Stan J. Caterbone
ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP
Freedom From Covert Harassment &
Surveillance,
Registered in Pennsylvania
1250 Fremont Street
Lancaster, PA 17603
www.amgglobalentetainmentgroup.com
stancaterbone@gmail.com
717-528-2200
NIKKI HALEY
UNITED STATES AMBASSADOR TO THE UNITED NATIONS
UNITED NATIONS
760 UNITED NATIONS PLAZA
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10017
Enclosed is my October 4, 2009 COMPLAINT to the United Nations Council for Human
Rights October 4, 2009. I just read your March 29, 2017 proclamation that you declared the
Human Rights Council So Corrupt, with much dismay. That being said, I would be better served
sending you my updated complaint directly.
My torture and suffering has been meticulously documented for the FEDERAL, STATE,
AND LOCAL courts since 1987 as a TARGETED INDIVIDUAL AND VICTIM OF U.S.
SPONSORED MIND CONTROL.
I have been collecting Social Security Benefits for symptoms and illnesses as a direct
result of the SYMPTOMS AND ILLNESSES RELATED TO U.S. SPONSORED MIND CONTROL
TECHNOLOGIES since 2008, and the Social Security Administration declared me PERMENENTLY
DISABLED on December 5, 2005; the date that I declared I became a victim of 24/7 synthetic
telepathy. The fact that I am a Federal Whistleblower only complicates my case. I am
sending you raw data in the form of files and folders that are authentic, with the exception of
certain manipulations by computer hackers. Enclosed you will also find a file listing of the
documents.
I watched your criticism of Russia and wanted to tell you that in 1991 I was selected as
an EXPERT in optical publishing by the Executive Director of People to People
International, Sandra Paul. We were schedule to meet with our RUSSIAN counterparts
in Moscow, Czechoslovakia, Prague, and a few other Eastern Block Countries. The
mission was to help educate our counterparts the technology of digitizing information
to CD-ROM. Unfortunately, I was not able to attend due to these unfortunate
circumstances.
I was also selected to attend President Clinton's Global Initiative in 2005. I had
submitted an essay with the application and was sent an invitation from Bruce R.
Lindsey, Chief Executive Officer, of the William J. Clinton Foundation. Again, I was not
able to attend.
Letter to U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley Page 1 of 16 Sunday April 16, 2017
UNITED NATIONS COMPLAINT Page 1 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
Below is the statistics from my hosting company, OMNIS, that demonstrates the global
reach of my website, www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com. The statistics are taken
from my hosting company on January 10, 2017. You will note that THE RUSSIAN
FEDERATION and CHINA are frequent visitors, as well as other Middle Eastern
Countries, which should be cause for concern. My website has been static, or has not
been updated since 2010 due to computer hacking.
You must understand that in 2009 the Muslim group IKWAN Scope, "The Largest Muslim
Brotherhood's Scope on the Web" has been a frequent visitor. Notice Pakistan below.
In addition the country of Seychelles would often appear, which appears to be home to
computer hackers. Back at that time, my former hosting company was able to track and
identify IP addresses and list them in my statistics page. Additionally several
government agencies were also frequent visitors including DARPA, The Naval Command
Center, NIST, the Department of Defense, and others.
Letter to U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley Page 2 of 16 Sunday April 16, 2017
UNITED NATIONS COMPLAINT Page 2 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
There are EIGHT (8) main documents that will serve as my Updated Complaint to the
United Nations Council for Human Rights and SIX (6) documents for REFERENCES AND
CREDIBILITY:
Respectfully,
_______________________
Stan J. Caterbone, Pro Se Litigant
ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP
Freedom From Covert Harassment & Surveillance,
Registered in Pennsylvania
1250 Fremont Street
Letter to U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley Page 3 of 16 Sunday April 16, 2017
UNITED NATIONS COMPLAINT Page 3 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
Lancaster, PA 17603
www.amgglobalentetainmentgroup.com
stancaterbone@gmail.com
717-528-2200
Notice and Disclaimer: Stan J. Caterbone and the Advanced Media Group have been slandered, defamed, and
publicly discredited since 1987 due to going public (Whistle Blower) with allegations of misconduct and fraud
within International Signal & Control, Plc. of Lancaster, Pa. (ISC pleaded guilty to selling arms to Iraq via
South Africa and a $1 Billion Fraud in 1992). Unfortunately we are forced to defend our reputation and the
truth without the aid of law enforcement and the media, which would normally prosecute and expose public
corruption. We utilize our communications to thwart further libelous and malicious attacks on our person, our
property, and our business. We continue our fight for justice through the Courts, and some communications
are a means of protecting our rights to continue our pursuit of justice. Advanced Media Group is also a
member of the media. Reply if you wish to be removed from our Contact List. How long can Lancaster County
and Lancaster City hide me and Continue to Cover-Up my Whistle Blowing of the ISC Scandel (And the Torture
from U.S. Sponsored Mind Control)?
Letter to U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley Page 4 of 16 Sunday April 16, 2017
UNITED NATIONS COMPLAINT Page 4 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
Stan J. Caterbone
ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP
Freedom From Covert Harassment &
Surveillance,
Registered in Pennsylvania
1250 Fremont Street
Lancaster, PA 17603
www.amgglobalentetainmentgroup.com
stancaterbone@gmail.com
717-528-2200
MARCH 21, 2017
Notice and Disclaimer: Stan J. Caterbone and the Advanced Media Group have been slandered, defamed, and
publicly discredited since 1987 due to going public (Whistle Blower) with allegations of misconduct and fraud
within International Signal & Control, Plc. of Lancaster, Pa. (ISC pleaded guilty to selling arms to Iraq via
South Africa and a $1 Billion Fraud in 1992). Unfortunately we are forced to defend our reputation and the
truth without the aid of law enforcement and the media, which would normally prosecute and expose public
corruption. We utilize our communications to thwart further libelous and malicious attacks on our person, our
property, and our business. We continue our fight for justice through the Courts, and some communications
are a means of protecting our rights to continue our pursuit of justice. Advanced Media Group is also a
member of the media. Reply if you wish to be removed from our Contact List. How long can Lancaster County
and Lancaster City hide me and Continue to Cover-Up my Whistle Blowing of the ISC Scandel (And the Torture
from U.S. Sponsored Mind Control)?
