Applications of Tactical Mapping Figure 3: Mapping out from the Center Relationship
Tactical mapping can be used to think about the International Regional &
NGOs United Nations
following questions: Government conventions &
Institutions, laws, monitoring bodies
t 8IJDILFZSFMBUJPOTIJQTOFFEUPCFBòFDUFE mechanisms available, etc.
to move your issue and strategy forward?
Police education
t 8IJDIUBDUJDTBSFDVSSFOUMZBUQMBZPS & training
Judicial system
available? A concrete
“face to face”relationship
t )PXEPUIFTFUBDUJDTBòFDUUIFDPOUFYU
that best represents
your issue
organizations, key relationships, etc., you
Victim related
want to target? Professional Family, organizations,
associations community of faith
t 8IJDILFZJOTUJUVUJPOT
TPDJBMHSPVQTPSSFMB-
Nongovernment
tionships are unaffected by current tactics? Business, media, civil society, International
religious bodies economic bodies
t 8IJDIUBDUJDTNJHIUCFVTFEUPFOHBHFUIF IMF, WB, WTO,
regional bodies
areas currently unaffected? International (e.g., ASEAN),
professional private business,
t $BOQPUFOUJBMBMMJFTCFJEFOUJöFEGPSCVJME- associations NGO funders
ing a more comprehensive and effective
strategy? The second task is to map relationships that affect the center but don’t have a direct relationship with the “center” relationship (see ovals).
The third task is to map the international or external relationships that affect the center relationships (see rectangles).
s "Y PROVIDING A REPOSITORY OF RELATIONAL abuses, the impact of existing tactics, in analyzing their terrain to determine
networks and associated tactics that and additional targets in need of inter- options for action.
other actors can use in similar situ- vention. Consider that a torturer is con- The development of more technologi-
ations, the mapping tool serves the nected organizationally, professionally, cal tools, such as database systems, to
larger context of generating strategic and socially. In order to create change house the research collected and feed
thinking within the human-rights com- within these various relationships, it is this wealth of information into a tactical
munity at large. important to understand which individu- mapping program would greatly increase
By identifying the complex relation- als or organizations can do so already the adaptability and response time for
ships involved in human-rights issues, or be put in place to do so. A tactic, for significant change in the human-rights
organizations benefit greatly from such example, may target the torturers’ mem- arena.
research systems. By coupling this bership in a police union or association, Each of these contexts requires
information with a tactical mapping which may in turn provide an oppor- ongoing research to understand the
tool, civil-society organizations, interna- tunity to work through professional systems and people involved in human-
tional organizations, and governments associations that reach across national rights abuses—and that means those
can better use the data to develop more boundaries, thus exerting pressure from who make bad decisions as well as those
comprehensive strategies to combat within and outside. who could protect human rights. Cer-
human-rights abuses. Mapping these relationships can be tainly, activists on the ground have begun
Once the tactical map diagram is done with simple tools at the grassroots to collect this information. Building col-
“complete,” it can then “map tactics” level: with a stick to outline relationships laborative partnerships with sociologists,
and create understanding about which in the dirt, with Post-its, or on paper with political scientists, and other academics
relationship(s) each tactic is expected to colored pens. A class of students at the can help enhance this research. New
affect and how. University of Iowa, for example, used Tactics is especially interested in docu-
The process of mapping relationships a Post-it method to highlight concern menting tactical interventions and evalu-
and identifying current and potential about a sexual harassment incident ating their results so that others can gain
tactics creates a diagnosis of the situa- on campus. The tactical map tool pro- insight into possible interventions for
tion in a given context, including the key vides an excellent medium for seasoned their own settings.
relationships surrounding human-rights human-rights advocates and students In our experience, the tactical
MN Dept of Education
and relationships that enriched the map
MN DHS HealthNet
National and knowledge among the group.
Public schools Discovering common targets and
Health: MFIP Pre, Elem, MS & HS tactics. Two groups had a grant by the
MA, GAMC, GA HealthNet
MNCare WIC Minnesota same foundation to write about the
Teachers impact on Guantánamo prisoners (from
Cty soc Provider Patient School SW
the legal and medical/psychological per-
serv offices
spectives). They collaborated and wrote
Doctor M adult School nurse
Local NGO a comprehensive report that has been
agencies Nurse F adult one of the few resources cited and used
Midwife Adolesc African
on Capitol Hill. Two other groups that
St. Mary’s community had planned action in Washington, D.C.,
clinics MH practitioner Child NGOs
on the same day worked together to
Park Nicollet expand the scope of each group’s action.
Health Services Building new collaborations.
Provider
network Housing
resident mgrs
Parish nurse Several organizations forged stronger alli-
NW Hen.
Healthy Comm ances that led to new campaign actions.
Planned Public Religious In July 2007, CVT’s New Neighbors,
Park Nicollet CVT-NNHS institutions
Parenthood housing Hidden Scars project used the tactical
Foundation
map tool to examine and evaluate the
progress toward building an effective
One way (power) Two way (mutual benefit) More information needed health-provider network for refugees in
a Minnesota community (see figure 5 on
Figure 5 provides an example of how to use tactical mapping to depict a state-level organization’s internal and external relationships. page 98). As the project neared its end,
the visual tactical map tool provided
of the main causes for difficulties in This application of the tool explored focus on the remaining steps required
the overall litigation process—apart possibilities for future collaboration for bringing together health-care pro-
from corrupt local administration of civil-society actors to promote and viders and refugee groups to deliver
that back[s] mining companies and protect the human rights of herder better health-care services to the refugee
low community awareness to collec- groups at extractive mining sites and community.
tively claim rights—was lack of judi- resulted in the development of tactics Over the course of just a few years, the
cial precedent and reference tools that had not been considered to uphold tactical mapping tool has provided numer-
for the defense to quantify damages these rights. ous organizations with a fresh outlook on
endured from environmental degra- In November 2006, CVT and New how to prevent torture. It provides not
dation and loss of livelihoods for the Tactics gathered a group of represen- only a means to visualize the web of rela-
herder community. The following tatives of 13 U.S.-based organizations tionships in which human-rights abuses
tactics were proposed for serious working on the issue of U.S. torture at occur but also concrete new tactics
discussion after the workshop: (a) Guantánamo Bay. We provided a draft to combat these violations. By starting
engagement of specialists from the tactical map based on our knowledge of from a place of knowledge gathering and
state professional inspection agency the situation. This saved group time and visualization, the tactical mapping tool
and other relevant authorities to made it possible to more deeply examine has provided human-rights activists with
develop guidelines for environmental different areas of the map where other a new vantage point to understand their
assessment of exploration damages; organizations had greater expertise and opponents and to support the victims of
and (b) organization of a roundtable knowledge. The participating organiza- human-rights abuses.
meeting to sensitize the judiciary on tions gained additional benefits, includ-
human rights of herder groups.7 ing the following: