توازن القوى في الشرق الاوسط بعد احتلال العراق

2011 2003
The Unbalance of Power in the Middle East after the U.S. Occupation of
Iraq.
!"
& ' $ !:#$
'"
', ()$) ..
-$
./ 01
-$ 6 5$ -5 4! 3 0$ 2 $
-$ 6 61
6 # -
-$5
2011/$7 8

' &!" #$%

!)*
$:) : : :)$; .$ 4" $ 5 6
<.: 0:=$ .= $8$ -$

./ 4! ' >. ', ()
: <$: 4:" $ 6 ?. = 0 0= 4
6: 6:1 - -@8 A$)! -$ 4" 3$= #
.-$

0$

B;
-=5 1
A/C

0$ -@$1
D,
1 -$ - : 3;
1
3
3
3
4
4 # ! "
5 $% &'( !
13 #(
13
14 -= 6$E= ,$ :=$ 3;
16 -= -$3 1 -5 -/: F
19 !) * +#
20 ,- !) *
21 !) * $!( !
( )
21 (!
().%
25 -= - G$ &$3 :=$ F
26 !) * $!( 1 ) 2 3
29 %) %(% !) *

-= 6$E= 4! $/ H, # :F$ 3;

32

33 6$E= 4! -$ H, #
33 44 56 7 1 1%" , 44 56
1 ;$ 7< 3'( 9: 4 *" .8 8 %" 5(
38
!) * $!(
-= 6$E= 4! <J :I 3;
41

42 -= 6$E=
6$E=
42 +# =
43 ( =
43 ,- =
44 =
46 " =
48 !) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< 9: 4 %" 8
50 !) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< 9: 4 %" "#
54 2001%% 11 "% 1 1%" 1$ 7) *<>
, 68 -1C - 0L :K$, 3;
55
-=
56 ) ( .%$ 1 3'( -
58 ) ( ; 7
59 ) ?$ .%$
61 ( 9: '

65 :=$ F
65 @8 *" <A
70 .8 - "% *: 1 )
72 *" 1) .8 - "% , % !
73 %" $!( *" .%$ *" 1 1) #

, <5 -! M -1" 1 3 :F$ F

75
-=
75 !) * $!( 1 1(
86 7(% B# (
86 1 ( # :-
C
86 7(% 7E
88 1( &(
89 %" 4 7E
90 !) * $!( 1 1
91 (4 56 < F(4 1 ,
94 1 1
95 *" 1 1
103 %" 4
105 !) * $!( 1 1
111 1 &(
112 %" 4 .E
114 5 6$E= - $7 - 0:I F
116 4
6 :#- ;$ G 3 :-
C
121 %"
(8 ?$ :C(4
123 1%" 3" 1 4 ## ) H6
* $!( 1 ;$ 7< 1 B4 # 1%" 3'( %$ *I
124
!)
127 6
129 5(
131
132 I5 $3

D,
J*" 1) .8 - "% !) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< .86 F#
* $!( " KE J!) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< (% . 9: F F$
;$ 7< 3'( $ 3: <<8 " 1 *!( 4 7 !)
## + 7 K G% 2003 3" *" 1) .8 - "% 6
;$ 7< ?, ( K
( 9: , ;$ 7% L( 1 4
.;6) ,
$ :<:< 1 2 4) .1948 3: $!( , 1 .E ' 7 $
! 3 3'( % "% 1979 3: 7E 1 1(6 ?4 -( 9E $!(
*" : J@" !) * $!( 1 1, ;$ 7< 3# 9: ."
-( 9E ; &K ) 7E G ?% # .86 7 @" 9E
F# 7 9E J(7E *")$!( 1 ;$ 7< 1%!, 7% 9) 56
.8 3 KE (*")$!( 1
? - , 1 J44 56
.(2003) 3: *"
, 7N );% %: A ,E ;, 1 J F# *" .8 7E
* $!( 1 4 1 J%" 4 7 -E J!) * $!( 1 (.E
BK P
7 J7< -" + 1 4)% 7 7 G, 7 7 !)
.!) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< C# 8
C +

Abstract
The study of the imbalance of powers in the Middle East after the
U.S. occupation of Iraq came to shed light on the structure of the balance
of powers in the Middle East, as the Middle East is considered as one of
the most regions exposed to instability in the system of the balance of
powers , especially after the U.S. occupation of Iraq in 2003 and the
geostrategic subsequent changes represented by the competition and the
conflict between the regional powers for dominance and the leadership of
the other regional balance of powers.
The emergence and establishment of Israel in the region in 1948 had
the clear effect in the destabilization of the region until Thursday
Revolution in Iran in 1979 erupted and after the security system had
restored there was an adjustment in the size of the regional balance of
powers in the Middle East, what led Iraq to try to modify it
through direct confrontation with Iran, which led to the outbreak of the
first Gulf War between the poles of the balance of powers in the region
(Iraq and Iran) followed by the Third Gulf War led by the United States
against its ally in the region (Iraq) whereas Iraq was occupied in (2003).
The occupation of Iraq came to be in the interest of the largest non-
Arab regional powers (such as Iran, Turkey and Israel in the Middle East,
but the Arabic gaps, which occurred in the Middle East was expected to
have a significant impact in changing the equations of balance, and these
variables to impose a new form of balance of powers in the Middle East.
1
3;
-$ -
:8
1 ;$ 7< ( @: *! &K 1" ;$ 7< 3'( "
" 9: ?! ;$ ,8: 3'( @() ! ;$ 7<
. 7= 1 74 % G 7
C# ? 1, 1 $8 C ;$ 7< 3'( . Q
1 1, 1 3'( < ?R"% 1, 1 $- '

.
P" !) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< 3'( 7 ' 8 7
1 (< .
% K J+ . % (E J$-% - @"#
7N K .1 1, 3'( (: 7% :
, 8:

?+ . "%!% . : ;% . 7% 7 " 1 *!( 4
9: ?, 7+! 7 .6 P" ;$ 7< 3'( 7 9("% J: A
;, 7+! <% 1 C%% 7 ;% . ( .86 7 J;6
;, 7+! <% 1 C%% 7 ;% ( .86 7 ;6 9:
. 4 7 ?:
3'( P" .< P" KE J*% 7 1> !) * 7E
1 + # %% J - <<- 7 " @ ;$ 7<
1 1, 3'( 1 ?4= 1 3'( + # 7 $!( 1 , ;$
P 1 3'( K :
;$ 7: 8
C (4 # 7 !) * $!(
.!) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< . 9: C% L"( +
? - K% 7'" 7 *% 7 7% ) 7 7 K
9: ( P
1%+ "- %$ 7 F(- "% $!( 1
)
.!) * $!(
* % R " 3 "%! J1+# G, # S K
.%+ . (J ? 7
2
1 # ) ? - 9: "- . 1$% 1
1 ( A ( . 9% ." ( 1: K 7N !) * $!(
.$!( 1 ( : 9 ,E ?, & T# 2%
3, .86 7 %J!) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< .86 : 7E
1 ?: %" ;$ P#E 7 "% K * J1948 3: .E
. *" J$!(
*!( .8 1967 3: 1956 3: 9: 1484 7"
;$ " 9: "# (J(7-#U%+
U?<AUF()%"
.$!( 1 < : ?$ ?
1 %" ;$ F P#N%
F - 34 7J.E + G 6 1 .86 7 # (
.1979 3: .E G 38 ?" .86 7
6 !) * $!( : V 7 6 K(
* $!( 1 ;$ 7< 9: K L"( J?% # 7
% Q .= 3 1 ;$ .% ( ,E ?, *" 'J!)
3: 1," &( .:
.86 7 J?: ," ?$ P#E :
56 (1988U1980)3: 7 7E G ! % *" W # 34 7 (1981)
3: *" 1) .8 - 9E (1991U1990)3: (4 56 9E 9)
.(2003)

) ? - .%, 7 2 1$$ + %4% @ K 7
?$ 7 *"J!) * $!( 1 ( ?, & T# 2% 1 $!( 1
@(% @8 % ( ;$ !6 7 @ <E @: F$ 3 1 <%)
.(2003)3: ,- "
(2003) 3: *" 1) .8 - 7 7% Q % F#
6 7 KE !) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< 9: ?% #% 4= Q .
.$!( 1 .E 7N ;6 ,E ;, " 1 4) ,E ?, *"
;$ 7< 1 .86- *" % *" A 1 ;$ BK #
." 7I 1 1#) &" K
( !% ?!
3
?># ' 1 %"

(- 4 1 G, 7 @(NJ K (# 9E
J#6 6 + 3 .# , (>% %" . P"% 1
;$ 7< , (E G 8:
!6 $!( @# . " 7 7 7
3
1 @" 3 K J%" . 7 # 7,E 7: '
* $!( 1 ;$ 7< 9: K 4> $!( 9: ! &K # G,
.!)
: $8 @ - -
$!( 1 ;$ 7< .86 9: 1 4) 1 7
7: %# .86 7 K (2003) 3: *" 1) .8 - "% !) *
U: )
7N) ,E ;, " 1 ( ,E ?$ ," ?$ ( 4 .1
X (2011 9 2003)3: 7 +% !$ "% ? 1 C (.E
1 ;$ 7< .86% ) ? - 6 #6 ;$ .2
X !) *
X !) * $!( 9: L( ?< 9E 1 ." .3
7< .%$ 9: $!( 7% P"% 1 !$ - G, 4) .4
X 3$ ;$
:- '/
( ?# ) *$ .# 7 G 1 Q % BK .
. BK " %" '() (E ; 9: , .%$ .
.3, 1 ?# *$ P
1 .EJ J7E .4 ;6 ;, <% 9: ," ?$ ( 4 .1
.!) * $!(
* $!( 1 ;$ 7< .86 9: *" 1) .8 - 4 .2
.!)
.!) * $!( 9: L( ?< 9E 1 ." .3
1 ;$ 7< .%$ 9: %" $!( 1 !$ - 4 .4
.!) * $!(
4
:- -/

G# 9: " 1 1%" 1 $ G( ?E 1 7
7 (# 9EJ!) * $!( 9: 4> ;$ 7< 1 -86-

%" 4 F 9: 1, 3'( . ! 2 1

G, 3 34 % + ( " .# 1 76
.# 1
:- -)
1 ;$ 7< 1 .86 9E ; ( 2003) 3: *" 1) .8 - U
-( .( ,E ?, .4 7 *" 7E %% !) * $!(
;$ 7< ?# !6 3 " 7 G, 7 (2011) 3: %" 4
.$!( 1
:-
. U.EU 7E) !) * $!( . :-=$ .
.(7) U7(% U*" 9E @8% 1%" 56
.(20119 2003)3: 7 U:-=$ : .
:-@5C 0$3 '
: .1
?
( $ (% $ (: > ." 1 1
7 Q % J" ( 7 A G
. 7 :#
7 # %#
. :# BK
-# G# 1 ." G 7 C ( % J4 ;6
.$- *$ % .6 & Q (: BK 9E ?"
7% 4>J?$ ." @% ." G< 7 :@(>% K ;$ 7< "
F 1 ?4= ;$ BK ."# C C'( *6 "< ) ;$
!) # 9: ' 1 $- '
% J? :$ 7 :#
.(27HU1971U$)7< 7< 1 )
5
.-= -1C $(2003)1 $ -1 -$ :$@5"

: .2
9E !) * %" 36 " J $ #( 1+# T8!
P%) % . % ! 1) 9: 3 *! J(4 "
%" ?<# 9E %+ 7 ? , %(# !
.(224HU1 3#":2006U7<)7E
H, : 4! &3 ./ $3 1 :$@5"
.@ $ " : 4" -$)C$ $= $
: -$ 0$ >E= $C
:- >E= $C 1
* $!( 1 ;$ 7< G% .86 7U - &'( ! 7
5( K% C" !) * $!( %
6 6 . %: !)
.1 1
5( 3'( . 5( 9E E 16
:1 9: < &'( ! 7N L) K 9:
. ((: 1) .8 - "% !) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< .1
5( ", '( ,8" 1 6 '( %6 .2
14 9: 3$ 1(% 5( K $ 2 ? 9: 1(%
.:
@( 1 1 3'( . 3'( '( *! 1 G#
.( ?
- ; <# ( 1 $% .( .3
?$ '( 7E .$ 7 %- @(N ,;$ 7< . 7
1 *$ &'( . # 9:
( J", '(
P"% B# : 3'( ?% #( J(4 " .%, ?
*$ G 1$ !6 G 4> $4% ?, < *6 9E ;% ;$
3'( 7< 9: K 1
: ( 6 9: *

.B$ 1
6
L"( -E $(- % 1", B#- 7E

@# K , J'( # 7 % ?% ?$ <
7% 7 4 1 @"( % ) ? - 1 ?% #%
.;6)
?$ ( 1 '( 7% C< 7,7< ?$ *! (:
1 G,% -
C '( 4
( R " 1 ,", '( 1 T8!
(",)'( BK 1(% 9E 7<% ?: 7 7 &K @: 7: C%"

"?$% : " ? 9: 1(% 1 . 5(
. (14HJ1971J$)U4(#U ,8" 1 1)
*!( 1 % 1 ?$ !E 1 '( BK 3
1
BK (" 1 ?$ 7N 6I C J?! 4> ?
% (4(#) @
K% 1 J% ,8: 1 . @ &K 1%( 4> ; 1 ", '(
K 7 C,!( G 1 (E " @>% (" 7 7 7 -
.:
A + 7 % " ' 1 1( ( 1 4%
% ?, 3# ( 1 [ &K J ( (" BK 7% 3 &K
. 7 A # 1 1 4> 1 (E 3# BK
.(1615HJ1971J$)
( 9: ,8" 1 G# 9E ", '( '( ( 7
P+% # 1
% 8$ ?, ?< (
.;6) . 2 1 1 4> 7: '(
% ?$ 9: K ? 7 *!( J) ? - (
) " # 1 C J"
"%! 1+# G, K !) * $!( 1 C ($
5( $ 7 BK <% 7
7 @(N J* .) L=
*$ ( 1" 7 J#6 ?$ <- (
) 3: .% #6 1( $
.C !) * $!( 1 H6 .%
7% J$ 2 ? 9: 1(% 1", 5( K 9(% BK 7E
#6 ($ 2) . 1 5( K # 7
7
@ + %( 7 . 1 J", A "

% 7
..6 6 1 3" &
" # ) 7: 2 %" 1 "$ 2" ? 7E
1 Q , &K . :< .% 7 3A% J3" 7 $!( B#
7 9("% J? :#- J 3$ K( 1 ?! # !(
9: .-- @!% 7 &K 3" L$ C% C .' " $
.(20H1971U $)1 G# 1 : &) 1#6 1 ."
9: F(% 1#6 1 ( K 7 K6) 1 - 7E
(% ." J6I (# & ?: 7 " # ) $ 2
8 % ) ? - #6 $!( : 7$ 9:
1 G# 1 .8 - K : 7 "# ((, ", % 7 *"
.% A
* $!( 1 ;$ 7< '(% .86 *" 1) .8 - 7E
J1 G# ( 14 ) 9: 3$ 5( C
6 '( ( 7 F# J!)
. 1 1 3'( ! 6 7($ 3 9: 3, 1 3'( # .86 7
(" % K%( (" ? 3) *4 #% # KE J1 G# 7=% *"
%:) *!% 86 . 1 3'( ! F 9E : 7"
.(27HU1996U 1
* $!( 1 # ;$ 7< .86 &'( ! . (:
1 " #(- 9E . C< 7 J*" 1) .8 - "% !)
.;6 9E 7 ?$ < .$( 9E
7 C L%$ J:
@( 1 1 3'( . 9: 3$ 5(
9 ( ! Q .4 BK 3'( '( J:#- 3" ? 1 (3'() '(
.$%! :#- 3" . 1 1
(78% 7) ,8" ? 1 B#- K 1 7<% ?: <% 7
( 1 :
3'() :@% 1 8
C
'( BK T &K
.( 23HU1971$)
8
.86 7 1 1 3'( "%! . ?> ,3'( '( 7 %
1
1
3
'(
% 1
Q
1
8:

(Input) 86

3'( "%! , J#6 6 @"( .:
K (Output) #6
(4 %!$ 3'( ;$ 7< 3'( 7 <E - "
. %!$ & I 3'( 9E
;$
7 : # 9: 3$ &K 3'( ;$ 7< 3'(
,= *
& .8+ 7 ;, & K , , > 1 ?
.(24H 1990U .:E)3$ 1, 1" 1 G 3" + , 1
:-$ 0$ 2
7 %, G 7: 4 1 7 : 9: 8!- 3
.Q %) < () "# % 9E # .86 7
BK 5" 1
L
( 9E ,! , BK 7 \ Q % # 3 KE
1 ( ?
- ; 7 " H86 3 ,
, "# . 3 4 % 3 % ( F "# E ? 3 KE ,BK
. ( 3
9
:F$ 1
"#U?% "% !) * 1 1 1, U2001U& (1)
.7:U()
'( 7 3 KE . 1 G% . "%! 7 %
: 9
1 3 1+# G,% G ?# ,E @
% . 7 C6 J!) * $!( 1 4> 9: ?, C
: ?$% G 7 Q 7 (19) % Q 7 3" 1 (34)
7 7 JC 7 1!) . 1 : 9E % J6
9E 1, (< K
( ?< *$ (>% $!( 1 @= &K
1 BK 7 C6 1%+ % *" #6 2 (#
J$!( G ,8: 1 C' C! 1 ?% ? 1 @
,) B $% @!% <% 7 ." ?: %: 3 K 7 7: 8
C
, % !E 1 F 1! * 3'( 9E $!( . J ( 7
.;6 ( 7 38E B - ,- ,- :
:- H@$ =
K
( P"% " $!( 1 ?# , % 3$ %
-# 1 , : 9: . 7 ( 1, 7 <<" *%
! ,- (% ( 9$%.?# 4-
1 7 1 1 ." BK . , ! 7: 8
C
.'( ; 1 7) ? 1# 1 7" 9: C " &K 1! *
( .) ! 1(4 .
1 F# J. "% $ 9: KE
.T$ 1!) * 3'( 7: Q U
.! * % 7: Q *! U1(4 !
., ;$ P"% G ,8" . UQ4 !
< 7 1 1 , U.) Q % 1 .(U 7 Q4 .

U1 9E U1(4 Q % *! (% U
6 %(# (4 56
. %(% B< 1
10
7S 1 U1 !6 7% UL6 Q % F#
.1%" 1$
U?# %$U1%" 56 $!( 1 ;$ 7< ?:EU(2004)U1(" (2)
.7:U() "#
:- -/
$!( 1 ;$ 7< ?# $ T! F# ( 1 7
K( % R 1 @ 1 7< K 16 '( G% .86 7 J1%" 56
.44 56 9 (4 56 % C 9) 56
$!( 1, ;$ 7< 3'( 1 - + 9E E
# 7% . 9: BK 1 < 1%" 56
.$!( 1 ;$ 7< *!( 9: ?4= 5( 7 K 9: *"
:- H@$ =
(% J$!( 1 7E *" 2 . ( ?4 7%E ;$ 7< 7
#( 9) 56 -( "% JC%(
" ;6) %" 56 . (
. 6 1#- L"( J;$ 7< , , :< 9: L(
9E 9 &K J(1981)3: . BK 7 7" L# , 1,E 1%: . 1 "
F(4> J(7E *") 7$ 7% 7< ' . $!( 1 ?# ?, #E
% J7E *" 1#6 7" L# . P"% : J( ,"
7 ) P"% 1 7E ?: .86 7 7< K 9: ' L# . P"% 7
.1%" 56 1 @:! 7% @(% ,*" @# 1 ,
U# U7(% U1%" * 1 1, 7E U(2005)U
U
. ,8" ,- U "#U ,8:
) : .86 7 $!( 1 1, 7E @ 1 Q % *! KE
$!( 1 1 1#-
& 3'( 1 4 "
.7(% 1 ] <
11
05 2
(152) "U #U# !) * 7E :(2003). JB (1)
.(132)H U?$
: $8 $ - $ 0= ."

. L" 9:J$!( . $ 7 7 !) * 7E
K
( 7 ? - G( 7 :-= % ! Q J$- 3"
;$ %" , ;$ 7 . 7 7% %# ( X$!( 1 !!6
. !!6 . 7N ;6) ,
1 ? - 2 G 7E 2 * . :-= % !
.X$!(
#U"% *" 9: = :(2003):J# (2)
.(150)H (152)"U
3'( + *" 7
.) ! R " .E 7 9: KE
3, 9: (: .E 7J? - . + .: 3'( (J@ 3
8 2 P" 7 7 C%$ C6 ( 7 G '( ? -
."% $!( 1 7
U(153)"U #U1 1 :(2003)#JB:(3)
.(322)H
16 !J3" !E 1 ,8" 7: Q KE
. . Q (1958) 3: K( % Q , .E 7% ,8"
7< 9: K 4 G .( ,(&! *
-) 3 &:
.!) * $!( 1 ;$
:0= 3
U, # "( ) ? - U(2005 )B (2)
%U# Q % < $" (
.1%'
J*" .8 7 ) ) 7: Q J?( BK @% F# <% 7
( # 2 '( 7 44 56 , :
.!) * $!( B#
12
U1%" 56 1 1#- 4)U *" 7EU(2005)B (2)

.1%' %U < (
, ;$ 1 9: K 4 ," 1) ? , ?( KE
!) * 1 1#- 1 G KJ 7N *"% !
U " ,
- ( ,(22 21)HJ 1%" 56
.(24)H 1%" 1$ 7) 9: 4
: G:) 0: / 0$ $/M ! -
./ $ "
$:8=" N-$: 0$: $ 0A$5 $8=" N 1C 6$E=
N -: >$ 6$E= E -= F 0A$5
6: : <, - 0A$5 $8= N $/J$; - < 0$ O 4!
I5 >. $ ?. N -= G)
N@:" $ P 61" -$= , -1" 1 4"
.;= , -85 N- L5 I1 -85 61C -/ ?.
.-; , $8 $5C = $8 =8
./
7% 1 !$ - - "% BK <JC6
." (2003) 3: K( ;$ 7< 9: F$% 1 ", 3,
.B+ 9:
13
:- -58=

U : 1 1" 5( 36 Q % 9: "%!
Q ) # !%(- F$- .86 7 U1 1
5(
7: #( !) * $!( 1 %$ #( 9E -
C "
.!) * $!( 1 7< .86% $" 3'( 86
:- -/

#(- .( 6 ,. 6 ,: $ 9E 3$ 3 $
.
14
=$ 3;
-= 6$E= ,$
.%, 1%" 56 $!( 7 (- 9: <: (!% (: 7 K(
" # 6% ;6) :
. J(31971)(
^
F. L J@4 . ^
F. > ( . J$!( 9E G! "
* 1%" 1, 3'( 1 $!( 1 # ;$ 7< F( (E
( 1%+ 1, 7%!$ 7% ?% <E 7 - JC: 1!
.3" $% 7 "$% . 9: 8'% 1$ .<
J %! !) * $!( ("% ( 1
9" J7E 1 8 ?4 "( # 7 J$!( 1 ;$ 7< 9: 4
C6 $!( . 9E 9E (1(6) ( ?4 9:)
%# F . 7 "% 1%: 1,E " *" 9" ;6 # 7 1%" 56
.1978
,
G, "% 1%" 3" 7: <: 1 &
! 4 7'" 7$ % J( ," . ." G
7 1 - J$!( 1 9: '
!) * $!( 1 ,
4 :( ? : Q J!) * $!( 1 B 9E G!
1 1 &" .6 > 7" ? - J!
" 9E 7"! (7E *")$!( 1 7, % % 6_ (# 1 J$!(
,! 7 ( 1(4 ? (% ? @<( 3A , :<
. , ,% ,
G :<( @ 2% J7E G @% 1 C( *" 6 7 "%
1 J(1991U1990)(4 56 "( J @# 9: 1#
1 - (% J" $!( V 1 &K# . !$( (
* 1%" 1, 3'( 1 ;$ 7< 3'( 1 -
C " C! ? -
.@% 1!
15
- 1" J(2001 %%11) Q 4 9: J44

) G! G
. : $! 1 . , &" # 9E ?
3: 44 56 F# J( 7E *") 1 4 " "
.7E *" 7 7 !) * 1 ;$ 7< 3'( 9: 1$ (2003)
$!( 1 ;$ 7< 3'( 16 ! .

K .(J@E C(
* $!( ,- #- S :.) Q % P" K !) *
.!) * $!( 1 !) 2 :1(4 Q % .( ,!)
16
F
-= -$3 1 -5 -/

:-5 -/ :2
7 3 @ 7 3 ( 1" 3- 7 3) BK 1 !) * .
@,E * @ 1 "# " ;$ < 3 J 8 T
K( 3)
.@, & 1
"( ,@6 ! 1 $ ." # 3- K L
B L J9! $ " 1 " ;$ < @( "# J@#
( ;6 ? . 1 Q 9E ? @# J@# 1 K6 1 '$
&K 1#- 1 < B (E J.4 & @,
@: +
.@ 9: ( ! " ;$ L( < @( ."#
1 ! K 7 J1#-

! + $
% % ,.!) *% 1" 3- 7 <

( ;% ? 3" 7 "# Q % . " 7 #-
4> J1 1 <"% '
1 3,) % J
B#- K ; 9: 3 % J" 3" %
J7 7% 1 - 9: ) ? - . KJ@
J(1823)( ( % 78:E K( : # 1 <" K%( 9E C6 "
@$: 7 L 7" 7 .%, 9 J# .% J" 1 -
7" 7 7( "7>% ?% 3" # ,(1947)( ?#
J1(6).", ? - 1(" > (1 7" @% 1(") 1#6
(26 HJ1950
" 3 J1" 2% ? - # B#- K
" 7: a(% J. " :# 7: .<"% `" 7 C:!
. 4= # 1
17
@ C" @ C%% ( .: ?"% " # B#- K 4> ,
.(26 H J1(6 ): 4= # 1
@"% 3" !% % 1 ,?# 8 !% 1 ." BK .

