A. Background
Being successful in teaching English is the dominant factor that the English teacher should pay attention to,
especially in teaching reading. Through reading, one can enhance his experience, develop new concept, solve his
problem, and broaden his horizon of thinking, which are needed to ensure continuing personal growth and adopt the
change in the world yet the importance of reading has not been realized by most of our society a large number of our
population is classified as poor readers and the majority of the people are content to read materials of poor quality.
In reading comprehension, the message to be imposed in the written form is the most important element that
the students must recognize, because the primary purpose of reading is to know the thoughts expressed in the
printed material. Therefore, reading wit comprehension is only a way for the students to arrive at what they want to
know from the reading material. However, the problem is how to make them comprehend.
For students from elementary to university level, reading is something that has to be done. They have to read their
compulsory books or other materials related to their lesson. For students who are studying languages, reading is one
of the skills, which has to be learned and is considered as the most important one because it can influence other
language skill (listening, speaking, and writing). According to Kustaryo (1988;2) it is certainly not easy to present the
English reading for Indonesian students whose language system is different. Reading is a complex process which
involves not only the read the text but also their experience to comprehend it. Because of its complexity, many
teachers of English at junior and senior high school find difficulties in all teaching reading and prefer teaching
structure to reading. Based on all reason above, the writer thinks that humour stories can motivate students to read,
because humor stories are interested in conducting research entitle Improving the students Reading
comprehension by using humour stories of the second garde of year students of SMA Negeri 5 Makassar.
In the teaching reading, English. Teacher should introduce the humor stories as an alternative way to give variation to
the students in teaching and learning process.
Based on the junior high school curriculum, reading is one of the four skills in studying English. Reading consists of
narrative, descriptive, procedure, news item, recount, and anecdote. The aim of the students learn reading, they have
to know basic competence and achievement indicators in reading. Basic competence of reading: Understand
transactional discourse, interpersonal discourse, and oral monologue especially in the forms of descriptive, narrative,
anecdote, analytical exposition, and hortatory exposition using oral language variation. And achievement indicators;
Students can read continuous story, students can identify rhetorical moves of a text in the narrative, descriptive, and
anecdote form, students can identify main ideas, Supporting ideas, and detailed information of the text, and students
can identify and use the tense
B. Problem Statement
According to the statement above, the research question is formulated as follows:
Does the use of humour stories improve the reading comprehension of the second year students of SMA
Negeri 5 Makassar?
CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF THE RELATED
LITERATURE
This chapter deals with some previous research findings. Some pertinent ideas, theoretical framework
and hypothesis.
students achievement in two post test shows that the application of cooperative learning is able to improve the
students score.
From the previous findings above, the writer using humor stories techniques as a media in teaching because
humor stories are one way to improve students activity in reading class. This research has difference with previous
finding above. The writer used humor stories into steps: (1) Introduce about the humor stories and identify main
ideas, (2) Read the questions, (3) Supporting ideas, (4) getting the general and specific information, (5) find out the
answer in reading materials. In this case, the teachers are expected to give and use many kinds o technique in
reading class and also the interesting materials.
B. Definition of Reading
1.
What is Reading?
There are reading definition are given by some people, which related the similar meaning.
Charles in Tohir (2001:5) states that reading is a transmitting of information process where the author tells all
the readers about his ideas or message. Such as, the author is regard as the informants (sender) and the reader on
the another hand is receiver. During the reading process it means that the reader can be done during reading activity
is only grasping and decoding information, meanwhile he can not as question or comment to the author directly.
Tinker and Cullogh (1975:9) state reading is identification and recognition of print or written symbol, which
serve as stimuli for the recall of meaning built up through past experience. From those definitions, it can be concluded
reading is meaning getting process the reader always tries to catch what the writer says and means actually. Also
from those definitions of reading some people formulate definitions of reading comprehension.
According to William (1984:486) reading can be point as four step process. The four steps are interrelated to
other, they are:
1.
2.
3.
4.
2.
Reading Concept
There are different reading definition given by linguistics which indicate the similar sense of meaning some
defied that reading is a comfortable activities for relax time, come others state that reading is valuable learning
activity where knowledge and science are required to be acquired by the students academically.
