Park, with purple areas highlighting the extension
of urban areas in 1963 to 1973 / 1980 (United States Geological Survey, Palos Park,
Tinley Park Mokena, and Sag Bridge Quadrangle Maps, Scale 1:24,000, 1974 Edition
(1963, photorevised 1973 and 1980, Historical Topographic Map Collection).
40
financial futures, found it more profitable to sell their land to developers rather
than farm it. Higher land taxes and increasingly expensive farming methods cut
sharply into profits. As a result, farming as a way of life in Orland Park began
to wane.93 By 1986, Orland Park was deemed the second-fastest growing
community based on the number of building permits issued and the scope of
construction activity, only behind Naperville in the west suburbs.94
THE RISE OF THE MALL AND SURROUNDING SHOPPING CENTERS
Prior to the 1970s, Orland Park had grown to accommodate a small retail
and service center, but most residents continued to rely on nearby larger
towns and Chicago for shopping, health care, and jobs. Yet after the 1970s,
the unprecedented increase in retail establishments and shopping centers
transformed the Village. Between 1970 and 1984, approximately 2 million square
feet of retail was built in the Village.95 During the same period, the population
rose from 6,391 to about 25,000, highlighting both the substantial commercial
and residential growth. Retail sales increased 115%, from $8,231,863 in 1967 to
$17,699,000 in 1972.96
Orland Parks success was secured with the construction of Orland Square
Mall. In 1976, Orland Square Mall was constructed at 151st and LaGrange
Road on land previously used for farming. The construction of Orland Square
Mall coincided with the national trend of developing major shopping centers in
suburban areas within the outer rings of a citys metropolitan area.97 The location
of a major regional shopping center with about 1.2 million square feet of retail
space secured Orland Park as a prominent suburb and the commercial hub of
the southwest Chicago region.
While some suburban communities primarily focused on redeveloping farmland
for housing for ex-urbanites, Orland Park burgeoned also as a prominent
commercial center. As written in a Chicago Tribune article in 1983, to be put
on the map, [a Village] need something more than tract homes as far as the eye
can see, with fix-figure price tags and two-car attached garages that are the
homes most prominent architectural trait. Very often, it takes a super-regional
shopping mall to make a place like Orland Park, a little more than a cow town
a decade ago, into a household word for thousands of southwest suburban
41
residents. Suffice it to say, Orland Park would not be what it is today were it not
for the sprawling Orland Square shopping mallEven without Orland Square,
the inexorable suburban sprawl of the 1970s would have seen the Village grow
as acre after acre was annexed and households filled with families sprang from
the ground as bountifully as crops once had.98
It was Orland Square Mall that put the Village on the map. The Mall is commonly
seen as one of the most important elements that led to the growth of Orland Park,
spurring a new wave of building and transforming the Village into a commercial,
financial and residential suburban center. It became a regional center and a
catalyst for other related commercial and office activity. This related activity will
help to form a new commercial core at the intersection of 151st Street and
LaGrange Road.99 Prior to its construction, Orland Park still had limited retail
establishments both in the Village and nearby. After, large anchors such as
Marshall Fields, JCPenney, Carson Pirie Scott, and Sears, as well as hundreds
of other smaller shops and restaurants served the Village as well as surrounding
towns. The brilliant gem brought some of the best products the world has to
offer right to the doors of Orland Park residents.100 It bolstered the Villages tax
base and branded Orland Parks image as a growing, affluent community. The
substantial retail sales tax revenue from the mall and restaurants, services, and
copycat malls that surround it like satellites around a larger planet became the
key to the Villages financial success.101 Property taxes were able to remain low
for residents compared to other burgeoning municipalities. In 1985, Orland Park
generated a totaled of $4.6 million in sales tax revenue about 40 percent of total
Village revenues.102
The importance of the construction of Orland Square Mall is aptly described
by John Stuart Humphrey, the son of John Humphrey, the first mayor and
credited founder of Orland Park. At a speech at the opening on the mall in 1976,
Humphrey stated:
One time I wished to live long enough to see the result of the trip to
the moon. You may remember, the scientists were uncertain whether
or not the crust of the moon would support the weight of a man and
how carefully Neil Armstrong took that first step. Well, Ive lived long
enough to see the result of that great adventure. Then when I head
"In typical suburban fashion, the major impetus for the turnaround in the
erstwhile farmtown was the construction of a shopping mall. Orland Square ...
immediately began drawing shoppers from surrounding south and southwest
suburbs. Whether the developers of the mall foresaw the area's inevitable
growth or the mall itself fed the potential, Orland Park - like Schaumburg
with Woodfield and Oak Brook with Oakbrook Center before it - became
inextricably linked to its retail mecca. The mall brought a tremendous
commercial rush to La Grange Road, with every imaginable business from
fast foods to health clubs competing."
Steve Kerch, Orland Park: From a Farm Town to a Boom Town: Village's Growth Continues
the Pace Started in 1960s, Chicago Tribune, May 28, 1986, 3
LEFT: Chicago
area
map illustrating the void
of major retail centers
within a 10 mile radius of
Orland Park prior to the
construction of the Orland
Square Mall (Wm. S.
Lawrence and Associates,
A Supplementary Report
to the Comprehensive
Plan, 1975, 20).
RIGHT: The construction
of Orland Square Mall
in 1976, surrounded
my farmland - looking
northwest (Village of
Orland Park Archives).
42
of this multi-million dollar shopping center being planned for Orland Park, I hoped
to live long enough to see that completed. Do you realize that Orland Square with
Marshall Fields and the other stores and shops will mean more to each of us in
Orland park than did that trip to the moon. Personally, I am both sorry and glad to
see Orland Square coming to completion. Now I have no future event to look forward
to with expectation and I can but repeat what I think my father would say if he were
here Orland, youve come a long way baby!103
The redevelopment of the 103-acre site highlights the shift from farm land to a typical suburban
environment. Initial planning for the Orland Square Mall illustrates the Villages prior overall
lack of development. The few roads traversing Orland Park were inadequate to support new
traffic to the mall. New thoroughfares were needed. As a result, 151st Street was extended
from 80th Avenue to Harlem, Harlem was extended south from 149th Street to 191st Street,
and roads were widened.104
The mall unleashed a flood of nearby commercial development, particularly along LaGrange
Road between 143rd Street and 159th Street.105 Orland Park Place, the second largest mall
with800,000 square feet of retail, was constructed shortly after in the 1980s. Originally
named Orland Court, the mall is located directly south of Orland Square Mall. Similar to the
mall, it also replaced a farm.106 Additional shopping centers followed, capitalizing on the
growing market area and residential population. This includes Lakeview Plaza (159th Street
and LaGrange Road), Horton Center (John Humphrey Drive), Regent Plaza (151st Street
and Regent Drive), Sevillle Plaza (8900 159th Street), and Highland Plaza (153rd Street and
LaGrange Road).107
In the 1990s, Orland Park had about 5 million square feet of store space, which to put it in
perspective is 800,000 square feet more in retail space than the gargantuan Mall of America in
Bloomington, Minnesota.108 The Villages strong retail base secured it as a regional shopping
center for the south and southwest suburbs and provided more than $8 million a year in
sales-tax revenues, amounting to more than half of the Village's annual budget.
Extensive commercial development along LaGrange Road led to some challenges. For
example, Orland Park Place south of the mall remained largely vacant after it opened and the
original developer went bankrupt soon after.109 Yet, overall, the onslaught of retail development
helped to further bolster residential development and provided a growing community supported
by an increase in sale tax revenue and services to residents.
43
ABOVE: Farm on 94th Avenue, which was converted into the Orland Park
Place shopping center (Orland Heritage Book Association, The Orland Story:
From Prairie to Pavement, 217).
1970
1978
"Retailers almost seem to be waiting in line to grab a spot in Orland Park's bustling commercial sector along La Grange
Road between 143rd and 159th Streets. The wide-open spaces are vanishing steadily along this 2-mile stretch of stores
and businesses, which is less than a decade old. Led by Orland Square Mall, between 147th and 151st Streets, shopping
malls report few vacancies, and new centers say they are having little trouble attracting tenants."
Jane Michaels, Orland Park Business Boom La Grange Road Sites the Main Target for New Retail Rush, Chicago Tribune, May 28, 1986, 7
LEFT: Aerial Images of Orland Square Mall and the surrounding areas, before and
after construction in 1970
and 1978 (CMAP Imagery
Explorer, 1970 Aerial Images, Northeastern Illinois Air
Photo Archive and Webmap,
Chicago Metropolitan Agency
for Planning Imagery Explorer,
1995; United States Geological Survey, Aerial 1978, Entity
ID:1VEQZ00020086, USGS
EARTH EXPLORER, October
30, 1978.
44
45
1400
400
1200
1000
300
800
200
600
100
400
200
1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971
TOP: Advertisement sign for Village Square Homes Subdivision (Geo Thompson,
"Village Square Homes," Photo gallery: A history of Orland Park. Chicago Tribune,
1983); BOTTOM: Residential building permits in Orland Park from 1960 -1971
(Wm. S. Lawrence and Associates. Orland Park, Illinois: A Supplementary Report to
the Comprehensive Plan, 1975).
RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PERMITS
1975-1993
800
700
600
500
19
RESIDENTIAL
BUILDING
The Catalina Construction TOTAL
Corporation
became
one ofPERMITS
the first major
1960-1971
developers, constructing a subdivision twice the size of any other property
119
previously under
The sheer size of the subdivision
500development.
development aided growth during the 1970s and led the way to subsequent
subdivisions. The
400housing market continued to grow through the 1980s,
particularly with a focus on the high-end residential market. In 1985, 1,064
building permits300
were issued, followed by 1,338 permits in 1986 (a 24%
increase). In the same period, permits for single family homes alone went
120
from 395 to 511.200
Although the Village originated over a century early, by
the early 1980s, two-thirds of the homes in Orland Park were less than 15
years old.121 It was the second leading suburb in the Chicago Region in
100
1983 in terms of the number of dwelling units built.122
TOTAL RESIDENTIAL
BUILDING PERMITS
TOTAL RESIDENTIAL
BUILDING PERMITS
1960-1971
500
400
1987
1988
1989
1990
Jack Houston, Nobody Knows Why Village a 'Boom Town', Chicago Tribune, March 20, 1977
Single Family
Multi-Family / Townhomes
400
0400
200
1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971
200
0
198
*D
400 for
knows
1986
600
600
100
500
1985
800
200
800
1977
1000
300
1000
1976
1200
1200
1975
1400
1400
During the period of growth, not only was the amount of housing increasing,
1960was
1961also
1962changing.
1963 1964123
1965
1966
1967 1968
1970 1971
but the type of housing
After
World
War 1969
II, housing
demand resulted in a rush of modest and lower-priced new homes. Houses
catered to the family lifestyle and typically were constructed in the form of
ranches and bi-levels that featured big back yards and garages on cul-desacs. Toward the 2000s, larger homes on larger lots became the trend.
Nobody
sure why Orland Park is booming, but
anyone who happens
through this suburb, 23 miles southwest
300
of downtown Chicago,
is left with little doubt its true. Heres a
200
sleepy, little village suddenly come awake. Its first housing, still
standing, dates100
back to 1890, and its next housing springs daily
from the ground.0
TOTAL RES
1975-1993
100
0
1975
1976
1977
1985
1986
Single Family
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
Multi-Family / Townhomes
1991
1992
1993
ABOVE: Residential Building Permits from 1975 - 1993 (Village of Orland Park, "Community Profile," 1994).
Vill
LAND USES
With the increasingly development from the 1970s
to 1990s, more intense and diverse land uses
filled Orland Park. However, single-family homes
continued to dominate the Village. The following
Village Land Use Table, from a field survey
conducted in March 1973, shows nearly 51%
of the developed land, or 836 acres, within the
corporate limits was single-family residential.125
Forest preserves, existing golf courses, parks and
recreation comprised the other predominant land
uses in Orland Park, amounting to about 32% of
developed land, or 538 acres within the Village.
Bodies of water contributed to an additional 105
acres.
Nearly all commercial development was contained
in the area of Route 45 and 143rd Street and south
along Route 45 to 151st Street. Some neighborhood
and strip commercial activity was located along
159th Street, and specifically, at the intersections
of 159th and Wolf Road and 159th and Harlem
Avenue. Only 2.4% of developed land, or about 40
acres, accounted for retail businesses. Offices and
wholesale establishments accounted for even less,
with 2.1 acres, or .12% of developed land. Both
industrial manufacturing and non-manufacturing
uses were about 4.5% of developed land, on over
73 acres of land.
Yet, approximately 58% of all land in Orland Park
remained undeveloped in 1973. The existing land
use pattern was utilized for projecting future land
uses on the remaining 2,450 acres of undeveloped
land in Orland Park.
47
LAND USE
Single Family
Multi-Family
Farmstead
Retail Business
Offices, Wholesale
Auto-Oriented Businesses
NUMBER
OF USES
TOTAL
SQUARE FEET
ACRES
2,624
36,411,440
835.9
50.92
19.9
81
832,000
19.1
1.16
0.45
113,280
2.6
0.15
0.06
32
1,714,000
39.4
0.4
0.93
92,800
2.1
0.2
0.05
PERCENT OF
DEVELOPMENT
PERCENT OF
TOTAL AREA
13
699,100
16.1
0.9
0.38
Industrial Non-Manufacturing
142,800
3.3
0.2
0.07
Manufacturing
3,058,200
70.2
4.27
1.67
17
2,212,800
50.8
3.09
1.2
23,436,800
538
32.77
12.81
0.82
0.32
586,000
13.5
15
4,588,000
105.34
1,512,000
34.7
2.11
0.82
688,800
15.8
0.96
0.37
76,088,020
1746.8
41.6
Vacant
106,855,268
2453
58.4
TOTAL AREA
182,943,288
4199.8
100
Bodies of Water
Roadway R.O.W
Railroad R.O.W
Total Developed
2.5
TOP: Land Uses in Orland Park in March 1973 (Wm. S. Lawrence and Associates. Orland Park, Illinois: A Supplementary
Report to the Comprehensive Plan, 6).
48
49
50
51
REGIONAL MAP
LAKE
MCHENRY
LAKE
MICHIGAN
294
COOK
90
94
290
290
KANE
DUPAGE
90
355
290
88
COOK
Chicago
88
90
294
55
Orland
Park
KENDALL
94
80
80
GRUNDY
55
WILL
57
POPULATION
The Village of Orland Park has experienced a dramatic shift in population
over the past century. From its humble beginnings as a small rural
town, Orland Park is now a regional economic hub with post-war
housing developments. In 1900, the town had a population of only
366. The population remained relatively unchanged and under 1,000
people until 1960.
