PREOPERATIVE PLANNING
Surgeons continuously strive to master the art and science of surgery over
many years of arduous training and hard work, both in their years of residency
~
From the Minnesota Ear, Head, and Neck Clinic, Minneapolis, Minnesota
~~ ~~~
and years of fellowship, and more importantly in their years of private practice.
As such, this endeavor is a never-ending challenge that keeps us all motivated to
carry on and to tolerate all of the various difficulties associated with being a sur-
geon, no matter how minor or major the case may be. In the operating room, one
needs to master more than one way to achieve the same surgical result. This is the
principle of "flexibility" that most successful surgeons routinely adhere to and
execute smoothly. One of the signs of a less versatile and possibly less successful
surgeon is one who does essentially the same surgical technique for most patients
with a similar diagnosis.
Every intraoperative surgical decision needs to be custom-made to the indi-
vidual patient's needs and the surgeon's capabilities and facilities. Surgeons must
avoid fitting their patients to their surgical techniques. On the contrary, we must
adjust our surgical choices to fit each patient's situational needs. Multiple choices
may have to be considered before each patient is offered a particular type of sur-
gery, and surgeons need to be prepared to change their techniques accordingly
and competently. One of the best ways to avoid postoperative complications is
proper preoperative planning and flawless surgical technique, but without proper
postoperative care, many successful procedures may end with undesirable results.
During the first 2 weeks after surgery, patients make their initial postoperative
visit for removal of packing and sutures.Mastoid pressure dressings are used only
for mastoidectomies. Most tympanoplasties require only an oval eyepad applied
to the external ear. Proper intraoperative hemostasis is essential to the avoidance
of postoperative hematoma at the wound.
In the recovery room, all otologic patients should have function in their facial
nerve tested and should be checked for any unusual nystagmus that would in-
THIERSCH SKIN GRAFTING AND POSTOPERATIVE CARE OF OTOLOGIC PATIENTS 599
First PostoperativeVisit
In about 7 to 10 days, one should remove any sutures and external meatal
packs but leave the deeper gelatin sponge packing undisturbed. Avoid suctioning
any deeper than the meatal opening. Check for excessive formation of granulation
tissue or bleeding. If there is such, consider repacking with a less occlusivesponge
for another week. Keep patients on prophylactic oral antibiotics as long as they
have a pack in place. If the ear has been repacked, see the patient the following
week and consider Thiersch skin grafting, if indicated.
On the second visit, 3 weeks after surgery, most patients are feeling much
better and external wounds have healed well, but sites of internal incisions in the
canal may show excessive granulation tissue. If this is seen, consider local use of
silver nitrate or phenol cauterization and repacking if the granulation is limited
to a small area. Use the office microscope and carefully check for any remnants of
foreign bodies, such as surgical packing or gauze, that could be causing a foreign
body reaction. If larger areas of granulation tissue and raw surfaces are involved,
or if an open mastoid cavity procedure was performed, schedule the patient for
Thiersch skin grafting with the patient under local anesthesia, using light intra-
venous sedation in the suite for minor surgery in a week or two. If no significant
granulation tissue is detected, have patients leave the ear canal uncovered and
use sulfa and hydrocortisone ophthalmic drops in the ear canal to dissolve the
deeper gelatin sponge packing. Have patients start the drops a month postoper-
atively, twice a day for 10 days, and then schedule their third visit 5 to 6 weeks
postoperatively.
At this time, carefully suction the remaining gelatin sponge packing from the
deeper canal and tympanic area, and check for signs of stenosis of the canal, la-
teralization or blunting of the graft, effusions in the middle ear, and location and
function of ossicular prostheses. Obtain an audiogram if the tympanic area seems
clear and intact.
600 SAJJADI
By this time, most ears have healed well. Care of the mastoid cavity becomes
an important issue if a canal wall-down mastoidectomy has been performed. The
ultimate goal in care of the mastoid cavity is to achieve a self-cleaning and dry
ear that needs minimal professional cleaning of the mastoid cavity once every 10
to 12 months. Selected patients are instructed to irrigate the mastoid cavity gently
with alcohol and vinegar two or three times a day for 6 months. The irrigation
seems particularly helpful if the mastoid cavity has deep pockets that collect mu-
cous and debris. In-office cleaning of the mastoid cavity is performed under a
microscope, and occasionally rigid otic endoscopes for office use may be needed
to evaluate and fully clean all hidden areas in the mastoid bowel.
