Brief Description
century American scientific and technical texts. Through vivid and often beautiful
medicine, and engineering across the medium's first six decades. The goal is to reveal
photographic evidence, and the philosophy of science in the American culture of the
period. The examples presented are many vast and rich. Scientists and illustrators sought
methods for integrating new photographic imagery into the older communications
offrom its metal plates. Yet the detailed realism of the daguerreotype fueled a desire to
integrate photographic images directly into written arguments without the intervening
At the same time that scientists made innovative improvements in the technology of
photography, they also sought to discover new information about the nature of light
itself, including qualities of spectra beyond visible light the ultraviolet, infrared, and
eventually, x-rays. As the century progressed, the desire for improved photographs
drove the development of new materials and imaging methods in fields like optical
science, microscopy, and astronomy. Americans took leading roles in this work in several
areas, embracing the technology of the camera and light-sensitive plate and adapting it
whose photo-illustrated work is featured in this book are the chemist and physicist John
James Deane (1801-1858), the astronomer Henry Draper (1837-1882), the physician and
microscopist Joseph Janvier Woodward (1833-1884), and the engineer Octave Chanute
(1832-1910). While these authors will not be familiar to most lay readers, they produced
important work in their disciplines, and biographical information will be included about
each.
What categories of claims for truth can we recognize for scientific and
texts, and how did these conventions change, and in response to what
Outstanding Features
The chief highlight of the book will be its rich imagery selected from photo-based
illustrations published between 1839 and 1900 in the natural sciences, medicine, and
engineering. In each case, history is revealed through the author's attitude toward the
nature and power of photography and photo-illustration. In all, some 158 figures are
drawn from more than 60 photo-illustrated texts in science and technology that reflect
innovative photographic methods and written arguments. All are nineteenth century
Wickliff4
texts for which copyright protections have expired and most are in government
collections. I have also been able to purchase a small number of primary texts myself,
and from those, have created high resolution CMYK scans of key images.
Another highlight of the book is its close connections to the Smithsonian Institution
where the Lemelson Center is housed. In the summer of 2014 I was resident fellow in the
Dibner Library for the History of Science and Technology in the National Museum of
with the Archives Center of the NMAH. The book highlights this research and points to
holdings in the Smithsonian Libraries, the NMAH Archives Center, the Photographic
History Division, the Physical Sciences Division, and the National Portrait Gallery. Other
materials are drawn from the Library of Congress, the National Museum of Health and
Medicine, the National Library of Medicine, as well as the Special Collections at the
Competition
cultural critics. Early photographs have most often been treated as part of the art history
tradition less often as artifacts of the culture of science and technology. Much
Matthew Brady as described by Alan Tractenberg and William Welling, but less so the
William Draper and Samuel Finley Breese Morse, although Sarah Kate Gillespies recent
book in the Lemelson series begins to address that gap. We are moved by the Western
Bacon Hales and William Truettner, but have difficulty interpreting the scope and import
of the government-sponsored geological surveys for which their images were created.
Other historians, too numerous to list, have examined closely the significance of
French and British traditions, including the earliest surviving images made by Joseph
Nicphore Nipce, the subsequent photographs by Louis Jacques Mand Daguerre, the
paper-based images and innovative book illustration of William Henry Fox Talbot. Yet
including the camera obscura, the daguerreian camera, the wet and dry plate processes,
This book participates in a conversation about cultural history of the kind that Susan
Barger, Carol Armstrong, Mary Warner Marien, Martha Sandweiss, Ann Thomas,
Jennifer Tucker, Stephen Bann, Johana Drucker, and Sarah Kate Gillespie have written.
Published histories of modern science often pay scant attention to the roles of
photography in establishing claims for truth, and most histories of photography attend
Wickliff6
only rather narrowly to the sweep of science in the era from which they were produced.
The exceptions include the works of Franois Brunet and Kelley Wilder. Scholars of
writing and rhetoric, too, have seldom explicitly focused attention on the claims made
for and by the images appearing in historic publications a rich bound context of
intellectually separated from its written context. Richard Bensons work begins to
address issues of reproduction and process in The Printed Picture, but the focus is not
primarily upon the history of the works from which the examples are selected.
textures, tones, colors, cropping, and methods of reproduction all affect a reading of the
cultural artifact, a persuasive or not-so-persuasive claim for the truth or the worth of an
technical publications because it is there that authors reveal their attitudes toward
observation and representation itself (Jonathan Crary, Techniques of the Observer), and
Wickliff7
even toward the social and ethical roles of the scientist or engineer in a century
dominated by debates over race, slavery, and the Civil War (Molly Rogers, Delias Tears).
Apparatus
The book will include figures, a glossary, a bibliography of primary sources, a list of
graphic technologies. No supplementary materials beyond the book itself are planned at
this time.
Audience
The book will have several audiences, including lay and professional readers of the
history of photography, lay and professional readers of the history of science and
especially valuable for student readers interested in the history and illustration of
technical and scientific communication in America. Four of the chapters build upon
The chapter focused upon Civil War era medicine and technology may also attract
readers interested in the cultural effects of that conflict. The work does not assume
previous familiarity with the history of photography, but does include specialized
Wickliff8
some vocabulary from the scientific disciplines. Each term will be defined on first
Market Considerations
This book should appeal to readers interested in the history of photography, the
and students of scientific and technical communication. The book might also be able to
support museum exhibitions on the history of American science and photography. It will
showcase a large number of photographs that are outside the canon of popular images
from nineteenth-century America, each of which helps to tell a story about science,
medicine, and the authors and illustrators who created it. A good deal of biographical
information will be included about each major figure whose photographic work is
featured. The book should appeal to members of the History of Science Society, the
Society for the History of Technology, the Society for Technical Communication, the
Association of Teachers of Technical Writing, The American Association for the History
of Medicine, the American Philosophical Society, the Daguerreian Society, and similar
organizations.
