W
U??I?? WMM_ rN??

wKO
u bL bO

WOM_ U?bK WbI

W
bI

Y
??  ZU?d wM_ l?UD U?? H? { Securitization Theory WMM?_ W dE d?? ?
? ?F
W?O
M W dEM c dN d?O_ WM   W?OM_ Ub qI w U?OI
UOMOU?L nB
M s b
 WOb U?F hB w Xb? w
 W u uD
K
b `
 hB?
 v WOF{u b?F UUI*U dF U uu s d?AF dI
Social Constructivism W?OU?L?
 W?OzUM U?N? vK b b W b?I U?O?NM u?b
W UN w Ole Wver d?H w t?b c b?* qL?F v WMM_ W dE? u u?F
U?? I? ? d uD
? U??  c s W?? OU?D) U?? F_ u??  d?? BM* d?? I U?? OM?OU?? L
sU??NMu? b??N?F?  Y
 o d?? wU Barry Buzan u?O? U U?
? _ l d?
? U
WOM_ UbK
c d??
? H r?KJ U??O?  W??OUD W??U??L? L? s_ n? d??F s WMM?_ W dE oK?DM
UNM rKJ
? s W?OM WO?C? `?B
? W?O?UL?
? WU? WKJA? Q W dEM
s Y b(U 5F? qU u?I UbM WMM_ b% b b?N
 dD) wU?F qL% U?F
d?N? WKJA? s su r?KJ
Q u? wM b b?N?
? WMO?F W?O?U?L
? WKJA?
b b% s WMM?_ WOKL Q W dEM d?
H wU
?U t
OU? tM_ u b bN?

` d? qJ?A sKF b b b?N?
 d?H? b??
?U WKJA* s? qU?H rKJ
rKJ lO?D
?! qU? q Q ` d? qJA? d?
?H W dEM Q wMF? c t W?{d? tQ
tNu c dD) b bN
 s  ` dB
 vK bI pK1 t vMF0 s_
WOUM s W?"U WO{dH? c Q Wb c w UM bzU! UO?
 iOI vK
q wU?
? R?! dDM nu* c U?? w d??
 q?Ob l oUD
 W?O? IDM*
s_ rK?J vK W?? "? UJ
?? b??  W??OKF??H? W??O? UM? s U??U??L? ' d?? _ pK1
qu?H b? w XGU b? sUNM?u W?b? Q UM U?M b b?N uu ` d?B?


W??U??O???
U????
W?????F????U????? W????O?
b

dze'


W??U?L* c U??N? O? uJ w?
 U?( XK?L wM_ UD) U??
 s_ rK?J vK
Q sO?M d?A q
? rzd? u WK? h
? ? s b?O I? WU?F WOUD)
w rN b; b bN
U ` dB
 s b X?LB e
 sKCH U!M quH iF
s b XL?B w b? bN?
? UO? q?UH?K WKC?H* W?O??Od?
? XU? WU?( c
WOKL Q UM d WO?U s U_ s b% s WMM_ Q wMF cN rKJ

W??U??L? L? UUM? qC??_ s jI?? W??OU?D) W??U??L* vK v?M sJ1 W?MM_
UM U? U?O?U qOK
?
 e? d? v? u?N?L?' U? ? s p W??O?U?L?
?
WMM_ u{u sMQ* WMM_U uI s sMR* 5 WF

sUNMu Wb
w WMM
_ WdE rKJ s
_

UMu s U?O_ t nB UMu? UdUA? s t d u J? s Uu UM
W?GK ULK e?O1 WHK
?? UO?Q t s u?I WMO?F U?L t?
Du eM d? u
UN?b s tU?F UF_ U?
 vK rKJ
* b ? s J s 5uM s c 5
qF??HK Z
M?* d?O? Z
M* ?JK wzUM? d?H?
 c vK? WMM_ W dE? d?H w? wM
W?OzU?A U?F s 5u? 5 dO?N?A John Austin 7 u? e?OO9 s f?
?I*
nzUu w? d?B?
?M w
 W d???) W d d??I?
 W?MO?F?  U?F? U??$ vK u??I w

jI W d!

s
_  UF
X!O Constatives W d dI
 U?F Q J UF_ WU?F t
dE w 7 sO bI
U? b qL
wb?
 dO?F
U W?GK ULF?
 w WMJL* bO?u WOEHK UU?O
 UI w
 WKL?'U cJ bBU UNOK rJ( sJ1 U"?O d nB
WU? W?U? X!?O? d?? l c U?N e q? rF d??I b?I? rd? w
7 U?N?O? L?! w
 WKL??' c w e U?N kHK?
 d?0 ?F? e??M w U/
tM e' UA qFH U$ u WKL'U oDM Performatives WOzUA W U$
U?????? qF???H
U u?? ?
? ?!? ? W? v Speech Acts J? U?? F? ?  7 nM?B
qL?
c U?? wA U?F oDM kH?K W Q u Locutionary Act kHK
 qF?
vMF t uJ U? wA rKJ
 u WU! cJ b?B rJ( lC U d? vMF
d??OQ??
 u Perlocutionary Act kH?K
 d q?F?  d??OQ??
qF??H
UM ld??
t?F? lL?
?!* vK? d?OQ?
K t? s b?N U? w?A t?IDM rKJ
* b? d c u?AM*
tU?dB UJ VU?< U?U!? vK dOQ?
 u b?
 vMF0 5F? qF?H UO?IK


s d??O?  r?KJ
* vK? dR W?? d?? Z?zU??
 u tM? eK
??! U?? w? u?? ?? s
u Illocutionary Act kHK
 u qF wIOI
qFH
dO s d U_
d?0 qF? U$ ? vK U? w u? U w q?F U?$ t J qF?
s W?d?
? W U?$ u  wI?O?I?

