2 ip Stee De ihe et oe Back Pings 10-2 Se a i esc a The Dehumanization of Art 1925 “Testy of rom he sco pin ew might tit soem a {aren theme rather ke stdhog a me from is do At Bight {he socal eles of at re 0 extra 0 remote rom ace ea: {inky hts ot ay tose how on thi epi onsen sc {ly explore the sera of sj. Botte fri specs ef {oct ofa were snexprealy ovale toe when, fon Jars Aout nppesd to be wg abou hema rm Whh aad Wh iy. My prose masta dtae cet ar pute he ieee tecweea moda and tedsional ase Tae peblom mas cy Sesto, yt found the shortest oad tvards i soln sed Irom 3 stl olga phenomenon: te wappulrty of ere Thou nw ket ome al she rs which are il hr in rope: moe mes, pining os. aed ue The wy tat cscs ida ile niet ned Se ing and peri. Aa Seal nsdn i ogee Rest nors ara Wihoutteap sa o's he ose meta ‘erping ete n sound ery the sme Sexe vl he Contemporaries te ptr the pet to he ama Aad tes {Sy farts spendin mu, eae bean ental etlopead et Te uapopausiy of ys mason bythe npopuiy tte eter ra Al sew at pope, eco So a6 ‘hanes or secket Tei tes that ery aes mt go hoop pid of gue nin an one may real he codons the yet of Romantkem, The pops of modern art, Hoeven, of very ina inde woulda we dang ever wa pope: Jnr and tt mpopl. An ovary sje hse ix ‘wiosng popular fst popu, ba ctr i vapopalr Tar ‘Sarplofte pubes acerance of Romantic wae feat op fst that preted ymder itimase sry rap congue “pop, whose aon ha acter en Spy ld by theo co aft Tae eeny i ch Romanian tocetend as pei set mii wo ad femsine lop to the seis sane f the pone anc ime Romane works were the istsne he mention of prising C0 eoy tg eduons: Above a ter movements Romana wate 6- popular. The ir-bore of democracy, i as tete by the ses with re grsie aecton etn one ten, ke ss ase Sola Any now 307 wtaunee! SUBTEST profess © eo Encologal eer onthe publ, epg H lta to parts. Ose, the Ise group, is formed by a smal oumber of persons who ae favorable fo; the ahr, the great majority is host. (Lt ws eae ase these ‘auivcal eet, the spo) Ths the work of art aes as soil fore creting to stagoise groups, separating the asics ato exo iret castes of en. "What be pice tt ierentines these wo classes? Every work ‘of artawakeat difret responses: some peopl ite, ober 30 not; ome ket es, cers more, No principle is involved the accident of ‘or individual disposition wil deed where we stand But the case ‘of moder art the spsraton cei on Seper pane than the mere ‘ieceaoernindvideal tase. Ie ota mater ofthe majority oft andthe minority ing. What happens Ets eshte eee ote pele decors amy opto, erates af eonenporary ar rom be ocio= Jog pot of ews hat divides the pubic intotese wo elses of ‘men! thor wo understand I aad those who dono. Ths eps tht {he oe group posses a erga of comprehension dened wo the the {hat they are to iinet vretsof the human specie, Modem St ‘ely aa for everybody, as was Romane a, hut om he OO etisalat speci, ied misony. Hence curtain aroassin When someaee does no ikea wor Of a7, Ba Te ‘ood i heels apeior to tand has 9 oom or ieraton. But when ‘sae ass fom the ft fli 0t having bees understood hen th ale bonita, re aware of Te a jp af hie Mera. by is mere presence obese good bourgesisto fel vat hela 2c 0 sl this cannot bappen whimper 2 ‘bude years of sbembracing ater fhe mass dt apobeosis te pol: rato a donne in ohn, theses "For ceatry and halthe peopl’ have pectended o be the whole cof sociy. The muse af Stravinsky or the drama of Pirandlo obliges {hem wo fecogalae hemsehs for wha they are one ingredient among savy in the soil sirctry, ner mater of te hiv process 8 “ ‘The ine i approhing when society, from pole oat wil once roworgeite no tho oe: dnl ad a. algae The vadiflerctate sy css, morpus, whoa a8 gaol soca pening pie cant conor Beal, allestenpoe ea and a8 ig ality gest among en rs the oe art ot igi to everybody, thi imps that er sources are not the hmaa. i i aot an et for neo fn teeral, bt fora very parla eas of men, who may ot be of ore ‘Sor han be others bat who are appareay distinc “Thre i one thing above al that X woud be wll to dee. What do the majory of people call esthetic please? What goes on in het faiad when a work of art please? them? There bo daub abut the toaver: people thea woth 8 “The loves, hates eres and joys ofthe ‘carat: toveh ter ear they parcpte in them, a8 they were tering veal Ue And they sy work "god! whee it manages to rode the quay of thon aseszary forthe imaginary charters {ore asiving persons ln pot they wil look or the loves and es ‘tthe aia beied the pot In itn they el be atzated oa by those pctares where they find men and Women who would be interesting toknaw A landsape sl appear pet tom when the scee repre ‘ented ers vst on ee0urt os pasa or emai characteris ‘This means that forthe majority of people texte eajoyment is saotaeattde of mid eset dire fom the ope bey habitual) Sept in othr arse of if; but is perhaps ess wtaan, mare com pict sed without anplasatconsquonees In een, he jet wich encems them nan ich sree thefts of ther aention ad the ‘st of thee facuie, isthe same asin every fe: bua beings and ‘hei psoas, And they wil call that whieh provides tem Wh the tnssek of aking contact with human things. Thus they wil Werte eta forms of uvelity and fas only to he exe that they do not {Serre w the peop of ns fe ad soto Aa ss te purely acsite cmon some domant and deacke- ean, op now hes ed wih och object han at of a ot nia veel eves has whos aE Py @sa perfectly simple mater of opts. In ode tose a objet we bv toast ou jes in a cetaia vay our sl accomodation s inndaguate we do tse he object, we se nperfny agine Me te looking at a grea trough a window. Our ees aja themselves So tat oar ghnee penetrates the gas wihout ingering upon t,and ‘ete oon the lowes and foliage As the goal of won twas which ee earner pases through i. The clearer the gas, theles we et But ater, ranking an efor we can ignore the garden, and, by reroctng ou cts let test onthe window pane. Thea te arden digppears em ‘tees and all we eof kare some confsed muses of calor whieh ‘ecnloadbecto ibe glass Thstoscetbe garden and toserthewindoe ‘ane are oro incompatitle opertins: the ne ecldes te ober and {eyeach euien dierent foes. To the same manae, the psn who seks ovale himel through fa work of art, wilh he destinies of Jo and Mary or of Titan and Teale and djs his prea perepion to these mates, wl tee the wor ofa. The mafortiesof esta, a5 uch ean oly moves {0 he eve tha hy ar ken for seal. ut ears ose ti yw ino en These ¥ Seeman Carts eit tesa endian do ‘Scere ving Chars buoys porate nt, ‘aurea ioge: The nt ported aod hs portal are wo compete} stato eer wesre treed ation or mie hr Ia he former nessa ih Charente ere Sonepat ‘nol uc port {Sr bomun aly wie be nk sey Ithy a aed fi and str eo i il vo fa ey cnn (nthe do ote Roms Spicer aero boet ener putetsner sa Smineres Ee ean endnieorcane SS nauameeres etre; Chateaubriand ie Zoe, asa ea, Romain and {etunlisn, wen fom he ewpit of wy, oer tpt and ‘eathiecommon ootin ea. "Werks thar are oly partly works ofa Inonderto joy them we donot ve ove ats Tr noaph to one tamniy an wings wo sympudise mh our might gua ‘nd jy ts terse ederandabie atthe a of te neo, eat shuld ae Been so pop, sine ws appreciate by the Sxl a propoion fos ot beng ar bua exact om le eres thar aller whichhve had vo set pes fata {or thee nd aoc forte my =the ater bas says bees rea [Mi fa he Biddle Agen, for ctomps coreponding othe teed Strate of oct thee war Doth sataricon ‘tat and teal, abd» poplar st whch wat tala Steal ‘Wevill not dass nox whether pre ans posible. Pestaptis ot bur the nasoo re somevba tals nd any ose Bt grey ‘Met he mater der dscsion- Alhough pe ar ay on 8 por Sl theres no dub tnt tere roo fora movemeat toned ‘Thiswould aoa progesiv mination of be human o fo hora ‘lemcts carci frome and mura ort ofa sad ‘it wlbereached ia whch th man content oe work ini: Solita scl bene. Thon me shal Have as