ORGANIZATIONSANDPHARMACYSTUDENTJOBPLACEMENTRATE
Damienne C. Souter
ETR 520
May 2016
RELATIONSHIPBETWEENINVOLVEMENTINSTUDENTORGANIZATIONSAND 2
PHARMACYSTUDENTJOBPLACEMENTRATE
Table of Contents
Problem to be Investigated............................................................................................................4
Justification................................................................................................................................4
Research Question.....................................................................................................................5
Hypothesis..................................................................................................................................5
Definition of Terms....................................................................................................................5
Literature Review..........................................................................................................................6
Procedures....................................................................................................................................10
Timeline........................................................................................................................................16
References.....................................................................................................................................17
Problem to be Investigated
Justification
likelihood of landing a job upon graduation? Many students side-step this extra-curricular
organizations teach collaboration, leadership, and philanthropy, which are significant skills in
professional careers.
The potential role of extracurricular activities in developing employability skills has been
less studied than the effects of the curriculum. [a few noted studies] focused on motive
whether extracurricular activities were about reinforcing ones current student self or
Similarly, Roulin and Bangerter (2013) suggest, Future research should examine
as potential moderators of the relationship between job market pressure and external motivation
Advincula (2015) conclude that Motivation for pursuing a leadership role [in student
RELATIONSHIPBETWEENINVOLVEMENTINSTUDENTORGANIZATIONSAND 5
PHARMACYSTUDENTJOBPLACEMENTRATE
While several studies have been done regarding the positive impact that ECAs have on
student development, this study is seeking to look specifically at the correlation between
pharmacy student organization involvement and students ability to land jobs at the time of
graduation, especially in light of a tighter job placement market for graduating pharmacists.
Research Question
Is there a relationship between the number of pharmacy students who actively participate
Hypothesis
Students who are actively involved in student organizations are more likely to land a job
Definition of Terms
For the purposes of this study, all of the following terms are defined as follows: a job
having a job secured one week before graduation (this does not include students who secure a job
shortly after graduation); student organizations include only those that are sanctioned by
Midwestern University (they do not need to be pharmacy related); research activities refers to
those that are mentored by Midwestern University faculty, including adjunct professors; part-
time jobs refer to those that are pharmacy-related; extra-curricular activities refers to
Phillips, McLaughlin, Gettig, Fajiculay, and Advincula (2015): an executive board position
(president, vice president, secretary, treasurer), committee chairperson, or task force leader.
student organizations and the job placement rate at graduation, the graduating class of 2016 at
Midwestern Universitys Chicago College of Pharmacy will be surveyed as part of their end-of-
year surveys and graduation clearance process. The survey will be emailed to the students in a
SurveyMonkey format, and it will seek statistical information only, as there will be no open-
Literature Review
In searching for current literature, the researcher accessed the ERIC and PubMed
databases via the Northern Illinois University Library and reviewed articles based on search
employability, and Pharm.D. graduates. Google Scholar was also utilized with similar search
terms. In this review of current literature on this research topic, the literature will be reviewed as
they pertain to the following categories: job placement outlook of graduating pharmacy students,
Over the last ten years, there has been a significant increase in the number of pharmacy
schools across the country, and hence, the number of pharmacy graduates entering the workforce.
According to Brown (2013), in 2001 there were just 7000 pharmacy student graduates entering
the workforce. In 2011, there were 11,931, which is a 70% increase. In 21 states, the number of
RELATIONSHIPBETWEENINVOLVEMENTINSTUDENTORGANIZATIONSAND 7
PHARMACYSTUDENTJOBPLACEMENTRATE
statewide graduates is expected to grow by 100% or more for the 2001 to 2016 period (Brown,
2013). These statistics imply a challenging outlook for job placements among pharmacy school
graduates.
The Occupational Outlook Handbook Web page by the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
(BLS) recently adjusted its job outlook for pharmacists down to a 3% growth rate for the
projected time period of 2014 to 2024. The BLS describes this as slower than average growth
(2016). In its January 2016 data, the Pharmacy Workforce Center indicated that the current
national aggregate demand index (AGI) for pharmacists is nearly balanced at 3.05, where 5
indicates a high demand and 1 indicates demand is much less than the pharmacist supply
available. The trend is downward as the national AGI is down from 3.51 just 12 months earlier
(Pharmacy Workforce Center Inc., 2016). These statistics recognize a decline in demand, but
Grabenstein (2016) further points out that a greater number of graduates does not
automatically mean an increased supply of pharmacists. Rather, it provides some opportunity for
more pharmacists to spend more time in patient-centered roles, after compensating for
retirements, increased use of medications, population growth and migrations, and other factors.
