Doctor, doctor
Meet a Trust
Clinical Fellow
Café culture
School science cafés
Great Scott
Wellcome’s role
in Scott’s epic
final expedition
Wellcome News Editorial
Wellcome News is published four times sequencing later showed that mutations
a year and is available free of charge. in a gene related to factor H are associated
To subscribe, contact: with a newly described form of
Publishing Department glomerulonephritis, a kidney disorder –
Wellcome Trust work led by Matthew Pickering, a Wellcome
FREEPOST RLYJ-UJHU-EKHJ Trust Senior Research Fellow, and his
Slough SL3 0BP
collaborators. These studies raise further
T +44 (0)20 7611 8651 important questions about how variation
F +44 (0)20 7611 8242
in complement regulation causes eye and
E publishing@wellcome.ac.uk
kidney inflammation.
or go to:
www.wellcome.ac.uk/wellcomenews Genome-wide association studies are
transforming our understanding of the
Ideas, comments, suggestions? genetic basis of common diseases such
Get in touch and let us know. as diabetes. Until about four years ago,
Please contact: perhaps one variant per year causing
The Editor The sequencing of the human genome
increased susceptibility would be found.
Wellcome News ranks among the great scientific
Wellcome Trust Now there are many hundreds of such
achievements of the last 100 years, and
Gibbs Building discoveries each year. While it would be
we are extremely proud of the Wellcome
215 Euston Road naive to expect findings about disease
London NW1 2BE Trust’s fundamental role in this iconic
mechanisms to lead to instant predictive,
E wellcome.news@wellcome.ac.uk project. Now, in the tenth anniversary
diagnostic or therapeutic outcomes, the
year of the working draft sequence,
Editor Chrissie Giles
real value of these associations lies in
the project’s success is beyond doubt.
how they reveal the pathways underlying
Writers Craig Brierley, Chrissie Giles, The first impact of the genome sequence
Mun-Keat Looi, Jen Middleton the development of diseases. A better
was to enable genetic analysis on a gigantic,
Design Mark Barham understanding of a condition’s causes
genome-wide scale that was previously
is essential for the creation of new drugs
Assistant Editor Tom Freeman inconceivable. Human genetic variation
and strategies to treat or prevent it.
Photography David Sayer is being described in ever greater detail
Also, importantly, advances in genomics
Publisher Hugh Blackbourn through global collaborations such as
are not restricted to human sequences, but
All images, unless otherwise stated, are from the the SNP Consortium, the International
Wellcome Library. Copies of images can be obtained
are transforming our understanding of
HapMap Project, the mapping of copy
through Wellcome Images (images.wellcome.ac.uk). infectious diseases.
number variation and the 1000 Genomes
The Wellcome Trust It is imperative over the next decade to
Project. Meanwhile, genome-wide
We are a global charity dedicated to achieving turn this increasingly detailed knowledge
extraordinary improvements in human and animal association studies, such as the Wellcome
health. We support the brightest minds in into new ways of helping patients.
Trust Case Control Consortium, and
biomedical research and the medical humanities. ‘Maximising the health benefits of genetics
Our breadth of support includes public large-scale sequencing programmes,
engagement, education and the application of and genomics’ is one of the Trust’s five
research to improve health. We are independent
such as the Cancer Genome Project,
challenges for 2010–20 and, in partnership
of both political and commercial interests. are revealing how inherited variations
www.wellcome.ac.uk with the UK Department of Health, we
or mutations affect health and disease.
have created the Health Innovation
This is an open access publication and, with the As explored in this issue, the decisions
exception of images and illustrations, the content Challenge Fund, which this year made
may, unless otherwise stated, be reproduced free to support such large projects were not
of charge in any format or medium, subject to the
£20 million available for translating
easy in fields in which technologies were
following constraints: content must be reproduced genetic discoveries into clinical practice.
accurately; content must not be used in a still emerging. We had the courage to
misleading context; the Wellcome Trust must be
The Cancer Genome Project, seeking
back these ambitious undertakings because
attributed as the original author and the title of the the mutations that drive the development
document specified in the attribution. The views they were led by outstanding scientists;
and opinions expressed by writers within Wellcome of common cancers, is the most advanced
the results speak for themselves.