Letter to U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley Page 5 of 16 Sunday April 16, 2017
UNITED NATIONS COMPLAINT Page 5 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
Letter to U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley Page 6 of 16 Sunday April 16, 2017
UNITED NATIONS COMPLAINT Page 6 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
Letter to U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley Page 7 of 16 Sunday April 16, 2017
UNITED NATIONS COMPLAINT Page 7 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
4. History of the Internet - DARPA and Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group
March 12, 2017 https://www.scribd.com/document/341681178/History-of-the-Internet-
DARPA-and-Stan-J-Caterbone-and-Advanced-Media-Group-March-12-2017
Letter to U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley Page 8 of 16 Sunday April 16, 2017
UNITED NATIONS COMPLAINT Page 8 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
https://www.scribd.com/document/340996107/Stan-J-Caterbone-LETTER-to-Matthew-H-
Haverstick-re-MARTIN-v-Reese-CI-17-04626-March-5-2017
11. STAN J. CATERBONE NEW CASE IN U.S. FEDERAL DISTRICT COURT IN EASTERN
DISTRICT CASE No. 17-867 CATERBONE v. NSA, et.al., PRELIMINARY INJUCTION
FOR EMERGENCY RELIEF https://www.scribd.com/document/340923402/STAN-J-
CATERBONE-NEW-CASE-Case-No-17-cv-00867-EGS-Preliminary-Injunction-for-
EMERGENCY-RELIEF-in-U-S-EASTERN-District-of-Pennsylvania-March-4-20
19. STAN J. CATERBONE LANCASTER COUNTY COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CASE No.
CI-08-13373 PREACIPE TO ADD DEFENDANTS MASON PFLUMM et.al., February
25, 2017 https://www.scribd.com/document/340354387/Lancaster-County-Court-Case-
No-08-CI-13373-re-PRAECIPE-TO-ADD-DEFENDANTS-February-25-2017
Letter to U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley Page 9 of 16 Sunday April 16, 2017
UNITED NATIONS COMPLAINT Page 9 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
Letter to U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley Page 10 of 16 Sunday April 16, 2017
UNITED NATIONS COMPLAINT Page 10 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
1. ERIC COHEN AND ROBERT BERUBE, Federal Public Defender for Esteban Santiago, Ft.
Lauderdale Shooter, INVOICE AND FEE SCHEDULE January 20, 2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/337072519/ERIC-COHEN-Federal-Public-
Defender-for-Esteban-Santiago-Ft-Lauderdale-Shooter-INVOICE-AND-FEE-
SCHEDULE-January-20-2017
5. Video: Media Blacks Out Edward Snowdens Talk On COINTELPRO & History Of Mass
Surveillance
http://www.mintpressnews.com/video-media-blacks-out-edward-snowdens-talk-
on-cointelpro-history-of-mass-surveillance/224222/
6. Letters: Snowden deserves pardon by John and Bonnie Raines, Philadelphia of the
Citizens Commission to Investigate the FBI in 1971
http://www.philly.com/philly/opinion/20170119_Letters__Snowden_deserves_pa
rdon.html
Letter to U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley Page 11 of 16 Sunday April 16, 2017
UNITED NATIONS COMPLAINT Page 11 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
9. That time the CIA was convinced a self-proclaimed psychic had paranormal abilities
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2017/01/19/that-time-
the-cia-was-convinced-a-self-proclaimed-psychic-had-paranormal-abilities/?
postshare=8421484844095309&tid=ss_tw&utm_term=.b487b6ae00e7
10. Obama's most enduring legacy may be the establishment of the modern US
surveillance state
http://www.businessinsider.com/obamas-most-enduring-legacy-the-modern-us-
surveillance-state-2017-1
11. The Extortion of 220 Stone Hill Road, Conestoga, Pa by COINTELPRO PROGRAMS
January 17, 2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336832214/The-Extortion-of-220-Stone-Hill-
Road-Conestoga-Pa-by-COINTELPRO-PROGRAMS-January-17-2017
12. AMG LEGAL SYSTEMS PROTOTYPE Mastered on April 16, 1991 at Commadore Inc.,
January 17, 2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336787897/AMG-LEGAL-SYSTEMS-
PROTOTYPE-Mastered-on-April-16-1991-at-Commadore-Inc-January-17-2017
13. Stan J. Caterbone, Controller of Pflumm Contractors, Inc., 1993 to 1998 January 17,
2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336787739/Stan-J-Caterbone-Controller-of-
Pflumm-Contractors-Inc-1993-to-1998-January-17-2017
14. Sam Lombardo and Raolph Mazzochi Charlotte Street Proposal by Advanced Media
Group and Stan J. Caterbone January 17, 2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336787416/Sam-Lombardo-and-Raolph-Mazzochi-
Charlotte-Street-Proposal-by-Advanced-Media-Group-and-Stan-J-Caterbone-January-
17-2017
16. 1999 Excelsior Place Business Plan by Stan J. Caterbone January 16, 2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336719627/1999-Excelsior-Place-Business-Plan-
by-Stan-J-Caterbone-January-16-2017
17. Stan J. Caterbone AIM MUTUAL FUNDS Consulting From 1999 to 2002 January 16,
2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336738750/Stan-J-Caterbone-AIM-MUTUAL-
FUNDS-Consulting-From-1999-to-2002-January-16-2017
18. Pro Financial Group Brochure and Eastern Regional Free Agent Camp by Stan J.
Caterbone January 16, 2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336704842/Pro-Financial-Group-Brochure-and-
Eastern-Regional-Free-Agent-Camp-by-Stan-J-Caterbone-January-16-2017
Letter to U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley Page 12 of 16 Sunday April 16, 2017
UNITED NATIONS COMPLAINT Page 12 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
19. STAN J. CATERBONE ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP JOINT VENTURE WITH DALE HIGH
January 15, 2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336637179/56-STAN-J-CATERBONE-ADVANCED-
MEDIA-GROUP-JOINT-VENTURE-WITH-DALE-HIGH-January-15-2017
21. 1987 JOINT VENTURE - Tony Bongiovi, Power Station Studios, and Flatbush Films
with Stan J. Caterbone January 15, 2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336637176/55-1987-JOINT-VENTURE-Tony-
Bongiovi-Power-Station-Studios-and-Flatbush-Films-with-Stan-J-Caterbone-January-
15-2017
22. STAN J. CATERBONE'S Financial Management Group, Ltd., Anti-Trust Litigation File
of October 17, 2015
https://www.scribd.com/document/336637173/57-STAN-J-CATERBONE-S-Financial-
Management-Group-Ltd-Anti-Trust-Litigation-File-of-October-17-2015
24. Letter REQUEST for COMMUTATION of the Sentence of Lisa Michell Lambert to
President Obama, November 15, 2016
25. Stan J. Caterbone and Conflicts With the Trump Administration - Monday November
14, 2016 | False Claims Act | Military
26. STAN J. CATERBONE and the DEPARTMENT of DEFENSE Documents and Evidence of
Conspiracy to .... Saturday November 12, 2016
27. Feds Probe Fulton Bank and 3 Other Subsidiary Banks of Fulton Financial With Stan
