Preface
1. Introduction to the biobased economy
1.1 Drivers of a biobased economy
1.2 Biobased economy: part of a transition to a sustainable economy
1.3 The basic principles of a biobased economy
1.4 Conflicting interests
1.5 Learning
2. Biomass production
2.1 Growing biomass
2.2 Agricultural challenges
2.3 Biomass availability
2.4 Biomass types
2.5 Learning
The wikiwijs arrangement Introduction to the Biobased Economy is made and kept up to date with
help of the Centre of Biobased Economy (CBBE).
In the Centre for Biobased Economy (CBBE) eight education and research institutes have joined their
efforts, with help of trade and industry, to educate young professionals for a strong and sustainable
biobased economy. Core activitities are:
Watch the two embedded videos for gaining a better understanding of what a biobased economy is.
Global warming
kn.nu/wwd7581e1 (youtu.be)
In the next figure the concentration of atmospheric carbon dioxide is depicted in the last thousands of
years. Data from an Antarctic ice cores reveals an interesting story for the past 400,000 years. during
this period, CO2 and temperatures are closely correlated, which means they rise and fall together.
In august 2015 the concentrations of carbon dioxide reached 399 ppm, explaining the concerns over
global warming. (In the graph the concentrations do not surpass 300 ppm, left axis).
Millions of years ago, huge numbers of microscopic animals and plants - plankton - died and fell to
the bottom of the sea. Their remains were covered by mud. As the mud sediment was buried by
more sediment, it started to change into rock as the temperature and pressure increased. The plant
and animal remains were cooked by this process, and slowly changed into crude oil.
Fossil resources has been fundamental to industrialization. They delivered energy but also served as
basic resource for producing materials such as plastics, paints, floor coverings, pharmaceuticals,
shampoos, clothing, computer mouses, asphalt.....
The limits of this resource had been foreseen and discussed back in the 1950s when Hubbert
(1956),developer of the Peak Oil theory, made the first extrapolations of future oil production rates.
The point in time when oil production within a given area (a single oil field, a country, a region or the
entire earth) reaches the maximum rate of production was later named peak oil. History has shown
Pagina 5 Introduction to the Biobased Economy
that in practice it is impossible to raise the rate of production after a decline. Hubbert said: The
amount of oil will never be completely finished, but the availability of oil will decline. In other words:
at a certain point in time there may still be oil but can we extract it?
Peak oil and oil demand, shortages will lead to higher prices for fossil fuels.
Let's take a look at the Dutch situation. The Groningen gas field is a giant natural gas field located
near Slochteren in the province Groningen in the eastern part of the Netherlands. Discovered in
1959, it is the largest natural gas field in Europe and the tenth-largest in the world. Substantial
income from the national gas endowment has been part of the Dutch governments operational
budget since 1963. The discoveries of oil at Schoonebeek (1943) and gas at Groningen(1959) have
had a tremendous impact on the postwar economic recovery of the Netherlands.
Does the Peak Oil theory apply to the Dutch gas bubble? Although much effort is invested to unlock
unconventional gas reservoirs large enough to delay the unfolding of a peak scenario for Dutch gas,
the answer be cautious yes.This is illustrated in the next figure.
The graph shows stacked on top of one another the production profiles of the Groningen Field, offshore small
fields, and onshore small fields.
In figure below is clearly illustrated that there energy consumption has increased immensely the past
two centuries. So, two conflicting issues can be ascertained: a decrease in the availability of fossil
fuels and an increase in the demand of energy worldwide.
Brazil is satisfying its fuel needs with bio-ethanol from sugar cane
Example Three
Mention in this short video how the Head of Operations of Clariant's Straubing biorefinery, explains
how their new plant uses the latest technology to produce fuel from residues left over after the wheat
harvest. The benefit is a sustainable energy source that substitutes for imported petrol and provides
additional income for local farmers.
kn.nu/ww1d5a78e (youtu.be)
Bio based Delta, an extensive biobased network of chemistry, process industry, greenhouses and
research facilitites along the North Sea.