objet whch cam be fected only by tous who puis that pes gi of re se {iyi sm ator arte a not the mates il a a fea, ot det THe pring we have found dh eon why the mdm ait viding he pubic two cles, ose who undesandan hese WO ‘do not that ais hoses a thom who are not. Formodem a ‘Sanantdeare Tae cking texte hs sew maa ofan il eto den gate te casio ofthe ns centr. Cam ang eo eying them, Men ats 9 uaera fat. Dang he wey Yas the ‘ow wana of wo cee pesos Pe, Bly Landen, ew York Rome, and Madrid hive found thomas srk y tit Fncutble ttt rial at not only does no tere thes ‘hoy ates find i epupme With se ders ast {0 sone of wong ter hat them or nko er ade Stand tem Ar con Son ester roar he ter cure one ‘namely notions ne soncepton of a ia thr work ‘ich sq cobeat a atl fer om Sng cx, ‘arsung show to embody the merisbl ee nde al ot ‘ome ofalprevouriaicevteion‘chance of achlevenest. Erea so be ny sill aan soting: but his fires roch more etn he were to vompese ane more Wagacrias ‘operon yetanotber satura eovel nar al repetion vale. Each syle the history of area tw engenders cain ounbe of diferent Forms iin peas pe. ‘Bottherecomesa day whes the ch oe comply Worked out This dus happeed for example, with he romani and atralisc nev and ‘ply isan ingenous err to breve tht the presenta ste ‘oth el se to nck af persona let. Wat bas happened tt ‘i poste permotatogs have teen exhsed te frtnate tha he fentgence of new avarenes capac of exploring avorked veins ‘Souldenseide win tiseshowsion ‘Aulying the new spe one Gods in it cera closely conneered tendencies tends ond he dehumatiation of ar oan svedance ‘Sez roy:toanavoiance of ulschood: and fal tovards a8 ‘Sr obi makes no spel or tansendenal aims whatorser ‘Wah veriginous peed nadernarthasdvergeditoa pent variety of ‘ection and iatentons is x to empath ferences betwee ‘oe work and anoiber Butts wil be aloes uss West determine ‘he common Sas whieh t Unes coneaicorly, moders rt hares ‘The specie dilerences inthe at tday are of en) moderate terest ‘mead, part fom some excepting, am covered alse thay ‘one work. The importan thing ith thers oe ane aware evened wot onl ate sss thales bat alos ome members oF ‘he pb When eid today's atest pimac for rT meant hot ‘ext these wo produce it et als those whe Rave caput for ape ‘ating it Now I sal eullne which sige characte of modert at ‘ers to me (9 be of pate importance: he tdensy to dehannoe tw compar & mer piting wit ae pit i sy, 1860, we ‘an sat by conrag the Sj preted in bath wie pera Sina, a Nese, or sountan We soon ste that hic 01800 Tasabowealitnded he Bessie picture to ave the ame rand yet ym a fag ey. Posty ao rt aed may he cought chee epstiony, Bathe inporant thing to oti tt ebay aking sre ofthis extra! acne ‘Maa, hoe and mows ar meaty recoil hy re oot 7» feds, On he ter hac hs things in he moder paige {que ore elo er wecan eegnie te, The peor may ink ‘Bath piter ingle of scuewag acne. Bt he pcre of 18, too maybe pid buy ~ ta to sy there may ew gal ence th bjnn the ptr andthe ely thy span: Neer {les ht ety the gol towards ic he tes In he ter Fhning, however, eveything te oposite i ola eae te false naling mss suds aling to aciee te satel rene ‘Exner ee quis bums)rht ens ow oad edg Airey ay rom ts human bee “The ptr. fa rm numbing toads iy, i tent e pox ceri nthe contary deen, Hea bie rslaton fealiy beak ts ham nge, debmans es pone egy ining inthe compa ofthe hing represented in» rations poe, Sosintion wih the ing sown in bene sar poe. Ia ‘ing theo hk apes of lving stn te pe as erred {be bide aod ern te ose wh might Coe hour ee tomy nol He eaves imprisoned iam are word and fers ‘hvo Cottons oats inp to en mely We ately have {9 spproach thse ping with» comple pea mind, wees ‘ete and inst sont imaginable creer nich ight ‘Topecaceptoal ojos Ths pete town ppontocoes ‘iponsecnte nd rom resin expen preci whn rie Soipcbcnionsnenjoymere about There 0 skin ens Sd pasion bat thy bongo 9 payee ora te die fom tat ‘hich cove