The introduction and chapters are drafted. The supporting apparatus is currently
being drafted, and editing of the entire work could be completed by August 2017. In
double-spaced type, the text is 322 pages in manuscript. The book will have an
Reviewers
immediatedescendants,hasdevolvedthedutyofdevelopingonascalehithertounknown
inthisworldtheresourcesofthegiantempire,whichisgoingtostretchfromtheAtlantic
tothePacificocean.Themenarenowbornwhowillheartheloudsnortofthe
locomotiveinthedesertsbeyondtheRockyMountains.Nosystemofeducationthathas
everyetbeentriedwillmeetourwants.Wewantmeansfortherapiddevelopmentofall
ourpowersmeansfortherapiddevelopmentofallourresources.Thesoilbeneathus
teemswithwealth;ourpopulationisincreasingbeyondallexample;wearemenof
enterpriseandenergy,livinginaperiodoftheearth'shistoryunlikeanythathas
preceded,whentheforceofintellectisfastsupplantingallotherpowers,andundera
governmenttheconstitutionofwhichhasnoexample. 1
Delta[JohnWilliamDraper]SouthernLiteraryMessenger,1840
Itseemsmorethancuriousthatthedevelopmentofsuccessfulphotographyandthe
electromagnetictelegraphsocloselycoincide,inthecastofkeyindividualsaswellasthe
periodoftime(seeFigure124).SamuelMorseandJohnWilliamDraperseemtohave
beenswepttowardeachotherintheFfallof1839,withtheirsharedexperimentsin
photographyandelectricity.ByAprilof1840theywouldoperateadaguerreotypestudio
togetherfromtheroofoftheUniversityoftheCityofNewYork,andbegintotraina
generationofphotographers.Inresearchingtheelectromagnetictelegraphy,bothhad
studiedtheresearchofJosephHenry,whowouldbecomethefirstsecretaryofthe
Wickliff11
SmithsonianInstitutionin1846.Henryhadpublishedapaperin1831thatexplainedthe
designandconstructionofalargeelectromagnet,theprincipalofanelectromagnetic
switch,operatedatadistanceacrossacoilofwire.Morsecontributionwastorecognize
thepracticalapplicationofsuchadevicetotreatitasadistancecommunication
technology,topatentaspecificdesignintheU.S.andabroad,andtosuccessfullydefend
hisinnovationsagainsttheinroadsofotherwouldbeentrepreneurs.Communications
processesanddevicessoonbecamethestuffofpatentwars.
Thenineteenthcenturyhadbegunwithaperiodofrelatedchangesintransportation
engineeringandcommunicationtechnologyintheUnitedStates.Steamboatsfirstmoved
uptheMississippiin1811,andatthesametime,FriedrichKoenigssteamprintingpress
inLondonwasbeginningtofacilitatearevolutionintheavailabilityofinexpensivetexts
andaparallelriseinpopularliteracy.CanalbuildingwaswidespreadintheUnitedStates
bythe1820sand30s.Railroadswerealreadyexpandingrapidlybetweenmajorcitieseast
oftheMississippiinthe1830sand40s.SamuelFinleyBreeseMorse,buildingonthe
workofJosephHenryandwiththesupportattheUniversityoftheCityofNewYork
fromLeonardGale,AlfredVail,andevenfromJohnWilliamDraper,developedand
testedhiselectromagnetictelegraphacrosslongerandlongerstretchesofwirefrom1837
forward.In1854,thefatherofthesteamnavy,MatthewCalbraithPerry,commandedthe
U.S.S.PowhatanasheconcludedhistreatynegotiationswiththeJapanese,expandingthe
reachofU.S.trade(seeFigure125).Then,asnow,transportationengineeringwas
makingtheglobefeelsmaller.Beginningin1856,aseriesoflessthancompletely
successfultransatlanticcableswerelaid,withAmerican,British,French,andGerman
Wickliff12
ownedlines(SeeFigure126).By1865,theAmericanCivilwarincreasedthepaceof
developmentoftherailroadsandtelegraphnetworksacrosstheNorthAmerican
continent.InJapanandacrosstheUnitedStates,photographerscapturedimageswiththe
technologyofcamera.By1844,Draperhadinventedachemicallightmeterthathecalled
thetithonometer,designedwiththegoalofquantifyinglightenergyinthesamewaythat
steamenergyhadbeenharnessedandmeasured(seeFigure127).
ThepushacrossthefarWestthatDraperhadanticipatedinhis1840articleforthe
SouthernLiteraryMessengerabouttheJamesSmithsonbequesthadbecomeareality
longbefore1860,buttheU.S.CivilWardivertedresourcesfromlargescalecivilian
engineeringdevelopment.ThewarhadseenuseofphotographyonthefieldofBattleby
cameraoperatorsretainedbyMatthewBradyandAlexanderGardner,aswellasoneof
theU.S.ArmysownsoldiersinthecaseofAndrewJ.Russell(seeFigure128),andtheir
imagesservedasthebasisforengravingsinthenewsmagazinesoftheera(seeFigure
129).FollowingthesuccessofJamesWallaceBlackinphotographingBostonfromahot
airballoonin1860,headvocatedtheuseofthesametechniquebyCoastSurvey,directed
byAlexanderDallasBache,andbytheArmysTopographicalEngineers,whodirected
theexperimentalworkwithballoonsbyThaddeusLowe.TheU.S.Armyraisedaballoon
corpsunderLoweforthepurposeofobservingenemymovementsandinJune1861,
LowedemonstratedaerialreconnaissancetelegraphyinWashington.Atthesametime,
DraperandothermembersoftheAmericanPhotographicalSocietyadvocatedforthe
potentialvalueofaerialphotography(seeFigure130).2Despitemediaattentioninthe
popularpress(seeFigure131),neithertransportationnorcommunicationtechnologies
Wickliff13
weredeeplyshapedbythewartimeexperimentofreconnaissanceballooning.Butwhen
theU.S.CivilWardrewtoitsclose,PresidentLincolnimmediatelybegantheprocessof
divestingthemilitaryofenormousamountsofmoreconventionalresourceshumanand
technological.Civiliantechnologicaldevelopmentwasrekindledininnumerable
directions,whiletheassassinationofLincolndrewtogetherindividualsfromallwalksof
lifeinsummationofthelossesofthewar.JosephJanvierWoodwardcontinuedthework
inphotomicrographythatwouldleadtowardSternbergssuccessesinbacteriology,and
participatedintheautopsiesofbothLincolnandJohnWilkesBooth.OctaveChanute,as
anengineerontherapidlyexpandingChicago&AltonRailroad,traveledthefinallegof
Lincolnshomewardjourney,fromChicagotoSpringfield,justaheadofthefuneraltrain
itself,makingsurethetracksweresafeandclear.3AndasLincolnsbodywaslaidtorest,