POPULATION CHANGE (1900 - 2010)
56,767
60,000
51,077
50,000
40,000
34,391
30,000
23,045
20,000
6,391
10,000
366
369
343
571
631
788
1900
1910
1920
1930
1940
1950
2,592
0
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
2010
POPULATION DENSITY
1990
2000
2010
2,673
2,668.4
Total Population
35,720
51,077
2,594.7
1990
56,757
13.36
19.14
21.88
1990
52
20,000
20%
15,000
15%
12,484
5%
0%
2014
10,000
10%
5,000
Less than
$15,000
$15,000 $24,999
$25,000 $34,999
$35,000 $49,999
2020
7,572
0 $50,000
$75,000 $74,999 1980 $99,999
.6%
22,443
11.1%
17.7%
2020
15,000
19.5%
12,484
TOTAL HOUSING
IN 2014: 22,330
10,000
5,000
7,572
2010
19,045
20,000
$100,000 $149,999
1990
27.1%
2014
24%
0
1980
1990
2000
$70,000
2010
$75,000
$80,000
$85,000
$90,000
$95,000
ABOVE: Orland Park's household income in 2010; BELOW: The number of housing units from 1980-2010 and year
YEAR STUCTURE BUILT
housing structures
built in 2014 (U.S. Census).
.6%
11.1%
53
22,443
19,045
17.7%
Built 2005 or Later
Built 2000 to 2004
Built 1990 to 1999
Built 1980 to 1989
19.5%
TOTAL HOUSING
IN 2014: 22,330
27.1%
5.5%
1- Unit, Detached
1- Unit, Attached
5.3%
2 Units
60%
20.3%
3 or 4 Units
5 to 9 Units
10 to 19 Units
20 or More Units
Other
17.7%
19.5%
TOTAL HOUSING
IN 2014: 22,330
27.1%
24%
54
$1,600
Nov 2010
Nov 2011
Nov 2012
Nov 2013
Nov 2014
Nov 2015
COMPARISON OF MEDIAN
HOME VALUES (MAY 2016)
55
Orland Park
$263,400
Cook County
$202,400
Tinley Park
$204,100
Chicago
$208,600
Schaumburg
$214,100
Oak Lawn
$165,900
Joliet
$121,000
Palos Park
$358,500
Palos Heights
$249,900
Homer Glen
$300,600
June
2007
June
2008
June
2009
June
2010
June
2011
June
2012
June
2013
June
2014
June
2015
Nov 2011
Nov 2012
Nov 2013
Nov 2014
Nov 2015
23,000
20,000
22,000
19,000
23,000
21,000
2010
22,000
2012
2013
2014
19,000
21,000
2010
ECONOMY
23,000
Its retail environment
is critical to the local economy. With over 11 million
square feet of commercial space, the Village has an effective trade area
150
of over 840,000
The Villages general merchandise retails sales
22,000 people.
are also significant. For 2015, Orland Parks total retail sales amounted to
$2,062,467,543, or $35,682 total sales per capita. This is significantly larger
21,000
than Cook Countys total sales per capita during the same period, which was
151
$13,399.
20,000
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
JOB INDUSTRY
NUMBER
PERCENT
1,094
4.8%
1,470
6.5%
Educational Services
1,768
7.8%
2,910
12.9%
3,167
14.0%
Retail Trade
6,832
30.3%
2011
2012
2014
24,000
24,000
23,000
23,000
22,000
22,000
21,000
20,000
21,000
19,000
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
20,000
JOB INDUSTRY
NUMBER
PERCENT
1,094
4.8%
1,470
6.5%
2,910
12.9%
3,167
14.0%
6,832
30.3%
19,000
Finance
and Insurance
2002
Educational Services
Retail Trade
JOB INDUSTRY
NUMBER
PERCENT
4.8%
Retail Trade
Finance and Insurance
1,470
6.5%
Educational Services
1,768
7.8%
2,910
12.9%
3,167
14.0%
AccommodationFinance
andandFood
InsuranceServices
Professional,
Scientific, and Technical Services
Retail
Trade
6,832
0
2013
20,000
19,000
2011
20,000
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
30.3%
5,000
6,000
7,000
56
INFLOW / OUTFLOW
In 2014, approximately 20,103 people employed in Orland Park, lived outside the Village.152 Conversely, 20,283 people who lived in Orland Park were employed
outside the Village. Only 2,454 people were both employed and lived in Orland Park. Residents who live in Orland Park commute to the following top destinations
for work: Chicago (19.9%), Orland Park (10.8%), Tinley Park (4.0%), Palos Heights, (2.9%), Oak Lawn (2.6%). The top five places people travel from to be employed
in Orland Park are Chicago (11.3%), Orland Park (10.9%), Tinley Park (6.1%), Oak Forest (2.5%), and Homer Glen (2.2%)
INFLOW / OUTFLOW
2,454
20,283
57
Commercial
1,094.30
Industrial
225.3 1.6
Institutional
676.6 4.8
Mixed Use
11.2
0.1
Transportation and Other
Agricultural
1,902.00
Open Space
1,758.40
Vacant 634.6 4.5
TOTAL 14,185.40
100
7.7
2,334.00
13.4
12.4
16.5
LAND USE
Over Source:
the past Chicago
decade, commercial
and
residential
development
has been Land Use Inventory.
Metropolitan
Agency
for Planning
Parcel-Based
relatively steady. By land area, Orland Park is approximately 75% developed,
with the majority of the available land planned for residential development.153
According to the Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning Parcel-Based
Land Use Inventory, land uses are largely composed of single-family
residential properties.154 This is in line with the Villages past development
patterns.
LAND USE
Single-Family Residential
ACRES
PERCENT
5,226
36.8
323
2.3
1,094.3
7.7
Industrial
225.3
1.6
Institutional
676.6
4.8
Mixed Use
11.2
0.1
2,334
16.5
Agricultural
1,902
13.4
1,758.4
12.4
Vacant
634.6
4.5
TOTAL
14,185.4
100
Multi-Family Residential
Commercial
Open Space
LEFT: Land use map for the Village in 2013 (Adapted from Village of Orland Park).
ABOVE: Land use table for 2010 (Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning Parcel-Based
Land Use Inventory).
58
59
ABOVE: Branding Images of the Village as the Golf Center of the World (Wm. S. Lawrence and Associates. Orland Park,
Illinois: A Supplementary Report to the Comprehensive Plan, 1-3).
BELOW: Aerial Images of the LaGrange Road Corridor from April 2011, looking south at 143rd Street (Illinois Department
of Transportation. US Route 45 (LaGrange Road) Reconstruction and Widening. Illinois Department of Transportation.
2015. Accessed May 1, 2016. http://www.idot.illinois.gov/projects/us45-reconstruction-and-widening).
to the highest concentration of golf holes within a 15-mile radius of any town in
the world represents its break from its past as a farming community and future
as a suburban mecca. Today, Orland Park epitomizes suburban sprawl with its
shopping malls and subdivisions. Despite its rapid growth, parts of the original
downtown, Old Orland, have been preserved through decades of planning
efforts, described below.
EARLY PRESERVATION & PLANNING EFFORTS IN OLD ORLAND
In the early 1980s, as Orland Park was increasingly transforming into a burgeoning
post-war suburb, attention shifted toward preserving the original atmosphere of
town.157 Many of the older buildings faced demolition as land values climbed.
Residents began feeling that the town was growing very quickly and Old Orland
was being left behind.158 One Village planner at the time noted, Other towns
such as Schaumburg, have lost their downtowns, but Old Orland has kept its
integrityWe dont want Orland Park to look like any other suburb. We must pick
out the unique characteristics. And Old Orland is a unique characteristic.159
As a result, the Village, residents, businesses, and other community organizations
actively worked to preserve and improve Old Orland. The Village began
identifying issues within Old Orland and planning for its future. At that time,
Village ordinances pertaining to development and redevelopment could not be
applied to Old Orland, creating nearly unworkable hardships on owners and /
or purchasers.160 Outdated regulations not only limited how historic buildings
could be preserved and maintained according to code, but also created issues
regarding allowable land uses and the compatibility of new construction in the
district. For example, district zoning regulations required minimum 10,000 square
foot lots, much larger than Old Orlands non-confirming lots. But the opportunities
for Old Orland were increasingly acknowledged, Original Orland should not be
overlooked or forgotten by our guidelines of development. There is considerable
property investment and overwhelming pride in property owners to keep up land
improvements. The Village ordinances could be amended in numerous ways
to support this tangible and intangible resource. Recommendations were put
forward to amend existing Village ordinances, including:
-- Allow reconstruction on vacant lots without hardship
60
buildings were wood frame buildings rather than brick. In addition, designation
was important to setting the stage for tax incentives related to restoration work.
Planning for a full preservation ordinance was underway, which sought to
address a parking program, building and fire codes, historic theme, architectural
consistency, events and promotions, public facilities reconstruction, financing,
reevaluation of lot coverage, setbacks, off street parking, lot size, accessory
buildings, building height, materials, architectural review, permitted uses,
hardship criteria. By the end 1986, five ordinances were passed that established
a recognized historic district, created a historic preservation commission, and
introduced specific regulations geared toward preservation and planning for Old
Orland.164
In 1987, the Old Orland Heritage Foundation was formed with the goal of
projecting and preserving Orland Parks historic assets. The first project of
restoration of United Methodist Churchs twin towers sanctuary built in 1898
at 144th Street and West Avenue.165 The group was previously instrumental
in preventing the demolition of a number of historic buildings in Orland Park.
They have been credited with preserving the Maue House, a farmstead, as
well as saving and restoring the Twin Towers Sanctuary. In contrast, the Orland
Historical Society manages the Humphrey House Museum and has played a
major role in preserving the Hostert log cabins and continues to collect oral
histories and artifacts about Old Orland.166
Old Orland was included as a focus in the 1991 Comprehensive Plan for Orland
Park, which sought to reexamine past planning efforts and further guide policies
for future development in the Village.167 The 1991 Plan marked the first time
that Old Orland was fully included in comprehensive planning efforts. A section
of the plan was devoted to historical significance, acknowledging there were
many significant structures with historical value that comprise the heritage of the
community and worthy of preservation. 168 The goal To promote the economic,
cultural, and aesthetic welfare of the community through the preservation,
restoration and adaptive re-use of historical structures and sites included the
following objectives:169
-- Support sensitive development practices which incorporate and defer to
61
----------
the historic value of structures and sites in order to protect the character
and traditions of the community
Encourage the care and maintenance of historic structures and sites
Encourage the economic and adaptive re-use of historic structures
Utilize preserved historic structures and sites to establish identity and
unique character for development in order to enhance property values
and a sense of community
Capitalize upon the economic benefits of tourism that accrue from
successful historic preservation efforts
Maintain historic preservation regulations and procedures within the Land
Development Code to implement preservation objectives
Utilize a historic preservation district to protect and enhance the character
of the Old Orland area
Designate historic landmarks throughout the community as provided for
in the Land Development Code
Coordinate local preservation efforts with other relevant state and federal
agencies responsible for historic preservation
Encourage all construction, alteration, and improvement of historic
structures to comply with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for
Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings
The Old Orland Element of the Comprehensive Plan adopted the goal to
maintain the scale, architectural integrity, and general character of Old Orland
while enhancing its residential and commercial environments.170 The following
objectives included:
-- Obtain input from long time residents and merchants
-- Maintain an overlay-zoning district within the Land Development Code
which is tailored specifically to building setbacks, street widths, and other
characteristics of Old Orland
-- Establish a set of design standards including architectural style, signage,
and scale
-- Create a physical plan which provides adequate access, parkway amenities,
improved streetscapes, and linkage between Beacon Avenue and Union
Street commercial areas
-- Create a capital improvement plan based upon said physical plan
ABOVE: Orland Park's first attempts at creating a historic district. The map was adopted in 1984
as part of Ordinance 1386, "An Ordinance Establishing Building Standard Criteria for Historical
Buidings" and shows shows buildings and structures designated by Village as having special historical character and community interest and value to the Village. Today, the boundaries of the
Old Orland district are much smaller: the historic district only includes a portion of the highlighed
areas on this map.
62
While Orland Park immediately approved the proposal for a fast food restaurant,
Rather than putting out the welcome mat and approving the proposal like the
Orland Park panel did, commissioners unanimously voted to recommend that
any fast-food restaurant wanting to come to town be forced to obtain a specialuse permit that would give the Village tighter control.174
Frankfort made a conscious effort to capitalize on its rural heritage, vigorously
promoting itself as the Village with 1890s charm. Orland Park, on the other
hand, is very much a child of the 20th Century. Its turning point came when
Urban Investment & Development Co. settled on Orland Park as the site of a
major shopping mall.175 While Orland Park became a mecca for shopping and
regional commercial center, that commercial core has created a community
that many view as lacking a human one. On weekends and over the Christmas
holiday season, traffic congestion is so bad along La Grange Road and 159th
Street that many residents refuse to venture out of their homes As subdivision
after subdivision has grown out of cornfields, the neighborly feelings that used
to characterize the Village have all but disappeared from its neighborhoods,
some say. A major reason is that both partners work and are away from home
most of the time. Another is that there are few places to get together.176
As Old Orland no longer held its place as the center of town, the Village gained
a new suburban character. Rather than maintaining and building upon the
existing charm of the original downtown, new dispersed shopping centers were
built. Arguably, Old Orland was overlooked by the rapid suburban development
occurring around it and neighborhood planning efforts. The area became
known as one of the unique places in Orland Park and a quaint area for its
small stretch of antique stores housed in historic buildings.177 According to one
article, If people think Orland Park has become one big cash register, they have
not looked beyond the main drags. One need only see the town's distinctive
water towers, painted to resemble a golf ball on a tee, to realize there are other
pursuits besides shopping that are dear to the Villagers.178 Nonetheless, Old
Orlands fate was set: reinvestment and preservation would be pushed to the
back-burner as other large-scale development and more profitable projects
became a priority for Village growth.
RECENT COMPREHENSIVE PLANNING
63
other people."181 The Main Street District will help solve the loss of the
Old Orland Historic District as the main downtown by creating a new
sense of community.
The development of the Main Street Downtown District and its adjacency
to the Metra commuter station highlights the Villages efforts to
transform Orland Park from its classic automobile-dependent suburban
form. With decades of urban sprawl, Orland Park is characterized by
the features typical of most post war suburbs: a spread of residential
subdivisions, super blocks, commercial growth that grew nearby Orland
Square Mall, miles of big-box stores and restaurants along La Grange
Road and 159th Street. The transit-oriented, walkable Main Street
District represents an antidote to past suburban sprawl by attempting
to plan for people, not cars. In line with new trends across the country,
the Village is attempting to change the suburban landscape.182 The Main
Street Downtown District is not only connected to the Metra Commuter
train station, but also is within close walking distance to nearby areas,
including Orland Park Crossing shopping center, the Old Orland Historic
District, luxury apartment buildings, Marianos grocery store, the Village
Center, as well as other services and restaurants located on LaGrange
Road. The creation of a vibrant, walkable downtown connected to
transit and expanded multi-family luxury housing options is expected
to attract professionals, younger generations, residents commuting to
their jobs in Chicago, or empty nesters looking to downsize.