? qFH e?O?L?
szd?I s U U? d u?I
s Vd?
* qF?H U?A w oI?
?
c tM u?BI* d?OQ?
 b? w J U?$
t????  U?? w s d? c??
?
? c?? cJ ?? ?  b??u?U?? kHK?
 oDM? W Q
u?
?
?  b? u qF?H v?K U??F uDM?* u? u wI?O?I?
?
 qF?H WU??!?
d??
? t q WU?
J? rKJ
K W?O?u?O U* 7 d??
?F u?G?K U?B vMF?
Illocutionary Forces wI?OI
?
 qF?H u  W dE u? w U W?GK nzU W dE
?F? e?M r?KJ
 oDM W Q 7? bM J U?F? W dE V?!? U? qJA
qFH t!H u uI UB
U oDM q WLzUI WU
K d UG WU
U?O WMM_ W dE vK d?O? d?OQ W?GK wKzU?u Uu?B J UF? W dEM U?
U q s dJ* tUL? w 7 W dE dH qLF
 sUNMu? Wb0 dF U
w bzU??! u??N? H? LK W??Oe??
?  W U* UU??I* s W??HK?
??  W??I dD? s_ W??L?N? H? 
d??O? W??O??
 W? w d??BM* d??I U?O?MOU?L? W U?N l? W?O? ?Od??
? U??b
b? s_ u{u0 oKF?
U?LO? wIO?I?

 qF?H W?OU U?A
? d?H U u?AM
qF WOUD WU?LL u?B vK uI s q b u?NH* ub v? t
U
? tU
s wMO
? n dF U?
 sJ1 U? v dH qu WDO! q?OQ WOKL b?F
sJ1 WGK W dE bU!0 s_ u U uNH* d uD w dONA tULU! b w
w v qO?
 U? fO s_ U?L?F?
? c V!? ? qFH? s_ d??
?F
W dEM wu?N?H? qb? WU0 n d?F?
 c `? qF?H u t w J u?LK
WU w? WOC? q nOMB r
O? J UF? W dE s WMOK W?!MK U?UOI? WMM_
b? WO?IO?I% u? ULKJ p?K
9 d0 W?OM dH0 U?NM rKJ
 d?0 s_
vK b?I rKJ
* qU?H `M1 ? qF?H s?_ n dF Q d?J X w d?H U?
s_ sO?F?  nM v wL?
M U??N vK WMO?F? W?U? n d?F ? s WM?M_ p d?%
r dD c V! U?N
U?; du?
* qzU?u q UL?F
? v Wb qO9 YO?
UU??I* w U?? U?L? UM b??$ u??LK wu??{u? w v? d?O? A s_ b??F
_ sMQ* h?? w UM? b?$ W?O W?O??F?d? s U??? `? U?/ W b?OKI??

_ sJ U??O?I?O? I? U??OKF? b? b?N qJA U??N d?: w?M lU  `??B W?O?C? I
WMM_ qF? s wc b?F? c wB? r?J pc Uu?B?
sMQ* qU?H
UNJ d

 WOU

 uD)U s_ oD rKJ fR _ UI* w WOUD WU2


U? qu??HK W?OUD?) u?I s W?&U W??OKL? WU?? u WMM_ s_ WU??!?
u u??N? H? LK W u??GK? WU??I* c XKJ? b??I JK W??O? I? O? I?
?
 u??IU 7 U??
e?OO?L?
 qI?( a U WU?
bM? sJL* s `? YO
 W?OM_ U?b w W?O1d
UbF U dH q U WKd 5
Politicization fOO!
 Mobilization W"F?
 W dE UNQ WMM_ W dE n sJ1
WGK VFK W dEM s uM c? w dF? u U?L W?O?UO?! W?"?F?
 W dE qIM
b wU?O d? _ uKD* rb b?OM& w W u??F
 W?OKL?F w U?LU?
W?OKL  d?{ dA? tF?{  s `?{ qJA b c rUF? dH b?
d?O? G?
? L? WM?M_ b? d??H nB WMM?_ b?% s ?? b W?G b? WMM_
UH d?F bI r t s rdU b?U!
* uD) s WK?!K w dO WKd? W?O

v W R* Process W??OKL??F d?? w U?? U??u V?N?  t WMM_ `K?DB* U??
d??
UNU

b b% w v
_ qL
 qd  w WU W?HB WMM_ WOKLF c d sJ1
wKF? u b b?N
? d?
?F u c qU?H WO?CI? w U W?OM_ WKJA*
d?N b<U U_ w wU?L
 lU  WKJA* c? uJ U U qL
?

W?OM_ WKJA* b b?% b?F b b?N?
K W?d? WeM vD?F U?N!?O?O?! d?0 sJ ??
v d?H dO?A WKJA* c s rKJ
 ? s WMM_ w W?OU?

? uD) wQ
qJA WDK! W
b
W? w p b?F UN?M rKJ
 W?OM_ WKJA* b?% w
 W"?H
WDK! qU Ud?
F v
 W?OM WOC W?OM_ WKJA* `B
? t!HM V
J U?L U
p" U?NM rKJ v
? W?OM W?O?C? XU? UL?N? WKJA* `?B W?O?H?OJ c?N pc
b b??N?
? qu??H iF n d??F?
 Wb V? u?I YO?? WDK! dz w? u?u*
W?OM U??F U U?C?I iF? vK wH?C 5 w W??O?FDI* U?N? (U?B? l U?O?U?9 W?OM
Q d?H d?
?F YO? W?bK W?OM_ bM_ W?L? v U?N?F? W? u_ W?G?O? U?NzUD
d_ U UCI lOL lu UO UNFu dOG WOM WKJAL WOCI n dF
W?H?u
? vI? U?N_ WMM_ b?( U? d?O? WO?M dH0 W?DK! W??M rKJ sJ
q?L
 c?J 5F u?N?L w 5F?L?
!?* w UD) tb
? c lu
* d?OQ?
 vK
5
O?
 UNUI
? qL

UM WMM uNL?' lL
: wIK w WOU
WKd*
wU rK!* dD d?U?N* Q u?IU? b b?N
K W?DK! n dF? uN?L?' qI U?
qI lL
: w sLON* UD) W UNM w `B
 bUI v WMM_ dAM pc
rKJ w UM
vK W?Hu?
 WMM_ wMF c WMM?_ qAH b b?N
K WDK! n d?F
JK W dOQ
 uIU 7 U U s_


U?LF?
? w W?
U
WKd* wQ U?N?
MMQ u?NL?' UM w WDK!? U$ U? w
b b?N?
 W?N? u* WzU W?O?zUM?
?  uJ U? U??U? d? d??Ob?
 s? W?u?L? ?
`M9 u? b bN?
? WMOF? WO?C? qU n d?F Q WMM_ W dE d?
?H tzu
?
d?% d??L?? U?N?F? qU?F?
K W?OzUM?? d? U?L?F?
 w? o( WDK!
bu?I u! Y?O Normal Politics W U?F WU?O! U? s W?O?CI qI?
M WMM_
cJ b?u??I c?N qL?F? oOKF r
YO?? uD W?U?O?  rU? v W?O?d?I1b
UM?
 WU d? WOd?I1b d oOKF w o?( UO! VU? pK
1
U?NH? U?L WMM_ `?B W?I dD c?N lL
??LK qL?

