AbstractThe conducted as well as the induced voltages on control cables and control circuits due to transient electromagnetic
(EM) fields generated during switching operations in a gas-insulated substation (GIS) depend on the waveshape of the very fast
transient overvoltages and the associated very-fast transient currents (VFTCs). The aim of this paper is to build a basis for characterizing the VFTC generated in gas-insulated switchgear and the
associated equipment during switching operations for the study of
transient coupling phenomena. The peak magnitudes of VFTC and
their dominant frequency content at various locations have been
computed in a 245-kV GIS for different switching operations as
well as substation configurations. Finally, the influence of the substation layout on the frequency spectrum, dominant frequencies,
and the highest possible frequency component of the VFTC at various distances from the switch have been reported.
Index TermsElectromagnetic compatibility (EMC), electromagnetic interference (EMI), frequency spectrum, gas-insulated
switchgear (GIS), switching, very-fast transient currents (VFTCs),
very-fast transient overvoltages (VFTOs).
I. INTRODUCTION
Manuscript received March 8, 2004; revised September 30, 2004. Paper no.
TPWRD-00117-2004.
M. M. Rao and B. P. Singh are with Bharat Heavy Electricals Ltd., Corporate R&D, Hyderabad 500 093, India (e-mail: mmrao@bhelrnd.co.in;
bpsingh@bhelrnd.co.in).
M. J. Thomas is with the Department of High Voltage Engineering, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore 560 012, India (e-mail: thoma@hve.iisc.ernet.in).
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TPWRD.2005.852362
addition to the radiated EM field coupling, conducted mechanisms are also responsible for the coupling of very-fast transient
currents to the control wiring. The current transformer (CT)
and the potential transformer (PT) get conductively coupled to
the high-voltage bus of the GIS through the stray capacitance
between the primary and secondary as well as the Faraday
shields. Because of this coupling, a portion of the bus transient
current couples directly to the central conductor of the control
cables which, in turn, may appear at the terminals of the relay
or data-acquisition (DAQ) systems, etc. connected to them
[3]. All of these modes of coupling summed up with different
waveshapes, frequency content, and relative phase shift result in
a waveshape different from that due to any one of the coupling
mechanisms acting alone [4], [5].
The protection of the control circuits against the induced transients is an important aspect for the reliable operation of a GIS.
Malfunctioning of the primary/secondary equipment has been
reported by many authors during switching operations in a GIS
[1], [2], [6]. Since the transient voltages in control circuits depend on the nature of the radiated EM fields, it becomes necessary to estimate the magnitude and waveshape of the VFTC
along with its frequency spectrum. Further, knowledge of the
VFTC characteristics would be required in the theoretical study
of EM field coupling as well as shielding of the sensitive secondary equipment used in modern GIS.
This paper covers the estimation of VFTC at various locations in a GIS for different switching operations. The configurations, such as small length of the bus section, high capacitance terminal components, and multiple branches of the bus
section on the source/load side of the switch, are considered
for the study. The peak magnitude of the transient currents at
different locations and their attenuation with time/distance are
calculated for various switching configurations. The variation
in the frequency spectrum of the VFTC with distance from the
switch operated for different switching configurations and substation layouts have been analyzed. The approach used in the
present study can be extended to any other GIS also regardless
of the size, rating, type, etc. EMC problems due to VFTC are
of most concern for system voltages above 245 kV and at these
voltages, segregated-phase GIS is normally used. Hence, such a
system has been taken up for the study.
II. VERY-FAST TRANSIENT CURRENTS (VFTCs)
The parameters that characterize the VFTC are of more relevance for the protection of GIS controls and are as follows [7]:
1) amplitude of VFTC;
2) attenuation of the amplitude of VFTC with distance and
time;
RAO et al.: FREQUENCY CHARACTERISTICS OF VERY FAST TRANSIENT CURRENTS IN A 245-kV GIS
2451
TABLE I
ELECTRICAL EQUIVALENT REPRESENTATION OF GIS COMPONENTS [3], [8], [9]
Fig. 1.
2452
occurs very near to the switch (i.e., at the BUS LINK). The peak
magnitude of the transient current at the GIS-cable junction is
about 4.12 kA. The reduction in amplitude of transient current
at the cable end for the SW2 operation may be due to the presence of the gas-insulated bus-sections (245 kV BUS II) on the
source side and a smaller length of the bus section on the load
side of the switch. More clearly, the transient current divides
between the BUS II and the incoming line. To understand the
effect of high surge capacitance components on the peak magnitude of the transient currents, the third switching operation has
been considered and the results are shown in Fig. 4. From this
figure, it is clear that the peak magnitude of the transient current at the switch operated is high compared to the other two
switching operations and the highest magnitude of the transient
current occurs at 1.9 m from the switch (load side of CB3). The
increase in transient current may be due to the high surge capacitance on the load side of the switch. The peak magnitude
of the transient current at the GIS-cable junction is about 6.92
kA. Also in the present configuration, the transient current divides between BUS II and the incoming line as in the case of
the second switching configuration. From the above analysis,
it is also clear that the peak magnitude of the transient current
near the open end of the bus sections is significant (up to 3 kA)
and is of higher value for the SW1 operation than for the other
two switching operations. This may be due to a) the high capacitance termination for the third switching configuration and,
thus, the current flowing through the open end bus section is
low; b) branching of the transient current between BUS II and
the incoming line for the SW2 and SW3 configurations.