The impacts of the development of the Main Street Downtown District
on Old Orland remain to be seen. The surrounding districts, particularly
the Main Street Downtown District, will be further discussed in the
following chapter. Nonetheless, Orland Park should not follow in the
footsteps of the past. Beginning in the 1970s with the construction of
Orland Square Mall and unprecedented suburban growth, Old Orland
was largely forgotten in many planning efforts. Existing and future
planning, particularly for the up-and-coming downtown, should not
again overlook Old Orland.
MAIN STREET
DOWNTOWN DISTRICT
3RD DOWNTOWN
OLD ORLAND
1ST DOWNTOWN
64
ENDNOTES
1
McGuire, Igleski & Associates, Village of Orland Park
Residential Area Intensive Survey (Village of Orland
Park, 2008), 8-10.
2
J. Penney, Where they came from to settle in Orland,
The Palos Regional, May 28, 1981, 20;
McGuire, Igleski & Associates, Village of Orland Park
Residential Area Intensive Survey, 8-10.
3
Weston Arthur Goodspeed and Daniel David Healy,
History of Cook County, Illinois--Being A General
Survey of Cook County History, Including a Condensed
History of Chicago and Special Account of Districts
Outside the City Limits: From the Earliest Settlement
to the Present Time (Chicago: Goodspeed Historical
Association, 1881), 334; A. T. Andreas, History of Cook
County, Illinois: From the Earliest Period to the Present
Time (Chicago: A. T. Andreas, 1884), 827; Orland
Heritage Book Association, The Orland Story: From
Prairie to Pavement (Orland Park: Orland Heritage Book
Association, 1991), 29.
4
Anne McGuire & Associates, Orland Rural History
Survey (Village of Orland Park, December 1995), 7.
5
Ibid., 10.
6
Keating, Ann Durkin, Chicagoland: City and Suburbs
in the Railroad Age (Chicago: University of Chicago
Press, 2005).
7
Ibid., 14.
8
Orland Heritage Book Association, The Orland Story:
From Prairie to Pavement, 51.
9
Ibid., 61.
10
Ibid., 61.
11
J. Penney, Where they came from to settle in Orland,
20.
12
Ibid.
13
A. T. Andreas, History of Cook County, Illinois: From
the Earliest Period to the Present Time, 827.
14
Ibid.
15
A. T. Andreas, History of Cook County, Illinois: From
the Earliest Period to the Present Time, 827; Orland
Heritage Book Association, The Orland Story: From
65
2002).
38
Orland Heritage Book Association, The Orland Story:
From Prairie to Pavement, 36.
39
University of Chicago & Andrew Corporation, Toward
a Plan for the Andrew Corporation and the Orland Park
Community: A Pre-Planning Report (Chicago: 1951), 81.
40
Orland Heritage Book Association, The Orland Story:
From Prairie to Pavement, 95.
41
Ibid., 88.
42
Ibid., 105.
43
McGuire, Igleski & Associates, Village of Orland Park
Residential Area Intensive Survey. 20.
44
U.S. Census Bureau, Census of Population and
Housing. 1950, https://www.census.gov/prod/www/
decennial.html; U.S. Census Bureau, Census of
Population and Housing. 1960, https://www.census.
gov/prod/www/decennial.html
45
Ann Durkin Keating, Chicago Neighborhoods and
Suburbs: A Historical Guide (Chicago: University of
Chicago Press, 2008), 9-11, 36-38.
46
Wm. S. Lawrence and Associates & Orland Park
Plan Commission, A Comprehensive Plan for Orland
Park, Illinois (Chicago: Wm. S. Lawrence & Associates,
1969), B-11-18; Keating, Chicago Neighborhoods and
Suburbs: A Historical Guide, 35-37.
47
Wm. S. Lawrence and Associates & Orland Park Plan
Commission, A Comprehensive Plan for Orland Park,
Illinois, B-12.
48
Ibid., C-4.
49
University of Chicago & Andrew Corporation, Toward
a Plan for the Andrew Corporation and the Orland Park
Community, 83-84.
50
Ibid., 84.
51
Ibid., 70-71.
52
Orland Heritage Book Association, The Orland Story:
From Prairie to Pavement.
53
Northeastern Illinois Planning Commission,
Preliminary Suburban Factbook (Chicago: Northeastern
Illinois Planning Commission, July 1971).
54
Wm. S. Lawrence and Associates & Orland Park Plan
Commission, A Comprehensive Plan for Orland Park,
Illinois, B-26.
55
Ibid., B-28.
56
Ibid., H-7.
57
Ibid., B-20-21.
58
Keating, Chicago Neighborhoods and Suburbs: A
Historical Guide, 4, 35.
59
University of Chicago & Andrew Corporation, Toward
a Plan for the Andrew Corporation and the Orland Park
Community, 70-71.
60
Wm. S. Lawrence and Associates & Orland Park Plan
Commission, A Comprehensive Plan for Orland Park,
Illinois, B-23.
61
Ibid., G-3).
62
Ibid., C-16 - C-23).
63
Orland Heritage Book Association, The Orland Story:
From Prairie to Pavement, 125.
64
University of Chicago & Andrew Corporation, Toward
a Plan for the Andrew Corporation and the Orland Park
Community, 85.
65
Wm. S. Lawrence and Associates & Orland Park Plan
Commission, A Comprehensive Plan for Orland Park,
Illinois, D-3.
66
Orland Heritage Book Association, The Orland
Story: From Prairie to Pavement; Stanley Ziemba,
Andrew Corp.'s departure to change Orland Park,
Joliet, Chicago Tribune, November 19, 2005; "Andrew
Corporation,"International Directory of Company
Histories, 2000,Encyclopedia.com.
67
Orland Heritage Book Association, The Orland Story:
From Prairie to Pavement.
68
University of Chicago & Andrew Corporation, Toward
a Plan for the Andrew Corporation and the Orland Park
Community, 86.
69
Ibid., 86-87.
70
Ibid., 78.
71
Wm. S. Lawrence and Associates & Orland Park Plan
Commission, A Comprehensive Plan for Orland Park,
Illinois, Introduction.
72
Ibid., B-3.
73
Ibid., E-3.
74
Ibid., C-9.
Ibid., E-3.
Ibid., C-9.
77
Ibid., B-22.
78
Ibid., C-28.
79
Ibid., C-8 C-10.
80
Orland Heritage Book Association, The Orland Story:
From Prairie to Pavement, 207.
81
U.S. Census Bureau. Decennial Census, 1970.
Prepared by Social Explorer. http://www.socialexplorer.
com/ (accessed January 10, 2016); U.S. Census Bureau.
Decennial Census, 1980. Prepared by Social Explorer.
http://www.socialexplorer.com/ (accessed January 10,
2016).
82
U.S. Census Bureau. Decennial Census, 1990.
Prepared by Social Explorer. http://www.socialexplorer.
com/ (accessed January 10, 2016); U.S. Census Bureau.
Decennial Census, 2000. Prepared by Social Explorer.
http://www.socialexplorer.com/ (accessed January 10,
2016); U.S. Census Bureau. Decennial Census, 2010.
Prepared by Social Explorer. http://www.socialexplorer.
com/ (accessed January 10, 2016).
83
David Elsner, Bucolic Area on Verge of Boom
Rustic Ways Face Urban Expansion Series: Southwest:
The New Frontier. First in a Series about Growth and
Development Issues in the Southwest Suburbs and the
Challenges the Region Faces,"Chicago Tribune, May
17, 1993.
84
David Ibata, Orland Park is Blossoming into a 'Boom
Town', Chicago Tribune, October 2, 1983, W-B1.
85
Ibid.
86
Jack Houston, Nobody Knows Why Village a 'Boom
Town', Chicago Tribune, March 20, 1977, S-B2A.
87
Barnum, Art. Jun 1, 1983. Suburb finding pleasure in
growing pains. Chicago Tribune, pg. ST4
88
McGuire, Igleski & Associates, Village of Orland Park
Residential Area Intensive Survey, 24.
89
David Ibata, Orland Park is Blossoming into a 'Boom
Town'; Steve Mills, Move On Out Orland Pushing
The Envelope Of Where `Suburbia' Begins, Chicago
Tribune, October 14, 1995, 3.
90
Orland Heritage Book Association, The Orland Story:
75
76
66
67
Ibid., 19.
Ibid., 24.
172
Kerch, Orland Park: From a Farm Town to a Boom
Town: Village's Growth Continues the Pace Started in
1960s.
173
Elsner, Facing Future in 2 Directions: Orland
Park Pushes Growth; Frankfort Clings to Past. Series
Southwest: The New Frontier. This is the Third in a
Series of Articles about Growth and Development
Issues in the Southwest Suburbs and the Challenges
the Region Faces.
174
Ibid.
175
Ibid.
176
Ibid.
177
Jane Michaels, Orland Park Business Boom La
Grange Road Sites the Main Target for New Retail
Rush; Kerch, Orland Park: From a Farm Town to a
Boom Town: Village's Growth Continues the Pace
Started in 1960s.
178
Kerch, Orland Park: From a Farm Town to a Boom
Town: Village's Growth Continues the Pace Started in
1960s.
179
N. Swedberg, Survey examines perceptions of
Orland Park, Daily Southtown, January 21, 2016.
http://www.chicagotribune.com/suburbs/dailysouthtown/news/ct-sta-orland-branding-plan-st-012220160121-story.html; Ann R. Martin, New project has
old downtown feel, Chicago Tribune, May 2, 2003: 5;
Ashley Rueff, Downtown area taking shape: Orland
Park is closer to 20-year quest to create a town center.
Chicago Tribune, January 31, 2013: 1.
180
Patricia Trebe, Pursuing an Ambitious Vision; Orland
Park Mayor says a Downtown Tops List of Priorities.
181
Martin, Ann R. Orland park aims to revive
downtown.Chicago Tribune, June 1, 2003.
182
Taylor W. Anderson, "Orland Park's Downtown
Focus Part of Suburban Trend," Chicago Tribune,Feb
13, 2014; Mike Nolan, Suburbs' downtown plans move
toward transit-oriented housing, Daily Southtown,
July 31, 2015.
170
171
68
69
PLANNING CONSIDERATIONS
An Analysis of Opportunities and Challenges in the Old Orland Historic District
Over the past decades, Orland Park has experienced rapid
growth which has nonetheless impacted the original downtown
area. Today, surrounded by modern suburban development, the
Old Orland Historic District faces new challenges that will impact
its future growth and the preservation of its buildings. This
chapter will describe the key aspects of Old Orland, its historic
and current importance, and its policy context.
To determine assets, challenges and opportunities, the existing
conditions in Old Orland will be evaluated, specifically in regards to
the built environment, connectivity, surrounding neighborhoods,
historic resources, open space, district character, business
activity, and zoning and land development policies. These issues
will be examined for their impact to the preservation of the
historic district as well as how they factor into its future growth.
Recommendations will be proposed in the following chapter to
enhance the uniqueness of the Old Orland area by building on
its assets, addressing challenges and maximizing opportunities.
70
71
LAGRANGE ROAD
142ND STREET
High Traffic
Thoroughfare
Challenging
Intesections
Limited
Connection to
Ravinia Avenue
LEGEND
BEACON AVENUE
RF
OL
K
SO
UT
HE
RN
Railroad
Bisects the
Historic
District
NO
WEST AVENUE
143RD STREET
RAVINIA AVENUE
UNION AVENUE
SO
UT
H
W
ES
143RD STREET
METRA STATION
72
Heavy traffic along 143rd Street imposes physical barriers on the Old
Orland Historic District, particularly impacting how it links to the Main
Street Downtown area. As a result of the railroad bisecting the District and
the physical barriers of created by the high trafficked thoroughfare, there
are important connections to resolve. Additionally, the number of streets
intersections with 143rd Street on the north side of Old Orland creates both
unsafe road crossings and a confusing traffic pattern. From West Avenue to
Ravinia Avenue along 143rd Street, there are four traffic signal lights (West
Avenue, Union Avenue, Southwest Highway, and Ravinia Avenue), a railroad
crossing, in addition to three other road intersections (Brook Street, Beacon
Avenue, and Main Street) and multiple parking lot driveways. Union Avenue
and Southwest Highway intersection traffic signals are directly adjacent to
one another, creating a confusing and inefficient circulation pattern.
LaGrange Road, another major thoroughfare located to the east of Old Orland,
also creates a challenging physical barrier to connectivity. Fast-moving
automobile traffic poses safety concerns at certain intersections. However,
the LaGrange Road widening project is currently underway, which should
reduce some of the safety and streetscape concerns. The project includes
additional road lanes, intersection improvements with improvement traffic
signals, a landscaped median, decorative lighting, parkway trees, decorative
sidewalks concrete cross walks, and corner monument signs.1
In addition to street connections, sidewalks serve as an important feature for
both residents and visitors, connecting Old Orland to the surrounding Main
Street, Village Center, Orland Crossing and LaGrange Road Corridor areas.
Fortunately, a decent existing pedestrian realm is in place. The residential
areas of Old Orland include walkable, tree-lined neighborhood streets that
highlight the areas historic character. However, there are no sidewalks on
some streets and either a lack of or inefficient pedestrian routes between
important areas within and surrounding Old Orland. As discussed further
below, the pedestrian realm within the business areas suffer from a lack of
engaging storefront atmosphere. Some areas along 143rd Street, Beacon
Avenue, and Union Avenue do not have an inviting appearance and lack
pedestrian amenities.
73
74
75
76
77
78
3) LAND USES
The Old Orland District has a mix of uses. Single-family homes dominate the
area, with mixed-use, commercial, office, institutional, and multi-family buildings
located at the north end of the District along 143rd Street, Beacon Avenue, and
Union Avenue. A handful of churches are scattered throughout Old Orland and
an elementary school is located on the north side of 143rd Street. Some of the
most notable historic properties include the Twin Towers Church and the John
Humphrey House Museum, which are both listed on the National Register of
Historic Places. Recently, the Orland Park History Museum opened in the former
Village Hall site on Beacon Avenue.
ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
The commercial area along Union Avenue and Beacon Avenue primarily consists
of a small number of antique shops and stores, with three small restaurants
along 143rd Street. Known as Antique Row, the small commercial area is a
destination of choice for many seeking antiques. However, existing businesses
have limited hours and the lack of strong anchor establishments prevents a
dynamic business climate. Because Orland Park is dominated by national chain
stores and big-box shopping centers, Old Orlands small and local businesses
are often overlooked.