J. Caterbone Civil Actions and Mind Control Research of Monday November 9, 2016 |
29. Letter to James Comey, Director of FBI Re Cointelpro Used to Obstruct Justice
Monday November 28, 2016 | Federal Bureau Of Investigation | Central Intelligence
Agency
30. VITALLY IMPORTANT - LETTER and DOCUMENT to Cappello & Noel, LLP of Santa
Barbara, CA Friday November 25, 2016
32. Pro Se Legal Representation In The United States | Motion In United States Law
33. Lancaster Mayor Rick Gray Says There is Room for Improvement in Police
Letter to U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley Page 13 of 16 Sunday April 16, 2017
UNITED NATIONS COMPLAINT Page 13 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
34. Communication - CATERBONE v. Lancaster City Police Bureau, et.al., November 22,
2016 | Central Intelligence Agency
35. Chapter 12 - ROHYPNOL AND SATELLITE and Chapter 11 - NEIGHBORS FROM HELL,
from Satellite Terrorism in America, by Dr. John Hall Copyright 2009
37. JIM GUERIN, FOUNDER OF ISC, FAREWELL LETTER OF 1989 December 26, 2016 |
Justice | Government
38. CHRISTOPHER PATTERSON Candidate for JUDGESHIP and His 1987 EFFORT FOR MY
GUARDIANSHIP Friday December 16, 2016
39. ANOTHER LANCASTER COVER-UP THE SALE OF THE MASONIC HALL IN THE CITY OF
LANCASTER, by The Advanced Media Group, December 15, 2016 | Fraternal Service
Organizations
41. My Friend and Colleague Soleilmavis Liu of China a Victim of Mind Control Living in
China Who Started Peacepink- August 28, 2016
42. TD Ameritrade TRADEKEEPER PROFIT-LOSS FOR 2004 TRADES and 2017 FULTON
STOCK January 9, 2017
43. POLICE INCIDENT REPORTS OF PHYSICAL ASSAULTS FOR STAN J. CATERBONE 2005
TO 2016 January 6, 2017
44. Judiciaries
48. Torture
49. Stan J. Caterbone on Twitter: "I'm reading FALSE IMPRISONMENT AND ILLEGAL
INTERROGATIONS by U.S. Intelligence... on @Scribd! https://t.co/T3D9nIYvMt
#ReadMore"
50. Lancaster County Court Case No. 08-CI-13373 re PRAECIPE TO ADD DEFENDANTS
COMEY AND TRUMP REMOVE OBAMA January 23, 2017
51. INVOICE AND Letter to James Comey, Director of FBI Re Pro Se Billings Invoice
Wednesday November 30, 2016
Letter to U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley Page 14 of 16 Sunday April 16, 2017
UNITED NATIONS COMPLAINT Page 14 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
52. Kathy Harrison (KATHLEEN HARRISON NAMED IN SAVAGE SUIT v. Dave Brown)
Email Re Bi Polar March 10, 2005
54. LANCASTER COUNTY COURT OF COMMON PLEAS Cases No. CI-17-00210 and CI-17-
00206 BOWMAN and SAVAGE v. BROWN, et.al.,
55. REQUEST FOR APPEARANCE and AMICUS BRIEF January 25, 2017.pdf | Amicus
Curiae | National Security Agency
56. Family of Karlie Hall files suit against Millersville University, others; calls death
preventable January 25, 2017 | Law Reference | Government
57. Stan J. Caterbone Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Case Filled in Forms January 27, 2017
58. U.S. BANKRUPTCY COURT ISSUANCE LETTER FOR NEW CASE NO. 17-10615-ref To
Judge Fehling Friday January 27, 2017
59. Stan J. Caterbone Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Case No. 17-10615 Judge Fehling Filed On
January 27, 2017 - CASE FILE | Plea | Defamation
60. Lancaster County Court Case No. 08-CI-13373 EXHIBIT re THE DONALD TRUMP
PRESIDENCY and STAN J. CATERBONE as of January 28, 2017 - electronically filed |
Federal Bureau Of Investigation | Nasa
61. ACCIDENT REPORT NO. 1701-029468 LANCASTER CITY POLICE OFFICER REPPERT
SATURDAY JANUARY 28, 2017
62. Lancaster County Court Case No. 08-CI-13373 PRAECIPE TO AMEND COMPLAINT
January 29, 2017 - FILED ELECTRONICALLY January 29, 2017
64. 16-cv-2513 Preliminary Injunction for Emergency Relief in Middle District NOTICE
OF APPEAL TO USCA THIRD CIRCUIT January 26, 2017 | Defamation
66. Stanley J. Caterbone, Pro Se, U.S.C.A. Third Circuit BRIEF STATEMENT OF JUDICIAL
MISCONDUCT OR DISABILITY of February 1, 2017
69. Jeremy Scahill on Donald Trump and the Military-Industrial Complex - Truthdig
In an interview with acTVism, the investigative journalist also discusses the
Letter to U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley Page 15 of 16 Sunday April 16, 2017
UNITED NATIONS COMPLAINT Page 15 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
71. Pennsylvania State Police Liquor Control Enforcement Formal Complaint AGAINST
DOWNTOWN LANCASTER BARS, August 12, 2016 | Lawsuit | United States Courts Of
Appeals
73. Torture LAW and the United States - Wikipedia by Stan J. Caterbone and ADVANCED
MEDIA GROUP, February 4, 2017
74. CI-16-08472 DOCKET SHEET February 3, 2017 and Torture LAW and the United
States - Wikipedia by Stan J. Caterbone and ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP, February 4,
2017
75. LIP News - CORRUPTION IN THE LANCASTER CITY POLICE DEPARTMENT AND LNP -
February 4, 2017
78. 16-Cv-2513 Preliminary Injunction for EMERGENCY RELIEF in Middle District ORDER
by JUDGE KANE TRANSFER to EASTERN DISTRICT PHIL January 31, 2017
82. Third Circuit Senior Judge Maryanne Trump Barry, who is President Donald
Trump’s older sister, decided this week to go inactive on the bench, relinquishing
her staff and chambers despite being scheduled to hear cases this year.
83. STAN J. CATERBONE June 18, 2008 US District Court Case 08-02982 CATERBONE v.
Lancaster City Police Bureau, et.al., CASE FILE | Complaint
Letter to U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley Page 16 of 16 Sunday April 16, 2017
UNITED NATIONS COMPLAINT Page 16 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 16Page
of 2413
17 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com
717-826-5354 Phone
888-533-3606 Facsimile
Scaterbone@Live.com
October 4, 2009
The following 727 page document that I prepared on October 2, 2009 establishes the following:
2. That there have been established some links to the same offices and departments of the
Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) that have in the past been responsible for the MK ULTRA
Mind Control Program.
3. That the Republicans of the U.S. Senate and at least 7 former Directors of CIA and Central
Intelligence will do anything to stall and/or stop the investigations into the torture
programs.
4. That there is credible evidence that U.S. Sponsored Mind Control Experimentation that is
occurring today in the domestic United States contributes to the same operation of
interrogation and torture techniques used in the Middle East Theater of War.
5. That there is existence of the HAARP Program was designed to have major contributions to
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control Experimentation.
6. That Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group is a TARGETED INDIVIDUAL and
COMPANY of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control Experimentation.
