DOI 10.1007/s00710-001-0178-8
Summary
Many granitoid intrusions display textural evidence for the interaction of mac and
silicic magmas during their genesis. The 400 Ma Galway Granite exhibits excellent
evidence for magma mixing and mingling both at outcrop=map scale (magma mingling
and mixing zones), and at thin-section=crystal scale (mixing textures). These textures
quartz ocelli, rapakivi feldspars, acicular and mixed apatite morphologies, inclusion
zones in feldspars, anorthite `spikes' in plagioclase, sphene ocelli, K-feldspar mega-
crysts in mac microgranular enclaves (MME), and mac clots constitute a textural
assemblage whose origin can be explained in terms of magma mixing and mingling
models. Furthermore, textures from this assemblage have been recorded throughout the
Galway batholith indicating that magma mingling and mixing played a key role during
its evolution.
Introduction
It is recognised that mac (mantle-derived) magmas have an important role to play
in the generation of granitic melts, through, for example, providing the heat energy
for crustal anatexis (e.g. Huppert and Sparks, 1988; Wiebe, 1996). Petrologists
have also recognised that the wide range of rock types observed in many calc-
alkaline intrusions can be produced through mixing and mingling of mac and
felsic magmas (e.g. Reid et al., 1983; Frost and Mahood, 1987; Hibbard, 1991)
for a historical review of this idea see Wilcox (1999). Often, it will be geochemical
and isotopic data that provide much of the evidence for hybridisation (linear trends
on Harker diagrams being an obvious example), but fundamental to such inter-
pretations is the recognition of petrographic textures that may form during such
64 S. Baxter and M. Feely
Fig. 1. Simplied map of the Galway Granite, showing the distribution of the major
granites (s.l.). The Barna area is outlined
interactions (Hibbard, 1991). Field evidence for magma mingling (mac sheets and
MME hosted by the incompletely mixed magma mingling and mixing zone
(MMZ) granodiorite) and geochemical evidence for magma mixing (linear trends
on Harker diagrams) have been described previously from the Galway Granite,
Connemara, Ireland (El Desouky et al., 1996; Crowley and Feely, 1997). This paper
describes an assemblage of magma mixing and mingling textures from the recently
mapped Barna area (Baxter, 2000) at the eastern end of the Galway Granite (Fig. 1).
Granite), alkali feldspar granites (Murvey Granite), and the Roundstone Granite
satellite pluton (Coats and Wilson, 1971; Leake, 1974, 1978). The upthrown
Central Block (Leake, 1978; Madden, 1987) exposes a much wider range of li-
thologies. An axial ESE-trending magma mixing and mingling zone (MMZ),
composed of mac enclaves hosted in the MMZ Granodiorite, is bound to the
north by the Megacrystic Granite (MG) and intruded to the south by the Lough
Lurgan, Knock and Murvey Granites (El Desouky et al., 1996; Crowley and Feely,
1997).
In the Barna area, Baxter (2000) recorded a new but signicantly narrower
(< 100 m) magma mingling and mixing zone (the Barna Mingling and Mixing
Zone BMZ see Fig. 1). It strikes in an ESE direction across the southern part of
the area, approximately parallel to the 34 km wide MMZ mapped to the west
(El Desouky et al., 1996; Crowley and Feely, 1997). The BMZ is similar, but not
identical, to the MMZ, which has an aphyric or weakly plagioclase-phyric
granodiorite host the MMZ Granodiorite contrasting with the megacrystic
nature of the BMZ Granodiorite.
The magma mingling and mixing textures from the Barna area
The textures presented below come from the two mappable units (the Megacrystic
Granite and the BMZ) described in the previous section (also see Table 1). These
textures, attributable to magma mingling and mixing, are as follows: (a) quartz
ocelli; (b) rapakivi and anti-rapakivi feldspars; (c) acicular and mixed apatite
morphologies; (d) inclusion zones in feldspars; (e) anorthite `spikes' in plagio-
clase; (f) sphene-plagioclase ocelli; (g) K-feldspar megacrysts in MME; (h) mac
clots.
Quartz ocelli
These consist of quartz crystals rimmed by hornblende and=or biotite (Fig. 3a,b).