thefederalgovernmentbegantodivestitselfofthematerialsofwar.JohnWilliam
Draperwouldcatalogtheprocessinhis1867threevolumehistoryofthewar,oneofthe
earliesthistoricalaccountsofthewar,drawnlargelyfromtherecordsofSecretary
StantonandGeneralSherman.AsDraperreportsit,byNovember1866,afederal
militarythathadatonetimeapproachedtwomillioninservicehadbeendisbanded,
leavinginservice11,043volunteers,whiteandcolored.4Aspartofthecivilian
politicalshifts,themilitarytransportationandcommunicationsinfrastructurewassoon
soldoffaswell:
Of262vesselswhichhadbeenemployedoninlandtransportationatanexpenseof
$4,193,53328,nonewereremaininginserviceonJune30,1866;salesofriver
transports,steamers,andbargesduringtheyeararereportedasamountingto$1,152,895
92.Themilitaryrailroadswhichwereoperatedduringthewar,atatotalexpenditureof
Wickliff14
$45,422,71915,andwhichareofficiallyreportedtohavereachedanextentof2630
miles,andtohavepossessed433locomotivesand6605cars,haveallbeentransferredto
companiesorboardsorpublicworks,uponconditionoftheadoptionofloyal
organizationsofdirectors....Themilitarytelegraph,whichattaintedanextentof
15,389milesoflines,constructedduringthehostilities,withatotalexpenditureof
$3,219,400duringthewar,and$367,637duringthelastfiscalyear,hasbeen
discontinued,thematerialsoldanddisposedof,andtheemployeesdischarged.... 5
Investorswerelookingtorebuildandtocreatenewpostwarmarkets.Consequently,the
transportationofpeopleandgoodswascentraltothepostwareconomy.Althoughthe
nationhadexpandedwestwardquicklyfollowingtheMexicanWarandduringthe
Californiagoldrush,transportationtotheWestcoastwasdifficultatbest.AsSimine
Short,thebiographerofthetransportationpioneerOctaveChanute,explainsit,atthe
closeoftheMexicanWarin1848:
ThefrontiertownofChicagosatattheedgeofcivilization,withmorethan2,100miles
ofland,unpopulatedbysettlers,separatingitformfromburgeoningCalifornia.Toreach
theWestCoast,onecouldtravelbyseadowntheEastCoast,crossthemalariainfested
IsthmusofPanamaonamule,andcontinuebyseatoCalifornia.Oronecouldsail
aroundSouthAmerica,whichtookaboutthreemonths.Alternatively,onecouldtravel
foranundeterminedtimebycoveredwagonthroughmostlyunchartedterritoryacrossthe
continent.6
WiththeCivilWarended,agreatopportunityandchallengewouldbetoestablishrail
transportationbetweentheEastandWestcoastsofthereunifiednation.Doingsowould
requirefeatsofengineering;.bBridgesneededtobeconstructedacrossmajorrivers,
mountainpassesgraded,andtunnelscut.Itwouldbeachallengeofbothgovernmentand
Wickliff15
corporatesponsoredengineering.Andthecamerawouldgoalongtodocumentthe
engineeringaccomplishments,andinsomeimages,thenaturalresourceandhumancosts
ofdevelopmentandurbanization.AstherailroadsbranchedwestfromChicagoandSt
Louis,newurbancentersgrewuprapidlyatkeyjunctions,andacontestemerged
betweentheshippinginterestsofthesouthflowingmajorrivers,andthewestwardpush
oftherailroads.Therailroadbridgesthemselveswerethelegalandtechnological
fulcrumsinthebalanceofpower.Theearliestmajorbattlewasoverthefirstrailroad
bridgeacrosstheMississippiatRockIslandIllinois,aprojectthatdatedbackto1853.
Amongtheprinciplepartiesinthe1857lawsuitoverthebridgewereAbrahamLincolnas
anattorneyfortherailroadsand,JeffersonDavisasSecretaryofWarwhoclaimedRock
Islandforthemilitaryandwantedthebridgehalted.Appealscontinueduntilin1863,
whentheU.S.Supremecourtallowedthebridgetostand.Theninthepostwar
economy,theracewasontobridgetheriversandunitetheeastandwestinavast
transportationandcommunicationnetwork.
By1867,inanemergentKansasCity,OctaveChanute,aFrenchbornAmerican
engineerwhowouldlatercollaboratewiththeWrightBrotherstowarddesignsfor
poweredflight,documentedcarefullyandphotographically,thetwoyearconstructionof
thefirstbridgeacrosstheMissouririver.Atthesametime,fartherwest,survey
expeditionswerebeingmounted,withphotographersemployedintheparties,tocarrythe
networkofrailroadsallthewayacrossthecontinent.Thesewesterncamerasand
railroadsbroughtvisualargumentsfortechnologicalprogressandprowessbackto
Easternreaderswheremuchofthepopulation,andmuchofthecapitalforcivilian
Wickliff16
investment,remainedcentered.
RailsReachWestfromChicago
ThecareerofOctaveChanute(18321910)providesanidealpointofviewthrough
whichtoenvisionandevaluatetheurgeforwestwardexpansioninofthefinaldecadesof
thecentury.Hisisthestoryofanimportanttransportationengineerwhorosefroman
unpaidlaborertochiefengineeroftheErieRailroad,fromgliderdesignertoaforefather
ofpoweredflightandcollaboratorwiththeWrightbrothers.Tounderstandhis
accomplishments,andparticularlythesignificanceofthebridgeconstructionhe
supervisedacrosstheMissouriRiveratKansasCity,weneedtounderstandhislifeasa
youngimmigrantfromFrancewhoarrivedinLouisianainDecember1838,justdays
beforeDaguerrespublicpronouncementsaboutphotographywouldfirstbereportedin
thenewspapersofParisandLondon.
AsSimineShortexplainsinherrecentbiography,ChanuteistheAmericanspelling
adoptedbyOctaveAlexandreChanut,whocametotheUnitedStatesatagesixwithishis
father,Joseph,whohadbeeninvitedtoleavehispositionasaprofessorofhistoryin
ParisattheLyceHenriIVforthepositionofvicepresidentofayoungJefferson
CollegeinLouisiana.Octavesmother,Elise,hadrequestedalegalseparationfromher
husband,whowas16yearsolderthanshe.Octavewastheoldestofthreeboysfromthe
marriage,andtheonlyonetoaccompanyhisfathertoAmericaonthealmosttwomonth
voyagefromFrance,toNewYork,toNewOrleans.Whileatfirstthefortunesofthetwo
ChanutsinLouisianaseemedwellrewarded,thedestructionofJeffersonCollegebya
firein1841becametheirundoing.Thecollegestruggledtogetbackonitsfeetand
Wickliff17
Josephwasonlypaidintermittently,soin1844heresignedandmovedwithhissonto
NewOrleans.7By1846,thefatherandsonpairwastravellinginlandtoNewYorkCity
inthehopeofmakingyetanothernewbeginning.
