What is Obesity
Hippocrates (460 BC370 BC) described the health for human body as a balance
of four humors (fluids): blood, black bile, yellow bile, and phlegm, and any
deficiencies or extras were considered causes of diseases [4]. Obesity was
defined as the surplus of humors [4]. For a big part of human history extra weight
was considered as an indication of good health, as well as wealth and prosperity.
Hippocrates was the first who realized that obesity leads to infertility and early
mortality [5]. It took more than two thousand years to test his hypotheses
scientifically and evaluate how surplus of humors relates to different health
outcomes and early deaths.
Feet Inches
5 1 120
5 2 125
5 3 130
5 4 135
5 5 140
5 6 143
5 7 145
5 8 148
5 9 155
5 10 160
5 11 165
6 170
In 1889, the Actuarial Society of America and the Association of Life Insurance
Medical Directors of America were founded which made possible a uniformed
approach to the industry-wide height and weight tables [7]. In 1912, Medico-
Actuarial Mortality Investigation published the statistics of height and weight of
insured people and set up a goal to provide an accurate Standard Table of
Heights and Weights and to determine the influence of build on longevity [7].The
whole process of development of standard weight tables with major milestones is
summarized in Section 3.2 and Table 3.
In 1959, The Build and Blood Pressure Study was conducted by the Society of
Actuaries with collaboration of 26 insurance companies to determine the mortality
of insured persons according to variations in body build and blood pressure [12,
14]. The weights were derived from data of people with lowest mortality who
were insured between 1935 and 1953 and followed to 1954 in the United States
and Canada [12]. Measured heights and weights were of people wearing indoor
clothing and shoes and included 20% of self-reported values [12]. Frame size
for this study was not based on measurement of skeletal dimensions but
arbitrarily divided the distribution of relative weights on the assumption that
skeletal size was associated with a persons position in that distribution [12]. The
association between body weight and mortality, particularly from cardiovascular
diseases, was demonstrated, and MLIC 1959 weight tables were created, where
ideal weight was replaced by the desirable weight [11].
In 1979, the second study of The Build and Blood Pressure Study produced the
revised tables based on the mortality of insured people from 1950 to 1972 where
desirable weights were higher than those in previous study [14]. Based on the
data from new study, the MLIC 1959 tables for desirable weight were replaced
by MLIC 1983 tables of height and weight [13].
Overweight and obesity are the nutrition-related disorders which are caused by
the accumulation of extra fat as was stated by the Department of Health and
Human Services (HHS) and the Department of Agriculture (USDA) which were
responsible for issuing the Dietary Guidelines for Americans in 1980 and for
updating the document every 5 years [32]. The goal of the document was to
provide nutritional and dietary information and guidance for general public. In
1980, US Department of Agriculture and US Department of Health, Education
and Welfare published the first edition of nutritional Dietary Guidelines for
Americans and advised the public based on current knowledge of the
relationship of diet to health and disease [18]. The guidance included a table with
suggested body weight based on the tables recommended by Fogarty
International Center Conference on Obesity with the adjustments for height and
weight [18]. Adjustment for height was done as 1 or 2 inches (2.54 and 5.08 cm)
for shoes and 10lb6lb for clothes (Table 2) [18, 33, 34].
Table 2: Range of acceptable body weight [18].
410 92119
411 96129
50 96125
51 99128
52 112141 102131
53 115144 105134
54 118148 108138
55 121152 111142
56 124156 114146
57 128161 118150
58 132166 122154
59 136170 126150
60 148184 138173
61 152189
62 156194
63 160199
64 164204
In 1985, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) and the
Department of Agriculture (USDA) issued the second edition of Dietary
Guidelines for Americans [24]. That document used the desirable weight to
height tables from MLIC 1959 and translated the numbers into overweight level
of BMI for men ~25-26 and for women ~24-25 [24, 34]. In the 1990 third edition,
tables for men and women were combined into one and presented by two age
groups where unhealthy weight was translated into BMI 25 for ages 1934
and 27 for ages 35 years [25, 34].