And according to Zavadski (2014), many pharmacist graduates opt to teach at the numerous new
colleges of pharmacy, which also mitigates the problem of the significant expansion of pharmacy
schools.
The results of a recent study by Sweet, et al. (2015) with eight colleges of pharmacy in
the Midwest showed an 81% job placement rate among its collective 783 graduates who
responded to the studys survey, which sought to learn more about graduates preparedness and
job search tactics. This study did raise concerns about the homogenous nature of the participating
RELATIONSHIPBETWEENINVOLVEMENTINSTUDENTORGANIZATIONSAND 8
PHARMACYSTUDENTJOBPLACEMENTRATE
eight schools of pharmacy, and the validity of the 81% placement rate with the response rate of
79% and possible non-response bias, or those who perhaps did not have jobs may have resisted
responding. This is the only study that was found regarding current job placement rates among
graduating pharmacists in the current, more competitive environment. This study did not review
organizations or extra-curricular activities (ECAs) often builds skills that can enhance
employability. There are several studies done with college students that focus on the motives and
value of participating in student organizations while students pursue their degrees. A study done
by Roulin and Bangerter (2013) looked at the relationship between students and their
participation in extra-curricular activities (ECAs); student motives for participation were found
to change over time. They found that students tend to initially engage in ECAs because they are
passionate about the chosen activity (internal motives). As they get closer to having to enter the
labor market, they tend to engage in the types of ECAs that might enhance their skills and add to
their resume (external motives). The study done by Clark, Marsden, Whyatt, Thompson, and
Walker (2015) confirmed this, where students hoped that their participation in ECAs would be
On the other side of the table, recruiters noted that when it came to comparing applicants
with the same degrees and academic performance in college, reviews of applicants participation
in ECAs had a positive impact on selection (Clark et al., 2015). Similarly, in the study done by
Finch, Peacock, Levallet, and Foster (2015), employers indicated that meta-skills, such as
RELATIONSHIPBETWEENINVOLVEMENTINSTUDENTORGANIZATIONSAND 9
PHARMACYSTUDENTJOBPLACEMENTRATE
communication and the ability to work with others were valuable and a potential source of
While students may engage in ECAs, some do so to a greater degree than others,
particularly in the area of leadership, which may have a greater impact on the development of
skills that may lead to higher employability. In the study done by Lau, Hsu, Acosta and Hsu
(2014), graduating college students who had been core members in ECAs were more likely to
positively evaluate their communication, leadership, creativity, and self-promotion skills than
those students who participated to a more limited degree, as well as those who did not participate
at all. The study did not review how these positive student perceptions translated to actual job
placement rates. However, the more relevant issue that guided the Lau et al. study is that it was
done in Taiwan, where the labor market is very competitive for college graduates, similar to the
As with the pursuit of most professional degrees such as the Pharm.D., full-time graduate
students are stretched for time. Intense focus on coursework, coupled with demands during
rotations that practice whats been learned in the classroom, often leaves a limited amount of
time to participate in student organizations. And there appears to be a trade-off between time
spent in pharmacy student organizations and a higher GPA. According to the study done by
Kiersma, Plake and Mason (2011), incoming students who had higher GPAs during their pre-
pharmacy coursework were less likely to participate in student organizations, while those who
had become involved in ECAs during their undergraduate studies were more likely to continue
with that endeavor. Its beyond the scope of this researchers study to assess the impact of GPA
on employability, however, this finding does address the time challenges of pharmacy students.
RELATIONSHIPBETWEENINVOLVEMENTINSTUDENTORGANIZATIONSAND 10
PHARMACYSTUDENTJOBPLACEMENTRATE
(two years vs. four years vs. early assurance program) and the number of leadership activities
participation, Phillips, McLaughlin, Gettig, Fajiculay, and Advincula (2015) noted that
activities. This participation also greatly influenced their leadership, teamwork, confidence and
Procedures
This study will utilize correlational research methodology. This quantitative study will
seek two data points from each student: the attainment of employment and the level of
exists between a high level of student organization participation, such as taking on a leadership
role, and the ability to have a job secured at the time of graduation. This is appropriate because
this correlational research will describe the degree to which these variables are related (Fraenkel,
Midwestern University, and the intended sample is all of these students. The characteristics of
this class include an age range of 23 to 48 (mean age of 27); 34% are male and 66% are female.