Asateenager,ChanutebeganworkingasachainmanontheHudsonRiverRailroad
inNewYorkasteenager,eventuallybecominganengineer.8Theworktookhimwest,to
Illinois,thenSt.Louis,andthenChicago.By1864hehadbeenmadethechiefengineer
oftheChicago&AltonRailroad,andjustmonthsaftertheCivilWarended,wasselected
todesignandbuildtheUnionStockYardsinChicago.InJuly1866,Congresspassedan
amendedOmnibusBridgeActthatincludedaprovisionthatallowedfortheconstruction
ofseveralmajorbridges,includingoneacrosstheMissouriRiver.Butthechallenges
weredaunting;t.TheMissouriwasconsideredbymanyprofessionalsunbridgeable
becauseofitsshiftingcurrentsanddeepsands.TheBostongroupinvestor,James
FrederickJoyaDetroitattorney,railwaymagnate,andformerfriendoftheassassinated
LincolnselectedChanutetodesignabridgeacrosstheriver.Chanutewaspleasedwith
thechallenge,butthebridgeacrosstheMissouriRiveratKansasCityrepresentedthe
westernfrontierin1867,andhiswifewasinthebeginningreluctanttomakethemovein
thebeginning.9Butsoontheywereinanewhomeoverlookingthebridgesite.
ClearlyChanuteintendedtomakethebridgeasignatureprojectforhimselfasvery
earlyintheprocessheretainedtheKansasCityphotographerWilliamOwenRaganas
theofficialphotographerforthetwoyearbridgeprojectforareputedcontractfeeof
$2000.10Chanuteandoneofhisassistants,GeorgeMorrison,wroteadetailedtreatise
abouttheengineeringproblemspresentedbythebridgeparticularlythesubmarine
Wickliff18
foundationsofitspiers.Overall,thebridgeworkscoveredaonemilespanwithseven
limestoneandconcretepiers.Acenterspanpivotedallowingtallboatstopass,andthe
bridgewasdesignedtobeusedbypedestriansandhorsedrawnvehicleswhentrain
trafficallowed.ThechallengesandsuccesseswerecarefullypresentedinTheKansas
CityBridge,withanAccountoftheRegimensoftheMissouriRiver,andDescriptionof
MethodsUsedforFoundinginthatRiver(1870).
Working300milesfromanygeneralmarketsormachineshopsfortwoyears,
Chanutesupervisedsteamboats,andtheworkofcrewsofmasons,carpenters,and
ironworkers(seeFigure132).Becauseoftheriversshiftingcurrentsandscouringeffect,
Chanuteconcludedthatatleastthreeofthepiersneededtorestdirectlyonbedrock.To
doso,submarinediverswereneededtofitthematerialstotheexcavatedstonesothatthe
waterinthecaissoncouldbepumpedoutandthestoneleveledtobeginthemasonry
work(seeFigure133).Itwasnosmalltask.AsaHarpersWeeklyarticleaboutthe
progressoftheworkexplained:......thecaissonwasloweredtowithinfourfeetof
thebedrock,whenacloselayerofboulderswasencountered.Theservicesofthe
submarinediverswererequiredtoremovetheseonebyone,theyworkingforawhole
month,nightandday,atadepthofaboutfiftyfeetbelowthesurfaceofthewaterwith
3000tonsofmasonryabovethem.11Bythetimethebridgenearedcompletion,telegraph
linepoleshadappearedalongitsspanaswell(seeFigure134).Thecompletedbridgewas
thesubjectofgreatcelebrationandengravings,basedonRagansphotographs,andwere
featuredinScientificAmerican(seeFigure135)aswellasHarpersWeekly.The
completedbridgebroughttogethersevenraillines,includingroutestoSt.Louis,
Wickliff19
Leavenworth,St.JosephandChicago,aswellastotheKansasPacificRailroadandthe
roughlyfourhundredandgivemilesinoperationtothewest.Justthreemonthsearlier,
A.J.Russellhadmadehisfamousphotographofthecelebrationofdrivingofthe"Last
Spike"atPromontorySummit,U.T.,May10,1869.
TheLastSpikerepresentedtheculminationofyearsofgovernmentsponsored
resourcedevelopmentintheWest.Soonafterthecloseofthewar,militaryengineering
hadbeenredirectedtowardatranscontinentalrailroad.InMarchof1867,Brigadier
GeneralA.A.Humphreys,ChiefofEngineersinthe,DepartmentofWar,gavetheyoung
geologistClarenceKingorderstodirectageologicalandtopographicalexplorationof
theterritorybetweentheRockyMountainsandtheSierraNevadamountains,including
therouteorroutesofthePacificrailroad12Thepurposeoftheexplorationwasto
examineanddescribethegeologicalstructure,geographicalconditionandnatural
resourcesofthebeltofthecountryextendingfromthe120thmeridianeastwardtothe
105thmeridian,alongthe40thparalleloflatitude,withsufficientexpansionnorthand
southtoincludethelinesoftheCentralandUnionPacificrailroads13Sobeganone
offourmajorlatenineteenthcenturygeologicalsurveysoftheAmericanWest,surveys
inwhichthelandwasremapped,renamed,photographed,andcataloged.Inoneway,it
wasaconquestofdocumentation,amissiontorecordrockformations,mountainranges,
detritalplains,mines,coaldeposits,soils,minerals,ores,salineandalkalinedeposits;,a
campaigntomapthechiefminingdistrictsandthetopographyoftheentireregion;,anda
missiontoassemblecollectionsofbotanical,geological,andethnologicalspecimens.
