By: Group 8A
Airlangga University
2016
1
CONTENTS
CONTENTS ................................................................................................................. 2
PART I BRAINSTORMING AND COGNITIVE STRATEGY ................................. 4
1.1 Main Problem ...................................................................................................... 4
1.2 Keywords ............................................................................................................ 4
1.3 Early Hypothesis ................................................................................................. 4
1.4 Additional Question or Information .................................................................... 5
1.5 Learning Issues ................................................................................................... 6
1.6 Early Concept Mapping ...................................................................................... 7
PART II PROBLEM ANALYSIS ................................................................................ 8
2.1 Cognitive Strategy............................................................................................... 9
2.2 Answers of Learning Issues ................................................................................ 9
2.2.1 What are the sign of partus ? ....................................................................... 9
2.2.2 What is meconial aspiration syndrome ?.....10
2.2.3 What is the medical ethical issues in Indonesia which is related on the case
based on KODEKI, UU no. 29 tahun 2004 dan UU Kesehatan no. 36 tahun
2009?...........................................................................................................11
2.2.4 What are the Standard Operating Procedure of giving birh in
Puskesmas?.................................................................................................12
2.2.5 What are the criteria or procedure of refrence from local health provider
(Puskesmas) to Hospital?........................................................................ ...15
2.2.6 What are the content of informed consent?................................................19
2.2.7 In what condition do the doctor needs informed consent from the
patient?........................................................................................................20
2.2.8 What are medical malpractice, negligence, and error ?...............................21
2.2.9 What are the criteria of normal & caesar childbirth facility?......................23
2.2.10 What are the Caesarea Section Surgery Procedure?..................................29
2.2.11 What are the indications of caesarean section?.........................................31
2.2.12 Which KUHP is indicating the scenario? .................................................33
2.2.13 How the informed consent in an emergency situation?.............................34
2
2.3 Summary of Literature Review ......................................................................... 35
PART III PROBLEM SOLVING ............................................................................... 38
3.1 Final Concept Mapping ..................................................................................... 38
3.2 Final Hypothesis ............................................................................................... 39
3.3 Group Discussion and Opinion ......................................................................... 39
3.4 Conclusion ........................................................................................................ 39
REFERENCES ........................................................................................................... 41
CRITICAL APPRAISAL ........................................................................................... 44
3
PART I
BRAINSTORMING AND COGNITIVE STRATEGY
1.1 Scenario
Mrs. Ita was referred from the primary health care to the hospital with the
diagnosis of dilation phase 2 of delivery. After 8 hours into delivery process,
there wasnt any improvement, there was even meconium detected. The doctor
decided to perform a caesarean operation, the baby was born but Mrs. Ita died 20
minutes after the operation. Mrs. Itas family sued the doctor for malpractice.
1.2 Keywords
From the problem above, we found some keywords as below:
1. Malpractice
2. Caesarian operation
3. Meconium
4. Patients death after operation
5. The second delivery opening but eight hours there has no progress
4
1.4 Additional Question or Information
In order to obtain more information about Mrs. Itas delivery and the cause
of her death, we asked some additional questions as will be mentioned below:
1. How old is Mrs. Ita?
She is 26 years old.
2. Is this Mrs.Itas first pregnancy?
No, this is her second pregnancy.
3. Did Mrs. Ita has a history of abortion ?
No, she didnt
4. What is the habits of Mrs. Ita ?
She is a housewife so every day she just managing the household
5. How was the childbirth of Mrs.Itas firstborn?
There was no problem on her first childbirth. The child was delivered
normally at the local clinic.
6. How long was the time gap between Mrs. Itas first childbirth and her
second pregnancy?
The time gap between her first childbirth and her second pregnancy was 2
years.
7. How old was Mrs. Itas pregnancy at the time of delivery ?
Her pregnancy was 38 weeks old
8. How was Mrs. Itas condition and habits during her pregnancy?
Since the beginning of her pregnancy until before delivery, she regularly
came for controls. There was no problem on her second pregnancy.
9. How was Mrs. Itas condition at the local clinic?
She was scheduled for normal delivery. She was diagnosed that her
progress of delivery is already at phase dilution 2 but there wasnt any
improvement.
10. Was there informed consent before the caesarian operation performance on
Mrs.Ita?
5
There was spoken informed consent between the doctor and Mrs. Itas
family
11. How was the competence of the doctor who performed the caesarian
operation on Ms. Ita?
The doctor was competent to perform a caesarian operation.
12. How was Mrs. Itas psychological condition ?
Her condition was good
13. Was the caesarean operation done according to the standard operational
procedure ?
Yes, the caesarean operation was done according to the standard operation
procedure.