, ?" F ( 7% G .- . J: 8 ! 7N JP"% G
!% ? 3" 2% J1" .- 1 7< 1: 9: 9,
3" .% :K # # % 7 " 8 .
.
6 @:$% 1 `" 1 % :# 7% 8 &$ % ,@# @4
9: L(# ? %, ( " 3 J%+ " 1 1(( 1: '$
3: (
?4 (: 1 7( *$ ( KE J) .8+ 6I
$4 1 3" 9: *$ BK (: , ? 3) '( ( KE K J(1789)
7) 4 7 38 ." JE ? 7 .6 3 $ G 7) 7N J
BK 7 3 # 1(( 1: K 7 -E J7( *$ ,E : -
C (
KE .B! . 1(( 1: 78: K 7 $% (: 1 *$
7 3 1(( 1: 7N ,7( *$ ,E 3" (: , ? 3) '( (
." . & ! ?4 (E J@ 7 3 J78: K 9: 3$
@( 7( E 7 @ $4
9: 3$ &K ! K J#
? F(% 1 C C4> 74= 3
% C"# 7!% 7%
3"
.6 1 3 % 3 ,8: 1 B4 1(( 1: K 7 ,3" 3$
@ 7 J6I 9: L(# ? ( " 3 P"%% "% " ,8: 1 ,
(
%" ;6 .+ 7 * 7 7 3 J ,8" 1 B4
7E # 1(( 1: K ; -E " * 7 3 J)
3 JB4I 9: P$ 3 ( -E @: , , %+ '() ? #- (
" 3 J@ L$ * K %A $ 7 B 7< 2% J@( 7
@,8: $% " * 9: 3$ $% " 7 @ 9: 3$
.(26 H J1950:1(6 ).(: #
BK 7 $!( ,V 3" @ !!6 C( !) * $!(
7% V . %: " # 7 , . $!(
18
, J(" ) 7 C4 $!( % 1 # ( 1 ;$ 6
(1H J1972 J %:).
6 H6 7 @% <R 9:
:
;$ G# %(% b C# C( !) * $!( K6 $
3" , 7% C! C", . $!( 7 9E K " J1 G# 1
# " 8 % 3'" GR# J(% J$ JI)Q84
% J< * :.4 7 : 1 3 J% %
() J" 8 & 7 " 1 L ?(, 7: 8
C J*! .%# J (
) % 1(+ I 1%(#% :( + . . , . & % *!
C (+ $) ?$% + . . J6 " % ;$
* $!( ."# .L ( 3 3( .4 :( <8 6%
H J1960 J ) .7) % 7% I * (# 7% . ?< !)
.(7877H
+ ? K *!( 7 !) * $!( "
J#( ,-% !% J9'" ;$ !% "% $" ( F
", %% J%) ) 2 '( 1 ;% $!( % Q
J!
( C6 ,- 7 " 8- JC$% 1 - 7 $
:( F(% 1 ?: 7" (# 9E J<+ ,!J" &)
!) * .R K% J1#( 1" 3$ 7 " ?:, 9: < J
* J 3 1 d7c =[ @() J;% :( ;$ 3 1# T 9E
J3" 9: ?! 7 BF# @ 7 J) <+ !
(
L &K J!) * 7>% 1$ ( !% ? - ."# K
.(18HJ1991: &<A) ,R( 1 & " .e J$
C"[% C . !) * $!( 7 %+ % . , K
& ( 7 J ,)
% 1%) 7) 9: C4= 8
C : J C#
K 9: . J%) 2 C$$ C .4 $!( BK 1
9E .% ' C, %" . E 9E 1 ,(1973)3: %
J?% ).1%" !
( 9: " 1 % 1 :K 4 J%) . P"%
.(139U136H H J1981
19
- 3 < J , 9 1 7$ 7 (" G! K(
Q J!
(% (+ 1%" 56 $!( - J!) * $!(% ) ?
?K ,(1990) 3: 7< 1 ) #- F%6 "7 7 " 3,
J!) * $!( B# ) #- 3
. ,(`%)L ?E 9E
? *$ 7 % 7 @E @# # 1 3'( 7E" :1 F#
J..@ # 1 '( ?:E 7 1 - @E @# J ,
: $ 3 7 ( J$!( 1 ) #8 # 3
1
( ("#
9: ,- ?$ &,- 3
@ ! R+ 1 3'( 3 J?#
: ?, ? - 7" : J "" ?$ 3
7 :
< (: 7< 1 <#: 7 1("( 7 ( J ,- ?$% ( ( G#
7! " 6I "% C: ,- (%: <J(, 1 !% .
$" 1 (( 1(" K ..< !6 PR" ; 7>% 1)
J1991 J&%) ."7% % %) . 7, 7"% -E 7( 7 $
.(115H
-L5 :$2=$
9(" 7 % - !) * +# 7: Q % K A 1 P6 .%,
.@( 7!$ 1 . " 1 ,4 C, BK
( (E J9) " .%, " 7 3 4 !) *
3( % 7(!% .# 7 9: BK ( , J%$: 1
1 ?%" BK ." 34 J?$ 1 !) * ?, ( (: K
.@(" &K 1 1+# ! 9: - *! % 9
$ %" ." 9E . .< - BK% K6> 3 "
. K6 , " BK ( 7 J* 1, 3$ : ;# 1 $
" K% 6 U(!% " K% J?# ?%" ." 9E
* 7("% $!( BK 7: @4 % @% @(N J#6 7= 1(!% 1
.86 !) * "@% &K .4 ,<() 7
= K !)
"(1946U1939 7 .86 !) *" @% 7(: ."# &K , "
.(5H J1950J1(6 ).4 A
20
1(1947)3: 1 F9( $ JC BK 9: # ? - 1
* # )7(" BK% # J!) * " 7!(
!%- C$%! F# , J1+# @( 4 1 %" CKE !) * J(!)
%" K 7 4 #- 3, ? % , ,@%"
7+# 7 ( ."# J9() !) * 7% *
&K 1+#
*! 1 1 ,7(+ 7E *" %" ?<# :7 - 7 J7
(
7$% ?<# @% : 7 (4 7 ,!) * 1+# 3$ %" 1 :
.9() *% 9 3 8%
? 7 1, *!( K @: 3$ *%! - 3$ K 7 -
.6 @ ? 7: 8
C ,
:. 7 ?# , , ? !) * .
% " ?<# @% 7! () 7(% *"
7: !, J7:
[ J J7 % J7J" %" ) ,
f% .H%, 7 7E ,(
3$ K% #6 7= 1(!% 1 " K6 , .C"% 8 (3732...)
1 %" K . @: ;# K 6 - ,Q !) * .% "
J #- ? BK 1 % E 9E . - @( A ;6) 8%
( %: 9: !) *% !% 7 3"% @: ;# 3A 7+) 5 3 @(
J1950J1(6 ).!) * .% !% 7 4 ( 9! I .% !%
.(6H
:-$3 1 -/ :$2$
56) %" $!( 1 C ,@ !

( "% !) * G%(
9E 1 ! * $!( " ) BK . !: 1 ,(1%"
J% K( %(% L 1# 1# G,% G ( (#
. 1 3" 1 9) $!( R " K J !
( , $% G
$: ! :( ? ?, J1" !
( ?( R"% J1" ,-
.(8H J1994J1 ).3 9 3( 7$
21
: -= -;= -/
: (;=)
.% V 1 - # ! % !) * 1 .% ' *
.% 36 .' $ JC ! V 1 7 J @ !
% 7 7<(% ?$% 1I 6 3 9 ?F PA 9: !$ C,
.( .$( . 1 :( 1 16 * - I 36
36 7 ! I K6 "% J#- .% ' ,
3$% 2 ' K6 C: @: " J( .$( -I 36 9E
.6 J(31917)3: 7 1 ? .) %% ' ,9) " .
@(:
% .%$ 7 B'( 7 (: 7 JC44 C(: 7!
. : J(4 " Q
: I . &K 1% ! K "% .% 2% ,
.@ 36 ,@"%( 9: ! 7 ( 9 J4
#- .% >% >R%( 7 . 1(!% () .) R "
K Q %% (KE K 7J(31904)3: % 9 (: J(31882)3:
(!% % # 1 '( 3" L
( 1 (# > (!% % # ."
.
6 B 7 @: , B .% 7
9E 3
36 7 .!) . 7) C #( .) ?: * 3
@ 7) J<#( (# 7g "# # - .% 36
G! - ,) ? - 7 7 .% 7 !%
7: (" 3
7 1 3" 8 7 %5 7 4>% 7 % 1

( G 7 % <# - J#6 9: :-
L
( 1 .% * 7 J@(
: @, .!S C"
( 4 ( #6
K6S (!% % ( U<#( .% > J7E 1 3"
." % .!) ?, 7 < K 7) 3
7 -
C % .% 36% '(%
.(12HJ1 ).(
22
9: .! C % CK

( " 3 "1
56 "#- ) ': ,
*! BK # .," B:, " 3 ( 9E % !!6
.,% < .!S 1 ! 56 2% (E
L
( 1 4) 7 L 8% 1 .% 7: Q % $( .:) ( ,
2( *" .% .8+ 9E @" 1(4 %: 7! 1(4"
6
7 1 J31903 3: ?<# P .% < +% !6
.(32HJ1950J1(6).( 1%(# F<# 1 .% .8+-
( 7 %: 7! % , 1 # #( (
1() (% L 1 3 J(31913)3: *" .% .8+8 .%
<#(E = 7 J1(! (% ,%25 %(% +% !6 3%
.(32HJ1(6). %22.5 %(% <#( .% ,%47.5 %(%
. L( C( ,% B 9: % 7 "% !) * 2%
!( , J@ 1 .8+- < 9" % B 4 9:
!( K 7 9) " "% !) * 1 .% 7: Q % .:
7 % <# 1 .% 7: Q %% < ( 7 ,7) ( 7 #
J# K .8+- 7 % .% ( J(31931)3:
J" J1%" 56 9: 1 .% 7: Q % < 9: J(31935)3:
7: (!% 3 <( 7 "% " %" 7 ) % 9: <#
% < 7 C 7) .( , J$!( 1 <
.(16HJ1994J1 ).L ?(, 1, G$ P 1 J(31937)3:
K( 1 .% 7: Q % 9E # : 1 # ,
7 1, 1%(# F<# 1 .% 7: Q % .: , J(31925)3:
7: !) * $!( 1 # $( Q % .: .< - .()
% a! 6 $!( F<# 1,% C% 7 .
i 1 ?#
., !
*!( '( : :( 1 1_ 3$ ,9) "
,
9: ?! 8+ . 1 (>% . .%$ 3" 1 .%
.!) * 8% -
23
"%J(4 " % ( < E 1 B !) * .% " $
# 9 @( 3#(E ?< 9E 3" 9,) * .% 7 F
3 7
" ( " 1 7
$ :! K .
% J
F
, ( Q % J@( %, , @ ( &K , 1 $ .
.% G%( % , ,( 1 ( 9E 3, &K 3# 9E 7 $( 7
@,
- F8- % C#g # C #- @ ! "%
( < E 1 4= ." $% '
1 J;6) #- PA)
? 7 .!" @ . % B 7 " 7 7N J" ;,
.(9 H J1(6 ).%
( 7 %58( 1952) 3: !) * $!( 1 !

( (E . $
" ?# 1 . !
( .# 7 %62 ((4 ! 1 . J1"
1! - $ 3 JC$% : . F(4% 3" 1 !
( (E 7 %40
.(19H J1994 J1 ). %65 <# % !) * $!( 1 1!
(
KE J%" $!( C6 !) * $!( C< C: ("% R "

. ?4= , ?, F
E 9E ?
.86 !
( ?
!
- ("% 6 1 1 !) * $!( 1 #(
(
: 9E
4 # $ J@6 1 3" ,
.3 3: 1 .4 - ?% &
9E 7"% @: 7 * 7 J1 !

( * . ((4 % K(
1 ! %A ( ," #( J7 @: ! *
7 ! , J . 2 ? % !
( P:
!
( 9: ! 1 <% P
6( Q JCK# 1!
( G + " P
6
J(1985U1984)?
.86 C .% 7(31 30)f% 9, 7 %)
9E C .% 7 21)7 ?
1 1%" 7! 1 !
( (E 3# P
6(
.(53H J1992 J #).(C .% 7 10
J!
( "% < , !) * $!( (E 7 - @( 3A
) ?< 1 1 ;6) ." 7 " .# C 7 - @( -E
1()1$ P( J(4 " ? 1 C6 $!( BK
24
. ."# , ,$ ? .8$- 9E $!( " T! J(1%"
!!6 G J%, 7 ) ? - (!% 6 "-
"% 6 1%" ! 7: $!( .<" " 8 ) ,
3: ( J(1962)3: ( 34 J(1958)3: ," ?4 J1956 3: L
.(12H J1993 J1"().(1979)
- 7% ?% 7% ?% !) * $!( %
3< ,E 9E ) ? - " KE J) ? - 1
- 7 @"( J1 - # 7% 9E % 7 ? 8 ) 7
#6 < : U <# J(1973)( 1
J$!( BK ( C%(#
2 G# $!( (>% !) * $!( 7( L : 1 1)
.C# #- , ,-, ? -
% 1) < ( (L( L#) 3, C%$ @

( , 1
U: ( 9: $!(% 2
. 7 " ?$ F .
.56 !
( 9E . .
.E $!( 7 1 ) ! ,7

.#
7 6I 7% !) * $!( 1 G !% $ 1 " 9:
76I JAI ).1 1%" & J ) -
.(21HJ1980
) ? - ' J7(+ <+% 1 - 3, (:
7 T% (: KE J) #6 ?(# 1 !) * $!( ?%
%4% 7 !) * $!( 9: ?! #6 ?, 7 &
J" ?$ K 1 % . % # ? - 2
BK :
[ !) * $!( B# ) ? - # K%
.(120H J1994 J1(! $)." 7( %%"#-
3" . C%! K 3, 1 $- 7) 2% K #(
? *$ C: () @= P G! 3, 9: ! 7 7 - G#
.@:
25
=$ F
-= - G$ &$3

G# 1 :
;$ G# 3 1# G,% !) * $!( '
J$ JI)Q84 3" , 7% C! C", . $!( 7 9E K " J1
1 3 J% % # J" 8 % 3'" @ G# J(%
L ?(, 7: 8
C J ( % J< * .4 7 :
.(1H J1972: %: )." 8 C C( " 1
+ ? K *!( 7 !) * $!( "
J#( ,-% !% ,9'" ;$ !% "% $" ( F
$ ", %% %) ) 2 '( 1 $!( % Q
.(18H J1990 :&<A).C $% 1 - 7
J? - @% 3 &K 3" 7 F<# K 1 R C< . $!(
? *!( 9: < 9E B: 1 (L )% %+ % .
1%" 56 1 *!( BK J) ? - : # K
.39 J Miclael:(1991) pJ(Stevner).% I * .
.! % %: % (# 9: < , %+ % . 7N K
G G( 1 + 484 ( 7>% .$ 7 3$ F 1
(10H: %:):( 1 !) * 1 1#-
. 1 - ( .1
. . *" 7% (4 56 < .2
.1 1%" .3
< , %+ % . ? - 7 8

C 7N *% #(
F 1 J7! ?% 7 $!( BK !) * $!( 9:
!) * $!( 1 %) ) 2 3 9E ? 7 % - K
U:1
26
: -= - &$3 6/ :2
) () #-) $4 , K

484 + F 1
B" % , J) ?< 7: (31994)3: ? (!) * 1
: 2 ) $ 3 !) * 1 ) 2
1 ;$ 7< F(% %: K J) 2 ( 1,E 7<% '
- .1
9: ( 7 ,E ?, 7 3: J, ? - F

.(26 JH J1996 :# %: ).$!(
U26 H .H # %:).!) * $!( 1 . ( ' .2

.(30
?! 7J!
( *% *" 1 # ,- 2 .3
J1992 ::<) ).B: 4 B" @$( @#6 : 9: )
.(57H
.(62H J 1998 := ). " .E 7% !) * 1 *$ .4
1 !) * 1 38 = $: 9E ?: 1 ? - #( $
:! J1 U1%" ! @ 1 (1990). 7
( 7 <<" 3'( L = T! ?% 3< K6 ? -
* F# K ,(.E) $!( 1 1#-
G #
F#KE J(? - .E) %(% # 2 *$ 9: C, 1!
@:JK(I 1 F< L "<% 7" " F(% 7 K
(80H J1994:<% ).? - @%
!) * 1 $ ) 2 C8,

6 , ;6 3$
(3029H .HJ1992 :J# %:) :1 ( 9:
1 ;$ 7< F(% %: K J) 2 ( 1,E 7<% '
- .1
'( # 7 7< K 7 J7, ? - F

JE #(j ? - ! , 1 : #
( G( 7 )
& 9: ( 7 ,E ?, 7 3: 7< K *$
( " ?, ) 7 @( %: 9: J$!( 1 :
3,) 7
27
,- 2% % !

( " % :8 7 )
.)
9E 9" 1 ? - 9:J. ( 9: ?! .2
. ( G( # 7% 7< 1: 7 K *$
8 7 , P"% $" 1 $!( . () # - J ( 7
.;6 ( 7 3() C( .4 .
?! 7, !
( *% *" 1 # ,- 2 .3
7 B: 4 B" @$( @#6 : 9: -
.(47H J:<) ). + # ) "
%" . # 1 1, &" ,

7J.E .4
# K J@: :- 7 &K ( *!( 7J"#
* 3, 1"
3k'( 7 7) = .E 1 ? -
$!( 4 7: ?! 1 ) G! ( % J!)
"*6 ? .E G $: 9: ? - C ( 7 J$
3,E 3'(% .E 3, 1% JE ?, " 1! * 3'(
2 36 1 ? 9: @ JE ?, "1!
1 .E % Gk 1 ,- " ?$
6 9: J? -
.(42HJ1999 :7< %).$!(
#- 1 .E ( 7>% R ( ' ?% F( "% 7
1 @ .E ( &K # F$( %% G# , )
.(5H J1991:3"( %: ).?% 7< $!(
( .E G
" ? - % $ JL" Q 7
# J1( # J56 7 1 :
!) ?" (4
!E 1 J'( 1 ! 8
: G 9E 9" &K 1 1#- !6 ? - (k %
: F!%E .%$ 1, &,- 7"
.(121U120H J1991 :3).,
28
C 1 J1%" (# 7% !) * 1 R *$ .5
G J$!(% 7( *$ ( !$ ( `"
J(7 J7E J*"J%) ( 1: 1 3'( F
, :<( : -( H H$ JR!
1, 7) f 1= ! F(% ,: 9: ." G J 9:
.(63U62H J=) .1%) 1%"
G( K J<,$ $!( 1 - J!) * (# 1 $- 3: .6

J ( ? -
. 9E *!( BK 1 $- 3: (
BK 1 2 K !) * ;, 7% $!( . G(
.$!(
? 9: . 1#6 7" L# . 7% J(4 () % .
.7
7 K @: &!( % J - ( (!% ? -
.1%" 1:# 7) f 7: "%-
!$ @ L J1%" 56 $!( 1 3 1 & % # 9: '
.8
: 7: C :S (E J? - ?% 2
.(118U117H 1992 :1%" 1#- $) .$!( 1 $ 3'(
K 9E '( J1%" 3'( ? , J%" ? .!" .9
2 .%$ 9E %(% % 7"% 8$- B 3'(
-E J3"k! 3 " 2 ` 9: ." :
% J)
.(28H J1992 :1 ) ." ) F: 1 (# BK (:
3 !) * B# ) #- 7>% K .86 7 Q % 7R%
K 1 # 7 % J?% ( "% # + 7 4 %
6 1, +% J!
( $ ?:E 7>
) #- ! 9E ?% K 1
J#6 9:
F - ) H6 @#% ( <% J BK # .% BK 7:
&" (- 56 1 7R,E 7, % R "% 7E *" (<
.(152 151H HJ1991 :P:) .$!( 1 % 1)
29
% ) ? - # % ((4 ( K( @(E K
7EJ " % "T! "% % !) * $!( .6 7 7,E F: #
@: <k &K &$
" % KE .E ( G 9E ; , + K
.E 7$ 7: '( P+% J$!( 1 *$ 1 ? - #
.86 7 "
, ( 7 -E J?% ( "% #- 7 P"%
7 1(" K , " ,- :(>% ) : ?<
.) #- 1 .E (
1 # A .: (
:$ -=$ -= -/ :$2=$
: %S K %) 1 6 !) * $!( % $
: : -$3 1 &$3.
. !
( L < R "% $!( . 7 %) !
( 7 -
.(167H J1993 : ) .%)
!) * $!( 1 %) 6 *) 9: '

7 -
C"%! C $!( % R "J8- ( :( F
.:( #( 8 , C, R: , C#
.(30H J1977:<%)
2 P" , @() !) * $!( 9: ;% & ?! 3: -
2 P" ( (: @( % ' $ J!6 %)
J<%) .9) % K6> ) 2 7N J%) 2 G )
.(30H
7 9 KJ!) * $!( 1 &,- 1 $- 7 -

.(92H J1991:1<() .,- #- 7 %
.86 7 C 1%) 8 %(% !) * 1>
1 B ?:E .# 7 1%) - @ ! &K ! %)
( 1 ) ? - 2 C"# 1%) 7 "% J$!(
U41H.H 130 U # J1997 %:) .$!( 9: ! P 7
.(49
30
: -= &$3.2
7 7k 9 ,!) * $!( 1 &,- 1 $- 7 .
*$ % %+ % . 3 < K J,- #-
1 (< ? *$ ( 1%) R F 9: $!( 1 $-
F 9: , % < 8 7 %+ % . $"J1 3'(
.!) * ! % $!(% C: !% # 1" 3'( 1
.(92H J1991 :P")
G%( 9: ?!% ?, 3, (E 4I , *" <A 7 K .4
. R6 <+ 4 J4- ") 9: <) 4= 7 . J.%
?< .' 1 %" . G ! % "% (E 7 %+ %
.(55H J1991 :&:) .$!( 1 1) #
2 PR" , @() J!) * $!( 9: ;% & ?! 3: .
) 2 P" ( (: @( % ' $ !6 %)
# ! J9) % K6> ) 2 7N J%) 2 G
9: ' .E 3: !) * 1 %+ % .
.(30H J 1998 ?( :<%) .!) * 1
$!( 9: ?! .4 Q G( 9E , 1 % 9" K
1 %" # (# 9E # 3% %) . : Q .!) *
" " Q J? - 1 K
( #
.$ ?E 7: Q % C6 C, 8
C $4 .k4 7>% 7%)
.(167H J1998 ?( :76I JP:)
. P"% 1 C C$, 74 % 7K R! 1 7" .
7 J#% J J( ) ( G( 9E E %" %)
" .4- J, ,
- : H( 1 :$ 3 .86
$!( !) * $!( ."# # .K% K JT8 <( 2k 7
:" % ) .( 7 F#E K6 J. 7 6
.(84H J1999
31
9E .R 1 1%" %( . #% *" 2 ..3
% ! 1 G 3R$ 3 $ 1 %$" < J@ :
.(116H J1999 :1%) . %+
!$ "% 4 J%" 7% 9: ,- ?! %) ?" 3 .4
7% % 7% ,- 2 1 P,( P"% ( 8
C 4 J1%) "-
K $!( BK ."# !) * $!( 1 ) ? -
J1985 :?#) .%" . 7% @(% 6 ,8" 3 % K J1%) !
.(46H
.$( *! 7: $!( & 1$4 "- *$ 9" :$4 2 .5
$ 9E %" .4 1 $!( BK 7> .# 7 %+ $ "
.(168 J1990 :.6) .$ % K
( $!( "l $ 7E KE
32
F$ 3;
-= 6$E= 4! $/ H, #

:8
+ ; E 1 7 9: ,8" 1 H6- . *

) 9) 56 J 1 1, ; 9: F ;$ 7<
?, % 7% ( 7 - J K 7: 6 - (( ,"
3: .E G
,
G, 4 %" 7: .<: "% %:
C# ,C 8
C $4 J $!( 1 8E ?, % J (31978)
2% KEJ K(I !) * 1 , ;$ 1,%% ($ 8
C C:, C,
9E $ &K J , %!$ 1(4 J 7 7% !% ;$ 7< 7 (
. $!( 1 $- 3:
U:.
K .( K
. !) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< 3'( 9: 4 44 56
33
F$ F
-= 6$E= 4! -$ H, #

7 *" 9: " #()" 44 56 F#
(4 56 < K( *" G 7!( @% &K " : ".
%+ U) 8: % G 7"% K .%, % J(31991)3:
G( 1 F !!6 @!6 %% @: &,- P *"
7" 3: J. : 7" K 1 6 J1#( &"
56 ( KE J <+% K 1 7) L# , G *"
# : > ;$ 7< !) * $!( "%E " (4
3'( 1," 3'( "F( " ( 44 56 7N J$!( 1 1
.@% 1%" 3'( 1#6 1,
1 ;$ 7< 3'( 9: 44 56 4 Q % .( Q % K 1
: .86 7 !) * $!(
( -= 6$E= 4! $/ -$ H, #)
: '1 .1
% *" 9: 78:E 1 1(!% 1) $ 7 C % (:
F<E JC: *" 9: " 7% %" . $( JC=
7 #
7 %" . *!( 7 J@# ) 9: $ J&#
8% *" ) ? 3 7 > ? 3S 9!"
. & 3$ 7 7 3 P+ K 1 7# 7 6 J.
4 ( . 1 ! 1 ) 7% 7 JH6 K% G($
? 78:E 7 K . *!( 7 J3- = 4 6
1 3" 1 3 '( 7 BR"% J?$% 1," 3 3'( + ( )
7 1#6 .6% 6 + Q ?!6 $% K
( G @" .
).$- 3: !- .: $( - $!( 1 @ ( - C 7 @(>
.(H 2003 :
34
9: P:- 7% (" A

, :( $ 4I 1 .

