DowWH-2595

Ex. 5 -- Deliberative Process Privilege; Ex. 5 -- Attorney Client Privilege; Ex. 7(A) -- Law Enforcement Proceedings

Catherine

Catherine
To
David Batson, Deborah Dalton

Garypie //

Garypie
R5

5/

5/

R
USEPA/
/US

USEPA

cc

03/03/2008 01:53 PM

bcc

Subject
Fw: Access agreement documents and implementation plan

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

PRIVILEGED

FOIA-

-EXEMPT

-EXEMPT

FOIA

U.S. EPA/MDEQ.
Exemption 5; Exemption 7(a)
... Non-responsive .

Catherine Garypie, Associate Regional Counsel

Office of Regional Counsel

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Region 5

77 West Jackson Blvd. (C-14J)

Chicago, Illinois 60604

PH 312-886-5825

FAX 312-886-0747

email: garypie.catherine@epa.gov

CONFIDENTIAL: This message may contain information that is privileged or otherwise exempt from

disclosure under applicable law . Do not disclose without consulting the Office of Regional Counsel . If you

think you received this email in error, please notify the sender immediately.

----- Forwarded by Catherine Garypie/R5/USEPA/US on 03/03/2008 01 :50 PM -----

Catherine
Catherine

Garypie //

Garypie
R5

5/

5/

R
USEPA/
/US

USEPA
To
Leverett Nelson/R5/USEPA/US

03/03/2008 01 :50 PM
cc
Jeff Cahn/R5/USEPA/US@EPA

Subject
Re: Fw: Access agreement documents and implementation

plan

PRIVILEGED /CONFIDENTIAL
PRIVILEGED
CONFIDENTIAL
/FOIA

FOIA-

FOIA-EXEMPT

EXEMPT

OK, I am heading out the door now. One quick thought...

Exemption 5; Exemption 7(a)

While I am on travel (I'm back on Wed), you may be able to reach

me on my cell ( Non-responsive ) or tonight at Non-responsive or tomorrow at the U .S. EPA

Westlake Ohio offices.

Catherine Garypie, Associate Regional Counsel

Office of Regional Counsel

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Region 5

77 West Jackson Blvd. (C-14J)

Chicago, Illinois 60604

PH 312-886-5825

FAX 312-886-0747

email: garypie.catherine@epa.gov
CONFIDENTIAL: This message may contain information that is privileged or otherwise exempt from

disclosure under applicable law . Do not disclose without consulting the Office of Regional Counsel . If you

think you received this email in error, please notify the sender immediately.
DowWH-2854

Ex. 5 -- Deliberative Process Privilege

Mathur

Bharat Mathur /R5

5/
5/

USEPA
USEPA
/US

//

US

To
Barry Breen

03/28/2008 10:59 AM
cc

bcc
Mary Gade

Subject

History:
This message has been forwarded .

Barry, below is the email from Steve Ells that I had mentioned earlier in our call .

Exemption 5

I look forward to hearing from you; please feel free to call on my cell phone at Non-responsive

Bharat Mathur

Deputy Regional Administrator

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

Region 5

Phone: 312-886-3000

Fax: 312-353-1120

----- Forwarded by Bharat Mathur/R5/USEPA/US on 03/28/2008 10:50 AM -----

Cynthia Faur
Faur
/R

//

R5

5/

5 /USEPA

USEPA/

USEPA
USEPA

US
To

03/28/2008 10:48 AM

Subject

----- Forwarded by Wendy Carney/R5/USEPA/US on 03/24/2008 01:53 PM -----

Steve Ells
Ells

/DC/

DC

/USEPA

/USEPA
USEPA

/US

03/24/2008 12:52 PM
Wendy Carney/R5/USEPA/US@EPA

To

cc

Subject My phone call on April 8 briefing

Wendy,

Exemption 5
 Exemption 5

Exemption 5
Would you mind sending an invite to the right

people at the State and let me know if you and/or they want to participate?

Please call so we can discuss this further.