? wKF? b bN u?
WMO?F WKJA? n d?F
 U?O! VU? uI? WU?
 u? WOKL? Paul Roe u
vK W?Od?A UH?{ U?NOK W?Iu*U u?N?L' VO?
?! V czbM W?OM WO?CI?
v W?IU?! d?I?H W b w Ud? V?! c?N WzUD W?OzUM?
? d?Ob?

d?H b??OM& lL?
? : W?"??F?
 WDK! WKO?? wN? fO?O? !?
 W?"? ?F?
K W d?E WMM_
rKJ
 WOC W vK wUO! lUD UH{ U?C WKO UN UL tOK sLON* UNUD
s qOK?I u?
?% WM?M_ v d?H U?? cU d?_ c??N b b?N?
? WDK! U??NM
WUO! s dOJ s_
vK qUH b UNQ WMM_ n dF UMMJ1 WIU! W qd* lOL&  s
U?L?F?
? r? U?N u?N?L?' UM W?O?M d?H? U?L?F?
?U? WMO?F? WKJA? s? rKJ

d?? _ sU??NMu? W?U?O?  s n d?F?
 c? d?
?I U?N?
?N?u* d?? d?Ob?

c wUJ dOQ
 bS b; W ed WO WOM cN W uI v
 bOIF
U?NU?O? w U?N
?U t?? s w
 b?u?I U? U?N?
 qL?

? 5F u?N?L? qF?
_ U?I* w wU??L?? qU??H s U??? w? WMM_ v U??H d??F?
 c? d?O? A
dU w U/ t sMQ* d?O?L{ u?
!? w sLJ WO W?O?Fd? X!O wU?
U
tu?I U?"?O U?OK? vDF? U?"?O? s_ b?F r vMF* c?N W?OUc W?O?UL?
?
U?OUc U?OU?L?
? vM s_ U/ Rita Taureck u U?
b? R U?L? sMQ*
wN b WMM w WOUc
 wUL
 qUH?
 vK bO Q
 c UI b b
sJ U?N lL?
?: u?? vK nu?
? WMM_ U?$ v o?U? X w UMU? dE
t?I
?
! c wUJ d?O?!H?
 u wUL?
 qU?H?
 `M1 r dH U?( l
qK qL t 5 w s_ rKJ?
s sMQ* qUH vK e?O d rE?F V b?I
WO?UO?I UN?
?! w t?
dE d
?H WU? WH?B uN?L' wIK
* VU? WO?L s
lL?
?: qb vK? nu?
? U?N?U?$ r s_ rKJ d?0 Z
M? WMM_ Q
dH eO? d wM_ qFH U
 W?OU d
?F rKJ
LK Illocutionary Force WOIO?I

 uI


Thierry Balzacq

eU d??O U?? U* t??O?M s rU w?M_ qU??H sMQ?*  vK

d?? d??
?H w
 J U?F? _ 7 W dE w u?u* W??GK U?O?H?!?K uEM
b b?N?
? d?F b?
 U?LKJ k?HK
 oDM W?? !M c w U?O?_ e??M oDM
d??A? u?? N? L? ' u??? ? l{ d??H r? W??OM_ WU?? ( UM v R? u??u
WKJA* W??IU?! W? qd* v? u?dU lu w UM W?MM_ U?$ d?{
UNM rKJ
 WKJA* b b% v_ WKdLK UF U?UL
 v b b$ WMM_ WOKLF
5 d_ 5
Kd* U! vK
vK r?J( s sJL??
 wJ W?MM_ U??
 w u??N?L? ' d??H u??B nO?? dM
U"O? dF c UD qF Q d?H b bI b U
? lu s t
UI? W UH
d? `?B U/ b?u WMM_ oK 5?F ld? u?{u v u? b b?N?
U?
b w uN?L' UNKI v
 jI W?OCI sMQ Securitizing Move wMOQ d%
W d? s J UMMJ1 u?I c q? vK U b?u dH nO?C t
W??'U?F* c u??I U??OKF?? sMQ?? `?? b?? ld* u??{u* fO? jI?? 5Q
d? WMM_ b?u Z
M J qF? UIU? tO U?d U? fJ vK U
M
?
oOI?% lOD
! s?MQ* qUH Q d? d wMF c wM_ qF?H fR oDM
c f? b?? d?? H p? ?? s? `C??
u?? N? ?L? ' q?b b d?? H0 WM?M_
wUc??
 s uJ?
K wzUM? u??B vK? UM
??U? u??N? L? ' rK?J
* 5 W U?? L?
? 
w WOc quH q? s ]b
 WO WOFd? s_ Q b R 5 wH WMM
d??_ d?I? w fO W??OM W??O?C? I? WKJA?? W n d??F _ W??O?U?? X!??O U??I?
? 
W?O?u w d?H uI W?eF* W?O?B??A uI?F w qL?
 W?O?uM c rb?u
WMM WO?UL
? WOUM s qJA? wUc wUD rU s e W?OUL?

nM d?H ? o? b? wU?L?
?  wu?{u? wU? u?G? w _ U?U?
wU? U? b?u u?G wK _ 5K?U2 5HM v `UM J qF? d?
sMQ* 5 U?H?
? s_ qF? Q d?F UM
?? wU?O? wU?L
? wU??
qF? uN?L? sJ sMQ* d?? dI W?
?UM WMM_ d?H u?I UL? u?NL?'
W dE w U?L?U? VFK u?NL?' Q u?I UMMJ1 W?DIM c bM s_
UM sJ wM?OQ d?% d??L? ? qF? q wN?
M tb b?% WMM_ _ d?H
s uN?L' v UdE V s UMd
? ULK U"?OA U"?O l!
 w dNE b? dG
c d?O?!H?
 b sJ? t w uN?L?' u? w sLJ WKJA* W?HK
?? W
W dEM w dH t t
M1

qOK ed
v uNL' U

dO_ c? e
 pc tU?O w uNL?' u vK UH?u
 WMM_ U$ d?H qF
J qF? b d?0 uNL?' dC?
wM_ UD) U?I
? wIK d? w
d c?
M XLB w u?NL' w?H
 VO?G J qF c q? UM sJ r sJ
w uN?L' `?B dO?!H?
 c V! U?OU?L
 W?OM W?OUc UU? WMM_ Q
bu WU( c? w UD)U `CM c Uu JK W d
! u?I U
 t
UB uM qDF V?! tKI
?! UD) uNL?' lL! UL?
 b
dH  W!MU uNL' uM
 U!I b b t_ UN!H WI dDU tOK d d
rU?! t_ rKJ
* s qI
?! w t?!H Xu w W?OUD) WU?LLK w{d? "U
WUL* w WMM_ WOKL? uB
 c dB
ULNMO U?
 s uJ bu tM uJ w
qF b WMM b WOU?L WUL* v?K UMM UM WOUJ wGK WuGK