% 9 7 6 (J." K 9: $ 7% JC: *"
%" . 7 A P:- J9) 1 1) + Fb $
7 ) 1 . 7N C6 J(4 1 %" # !6
. @8- F @(# 9: C!6 ."
% .4 1," 3'( 7 7
K%g '( 7 J7# F-= B# @ F *% J) ? 1:
?$% @<N% -E @ . - @6 G ." 1 ?$ #6 @ 1 F
.(H : )..6 K -- 7: '( P+% 1#6 .6% K 7 9
F< L# 7 J; %" . , !6 $% , 4
&K % 1 %" $ "% 7 J(32003)% 1 3> 7 " #6
J*" 9: P% 1%" 3'( %4 : V 3 ( 1 @
3" 7) 7 . " (: 7 J1%" 1$ 7) 1(" 9: >
1 7(% ? .8+ " #6 F< # 1 %" . "#
3$ P% . 3< 9: H( (% N% '( # .4 ?% 1
$ 7 J*" 1 36 ) ? - : 8
7 $ ( 9: '
, #% 7" 1 K 1
K 7) L# $ *" *%! 3: 9E % J*" .%, 7
K 7) L# %" . "# $ ( C( %
7 BR"% (% K 9: C'
1 , F# J *" <+%
7 ;) , , < ," ?$ G $"
1 (% K ." "% 7 J ? 7S 1," J.
BK 1 3: 36 V 3 1 ! %" $ #
C$ - " #6 F< L# $: (: .$ , 9: $
%! J7" (E 1 !6 2 $ F# *" 9: 7" G, 7 "%
1 % 8!8 ? 3) ?: J*" 7: C " $ F8# ,%
"(). $ BK K
( 9: ." 1 ? !6 G G K
.(43H,32003:
35
(: $ %4% C"%! % JCKE

%" , :(
&
" 9: F C"# < 7 A J1:# " 9E $(
3 7 G, K % ) !!6 K
( $ J: A ( ( 1:#
.(*% G#).*" .8
:=C '1 2
7 ' 8 7 A J*" : % @#% 7: 7E %:
(E 1(" &K ) J? - (# 7 %% *" P K
K 1 U C$ - Q U ? 3) 7 $% KE % 9: $
7E " 7 9: , 32002/8/24 &<6 . 1( #6 < 7 *
.(H 54 ,2004: )." (# : K
( " (:
J7E ; ?: 6 ( U <- ( @( 9: > 1+%(
% , . ! 9 1 $!( .6 @8 *" " " 7
Q J(32002)3: P 16 L ?< .86 C ) K
7E " 7 18 = '( $ ; 8 7E # 3 (
.(66H,2003:7# )."44 9E # % $!( 7 9: $
"
: '1 3
J, , 7 BA 7 ?!6 6 4 1 ,R "
# : ?:, 3 J( 1 C: ( ? -% ,8:
F<E '
7 1 , 7N K J"<#(" ?:, 1
J*" . 3$% 1( ! 9E K &= 7 7 ?$( 6 J*"
1 ?# F# 7 1 ,- % 1 ,- 6 7: 8 C
.(231HJ 2003U2002:1%" 1#- $ ).$!(
3, J ,

E 3"% ?$() ) (>! 7 3A 9:
7 -E J(32002)3: .86 ) F 8% &<%
. 7 . & 7!( 3$ 3 % 3
, 9:
" < ( @: ! &K 1 7% P KE J# :
$ @ 7 *!( 7 P J 1 : J(
7 7
6 9: P K F# J,: %# 2 .# 7 )
6 G( 1,E 1%: , . ".A ]%:" % < 1" :
36
F$-).8
C 6 %" " : :(4 J
.(44HJ:1#-
L"% J44 56 1 7 G( 9E "# ." BK
.(4 56
: '1 4
.6 7%$ 7" 7% *" 9:

6 9: T% < 7
# 7 (J8: B< ,1 @%!6 @= ( . %) ?$
1 ?% 3 *" % 1 ? - 1(" &= :#
(% ?$ * ! 1 J( ( !E (% (!% % A
: 9: "# . BK E * J*!% . # #
( @# 9: 1 %!6 1 =J+% 1 3 3'( + &" .6
."# J& 3 7 ! $: "% *" 1 !$ % .8 E
) . F$- 7 3A 9: J@% ;K C,E C#K( 7 3 "% *:
#
&K ) n86- ? :# BK F: G 7N ;%
.) >
1 7!( ,% @% ?% " % (!% * 7 1

3 9: 9) % 1 ? - G 1# G E !E
.%$ *" 9: %< %" " %: .%, & J )
?% ( ( ( ' 1 @ @# K J1%) (- :
.(2003: &< ).C'
4 1! 1(%) > 1> U:
( ( , . ?6) 1 < ;6 # 7

., #% #% ?% " J) # ( (4 :#
: 3: 9: :# BK 7" !6 . . 5( 7(
. K
( "% -E ," . <( 1 " ?$ 36
3'( + % .6 <# 3: 9: J? 3) 7 2 H6% J;6)
1 * 7 7 : '( % K J$!( . 7 A *" 1 3
.(2000: %).1!$ . .4 % 7 K
37
1%" . 1 ; !) * ?'( 9E BK (
%A 9E 3 % 1
C! *" 9: 1 T8 1 F% !$( 1
7% :% 3: L .' 1 18 1%+ 3" 7% # ;=
:# BK . , F ( 2 ., % % J
.(151H:&< ).
? ) ?= :# .4 C C 1>
. ) ? G 86 .# 1 L)% A (

J% $ 9: ? ( F8#% 2 Q % " :<( ?E
1 .& !%% 1" L 7 *!( 9E 3 BK ( KE 6
J*" G !) * 1 6 2 (
C C %
%( L% 8$ ,% K 1) , 7 C%, C
, 1(% "# 1
.(160H:1%).7% %" 7 1 " 1 7!( 7:
% ?$

(
.' 1 : 6I " 9: (
7 G ?# F 1 J) ? 7: .<"% C: (
9: U!) * 1 G ( & F<# U() $ 2 7>
.(60H : 1%).? - F" :! %:
38
- -1C - H@$ = :$2 $
: -= 6$E= 4! $/

3'( 1 *" .8 - 5( 7" ' 9 *" 9: ( 7
P 9: 9E 7!( " *$ :# 1 4 1 J1 1%"
(2003: &-# ) :1- 1 JG,
,8: 1 % ) ? ; 1# % L .1
7 . 1 " (- "% JQ4 3" . G C 6 J
" 9: ( ? P 7 < 2
,*" ,7(+
.;6) .
% # 1" 3'( 1 9) ?$ R"% ? - L .2
P
;$ 7< + 7 9E J'( A 1(< ; %!$
$" .86 ?: " ( BK 7 6 J !,) " 3:
- B!, 7% . f ! 7 "% 1%) - .%, 7 1
,- @: 7 CF<# 1 " 7 "% K J$( ?
* (# 1 1# &, 7 1( J @8$
.I
8 .86 7 C: ,! !
( 9: ? - ( <<" .3
% & @( $ &K 1%" 56 $!( 9: ( *"
! 7 "% J, 3: 1 + ,3" 1 1!
( 7<6
7= ,! 9: ( BK J7<, % <A !
( 9: ? -
%: 1" &,- ( o% 3 9: ?$ ) ? -
"% ,! L .' , $" !
( 7 6 J,! ">% 3
.( ,! 9: :- .$ J% ,! G G#
+% C!% (4 " "% >( + ? 3) "E .4
# 1" 3'( %!$ ) > K J1" " 9: ;$ 7<
L# 1 3'( K 1 % : ! , # + 7 1("
.(: $4%( '( $% K J" "# 7)
39
) < $ J!) * $!( 1, 3'( ; 9:
9: C (E J*" 1 .%$ 9: !$ L J?4 : *" 9:
L# . 7E *" 3 &K * B("% F 1#6 1, 3'( .%$
.7(+ ,7% ,7 , . G B("% 56 7"
C" F ?# C: < , (< !6 7 *" 6
$!( !6 3 ?:E 2! <% $ J6_ P"% C!% J;$ P"% %(%
F% G !$ 3 2! K ' 7 % J1) 1 !6 1
1 T! ) K 7 = J! ?
% $% (E J*" 9: )
76 7 J!) * $!( !6 3 ?:E 7 % J) #
(2003: 8):7
F
6 . <% @: J1 B("% !6 3 ?:E : $,
@:, . F(4% A @( 7%, ; J;6 .
9E *" 1,% 3$ 3 J 3$ 7 7 7 Q J*"%
.) ?j Fb - 4 7 ?+ (
L J "$!(% $ 3'(

+ " 9("% !6 3 ?:E :=$ $,
) ? 7" "1) . " ?:N J. !6 +
'( + (E J?# 7!) . F(E L + L
? 7) U % L 7 7 ,- 3
.$ 1 '( ?:E *8! 9: - )
1 .< J!) * 1 ;$ 7< 3'( 7N J 7 7
% J$!( 1 ;$ 7< # . 7: Q , P"% "1" P6"
" 7 . 1 C $ " BK 1 ?6 ;$ 7 $$ 1
( - K 7
.# G K .' 1 % . 7 " .E " %: 7 J "7E
1) !+ ( 9 P" J1," 3'( ( K( 7N
7 ) ? 9" J*" % 1 GK 7: 6 3 J?: GK
("% 80H J2003 :&" ):( ?: *$ K
40
(% 3: .86 7 *$ K J6 *" 7= 1 1( .6 G( .1
(E G L 38 7 9: H( ,= 1," 1
"
! 3: .86 7 7E .6 3: 9: - BK G
.*" 1
" C'( % . 7!( BR " &K 1((% ] < ?: 7 7E G( .2
. "C%E
." " 1 7" 7 % , F% 7E 9: !+ .3
7< " 7 #6E C J1 1,E 1# !$ 7! "E .4
K ,! ! 7E p "% C 6 .!) * 1 ;$
) (!% : 1 ?< 7! 9E 1) L+( 7 ?<
"% #6 7N K ."
3 KE .7, G% 7 4 "!, "% <
9: 7!( ." &K $!( 1 1, G, :6E .# 7 G$
.% !) * 3'( 1 .4 @$%!
7E P" 1 7 ? 4 !+ < "
# 7 3 7E 1 J@: ( : K# 6 1#- G JC
% % . 7!( .%, 7 (: " ( -E " " , 9:
* % .%$ %#E J% !) * 1, G, " :6E
1) L#( $ 32003 % ( 1 J
# !
% # ,- %$" P " % " , 9:
" . &( .6 ) !% 3<8 " # % .(32003 :J%).:
."(! ? 1( 1) 3
* "?6
G! 9) J.E J J44 56 7 % . H6%
?, % 1# 1+# ", 1A &" $4% 7 7 9E
1) B#% 7 KE C+# C" *$ 7 J!) * $!( 1 :
7!( G 1#
.86 7 . 7N K J 1) ,"
9: J$!(% .E ?, , 7 <<: &K # ;$ 7< 9: ' 7 9E
G $ ,8: .86 7 @# J 1%" 56 . 7E
!
( 4 $!( . 9: ( ?! . *( 9E .E
.(82H :&") .,-
41
I 3;
-= 6$E= 4! <J
&$ 1, F B 7: '( P+% J;$ 7< 3'( G6
#6 % 7 Q % J%#E C% E @: L"( 1 4= 7 # J1
;$ ) J% % @! ,8: %" C"% 4> <% @% !
1 $ ;$ 7: 8 JK 3'( K 1 ;$ *
6E " 7 #6
;$ 9: 1, ,
3: #6 ,8"% !%- 7: 7< K !E
.;6)
1# $!( G, 3 % !) * $!( . 3'( !E 1
: 7 - J&,- 1# " 9: F
% 7 $ 4> ."g : G6 (N J!
( 1 4 :( ?
1 3'( (% 1 4 J C+# % ! , F #6
4> !) * $!( " % ( J(4 @: ( ;$
G! K( : ? - (
( J?% 7%E 7'" 7$
.1 7$ 7 ("
J!) * 1 ;$ 7< 3'( 1 4= ." 3 Q % $ @:
:.86 7 ( 1
. !) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< 3'( 9: B4 1%" 3'(
42
. -= 6$E=

6$E=
+# 9(% # 7 1%" 3'( (% 7 :1%" 1, 3'( (%
:# 1 . 1 @ ( F:) . " ,,- ,(
1$ <).'( ( 7 .,) 9: 3'( K ?, (#
.(1133HJ(1999):#-
"% 1 1%" 3'( ?$ =% BK 1 (: %"( 1
:Q4 ( = :1(4 +# = :.) .( !
:1_ ( 9: K ," = :G% ,- =
:-L5 0J 1
56 7 " !6 1 " +# 9: 1%" 7!
,-
C ! % L! .%# 7 JC%A 1!) ! 9 C, 1%"
7 14) % C%(# ;% $) F % % &( ! 9
1,% (%72) %(% .$ ?, 1 @( %) F<# G$ $ I 1, 1 (23
< .@ 3" 1#E 7 (%10.2) BK . (%28) %(% I 1
1 7% 7 1(" K Ja A C"< (22) @ 7% BK
1 ( 74>% %: . Q84 4> 8
C 4 +# G<
&
%
(% (%15.77) "
, (%17.48)
<# ,(%18.39) 7

7 (%49) ,% ?: G 3$ (% J# 7 (%51.64)
.(107H J(1999): J* ).1%" 7!
C+# C", . 1%" 7! C: 1%" 7! +# S %(%
" # *! 1 3 J3" , 7 Q84 , 9$ 1 G$ JC<
.(54H J(2004) : ).C#, C % ,C%
.!
( $ 1 3" ;% K , 4 @(!% 1 7<6 @(
" ! - 7 (%61.1)@8 (# 9E 1" ( 7 (%30) 5( Q
: , +# >% 1%" 7! !% K <+ ! 7 (%30)
7 C4 @: # &K ) JC4 C, ;% ;$ ! 3 ! @"#
.(57 H J ( 2004) : )." Q 3$ V 1 %(#) 86
43
:-=$ 0J 2
B!, 7% 7:< ( 275 (32011) F E 1%" 7! 7 " f%
) 1 @-" 9: f% J( %2.1)B, 1( ( ."%J A ?% (22)
.(70HJ1999 J&").(%1.4) $ <# L( 1 B( (%4
:-$3 1C 0J 3
(# . J1( 3" . 7 &,- G Q 7 1%" 7! (
:_ %S K C,
6
:( .# 1 C6 J?! :( . 9(% # 3: -
.1$ 5( 7 (%11) % ; 3 - 1:( !$J
#% #6- :( ) 9: %" ,- : -
." * %$ P" &K !
(
%" 7% 1$ 5( J"# %" 7% 1# 1$ 5( " -
1# 1$ 5( ( 7 ., J;6) .% C, C# "
? -% ($ ( ! R " 1 J(!% .4 !
.(43U32HJ114"J1993 J] %:).( ( )
:1_ 1 .4 1%" 3'( ,- = 3
:<+ !
( -
(42 ) J C!
( C (56) $ J (2011) 3: .86 %" . $$ $
1! - $ 7 (%57.5) ( 9: ?K %" . ' J C<A C
7 %" . (E .' J 1"%! <+ ! 7 (%29.1) J !
( 7 =
. "
J 1" ( 1#E 7 (%29.4) @%( . 36 !
(
$ ) . 1" 1# 7 (%14.6) . * <+ 7 %"
. ((2011) : 1%" &,-
44
U: :( -
99303) 1 % (2010) 3: 1 :( !$ 1 5( , 1#E $
%(% G
@( & J (2009) 3: 1 (- 735.3) 1 G ($ ( -
!
( # :( : 1 ?% ?< 9E K G# . (%35.1)
1 5( 1 1:( !$ "
J 3" 7 .) ( .86
%(% @ G ($ (%52.3) f% (2010) 3: 1 %" . 1#
.((2010) : 1%" &,- $) (2009) 3: (%48.9)
%" . 7% "% %" . 7% &# .% 1 .6 ( :?# -
%( .$ KE %" ?# !6 1 .% K " 1 .4 1#6 3"
3" " 7% &# .% 7 (%10) 7: %" . 7% &# .%
. .# 1 #E # 3: 7: 5( C# . 3, K
? L# F(E 3A J1%" 3'( = !E 1 1%" &,-
(242HJ2000 J&%).1 7$ 7 (6 % K( %" ,-
U: :< U
.%$ - (124.5) 1 J (2011) 3: %" . 1:< 5( , +%
. (%10) %( ?<% & J (2010) 3: 1 - (11302) 1
1 J 3 1 :< *%! 9E J 1:< 5( 1 ( % "
7 .4 J :< %" . 7 : 1 1:< !( F 7
. "# 7($ *%! J :< ($ 36 .86 7 K . <#
( K% $$ C- (361) 1 (2011) 3: 1 1:< 5( 7
( f%
. (2011) : 1%" &,- $) . (%7.1) B,
:-$ 0J .4
JF:) (22) %" . 7 1%" 1, 3'( (% 7
1= ! . 1 "% , '( %" "# 9E %
.1%" 3'(
45
3'( :7, 9E 1%" 3'( ( 3'( 3$( : 3'(
6 H6 7 :# 1 3'( BK *
,4 3'( ,#
1 # E 3'( 1 1 3'( . Q 7 3'( BK J;6 :# 1
1 '( (4 : %, 4 : C'( : "% : A)
: *%!( ( (# .)1( 3" . 9E 1 ! Q 7 "# 1(
: Q 7 3" 7 F<# K 1 3'( H6
1% J 1%) "- 34 1(4" .8 8 ! ?

:6
< $4 ?! $4 ,- "% Q 7 : 1% B4>
. C$4 ,C, ,C "-
.4 ;6) H6 7 : (# 9E
& F) " .8$- 4 .4 ;6)

?' ( ( B, G# 6 1
' 9: ?$ 3:
4 1 "( # 7E 1( G# = " K J& 1
1 4 = K J '() 1 C6 %" !,) 7
3'( +% 4> , (" $: % K( 1%" 3'( 7 -E.# '()
"% ,@ ;% ;$ 2 4 3 1+# @", %% J1
+ %# 3'( .# 1 T% K ' ;$ ,-
1 4 (" $: % ((4 6 1 1 3'( 1 4 1 "
- <% !$ ?4 ( , % 1 '() !$
3" 9: % $4 3" 1 3'( , 9: ) ?
6) 7( V ( J"%" .4 @# K 3: (" % 5
+ 4> K %#- ' 3 % !$ @ # &K
:1
L(J<# J7).&" 1!$ 3'( 9E < 3'( 7 . -

.(J
J7)).& 1 3'( 9E &

1 3'( 7 . -
(175HJ2000 J &%#) ( +J7 %
46
4 " 8E F#N% '() C6 6_ "% 3, -

(57HJ1999 J.8) .(7 %J7:J!,J") .(" %( L# ,E 1
:- 0J 5
: " ( $ 9: 1%" 3'( " (%
&" G%! K = 9: @ F:) 7" 7(4- %+ .
7 : 7 %(, ! - " $ : .4 1:
8% $ &" " : 9E % (1)3, .# (%
#, % ,% " _ " 1 4
6
.A
($ 3 1%" 1, 3'( 1 " (% T
C( . .: .4 1 @% ! , $ " =%
7< q$ 2 1 1( 7 .4 ;6 C( 7E G .
: 1(:) U: 1 .# 1 2 . BK% ($ 1%" 3'( &"
( 85 H J (2005)
47
(1)3, .#
1( 7 7E 1%" 1, 3'( $ :
-@ -= G5 0 0 0 -, G5 -=

- 0 0 -5 - - - $
$5" - (8$) ()
$
2.1 104050 13500 480 90000 4.9 7)
2.5 64500 4000 1500 59000 2.6
1.8 11000 1500 1000 8500 0.6 7 %
0.4 35000 3500 4500 27000 12 9.6 L(
0.4 122000 10000 7000 105000 12 29.2 <#
1.2 8400 200 200 8000 0.7 1%%#
0.9 162500 18000 13500 131000 17.5 "
2.3 94700 3000 1700 90000 36 31.2 7
2.0 320000 40000 5000 275000 30 15.9
6.0 .
1.9 429000 35000 2000 392000 24U18 23.1 *"
2.1 43500 4100 4200 31500 2.1 7:
2.0 11800 1500 1800 8500 0.6 !,
0.7 15300 2500 1800 11000 2.2
1.3 55100 800 1000 53300 4.2 7(%
1.1 65000 22000 8000 35000 24U12 6.0 %
0.7 450000 30000 20000 400000 36 61.3
0.7 196300 13500 7800 175000 18 29.3 +
0.6 15650 150 500 15000 24 2.5 (

48
0.4 66300 3500 1800 61000 36 15.9 7
23.1 2270100 206750 83780 1975800 269.5 G5

0.8 545600 50000 20600 475000 24 70.7 7E
1.0 639000 63000 51000 525000 18 62.6
3.0 175000 32000 9000 134000 48U21 5.9 .E
-= 6$E= 4! $/ - 0 :$2=$
( :<( P
6( ((4 ( 1 %" '() 7% < $ ;

1 %" . # 1 !+ 18 9E %" $
? 9: @( 4 (% 1
' . ,8: 9: < '() % J$%
.% %" %" 86 .' 1 (- *$ %" ; E #(
1 , - 7 :# 7" 7$ 7 74 $" J 3:) .)
F(E 9: H( 3 %" . "# *4 7 3A 1%" # #
. " L# " 3 , '( BK 9: *! , J "# .6 '(
7 8
C 3 &K J(1981) 3: 1#6 7" L# : 1 , 8 BK
L# J ( ? %" J 7[: J !, J 7 % J J ")
J (1 7 J *" J7) J ) 7 8
C 3J(1989) 3: 1%" 7"
3: (( + <# L( % ) 3 &K 1%+ 7" L#
. 9E E , 7 8
C 3 (1991) 3: * 78:E . J (1989)
! R " 1 , L# ( C# !: 1 J 1#6 7" L#
( 78HJ(1994) : 6 ) . %" ? !$ . 7%
." *!( G 1 L# 8 BK . 7 ) ?

(
J . 1%" 1, 3'( !E 1 1%" 7" L V J 1%"
!$ 7% ! L# BK 7 7 % J %" . "# 1 84
( 8 H (2000) : 2 ) . ,- () -# 1 - %" ?
49
*$ 1 L# BK . L %# %4 L# BK 6 ?%6% 7
9: '
1 (E J 1%" ." 3
*$ ,%" ?
7$" .86 1%" 3'( % 1 : .' 1 ()
. # %A $$ % L# . . ' 7 7: 8
C J 7(
1%" ." - F:) . (! 2% . *$ % @ F:)
.
( 7 7 J(1989) 3: % 1 1%" 7" L# 3, 7 7 $
) 1%" 3 *$ ( %" ,- # 3: B#% G ,
1( F!A # 7 @( (4 56 "% 2 @( % J ( %" *
1 '( # 7 .,) 9: J <A (: *" 7: 1:
( 81H : 6 ) . K(I ,
G, 9: ," ?$ E
,- @ *$ 7 7 7 7 L# ( " ?< . (:
1 1," T#- G $ J G, P 9: : *
- 3 1
6> 7E J L# K C @, 9: 17 1 "% & J(1990) L!A
(81H : 6 ) .(1994) 3: 9 L# K . 7: C 78:
J%! %: ,E ' 1 a( $ 1%" 56 . 7" L#
1%" 3$(- J 7E 1 8 ?4 $: ( ," 3$
9E 1 1%" 3'( 9: K L"( J 7 = *" = 7%
"
" ,
G, "% %" 7: .<"( .' 1 : ,8:
1 9E % J 1%" 56 $!( 1 1() G ( J(1979) 3:
&( .:

, 1 ?+ F# 7 1#6 1%" 7) <
%: ,E .
"# %) BK . J(1981) 3: 1,"
7" L# !E 1 1( 1: 7" ( 56 . " J?!6
( 30 28 H .H J(2000) : V ) . 1#6
7 ` (% 31989/2/17 1 @, 7: 7: $ 1%+ 7" L#
( 1989 : 18
) . ( % L( <# + : 1 . L6 .%,
50
. 7% :<( 7 " 16 Q : L# K @# ,
. &K <# + 7% & <( .4 J - 1 F:) %"
" &$ # " . L( % 7% <( C ( J (31963) 3: 2 <(
( J % 1 (1969) %% 7 2
?4 3, K( , B 1
? 7 <# 1 J ( 233) 3, !$( . 86 1 <# L( 7%
<# 86 %+ F %" J .8$- "% (

(1998) : !, ) . 7_ 9 + .+ < - 1 ?<% $ 1 %+
( ( 28 ) J
, B, 1 .+( $% L# 7 L# . 7 *% 2
"# ?: 1 2#( 3 @( J (% :<( %A 1 J6
.% 3 3 ( J # 1 %" , <) . 1 %" .
BK 7N K 7: 8 J : A 7% >( 1 , $ 7 " &K#
. J %" ? %" $ 9: , 7 R L#
. J %" "# *4 G P" 9 @% 3< &K H6 @'( @ L#
Q J 1%" 56 K% J 1%" 1, 3'( % (" %4 2 L#
, 1 , 8 BK J 44 (4 56 .86 7
J F<E 1%" , 1 L# BK J <) B# :
. %" . "# %: J (% .- (, !E 1 F
-= 4! $/ - -$5 :$2$
%" . 1$ " %" "# # J(1945) 3: 1 > K(
$4 6 !% 7 " G# 9E ( ? '( !% . 1
.86 7 # 7 - 1 <#( 7 4 *$ :! , :#
. !E 1 ." 1 6 :
'( 7 "
.# 1 1%" 1, 3'( 9 = %" "# *4 1$% $
7 %" !,) 7: !E 1 J @: 7% >( 1 :<( .
J 6I !E 9E .$(- .%, . " 9: 84 H( 3 KE J C# C$ #6
( 125 H J(1995): 9 ) . !N "# "
51
." 7 J @% 1%" 1, 3'( " ' 7 34 7
(6 J" K 1 6I %" . $ 7% 6
J ! L 1 7(" H6 7 1 86 ( 86
C6 7 1 86 7 4 1 %" $6 1 ." 7 (
86 7 4 1 %" $6 1 ." 7 ( J ! L 1 7("
: 9 ) -# 86 .! 7 9E ; &K ) J $ B( G( :<(
.(125 H(1995)
. "# F ; ! 3$ 3 *: ." 7E
. 1%" 1, 3'( 1 1 %"
( 2003: ." %: ) : ' 8 .# K 1 7
. 7 4 7 7% *" C C,

6E "# $
6 U1
7 CF% J F: . (# 7 E # F:- F:)
:# ( "# F(E 7 !$ ( Q84 "% , (1948) 3:
7 1% ( J %: . `# , 9: + 7 (
J (1956) 3: 9: 1484 7"% C J %" 7! P .8
7) , , : 1 %: . Q84 P 9: 1 7"
34 J (1981) 3: .E .%, 7 1," &( .:
J (1967) 3:
J (1986) 3: % 9: 1) F:- J(1982) 3: 7(% .E T#
.% (1990) .$ 1%: % .8 7: @%," *" 1(4 1
# 3# ;< $: 7 7 "#% @: @ 8 .% G
J(1991) 3: . 1 1) .6 J *% 1," 3'( , 1
P"% E .8 J 7 3 7) '
7) L# 7 1 $%
9: ? - F: J (1995) 3: ) % .6 1 ( <#
J(2003) 3: *" 9: 1(!% 1) 7" 34 J(1998) 3: 7
1 F:- 7 4 K A J(2006) 3: 7(% 9: 1 F:-
3 $% $ J .% K C "# % ."
3 J %" . "
"# *4 7 ? 3 %, 7 J 1%" ,

.8
C : 1"
*%! G G 3 J C8 ."
?K(
52
%" %" ,8" < <% " 1 *" .8 < U2

(: ?< 9E J 7%" 7 7) 9: C4> 4 J *8! 9:
<#: $ J @ 1%" 1, 3'( 7 J %" . "# %
!E 1 1 . #E .
% J <) BK G 1%# ." 7: "#
. 6 3( 1 %(#) 86 !6 " 1$ 1%:
=: 3$( (" J "# $$ $ ' 44 56 < 1 U3
;( " 7 ; G! - ( > J "# 1 C# Q
% J C
" < G 1 <) BK 7 "# #6 J `$(
%" "# 3" 7) 7 C< ( B%" 9: %A J (-
1 ( % E 3: 7 %A J *" (# 9E
J.: & "# $ ( 1 J $ .: .# 9: 1," L
J 7"% ( 1 (E ( J *" 9: ) # F<E
. @ @ 9: '
J *" .8$% %!
%# 1 F(4- T#( 7 J .) ( "

3: *
6 7E
(58 H J(1991): 3' ) . 7) (# F<E %" . "#
1(" 1%" ." = 3'" %" . "# $
K$(E 7: <#: J ?< %" # 7 . <#"% # . 7
.(1990) 3: G . J # 1 1o 7 %" . P"%
%+
7 F<# .8 ?:E J *" 9: ) F#
# .# 7 "
J 8E %" "# ! , 4 J ?<A !,
( 624 (2003) : ( % ) . ;6) ? 1%" 3" 1 <)
3 9: < 7 @( % J "# T8 ;= " $
U20HJ (2003) : 1#- < ) U:1 ( 9: ;= 1 !$(
:(24
F %A) ?:, .: 1 G ? J $ K6 3'( T8E U1

G# < %A) $% 9' 1 $ ."# G J $! !%
. F(4 8%
53
%" . 3< 3: % $ " 3<- " @: *! #" T8E U2
%" "# $ %% G%( , J ." F<E " K
(%
.@: 7$
K
(% : 3<E 7 ( _
F#E , K6%

( 1 . G( # * "# L# F!:E U3
9: !$ 4= - $ BK 7E KE J ;6) %" . 9: 4=
. %" . G# 9: 4= (E J $ ?K6 (!
.# 2 J ' 7! .86 7 K J "# 1'( . T8E U4

&K & F ! .6 7 7 %" ) 7 S
. %" ?<# %A @( 1("
G,% " % "# 7>% . " 3" 7) ( U5
7S 7 8 JF:) . * G 3" 7) .: 3$ 7 % - J
. %: 7 6 : 7: ?%" , K6 7 3"
.
KE * 7 :#- 1 . 7 3'( .6E U6

3: 1 1 1(( !% ( J (! * % 3# %
7 %" "# F: 7 . 6 7= 1 6 J
. #6
9: 3<% %" %" :<( P E ( " %: F(E U7
-
C % 1%" ! 1 %" 86 . ? 7 J F:) !)
. 44 (4 56 1 . J , 7
56 $!( 1 %" <S %( . #E 1 %" "# *

6E 7E
. (" f P 7: <#: J 31990 3: *" <A 7 C%: 1%"
J $!( 7: 2% "%E 1 34 7 J ( ! ," <)
J1%" 56 *" 1 &" # .6 ? - 3

. "# J 1#6 7" L# . .%$ . 7 " 6= 4
J (2003) : 1#- < ) . 6% % - &K "# 7 G .' 1 %"
(26H
54
2001 11 $ - Q :$2
3" $ 8 ! + 4 %% 7 : & Q K(
( - 1J,-, # , ,()
6 ?") 9:
BA 7 4g (" 7 1%" 3" 7) JG# 3" . 9:
6 :
%" . P"% 3 7: 8
C F ,% %: (: 3- Q ) BK%
.7 P"% G ,8: #%
% 1 ! ?F$% J% C4> 4) C 7 @(N
C,<> 4 BK 7E .$ 7 J' BK 9 ? < - 1 8:

