www.bjsportmed.com
www.bjsportmed.com
19
41
42
40
18
Reconstruction
Soccer
N = 30 (=: 21/R: 9)
N = 33
N = 59
N = 33 (=: 20/R: 13)
Mostly soccer, handball,
alpine skiing
N = 50 (=: 32/R: 18)
N = 102* (=: 74/R: 38)
N = 83
N = 180 (=: 95/R: 85)*
Football: 11 Rugby: 12
Other: 7
Hamstrings
BPTB
BPTB
Hamstrings
Hamstrings
BPTB
Hamstrings: N = 90
BPTB
BPTB
BPTB
BPTB
BPTB: N = 90
BPTB: 26
BPTB
Non-operative
STG: 4
57/22
Non-operative
46/25
89/65*
Operative/Non-operative
41%
9%
22%/19%*
74%*
44% reduction in op/70%
reduction in non-op*
58%/82%
Return to sport
4.8
5
(211)
5
5.2
47
5
5
7
7
7 (59)
611
14
1013
14
3%*
9%
3%**
9.8%
Hamstrings: 8%
4.4%
2.9%
BPTB: 3%
10%
3.3%
12%*
13% *
Follow up
(years)
Re-rupture
Not examined
61%
28%
5%
25.4%
Not examined
24%
Not examined
Not examined
37%*
12%**
57%
Not examined
50%
Not examined
50%
42%/46%**
86%
78%/83%
Osteoarthrosis
Remarks
*BPTB reconstructed
**Radiological exam of 50 players
*All occurred in pivoting activities
A total of 540 papers were identified through a Medline search using the following key words: Anterior Cruciate Ligament/*injuries AND Follow-Up Studies. Abstracts were reviewed to identify studies reporting on the return rate to sport,
the reinjury rate, and/or the prevalence of osteoarthritis with a mean follow up period of at least four years. In addition, reference lists of selected papers were reviewed to identify additional studies. Follow up studies describing partial ACL
ruptures or reconstructive surgery with sutures only were excluded. A single or double asterisk is used to indicate which piece of information the remark in the Remarks column is referring.
Op, Operative; Non-op, non-operative; BPTB, bone-patella-tendon-bone graft; STG, single strain gracilis; Hamstrings, includes semitendinosus, gracilis and iliotibial grafts; LAD, Kennedy ligament augmentation device.
Bak et al
43
Wang et al
Patel et al
Cooley et al
Ferretti et al
39
32
21
Otto et al
Jennings et al
28
Brandsson et al
Howe et al37
38
Pinczewski et al
36
Johma et al34
Scavenius et al35
Ruiz et al33
Roos et al
10
Myklebust et al
14
Material
Follow up studies on the rate of return to sport, risk of re-rupture, and the prevalence of radiological osteoarthritis after an initial anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury
Von Porat et al
Study
Table 1
128
LEADER
PREVALENCE OF OA
Using the rate of return to sports or even
the reinjury risk as measures of treatment success may be grossly misleading.
An ACL injury entails a significant risk
of OA,22 and it may be that the initial
injury itself is an important determinant
of the development of OA, no matter
what treatment is used or how the knee
is loaded during subsequent years.
129
100
Osteoarthritis (% of patients)
LEADER
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
10
12
14
Follow up (years)
Figure 1 Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) follow up studies and osteoarthritis (OA) prevalence.
OA risk after both reconstructive surgery with bone-patella-tendon-bone graft or hamstring graft
and non-operative treatment is shown. The dashed line indicates the forced regression (y = 6.0 t; r
= 0.85) between time (t) and OA prevalence (y), with the 95% confidence intervals shown by thin
solid lines. Follow up studies describing partial ACL ruptures or reconstructive surgery with sutures
only are omitted.
www.bjsportmed.com
TIME TO QUIT
In 1970 Kennedy stated that the ACL is
the most common cause of the exathlete.31 In other words, the treatment
offered at the time did not permit
athletes to go back to sport. This is no
longer the case, at least in the short
term, thanks to major advances in
surgical treatment and rehabilitation
programmes. As shown above, most
elite athletes are initially able to resume
their sports career. However, the data
also show that the retirement rate may
be higher among athletes with a previous ACL injury compared with healthy
athletes. Furthermore, it is apparent
that there is a significant risk of reinjury
to the graft, as well as the menisci and
cartilage with continued sports participation. Finally, there are convincing
data to show that nearly all patients
will develop OA with time.