14. How was the babys condition before and after the caesarean operation ?
The baby was in good condition both before and after the caesarean
operation
15. How heavy was the baby when it was born ?
The baby weighed 4 kg when it was born
6
7. In what condition do the doctor needs informed consent from the patient ?
8. What are medical malpractice, negligence, and error ?
9. What are the criteria of normal & caesarean childbirth facility?
10. What are the Caesarea Section Surgery Procedure?
11. What are the indications of caesarean section?
12. Which KUHP is indicating the scenario?
13. How the informed consent in an emergency situation?
7
8
PART II
PROBLEM ANALYSIS
9
Based on guide book from Indonesian Health Government(2013), a normal
Partus divide to some phase:
Phase I, divide to two phase
Laten phase: Cervix open about 1-3cm, need time about 8 hour.
Active phase: Cervix open about 4-10cm, need time about 8 hour.
Phase II: Cervix fully open until the baby born, need time about an hour in
primigravida and two hour in multygravida
Phase III: after baby has born until the placenta come out, about 30 minute
Phase IV: after the placenta come out until 2 hour post partum
10
2.2.3 What is the medical ethical issues in Indonesia which is related on the
case based on KODEKI, UU no. 29 tahun 2004 dan UU Kesehatan no.
36 tahun 2009?
a. UU no. 29 tahun 2004 tentang praktik kedokteran Paragraf 2 tentang
Persetujuan tindakan kedokteran atau kedokteran gigi ayat 1-5
(1) Setiap tindakan kedokteran atau kedokteran gigi yang akan dilakukan
oleh dokter atau dokter gigi terhadap pasien harus mendapat persetujuan.
(2) Persetujuan sebagaimana dimaksud pada ayat (1) diberikan setelah
pasien mendapat penjelasan secara lengkap.
(3) Penjelasan sebagaimana dimaksud pada ayat (2) sekurang-kurangnya
mencakup :
a.diagnosis dan tata cara tindakan medis;
b.tujuan tindakan medis yang dilakukan;
c.alternatif tindakan lain dan risikonya;
d.risiko dan komplikasi yang mungkin terjadi; dan
e.prognosis terhadap tindakan yang dilakukan.
(4) Persetujuan sebagaimana dimaksud pada ayat (2) dapat diberikan baik
secara tertulis maupun lisan.
(5) Setiap tindakan kedokteran atau kedokteran gigi yang mengandung risiko
tinggi harus diberikan dengan persetujuan tertulis yang ditandatangani oleh
yang berhak memberikan persetujuan.
(6) Ketentuan mengenai tata cara persetujuan tindakan kedokteran atau
kedokteran gigi sebagaimana dimaksud pada ayat (1), ayat (2), ayat (3), ayat
(4), dan ayat (5) diatur dengan Peraturan Menteri.
b. UU no. 29 tahun 2004 tentang praktik kedokteran Paragraf 6 tentang
Hak dan Kewajiban Dokter atau Dokter Gigi Pasal 50b
a. Dokter atau dokter gigi dalam melaksanakan praktik kedokteran
mempunyai hak:
a. Memberikan pelayanan medis menurut standar profesi dan standar
prosedur operasional
11
b. UU no. 29 tahun 2004 tentang praktik kedokteran Paragraf 6tentang
Hak dan Kewajiban Dokter atau Dokter Gigi Pasal 51 a dan b
b.Dokter atau dokter gigi dalam melaksanakan praktik kedokteran
mempunyai kewajiban :
a. memberikan pelayanan medis sesuai dengan standar profesi dan
standar prosedur operasional serta kebutuhan medis pasien;
b. merujuk pasien ke dokter atau dokter gigi lain yang mempunyai
keahlian atau kemampuan yang lebih baik, apabila tidak mampu
melakukan suatu pemeriksaan atau pengobatan
c. UU no. 36 thn 2009 tentang Kesehatan Paragraf 2 tentang
Perlindungan Pasien pasal 58
(1) Setiap orang berhak menuntut ganti rugi terhadap seseorang, tenaga
kesehatan, dan/atau penyelenggara kesehatan yang menimbulkan
kerugian akibat kesalahan atau kelalaian dalam pelayanan kesehatan
yang diterimanya.
(2) Tuntutan ganti rugi sebagaimana dimaksud pada ayat (1) tidak
berlaku bagi tenaga kesehatan yang melakukan tindakan penyelamatan
nyawa atau pencegahan kecacatan seseorang dalam keadaan darurat.
(3) Ketentuan mengenai tata cara pengajuan tuntutan sebagaimana
dimaksud pada ayat (1) diatur sesuai dengan ketentuan peraturan
perundang-undangan.
12
and baby.
b. Prepare by wearing an apron
c. Washing hands with six rare technique h
d. Wearing gloves
e. preparing oxytocin
B. Ensure Existing Opening
a. Clean the vulva with vulva hygiene techniques
b. Check in
c. Then handscoon used dipped into a solution of chlorine
d. Check the fetal heart rate
C. Maternal and Family Ready To Lead
a. preparing mother
b. Tell your family
c. When his exist, lead the mother to push and give praise to the mother
that mothers can give birth normally. If his does not exist, encourage the
mother to rest, give drink, and listen to the fetal heartbeat.