RELATIONSHIPBETWEENINVOLVEMENTINSTUDENTORGANIZATIONSAND 11
PHARMACYSTUDENTJOBPLACEMENTRATE
The ethnic breakdown is 51% white; 41% Asian; 5% Hispanic; 2% African American; 1%
Hawaiian/Pacific Islander. The subjects are all on the campus of Midwestern University in
Downers Grove, IL. While 53% of the students originate from Illinois, the balance of students
hail from all parts of the country. Top feeder states include: California (17%); Michigan (7%);
Wisconsin and Florida (3% each); and Arizona, Texas and Missouri (2% each). The remaining
students hail from an additional 17 states (including Hawaii), plus one foreign student. This is
important because it is an indicator of flexibility in job locations, thus affecting the job
placement rate.
There are approximately 200 in this particular class, which is large enough to be
considered a good representation of all graduating pharmacy students. All students in this class
will be surveyed, subject to IRB approval to do so. In addition, this researcher is employed by
plus many more that are open to all attending students. Thus, there is ample opportunity for
All graduating pharmacy students must participate in exit surveys as part of gaining
clearance for graduation. With the approval of the College, the Colleges Assessment Committee,
and the IRB, this researcher will develop and add a short series of questions to this exit survey
(see Appendix A). The surveys are electronic in SurveyMonkey format, and they are emailed to
each graduating student. Participation in the exit survey is mandatory as part of graduation
clearance, and the data feeds into the Colleges accreditation requirements.
RELATIONSHIPBETWEENINVOLVEMENTINSTUDENTORGANIZATIONSAND 12
PHARMACYSTUDENTJOBPLACEMENTRATE
The electronic surveys will be emailed to the class of graduating pharmacy students by
the Assistant Dean in the College of Pharmacy. Students will have two weeks to return their
surveys, and reminder emails will be sent. Upon receipt of all the surveys, this researcher will
then access the results of this portion of the survey data in SurveyMonkeys Website.
When reviewing the data, each respondent will be placed into one of three categories:
Secured employment, seeking employment, or not seeking employment. Respondents in the third
category will be removed from further analysis. These categories of students are the job
placement rate, also known as the dependent variable. The independent variable is the
involvement in student organizations. If involvement is indicated, then the respondent will give
an indication of the level of involvement, such as leadership position(s) held. A crossbreak table
of the frequencies will be used to indicate the level of relationship between job placement rates
Further, in order to seek validation of the relationship between these two variables,
students will be asked to state the percentages of non-class time they devoted to each of these
employment in a part-time pharmacy job. Each students percentages will equal 100%. The
means of these percentage breakouts will be applied to each group (secured a job vs. not yet
secured a job) to determine validity. The mean percentages for each group will be presented in a
pie chart.
One of the primary concerns about reliability is a non-response bias. Because this portion
of the exit survey is voluntary, and hence, not required for graduation, its anticipated that those
who do have jobs or residency positions secured will be happy to confirm this. Those students
RELATIONSHIPBETWEENINVOLVEMENTINSTUDENTORGANIZATIONSAND 13
PHARMACYSTUDENTJOBPLACEMENTRATE
who are still looking may decide that they do not need to answer this portion, especially if it is
not required. As such, there may be a bias towards those who have secured employment. The
reliability of the results will depend on both the overall response rate, as well as the participation
There are several potential threats to internal validity. The first could be a subject
characteristics threat. There are students who may not be able to participate in student
organizations due to economic challenges. As such, they may be obligated to focus on a part-time
may have to acknowledge this circumstance in the conclusions, when discussing the students
A second threat might be attitude of the respondents due to testing fatigue. This series of
questions would be added to an already lengthy survey, possibly resulting in fatigue of the
respondents. To minimize this, the researcher would aim to be as smart as possible with the
number of questions in the survey and ask questions as effectively as possible and try to avoid
Another threat might be a location threat. While a large portion of students come to
Midwestern Universitys College of Pharmacy from other states, many come to the Chicago area
hoping to land a job here, or in some other major metropolitan area. The problem lies with where
the job prospects are greatest: in rural areas. Many students are hesitant to relocate to such areas,
thereby limiting their prospects. In addition, in general, job growth is slowest in the Midwest.
However, in an effort to keep the line of questioning concise and avoid survey fatigue, this threat
RELATIONSHIPBETWEENINVOLVEMENTINSTUDENTORGANIZATIONSAND 14
PHARMACYSTUDENTJOBPLACEMENTRATE
may not be addressed in the surveys questions. This variable may be raised when discussing the
surveys conclusions.
