EVIDENCE

Atty. Demetrio C. Custodio

RULE 129 SECTIONS 1 & 2 JUDICIAL NOTICE

1. State Prosecutors vs. Muro 236 S 505

2. Spouses Latip v Rosalie Palana Chua GR 177809; Oct 10, 2009
3. People vs. Reanzares 334 S 624
4. People vs. Tundag 342 S 704

RULE 129 SECTION 4 JUDICIAL ADMISSIONS

1. Camitan v Fidelity GR 163684 April 16, 2008

2. Aguenza vs. Metropolitan Bank & Trust Co. 271 S 1
3. Philamgen vs. Sweet Lines, Inc. 212 S 195
4. Alano vs. CA 283 S 269
5. People vs. Solayao 262 SCRA 255

RULE 130 SECTION 1 OBJECT EVIDENCE

1. People vs. Manalo 219 S 656

2. People vs. Malimit 264 S 167
3. People vs. Jumamoy 221 S 333
4. People vs. Flores 328 S 461

Rule 130 SECTION 2- DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE

1. BPI v Reyes GR 157177 February 11, 2008

RULE 130 SECTION 3 BEST EVIDENCE RULE

1. Country Bankers Insurance Corp v Lagman 653 S 765

2. National Power Corporation v Codilla GR 170491 April 4, 2007
3. Borje vs. Sandiganbayan 125 S 763
4. Widows and Orphans Association, Inc. vs. CA 212 S 360
5. People vs. Tandoy 192 S 28
6. Security Bank and Trust Co. vs. Triumphs Lumber and Construction Corp. 301 S 537

RULE 130 SECTION 9 PAROL EVIDENCE RULE

1. Inciong, Jr. vs. CA 257 S 578

2. National Irrigation Administration vs. Gamit 215 S 436
3. Gurango vs. IAC 215 S 332
4. CKH Industrial and Development Corp. vs. CA 272 S 333

RULE 130 SECTION 20 WITNESSES

1. People vs. Taneo 218 S 494

2. People vs. Balanon 233 S 679
3. People vs. Baid 336 S 656
 4. People vs Lolito Honor 584 S 547
5. People vs Solomon Dioneda 587 S 312

RULE 130 SECTION 22 DISQUALIFICATION BY REASON OF MARRIAGE

1. Ordoo vs. Daquigan 62 S 270

2. People vs. Castaeda Jr. 88 S 562

RULE 130 SECTION 23 DEAD MAN STATUTE RULE

1. Razon vs. IAC 207 S 234

RULE 130 SECTION 24 DISQUALIFICATION BY REASON OF PRIVILEDGED

COMMUNICATION

1. US vs. Antipolo 37 P 726

2. Lim vs. CA 214 S 273
3. Krohn vs. CA 233 S 146
4. Fortich vs. CA 268 S 152

RULE 130 SECTION 26 ADMISSIONS OF A PARTY

1. People vs. Agustin 240 S 541

2. Tuason vs. CA 241 S 695
3. People vs. Chua Uy 327 S 335
4. People vs. Cepeda 324 S 290

RULE 130 SECTION 27 OFFER OF COMPROMISE NOT ADMISSIBLE

1. People vs. Lase 219 S 584

2. Trans Pacific Industrial Supplies, Inc. vs. CA 235 S 494
3. People vs. Buemio 265 S 582
4. People vs. Amaca 277 S 215

RULE 130 SECTION 30 ADMISSION BY CONSPIRATOR

1. People vs. Condemena 23 S 910

2. People vs. Provo 37 S 19
3. People vs. Puesca 87 S 130

RULE 130 SECTION 32 ADMISSION BY SILENCE

1. US vs. Bay 27 P 495

RULE 130 SECTION 33 CONFESSION

1. People vs. Agustin 240 S 541

2. People vs. Tiozon 198 S 368
3. People vs. Tujon 215 S 559
4. People vs Ladao GR 100940-41 November 27, 2001
5. People vs Encipido 146 S 478

2
 6. People vs Janjalani 639 S 157

RULE 130 SECTION 36 HEARSAY RULE

1. People vs. Valero 112 S 661

2. People vs. Damaso - 212 S 547
3. Agcaoli vs. Molina 249 S 482
4. People vs. Brioso 37 S 336

RULE 130 SECTION 37 DYING DECLARATION

1. People vs. De Joya 203 S 343

2. People vs. Dunig 215 S 469
3. People vs. Amaca 277 S 215
4. US vs. Antipolo 37 P 726

RULE 130 SECTION 42 PART OF THE RES GESTAE

1. People vs. Tiozon 198 S 368

2. People vs. Naranja 108 P 781
3. People vs. Palomones 336 S 80
4. People vs. Raquel 265 S 248

RULE 130 SECTION 44 ENTRIES IN OFFICIAL RECORDS

1. People vs. Bernaldez 294 S 317

2. People vs. Divina 221 S 209
3. People vs. Leones 117 S 382
4. People vs. Crisostomo 160 S 47
5. Feria vs. CA 325 S 525