D. Ready For Helping
a. Prepare a clean towel over the mother's abdomen
b. Place the pedestal butt
c. Open
d. Wear gloves
E. Helping New Baby
a. Protect your baby's head
b. Wipe mouth, nose, and eyes with a sterile cloth Gaas
c. Check there nuchal cord or not
d. Wait a pivot swivel head held outside
e. Labor the shoulders by way of biparietal
f. To deliver the body use sangga susur method
g. Right hand down the baby's body
13
F. Handling Baby
a. Put the baby on the mother's abdomen
b. Dry the baby with a clean towel
c. Pinch the cord
d. then cut
e. Change towels attach baby clothes
f. Then give to his mother to breastfeed
Stage III
a. Check fundus
b. Tell mom what shall we do
c. injecting oxytocin
d. Stretch Cord Controlled (PTT).
e. Move clamps first.
f. Position the clamps layout
g. Tighten the cord
h. Pull the placenta slowly, the left hand pressing the fundus to dorso
cranial.
i. Rotate the placenta that are already out
j. Perform massage
Post Actions
a. See tone baby
b. Clean baby
c. Tie the cord
d. Tie the cord again
14
e. Clamp the umbilical cord
f. Wrap the baby with a clean cloth
g. directly provide breast milk
h. Evaluation of uterine contractions
i. Teach mothers to give a massage
j. Check blood pressure
k. Check the pulse
l. Sterilize tools parturition
m. Dispose of garbage secondhand clothes. Clean the mother
o. Give comfort to the mother
p. Perform decontamination on equipment
q. Dipping into the 0.5% chlorine solution
r. Wash with running water
s. Record all actions in partograf
t. Measure pulse, blood pressure, temperature
2.2.5 What are the criteria or procedure of refrence from local health
provider (Puskesmas) to Hospital?
The factors that influence the evaluation (Katz, 1983):
1. The attitude of the staff towards the evaluation itself.
2. Skills, money / funds and time available.
The purpose of evaluation:
a. Seeing the final service conditions.
b. Looking for ways to improve services.
c. Determining the need for modification of purpose and service.
How to assess a reference service that is:
1. Assessment of Direct
In direct assessment appraisal done on the efficiency and effectiveness
of services to the user reference.
2. Assessment of indirect
15
assessment was conducted on matters pertaining to the budget,
personnel, collections (number, age and value of the reference
collection).
Reference Type
a. Medicalrefrences:
o Referral of patients,
o Referral knowledge, and
o Referral laboratory or examination materials.
b. Referral Health:
o Referral of science, technology and skills, for example: shipping
specialists, especially surgeons, obstetrics and gynecology, internal
medicine and pediatrics of RSU province to the RSU District
o Shipping assistant senior expert to the Regional Hospitals that do not
have a specialist in certain period of time.
o Delivery of health workers from health centers to hospitals
Provincial District Hospital.
o transfer of knowledge and skills in the field of clinical, management
and operation of peralaan.
c. References Management
o Delivery information
o Drug, cost, manpower, equipment
o Request for help: an epidemiological survey, overcome the epidemic
(an outbreak)
Reference Groove
16
Medical referral health centers carried out gradually from:
a. cadres and TBAs
b. posyandu
c. maternity / midwives
d. puskesmas maid
e. puskesmas hospitalization
f. district hospital grade D / C
In this regard the referral path for emergency cases can be carried out as
follows:
1. From Kader
Can be directly refer to:
1) community health clinic
2) The cottage maternity / midwives
3) Health Center / Puskesmas inpatient
4) Hospital public / private
2. From IHC
Can be directly refer to:
1) community health clinic
17
2) The cottage maternity / midwives
3) Health Center / Puskesmas inpatient
4) Hospital public / private
3. From the health center
Can directly refer to hospital-type D / C or private hospital
4. From the cottage maternity / Village Midwife
Can directly refer to hospital-type D / C or a private hospital.
Flow Referral Service Emergency Obstetrics and Neonatal
The referral system to maternal and neonatal emergency service
refers to the main principles of speed and accuracy measures, efficient,
effective late in accordance with the ability and authority service facilities.
Each case with emergency obstetric and neonatal coming to health
centers directly managed in accordance PONED must remain in accordance
with the procedures of Reference Books National Maternal and Neonatal
Health Services. After stabilization of the patient's condition, then
determined whether the patient will be administered at the health center level
PONED or referral to hospitals PONEK to get better service in accordance
with the level of kegawat daruratannya.
Polindes village midwife and can provide direct services to pregnant
women / mothers in childbirth and postpartum mothers who came alone or
on rujuka cadres / community. In addition to normal delivery assistance
service delivery, the midwife in the village can do with the case management
of certain complications in accordance with the authority and ability level or
made a referral to the health center, health center and hospital PONED
PONEK in accordance with the appropriate level of service.
PHC non PONED at - least be able to stabilize patients with obetetri
and neonatal emergencies that come themselves or be referred by a cadre /
shaman / midwife in the village prior to referral to a health center and
hospital PONED PONEK.
18
PONED health center has the ability to provide direct services to
pregnant / maternity / puerperal women and newborns who come alone or on
referral cadres / community midwife in the village and the health center.