AmongthephotographicplatesmadefortheWesternsurveyswouldbethenowfamous
Wickliff20
imagesbyWilliamBell,E.O.Beaman,JohnK.Hillers,JamesFennemore,William
HenryJackson,TimothyOSullivan,andCarletonWatkins.TheseimagesoftheWest
suggestanineteenthcenturytraditionofnaturalresourcepreservation,butread
historically,thesurveyphotographsappearlesstheproductsofanindividualsaesthetic
sensibilityandmorereflectionsoftheeconomicandpoliticalforcesthatcolonizedthe
AmericanWestinthedecadesaftertheCivilWar.14
AmongtheprimarylongtermgoalsoftheearlyU.S.geologicalsurveyswereboth
thecelebrationandthesubjugationofnatureintheAmericanWest.Selectedviewsofthe
naturalwondersofYellowstoneandYosemitewouldfunctionaspublicityforan
incipienttouristindustrytobringeasternerswest.ImagesfromJohnWesleyPowells
voyagesthroughtheGrandCanyonwouldshowAmericantechnology,courage,and
resourcefulnessovercomingthedangersofthemightyColoradoRiver.Whileattheother
extreme,surveyphotographerswerealsodirectedtorecordimagesofdevelopingcities
likeSaltLakeCity,Utah;VirginiaCity,Nevada;andLeadville,Coloradoplaceswhere
agriculturalorminingindustrysuccessesseemedtopromisewealthandculture,thatis,
cultureinthesenseoftechnologyandartnaturereshapedforspecificends.
Thefederallysponsoredgeologicalsurveyswereprimarilycivilianeffortsthat
reinforcedthepracticesofearlierstatesponsoredsurveys.UnliketheMassachusetts
surveythatEdwardHitchcockhaddirectedinthe1830s,muchofthetopographyofthe
AmericanWesthadnotbeenofficiallymappedbeforetheCivilWar.IntheCalifornia
Geologicalsurveyof1863,keygeologicalfeatureswerestillbeingmappedforthefirst
timeoftenwiththeassistanceofnativeguidessketchedandphotographed,surveyed,
Wickliff21
andmappedbutwithlittleornoregardtoNativeAmericannomenclature.15The
governmentwasanxioustomapthenewlyannexedregionsoftheWesttoaffirmastrong
politicalunionbasedupontheinfluxofprimarilywhiteeasternimmigrants,evenatthe
costofthosealreadyinhabitingtheregion.AtYosemite,CarletonWatkinshad
photographedtheSierralandscapesforaStatesponsoredexpeditionledbyJosiah
DwightWhitneyaftertheareahadbeensetasideforpublicrecreationandusebythe
CivilWarCongressof1864.Oneofthechiefproductsofthatsurveyandits
photographicallyillustratedreport,TheYosemiteBook(1868),wasthemetaphorofthe
valleyasoneofthewildanduniquenaturalwonders,aplacetowhichEasterntourists
shouldcometohavetheirspiritsrenewed(seeFigure136).Becauseitwasatadistance
fromanyurbanareas,itheldoutthepromiseofbecominganattractionwithoutthe
commercialismthathadovertakenNiagaraFalls.Possessionofthevalley,however,
presupposedthesuccessfulremovalofnativeinhabitantswhoatonetimenumberedas
manyasfourhundredandfifty.16TheYosemitearea,intheyearafteritsdiscoveryby
whites,18511852,wasforciblyrendereduninhabited.InWhitneyssurveynarrative,
theexpulsionofAmericanIndiansisjustifiedbecauseofconflictswithwhitecultureand
aperceptionthatwhiteprogresswasinevitable.InWhitneysrendition,thebadIndians
arekilledorexiled,whilethegoodIndianassiststheexpeditionteamandisrewarded
withatopographicalappellationandacaptiontoaphotograph:photograph:
ThewhiteslivingonthestreamswhichheadinthevicinityoftheYosemitehad,in1850,
foundthemselvesunabletoliveinpeacewiththefewscatteredIndiansinthatregion,
andaftersomemurdersandmuchtrouble,amilitarycompanywasformedtodrivethem
outofthecountry.Inthecourseoftheskirmishingandfightingwhichtookplace,itwas
Wickliff22
ascertainedthattheIndianshadastrongholdorretreatfarupinthemountains,inwhich
theythoughttheycouldtakerefuge,andremainwithouttheslightestdangerofbeing
found.ThisplaceofrefugewastheYosemitevalley,andthiswasthewayitfirstcame
tobeheardofbywhitepeople....UndertheguidanceofanoldchiefnamedTenaya,
whonameisperpetuatedinthebeautifullakewhichliesbetweenMt.Hoffmannand
CathedralPeak,andinthebranchoftheMercedriverheadinginthatlake(seePlate
XXVI)thepartyreachedtheValley,droveouttheIndians,killedafew,andmade
peacewiththerest....[Now]thenumberofIndiansactuallyandpermanentlyresident
inandabouttheYosemiteortheMariposaGroveisverysmall.Liketherestoftheso
calleddiggersinCalifornia,theyareamiserable,degradedandfastdisappearingsetof
beings,whomustdieoutbeforetheprogressofthewhitemanscivilization,andfor
whomthereisneitherhopenorchance17
Inthecaptionsfortheimagesandinthenamesforgeologicalfeaturesprintedon
topographicmaps,governmentallinguisticchoices,howeverodd,carriedtheday.
Examplesarenumerous.ToquoteStephenPowersintheTribesofCalifornia
(California(1877),avolumeofJohnWesleyPowellsContributionstoNorthAmerican
Ethnology,anditselfpartoftheU.S.GeographicalandGeologicalSurveyoftheRocky
MountainRegion:
InthefirstplacetheaboriginesneverknewofanysuchlocalityasYosemiteValley.
Second,thereisnotnowandtherehasnotbeenanythinginthevalleywhichtheycall
Yosemite.Third,theynevercalledOldEphraimhimselfYosemite,noristhereany
suchwordintheMiwoklanguage....Thevalleyhasalwaysbeenknowntothem,and
istothisday,whenspeakingamongthemselves,asAwani.ThewordYosemiteis
simplyaverybeautifulandsonorouscorruptionofthewordforgrizzlybear....