nds fo pray ad human ie They arouse {Sronday enaions niche socal aeteto Tew be ad shat wold be spl to dapese aogier with thou mim forme = man, out, rowland const wry ‘vial ge. Bt hr nse rs place reprise nthe ok sisint omameval line dormant rvocon of cera ‘str! forms my ger easy. Tate second place ~ and th ore Inport the at of which eae peaking ton aa hain {hn dus not comprise human things, bat ws sete consort is tbe ‘ery epenton of dekuansing In hs ight rom te amas, Ast Fae (the arts sno so moh ean the udeled pal, a8 {ting a rom he homan ape whch is desoying Me nt Sse of pling tomtng oly dst from a manor & howe ot & ‘Bouma ba sf stings sat wah the at publ remblane > torn hose wie conseyes onl what ety aeesary ore is tmetmorposa cone sich bas miecltaly emerged fem wat mas {frm mountain The sth plese for ody art comnts {rom th amp over th aman ero eceary to make he ”er vitry conerete and in cach ease diplay the visti that bas been tis commonly belived that to ron ny rom ality sean, whereas ‘Rise mot fal hing inthe word eany oy or alt tang ‘whichis uineligive, compl ecking in meaning it ough to Scag together words without conection, of ra tne a andor But te suceod in consrotng someting walsh neta copy eft "satar” fod ye posses some subsume quay imple amos subline leat. "Realy constantly lurks in ambush reny to impede the art's In works oft popular in the fst centarythr ia 2 oss of livag reat whch lina’ form th ance ofthe bei. 1s opon fr eabuanee Wat at operates, cabelstig at buna ‘ocean, ging it iliac ad rastans Far te aj f people {isi th mo ator indeed the ony posible, acto Werk of fr Anise tection ole tsa ora though pera [Sth repression of the bumn, et Both ft itt, 9 eserves, today's eit iat on the ponte, Why mst i lt iy be outed rh fos, hen tomorow away sss the Somme theo? Abo ly sues to toc ncgant or Zaks on ony. Ou mest rooted sd wnguesianed convictions are {Bose wos oper to nupiion They demons one ou or fine Life of smal acount If st iinet wth» fre ‘ages o etna fonr- One ves in proportion a on peares {ole mor, The cbt dso remain wh our ata heron Pinto decade of il engi. The hoon «lope, ving eran ef curbing: we we joy pele the forians etcbe cpus nds sassy smo nine how beth {ny Os th eet, when hehozea somes inoovabe ego ‘Tebaenng of tare unt entry nto eso qui seen nth scr uae that a ork of at -mat necessary conan a na ceo he Maes oboe ‘belt Tap would beta edu atoms conn he sendy Pst ou hal the prepion of ving tly sod tc percep et {is form aren pip compatible Sse ey requ aire Sajna of or von A at ta eso mal oe oth way at ew b a cesoped art The works of enact Set fat fom epeeeatig a sormal tn, are prhaps the pests! anny ee ‘itoy of ste Al te grat pessoa avd fag he tama lee the cen of gin the wor fart That Joma for sce ales wc asf te ps etry pea demomieian then ibotpulnineslucosl sea, n ‘Whence itfllows that he new npn so exoagaat in spearance, in treading the ue oad ofa, the road eal the dx for sy Now, to siete distor there to make vase Styization ples dehumanization. And, vie vets, thee iso other unset of o> hhumanicing than sition. Realism, onthe eter hand, faites Ue arto foow docile the orm of tings, tvs in abn ye. ‘A Zarbarn eathusast sas that is plteres have share jat a8 Leas o¢ Sool Dickens o Gals, ave character and st sje Tae eighteenth cetary, on ue cone, which hassle curler, pose ‘iapietosstunion pint Moderiss have decared thatthe intrusion of the human ia aris taboo. Now, human corte, the component elements of our day Lives poses rarely of thee anks Fast comes the ode of pesos then {hat of eter ving ecole, abd aly tt of norganle things A today exerci is veto with an eeergy i proprton tothe Mearchil shituee of the objet. The persoeal, by being the os Ruma of the ‘bumaa, is whats most sbuntod bythe moder “This can be sen very carly io muse and poet. From Becoves 0 Wapper the theme of musi on the expen of penal figs ‘The ye ast compoved grand dis of sound in order to thew