PHC PONED can do with the case management of certain complications in
accordance with the authority and ability level or made a referral to the
Hospital PONEK.
Terms of Reference
Recording of certain:
1. Letters of reference
2. Health Card for clients who can not afford
3. Recording the appropriate and correct
4. Card reference monitoring maternal and infant (KMRIBB)
5. The existence of reciprocal understanding between the referring and
receiving referrals
6. There understanding of system tasks rujukan
7. Nature of horizontal and vertical reference (towards a more capable and
complete).
19
c. alternatif tindakan lain dan risikonya;
d. risiko dan komplikasi yang mungkin terjadi; dan
e. prognosis terhadap tindakan yang dilakukan.
2.2.7 In what condition do the doctor needs informed consent from the
patient ?
Conditions About General Medical Statement Measures (Informed Consent)
a. Understanding
1. Approval of medical action (informed consent) is the statement
given patient or family on the basis of a description of the medical
action is both treatments, diagnostic or therapeutic to be performed
on these patients.
2. medical action is a diagnostic therapeutic action on a patient.
3. The action is invasive medical action that could directly affect the
integrity of the network.
b. These types of measures that need to be informed consent
Informed consent is consent orally medical given orally, among
others:
1. Taking blood for diagnostic purposes.
2. Provision of a drug for therapeutic purposes in intrakutan,
subcutaneously, intramuscularly or intravenously.
3. Installation chateter venous infusion / IV needle.
4. The stabbing the needle with a particular area (eg acupuncture).
5. Installation of certain tools:
a) Catheter Nelaton for men and women.
b) a metal catheter just for women.
c) Installation nasograstrie tube.
d) Installation of a splint.
e) Installation of traction.
f) Aspiration lenders from the nose, mouth, or from endotracheal
20
tube.
g) foreign body retrieval from the nasal cavity or ear canal.
h) treatment of the wound, wash the wound with local anesthetic.
i) Decision gerpusalineumpada eye (eg: gram cornea /
conjuncition).
j) Provision lavement (washing of the colon), for inspection
radiology / preparatory operations.
k) The function of ascites or pleura.
c. Written informed consent
Medical action is consent given in writing. Medical actions
associated with different measures or actions Invasive or potentially
endanger patients' lives, should be given a specially informed consent
(written), among others:
1. Surgical treatment of small, medium, large and special.
2. The action of local anesthesia, regional, general.
3. Measures invansife.
4. The act of amputation (removal of body tissue).
5. Sophisticated medical action (IVP, Endoscopy, photos with the
contras) (pratita,2013)
21
KUHP that needed the culpa lata proof from a doctor or dentist. (
Marleni, 2010)
Thus for proving malpractice under the criminal law includes the
following elements:
1) It has been deviated from the standard of the medical profession;
2) Fulfil the element of culpa lata or negligence; and
3) Measures serious consequences, fatal and violation of pasal 359,
pasal 360, KUHP.
The elements of pasal 359 danpasal 360as follows:
1) The existence of an negligence (culpa).
2) There is a particular form of action.
3) The result of severe injuries or death.
4) The existence of a causal relationship between the form of the act
with the death of someone else's.
Three levels culpa:
a. Culpa lata: a serious mistake, a reckless (gross fault or neglect)
b. Culpa levis: regular errors (ordinary fault or neglect)
c. Culpa levissima: errors mild (slight fault or neglect)
Proof of the civil lawsuits, the parties that argue something must submit
evidence. In this case can call an expert witness for the requested
opinion. If a mistake is done by the doctor (res IPSA loquitur, the thing
speaks for itself) so an expert witness is not needed again , the burden of
evidence may be burdened to the doctor. ( Marleni, 2010)
22
C. Medical error defined as the failure of a planned action to be completed
as intended or the use of a wrong plan to achieve an aim (Ethan D.
Grober, 2005)
2.2.9 What are the criteria of normal & caesar childbirth facility?
NORMAL CHILDBIRTH
Utilization of health services among others visit antenatal checks
carried out, preparation for labor, birth attendants election, and the election of
the place of delivery. Antenatal visit is antenatal health care workers where
the frequency of inspection visits at least 4 times is 1 times in the first
trimester, 1 time in trimester II, two times in the third trimester.
The results showed antenatal care visits related to the incidence of
complications of labor, but this relationship is protective in which the mother
who did not visit antenatal care at least four times likely to experience birth
complications by 0.86 times compared to women who visit antenatal care at
least four times. Likelihood of this happens because mothers more often
during their pregnancy are those who feel their complaints or notified that
they lead a pregnancy high risk. Reports maternal health programs shows that
the percentage of pregnant women who visit antenatal checks at least 1 time is
quite high, but the percentage who visited antenatal clinics four times the
national standard is lower. The report also showed that pregnant women
consider the quality of service is low (Department of Health, 2001a).
According Carolli, Rooney and Villar (2001) on research in
Zimbabwe, effectiveness of antenatal visit four times as effective as the visits
six times or more. And the effectiveness of antenatal care provided by a
midwife or GP as effective as antenatal given by obstetricians.