RESTAURANTS
79
SO
UT
HW
ES
T
HW
143RD STREET
LAGRANGE ROAD
RAVINIA A
VE
NU
LEGEND
WEST AVENUE
ME
TR
AS
OU
TH
W
ES
ANTIQUE STORES
Old Orland
Historic District
Village Boundary
Metra Station
1/2 MILE
1/4
Manufacturing
Single Family Detached Residential
Single Family Attached Residential
Multi Family Residential
Senior Living
Golf Course
Open Space
Utility
Vacant/Agriculture
94TH AVENUE
CHURCHES
Government
School
Higher Education
Funeral Home
Place of Worship
80
ES
T
HW
HW
UT
SO
SO
UT
HW
Cook County
Orland Grove
Forest Preserve
T
ES
HW
Metra
Station
Residences at
Orland Crossing
LAGRANGE ROAD
Marianos Grocery
Store
Orland Crossing
Orland Park
Elementary
Old Orland
Historic District
144TH PLACE
OLD
ORLAND
Orland Park
Recreation
Franklin
Loebe
Center
Village
Hall
147TH STREET
Humphrey
Sports
Complex
Village Boundary
Metra Station
1/4
1/2 MILE
WEST AVENUE
Old Orland
Historic District
Orland
Township
Orland Park
Library
LAGRANGE ROAD
LAGRANGE ROAD
LEGEND
RAVINIA A
VE
NU
WEST AVENUE
Humphrey
Woods
RAVINIA AVENUE
VILLAGE
CAMPUS
T
OU
TH
W
ES
ME
TR
AS
Frontier
Park
Civic
Center
143RD STREET
145TH PLACE
ORLAND
CROSSING
81
BEACON AVENUE
143RD STREET
UNION AVENUE
MAIN
STREET
143RD STREET
University of
Chicago Medical
Center
Ninety7Fifty
Orland Square
Mall
ABOVE: Orland Plaza Shopping Center and industrial properties located within the Main Street Downtown District before
redevelopment (Village of Orland Park; James, Marquette Bank, Orland Park, IL. Flickr. February 5, 2012).
82
DOWNTOWNMAINSTREETDISTRICT(CONT.)
MAIN STREET DOWNTOWN DISTRICT PLAN
ExistingParcelsSummary
ParcelA
VillageOwned
ParcelB
VillageOwned
ParcelC
VillageOwned
ParcelD
Ninety7FiftyonthePark
ParcelE
VillageOwned
ParcelF
PublicParkingDeck
ParcelG
UniversityofChicago
Outlot
VillageOwned
LEFT: Aerial image of the Main Street Downtown District before redevelopment, in May 2000, looking northeast (Village of Orland Park); RIGHT: Main Street District Parcels and Overall
Plan (Village of Orland Park, RFP #16-017 Downtown Main Street District Parcel C Development, Village of Orland Park, April 13, 2016).
9|P a g e
83
Crescent Park, at the center of the Main Street Downtown District, provides open
gathering space for summer events and concerts and is connected to other
neighborhoods and green spaces via sidewalks, bike trails, and roadways.
Ninety7Fifty on the Park
Completed in 2013, Ninety7Fifty on the Park was one of the first phases of
development for the creation of the Main Street Downtown District.7 Located
at 143rd Street and Ravinia Avenue, the six-story, 295-unit apartment building
includes luxury rentals, 4,000 square feet of ground floor retail, and a parking
garage. The building features high end finishes and a range of upscale amenities
including an outdoor pool, indoor lounges, theater room, fitness center, outdoor
lounge with grilling areas and a fire pit, a dog park, a computer room, and
conference room. With a minimum qualifying income of $70,000, rentals range
from $1,500 a month for a one-bedroom apartment to more than $2,500 a month
for larger apartment units.8 The building has maintained a high occupancy rate
since opening in 2013. As of Summer 2016, the building is 94% occupied.9
Its location near the 143rd Street Metra Station has deemed it an ideal place for
both empty nesters and young professionals looking to commute to the Chicago
Loop. The Village of Orland Park assisted in financing the $65 million project
through a $38 million loan and about $24 million in financial incentives.10
84
LotCoverage:
Height:
75%max
6stories,70max
11
12
85
AerialwithExistingandFutureImprovements
SITE PLAN
10|P a g e
SCALE: NTS
MAIN STREET
TRIANGLE PARKING
STRUCTURE
EXTERIOR
RENDERINGS
SCALE: NTS
TOA
A-0.0
86
2) ORLAND CROSSING
Orland Crossing, located to the east of the Main Street area across
LaGrange Road, includes a recently constructed shopping center with
a mix of stores, restaurants, and offices.16 Constructed in 2006, Orland
Crossing was planned to include walkable blocks, mixed uses, and a
connected street system to complement the Main Street Downtown
District. It is connected to the Main Street area and the 143rd Street
Metra Station via a pedestrian bridge over LaGrange Road as well as
sidewalk connections along LaGrange Road.
The area also includes the John Humphrey Drive corridor, which includes
a cluster of office buildings. In addition to office spaces, stores include
Ann Taylor, Talbots, Yankee Candle, Chicos, Coldwater Creek, White
House Black Market, and restaurants such as Starbucks, P.F. Changs,
Brass Tap, and Granite City Food & Brewery. A Marianos Fresh Market
grocery store recently opened in January 2016.
The Residences at Orland Crossing
The Residences at Orland Crossing is the second luxury rental community
to be constructed and is located adjacent to the Main Street Downtown
area. Located at 143rd Street and LaGrange Road, the 231-unit project
opened in May 2016 and is part of the overall planning to create a
pedestrian-friendly, mixed-use downtown.17 The 12.5 acre site has direct
access to the developing Main Street downtown area and the 143rd
Street Metra station by the pedestrian bridge over LaGrange Road.
The Residences at Orland Crossing includes four mid-rise apartment
buildings with 42 apartments and 38 two-story rowhomes.18 With
a minimum qualifying income of over $100,000, units begin at about
$1,600 per month for a one-bedroom unit and are over $2,600 a month
for a three-bedroom unit. Like Ninety7Fifty, the Residences at Orland
Crossing offer luxury and high end amenities, including a business
center, club room, coffee bar, theater room, swimming pool, fitness
center, and outdoor fire pit and grilling stations. Since opening, there
has been a high rate of leasing.
87
88
3) VILLAGE CENTER
Village Center area is located to the south
of Old Orland and includes a concentration
of public institutions along Ravinia Avenue.
The area includes Village Hall, the Franklin
Loebe Recreation Center, the Civic Center,
Orland Township, Orland Park Public
Library, Orland Park Police Department,
Orland Fire Protection District, and two
schools. The John Humphrey sports
fields, an outdoor amphitheater, and the
historic preserved Humphrey Woods are
also included in the Village Center District.
In addition to housing civic buildings, a
number of popular special events are
frequently held at the Village Center, such
as the summer farmers market and the
Taste of Orland Park.
VILLAGE CENTER
89
5) OPEN SPACE
There are a number of parks and recreational amenities
within and close to Old Orland. In Old Orland, there is a small
neighborhood park on First Avenue and 144th Place. The
Humphrey House Museum, at 9830 144th Place, is owned by
the Orland Historical Society. The property is considered an
Orland Park Landmark and is listed on the National Register
of Historic Places. The Humphrey House includes the largest
open space in Old Orland, a half-acre piece of land is located
to the north of the Museum. The space was previously
planned for a community botanical garden, but was never
implemented because of storm water runoff drainage issues.
POCKET PARK
FRONTIER PARK
HUMPHREY WOODS
90
-------------
91
92
7) PARKING
Old Orland has Metra commuter parking, on-street parking, and private offstreet parking. Since the 1980s, a lack of parking has been cited as an issue
for businesses in Old Orland. Many businesses have complained there is not
enough surface parking lots or off street parking to accommodate customers.
Existing plans for increasing public parking within the areas around Old Orland
are currently underway. The Village is currently constructing a five-story parking
deck to serve the Main Street Downtown District and as part of the development
agreement with the University of Chicago Medicine Center.20 When completed,
the parking deck will include over 520 parking spaces, with majority of spaces
for public parking with the exception of the two upper levels reserved during
business hours for University of Chicago employee parking. Additionally, a
surface parking lot north of the University of Chicago Center will be available for
public parking on nights and weekends.
93
The addition of public parking spaces within the Main Street Downtown District
will provide nearby parking to Old Orland. While these public parking lots are
within waking distance from Old Orland, they may not be utilized by visitors for
shopping and services in the Historic District. Off-street parking can be improved
by better organizing existing and proposed parking lots. The existing surface
parking lots contribute to poor pedestrian connections, particularly along 143rd
Street and other business areas. The large number of parking lot curb cuts and
driveways along 143rd Street create both an unattractive street wall and unsafe
road crossings. Consolidating driveways to minimize openings and screening
parking lots from view will provide a buffer from adjacent uses and pedestrian
walkways.
RESIDENTIAL PARKING
8) HISTORIC RESOURCES
One of Old Orlands strongest assets is its historic character. The area remains a vestige of
history, illuminating a time when agriculture and the railroad dominated before Orland Parks
turning point as a post-war suburb. The Historic District is home to the Villages oldest and
historically significant buildings, including the first bank and oldest church. In addition to
these unique properties, examples of National or Folk style buildings are scattered throughout
the District and define its character. Relatively simple, modest homes of frame construction
reflect the utilitarian style of the working-class people who settled in the area. There are few
references to the architects that built or designed many of the houses scattered throughout
the District.
Growth and change can be seen in Old Orland, as small farm houses and older buildings
sit next to larger, newer houses and mixed-use buildings. The neighborhood represents the
Villages early days, but also includes building styles popular from all eras of its development.
According to a 2008 Survey, about 20% of the buildings were constructed from 1850-1899,
Orland Parks earliest period of development.21 Although many of these buildings have been
altered over time, collectively they convey the unique character of this earlier period. Early
20th century growth is also represented, with approximately 26% of the buildings constructed
from 19001940. Finally, newer homes reflect mid-century and modern styles. This unique
environment allows residents to experience the history of Orland Park from many different
eras, and illustrates the architectural heritage that is extant beyond the borders of the
established Old Orland Historic District. It is important for historic buildings outside of the
district to be recognized, appreciated and preserved by being valued by individual owners
and the community at large.22
The people who built houses and businesses in Orland Park were generally not wealthy.
As residents of a rural village, they constructed modest buildings; the occasional larger,
high style homes were constructed by prosperous business owners. The Villages
rural heritage is reflected in the large numbers of National style buildings... Even John
Humphrey, an attorney, State Senator, and Village Mayor built his house in a vernacular
form... Often there is little information about the people who designed and built buildings
within a community and this is especially true when a community has a preponderance
of National style and folk forms. These buildings were constructed by local builders, not
trained architects. This bears true in the [Old Orland] area... 23
TWIN TOWERS
HUMPHREY HOUSE
94
95
Yet, even with these updates to the LDC, additional amendments are needed
to further encourage the restoration of historically or architecturally significant
structures, to avoid inappropriate changes to existing buildings, to prevent future
demolitions, and to guide future planning objectives to strengthen the Districts
economic and social vibrancy.
96
97
Final
-- Examining methods for preservation financial aid that will assist the
community in upholding and improving the Old Orland Historic District
and Orland Park Landmarks
Over the past year, the consolidation of the HPRC with the Plan Commission
has streamlined the review process for projects within the Old Orland Historic
District. However, the loss of the HPRC may create unforeseen planning
implications. Since 1991, when officially enacted with the creation of its by-laws
to administer the Villages historic preservation ordinance, the HPRC had been
in charge of reviewing Certificate of Appropriateness applications, conducted
regular monthly meetings, maintained the register of historic contributing
structures and landmarks, pursued a number of historic building surveys,
created and revised zoning ordinances and amendments, and overall oversaw
and guided development to maintain district integrity and character.
Without an official government body solely focused on overseeing the Villages
historic preservation programs, Orland Parks ability to proactively identify,
evaluate, and protect historic properties as well as to create a strong longterm preservation strategy may be impaired. The dismantling of the HPRC may
also bring positive change, providing new opportunities for how Orland Park
handles future planning and the review process of projects within Old Orland.
Nonetheless, the impacts of transferring the responsibilities of the HPRC to the
Plan Commission remain to be seen.
HISTORIC DESIGNATION
The majority of historic properties identified worth preserving in the Village as
a whole are predominately located in Old Orland. There are 22 Landmark sites
scattered throughout the entire Village, which includes 16 structures in the
Old Orland Historic District. Based on the 2008 RAI Survey, buildings within
Old Orland are determined to be either contributing or non-contributing to the
District per the regulations defined in the LDC. Some of the notable contributing
structures in Old Orland include the Twin Tower Sanctuary, the oldest home in
Orland Park, Christ Lutheran Church, Loebe Brothers General Store, and Orland
State Bank.
98
99
PUBLIC
HEARING
PUBLIC
HEARING
PLAN
COMMISSION
PLAN
COMMISSION
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
COMMITTEE
COMMITTEE
BOARD OF
TRUSTEES
BOARD
OF
TRUSTEES
ADMINISTRATIVE
REVIEW
ADMINISTRATIVE
REVIEW
X
XX
X
Minor Change
(All Buildings)
Routine
Maintenance
Routine
Maintenance
Demolition
Demolition
New
Construction
New Construction
PLAN
COMMISSION
PLAN
COMMISSION
COMMITTEE
COMMITTEE
BOARD OF
TRUSTEES
BOARD
OF
TRUSTEES
ADMINISTRATIVE
REVIEW
ADMINISTRATIVE
REVIEW
X
X
X
X
X
X
Not Required
Not Required
X
X
Major Change: Substantial change to the exterior appearance of a structure, or any change to the impervious
coverage on the site, including but not limited to: new construction or additions, including new decks visible from
the right-of-way, porches, driveways etc.; demolition of any contributing structure or any part of a contributing
structure; relocation of buildings; significant alteration/ removal of historical or architectural features.
Minor Change: Changes that do not have a substantial impact on the exterior appearance of the structure or
site, including alteration, addition or removal of exterior architectural elements such as doors, windows, fences,
skylights, siding, exterior stairs, roofs, tuck-pointing etc.
Routine Maintenance: Includes repair or replacement of exterior elements where there is no change in the
design, materials, or appearance of the structure or property such as gutters and downspouts, drive-ways etc.
Landscape changes for gardens, planting beds, new trees, outdoor lighting for single family homes etc. will be
considered as routine maintenance.
New Construction: The construction of a freestanding structure on any developable lot, including new
construction that involves additions to existing buildings.
V I L L A G E
O F
O R L A N D
P A R K
O F
O R L A N D
P A R K
V I L L A G E
O F
O R L A N D
5. 14306Orland
V I L L A G E
P A R K
Orland
Park
SchoolP A R KAvenue
Christ Lutheran Church
Former Residence
V I L L A G E O
F 14320-24
O R L A N DBeacon
10.
11. 14330 Beacon Avenue
4. 9925 W. 143rd Street
57
W. 144th Street
14306-10 Union Avenue 8. 9967
14314 Union Avenue
Twin
SanctuaryAvenue
12. Towers
14315
12. 14315
BeaconBeacon
Avenue
Former Residence
Loebe House
V I L L A G E
O F
P A R K
Street
Commercial Emporium
57
7. 9952 W
Loebe H
57
Residence
Cox House
Residence
9830 W. 144th
PlaceBeacon Avenue
14339
Humphrey
15.House
9830 W. 144th Place
Cox House
9. 14316
Orland
Humphrey House
Humphrey House
58
100
59
CONTRIBUTING
VS.
NON-
While the 2008 RAI Survey notes that the findings do not support extending the
boundaries of the existing Old Orland Historic District, it notes that 20 buildings and
one historic landscape outside of the District meet local landmark criteria and can be
considered for designation based on their historic significance and integrity.30 Since
the 2008 RAI Survey was completed, some of these buildings have been lost. However,
the remaining buildings hold the potential to be designated as historic properties.
101
102
DEMOLISHED BUILDINGS IN OLD ORLAND LISTED AS POTENTIALLY CONTRIBUTING TO THE HISTORIC DISTRICT
103
-- That the cost of repair of the building or structure exceeds the value
of the land and the building, thus creating an economic hardship for
the owner
-- That a historic landmark survey has been conducted and documents
the historical and architectural significant of the building or site.
104
in 2003, there was market demand for larger homes with at least three bedrooms.
Many of the existing homes in Old Orland cannot meet those expectations
and thus is contributing to the demolition of structures. This trend still holds
true after the 2008 economic recession. During the economic downturn, while
new construction was practically halted throughout Orland Park, construction
boomed in Old Orland. This speaks to the stability and value of the District.
The moratorium was deemed unnecessary as layers of protection associated
with historic district designation and the LDC regulations were already in place.
Although a moratorium was never enacted by the Village Board, it encouraged
future planning discussions. Within the following years, the Village hired a
consultant to conduct a survey of properties in Old Orland. Staff and the HPRC
also worked to revise existing regulations and prepared a new ordinance to
further protect the historic resources in the District. Regardless of whether the
moratorium would have altered the course of planning in Old Orland, it showcases
an interest by businesses, residents and some Village officials to protect the
Districts historic resources. Protecting buildings against demolitions remains an
issue in Old Orland today.
Perceptions of Old Orland
The perceived significance of historic buildings also plays a role in demolition.
A large portion of the residential historic buildings in Old Orland are small,
simple farm houses of long forgotten and unknown farmers and residents. Their
past status or wealth, which undoubtedly is represented through the simple
architectural styles, makes it difficult for developers to justify spending resources
to preserve a form that they can more efficiently build. The Twin Towers and
John Humphrey House, two buildings listed on the National Register of Historic
Places, have been noted as some of the only buildings in the District worth
preserving.32 Yet other buildings in Old Orland, particularly those which have
not been properly maintained, are often overlooked and not deemed worth
preserving, leaving some saying, I just assumed whatever teardowns went on
would be improvementsThese houses, theres nothing cute or historic about
them. Theyre just old and frankly, quite shabby.33 Others have noted, few
structures would jump out as historic to a layman and Some of the buildings
are marginally historicLets look at what buildings are really worth saving. 34
105
106
to the Historic District per the 2008 RAI survey. They were also noted as in good
condition with medium integrity. Even though both structures were covered in
synthetic siding and had been somewhat altered over time, they were eligible
to be contributing structures to the Histrict District. But because the LDC does
not recognize either as an official contributing structures or landmarks under
Section 6-209 or Section 5-110, they were considered non-contributing and
were not protected from demolition.
As previously discussed, the 16 contributing structures to Old Orland are
the only buildings protected by demolition per code in the District. However,
even a handful of these structures are now featuring some neglect and poor
maintenance. The Humphrey House, which today serves as a museum, is
showing signs of aging and deferred care.
NEW CONSTRUCTION, MARKET DEMANDS, AND HOMEOWNER
PREFERENCES
New construction also stems from market demands and homeowner preferences.
Home buyers are attracted to the Historic District for its unique character, charm,
walkability, and close proximity to shopping, transportation, and other amenities.
However, the very historic character and charm that attracted homeowners
to the area is being replaced by new homeowners redeveloping simple farm
houses into modern, large houses built to mimic Old Orlands historic building
styles. Many of the newly constructed homes that replaced small farm houses
or simple frame buildings dwarf neighboring houses. In some cases, buildings
have been torn down and the lots have been re-subdivided to accommodate
larger houses.
NEW DEVELOPMENT IN THE MAIN STREET DOWNTOWN DISTRICT &
SURROUNDING AREAS
Old Orlands close proximity to the 143rd Street Metra Station, the Main Street
Downtown District, Village Center area, and nearby major thoroughfares make
it an attractive location for redevelopment. New construction projects have
been recently completed and are underway just outside of the Historic District,
particularly in the neighboring Main Street Downtown and Orland Crossing
107
Districts. Local real estate market pressures are pushing redevelopment, which
is contributing to the increase in the number of valuable buildings lost in the
District.
Development in the adjacent Main Street Downtown District has triggered
growing concerns over the past decade.37 When the Main Street project was
in the planning stage in the early 2000s, development in the area was cited
as bringing rampant land speculation, which had many residents looking to
put the brakes on changes to the historic district. 38 Many noted the need to
curb construction and the demolition of buildings in the District. One resident
noted, We needto stop people from buying up three or four lots and building
their three story monsters, while the Old Orland Heritage Foundation President
commented, If we dont stop it, that whole district will probably be disappearing
one at a time, two at a time.39
During the planning for the Main Street Downtown, a series of workshops and
meetings were held to get input from Old Orland businesses and residents on
the future development. At that time, maintaining the Districts turn of the century
character while new homes and businesses were built was considered important
as well as retaining and expanding small specialty shops rather than large chain
stores. New buildings were recommended to blend with the Historic District so
the area did not appear to be a hodgepodge of old and new. Additionally, it was
noted that planning for Old Orland should happen alongside and be a part of
the larger Main Street Downtown District plan: we have to make sure what
they do now makes sense. It needs to be one plan, one package (that) takes into
account the future of the area and addresses issues of traffic40
The new downtown project has been touted as a way to rejuvenate Old Orland,
bringing needed reinvestment into the Historic District.41 Village officials noted
that the Main Street Downtown District and Old Orland were supposed to be
thought of as two interconnected areas and as extensions of each other.42
However, many of the promises for revitalization have yet to been seen and
investment has been uneven throughout the district. Rather than reinvesting in
and pursuing plans for Old Orland, the Village has targeted efforts creating the
new downtown.
108
been demolished. But today the building is one of the Village's most prominent
landmarks and it is hard to image Old Orland without its presence. The restored
historic church is now used primarily for events and can be rented for parties,
receptions and gatherings. The building stands as one of the most impressive
architectural features of the District, representing spiritual and social history of
community. Its story is critical for understanding preservation challenges and
how the partnerships between the Village, local organizations, and residents
was necessary for preventing demolition. Taking action too late or pushing
matters to the backburner could have led Twin Towers to ultimately suffer the
fate of other historic buildings in Orland Park. Yet, today the building has been
preserved for future generations.
The demolition of additional structures would cause the loss of many buildings
that symbolize the Villages early history and farming past. The absence of a
stronger demolition policy, the lack of protection provided by the existing LDC,
and outdated regulations highlight the fact that contributing structures to the
District are not properly protected from demolition. The Village will need to
determined how to reinvigorate Old Orland and its businesses alongside the
massive growth occurring within the Main Street Downtown District. Addressing
challenges related to demolition by neglect and redevelopment pressures will
create new opportunities to transform the district into a vibrant commercial and
residential neighborhood that preserves the past and adds future value to the
area.
The importance of Old Orlands existing historic buildings and the benets of
preservation potentially spurred by preserving old buildings are not meant to
insinuate that new construction is expendable. Old Orland is a dynamic place
that cannot be treated as an exhibit in a museum. A diverse mixture of old
and new construction reects the economic past throughout generations and
also encourages growth. Building diversity in age and structure helps create
lively areas by supplying different aordability levels and economically valuable
places for specic businesses and residents.
109
District. This may be because the grant has not been widely marketed or because
businesses and property owners are not aware of the program. Additionally, the
grant program only provides financial assistance to the 16 contributing structures
in the Historic District. Finally, AIG funding is rarely granted for changes to the
site, landscaping, or streetscape improvements. In addition to faade and
storefront renovations, some of Old Orlands businesses along 143rd Street,
Beacon Avenue, and Union Avenue could benefit from improvements to the
public realm that are not supported under the AIG program.
With the infrequent use of AIG funding in Old Orland in recent years, the Historic
District has benefitted little from the program. In the future, the AIG could become an
important financial tool in helping with the preservation, restoration, rehabilitation
or maintenance of historic properties in Old Orland. The program has the potential
to be revamped to support the revitalization of the business areas as well as
address long-standing concerns about property maintenance and buildings falling
into disrepair. With financial support, property owners and businesses could reinvest in Old Orland, changing the appearance and perception of the District. New
storefronts, faade enhancements, landscaping, streetscaping, and restoration
work would also help encourage additional reinvestment in the District.
HISTORIC MARKER PROGRAM
In 2007, the Historic Marker Program was established to locate interpretive
signs explaining the history of local landmarks in Old Orland and throughout
the Village. While the program is a long-term project and new markers have not
been installed in recent years, the historic markers are important in educating
visitors and residents about the significance of landmark buildings in the Village.
HISTORIC AWARDS PROGRAM
The Awards Program was created to recognize property owners or businesses
that contributed to the preservation and enhancement of the Old Orland Historic
District. The program is currently inactive and awards have not been granted in
a number of years.
110
111
Unfortunately, some of these groups no longer exist and others are inactive.
In the past, these groups were involved with the Villages Historic Preservation
Review Commission, working on a number of projects that sought to create new
programs and advance planning efforts in Old Orland. With the decommissioning
of the Historic Preservation Review Commission in the beginning of 2016,
remaining local preservation groups, neighborhood organizations, residents,
and business owners interested in improving Old Orland are limited in how they
can proactively assist or collaborate with the Village and planning efforts. The
combination of a lack of interested stakeholders involved in planning for Old
Orland as well as the loss of an official government body focused on overseeing
the Villages historic preservation programs may impair a long-term preservation
strategy.
Community partnerships, public engagement, and multi-stakeholder involvement
will be necessary to preserving and instilling a renewed interest in Old Orland.
Within Old Orland itself, past collaborations between various groups, the
Village, and residents have made profound impacts on the preservation of and
development within the District. The Twin Towers Sanctuary is fitting example of
how partnerships are critical for preserving meaningful buildings and improving
the Historic District. In 1987, when the Twin Tower Sanctuary faced demolition,
the Village worked with the newly formed Old Orland Heritage Foundation,
church members, local residents, and volunteers to prevent the churchs demise
and to painstakingly restore the building. According to one Village planner at
that time, It was a great core group of people who took it over and really got
at the project right awayIf they hadn't been there, I question whether the
building would even be here today or if it would have had to have been torn
down anyway due to lack of maintenance or vandalism. It was the bureaucrats
like me who kept the church from being torn down, but the major credit really is
due to people [from the Old Orland Heritage Foundation] and all the volunteers
who worked with them."52
Today, it is hard to imagine Old Orland without the Twin Towers. Through
combined efforts, the Old Orland Heritage Foundation and volunteers worked
for over 10 years to restore the Twin Towers Sanctuary into one of the most
impressive and important buildings within the District. Yet, public involvement
and negative perceptions of the Old Orland remain prominent issues today. Over
a decade ago, during the restoration of the Twin Towers, a Chicago Tribune
article aptly stated, Preservationists say they realize the district has to adapt
and improve or risk dying not by over-development, but by a lack of interest.53
112
local
CHALLENGES
-- Redevelopment pressures
113
114
ENDNOTES
Illinois Department of Transportation, US Route
45 (LaGrange Road) Reconstruction and Widening,
Illinois Department of Transportation. 2015. Accessed
May 1, 2016, http://www.idot.illinois.gov/projects/
us45-reconstruction-and-widening; Village of Orland
Park, LaGrange Road Widening Project FAQ, Village
of Orland Park. https://www.orland-park.il.us/index.
aspx?NID=1566.
2
Regional Transportation Authority Mapping and
Statistics (RTAMS), 143rd Street (Orland Park)
Station Weekday Ridership, Regional Transportation
Authority, Accessed May 20, 2016, http://www.
rtams.org/rtams/metraHistoricalRidership.
jsp?level=station&ridershipID=8236
3
Diana Strzalka, Orland Park is Trying to Move Concrete
Firm, Chicago Tribune, April 30, 1998; Margie Ritchie,
Triangle Advances for Orland Downtown,Chicago
Tribune, June 22, 2005; Patricia Trebe, Pursuing an
Ambitious Vision; Orland Park Mayor says a Downtown
Tops List of Priorities, Chicago Tribune, May 22, 2002.
4
Village of Orland Park, Development Services
Department, Requests for Proposals: Project Summary
for the Main Street Triangle, Orland Park: Village of
Orland Park, February 2009: 4.
5
The Center for Neighborhood Technology, TransitOriented Development in the Chicago Region: Efficient
and Resilient Communities for the 21st Century,
Chicago: The Center for Neighborhood Technology, April
2013; Teska Associates, Inc. and Fish Transportation
Group, How to Make Your Community Transit Ready:
Setting the Stage for Transit. Prepared for the Regional
Transportation Authority, Chicago: April 2012, 19.
6
B. Kink, Forums explore Old Orlands character, The
Regional News, 3.
7
Sharon Stangenes, Luxury rentals in the heart of
Orland Park, Chicago Tribune, February 16, 2014;
1
115
116
117
RECOMMENDATIONS
Connectivity, redevelopment pressures, the streetscape
appearance, and business vitality represent only a few of the
hurdles facing the Old Orland Historic District. Even though
Old Orland longer can claim the title as the Village's downtown,
tremendous opportunities exist for linking the Historic District
surrounding neighborhoods. While construction in the Main Street
Downtown District has initiated the creation of a new transitoriented town center, planning efforts should now turn toward
Old Orland. With the Main Street Downtown District as a catalyst,
new economic activity can trigger much needed improvements in
Old Orland. The Historic District has the potential to once again
become a vibrant place that fosters business activity, attracts
visitors, and enhances residents quality of life.
The following recommendations attempt to address the planning
challenges discussed in the previous chapter, build on the areas
existing assets, and at the same time protect the existing historic
character of Old Orland. The recommendations were determined
through carefully examining the past and present conditions in Old
Orland as well as from using lessons learned from other historic
downtowns. Countless historic neighborhoods have become
valuable educational resources on the history of the surrounding
118
119
SUSTAINABLE ENVIRONMENT
120
1) A WELL-CONNECTED FRAMEWORK
Strengthen the street network & connect Old Orland to surrounding districts
Old Orlands built environment features a number of existing assets, including
a street grid with walkable blocks, appropriate scale and density, mix of uses,
historic character, and close proximity to transportation and nearby shopping.
The hierarchy of streets, traffic volumes, size and shape of blocks, appearance,
ease of access and mobility for pedestrians and vehicles, and parking are all
important components of the existing street system. Streets, sidewalks, walking
paths, and the railroad are all important routes that provide access points to the
neighborhood and from surrounding districts.