The following salient features have been observed during the
VFTC characterization.
Fig. 3. VFTC waveforms at three different locations for the first switching
operation (SW1).
TABLE II
TRANSIENT CURRENTS IN kILOAMPERES AT DIFFERENT GIS COMPONENTS.
RAO et al.: FREQUENCY CHARACTERISTICS OF VERY FAST TRANSIENT CURRENTS IN A 245-kV GIS
2453
TABLE III
DIFFERENT SUBSTATION LAYOUTS UNDER THE STUDY
Fig. 5. Variation in peak magnitudes of the VFTC with distance for various
substation layouts.
Fig. 4. VFTC waveforms at three different locations for the third switching
operation (SW3).
2454
TABLE IV
ATTENUATION RATE OF TRANSIENT CURRENT AMPLITUDES WITH TIME
elements such as an overhead line. Similarly, if the GIS is terminated with a long length of GITL, there is a possibility of the
transient currents for a longer time duration.
The attenuation rate of the amplitude of VFTC with time has
been calculated at different locations of the GIS for the above
substation layouts and are listed in Table IV. For the purpose of
comparison, the peak magnitude of the transient current at about
2 s is considered as the base value. The attenuation rate of the
at a particular position in GIS is defined
transient currents
as follows:
%
(2)
where
is the peak magnitude of transient current for the
is the peak magnitude of transient
entire time duration and
current after 2 s of the strike between the switching contacts.
The attenuation rate of the amplitude of the VFTC with the time
at the switch operated is more or less in the same range with
a cable or a GITL termination on the source side and a power
transformer on the load side of the switch. The attenuation of
transient currents with time is low if the GIS is terminated with
an overhead line (CFG4) on the source side of the switch. In
other words, there is a possibility of higher transient currents for
a longer time duration. There is a considerable change in attenuation of the transient current amplitude at the GIS-cable junction
if the load side of the switch is terminated with GITL (CFG5)
instead of a power transformer (CFG1). More clearly, the attenuation of transient current at the source side of the switch
not only depends on the source side termination but also on the
load-side termination and vice versa.
In the second stage of the analysis, the fast Fourier transform
(FFT) technique has been employed to identify the dominant
frequencies of the transient currents. The frequency spectrum
has been calculated by considering the VFTC waveform for the
time duration of 4 s. Fig. 6 shows the frequency spectrum of
the VFTC at different locations of a 245-kV GIS during the first
switching operation. From this figure, it is evident that the dominant frequency components of the VFTC at the switch DS1 are
up to 150 MHz, except that there is a high-frequency component
of 238 MHz with considerable amplitude. The high-frequency
content of the transient current may be due to the small length
of the open-end sections near the switch operated as well as due
to the fast voltage collapse (a few nanoseconds) between the
switching contacts during its operation. Near the switch DS1,
the highest frequency of 310 MHz is possible and this highfrequency component created locally is observed to attenuate
within a small distance (a few meters) from its point of generation. Similar observations have been made in the earlier experi-
Fig. 6. Frequency spectra of the VFTC for the first switching operation
(normalized amplitude in arbitrary units).
mental works reported in the literature [1]. At the current transformer location, the frequency components of the VFTC are
not dominant beyond 150 MHz except that there is a high-frequency component of 238 MHz with reduced amplitude. However, there is a considerable reduction in the amplitude of the fre-
RAO et al.: FREQUENCY CHARACTERISTICS OF VERY FAST TRANSIENT CURRENTS IN A 245-kV GIS
2455
Fig. 7. Frequency spectra of the VFTC for the third switching operation.
2456
RAO et al.: FREQUENCY CHARACTERISTICS OF VERY FAST TRANSIENT CURRENTS IN A 245-kV GIS
2457
[7] M. M. Rao, M. J. Thomas, and B. P. Singh, Frequency spectrum analysis of fast transient currents (FTC) during switching operation in a 245
kV GIS, in Proc. IEEE/PES T&D Conf., Yokohama, Japan, Oct. 2002,
pp. 22392243.
[8] S. Ogawa, E. Haginomori, S. Nishiwaki, T. Yoshida, and K. Terasaka,
Estimation of restriking transient overvoltage on disconnecting switch
for GIS, IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. PWRD-1, no. 2, pp. 95102, Apr.
1986.
[9] Z. Haznadar, S. Carsimamovic, and R. Mahmutcehajic, More accurate
modeling of gas insulated substation components in digital simulations
of very fast electromagnetic transients, IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 7,
no. 1, pp. 434441, Jan. 1992.
[10] P. Osmokrovic, S. Krstic, M. Ljevak, and D. Novakovic, Influence of
GIS parameters on the Toepler constant, IEEE Trans. Elect. Insul., vol.
27, no. 2, pp. 214220, Apr. 1992.