7. That there is credible evidence that now current Secretary of State Robert Gates; Joseph
Tate; Dick Cheney; and the ISC Scandal all have direct links to the whistle-blowing
activities of Stan J. Caterbone; dating back to 1987.
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 17Page
of 2413
18 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
OHCHR-UNOG
October 4, 2009
Page 2
Additional supporting evidence and documentation to support the above can be found at the
following:
www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com
U.S. District Court for The Eastern District of Pennsylvania Cases No. 05-2288; 06-
4650;06-4734; 06-5138
U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals Cases No. 07-4474; 07+4475; 07-2151; 06-3955; 06-
3054
The human rights violations that have been perpetrated against myself have begun in 1987 and
have accelerated and been most harmful and painful since 2005: including the use of
electromagnetic weapons; synthetic telepathy and other lethal mind control techniques. Upon
review of the above aforementioned materials, there is mounting evidence that my brother,
Samuel A. Caterbone and father, Samuel P. Caterbone, both now deceased, have been subjected
to the same inhumane treatment of Mind Control Experimentation. This is outlined in the
Executive Summary under the HAARP bookmark.
Stan J. Caterbone
Advanced Media Group
www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com
Notice and Disclaimer: Stan J. Caterbone and the Advanced Media Group have been slandered, defamed, and publicly discredited
since 1987 due to going public (Whistle Blower) with allegations of misconduct and fraud within International Signal & Control, Plc.
of Lancaster, Pa. (ISC pleaded guilty to selling arms to Iraq via South Africa and a $1 Billion Fraud in 1992). Unfortunately we are
forced to defend our reputation and the truth without the aid of law enforcement and the media, which would normally prosecute
and expose public corruption. We utilize our communications to thwart further libelous and malicious attacks on our person, our
property, and our business. We continue our fight for justice through the Courts, and some communications are a means of
protecting our rights to continue our pursuit of justice. Advanced Media Group is also a member of the media.
Cc: Exhibit A-38 Case No. 08-13373 Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas
United States Secretary of State, Ms. Hillary Rodham Clinton
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 18Page
of 2413
19 of 2593
UPDATED COMPLAINT TO THE UNITED NATIONS COUNCIL FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 19Page
of 2413
20 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control
UPDATED and the
COMPLAINT TO2009
THE Senate
UNITEDInvestigations into CIAFOR
NATIONS COUNCIL Interrogation Programs
HUMAN RIGHTS
CIATortureInvestigationsEITProgramSERE
and
U.S.SponsoredMindControl
October2,2009
Advanced Media Group Page 1 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 20Page
of 2413
21 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
TABLEOFCONTENTS
1. Smoking Gun on CIA Torture Conspiracy- Human Experimentation Central to EIT Program Sept
27, 2009
2. EXCLUSIVE CIA Experiments on U.S. Soldiers Linked to Torture Program September 9, 2009
3. CIA doctors face human experimentation claims September 18, 2009
4. CIA Sets its Technology Priorities for 2006 CIA Organizational Chart
5. David Addingtons (Cheney Staffer) Direct Involvment in Torture Memos
6. Washington Post Expose on MKULTRA August 19, 1977
7. Sen. Bond (Ranking GOP on Sentate Intelligence Committee) Pulls GOP Staff Off Torture
Investigation Sept. 25, 2009
8. Ex-CIA Chiefs Decry Holder Interrogator Probe in Letter to Obama, September 18, 2009
9. Letter by Former CIA Directors to President Obama, September 18, 2009
10. Future Technologies Inc., Home Page, October 2, 2009
11. Future Technologies Inc Directors October 2, 2009
12. Sen. Bond (Missouri Ranking GOP on Senate Intelligence Com) Pulls GOP Staff Off Torture
Investigation September 25, 2009
13. The Nature and Influence of Intuition in Law Enforcement
14. Committee on Armed Services U.S. Senate Detainee Report Final April 22 2009
15. CIA Inspector General Report Health Professionals' Ethics and Human Rights Violations May
2004
16. CIA IG Inspector General Report on MKULTRA 1963
17. CIA Technical Services Division and Assassination Plots
18. Full Version Senate Select Intelligence Joint Hearing on MKULTRA, August 8, 1977
19. Duke Street Business Center 08-13373 Preacipe to File Exhibit A-37 October 2, 2009
20. Ex-Bush officials face lawsuits over their actions September 29, 2009
21. HAARP, The United States Government, and Advanced Media Group September 23, 2009.pdf
A close reading of the CIAs Inspector General Report and the Senate Intelligence Committees
narrative on the Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) torture memos reveals a more detailed picture of the
CIAs involvement in the construction of those documents.
What emerges is consistent with recent charges of CIA experimentation on prisoners, and of the
overall experimental quality of the torture program itself.
It also points to a crucial piece of analysis by the CIAs Office of Technical Services, a memo which
may or may not include damning medical and psychological evidence of the damaging effects of SERE
techniques, and which the IG report maintains was utilized in substantial part in the drafting of the
August 1, 2002 Bybee memos. If one is looking for a smoking gun in the torture scandal, in my
opinion, one doesnt have to look much further than this.
The quote below is from the April 22, 2009 Senate Intelligence Committee narrative of the Office of
Legal Counsels opinions on the CIAs interrogation program. Please keep in mind as you read the
quote and the added bolded emphasis, that recent documentation has shown that for years the CIA
and Special Operations had researchers studying the effects of SERE training.
Moreover, the research had been published in peer-reviewed journals, in part because the research
was also meant to add to the psychiatric communitys understanding of the mechanisms of
Post-traumatic Stress Disorder. Some of the research had also been published in the June 2000
edition of Special Warfare, The Professional Bulletin of the John F. Kennedy Special Warfare Center
and School.
So, keeping this all in mind, consider the following from the Intel Committees narrative (emphasis
added):
According to CIA records, because the CIA believed that Abu Zubaydah was withholding
imminent threat information during the initial interrogation sessions, attorneys from the
CIAs Office of General Counsel met with the Attorney General, the National Security
Adviser, the Deputy National Security adviser, the Legal Adviser to the National Security
Council, and the Counsel to the President in mid-May 2002 to discuss the possible use of
alternative interrogation methods that differed from the traditional methods used by the
The CIAs Office of General Counsel subsequently asked OLC to prepare an opinion about
the legality of its proposed techniques. To enable OLC to review the legality of the
techniques, the CIA provided OLC with written and oral descriptions of the proposed
techniques. The CIA also provided OLC with information about any medical and
psychological effects of DoDs Survival, Evasion, Resistance and Escape
(SERE) School, which is a military training program during which military personnel
receive counter-interrogation training.
While the fact that the OLC accepted at face value the CIAs statements regarding the safety or the
effects of the interrogation procedures they were proposing is no surprise to anyone who has read the
torture memos and evidence of the unprofessionalism and bias of the memos authors the
degree to which the conspiracy (by CIA or OLC, or both) to withhold evidence of the real effects of the
Enhanced Interrogation Techniques (EITs) by the CIA has never been made more concrete than
now.