According to Rubin (1982) reading is the bringing of meaning to and the getting of meaning from the printed
pages while Simanjutak (1988) states that reading is the process of putting to reader in contact and communication
with ideas. Widdowson in Rubin (1982) states that reading is not a reaction to text but an interaction between writer
and reader medicated through the text. It is clear that reading is a fundamental requirement that can influence the
students achievement in studying English through reading, we can broaden our horizon of thinking
Anthony (1995:77) states that teaching English as a foreign language to the second language learners
requires the learners to be able to use this language to in daily, interaction either in the classroom learning process
that are well known as in formal communication, but we can deny that we have not yet achieved the goal of teaching
English as a foreign language.
In teaching reading English teacher should introduce other materials as an alternative to give variation to the
student in teaching and learning process. These materials can be a form of media that can create a comfortable
atmosphere to interest and stimulate the student in the classroom learning process.
Learning English could be fun for the students who learn another language. In this case, teachers of English
should have a good preparation in teaching. It is very essential for the teachers to create a good classroom
atmosphere and to avoid the students from getting bored. According to William in Rahman, teaching must be learned
in such a way that learning becomes interesting.
A wide selection material will be interesting if the material is humorous. Sudjoko in Hamka (2001;3) says that
humor can entertain, humor also can help some one to comprehend any complex matters. Because the importance
of humor in learning and teaching, the writer offers the use of a kind of humor. Which is funny (Written humor) in
teaching reading . Reading is an active in which the reader must make an active contribution by drawing upon and
using concurrently various abilities he has acquired. In addition, reading is concerned mainly with learning to
recognize the printed symbols that represent language and to respond intellectually and emotionally when being
asked about the content of the she/he has read.
3.
Comprehension is a special kind of thinking process. The reader comprehends by actively constructing
meaning internally from interacting with the material that is read (Anderson and Pearson in Alexander, (1993;160).
Successful comprehension involves the reader who can discovery the meaning. It may be finding a particular piece of
information, solving a problem through reading, working to understand an idea or following a set of directions. From
the point of view given above, it can be concluded that reading is an active thinking process where the reader tries to
gain information given by the author and understands what actually the purpose of author.
4.
1.
Literal comprehension; that is the skill of getting primary direct literal meaning of a word, idea, or sentence in context.
2.
Interpretation; that is to identify ideal and meaning that are not explicitly stated in the written text.
3.
Critical reading; that is to evaluate what is read, and examines critically the thought of the writer.
4.
Creative reading; that is to apply ideas from the text to new situations and to recombine authors ideas with other
ideas to from new concepts or to expand old ones.
b) Level of reading comprehension Carnine in Carnine (1990) are:
1.
a)
b)
Sequencing comprehension; that is to under several from a passage according to when they happened.
c)
2.
a)
Inferential comprehension; that is to reveal relationship between two objects or averts (stated on not stated).
b)
Critical reading; that is to identify the authors conclusion to determine what evidence is presented, and to identify
family argument.
c)
Comprehension skill for the advanced level that is the appreciation of the author work.
5. The Reasons for Reading
According to Harmer (1987). there are four reasons for reading, they are:
1.
has to work out the significance of these message. The reading to confirm expectation technique is highly motivation
and successful since it interest students, creates expected, and gives them a purpose for reading.
2.
3.
b) Silent Reading
Silent reading is reinforcesing the readers to find out the meaning of the words. This kind of reading leads
the readers to the better comprehension. This reading is skill to criticize what is written, to discuss written meaning
and to draw inference and conciliation as well as to tell new ideas on thesis of what is read.
c) Reading Fast
Reading fast used to improve speed and comprehension in reading. This skill must sun side with the main
purpose of reading that is comprehension it depends on the kinds of reading material. This speed rate if reading a
story or narrative on will be different room reading scientific mat.6. The aerials.
7. The Strategy of Reading
There are three strategies we tend to approach when we read, they are;
a. Skimming
Skimming is to read text superficially a rapidly in order obtain the gist or main idea it is a skill that requires
concentration. Adequate knowledge among of practice is necessary in order to skim fulfill their purposes.
b. Scanning
Scanning is to read a text quickly in order to locate a specific item of information it is used to design the process
of locating quickly a particular word, phrase, sentence, and fact of figure with a selection.
c. Intensive reading
Intensive reading is a for recall or total accuracy it is an activity in class way in using reading. It deals with the
detail content and linguistic study.
