AND
STEFANO DOTTAVIO
Italian Soccer Federation (FIGC) and Italian Referees Association (AIA), Rome, Italy.
ABSTRACT
The aim of this study was to verify whether referees maximal aerobic power could influence competitive match exercise intensity. Eight elite-level referees (mean 6 SD age, 37.6
6 3.4 years) were each observed during 2 Serie A matches
(n 5 16), and the mean of each match activity was used for
analysis. Match activities were monitored with encoderequipped cameras. VO2max was assessed under field conditions with a portable device during a progressive multistage protocol. The VO2max of each subject was expressed
in absolute terms (V O2maxab, Lmin21), relative terms
(VO2maxrel, mlkg21min21), and independent from body
mass (VO2maxind, mlkg20.75min21). Significance was set at p
# 0.05 for all measurements. Total distance covered during
the match correlated significantly with VO2maxind (r 5 0.77)
and VO2maxab (r 5 0.87). VO2maxind, VO2maxrel, and VO2maxab
correlated negatively (p , 0.05) with the time spent standing
still during the match (r 5 20.90, 20.85, and 20.86, respectively, p , 0.05). During the first half of the match, referees
with higher levels of VO2maxrel (r 5 0.93, p , 0.05) and
VO2maxind (r 5 0.90, p , 0.05) were able to cover more distance at medium intensity. In the second half of the match,
medium-intensity distance and low-intensity time correlated
significantly (p , 0.05) with VO2maxab (r 5 0.76) and
VO2maxrel (r 5 0.75), respectively. The results demonstrate
the positive influence of VO2max in determining both the
total amount of distance covered and the exercise intensity
during a game. Higher levels of VO2max may provide referees the opportunity to be more active and therefore closer
to the action on the field during the game.
Introduction
ecent studies have shown that refereeing is an exercise mode that relies mostly on the aerobic pathway (7). Corroboration comes from the finding that
during friendly matches, officials exercise at intensities
420
Methods
Approach to the Problem and Experimental Design
Previous studies have examined the effect of maximal
oxygen uptake on match performance in elite soccer
players (4, 5, 25, 27). In those studies, the influences of
players cardiorespiratory fitness on the physical expressions of the game were reported as correlations (r
values) between distances covered during the match in
a series of arbitrarily defined match categories and
O2max values. Compared with players, the
players V
analysis of the global distance covered by soccer referees is particularly useful because referees, during
the course of the match, do not experience physical
contact or perform other categories of activity that are
not taken into account in the distance covered (e.g.,
tackling, heading, kicking, getting up from the
ground, etc.) (3). Thus, distances and times spent in
match activities may be considered as valid variables
of the physical involvement of the referees during the
O2max and match coverage
match. Furthermore, V
seem to be role dependent among soccer players;
therefore, is difficult to draw conclusions about the ef O2max on match performance in referees
fects of V
based on the experiments performed using soccer
players. In this study, only official first-division matches were observed, as soccer match intensity has been
demonstrated to be competition-level dependent (4,
13). In light of the previously noted rationale, the in O2max were plotted against disdividual levels of V
tances and times spent in a series of arbitrarily defined
O2max on the
match categories to assess the effect of V
physical stress imposed on elite referees during competitive matches.
It is a common belief among individuals assessing
Italian referees that those referees who are closer to
the action cover more distance during the match than
their counterparts who are more distant from the action. Being closer to the action probably enables referees to be more reliable with regard to the judgments
that they make and lessens the likelihood that they will
commit mistakes. Furthermore, international governing bodies such as Federation Iternationale de Football
Association (FIFA) and Union Europeen de Football
Association (UEFA) consider good aerobic fitness as a
requirement for good refereeing (12).