Childbirth women done is discussed with the family about the place of
birth, transportation to the place of birth, birth attendants, and the cost for
labor, incidence of complications related to childbirth. However, after being
controlled by other factors, childbirth is not associated with the incidence of
23
complications of childbirth. Childbirth and referral at this time is one
component in the standard antenatal care 7T criteria. With the existence of
this preparation is expected to circumstances related to the Three Delays have
been discussed with the family during pregnancy.
The results showed no association between birth attendants with an
incidence of complications of labor, but this relationship is protective in
which mothers who choose birth attendants instead of health workers tend to
experience birth complications by 0.79 times compared to mothers who
choose birth attendants with health professionals. The percentage of mothers
who choose birth attendants with health workers as much as 53.5%. Qualifies
as a birth attendant health personnel is only birth attendant health workers
which general practitioners, obstetricians, midwives, nurses or midwives
without interference birth attendants who are not health professionals such as
a shaman, or other relatives.
According to Sihombing (2004) on analysis of Household Health
Survey 2001 found that birth attendants are the factors that influence the
incidence of birth complications (p = 0.015, OR 2.412). According to Djaja
and Suwandono (2006) of the Regional Health Forum WHO South-East Asia
Region (Vol.4), births attended by skilled health is not at risk 1.8 times higher
chance of developing a fever during the postpartum than births attended
byhealth workers. In this case the birth attendant morbidity associated with
the mother during childbirth.
Still the number of births attended by health personnel is not like a
shaman because shamans understand the local culture and understand the
emotional needs of the mother. However shaman can not provide effective
services in the management of complications of pregnancy and childbirth. In
the study Goodburn, et al. (2000) in Bangladesh, providing training for clean
delivery at the TBA in terms of washing hands with soap, clean cord care, and
a clean delivery was not associated significantly in preventing postpartum
24
infection. That is the role of the shaman still can not be an alternative in the
choice of birth attendants.
According to the WHO definition, skilled health workers as birth
attendants are health professionals who have knowledge and skills in handling
normal birth and is able to provide basic emergency obstetric care. A skilled
health personnel in attending births should be able to do the things below
(UNICEF, WHO, UNFPA, 1997):
1. normal delivery care using aseptic technique
2. Active management of the third stage in labor
3. Provide newborn care, including resuscitation
4. managing postpartum hemorrhage with oxytocin use parenteral and
abdominal massage
5. placenta manual
6. managing eclampsia with parenteral administration of
antihypertensive
7. Recognize and manage postpartum infection with parenteral
antibiotics
8. Helping labor with action through the use of vacuum extraction
9. Manatalaksana incomplete abortion with manual vacuum aspiration
10. Knowing how to refer the mother to a higher service and stabilize
the state of the mother during the trip
According Utomo, et al. (2007) on the results of research IMMPACT in
Indonesia, the use of health services is still low even though in areas with
sufficient density midwife. Rural areas and remote areas underserved because
they do not have a midwife who lived in the village. Mothers in the village
with a midwife who lived in the village and more experienced tend to be
reported more births assisted by skilled health personnel and maternal
mortality is lower.
Value OR <1, which means protective on a visit antenatal and birth
attendants election should be more careful in interpreting it so that it does not
25
mean that more frequent antenatal and birth attendants with health workers are
even at risk for complications of delivery. Should be analyzed more deeply to
see the characteristics of the mothers in the group. It turns out antenatal
mothers more than four times and women who chose birth attendants with
more health workers in mothers with higher education and high economic
status. The group of mothers with higher education and higher economic
status will be more concerned with health and easier to get / receive
information about her pregnancy and has the option to receive better health
care.
In theory the search behavior and use of health services, the actions of a
person affected by a perceived vulnerability, perceived seriousness, benefits
and obstacles, as well as signs experienced. In this case the mother who have
symptoms of complications and considers the issue important for the safety of
herself and her baby will be looking for better health care, which is more
frequent antenatal and choose a birth attendant with power and not according
to standards could lead to the negative attitude of the public as users of
services so that they are reluctant to re-use existing health services.
SECTIO CAESAREA
Preparation for a caesarean section
To prepare for your caesarean:
1. You will need to fast no food or drink, including water for six hours
before a planned caesarean. If it is an emergency caesarean, the doctor will
ask you when you last had any food or drink so they know how to proceed
with your operation.
2. You will have blood tests taken.
3. You may have a support person with you, unless there are serious
complications or you need a general anaesthetic. It is generally possible for
someone to take photos of your baby being born, so ask your support person
to bring a camera if they have one.
26
4. Dont be afraid to ask questions or to tell the doctors or midwives if you are
feeling worried. If you have any special preferences, please talk to your doctor
or midwife beforehand, so they can try to support your choices.
5. If the doctor believes you are at increased risk of blood clots, you may be
measured for compression stockings to wear during the operation.
6. The theatre team will clean your abdomen with antiseptic and cover it with
sterile cloths to reduce the risk of infection. In many hospitals, the hair around
the area to be cut is shaved so that it is easier to clean. You will have a
catheter (plastic tube) inserted into your bladder so that it remains empty
during the operation.