Consideration of and preparations for a second-look procedure in ears that
had cholesteatoma should be made during this visit. Endoscopic exploration has
been extremely valuable in evaluating such patients. Particularly in cases in which
excellent hearing results have been obtained from the primary procedure, it is best
to avoid disrupting the ossicular chain or the grafted tympanic membrane if at all
possible.
POSTOPERATIVE INTERVENTION
During the entire period of postoperative follow-up, the following issues need
to be considered to ensure an excellent surgical outcome: rejection of prostheses
in the middle ear, placement of ventilation tubes, second-look endoscopic proce-
dures, meatoplasty, and Thiersch skin grafting.
no discharge from the ear, and usually an intact graft or tympanic membrane.
Infection near the prosthesis presents differently, with acute pain followed by a
ruptured eardrum or failure of the graft, and otorrhea, possibly with a low-grade
fever before the ear drains.
With clinical suspicion of rejection of the prosthesis, treatment is with oral
prednisone, 1 mg/kg/d for 5 days and then slowly tapered over 10 days. An
intramuscular injectionof Depo-Medrol (methylprednisoloneacetate),40 to 80 mg,
may be substituted for the oral dosing. Follow up the patient closely and repeat
the test with a 512-Hz tuning fork or obtain an audiogram. Patients may need to
continue prednisone therapy for a longer period of time if the hearing fluctuates.
Counsel patients about the technique and its limitations, especially the fact
that an open procedure may be needed if significant disease is encountered. Usu-
ally, these are done with the patient under monitored anesthetic control (MAC),
that is, local anesthesia with light intravenous sedation. If there is a need to open
up the ear, then general anesthesia can be induced at the same time. A small
inferior tympanomeatal flap is elevated, a l.5-mm, rigid, 30" otologic endoscope
is carefully inserted, and the middle ear is inspected. Alternatively, a flexible 1.0-
mm endoscope can be inserted through a large myringotomy incision, but it is
best to avoid incising grafted eardrums.
If no significant disease is found, attention is given to the mastoid cavity and
the attic area. If a previous intact canal wall mastoidectomy was performed, one
should search for an air-containing mastoid cavity using a 5-mL syringe and a 21-
gauge needle in the postauricular area. Once air pockets are located, make a stab
incision and insert a small, 1.5-mm rigid otologic endoscope and evaluate the
mastoid, and especially the attic, for recurrent or residual cholesteatoma. If no
cholesteatoma is seen, the tympanomeatal flap can be put back down, and light
602 SAJJADI
gelatin sponge packing in the ear canal is all that is needed. The entire exploration
is done in less than an hour in most cases.
Meatoplasty
This is probably the most important, and yet a very simple, technique in the
otologicsurgeon's list of things to do after ear surgeries,but it is mainly a forgotten
skill, not taught at most otolaryngologic residency programs worldwide. Thiersch,
in Germany, first described the technique early in this century. It was popularized
in the United States by Schuknecht, who taught it to hundreds of residents and
fellows, including Paparella, who has continued to teach it to numerous residents
in otolaryngology and fellows in otology to this day. Unfortunately, the vast ma-
jority of residents in modem otolaryngology have not even heard of this highly
effective technique.
Poorly healing ear canals after canalplasty or even routine tympanoplasties
should be Thiersch grafted. Extensive raw surfaces in the mastoid cavity after
canal wall procedures should be grafted. Minor defects in a tympanic graft after
an otherwise uneventful tympanoplasty should be grafted.
Obtain an extremely thin split layer skin graft from the ipsilateral inner arm.