In 1990, the National Nutrition Monitoring and Related Research Act of 1990,
Public Law 101445, Title III, , stated that a report entitled Dietary Guidelines for
Americans shall contain nutritional and dietary information and guidelines for the
general public and be published at least every five years [28]. Each such report
shall be promoted by each Federal agency in carrying out any Federal food,
nutrition, or health program [28]. Basically, the law stated that the definition of
healthy weight or overweight from the Dietary Guidelines for Americans should
be used by the constituent Federal agencies [28].
In 1995, the next step was taken to combine not just both sexes but also age
groups where healthy weight was translated in BMI 25 for all adults in the
fourth edition of Dietary Guidelines for Americans [27]. The report used WHO
criteria for publishing healthy weight ranges for men and women by each inch of
height [27]. The edition was very important because it led to publishing the
prevalence and trends on overweight (BMI 25), preobese (BMI: 25.029.9),
class 1 (BMI: 30.034.9), class 2 (BMI: 35.039.9), and class 3 (BMI 40.0)
obese in the United States data from 1960 to 1994 (NHANES I, II, and III) for first
time to facilitate comparison with international data [2].
BMI (kg/m2)
Classification
Cut-off points Additional cut-off points
18.5022.99
Normal 18.5024.99
23.0024.99
25.0027.49
Preobese 25.0029.99
27.5029.99
30.0032.49
Class I 30.0034.99
32.5034.99
35.0037.49
Class II 35.0039.99
37.5039.99
Class III 40.00 40.00
23.0024.99
27.5029.99
32.5034.99
37.5039.99
Source: from WHO, 1995, WHO, 2000, and WHO, 2004 [15, 26, 29, 30].
BMI has never been a perfect index for children because it correlates with
height. In the United States, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)
2000 used five nationally representative surveys to develop BMI charts for
children in the United States: the National Health Examination Surveys (NHES) II
and III in the 1960s, the National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys
(NHANES) I and II in the 1970s, and NHANES III for the period of 19881994.
Those charts included gender-specific BMI by single month of age curves of
growth. Currently they are used in the United States for children who are 219
years old to define overweight as BMI 95th percentile or at risk for
overweight if BMI is between 85th and 95th percentiles [26, 36].
In the current edition of Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2010, the BMI cut-offs
are consistent with internationally recommended [16]. By the Public Law 101
445, Title III, , all Federal agencies have made the transition to define overweight
and obesity as a BMI consistent with recommendations in the current edition of
Dietary Guidelines for Americans [16, 28]. The table of weight category based on
BMI level from Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2010, is presented in Table 5
[16].
Table 5: Overweight and obese children and adolescents .
Background
In the Theory of Leisure Class: Conspicuous Consumption, Thorstein
Veblen once wrote, The successful are thin to show that they are assured of
their next meal. This sentence gave insight to why people wanted to be thin.
Furthermore, it tends to be a reason why many of us climb on our scales at home
each day, and depending on what is read, determines whether we have a good
day or a bad day (Beller 264). Whether its the unhappy news of the gained
weight on the thighs, age creeping up on the body, or perhaps only being
uneducated in nutrition. Overall well-being should be the goal for weight control,
not only to enhance the bodys appearance (Sobal 81). Being overweight can be
helped; as any degree of obesity can be considered one of the most preventable
causes of death in America (Frankle et al. 1). Obesity in the United States has
grown over the years with no real solution, however vegetarianism can contribute
to overall well-being of any individual.
Why do people eat more than they spend? Factors that are included in obesity
are genetic, environmental, cultural, behavioral, socioeconomic, psychological, or
metabolic (Whitney 257). The most common are genetics and psychological
(emotional; for the need of ice cream, for example).