8. Selection of materials
Teacher of English language are expected to be more creative and more innovative selecting and then
presenting materials relatively and using a wide variety of resources that can enhance and motivate students to learn
English. Through anecdotes, the student will be entertained in reading the materials. The reading materials should be
interesting; the teacher should notice that in selecting the materials he/she should be sure that they are in time of
students interest in order towing their attention. This is important for the smooth less of the way to the students to
good concentration and attitude toward reading lesson. If the materials are not interesting, the students will passively
not pay much attention to the lesson. This way means that the teacher will be difficult to attain the objective of his
teaching.
According to Huck in Burns (1984), intermediate students are interested in reading fiction, biographies
adventure and stories of the past. They like suspense, action and humor. Teacher can asses student personal
reading interest them. In selection reading materials, there are at least three areas that should be concern:
2.
3.
4.
To achieve the purpose of reading one should read effectively. General in Rahman (1998:8) states that
effective reading means being able to read accurately, efficiently and to understand as much of the passage as you
read in order to achieve your purpose.
To achieve one purpose of reading, he can apply some reading technique as follows:
a) Survey Reading
Brown (1987:930) says surveying is specialized technique for getting a mountain top new of an article
chapter content and it helps to give a general point of view.
b) Skimming
Skimming is a kind of reading that make our eyes move quickly in order to get the main idea from the
reading material. Skimming enable people to select content that want to read and to discard that which is in
consequential for their purpose.
c)
Scanning
Scanning is reading the text quickly to answer a specific question. This technique enables people to locate
specific information without reading all the material around It. Brown (1987;138 ) states that scanning serves two
functions. It uncovers relevant information and accelerates your reading speed.
d)
Pre-reading
Pre-reading is a technique that a reader uses before he began to read the material to improve his
comprehension and recall. Whorter ( 1992 ; 25 ) states that pre-reading involves only at those part of reading
materials that will tell you what it is about or how it is organize. Further he explains the port on to look at in reading a
text book chapter are:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
C. Humor
1.
What is humor?
According to Webster New world Dictionary (1996), humor is the quality that makes something seems funny
or amusing: comicality, it also means mood, state of mind humor must be funny but it has to be considered that funny
element is not the humor but symptom of it. Funny is used in the little to refer to humor and act, which can cause
laughter.
2.
Theories of Humor
Humor in modern usage means the comic or laughable. In general sense, all theories of humor could be
divided into two classes; those that find all humor and laughter innocent, harmless and joyful. More precisely the
theories of humor can be divided into three groups;
1.
2.
3.
Humor, even at its most malicious, even at its most exaggerated, can not dessert truth toilet, the Kings answer is
the only pooper one and you lie Sirrah, well have you whipped.
Function of Humor
Sudjoko in Hamka (2001) says that humor can function to do all intention and all goals in every facet, humor
can make someone to see problem in any different sides, humor can entertain, humor can swift mind, humor can
increase someone smartness, humor can make someone tolerate something and humor also can help some one to
comprehend any complex matters. Actually our society have realize some functions of humor, as policy function or
refreshing tool to make people able to concentrate their attention for long time. In the advance country, employees
sometimes make humor as long as it helps to facilate their work or function to reach their goal. Another important
function of humor is recreation in this case, the role of humor is to vanish the saturation in people routine activities
such as working or studying. Besides as an entertainment, humor also function as tool to convey critic, which is
usually indirect. Recently, this kind of humor grows greatly as our society become more critical and they already able
to see any betrayal in our surroundings.
Humor also functions to explain something in an attraction way, if they find any hard matter, they will seek
humor that is relevant to the matter. This method also used in explaining sexual problems to the young generations.
Kinds of Humor
Setiawan in Hamka (2001) categorize humor according to its expression form he states the kinds of humor as
in the following:
1.
Performing comedy. Such as jest, pantomime, etc, graphic humor such as caricature funny picture etc
2.
Literature humor such as funny story humor stories, anecdote etc. Koesler in Hamka (2001) categorized humor into
two classes, according to its performance and according to its goal.
Humor in the view of performance can be divided into three as in the following:
a)
Spoken humor
b)
Written humor
c)
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
7.
2.
3.
Interesting
In teaching reading, english teacher should introduce the humor stories as an alternative way to give variation
to the students in teaching and learning process. Humor stories can make someone to see problem many different
sides, humor can entertain, humor can swift mind, humor can increase. Someone smartness, humor can also can
help someone to comprehend any complex matters. The students can understand the implicit meaning and stages of
theoretic development in written text in the form of narrative procedure, descriptive, anecdote, report, recount and
new items.
D. Theoretical Framework
Reading material as one element in English language teaching has the important role. Because reading
material as one factor that might influence the students reading comprehension.
The theoretical framework is put in the diagram below
In the diagram above, the three main components are input, process, and output
1.
Input refers to the humorous stories that will be given to the students
2.
Process refers to the implementation of humorous stories in teaching reading ability in the classroom
3.
E. Hypothesis
The hypothesis of the research presented as follows:
hesis)
There is a significant difference of the students reading comprehension before and after presenting reading material by
using humor stories.
There is no significant result students reading comprehension before and after giving treatment..
CHAPTER III
METHOD OF THE
RESEARCH
This chapter deals with variable and research design, population and sample, instrument of the research, procedure
of collecting data and technique of data analysis.
Independent variable was the use of humor stories to improve reading comprehension. Humor is the quality that
makes something seem funny or amusing to comprehend any complex matters.
2.
Dependent variable was the students reading comprehension means understanding, evaluating, utilizing information
and gaining through an interaction between reader and author.
2. Research Design
The research employed a pre-experimental method with one class pretest and posttest design. The diagram was
given below:
01
02
Where :
01 = Pretest
X = Treatment
02 = Posttest
(Gay, 1981 : 225)
B. Population and Sample
1. Population
The population of this research was the second grade students of SMA Negeri 5 Makassar in the 2006/2007
academic year. The number of population 360 students consisted of nine classes; each class consisted of 30 40
students.
2. Sample
The writer took only one class as the sample and respondent of this research. The number of the sample is
30 students were chosen (II IPA1) because that class is excellent class than the other classes. This sample was
chosen by using cluster random sampling technique.
C. Treatment
The researcher carried out the class in four meetings. In each meeting the researcher used to be discussed.
1.
The first meeting was on Tuesday, 10th October 2006, the topic is about My Holidays
a.
b.
The researcher gave explanation about reading comprehension by using humor stories to stimulate the students.
2.
The second meeting was on Wednesday, 11th October 2006, the topic is about Restaurant
a.
The researcher asked the students what their difficulties about the humor stories.
b.
The researcher gave 3 (three) humor stories as a sample and then students read
3.
The third meeting was on Tuesday, 17th October 2006, the topic is about Policeman and Bachelor
a.
The researcher gave essay test and each student answer the questioned about the humor stories.
b.
The researcher asked the students again what their difficulties about the humor stories.
4.
The fourth meeting was on Wednesday, 1st November 2006, the topic is about Frog
a.
The researcher gave essay test again by using humor stories and the students repeat and correction.
Pretest
Before doing treatment, the researcher applied a pre-test which was carried out on Wednesday morning, 4 th October
2006. It lasted in 90 minutes, with 2 x 45 minutes. Students were in the class joining the test. The researcher
distributed to identify the students prior knowledge in reading comprehension.
2.
Posttest
After doing treatment was on Wednesday morning, 8th November 2006. The writer post-test for the experimental
class. It lasted for 2 x 45 minutes. The post-test was conducted to find out the students achievement and their
progress after giving the treatment about the use humor stories in reading comprehension. The content of the pretest
was the same as the post test.
Score =
2.
a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
f.
g.
Where:
n
: frequency
Where X
: Mean Score
: Total row score
N
5.
Finding out the significant difference between the pretest and posttest by calculating the value of the test. The
following formula is employed :
Where :
: Deviation
: Standard deviation
N
Where
: Number of students
SD
: Standard deviation
: Total row score
Where :
: The difference between the score of pretest and posttest
D : The mean score from the different score of pretest and posttest
D2 : The square of D
N : Number of students