vit is atobiogaphy. AM was more or less confession. There Was 80 ‘othersayof seahenjoymen ker ant contagion a ings Even ‘iewsebe said, "ta mst, he pasons lke plese from thee ‘Wager injects his aduter with La Wesepdonc nt Tso, a aes as wih oo oer remedy ie wish to ejoy hs work, than to become ‘agus adulterous fr 3 couple of tours. That meso i wih oom [puscton, nd to exjy tne have to meep, slr anguih, or me with Ioveinsparmodivalptuousnes. llth use of Beethoven o Wagner ‘smelodrama “The modern cist would say that this teacher that i plays on man’s noble weakness whereby he becomes infer by he pala 0 oy ‘of his fellows ‘Tircomagion i at of spel order, merely @ Fees reaction, a when one's eth area om edge a ie eraped {las ao insect esponse to more. It a0 good coelsiog the elles. ‘Of tchling with te experience of gladness, Art canet be subject 10 “tnconsciouspuaomenon [ork ought o be allay, the high noon of ‘xcbration. Weeping and lupe ste sstbeslly frauds. The ex reson of beauty never goes beyond a sails, wheber melancholy of Selig, and is beer sll bow ether. "Toute maine oe fe rod” Oats). ‘ele the judgment ofthe young ars is ound enough. Aastha Plasues maybe led or perspicetou, Thy of isblnd; 2~ ‘eevebig ita cas whist, ait ak mode. The Iman its pti sao abo ras btn iret mane Tera tet of oti dene s Bal tae So cael nse a ots mechan hg i ime oo sit cearapued cancer lige mata, Ye te pe 2 fms ete ata ay eoprton wh cont at ‘Soatebey stm te dow te ingnod may eager lane linn re rr wr ee is arin oa detace. A pojetr i operating within work ‘of et both movig things fer tay ad transriag ter. Ons ‘age sren we eonlemplate them anise fom the ea, absolutly remote, When Wis dorelzaion is lacking it produces i ws 2 fal ‘eclation: we do not Hnow whether we are Ling the tgs a cone them, "ie haves a pela unease ie font of wax Sigures. This arses ‘rom Beinsseat ambiguity whieh ants them and which prevets our code ate towards he, Treat them 2 vo beings ‘tedhey mock ws by reveling their cdverous ad wrasen sere et ‘we lok on them 35 gol they seem fo protest Theres 00 wa of ‘edi them lo mere bjt Laaking a them, ne Bear easy {he suspicion that they who are looking at ws. And we end Up by eating luting tress species of hited corps. The max Hie is ‘Rodi ping let ska ew random enon, wih he aeons of {caving them unanswered for the time big. What does sign, hs Sethi for th burnin a7 Ts iby aay chance 9 foating of the fnuman, of reality of ie ~ ors prbaps the opposite, a espe for fe ‘anda epupnance [or setng contd wth anything afro eat? ‘Bo what all uss sbout at beng a inferior fencon~ dre atthe ory of chitin, tbe pnmacle feature, und so fri? T haves, {esearerundom questions nt petoent the ined sue. "a Woper, melodrama reaches ks highs exalt. And as alvays hea form alos is maximus hs conversion ino the ‘oppose at ence bg. Alwady a Wagaer the hua voice i cesng “ to be s protagonist and is bcoming submerged in the comic uproar of teotheriasuuments conversion femoceradicalting wasinevale, 4x became arcessary to eraieate personal seimeats fom mms, TIS vas the aceooplshnent of Debus). Sace his day it has become pose She o hese muse een, without rapeare aod wihoot ears, All tbe “aritions and developments that have cated i the art of ruse in these st decdes Wend upon that extrsteretlal ground belly onquereé by Deby. The conversion rm the bjs tothe bee fiver of sch importance that subsequent diferentiatons dinppear before it Deby debemanized musi ad for tha reson the era modern suse dats from Ni. His wa the st of c0008. “The same conversion ook place In pty as meet to erate poetry. which, weighed dows th hua teri was Sink to earth ikea dtsted balloon, Basing sel against the tes and rootops. this cae ws Male who Iteated pty and gave back is suring postr and freedom, Pethae he hinted not quite rele it ambition, at as capa ofthe new spac explorations he ge the deck Sve command? tow the alas cvemoard, Recall wht ised to beth theme