Watch this video about the biobased delta.
https://vimeo.com/blocnl/biobasedbackbone
kn.nu/ww.af6f7d6 (vimeo.com)
kn.nu/ww.26eb0ec
(youtu.be)
Let us take the example of the fridge to explain the difference between our present lineair economy
and the circular economy.The present economy is ruled by the "end of pipe" principle. You buy a
fridge because you need cold to store and cool your food. When the fridge is not functioning properly
anymore only one option remains: discharge the fridge and return to the store to buy a new one. The
destiny of the old fridge is most often the garbage dump. The question is: do you need a fridge or do
you need cold? Obviously you need the latter: the cold. So, why not go to the store and ask for cold
in stead of a fridge? Imagine, you buy cold for several years. It is then up to the store to choose how
to fulfill your wishes. They can decide to provide you with a fridge. When this very fridge is broken
down, the store is obliged to replace the fridge. In the end, it is a prime interest for the store to deliver
a fridge that lasts long and to deliver a fridge that can easily be disassembled and all parts van be
reused.
Resuming, the circular economy aims at resuing and retrieving of the valuable raw materials. At the
end of the life cylce, products are collected and the all the indivudual components are seperated for a
future product. The circular economy requires innovative designs and production systems, adapted
logistics and business models. Meeting the needs of consumers and services wil be become more
important than owning products.
A circular economy seeks to rebuild capital, whether this is financial, manufactured, human, social or
natural. This ensures enhanced flows of goods and services. The system diagram illustrates the
continuous flow of technical and biological materials through the value circle. Click on the link to see
the diagram on the original website.
Many cultivated plants are grown for one specific purpose or prime ingredient. For example soy or
grass is produced because of the protein it contains, sun flowers and rape seed because of the oil,
and mais and sugar cane because of the sugars. In the figure below an illustration is given off the
utilization of all different parts of the plant, in this case hemp.
Principle 3: Use the most valuable parts of the biomass for the most added value products
The easiest way to converse biomass into a product is to combust it and produce energy. Burning
wood is world wide the most common method to produce heat. Think of the use of dead wood in
developing countries. Although this is a good example a biobased practice it can be questioned
whether this is the most ecologically desirable and economically profitable way.
The biobased economys value pyramid indicates that biomass value is determined by its
applications and end uses.
Converting biomass to energy is depicted at the bottom of the Value Piramid. The market for energy
is large (everyone needs energy) , but the market price is low. The market for fine chemicals or
pharmaceuricals is small but the price of these products is high. The intention is to convert the most
valuable parts of a plant to a product with a high added value. The principle entails optimal value
utilization meaning that those substances or materials that can be used in high quality products are
isolated first. So, a medicinal plant rich in special plant compounds is in the first instance used to
produce pharma. In second instance, applications of remaining components of the plant are being
sought in lower regions of the piramid. Taking manure as biomass stream, two high value
Initial causes of the late-2006 price spikes included droughts in grain-producing nations and rising oil
prices. Oil price increases also caused general escalations in the costs of fertilizers, food
transportation, and industrial agriculture. Root causes may be the increasing use of biofuels in
developed countries and an increasing demand for a more varied diet across the expanding middle-
class populations of Asia. These factors, coupled with falling world-food stockpiles all contributed to
the worldwide rise in food prices.
Although the rise of food prices can not be fully contributed to the production of first generation
biofuels, the food fuel debate had an enourmous impact on the european and dutch view on the use
of biomass. For example, EU directives were changed.
Old directive:
Under the Directive 2003/30/EC on the promotion of the use of biofuels or other renewable fuels for
transport, EU established the goal of reaching a 5.75% share of renewable energy in the transport
sector by 2010.
New directive:
Under the Directive 2009/28/EC on the promotion of the use of energy from renewable sources this
share rises to a minimum 10% in every Member State in 2020. Regarding the expand of biofuels use
in the EU, the Directive aims to ensure the use of sustainable biofuels only, which generate a clear
and net GHG saving without negative impact on biodiversity and land use.
Since the crisis Dutch efforts in the biobased economy were focussed on second and third
generation biofuels and the use of biomass for biomaterials & biochemicals instead of biofuels.