Wickliff23
ProfessorWhitneyandMr.Hutchings,intheirrespectiveguidebooks,statethatthey
derivedtheircataloguesofIndiannamesfromwhitemen.TheIndianscertainlyhavea
righttobeheardinthisdepartmentatleast;andwhentheydifferfromtheinterpreters
everyrightthinkingmanwillacceptthestatementofanintelligentaborigineasagainsta
scoreofAmericans.18
Tutokanula,whichbecamethewhitetopographersElCapitan,wasrenderedby
Whitneyasanimitationofthecryofthecrane,,butthenamewastranslatedbyPowers
asthemeasuringwormstone.19AccordingtoPowers,thisimagefigurescentrallyina
triballegendofhowtwosleepingboyswerecarriedintotheskybytheverticallyrising
stoneandthenwererescued,notbytheleapsofthemouse,therat,theraccoon,thebear,
orthelion,butbytheverticalascentofaninsignificantmeasuringworm,whicheven
themousecouldhavecrushedbytreadingonit20.Inanotherlegend,afteralongdry
journey,awife,Tisseyak,andhusband,Tokoye,cameuponthevalley,thewoman
comingfirsttothelakeAwaia.Shedrankthelakedrybeforeherhusbandarrived.In
anger,hebeatherwithhisstaff,andthensheweptandflungherbasketathim:
Soitbefellthat,evenwhiletheywereinthisattitude,onestandingoveragainsttheother,
facing,theywereturnedtostonefortheirwickedness,andtheretheyhaveremainedto
thisday.Thebasketliesupturnedbesidethehusband,whilethewomansfaceistear
stainedwithlongdarklinestrailingdown.
SouthDomeisthewomanandNorthDomeisherhusband,whilebesidethelatterisa
lowerdomewhichrepresentsthebasket.21
NATURAL RESOURCES
Inadditiontolinguisticandsemioticprojectsrepresentedbyofficialmaps,likethose
Wickliff24
ofYosemite,theimpositionofgovernmentcontroloftheWestwascarriedoutonan
economicfrontingeologicaldiscussionsofWesternminingindustry,logging,and
agriculture.ThefirstdirectoroftheconsolidatedU.S.GeologicalSurvey,Clarence
King,arguedthattheroleofthesurveywastocreatetextsandtoproduceaseriesof
landmapswhichshouldshowallthosefeaturesuponwhichintelligentagriculturists,
miners,engineers,andtimbermenmighthereafterbasetheiroperations,andwhichwould
obviouslybeofthehighestvalueforallstudentsofthepoliticaleconomyandresources
oftheUnitedStates.22HefocusedfirstupontheminingdistrictsinNevadaand
Coloradolikelytoproducethelargestyieldofpreciousmetals.Hisminingindustry
reporttoCongressalsomakesitclearthatfromthepointofviewofKing,thesurvey
director,thereportsweretofacilitatethetransferofmineralresourcesinthepublic
domaintoprivateorcorporateownership.Hebelievedhistaskwastofindwaysto
extendthedecliningyieldsoftheComstockLode,thesilverandgolddepositsthathad
playedalargeparttoinspirethedevelopmentoftheWesternrailroadsandtospur
speculatorsandcorporationswestwardeventsthathadjustifiedundertakingthe
geologicalsurveyitselffromthepointofviewofCongress.Easternpublicopinionhad
largelysupportedthesegoals,asabrief1867articleinNewYorkTimesannouncingthe
firstKingexpeditionmadeclear:
[Theregiontobesurveyed]includestheproposedrouteoftheCentralPacificRailroad,
onwhichtheworkisprogressingsorapidly,anditistheobjectoftheGovernmentto
ascertainallthecharacteristicsoftheregionwhichisthustobetraversed.Thelayofthe
landisfirsttobeascertained,andanaccuratemapprepared....Thenthesearchistobe
madeforcoal,thediscoveryofwhichmaybemorevaluabletotherailroadthanagold
Wickliff25
mine;andforwater,whichinthedeserttrackbetweentheSierraNevadaandtheRocky
Mountainsproper,isnotalwaystobefoundwhenwanted.Theminerals,thefloraand
faunaofthecountry,anditsagriculturalcapacity,arelikewisetobereportedon.Infact,
alloftheworkofnatureinthatwildandunknownregionistobescannedbyshrewdand
highlyeducatedobservers.23
Theearlygeologicalsurveyreportspresenttechnicalaspectsoftheworkclearly,but
oftenminimizingthehumancosts,asisthecasewithreportsofminingoperations.24
Largelyabsentfromthegeologicalsurveyreportsareexpressionsofconcernforthe
healthandsafetyofWesternminers,despiteTimothyOSullivansphotographicimages
takenbymagnesiumlightofminersattheirprecariousworkandtheaftermathofacave
in.Theworkingconditionsofanonymousminersarepresentedasdangerstoattemptto
overcome,asimpedimentstofullandefficientexploitationoftheminerals:
Byfarthegreatestobstaclehasbeentheheat,whichincreasesabout3degreesFahrenheit
foreveryadditionalhundredfeetsunk,andwhichseemslikelyeventuallytoputanend
tofurthersinking.AccordingtoMr.Church,theamountofairpassingthroughthemines
isnearly300,000cubicfeetaminute,while,exceptatthechangeofshift,thereare
probablynever1,000menbelowground;yettherearefewspotswheretheminerscan
workmorethaneachalternatehourduringtheeighthoursshift,sothatthedoublegangs
torelieveeachotherarepracticallyalwaysnecessary....Tthemenmustalsobe
suppliedwithunlimitedquantitiesoficewaterbothfordrinkingandwashing.Withall
theseunheardofeasements,manymenhavediedfromoverheating,somefromcontact
withscaldingwater....Itissaidthatshortasthehoursoflaborare,thework
accomplishedpermanisasgreatasincoolmines(Becker3Becker34).
Wickliff26
Theannualreports,monographs,andbulletinspublishedbytheUnitedStates
GeologicalSurveyaretheproductsoffouroverlappingsurveysmadebetween1867and
1884threecivilianandonemilitary:1)TheUnitedStatesGeologicaland
GeographicalSurveyoftheTerritories(18671878)directedbyF.V.Hayden;2)The
UnitedStatesGeologicalExplorationoftheFortiethParallel(18711878)directedby
ClarenceKing;3)TheUnitedStatesGeographicalandGeologicalSurveyoftheRocky
MountainRegion(18721880)directedbyJohnWesleyPowell;and4)TheUnitedStates
GeographicalSurveysWestoftheOneHundredthMeridian(18691884)directedby
Lieut.GeorgeM.Wheeler.Thepublishedproductsofthesurveyscomprisemorethan
100boundvolumesandanadditional100detailedtopographicmapspublished
separately.Inall,theboundvolumescontainmorethan46,000pages,includingsome
4100illustrations,plates,andmaps.Oftheillustrations,severalhundredare
photomechanicalreproductionsofphotographsorengravingsbaseduponphotographs.