Thus it seems reasonable to question
whether return to high level pivoting
sports really is in the athletes best
interestif long term knee health is
the primary concern. The relevant issue
that needs to be addressed is: what are
the additional risks of further injuries
and early OA associated with return to
sport? We cannot answer this question
properly from the available data. Until
we can, as physicians and physiotherapists working with this patient group, it
is our obligation to provide adequate
information of the potential consequences of returning to pivoting sports.
We must enable the athlete to make an
informed decision with all necessary
information available, including the
caveats related to future risk of knee
problems and OA. This includes clearly
pointing out that ACL surgery can only
be expected to improve knee stability,
but that ACL surgery does little or
nothing to secure a future healthy knee.
www.bjsportmed.com
15
16
17
......................
Authors affiliations
18
REFERENCES
1 Fox JA, Nedeff DD, Bach BR Jr, et al. Anterior
cruciate ligament reconstruction with patellar
autograft tendon. Clin Orthop 2002:5363.
2 Haddad FS, Oussedik SI. Cruciate ligament
reconstruction. Hosp Med 2004;65:41217.
3 Grant JA, Mohtadi NG. ACL reconstruction with
autografts, weighting performance considerations
and postoperative care. Phys Sportsmed
2003;31:2740.
4 Fithian DC, Paxton LW, Goltz DH. Fate of the
anterior cruciate ligament-injured knee. Orthop
Clin North Am 2002;33:62136.
5 Siegel MG, Barber-Westin SD. Arthroscopicassisted outpatient anterior cruciate ligament
reconstruction using the semitendinosus and
gracilis tendons. Arthroscopy 1998;14:26877.
6 Gobbi A, Tuy B, Mahajan S, et al. Quadrupled
bone-semitendinosus anterior cruciate ligament
reconstruction: a clinical investigation in a group
of athletes. Arthroscopy 2003;19:6919.
7 Feller JA, Webster KE. A randomized comparison
of patellar tendon and hamstring tendon anterior
cruciate ligament reconstruction. Am J Sports Med
2003;31:56473.
8 Corry IS, Webb JM, Clingeleffer AJ, et al.
Arthroscopic reconstruction of the anterior
cruciate ligament. A comparison of patellar
tendon autograft and four-strand hamstring
tendon autograft. Am J Sports Med
1999;27:44454.
9 Myklebust G, Bahr R, Engebretsen L, et al.
Clinical, functional and radiological outcome 6
11 years after ACL injuries in team handball
players: a follow-up study. Am J Sports Med
2003;31:9819.
10 Roos H, Ornell M, Gardsell P, et al. Soccer after
anterior cruciate ligament injury: an incompatible
combination? A national survey of incidence and
risk factors and a 7-year follow-up of 310 players
[see comments]. Acta Orthop Scand
1995;66:10712.
11 Eastlack ME, Axe MJ, Snyder-Mackler L. Laxity,
instability, and functional outcome after ACL
injury: copers versus noncopers. Med Sci Sports
Exerc 1999;31:21015.
12 Fitzgerald GK, Axe MJ, Snyder-Mackler L. The
efficacy of perturbation training in nonoperative
anterior cruciate ligament rehabilitation
programs for physical active individuals. Phys
Ther 2000;80:12840.
13 Fink C, Hoser C, Hackl W, et al. Long-term
outcome of operative or nonoperative treatment
of anterior cruciate ligament rupture: is sports
activity a determining variable? Int J Sports Med
2001;22:3049.
14 Von Porat A, Roos EM, Roos H. High prevalence
of osteoarthritis 14 years after an anterior
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
LEADER
LEADER
131
N
N
N
N
N
The seminar is free for COPE members and 30.00 for non-members. Numbers are limited
and early booking is advisable. For registrations or more information please contact Sam
Knottenbelt at cope@bmjgroup.com or call 020 7383 6602. For more information on COPE
see www.publicationethics.org.uk/
www.bjsportmed.com
doi: 10.1136/bjsm.2004.010900
Updated information and services can be found at:
http://bjsm.bmj.com/content/39/3/127
These include:
References
Email alerting
service
Topic
Collections
This article cites 40 articles, 13 of which you can access for free at:
http://bjsm.bmj.com/content/39/3/127#BIBL
Receive free email alerts when new articles cite this article. Sign up in the
box at the top right corner of the online article.
Notes