1.5 Learning
1.5.1 Multiple choice questions
1. The greenhouse effect is based on the relation between:
A. % CO2 en water availability
B. % CO2 en temperature
C. % O2 en water availability
D. % O2 en temperature
1.5.2 Assignments
sun flower
maize
sugar beet
reed
manure
In relation to principle 1: Use renewable resources which are available today for the needs of today
1. What is the production per year of the plant or waste steam in the Netherlands?
2. What is the current valorization of plant or waste stream? So, of what use is the biomass today?
(Recommendation: take a look at the example of the hemp plant, paragraph 1.3)
In relation to principle 3: Use the most valuable parts of the biomass for the most added value
products
5. List the applications from low value to high value.
6. Make the value pyramid (see paragraph 1.3) for your biomass.
Assignment 2
Read the following article about the biobased initiatiave HarvestaGG.
For a proper understanding of this chapter it is important to refresh the basic knowledge of
photosynthesis. To help your on your way the following video about photosynthesis is embedded.
Explanation of photosynthesis
kn.nu/wwcf4fdc9 (youtu.be)
Potential production is determined by light, ambient CO2 concentration, temperature and plant
characteristics. Crop management is assumed not to hamper growth. Under conditions with water
limitation, potential yields are reduced by water shortage. If nutrients are in short supply, but
assuming perfect water supply and full crop protection, yields are denoted as nutrient limited. Of
course most crop production suffer from a combination of water and nutrient shortage. In developing
countries the loss of production due to water or nutrient shortage is larger than in, for example, The
Netherlands. The availability of nutrients and water is stronlgy related to the soil quality. A high
quality soil has a good water holding capacity and steady rate of mineralisation creating a continuous
nutrient flow. A low quality soil retains no water and in this soil mineralisation hardly takes place
because of a lack of organic matter. Actual production refers to yields reduced by pests, weeds and
diseases and/or toxicities (e.g. pollution), often in combination with water and/or nutrient limitation.
Reality is always more complex, several factors concurrently exerting their influence, but this
framework can assist in analysing and understanding crop production situations. Potential growth
varies with latitude, altitude and time of the year. (Langeveld et al, 2010)
Artifical fertilisers are made by the so-called Haber-Bosch process. Carbon and oxygen are also
critical, but are easily obtained by plants from soil and air. Even though air is 78% nitrogen (N2),
atmospheric nitrogen is nutritionally unavailable; many plants are unable to use this form of nitrogen.
Nitrogen is a strong limiting nutrient in plant growth. In 1913 Carl Bosch managed to converse
nitrogen from the air in ammonia at full scale. Some people consider the Haber process to be the
most important invention of the past 200 years! The primary reason the Haber-Bosch process is
important is because ammonia is used as a plant fertilizer, enabling farmers to grow enough crops to
support an ever-increasing world population. The fixation of atmospheric nitrogen (N2) to ammonia
(NH3) via the Haber-Bosch process is equivalent to 1-2% of the world's annual energy consumption.
The process requires high temperatures and pressure. This is an important disadvantage of the
process; ik depends heavily on fossil energy.
Possible solutions for replacing artificial fertilisers are:
- the use of nitrogen fixating plants. Nitrogen fixation is a process by which nitrogen (N2) in the
atmosphere is converted into ammonium (NH4+). Plants that contribute to nitrogen fixation include
the legume family Fabaceae with taxa such as kudzu, clovers, soybeans, alfalfa, lupines,
peanuts, and rooibos They contain symbiotic bacteria called Rhizobia within nodules in their root
systems, producing nitrogen compounds that help the plant to grow and compete with other plants.
When the plant dies, the fixed nitrogen is released, making it available to other plants and this helps
to fertilize the soil
- switching to a (more) vegetarian diet. World meat consumption increased from 47 million tons in
1950 to 260 million tons in 2005, more than doubling consumption per person from 17 kilograms to
40 kilograms. Consumption of milk and eggs has also risen. In every society where incomes have
risen, meat consumption has too, perhaps reflecting a taste that evolved over 4 million years of
hunting and gathering. As depicted below the conversion of vegetable protein to meat leads to a loss
of protein. So, a vegetarian diet stimulates the economically most wise consumption of protein.
