By
TOPIC:
The History of Co-operatives in Pakistan has
been
disastrous
_________
Analyse
the
position
with
TERM PAPER
TOPIC:
The
History
disastrous
of
Co-operatives
Analyse
the
position
in
Pakistan
with
has
reference
been
to
the
DEDICATED TO
MY FRIEND
SHAHID MAHMOOD CHEEMA
Chapter
CONTENTS
T i t I e
Pages
01-02
II
03-07
III
08-10
IV
16-18
VI
19-21
VII
Agricultural Credit.
VIII
25-27
IX
28-29
30-31
Xl
32-34
Xl-
A Problems of Cooperatives.
XII
11-15
22-24
35-37
1
CHAPTER 1
PREFACE AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
eight
years
to
accept
the
alleged
role
of
the
of
socio-economic,
commercial
and
banking
and
traders
caused
disruption
in
the
entire
movement.
Under
the
stress
of
rapidly
changing
2
content but also in conception. This small document is an
humble attempt to highlight the tremendously constructive
and
effective
contributions
made
by
the
movement
in
M.
Rashid
Director
invaluable guidance.
Research
in
particular
for
his
3
CHAPTER II
INTRODUCTION OF THE COOPERATIVE MOVEMENT
Before the advent of the British rule in India, the
village community had a well developed organization which
drew its force not from legislation but from the willing cooperation and consent of the community as exercised by
the village elders of established reputation. Not law but
social
sanctions
were
the
force
to
arrive
at
various
also
carried
on
his
three
main
functions
of
which
requirements
were
of
needed
the
for
members
meeting
of
the
the
daily
community.
He
were
tampered
with
moderation.
The
sanctions
which
enabled
the
members
of
the
money-lender
exploited
the
rural
masses
by
4
source of credit in the form of taccavi and the other to stop
the process by which the land was gradually passing out of
the hands of the actual cultivator.
The Cooperative Societies Act:
This legislation was not enough and it was soon
realized that something more must be done if the process
mentioned above was to be successfully arrested. The
Government, therefore, passed the first Co-operative Credit
Societies Act, 19014. This Act, however, regulated the
lormalion and working or tIic Cooperiitive Credit Societies
only. Soon afterwards it was felt that the scope of the
movement had to be extended if it was to play the part it
was meant for. The 19014 Act was, therefore, amended in
1912 and renamed as the All-India Co-operative Societies
Act, 1912. The scope of the Co-operative Movement was
extended to spheres other than credit.
Four Stages:
The Co-operative Movement passed through four
distinct stages upto partition. The first stage began in
19011 and ended in 1918. The second lasted from 1919 to
1929. The third commenced in 1929 and continued till
1939. The fourth began with the Second World War and
lasted till partition.
First Stage 19014-1918:
From its very inception the Movement met with
serious opposition from vested interests, who were anxious
that the movement should not be successful. The moneylender in particular realized
5
that the success of the Co-operative enterprise would mean
his displacement. Besides, the persons who administered
civil law, mainly came from non-agriculturist classes. They
had a bias in favour of the money-lender and against the
movement. The progress of the movement was, therefore,
slow. By 1912, the number of societies, membership, and
share-capital did not increase as expected. The conditions
which had marked the infancy of the movement continued
even
after
1912,
but
the
officials
and
non-officials
less
afraid
of
those
who
were
against
them
could
go
behind
the
loan
transactions.
These
Societies
were
organized
with
view
to
suddenly.
The
money-lender
resorted
to
coercive
Golden
Laws.
The
protection
which
the
new
laws
members
to
exploit
the
situation.
As
7
Fourth Stage 1939-19I7:
The debt legislation had started affecting the
movement towards the end of the third stage, but their real
effect was felt during this period. Recovery became even
more difficult and the credit side of the movement showed
a
further
decline.
The
number
of
better
living,
cattle
the
wholesale
work
for
controlled
articles
like
8
CHAPTER III
EFFECTS OF PARTITION ON THE MOVEMENT
As a result of partition, thirteen districts, which
were the most advanced from the Co-operative point of
view, went to the Indian Dominion and with them a large
number of societies, a very large number of members and a
good deal of working capital were lost to the movement.