News do not necessarily reflect those of the large-scale genomic study in turning
Wellcome Trust or Editor. No responsibility is These major studies are in many ways
assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or genetic discoveries into new treatments.
damage to persons or property as a matter of
just the beginning: they tell us which
There are already drugs undergoing clinical
products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from genes are involved, but not how they
any use or operation of any methods, products, trials as a result of this global partnership.
instructions or ideas contained in the material
work. The challenge is to understand
We are proud to have been such a major
herein. ISSN 1356-9112. First published by the the complex biological effects of genetic
Wellcome Trust, 2010. © The trustee of the part of the Human Genome Project, and
Wellcome Trust. The Wellcome Trust is a charity variation. To take a personal example,
will continue to ensure that our funding
registered in England and Wales, no. 210183. Its related to my own research into the
sole trustee is The Wellcome Trust Limited, a supports outstanding scientists to drive
company registered in England and Wales, no. complement system and rheumatic and
2711000 (whose registered office is at 215 Euston
forward genetics and genomics at an
renal disease, I was excited that one of
Road, London NW1 2BE, UK). ever-increasing pace.
the first discoveries from the HapMap
PU-4737.2/13.9K/06-2010/MB
Project was that inherited variation in the
Cover image (and page 10): Anton Zhukov, Ashok Rodrigues
and Renata Osinska/iStockphoto (composite) complement regulatory protein factor H
This document was printed on material
was associated with an important cause
made from 25 per cent post-consumer
of blindness in elderly people: age-related
50%
waste & 25 per cent pre-consumer waste. Sir Mark Walport
macular degeneration. Large-scale Director of the Wellcome Trust
WellcomeNews | Issue 63
In this issue
Funding
18
9
News
Research
Noticeboard 21
Features
20
2
WellcomeNews | Issue 63 | 1
News
Mike Stratton named new Sanger Director Book Prize panel
announced
The judging panel for
the 2010 Wellcome
Trust Book Prize will
be chaired by Clive
Anderson, comedy
writer, presenter and
former barrister.
Panel members are:
Maggie Gee, writer and former Man Booker
judge; A C Grayling, writer, professor and
former Man Booker judge; Michael Neve,
medical historian; and Alice Roberts,
anatomist, anthropologist, presenter and
author. The shortlist will be announced at
the Times Cheltenham Literature Festival
in October, and the winner will be named in
November. www.wellcomebookprize.org
Professor Mike Stratton is the new Director that we will all have our genomes
of the Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute sequenced as a routine. Our Institute
(above). Deputy Director there since 2007, will make a major contribution to
he heads the Cancer Genome Project and understanding what these sequences mean Wellcome Library on loan
is a leader of the International Cancer and will also be a leading voice and activist
Genome Consortium. in society’s consideration of how they
“It is a truly extraordinary challenge and should be used in order to achieve our
great privilege to be appointed Director of collective central mission, improving
the Sanger Institute,” said Professor human health.”
Stratton. “The Institute is currently on the Sir Mark Walport, Director of the Trust,
crest of a wave of discoveries in revealing said: “On behalf of the Wellcome Trust, I
how genetic variation in human beings would like to congratulate Mike Stratton on
and in infectious agents cause disease. his appointment. Mike is an exceptional
I aim to build ambitiously on the scientist who has made major discoveries
Institute’s current leadership in large-scale about the genetic mechanisms of cancer.”
analysis of genomes and experimental Items from the Wellcome Library’s vast
studies in model organisms to develop Read an interview with the Sanger collection are contributing to some
cellular systems that will explore human Institute’s previous Director, Allan fascinating exhibitions around the country.
biology and to provide transformative Bradley, on page 5, and more on China Through the Lens of John Thomson
insights into how diseases develop. Prof. Stratton’s work on page 11. 1868–1872 will visit Hartlepool in late
“In ten to 20 years’ time it is conceivable 2010 and the Burrell Collection in Glasgow
in 2011, having already exhibited at the
Merseyside Maritime Museum in Liverpool
Young people enjoy science, survey shows and touring China last year. It features
150 photographs selected from 688 glass
medical research should be supported negatives by the Victorian traveller John
and encouraged, even if a lot of public Thomson (1837–1921), from Sir Henry
money would need to be invested, Wellcome’s collection. The portraits record
though support was significantly higher Thomson’s travels in China, Indochina
for clinical research than for basic research. and Cyprus in the 1860s and 1870s. They
The survey showed that young people look offer a fascinating insight into his subjects
favourably at science as a possible career and majestic landscapes, yet were for the
choice: 44 per cent said they were most part unpublished in his lifetime.
interested in pursuing a career in science, Meanwhile, the National Gallery
with medicine, forensic science and in London is exhibiting ‘Acts of Mercy’
engineering the most popular choices. (above; 14 July–17 October) by Frederick
The first Wellcome Trust Monitor survey “There has been a big push towards Cayley Robinson, one of the most
on attitudes to medical research reveals improving young people’s experiences distinctive yet elusive British painters of
unanimous public support for research of science both inside and outside the the early 20th century. Purchased by the
and shows that, contrary to popular belief, classroom. It could be that these activities Trust in 2009, the work comprises four
81 per cent of young people find science are beginning to pay off,” said Professor large-scale panels in two pairs, exploring
lessons interesting. Derek Bell, Trust Head of Education. the positive forces of the human spirit in
Almost all respondents thought that www.wellcome.ac.uk/monitor the face of destruction.
