00
# 2005 Institution of Chemical Engineers
www.icheme.org/journals Trans IChemE, Part A, February 2005
doi: 10.1205/cherd.03289 Chemical Engineering Research and Design, 83(A2): 196204
T
he stripping of ammonia from aqueous solutions in the presence of carbon dioxide in
the low concentration region is studied experimentally and theoretically. The phase
equilibria method of Edwards et al. (1978) is selected by comparison of different
methods with newer experimental data. The differential two adjacent films model enabling
component fluxes calculations is used in a stripper model. In the experimental part the sys-
tems NH3 water air and CO2 water air are used in order to select the best physical
mass transfer coefficients correlations. The system NH3 CO2 water-air modified with
strong acids or bases is used for experimental verification of the process model in a wide
range of process variables. Model predictions in conditions of negative enhancement of
mass transfer are presented. The influence of this effect on ammonia stripping efficiency in
the presence of carbon dioxide is analysed.
196
STRIPPING OF AMMONIA FROM AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS 197
Trans IChemE, Part A, Chemical Engineering Research and Design, 2005, 83(A2): 196204
198 BUDZIANOWSKI and KOZIOL
Electroneutrality:
X
NC
zi Ci (x) 0 (11)
i1
Fluxes:
dCNH3
NNH3 DLNH3 j (12a)
dx x0
dCCO2
NCO2 DLCO2 j (12b)
dx x0
Figure 3. CCO2 distribution in the gasliquid boundary layers (case 1: NH3 STRIPPER MODEL
in excess). CiCO2 0.0119 mol m23, CbCO2 6.80 1024 mol m23,
Cb,Tot 23 b
CO2 10 mol m , p CO2 31 Pa, NCO2 2.12 10
26
mol m22 s21, A stripper model developed here is based on flux calcu-
ECO2 2.53. lation. The parameters required were carefully collected
Trans IChemE, Part A, Chemical Engineering Research and Design, 2005, 83(A2): 196204
STRIPPING OF AMMONIA FROM AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS 199
dpi Ni aAk P
(13a)
dz G
dCi Ni aAk
(13b)
dz VL
L 2=3 2 L 1=9
gz r gz r
kiL ae 2:5 103
EXPERIMENTAL PART
ah L hL
L3 L 3 1=4 L 1=2 The experiments were carried out in a steel column with
W h a h
(15) an internal diameter of 0.1 m and a height of 1 m filled with
2
gz r L4 r DLi
L
15 mm ceramic Rashig rings (Figure 7). Ammonia and
Figure 7. Experimental set-up. 1, stripper; 2, fan; 3, pump; 4, tanks; 5, heater; 6, humidifier; T, thermocouple.
Trans IChemE, Part A, Chemical Engineering Research and Design, 2005, 83(A2): 196204
200 BUDZIANOWSKI and KOZIOL
Trans IChemE, Part A, Chemical Engineering Research and Design, 2005, 83(A2): 196204
STRIPPING OF AMMONIA FROM AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS 201
Figure 11. CNH3 and CCO2 profiles, ENH3 24.1. Figure 13. CNH3 and CCO2 profiles, ENH3 1.06, ECO2 22.2.
here the negative enhancement of mass transfer. Ammonia Absorption of carbon dioxide results in an decrease of
and carbon dioxide may directly react in the liquid phase hydroxyl ions and free ammonia concentration in the
to form ammonium carbamate. Reactions (2) and (6) liquid film. Ammonia is absorbed although its total driving
in absorption/desorption of CO2 result in consumption/ force is negative indicating desorption in a physical pro-
production of OH2 in the liquid film. Carbamate ion cess, ENH3 22.4. Ammonia is produced/consumed in
transports both compounds in the film since its depletion the region of large CO2 driving force mainly by reaction
results in larger driving force. The decrease/increase of (1) i.e., r(1) (4)
NH3 r NH3. The mechanism of depletion of NH3
hydroxyl ion concentration in the liquid film shifts the in the liquid film is connected with reactions of absorbed
instantaneous reaction (1) into the direction of free CO2 which results in depletion of hydroxyl ions which in
ammonia consumption/production. All those effects accom- turn shifts reaction (1) into hydrolysis of free NH3 in the
panying carbon dioxide mass transfer influence an ammo- film.
nia flux. As a result an ammonia flux is dependent on a Desorption of ammonia results in a decrease of hydroxyl
carbon dioxide flux which may result in the effect of ions and an increase of carbon dioxide concentration in the
negative enhancement of mass transfer. In the case liquid film. A carbon dioxide flux changes its direction in
when ammonia driving force (calculated here as the differ- the liquid film. CO2 is desorbed although its total driving
ence between the interface and bulk concentrations) force is positive indicating absorption in a physical process,
is positive whereas the flux is negative, the ammonia ECO2 22.2.