Steve

Stephen J. Ells

703 603-8822

FAX: 703 603-9112

Mailing Address:

US EPA, OSRTI, 5204P

1200 Pennsylvania Ave. N.W.

Washington DC 20460

Fedex/UPS Address:

One Potomac Yard South

5th Floor - # 5237

2777 S. Crystal Drive

Arlington VA. 22202

DowWH-3186

Ex. 5 -- Deliberative Process Privilege

RALPH

To
James Woolford

DOLLHOPF
DOLLHOPF
//

R5

5/

5/USEPA

R
USEPA/
/
/US

USEPA

cc

04/16/2008 09:08 AM

bcc
Mary Gade

Subject
edited note to Susan

History:
This message has been replied to and forwarded .

Jim, I've edited your note -see below. Exemption 5

Per your other question, Non-responsive

Exemption 5

DowWH-3200

Ex. 5 -- Deliberative Process Privilege

RALPH

To
James Woolford

DOLLHOPF
DOLLHOPF
//

R5

5/

5/USEPA

R
USEPA/
/
/US

USEPA

cc

04/16/2008 03:13 PM

bcc
Mary Gade

Subject
Re: Deliberative - Update on Dow contacts with HQ

History:
This message has been forwarded .

Thanks Jim.

Will Exemption 5 and transmit to you tonight or

tomorrow.

James Woolford

----- Original Message -----

From: James Woolford

Sent: 04/16/2008 03: 57 PM EDT

To: bodine. susan@epa. gov; breen. barry@epa. gov

Cc: Ralph Dollhopf; Barnes Johnson; southerland. elizabeth@epa. gov; Doug

Ammon; Steve Ells; Norman Niedergang; Dave Wright; Marc Greenberg

Subject: Deliberative - Update on Dow contacts with HQ

Exemption 5
 Exemption 5

James E. Woolford, Director

Office of Superfund Remediation &

Technology Innovation (OSRTI)

Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response

US Environmental Protection Agency

Mailing Address:

1200 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

Mail Code: 5201P

Washington, DC 20460

Physical Address:

Room 5622

2777 Crystal Drive South (Potomac Yard South)

Arlington, VA 22202

Phone:

(O) 703 603-8960 (secretary)

(D) 703-603-8722

(F) 703 603-9146

OSRTI Web Site: http://www.epa.gov/superfund

DowWH-3201

Ex. 5 -- Deliberative Process Privilege

RALPH

To
James Woolford

DOLLHOPF
DOLLHOPF
//

R5

5/

5/USEPA

R
USEPA/
/
/US

USEPA

cc

04/16/2008 03:13 PM

bcc
"Mary Gade", "Bharat Mathur"

Subject
Re: Deliberative - Update on Dow contacts with HQ

Thanks Jim.

Will Exemption 5 and transmit to you tonight or

tomorrow.

James Woolford

----- Original Message -----

From: James Woolford

Sent: 04/16/2008 03: 57 PM EDT

To: bodine. susan@epa. gov; breen. barry@epa. gov

Cc: Ralph Dollhopf; Barnes Johnson; southerland. elizabeth@epa. gov; Doug

Ammon; Steve Ells; Norman Niedergang; Dave Wright; Marc Greenberg

Subject: Deliberative - Update on Dow contacts with HQ

Exemption 5
 Exemption 5

James E. Woolford, Director

Office of Superfund Remediation &

Technology Innovation (OSRTI)

Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response

US Environmental Protection Agency

Mailing Address:

1200 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

Mail Code: 5201P

Washington, DC 20460

Physical Address:

Room 5622

2777 Crystal Drive South (Potomac Yard South)

Arlington, VA 22202

Phone:

(O) 703 603-8960 (secretary)

(D) 703-603-8722

(F) 703 603-9146

OSRTI Web Site: http://www.epa.gov/superfund

DowWH-3211

Ex. 5 -- Deliberative Process Privilege

RALPH

To
James Woolford

DOLLHOPF
DOLLHOPF
//

R5

5/

5/USEPA

R
USEPA/
/
/US

USEPA

cc
"southerland elizabeth"

04/17/2008 02:03 PM

bcc
Mary Gade

Subject
Re: made a slighyt change- use this one

History:
This message has been forwarded .

Thanks, Jim. Have a couple of comments that I'll get to Betsy tomorrow. Ill see about Exemption 5 as

well.