2 | WellcomeNews | Issue 63
Election success for Trust researchers Wellcome Collection reveals
the naked truth
The Academy of Medical Sciences has Shaw, Institute of Psychiatry, King’s
announced its 40 newly elected Fellows College London; Inderjeet Dokal, Barts
for 2010, who include over a dozen and The London, Queen Mary; Alan Knox,
currently Trust-funded researchers as University of Nottingham; Sheena Radford,
well as our own Head of International University of Leeds; and Nazneen Rahman,
Activities, Dr Jimmy Whitworth. Institute of Cancer Research.
Academy Fellows are elected for Professor Sir John Bell, President of
outstanding contributions to the the Academy of Medical Sciences, said:
advancement of medical science, “Our new Fellows illustrate the wealth
for innovative application of scientific of experience and diversity of talent
knowledge or for their conspicuous amongst the UK’s research community.
service to healthcare. The 2010 Fellows I look forward to working with these
who currently receive Trust funding skilled scientists to ensure their strengths
include (all Professors): Anthony Costello, across academia and industry are used
Geraint Rees and William Richardson, to promote basic science discoveries,
University College London; David Newby innovative healthcare and the rapid
and Mark Woolhouse, University of translation of research into patient
Edinburgh; Nicholas Craddock and Alun benefits.”
Davies, Cardiff University; Richard Wise, For more, see: www.acmedsci.ac.uk/
Imperial College London; Christopher p109.htm
WellcomeNews | Issue 63 | 3
News
Wellcome blogs launched Prizes and honours
There’s now another way to stay in the-scenes insight into the world of
touch with Wellcome-related activities: science from a Trust perspective.
two new blogs. The Wellcome Collection blog
The Wellcome Trust blog (wellcomecollection.wordpress.com)
(wellcometrust.wordpress.com) covers features discussion and highlights of
science and biomedicine, their crossover subjects and activities of interest, in
with arts and history, and the many other keeping with the venue’s unique mix of
activities related to our work. From new exhibitions and events that consider what
PhD students to senior researchers, it means to be human. The blog will offer
museums and plays to documentaries reports on what’s been happening in the
and films, the blog will feature a variety building and show off new content from
of news, stories, event reports and behind- the Wellcome Collection website.
Congratulations to Professor
Nick White (above), Director of
Have you got a winning image? the Wellcome Trust South-east Asia
Programme, and Professor Peter
Ratcliffe, Head of the Nuffield
Department of Clinical Medicine at
the University of Oxford, who have
been honoured in the 2010 Canada
Gairdner Awards, Canada’s only
international science prizes.
4 | WellcomeNews | Issue 63
62
A decade at Sanger
Earlier this year, Professor Allan Bradley stepped
down as Director of the Wellcome Trust Sanger
Institute after ten years in charge. In an interview
with Mun-Keat Looi, he reflects on the Institute’s
changes and achievements in that time.
WellcomeNews | Issue 63 | 5
thing that I want to do:
make a big difference by
understanding how these
things happen.”
Dr Dawson’s first taste
of lab research came as a
project on human cancer
genetics using zebrafish,
completed as part of his
Bachelor of Medical
Science degree. His
involvement in clinical
research continued after
he qualified as a doctor,
mainly in the areas
of bone marrow
transplantation
and blood cancers.
This passion for being
in the lab led him to do
a PhD. Supported by a
prestigious postgraduate
scholarship awarded by
Doctor, doctor
the General Sir John Monash Foundation,
he began his research in Cambridge in 2007.
6 | WellcomeNews | Issue 63
fusion genes, which, in some cases, drive
the development of cancer. But how? Some
fusion genes have special properties that
may be involved. “One that I’m studying
has the ability to reinstate self-renewal in
cells that have lost the ability, effectively
making them leukaemia stem cells,” he says.