Before partition, commerce, trade and banking
were almost entirely in non-muslims hand. The Muslims
mainly depended on agriculture and allied occupations. The
headquarters of the majority of the banking institutions and
whole of their funds were transferred to India or to places
out-side Pakistan. A vacuum was thus created in the realm
of trade, commerce, banking as well as in the sphere of the
pacca and kacha arhties. The cottage workers had to face a
similar
situation
due
to
the
migration
of
non-muslim
financiers.
Rice Problem:
The
paddy
crop
was
harvested
soon
after
9
that prevailed. Government finance at this critical period
was completely out of question. The Cooperative sector had
not only funds, which consisted of the accumulated savings
of
the
members
organizations
for
over
four
decades,
but
also
had
The
Cooperative
Movement
had,
under
the
10
Food Procurement:
The Government
requested
the
Cooperative
set
up
number
of
purchasing
centres
and
Sector
at
the
instance
of
Government
11
CHAPTER IV
POST-PARTITION ACTIVITIES
In the beginning the Co-operative Sector agreed
to work the rice husking mills as there was no-body else to
do so. Gradually normal channels of trade were revived and
a number of private persons came forward to run these
mills. The Government, as a matter of policy, withdrew
these mills from the Cooperative Sector and allotted them
to deserving private persons. In the same way the cotton
ginning mills were also given to private individuals. As
things
returned
gradually
to
withdrew
normal
from
Central
the
Cooperative
business
of
Banks
handling
the
matter
of
import
distribution
of
sugar
as
well
was
as
wholesale
gradually
and
given
to
retail
private
institutions
and
individuals
who
were
in
The
real
co-operative
followed
nor
was
it
emergency.
In
spite
possible
of
principles
to
do
defective
so
were
in
neither
time
organization,
of
these
12
service in a time of national emergency The societies
worked
satisfactorily
so
long
as
they
were
under
the
organization
namely,
the
Punjab
Provincial
Co-
to
supply
consumer
goods
through
co-operative
Store
was
established.
The
membership
was
13
the above mentioned two very big ventures were takn in
hand by the movement. Both of them have now been sold
to the private entrepreneurs.
Co-operative Insurance Society of Pakistan:
Partly to fill the gap but mostly with a view to
making arrangements for getting insurance effected within
the movement this Society was organized. This society was
intended to serve those Co-operative Organizations which
were dealing in articles needing insurance and had to go
out-side the movement for getting them insured.
Co-operative Farming Societies:
With the twofold object of affording monetary
assistance to the refugees and trying on experiment in cooperative
farming,
co-operative
farming
societies
were
Cooperatives
in
Pakistan
by
Riazuddin
14
Second Phase - 1955 to 1960:
During
these
six
years
all
the
commercial
days,
to
expand
and
revitalize
the
movement.
15
(b) that no person would be a member of the
managing committee of a co-operative bank for
more than two consecutive terms;
(c) that no new bank other than an apex or
central bank would be registered;
(d) that no trader would be a member of an
agricultural credit or marketing society.
With the passing of this Order a great upheaval
took place in the movement whereby many directors of
cooperative banks all over the country were unseated.
Another significant development of this phase is the coming
into
being
of
the
Federal
Bank
for
Co-operatives
in
was
formed
on
May
23,
1983.
An
Inquiry
16
CHAPTER V
CO-OPERATIVE DEPARTMENTAL SET-UP
At the time of Independence in the Punjab, Sind
and North-West Frontier Province the Organizational set-up
of the respective co-operative departments was almost the
same
except
operatives
few
differences.
Department
was
the
The
Head
Registrar,
of
the
Co-
Co-operative
Training
College
were
created
by
the
and
designated
as
Commissioner
Co-operative
regions
and
six
Regional
Registrars,
Co-operative
17
A
Co-operative
Development
Board,
as
officials
and
co-operators.
The
Board
was
movement.
democratization
of
however,
abolished
January,
1967
It
was
the
in
office
step
movement.
December,
of
the
towards
This
1966
Board
and
Registrar
from
the
was,
1st
Cooperative
year,
the
Co-operatives
Department
which
was
of
the
co-operative
societies
particularly
to
agricultural
credit
societies
had
increased
this
time.
department in
To
streamline
the
working
of
the
increased.
The
Department
was,
therefore,
18
This
timely
provided
promotion
improved
efficiency
frustrated
and
expansion
opportunities
of
the
demoralized
field
during
of
the
which
department
resulted
staff
which
had
all
these
years
in
felt
of
19
CHAPTER VI
CO-OPERATIVE FINANCIAL SET-UP
Each province has a co-operative bank called the
Provincial Co-operative Bank. In order to provide credit
facilities extended by the Federal Bank for Co-operatives to
Azad
Kashmir
and
Northern
Areas,
the
Azad
Kashmir
Bank
have
also
been
declared
as
Provincial
Banks.