Yet, Old Orland remains physically and visually disconnected from the adjacent
Main Street Downtown and Village Center Districts, which includes nearby open
spaces, shopping, and services. Existing street and pedestrian connections also
limit access and mobility inside the District. The existing street network directly
impacts Old Orlands character, function, and business vitality. Because 143rd
Street is a major thoroughfare, people quickly pass by Old Orland. Instead,
the street network should encourage people to stop to spend time or shop in
the District. Enhancements to access and mobility will particularly impact the
business vitality along 143rd Street, Union Avenue, and Beacon Avenue as well
as make Old Orland overall a better, safe, pleasant, and engaging place to walk
and visit.
The following recommendations seek to provide better linkages and access in
Old Orland, both internally and externally. Pedestrian movement is prioritized
and integrated into a harmonious network of various modes of transportation,
including automobile, pedestrian, bike, and train routes. Through improving
connectivity and strengthening the existing framework, Old Orland will be
integrated internally and connected to the surrounding areas.
In both short and long term, Old Orlands streets should be enhanced and
planned in ways that accommodate automobiles, pedestrians, and bicyclists.
121
The traditional street grid pattern should be maintained where it already exists
and introduced in places where there are no connections. Sidewalks and public
spaces should help create a dynamic business climate that brings people
together and encourages interaction. All of the Historic Districts streets should
aim to be comfortable and safe for both vehicles and pedestrians, promoting the
use of public spaces and access to businesses.
STRATEGIES
1) IMPLEMENT NEW IMPROVEMENTS ALONG 143RD STREET
Currently, 143rd Street serves as the main roadway connection between Old
Orland and the Main Street Downtown District. Yet, as a major thoroughfare,
it acts as a barrier between the two neighborhoods. Heavy traffic, wide and
difficult-to-cross intersections, limited destinations, and poor streetwall and
appearance create a disconnected environment between the two districts.
In particular, an improved and appropriate design for the intersection of 143rd
Street, Union Avenue, and Southwest Highway should be studied. Improvements
to traffic circulation, access, safety, and parking along 143rd Street should
be further explored, including new traffic calming measures, relocating traffic
signals, realigning streets, and the consolidation of driveways opening to
minimize openings to 143rd Street.
While some intersection crossings are clearly defined as pedestrian connectors,
additional improvements can be made to improve traffic flow, connectivity,
and safety within the business areas. For example, intersections closer to the
Main Street Downtown District along 143rd Street, such as on Beacon Avenue
and Ravinia Avenue, have decorative-brick paved crosswalks. These types
FRAMEWORK PLAN
122
123
The reconfiguration of the interior streets and connections within Old Orland
should also be examined. For example, a street connection between Union
Avenue and Beacon Avenue could provide a link between Old Orlands two
commercial areas. At the very least, a pedestrian connection and public plaza
or park could tie the two areas together. Future redevelopment of multi-family
and office buildings between Beacon Avenue and Ravinia Avenue may provide
a chance to construct a new street linking Old Orland to Ravinia Avenue.
Given the challenges of constructing new roads within the existing street grid,
increased pedestrian connections and an extended dedicated multi-purpose
path can provide a way to link Old Orland to nearby neighborhoods, attractions,
and open space. An improved internal trail system featuring seating, unique
paving, lighting, and signage can help bolster linkages to nearby amenities
and provide local residents and visitors with a more enjoyable walking route.
The outcome will be a neighborhood with pedestrian-oriented places and safe
pathways separated from some busy streets.
124
The future trail system will create new linkages, allowing cyclists, pedestrians,
shoppers, office workers, and other Downtown visitors appreciate and enjoy
using the trail on a regular basis. In addition to improving connections, new
public spaces and an enhanced public realm will be integrated into the system.
Features of an improved pedestrian and open space system include:
Establish a Railroad Crossing Connecting Beacon Avenue and Union
Avenue
The Norfolk Southern Railroad splits Old Orland into two distinct districts and
limits both street and pedestrian connections. The tract of unincorporated land
particularly impacts the commercial area, separating between the businesses
along Union Avenue and Beacon Avenue.
A pedestrian connection between Beacon Avenue, Oak Place and Union Avenue
will help to connect the two business areas in Old Orland. A pedestrian connection
was proposed to the Norfolk and Southern Railroad in the early 1990s, however,
it was never implemented. Creating a new rail crossing, whether in the form of a
new street or as a pedestrian path, is a challenge. Yet, a new pathway will help
address some of existing connectivity problems in Old Orland. A new street
providing a vehicular connection between Union and Beacon Avenue will be
difficult to implement given existing grading, building configurations, costs, and
negotiations with Norfolk Southern Railroad property owners. However, a new
street could be built in the future with the redevelopment of certain properties.
It would help improve eastwest continuity of the existing road system by
providing a direct link between the two business areas. Further, the new street
would provide a safe, walkable environment that diverts traffic away from the
congested existing grade crossings at 143rd Street and Southwest Highway.
In the short-term, a new pedestrian connection between Beacon Avenue,
Oak Place and Union Avenue will help to connect the two business areas in
Old Orland. A new pathway connecting these existing streets ties into plans
for converting the old Metra commuter parking lot on 144th Street into a new
park or plaza. The Village of Orland Park has explored the creation of a park or
plaza in this area, known as Beacon Park. This site will be discussed further in
125
126
127
OPPORTUNITY AREAS
128
Land Uses. Commercial and mixed-use buildings along 143rd Street to create a full frontage
of new and old buildings filled with restaurants, cafes and outdoor seating at the street level
with offices or residential units above. A mixture of commercial retail, restaurants, offices,
entertainment, and civic uses on the ground floor of buildings with residential and office
uses on the upper floors should be prioritized. Mixed-use projects will bring a renewed
combination of residential, restaurant, entertainment, and recreational activities along 143rd
Street. Strong business and restaurant anchors along 143rd Street will become the central
feature of the District. A balance of retail, restaurant, and office activities will provide vital
services to the residents of the community and will attract visitors to the area.
Historic Preservation. Support the adaptive reuse or rehabilitation of historic and potentially
contributing structures.
Cities need old buildings so badly it is probably impossible for vigorous streets and districts to grow without them. By old buildings I mean not museum-piece
old buildings, not old buildings in an excellent state of rehabilitation - although these make fine ingredients - but also a good lot of plain, ordinary, low-value old
buildings, including some rundown old buildings... Even the enterprises that can support new construction in cities need old construction in their immediate vicinity.
Otherwise they are part of a total attraction and total environment that is economically too limited - and therefore functionally too limited to be lively, interesting
and convenient. Flourishing diversity anywhere in a city means the mingling of high-yield, middling-yield, low-yield and no-yield enterprises.
Jane Jacobs, The Death and Life of Great American Cities.
129
Infill Development & Redevelopment. Underutilized land, vacant properties, and surface parking lots should
be converted into meaningful, productive uses. New buildings or additions should be sensitive to adjacent
historic buildings and reflect the existing development pattern through compatibility with building orientation,
height, massing, setbacks, land use, and the location or visibility of parking lots.
Transit-Oriented Development. While there is train access via the 143rd Street Metra Station and a higher
density of newer buildings within the Main Street area, the overall area still is noticeably automobile-oriented
with single-story commercial buildings and surface parking lots. Building heights and higher densities should be
highest along 143rd Street to take advantage of the nearby Metra station and Downtown development.
Public Realm. Ensure a high quality design and development in both the public and private realms. Create
a strong streetwall that visually maintains a connection between Old Orland and the Main Street Downtown
District as well as engages and activates the pedestrian environment. Buildings should be oriented toward the
street, located at or near the sidewalk with attractive storefront facades. The importance of public spaces and
sidewalks should be emphasized to promote a sense of place and welcoming environment for residents and
visitors. Outdoor seating, building and streetscape design, ground floor activity, landscape elements, and other
pedestrian amenities will give life to the sidewalk.
130
Parking. For the past few decades, businesses in Old Orland have noted a
lack of parking. A five-story parking deck is under constructed on Ravinia
Avenue and 143rd Street, which will serve the Main Street Downtown
District and University of Chicago Medicine Center for Advanced Care.
When completed the parking deck will include over 520 parking spaces,
most of which will be dedicated for public parking. The addition of these
public parking spaces will provide additional nearby parking to Old Orland.
Wayfinding signage should be located between the parking deck and Old
Orland to promote off-site parking opportunities. Convenient access to
additional parking in the Historic District should be further pursued with
redevelopment. Shared access points and cross-access between buildings
should be promoted. Off-street parking can be improved by better organizing
existing and proposed parking lots.
Existing surface parking lots, particularly along 143rd Street and other
business areas, contribute to a poor pedestrian environment and should
be removed with redevelopment or properly screened during site
improvements. The large number of parking lot curb cuts and driveways
along 143rd Street also create an unattractive street wall and contribute to
unsafe road crossings. Consolidating driveways to minimize openings and
screening parking lots from view will provide a buffer from adjacent uses
and pedestrian walkways.
Future parking lots should be located behind buildings at the rear of the
properties and designed in a manner that provides both a coordinated
shared parking area with cross access. Using a shared parking approach
will help to create a more efficient site design, reduce the number of curb
cuts, alleviate congestion, and enhance the appearance of properties from
the street.
Streetscape Improvements. Improve appearance of the street through
screening surface parking lots, adding new landscaping, and modernizing
outdated facades.
Plazas & Civic Spaces. Locate public gathering spaces and plazas across
143rd Street.
131
132
buildings have been converted into commercial uses or antique stores. The
adaptive reuse of other building may also be supported through addressing
building codes and economic incentives.
Capitalize on Existing Museums. There are currently two museums along
Beacon Avenue: the Humphrey House Museum is located on the corner
of Beacon Avenue and 144th Place and Orland Park History Museum
recently opened in the former Village Hall site on Beacon Avenue. While
these museums represent an important pathway for spreading awareness
of local heritage, both museums are not living up to their potential as major
tourist attractions. Both museums have limited hours, funding, staffing, and
HUMPHREY MUSEUM
133
134
135
136
STRATEGIES
1) PROVIDING NEW OPEN SPACES & PLAZAS
Although there are numerous parks and open spaces surrounding Old Orland,
there is a lack of public gathering spaces within the District and a lack of
connection to the surrounding park space. The area would benefit from both
large and small permanent gathering spaces, including a central plaza or
smaller parks. The newly developed open spaces and extended trail system will
provide additional areas where people can interact with one another and enjoy
a method for easily moving between adjacent districts, parks, and recreational
opportunities.
New civic gathering spaces in Old Orland will support special events, help
promote activities, and attract visitors and potential shops to the area. The
following areas have been identified as ideal locations for new or improved civic
and open spaces:
137
138
can serve as the gateway to Old Orland and connect the Historic District to
Humphrey Woods, the Village Center Campus, and the Humphrey Sports
Complex located to the south. A new multi-use trail can extend from this
entrance to the existing path in Humphrey Woods.
Humphrey House Garden. The Humphrey House Museum, at 9830 W
144th Place, includes a half-acre open space, the largest open space in
Old Orland. A community botanical garden was previously planned on site,
but was never implemented because of storm water runoff drainage issues.
The site should be re-evaluated for its potential to hold a community event
space that can be utilized by residents and also help attract new visitors to
the Humphrey House Museum.
Other Redevelopment Opportunity Sites. Additionally, smaller public
open spaces can be located within existing parking lots or underutilized
land to offer attractive places for gathering. Redevelopment and infill
development projects should ensure that small publicly-accessible open
spaces or small plazas are incorporated.
2) COMPLETE STREETSCAPE IMPROVEMENTS
Old Orlands physical appearance, particularly along 143rd Street, is in need of
improvements. An attractive, pedestrian-friendly streetscape should include a
combination of landscaped areas and planters, a tree canopy, lighting, street
furniture, public art, and other amenities. Enhancing the existing streetscape
experience will help make Old Orland more inviting for shoppers, diners,
residents, and visitors as well as connect the Historic District to the Main Street
District. The following improvements will help to support existing businesses,
attract new development, and create a well-connected, attractive environment
while maintaining Old Orlands character and identity:
Bury Overhead Utility Lines. Overhead utility lines and poles are located
on a number of streets in the Historic District. Of note, the utility lines
along 143rd Street and Beacon Avenue should be buried to enhance the
appearance of the street and improve the appearance of the business
139
district. Residential streets could also benefit from locating utility lines
underground.
Install Consistent Street Lighting. A handful of historic-inspired street
lights are located throughout Old Orland. Yet, street light styles are
inconsistent throughout the District. Large street lights and overhead utility
lines along 143rd Street create an unattractive and cluttered appearance.
Lighting can have a dramatic impact on creating a sense of place. When
properly designed, lighting relates to a pedestrian scale using repetition and
pattern to create a consistent image. For Old Orland, street lighting should
be replaced with one unified style, preferably the existing historic street
lights. These lights will serve as a unifying feature for the entire area.
Plant New Landscaping & Trees. Landscaping and trees are limited along
143rd Street and Union Avenue. Adding trees and landscaping in proper
locations can have a positive effect on the pedestrian environment, business
climate, and overall image of Old Orland. They provide comfort to public
spaces, create a sense of safety and security from traffic, and reinforce the
importance of a walkable street. New trees will create a continuous canopy
while raised planters and landscaping can help define spaces and screen
surface parking lots. Plantings along the Norfolk Southern Railroad right-ofway would also help enhance entry point to Old Orland.
Provide Street Furniture & Public Features. Street furniture and public
features would improve the pedestrian experience of Old Orland. Benches,
trash receptacles, bike racks, lighting, public art, and unified landscaping
elements will help activate the public realm and help to create a warm
and inviting place. These type of features are particularly important within
the business areas, unifying the area into a unique, pedestrian friendly
environment. Street furniture would have a cohesive style that would reflect
the Historic Districts historic character. Outdoor dining and public art
should also be pursued to enhance the pedestrian environment and support
economic activity.
To build on Old Orlands historic character, public art related to the
Villages history could be located throughout the District. This could include
Old Orland can become an important place to stop for both residents and
visitors. Attractive gateways and wayfinding signage will make it easy to
find Old Orland from the major routes into Orland Park as well as from the
Village Center, the Metra train station, and new development in the Main
Street District.
Large gateway signs should be aimed toward approaching traffic and
advantage of the location they are placed in. Ideal locations for large gateway
signs or arches include 143rd Street and West Avenue, the intersection of
the Norfolk Railroad and West Avenue, 143rd Street and Beacon Avenue,
143rd Street and Southwest Highway. These areas will help define visible
entrances to Old Orland and enhance the Districts unique identity.
There are little if any visible directional signage located on major street
arteries, leaving the businesses with less direct exposure from nearby major
traffic routes. Wayfinding should play an especially important role in helping
visitors locate the Historic District from these routes. Signage that identifies
and directs visitors to Old Orland should be located along the east, west
and north approaches to the La Grange Road as well as along 143rd Street.