James Woolford

----- Original Message -----

From: James Woolford

Sent: 04/17/2008 01: 52 PM EDT

To: Ralph Dollhopf

Cc: southerland. elizabeth@epa. gov

Subject: Re: made a slighyt change- use this one

Ralph

Thanks,

I Exemption 5 .

Exemption 5
.

See how you like it.

[attachment "Dow letter.doc" deleted by RALPH DOLLHOPF/R5/USEPA/US]

I think Exemption 5
.

I am Exemption 5

Thanks for your help and doing the first draft.

And, as things come up, please feel free to contact me.

James E. Woolford, Director

Office of Superfund Remediation &

Technology Innovation (OSRTI)

Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response

US Environmental Protection Agency

Mailing Address:

1200 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

Mail Code: 5201P

Washington, DC 20460

Physical Address:

Room 5622

2777 Crystal Drive South (Potomac Yard South)

Arlington, VA 22202
Phone:

(O) 703 603-8960 (secretary)

(D) 703-603-8722

(F) 703 603-9146

OSRTI Web Site: http://www.epa.gov/superfund

RALPH DOLLHOPF/R5/USEPA/US

RALPH

DOLLHOPF
DOLLHOPF
//

R5

5/

5/USEPA

R
USEPA/
/
/US

USEPA

To
James Woolford/DC/USEPA/US@EPA

04/17/2008 08:56 AM
cc

Subject
made a slighyt change- use this one

[attachment "Dow letter.doc" deleted by RALPH DOLLHOPF/R5/USEPA/US]

DowWH-3212

Ex. 5 -- Deliberative Process Privilege

RALPH

To
James Woolford

DOLLHOPF
DOLLHOPF
//

R5

5/

5/USEPA

R
USEPA/
/
/US

USEPA

cc
"southerland elizabeth"

04/17/2008 02:03 PM

bcc
"Mary Gade", "Bharat Mathur"

Subject
Re: made a slighyt change- use this one

Thanks, Jim. Have a couple of comments that I'll get to Betsy tomorrow. Ill see about Exemption 5 as

well.

James Woolford

----- Original Message -----

From: James Woolford

Sent: 04/17/2008 01: 52 PM EDT

To: Ralph Dollhopf

Cc: southerland. elizabeth@epa. gov

Subject: Re: made a slighyt change- use this one

Ralph

Thanks,

Exemption 5

See how you like it.

[attachment "Dow letter.doc" deleted by RALPH DOLLHOPF/R5/USEPA/US]

I think Exemption 5

I am Exemption 5 .

Thanks for your help and doing the first draft.

And, as things come up, please feel free to contact me.

James E. Woolford, Director

Office of Superfund Remediation &

Technology Innovation (OSRTI)

Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response

US Environmental Protection Agency

Mailing Address:

1200 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

Mail Code: 5201P

Washington, DC 20460

Physical Address:

Room 5622

2777 Crystal Drive South (Potomac Yard South)

Arlington, VA 22202

Phone:
(O) 703 603-8960 (secretary)

(D) 703-603-8722

(F) 703 603-9146

OSRTI Web Site: http://www.epa.gov/superfund

RALPH DOLLHOPF/R5/USEPA/US

RALPH

DOLLHOPF
DOLLHOPF
//

R5

5/

5/USEPA

R
USEPA/
/
/US

USEPA

To
James Woolford/DC/USEPA/US@EPA

04/17/2008 08:56 AM
cc

Subject
made a slighyt change- use this one

[attachment "Dow letter.doc" deleted by RALPH DOLLHOPF/R5/USEPA/US]

DowWH-3224

Ex. 5 -- Deliberative Process Privilege

RALPH

To
Elizabeth Southerland

DOLLHOPF
DOLLHOPF
//

R5

5/

5/USEPA

R
USEPA/
/
/US

USEPA

cc
Debbie Dietrich, James Woolford, Kenneth Patterson,

04/18/2008 10:44 AM
manges.ellen, Phyllis Anderson, southerland.elizabeth,

tulis.dana

bcc
Mary Gade

Subject
Re: Letter to Susan B and Grant from the Lone Tree Council

History:
This message has been forwarded .

per your request, a few comments for you to consider if you wish...