d?H d?H qF J? qFH w?UL?
? fO u?GK =uJ* vK b?O Q?
 ?
uG?K uB _ W?dH?
 qL d?I lC? b uN?LK? t
dE w W?OU? WU?!
b uN?L' sJ r W?O
M W dEM w d?O!H d?OG
L? WOF?OD t
UJ t?K WMM
ld* u{u* sMQ* qUH U UL t
dE w qOK

 e d
uN?L' U ? s dH t d c d?H q o X w 5U? iF U
WM?M_ W dE?M wH?? !KH? uEM* u?? I 5? w qO?K
??
? e?? d??  v l?L?
? ?:
uEM* b R rKJ
* s qI?
! UOK? vDF UOJ U
?  s uNL?' e
U
uEM* c V! uNL' sMQ* 5 U* suJ
vK WGK q b wU?L

uB
 c Q s _ W?OH!KH WUI* d
H UL? uNL' oK J qF
v u?N?L?' U?? wU?
U J qF?H? w{d? "U d?? v u?N? L?' u?

dL fO? UDK Z
M UOJ UOzb uB r
V? W dEM w wFOD tUJ
Xu w rKJ
? lL
?!L? u?NL?' uB V tQ wM?F c VU q?I
?! oK
?
dA w bU! t_ rKJ
 WLI s UO?! VU UD rK
! t_ lL
! t!H
d? vMF0 t?C tu?? WDK vK UM t?U?$ dI b?U?I v UD) p
b?u W?" v t?U W?FU qOK% b d?L? U?
 u?NL?' e
? V
uN?L' U?
? US wC?I WMM_ WO?KLF b?O rN v?K uB?( WL?!M
W? uM w 5HK
?? s bU?A? v t?L?O?!?I p s r_ UDK W??
M u?I?
WO!M uI 5OUL
 bF


 UH
 c fJF s_ rKJ vK U?N!H bI uOK; bUA* pK1
WO?! Wu?N WO?FL?
: U"?H iF b& qu?HK WO?!M u?I wUL
? lu* w


Wu?F d? U?" t?u U?LMO lL?
: w sL?O?N* UD) U
 w? WLU?!* w
u?NL?' rU rKJ
s u? R! U?H
? c dO? UOK? WOUJ c s d?

U??!? R* ?? s U/ t??!? HM rK?J
lL??
? : v d??H U?? b??I lL??
? :
rd?O? s b? b? qu?H iF Q? t!?H? Xu w d?
? b? tK qu?H
r lL??
? : rU r?KJ
 vK U??I R? r s lL??
? : rU b??
?
? vK
dJ v WUU R?! c s WU vH
? oO qJA quH R d?H b

wU?
U W??u?L?: d?F W u?N Q d??
?H w
 Societal Security wF?L??: s_
rKJ
 rNu? WMO?F? WO?F?L?
? W u v u?L?
M c p" r 5LKJ
* qu?H `?B
UL U?FL
: sJ? UL!M lL?
: U jI `O?
 c sJ s
M rU
w U!R* W]OdN WO dONU W"OK s U
 b b t!HM dH d
F
wU??L? ?
?  lu*U? uM wM?_ rKJ
 `?? B wF?? L?
? : fU?? & uM
? c q
U?N WO? d?ON? w tF?u? qUHK? w!M n?FCu?I W?O?!M tu? rKJ
?LK
X w U U0 wUJ? U
 U?NDF r dH sJ wM_ qI?( vK WLN? dOQ
W U??!?
?  X!?O lO??{u* 5 W???F v U?? U?bM? d?G?? c b o
qU?H tK?
?
c lu* V!? U?H?
?
? WMM_ U?$ W?OUJ W?KU?L?
?
WMM?_ UD v U??L?
? ? u??F? OD
??! U? u??_ bU??A* Q U?? q?JA Z
?M
??!
UD) uK?I?
?!? b? U?H?F?C bU?A* U?LMO id? u??IU t?F? U??

lL?
?!* 5 lU? U? U?M vMF? d?OQ rN?C? rNu??I? uJ WKL?
_ uM l dH V! WMM_ oI

 p  XUB lL
!* rKJ
*
w U? `C
? WMM_ W dE w? oOK qJA t?HOu r
W?O?!M u?I u?NH?
5KK?; b?? ld* u??{u*U sM?Q* qU??HU u??N? L? 'U WD?d? W??O? U??
WFL
 W UUOJ c v U?Nu!M U qJA eM qFH uJ vK Ud
d?O?  qF?H U??$ Q d?
?  d? W??G?O?  w ?U? u?J wMF U u?? uJ
u?I lu* u?I? wU?L?
? t?U?O? vK U?C? sJ W u?GK t?
?OM? vK nu?
?
p ld* u??{u* sMQ?LK? W?O??!M? u?IU WU?I?  d q u?N?L? K W?O?? !M
uJK1 s c s bUA* s W?!UM
 U0 WHK?
 u 5 WL?!I w 5!
w U( s dO w uNL' uJ UOU UN
U2 UJ u WM U
 OCH
wA tQ ld?* u{u?LK o?Ob? n d?F
? ld* u?{uL?K U d?{ UuJ t
uJ UO_ rEF w UIU WUD* w d?A* o( pK1 c U u ]bN*
weM* nMFK U{dF* U!MU lL
: uNL' s e U u ]bN* wA c
s e?? s? t Xu w? U u?? b? N?  s?N_ ld?? u??{u??  d???
? F? ??? 


W??O?? !M u??I d sJ1 d?? V?? UM lL??
?: w s b?U?A* u??N?L? '
W?OuM WMM_ W dE w W?O?!M u?I jd uN?L' d?OG?
 l? WUI*U sMQ* qU?HK
U??I W??"? H? c w d??H lC? YO?? wU??L?
?  t??F? u?? s?_ rKJ
c? qU??H
W? w d vMF0 UdO jG?C UuL? UuJ( WOd?dO 5OU?O!
UF w quH R q VFK wLd dO lu UUMF0 WDK! Wb
U u? rN_ vMF0 qIM U u? ]b?N d?O? rU?I _ ld* u?{u*
Wb U?? b?? w Statecraft rJ( u??_ U? d? vMF?? WMM? d?H? wDF
n dF?
 cN W W?OzUM
 d?Ob
 d U?LF
U 5?F UD 5Q vK
W?O?F? u?
 s Post-structural Realism W u?OM b?F W?O?F? WU?I? s d?H d?
?