of postry in the roman er. Ia feat vers the poet Jt ws share Bis pate, bourgois emotions: it Sifiags grat Sd ral, ie nostalgia, is religous or polieal pre ‘ecuputions, sed, he Were English, As pipesmoking revedes On ‘ccasionsinavidal ecsallowedsoresabiieemantion to enelope ‘the homan cea ofthe om at we Und ie Baudet fr example Buc tis splendour ass Oy-product All he poct wished as fo be 8 ‘human beng ‘When be writs, 1 beleve today's pot simply propos to ea poet. Preset ve shalseehow allmedert at clacag a tis With modes technol, sence and poli, in sort with ies is today, loses Al blurred footers ts symptom of meatal eleganes oasis on cleat Sisinons, ifs on hig poetry ance, the young writer thinks = frat eat els. The poet bees whore the man stops. Te ners to Iie out bis barman desing; the misono the forme i 0 ave what ‘oer not exit, In sway the Tton of poetry jad. The poet jets the word ding to the el whic sale there, a ware fspet Malle was the first poet fh intent entry Wo wasted {ole nothing but a poet A he himself sy, be reece autres male il and composed ite cal objets dnt from human fsa sad ors. This psty docs no azed to be fl, because theres aothing ‘ofthe human at there snot of pathos in eer. he speaks of 2 voman tit 'any wore’ and ifthe cock sites itis the mising hour fon the clock fae: By a process of devil, Malraé's vere ana all hhomaa etboes and presets us wth Hig 50 far beyond realy that 1syy ‘merely to contemplate them isa delight, Among such ihuraan sur Founding: what ean the man oficing ss pot 60? Ons thing ony Sper oi a eevee at fp, mormon feat embed wort cal protagonist al [ares That pre anoaymous oie, mee acoustic carer ofthe Wes, ite ocr ofthe pet, wo har erat how to slate his fom the manele Frm ey dion econ toh ie cnn: ae om ‘he aman pots The press ace many. Peraps {ody very eileen roses fom those employed by Mallarmé domi ‘oy and Tam aware that eves in is owe Work there ill orur romantic Steatoos: But ju ae moder mu belongs to he att ars with Deny, ale port advances a te dieton pointed out by Mal lame: lnk wih bodh names seme tome exeail i we Wish to {Slow the man ont of tbe new ye "Today itt efor anyone wader tiny wo become interested ‘book deseag under the retest fat the bebaviour of pele me fod women He rete ‘hi to sociology ad prjchelogy, and WoW eset wth please fot wo confuse thugs, were refered L098 ‘och But at Torhim ssomehing iret. "Pet today the higher algebra of webs Matapor is probably the mot fre of a's resources its ectie- ‘es Yergag 0a the mirsclous All other faculties keep us enclosed trihin ern, within what lead i. The most we ean doi of {obesatchiags to of rom others Only metaphor ais our escape and ‘retsarong al thigsinaginay refs nade pregnant wih alison, ti oealy srsoge, the existe of (Ms meat) ect in wan whereby be soplans one ting by another, nots much out of eager ‘new to acre the one ae fom ¢ dese to sus the eter. Metaphor lon objet ether of notes, anit wou not nae sense beneath edi ot eran instnt whichlends towardean avoidance otra. ‘A pochologst rectly coguiig nto the origin of metaphor ds. coved that oe oferty in the spit ol ton. As {ibs importance would be designated by enoter nace, The stro ‘meat of metaphor came ter o be expoyed forte mos diese ends, ‘2a often, the one at hs predominate in poetry, bingo enable ‘Bored diet Simleshave been wed for decorate purpsts, to adoro and enbroier the beloved reali. It wool be interesting fd 0 tthe, der ro arning the eaphor nt substance aed hot “rsument, tb nage bs not aoytd a curios denigting geal, ‘Which ead of exaoblig and enhancing diniihes and Goparages %6 oor aly. Ale while go Tread book of modera poetcy where Tigatelng was compared to acarpeate's ule and wats ales et {o brooms sweeping the sk The rial weapon istarme again astral ‘Bingsand damage. cve ensianes thom, Bu, if meapbor ithe most radial instrument of debunaniation i ‘Sot bei ob ony one There ar cous ter of vying rane “The smpst