enhancement factor is negative. The profiles in the gas Absorption of ammonia results in an increase of hydroxyl
and liquid films are shown in Figures 11 14, data used ions and a decrease of carbon dioxide concentration in the
are in Table 1. liquid film. Carbon dioxide is absorbed although its total
Desorption of carbon dioxide results in an increase of driving force is negative indicating desorption in a physical
hydroxyl ions and free ammonia concentration in the process, ECO2 224.7. Carbon dioxide is produced/con-
liquid film. An ammonia flux changes its direction in the sumed in the region of large ammonia driving force
liquid film. The ammonia interfacial flux is increased, mainly by reaction (4) i.e., r(4) (2) (6)
CO2 rCO2 rCO2. The
ENH3 24.1. mechanism of depletion of CO2 in the liquid film is
Figure 12. CNH3 and CCO2 profiles, ENH3 22.4. Figure 14. CNH3 and CCO2 profiles, ECO2 224.7.
Trans IChemE, Part A, Chemical Engineering Research and Design, 2005, 83(A2): 196204
202 BUDZIANOWSKI and KOZIOL
CbOH2 2.66 1025, mol m23 CbNH2COO2 1.49 1026, mol m23
gas comp. (Figure 11) pbCO2 31, Pa
pbNH3 0, Pa
gas comp. (Figure 12) pbCO2 10 000, Pa
pbNH3 0.0003, Pa Figure 16. Dependence of CO2 flux on NH3 driving force.
23 23
Cb,Tot
NH3 200 mol m , Cb,Tot
CO2 67 mol m , pbNH3 04000 Pa,
liquid composition b
pCO2 60 Pa.
(Figures 13 and 14)
23 23
Cb,Tot
NH3 200, mol m Cb,Tot
CO2 67, mol m
CbNH3 100, mol m23 CbCO2 0.001, mol m23
CbOH2 0.025, mol m23 CbNH2COO2 12.7, mol m23 bulk contains no ammonia in the example. This is not the
gas comp. (Figure 13) pbCO2 100, Pa case in Figure 18 and ECO2 becomes negative for large
pbNH3 0, Pa positive ammonia driving force.
gas comp. (Figure 14) pbCO2 60, Pa If wastewater already contain large amount of CO2 it
pbNH3 4000, Pa
should be considered that ammonia flux is a function of
CO2 driving force (Figure 15). Desorption of CO2 (negative
driving force) increases an ammonia flux in stripping. So
interfacial concentration of CO2 should be kept as low as
connected with direct reaction of absorbed ammonia with possible. Such conditions are enhanced by low gas phase
free CO2. CO2 content and low CO2 mass transfer resistance in the
Driving force is used here as CiCO2 2 CbCO2 or CiNH3 2 gas phase. Carbon dioxide is then firstly responsible for
b
CNH3. Absorption of CO2 (positive driving force) decreases higher pH value at the interphase than in the bulk, then sec-
an ammonia flux while desorption of CO2 (negative driving ondly acts as a transporting compound which transports
force) increases an ammonia flux in stripping (Figure 15). ammonia bounded as carbamate from the bulk to the inter-
The effect of negative enhancement of mass transfer phase. On the other hand if waste gas containing large
increases with absolute value of CO2 driving force. The amount of CO2 is used for stripping purposes the two
same may be concluded for CO2 (Figure 16). mechanisms indicated are responsible for low pH at the
It is shown in Figure 17 that the enhancement factor of interphase and the transport of ammonia from the
ammonia tends to +infinity when the physical ammonia interphase into the bulk in the form of carbamate.
flux tends to zero. For large positive driving force of
carbon dioxide only ENH3 0 is possible since the gas
Figure 15. Dependence of NH3 flux on CO2 driving force. Figure 17. Dependence of ENH3 on CO2 driving force.
23 23 23 23
Cb,Tot
NH3 0.624 mol m , Cb,Tot
CO2 1 mol m , pbNH3 0 Pa, pbCO2 Cb,Tot
NH3 0.624 mol m , CO2 1 mol m ,
Cb,Tot pbNH3 0 Pa, pbCO2
313000 Pa. 31 3000 Pa.
Trans IChemE, Part A, Chemical Engineering Research and Design, 2005, 83(A2): 196204
STRIPPING OF AMMONIA FROM AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS 203
Trans IChemE, Part A, Chemical Engineering Research and Design, 2005, 83(A2): 196204
204 BUDZIANOWSKI and KOZIOL
Edwards, T.J., Newman, J. and Prausnitz, J.M., 1975, Thermodynamics of Shaikh, A.A. and Varma, A., 1984, Gas absorption chemical reactions. The
aqueous solutions containing volatile weak electrolytes. AIChE J, 21: case involving a volatile liquid component. Chem Eng Sci, 39:
248 259. 16391641.
Eigen, M. and Schoen, J., 1955, Stobspannungsverfahren zur Untersu- van Swaaij, W.P.M. and Versteeg, G.F., 1992, Mass transfer accompanied
chung sehr schnell verlaufender Ionenreaktion in wasseriger Losung. with complex reversible chemical reactions in gas liquid systems: an
Zeitschrift fur Elektrochemie, 59: 483 494. overview. Chem Eng Sci, 47: 31813195.