Neoclassical Realism WOJO uO
c lu* rJ
d?O W?O! u? pK
1 WDK! sMQ* qUH Q d?H d
?H ULMO
]b? N* wA t??H d??F? rJ
 U??N W??O? U??) ld* u??{u* v q?O?
? tK
??

t WIOI w nFC c bB sL?J nOF{ UO u ld* u{u* S U u
WMM_ qF? vK W U?!?
? b? d?H t?
M1 r V?! c?N s_ rKJ vK U? d?O?
Ud? U?L? ld* u?{u* l w sLJ? U?C nF?C c?N d?? b?B? UM
U? t_ s_ r?KJ u? s t?d? d??H S? pc u?N?L? ' u uJ U? U?U?? U?IU?
WKI??
? !?  W??OUD? u?? t??
M1 r WDK?! rKJ
?* UD w u??N? L? ' e??
? U
5b? s uJ
? W?O?F?u W?O?UM s WMM_ W? dE Q dD c vK UM? Z
M
?!
tFM?1 c ld* u{u* rKJ
 vK b?I uI t?Fu? t
M1 c sMQ* q?UH
rKJ
 s nOFC tFu
s p?K1 ld* u?? {u?* Q wMF? lu* u?? I v?K fR?* rO?? !? ?I?
? c
ld?* u?? {u* `?? B U?? b?M lu? w rz qJ?A s_ r?KJ v?K b?? I pK?
1
d?B wF?O?D s `?B wU?
?U wM_ qU?H W?H? V!?
JO? tzU?I w b?N?
XL?B?U b b?N?
 t?u s u?? d? U?? F b b?N?
?K u?{u?L? t?!?H s? sKF
s dL
U u?LKJ
WO d
 b( v s U?H 5 u! 5" tM uJ!
v u?U?
?
r W?O?? Wb rOEM U?b?S W?OK_ d?(U b?N* rNU?O?
U?L? W u?! WDK?! WU?( c? w sMQ* qU?H? _ rN?
MMQ? u?I?O d?? h?
w
 U( w tQ wMF? c b bN
 bB? t w u VzU U d?H UN{d?
H
vK ld* u?{u* bL?
F V WM?M_ vK U u?u WDK! U?NO? uJ
uF? WO?Od
? wM tO?K Vu
W?OM_ WU?LLK u?{uL? t!O?Q w t!?H
.Self-help wc


r u U? rKJ?
 s ld* u?{u* sJL?
r? u U? UM sLJ WMM?_ WKC?F? sJ
WG?OB dD w UI? tUO Q ? ` dB
 s U u? ]bN* qU?H lD
!
r WU?F bO?I s_ rKJ vK qU?H b XU WM?M_ b% q b b% d?
U? U?OK?? vDF? w J vK q?U?H b? Q d?
? WK"?_ c? d?H dD
uB?
 cN qU?HK wUL?
 lu* uI? U
 fO uU W?!
J W?Ou t?A
rKJ ]bN* qUH UN?O lOD
! w
 U( s v{UG J qFH wuu?O t
WE* c UuI W?HOFC W?O!M tu? WO dO?N w wb
* tFu? V! s_
w WOU?L
 WU2 w U/ W uG W?OM d X!O WMM_ vK bO? Q
 U v
W??OUD? d?O?  W??OU?D uJ sJ?1 WMM_ Q e?U l oH??
 s
? pc U??_
UM w
 dJH U?N w qF X!?O sJ WOzU?A bL?F
? dO? bL?F
?
qI W? d?O? ? F u? p?K1 t_ U??C WMM_ Z
?M XL??B w wU??
 r!??I w U??N
UOIK lL
: q? W!R* uI U w c
 u? w J qF s WOL
U?!M b? b? U?? w Y
? ? s XL?B dU? UA?J
?U b?M pc
W dE W?O?b?B? U?
?
? l
?2 d?_ t sb?{ U?L* nMFU ` d?B?
 r?KJ
 vK
dd d?? _ W?O?F?
?: W??
d?A d u d??H nu? uJO? n?O? qO??
 ?J qF?
UNUD c b bN
U ` dB
 rKJ
 vK U dO U!M

UHFC UD XLB u

v Lene Hansen s!U 5? U? l UD vK W??!??
? I? W?OJ?O?? WU??I? w
dUE t?
H U?LO? s_ qF b? wM_ qUH U?NO? lOD
! U? u
b?F X u?B W?OUJ c?F?
 v?
? UU?I?
 w? dUE c b?% XL?B? s_
r
c b b?N
? nUC b? O?
?
!? WO?M WKJAL? w l uJ U?bM s_
Q s!U X
 U
?! U w dA rzd U( UN?
  s t
Nu
UeU? sN?U??N s U??u?? XL??B e?
? sKC??H U?B?
?  s{d??F?
? wz U??!M
s wFd* u?{u* pK1 U( c q w d?A rzd' U U
{ sN?u
WU?
? v s!U d?O?!?H V!? V?! ld W?OM_ t?
K?JA? rKJ vK b?I
XU? cN lL?
?:U sNOK q?JA* b bN?
 W?HU?C0 dU?
? sN!?H 5Q U?!M
UJ XL??B w VU?G w U??OU?
?!? U?? U?!M q? s U??
?< W?O??O?d?
?
WdF WU( X
 U w dN
eO? d
 s_ rKJ?
 WOF?O W?OK u? pK1 wM_ qUH Q? s!U W? b R
u{uLK q b wM? UD XLB WOL V?
wNHA J qF  t?
 U vK


sO? U?
? U? b? d?O?_ uM! b??N? s!U WU? w U??!M ld*
W dEM? 5!?% W??F?d??L? U??N?LE?F? U?? b? Qua Silere XL?B?K W?OUD?) u?I
UJ U?O?Od
? W?) ? UF?_ dO?N? W wH? J UF?_ 7
UJ XL??B s u? W 5 Rae Langton u??
 e?O?  U??N W?I? d*
W?H?O? F?{ W?u?L?? e??
K b? 7 U?N? d?
? w
 J U??F? qA? vK W??OM?
U!M wL
M rNO lL
!O b? Q bI
F rN_ uHzU UdUM _ XLB
oH?? U??IKD U??LK?JU oDM r?
YO?? XL??B s uM c? v U??OU??
?!? U??
sJ U??O?_ iF w? W?u??L?: rKJ
? b? U?OU U??  qF??H w u?L?KJ
*
w rKJ
* o?H W?U( c w? uB?I* d?OQ?
 b? w rNU?LK oH??
?
u?B?I* d?OQ
 b? w qA?H U?NMJ W?u?L?: rKJ
 b? U
U d?OQ
 qF?H
U??L?KJ r W?U??( c w? b??B? I? c t qF?? H w oH??  U/ j?I? 
bF UM
b rN u
 qOK% wIOI