One must Thiersch-graft all raw surfaces in the ear canal and mastoid to ensure
proper healing and avoid stenosis and persistent discharge of the mastoid.
up of the previous surgery on the ear to correct minor irregularities that may
have gone unnoticed or may have developed since. Not all patients need to receive
grafts, and by delaying, many patients heal just fine on their own. When a Thiersch
graft is obviously needed, such as after primary open-cavity tympanomastoidec-
tomy or after repair of congenital atresia, a proven method the author has used
routinely is to remove the packing and stitches 10 days after surgery and apply
Thiersch grafts at the same time with the patient under general anesthesia (chil-
dren) or local anesthesia (adults).
Surgical Steps
Most cases can easily be done with the patient under local anesthesia with
light sedation (MAC). Minimal surgical instruments and supplies are needed.
Three steps need to be followed systematically.
Step One: Prepare the Ear. This is done under the microscope using ear cu-
rettes, after the achievement of topical anesthesia (1-2 mL of topical 4% cocaine
put on a cotton twirl tape in the ear). Remove any surgical packing or suturing
material at this time. Check for proper placement and patency of ventilation tubes
and correct any problems if found. Inspect the size of the meatus and perform
conchomeatoplasty as needed before obtaining material for the Thiersch graft.
Using the curette, clean off superficial granulation tissue and identlfy squamous
epitheliallayers to avoid burying any such layers and causing delayed cholesterol
pearls. When the ear is ready, pack the ear with cotton twirl tape impregnated
with topical 1:lOOO epinephrine, and proceed to step two.
Step Two: Harvest the Grafting Material. First inject the inner aspect of the
ipsilateral upper arm with 2% lidocaine with 1:100,000 epinephrine in the sub-
dermal layer, and mark the anesthetized area. Use a regular razor blade of the
type found in grocery stores, mounted on a heavy Carmalt clamp to remove the
extremely thin graft. The skin should be SufficientIy thin to be able to read the typed
lettering on the razor blade through the skin. If you are using a dermatome, set it
to 0.009-inch (0.23-mm) thickness, but use of the razor blade is the preferred
method in the authors clinic.
Grafts of various thickness can be harvested, depending on the patients
needs. Larger areas deep in the mastoid cavity may do better with slightly thicker
grafts, whereas areas in the ear canal and near the tympanic membrane must have
extremely thin grafts to avoid circumferential stenosis and blunting. Estimate the
size of the graft needed, and apply a temporary dressing over the donor site. Put
the grafts over silk gauze on a Petri dish impregnated with gentamicin ointment.
Cut each graft in small, rectangular strips ready to be applied onto the ear. The
weight of the ointment-laden silk gauze is what keeps these extremely flimsy and
thin grafts in place.
604 SAJJADI
Step Three: Apply the Thiersch Graft and Arm Dressing. Remove the epi-
nephrine packing from the ear. Avoid any further curetting because this may cause
minor bleeding and decreased success of the graft. Cover all raw surfaces with
the Thiersch strips. A slight 0.5-mm overlap is desirable to avoid burying squa-
mous epithelium with the grafting strips. No packing is necessary in most cases.
If it is needed, use small, nonadhering sponges in selected areas. Note on the chart
the number of strips that were used.
Apply an oval eyepad to the outer ear. No cotton balls in the meatus are
needed. Apply a large, transparent, sterile dressing to the donor site on the arm,
wrap it with gauze, and leave it wrapped for 24 hours. Leave the transparent
dressing on the arm for 14 days. Inspect the ear with a microscope in 10 to 14
days, and then remove the silk gauze, making sure the count is correct and all
strips are removed!
STAPEDIAL SURGERY
Most stapedectomies and stapedotomies are done with the patient under
MAC (monitored anesthesia control), so most patients are relatively stable in the
recovery room and go home the same day. With the advent of lasers and small-
fenestra stapedotomy procedures, severe postoperative vertigo has become less
common. The best way to avoid postoperative complications following stapedial
procedures is to exercise meticulously careful surgical technique intraoperatively.
Local anesthesia does allow for monitoring of the patients gross threshold for
hearing and for assessing for severe vertigo, which may result promptly if the
prosthesis is too long or if an active perilymphatic fistula is starting. Surgeons
must communicate in advance with the anesthesiologist regarding the need for
light sedation. This is important because most anesthesiologists are trained to
provide deep sedation, and in these otologic cases, the patient must essentially be
awake during the stapedial fenestration and insertion of the prosthesis. Alterna-
tively, some patients who are nervous of fearful, and who might move during,
local anesthesia can be treated successfully under general anesthesia.