Goppert, U. and Maurer G., 1988, Vapor-liquid equilibria in aqueous Vas Bhat, R.D., van Swaaij, W.P.M., Kuipers, J.A.M. and Versteeg, G.F.,
solutions of ammonia and carbon dioxide at temperatures between 1999a, Mass transfer with complex chemical reactions in gas liquid
333 and 393 K and pressures up to 7 MPa. Fluid Phase Equi, 41: systemsI. Consecutive reversible chemical reactions with equal diffu-
153 185. sivities. Chem Eng Sci, 54: 121 136.
Hikita, H., Asai, S. and Ishikawa, H., 1977, Simultaneous absorption of Vas Bhat, R.D., van Swaaij, W.P.M., Kuipers, J.A.M. and Versteeg, G.F.,
two gases which react between themselves in a liquid. Ind Chem Eng 1999b, Mass transfer with complex chemical reactions in gas liquid sys-
Fund, 16: 215219. temsII. Effect of unequal diffusivities on consecutive reactions. Chem
Kawazuishi, K. and Prausnitz, J.M., 1987, Correlation of vapor-liquid Eng Sci, 54: 137147.
equilibria for the system ammonia-carbon-dioxide-water. Ind & Eng Vas Bhat, R.D., Kuipers, J.A.M. and Versteeg, G.F., 2000, Mass transfer
Chem Res, 26: 14821485. with complex chemical reactions in gas liquid systems: two step revers-
Kurz, F., Rumpf, B. and Maurer, G., 1995, Vaporliquidsolid equilibria ible reactions with unit stoichiometric and kinetic orders. Chem Eng J,
in the system NH3 CO2 H2O from around 310 to 470 K: New experi- 76: 127 152.
mental data and modeling. Fluid Phase Equil, 104: 261275. Versteeg, G.F., Kuipers, J.A.M., van Beckum, F.P.H. and van Swaaij,
Maurer, G., 1986, Phase equilibria in chemically reactive systems. Fluid W.P.M., 1989, Mass transfer with complex reversible chemical reac-
Phase Equil, 30: 337352. tionsI. Single reversible chemical reaction. Chem Eng Sci, 44:
Mohunta, D.M., Vaidyanathan, G.S. and Laddha, G.S., 1969, Effective 22952310.
interfacial areas in packed columns. Ind Chem Eng, 11: 3942. Versteeg, G.F., Kuipers, J.A.M., van Beckum, F.P.H. and van Swaaij,
Ozturk, S.S. and Shah, Y.T., 1986, Gas absorption with chemical reaction W.P.M., 1990, Mass transfer with complex reversible chemical reac-
involving a liquid reactant: penetration theory solution. Chem Eng Sci, tionsII. Parallel reversible chemical reactions. Chem Eng Sci, 45:
46: 6571. 183197.
Pangarkar, V.G., 1974, Gas absorption with reaction in a solution contain- Wilson, G.M., 1980, A new correlation of NH3, CO2, and H2S volatility
ing a volatile reactant. Chem Eng Sci, 29: 877 882. data from aqueous sour water systems. U.S. Environmental Protection
Pawlikowski, E.M., Newman, J. and Prausnitz, J.M., 1982, Phase equili- Agency, EPA-600/2-80-067.
bria for aqueous solutions of ammonia and carbon dioxide. Ind Eng Yu, W.C. and Astarita, G., 1987a, Selective absorption of hydrogen sul-
Chem Proc Des Dev, 21: 764 770. phide in tertiary amine solutions. Chem Eng Sci, 42: 419424.
Pinsent, B.R.W., Pearson, L. and Roughton F.J.W., 1956a, The kinetics of Yu, W.C. and Astarita, G., 1987b, Design of packed towers for selective
combination of carbon dioxide with hydroxide ions. Trans of the Fara- chemical absorption. Chem Eng Sci, 42: 425433.
day Soc, 52: 15121520.
Pinsent, B.R.W., Pearson, L. and Roughton F.J.W., 1956b, The kinetics of
combination of carbon dioxide with ammonia. Trans of the Faraday
Soc, 52: 15951598.
Puranik, S.S. and Vogelpohl A., 1974, Effective interfacial area in irrigated
packed columns. Chem Eng Sci, 29: 501 507. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Rajniak, P., Kralik, M. and Ilavsky J., 1992, A steady state equation-
oriented simulator for separation processes of solutions with weak elec- The authors wish to thank State Committee for Scientific Research
trolytes. Comp Chem Eng, 16: S457S464. (Poland) for their financial support to this investigation.
Roper, G.H., Hatch, T.F. and Pigford, R.L., 1962, Theory of absorption
and reaction of two gases in a liquid. Ind Eng Chem Fundamentals, 1: The manuscript was received 21 July 2003 and accepted for publication
144 152. after revision 7 December 2004.
Trans IChemE, Part A, Chemical Engineering Research and Design, 2005, 83(A2): 196204