.1%" 1$ 7S
.' A .' 1 6 J?" (# 7 C ,<> @# 1%" 1$ 7) 7E
" 7 7 3A%J(%% 11) Q < 1 : G 9!" 1%:
? #E " 3 3( -E J(%% 11) Q >% C4> !) 4 (
9: F:- F<E 3
,, K 9: .4 7 C C
, K6 9
6 9E : P"% ,(% ?: , ' Q J1(!
"
: P"% " % ,8" G!, 9E : 6) P"%J.E #
, % 7: 7<#: " % $( BK F<E J!
( T8 36 9E
.8 F<E . K J1(!
" F: 1 1 .E F<E
. " .%, 7 , 1 2 3$(-J) $ .%, 7 *"
# : % % : ! BK ?F, " G! .
.(245U242H J(2003) : )X" 1!"R 8 #
55
K$, 3;
, 68 -1C - 0L
-=
:8
J 6I &, 7< 3'( & 7> @(> J !) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< 3'(
.% J C4 C, B' ,@ I 9: "( 1 + 7 .# P"
* $!( 1 3$ ;$ 7< ( .%$ 9: + BK 4=
.!)
.8 - 7 , + K J 3" 9: ?! ?$ ) ?$ <%
7N %: A 6 ;$ " 7 K * J (2003) 3: *" 1)
1 3 K . J (2010) 3: 1%" 3" 1 ( Q ) J .E
(< Q E 9E &= % &K J !) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< .86 *"
. .%, 7 !) * $!( " 3 $!( 1 # ( 7 ;,
56
F
- 0L :
- -=8 6$E= 0 1
K6I 3'( (4 %!, 7%J1 3'( $( ? %4% J (" ? (
1 3'( 3 Q J" " ? (>% ?
BK 9: *! K J.%
1 J;6 ;, 9" , 1 !, ( @$( "% > 3 J. @(>%
J% 4) @ 7 (2001 %%11) Q , 7 -E .1 - . .
3, 9E J1) " " 7 J1 3'( .$( 9:
7 9: 1 1) !6 7: J%!$ & 1 3'( F( 1)
P" = 7% 3" 3$( J(( (" L 7 @() T% (`%) L
, " TE 7 7 J ? $% G J3" . A 7
9: ) F# K J 9: ? -
(131H J(2008) : &<").*% A 1: > F!+% : 7(+
!) .6 -# 7" & 7$ 7 .) $"
G J . 1 % &K J ?% "% 3'( 1 ) )
< . 3( 7$ 7 (" % ((4 ( 1 1 - (
J # 7 ) ?$ $ L @# 1 # . .# K
J1!" %:) . ;6 # 7 1 " 9: ;$ 7< 1 + -
(303HJ173J2011J
: -= # . .# K ,
7% ? BK ) (4 9E " 3 %!$ " 9E 1 3'( <( .
; " %!,8 " 7 9E . 3 J X ( 7 ) ? -
- ." J X, . = G ;% . K
(
( K( @, 9: G% &K 1 3'( (% 1 &# + K G ?
G# 3 3'( K 1 8: ? - .' . X 1 -
. X ;6) ;$ 3$ ,:E @$%
( 9: ' ( . J X
57
.86 ) 1 3<> < 7 `$( K ? < ,
3,
$: J " 7%- `% % # " *%) 1) L 3 1(4 (
( 1 1" @ 7 J 1) ,- % 1 <) ?
. (2008)3:
( 7N J . ! 1 &K 1 3'( . . ;= 86 G
" 9: ) ? - . &$ L( " 7 7 9: ,

#- " % 7(" J ) (! %6- L# $ G, . 1
( J C, 3" . % 7 7 7 J " 3" . :(2025)3" "
1 4> 7 < " " .' 1 J ? : ?, 7
(National-Intelligence Councill-2008).6I % & 7 $ ( 7" ; 9:
58
: - -=8 3 :2
( ( @ 1 !$ 7 " 7 7 4 G#
<) F 1 J 1) B'( G# J 1( &,- ( 9E )
. $ $" .86 (" 1) 1 3'( .' 1 ?"
L#( G% (< 2 J .4 .% 9"

9E . 3$ $" .86 1) 7 7 (Congressional Budget Office)J1)
$ 1 J ) ? - ( GDP ) 1# 1 5( 7 (% 90)
, ", . 1) ( ." P
6( ", .' 1
P"%
? - 1# 1 5( G 1) 7 ; 7 1 $( *(
. 7( !E ( $ %( @% J( 2015)3: . %
G
J( 7%- ) `% # *% L E "% 1 #(
?
.86 (
19 9E
13) 7 & J (% 50) %(% 3" 7 7
(
G, (% 9 %(% - 7 1.6) 9E (2009) ( <#" .
:3<6 %).(2020)3: 9 3" 1 - 7 ."% < 7 L#( (<
(33H J (2005)
,
# 7 7 1 74 % 7 : K .
. 1" : ? - 9: ,
*! 7 ; J ? - & 9: 7 ?, 7 &( <# .$
9: # 1 '( J ? - ?, L( 9 8! .< -
. # 8 J
*!( 8 J ( "
J (% 6) %( 9E . 1( 1 5( ( ." 7 P%

.6 ( 7 ; "&(" 7N J(2030)"% (% 2) ;" 7 1) ( ."
, 7 7N J ;6 ?%"% . ) ? - 1 B'( 7 ., 7 1
( K 7 J ( G% 7A 1 1) ,- 3# L
( 9E .
.7% 7% 7 7 &,- !
;
1 . 3 7 7
9! $%! 1 G % + 7 ( KE : .F .
.6
59
,) 7% F- J *!( 1 $

J , ? 3: J
. - 3 ,"
I * $!( 1 - & 1 2! 7 7 ; 7 9: "&("
7 ( %A . 1 9 @ 7 @(>% J : 34 J
A - 7 7 .'( ; 1 K *$ 9: " ?$ 7
3 , *A 7 6 .' 1 J #6 . F" (# A ?4E 1
G &: 1( & 7 9E % . 7 ( #(
. :( ? 7% ?, "E (> 7
. 9E (#
1( J 7% ( J I . 7 " ( 7 "&("
1# .' 1 ) 1 J _ ?$ 1 .:
;$ , 7 . ( ) ,8" 7 J 7% ? - 7%
J $ 1 7 E 7 J7% ( ? - %# @ &K
7 1(: & 7 ! "- G J .= " < 3$
(60HJ (2002) :1 %:).?: ?$
7 Q & % .! F(% 9: ." 7 7 K% #
1 9: , ."
" ?$" A ?:E 7: 8 J +
. ! % 1 K
( 9E % 7 * (#
. 4 2% 7 7E ( 7#(% ) ) ?< $ .$

(60H J (2002) :1 %:).1 " 9: : ? - ( 9: ?,
: - <$ :8
3'( 1 :
?$ .' ? - 7 9: ) % 3'" *

? - 7% ;$ 7< .86 7 -E J . ! 1 .< - &K 1
J < 7 6 1 ? - ?, 9: *
. * ?: ;$
(36H : 3<6 %).1 K
( <<"
8+
' J ? - @% 7% ($ 74 % 3'" P
7 ? - 7) '( J (!% !% ( $% 1
. @( 1 (!% @$ ?$
60
( 4 J .% +# ! A ( 1 (!% 7: 6 (
. (!% ,(
J 1 &,- 3<> <# 9: 1) ,- ?$% G *
;
9E G# (J ) ,- '( 1 , .6% !% - <) 7
7 ? - 1" . 1 . " ?% 8E 7
3: .' 1 6 J 1" ; 9: 8: 7 (N J ,- <
. ;6) . ; %K#% 1 1( 7#K( G
9: : 1 7 :# ."

% ) ? A ,
.# 1 % ?< J 6 ?< G# : ( J,-% P(
(17HJ (2003) :9").,! .8+ 1 ?# ! J #( 3"
1 " 7 @ 1 7 ?, 7N J " #( : 1
. 7 84 9: 7!( *
1 J :6- #% #( .#
#( :() #((( :( 1 ? - .;6)
($ :( 7 : $$ $ . ( ! % *$ J #% ($,
*$ . % @$$ " 6 J(- 50) 7 4>%
9: '
7: 8 J ($ .# 1 " " 7 (% 76) @%(
. " $4 3" -# 1 $ (
1 % %(

- % '
? - 7E
1,% 7 : ? ?# '( K . 3$ 1 : ." 1 :#-
!$ % ( 7 7# K# 9: , ? - .3" .
, . 1) V $4 $% 1 7# 5 1 #( J
9: P% 1) (%) 1$E . 7 1 ( 1 K # '
1 V 1 $% .> P%) % 9E @ .% J (
(42HJ (2001) :1A).1)
Q % : 1 1) 4 %(
% ? - <
1" Q % 9: *
( 1 ? ? - ( J( 2007)3: 1
. !
1%) - 34 J - 7 (288) % I J - 7 (396) % $ %
61
9: 1# 1 5( 7 (% 2.7) ? - *

( . - 7 (263) %
F% .# < 7: ( J 7 @$
( " ( & J ! Q %
3" . *
J(2007)3: 1 6 ?F% ( 80) 9E 1 6-
(205H : 1!" %:)."#
" &K 1" 3" 9: *
( 1 . 1,% 9: ? - *

" 3" 9: *
( 1 J " ?4 : 1 ? - , #(
J(2009)3" (Times Higher Education) 3$ 1 . 7% ( ( *
(E
1 . 3" 1 "# : . 7 "# F#
"# ?: G% F#(2010)3" (Shanghai Jiao Tong University)
: % 9: ? - 1(! . 9E % J"# 7: . 7
?$ <<" J ;6 & 7 9: 1" ( ." 7 . .%( <# 7
(205H :1!" %: ).) ? - :( ?
: - -=$ 4! E$; -; :9
'

% *" 1 .=% ) ) !) .+(
BK ?# ;, " .' 1 J 1 3'( ?$ 9: ? -
G# "% - J ) ? - . . 7 1 A J (
. 7%- L 3 1(4 ( .86 7) K
(
U1$ 7S U% L #)1$ 7) # F# ,
(http//wwwwhitehoues.gov/sites/defawlt/files/rss/viewer):1 !% 9: 2011
7 $ "% J(2010) 7 7" G% 1 % % ?E (: 1
G# # ) ? = L" J P%) % 1 :
% 7) 7 7 ?: -$ : . : 1) K
(
< 3( J = BK "K ( Foreign Affairs ) #6 7
BK : , .7( &8 ) #6 ?< J L#% 1)
" < 7 L J " " 1 3'( G ."
) = -$
."7 7 #
" 9: ) ?$ 3: 9E ?# ) #-
9: K J 7" & 7$ 1 *$ J 1" 3'( 1 &,
62
^ 9: ." 1 .4 J (4 . 6 , F(% 1 .4 J7
1 " % " (: %: :(, 7 K *!( . # 7 7 1 3'(
( @( " :
J $4 @$ 1 1 J 1 .
7 4
J "
% " . & G! J , 7: '( P+% J ?
#( *$ 9: ?$ (" %$ A ?:E P
&K )
.
<<" ? J 7( &8 J ) #6 ?< = J %(# 7
7: 8 J $" G J F
G ) ? -
7 4 1 ?# 1) 1$ 7) $4 @ . # F 7: Q %
1$ 7) $4 " #6 7 " # 1 ?6) " &8 " $ *
. G
J $ = G 7" 9: ? - < ? 1 1)
.86 1) 7" G# 7 ? "% J ? 3) '( J 7" :# .4
(# . !% = J , = 7 : G K J 7%- `% 1
7 " : J = ."
. ) . '( J I *
7 7>% J 7" & 7$ 1 3" 4 1 : 4 7 7 9E 74 %
(Stephen .1 T 9: ?: ( ;$ % .4 (
G-2009-v.88.N8)
: 1 7 Q % J ) % 1 . Q E K
7 J P 1% ." 9: !$ < 7 - J ) #6
) - .86 7 1((E &( ) % 7 7 % -
1 J ( ) .4 J ) #6 ?< "% (
< B J 1) &" ." G (# 9E %(# ."
7( &8 = J %(# 7 . #6 7 % @$ 1 1)
3 1(( &( ." 3E . 7( 7% 7% ,8"
7 . 9E : J . *!( 1 - J `# 1
6 7= 1 .6 % C %" % 9E $ %
( 206 H : 1!" %: ) . .
1 : ( 9: '
1 ) ? - T#( !%
J #( ? # 1 :( ? 7$ 7% 7< Q E 9: , ;
63
# . 3 Q % J ( Smart Power ) K ?$ : *! 9

.' 1 J : ? - 4> : G# ' G ." 86 7 G!
(E J ?$ K 1 ?$ " 3 . ?$ " ;$ < "
L F(% J 6 8 7 *$ 1 #( # 1 #E

.6 Q 7) J .6 1 1( .6 7 % ) ?$ ,
!% . % !% < 3: 1 - J 6 K
( ,
,86) , ( , ? - ( ?, ?" 7% #
(43H :3<6%).
7) $4 %K % ( , ?"- 7!( !6 9 <
3
: , <>% &K 1) ,- G 9: ?# 1) 1$
%(% 1) ,- J3( 7$ (484 1 % K(
*$ ? 9: #- < $ K . ) ?$ G%( #8
P
6 J ?# ' *6 J 1 <#" P
6 J G &, `"(
9: ?, ( 4 ?# (% ?:E J 7) 7(! :
. "%! Q () #
J 1" " 9: , ? - ?" ? $4
@$ 1 (%) $ . .! ; 9: ( 9: 7) ?, ?<
. " . L 1 " @ 7 3: 1 L( (F(% 3"r ( 7 # " : #j
- ?< 1" Q % , G 9: < $ J K 7 ,8!(
9E '(( 7 # ": % .$ . ", A : ,6 *$ J "
! 9: ." K 9E . " ? - ?$ L> ) %-
&K J ) G( @% &K &
) , . .
'( ,!
1%6(- @#(% 1 % B(% J1#6 !
(% 1) !%- 9E $
(201H :9") .(2008 )3: .86
%:- ?:E 9: ." ? 9E #- K J;6 ( 7
.4 1 J ? - 7= F%_ : K( ) q% 3$ :#
G J
$
# J( 3: J 7($ 3 J ) *$ <<" 1
.7( *$ !$ 3) 7% 38 :
64
< .86 7 9> 7 ) ?$ " J ?$% 7 - 3, 1
J K 94 $! . " 3I %!6 .86 7 7 J76_ , 1 6
$% !% K J 1) " $ ?, 1 .4 J #- K
7(! J A '( J H6 !$ J % J
" %!6 ? - 7 *$ 1 C " 3( . J 7" 7)
(207H :1!" %:) .3"
" %!$ & " 3'( J "% # 1 3'( % 3 J *% C(
;$% ($ J 1) &" *
( Q J" ?$ " 9:
K 7 7< 7 .! T " ?$ .' ? - 7 9E J ?:
;$ < " Q J &,- " 9: " !,) " " 7 3'(
,8" L# " L = J " !,) 3: " @K , 1 J ,-
.$ - ,E ;, " # 1 3'( .L 1) " #6
( Non State Actor ) 7 7: J ?: ;$ 7:
J < 1 J :# (# ?" 7
. ?! 6 G, J %" ,8" 3" # .
. $
9: , ;% : .:
? - ( .%$ !%
J :# J ?# ;, " &K # 1" 3'( K # G ."
. $ . P"% *
4> ?, K "# ?$ 7 '(
1 ?% 4" 3 ( -E J 3" 1 ;% " ?$ ( 7 3A 9"
P" 1 ? ( %% 4> 4 " , J " %
. ;6) ?: ;$ , .%, 7
G . .% (" J - G ? - . 1
7 # &" 3'( 9E %!$ & 3'( -$( 3 @(N J ?: ;$
;$ P"% (#% @ 8: ? - 7 J Q 7
.;6)
65
=$ F
-1C 0L :$=$
2003 6$!
O M 2
# ) 1
7 @( 9: 1 1 * 7 &K U7 ) #6 < 3,
- 9: %4E @( 9: 7) L# 9E (2003)!% . 1 U3
1 P+ 7 7 7 7%% J (6 K),:
JC((, C,86 % *" % 7" 7>% 1 G# (,E J(.%) Q
<(- 1 7) L# F: 9: !+ ? -
5( *$ 7 3 " " BK 7 C % 7 . % 1) 7" 3>
<% 7) L# 1 %! %A) 7 :! 7 3 .7!( 1
F:) 7 4 .%, 7 P$( * 36% ?< -
(355HJ (2004):<(J#).7
7 J 1 7= % F< L `% L K6
J." K .4 9: $ F!:E ? 3) KE 9 ?% 7 *"
.# " 7 @( (1.1.3) 7<
%$ 1 2003/KI 6 1 % 1( 7:
(358H : <( J #). 9E K 7) L# 1 P$(
7 , 9E $
: A 7 9: 7 % `% 7 F8#% 7% $
&
% 2 1) ? 3) *4 7 (51) ? ( J 7) L#
7>% G & KI (10) 1 7( 1 (2 3# G, KE L
( 7: 1:#
.? 3) 7 P
9E $- : A 7 ( G<
5( 1= (KI 9 J (2003) :7 %)%, 9 7 3
6 7 ((% U(!%) 7!( 9: 7" @( C % J %A
( , J*" % ? 3S , 1 $ G 7:
? 3)
1!"[ 7 J" ." > % Q 7 ?" ;6 .
.<% +% 3 KE K "% 1> , 7 J , 7 E ? ?
66
&K J7!( @" &K 1(< .# C$ J ( 1) (- 7
.*" &" ." 1 & 7 ? 3) "%
: M 2
# 1) L G% J 484 7
3" L/KI 7 7" 1
J*" 9: % 78: +% 1 ( 1 9: (
%)`%
1 J"% @( 3 J 7 1 J7 8% 6 J78: K G
3) *4 J1 7($ G $%! J: ; . J.# 7 4 4 <
L(J(%) (1441)3, 7) L# $% =
? - $ J?
(2006 :7
% G , $ J*" " ", (( 4 %#
7 &K 1995/986 3, , 1 7) L# B, &K "FK+ .%$ !
( " 5(%
G< .!" 7!( .%, 7 .8+- ?F P: J *8! 9: A
P) 1
K+ F ( 7 J B "!$( K+
?> @# 1," " 7 9E 2003 KI 1 7( 1 , .B% $(
?: 1 7($ %! !) G#) 1: 7 1 @ 7: : J?#
7 7 7( 1 @$ 7 1+%( 7 (
+ 1 6 < 7: J$,
.% < *" 7>% ?4 , 4J? 3) *4 7( (!%
(360H :#).@ @ ( 9: - *" T8 <( 9:
1 ? - !% @86 7 " "# G! .% ( 7 3
9E F# 1 T#( 7 2 7 7 7 J F( !6% 3$ J
%: J7!(g # C# E % . &(" 7< @ 7 (377)$
., J % 6 : ,8: % # 9E ? -
9: C!+ L ? - 7>% Jan Kavan (7 7#) " "# L
$: 7 , . " K 7>% " "# # $: P" 1 ?4 .
? - @# $ A *" 7>% " "# #
!
( "5(%% ." ?:E 2 #% KI (28) 1 7) L# $
. % (: (2003) KI (19) 1 @(: F(+- 3 &K "FK+ .%$
. G# 7 " .$ 1 %+ ?%" ;6 ? (1472)$ 7
, *" @ 7 &K , 1 J " @ 8 *" ?% < F:)
67
9E ?" E C $ ; J%(# . .%, 7 .8 - <+ P"
(( " "(( 4A ".") ( ! - ".4 %:
.V..."!
7: ) % 1 = A 3 "% *" 1 ? 3) , %
7( 19 1 1%) - 4 , , J"C "C " 3) 7 `% L
."C< " C " ? 3) 7 J(4 1
H6 J< ?: ( 7 , J 7 "% 1 7(!% 7$!( 7:
C " 7>% ? 3S 2 7 @( = ) 7 . 1 7%:8 6
1 ) *
7 7!( # , KE -E C< C
(362 :#).$!(
3
(% 1 1) 1$ 7) #- C$%! *" 1) .8 - .4
7 Q % J " , % " % - J (2002)%% 1 `% # ?E
? 7 G J?# #- BK 9) %6- 7 *" 7 .$
# 9: ? BK (# 7 C: C %:% #- BK , )
) G, 1 .4 ( ( 1 ) 7N J ( 1 (%% 11)
1 1( 7 ' 7 &'( `% ?E 1= % ) C: C$%!
" B *%! 4 %% # 1 # &K ? -
. 9: 6
`% ? *$ J 7 3 3 3'(% ! *" .8 7E
J ? - 3:< 7 3'( K .4 9: F$ 1 .4 ?%
+% $!( 1 &: #% '
- J 1," !
( 9: ) ?!
56 1 1) &" # 1 ) ?< *" 2% Q % .)
<# *$ 1 *" 8 .8+ 9E 9" `% ?E 7N J ?%
(150H J (2003) :#) .* 1," *
%: Q J( % .%
, .E 7 J*" 9: $
> J(1948) 3: > K( $!( 1 "% %4% BK
" : # , J: 7% "J
68
G $ .86 7 C, JC(- " _ !% 4
F(N% 4 C# J1," !
( " ) ? -
BK "E 3 Q .E G K *! . 1 4 8
(2004 :?<) ..
. 1!$ . 1 & K( *" 3$ 9E 9" `% ?N
1 1!$ 3'( ,E 7 $ 9: 1) 1 !6 <J%"
1!$ . $ 7 % ;6) $!( . @ C#K( 7 *"
( 3:< 7 9E " 7 A .@>% 1%" 3" 1 .
(# 7 "(! # .' 1," K( %: 1%" 3" 1 !$
: ) .*" 1) .8 - 7: 4 ? F
`% ?E
(60HJ154J(2003)J
% , ..! 7<% (2003)3: .%, 7" % ) ?$ 3# 7
7 (# 1: 3'() ,E 1 (1991)3: (4 56 "% ? -
) P" 1) 1) , %A 7!( ? @ %+
" 7E) :@$% 1) 3
, K 1 1 3"( ()
(7(JKI 25 J (1991) :3"().(!$ 3< 7 - 7 ! 7 # C4 ")
T .% 3" %: BK .E 1 *" (2003) ,
(363H :#).3
F1 7 ) 2 - Q % % 7 7
U( 1" ?# < #
9) ( ;K . G
? - % J(2001)%% /. 7 : & U7!( U7A(%
1," F E Q"% 1 J7 7%, 7 " K G, J)
J7 7
!( , V (1998) ( K( 3, *" 7 ;:% JC#
.4 J . 8 ( @: % @!( (%
1 JB ? ) $ *" (# 7 C" C( ) ?
@< 1 H6 @!( 7: , ?% ;6 3 7% 7 @<
% % ) ? - , J! 1 . . 7
3: 9E 1 3'( G ( P+ #6 . .6 8:E
, 9: 1 7) L# 7 . .# 7 K *" > !
(78HJ (2003) :!<).*" ?$ 36 <#
69
% ? J !- !%6% 1," ? - ?E < $
7E (# 9E 7 *" ( "% 6 J % %
J $!( 1 ) 2 J 7 7) 3 J
J 1!$ 3'( P & 3'( 7 1," " K$(N% %% ;6 ?
7) L# , # 1 : 3 P "K% ;6 ?
(26HJ191"J (2003) :1().. 9: F$% ( *" 6%
!!6 1 ( (L
( 7: 1: * ) %
) 6) K 8 ;:% J*" 6 ) ? -
9E F# 1$ J . 3" ? - 2 7 % .
* !E 1 K @4 .%, 1," !6 K B ?$
J 3 1,: 7: 7 6 9E ( - 3
K 7 , J 1,
? - 7) *" @% 3$ 1# . 3, !6 7 6 (E
(25 H J 290 " J (2003) :!<). . 3"
( G .> "% > ? - ! 7 3$ % K
: % 3:< 1%A 1$ % C: # L
( 7: *
7: & 9: C .% J 8
C " G, 2 7: 9: !$ L L
( 7:
@$! 1 G, , 7" K 7 3 9 & J 7"% ,
1 1"%! * ,N% *4 7 (51) 3, ? 7E K 1 3( J*$ (
1(% 9: $% " ?:$ 9: ' 7 K F 7 (E L
( 7:
.L
( 7: 1, % 2 1 *4
<# ? - G J 1," # 1 ?
BK ? J % * 3:< 1," !6 K 9: ?$ ."
@K # 1 3# !6 P" % 4 1$ 1
-E (!6 K) B ( - &K .% K J@4 1 & 7 -
1 "(>% (Anzilotti) 1<( : J;6 *$ 2 ?%
1!" ? 7 9("% 7($
6 A ;6 % .
L G# ?$ 9E F# 1 * U1$
K U
70
BK 7 (: L

( 7: * C$%! 1 8$ % !$
(31H : !<).", 3# !6 @:
7% ( ? 3) 1
T P 1," L (1998) 3: K(
, (1991/687) 3, 1 7) L# , K%g ( % 9E ?"%
- @E ( K 7 (78HJ2003 :#)J@K . $ 8 L#
.," .
( 7: G 1 $ 1 % 3: 1 ?
.% (Dick Cheney)1( 7 (: J7< 7 $: 7 4 K(
!6 7" ( J.) `% ?E 1 7A(% 1 78" (Paul Walfowitz)<

- ?E P J, ,% %% 3$ 9: < 1 - "%
* 7 1 !6 " J" ?$% 3" $% 9: ?
1 *4 BK !( ? : $ " 1: !!6 . "7("%
(40HJ2003 J#).7" 7$ (" 9E 6 "
8
C 4 J*4 BK 1 ?" %!6 1 7%- `% L
(2002)( 1 (% L 1 7#6 1 B$ &K @%!6 1 `% L Q
" . %#% K 1 " - "@%!6 1 ? . ! 1 ?
7: N%
.!6 3,
7 .%, , % ? - @# 1 "
" ?$ ? - 36 7 1: # 1 5( K 7E
#% 9: . 9" J" &
J ?# ?$"% `% L @: 2! 7E J - : & J(
# L .$ 9) ? ( 7) 7" 7= @(: %:
(40HJ2003 J#).(: K .$ 7 % . @(E J"-
C ( ":(:
$ ! - 0$ 0$$C :$2=$
*" 1 $$ 9E ) ) 9" 1 #- ) &!(
.(% &# P,( 9: (" A (" F
? @" C C % $!( 1 1!$ 3'( ,N% *"
7 9: G# 8 7) J *" 8 6 % )
`% ?E 7 1(" J+% 1 3 G% 3'( .8 E 1 < ? -
KE - *" 1 $$ !$ %6( : 5( .%$ ?"
71
:7%).+% 1 , ?$: K 3 3'( . 9E %6(- BK .4

(116HJ2005
9E ) `% # L 1$ 7) ? "

(%" ,
J ! 9: 7K 3( 7 ((N *" 1 %6(- 1 7 ( KE @(
9E " %A) . . .%$ ?" ? - 7 9E K
,E +% 1 3 " ( . 1(" K 7) *" 1 3
? BK 7 J `% ?E @% A - 7E *" 7% $4 ,8:
7) *" . 1 S 1K 3 9 $ * 2( C ?"
1 $$ !$ # 7N 34 7 J 1 - C,E C% % K
7 *% % !% J ) #- ) G 8
C P" *"

# + % G! (>% ) #-
!%
6% > BK G ? - ." J1," G# ;%
1
9: C6 $ %" # ( ? 7 -
C % J7
7," (,N% 2
( ? - 7N (
! ; - J1,"
,8"% !%- 7 -
C % J* '( 7 ," (! 9: !$ <%
G , !% 5( 1 2#( 7 ? - 1%" 3" G $4
$4 ,8: ,E G 1)
1 C, C# @"# # *"
..E 7% @(%
1 ?C : + - "# 1 ;% $4