They are recorded from the MG-hosted MME, and from the MME from the BMZ.
In the latter, hornblende-rimmed quartz ocelli ( 1 cm in diameter) can occur
locally at a population density of 10 per 100 cm2. Cole (1916) described the BMZ
as `composite gneiss near Barna' and interpreted the magma mixing and mingling
features as being the result of granite entering schists along their foliation planes.
The invading magma was inferred to have increased the silica-percentage of the
schists ``as may be seen by the abundance of small knots of quartz.'' Over fty
Table 1. The lithological distribution of the magma mingling and mixing textures in the
Barna area, with indication as to the relative abundance of each texture in each lithology
Texture=Host rock Megacrystic MME hosted BMZ MME hosted
Granite by Megacrystic Granodiorite by BMZ
Granite Granodiorite
Mac clots Very frequent Frequent Frequent Frequent
near MME,
rare otherwise
Quartz ocelli Infrequent Frequent in
some zones,
rare in others
Rapakivi feldspars Infrequent Frequent Frequent
Acicular and Frequent Frequent
mixed apatite
Inclusion zones Frequent Frequent Frequent
in feldspar
Anorthite spikes Frequent Frequent
in feldspar
Sphene-plagioclase Infrequent Infrequent
ocelli (although
frequent in
certain areas
of the MMZ)
K-feldspar Frequent Frequent
megacrysts in MME
Fig. 3. Field and thin section photographs of various hybridisation textures in the Galway Granite. a Quartz-hornblende ocelli in hybrid MME from the BMZ;
b Thin section of quartz-hornblende ocellus from hybrid MME, BMZ; c Resorbed K-feldspar with plagioclase mantle (rapakivi texture), BMZ Granodiorite;
d Acicular apatite and mac clot, MME from BMZ; e Zone of inclusions of biotite and hornblende, BMZ Granodiorite; f Anorthite spike and apatite-rich
overgrowth on plagioclase, MG-hosted MME. g Polished hand specimen of MME from MMZ, showing numerous sphene-plagioclase ocelli, with h thin section
(PPL) of this sample; i Two sphene-plagioclase ocelli from MG-hosted MME. Note lack of mac minerals in plagioclase `halo'; j Part of sphene-plagioclase
ocellus from MG-hosted MME. Note laths of plagioclase in ophitic relationship with sphene; k Hybrid MME from BMZ, with K-feldspar megacrysts crossing
contact between MME and host granodiorite; l Mac clot (mainly hornblende and opaques) in MG adjacent to MME
S. Baxter and M. Feely: Magma mixing and mingling textures in granitoids 69
years later, Coats and Wilson (1971) wrote of quartz and K-feldspar invading the
cognate xenoliths ( MME) in the MG increasingly as granitisation proceeds, with
the resultant quartz porphyroblasts sometimes having a mac rim. These quartz
based textures are most likely the quartz ocelli described above.
The formation of quartz ocellar hybrid rocks in the Tyrone Igneous Series was
attributed by Angus (1962) to metasomatic transformation of basalt xenoliths en-
gulfed in granitic magma. More recent interpretations of the structure (Vernon,
1990, 1991; Hibbard, 1991) conclude that as mac and felsic magmas mix, quartz
crystals from the felsic system are introduced into a new, more mac hybrid magma,
an environment in which they are unstable. Marginal solution of the quartz
xenocryst extracts latent heat of crystallisation from the adjacent melt, causing
localised under-cooling. This promotes the nucleation of, for example, hornblende,
leading to the growth of ne-grained aggregates which use the xenocrysts as a
substrate. Subsequent precipitation of quartz may `lock in' the hornblende rim,
preserving the texture, and leading to an outer rim which is devoid of mac minerals
(Fig. 4a). A review of the ocellar texture both its occurrence and petrogenetic
interpretations of its origin by Palivcova et al. (1995) concluded that magma
mixing was the only process which could satisfactorily explain its occurrence.