? qFH w oH rKJ
* WuDM
b??  u XL?? B U??
 w r?N?  q?U?? n?MF b b?? N? ?
 Q s?O? ? U??? ?
tFM0 fO UJ v rKJ
* dF
b UOU UJ w WKL?F
!* UOOd

U?
 XL??BrKJ
 U?U u??B?I* d?OQ U?$ s? t?FM0 sJ U?LK?J oD s
UJ U?O??Od?
? _ b W?L?N? d?O?_ WDIM c qu?H 5 u?I U??F
vK d?R J UF? vK bI uJ? b quH 5 u?I u vK WO?M
XM U?H?FC? s d? J U u? sJ1 u?
 u?I U?L? WO?U?O?! WDK!
vK U? rK?J
 U? sJ pU?LKJ U?NK?F?H sJ1 d?O?? U?O? UM U u?
u?N U?OK U?
? fO XLBU? U?!?
 d?CU fO XL?B S u?I
U??L? d? d?? XL??B qF?? U?? u J? U?O?  U/ J? U?O?  d??? w?MF
U?) s U??{d?H? XL??B uJ b? W??d? Cheryl Glenn ? q d??O? U?
b?F U d?CU uJ s u? wU
U 5?F vMF? qL?
wJO?
J U?O
? U/
R U?? O? ? XL?? B U?? O? {U? d w d?? H? ?B q??  U/ u?? ; d?? H u?? I
UF s Z
M
UD) Q d u 7 ` W dO* s uJ b WHO
W dOQ WOIOI% u UC pK1 XLB jI J
lO?L? ' U?U??
? fO s_ rK?J U?C d??H  WKJA?? XL?BK wzU?M rN?H c? qJA
WHUC UIF s u) V! U qFH lOD
! UNCF _ quH
uIH rNMJ ULKJ oD s_ rKJ s uMJL
b p s u_ rNOK s
s_ rKJ? U? wU?
U? rN?!?H 5?Q tb?B?I? c wI?O? I?
?
 qF??H w
W?LJ XL?B bO?H? 5Q W?O?Od?
? XLB? `B u? qU?H W?OF?{ qF?


=uJ U?I?K W?O? ?Od?
? u?N? d? nzU XL?B b? 5Q?
? c vK U
vK e? d?
W?b c w UMU?L?
 r W?U?I?LK WKO? W?U?L?K du?
UM
??( W??L?N? W?U?I?LK WK?O?u? XL?B dJ U??I? XL?BK W?OM?_ W?H?Ou
W?O? d??O?N w rN?F?u?? qu?H 5 W?"? UJ
? u?I U???F WDd? U??N_ U?C
XL?BK WOUD?) UF_ U?AJ
U?  q d?O XU? U?* qO? vK W?OU?L
?
UbM WOUO! WOUL
 WUIK WOUC WDK! UI sJ1 u! luL
s dOF ? qL
bI WUI?LK WKO `B tS qUHK UO U?O
 XLB uJ
WKO XL?B uJ b W u?F
 Uu?N U? WKO WDK! d?OU b i
U bI WUD UH s dOF uJ  lL
?LK WOUC buI WUI* UC
WDK! U?{dH? UUJ XL?B uJ v
 qU?I*U UJ Tu?
K O?9 uJ
UN
UI WDK! c vK q U

K dJ* s Ud{ uJ sJ1 WOU

W9U
U?
E? UM W?b c w dF?* qOK
?
 s WB?K
?!* ZzU?
M r w U?
U? qJA W b?IM W?O?M_ U?b sU?NMu? W?b0 oKF?
U? w U?
?O?U?
?
UD) U??
 s_ rKJ vK W??OM_ qu?H? b? vK e?O? d?
U b* c? u?I
s WM?O? F?  U/_ 5F??{U??) u??  qu??H? qL??N pc U??N? U??O?  w? wM_
U?NUL?S UD) uB?K W UO?F? WO?uuD W?O?I? WMM_ W? dE wDF UJ
Ue?O? d W b?IM W?OM_ U?b d?B?% lL
?!* rK?J
L?K W"?UJ
? u?I U??F
U u_ polemology UOuuLOu vK
d??B?
w?M_ rKJ
 v?K b?I s?_ ? U??F? v?K d?B? ( e??O? d??
 U?OU
Z
M s?J1 w
 d?_ W??O?U?L?
? U??U?L* qL??N W u?GK? W?U?L* w? WMM_
UM UL WOUD dO WOU?D uJ sJ1 eU b R UL WMM_ WMM_
WO?UL?
 U?UL* W?O?
M XLB?  s UD) Z
M sJ1 W?b c w
u?I q?L?N b? J v?K W b?IM W??OM_ U?b e?O? d wU?
U _ U??I* w
wCH b w
 WHK
?< UUL* wM_ UD) U
 w quHK W"UJ
? WO!M
Ud?? f?O J r? W??L? N?  WE??? v t uM?
 s b UM? WMM_ U??
 v
wCH* w?MOQ
 d?

  w rU? qU vI? tMJ ]bN* qU?H WMM_ U d
U?F?  b? s_ rKJ?
 W??O?
M U?Lz W?MM_ b?% t??!?H Xu w W?MM
bA WUF bOI UO_ s dO w uJ
 rKJ
 vK quH b _ J

g
uN
John L.Austin, How to Do Things with Words (Oxford: Clarendon Press,1962),
pp.5,6-7.
wUO U? n w fO lDU WU) U?UM* w WKL'U kHK
 WK?_ c s `C
7 V
J
u WKL'U oD?M q qFH pc ULzU? wu X b w UL? u
M c vK b?% w qFHU
vK? o b??B? ?
 vK? tM w b? U??N k?HK
* U?? ? ?F s UM? td?? U??  r UU?? A UU?? $
tOK W( d w UM bzU tu{ t
b wA c vK rJ( V w q V cJ