# 7 A
" 7 " :!, " 1 ? # ( BK .4
1 %$" ?>! 1(" @ &K 1%" 3" B# 1,"
(116 .H : 7%). ("
*"
$4 % 1 *"% *" 1 1$
K# 7E
J : %:% !% *" 1 1%" 1$
K# 7 9E %
1 $ * 1
$ # # ' .4 @( Q
4> 7 # - 7: '( P+% %4 .' $$ 1 .
.1%" 3" B# 1," " 7 " :!, @% " ? &>% C4
72
1 *" 1) .8 - F# 1," " 1 ?(" 3# 7E
@# 7: J K 7 3 3 ? F(4 @(" 7 % #% 1(" @"#
9: ,- ( !!6 K
( 9: !$ < &K 18+- .8 - K
@% % ( 7 "% @# 1 , 1," " 7 " :!, G *"
.*% 3'( 7 H6 % 1
) $ $ : F 1 ." *% .4
) '( # 7 G, A C#
C! R " J *" 1 (!%
.4 @%" .-KE B .8+ *" .8 9: C## # 1 .4 1
$ BK : K J1," G# # + - C
G, F 9: G$ " BK ( 7 "%
7 ( 7 :%
?% : (N J ) $% C% C ? 6
*$ G ) $ 1 4 6 C$" 4 36% '( : 9E
% J*" 1 1) # < P 9: = ( <% J $
9E ? - 9" : , % &) P 7 K @(
(69U68HJ154 "J(2003)J : ).*" 1 $%!
: -1C -@ 0
1 K ' J%" !,) G# J! * !, <%% K .4 ,
J:
% + C# &( T8 @8 , % J1( !$ ^<%
J(7A)?$% 1 # 38 ^<% JH6 @# 9: ? -
7 7) 9" , -" .' 1 6 .4 &K
.@% (- 3: # JC,E C%!, %:% 8$
.6 7 *" % ) $ 7A $ 3: JK ,
%: !, "# 7 1 J(2008) 3: B<A 7 , C J
- ?! 7 J(2001 %%11)Q "% 6 J" .4
( # G K * 7 J(2003)3: *" 8 % J$!( 9: ) ?
J A C: .E ) ? - : Q J$!( 9: E
J 7JG#).$!( 1 ?# , ;$ 9: *
J(< 7 (
.(23 J2009 " #
73
- -= 5:$2
-E P+ 1 *" 9: ) 1) # % .4[ -
> 3 1 . 7" n<+ K 9: % 5(
!
( G%( 9: ?! G# 3" @( 7" A J7_ 9 #
4 J7 3 !$ GJ? - ?! $!( . 6
7N J$ % 7 1," " H6 !$ *$ 7: : 7
.@%8 !$ "% Q (% K 86 9: [ )
" 7 7 %( X? - %$ : .=
.4 ;6 " . *: 1,% %40 1 ( %( G ;
%( 7 (3.8)*" 1 3: f% 7K ) ;( 7) 7
F% J*" 7 # 7 %16 1 3" 1 3: # 7 (%18)74
.(92 J2003U&") (4" !% !$ G 3% 6 % 3
7 7' A X7 7% # %(% ?# 1 ?$ BK .4 .
%( *
1 ( # 7 96 ? - 7) n*$ 7 K
(: .% JC8 " 7E G BK 1,8 H6 @#% 96 1 J"
1
( ? - # K .1( <! % 2 7 (
1 G 9: .%$ *" . .."
% @ S .: @(" 7% 1$$ *<>
# 7) n.# 4 C K X
6 @%( 1
! 7% %: 1 K6>
G # J G 8 : 4 & 7 . 1
F: . F# 7
( 6 4 7 @(> 7 (# 1 " H6
, &( 7E 5(% B# `% , J7E 1 3(,>% *"% "
1 7:
F(E &# JQ %S ( 8:
6 7E 7E KE n
? - !+ J( $ Q %) ?:, 7 K% J%
7E 5(% <8 % 7E E 7:
7 9: )
.(310 U308HJ2003 U& )&(
3! 9: ." $!( 1 C ? - # 7 1"%! 7
K 7 J, 3$ - 9 %" 8% 7% , !% J *" *:
74
3, G U8
C C
" U%" "# "E 9: ." 7 '( 7 *!(
& 7 J 3 9" %: L ?# ! * "#% % J# *:
..E %
7! 1 G% (Diffusion)) q% ( 7 @' 8 @( K% #

&$ 4> 7 : 9("% n+# (- '( q% !) * 1%"
C"% n@(: "%% 7 9E U" J*" $8 7% 1 7 %
9: 1> 1%" * 3 7 J(Distance Decay Theory)'(
( L @(>% C6= 1) < K 3: J1%" +
*" 7 7_ %4 KE n) ? - K 7: ;>(% $!( 1
K % J .%, 8
C # # !) * !6 1 $ 1
.E .4 @: P
l ?# -
C 7N # !) * 1 1+# 3

.(139 U132HJ2003 J? ).7E
75
F$ F
<5 -! M -1" 1 3
-= 4! $/Q

:8
?# !) 7% C: 8

C : C 8
C : 1+# # R "
?, ( *!( 1 "%! (#( 1 ,8" "%!
.4>
7: K - @(N @% ! ;$% @,8: 1 1%" 1, 3'( %(%
16 ." ." 7 :# " @,8: @ Q ?:$
9E 7E 7 . %(% C6 &,- 1$4 1 1+#
(: $!( 7 @" .:
*!( 1 1( 7 86 9: %4E
(60U27HJ1991 J2" J&). %
% 1 % ;$ BK 1%" 1, 3'( 7% ,8" !%- #(
?6) BK @ C'( JK $% 7 4> 1 ;, R " 1
( ." J1%" 1, 3'( 9: 1% 4> K + 7
;$ 2 ;$ 7< 1 % .6 3'( K " ,- $
(% 3 1%" 3'( .6 ?# A &K ) %" A ,
J%" 2 9: *$ ( 3'" 1" % .6 7
." 1 ;$ +% 1 1%" 1$ 7S ?% 7: (
(188U180H J 3 J2000 J& ) .1%" 1, 3'( B# 1(
-= =C :2
,- , .

%J!) * $!( 1 ,E ?, 7E "
7 - &K &!% & 4E (# 9E J?% % "
% A 1 (% C L 7 1 J
6 . .86 #( J@
AE
L
(% J9 , & 1 J1( 1, ' 3 % 7 .$!( 1 ,
76
B% ! 1 8 ?4 T#( "% % 1' 7K 36< )
.1979 3: ;%
. , 7E .! CK# + 4 7 % J' BK 1

7$ 7 ("% $: 7 F% % UB : .86 ( 7 "%
C: %+ 2 1 C %" Q J + F
3 U1
G "7( %%" 9 " ?< JH6 @# 9: )
2 : 9E 7E J" 4 1 ,- ?<
&K . 8$(- 3A 7 J.E 7 56 7 !
( * 9: J +
3 ?4 : 1 7E 7N JB 3'( #( 1 .# 9: ?4 @4
9: 7 ?# < 9: * K 1 : , ! 7: .6
J%" . 3'" G ,8: k 9E 1J6 9E ?4 "% 9
$(- " 7: 8
C J ( 1(4 *" G 1 6
.,E
"% C#6 C6 1#) !6 G# .4 J?: .: ."
%
J1 - (
6 9: 1 !$- : F( J1(6 3 ?
7E "% J 9E ?4 7 ". "% 9 7
L> .4 J;6 >% (: " J3, ! G " 1 "?4 "
3, 1 E % A 9: %: ;, G $4 ,8:
J1((% "] < ".4 J '( 7 " G . (, 2 JC%: F!A
#- F!6) 4 7: 8 J 7(!
"18 # "L " 1
" % 9 F% "% - J , ;$ 7 " % 1
3: K J*" 7(+ 7 . .8 % ( 1 " 9: )
J 1#().# 7 3 7E J,
3'" 1 C C, 2% 7 1 !
(54H J185"J2011J
1 (" G! ((4 .86 J 1%" 3'( B# ( 8:

4>
$ 6 ." %(% . , 6 ." 7 "% J1 7$
, 1(6 ] I 3 8 ?4 1 3:< ? 1 4
7 :# F#E (598) 3, 7) L# $% 7E .%, "% ( U,"
77
31989 3: (% %6( . F#E 8

.3 9E A% ?, . 9E
J(1991/1990) 3: (4 56 < 1 4 $ , ."

. 7% : *8!( @: 7% 3$(- $: 1%" 3'(
" 1
.) ? - *" 7% <) 1( 7 %"
?$ ) ? - <% 1 - ( > ."
"% < 7E B# (: (% 1 3'( , 1 ? 9':
$!( 1 3 &" # 9E % J(2001)%% 7 : & Q
J258" J' ).1$ () C , C 7E @%: &K ) J*" 56
%" $!( B# #6 1 T
(- ( 7E G (191U170HJ2000
:1_ .86 7 6 + Q ) '
:5, $ K5

$5 =C S$ ;= 1
7 % 1#6 7" L# . B# ( 8:

?%
:1 ( 9: K ;6) 3" 7: . 3"
6 7(<
:61997 1990 N4 -
56 . B# #6 ( ," F( K( 7E "%
3 7" ,8: ,E 1
1! 7" T
(- 9: , J1%"
4 ) P"% 7: 16J. 1 $ 3 '( G .%
. 1 @# K F# , (110HJ1993 J168" JL().;6) . ( ?4
(1989) 3: %6( 1 B< $: 1(#( 1 1( L @% 9 2
% 7E %A @ 7: J 8 . 7E 1 1 = $"( F(4
7 J7% (# G 7" 7 9: 3$ #6
F(4 @# K %4 : , K G% 34 - < 1 $
?$% *" .8 7E : (: (4 56 <
? 3) , K
(% < !% A- +# + & %: J"
7 7 .# ! 7% 7< 7 $ ?% :! <) BK% $"
" 56 1 1%(#) # L$ # 9E 7: .6 1
78
1#6 7" L# . 1 (# $4 1 (82U61H.H J %4). J7
7 "% 3$ J( U," K( 3" :!$ % ,8" ?:E
%$ ,E % & 1 7 .: % %! J. BK <
- "%! ( ?$ E 3 L" &K ) J56 7)
J1990J 3) <) 7 " *$
' " R
. G ,8: 1 7 F# 4 9: 7E : @
( * 1 .(142H
7 : $: 1 4 7% G , # !% ,N% 1#6 7" L#
, 1 # "
P" 1 # -% ,
-
$!( 1 C " !
( * 1 . G
, *( K J7%
.7! 2 36 ? !
( #- %)
5( % %:% " %" 9: #% 7E < ,
1 4 7 %#E 5( 7: 4 , J%) $!( . 1 !
(
2 &K 1(U&" $ 7 # *$ J!
( " 1 $E
J1'). .3: .% $!( . G
6 8:
1 G -
C # 7
(77HJ2001 J102" *4 <
:62002 1997 -=$ -.#
1 7 F# 4 1 ( #6 BK .86
L < "% 56 1 ?# . G ,8: 1 - 4
C
( 4 #6 9(% &K J(31997)3: %6( 1 16 1(
# , .C: 1#6 3" C6 J7#6 7E 7# B#
L# . 9E 7E 7 ; " < 1 4 : !6 1
1 1: 1( 3'( H6 <# L ?< 1#6 7"
1 K J@ &" " 1 .%$ " %" 1(#(
$ = 1 ; G L 9: <<" %: 7% ] %: ) &" "
L 9: <<" %: 7% 7! ) ?< 34 (1989) 3: 7! 1 18
7% G ; K% :( 7 7< . 1 (2000) 3: 7! ; G
1( < ?< 34 J(1979) 3: 7E 1 8 ?4 3, K( 7%
3: 1 .# 1 7% 7% 1( *
$: " %"
79
G, ?% K G% (175HJ2002 J106" J*4 " < J&). (2000)
F(4% 1#6 7" L# . . G 4 () ,
- 7 :
7E .8 #( % " 7E ,8: < 1 ? %"
3 %" &K J9 % ?<# ;+ (! ;% (! Q84 <#
7E 7E .$ 7 K G J3: .% #6 ( ,8" 7 3 %$:
" (! 36 #6 (E ,8: F(% - 7 C4

.7
:- - -! -)$ -=; -) 6! 2
1 + # G 9: ?$ FK 7 # L

(%

, 4 9: : 7#6 (# G ,8: 7 ( ?$ '
.86 7 J1%" 7! 1 K
( 7 < *$ (!
$ : ?=
.$ BK B# , - < 1 ?# !" G ."
" , %: 1# *!( 7 : B# 1( , *!( $ K
1 9) % . 7 # 1 $ %: .% J7 . 3 1(!

7 (60H J1993 1771"J%" ? <JG J3$).18 3"
#( J1( 7 G
*! 7: 1> - $ . &
L 9: 3$ 1( 1 #) (" "%!
G
9: K K
( 1 7 K : 7! 1 3 7!-
. 7N *!( K 7 .1 3'( 1 8 '(S " :
;$
&K 7 K <(- " ?$% -E 3 7 1( U1%" .4)
3: :E $!( " . 7% *< ,
*6 8 ) , 1 LA
(60H J 102 2002 J*4 Q % < J7% 7#). . $-
1( U1%" : 7E : *!( K 7
%" " : *$ 1 !
(6% %" !)
.) !+ 6 8
1 " " %" (! ;$ 8

C %
( 7E !
7 ;$ 7 &K &" 1 3: , J7(% (# 7!
80
-
- C" " .% K% 3 .1( . T

(188HJ1999J3) <) .1
R ( 7 G
@( " ?= %" '() P"% F: 7E ) K ,
:8 .6 T $!( " 7 4 ; ( 9!: , L
( 1
A ?% 7E 9 @
AE 7 - .% 1%" 1, 3'( 8:
1 1
: 4" "% C6 J7E : 1 " ;$ %:
7 1 7E =%( * @" % ,
8 1( 7 (
7 J 9E %+ %" *$ 7 7 - 1( 7 G

%4 , . " 3
- 1 " ?$ *$ #- .%
1 P) 9: *$ 1 7E : 1 ;$ T#( "% % =
(# 7 1( 7 ( 1 4 1 J1( 7 G :
C 7E @: &K ] < 1$ .%, 7 @ "# % 4> 1((%
.C: C
K( P) .6 (!

$ ;, $$ 1 #( 7
3" .86 : f% 1 :(
: .86 7 % 9,)
(
J196" J7<). (1948)3: P) .6 : 84 ( :(800) .)
(E 3A ?% , 6 1( 7
1 (44HJ2001
1 . *
3A 7! 7% : 7< 7 C, *$ 7 J"
+ 7 -E .
(- 7 .) 3" .86 ,- ;$ 7<
9: ) (2001) 3: %% 7 : & Q 1 4
3: ?: 7: 7E 9: ) !+ ?< *" .8
:% 9E ;$ 7E 3: G# 9E ?(%
1 ;6) ;$ P"% ) ? - ( 9: 3$ ?# #
&" 1 : H$ (304HJ2004J 1%" &,- $ G#). J$!(
GK 2% &K % - C%(# (!
((% (! $ ;$
1 Q P" 1 . P"% ) ? -
.*" 7(+
81
: = =C S$ ;= 3
*$ *!( 7 J1%" 3'( B# 8:

1 7E $!(
: @ &K &,- ' P+% F 9: # ,-
( 7(, F - % : (1993) 3: K( ) ? -
J(1997)3: 7E 9: &,- ' 9E ( (
)1)
%: K .3" L
( 1 ) ? - 1 ( ?) # ,
<" P+% @ *% 7#6 (# B#
( %
,8" 7 9: : KE :
7 ) ? - 1
A 1%" 1 1%" 3'( 1 :
%" . G
.1#6

%:% (1997)3: K( 9: #% 7E < ,
( 7 @ J7E (# 9E 8 ? 1(4 T(# 16 L
(114HJ 2001 3" 1%" 1#- $) .18 1%" 3" 1 ?%
Q "% J?$ ?< 7 : .N% 7E , $ K
16 L ?< 1 ( < 3 ( (2001)%% 7 : &
7 ?$ &<6 . 1( #6 < ?< KJ(2002)3: ?$
B# ? 3) 1 7% , *( P
%J(2001) 3: .86 K .%, 7
U1( $ *$ .% 1 . j 2 " #E $!( 1 Q )
$ *$ .% 1 . j 9: !+ 9: 7E : 1%"
7! 1 8 9: !+ 9: 7E : 1%"U1(
1( 7 G " ?= %" '() B# ( 7 %4 7(%
G ,8: 7 *! 1 C% C! 7E "!, , . 9:
6 K( 7% 7% :!$ % ,8" ?:E 9E . 7
) U ,8" 1
"% C6 J ("%
38: . P"% ( 1 (8: F# %% 7 : & Q $:
1%" 1#- $). % " %" 9: )
(114HJ2001:3"
82
H, <5 -= 0$ !$ ! F 4
q% 484 9: ("% $: % K( 56 7 B# 7E # <
(157U135H .H J1994 :1(8). :1
,E % & 1 7 # $!( 1 , ,E 7E 7 .

.56 7) $
6 , % 1 %(# #6 A %: P .

.56 1 7) %%
. H6 56 7 %: 56 7 %(#) $ 6E 9: ." .
.@: !
7E 7 *!( 7 56 7 B# 7E $!( $ .) % %(%
7) % 1 C C =!:E # # 3: # $!( 1 ,
1 (4 56 < F(4 C '( K *$ , .56 $!( 1,
$: 56 7 1 .: 1%$ % .%$ 1, K
( 7 < *$
1#6 . 7 4 7 9: :- K F#. 7 *" 6E 7 F(-
1 7! @< F(4 1 #6 < .4 .% 9: 3( <) ? .!
# $!( 1 ?% 7E 7E ":8
C , 7
T &K J19990/8/24
(120U110HJ 1996 J]%") ."56 1, 7_ *$ 1 .: 7 7
1 1( 9: K(I 1#6 7" L# 3: 7
T Q @# 7 - @ C C 7E %: 56 7) , %
,E ( % 9E . !E 1
(: P
.%$ 7>% " :7

7 JB$ 56 7 9: ' 1 F 7 ( J7E G 7"(
1#- $ )."7> K 1 7E G L# . 7" 7 &
(148H JJ1990:1%"
@# K A @!

( 56 9: ?! 1 ) %A 7 -E
! . 36 1#6 7 7 56 1 7) J7E 2 A 1 1#6
J) ? - 1$ 7)% !% 1 7 9E #% @:
3: K( ) ? - G (4 ( ,
- . G, "% C6
83
.? %" F(4% ;6) 56 . $% 34 % % (1991)
(98H 63J1992 J3)
$ J56 7 1 %(# %: & P% *" 1(4 %
% 1 %" P ( . ?: .86 7 @$$ 9E 7E "
&K * 78:E . L# 78:N% : P .86 7 56 1 () ,
) " " F( $: J 56 7" L# . @,
" .86 7 J56 7 1 1) 7E (1991)56 1
. P"% 7% (4 () ,
- : 56 1 1) 1%(#) #
J`() J1( 1$ 7S C!6 C %: ) ? - #6
$ 4 &" # .' 1 C6 (44U42H J102 1994J7
$!( 1 3 F$% 9: ) ( T "% . 1 )
.(1998)3: 6 1 56 . P"% @< F(4 1) <
(184H J107 J*4 Q % <2002 J 3 <)
:% %: $!( 7 ) $ 6E 9E ?# 7E " ,
,
- 7 : G, 9E % KE J56 1 %" . B# (!
(
J(2000) 3: % 1 1( 6 < ?< F(4 . G ()
1 9E . 1( 7" %: . G $ 7 < *$
?4 -( K( ? .) J7 % 7:
[ .4 ( P"% G : (
#6 ( ,8" 7 -E % $ K 3A . ("% 6 1 (
;% (!) <# 7E .8 - #( 7 K % ! '
*$ 7 J;6 .: (# 9EJ 1 (9 % ?<# J;+ (!
( ,E % ,E 56 7 %(#) $ 6E 1 .4 1(
(185H: 3 < ) .56 9: ! . 7
<) F# 1%" 1, 3'( : 1 " 7 86
< $ 1 3'( K 9: - : J(< (% %"
;$ 2 ;$ 7< 1 8
C 6 4 1J(1991) 3: (4 56
@8:
1 .6 &, 7: Q % 9: J7E ( ;$ A , J!
:( 7 7 : *$
84
& 1 ? 56 7 1 1( >% 1#6 :- U1

.56 7 H6 %$ ,E %
1 1," `# : 9 1 ( 1) 7 % F<# ?" U2
.(1988U1981) 3:) .86 7% 7%
F# 1( 1%" 1 1%" 3'( .6 7E K

( ?< U3
.*! ( 1 4" 1 " " ;$ :
: 4! =$ " <$;
$: % K( C6 J1 ."% C: %" U( ,8" !%
1 J.$ *% , ;$ 7< 1 + 7 B ("
9: 6) 1(!% U1) 7" 7 1( , 1 ?$% C 7
, . Q84 7% ( < 7 7J(2003) 3: L 1 @8 *"
:1_ ( 9: 7" K B# 1(
:> G1 1 =C '1 1
6
( 1(!% 1 7: &) 1( P 1 , K .4 ,
1$ 7S C!6 C .4 7" K .4 , 7 *!( 7 J? 3) *!(
*" G 1+# <# 3 % 7E 9: % 1) $[ 1(
7E 1 8 ?4 3, K( ) U( ,8" 1 %%
1) &" 7" Q G( 7E : A %) BK .(1979) 3:
- ( 1(" K .@: ? 3) $ ! J
( .% *" 9: %
1,E 36 1 4 7 (! .4 @( *" 7 G(
" C!( 4 @( H6 .
[ $!( 8:
1 L( &,
1 @( ?
- 9E 7E : &K ) J3: .% $!( *" 7= 1
(65HJ 111J2003J ) .7" , $$ > (: 1" G,
: A$= =C '1 2
9: : J*" 9: 7" 7 9: ? - 3<: 7 > (:
7: J" % 3!- (# ? - ( L 9: 3$ , ?%
85
.1( 1) 7! 2 *$ C" *( 7" 7N% F *!
1," #6 < .%$ P ( K 9: . , K6% 7E % Q
! T! .86 7 (2002)3: 6 1 7! ?< &( 7 &K &% 1#(
1 7% 7% ( 1(4 " ! .4 J?< .%$ ?<

BK:% ?C 7 7 3 1," L K: 9) 56
(66H J2003J ).
6 7 7$ ," " , P"% .%$% C 7E ,
3 () J*" . .% ( 1 $"( " =
.7! 1 ,E F(4 $ % +% ?
3- 'E J?
.86
,( *" B# (" ) G $

, BK
.*" 9: 1) &" 7" " 7 7" 1( , G
(224H : )
: =C '1 3
9: 7E : J(!% ) ? - 1 *" !$ "%
1 4 P"% *$ *" 1 # G 7 ?
-
9E ( "
! 3: *! 7: *" .6 1( K
( ?<
(104H J2004 J37" J1). , & 1 !
7 , 7>% *" ?# . G

, *( 9: 7E :
$" , = 1 *! 7: .8 - "% # *"
..8 - "% *" G ,(%
7 . &K 1$(- 3 L#% :- .86 7 JG, )% :
7 .# 7 7 K . ." 7 %A 7 &K <+ "% .8 - , .%,
" 7E J# *" 1 #- *$ 7E 2 *$
1 C# ' J%" ) *" G ) 2
(104H :1).*" 1 ,N% " ! B# 1( 1
86
$= $
$5 -=C -$ 5
$ -=C -$ 0$85
G ! J7E 1 8 ?4 $: 1 1( U& >( $
<% $ JC' "# ) G P"% 7 7 1 .7<
1 .# %: 7% 7% ! J# 9E ;6 .:
<% .: 4 7 ' 8 7 .% ,8: "%! 9: 4>
:." BK 3 7 J1%$ @# K (
%(% 7(% 1 " & J 7 7% 2 .1
.7! 8 %(%
6 %:- ( 7E JF 9: 7E
2 9: '
J1, ;$ 7<% $" %:- .2
.7
7 #-
,8" (% J?$ A %K%K

$!( 1 JG, 1 .3
J
).C %$ $!( 1 ;6 ,8: 7 C %4 4 ( (
(115HJ2005
$= " .#
- " 1
1 .4 3" ." (1975)< 6 1 . F(E 7: 78: 3

9E . ( J( U," ( G J7(% 1 "
!
# K J*" ?= % ?# 9(% , J*" &" 1( "
7" B=: 2% J@
( 7(% 1 ?: < . (1980) 3: 1 ((%
G (" 8 7E 1 8 ?4 , J?% 7E 1 8 ?4 G
7E 1 . 7: .= 3( . (: 7 % :
J J1#().] < 1 7<% "% 2% &K 7) 3%E
(77HJ185J2011
:T # " 2
% 7 : ( !+ J( 8 ?4 $

P 1 " . J1( G .8 - # 1 1%" <#" J)
87
:(, *6 :

?4= .: J44 # 7 ? 3) '( .6 " 3%!
7 7>% J18 ?= (= J 8 :# ;
.$ 9: J%" 1) .8 1 G A- 9: 3$ 1(
. $ + -E G 8 1% JG
7(: ] < F: G# &$ < 1( T#- . K
(1982) 3: 1 ] < L> .1%+ K
( 1( .8 - # P:
.(1984) 3: 9 C .' J
.8 - % ( 1 J 8 $ BK ?>( 7E .$ 7
1, "% 1 ( ( 1 (# 1 36 1 J1(
<(% ( , J@,E @$
- " &K 18 G# L s J1
" :# 3 C%< B%:% J7(% 1 ] < $$
J38). C, 1(6 3 1 J C#K( ( 8 ?4 1 ; 1
(121U117H J2005
2006 6$! $= # " 3
7!( 7 . = 1 7(% 9: 7 9E ? #
.(% $ # 1$$ %6 %4% 7!
] < 9: F$ 7) J 7 $ ! ( ( $" 7N

7 %: ( JE $ % @# B(" . B F(
J?: 7 6 - % J7(% 9: 7: 6 1 J :
( *$ 1 .E . , ( U*8! 9: U
6 . .N% < * E %" 3: 1(" % J] < 9: ' &:
.'( , G # 1
@# 7 JP) 9: B @ , 7: 7

9E .86 # 1 J'() ) 7 K 9E .? , .%
, J 1, " 9: 7E K
( J<) .6 9E : 7E
(180H J133" J2006J J1#().$" ,
.6 9:
88
=C >= ' 6
. , 1 J< $

9: J2006L!A 22 1 J 7E 78:N%
J( 9E E 7) L# 1 " L6 . 1 (1+5) :#
6 ;6 JC% ?# 6 , 1( &( < 7
L# # 1 "BF(%" 4 % "% C6 J<) 1%
-% #6 9:) *(J1(# 9: J1( 1$ 7S 9:)
- % BK 7 J(2006) %% 10 91 ( 1 J(- 6 J1%)
.7E 9: %$: P . 7 ? BK 6
9:) *( J(- 6 : 1 "< <" 9: 1(
% J3" L
( 1 ( 6 1 7! @< .86 J1%) -% #6
J;% ;$ P: ( 1 !$( P"% . .= 7 KE JCA %
7: .
J() ,- < *%! 1(< .# .86 7 7E %!
.P" 9: $ . 1 J( ,E % 1 . 1(E
" *% ,% 7) L# 1 ! 7E J@
( , 1
% ?#
K # J( (E 9E ( J3( 6
(176H J133" J2006 J J1#().(2006)L!A 23 3 K( "-
() 3 +Q84 %) . :# $: 2012.%E 7( /14 1
?" .%(! 1 C:# (7 ? - (!% (
.% K &( 5(% . 7E G ,(
&# % 3$ 9: <" # 7 3+ Q84 %) . '
3 7 @#(% "%!% *" ?) *$ % BK %# % 7E G
%$ ,( .%$ #E % 9: *
- 7 7 3 ,. K % @%#
, #% K $4 F(% #: %% 3$ 7E 9: 7
.K ,! ? 3S "% 7) L#
?< (2012 .% /7( / 14) .%(! # U1( &( 5(%)
:1 !% ((- G, %) #6 7=
http://www.diplomatie.gouv.fr/ar/article4825
89
- 0 " 7
% K( %" . T# 1 J1!$ . + # F# $
.# 7 7E % * % J2010
%" ## - 4 BK 4> 7: Q C% .< - , 7 3A
: P
! BK 7E .$ 7 @(N J$!( 1 1#- 7< 1
3 1 %-
.1, 7E 2 9: (%
J? (E 7: " Q 7 - # J ! BK G 7! ." %
J J1,).7 ) P"% 1 ,( % ?" (E
(48HJ148J2011
1 "&4 1( # " ) : F<E (! 7E % $
1'(% ! 1 #( G C6 J(2011)( K( !) * $!(
F
7 7" 7K J% 1( & 1: 7% 7%" 7< 1( L
- K% 1 # . 9: C= 3$ !$ 7 1(" J$!( 1 +
9: <: P
J!) * 1 , ;$ 7 " : J) ?
&K ""( % 9 ( 9: J, ( ! 2% 7E
18 # L 1 1((% ] < 7 8 3 J7E B$
1#6 7" L# . 3 7 &K .:- G @# 1 J7(!