As many fusion genes are known to
modify chromatin (the DNA and histone
bundles), Dr Dawson is looking to
understand how changes in chromatin
could lead to leukaemia stem cells. The
next step will then be to understand the
differences between leukaemia stem cells
and normal blood stem cells (from which
blood cells are made), to give researchers a Mark Dawson on…
way to destroy the cancer stem cells but
WellcomeNews | Issue 63 | 7
Funding
Investigator Awards: new details
In November, we announced our academic posts – that is, those who have established academic position and already
forthcoming Investigator Awards scheme. permanent, open-ended or long-term have an outstanding track record. They
Further details are now available. rolling contracts of employment salaried must be at the forefront of their field
Wellcome Trust Investigator Awards by their university or research institution. internationally and have a compelling
aim to give exceptional researchers the There are two categories: New long-term vision for their research.
flexibility and support they need to be Investigator Awards support world-class Applications will open from 1 October
innovative and to pursue bold ideas. The researchers who are no more than five years 2010, with the first Awards made in May
Awards’ scale and scope will facilitate from appointment to their first established 2011. We strongly advise potential
long-term planning and release academic position, but who can already applicants to contact us, so we can review
Investigators from the constant pressure show that they have the ability to innovate their eligibility for the scheme and provide
of the grant application cycle. The scheme and drive advances in their field of study. advice as needed. www.wellcome.ac.uk/
extends the successful model of fellowship Senior Investigator Awards support investigators
support to researchers in established exceptional researchers who hold an
8 | WellcomeNews | Issue 63
Sharing stories on the NHS Populations and Public
A new study looking at the
Health update
experiences of ordinary people and
Professor Mike Begon from the
their opinions of their care over the
University of Liverpool and colleagues
first 60 years of the National
have been awarded a project grant
Health Service has been published.
through our Populations and Public
‘Ordinary People Tell the Story’
Health funding stream to study
provides colourful accounts of
changes in numbers of the great
people’s encounters with the
gerbil (below), a major carrier of
NHS in 1949, 1997 and 2008. The
plague in Kazakhstan. They are using
accounts are taken from the Mass
satellite imaging to look at burrows
Observation Archive, which
near human settlements to see
specialises in material about
whether they can predict when and
everyday life in Britain.
where plague outbreaks will occur.
Study authors Linda
Other grants awarded include a
Lamont, Honorary Fellow in
project grant to study the pathway
Contemporary History at the
of care for children who died or were
University of Sussex, and Fran
referred as emergency cases to a
McCabe have drawn on 60 years
paediatric intensive care unit in South
of comments by patients and
Africa. Dr Alison Ward and Professor
health practitioners to make
Andrew Argent, from the Universities
their own recommendations
of Oxford and Cape Town respectively,
about the future of the NHS.
will try to identify failures in care
McCabe says: “The mass
(without apportioning blame).
observation material gives us an
Medical records will be scrutinised by
absorbing and vivid perspective of
A World War II poster to recruit nurses and midwives. an expert review panel that will make
the NHS going back to its birth. We
recommendations for how care could
should not forget that despite its problems,
have been improved.
without the NHS many people, especially when they have had problems using
those without means, would not be the NHS, they still hold its values to
alive today. their hearts.”
“People who have contributed to the The study was supported by the
Mass Observation Archive are reflective Department of Health and a Wellcome
and prescient about the strengths and Trust History of Medicine grant. It is
shortcomings of the NHS. They are aware available online at www.nhsnarratives
of its complexity and discuss contentious massobservationlamontandmccabe.
issues around ethics and funding, co.uk and the Mass Observation Archive
sometimes suggesting solutions. Even is at www.massobs.org.uk.
WellcomeNews | Issue 63 | 9
Great expectations
June 2010 marks a decade since the draft human genome
sequence was announced. How much of an impact has this
development had on genetics, genomics and science in
general? What are the ethical and legal issues arising from
this work? Chrissie Giles spoke to people who worked on
the project then, and those who use the sequence and
subsequent research in their work today, to find out.
This focus on the whole genome gene if you can lay claim to it.” Still,
transformed the way science is done, he even when the private company Celera
argues. “As the sequence started to flow Genomics was set up to sequence the
for the worm, human, fruit fly and yeast, human genome, the public project
people in sequencing labs started to get continued, committed to releasing the
enormous amounts of correspondence data as it came.
from people working on other organisms
who had discovered their favourite gene
Professor Sir John
being matched,” he says. “There was this
Sulston: “The key was sense that different organisms in biology
tackling the whole genome” were talking to each other, and the genome
work introduced a cross-fertilisation in
biology that was quite novel.”