Fig. 4. Schematic diagrams (after Hibbard, 1991) illustrating possible ways in which the
recorded magma mixing and mingling textures from the Barna area may have formed
70 S. Baxter and M. Feely
Rapakivi feldspars
This texture, in which K-feldspar crystals are rimmed by plagioclase, is most
obvious in the BMZ Granodiorite and MME (Fig. 3c). Hibbard (1981) attributed the
formation of mantled feldspars to magma mixing (Fig. 4b), and used the texture as
one of the twelve textures which could form part of an assemblage of magma
mixing textures (Hibbard, 1991). Mixing of magmas of contrasting composition
leads to quenching of the more mac magma, and may result in the epitaxial growth
of plagioclase onto K-feldspar crystals derived from the more felsic magma.
Sphene-plagioclase ocelli
This texture consists of sphene crystals (commonly in ophitic relationship with
calcic plagioclase laths) within a zone of plagioclase quartz K-feldspar, which
is notably devoid of biotite and hornblende. These ovoid ocelli are up to 0.5 cm
across and a spectacular occurrence of the texture is found in the MMZ, outside the
Barna area (Fig. 3g,h). The texture is also displayed by the MME in the MG and
the BMZ (Fig. 3i,j). Hibbard (1991) presents a two-stage mixing model for the
formation of this texture (Fig. 4g). During the rst mixing, the undercooling of
the more mac system results in the crystallisation of the plagioclase and sphene in
ophitic relationship in the more mac magma. Mixing leads to the mantling of the
sphene-plagioclase unit with plagioclase, K-feldspar and quartz. A second mixing
event with more mac magma causes these partially-crystallised units to dis-
aggregate, and leads to the crystallisation of biotite in the inter-ocellar area.
Hibbard (1991) notes that, due to the special conditions required to create this
texture, it is quite rare.
Mac clots
Hornblende occurs in association with biotite and the accessory minerals sphene,
allanite, apatite and the opaque minerals in `mac clots' (c. 2 mm long), where
72 S. Baxter and M. Feely
the component crystals are 0.1 to 0.5 mm in size (Fig. 3l). These clots have a
granular texture, with the constituent crystals being euhedral to subhedral, and
are of edenitic ferrohornblende composition (Crowley, 1997). The clots occur
in all of the lithologies described from the Barna area. Indeed, similar clots have
been recorded by previous workers in similar lithologies to the west and east of
the Barna area, e.g. Coats and Wilson (1971), and Callaghan (1999). Elsewhere,
mac clots with a ``granoblastic-like texture'' have been described from calc-
alkaline plutons by Castro and Stephens (1992), and Sial et al. (1998). They
may be the result of pyroxene crystals reacting with a magma precipitating calcic
amphibole. While these mac clots are common in the MG-hosted MME
(sometimes comprising up to 15% of the rock), they are usually only seen in
samples of the MG itself which are adjacent to MME (Callaghan, 1999; Baxter,
2000). This distribution suggests that the clots have originated in the mac magma
which has formed the MME, and their presence in the MG is due to limited
interaction between the MG and the mac magma.
Conclusions
This paper has shown that the Galway Granite in general, and the Barna area in
particular, is an outstanding natural laboratory in which to study magma mingling
and mixing, due to the many mixing-compatible textures which are identiable.
The heterogeneous nature of this mixing is indicated by the varying distribution of
the textures between and indeed within lithologies. Does this reect localised
incidental mixing? Petrographic descriptions by previous workers from adjoining
areas, e.g. Coats and Wilson (1971), Feely (1982), El Desouky (1992), Crowley
(1997) and Callaghan (1999), indicate their presence on a regional scale within the
Central Block of the Galway Granite. Furthermore, mac clots, rapakivi texture
and inclusion zones in feldspars have been described from the Carna and Errisbeg
Townland Granites exposed at the western end of the batholith (Wright, 1964;
Leake, 1974). This regional distribution of mixing-compatible textures combined
with the recorded occurrences of MME on the same regional scale suggest that
magma mingling and mixing was a major process during the evolution of the
Galway Granite.
Finally, it should be noted that even the most mac of the MME recorded in this
study exhibit mingling and mixing textures (e.g. sphene-plagioclase and quartz-
feldspar ocelli) prompting the question do any true mac end member lithologies
remain at the present exposure level in the Galway Granite? a question that must be
addressed when choosing end member lithologies for magma mingling and mixing
models.