To my knowledge, we do not have the specific document wherein the CIA provides the medical and
psychological effects of SERE school. I have been told that this document is still classified. But it
seems possible that the CIA did pass on the details of the research that was available to it, including
the debilitating effects of SERE techniques, which sent stress hormone levels, according to one
research report, some of the greatest ever documented in humans. Another report cited
neuroendocrine changes [that] may have significant implications for subsequent responses to
stress.
One of the authors of these reports, Charles A. Morgan, III, M.D., who has identified himself in
certain settings as a Senior Research Scientist on the CIAs Behavioral Science Staff, has criticized
my coverage of CIA experiments on the psychological and physiological effects of SERE training upon
human subjects. While he could not specify what aspects of this coverage he felt were inaccurate and
misleading, he did insist:
The research conducted by our research team at the National Center for Post Traumatic
Stress Disorder is not, and never has been, conducted for any other purpose than to help
us understand the pathophysiology of stress disorders and we might better help in the
treatment of veterans.
In making his mea culpa, Dr. Morgan never mentions that some of this research was funded (over
$400,000) by the Army and the Office of Naval Research. He doesnt mention his acquaintance with
great people who do military interrogations. He also forgets to cite his book contribution, where he
states (emphasis added):
The SERE training environment affords the military services the opportunity to
collaborate with various other government agencies in exploring old and new
techniques in gathering human intelligence.
Of course, he neither confirms nor denies his affiliation with the CIA, an affiliation which I have traced
to the CIAs Science and Technology directorate, through his association (large PDF) with the
Intelligence Technology Innovation Center, which is a research organization under the CIAs
authority that answers directly to the CIAs Science and Technology directorate.
But most of all, Dr. Morgans arrows fall way short of his target, as I have never accused him of
personal involvement in the reverse-engineering of SERE techniques for use in the torture program.
What is disturbing is his seeming lack of concern over the possiblity that the research he helped
conduct was either used to further experiments upon torture victims in the CIAs clandestine prisons,
or contrariwise, was withheld from Office of Legal Counsel lawyers who relied upon CIA advice
concerning the effects of techniques derived from the SERE schools.
What is indisputable is that by virtue of his position, Dr. Morgan had access to CIA officials just at the
time that another department of the CIA, one to which he is affiliated, was, according to the CIAs
own Office of Inspector General Report (large PDF) involved in vetting the SERE techniques for use in
interrogations. The other department was the Office of Technical Services (OTS), part of the CIAs
Science and Technology Directorate. This, by the way, is the same division that was responsible for
the MKULTRA experiments of the 1950s and 1960s. From the OIG report:
CTC [CIA's Counter-Terrorism Center], with the assistance of the Office of Technical
Service (OTS), proposed certain more coercive physical techniques to use on Abu
CIAs OTS obtained data on the use of the proposed EITs and their potential long-term
psychological effects on detainees. OTS input was based in part on information solicited
from a number of psychologists and knowledgeable academics in the area of
psychopathology.
OTS also solicited input from DoD/Joint Personnel Recovery Agency (JPRA) regarding
techniques used in its SERE training and any subsequent psychological effects on
students. DoD/JPRA concluded no long-term psychological effects resulted from use of
the EITs, including the most taxing technique, the waterboard, on SERE students. The
OTS analysis was used by OGC [DoD's Office of General Counsel] in evaluating the
legality of techniques.
OTSs solicitation of information on SERE from JPRA elicited some sort of feedback from JPRA, which
supposedly told OTS that SERE training caused no long-term effects. The IG Report does not say if
this was in the form of a memo and only speaks of OTSs analysis. In any case, we should not confuse
any OTS analysis with the information provided by JPRA itself to the Office of General Counsel,
which produced a number of memorandum and attachments in late July 2003. Marcy Wheeler has
been analyzing the timing of these JPRA items, including the fact that one of these key documents is
missing.
The CIA IG Report is relating a story whose emphasis differs from that produced in the narrative of
the Senate Armed Services Committee investigation (PDF) into SERE torture. In the latter, JPRA is
the main culprit in providing cover for the supposed safety of using SERE techniques. Yet, in the OIG
account it looks like the CIA used DOD/JRRA as a cover for the safety of techniques that it knew were
in fact harmful from their own analysis of the data. Moreover, it was the OTS analysis that was used
in substantial part as the basis of the August 1, 2002 memo approving the Enhanced
Interrogation Techniques (EITs).
That legal opinion was based, in substantial part, on OTS analysis and the experience
and expertise of non-Agency personnel and academics concerning whether long-term
psychological effects would result from use of the proposed techniques.
Moreover, the CIAs Office of Medical Services was frozen out of the initial analysis of the risk and
benefits of EITs, and not even provided with a copy of the OTS report given to the White House
Office of Legal Counsel. Such compartmentalization of information is indicative of a covert operation,
such as a Special Access Program (SAP). This SAP would have included personnel in CIAs CTC, OTS,
OGC, and Directorate of Operations, also portions of DOD (JPRA and Special Operations Command),
and probably the White Houses OLC, Office of the Vice President, and National Security Council.
It seems highly likely that the CIA report to the OLC on the medical and psychological effects of the
SERE school program, mentioned in the Senate Intelligence Committee narrative quote above, is in
fact the OTS report, which came from the same CIA directorate to which Dr. Morgan belongs. This
does not speak to Morgans foreknowledge of what would be used, nor to the amount of his
involvement. But it does speak to the likelihood that the government research he conducted (with
others) was available and likely used by his associates in the CIA.
To what purpose was this information used? It seems Dr. Morgan has serendipitously given us the
answer himself: exploring old and new techniques in gathering human intelligence. The CIA appears
to have used torture to conduct what Physicians for Human Rights, in a white paper (PDF) recently
published, called possible unethical human experimentation, [which] urgently needs to be thoroughly
investigated. The government should declassify the OTS report, and bring the process of
investigating the CIAs role in the torture conspiracy fully into public purview.
Jeffrey Kaye, a psychologist living in Northern California and a regular contributor The Public Record,
has been blogging at Daily Kos since May 2005, and maintains a personal blog, Invictus. E-mail Mr.
Kaye at sfpsych at gmail dot com.
14 retweet
Editors note: Click here to listen to Jeffrey Kaye discuss his groundbreaking report with radio talk
show host Peter B. Collins.
A number of new articles have been published recently that have highlighted evidence of illegal
human experimentation on U.S.-held terrorism prisoners undergoing torture. These articles
followed the release of a white paper by Physicians for Human Rights [PHR], Aiding Torture: Health
Professionals Ethics and Human Rights Violations Demonstrated in the May 2004 Inspector Generals
Report.
This report looks at those recent charges, and reveals that experiments by a CIA researcher on
human subjects undergoing SERE training went unreported in the legal memos the Bush
administration drafted to approve their torture program. It will also connect major military and
intelligence figures to the SERE experiments, and tie some of them to major science and
experimental directorates at the CIA and Special Operations Command.