John Sulston is among the few pioneers As founding director of the Sanger
who, in the 1980s, began to develop the Centre, he was closely involved with the
field recognised today as genomics. He and Human Genome Project, including in
Hatching C. elegans. Sanger Institute
colleagues began a project to sequence the establishing the principles around data
genome of the nematode, Caenorhabditis sharing. Famously agreed at a meeting Freedom of scientific information is
elegans, in 1990 – the success of which fed in Bermuda in 1996, these conditions still part of his focus in his current role as
directly into the plans to sequence the included that no one would take Chair of the Institute for Science, Ethics
human genome and set up the Sanger intellectual property rights over genome and Innovation at the University of
Centre (now the Wellcome Trust Sanger data, which should be made freely available Manchester. “At the least we need much
Institute) near Cambridge. within 24 hours of being produced. clearer and higher thresholds in not
“I was very committed to the whole- For the worm community, sharing applying intellectual property to
genome approach. My philosophy, in a data was part and parcel of their research. fundamental information. The battle’s
Douglas Adams kind of way, was that this Not so for those working on the human. not won, but the human genome is a
thing is big, it’s seriously big. You’re not “There were quite a few fraught political tremendous demonstration of how
going to solve life by looking at a handful episodes,” he says. “You can get seriously valuable it is not to patent genes and
of genes.” rich and famous with a particular human other fundamental information.”
10 | WellcomeNews | Issue 63
He proposed the Cancer Genome Project
Professor Mike to the Wellcome Trust, and the “first
post-genome project at Sanger”
Stratton: “Recent began in 2000, even before the
discoveries are a sequence had been announced.
remarkable testament The project’s first major finding was
to the power of the published in 2002: the discovery that
Human Genome Project” the gene BRAF is mutated in 60–70 per
cent of malignant melanomas (a type
of skin cancer) and 10–15 per
A pathologist drawn into genetics in the cent of colorectal cancers.
mid-1980s, Mike Stratton spoke about the Subsequent research,
potential of the genome sequence to including a Trust-funded
transform cancer treatment at the June drug discovery programme,
2000 announcement. Now Director of is today yielding drugs to
the Sanger Institute, how does he rate block BRAF and thus treat
the progress so far? melanoma, something Prof. Stratton
In the 1990s, he was working at the describes as a “remarkable testament to
Institute of Cancer Research, studying the the power of the Human Genome
Depiction of the structure of BRAF with an inhibitor
genes that predispose to breast cancer. In Project to start these lines of enquiry off”. (solid orange shape) bound to it. Alfonso Zambon
1994, he and colleagues located the second A fulfilment of the vision he presented at
major breast cancer susceptibility gene, the 2000 announcement came in December insight into the processes that cause cancer.
2009, when researchers at the Sanger What will this mean for treatment,
Institute and colleagues published the ultimately? He predicts routine sequencing
first-ever complete cancer genomes. Now, of cancer genomes to ensure that patients’
researchers are working to sequence 25 000 treatments are tailored to the mutations
cancer genomes, from 50 different kinds of present. “By the end of this decade we’ll be
cancer, through the International Cancer using the genome sequence as the natural
Genome Project. This will identify all the diagnostic for cancer.”
driving cancer genes and provide great
WellcomeNews | Issue 63 | 11
Professor Stephan
Beck: “It was the
opportunity of a lifetime” Gene map and image of chromosome 22, the first to be
sequenced. Dr TJ McMaster
12 | WellcomeNews | Issue 63
investigate the molecular basis for that The data produced is only one side of
variant I ended up stumbling across the sequencing’s legacy: it also catalysed
structural variation, and how one can the development of new technologies and
predict the likely location of these that applications. “Knowledge and technology
might cause disease, just from the go hand in hand, one catalyses the other.
primary genome sequence.” Thanks to the Human Genome Project, we
His work since has focused on
understanding how these variants are
Dr Matt Hurles: “The associated with common diseases. He
direction of my career thinks that while we’ve learned a lot
changed completely” about common diseases, what we have
learned hasn’t been that useful: “It’s not
ten or 20 mutations for each condition
In 2000, Matt Hurles had begun a postdoc, having a fairly major effect in the
looking for variants on the Y chromosome population, it’s hundreds and thousands.”
to trace prehistoric migration. The work But the success or not of the genome
he did for his PhD became obsolete and goes beyond understanding common
outscaled virtually overnight by the diseases, he argues. “We’ve learned a fair
work made possible because of the amount about the genetic basis of rare Genomic variation can be used to track changes across a
sequence release. diseases, which has led to a five-fold population. Fiona Pragoff
“The first piece of the Y-chromosome increase in diagnosis for patients with such
sequence that came out actually conditions.” There’s also the potential to now have the technology to do the
completely changed the direction of learn a huge amount more about human blindingly obvious experiment – to
my career,” he says, as it contained one of history, and how genomes work, including sequence the genomes of patients and
the variants he was trying to track down the role of non-coding sequence in health compare those to people that don’t
for population prehistory. “In trying to and disease. have the disease.”