The Punjab Provincial Cooperative Bank:
The Cooperative Credit structure in the Punjab,
prior to October 1976, was three tier system. Primary
cooperative societies and the Central Cooperative Banks
alongwith Banking Unions and Industrial Unions etc. formed
the first and the second tiers of the financial setup. In
order to further strengthen the financial structure of the
co-operative societies an apex institution known as Punjab
Provincial Co-operative Bank was established. This was the
third tier of the system. The Bank was financed by the
State Bank of Pakistan through lumpsum allocation in the
Agriculture
Sector
against
guarantee
furnished
by
the
Provincial Government.
In
October,
1976
the
Federal
Government
for
Co-operatives
and
Regulation
of
Co-operative
20
Industrial) in the Punjab were dissolved and their assets
and liabilities stood transferred to the Punjab Provincial Cooperative
Bank.
The
dissolved
Co-operative
Banks
in
1934
the
Central
Co-operative
Bank
at
it
was
affiliated
to
the
Punjab
Provincial
Co-
21
The Baluchistan Provincial Co-operative Bank:
The movement in the province of Baluchistan
started
late
after
independence.
The
Provincial
Co-
of
twenty-seven
societies.
Its
membership
Bank
was
established
under
the
Co-operative
Banks
and
regulate
their
150
20
10
10 millions
5
200 millions
22
CHAPTER VII
AGRICULTURAL CREDIT
The small farmer has few resources to run his
small farm. Availability of credit for him is limited, cooperative credit is the only orqanized system which can
provide him credit and agricultural inputs on credit at his
door-steps. The position* of agriculture credit Societies in
the country is given below:
Number
Membership
34,111
1,398,163
The
number
of
cooperative
societies
actively
the
opposite
in
Sind.
Since
the
co-operative
population
is
sparsely
distributed
the
number
of
* Agricultural
Ahmad.
Cooperatives
in
Pakistan
by
Riazuddin
23
inputs like fertilizers, pesticides, seeds etc. on credit.
Only in Barani areas part of the loan is given in cash. The
loaning to farmers is intensive. Some new programmes in
this connection were under taken in the Punjab which are
as under:
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
Societies.
through
co-operatives.
During
Rabi
1980-81
24
on cash and credit as against 63 lacs bags during the year
1979-80. Similarly during Kharif 1981 about 25 lacs bags of
fertilizers
were
distributed
as against 22.25
lacs bags
this
programme
wheat
seed
certified
by
the
is
not
possible
farmers
can
purchase
this
of
water-courses
was
under-taken
in
the
the
water
courses
and
clear
them
of
any
25
CHAPTER VIII
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION AND COOPERATIVE
MARKETING
It is essential that greater credit facilities should
be afforded to the rural masses, the majority of which lives
on
bare
subsistence
level.
The
various
Government
by
increase
in
production
and
provision
of
However,
single
commodity
marketing
co-
the
Punjab
a scheme
under the
name
of
* Agricultural
Ahmad.
Cooperatives
in
Pakistan
by
Riazuddin
where
such
societies
did
26
not
exist,
new
ones
were
thought
essential
for
improved
agricultural
the
requirement
of
the
member
societies
in
agriculture
machinery
on
hire
basis,
as
well
as
shear
mismanagement
these
centes
have
run
into
Development
of
Cooperative
Procurement
by
conditions
of
farmers
members
of
-the
co
27
primary agricultural societies, Farm Service Centres and
IRDP
Markaz
Associations.
At
the
provincial
level
Co-operative
Supply
and
Marketing
Federations
only.
The
object
of
the
above
federations
are
to
members
of
their
affiliated
societies
as
well
as
28
CHAPTER IX
INDUSTRIAL AND WOMEN CO-OPERATIVES
Industrial Cooperatives provide many advantages
to individual artisans and craftsmen. They raise capital,
purchase raw materials and other requirements at a fair
price and endeavour to sell their products on favourable
terms. These co-operatives cover the trades of hand-looms,
powerlooms, sports goods, surgical instruments, textile and
leather
goods,
furniture
making,-
metal
goods
etc.