Subjects
Subjects (N 5 8) were all experienced elite-level referees enrolled in the Commissione Arbitri Nazionali
(CAN) and thus officiating in the Serie A and B Italian
championships. Each referee who took part in this
study had no less than 20 years of officiating experience, of which 5 years were spent at the first-division
level (Serie A B). Three of the officials were international-level referees. The referees were at the moment
of the study in good health and following a supervised
physical training program that we had implemented.
Written consent from all referees was obtained before
the study, after they were given a detailed explanation
as to the nature of the research.
In this study, each referee was observed during 2
regular season first division matches (Serie A). A total
of 16 matches were examined during the course of the
19921993 and 19931994 competitive seasons. The
mean 6 SD age, height, and weight of the referees
were 37.6 6 3.4 years (range, 3141 years); 182.9 6 4.5
cm (range, 179190 cm); and 77.6 6 7 kg (range, 69
90 kg), respectively.
Match Analysis
Referees were observed during the whole match by
means of 2 cameras (Play Controller, Phromos, Italy),
each attached to a tripod, that were equipped with encoders according to the procedure used by Ohashi et
al (18). The cameras were set approximately 10 m
away from one of the sidelines of the football pitch.
Signals of angles obtained by the encoders were sequentially converted into digital data and recorded on
a floppy disc for postmatch analysis (18).
421
Standing
Walking forward
Low-intensity running (,13 km per hour)
Medium-intensity running (13.118 km per hour)
High-intensity running (18.124 km per hour)
Maximal speed running (24 km per hour);
Walking backward
Running backward
Running sideward
High-intensity activity (HIA, the sum of the activities performed at speed .18.1 km per hour)
11. Unorthodox directional modes distance (the sum
of backward running and inside-ward running, as
described by Reilly and Bowen [22])
The validity and reliability of the method used for
measuring the distances have been reported elsewhere
(10).
We performed z-tests for each of the 11 match categories to verify that the 16-match sample data could
be considered as representative of data in a database
of 96 serie A matches collected and previously analyzed (11).
O2max Assessment
V
Testing Protocol. Participants (N 5 8) were evaluated for
O2max with a progressive multistage protocol conV
ducted under field conditions with K2 technology (K2,
Cosmed, Rome, Italy).
The subjects performed the test running on an athletic track marked with cones every 20 m. After a brief
warm-up carried out on an individual basis, subjects
ran at 8 km per hour for 2 minutes. Thereafter, the
speed was increased every 2 minutes by 2 km per hour
until exhaustion. The pace was set with the help of an
audio player broadcasting prerecorded beeps of an audiocassette. The beep indicated the moment when the
subjects had to pass near a cone to maintain a constant
speed.
Physiologic Measurements. During the tests (N 5 8),
expired air was analyzed with a portable telemetry
system (K2). This system allows the measurement of
oxygen uptake and ventilation. During the test, the K2
system was strapped to each referee with a chest harness. Expired gases were analyzed every 15 seconds,
and the data were transmitted telemetrically to the K2
receiving unit. Before each test, the K2 system was calibrated according to the manufacturers instructions.
The K2 system has previously been described and validated (16).
The highest oxygen-uptake level attained was con O2max). Maxisidered the maximal oxygen uptake (V
Statistical Analyses
The data are presented as means 6 SDs. Comparisons
between values for match activities were performed
using the t-test for matched pairs (28). We also performed z-tests comparing the sample means (16
matches) with those of a database of 96 serie A matches previously collected. Relationships between variables were analyzed using Pearson correlation coefficients (r). The a level of significance was set at 5% (p
# 0.05) a priori.
Results
z Score Analysis
Results showed that the mean value of the 11 match
categories could be considered as if randomly drawn
from the 96 matches previously collected and analyzed
(p . 0.05) (11).
Times and Distances for Individual Activity Categories
Whole Match Activity. During an average soccer match,
the referee stood still for 775 6 161 seconds. This represents 14% of the total time played (5,682 6 60 seconds).