There are a number of key location options for directional signage in the
surrounding area, such as along LaGrange Road and within neighboring
districts, including the Main Street and Village Center Districts. Ensure
wayfinding signage is property designed and located near the Main Street
Downtown District will be important, particularly for directing visitors to and
from public parking opportunities currently under construction.
Finally, there is an opportunity to integrate history into new signage,
particularly along sidewalks and an integrated trail system. Interpretive
signage can relay the story of Old Orland and raise awareness of its history.
Currently, there is a Historic Marker Program in Old Orland, where plaques
relay the history of typically of individual buildings. However, these only
exist on a handful of buildings.
140
STRATEGIES
1) REEVALUATE HISTORIC LANDMARK STATUS & ENCOURAGE
HISTORIC DESIGNATION OF POTENTIALLY CONTRIBUTING BUILDINGS
FACING DEVELOPMENT PRESSURE IN OLD ORLAND
The 16 buildings classified as contributing structures and landmarks in LDC
Section 6-209 and Section 5-110 are the only buildings protected in the District
by code. According to the 2008 RAI Survey, in addition to these 16 contributing
141
Many cities and towns have enacted demolition delays to help prevent
demolitions within historic districts. Demolition delay places a moratorium on
demolition permits for historic or potentially historic buildings, for a fixed period
of days or months. This period allows time to explore alternative options to
demolition, other economically viable uses for a property, a public hearing
before a government review body, and notifying property owners of demolition
plans within a historic district. A demolition delay is an opportunity to open
conversations about alternatives to demolition of a contributing structure, but is
not an absolute means for preventing demolition.
In Orland Park, contributing and landmark structures are subject to a demolition
delay period. Demolitions of contributing structures require a Certificate of
Appropriateness (COA) for Demolition and are subject to a 90-day demolition
delay pending a public hearing at the Plan Commission, Development Services
and Planning Committee, and Village Board. If a COA for Demolition is denied,
a demolition permit will not be issued until the 90-day demolition delay has
expired, until the building is surveyed and documented for its historical or
architectural significance by a qualified historic preservation consultant, and
building information archived by the Village. Additionally, the 90-day delay
period provides an opportunity for a reasonable alternative to demolition. If an
alternative is determined by the Development Services Department, it will be
presented to the Board of Trustees for review and consideration, which then can
grant or modify the alternative proposal with conditions and deny the demolition,
or deny the alternative proposal and grant the Certificate of Appropriateness for
Demolition.
While Orland Park has strong measures for protecting its contributing and
landmark buildings, there are no effective mechanisms or demolition delay
Protecting this country's heritagefrom fishing villages to city neighborhoods, from barns to courthouses, from historic bridges to older schools, from urban parks
to rural landscapeswill help make America a better place... Preservation ensures that future generations will have a past to appreciate. Preservation is more than
just saving buildings, a house museum here and there. It's about creating and enhancing environments that support, inform, and enrich the lives of all Americans.
Preservation is revitalizing traditional downtowns, the "Main Street" businesses that are the lifeblood of small cities and rural communities. It is bringing new life to
the neighborhoods of great cities that have suffered from decline and neglect.
142
important for preventing the loss of historic structures. These include establishing
preservation and rehabilitation incentives, maintenance requirements, and
preparing property owner notices of the need to repair.
3) UPDATE THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION REVIEW PROCESS
The Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) review and approval process is
intended to protect against insensitive alterations to historic properties and that
new construction is compatible in design with the surrounding District. A COA
must be is obtained before building permits are issues and any proposed work
begins. While improvements to this process have strengthened and streamlined
the historic preservation review process in many ways, potentially historic
resources are left unprotected from insensitive alterations and redevelopment
pressures. The following updated process, shown to the right, reflects changes
and demolition measures discussed above.
4) UPDATE DESIGN GUIDELINES
Design review through the Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) application
process and design guidelines help ensure that building alternations and new
construction projects are compatible with the character of Old Orland. Old
Orland design guidelines are incorporated into the Villages Land Development
Code, which is available online and in the Historic Preservation Resident
Handbook provided by the Development Services Department. The design
guidelines are important in that they provide guidance to property owners
and businesses undertaking exterior changes to both contributing and noncontributing buildings within the Historic District.
Historic preservation clearly does much more than preserve bricks and mortar. It recognizes that our built history connects us in tangible ways with our past
and provides context for the places we occupy and the world we live in.It fuses art with craftsmanship, capacity for modern utility with embodied energy, and
progressive ideas for economic revitalization with traditional authenticity. Historic preservation is at the same time wonderfully egalitarian; all socioeconomic
classes in every corner of the nation have successfully utilized its principles to protect their heritage and revitalize their communities.
Craig Potts,Executive Director of the Kentucky Heritage Council and State Historic Preservation Officer
143
HEARING
COMMISSION
TRUSTEES
REVIEW
Routine Maintenance
Demolition
CURRENT
REVIEW
PROCESS
FOR
NON-CONTRIBUTING
STRUCTURES
& NEW
CONSTRUCTION
REVIEW
PROCESS
FOR CONTRIBUTING
STRUCTURES
AND
LANDMARKS
REVIEW
PROCESS
FOR
NON-CONTRIBUTING
STRUCTURES
AND
NEW
CONSTRUCTION
PUBLIC
BOARDOF
OF
PUBLIC
PLANPLAN
COMMITTEE BOARD
COMMITTEE
HEARING
COMMISSION
TRUSTEES
HEARING
COMMISSION
TRUSTEES
Major Change (All Buildings)
New Construction
X
X
Routine Maintenance
Demolition
X
X
Routine Maintenance
Demolition
ADMINISTRATIVE
ADMINISTRATIVE
REVIEW
REVIEW
Not Required
X
PROPOSED REVIEW
PROCESS
FOR
NON-CONTRIBUTING
NEW
CONSTRUCTION
REVIEW
PROCESS
FOR
NON-CONTRIBUTINGSTRUCTURES
STRUCTURES &
AND
NEW
CONSTRUCTION
PUBLIC
HEARING
Major Change (Contributing Per 2008 RAI Survey)
PLAN
COMMISSION
X
COMMITTEE
BOARD OF
TRUSTEES
ADMINISTRATIVE
REVIEW
X
Not Required
Routine Maintenance
Demolition (Contributing Per 2008 RAI Survey)
New Construction
144
also can help to identify which features are significant and should be preserved,
and conversely, which features are less critical to the integrity of a historic
resource, thereby indicating where greater flexibility may be afforded.
5) ACTIVELY ADDRESS THE PROBLEM OF DEMOLITION BY NEGLECT &
PROPERTY MAINTENANCE ISSUES
Aging buildings & property maintenance have contributed to certain demolition
by neglect cases in Old Orland. Additionally, poorly maintained buildings harm
the integrity of historic structures and create a negative appearance of the
neighborhood. New options should be explored to eliminate demolitions by
neglect and address maintenance issues.
6) CONSIDER ADDITIONAL LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE UPDATES TO
IMPROVE THE OLD ORLAND HISTORIC DISTRICT
Additional regulations related to historic preservation should also be evaluated
and revised where needed to ensure they reflect preserve Old Orlands unique
character and contribute to its future vitality:
--------
The past is not the property of historians; it is a public possession. It belongs to anyone who is aware of it, and it grows by being shared. It sustains the whole
society, which always needs the identity that only the past can give. In the Grapes of Wrath John Steinbeck pictures a group of Oklahoma farm wives loading their
goods into an old truck for the long trip to California. They did not have many possessions, but there was not room for what they had. These are not members
of a historical society. They had never seen a museum or a memorial. They were just people, asking a poignant and universal question: "How will we know it's us
without our past?" We do not choose between the past and the future; they are inseparable parts of the same river.
Carl Feiss, With Heritage So Rich
145
Zoning & Land Use Flexibility. An overlay district can allow a greater
flexibility of allowable uses and development standards for a property,
with a goal of finding a use that is compatible with the historic character
of the property that will help ensure its continued productive use. Allowing
a different set of permitted land uses will support downtown development
activity and properly transition properties closer to the Main Street Downtown
District. An example of this is a professional office in a historic house in a
residential district where such an office would not normally be permitted.
Additional reductions in parking requirements could also be allowed.
Building & Height Density. Allow a higher density of uses within mixed-use
buildings along 143rd Street to take advance of the nearby Metra Station
and create a continuous streetwall between Old Orland and the Main Street
Downtown District.
Promote Improvements to the Public Realm. Guidelines and incentives
can encourage development projects to create pedestrian friendly streets
with a mix of civic uses and public open spaces as focal points of the district
Historic preservation has a proven track record of stimulating economic
development. It should be seen as an economic development strategy, with
various related financial programs and incentives encouraging growth and
investment. Many times the rehabilitation of historic properties and associated
incentives can be a catalyst for downtown revitalization. Incentive and grant
programs improve the look and feel of downtown areas, which in turn helps draw
people who spend their money in shops and restaurants. They are important in
off setting costs and can help revitalize historic areas by promoting community
pride, good design, and the productive use of buildings.
A building does not have to be an important work of architecture to become a first-rate landmark. Landmarks are not created by architects. They are fashioned by
those who encounter them after they are built. The essential feature of a landmark is not its design, but the place it holds in a citys memory.
HerbertMuschamp
146
5) ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Provide incentives for historic preservation while fostering a healthy local economy
To support economic development and reinvestment in Old Orland, the
Village can revise and enhance existing incentives for historic preservation
as well as develop new incentive and financing programs. The following
options can be considered to support historic preservation, adaptive reuse,
appropriate new development, and public realm improvement opportunities.
STRATEGIES
1) REVISE THE APPEARANCE IMPROVEMENT GRANT (AIG) PROGRAM
Orland Parks Appearance Improvement Grant (AIG) provides financial
assistance to property owners and business tenants for improving the
exterior appearance of all commercial and historic properties.2 Eligible
faade improvements under the AIG program include improvements visible
from the public right-of-way, such as for awnings, doors, windows, signage,
screening rooftop mechanical equipment, storefront architectural features,
removal of inappropriate materials, restoration of historic architectural
features. Landscaping improvements are allowed on a limited basis.
Grant funds can be used for architectural design fees, contractor fees, or
procurement of materials and construction. The grant will match 50% of
the cost of work up to a maximum of $20,000 per project, with a minimum
investment of $1,000.
With modifications, the AIG program could be an important financial tool
in helping with the preservation and maintenance of historic properties in
Old Orland in the future. This program has the potential to improve the
appearance of business areas on 143rd Street, Union Avenue, and Beacon
147
Avenue. With financial support, property owners and businesses could reinvest in Old Orland, changing the appearance of the Historic District and
transform it into a destination for community residents and visitors.
As noted in the previous chapter, there are a number of issues with how
the current program is set up and how it benefits Old Orland. AIG funding
is largely distributed to large commercial projects outside of Old Orland.
Within the past few years, almost no projects have utilized AIG funding for
updating commercial facades or rehabilitating historic structures in Old
Orland. The following initiatives will improve planning efforts in Old Orland:
Expand the List of Historic Buildings Eligible for AIG Funding. Only
the 16 contributing historic properties in Old Orland are eligible for
rehabilitation assistance. As noted in the previous chapter, there are
a number of non-contributing structures in the Historic District which
were classified under the 2008 RAI Survey as contributing, but are not
recognized by the Villages Land Development Code. These buildings
are valuable to the District and contribute to its historic character, but
are most vulnerable to demolition. AIG funding for historic rehabilitation
and faade improvements should be extended to these buildings where
appropriate with the condition that these buildings are designated as
landmarks. The extension of funding to potentially contributing structures
will help preserve valuable buildings and promote preservation and
restoration efforts. Additionally, the extension of the AIG program to
potentially contributing structures that will be landmarked will address
long-standing concerns about property maintenance and buildings
falling into disrepair.
Expand the Scope of Work Allowed Under the AIG Program. AIG funding
is rarely granted for changes to the site, landscaping, or streetscape
improvements. However, these are the issues directly contributing to
the negative appearance of certain areas of the District. Some of Old
Orlands businesses along 143rd Street, Beacon Avenue, and Union
Avenue could benefit from enhancements not supported under the
AIG program that improve the public realm. The AIG program should
create a separate category that funds streetscape improvements, new
landscaping, screening surface parking lots, constructing plazas and
outdoor patios, as well as implementing sustainable green infrastructure.
Reimbursements for streetscape revitalization would acts as another
tool for improving urban design.
Another option to consider is utilizing funding for the adaptive reuse of
historic and old buildings. There are several barriers to adaptive reusing
older buildings, particularly smallscale residential or commercial
buildings. These types of buildings contribute to Old Orlands character,
but issues with small site or building sizes, ADA accessibility, lack of
flexibility in preservation criteria that may prevent amenities to promote
reuse, restrictive parking requirement, and building or zoning code
requirements make it difficult to meet given building size, design, or
layout. Thus, these types of underutilized buildings are generally
demolished despite their potential to be a part of a meaningful and
Historic preservation makes sense in large measure because historic preservation makes dollars and cents, but it also saves dollars and cents. Historic preservation
is a rational and effective economic response to overconsumption. To make a new brick today to build a building on a site where there is already a building standing
steals from two generations. It steals from the generation that built the brick originally by throwing away their asset before its work is done, and it steals from a
future generation by using increasingly scarce natural resources today that should have been saved for tomorrow.
Don Rykema, The Economics of Rehabilitation
148
149
Special Service Area (SSA). A SSA, also known as a BID, is local tax
district that are largely used in commercial districts to fund a wide range
of special services or physical improvements. A small property tax
levy is placed over a contiguous, defined area to assist with financing
enhanced services or programs in addition to those currently provided
through a local government. One benefit of establishing a SSA is that
local governments can establish special tax district areas without
incurring debt or levying a tax on the entire municipality. Additionally,
the districts can ensure funds are locally managed and distributed only
within the boundaries of the SSA. Projects commonly funded through
SSAs include:
-- Infrastructure improvements, maintenance and beautification
efforts. This may include streetscaping, landscaping, lighting,
signage, benches, trash receptacles, sidewalk paving, street,
storm sewers, and parking lot improvements
-- Land and building improvements, with redevelopment, storefront
improvement grants or loans
-- Downtown marketing, promotion, and advertising
-- Special and promotional events
Improving the character of Old Orland through new and improved financial
incentive programs will draw shoppers, restaurant patrons, office users,
and tourists to the District. These programs could also encourage property
owners to maintain and preserve properties in the District and provide
an opportunity to connect community goals with business goals. In the
end, economic development can be tied to historic preservation, with
small, incremental projects enhancing and unifying the appearance and
connectivity of Old Orland and larger improvements further stimulating
private investment and revitalization.
The good news is historic preservation is good for the economy. In the last fifteen years dozens of studies have been conducted throughout the United States, by
different analysts, using different methodologies. But the results of those studies are remarkably consistent historic preservation is good for the local economy.
From this large and growing body of research, the positive impact of historic preservation on the economy has been documented in six broad areas: 1) jobs, 2)
property values, 3) heritage tourism, 4) environmental impact, 5) social impact, and 6) downtown revitalization.