Phosphorus is one of the building blocks of all life. Every living cell requires it. Plants need
phosphorus to grow as much as they need water. Many soils do not have enough to meet the
demands for phosphorus of high production crops. By mining phosphate rock and turning it into
fertilizer to spread on the land phsphorus can be supplemented to the soil. Unlike nitrogen,
phosphorous (P) is a finite mineral resource (current global reserves depleted in 50100 years and
declining production will occur much earlier). Therefore, future crop production will increasingly have
to rely on recycling of P from urban areas, as well as on the breeding of crops that are more efficient
in utilizing the soil phosphorous.
The Bou Craa mine in the Western Sahara sends phosphate down a 150-kilometer-long conveyor
belt to the port of El Ayoun.
Currently, only about 15 percent of that comes from mines in the Western Sahara and Morocco. But
The soil is fundamental to biomass production, and there is a great challenge in developing new
agricultural methods in Europe that can improve organic matter levels, soil biological activity and soil
structure. Many cultivated soils show a steady decline of organic matter unless they receive frequent
applications of organic matter (e.g. animal manure, compost). Soil organic matter improves the water
holding capacity and the activity of living soil organisms and thus the soil structure and health.
Sustainable biomass production should lead to a maintained level of soil organic matter. As organic
matter levels have been declining for many years, it could be argued that even an increase in the
organic matter level would be desirable, trying to compensate for historic non-sustainable land use.
Soil organic matter can be managed by inputs (growing perennial crops and use of organic fertilizers)
and minimising the degree of disturbance, for example soil tillage (Langeveld et al, 2012) .
3. Second generation feedstocks generally contain more cellulose than starch. Therefore:
A. Second generation feedstocks have less competition with food
B. Second generation feedstocks result in stronger end products
C. Second generation feedstocks are more easily converted
D. Second generation feedstocks can be cultivated with less fertilisers
1. Greenhouse gases
Considered over the entire chain, the use of biomass needs to result in a sharp reduction in
greenhouse gas emissions compared to fossil fuels.
2. Competition with food and local applications of biomass
The production of biomass for energy purposes may not endanger the food supply or other
local applications.
3. Planet Biodiversity Biomass production may never harm protected or vulnerable biodiversity
but wherever possible needs to strengthen the biodiversity.
4. People Well-being The production of biomass needs to contribute to the well-being of the
employees and the local community.
5. Environment In the production and processing of biomass, the quality of the soil, surface and
ground water and air needs to be preserved, if not improved.
6. Profit Prosperity The production of biomass needs to contribute to the local economy.
each fruit containing about 50% oil. As a result they require ten times less land than other oil-
producing crops. In fact palm oil can be found in a huge percentage of every day supermarket
products. As a result they can be found in one in two supermarket products, ranging from margarine,
cereals, crisps, sweets and baked goods, to soaps, washing powders and cosmetics. Nevertheless
you may never have heard of palm oil since its rarely listed as an ingredient on product labels, with
the term vegetable oil often being used instead. Palm oil can also be used in animal feedstuffs and
as a bio fuel.
Question?
Is palm oil a sustainable biomass?
Search the internet and check the 6 sustainability criteria to formulate your answer.
Answers MC questions
1. C
2. C
3. A
The previous chapter discussed how the biomass as raw material can be produced. However,
biomass is not the endproduct. To make an endproduct conversion steps are necessary. Multiple
options exists to go from biomass to products. A nice overview of all the possibilities is given in the
so-called "Routekaart biobased economy" which you can find here.
Routekaart
kn.nu/wwef9fb87 (biobasedeconomy.nl)
For a proper understanding of this chapter it is important to refresh your knowledge about the
structure of the basic molecules in biology. Therefore the following video is embedded.
The major groups of these basic molecules are:
1. Sugars or carbohydrates
2. Proteins
3. Fats or triglycerides
4. Secondary metabolites (vitamins, compounds responsible for color, smell, taste, plant defense etc)
5. Minerals
Often biorefinery serves to (partly) separate the different groups of molecules, and to converse them
in order to form bioproducts.
The three main components of wood: cellulose, hemi-cellulose and lignin. There is one C5 sugar
present in hemi-cellulose. The C5 sugar has a ring with 5 angles.