consis in a mee sbnge of te customary perpetne oom th has pt cw ings veo order, 3 Stemi Nr sr, Some uemveryinporan oes fe fo, oer tally fig ‘Sinn ower to say the ge to deomasie wot errs, Sty tombe erent at of tigger is Sree of porane abd wake tia wh looming op monet: {ivi tocomd. apport einen npr “iit tent coaneon ung apparent incompatible ors of suodem ar the ila eine of igh om he eal aed book {nthe smal of etphor od wht ight be cal ileal ny by sore ote eg of pote ‘Sslaion but ae by paying enagecsed senor to the west ‘Sail Thetetexampleof hiro stead, as inhane te mer ‘Kope topes oleate to be oven Frow, Rama Goer de Stance. As Dave sad the purpose of hia ie merel to deseo moder et by mean ofsomne oie dnt estore. Bo fs tur, is iteaton finds elf ersng»coty broader an these poges could eat), #9 atthe reader eft oh private median, fee ote folowing Thewbar | tate poloted ou that at an pur scenes, prc by bing the fest of scthtis, and ess dependent on soil condions, at {he fs eld in which any change othe colle consciousness ca bees. When tna mode is beat to ie be arts by an Feng his new atavenee in both aris creation and in sieatic ‘heory. The sential of both ares makes hem inhiely suscepibe to {he lipest breath ofthe winds of te prt. AS ina vil, on opening {Be nndows te the moming we look atthe sake rom te chimneys i ‘ower tose which way the wind i blowing 0 we ca look a heats Sod scence of the younger geeraons with & salar meteorological ‘ator. But order to do this it was eset ndefice the new nomenon. 7Having done so, oly now can we stk wat a Westy moder rt fea fore fe? The reply woul eal testaon ie he (Stes of ts sang change of incon wich a2 hig. nd chs Stor mold be sete oo wig to undertake ee Why tis Seto demesne, hy hs ning tig forms? Probab, ke ‘Soy bir phenomenon uous ae 0 agen she se, Clete eel hen vets oe ete stands ou quite ery, thought canot be repsed ate on oe Shean of ows past onthe ae of a is someting at P setenteamtuimiiy Hoes ania portent tery ert me io ee tara llsisnin poston gemernctte thsi gusteeey eee Sie Sameera oe eer ee ene perc ia rate cents reste eee ene oa Secon a eee cae ween ieee Sresree sence ca veeercetsecs Sees ona ory tee eee eras eee tice eres: ponte eee eee Sesser Sree riteenenrres Le ee erie Seca oer serena peat meres nacre er Sierra aie aroletinms Seer a ere Dee se rete nme ee Sects rey cee ens ein ome ermine fp raete racer remo Domes etee aren enee ieee Say naman aooee ns ear atse ea ee agree eae Sees See a _ Seas = St abet asengety ste Ming aie aes bees hr if tie fee caer re 2 coe ee ig Se aeeieae ha panne Sromendteas ations onan _jure up an anreal borizon. To achieve this we can only deay our reality Cassmnaneael hcatmenee Sceecomanios te ‘Cert, this quality of rony gies modern aft @ monotony which highly exuperating. Bu, ke that as may, tbe contadiction between edad lve surfeit anderthusasn, now appears to be resolved. Hate ‘aroused when ai taken sion), ove, hea art soca as Farce, Ibuphinga everyhig. iacluing tse “Theres one ature of peat sgatcane which seoms to symbolize all that modern art stds for ~ the fct that es sped of al pra content Having wien this selene, 1am atoaised to find Ue - bec of dferet connotations care. The fact isnot that the as as Tide atresia is wok, But that interests prsiely beens ft ees not have grave importance, aa to the extent that it aks it The ‘ater will ot be propely understood i i not coasiered togeber| tthe state o art tit years ago, indeed, thronghon the past ent. Posty and muse ere ten acivieeof immense importance: il ss ‘was expec of them than the satin of the ur species ami the ‘a of regions end the inviabl elas of iene. Art x aa endeis nobe seme. Ie was transendene by eeasoa of he theres ‘shih iculed the most sesous problems of Romany, tel lending josation and dgty to huzuety. This was tobe sen in the lem ‘Secale ye grt porn poner fore desiny of he units a Thetpect that an att of today woul! Be apalled to ee