150
151
STRATEGIES
1) ESTABLISH A DOWNTOWN ORGANIZATION THAT FOCUSES ON
IMPLEMENTING PLANNING EFFORTS IN BOTH THE OLD ORLAND
DISTRICT AND MAIN STREET DOWNTOWN DISTRICT
A newly formed downtown organization would undertake a variety of activities
that advance planning efforts for both Old Orland and the Main Street Downtown
District in a cohesive and coordinated manner. It would form an alliance
between groups not typically involved or engaged in historic preservation or
downtown planning. In coordination with the Village of Orland Park, different
stakeholders could work in tandem to progress the goals of both Districts. As an
independent, non-profit, the downtown organization could consist of business
owners, property owners, residents, realtors, Chamber of Commerce, Village
officials and staff, church members, representatives of other local organizations,
among others.
A new downtown organization could be responsible for:
-- Implementing plans and improvements in Old Orland and the Main
Street Downtown District
-- Event, promotion, marketing, and branding planning and programming
-- Increasing public awareness among local parties about the Main Street
Downtown District, Old Orland, and preservation
-- Developing new educational and outreach programs
-- Assisting with business recruitment and retention
-- Recommending new policies, grants or incentives programs, or other
tools that address improving and preserving the entire downtown area
-- Reviewing existing ordinances and policies for their effectiveness and
impact on the neighborhoods
-- Promoting goals and initiatives that support historic preservation.
-- Initiating and facilitating landmark designations in Old Orland
It could be associated with an established Special Service Area, Business
Improvement District, or other established financing mechanism. Nonetheless,
a new downtown organization would help engage a variety of partners in
a coordinated effort that ties Old Orland into Main Street Downtown District
planning and progresses goals for both Districts. A new partnership will be the
initial step in signaling the Old Orland is evolving into a dynamic, inviting place
to visit, shop, work, and live.
2) CREATE AN OLD ORLAND BUSINESS ASSOCIATION
In preparing for the creation of a new downtown organization that focuses on
both Old Orland and the Main Street Downtown District, existing businesses in
Old Orland should be encouraged to create an active business association that
seeks organize, market and promote Old Orlands commercial areas. A business
coalition would help promote the district through marketing and special events,
create and implement plans within the district, encourage partnerships with
other local businesses, organizations, Village staff, and other stakeholders. The
future business association could be integrated into a newly formed downtown
organization while maintaining a narrower focus on Old Orlands business
leaders and community.
152
153
ENDNOTES
McGuire, Igleski & Associates, Village of Orland Park Residential Area Intensive
Survey, 29.
2
Village of Orland Park, Appearance Improvement Grant. Village of Orland Park,
http://il-orlandpark2.civicplus.com/DocumentCenter/View/1762
1
154
155
CONCLUSION
Old Orland serves as a tangible representation of the Villages
development and the growth of the suburb. Today, there are
ample opportunities to revive the Historic District. Orland Parks
entire up-and-coming downtown area has the ability to be
known for a place that combines both the old and the new. The
recommendations offered in this document aim to create a vibrant
downtown through a hybrid of preservation and redevelopment.
Building on Old Orlands existing assets will bolster the Districts
historic character and businesses viability as well as make it a
more desirable place to live and visit.
Within improved connectivity and a strong framework, Old
Orlands existing historic character and businesses will be
reinforced by the transformation of the Main Street Downtown.
Old Orlands charming historic character can be strengthened
with new development that brings more shops and residents to
the heart of Downtown. Mixed-use projects will bring a renewed
combination of residential, restaurant, entertainment, and
recreational activities along 143rd Street. A strong commercial
156
REFERENCES
Anderson, Taylor W. "Orland Park's Downtown Focus
Part of Suburban Trend." Chicago Tribune,Feb 13,
2014.
Andreas, A. T. History of Cook County, Illinois: From the
Earliest Period to the Present Time.Chicago: A. T.
Andreas, 1884.
"Andrew Corporation."International Directory of
Company Histories. 2000.Encyclopedia.com. http://
www.encyclopedia.com/doc/1G2-2843600016.
html
Anne McGuire & Associates. Orland Rural History
Survey. Village of Orland Park, December 1995.
http://www.orland-park.il.us/DocumentCenter/
Home/View/708
Barnum, Art. Suburb Finding Pleasure in Growing
Pains. Chicago Tribune, June 1, 1983, ST4.
Barton, Thomas W. Walking Tour Explores Old
Orland. Southtown Economist, Orland Park Days,
May31 June 4, 1989, 91.
Bowean, Lolly. A Tale of Two Orlands. Chicago
Tribune, October 10, 2008. http://search.proquest.
157
com/docview/420781634?accountid=14552
BRC Photography. Marquette Bank, Orland Park,
ILL. Flickr. June 16, 2014. https://www.flickr.com/
photos/9385421@N08/14438110972/
Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning. MetroPulse
Community Data Snapshots: Orland Park. Chicago
Metropolitan Agency for Planning, June 2016, www.
cmap.illinois.gov/data/metropulse/
Chicago Tribune. Advertisement. Home Festival Section
3, March 4, 1989, 53. Accessed July 3, 2016, http://
archives.chicagotribune.com/1989/03/04/page/86/
article/display-ad-78-no-title
Chicago Tribune. Advertisement. Home Guide Section
3, Nov 11, 1989, 50. Accessed July 3, 2016,
http://archives.chicagotribune.com/1989/11/11/
page/130/article/display-ad-114-no-title
Chicago Tribune. Advertisement. Home Festival Section
3. September 30, 1989, 50. Accessed July 3, 2016,
http://archives.chicagotribune.com/1989/09/30/
page/123/article/display-ad-95-no-title
Chicago Tribune. Advertisement. Home Guide Section
with-residences-of-orland-park-crossing
Daily Southtown Editorial. Orland must weigh rights
and history. Daily Southtown, November 12, 2003.
Danna, Jeff. Protecting the past set in law: Suburbs'
approaches to preserving historical buildings often
vary. Chicago Tribune, October 04, 2012. http://
articles.chicagotribune.com/2012-10-04/news/
ct-tl-historic-preservation-20121004_1_historicpreservation-preservation-ordinance-landmarksillinois
Delogu, Diana. Orland Park Rejects Proposal for
Town Homes: Developer's Plans Call For Too Much
Density, Village Board Decides. Chicago Tribune,
August 03, 1994. http://articles.chicagotribune.
com/1994-08-03/news/9408030339_1_densitytown-homes-developer
Delogu, Diana. 2nd Orland Builder Gets Ok For Highdensity Project. Chicago Tribune, May 12, 1994.
http://articles.chicagotribune.com/1994-05-12/
news/9405120280_1_town-homes-high-densityproject-spring-creek
Delogu, Diana. Spring Creek Deal Haunts Orland
Park. Chicago Tribune, April 29, 1994 http://
articles.chicagotribune.com/1994-04-29/
news/9404290129_1_density-spring-creek-acresof-buildable-land
Delogu, Diana. "Twin Towers Stand For The Past,
Future."Chicago Tribune, August 10, 1993. http://
proxy.cc.uic.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.
com/docview/283600334?accountid=14552.
Drakulich, M. Old Orland historic district facing
changes. Daily Southtown, January 27, 2006.
158
159
trend-st-0802-20150731-story.html
Northeastern Illinois Planning Commission. Preliminary
Suburban Factbook. Chicago: Northeastern Illinois
Planning Commission, July 1971.
O'Brien, Ken. Orland Park Fools the Forecasters.
Chicago Tribune, January 21, 1996, 2.
Orland Heritage Book Association. The Orland Story:
From Prairie to Pavement. Orland Park: Orland
Heritage Book Association, 1991.
Orland Park Plan Commission. Southwest Sector Plan:
An Amendment to the Comprehensive Plan of the
Village of Orland Park(Ord. 1413, Adopted February
4, 1985). Orland Park, IL: Village of Orland Park,
1985.
Penney, J. Where they came from to settle in Orland,
The Palos Regional, May 28, 1981, 20.
Pudlewski Embry, Christen. Restoring the Little Town
Around the Corner. The Regional News Section 2,
December 15, 1994.
Rand McNally and Company. Rand, McNally & Co.'s
new sectional railroad map of Cook, Lake, and Du
Page Counties, with parts of adjoining counties,
including the manufacturing district in Lake County,
Ind. Chicago: Rand, McNally & Co., 1903. http://
www.lib.uchicago.edu/e/collections/maps/chi1900/
G4104-C6P3-1903-R3.html
Rees, James H, and Ferd. Mayer & Co.Map of the
Counties of Cook and DuPage, the east part of Kane
and Kendall, the north part of Will, state of Illinois.
Chicago, Ill.: James H. Rees, 1851. Map. Library of
Congress. Accessed July 02, 2016. https://www.
loc.gov/item/2013593073
Regional Transportation Authority Mapping and
Statistics (RTAMS). 143rd Street (Orland Park)
Station Weekday Ridership. Regional Transportation
Authority. Accessed May 20, 2016. http://www.
rtams.org/rtams/metraHistoricalRidership.
jsp?level=station&ridershipID=8236
Rietsma, J. Teardown issue still unresolved. The Star,
November 13, 2003, 1, 4.
Ritchie,
Margie.
Triangle
Advances
for
Orland Downtown.Chicago Tribune, June
22,
2005,
http://search.proquest.com/
docview/420433787?accountid=14552;
Rondonell, Max.Snyder's real estate map of Cook, Du
Page and part of Will counties, Illinois. Chicago,
Illinois: William L. Mitchell, 1898. Map. Accessed
July 02, 2016 from the Library of Congress, https://
www.loc.gov/item/2013593089.
Rueff, Ashley. After 3-year hiatus, Orland Park reviving
faade program. Chicago Tribune, February 5,
2013. Accessed April 13, 2016. http://articles.
chicagotribune.com/2013-02-05/news/ct-tl-0207orland-village-board-20130205_1_village-fundsproperty-owners-buildings
Rueff, Ashley.Downtown area taking shape: Orland
Park is closer to 20-year quest to create a town
center. Chicago Tribune, January 31, 2013: 1.
Schaults, J. Historic landmarks make for cozy
commerce, historical reference. Chicago Tribune,
March 20, 2003.
Stangenes, Sharon. Luxury rentals in the heart of Orland
Park. Chicago Tribune, February 16, 2014. http://
articles.chicagotribune.com/2014-02-14/classified/
ct-mre-0216-apartment-hunt-20140214_1_mainstreet-triangle-flaherty-collins-properties-chicagoarea
Stanley,
Charles.
Restoration
a
towering
achievement.Chicago
Tribune,
May
22,
2002.
http://search.proquest.com/
docview/418292495?accountid=14552
Strzalka, Diana. "A Downtown Centerpiece Orland
160
161
AR1VAHU00030047;
AR1VAHU00030048;
AR1VAHU00030050;
AR1VAHU00030062;
AR1VAHU00030063;
AR1VAHU00030064;
AR1VAHU00030065;
AR1VAHU00030083;
AR1VAHU00030084;
AR1VAHU00030085;
AR1VAHU00030087. Scale 24000. USGS EARTH
EXPLORER, April 20, 1962. http://earthexplorer.
usgs.gov/
United States Geological Survey. Aerial 1978 (Entity
ID:1VEQZ00020086). USGS EARTH EXPLORER,
October 30, 1978. http://earthexplorer.usgs.gov/
United States Geological Survey. Aerial 1983
(Entity ID:NB1NHAP810316150). USGS EARTH
EXPLORER, April 25, 1983. http://earthexplorer.
usgs.gov/
United States Geological Survey. Aerial 1981 (Entity ID:
NB1NHAP810166079). USGS EARTH EXPLORER,
November 7, 1981. http://earthexplorer.usgs.gov/
United States Geological Survey. Aerial 1952 (Entity
ID: ARA000950030342). USGS EARTH EXPLORER,
September 28, 1952. http://earthexplorer.usgs.gov/
United States Geological Survey. Palos Park, Tinley
Park, Mokena and Sag Bridge Quadrangle Maps,
Scale 1:24:000, 1974 Edition (1963, photorevised
1973 and 1980). Historical Topographic Map
Collection.
http://ngmdb.usgs.gov/maps/
TopoView/
University of Chicago & Andrew Corporation. Toward
a Plan for the Andrew Corporation and the Orland
Park Community: A Pre-Planning Report. Chicago:
University of Chicago, 1951.
U.S. Census Bureau. Census of Population and
Housing. 1940, https://www.census.gov/prod/
www/decennial.html (accessed January 10, 2016).
U.S. Census Bureau. Census of Population and
Housing. 1950, https://www.census.gov/prod/
162
163
No%2CSeries_No;lc:RUMSEY~8~1&mi=20&trs=26
Wilkinson, Todd. Orland Park Mayor Stirs Things Up.
Chicago Tribune, May 28, 1986, 14
Wiss, Janney, Elstner Associates, Inc. Rural Historic
Structural Survey of Homer Township Will County,
Illinois. Chicago: Will County Land Use Department
and the Will County Historic Preservation
Commission, 2002.
Wm. S. Lawrence and Associates & Orland Park Plan
Commission. A Comprehensive Plan for Orland
Park, Illinois. Chicago: Wm. S. Lawrence &
Associates, 1969.
Wm. S. Lawrence and Associates. Orland Park, Illinois:
A Supplementary Report to the Comprehensive
Plan. Chicago: Wm. S. Lawrence & Associates,
1975.
Zabell, Martin, and Laurie Goering. "Orland Park`s
Early Days Live In 1st Mayor`s Home."Chicago
Tribune, October 31, 1991. Accessed July 3, 2016.
http://articles.chicagotribune.com/1991-10-31/
news/9104070979_1_farmer-john-house-frame.
Ziemba, Stanley. Andrew Corp.'s departure to change
Orland Park, Joliet. Chicago Tribune, November
19, 2005. http://articles.chicagotribune.com/200511-19/news/0511190178_1_andrew-corp-jobscoaxial
Zillow. "Orland Park IL Home Prices & Home Values."
Zillow. May 31, 2016. Accessed July 03, 2016.
http://www.zillow.com/orland-park-il/home-values/.
Zumbach, Lauren. "Orland Park Closes on Final Main
Street Triangle Property." Chicago Tribune,Feb 27,
2014.
Zumbach, Laura. "Orland Park Facade Upgrade
Program Growing." Chicago Tribune, July 29,
2014. Accessed April 13, 2016. http://www.
chicagotribune.com/suburbs/orland-park-homer-
glen/ct-orland-facade-improvement-program-tlssw-0731-20140730-story.html;
Zumbach, Lauren. Orland Park officials pleased with
apartments' progress report. Chicago Tribune,
March 3, 2015. http://www.chicagotribune.com/
suburbs/daily-southtown/news/ct-sta-9750update-report-st-0304-20150303-story.html
Zumbach, Lauren. "U of C, Orland Park Advance Plans
for Medical Center." Chicago Tribune,July 03, 2014.
164
165