Yohan Juliardi/iStockphoto
WellcomeNews | Issue 63 | 13
WellcomeNews | Issue 61 | 13
Research
First egg DNA transfer brings potential to stop disease Reducing suicide in
muscular weakness, blindness, fatal heart
Sri Lanka
failure, liver failure, learning disability and
diabetes. There are no treatments currently
available. The new technique takes the
genetic material from a fertilised egg that
carries faulty mitochondria and
transplants it into an egg with healthy
mitochondria.
“A child born using this method
would have correctly functioning
mitochondria, but in every other respect
would get all their genetic information
Suicide remains a major problem in Sri
from their father and mother,” said
Lanka, but interventions have halved the
Professor Doug Turnbull, one of the lead
suicide rate from 49 per 100 000 in 1995
researchers. “What we’ve done is like
to 23 per 100 000 in 2006. Researchers
Scientists at Newcastle University have changing the battery on a laptop. The
from the University of Colombo have now
developed a pioneering technique that energy supply now works properly, but
investigated all reported suicides in 2006
has the potential to help to prevent the none of the information on the hard
– 151 in total. Their analysis found that
transmission of serious inherited disorders drive has been changed.”
self-poisoning and burning were the most
known as mitochondrial diseases.
common methods used. Marriage
Mitochondria are often referred to as • Watch a short film on this at www.
problems were the most frequently cited
the cell’s ‘batteries’ and are passed on from youtube.com/wellcometrust
reason (accounting for 30 per cent of the
mother to child. One in 6500 children is
Craven L et al. Pronuclear transfer in human embryos to cases), with psychiatric illness accounting
born with mitochondrial mutations prevent transmission of mitochondrial DNA disease. Nature for just 6 per cent.
causing severe diseases, including 2010 [Epub ahead of print].
The researchers suggest that securing
access and restricting availability of
pesticides and drugs could help to reduce
No link between chronic fatigue and virus, study shows suicides further. They also call for better
interventions to help people deal with
Research at the Medical Research Council 299 people, including 142 samples from anger and domestic conflict, as well as
National Institute for Medical Research those with chronic fatigue syndrome, more recognition and treatment for
and St George’s, University of London, failed to replicate these earlier findings. psychiatric illness and alcoholism.
has found no evidence of a link between The new study supports research published
Fernando R et al. Study of suicides reported to the Coroner
chronic fatigue syndrome and a recently earlier in 2010 that similarly could not in Colombo, Sri Lanka. Med Sci Law 2010;50(1):25–8.
discovered virus. Also known as myalgic replicate the findings.
encephalomyelitis, chronic fatigue Dr Kate Bishop, the Wellcome Trust
Wellcome News: your feedback
syndrome affects around 250 000 Research Career Development Fellow
people in the UK. Its who led the study, said: “We found no Thanks to all of you who completed
causes are not clear but association between XMRV and chronic the online survey about Wellcome News
a 2009 study found fatigue syndrome. However, chronic – we had a great response. We’re looking
evidence of a fatigue syndrome may encompass through the results now and will be
retrovirus called a spectrum of different using your feedback to make some
XMRV in conditions, providing a changes to the magazine over the
two-thirds of possible explanation for this coming issues, so keep your eyes peeled!
people with discrepancy…It is important You don’t have to wait for the next
the condition. that we keep an open mind survey to share your thoughts, ideas and
The new about new scientific feedback on the magazine: email
study, which discoveries which point to wellcome.news@wellcome.ac.uk or
involved possible causes of this often write to the address on the inside front
sampling very serious condition.” cover of this issue to get in touch with
DNA from the team.
Groom HC et al. Absence of xenotropic murine
leukaemia virus-related virus in UK patients
A quick reminder too that all
Amanda Rohde/ with chronic fatigue syndrome. Retrovirology Wellcome News articles are available
iStockphoto 2010;7(1):10.
online, as well as PDFs of this and past
issues. You can also subscribe online to
Wellcome News and our other
publications, to make sure you receive
every issue, free, as soon as it’s published.
www.wellcome.ac.uk/wellcomenews
14 | WellcomeNews | Issue 63
Human sleeping sickness parasite sequenced Genetic clues to basis
of ALS
A pair of studies from the University of
Sheffield have revealed genetic clues to the
basis of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS),
the neurodegenerative disease that affects
physicist Stephen Hawking.
Approximately 5 per cent of ALS cases
are inherited; previous studies have linked
mutations in the gene FUS/TLS to the
disorder. Professor Pamela Shaw and
colleagues at Sheffield investigated the
frequency of these mutations in a cohort
of people with ALS from the North of
England, finding mutations in 5 per cent
Researchers from the Wellcome Trust remarkable level of similarity between the
of inherited ALS cases.