A final threat might be that there may be some students who are not yet actively seeking
because they have not been trying. To eliminate this, these students who identify as such are
The size of the graduating class at the Chicago College of Pharmacy is much larger than
most college of pharmacy classes, which average roughly 100 students. There is also a
significant portion of this class of students that originates from out of state, thus representing
interests from various parts of the country. Given these characteristics, it can be stated that the
study results may be indicative of trends seen for pharmacy students in general.
pharmacy students with any reliability of results. While still voluntary, the survey method
proposed seeks to limit the time needed to participate, while still gathering pertinent data points.
It could be argued that students who have not yet secured employment may be very close to
doing so, and hence, could be considered for placement in the other category. However, if this
study were to be conducted after graduation, response rates would be very, very low, and hence
The formats of the questions will gather frequencies of circumstances in the two primary
groups studied. As such, crossbreak tables that highlight the frequencies will help showcase any
In addition, when reviewing the percentages of non-academic time spent, there will be
some additional calculations of the ranges of percentages, standard deviations, and frequencies of
percentages in each of the three activity categories. This additional analysis will serve to validate
the relationship between placement rates and ECA participation, or it may potentially serve to
In order to promote transparency, students will be informed that the answers to the
questions associated with this study are voluntary. It would be inappropriate for students to be
under the assumption that the study questions are mandatory as part of the graduation clearance
process. Students will be advised that their answers are strictly confidential, and their identities
will be known only to the researcher and potentially the Assistant Dean. Just prior to answering
the survey questions, students will be advised that this portion of the exit survey is voluntary and
There are two potential risks to participating students. First is a psychological risk.
Graduating students who may not have found jobs could become upset and regretful at the
suggestion that the reason they have not found a job is because they did not do something they
now feel they should have done. Then there is also a social risk: Students who may not have
found jobs may feel stigmatized if their identities are revealed. As stated previously, identities of
the participants will be known only to the investigator(s). Because the data collected is statistical
Timeline
References
Brown, Daniel L. (2013) A looming joblessness crisis for new pharmacy graduates and the
77(5): 90.
accessed 2/21/2016.
Clark, G., Marsden, R., Whyatt, J.D., Thompson, L., Walker, M. (2015) Its everything else you
Finch, D.J., Peacock, M., Levallet, N., Foster, W. (2015) A dynamic capabilities view of
Fraenkel, J.R., Wallen, N.E., Hyun, H.H. (2015) How to Design and Evaluate Research in
Education (9th edition, p. 332). New York, NY: McGraw Hill Education.
Grabenstein, J.D. (2016) Trends in the numbers of U.S. colleges of pharmacy and their
25.
Kiersma, M.E., Plake, K.S., Mason, H.L. (2011) Relationship between admission data and
Lau, H.H., Hsu, H.Y., Acosta, S., Hsu, T.L. (2014) Impact of participation in extra-curricular
Pharmacy Workforce Center Inc. (2016) Aggregate Demand Index Newsletter March 2016 (for
http://pharmacymanpower.com/summary.pdf. p. 1.
Phillips, J.A., McLaughlin, M.M., Gettig, J.P., Fajiculay, J.R., Advincula, M.R. (2015) An
Renzi, S.E., Sauberan, M.M., Brazeau, D.A., and Brazeau, G.A. (2008) Relationship between
Roulin, N., Bangerter, A. (2013) Extracurricular Activities in young applicants resumes: What
are the motives behind their involvement? International Journal of Psychology. 48(5), pp.
871-880.
Sweet, B.V., Kelley, K.A., Janke, K.K., Kuba, S.E., Plake, K.S., Stanke, L.D., Yee, G.C. (2015)
Zavadski, K. (2014) The pharmacy school bubble is about to burst. New Republic. Retrieved
from: https://newrepublic.com/article/119634/pharmacy-school-crisis-why-good-jobs-
are-drying. p. 7.
RELATIONSHIPBETWEENINVOLVEMENTINSTUDENTORGANIZATIONSAND 19
PHARMACYSTUDENTJOBPLACEMENTRATE
The following statement and questions will be added to the current exit survey to be taken by
Consent/Disclosure Statement
The following questions are part of a research study. As such, they are highly encouraged, but
not required for graduation. There are only a few quick questions, and they should take less than
one minute to complete. Relative to these questions and this study, your identity will remain
confidential and known only to the researcher and potentially the Assistant Dean. Answering
these questions implies consent for participation.
2. During your time at Midwestern University, were you involved in student organizations?
Yes
No
In how many of these organizations did you hold a chair or officer position?
(ie president, secretary, event chair, task force leader, etc.) ____
3. In reflecting back on how you spent your non-academic time, please break out in
percentages how you spent your time among these three activities: part-time pharmacy-
related job, faculty-mentored research, and MWU student organizations. Keep in mind,
the three percentages should total 100%.