.;6) %" . P"% 7) (# 9E
4 3, 7 _ P"% 7: 7E 1 Q % $ JK 7: 8

C
< 7: C"% 1 G# 3 @# : J%" . 7 " 1
L .4 J?6) ?
1 &( 5(% # 1 #( J1( &(
? 7: &< ! ?<# 7 ., A : 6E 1 2#( &K " ("
T#( - 7 Q J3( 6 : 1 3$ 7 , % *$ J?!
?< 1 U( 74 ." ?K .86 U(2011)% K( 7E
3600 7 3# 5000)$% %3.5 %(% 6 3( 7 (<6
.((2)3# 410 9E (1) 3#
90
5( 9: P:- % ' &K 36< ) H$ :(4
& L < 7:
J(2009)3: 1 # 1 %6(-
"3'( .6 7 "" % @ 7 .4 1J(4 ?
% #(
J& .86 7 JP:- 9: *(6 * ( !
2(
.?# ' 3'( 1 -$: 7%
# . "% C6 J!
( " 1 ' ?< 7 ?
- :44
1 ;6 !
( . 9E . % ", <% J% 9E 1!$ +
.$!(
* ?- 7: Q 9E 7E "( J) %# : BK F 9:
' BK 1 : J !$ 1 '() P$( 9: J$!( 1 # !
! 1 : # 1 @(% &K "18E ! *" , :
* " .4 .(2003) 3: *" .8 $: J) ? -
(56H :1#().# !) * " J"% !)
#% JG# B$% C 2% `(- <<- @% , 1( 7E

KE J%" 4 B# 7E , < 7: 8
C @# 1 J6
1 ?4 B# ,
, (% J7 % L( 4 ?=
,
(53HJ184J2011J J1,).$!( 1
) 3'( ?: J
-= :$2=$
%: J A .! "% !) * -" 9E ?$% : $
" ( <# 7 "% J Q ) ?=% 1 8% " B: (< ,E
. $!( 1 " , "#
, G 6 2% KE J ?" BK 3 , *! 7
. *" 7 ` 5< 1 <-
J A #6 < 36% A J , 7
1+# # 9E " J6 *" * !6
1 (4 ?# , + . + 7 $: "% &
+ % ( @# E (4 H6) 9: J !
7K) 1 $
91
. (# * ( @# * ( # !% 7: -<( ! &K

9E ?( J 1#( 1(8$: .% " (4 ? " #6 "
1", L 9E K . ( ( J . " - T! 1(4 1 .6
@: . 7 7 9, < > J$!( . %% $: : L"
( 96 H 2010 J %) .$ , (< .' 1
!) * $!( 1 1 % 3- < ?6) (
1 1 ! 9E ( " < . "% - J B,
:(
6 = 3(% > 9: ?# , H J(2000)%(
. !) * ? 1 6% J
6 1 #6 ,8:
?
BK .86 %#E ! 7 ?$ (: @ 3- K 7 <<:
, 7% 9) % .8 1 #( Q J ,- "% 1 -
. 1# 1 5( 3# Q 7 (1" ; 9: ?: ) $!(
1 $ 7 " 1 @!( 1 ?< K
@% 1 1%" J ," $% *" F J $!(
T8 , 1 K( T! J 1( &( 5(% < J ?"
J J P" ) . $ 7 A J
6 B"%>% $!( 1 !$
( 60 H 185 J 2011
: 6 1991 / 1990 -=$ H, # - A$= '1 1
: 1 ( 9: <) B# 1 , H6 7

J*" ) ? - ?$% 1 .
J *" 9: 7" K *8!( 1 C ?C < C CF<# ( Q
" *" ?, 1 ) G $ $
%" $!( ?: C %(% (: 1,E 36 3#
< 7 ?
- 6I 9("% J 7 C$ C, C( C
H J 2 J 3 1991 J
6 ) . ? - G !% $ 1 "%
. ( 239
7 .) 3 K( K6 1 $ 3 7 ( 7 .
! *8!(- J 1) 1 ) " :$ 2
%
1) `# *" G % 2 *" ( )
92
K6% C , (# 9E J " @, J*" #
*8AE , ( *" 9: 3 N% $" ;6) $ 7 :
F( 1 &K 1) %: &K 1," !
( %( !6
( 92 H J 160 J 3 1992 J P" ) J ! % 9: 1 7#
3 E J *" 9E 7 G% .$( 3 # % *8AE
. @:
*$ 1 J <) &K 1%" 3$(- 7 ?

.
7 K J56 $!( 1 C %" $!( 1 ,

, ?> <) "% F(4 #6 !
( : 9: . .86
9E % J 1 - ( 100)7 4 , +% (
1 :) ?: .: $: 9: P"% .
#( 3 . * 2 ;6) 56 . P"% "
( 130 H J 1990 J 1(8 ).
: $ - - $= 2
1, 3'( B# 8:

$ 4
, J56 1 " " F( K( *" B# C6 J 1%"
" J(: 1) 9 1
, 4 9: :
#E *$ 1 J*" <) 1 1%" 3$(-
1 4 (: .:>% 3$ *! 7: K ?# %" !) 9:
: 1
1 ?C J?C *" . 1 ," 1) T#% 1 `# 3, .
3 *" . 1 7," S (I $!( ,N% %+ .
.:) ( 24 HJ P" ) .:< 9: ," `!% 7
*" 7 . ? ## - 3A (" $: .! (" <<
-
3 1J ( 70 68 H J 31998 31997 J %" ? < ) J%" "#
. 9E ?C # " .% J K 3 "
`# ( ?# %" !) ? 9: (<
93
K( T# : % 1 (1997) 3: % 1 *" . T#- 1
*" . S (I $!( ,E (1997)K- "% 1 J(1991)3:
$ " @ 1 F# ? *$ 7 CF<# K R :
7) .: *" . 1 1 `# @% 3$ 7>% "
*!( P"% ?" ) ! 7E J( 9 K 1 J 1$
*$ 3 ," ? 7 :!, J .
&K 1 `# ?, 7 4 @% 7= @# J"*" . 1 6
( 16 H J 76 J 3 1998 J 7 ) . (" )
G @"% &K 1(" ) L

( "% KE J % 3$ .
) 7= % 7 9: ? 1 .4 &K *"
1 F< L .4 .% 9: ( %( 7 4 1
+ 1 ((S @< F(4 (1996) 3: ( 20 1 < "
E 1( ." < : !6 7 K
3) < ) J 56 < "% ? K( @, @$
.( 203 H J (1998): #-
(: (1998)3: # 9, +% 9 1 :

3, J T#% 9: 1 `# % ,
1$ FN% , # % & %," , K6% 1 1$ 7) L#
1 78# ] %: & 1 @:< &K ' 1( ." <
3$% @ T P" < K (" " ,E
<) . 1) 7 C ,8!( 1) .6 : : 7%
#
7 <) ( 204 H J 3 1998 J #- 3)
(% ! , !) P"% .6 - 7% 7% ug: C:
1) 7 & 3:< 6E 1 .4 <S 1 . 9E .
. 7(% 7 . 1 ?# < K "% " *8AE
94
: @C '$ 3
,8: *4 1%" 1, 3'( B# @ &K 3 7
9E " -# 1 C6 J@" , !% ,E 1( 7 G
1 " J(1996)3: 6 9: @" 1# $:
7 1%" 3'( G ,8"% 9E K 9: '
.%
, .86 7 ) 7= % .86 7 2 J F(4
1 1 K R " . ?# %" . B#
C6 ) 7" ?$ P"% ; &$: 1#E 1$4 @# 7 CF<#
" 7% L 9: 3$ @# J (" #
G (- - %: @(: C"% K 18 1$4 ! 7: .<"(-
7 ( C$: . ( 1( 7 ) ! K 9: 1 6 7% J%
8 %" $!( 1 ) #- K
( % L .4 K
7 K & @( " ) :<( <% 1 - ( "%
, 3: J) #- !E 1 &, 1
v ,E v 7
#( 9: 9E % 1%) - 9E 3(-
1 1
( 5 4 H J 104 J2001 7 ( ) . ) :( 1 ?!
.4 #% @# K 7 %" . %: ( 7
<<: 7 "% C6 J %" S C" C C 1$ () C C
7 J %" 6 1 7 "% 1(" @# K
: 1
< 6 J1( 7 7% ; " < .% .
1 1( 7 & ?, 1$ .:E 1 7) L ?< "
1 1( 7 7 7 1 < ?<J(1997)% 6
1 7) L ( ?< K J@
( 3" 7 . .% 6
* L
( 1 . ( 1997) ( 1 ?% K "% 1( 7
3( ?< 1 ( 7= 7 : ?
.86 %$
7" 7= 7 : ?< K 7( #6 &<
95
K ,
- 7 : G, 7: 6 9E .: < 1 (
" -# 7 A V 7! .# 1 &" G%!
`# " Q C ,
- . ( 20 H J P" ) . ;6)
3, .%$ ( F%6 9: ( " G( 1 1
T . 1) 1 1( 7 ( : 8 3$%
%% 3$ 1 &# .# 36% ( % !
1( 7 C# C$: 2% 7 1(" F#) 1
. .# 1 7" G
CF<# R " &K *" 1$ 7S C!6 C R " "# .:) BK .
( 22 H J P" ) . 1%" 1$ 7) 7 C
1 7
v 4 *
v
% (1996)3: % 1 7% 7% 3% 1#- *
- 3: .
1 ! !% 1( 7 3$% 1$ (1996)3: L!A
J 109 J 7 ( ).( F4 ) <! 7 G( ) 1 `#
(21H
. %, 1( 7 G : (% 3$ .
1 3$(- $4 3: - *" ( 1 7) #
( 20 H J 7 ) . %"
7 : ,N% 1( 7 G # ,- ,8: *4 .B
(22H JP") . # "

. (% 7>% ) ( 7 .%, 7 ? .
(4HJ 7 () . $!( 1 %$ () , % ?(
: $ @$ 8 4
1% .% ?4= , *" 7 . 7%
3, 3'( ?" 9: G, P C'( 484 7% 7% %! ,8: F(% 1
7K
# &( G%( 1 7 # % J *" 7 . G B
+ 7 B (" $: % K( . Q84 . 1 1 7
96
% J?# %" 7% 9:
# J ,E
: 1 = 3 7 7 J *" 2 (:
&(
9: 6 G F(% 1 G 1 - .
!E 1 % ! (19) C(21) +% 1
#
K @%% 3A J.() * (# 1 1 ( GAP ) #
P
6( 1 4 *" 2 9: 7
(10) 7 ., 9E B 7 " (17) 7 7 9E $ B
. ( . 1 ,! & G 9: C% 4= &K ) J "
( 94 H J P")
1 :< ", 9: 4> ' .% 7( 8 1 B ( P
6( .
P 1 7(% 40)"%E 9E *" 1 . , 1 *"
( 115 113 H J 3 1999 J 1 ) . 1:< .8+- *!( 7

F. @ 9: < ? 3 1990 3: % 1
( ;# *8AE .
9 ## ( %# 7%" 7 !6E 7
( 114 H J 1 ) . %" "# ?(
%: *" 7 . G B 3$ ,
3% P .
1 !$( 6I 9 : ? 7 J 7 7( #
&(
7 1 L 2 F

(115HJ 1 ) . @
( .
,E % 1 L 9: 3$ 1,E 1 %A .B
&K 38 B % :
[ *! 7: Fb JB !% ( ,
.86 7 !
( 9: . .%$ B% #6 %" . P"%
H J 204 J 3 1996 : 7% ) J B% !
( % ) 7 P"% B
P"% ) ? - .%, 7 $ , % !E 1 ( 79
7 " 7% "% C !% ;6) , ;$
.1(
" %6(- 1 B< $: 1 ! ( " < 1 K(
3: ? "% J? .)
( .% @ ( 2002)%( 1
97
K
( ?< $ 8 + F# 1 1 $-
1 .< , *% 1 F< L !$ K( `# -(#
?%% < K K6 7 K K( ( 25 H J ] %: ) J (1995)3: (
%" . G $4 # F(% L 9: 3$ J1%" 3'( B# ?# #6
-(# (>! 1( 7 7% @(% 9: @
( , 1 '
q% ( 1 9: (" #- &K 1 `# 1 7
7 J) !+ 7: #6 8$ 6 1 ("
U: , .86 7 K . ' 8

) ? - % 3$ : % ) " U1
( .% E 9E 1" 7) L# *!( 6 *" (!%
: 1_ .86 7
(" . 7 %: . G% %: #% 1 L 3, U
1) , ."
, *( P+% J #% ," <)%
. <S . 7: Q % *"
! ,( $ ; 9: .%(! 1 #8 *"% ! . ?: U
(# <S 1 6 7: Q % 7" Q .%, ," ) <)
. ,
1
4 !+ 3A *" 9: 1) 7" 1 P U
7 (" # &K ) 7" ?$ P"% .%, 7 #
9: ?# ) :$ 2 C J ) ? -
: "% ) ? - 3, : ) $
. ?# : , & .%$ :$ 7 *"
'
L 9: 3$ *" 9: 1) 7" $: 2 1 , ?% U2
1) .8 - F(E 9E ?: J@<# G( *" 1 8 ? 9:
7% *" 1 ;$ ! G# %6( F#E J*"
. 7 3
. K( 7 ( ,8" K6 J %(% U3
7% < .% 7 7 K = 3 J ! 9E " <
98
1 9E ) % & L % 3, 1 ?< 7%
9E % J 3" L
( 7 1 @< L ?< KJ(2004)(
P+ K ?$"( , = .86 7 *" B# 7% , *(
. (2003)% 1 * =
1 1 , % $ ?
.86 1( 1%" %(% U4
J1(!
" B# ( " J(!
$ 3: B#
"$ @ 1( 7 (" $(- 1 4
$ 7 K % 3$ 1
-A- (E 1(!
"
.A ?% 7A ! # 1 F< L 7 KE J (!
$
6 1 1( .A K ( 2003)3: L 1 7 V
7 @ &K E 7 CF<# .:) R : J@
( 3" 7 .%E
: , K6% 3,J( 166 H 3 2004 : ) J 1(!
" 1(
L ( %$ P ( (" ( P L"
C @J(2004)3: ( 1 B$() @< F(4 1( F<
#% C 3, .
( ?
.86 ( .:) .# 7 %$
K 3< 9 1( 7 9E @ ?$ ( 1 ?< <8 "-
-A- `!% .$ .: 7 : B# @"% 7
1
F:% 7A . 1(!
" F(% 1
1(!
" B# ( 9: 1 # - 7 ( % . 7
#6 1 1%# + ( @R = %# , BK " .
4 @ F:) %" . ( KE 1%" 1, 3'( B#
(167H JBK *% G#) .
1 ! 5
1(" @# 7 *% 1
J( " < 8 K# -
,8" 9: % L"( .6 1 8 9E # !+
1 @$%! K( $ 7 " K( (" 3
7 L# 18 3"%
.
99
J (% %" F :<( ! . 7 & 1! 1 , -
. %+ 8 J %"
G $4 . !6 V( 1 "% 9E 2#( H J( " <
1 - !) * 1 - 7 L @(E .$ 7 9 JF(4 7 !) .
1!$ < J7:) . .4 G# G ?# ,8" BK .4% 3"
(56H J2010J1%"
K .:
, %" 1 < -%, 1 9,- -
*" <A " 7 ,8!( %" !) ' "% .%$
. *(6 1 3
( ) " # J@$
1 - $!( 1 1( K
( 3'" G 1 % (< -
" " J L G 7! ,8: %: 7! 7(% 1 *"
# '() (# 7 1 .%, 7 < 1 B<#: 1%"
. 1" 1( K
( 7
"# 1 1: @% 3$ &K ! 7 ' 8 7
K 9: A = J $!( $ 1 (E 7
1%) -
3 7 !) * 1 ) 9: 1%# 4> 1 ?$( , 7E " : 8,
.# 1 1%) 7% 7" 7: 5( , 1 <
. #6
J .6 + , 1 %4% ."
% 2% 1%) - 7 K
$!( 1 76w 1%) - % 7 7 7
. "
,E J3A 7 " 9: ( " < T
( 7 7% K
- 9 3(- 1#- 6 G P" - 3" ,8" .
(57H J 7:) . 1%)
%
P 7 7 7 % - @(E
7E KE J ?% @# <#( BK . 7 3A 9: 1 JP"%
&) $ 7 " $ 1 !) * 1 ;6) !,)
?<A ." J ( 7: ?# . (E J !() BK 3
1 @# 1% J " 7 . , , (% , ?6)
100
.A% 3 &K 1 K

( K . BK 7 ?% $ ?

" (E 1 4 8: $4 % ) 36% .A (E
9 1%" #:E 9: < 1 ?6) ?
1 8 7
) J %" . F ( . 1 " ) 7((
F " % 1 #
7 ?# 7 3 1 1 K
( .A 7 ?# ? " &K
(114HJ2004 J&)..%,
1 F6 <#" #( @# 7 % % 1 7 K ' 8[
<<" " 6 . # 1 ( 7 J$!( 1 1%"
(# 9: G$ J 7E & $!( 1 ;6) ;% ?$ 7 6 3",
K 7 ?
- ! J$!( 9: ) ( 1 P"
J1() . 8% ( B%: @( L# - @" . .%
(100HJ182J2010 J
1 2#( 1 $!( , 1 .:
!6(-% , K6 7 1
-
7 F<# 7 7 1 ." 7 " J 1 . K
!) * 9: Q , KE . : 1, ! !) * ?
: .: 1 .%$ ?: ." 7 :# ( J!$
1(" @# 7 *% 1
. ( " < 8 K# U
3"% ,8: 9: % L"( .6 1 8 9E # !+
. 1 @$%! K( C$ 7 " K( (" 3
7 L# 18
. (% 7 $4 3 ( J ( " < G
7 L# ( 1 7E 9: & K 1%" 7! 9: &
1 1(" 3'( 3 3 ( " < 7 2 . (: ( J ! (
(" .: 7 A J '( ; 1 G! - , J K - 8 J
J J%) . B: 1 #6 $!( 7 3
(97HJ182J2010
J (% %" F J :<( ! . 7 & 1! 1 , U
. %+ 8 J (% 8 J %"
101
G $4 . !6 5( 1 "% 9E 2#( H ( " <
- J !) * 1 - 7 L @(E .$ 7 9 J F(4 7 !) .
. .4 G# G ?# ,8" BK .4% 3" 1
?$ ?" 1(" - <( 1 ! ?, G ,8: & 7 BK *!(
G ,8" . #( BK %: . @
( <( 1 ! ;6)
G n 1%" " "( " " G 1%" " .:- " " G : F(4 7 G#
G n .E G G n.E G 7(!
G n L%: G L
7E G n G 7E G n 7(% 1(KI 14)G(KI 8)G n " G 7E
. 7$% <,$ 1 : ;$ G ) K ..E G
K .:
, . %" 1 < -%, 1 9,- -
B' 7< 1 (115HJ J&). %" !) ' "% .%$
J % 1%: % 1 < 7 B(: J *" .8 G
J .% 7 (# 7 !$ ( T! 7 J $ 7 @( 5(
- J %" !,) P"% 7 JK(I ) #6 <
*" <A " 7 . " . 6 G%!% K 4 .
J . *(6 1 3
( ) " # 7 3$ !6 7 ,8!(
;6 %: !, J *" . 1 F( G(% 7(" J
(98HJ %). !$ " 7 '( 9: 96
1 - J $!( 1 1( K
( 3'" G 1 % (< -
%" K . L G 7! ,8: %: J 7! 7(% 1 J *"
" :<( ?4E 9: ? - .E : 1 " ( (

.8 " .4 -$ ' J " .:- " . " 1 J 7 1% J "
7(!$ 1 7% 9E " " F( 3: J(] %: 1() ) " 1"
1(E # J ( % 1( *% & L) 6 9E .%
(103HJ 1() . ( ] %: &" ) ( L 7 )
$!( G
(# 7 1 .%, 7 < 1 B<#: 1%" " "
7 1( "% 7 F-= 7 7 . 1" 1( K
( 7 # '()
102
9E K# 1 B @ 7 , J ( " < % .4 J 1 38
(99HJ&). 1( K
( 7 < J 2% .,) 9: J "
7% 1%K F(- 7% J 7E 7% 16 L( 7: .<"% 7
" 1 J 1%K V
K 1 !$ 3 ( " < 7N J "#
?" %K 9(% K . . 9E (8 .%, * %K (
7 #
( 7% %K (% "# 7 ? 1 . @
( , 1
$ Q J " > F(k % -: 8 "% # 3 7 6 J 7:
K 7 : ((73). 7 .,) 9: ((15)% 7" :
# C$ J (! 2 + 1 ( " < : 1 J
J 1% J . $( ," %K 7
6E 8
"% "
7 J 7E 7 J .:- : 7 ? 9: J ?# ,8: 1
(59HJ 7:).
( 1 7 KE R:
r .= Q 9E 38 K .$(
X - 3 $!( 1 1(
7 ( 9E 1
7E 1 ?$ .: 9E = #
:( $ # J 1+# G, #: 7 7% 7% "%! ( "%!
1 2#( 7 "% " 7 3 J < 7 7 . " %
6_ "E 9E 9" 7 7E . 7E "E "
. @" 7" *" 9: ." -
C# C C$ .% J C: 7 C6 7 7 - (: $ 08E
.$( !!6 F% 1"%! <+ !
( -# 1 , ,
%> J C(
. ( " < .%, % , ( ,
1 . 4-
: J PA) &( 1 7E (# 9E
,
36 J: &, P 7E .<: ? - -
.7E 9: 1(: .: &)
!6 1 7E G . *( (! 1$ K
.8 "% - J & J 8% ? 1 1$ 7) @# 1
(115HJ &) .@$ *"
103
- 0 $ 6

< JF% J%" 4 G ." 1 C%(
6 % .6 (%
1 C 4 1 , 7 34 .L( 1 S ?K "% .6
34 J " ! %# J 8E .6E 9E 3$ 3'( ?: 1
7% 3 7A !6 1 J. % @%! (: 3'( $( 9E K "% .
.6 ( 1 C:( -
C s :
[ J(2011)% % 1 1
J 1(! 7)% % .% !% A J;6 . 6 7= 1 %
JP").
$!( 1 ;$ 7% ,8" 1 $%
(61HJ185J2011J
J% 1 #6 86 F<E 3: .% C'
4 F# 7
% J( 34 ( ?$% &" .6 !!6 %$" P : Q
G
(, 9: F$% G J(( 4A # 1 3 .6 1(% 9E ,
.! F) 1!
% # 3A .7 % 1 CK 4 1 , F#
?:% 9
1 , 7N J7E " 7 % $% --
3'( % $( 7 3: .% T8j ?: JL
( !% 9E !)
7 K G J@K 7_ 1 T8 % %#-% 7# %! J1( %
1 1 <% G# J.4% .$!( 1 1" U1( 3$(- !6
.86 7 7 .%$ 7 : (%
J% .6 %(# Q J(
<) #" ! .$(- #6 ?% : 7: %: J1!$ .
.(
G#J 1 ) ! G ." 1 C#< 8
C 6 (% JC6
3 1( > 4 G !" J# 7 @: * 3'( 7%
9: 3!( 1 1 1( G# !( G J;6 # 7 3%!
. 1)
( <% 9E $!( . 1 <) J() ( 7
1 !E 1 JH6 .% % 1 ' ( 9: :
.(( : .E 2 ' P
(
104
.6 ( *!( ,E .6 !!6 # 8 P"% 4 JK
* % 4> 7 J ) 1 J 1)
. 1) .6 7#8
6I .% .4 Q J- .' 4E - 7N JF%() BK ) 1
( 3A
.( " .%, 1 () S F: ?:E
1 %(#) " 86 7 9: ?, 7:

1 ' J6I .% % BK 1 !- J$!(
(62H J P").: . J 1 @
( P
, J%
C#K( 3$ 3 7 1 .4 !) * 1 ,E ?$ 1 "
9, *$ 1 J, ;$ G ,8: 1 *, 7<% '
- 1 :%
3" G *%!( 4 J.E G J7E G ,8: 9: K *%!( J 2
(29HJ2011 J3).1%"
7 7 3J( U," C%, C C
,
, ( 7
*: J1(6 7E "E 1 @
( ( @( "
3 J*" ? - <A (: JK G .."
% Q JC" 7 3
7:
(% >( J 1 ) ! C$!( 7 7
(6U5HJ181J2010J J ).*" % "

3 3'( 7 H6 7 7
$ 1 ( 1 8 C K G
" '
7 7
$ 1 ( C 7 K 7 3) 7 A 7
.3
( 7," @" '% 74% ," 9:
3' 1 F J7," ) G% . *"% 3
K6 ;6 ( 7 J 1 ) G $ 3,8: 1 38$
- 7E 7% 2( ! , K6 1 J7E F<E C(< CK C
,
,8" 9: @
( ) *%!( J&( #(%% *" J?
J (1949) 3: .N% : 8E . ( J
E ,8: ,E 1 4) %" 38 " 7 K
@% 9E 34J.E G *!( G &: 7" 9E Q J"%
105
%" !) 7% ! % ,8" BK 7 (# 9E J(% 1#
.3(% 3
9E . .% 1 .E
.E @% 3$ J # ( 7 ( % 3(% ,8" 7 -E
JB<A 9: 1 7" ( Q J1(!
" B# (:
.!) 7 C J7) L# $ C$ $!( 1 " *$ % %!
L" 7 Q J1%" 3" 1 B(E 7 - 1E B<A 9E @#
.1 7", B<A 1 7: ?(" G 1 3j C C%" C#
: # K C# 7 ,E ?$ J!) * 1 " 7E
7 *% &, F!A J$, (< *$ 1 $ :% A% 7 +
(76H J )." 38 (" !$ 8
% J, ( <<: , C%(# B#- J1%) - 7 . 7E
1 K6> J1 % C$ K J1! * ! % 3$ "#
*" @% 1 (A )#6 L( @(: s %:
r G * J7%
" = #- B8% ( 7>% 6 @:(, 7: @ %: &K J1#-
f%J + * 7% !% C# ( 7 4 J 1 : 4
(4"%) (
7%, "# 7J$!( 1 @ ! % )
(52HJ184J2011J J1,).(?#
-= @C :$2$
J1 $ G( !) * 1 , 3 ?:E , +
1 3 ( " < " J(2003) 3: *" 1) <+ K( %
J*" 1 1( K
( ?< 9E .) Q ; Q J(2002)3: %( 1
< 1 6 U ,8" G# 9E C# 1(4 ! ;
.# ,8: (>%
P"% 1 .E 1 ( 7 "% J
(:
: % @# ?% ? - (,E 7: .E <#: F# 34
9: ;% T! JC6 %" 4 -( 34 J1( &(
106
1 .E ( 7 1 4> ,