Elizabeth Southerland/DC/USEPA/US

Elizabeth

Elizabeth

Southerland
Southerland
/DC

//

DC/

/USEPA

DC
USEPA/
/US

/USEPA

To
James Woolford/DC/USEPA/US@EPA

04/16/2008 01 :34 PM
cc
Debbie Dietrich/DC/USEPA/US@EPA,

manges.ellen@epa.gov, RALPH

DOLLHOPF/R5/USEPA/US@EPA,

southerland.elizabeth@epa.gov, tulis.dana@epa.gov,

Kenneth Patterson/DC/USEPA/US@EPA, Phyllis

Anderson/DC/USEPA/US@EPA

Subject
Re: Letter to Susan B and Grant from the Lone Tree Council

Attached in this email is Exemption 5 . Please give

me
Exemption 5

James Woolford/DC/USEPA/US

James

James

Woolford

Woolford //

DC/

DC

/USEPA/
USEPA

/US
To
RALPH DOLLHOPF/R5/USEPA/US@EPA

04/15/2008 01 :19 PM
cc
manges.ellen@epa.gov, southerland.elizabeth@epa.gov,

Debbie Dietrich/DC/USEPA/US@EPA, tulis.dana@epa.gov

 Subject
Letter to Susan B and Grant from the Lone Tree Council

FYI - Just in today..

It has been assigned to Exemption 5 . We'll coordinate with

Exemption 5

James E. Woolford, Director

Office of Superfund Remediation &

Technology Innovation (OSRTI)

Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response

US Environmental Protection Agency

Mailing Address:

1200 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

Mail Code: 5201P

Washington, DC 20460

Physical Address:

Room 5622

2777 Crystal Drive South (Potomac Yard South)

Arlington, VA 22202

Phone:

(O) 703 603-8960 (secretary)

(D) 703-603-8722

(F) 703 603-9146

OSRTI Web Site: http://www.epa.gov/superfund

DowWH-3228

Ex. 5 -- Deliberative Process Privilege

RALPH

To
Elizabeth Southerland

DOLLHOPF
DOLLHOPF
//

R5

5/

5/USEPA

R
USEPA/
/
/US

USEPA

cc
James Woolford

04/18/2008 11:25 AM

bcc
Mary Gade

Subject
Letter to Dow

History:
This message has been forwarded .

Jim/ Betsy,

Made a few more changes. This version is

Exemption 5

Thanks.
DowWH-3236

Ex. 5 -- Deliberative Process Privilege

Samantha

Samantha
To
Mary Gade, Bharat Mathur, R5 SFD EPA, R5 SFD

Harvey /R

Harvey
//

R5

5/

5/USEPA

R
USEPA/
USEPA

USEPA

/

US
NON-EPA, Anne Rowan, Anthony Carrollo, Barry Breen,

04/18/2008 04:39 PM
BONNIE ELEDER, Craig Beasley, Douglas Dixon, Gary

Gulezian, Judy Beck, Larry Zaragoza, Laura Lodisio, Mardi

Klevs, Margaret Guerriero, Mark Johnson, Mary Canavan,

RALPH DOLLHOPF, Nancy Browne, Patricia Gowland, Phil

Hoffman, Rita Cestaric, Sally Swanson, Tinka Hyde, William

Franz, Robert Bronstrup, Elizabeth Southerland, Daniel

Oriordan, Dan Hopkins, James Vanderkloot, Maryann Suero,

Jon Gulch, James Justice, Brian Kelly, Jeffrey Kimble, Susan

Bromm, Dana Tulis, Ernie Watkins, Ed Chu, Patricia Mott,

Elmore Christenson, John Perrecone, Jennifer Ostermeier,

Syed Quadri, George Stone, Noel Vargas, Aimee Storm,

Susan Bodine, James Woolford, Debbie Dietrich, Barnes

Johnson, GailAnn Cooper, Bob.Frey, nehlshl, jdavis1,

DykemaL, rita.messing, Theresa Holz, Scott Sherman, Jayne

Michaud, KarenL Martin, Pat Carey, Jim Byrne, Cyndy

Colantoni, Walter Kovalick, Melissa Gibbons, Ronna

Beckmann

cc

bcc

Subject
Superfund Reports of Significant Activities - 04/18/08

The attached file is the Superfund, Region 5, "Reports of Significant Developments and Activities Ending

on April 11, 2008."