RULE 130 SECTION 47 TESTIMONY OR DEPOSITION AT A FORMER

PROCEEDING

1. De Leon vs. People 210 S 151

RULE 130 SECTION 48 OPINION RULE

1. Lim vs. CA 214 S 273 (supra)

2. People vs. Galleno 291 S 762

RULE 130 SECTION 49 OPINION OF EXPERT WITNESS

1. Cebu Shipyard and Engineering Works, Inc. vs. William Lines, Inc. 306 S 762

RULE 131 SECTION 1 BURDEN OF PROOF

1. Jimenez vs. NLRC 256 S 84

2. Mallari vs. CA 265 S 456

RULE 131 SECTION 3 DISPUTABLE PRESUMPTIONS

3
 1. Lozano vs. De Los Santos 274 S 45
2. LRT vs. Natividad 397 S 75
3. Del San Transport Lines vs. C&A Const. Inc. 412 S 524
4. People vs. De Guzman 229 S 795
5. People vs. Navaja 220 S 624
6. People vs. Castaeda 252 S 247
7. People vs. Simbulan 214 S 537
8. People vs. Balluda 318 S 503

RULE 132 SECTION 3 RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS OF A WITNESS

(IN RELATION TO THE RIGHT AGAINST SELF-INCRIMINATION)

1. People vs. Salveron 228 S 92

2. People vs. Malimit 264 S 167 (supra)

RULE 132 SECTION 4 ORDER IN THE EXAMINATION OF AN INDIVIDUAL

WITNESS

1. Bachrach Motors Co. Inc. vs. CIR 86 S 27

2. People vs. Padero 226 S 810

RULE 132 SECTION 10 LEADING AND MISLEADING QUESTIONS

1. People vs. Caparas 111 S 68

RULE 132 SECTION 13 HOW WITNESS IMPEACHED BY EVIDENCE OF

INCONSISTENT STATEMENTS

1. US vs. Baluyot 40 P 385

2. People vs. Relucio 86 S 227
3. People vs. Winston De Guzman 288 S 346

RULE 132 SECTION 19 CLASSES OF DOCUMENTS

1. Joson vs. Baltazar 194 S 114

2. Sales vs. CA 211 S 858
3. Lucente vs. Evangelista, Jr. 396 S 627
4. Yturralde vs. Azurin 28 S 407

ELECTRONIC EVIDENCE (as functional equivalent of documentary evidence)

Read: MC Industrial Corp v Ssangyong GR 170633, October 17, 2007

RULE 132 SECTION 20 PROOF OF PRIVATE DOCUMENT

1. Raz vs. IAC 184 S 720

2. Ong vs. People 342 S 372

4
RULE 132 SECTION 22 HOW GENUINENESS OF HANDWRITING PROVED

1. Layno vs. People 213 S 686

2. Jacob vs. CA 224 S 189
3. Security Bank and Trust Co. vs. Triumph Lumber and Construction Corp. 301 S
537 (supra)
4. Sy vs. CA 330 S 550

RULE 132 SECTION 23 PUBLIC DOCUMENTS AS EVIDENCE

1. Realubit v Jaso 658 S 146

2. Manzano Jr v Garcia 661 S 186

RULE 132 SECTION 34 OFFER OF EVIDENCE

1. Heirs of Carmen Cruz-Zamora v Multiwood International Inc GR 146428, January

19, 2009
2. Heirs of Pasag v Spouses Parocha et al GR 155483 April 27, 2007
3. Catuira vs. CA 236 S 398
4. Vda. de Onate vs. CA 250 S 283
5. Sy vs. CA 330 S 550 (supra)
6. Macasiray vs. People 291 S 154
7. Tuason vs. CA 241 S 695
8. Candido and Rumbaua vs. CA 253 S 78
9. People vs. Barellano 319 S 567
10. People vs. Sanchez 308 S 264

RULE 133
SECTION 1 PREPONDERANCE OF EVIDENCE, HOW DETERMINED
SECTION 2 PROOF BEYOND REASONABLE DOUBT

1. DBP Pool of Accredited Insurance Companies vs Radio Mindanao Network GR

147039, Jan 27, 2006
2. Encinas v National Book Store GR 162704, November 19, 2004
3. People vs Villarico GR 158362, April 4, 2011
4. People vs. Mejia 55 S 453
5. People vs. Matrimonio 215 S 613
6. People vs. Gondora 265 S 408
7. People vs. Cabiles 248 S 207
8. People vs. Lorenzo 240 S 624
9. People vs. Rigodon 238 S 27
10. Tin vs. People 362 S 594

RULE 133 SECTION 4 CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE, WHEN SUFFICIENT

1. People v Anticamara GR 178771, June 8, 2011

2. People vs. Salvame 270 S 766
3. People vs. Malimit 264 S 167 (supra)
4. People vs. Ramos 240 S 191

5
 5. People vs. Adofina 239 S 67

RULE 133 SECTION 5 SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE

1. Ang Tibay vs. CIR 69 P 635

2. Bascos v Taganahan GR 180666, February 18, 2009
3. Fabella vs. CA 282 S 256
4. PAL vs. NLRC 263 S 638
5. Villaflor vs. CA 280 S 297