1 . !(>% *" .E
" A % . J + $ !) *
::)# ( 9: ( . ?!6 ; J. , , (
(73H J185"
!X!) * 1 4> G# 6 1 ? - *A U1
G J 56 1 4> *!( G J + G !%

1" U2
.!) * 7: 7E .<: ? $
" 7 % 1%" 1, 3'( %E 9E - , K
%" 1 3$(- ( $ !( 1 %
% K( 1%" 3'( # 1( 7 ;A J@ *%
J165" :1(#)( #- ) 7 : *$ L 9: 3$ (" $:
(26H
.1:# 1 1%" :- 9: . U1
. " G B : T! U2
.C, C< . ?# ,E % ,E ( 1" U3
.1%" 1$ 7S ?% A ?% ?< U4
U:1 .% ) BK

3 2 7 <
:=83 $$ !$5 ' ! 1
3'( 9: 1 3'( (% 1 - < 1 % : 3 7
@ ( 1( 7% :- 1%" 3'( 7 .%, J1%" 1,
.%" P) .8 1 :
@>( % K( $$ 9E 7 K 9" 1 ( ) K .4 ,
:# %" .86 7 % A :- 7 ( @ *$
%% .%$ J? ! 9: @" L# (1991)3: % 1 = 1
? @" ? 1 %4 7 4 7: 16 @" % P

.(240U199H J1998 J %).7, ( 7: <
107
.% % 1 :- 9: 8

C " . , 7 1( 7 7 A
.( 7) <% %: . G % 4"%
1 3$(- " 1( 7 4 J* L

( 1
?
( <# . L 9: $ @= @! P
%"
:.) :P
7 P .86 7 1( U1%" 1$ G%! <(
1:# :1(4 1( 7 .%, 7 P 1 %" !) 7% 1(4
(113HJ&: )J$!( 1 1, 7" , ,( ;6) %" !) 3
@= P 1 C 2#( . ? 1 %" "# & "%
1 ) "# %: 3: (338) (242)7) L# &$ H6 B

.C$ - 7% J%" !) 7% @(% #

:- -$ S D, - 0!$; , 2
.86 7 7 K ! J1%" :- 9: 1( 7 . "%
@", "% C6 J%" 8:
*6 1 5( *$ 7 :
G %: & ,
J(1993)L 1 (!
'( G ,

8:
*: 9E G .% K
( "% ! Q .(1994) 3: 1 ()
3'" G . (, 2 1 4 %" 8:
,6 *$ %"
"!$ G J%" 3" P"% 1 # 2 ( %" .
) ? - 1 !+ 9: K 1 C"[ %" ,-
.E (% .2 " G, 7- G . %" 7% 9:
G .K J?6) ( 1 "? " 9E % ,8: ,% !
G%! ( G, A .% 6 1 ( %+ L( !, 7[:
E .4 2
% @" ! % @% ,8: ,N% 1( 7 G ,8:
P"% .E C *6- . (4H J212"J2004 JL%:).7 #

' ,E = E %" !,) P"% 9E < 1
4) <% 7 . : 1 ( 6 C C8:E
7 : ?< 7: ( J + L( 9E P"% ?< 4 =
(38H J192" J1995 J) J7: ?$ 7 . @% .% (
1 G . :< -# 1 @" (" ,
- 7 : G,
108
() 1) 1 " Q %S < 3, &K 7) G " -#
.1( 7 G Q %) F#E 7() 74 %
: 1C 6$E= - -1" I$ S 3
" 4 9: J) ? - @

1( 7 .:
1 J1, ;$ 7< 1 .6 %" 1 3$(-
< "% C J (" $: % ((4 $: 6 1 - 4
9: F$ 1 J1%" 3'( 9: ? 4 (4 56
3'( 9: F$ 9E ?# ,E G T! %: 1%" 3'( $
7 . ?# ,E %% @% $ &K 1%" 1,
$ 4 %" ) 9: ?! 7 86 7 7 ?$ G, 1(
.,-
1( 7 F< L @ ! &K K 9: 4) <% 7
3$ L 9: 3$ &K U# !) * U@% 1 (1994) 3: L% 7"
J1994:%" ? < J.
%:)1, 7" 484 9E $!(
:1_ ( 9: (106H
7 1K 3 *!( 7) 3 1484 G# ,E :9) ;
.1(
*!( 7) 1( 7 7(% 3 : 1(4 ;
.1K 3
1#6 7" L# . .) ; . (# 9E 3 :Q4 ;
.7% 1 P
.) L= 7 ?
- P+%
!$ ?- 1
G &<+ >% $" .
1 P6 7
.4 $ "# BK
6 484 1 1( 7 # 9E
1( ,- 7 &,- G%! K 8 BK 1 8:

.!
109
C$ 4) JC: C($ ;,) ! ?$ @# 7 7 1% 7
1 Q %) 7 : .86 7 ;= BK .4 T! % , #(
&,- .( 1 %" . P"% 1( 7 .6 Q % < 7:
+( ?%6)_ " C$ 3$ 7 '" $
1( 7 1%$
.(1#6 . + " + B
K *$ .% 1 C% C! 1( 7 G!, $ J" ( 7
P"% G (4 ,8" ,E %: : *8!( "% (" $: .86
7" , ,( $:
[ 1 , = 1 J%" !,)
= (1994) 3: F% = 7 F% :#
!E 1 1,
(1997) 3: =% F( J(1996) 3: ?$ = J(1995) 3: 7:
(" #( *! 9E : 4" %% .
% &K
1( *$ ( !6 .# &K ) J( 1
1) .8 - "% 2 8 % $ - 9E 1%" 3'( 9: F$
&K % !) * # 9 7 7E J(2003)3: L 1 *"
. 5 @ 7 7 J(2004) L G! 1 ) ? - @% $
< 6) K . ? ,E '( 1 1( 7 % $!(
.C$ - 2 ?$
: U -=83 08 <$ 4
. G

1 1( 7 .6 7 3A 9:
@( -EJ(1991) 3: % 1 = K( C (" $: % K( %"
7S ?% ? G 1 : 4- 7 K ; @# #
( "
7 :#% 1%" 1, 3'( *! .86 7 1%" 1$
:1
.319963: 1( U1 -1

110
% 9E % . E G 7 ,8: *4 -2
<# 1 : o( ,E ) % 1 3, a! #E
3: JK ."
% 3 ,).1%" 1$ 7) %" . 7 %$
.(2011
! 1 9'" % $!( 1 $) . G $4 ,8: ,E -3
B 9: " 1 .% * E % .( G%( % # 1 $
G# 9E % J7 C :< 1 .(
(# 1 ,E 7
@, 7 (# 1
.1%" 1$ 7S !6 < 7
H6)% 1 - 7:

( 1 _ . 9: T
(- -4
9: : , *$ I ! 1 ( 8
.. 1 1%" 3'( 2
J((E ( I * .% 7 ,8: T8E 1 4 -5

J1( 7 G : 1 %" . (# 9E $ ( 1
: $% @<% 7 K G ,8" ?:E !%
. K
J7 K ?# %" . P"% 9: % &" 7" -6
9: &" 7" <% 7 7 1 7(% 9: ? F:-
* % "% ?<# 7 K @ &K J(1996)3: (, $!(
?% *" .:>% 3$ 7 7(% G( K J( 7((% 7(!
3: 1(% ( B .8+ 7 "( .4 9: (!
.@,E 1 7(% 7E G, % J(2002)
% 7"% 3$ .% J % 6_ 7 7% ? -7

J F#) *6% 1( 7! 3, 1 .4 &K :
"% "% 9: 7: $!( 1 & *" 1 G,
( % (2003) 3: % 7 L6 1 * " 7
.7% "
111
1$ 7) L .:>% 3$ %" !,) P"% 9E L# % .E -8
7) 1 L .4 ." 6 .A .4 1%"
.(249H1998J 1%" 1#- $ ).(1996)3:
- %, :6E 3: . ! 1 - -9

.&( (- ?" 9: G, P K ,!
8 9E 8 %" . P"% # P#E -10
.% ( H6 9: ." J"( #(E #
" ?$ 36 ?% . ( F ( .
7 K
( 36 *! 7: ?% A J*" G 1( 7 .:
!+ % 3$ ) ? - ; 1(
9: . 7: 96 1 (" %" . 9: ,-
J1(8).7 , 1 7E G 9 % G . )
(18H J83" J1995
) ( 6 F(,- 3 2 *% 1 %" $!( .6E-11
"( F *! 7: ?! 4 ) L .86 7
.%" . 7 : % : . 1 C
@C >= ' 5
1 3 Q J.E 9) ( 1 1 &( 5(% :E %

1 1" !$% $ 6 ? 1 J.# 9 F(E (1949) 3:
$( F 1 7: ; 9: 1## 2% , 1 J ?<
% 3( 9E = 3 2 7 7 3A% J3( %
J# ).

3#( 7 @#6 *! 7: @( 9: . 7 $
(154HJ175J2009J
J(1952) 3: 1 K ,! (# F(E G ;6 ?!6 5(% K6
%(, G( 9E 1"% (: &( 7 &K J7#% (E 3" 9
(154H J# )!X"( 2%K 9E ;6 ? *( 3: 7 .> (
112
.%, K K Q %S .:

% .E <% ( , (1956) 3: 1
H( C,
.E ( ", (1957) 3: 1 , G%>% 9: 1484 7"
.( + 24)@, .:
F(%% ( 3$ 7 9:
<<" J. .$4 F 7 C(! 7: G%% (!% , (1958) 3: 1
< %6 ! ( (1960) 3: 1 J(1961)3: % % K
( 1 &( 5(% 7 , % . 1 (CIA) J)
(155HJ# ) .", $$ 2% , JK
9E 3(- P 3( 3 1 J!) * 1 ? 1 .E %"
. K ) ( 7 ?"
JK ,! 3" J1:% 7 " 7

9E 3(- Q % ( .E (: ?< .86 J(2004) 3: . ?<% 3,
%#N% "(, KE J( ) 7 6 $!( F(E . 1 !$ (
<( . 9E . *! ,
7 (4 *!( 1 38 4 !
J@4 P% 9 @( $" ( @4 G, - J1 U1(!

(159H J# ).&" &( #(% F(E 9: .E * 7
K J,E ?, %:% 9: ' J.E .' . 9:

! % .' 1 J? - G # ,8"% !% J:
(52HJ184J2011: J1,). F"% 3 %
- 0 @" 6
1 : 6 .% 7 % L( 1 Q 9E .E '(
?% !6 Q ) . - 9) Q84 . J 1 C Q
9$% 8
C %$ !) * . 1 . BK 4> 7 J 2 9:
.C
( J.E 3 K# 7 1+%( 7 J 1 ) !
J$!( 1 . &" 1 7 CF<# ( J" ., %#
(72HJ185J2011 J J@:).L ] < 7E 7 7
113
% 1 J%" 4 ! G# K % G , .E 7E
J(: ?# . 96 1 J$!( 1 J() C %
1 J3 " ;, 1 7 6 J 2 G * - ( 9:
J1 U1(E U& . J1( U1" J $ Q ;% 3"
1 %" . J? - 7% $ Q . J P(
9: 38
.E 9: !+ JC!$ -
C
(53HJ184J2011J J1,).& 1(!
7%(#
114
I F
5 6$E= - $ - 0

-=
:- - V.$= :2
4 J7" 7$ % K( #K( J?4 - " 1%" 3" 1
1 6 : ?4 J 1 (1919) 3: ?4 J K(l J%" %+ 1 (
?4 ( J1%" 7! 7 * F<# 1 J + 1 1%!6 3 %: J%
.8 - J"- ( (>% 4 BK 3" G%! 7 Q J7: 1
1 J
6 ( -E 7% J 4 BK @% 7 3A%.(%
J ) ." 7 ( J" ) ." 7 ( J *$
: J&:).(1919) ?4 J + 1 1%!6 7: ?4
(38H J184J2011
7 C
6 C#K( %" $!( : 7" 7$ 7 1(4 ( 1
( 1 J '() J: %8$( 9E L)% ( 1 J 4
4 J + . ,- J " ! 1% - J %A
9E K( BK .$( Q J(1952) 3: ?4 4 BK 7 J%" 7
(&4) J?4 7#K( . KE J7 7 % J J*"
. (' )6_
7 Q C%( . G 1 %" '() % J(1973) "%

'
- G F$% . 2 J(1973) % 1 *$ &K ( 7
*$ J
% - J(" 7% * 3: .,) 9: P,(%
5( 1 J"
7% J1!$ J1 T8 J:#- "
7 3 JF$
F(A) 7% ?#
, A , 7: G J1() %-
. J % .# ; 1#( J1" 1: '()
&K % .# J78# %" "# 1 # J ((- *! 7: 1:#-
1: K G J1$$ . 7 : 7K <#" .# J: $4
4 "%! $ ( JC$4 3" % $ 1 4 J$4
115
9E % J J7 J% 34J 34 L( 1 #

( 1 J;% %"
(39H J184J2011 J J). , 7 4 1 .%, J;6 %: 8%
J! $: ! B 3 "%) ) 1 %" $!( ,
G "% 1!$ . + # 6 1%" 3" .' 7 "%
$4 7% P,( # 7: .# K 1 1%: F(4 # 7: Q 9E P"%
3'( (%
% ?6) 1%" 3" % U!$ 3, %"
J7 7 % J % 1 34 J L( 1 % %"
( ."
% !
J%,% % J?== J 7) ## - F (
+ *! 7: C 7 F J! '() !$ C .' (+
J@ ).,- 8 P"% .6E *! 7: C<# J3'( .
(19HJ184 J2011 J
3'( 3'( 7% H6 J%" 3'( 1 86- 7 3A%
1 *
( 3'( BK 7N J" ? . !
( #( . 7% J#
, J"% 9E % ?4 ;$ ! ( K JH6 7 4
" !$ *$ J *8!E 9: ! BK <
(11HJ@ ).% .% 4 BK %" 3'( %# C % .:#-
% . (" 36 3 J" (6% 4 @ KE
T 4 J6 %: . 7 1 " 7=
" <# JL( <# "7>% J(1 ) J<# #6 <
& #6 <J"L( % 7" &K (1K$ 38 )
7N JG, P 9: 7 ."L( 7E ., &K (!+ % ) *%
( % . , J7 % 1 J 1 % 9E L( 1 Q
.:#- " 1!$ .
C" C:#g J7 % .4 1%" 56 . P"% %
1 . ( (10HJ184 J2011J J ). 3'( !$N% %!
:%"
(- 4 BK 3, % % 9: F F$ $ !
116
.< -; , -!$ 5 -$ - I 6/ :2
7 %:- 1 K6) G J ## - 1 1 ;$ 3 :C (4

. " ! 7 J%" 4 ( 4
: 6$ L 0$ 1
9: J1%" 3" 1 %" 4

(- ' 1 .: ?:
1%" 3" 7 Q4 7 4 .% (( 29 15 7% "
) % 7
"# < F, 7 ?" -
C
1(" J%% ?
!% " %
% G 1 "%! % 4 7 3A% .( ) 9: !6
KE .?4 G< '( 1 C% 8
C 6 ?6) $" 1 (N J%" $!(
:!, (% .?4 $% !% *4 !% K $ 6( 4>
' .% ?6) ( 1 ?' < ,.%" "# 7 "
. 1:#- &,- G# J? ?# * I 1(% @# G
( J *$ A J%- JG$ %" $!( 1("
?) < % % $ 6( 1 ! < G J7( *$ "
.
7 % : ' 9E %" $!( B &K 1 *(6- ,
( +% K "% J:# +d%
y K "% J## -
.,:
7% 1(! (- *$ 1 %" . 3'" J ;6 ( 7

( %A) ) , 3'" " J
6 (4 ," ( :#
( 1 J1:#- 1$4 1( < F, ' 1%" 3" 1
: .%" . 7 " 1 1:#- 1 $ ' < ?6)
$4 ,$ % %! :# BK % Q .#6 ,E ;,
.6 3 JC6 .3) 7: . 1<# .% .
(-% %! J
*" 1 %" $!( 6 7= 1 #6 ,E ;$ : 1#6
.$!( . 1 3$(- "
117
:-$ <; 2
" 1 % .4 Q %% ?

!% " %" $!(
F,E ' "
BK 1(" $!( 7 Q4 7 4 ( 29 15 7
" @ +% %!
$ 1 "# J1 1:# &,
!% G
Q J1%" 3" 1 % (" 1 . 3 7 !%
1 % .% !% ( <(%14.4)1" !% ($ % 7%(%25)9E
7(%95) ( 3" % .4 Q J.: 3" 9: . 3" % !
! 1 % .% !% ( G
J1%" 3" 1 ." 7: .!" %
E Q 7 3" *!( 7%g ( C", %" $!( .+ Q J " %
(10H J@ ).." * 1 ?
( ." Q J." ' FJ#) 1( C % 1("

:#- ' 1 C% JK . 4 , .1 A !$ 1 % 7(%72)
J% .% < 7 6> J(" ?'
Q J1%" 7! 1 %
29 9E 25)7 " 1 JK 7(%50) 7 4 7N J $ C$
1(" J;6 ( 7 .( . 7% 9:) %( 1 J< 3 *% 3 ((
A ; Q JC C F,E J1%" 3" 1 %
J7( *$ " (- J1( G# '( J < ) " J(
.: ($ .86 7 J 7: % ( 9E
.- J% 38: . ( G J?6) ( 1 7
%J ((- J%" ?<# ?(, .4 J
($ J4
7 " <# 7 3( J?# J!() 7= J1%" 3" 1 %
% 9E % ># J3'( %" 9: " 3'( 1 $
3 3: 7: %" J"% 3"% G . ( 9E 1:#- .
&K 6 <# 1 #( ## '( 3'( K J$ ) 7:
(21H J? ). ! $" %" 9: 3'( @
:!$ 5 >$3 1 W8 3
3'( 7 -EJ$!( . % G 1 % 4 7 3A%
7 " :!, .< - J:#- " ( *$ 1 $
6 %"
118
J* 6 AJ.6 1( J!% ) 1(" %" "
3,
; , . 1 ? 1 *!( $%! 7% ?#
7
!% $ 6( 4 JG .%
1
J:#- ,- .
' J1:#- 1 !6 < 9E J( "% !%
%" . 7 : B# G .%" . 7 " 1 G *!( 9: ##
G# J?6) ( 1 * , &,- 1(% 9E
( " :!, 1 C% 4 J' .% %" . 1:#- &,-
. 3: 9: % .% "
1 = 1 7 Q (% L()1 : 7 .8# .$ J K 1
1 Q (% J.
T#( % L$ J (1 $() *( : *"
F(4 %: G< 1 C " - J(: 38 *( (# 1 =
.< %(#) 4- J.6 ! @" JG
1$ 5( ( ." :$(
.( ( K( 1 Q % J ( 7" 1 L( 1 K Q )
= *( - 484 1 Q 7
?<JF$
F(A) 7% ?#
J!% ?< 1 ?! -E (: Q
7 6 1 Q % B4> ?< 34 7 J" + 3 ,- (
< J*( *%! 7 C: 7: 7 4 "% JL( 7 #( ( . %$
7 J( 1 Q L6 (% 4 &) C((%5)*
."% 1$ 5(
&(%50) (% 1 !% ." 7 % 2%> J?% !% ." C <
1 F j C$%!J 1 (%9)% ($% " ?$ 1#E 7 (%14)
F(A) 7% ?#
?% " JK .(7 1 $$ 7 4% ., ( 2#
7 1 7 7(%10)9(A 1 ( 4% 4 %> JF$

1 C
" 13)% ($%J7 7 (%10) $ @: . " 8 9:
$$ 7 @: 2#)(2008/2007)( 7: ? 3) F C$%!J(L(
(22H J@ ). - ; - F(A) @: . C4 7E KEJ4% C (
-$ 0$ #$M 4
1) .8 - K( 6 J?% ( K( %" . P"

&= $$ !$ 8E 1(% ?< #6 6 !+ J*"
119
9E J - "# < ) . J( *8!E 9E
3 %" . 7 -E J38: %6(- <( 7 ( G
7 + 3 1 8 P"% .6N%
J !+ BK #
.4 J " 7 % $% 1 . 9 J! '( 7
() (($ ) 7 " ( 9: : $ J +
. ( ; ,.1( G# '( 38: < ) $
" 1 7: 7(! ( 9E $$ 8E 1(% 7: %"
.1( G# '( < ) . " 9E
$%! F(% 7 6J3" 7>% 7 B# 1 .# *8+( 7: 5(
( $ 1 J% (, .86 7 9E J" 9!
3'" 1 ?% 3'( # 1 1 .: 3 9E 1 $!( ,"
K ## - 7 " C ' ?6) ( 1 J%" .
.(($ : 6 = !) 6 >( %!
9: 1 '( 1 7
7 . +% %!J1# T8 ! <# C%!6 (% J"
9E ?6) ( 1 % ># . 6( # 1 %" .86
% %% ## L> :#- G, 1( F
36
7 7!( ?6) (_ 1 ' .%" . 7 " 1 + C[ C
1( 1
! 1,: G%! K T#( 9: 3$ .) !( :$!( 1 +
1 Q J. .% (: .
(- 1 J< ! & 1
1 Q J< ? G6 - 1K 3 *!( L> 1 J7
T#( 9: 3$ J1(4 !( 7! 7 J*" 7(% .
!$E 1
6 "# 7% G# < - $ "%! K ##
1 ( K , J*!( " %" %" .86 7 6(
+ ( J%" . 7 : 1 7) 2 J 7 L(
( 3'( 1# .$(- ( 7 % J56 . P"% %J<#
7 T! A 2% J$% ( 1 7 7 " @ ! &K J!$
120
J7).7_ ! 1 .

(- ?4 .86 7 + (
(46HJ184J2011J
= V$= ! I5 5
9: :

: ?6) ( 1 %" .
, J1(4 1( 1," ( 7 .
v : $% G 1 . 1 6 J(!
! $" ! 3'( 3, $ 1
6 .: ?: 7 ?' BK #(
7: % %" * 7
6 :# 7 %.( $4 # %
.*" 1 " ) 1 Q J$: 7: $4 7:
%" $4 P

7 J1%" 3" 1 6(
C4 J( 8: " '( .86 7 ;6) :# 9:
L 4 < 9E 1%" 3" 1 (4 ( ," ,) "
1 Q J&,- 1 " 1 C 7 1$4 " 1 !$
(, ( 7N J C6 J7(% 56 *" 1 "J7 (# 7
7: %" 7 :# BK "( ( $
"% &,- 1 1$4 < ' " , .1((, 1: .% %!
(! :# 7: p8(- 9E %" . 7 " 1 :
:# 7
7 < 7: .
(- 9E # J:
.
-
.*" ( 1K 3 *!( J7 1 Q J?#
( 1 G .% %" $!( 1 ?' BK ( 7 2# 7
"k! 7: %" ?# 8 3, J$ . 7 :
$!( , J$
(47HJ7).! $" F, ` (: 1 :#

:-1" -5$, 1 !$3 6
1%" 3" 1 ! '( $ 1 % .% 4 &K 6) !
1 $!( . 6 1 7, 7 7:
:% !%
1 7 @(.%" $!( 9: % L 1#6 .6 J?6) (
( 1 "- ;$ @" &K 1, 3'( V% L)% C!% $%
. + ! 3'( 3:% J7" 7$ 7 .)
121
3'( $% .6 % ,E ;, : J?6) ( 1 7
- ( , (% 1 6 J$!( 1 ! 3'(% J1%"
1 1) .8 - J. 1 1) .6 * 1 K 9# , ?
J?<A !, 1 L .<: - J7 (# 1 .
(- % 3: *"
Q "% ?< #6 !+ " """ 3'( 9 7(% 1 ] <
8E .6 A 7% !% J%% 7 : &
(13HJ@ ).( *8!E
.4 ?: ,E ;, K

( 1 : ?6) ?
;6 ( 7
.1%" 3" 1 ' .% 4= % J 7E
J$!( 1 ) q( " ?< $ J7 %(%
J7(% 1 ] < J 1 ) 3'( .4 J 3'( 3:% ,
Q P"% G 7 % 1 " 7 1 14 J7! 1 L
J 7E ?% 1 " 7% $!( 1 ?# ?% F% 7:
, .) ? - 7 3: J" ?% ." "
7 A 7: K
( 7 1 " ' " 7% K <<:
& 9: 3, 7 7 1 14 7(% 1 ] < L .4
.8$- 7 .: $% G '( : :# L> 9: < !
(13HJ@ ). .6 L>% ;$ BK 3 9E P"% : J1K
:- 0$)$; = - :$2=$
1 %: . ?: 1 %"

(- 1 ;, G%
J" ;$ < ) J%% ## - :1 ?6)
(15HJ@ ).$!( %,
! K ;, C6 J ( : ;,
C J L( .4 J1( L(# 7 .: $% G 1 .
. (% J%$( %% ;, @ J$%! 9:
C" C J7 7 % J% .4 J$!( %, C
! C%!$ 1(" ;6
.
! $!( 9:
122
%"
(- BK , 1 ;$ "%! 1 86 # 3A
9: 7' 4 < ."% 9E % %! 7N J1 , 4

! +% K ! %A J:#- " !$ 7 7%!
J1
! !E 1 4 BK %, 3'( 7 3A% K J$!(
.% 1 Q 1$!( !E 1 7 % 7 1 Q
;$ $ 1 U4 .- ($ 36 3" 6 U % 7

?E 1 C C " KE J%-
# 1 %"
( 9E : 1
.,
(- BK
1 ( (&<<:% ) ."E ", 7 7 .%, 7 L
" ?> @, # KE J%" $!( L( 1 ?4 $! 1 1 @
(
.1%" 3" 1 ." 7: .!" 3" % 7
J%"
(- G (: $ J ;$ < )
6( % 3 .%% %" ;$ C"% C %" ( ' 8 7 7
> 7: 78: 1 6> 7 ) P"% 1 .% J%"
(- BK 9E ?:%
? : G 7 ( 1 Q J%% ;$
(: JK 7: < ) "# JE :# . 3( ## -
;$ < ) , 1 P"% ; ,.1%" % ,
.6 !6 J%" ## - #
%" 4 > 1 C C J( " %$( ;$ %" K
JL( 1 1" 3'( J.+ - 7 J( 1
.##>
1 %"
(8 @( 7: ?% 1 7: KE Q ?4 T#( 1 1
1 J;$ 7< + 1 % .% - 3( 3 ,.&
: .% "(
J7( *$ '( J( %$( < ) .4 ;6 %$( ;, G#
7%) L 7: *$(- 9E ( 1 1( `# G J?4 > 78:E 9:
.8% ?+ 9: B%#E (1:
( 1 8% @ &K &
1" 7 J 1
3 ( : ;, 3(- 7 J?4 7 ?6) L6
.! 7: .<( 9: @AE J% 9: *$(8 " = G 1 C
123
K ;$ 7 J1