After enzymatic hydrolysis yeasts ferment C6 sugars to ethanol whereas C5 sugars are not
fermented to ethanol by any natural microorganism in sufficiently high concentrations. A Dutch
company, Royal DSM, has developed the combined fermentation of C6 and C5 sugars from wheat
straw on an industrial scale. The combined fermentation results in a 40% increase in ethanol yield
per ton of straw, which can result in significant cost cuts in the production of bio-ethanol from
cellulosic feedstock. So, the company succeeded in producing industrial yeast strains that are
capable of co-fermenting glucose and certain C5 sugars.
Dilute or weak acid hydrolysis is one of the most effective pretreatment methods for
lignocellulosic biomass. Acid (sulphuric acid, sulphur dioxide, carbonic acid) is added to the
raw material and the mixture is held at elevated temperature (T > 160) for short period of time.
Hydrolysis of hemicellulose then occurs. Hemicellulose removal increases porosity and
improves enzymatic digestibility.
Alkaline hydrolysis. The major effect of alkaline pretreatment is the removal of lignin from
biomass, thereby improving the reactivity of the remaining polysaccharides, and
decrystallisation of cellulose. As opposed to the acid-catalysed methods, the general principle
behind alkaline pretreatment methods is the removal of lignin whereas cellulose and part of
the hemicelluloses remain in the solid fraction.
Examples HEALTH
The use of natural products with therapeutic properties (farma) is as ancient as human civilisation.
Of the 252 drugs considered as basic and essential by the World Health Organisation (WHO), 11%
are exclusively of plant origin and a significant number are synthetic drugs obtained from natural
precursors. Precursors are compounds needing one of more conversion steps to become an acitve
medicine. Examples of important drugs obtained from plants are digoxin from Digitalis spp., quinine
and quinidine from Cinchona spp., vincristrine and vinblastine from Catharanthus roseus, atropine
from Atropa belladona and morphine and codeine from Papaver somniferum.
Another group of high added value products are the personal care products enriche
In the following article the possibilities for The Netherlands to produce chemicals from biological
resources is explained.
Examples ENERGY
Biogas is produced by anaerobic fermentation as explained in Chapter 3.2. biogas can be converted
into electric power using combined heat and power (CHP, WKK in dutch) installations. Another
possibility is injection into the gas grid. Before being allowed entrance to the gas grid, biogas must
meet natural gas specifications. Purification (H2S removal), dehydration and partial shall removal of
carbon dioxide is needed to call biogas green gas.
The production of biofuels is another typical example of the use of biomass as energy. In the United
States and Brazil bio-ethanol feedstocks are primarily maize and sugar cane. In Europe oil rape seed
is the most important feedstock for biodiesel.
3.6 Learning
3.6.1 Multiple choice questions
4. Which process conversion technique does not affect the chemical strucure of the biomass
molecules?
A. Mechanical/physical conversion technique
B. Biochemical conversion technique
C. Chemical conversion technique
D. Thermochemical conversion technique
Assignment 2
In this assignment we will have a closer look at algae. Use the Internet for information.
The end product is presented on 1 A4 max.
Describe:
1. Minimal 5 products that can be derived from algae.
2. Minimal 2 techniques to extract compounds from algae.
3. Minimal 3 production methods to grow algae.
4. Give your own opinion about the future for algae.
Mention that sources (Internet links or book references) you have used to write your assignment.
Answers MC questions
1. B
2. A
3. D
4. A
4.1 Logistics
The purpose of logistics in biobased supply chains is to provide the right amounts of biomass of the
right quality at the right time to the right place. To meet the requirements of the industrial bioproducts
market (biofuels, bioenergy, biochemical and biomaterials) by delivering a qualitative steady, reliable
and year round supply of biomass, is a huge challenge. The relatively high moisture content and the
low bulk density of biomass coupled with a seasonal supply, in small quantities, spread over a large
number of locations, makes it even more complex to meet all these requirements. Logistical planning
is necessary for overcoming challenges of storage, handling and transportation. Besides this all the
logistical activities must be done as cheaply as possible to limit overall costs of producing industrial
bioproducts. Because of its low bulk density biomass must be densified to reduce transportation
costs. Also other pre-processing activities may be necessary to transform biomass into more suitable
forms for specific conversion technologies.