An article by veteran journalist William Fisher, looking at PHRs white paper, asks, Did physicians
and psychologists help the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency develop a new research protocol to
assess and refine the use of waterboarding or other harsh interrogation techniques?
[PHR] also raises questions about the ethics of medical note-taking during some of the
interrogations. Medical doctors and psychologists colluded with the CIA to keep
observational records about waterboarding, which approaches unethical and unlawful
human experimentation, Scott Allen, lead study author and PHR medical advisor, said
in a prepared statement.
Finally, a story in Wednesdays UK Guardian discussed the significance of the charges of unlawful
human experimention:
Human experimentation without consent has been prohibited in any setting since 1947,
when the Nuremberg Code, which resulted from the prosecution of Nazi doctors, set
down 10 sacrosanct principles. The code states that voluntary consent of subjects is
essential and that all unnecessary physical and mental suffering should be avoided.
The Geneva conventions also ban medical experiments on prisoners and prisoners of
war, which they describe as grave breaches.
After describing how [h]ealth professionals in the Office of Medical Services and psychologist
contractors engaged in designing and monitoring torture, as selecting and then rationalizing the
use of various harmful interrogation techniques, the PHR report goes on to say:
The possibility that health professionals monitored techniques to assess and improve
their effectiveness, constituting possible unethical human experimentation, urgently
needs to be thoroughly investigated.
The CIAs Office of Medical Services was supposed to be in charge of monitoring detainee health
under interrogation. However their instructions, described in an annex to the CIA Inspector General
report, exemplifies the dual nature of the monitoring, as this example from the report shows:
If there is any possibility that ambient temperatures are below the thermoneutral
range, they should be monitored and the actual temperatures documented. [2 or 3
redacted lines]
Rather than make changes to ambient temperatures, to prevent harm to prisoners, medical
professionals are instructed to monitor and document the situation. The torture techniques used by
SERE are known to cause endocrine and metabolic disorders (see section on CIA research below),
prisoners tortured and subjected to cold are at higher risk of hypothermia, which for a normal person
can set in at an ambient temperature of 60 degrees F. The monitoring in this case seems to be as
much about experimentation as it is any concern for a prisoners health. (For what other possible
reason could this section be mostly redacted?) Parallels to the experiments on hypothermia by Nazi
scientists at Dachau are chilling, as is the fact that some of these scientists were later imported,
along with their data, to the United States.
Questions were raised around possible human experimentation in an article last May at Firedoglake
on The Zubaydah Torture Experiment, noting, Of the many fascinating details coming out of [the
May 2009 Senate] Judiciary hearing the references to the application of an experiment by the
ex-SERE CIA contractor, most likely James Mitchell, seemed especially important.
The experimentation was not limited to high-value CIA prisoners. Last April, another article at
Firedoglake reported how the Senate Armed Services Committee report (PDF) on prisoner abuse
described the creation of an experimental battle lab at Guantanamo, demonstrating support for the
torture program from the main Army intelligence school at Ft. Huachuca.
According to the Levin report, in August 2002, COL John P. Custer, then-assistant
commandant of the U.S. Army Intelligence Center and School at Ft. Huachuca, Arizona
conducted a review of interrogations operations at Guantanamo. Custer called
Guantanamo Americas Battle Lab in the war on terror, and recommended combining
FBI and military techniques to extract information by exploiting the detainees
vulnerabilities. The Battle Lab label stuck, though some, like Colonel Britt Mallow, of
the Criminal Investigative Task Force, objected.
MG Dunlavey and later MG Miller referred to GTMO as a Battle Lab meaning that
interrogations and other procedures there were to some degree experimental, and their
lessons would benefit DOD in other places. While this was logical in terms of learning
lessons, I personally objected to the implied philosophy that interrogators should
experiment with untested methods, particularly those in which they were not trained.
Later, Dunlavey denied using the term, and Miller testified he couldnt remember.
The experiments on the effects of SERE-torture techniques began even earlier upon SERE trainees
themselves. An April 2009 AlterNet article reported on the history of experimentation on soldier
subjects undergoing SERE training. (SERE is a military program, the acronym standing for Survival,
Evasion, Resistance, Escape.) The article explained how the Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) and the
CIA ignored a wealth of other published information about the effects of SERE stress inoculation,
citing a June 2000 article, Assessment of Humans Experiencing Uncontrollable Stress: The SERE
Course, in Special Warfare (PDF). Special Warfare is The Professional Bulletin of the John F.
Kennedy Special Warfare Center and School (emphases added to following quote):
Results
As shown in the charts on page 7, SERE stress caused significant changes in students
hormone levels. Recorded changes in cortisol levels were some of the greatest
ever documented in humans. In some cases, the changes noted among the
trainees were greater than the changes noted in patients undergoing heart
surgery.
The Alternet article also quoted from a May 2000 article in Biological Psychiatry, Hormone profiles in
humans experiencing military survival training (emphasis added):
Looking beyond more than physiological symptoms, other studies have looked at purely
psychological data. Consider this oft-quoted study from the August 2001 edition of the American
Journal of Psychiatry, which looked at dissociative symptoms, such as depersonalization,
derealization, psychic or emotional numbing, and general cognitive confusion, produced in military
subjects exposed to SERE torture techniques (emphasis added):
The current study was designed to assess the nature and prevalence of dissociative
symptoms in healthy humans experiencing acute, uncontrollable stress during U.S.
Army survival training. METHOD: In study 1, 94 subjects completed the Clinician-
Administered Dissociative States Scale after exposure to the stress of survival
training. In study 2, 59 subjects completed the Brief Trauma Questionnaire before
acute stress and the dissociative states scale before and after acute stress. A randomly
selected group of subjects in study 2 completed a health problems questionnaire after
acute stress. RESULTS: In study 1, 96% of subjects reported dissociative
symptoms in response to acute stress. Total scores, as well as individual item
scores, on the dissociation scale were significantly lower in Special Forces soldiers
compared to general infantry troops. In study 2, 42% of subjects reported dissociative
symptoms before stress and 96% reported them after acute stress.
Other research results include the effects of SERE-style torture upon the immune system and other
biological markers. The findings regarding high levels of cortisol upon subjects was corroborated by a
SERE psychologist at the Navy Brunswick, Maine, SERE school, who according to an unclassified,
undated Talking Paper from the Joint Personnel Recovery Agency found empirical medical data
[of] elevated levels of cortisol in the brain stem caused by stress levels incurred during water-
boarding. The Brunswick school subsequently discontinued waterboarding as part of its SERE
training, as it created a negative learning environment. The other Navy SERE school, in North
Island, California, refuses to eliminate exposure to waterboarding as part of its training program,
despite the opposition of JPRA and the other SERE schools, which believe it can induce a learned
helplessness state in students.
One of the lead researchers in a number of these studies is Yale psychiatrist Charles A. Morgan, III.