27
After a caesarean section
A number of things will occur after you have a caesarean, including:
1. You will be cared for in the recovery room until you are ready to go to
the ward.
2. If you have had a general anaesthetic, you will most likely wake up in
the recovery room. You should be able to see your baby once you are
awake.
3. You will be encouraged to breastfeed. The earlier you start to
breastfeed, the easier it is likely to be for both you and your baby.
Having a caesarean can make breastfeeding harder to start, so ask for
all the support you need. Breastfeeding is the best possible food to
help your baby grow healthy and strong, and the midwives are there to
help you. Some hospitals encourage women to breastfeed their baby in
the recovery room if there is a midwife to assist.
4. Tell your midwife or doctor when you are feeling pain so they can
give you something to ease it. Pain-relieving medication may make
you a little drowsy.
5. You may have a drip for the first 24 hours or so, until you have
recovered from the anaesthetic.
6. You can start to drink after any nausea has passed.
7. The midwife or doctor will tell you when you can eat again.
8. Your catheter will stay in until the anaesthetic has worn off and you
have normal sensation in your legs to walk safely to the toilet. This
may not be until the next day.
9. Walking around can help with recovery. It can also stop blood clots
and swelling in your legs. A midwife will help you the first time you
get out of bed.
10. You may also have an injection to stop blood clots.
11. You may need antibiotics after the operation.
28
12. You may have trouble with bowel movements for a short time after the
operation. It should help to drink plenty of water and eat high-fibre
food. The doctor or midwife can give you more advice.
13. When your dressing is taken off, you will be instructed to keep the
wound clean and dry. This will help it to heal faster and reduce the risk
of infection.
29
clamp and cut the umbilical cord. The placenta will be removed from the
uterus, and the incisions will be closed with sutures.
3. Post-operation procedure
a. Assess the patients level of consciousness
b. Record the blood pressure, temperature, pulse, for 4 hours
c. Initiating breastfeeding
d. Optimum ventilation and haemodynamic status is maintained
e. Bonding between mother and baby
f. Fluid and electrolyte balance is maintained
g. Comfort is maintained Patient anxiety is minimized
4. Pre-operation procedure
Clinical decision made for caesarean section by obstetric team in
collaboration with the woman, support person and Local Medic Committee
(LMC). The woman (the patient) and the husband or family receive adequate
explanation about the surgery procedure from the surgeon and the woman
gives verbal informed consent. Agreement to Treatment form is completed by
woman and surgeon unless the condition is extreme emergency.
5. Operation procedure
Before the caesarean section, the abdomen will be cleansed. A tube
(catheter) will likely be placed into the bladder to collect urine. Intravenous
(IV) lines will be placed in a vein in your hand or arm to provide fluid and
medication. The patient may be given an antacid to reduce the risk of an upset
stomach during the procedure. Most caesarea sections are done under regional
anesthesia, which numbs only the lower part of the body, allowing the patient
to remain awake during the procedure. The doctor will make an incision
through the abdominal wall. It's usually done horizontally near the pubic
hairline. the doctor will then make incisions , layer by layer, through the fatty
tissue and connective tissue and separate the abdominal muscle to access the
abdominal cavity. The uterine incision is then made, usually horizontally
across the lower part of the uterus. The baby will be delivered through the
30
incisions. The doctor will clear the baby's mouth and nose of fluids, then
clamp and cut the umbilical cord. The placenta will be removed from the
uterus, and the incisions will be closed with sutures.
6. Post-operation procedure
a. Assess the patients level of consciousness
b. Record the blood pressure, temperature, pulse, for 4 hours
c. Initiating breastfeeding
d. Optimum ventilation and haemodynamic status is maintained
e. Bonding between mother and baby
f. Fluid and electrolyte balance is maintained
g. Comfort is maintained Patient anxiety is minimized
31
of controlling acute hypertension, oxytocin infusion that give a chance
to do vaginal delivery.
c. Eclampsia
Eclampsia is pre-eclampsia condition accompanied by convulsions.
Caesarean section needs to do rapidly for late pregnancy.
d. Ovarian tumors
The tumors should be removed during pregnancy or perform
laparotomy. In other cases the tumour should be removed as soon as
practicable after delivery of the child.
e. Cardiac disease
In giving birth needs powerful heart, so that in this condition the
best solution is doing the caesarean section.
f. Infectious disease
Cesarean section can decrease the risks in infectious transmitted
disease such as HIV and herpes genitalis.
g. Caphalopelvic disproportion
This cases marked by pelvic deformity. In early pregnancy pelvic
circumferences measurements needs to do so can predict whether the
pelvic at the normal state while giving birth.
h. Power to give birth
Vaginal delivery needs extra energy to push the baby out. So
mother in weak condition, cesarean section is the solution.
i. Repeat caesarean section
Patient that had a previous caesarean section, needs concern from
obstetric specialist. However there is a statement once a caesarean
not always a cesarean. This statement shows that a caesarean can do
vaginal delivery and still needs to consul to the specialist.