Acknowledgements
S. Baxter gratefully acknowledges receipt of a Department of Education for Northern
Ireland Postgraduate Studentship, and of an Enterprise Ireland Basic Research Grant during
the course of her studies on the geology of the Barna area. The manuscript benetted from
the reviews of K. McCaffrey and V. Janousek.
Magma mixing and mingling textures in granitoids 73
References
Angus NS (1962) Ocellar hybrids from the Tyrone Igneous Series, Ireland. Geol Mag 99:
926
Baxter S (2000) The geology of part of the Galway Granite near Barna, Co. Galway,
Ireland. Thesis, National University of Ireland, Galway, 212 pp
Callaghan BH (1999) The geology of the Shannawona Fault Zone of the Galway Granite in
the Casla Area, Connemara, Ireland. Thesis, National University of Ireland, Galway,
225 pp
Castro A, Stephens WE (1992) Amphibole-rich polycrystalline clots in calc-alkaline
granitic rocks and their enclaves. Can Mineral 30: 10931112
Coats JS, Wilson JR (1971) The eastern end of the Galway Granite. Min Mag 38: 138151
Cole GAJ (1916) A composite gneiss near Barna (County Galway). Quart J Geol Soc Lond
71: 183188
Crowley Q (1997) The geology and geochemistry of the Galway Granite in the Inveran
Sector, Western Ireland. Thesis, National University of Ireland, 294 pp
Crowley Q, Feely M (1997) New perspectives on the order and style of granite
emplacement in the Galway Batholith, western Ireland. Geol Mag 134(4): 539548
El Desouky, El Morsy MM (1992) Magma mixing in the Spiddal sector of the Galway
Granite: geology, geochemistry and genetic aspects. Thesis, National University of
Ireland, 396 pp
El Desouky M, Feely M, Mohr P (1996) Diorite-granite magma mingling and mixing
along the axis of the Galway Granite batholith, Ireland. J Geol Soc Lond 153:
361374
Feely MMJ (1982) Geological, geochemical and geophysical studies on the Galway
Granite in the Costelloe=Inveran sector, western Ireland. Thesis, National University of
Ireland, 183 pp (vol I), 350 pp (vol II)
Friedrich AM, Bowring SA, Martin MW, Hodges KP (1999) Short-lived continental
magmatic arc at Connemara, western Irish Caledonides: implications for the age of the
Grampian orogeny. Geology 27: 2730
Frost TP, Mahood GA (1987) Field, chemical and physical constraints on mac-felsic
magma interaction in the Lamarck Granodiorite, Sierra Nevada, California. Bull Geol
Soc Am 99: 272291
Hibbard MJ (1981) The magma mixing origin of mantled feldspars. Contrib Mineral Petrol
76: 158170
Hibbard MJ (1991) Textural anatomy of twelve magma-mixed granitoid systems. In:
Didier J, Barbarin B (eds) Enclaves and granite petrology. Elsevier, Amsterdam,
pp 431444 (Dev Petrol 13)
Hill RI (1988) San Jacinto intrusive complex. 1. Geology and mineral chemistry, and a
model for intermittent recharge of tonalitic magma chambers. J Geophys Res 93:
1032510348
Huppert HE, Sparks RSJ (1988) The generation of granitic magmas by intrusion of basalt
into continental crust. J Petrol 29: 599624
Leake BE (1974) The crystallisation history and mechanism of emplacement of the western
part of the Galway Granite, Connemara, Western Ireland. Min Mag 39: 498513
Leake BE (1978) Granite emplacement: the granites of Ireland and their origin. In: Bowes
DR, Leake BE (eds) Crustal evolution in Northwest Britain and adjacent regions. Geol J
(Spec Iss) 10: 221248
Leggo PJ, Compton W, Leake BE (1966) The geochronology of the Connemara granites
and its bearing on the antiquity of the Dalradian Series. Quart J Geol Soc Lond 122:
91118
74 S. Baxter and M. Feely: Magma mixing and mingling textures in granitoids