According to one source, Over the past 10 years, Dr. Morgan has served as a Subject Matter Expert
to the US Special Operations Command. But at a June 2004 symposium on The Nature and
Influence of Intuition in Law Enforcement, sponsored by the U.S. Department of Justice, the
Behavioral Analysis Unit of the FBI, and the American Psychological Association, Dr. Morgan is listed
as affiliated with Behavioral Science, CIA.
Additionally, in the Information Science Board (ISB) document, Educing Information which was
heavily drawn upon by President Obamas task force on interrogations, for recommendations on the
interrogations issue Dr. Morgan is identified as a member of the 11-person Government Experts
Committee, and listed as affiliated with the Intelligence Technology Innovation Center (ITIC).
According to Intelligence Online, ITIC is a research organization under the CIAs authority, which
answers directly to the CIAs Science and Technology directorate.
The Obama Interrogations Task Force recently made clear they found a lot to value in the ISB study
(emphasis added):
The Task Force concluded that the United States could improve its ability to
interrogate the most dangerous terrorists by forming a specialized interrogation group,
or High-Value Detainee Interrogation Group (HIG), that would bring together the most
effective and experienced interrogators and support personnel from across the
Intelligence Community, the Department of Defense and law enforcement. The
creation of the HIG would build upon a proposal developed by the Intelligence
Science Board.
Whatever the fate of the HIG, what is noteworthy here is that the Office of Technical Services (OTS),
which was cited in the recently released 2004 CIA Inspector General report as having vetted the
aggressive SERE interrogation techniques, is, along with the ITIC, also a part of the Science and
Technology directorate. OTS, formerly the Technical Services Division (or Technical Services Staff),
was the branch of the CIA in charge of torture and assassination. It was also in charge of the
experimental mind control and interrogation program known as MKULTRA.
Dr. Morgans online profile states that between 1998 and 2002 he received over $400,000 in research
grants from the Army and the Office of Naval Research (ONR) for studies on Psychobiological
Assessment of High Intensity Military Training and Neuro endocrine assessment of Survival School
Training. A 1977 Washington Post expose those were the days of scandalous revelations
surrounding the CIAs MKULTRA program describes CIA use of ONR to funnel funds for secret
experiments in the 1950s and 1960s. The same relationship was also explored during a 1977 Senate
Intelligence Committee hearing. This is not evidence that Morgans research was paid for by the CIA,
but along with his institutional affiliation, it is suggestive of possible CIA involvement.
While it is unknown to what degree the CIA was directly involved in the SERE research (outside of Dr.
Morgans affiliation), Special Operations Command reportedly was a major supporter.
The co-author of the Special Warfare article referenced above, and working with Dr. Morgan on a
number of other SERE research papers looking at physiological and psychological effects of SERE
techniques, was Gary Hazlett, a clinical psychologist with the Psychological Applications Directorate at
U.S. Army Special Operations Command. Moreover, Morgan and Hazlett cited the approval and
support [for their research] of Lieutenant General William Tangney, Major General Kenneth Bowra,
Major General William G. [B]oykin and many others
Maj. Gen. Bowra retired from the military in 2003, after serving as Commanding General of Army
Special Operations Command South, U.S. Southern Command. Following the military, he went to
work as Senior Program Director with Oak Ridge National Laboratory, serving as national laboratory
liaison to U.S. Joint Forces Command, J9 Directorate. Another source states that currently Bowra is
senior mentor/concept developer at USJFCOM J9 for Joint Urban Operations and Homeland Security
experimentation. J9 stands for the Joint Concept Development and Experimentation Directorate
(JCD&E). It leads the development of emerging joint concepts, conducts and enables joint
experimentation, and coordinates DoD JCD&E efforts in order to provide joint capabilities to support
the current and future joint force commander in meeting security challenges.
The possible involvement of USJFCOMs J9 in research upon SERE follows upon the revelation,
discussed above, that CIAs OTS, part of CIAs Science and Technology directorate, was heavily
involved in the implementation of the SERE techniques for use by the CIA. While the use of the term
experimentation appears to have a broad meaning in military usage, beyond that of conducting
scientific experiments, given the charges surrounding human experimentation upon torture victims,
any connections between these secretive experimental directorates and the SERE torture program,
or research upon it, is worrisome.
Maj. Gen. Boykin was the controversial former commander of Special Operations Command at Fort
Bragg, North Carolina, who resigned over statements that indicated he saw the war on terror as a
religious war. At the time he was Special Operations commander at Fort Bragg, according to a recent
New York Times article, SERE psychologist James Mitchell was completing his last military
assignment as psychologist to an elite special operations unit in North Carolina. Boykin previously
served as CIA Deputy Director of Special Activities, and in June 2003, became Deputy
Undersecretary of Defense for Intelligence under Donald Rumsfeld right-hand man, Stephen
Cambone.
Lt. Gen. Tangney is yet another former commanding general at Army Special Operations Command.
Also retired from the military, he is currenly Senior Vice President for Intelligence, Security, and
Special Operations, at Future Technologies, Inc., a supplier of, among other things, a well-
developed global network of experienced intelligence, security and special operations professionals
working with Special Operations, the Defense Intelligence Agency, and other military customers.
While Dr. Morgan appears to be well-connected among the military and intelligence elite, it is
important to remember that there is no reason to conclude that Dr. Morgan or his co-researchers
have ever been involved in torture or experiments meant to be used for torture. (We cannot say the
same for CIA or military medical or psychological personnel, however.) In fact, it is possible that Dr.
Morgans research has led him to oppose coercive interrogation techniques, as his published research
documents the debilitating effects of SERE torture, which utilized against a prisoner could only be
considered cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment, if not torture. (Although, at the 2007 convention
of the American Psychological Association, Dr. Morgan indicated he was against the idea of removing
psychologists from national security interrogations, which was being considered in a motion before
APA at that time.)
Many SERE veterans were appalled at the reverse engineering of their methods, said
Charles A. Morgan III, a Yale psychiatrist who has worked closely with SERE trainers for
a decade.
Dr. Morgans comments appear to put him at odds with other members of the CIAs Science and
Technology directorate, particularly those who work for OTS, as well as individuals within the
Pentagon and Special Operations Command, who have been tied to elements of the U.S. torture
program.
What is clear is that the CIA and the Pentagon had plenty of experimental evidence from the
peer-reviewed, published research of Dr. Morgan and his associates (and possibly others), both
before and after 9/11, that SERE techniques had serious, debilitating effects on individuals subjected
to them. As this research is never cited in any of the Office of Legal Counsel memos issued to the
CIA around their torture program, it appears such research was deliberately withheld from
government attorneys as the CIA sought approval for the use of SERE-style torture. Nor was this
obscure research, but had been funded by the government at a minimum of hundreds of thousands of
dollars, and promoted by some of the Pentagons highest generals.