Reduced to its basic components, the industrial bioproducts value chain begins with harvesting or
collecting a feedstock, which is then transported and brought together at a central location for
processing into one or more bioproducts. This processing may involve both pre-processing and one
or more stages of primary processing and secondary processing, resulting in one or more
bioproducts, including energy / fuel, materials and chemicals:
An expanded bioproducts value chain generally consists of the following parts: cultivation, harvesting,
pre-processing, storage, processing and biorefinery, market distribution, product utilization and
recycling and local and long distance transport between the different links in the chain. A schematic
representation of these activities is as follows:
Each link has its own characteristics that affect the logistic activities in the supply chain. Below the
main characteristics that have direct implications for logistics are mentioned shortly.
Cultivation and harvesting
Cultivated biomass has to be transported to a more centralized location, because the supply of this
primary biomass is coming from several regionally dispersed areas. Due to the fact that cultivated
biomass can be harvested only in certain periods of the year, a buffering in storage facilities is
necessary.
Pre-processing and storage
Advantages of pre-processing of biomass can be a high material density, favourable dosing and flow
properties, low moisture level, better stability during storage, less dust during handling and
standardization of quality. Examples of pre-processing that have a qualitative and logistical cost
Answering these questions starts with a detailed analysis of the biomass chain. Simulation and
optimisation models can be used to support the design decision.
The Biobased Economy ,Biofuels, Materials and Chemicals in the Post-oil Era, Hans Langeveld en
Marieke Meeusen, 2012. Beschikbaar in bibliotheken of aan te schaffen.
5.2 References
Annevelink. E. De logistiek van biomassa voor de biobased economy; startnotitie, ISBN-nummer 978-
94-6173-609-3, 2013
Cherubini et al. Toward a comon classification approach for biorefinery systems. Biofuels, Biopord.
Bioref 3:534-546 2009
Harmsen, P. et al. pretreatment of lignocellulose for biotechnological production of lactic acid, WUR
report 1384, 2013
Langeveld et al. The Biobased Economy Biofuels, Materials and Chemicals in the Post-oil Era,
2012
McCormick, K. & Kautto, N The Bioeconomy in Europe: An Overview Sustainability 2013, 5, 2589-
2608
Ros et al. Sustainability of biomass in a bio-based economy, PBL Publication number: 500143001,
2012
Colofon
Project informatie en samenwerkingsverbanden
Dit project is tot stand gekomen door een samenwerking binnen het Centre of
Biobased Economy (getrokken door Wageningen UR, HAS Hogeschool, INHolland
Delft, VanHaLL Larenstein en CAH Vilentum). Om de ontwikkeling naar een sterke
biobased economy verder door te zetten bundelen onderwijs en bedrijfsleven hun
krachten binnen het Centre fo Biobased Economy (CBBE) om professionals op te
leiden. Het CBBE doet dat door:
- Kennisoverdracht en onderwijsontwikkeling
- Versterking toepassingsgericht onderzoek
- Stimulering van innovatieprojecten
Dit initiatief is mede mogelijk gemaakt door het ministerie van Economische Zaken.
Het doel van deze wikiwijs module is om een zo groot mogelijk aantal studenten te
bereiken.
Meer informatie
Deze oplage is voor een ieder openbaar te gebruiken. U mag het Document
kopiren en verspreiden in elk medium, alleen voor niet-commercile doeleinden,
onder het voorbehoud dat deze Licentie, de auteursrechtelijke kennisgevingen en
de licentiekennisgeving die aangeeft dat deze Licentie van toepassing is op het
Document weergegeven worden in alle kopien, en dat u geen enkele andere
voorwaarde toevoegt aan de voorwaarden van deze Licentie. U mag geen
technische maatregelen nemen die het lezen of verder kopiren van de exemplaren
die u maakt of verspreidt belemmeren of controleren.
Bronnen
Bron Type
Centre of Biobased Economy Link
http://www.cbbe.nl
https://youtu.be/LAoy0kwK7e0 Video
https://youtu.be/LAoy0kwK7e0
https://vimeo.com/blocnl/biobasedbackbone Link
https://vimeo.com/blocnl/biobasedbackbone
https://youtu.be/zCRKvDyyHmI Video
https://youtu.be/zCRKvDyyHmI