At
Cycle
This
operative
is
society,
Industrial
not
only
but
also
Co-operative
the
biggest
one
of
Society,
industrial
the
largest
cocycle
very
exporting
popular
in
cycles
and
the
country.
spare
parts
The
society
is
also
and
earning
foreign
Pakistan
Sialkot:
Sports
29
Co-operative
Industrial
Society,
This society, with 165 members and a sharecapital of Rs.1 .31 lacs is functioning to procure and
distribute
among
its
members
units
raw
materials,
have
been
organized
among
and
societies
to
also
economise
on
function
to
family
expenditure.
create
These
opportunities
for
as
women
industrial
centres
for
imparting
painting,
sewing,
cutting,
embroidery,
knitting
30
CHAPTER X
CO-OPERATIVE PROPAGANDA, EDUCATION AND
TRAINING
In a country where the percentage of literacy is
very small, it is difficult to find men who can properly
appreciate co-operation and the people are not therefore in
a position
really
remembered
cooperative
that
the
best
society.
It
should
is
the
propaganda
be
actual
lie
in
over-rapid
expansion
but
in
ensuring
that
on
suitable
occassions.
It
should,
however,
be
and
coming
into
close
contact
with
the
rural
31
Co-operative Education and Training:
One of the most important sectors of the co-operative is
that of education and training. Without imparting adequate
training to its field staff the Cooperatives Department
would not be in a position to provide sufficient guidance
and
have
effective
supervision
over
the
co-operative
training
Colleges,
Hyderabad
and
at
is
imparted
Faisalabad,
the
at
the
Peshawar,
Regional
Co-operative
Quetta
Training
and
Institute,
32
CHAPTERS Xl AND Xl-A
CLAIM OF THE MOVEMENT ON GOVERNMENT
In
country
which
is
in
the
process
of
fields,
the
Cooperative
Movement
has
an
selfhelp.
selfdependence,
and
such
33
Problems of Co-operatives :
Some of the problems faced by the co-operatives
are enlisted below:
1. Poverty and Illiteracy: Due to the low literacy
rate
in
the
rural
areas
the
majority
of
the
leadership in the
This
attitude
needs
immediate
correction.
4. Financial and Managerial Weaknesses: The
main
reasons
perpetual
for
poverty
these
and
set-back
state
of
are
the
paucity
* Agricultural
Ahmad.
Cooperatives
in
Pakistan
by
Riazuddin
to
run
34
cooperative
their
societies
effectively,
Opposition
from
vested
Interests:
The
evolutionary
process
of
leveling
up
the
self-sufficient
autonomous
cooperative
institutions.
6. Lack of Consistent Political
Government:
The
interests
of
various
established
varrying
from
and
time
to
Support
governments,
time,
fluctuating
from
and
have
their
been
policies
and
priorities.
This
indifference
for
masses
the
which
betterment
in
turn
reputation
of
agency
bringing
in
the
and
adversely
movement
a
uplift
positive
as
of
affected
an
rural
the
effective
change
in
the
35
CHAPTER XII
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
It is appropriate to formulate certain conclusions after
having given the birds eye view of the Co-operative Sector.
Conclusions:
I. In almost all the developing countries the cooperative
movement was introduced by the Government, which did
not
prove
helpful
in
laying
the
foundations
of
the
Tax
relief
was
not
given
to
the
co-operative
societies. The establishment of the Federal Bank for Cooperatives tied the cooperative institutions to complicated
procedures,
rules
and
regulations.
These
two
factors
36
is bound to abide by and work according to the priorities
fixed by the government which has never duly appreciated
the good work done under very heavy odds. Instead the
governments have always lent very willing ears to the
deficiencies and a few minus points which are agitated by
certain
vocal
and
whenever
they
intending
to
influential
see
put
that
their
factions
cooperative
feet
down
of
our
society
functionaries
on
the
their
are
side
have
never
meant
to
apply
cooperative
goverIent
should
assign
the
movement
pre-
staff
properly
of
the
trained
Co-operatives
to
cope
with
Department
the
ever
should
changing
be
and
37
III. In order to eliminate the influence of the big landlords
and
middlemen
it
is
suggested
that
necessary
of
50-50
and
sell
their
products
through
the
members
of
the
societies
who
will
purchase
the
stores
and
can
be
control
organized
of
the
under
District
the
direct
Cooperative
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1.
Agricultural
Ahmad.
Cooperatives in
Pakistan by Riazuddin
2.
3.
4.
5.
on
the
Working
of