Austin, pp.94,108.
Austin, p.101.
Austin, p.99.
Austin, p.99.
Ole Wver, "Securitization and Desecuritization", in Ronnie D. Lipschutz, ed.,
On Security (New York: Colombia University Press,1995), p 55.
bB* s b bA
)
Ole Wver, "Security, the Speech Act Analysing the Politics of a Word," Paper
presented at the Research Training Seminar, Sostrup Manor, Jerusalem/Tel Aviv,
June 1989, p.42.
Barry Buzan, Ole Wver and Jaap de Wilde, Security: A New Framework for
Analysis (Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner,1998), p.25.
dE
J.P. Nettl, Political Mobilization: A Sociological Analysis of Methods and Concepts
(Basic Books,1967); David R. Cameron, "Toward a Theory of Political Mobilization," The Journal of Politics, Vol. 36, No. 1 (Feb., 1974), pp. 138-171.
w e?
? sJ1 W?OKL?F s rdU W?"?F?
 w U?L?U? WGK? VFK fU?Lu?O nO? u?I
WdA W?OM_ WGK b?
 s_ U?Fu vK d?O U?L
 W?OU?L
 W?"F?
 bL
?F b u?G VU
W?OU?
? U? d( W?OU?L
? UD_ `O?{u
 ? qzU? W dJ!F W?d?F* U
 s_ U?
U?N W?GK w W?OM_ U? UC?I? s WU?
J J a U?N b?B?
K W?HK
?< U?J_ b b?N?
 l vK
dE WOKUJ b
Jef Huysmans, "Defining Social Constructivism in Security Studies: the Normative
Dilemma of Writing Security," Alternatives, Vol.27 (2002),p.44.
Wver, "Securitization and Desecuritization,"Op.Cit., pp 54, 56.
wLKF e?? d* s_ n d?F U?? b b? UU?I? W b??IM W?OM_ U??b wKO?u? b?L? b?O?
v U u? b b?N qJA U?N vK? WO?C? b?I U?bM d?H u?I W?O?U?O?! U?bK
U U?N
?'UF* WOzU?M
 d? UL?F
 W?OM_ b bN?
K WU?) WFO?D d 5F? ld u?{u
W?'U?F* W??U? UDK c? W??"??F?
 Wb U?? o dD `
? tM?J u?I b??
?  l d?A?
 U?U??
?H? s_
s W dC W?OuM UL? U v WOM_ WKJA?LK dD{ lUD dH ld W uu b b?N

s_ UD w W?U?O?! u? U?N?Fd W?U?O?! w W u? U U?C?I wJOU?b qO??L?
 w W?O?uM pK
WU?( qUH wb sQ U?NH dF?
 cJ UOKF W u_ W?OCI? bI wJOU l?U WOC?I vK vHC
dE WOzUM
 qzUuU UN
'UF* o(


Buzan, Wver and de Wilde, Security: A New Framework for Analysis, Op.Cit., pp
21,26.
Wver, "Securitization and Desecuritization,"Op.Cit., pp 69-70.
o bB 5 WOU?O! W{UF* Q d c WOzUM
 u XO?L U UJ vK WMM_ W dE wM
s Xd?
? WO?U?O? X
? U?LK W?uLK W?u?B?) `B?YO
 U?dD U?U?!I? d? qJA b?F
dE bF o bB lL& w UdD d _ WDIM
Carl Schmitt,The Concept of the Political, Tans. by George D. Schwab (Chicago:
University of Chicago Press, 1996), p 37.
n d?F v tF? U c W?OuU?I U* vK u?I sJ1 wzUM?
 qF? d? UEM UM Q XO?L b?I
?F
w UO! dONA tU? w UNF{ UL UM
 WU ? tMJ1 c hA UN vK UO!
dE UM
 WU dI w

Carl Schmitt, Political Theology: Four Chapters on the Concept of Sovereignty,
Trans. by George D. Schwab (MIT Press, 1985), p.1.
Buzan, Wver and de Wilde, Security: A New Framework for Analy-
sis,Op.Cit.,pp.21,25; 224.Rita Taureck, "Securitization Theory and Securitization
Studies," Journal of International Relations and Development, Vol.9
(2006),pp.54-55;90. C.A.S.E. Collective, "Critical Approaches to Security in Europe:A Networked Manifesto," Security Dialogue, Vol. 37, No. 4 (Dec.,2006),
p.453.
Paul Roe, "Securitization and Minority Rights: Conditions of Desecuritiza-
tion,"Security Dialogue , Vol. 35, No. 3 (Sept.,2004), p.281.
Wver, "Securitization and Desecuritization,"Op.Cit., p,56.
uM U WOCI dR W?FK W!R* buI bF U WUO! c?Q c d

 u s_ d UJ w V

dE fOO!
 s UdD d W!M WMM dEM sJ1 cJ WUO! uH WUO! s U
Buzan,Wver and de Wilde, Security: A New Framework for Analysis, Op. Cit.,
p.23.
U??OU W u??u b b??N?
 uD? UuJ W v? WMM_ b r?!? b?? d??H v UM? uM
dE buI s U interunit bu 5 UF w dOQ
 UU qF
!* qLF
Buzan, Wver and de Wilde, Security: A New Framework for Analysis, Op. Cit.,
p.26.
lL??
? WMM_ d?  t?O? V
?? b? eU d?O? t?b? c p s U??C WMM n? d?F?
 c d??
?I
W?O?M u? d??O? W?O? U?O?   U?F?
? W U??  W?"? ?F r
Y?O? U?U??L* s u??{u?
u?NL?' l vK qLF c sMQ?* qUH q? s wUO? qJA a nu? WFzU? UJ dUM
ld u?{u* rU( nF?C u U?ON b UJ fO?U d?UA ZzU?
M s WJU?L
 WJ? UM
d?O? bN* W?F?O?D WU?N ld* u?{u* WU?S sMQ* qU?H U?L? UO?
? W?
KB? l wI?
K c
dE Ud uD lM* W u WUO VKD
 w
 Wu!*
Thierry Balzacq, "A Theory of Securitization: Origins, Core Assumptions, and Variants,"in Thierry Balzacq,ed., Securitization Theory: How Security Problems
Emerge and Dissolve (London & N.Y.: Routledge, 2011), p.3.
b bN?
 dD{ W u u? W W?UO? WDu sMQ* qU?H UD
 U?N dI?H w uH?OC
dE WMM WU bNA s
 tUO w UN bOIO w u w
 buI d s  uu