2. Condition of the baby
a. Fetal distress
32
This condition has become a common indication, signaled by
electronic fetal monitoring and confirmed by pH of scalp blood. The
condition which the heartbeat of fetal getting slower, the normal vale
is 120-160. This fetal needs caesarean section.
b. Placenta praevia
Placenta praevia is position of placenta in a wrong place at uterus
or close the birth canal.
c. Prolapse of cord
Prolapse of cord is a condition that position of cord at the birth
canal before the baby. Entwined baby needs to do caesarean section,
but sometimes it is not dangerous for the baby, it depends how tight
the cord.
d. Malpresentations and malpositions of child
Breech, face, brow or shoulder presentation in persistently unstable
position have high risk in doing vaginal delivery. This condition be
accompanied by others factors such as maturity and size of the infant,
size of the pelvic, and age of the patient.
33
jabatan atau pekerjaannya sementara, dipidana dengan pidana penjara
selama lamanya sembilan bulan atau pidana dengan pidana kurungan
selama-lamanya enam bulan atau pidana denda setinggi-tingginya empat
ribu lima ratus rupiah.
As for Article 359 of the Criminal Code, which states:
Barang siapa karena kesalahannya (kealpaannya) menyebabkan orang
lain mati, diancam dengan pidana penjara paling lama lima tahun atau pidana
kurungan paling lama satu tahun
First, when an element of negligence on the actions of doctors can be
proved, then the Criminal Code Article 359 or 360 can be imposed on
physicians who perform acts that result in serious injury or loss of life of
patients. Second, sanctions against medical malpractice is rendered
disciplinary action is determined by a panel of health workers to discipline
physicians who, according to the Council of negligence. As for the
compensation that must be fulfilled by the concerned doctor carried out in
accordance with the legislation in force. Applicable legistlation governing
compensation can refer to the book of the law of Civil Law. (Diputra et al.,
2013)
34
b. Spoken agreement
c. Agreement based on condition
Application of Informed consent:
1. In cases involving surgery / operation
2. In cases involving treatment that uses new technologies not yet fully
understood the side effects
3. In cases of therapy or medication that may cause many side effects, such
as laser therapy, etc.
4. In cases of refusal of patients
Informed consent in an emergency situation is not necessary because
some of the things that there is no chance to ask for informed consent,
andthere is no time to procrastinate, an action must be taken immediately,
to save lives or limbs (life or limb saving) based onPermenkes No. 290
2008 Article 4
This is also confirmed in Permenkes about informed consent Article
11, which written : "In the situationthat the patient is not conscious /
unconscious and not accompanied by his closest family, and medically in
an emergency condition or in an emergency requiring immediate medical
action for their own interests, not necessary approval from anyone ".
35
shes not in the conditions of having the rights to give the consent). But 20
minutes after caesarian section, Mrs. Ita is dead, and the family sue the doctors
for malpractice. Malpractice here means theres something wrong when the
caesarian section is given to Mrs. Ita. But the operation has been done according
to standard operational procedure (SOP). Below are comparation of the laws that
support the doctors and support the patient.
Support the doctor Support the patient
Permenkes no. 290/Menkes/Per/III/2008 UU no. 36 tahun 2009 Article 8
Article 4 act 1,2,3 Setiap orang berhak memperoleh informasi
Dalam keadaan gawat darurat, untuk tentang data kesehatan dirinya termasuk
menyelamatkan jiwa pasien dan/atau tindakan dan pengobatan yang telah maupun
mencegah kecacatan tidak diperlukan yang akan diterimanya dari tenaga
persetujuan tindakan kedokteran kesehatan
Keputusan untuk melakukan tindakan
kedokteran sebagaimana dimaksud pada ayat
(1) diputuskan oleh dokter atau dokter gigi
dan dicatat di dalam rekam medik.
Dalam hal dilakukannya tindakan kedokteran
sebagaimana dimaksud pada ayat (1), dokter
atau dokter gigi wajib memberikan penjelasan
sesegera mungkin kepada pasien setelah
pasien sadar atau kepada keluarga terdekat
UU no. 29 tahun 2004 Article 51d UU no. 29 tahun 2004 Article 45 act 5
Dokter atau dokter gigi dalam melaksanakan Setiap tindakan kedokteran atau
praktik kedokteran mempunyai kewajiban : d. kedokteran gigi yang mengandung risiko
Melakukan pertolongan darurat atas dasar tinggi harus diberikan dengan persetujuan
perikemanusiaan, kecuali bila ia yakin ada tertulis yang ditandatangani oleh yang
orang lain yang bertugas dan mampu berhak memberikan persetujuan
melakukannya
UU no. 36 tahun 2009 Article 32 act 1
Dalam keadaan darurat, fasilitas pelayanan
kesehatan baik pemerintah maupun swasta
36
wajib memberikan pelayanan kesehatan bagi
penyelamatan nyawa pasien dan pencegahan
kecacatan terlebih dahulu.