Sanger Institute have unveiled a high- two strains: sequences of comparable genes
quality draft genome sequence for the were, on average, 98.2 per cent identical.
parasite strain responsible for almost all This suggests that T. b. gambiense’s ability
reported cases of sleeping sickness. The to infect humans cannot be easily
chronic disease, also known as African explained by the addition or removal
trypanosomiasis, affects the human of a few genes.
central nervous system and is caused “Single-letter changes in the genome;
by the Trypanosoma brucei gambiense differences in the number of copies of
strain (above) of T. brucei. Scientists had genes; changes in how the activity of genes
previously sequenced the T. brucei brucei is regulated – all of these genetic nuances
strain, which infects cattle but is harmless could play that crucial role in determining
to humans. why T. b. gambiense behaves so differently,”
In the new study, researchers compared said Dr Andrew Jackson, lead author on
T. b. gambiense and T. b. brucei, looking for the study. Motor neurons. Dr David Becker
WellcomeNews | Issue 63 | 15
Classy conversations
Café Sci gives scientists a chance to escape the bench and get into
schools, and gives students a chance to discuss scientific topics of their
choice informally. Catherine Whitlock took a look at Cafés in the UK and
Uganda to find out more about this movement.
16 | WellcomeNews | Issue 63
Speaking my language
In Uganda, Café Sci and adult Café Scientifique events are generally held in English.
But, in areas where English is not widely spoken and where internet or library facilities
are not available, Cafés are held in the native language. In recognition of Café Sci’s
ability to extend access to scientific and health information, Christine Munduru
from the Open Society Initiative for East Africa has been awarded a Wellcome Trust
International Engagement Award to run native language evening Café Scis. These are
held in central village spaces where the local brew, Malwa, is served.
University, produces some hip replacement The goal is to discuss scientific knowledge that is of direct use to the community.
joints and artificial knees that grab the Past local-language Cafés have covered health-related topics, such as malaria in
students’ attention and help to illustrate pregnancy, TB and the community, and HIV testing and counselling. The scope is
the applications of her research. broader than just health, extending to topics such as fire and safety information,
Finally, the café-style environment, and fish and poultry farming. www.cafescientifique.org/uganda.htm
often with free drinks and snacks,
makes both the speaker and
students feel at home. In
the open, welcoming space
of the atrium at Stockley,
free from the constraints of
a classroom, students are
more likely to interact.
WellcomeNews | Issue 63 | 17
Research
Predicting the progress of autoimmune diseases Round-up
18 | WellcomeNews | Issue 63
Q&A: Peter Sozou
Human embryos created by in vitro What interested you about this area?
fertilisation (IVF) can be stored for use There was a widely reported case about a
in future fertility treatment. However, woman who had created embryos with
difficulties can arise if a couple create her partner before undergoing cancer
embryos together and then their treatment that left her sterile. The
relationship breaks down. With funding relationship later ended and he withdrew
from a Wellcome Trust Value in People consent for continued storage of the
Fellowship, Dr Peter Sozou of the embryos, depriving her of the chance to
London School of Economics and have her own genetic children. The case
colleagues looked at how UK law went all the way to the Grand Chamber
governing stored embryos might be of the European Court of Human Rights,
improved to give people more flexibility where the woman lost. A Wellcome Trust
over the type of agreement they can fellowship allowed me to explore this
Research reveals enter into. problem with Geraldine Hartshorne, an
expert in reproductive medicine, and
Salmonella’s sabotage What is the current UK legal situation? Sally Sheldon, a legal expert.
switch When embryos created by IVF are stored,
each member of the couple who created What other pressing issues are there?
Researchers have identified a ‘switch’ that the embryos has the right to withdraw A closely related problem is that of
enables Salmonella bacteria to sabotage consent at any time before the embryos withdrawal of consent by donors of
host cells. The new finding could one day are transferred to a woman’s uterus. In gametes [eggs or sperm]. Donors can
lead to drugs that interfere with the switch effect, both the woman and the man withdraw consent at any time up to the
in order to combat Salmonella and possibly maintain a veto over using the embryos time that sperm, eggs or embryos are
other bacterial infections. to try to produce a pregnancy, up until transferred to a woman’s body in fertility
Before Salmonella can establish an such time as they are used. treatment. We found that sperm donors
infection, the bacterium must first do withdraw consent occasionally. This
sabotage a larger human or animal host Why is this a problem? has had serious consequences, including
cell where it can replicate. It does this by Couples who have stored embryos destruction of embryos that had been
injecting a cocktail of ‘virulence’ proteins sometimes split up, and this can lead fertilised by the donor’s sperm. In an
into the host cell, which interfere with the to disagreements about what to do with article published in BMJ, we suggest a
cell’s defences and help the bacteria to their embryos. In some cases, stored standard set of options for donors wishing
grow. The new study reveals that a embryos represent a person’s only to withdraw consent, and there may also
chance of becoming a biological parent be a case for restricting the circumstances
– a situation that more commonly affects under which this can take place.