Buzan, Wver and de Wilde, Security: A New Framework for Analysis, Op.Cit.,
p.25.
Rens van Munster, "Logics of Security: The Copenhagen School, Risk Manage-
ment and the War on Terror,"Political Science Publications, Syddansk Universitet Denmark,10/2005,p.3.
u U fO qU?H dI U? t vMF0 WO WO?Fd u? s_ v UIU Ud? UM v UI t?
M V
d? 5KU 5 r
 U?N vMF0 WO WO?Fd X!?O WOUc WMM_ v UM d?OA U?LMO F u?u
b e* W?OUc WMM_ ULMO? WO W?OF?d s_  b? 5 qJA* rNH qU?H
 c?N oI
?

dE eOOL
 c u qOBH
 s
Buzan, Wver and de Wilde, Security: A New Framework for Analysis, Op.Cit.,
pp.29-31.
Rita Taureck, "Positive and Negative Securitisation - Bringing Together Securit-
isation Theory and Normative Critical Security Studies," Paper prepared for the
COST Doctoral Training School 'Critical Approaches to Security in Europe',
ACTION A24 : The evolving social construction of threats" Centre Europen,
Institut d'Etudes Politiques de Paris, France, June 16-18, 2005,p.3.
Balzacq, "A Theory of Securitization," Op. Cit.,p.1.
Buzan, Wver and de Wilde, Security: A New Framework for Analysis,
Op.Cit., p.25.
Buzan, Wver and de Wilde, Security: A New Framework for Analysis,
Op.Cit., p.31.
Buzan, Wver and de Wilde, Security: A New Framework for Analy-
sis,Op.Cit.,pp.26,31.
 dE
Thierry Balzacq and Sarah Leonard,Theory and Evidence in Securitization Studies
(Mimeo,2009); J. Ruzicka,"Have you Seen a Failure Recently? Why Failed Cases of Securitization Matter," Paper presented at the Annual Convention of the International Studies Association (ISA), New York City, NY: 15-18 February,
2009.
Balzacq, "A Theory of Securitization," Op. Cit.,p.2.
Balzacq, "A Theory of Securitization," Op. Cit.,p.7.
Wver, "Securitization and Desecuritization,"Op.Cit.,pp,69-70.
Loc.Cit.
d ULKJ s_ u tM rKJ
 r
c lu* vK dO b v? bI bL
F fULuO nO V
J
nu* v s?  d?O?A? wd? qJA U??M s_ s J? tMJ1 s w!??Ozd R?! `??B
d
H d? UF uI s_ nu* fH w h? q oDM cJ d_ s b WOF?L
:
dE UOUL
 l{uL
s_ qUH rKJ YO Ud b

Huysmans, "Defining Social Constructivism in Security Studies.."Op.Cit.,p.53.
Buzan, Wver and de Wilde, Security: A New Framework for Analy-
sis,Op.Cit.,p.31.
Buzan, Wver and de Wilde, Security: A New Framework for Analy-


sis,Op.Cit.,p.36.
Wver, "Securitization and Desecuritization,"Op.Cit.,pp,54-56.
Buzan, Wver and de Wilde, Security: A New Framework for Analy-
sis,Op.Cit.,p.41.
w W uOM bF WOF UNQ dBM* dI UOMO?F! lKD w s WK b W uGK t
UI dH d bI
WO?FuK W uO?M bF WUI? w vMF* cN U?NM W e
u W?!M fO sJ U qJA W?OFu? v wL
M
W uOM b?F WOb bF W?OJOJH WUI vK uI w t?!H Xu w WOJOJ? Uc v u
W?OL?!?
 b?B p s W?O?F?uK WOJ?OJH
 WU?I* s u w w?U
U b d? U U?L? w vK?
 UL?
UNMJ W?OF?uK W uOM b?F U d w W u?OM bF W?OF?u WOL?!
 dH? uI W uOM b?F WO?F
W?I dD c?N? wJOJH?
 b?IMK? w!?Ozd u?{u* e?
  W u?O?M W?O?F?u v U? qJA? W b?F U?C
U U?
{ fO t?!H Xu w UN?U WO?Fu q U? WI dD w WO?JOJ rOUH* vK? UM
U
dE pc X! UOF XM
Wver, "Security, the Speech Act Analysing the Politics of a Word,"Op. Cit.,p.38.
uKLF
 s c qz_ 5 s tKF? dH UL w Wb U bu u
! d?O!H wM Q uI UMMJ1
WOJO u?OM WOFuU uO dF U W?OzUM WUILK o tOM w wJO u?OM wFu qOK


WOJOJ WOFu WOUL
 WOzUM 5 UB c w fULuO nO ou V! cN WOzUM
dE WOb UFK b rN dH qL qF
Huysmans, "Defining Social Constructivism in Security Studies.."Op.Cit.,p.54.
Balzacq, "A Theory of Securitization," Op. Cit.,p.2.
Lene Hansen, "The Little Mermaid's Silent Security Dilemma and the Absence
of Gender in the Copenhagen School," Millennium - Journal of International
Studies, Vol.29, No.2 (2000), p.287.
Hansen, "The Little Mermaid's Silent Security Dilemma and the Absence of
Gender in the Copenhagen School,"Op.Cit.,p.294-5.
Langton, "Speech Acts and Unspeakable Acts,"Op.Cit.,pp.314-5.
Langton, "Speech Acts and Unspeakable Acts,"Op.Cit.,pp.98-9.
Xavier Guillaume, "The Sound of Silence: Voice, Security and the Mundane,"
DPIR Seminar, University of Sussex October, 2013, p.14.
Cheryl Glenn, "Silence: A Rhetoric Art for Resisting Discipline(s)," Journal of
Advanced Composition, Vol. 22, No. 2 (2002), p.263.
Alexander Bird, "Illocutionary Silencing," Pacific Philosophical Quarterly,
Vol.83 (2002),pp.1-2.
dE WULK du' s uJ
 u
Kennan Ferguson, "Silence: A Politics," Contemporary Political Theory, Vol. 2
(2003), pp.49-65.
Glenn, "Silence..,"Op.Cit.,p.262.
Glenn, "Silence..,"Op.Cit.,pp.263-4.
Guillaume, "The Sound of Silence..," Op.Cit.,p.17.
Balzacq, "A theory of Securitization..," Op.Cit.,p.2.