Some infant feedings, by genetics, could leaving a child permanently prone to
obesity (The Wholesome Diet 64). And in a couple circumstances (minor cases
rather than the major number of cases of weight problems), overweight is
directed to disturbances of the thyroid or pituitary glands, which neglect to
develop their secretions correctly (Fishbein 338).
Nonetheless, the global problem with obesity is that more energy (calories) are
consumed than are spent during exercise, no matter if its carbohydrates, protein
or fat, the excess energy is stored as fat in cells (Whitney 255). Being under-
active may be the single most important contributor to obesity, says Eleanor
Noss Whitney and Sharon Rady Rolfes. Experimental data always suggests that
the dietary fat in foods eaten influence the body fatness, therefore fat people
have a tendency to eat more fat (259). From observing various experiments and
the results, its obvious that less fat in the diet means less fat in the body. Sonja
L. Connor and William E. Connor note that reduced physical activity is the other
important obvious role in producing obesity (177). Although food is the source of
obesity, many individuals who are fat eat modestly and many who are thin
consume the opposite (The Wholesome Diet 64). This is because of the range
of activity each person exhibits (Karlsberg 78).
C.Related Literature
Child obesity is a serious problem with potentially profound health and social
consequences, not least the increased risk becoming an obese adult (Philips, F.
2012). New research suggests that childhood obesity is on the rise and the
health risks for obese children may be even greater than previously estimated
(BBC News, Anon, 2012). Philips states that childhood obesity has more than
tripled since the 1980s this shows that childhood obesity has hugely increased
over the last 30 years (Philips, 2012). The cause of childhood obesity differs
throughout research; they range from a lack of education about food, limited
cooking skills and limited money to buy healthier food to longer working hours
and marketing campaigns for junk food aimed at kids (BBC News, Anon, 2012).
The British Heart Foundation claim that parents play a vital role in shaping what
their children think about physical activity and therefore how much they do, for
instance research carried out by the charity highlighted that 79% of primary
school pupils live less than 2 miles (3.2km) from school; which is walking
distance! But only 54% of children walk to school (British Heart foundation PDF).
However Philips states that the problem with childhood obesity is worsened by
parents inability to recognise when their child is overweight (Philips, F. 2012).
II. Body
Overweight and obesity can be defined as abnormal or excessive fat
accumulation that may impair health.The obesity issue has generated
considerable debate fuelled by concerns of the World Health Organisation
(WHO) and governments around the world that obesity prevalence has reached
epidemic levels. A number of observers contest the general consensus of rising
obesity levels by arguing that the myth of obesity is perpetuated by the state
seeking to exert a big brother influence over the personal lives of its
citizenry.The majority view, based on extensive government and independent
research is that obesity represents one of the most complex public health issues
confronting governments in the decades ahead.
Even in the developing world there is evidence that levels of overweight and
obesity are increasingly affecting population health, many of who already suffer
from the affects of malnutrition. A 1999 United Nation (UN) study discovered
obesity in manydeveloping regions and growing rapidly, even in countries where
hunger exists. In China, the number of overweight people jumped from less than
10 per cent to 15 percent in just three years. In Brazil and Colombia the figure at
the turn of the century was round 40 per cent, while even in sub-Saharan Africa,
where the majority of the worlds hungry live, obesity levels are increasing,
especially among urban women. In addition to these figures, the study also
revealed that there was a correlation between rising income and increasing
obesity prevalence throughout these developing regions.
Another interesting finding within the UN report was the connection between
obesity and micronutrient deficiency. Despite the rise in levels of overweight as
well as those suffering from starvation, the study argued that both groups were
being deprived of important micronutrients like vitamins and minerals. According
to a Senior Officer in the UNs Food and Agriculture Organisation, The thinking
used to be that if people get enough energy in their diets, the micronutrients will
take care of themselvesBut increasingly people are eating larger quantities of
cheap food that fill the stomach but still leave the body without those
micronutrients.