Level of Activity
Activities that may endanger function of the ET (travel by air, scuba diving,
swimming, driving or hiking at high altitudes, and even use of express elevators
THIERSCH SKIN GRAFTING AND POSTOPERATIVECARE OF OTOLOGIC PATIENTS 605
PostoperativeVisits
The first visit is in 7 to 10 days, when packing in the external ear is removed
and a tuning fork (512 Hz) is used to check for gross results in hearing. If the
hearing is grossly intact, no audiogram is done until at least 1 month postopera-
tively, but if a patient reports an initial improvement in hearing followed by sig-
nificantly diminished hearing, one should obtain an audiogram to check for sen-
sorineural hearing loss. Prednisone at a dose of 1.5 mg/kg/d (tapered down
slowly over 14 d) is prescribed if postoperative sensorineural hearing loss without
significant vertigo is documented. An early immunologic foreign body reaction
may be present at the level of the vestibule, which may lead into formation of
granuloma.
These ears are better left unexplored because it may cause a total loss of all
hearing. If persistent or sudden onset of severe vertigo and nerve deafness is
present, the patient is treated with prednisone and is considered for possible ex-
ploration to check for perilymphatic fistulas in the oval window or dislodgement
of the prosthesis deep into the vestibule. The findings should then be addressed
as needed. These cases are associated with a poor prognosis for preservation of
hearing, with or without exploration, but some cases may be salvaged if treated
early enough.
After the initial visit, routine visits are scheduled for 1 month, 3 months, and
6 months, and 1 year postoperatively. An audiogram is obtained during each visit.
The contralateral otoscelerotic ear is not operated on until at least 6 months, and
preferably 1 year, has passed since the initial stapedial operation, and not until
the operated ear is hearing well with no vertigo.
Medications
every 6 hours, and antinausea medication and other supportive therapies. Patients
are discharged home on 1week of ampicillin and are encouraged to take meclizine
or diazepam as needed for vertigo, as well as oral antiemetic medications.
Level of Activity
All patients are requested to avoid heavy lifting, straining, and air travel for
2 weeks postoperatively. Most patients return to their preoperative levels of activ-
ity within 2 to 4 weeks. Surgical success or failure is not assessed until at least 6
months postoperatively. The postauricular wound and the ear canal are to be kept
strictly dry at all times, and the incision is dressed with antibiotic ointment twice
a day.
PostoperatlveVisits
Complications
This is a lengthy topic, and this short article is not intended to cover all aspects
of this complicated issue. Every well-trained otolaryngologistis fully aware of the
significanceof the facial nerve during and after ear surgery. Meticulous awareness
of the variable anatomy of the facial nerve, competent execution of the surgical
THIERSCH SKIN GRAFI"G AND POSTOPERATIVE CARE OF OTOLOGIC PATIENTS 607
This applies only to total paralysis of the facial nerve seen clinically either in
delayed onset or as in the case of "expected palsy seen after extensive manipu-
lation of the nerve with a clinically intact nerve. Obtain a baseline ENoG within
the first 24 hours; this should be normal and should stay that way for the first 3
to 4 days postoperatively.
Start the patient on prednisone, 1.5 mg/kg/d (with a slow tapering off over
14 d). If the paralysis remains unchanged, do serial ENoGs at twice-weekly inter-
vals; if these confirm more than 90% degeneration of the nerve on two consecutive
ENoGs, together with persistent total clinical paralysis, consider surgical decom-
pression of the nerve at the expected site of injury at the earliest possible time. If
the facial nerve shows significant and prompt improvement, either clinically or
on the ENoG, continue to treat with steroids and supportive care. Recovery of the
patient should be normal to near normal, and surgical decompression may not
improve the outcome significantly.Detailed and straightforward counseling of the
patient is crucial for the best final outcome.
SUMMARY
When proper preoperative planning has been carried out and a flawless pro-
cedure has been performed, delivery of postoperative follow-up care ensures SUC-
608 SAJJADI