ise appsited to soch an enormous mision and thts obliged to deal ith tmatess of compare magatuce ia hs work, He bap o experince ‘mahing of artic value preci when be sans to notice a hightess inthe ar, when his compostion begins to behave volo, feed af al fcmaliy Fe i, ths te thea ign ta the Moses eet If itis sl proper to say tha saves man, is only beau sve hie om th sousnes fife ad awaken ia han ueespeted Youn ‘es: The magi te of Pan whieh makes the Faun dace ste edge of {he restrain becoming the symbol of ‘Modes art beast be vedestndbs soqurng a cern ment of geass when i interpreted as an amp ofa yout fate an ancient world. Otter sles insted on being asoeated ath roma social or plea upacaval or with profound pioeopicel ‘eras curate. The ne sya, the conary, ak to be teoet ated wb the trph of sports and games, esas the sun os item, Inthe space of afew years we hav sen the til wave of spot alba ‘verwhsiniog the pager of our newspapers that beat zeroat News ‘Aces of depth threaten to sink ito the abyss tec ame imps, ‘whe the yt ofthe egtas si Vicoioul over testa. THe ase Tee oomph oper sp te vei fener ee FO ap The es ae oe tm ohchnpocxonrspoupan inrny pron the mania of idee sl eaoyd pat pe. sg Ay longo sop og boy mea poses reed ‘Wlotoreloe he asofteman paris pre Today, eboys 08 (rv tad to prlog te nanny, nd be young se oan Seta youties. “Tus sould co 9 pte Hiory moves in acord with set ‘lope thn te eaten changes igang apna fre orucasfre vould be siage fe majrand paar deren Ince eng te deena cfs adapta ctao acre a {Siseae pooh ine ems And dec be cay ‘Eaton vig yal fom nwo theater pocorn finesse ain gual tere min cern {ins cating he spt of ooh soda oer that of mata "ody. te predating nl age of Cuapnn cers x cot smelt omens ont os ti ern oie oe ys esa no monde tak even Sppa telobg forty “Ath chanctertesof oder cn be summed pia the base site wich ian ae epondng oa rebnged pron titeshy of tomas proces woud ny ator preven ‘Same ces ren ey cosetothe bb fen et ‘ie ejpon oft pina shy, hs moved ou tomers te pre fey, os ion ont freer afb harden {ay bs egy. mee remoe “heen ops ae, as en ered on at of ao poco cotary of ga mosey. A, ang bee emp ‘at pubes ea witout any ober mening whaorer= st ‘los tin be pornon at ofa mid ean he gps ‘ated nents lay has a mynd apc compan, aur at anemerai told vos renal clair ot ‘en ay of pri, the Kare bve expe i cany, ‘Bowden ote the cares ons Tc improbiiyneresas we ‘earn wah petro only at te big oe Jue) deh ac, rie core gly probate dt this description of modern art cotta ning nt ere Hang coco ystems ntearoe ‘hope ed wht ole fp scarey i low i Tk 2 would only confine theisues were to try ta corre! ay errs ave nade by singling out some arcu eture omited from ts analy, ‘Arts reap tl inthis eror when they tlk abou thei srt and do ‘ot stand far enough avay takes broad view ofthe its Ihave been ‘moved soe by the pasar of tng to understand — not by anger or usa. Thave endeavoured to sek the meaning othe teins of ‘nodern a and ths obviously presupporea Benevolent state of mid. ‘Wisely no posibleto approach theme n any ole manner wil cutecademning ito strily® vill esi hat the eat as ot produced aythag worthuile up to now, and L come very else to hiking te same. From esting ‘works Ihave beea yng to extect an intemon and I have et con roed ysl with bee lfiment. Who kaos wBst will come oot oF thisne onder! The etepise fabulous it seks terete out of noth Ing. hope thet ter 9 tw be content wit es td shies more, ‘uy, whateveritserorsmay be, theres my opinion one immovable point ia the new station: the ipossy of going back. Al he fins leveled at the lapraton ofthese arte maybe corel, but sill do ot contribute suit reson for condening i. Something pose would fave to be added: te suggestion of anotber rsd for at ‘hich ould nlite deburanie nor eave the oade lady ued ad hued. is wey easy to cry that ais alas pose within the tradon, utthiscomfarag phate woes for hearin No ava, wih Beh