Summmary
There is nationwide and global epidemic of obesity. As the first step to conquer a
problem, the concept of obesity should be clearly understood through the
historical process that led to the worldwide accepted standard definition. This
paper presents the history of developing current standard definition of overweight
and obesity. Understanding the roots will lead to the successful research on
obesity with a goal to defeat national and global epidemic.
Competing Interests
The author declares that there are no competing interests.
Acknowledgments
The author thanks Drs. Michael Szarek, Michael Walsh, and Elizabeth Helzner
for assistance with development of this proposal.
III Conclusion
Obesity as been the most common type of malnutrition and one of the greatest
with health hazards to life in the United States today, and it can be prevented
(Diehl 120). The solution is as simple as eating the same amount--but with
healthier choices and a life long diet, such as vegetarianism. Exercising is also
important to keep fit and use up any extra calories from that ice cream at dessert.
Nonetheless, some fat is essential for the body as heat, stored energy, insulation,
and padding (The Wholesome Diet 64). No one cannot cure obesity by simply
achieving a certain body weight. Eating healthy and keeping active is all apart of
a life long daily routine (Whitney 273). No diet should be promoted as a
temporary eating plan, but rather a permanent lifestyle for healthy eating (Sobal
81).
Using the 2012 draft evidence report Childhood Obesity Prevention Programs: A
Comparative Effectiveness Review and Meta-Analysis, we identified and
prioritized Future Research Needs. We identified 12 research questions
considered to be of potential health impact by a multidisciplinary group of
stakeholders. These questions focus on high-priority populations, interventions,
comparisons, and settings as identified by our stakeholders. During the
systematic review process, we identified methodological issues in the literature;
our stakeholders agreed that improving these methods will benefit studies to
come. This report may inform and support researchers to develop studies to
evaluate the Key Questions identified, as well as enable funding agencies to
dedicate their resources to areas most likely to make a health impact.
Hopefully after this activity you are more aware of the affects of obesity. Many
people do not realize how damaging obesity can be to the body and for your
overall health. Obesity is something that is increasingly on the rise today and will
continue to rise unless we do something about it like informing people of how bad
it really is and encouraging people to live a health-enhancing lifestyle. A healthy
diet and exercising two to three times a week is key to not becoming obese.
Let's change the trend of obesity by living healthy lives and building towards a
healthy.
References
1.U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, The Surgeon General's Call
to Action to Prevent and Decrease Overweight and Obesity, U.S. Department of
Health and Human Services, Public Health Service Office of the Surgeon
General, Rockville, Md, USA, 2001.
3.Nutrition and overweight, in Healthy People 2010, chapter 19, pp. 115, Food
and Drug Administration, National Institutes of Health, Hyattsville, Md, USA,
2001,
http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/hpdata2010/hp2010_final_review_focus_area_19.p
df.
6.H. Schwartz, Never Satisfied: A Cultural History of Diets, Fantasies, and Fat,
The Free Press, New York, NY, USA, 1986.
9.Ideal weight for women. Statistical bulletin of the Metropolitan Life Insurance
Company, 1943.
12.Build and Blood Pressure Study, vol. 1, Society of Actuaries, Chicago, Ill,
USA, 1959.
17.H. C. Fish, The Agent's Manual of Life Assurance, Mutual Life Insurance
Company of New York, New York, NY, USA, 1867.
20.J. Hutchinson, On the capacity of the lungs, and on the respiratory functions,
with a view of establishing a precise and easy method of detecting disease by
the spirometer, Medico-Chirurgical Transactions (London), vol. 29, pp. 137161,
1846. View at Google Scholar
31.J. Yudkin, Obesity: a report of the royal college of physicians, Journal of the
Royal Society of Medicine, vol. 76, no. 6, pp. 531532, 1983. View at Google
Scholar
36.R. J. Jarrett, Is there an ideal body weight? British Medical Journal, vol. 293,
no. 6545, pp. 493495, 1986. View at Publisher View at Google Scholar View
at Scopus