Generallypublishedinprintingsof2000to25,000copies,theseillustratedvolumes
broughttoaprimarilyEasternreadershipimagesofWesternlandscapes,manyimbued
withvisualmetaphorsforfederallysponsoredsettlementcoasttocoasttelegraph
communicationandrailroadtransportation;promisesofanagrarianparadisewitha
surplusofnaturalresourcewealth,especiallymineralsandtimber;theseedsofurbanized
commerce;thedisplacement,defeat,oracculturationofAmericanIndianswhomight
resist(seeFigure137).
Thegeologicalsurveysarecomplexartifactsofaconfluenceofhistoricalforces.
Wickliff27
Theyarerhetoricalandpoeticalworks.Textually,theypresentAristotelianrhetorical
argumentsoffactandpolicyaboutnaturalresources,b.Buttheyarealsoillustratedby
photographicimagesthathave,bymoremodernviewers,beenelevatedtothestatusof
artandpointedtoforthefoundationsofWesternAmericanlandscapephotography.
Theyembodyevidenceofgovernmentalandindividualideologiesdemocratic,
capitalist,scientific,technological,andmythic.Thehugemultivolumetextsfunctionin
retrospectasharbingersofthelongertermeffectsofuseandmisuseofnationalized
resourcesforpublicandprivategain,asenvironmentalindicesshapedbytheethos
affordedbyostensiblydisinterestedgovernmentscientists.Theyarerecordsof
individualvisionandcorporateachievement,aswellasofthecollectivelossesof
AmericanIndianswhoseclaimstolandswereoftencounteredbytheforcesofthefederal
governmentexecutive,legislative,andjudicial.
AhistoryofWesternexpansionintheUnitedStatesiscriticaltounderstandingthe
geologysurveysincontext.Thesurveysinmanywayswereanefforttoadd,
retrospectively,scientificethostotheenterpriseofWesternresettlementthathadtaken
placebetween1803and1849.AtleastthreevisionsfortheAmericanWesthad
competedfordominationinthefirsthalfofthenineteenthcentury,beginningwith
ThomasJeffersonspurchaseoftheLouisianaTerritoryin1803thatofavastpotential
furtradesecuredwiththecooperationoftheIndians;thatIndians;thatofaJeffersonian
farmersparadiseofindependent,egalitarianhomesteads;andthatremnantofColumbian
motiveofacommercialtraderoutetotheFarEast.East.ButasHowardLamarhas
noted,thesethreevisionsweretoprovecontradictory,becauseDevelopingafurtrade
Wickliff28
meantpreservingIndiantribesandthewilderness;settlingthevastLouisianaPurchase
withfarmersmeantIndiandisplacementorassimilationandanendtowilderness;
developingcommercethreatenedthestatusofbothIndiansandfarmers.25
Aslateas1822itappearedthattheWestmightendureasagiganticgamereservefor
thefurtrappinginterests.Inthatyear,underpressurefromJohnJacobAstorandother
furtraders,Congressabandoneditspolicyofonlypermittinggovernmentdesignated
agentstomaintaintradingpostsinIndiancountry,westoftheMississippi.Theresulting
competitionpittedcompaniesagainstoneanothertoexploittheanimalrichesofthe
UpperMissouriRiver.From1822to1840,anestimatedthreethousandAmerican
trappersexploredthefarreachesoftheWest.26InremoteOregon,theHudsonsBay
CompanydeterminedtokeepAmericanfurtrappersoutbypursuingascorchedearth
policybytrappingsomanyanimalsintheinterior,inpresentdayeasternWashington,
Oregon,andIdaho,thatAmericanswouldnotcomeintothearea.27Thispolicywas
continueduntil1845.
In1836,thecycleofviolenceanddisplacementthathad,withdisease,ledtothe
depopulationofNativeAmericansintheEastwasrenewedwestoftheMississippi.First,
theTreatyofNewEchota,cedingitsterritoryintheSoutheastandmovingWest,was
ratifiedbytheSenateinMarch,althoughitwasnotapprovedbytheCherokeeNational
Counciloritsleadingchief.TheninAprilofthatyeartheAmericanWestwasredefined
bythevictoryofSamHoustonandhisforcesoverSantaAnnastroopsintheBattleof
SanJacinto.TheestablishmentoftheindependentrepublicofTexas,andthentenyears
later,itsadmissiontotheUnionasastate,heraldedalegacyofviolenceingovernment
Wickliff29
expansionWestoftheMississippi.InTexas,Americanstooktheterritoryofanother
countrybyviolence,arguingatthesametimethatManifestDestinywastobring
freedomtobenightedpeoples,yetAmericansnotonlydeniedfreedomtoTexan
Mexicansbutallowedslaverytocontinuetoexistthere.28WhenMexicorefusedto
recognizeAmericanannexationofTexas,theensuingwarledtotheacquisitionofyet
moreterritoryfortheUnitedStatesandtothecompromiseof1850inwhichCalifornia
wasadmittedasafreestatewhileNewMexicoandUtahbecameterritorieswithout
referencetoslaveryincludingtheareasthatwouldbecomeArizona,Nevada,andpartof
Colorado.WhenthegeographicalboundariesoftheAmericanWestreachedtothe
Pacific,competitionremainedbetweenvisionsforthedominantresourceuseofthe
region.
ItwasJamesWilsonMarshall,acarpenteremployedbyJohnSutterinconstructinga
sawmillatColoma,CaliforniainJanuaryof1848,whosediscoveryofgoldinthe
millracesoonshiftedthebalanceofpoweramongthecompetingvisionsoftheWest.
WhenitwasdeterminedthatgreatamountsofplacergoldexistedinCaliforniastreams,
morethanninetythousandpeoplecametoCaliforniain1849tocapitalizeonthemining
wealthoftheregion.Twohundredthousandmorehadarrivedby1860.Jeffersons
imageofanagrarianempirehadlargelybeensupplantedbyadreamoftheWestas
Eldoradoamineralempireawaitingexploitation.Simultaneously,thegrowthofSan
FranciscoasaportmarkedthebeginningofanurbancultureintheCalifornia,andit
raisedtotheforefronttheissuesoftranscontinentalcommunicationsandtransportation.