the woman than the man. In these cases,
withdrawal of consent by the other Another important question is whether
person can have devastating to use one or two embryos in a cycle of
consequences. We examined whether IVF treatment. Using two gives a higher
the present law, specifying a ‘one-size- chance of achieving a pregnancy but also
fits-all’ agreement, can be improved to increases the chance of a multiple birth,
enable people to choose an alternative which can lead to complications.
type of agreement when this would suit Because the financial costs of any
them better. complications tend, to a large degree,
Salmonella bacteria. Janice Haney Carr/Public Health to fall on the public purse, there may
Image Library
What is your alternative? be circumstances where a single-embryo
molecular switch acts as a safety catch, We propose giving people the option of transfer would be preferable from
holding the virulence proteins until the one member of the couple voluntarily society’s viewpoint. How to mediate this
pH of the host cell has been recognised. giving up their veto over the future use conflict is an interesting problem.
The researchers stress that the work is of the embryos. The other person would
currently at an early stage but they hope then have sole control over the embryos, What do you do outside of work?
that ultimately, it may be possible to use so their future use would not be I probably spend more time than I
their findings to design better drugs or dependent on continuation of the should following news and current
vaccines to combat Salmonella-related relationship. This option would not affairs. I also enjoy walking, listening
diseases, which include gastroenteritis replace the current form of agreement to early music and eating chocolate.
and typhoid fever in humans, and similar but should be available as an alternative.
Sozou PD et al. Consent agreements for cryopreserved
diseases in livestock. It would be up to the couple to decide embryos: the case for choice. J Med Ethics 2010;36:230–3.
which agreement suits them best.
Holden D et al. pH sensing by intracellular Salmonella induces
effector translocation. Science 2010 [Epub ahead of print].
WellcomeNews | Issue 63 | 19
Exploratory medicine
As the summer holidays near and many of us depart to warmer climes, the centenary
of a chillier journey is upon us. The Wellcome Library’s Ross MacFarlane tells the tale
of Henry Wellcome’s involvement in Scott’s epic expedition to Antarctica.
20 | WellcomeNews | Issue 63
Health Innovation Challenge Fund
Call for proposals
A greater shift towards self-monitoring and self- Further information and application forms are
management could give a significant boost to patient available at: www.wellcome.ac.uk/HICF
care while reducing costs. The Health Innovation
Challenge Fund (HICF), a joint £100 million funding
initiative between the Wellcome Trust and the
Department of Health, is currently inviting proposals
for practical solutions to improve health monitoring in
the home and remote settings.
6–9 December
The Genomics of Common
Human embryonic stem cell growing on a layer of
Diseases 2010 11–18
fibroblasts. Annie Cavanagh Wellcome Trust–Nature Genetics Genome-wide Approaches with
GC: Event takes place at the Wellcome conference, Baylor College of Fission Yeast
Trust Genome Campus, Hinxton, Cambs.
Medicine, Houston, Texas, USA Advanced Course GC
For information on Wellcome Trust Conferences, see
www.wellcome.ac.uk/conferences.
For information on Advanced Courses
17–23 13–17
and Open door Workshops, see Protein Interactions and Networks Proteomics Bioinformatics
www.wellcome.ac.uk/advancedcourses.
Conference GC Workshop GC
27–29
September 2010 Bridging the Gap on Biomedical
January 2011
Genetics
4–8 23–28
Conference GC
16th Meeting of the European Genomics and Clinical
Society for Pigment Cell Research Microbiology
Conference GC November Advanced Course GC
7–10 15–28
Signalling to Chromatin 2010 Genetic Manipulation of ES Cells
Conference GC Advanced Course GC
WellcomeNews | Issue 63 | 21
A FREE DESTINATION FOR TUESDAY–SUNDAY (UNTIL 18.00)
LATE-NIGHT THURSDAY (UNTIL 22.00)
Free exhibition
10 June–
26 September
COLLECTION GALLERY
FREE EVENTS | CAFÉ | BOOKSHOP | LIBRARY | CLUB ROOM | CONFERENCE CENTRE www.wellcomecollection.org
OR CALL 020 7611 2222
MP-4477.6/06-2009/MD