37
PART III PROBLEM SOLVING
3.1 Final Concept Mapping
Pregnant
woman
is
on
emergency
Mechonial aspiration
Mechonial
detected
syndrome
Principle of law
3.4 Conclusion
Mrs. Itas family sue the doctor that suspected doing malpractice after having
Caesarian section that done by the doctor to Mrs. Ita. Mrs. Ita came to the hospital in a state
of prolonged parturition, had previously come to the clinic with a diagnosis already in the
second stage of the opening of labor, but after 8 hours, there was no progress, even looked
presence of meconium. This causes Mrs. Ita referred to the hospital. Meconium appears may
cause Meconial aspiration syndrome which would harm the fetus and the mother. The
decision for immediate Caesarian section is the right decision. For that the doctors asked for
informed consent to the family verbally, it is permissible because Mrs. Ita condition was in
emergency situation.
The doctor who did Mrs. Itas Caesarian sectionis a doctor who has a competency,
the whole action was done according to the SOP and was written in the record medic.
However Mrs. Ita died 20 minutes after surgery. It is demanded by Mrs. Itas family .
Because the whole action according to SOP and was undertaken by a team of doctors who
are competent, then there is no malpractice suits, and the results of medical records can be
39
used as supporting evidence even the death of Mrs.Ita is a medical risk. So Mrs. Itas family
can not demand the doctor as malpractice suits. However, up to the time of prosecution, the
doctor did not have the written informed consent from Mrs. Itas family for doing Caesarian
section, so that can be the evidence for demanding the doctor.
40
REFERENCES
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologist. 2010. Cesarean Birth (C-section). [Online]
Accessed from:
http://www.acog.org/~/media/For%20Patients/faq006.pdf?dmc=1&ts=20120731T1617495597
[Accessed on March 24th 2016]
Anny Isfandyarie. 2006. Tanggung Jawab Hukum dan Sanksi Bagi Dokter, h. 6. Jakarta: Prestasi
Pustaka
Auckland District Health Board, 2012. Caesarean Section (CS) Pre, Peri& Post-Op Care.
Australia: Auckland District Health Board . Available from:
http://nationalwomenshealth.adhb.govt.nz/Portals/0/Documents/Policies/Caesarean%20Section_.
pdf [Accessed 25 March 2016].
Bal, B. Sonny. "An Introduction To Medical Malpractice In The United States". Clinical
Orthopaedics and Related Research 467.2 (2008): 339-347. (online) available at:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2628513/
"Caesarean Section". better health channel. N.p., 2016. Web. 24 Mar. 2016.
Ethan D. Grober, John M.A. Bohnen. Defining Medical Error. Canadian Journal of Surgery
48.1 (2005): 39. (online) available at : www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3211566/ (22
March 2016)
F. Oyebode. Clinical Errors And Medical Negligence,-Pubmed-NCBI. N.p. (online) available
at : www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23343656 (22 March 2016)
FRY J. Why patients go to hospital: a study of usage. Br Med J. 1959 Dec 12;2(5162):1322
1327.[PMC free article] [PubMed]
HOPKINS P. Referrals in general practice. Br Med J. 1956 Oct 13;2(4997):873877. [PMC free
article] [PubMed]
41
I Gede Indra Diputra et al. 2013. Pertanggungjawaban Pidana terhadap Dokter yang Melakukan
Tindakan Malpraktik Dikaji dari Kitab Undang-Undang Hukum Pidana Indonesia. Bali:
Universitas Udayana
Kementrian Kesehatan Republik Indonesia, 2013, Buku Saku Pelayanan Kesehatan Ibu di
Fasilitas Kesehatan Dasar dan Rujukan.
Loudon IS. The contribution of general practitioner hospitals. J R Coll Gen Pract. 1972
Apr;22(117):220226. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
Mayo Clinic, 2015. Test and Procedures C-section. USA: Mayo Clinic. Available from:
http://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/c-section/basics/what-you-can-expect/prc-20014571
[accessed: 25 March 2016].
Myerscough, P.R. Operative Obstetrics. Tenth Edition. London: Bailliere Tindall, 1982.
Oddie JA, Vine SM, Hasler JC, Bennett AE. The community hospital. A pilot trial. Lancet. 1971
Aug 7;2(7719):308310. [PubMed]
Pane, Nur Adha. "Pelaksanaan Asuhan Persalinan Normal Bidan Praktek Swasta (BPS) Di
Kecamatan Lubuk Pakam Tahun 2008". Repository.usu.ac.id. N.p., 2011. Web. 25 Mar. 2016.
Werner, David, Thuman, Carol & Maxwell, Jane, 1980, When There is no Doctor, Hesperian
Foundation, USA.
Wilson JB. Referral to hospital. Health Bull (Edinb) 1971 Oct;29(4):186187. [PubMed]
42
WOOD LA. THE SIGNPOST. A STUDY OF REFERRALS IN A RURAL PRACTICE. J Coll
Gen Pract. 1964 Sep;8:223231. [PMC free article] [PubMed
43