The mean total distance covered over the period of
a whole match (;95 minutes) was 11,584 6 1,017 m,
ranging from 10,054 to 12,792 m. The mean distances
covered walking forward and backward were 975 6
146 m and 51 6 31 m, respectively. The mean distances covered by the referees in low-, medium-, and
high-intensity running were 4,840 6 700 m, 2,744 6
370 m, and 1,436 6 449 m, respectively. Runs at maximal speed amounted to 477 6 141 m. In unorthodox
directional modes (22) consisting of backward and
sideward running, the referees covered 966 6 530 m
and 94 6 82 m, respectively (Figure 1).
423
Table 1. Correlations (r) of aerobic power with activities during the whole match. Times and distances were determined by
motion analysis.
Variable
Standing time
VO2maxrel
VO2maxab
VO2maxind
20.85*
20.86*
.0.90*
Walking
forward time
Mediumintensity
time
Walking
forward distance
0.89*
0.83*
0.91*
20.81*
20.71*
Mediumintensity
distance
Total distance
0.89*
0.84*
0.92*
0.87*
0.77*
Table 2. Correlations (r) of aerobic power with activities during the first and second halves of the match. Times and distances
were determined by motion analysis.
First half
Variable
VO2maxrel
VO2maxab
VO2maxind
Mediumintensity
time
0.93*
0.90*
Walking
forward
time
20.74*
Mediumintensity
distance
Second half
Total
distance
Standing
time
0.79*
0.74*
20.86*
20.74*
20.85*
0.93*
0.91*
Mediumintensity
time
Lowintensity
time
0.74*
0.75*
Mediumintensity
distance
0.76*
0.77*
Total
distance
0.88*
0.76*
tensity running was totaled by those referees who possessed higher relative oxygen uptake (r 5 0.75, p ,
0.05) and absolute maximal oxygen uptake (r 5 0.76,
p , 0.05), respectively. Possession of higher VO2maxab,
O2maxrel, or VO2maxind enabled referees to stand still
V
less than their less fit counterparts during the second
half of matches (respective r values, 20.74, 20.86, and
20.85, p , 0.05). Furthermore, a higher VO2maxab and
O2maxind favored the fitter referees in covering more
V
distance during the course of the second half of matches (respective r values, 0.88 and 0.76, p , 0.05).
Discussion
During a match, the first assignment of the referee is
to regulate the behavior of soccer participants by implementing the rules of play. This activity is very often
superimposed on a relatively high level of physiologic
stress, as the referee is expected to keep up with play
irrespective of the tempo of the game. In this and in
other studies, it has been reported that elite-level referees cover during an average match a distance similar
to that totaled by an average competitive level
matched outfield soccer player. In fact, the match analysis performed in the present study revealed average
match coverage of 11,584 6 1,017 m, ranging from
10,054 to 12,792 m. With methodologies similar to
those used in the present study, Ohashi et al. (19) reported a mean total distance of 11,529 m for Japanese
soccer players. With methodologies that differ from
the one used in our study, other authors have reported
total match distances for soccer players ranging from
8,680 to 11,527 m (5, 6, 13, 20, 24, 26, 27, 30). Catterall
et al. (8) and Asami et al. (2) reported match distances
for soccer referees of 9,438 6 707 m (n 5 13) and
10,168 6 756 m (n 5 10), respectively. Asami et al. (2)
also reported a mean match distance of 9,736 6 1,077
m for 7 international-level soccer referees. Recently,
Harley et al. (17) reported total match coverage of
7,496 6 1,122 m for county leaguelevel soccer referees. This figure is quite different from that reported
here and elsewhere (2, 811) for higher-level referees.
Such findings are probably due to differences in the
competitive level of the games and/or fitness and/or
skill level of the referees studied. Furthermore, Harley
et al. (17) found a strong and significant correlation (r
5 0.80) between distance covered and mean assessment score for positioning, suggesting that the overall
match mobility of the referee is important for attaining
the correct position at the correct time.
In this study, first- and second-half total distances
differed (6%, p , 0.05). This pattern is comparable to
that noted for soccer players (5, 13, 20, 24, 26, 27), who
show a significant decrease in total distance covered
for the second half of the match. However, other studies of soccer referees performances have yielded conflicting results (2). Catterall et al. (8) reported a 5.5%
Practical Applications
Previous research has shown that elite-level refereeing
(Serie A, Italian First Division Soccer Championship)
O2max and 88% of
elicits the attainment of 68% of V
maximal heart rate (7, 9 10). Those findings, together
with the finding of low blood lactate concentrations
during matches (7), demonstrate the aerobic nature of
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
ABT, G.A., G. DICKSON, AND W.K. MUMMERY. Goal scoring patterns over the course of a match: An analysis of the Australian
national soccer league. In: Abstracts of the IV World Congress on
Science and Football; February 2226, 1999. W. Spinks, ed. Sydney,
University of Technology, 1999, p. 52.
ASAMI, T., H. TOGARI, AND J. OHASHI. Analysis of movement
patterns of referees during soccer matches. In: Science and Football. T. Reilly, A. Lees, K. Davids, and W. J. Murphy, eds. London/New York: E. & F. N. Spon, 1988. pp. 341345.
BANGSBO, J. Physiological demands. In: Football (Soccer). B. Ekblom, ed. London: Blackwell Scientific, 1994. pp. 4359.
BANGSBO, J. The physiology of soccerWith special reference
to intense intermittent exercise. Doctor of Science thesis, Krogh
Institute, University of Copenhagen, August 1994. pp. 3440.
BANGSBO, J., L. NRREGAARD, AND F. THORSE. Activity profile
of competition soccer. Can. J. Sport Sci. 16:110116. 1991.
BERGH, U., B. SJDIN, A. FORSBERG, AND J. SVEDENHAG. The
relationship between body mass and oxygen uptake during
running in humans. Med. Sci. Sports Exerc. 3:205211. 1991.
CASTAGNA, C., AND S. DOTTAVIO. Physiological aspects of soccer refereeing. In: Abstracts of the IV World Congress on Science
and Football; February 2226, 1999. W. Spinks, ed. Sydney, University of Technology, 1999, p. 67.
CATTERALL, C., T. REILLY, G. ATKINSON, AND A. COLDWELLS.
Analysis of work rate and heart rates of association football
referees. Br. J. Sports Med. 27:153156. 1993.
DOTTAVIO, S., AND C. CASTAGNA. Work-rate and cardiovascular stress in top-level soccer referees. In: Abstracts of the IV
World Congress on Science and Football; February 2226, 1999. W.
Spinks, ed. Sydney, University of Technology, 1999, p. 96.
DOTTAVIO, S., AND C. CASTAGNA. Physiological load imposed
on elite soccer referees during actual match play. J. Sports Med.
Phys. Fitness 41:2732. 2001.
DOTTAVIO, S., AND C. CASTAGNA. Analysis of match activities
in elite soccer referees during actual match play. J. Strength
Cond. Res. 15:167171. 2001.
EISSMANN, H. J., AND M. DHOOGHE. Sports medical examinations. In: The 23rd Man: Sports Medical Advice for Football Referees. FIFA, Leipzig, Germany, Gersone-Druck, 1996. pp. 719.
EKBLOM, B. Applied physiology of soccer. Sports Med. 3:5060.
1986.
GREHAIGNE, J.F. An analysis of goals in the French championship in 199697 and 199798. In: Abstracts of the IV World Con-
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
425
Acknowledgments
We are greatly indebted by the kind availability of Marcello
Faina, M.D., and his superb staff from the Institute of Sport
Science of Rome for performing and collecting the
physiologic measurements. We wish to thank Dr. Grant Abt
from St. Martins College, UK, for his help in reviewing the
manuscript.