! 1%$ 3$(- ' 7 1(" 1 . 1
7 J7 1
. 3'( 1%" 1 3 $!( %,
!
2 J: 3# "E 1 % 14 1%(#
;$ 3(8J < 1"# % .4 J;6 ;, 3 .#
( J% 1 K.7%$ @:% L !$E !$ 3 3 3'( !$% %!
@!$ 1K$ 3'( 7 . "%- ` 1(" 1 , *!(
1)"
! 4 Q J
! + 1%" K6 7 % 1 C6
%A) .4 ( 7 3A% K J1$4 < &,- 1 F, 1("
J ).! 3'( % %" 3':) 3$ ((
(15U14HJ184J2011J
: 6$ - -5$5 0$ D@$3, :$2$
7: 7!" " "# #6 % ## - ,U1
7 9E 9 " ( 1 2 .% F-= 3 ,J."
.;$
< ) .4): " = J%< !) 6 C

: % U2
.(." J( %$(J
.?
'() .< 9 J1%" L
( .! U3
# J J:#- ! 7 # !( 7: ## - %: U4
(135HJ378 J2011J1%" .%$ J( %:).1 T8 9E
@(% .: ?: 9:

6 %" - 1 F%6 7% 3: *
(
(- J1() G$
%" 3'( >J<% 7
(- F
3 " 1 $ ?$ . J +% 2 - !>% 1
L ! <) " L %: J % , 4 J?# %%
&K &,- T8
6 > J%" "# 1 !% $
( (.
J%, J"#
&( ` 9: J = , 7 3':
J1:).1 3'( 2 G %6( # 7: 8
C J(
.(75H J184J2011J
124
- $
-=

5 6$E=
A $!( C 7 J@( %" $!( C J3$ K( !) * 7E
%, # % J 3'( 28 " 7 ?% C%( $ 7 J?$
7 " % ", A .>% J #
( G$ J(>% 1 # $8
.#
3" J
( ?4 JC#6 C<A J,E C% Q ?C : #
(- 7 KE
3'( J
(" 4 7 ."
% #
(g $!( 7 -E J(1979)
F(% 1:#- &,- 1
. G# J%
J(1, 8
(-) 7 J1 , 1 %" $!( B 7E .%"
7 7 1 1,E !% # (E ( " 3 ! ? K(
%, A ( 1 . %# J@: J@
1 3, $E
7 J(2011).%, J %# G% 9: @# ? - J
A 9: J,E .% 6 #- 7 J (
1% J ( 1 7" 7 - J3$ " J J

% 1 9 J(F$%) ? 9E C( J
% 7_ .
%"% !% 1 J("%! ) ,8" . 1 1", B#8
%!-% 3 7: %" &K (Leviathan)` J(<% L)
,86 7 7 - JF$% .# 7 G# G# 6
.(6H J185J2011J J J38 %:).4
*" .8 "% J? , ?$ 7 "# J%" 4 7E
q% ? "# , 1( Q C C"# (2011) .%, J(2003)
#< 7: 8
C J$!( 1 ( " Q J2 ? 2
.%" 4 B# 7E
7 <-%

, KE J%-% 6) 1 K
J?# 1 . ", .86 7 @: '
. %" 4
& " (% .$!( 1 9: 6 K % $ .E
125
F(% 8 %" 2 B: 4 2% *% @'( , 7 7 "%
7 K .4 J1#6 7" L# .86 7 J1#6 " K C J@%"
<) ?E 1 @:% K J7E B# ?# ,E '( @" 1 1%( @ #(
?<# , .E J, ( ?$% 1 @, J7 7 % 1
J1#6 7" L# !E 1 %+ () 7 3 , J(()
.( Q ) .' 1 %" "#
6 7 "% J 1%" ." @,
' L : 1 J!) * $!( 1 & " 1( 7E
1 2#( J?% 7%E , ,( 4 # &K J)
, ;$ " 1 " 3, %4% ."# % J& 1,E V
( Q J3, #
(- C% % L ."# &K ( 9: J!) * 1
Q % % J& 3'( ( . JG# @( &K )
J1,).(DOOMSDAE).$ 3 (% %+
J
(: #
.(52H J184 J2011 J
*% @'( 7 H6 7 "% J"% K K6 $ &
") J@4 F(% 2 J8 %" 2 B: 4 2%
4 ( J3, 1 &# 3
J) 6 T
9$%J(&
1 .:)!%E 2% 7 E 1 C % J$" ? E
!) (# 7 4> &) ?" J(1,E * 7 4=
9E 1 4> ?, 1 ? (N 7_ 9 J(,
9: C 3, , 9E ; + C#K( @4 4 !$ J$!( ( .
J") J, 8:
G%!% . ;6 ! # G J $:
.(9H J185 J2011 J J38 %:).((
:-$ & Q N- 0 #! N -= "
.(%" %% %" 4) . 7 ;, % "# 7 .1
' 9E 8 KE J, ,8" 7 CF<# 2% ( .2
J1( 3" 9E ( ( = J7% *" L 9: J,E

!X1$ 9: 18E 1,E ' 7
126
& 7N KJ3, 9: ?% 4= J&$ A 7) 8 7E .3
?# 6 ) 1 % ( Q 74 . 7 $!( 1
8 ' 7E . * ? (% ,8" 7 3 9 J%,
( G J'( : 7 K J. 7 "%( $ A 7
7 A J% "%! Q% @4 J ?%:
. <) J3'( 3# J
JL( 1 % ; 1 7 7:

,8: 3 1 .4
., ?% % Q
1
( J*8! 9: < 7 7 $ , ,8" % .5
< ( 7 1% J76_ 1 4> @ 2 1 J! . ?,
" ?$ $% !%% *" 1J( . ; J,E ;,
7 4 $!( 1 # - J1 4> $ %6
'( ; 1 ,E ?, ( 7 7 1%J(" 7 C " 7(:
J38 %:).C
(- . 1 "$- 3:" "7$ 3: " # %%
( 8H
127
- $,
1) .8 - "% !) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< J @ (
.( Q J . 6 9E 3$ .86 7 J(2011U2003)3: *"
34 7 34 7JQ % " $ .) .

7 ! 3) " -= 34 7 J
. #( J$% &'( ! 7: Q 34
* $!( 1 ;$ 7< 3'( 16 ! .( $ J1(4 .

,- #- ) .( J.) Q %J Q % .86 7 J!)
$!( 1 !) 2 .( $ J1(4 Q % J!) * $!(
. !) *
$!( 1 ;$ 7< 9: 4 56 .( $ JQ4 .

$!( 1 ;$ 7< 3'( 9: 4 44 56 J!) *
.!) *
* $!( 1 ;$ 7< 3'( 9: ?4= ." .( !$ ,G% .

* $!(% 1, 3'( 9: B4 1%" 3'( @( .86 7 K J!)
.!)
3 1 , + J 7 6) L6 .

.(
: "%) Q % .86 7 J!) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< .86 *" 1
J%!$ ) 9E %!$ (4 7 1 3'( - U.( .) Q %
J.( Q4 Q % F# J*" 1) .8 - .( 1(4 Q % 34 7
7 J!) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< .86 ?# %: A ,E ?, "
7< 1 # 1%" 3'( %$ *I %" 4 .( $ JG% Q % 34
.!) * $!( 1 ;$
1 ( $!( 1 J

%4E J K $
7 Q J!) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< 9: (2003) 3: *" .8 4
.( ,E ?, .4 *"
128
1
1 5( J16 5( 36 .86 7 J ' KE
3, 7 G 9: ;$ 7<% 6 ,8" '( *%!
Q J;6 9E %$ 7 K J % +% !) * $!( 7 9: .
(% J" %$ % ("% ? : J& % (
1, 9 J1," 1( G JC: CE C 1((4 $"
. (" G! 1
%% 11 Q 9 $" K ! J" # 1 , "# Q

1 1) C% C# JC
4 C: C J% : 1 (2001)
7 K J" 9: ) " 9 !) * $!(
J1) ! J7(+ J*" .8 7:
J :
.;$ 7< 9: 3$ 3$ J1! * 3'( 3 7!(
C *" P 9: ) ? - # 1 %" 7
9+! 7 7 J&" !E 1 7 J# 7 , ?: 1 J6% .%
.;6) , ) 9:
28 <% 7 (1979) 3: ( ?4 K( J1( : Q
- .86 7 J#) ,- J" ?$% 8
C 4 J K :
9: C,E 1( K
( P
! ?E J&( 5(% . .# 7
$!( 1 ) #8 ( 7: 8
C K J56 . 6 J$!( .
1%" : &) "( J. 3 F" (8:E J!) *
< ) 7(% (L )7! 1 $ ;$ G!$( - &K 3: J1
. G 1#-
J(]
J1! * ! % 3$ @= "# J: 1 K
Q J!) * ( # J1%) - 7: J 7 "% C
.(?# (4") %
%, 7 ."# T!
K J,E ?, R"% J 9: ' ' $ (?: ?$).E
.) ? - G # ,8"% !% J:
129
4>% J*" T! <# 1 $ F#
7< 3'( .%$ J1, 3'( .%$ 9: J(%" 4)!$ -
J#
%" 4 7 9E ? #r @(N J!) * $!( 1 ;$
, ?$ 7 C:( 6 , J%" $!( 1 4 1 ?>#

7>% ' 8 Q J*" 1 1) .8 - "% $!( 1 ( J?:
<<- @% , J(2011) 3: .%, J*" .8 "% : 1(
J$!( 1 4 1 %" 4 7 #<- @
, .
% K J`(-
1 #<-% @
, Q J> ?4 7 @
, 1 K
7 : K % %" $!( 1 ) , 1 .E J%" 4 B>
() C J 4 BK % 7 7 C6 J : 3'( ? - F
.$!( 1
7
,
K( C,E G# & ' 8 7 -E
J1"%! @( K6) B" @ G$ J7 ! 1 @% @( (1979)3:
.# 1 % ` @ 2% KE J*% @'( 7 H6 7 "%
. %" ?j %# 4 J8 %" 2 ?C : J#6
1 2#( Q J1#6 7" L# .86 7 J1#6 " ' 8 K
7 % 1 <) ?E 1 @:% K J7E B# J? ,E '( ."
.' 1 J%" "#
6 7 "% J 1%" ." ?$ 2 Q 7
.( Q )
:- H@$ =
:1 ( 9: #E 7 1 5( 7 :# 9E
7 C G%( J!) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< 3'( $ 7E :2
!
( 4 7 @ 1#- G, 3 %JC, JC# $!(
P % J ,E ;, L( ?=% J!) * $!( % J,
2 J;$ BK #- 2 G 3F8 % ( J) G< -"
#- 2 %:-% K6> 3 , ;$ (< <% .#
.%" . C6 $!( .
130
$!( 1 ;$ 7< -" , 1 ;% J!) * !

( " $ :$2=$
.;% ;$ .6 -: $!( ."#
3: K( % , '( ( 7 J!) * $!( 1 1) # 7E :$2$
%% : &K ((<) 1) L B$ &K !6
6 9: J(1957)
1 ) $ % 1"
1" # 7E .$ 7 @( -E J((<)
.(2003)3: *" 1) .8 -% J# K 9# (1990) 7 % , J$!(
3:
,
G, 4E 6 "% J1," " 1( 7E :$2
1 J( ( 8) ?
7E @# G ! % *" < J(1979)
.8 J44 56 (4 56 34 7 J$!( .! %[ :
?! . ! ;, . 9: F$ 1 C C!!6 ( 7>% = *"
..E %% ? - 9: J;% ;$ (
!) * J: ?! $!( F - J G 7E :$2$,
1 - ( - 7 ( J) ? @ ! &K J%
3'( - 7E.!) * $!( 1 ) '( < ( '(
1 ) G ;= *$ *! J( ?$ *" ( 1
$!( 9: ?! 1 #- *$ 1 J!) * $!(
.!) * $!( 1 .E 7 *$ J@: ?! !
( *
J!) * $!( 1 (%" 4) J !$ - 7E :$2$
, ?$ " ?# ,E ( @# J$!( 7 9: = C ( %"
?$ " ( 7 Q J*" 1) .8 - "% C J(2011) .%,
..E J7N J%" A J,
%% .' 1 J"% @( 3 C,E C 4 , J%" 4 7E :$2$
"%! K J K @E . &K ;% 7 " 7 J7$ 3:J ?
&) J!) * 1 6 3: 9E 1
% 1 J@(: ( , -"
. ? ) ( L ( ( 7 ?# ,E
131
:0$3 2
BK ,- ) ! J$!( F(% 36 # ! * F(% ?:E U1
#E .86 7 K,@ ?# :<( 8 . C K %:% J.
.% % G< !
( @4 .
, ( '(
. :
% !$( 1 J!) * , 3 R"% J(!

$ . U2
.C!% C" 7 F J!$( 1 ;$ (<
% -# 1 + ?( 7!

8 % . #
;% ( !) * $!( 1 ;$ 7< > 7 ."#,,-
38 ( 7 3 !,$!( 1 ;,- ! 1 .E 9$% 7 (E
.(!
$ -: 8 7, 1$$
& 3'( . "% J !,) " J%!$ (4 3'( 9E ?" ? U3
.7 3 7) *$ 1 %!$
L( 7 " Q ) T 9: ? -
( >
#% - 3 1 2 4> 4) K 7 Q 1$$
3 *$ 1 B% 4 &K,!) * $!( 1 ;$ < )
.7 7)
(< "%! 7 + 7 G, 7 J!) * $!( 1 1%" G% 7E U4

7 J$!( 1 K .8+ 7 % - K J$!( 1 ? , ;$
.(( L 9:
F(% ), 8 % %+ !)
J%" 4 $: J?: ;$ 7% J1$$ ;, 7< #E 9: ." U5
$$ ? 7 "% K J!) * $!( 1 7E
. !) * $!( 1 .E J%+ . J) ? -
, ;$ .%$ 1$$ ;, 7< ?: ;$ BK . Q %
.;6)
132
:I5 $3

- I5 :2
:# .1
(46I)F%(- ? J3 7I$ U -
.G< ( . J"-$ 6! X$ n(1989):76I 3'( J % -
%!, J"D1 NI # L 0$58" n(2000):1(+
J% -
.G%!
.1% % J?$ J"=C V$ " n(1987):(# -
U1990)":L5 5
$5 -= -5$, -$ 1 I=3 "n(1999):?$ J.8# -
.+% "# .(1997
. " :?$ J1( U"1 G3"n(1986): 1(%J16 -
%U((% .( U"- 0L 5 $ 6$E="n(2009):7 .6 -
( ? = J" H, !$ 5 L "n(1975): J1 -
.G<
= % J"- E 4) 6 6$E= - 0$1 "n(1995): J7 -
. 1!
$U%" ? <U. ?, L, 5( "n(2006):.#J 7< -
< ?$ "- -$N0$= $= N 6$E= 3"n(1997):"#J ; -
1" 3-% #-
.1%" F( " J % 1! ."- -= - -$ "n(1982):< J -
( J?$ . ": 6$:E= 3 - -=$ "n(2000):J1 %: -
.%"
"# J Q % < J" 6$E= 3 "n(1992) :9
! J&: -
.?$
.1! J % J" N5 $ 6$E= "n(1994):<<: J -
:+% J"-: 0$:!= N- -$5 "n(1991):# 2J 3' -
.$4 7=
1((% < % J"=
6$E= G "n(1996):34J1(8 -
.
133
. , U % J"< I1 -=C <"n(1996):< J1( -
= : % J"@$: N@$ N0$ NH, # -! "n(1994):= J! -
.( %"
= % J1!N"- 4" 0$E= - 0$1 X$ "n(2002): JK( -
.G< ( "#
% ( J?$ U" '$ 0$$"n(1997):9
! T J( -
.1%
1(% J1! J" A) 4! - 0$1 - : "n(1991): J( -
.L( , ( :&<A
:%! # 1%" < % N" H, 4! G3"n(1998):7 %: J1"( -
.(
%" ? < J % N"- -$ 6E= "n(2002):" 7 1: J.8 -
"- # @" "n(1994): J@% -
% "F$ 6$ -$3 1 0 4" , "n(1987): #( 9: & %: J -
.,- 1%" F( "
0$ .2
J": : - -5 5 "n(2003): J -
.154" J
"H:, # $ 0$= - -=
$5 - -$ "Z(1992): J :< -
.! 7 "J18 3" .%$
:7( #- *4 J" H, $$)1"n1980:76 JAI -
.21" J( %" =
.102" # J" -! <" < 0$" :7 J% -
J J"<:5 $7 0$= - -5$, -$"n(2009):T
%: J% -
.177"
100" J J" $"n(2010):1(J1( -
.119 " J # J"- -3 - -$5 "n(1995):( J1 -
.178" J J"@C >= H$= 6! #L"n(2008): J# -
# J"2001 11 K #! / "n(2002):1<+ J -
.147" J
134
.152" J"- -$ -5 N1 "n(2003) :1<+ J -
.181" J"- -$ -5 NI$ $ 65= "n(2010):1<+ J -
# J"0 $ - ' , 6$! "n(2011):% % J1, -
.184" J
7( J8 7% # J": 6$E= # "n (2003):7 J& -
.187"

= U J23" J"# -5 N$ # "n(2006):7J< -
.G< ( %"
J": -= 5 I1 -85 @""n(1990 ):: J" -
.185" J
. % J172" J1%" .%$ # "0$)$; @" # "n(1993):7A J@8 -
J # J"@C - I :05 " "n(1987): E J -
.89"
J # "O $= O N $"n(1981):7 J1% -
.65"
J1!$ <J": -= ! "n(2010)::J7: -
.*
7= # J"-: 0L E 1C 6$E= "n(2000):A J2 -
.%"
.102" J # J" I - 0$$= ""n(1999):7 J ! -
.106" J # J"H, - - < "n(1990):F(4 J] %: -
.168"J1%" .%$ "H, - -! $ "n(1993):9
! J]%: -
J1%" .%$ #J1%" 7! 9: : 56 < .(1999)@% %: J*6 %: -
.184" J %
56 J"-3 -= 5, 5 "n(2002):*6 %: J]%: -
., J:%!
# J"@:C G3 H, # "n(1984): ! J*< %: -
.35"
J J"- -=8 6$E= 0 "n(2011):: J1!" %: -
.183"
. # J"- - 6 3"n(1979):7 J&!: -
135
J # J" 6$E= / - -5$, -$"n(2003):9
! J&: -
.153"
.184" J"%" 4 G 3" ." "n(2011):9
! J&: -
# J"-:= : -$ H, #"n(2003):" J&: -
.34" J#6 7=
18 3" .%$ # " 6$E= "n(1991 ) :7% J7A -
.(! J2"
. 29" 1%" # "0$= $ <5 & "n(1990): J -
.166"J J"0$$ # - =C >= '"n(2006):1#(J -
J"- 0 =C 1C W$= "n(2011):1#( J -
1"J
.152" J #N" 5, $ K5"n(2003):L " J -
J": -= 68; & $; ! F:6$E= 61""n(2011):38 %: J -
.185" J
#J"H, " 5 K$= "n(1999):3% J -
.136" J
J J" 11 $ - Q "n(2003):.6 J -
.149 "
.1%" 56 # J">=8 H, < 0$ -$"n(1985):.6 J -
J #J2 :"=C 1 G3 "n(1986): "! J3 -
.83"
#J"-: 0: :E : : "n(2011):1:JP" -
.185"J
18" J"- $ -$ $ "n(2010):% J9
! -
. 17
J"5 -$8= $ $ "n(2011): 7 J( -
# " 1C 6$E= - "n(1995): ]%: JB -
( %J1992" J1%" .%$
I$5 @$ 0$ .3

U# J7(% J" 1C =" "n(2005):
J38 -
.7 "#
136
J"<$: # 1C "n(2001):: J& -
.7: J() "#U#
J?# %$ J" H, -= <$!" "n(2004):( %: J1(: -
.7: J() "# U#
# J"- -! 01 "n(2005) :Q J7% -
( J= "#
0$J 0= .4
1#- $ U(2002) ?$ U1 - %" . "# " () -
.3-J#- < J19851%"

<
J(1990) 1

.(1989)1
%" 1#
-
$ -
.?$ U3).#-
.(2003), ! 6 !:.(2003U2002)1%" 1#- $ -
.?$ J%" ? <(1998)1 &" J1%" 1#- $ -
- *.(1999)&( 1#- J*% #- 1$ < -
.1(4
.(1991) 8"- " J %" , J56 < J 38: ?< -
.2011U2010 1" J 1%" &,- $ -
!C @$ '3 .5

2003.%2 J!) * ?# J7% # 8 J7A -
7% ?# 1, 3'( . ) L"( " % . J( % J -
.2003 2J 624"
261% J 7% ?# J1%" 1$ 7) 9: 4> ! * !, J -
.2001 %(
& ?#J%" , 1 ' J44 56 < J !, J -
.(2003) 25 J11999" J()
137
0= =.6
- ?# J*" 1 &# B# %" ( J J -
.2003/7/29
:1 !% 9: 2011 1$ 7S J% J1) L # -
http//www.hitehoues.gov/sites/defawlt/files/rss/viewe
7- 7 38 G, J*" 9: 7 1(
, 1%) + J1% J: -
.2003 L 1(-
6 7% JE % ) ( # ! * J( % J -
.2002 %
.2002/9/91(- ?<# G, %% 11 "% ) J7 J* -
.2002/9/11 1(- ?<# G, J1 3'( 9: %% Q : J % J3'( -
:-=5 I5 $2=$

1-Bendeict Kingsbury: "Legal Positivism as Normative Politics": International
LawJ European Journal of International Law. Vol. 13 (2002) No. 2JPA15.
2- Encyclopedia Britannica:(2003) available on the Internet http.\\www
britannica.com
3-The Midlle East In 2015 :"The Impact of Regional Trends On Us. Strategic
Planning-Arabic".jodet- Maali Mohammad(2005)-demasices

توازن القوى في الشرق الاوسط بعد احتلال العراق

Diunggah oleh

Informasi Dokumen

Hak Cipta

Format Tersedia

Bagikan dokumen Ini

Bagikan atau Tanam Dokumen

Opsi Berbagi

Apakah menurut Anda dokumen ini bermanfaat?

Apakah konten ini tidak pantas?

Hak Cipta:

Format Tersedia

توازن القوى في الشرق الاوسط بعد احتلال العراق

Diunggah oleh

Hak Cipta:

Format Tersedia

 

          

& ' $ !:#$

', ()$) ..

-$ 6   5$ -5  4! 3 0$  2 $ 

-$ 6 61

6 # -

   -$5

 ' &!" #$% 

< .: 0:=$  .= $8$ -$ 

-=    6$E= 4! $/ H, #  :F$  3;

    , <5 - ! M -1" 1 3 :F$  F

?># ' 1 %" 

:-  -/

.-=  -1C  $(2003)1 $ -1  -$ :$@ 5"

 L"( -E    $(-  % 1", B#- 7E

@ +  %( 7 .  1 J", A "

: $8 $  - $ 0= ."

U1%" 56 1 1#- 4)U *" 7EU(2005)B (2)

:-  -58=

:-  -/

- 1" J(2001 %%11) Q 4 9: J44 

$!( 1 ;$ 7< 3'( 16 ! .

   -= -$3 1 -5   -/

 1 ! K 7 J1#- 

@"% 3" !% % 1 ,?# 8  !% 1 ." BK .

   - L5 :$2=$

:-$3 1    -/ :$2 $

56) %" $!( 1 C  ,@ !

:   -= -;= -/

9: .! C % CK

( 7 %58( 1952) 3: !) * $!( 1 !

KE J%" $!( C 6 !) * $!( C< C : ("% R "

9E 7"% @: 7 * 7 J1 !

 % 1)  < ( (L( L#) 3, C%$ @

.E $!( 7   1 ) ! ,7

   -=  - G$ &$3

. 1  - ( .1

.  . *"  7% (4 56 < .2

.1 1%"     .3

< , %+ % . ?  - 7 8

:   -=  -  &$3 6/ :2

) () #-) $4 , K 

U26 H .H # %:).!) * $!( 1 .    ( ' .2

!) * 1 $ ) 2  C8, 

 ,- 2 %  % !

%" . # 1 1, &" ,

G( K J<,$ $!( 1  - J!) *  (# 1 $- 3: .6

:$  -=$    -= -/ :$2=$

: :   -$3 1 &$3.

!) * $!( 1 %)   6 *) 9: '

7 9 KJ!) * $!( 1 & ,- 1 $- 7 -

+  ; E 1   7 9:  ,8" 1 H 6- . *

   -=    6$E= 4! - $  H, # 

(   -=    6$E= 4! $/ - $  H, # )

:  '1 .1

9: P:- 7%  (" A 

(: $ %4%  C"%! % JCKE 

:= C '1 2

3, J  ,  

.6 7%$ 7" 7% *" 9:   

( ( , .   ?6)  1 < ;6 # 7

 .   ) ? G 86 .# 1 L)% A (

% ?$ 

& ' $ !:#$

', ()$) ..

-$ 6 5$ -5 4! 3 0$ 2 $

-$ 6 61

6 # -

-$5

' &!" #$%

<.: 0:=$ .= $8$ -$

-= 6$E= 4! $/ H, # :F$ 3;

, <5 -! M -1" 1 3 :F$ F

?># ' 1 %"

:- -/

.-= -1C $(2003)1 $ -1 -$ :$@5"

L"( -E $(- % 1", B#- 7E

@ + %( 7 . 1 J", A "

: $8 $ - $ 0= ."

U1%" 56 1 1#- 4)U *" 7EU(2005)B (2)

:- -58=

:- -/

- 1" J(2001 %%11) Q 4 9: J44

$!( 1 ;$ 7< 3'( 16 ! .

-= -$3 1 -5 -/

1 ! K 7 J1#-

@"% 3" !% % 1 ,?# 8 !% 1 ." BK .

-L5 :$2=$

:-$3 1 -/ :$2$

56) %" $!( 1 C ,@ !

: -= -;= -/

9: .! C % CK

( 7 %58( 1952) 3: !) * $!( 1 !

KE J%" $!( C6 !) * $!( C< C: ("% R "

9E 7"% @: 7 * 7 J1 !

% 1) < ( (L( L#) 3, C%$ @

.E $!( 7 1 ) ! ,7

-= - G$ &$3

. 1 - ( .1

. . *" 7% (4 56 < .2

.1 1%" .3

< , %+ % . ? - 7 8

: -= - &$3 6/ :2

) () #-) $4 , K

U26 H .H # %:).!) * $!( 1 . ( ' .2

!) * 1 $ ) 2 C8,

,- 2% % !

%" . # 1 1, &" ,

G( K J<,$ $!( 1 - J!) * (# 1 $- 3: .6

:$ -=$ -= -/ :$2=$

: : -$3 1 &$3.

!) $!( 1 %) 6 ) 9: '

7 9 KJ!) * $!( 1 &,- 1 $- 7 -

+ ; E 1 7 9: ,8" 1 H6- . *

-= 6$E= 4! -$ H, #

( -= 6$E= 4! $/ -$ H, #)

: '1 .1

9: P:- 7% (" A

(: $ %4% C"%! % JCKE

:=C '1 2

3, J ,

.6 7%$ 7" 7% *" 9:

( ( , . ?6) 1 < ;6 # 7

. ) ? G 86 .# 1 L)% A (

% ?$

- -1C - H@$ = :$2 $

: -= 6$E= 4! $/

L J "$!(% $ 3'(

. -= 6$E=

:-L5 0J 1

:-$3 1C 0J 3

:1_ 1 .4 1%" 3'( ,- = 3

1% J 1%) "- 34 1(4" .8 8 ! ?

L(J<# J7).&" 1!$ 3'( 9E < 3'( 7 . -

J7)).& 1 3'( 9E &

4 " 8E F#N% '() C6 6_ "% 3, -

:- 0J 5

-@ -= G5 0 0 0 -, G5 -=

2.1 104050 13500 480 90000 4.9 7)

2.5 64500 4000 1500 59000 2.6

1.8 11000 1500 1000 8500 0.6 7 %

0.4 35000 3500 4500 27000 12 9.6 L(

0.4 122000 10000 7000 105000 12 29.2 <#