BythetimeoftheU.S.GeologicalSurveysoftheWest,railroadswererecognizedas
Wickliff30
centraltothedevelopmentofnewcommercialcenters,includingLosAngelesandSanta
Monica:
ItwillbeseenthattheoutgoingconnectionsfromLosAngelesareplentiful,andthatitis
likelytobecomeaprominentpointuponthethroughlineoftransitsosoonasthe
SouthernPacificshallhaveconnecteditslineofroadfromSanFranciscototheColorado
River.ThedistancefromLosAngelestoSantaMonicabyrailis121/2miles,andatthe
latterpointalittletownhassprungup,consequentupontheadvantagesofcommercial
relations,transitofsupplies,&c....29
BytheendoftheCivilWarandthesubsequentcommencementofthefederal
geologicalsurveys,themetaphoroftheWestassourceofnaturalresourcewealthfor
commerceseemeddominant,whilethenotionofagricultureintheWesternU.S.,thebulk
ofwhichPowellwastodefineasanaridregion,shiftedinemphasisfrom160acre160
acrefamilyfarmstocorporateranchesthatexportedcattletotheEastforconsumption.
Bythe1870s,thefurtradehadlargelysuccumbedtoitsownexcessestoandtheforcesof
developmentthatwererapidlyalteringnaturalhabitats,eveninremoteregionsofthe
RockyMountains,eveninYellowstone,whichbecametheworldsfirstnationalpark
1872.In1875,GeneralW.E.StrongandpartyofmilitaryofficersthatincludedGeneral
WilliamWorthBelknap,PresidentU.S.Grantssecretaryofwar,travelledto
Yellowstonetohuntandfishfortwomonths.Strongsdiarylamentsthatthreeyears
aftertheareahadbeensetasideforwildernesspreservation,poachersweredecimating
thegame:
In1870,whenLieutenantDoanefirstenteredtheYellowstoneBasin,itwaswithout
doubtacountryunsurpassedonthiscontinentforbiggame....Duringthepastfive
Wickliff31
yearsthelargegamehasbeenslaughteredherebyprofessionalhuntersbythousands,and
fortheirhidesalone.Whenthesnowfallsandthefiercewinterstormsbeginin
NovemberandDecember,theelk,deer,andsheepleavethesummitsofthesnowyranges
andcomeingreatbandstothefoothillsandvalleys,wheretheyaremetandshotdown
shamefullybythesemercilesshumanvultures.Anelkskinisworthfromsixtoeight
dollars,anditissaidthatwhenthesnowisdeep,andaherdgetsconfused,onehunter
willfrequentlykillfromtwentyfivetofiftyofthesenobleanimalsinasingleday.Over
fourthousandwerekilledlastwinterbyprofessionalhuntersintheMammothSprings
Basinalone(105).30
Likewise,mostofthenativeculturesthathadsustainedthemselvesupongameand
agriculturalpracticeshadalreadybeeneconomicallyormilitarilysubduedanddisplaced
bythetimeofthegeologicalsurveys.Insomecasescases,southwesterncultureslikethe
ZuniandHopithathadpersistedinoneareaforamillenniumwithoutexhaustingthe
resourcesofthelandscape,werequicklydisruptedordestroyedbyepidemicdisease,
militarycampaigns,andtheforcesofacculturation.ButwhiletheApachesremained
defiantinthe1870s,mostNativeAmericanshadbeenremovedtoreservationswhere
theyweresubjectedtopressurestoassimilatethemselvestothewhiteculturein
religion,education,modesofdress,architecture,agriculture.Forthosewhoavoidedthe
reservationtheoncevastAmericanWestmusthaveseemedtobeshrinkingfast,and
evenfromthepointofviewoftheethnographer,Powell,theprimaryoptionswere
presentedasassimilationordeathinthefaceoftheadvanceofEasterntechnologyand
Wickliff32
1 Delta [John William Draper] The Smithsonian Institute. Southern Literary Messenger,
1840 p 25
2 Stansbury, Haydon, F. Military Ballooning During the Early Civil War. Reprint. Baltimore:
Johns Hopkins University Press. 2000. p. 331-333
4 John William Draper. History of the American Civil War. New York: Harper & Brothers.
Vol. III 1870. p 630.
5 John William Draper. History of the American Civil War. New York: Harper & Brothers.
Vol. III 1870. p 631.
8 Young, Pearl I. Octave Chanute: A Bibliography. San Francisco: Edward L. Sterne. 1963.
p. 1
10 Ragan, Owen. First Photographer In Kansas City Kansas City Times. March 9, 1927. p
89
14 Christadler, Martin. American Landscape: Geology and the Sacred, Commerce and
Manifest Destiny. in Pioneers of Landscape Photography: Gustave Le Gray, Carleton E.
Watkins. Ed. Weston Naef and Margret Stuffmann. Malibu, CA: J. Paul Getty Museum,
1993. p 111.
15 For a discussion of the rhetoric power of mapping and nomenclature, see Barton, Ben
F. and Marthalee S. Barton. "Ideology and the Map: Toward a Postmodern Visual Design
Practice." in Professional Communication: The Social Perspective. Nancy Roundy Blyler
and Charlotte Thralls, Ed. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications, 1993.
16Powers,Stephen.TribesofCalifornia.Vol.IIIofContributionstoNorthAmericanEthnology,
J.W.Powell,Dir.Washington:GovernmentPrintingOffice,1877.p.365
17 Whitney, J. D. The Yosemite Book: A Description of the Yosemite Valley and the
Adjacent Region of the Sierra Nevada, and of the Big Trees of California, Illustrated by
Maps and Photographs. New York: Julius Bein, 1868. p 15.
22 King, Clarence. Annual Report of the United States Geological Survey for 1880. in
Annual Report of the Secretary of the Interior. Washington: Government Printing Office.
p. 335
23 Exploring Expedition to the Rocky Mountains. New York Times (8 May 1867): p. 8
24 For a discussion of how mining reports have historically minimized the dangers of the
work, see Sauer, Beverly A. "Sense and Sensibility in Technical Documentation: How
Feminist Interpretation Strategies Can Save Lives in the Nation's Mines." Journal of
Business and Technical Communication 7 (1993): 63-83.
29 Wheeler, George M. Annual Report upon the Geographical Surveys West of the One
Hundredth Meridian in California, Nevada, Utah, Colorado, Wyoming, New Mexico,
Arizona, and Montana, by George M. Wheeler, First Lieutenant of Engineers, U. S. A.;
being Appendix JJ of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1876. Washington:
Government Printing Office, 1876. p. 257-258
30 Strong, William Emerson. A trip to the Yellowstone National Park in July, August, and
September, 1875. Washington D.C.: Northern Pacific Railroad company. 1876. Reprint.
Norman, University of Oklahoma Press. 1968. p.105