The frenzied search for data on waterboarding, sleep deprivation, isolation, confinement in a small
box, etc., to submit to OLC attorneys making legal determinations on whether proposed
interrogation techniques constituted torture, was a kabuki organized by the CIA. The OLC attorneys
involved John Yoo, Stephen Bradbury, Jay Bybee, and others were witting or unwitting partners
in suppression of CIA research on torture (as future investigations will disclose). Given the
participation of members of the Office of the Vice President, particularly David Addington and Vice
President Cheney himself, in the promulgation of the torture program, and the composition of the
memos, it seems likely they were also involved in the suppression of this material. As a result, the
memos produced authorizing the enhanced interrogation techniques were composed as the result of
fraud and bad faith, the result of a criminal conspiracy to implement illegal torture techniques.
The public response to the recent white paper by Physicians for Human Rights shows there is great
interest in following up on charges of human experimentation upon torture victims of the U.S.
government. The Congress and Department of Justice should move swiftly to initiate full, open
investigations and charges against those involved.
Jeffrey Kaye, a psychologist living in Northern California and a regular contributor The Public Record,
has been blogging at Daily Kos since May 2005, and maintains a personal blog, Invictus. E-mail Mr.
Kaye at sfpsych at gmail dot com.
21 retweet
larger | smaller
Doctors and psychologists the CIA employed to monitor its "enhanced interrogation" of
terror suspects came close to, and may even have committed, unlawful human
experimentation, a medical ethics watchdog has alleged.
Physicians for Human Rights (PHR), a not-for-profit group that has investigated the
role of medical personnel in alleged incidents of torture at Guantnamo, Abu Ghraib,
Bagram and other US detention sites, accuses doctors of being far more involved than
hitherto understood.
The American Medical Association, the largest body of physicians in the US, said it was
in open dialogue with the Obama administration and other government agencies over
the role of doctors. "The participation of physicians in torture and interrogation is a
Advanced Media Group Page 12 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 31Page
of 2413
32 of 2593
1 of 3 10/2/2009 2:40 AM
CIA doctors face human experimentation claims | World news | The Guardian http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/sep/02/cia-usa/print
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
effectiveness, using detainees as human subjects without their consent. The report
concludes that such data gathering was "a practice that approaches unlawful
experimentation".
Human experimentation without consent has been prohibited in any setting since 1947,
when the Nuremberg Code, which resulted from the prosecution of Nazi doctors, set
down 10 sacrosanct principles. The code states that voluntary consent of subjects is
essential and that all unnecessary physical and mental suffering should be avoided.
The Geneva conventions also ban medical experiments on prisoners and prisoners of
war, which they describe as "grave breaches". Under CIA guidelines, doctors and
psychologists were required to be present during the use of so-called enhanced
interrogation techniques on detainees.
In April, a leaked report from the International Committee of the Red Cross found that
medical staff employed by the CIA had been present during waterboarding, and had
even used what appeared to be a pulse oxymeter, placed on the prisoner's finger to
monitor his oxygen saturation during the procedure. The Red Cross condemned such
activities as a "gross breach of medical ethics". PHR has based its accusation of possible
experimentation on the 2004 report of the CIA's own inspector general into the
agency's interrogation methods, which was finally published two weeks ago after
pressure from the courts.
An appendix to the report, marked "top secret", provides guidelines to employees of the
CIA's internal Office of Medical Services "supporting the detention of terrorists turned
over to the CIA for interrogation".
Medical workers are given the task of "assessing and monitoring the health of all agency
detainees" subjected to enhanced techniques. These techniques include facial slaps,
sleep deprivation, walling where their padded heads are banged against walls
confinement in boxes, and waterboarding or simulated drowning.
The guidelines instruct doctors to carry out regular medical checks of detainees. They
must ensure that prisoners receive enough food, though diet "need not be palatable",
and monitor their body temperature when placed in "uncomfortably cool environments,
ranging from hours to days".
PHR is calling for an official investigation into the role of doctors in the CIA's now
widely discredited programme. It wants to know exactly how many doctors
participated, what they did, what records they kept and the science that they applied.
Home
Firedoglake
TBogg
Campaign Silo
Laura Flanders
The Seminal
ATTACKERMAN
La Figa
Christy
Blue America
Search Here...
Login Here
Username: Password Remember Me Login
What al-Nashiri and KSM Didnt Tell Us
Bad Max Provides More Details
As I noted yesterday, I've been reading old HJC hearings--including the hearing at which Daniel Levin testified about the torture memos. Levin basically testified that he was asked to
resign while he was drafting what became the 2005 Bradbury memos.
Mr. DAVIS. Mr. Levin, let me begin with you and Mr. Wilkerson, and put frankly everything I have heard today in some context. And I want to pull out two particular
events. The first one is the circumstances of your not being at the Department. I know that you were very careful in your answers to Chairman Nadler earlier. But let me
make sure I understand you.
Mr. LEVIN. I would have preferred to have stayed. I mean, when I was told I wasnt going to stay, I voluntarily left.
Mr. DAVIS. That tends to be what happens; when people who are over you tell you to go, you go. That is what in the real world is called being fired.
But he also revealed something else about what happened when he was drafting the replacements for John Yoo's crappy memos: he had no direct contact with David Addington during
the process--or anyone else in OVP.
Mr. LEVIN. I talked to a lot of people. As I mentioned in my opening remarks, I think one of the problems with the earlier memo was, it was not the subject of sufficiently
broad collaboration and discussion.
I talked, in addition to everybody in the Office of Legal Counsel virtually, people at the Criminal Division, various other people in the Department, people at the State
Department.
Mr. ELLISON. Did you talk to anybody in the Vice Presidents Office?
Mr. LEVIN. I dont believe I did talk to anybody in the Vice Presidents Office. I did submit drafts to the White House Counsels Office, and whom they circulated it to in
the White House, I dont know.
Mr. ELLISON. Okay. Do you know ifdid Mr. Addington have any input into your redraft?
Mr. LEVIN. Not directly to me. Whether he did so indirectly, I am not sure. He may have provided comments to White House Counsel that were then communicated to me
as their comments. I was not ever told anything that were his comments, and he never spoke to me about it directly.
Now, that's remarkable. We know from Addington's testimony before HJC that Addington met with Alberto Gonzales and John Yoo on the Bybee One memo (and his care to specify that
this description pertained to Bybee One, and not Bybee Two, may suggest his influence was greater with the latter).
Mr. NADLER. Just tell us what your role was, if you can.
Mr. NADLER. Because you said it wasnt nonexistant but you didnt help shape it. So what was it?
Mr. ADDINGTON. Mr. Chairman, my recollection, first of all, I would be interested in seeing the document you are questioning me about. I think you are talking about a
document of August 2002.
Mr. ADDINGTON. It would be useful to have that in front of me so I can make sure that what I am remembering relates to the document you have and not a lot of other legal
opinions I looked at. But assuming you and I are talking about the same opinion, my memory is of Professor Yoo coming over to see the counsel of the President and I was
invited in the meeting, with the three of us, and he gave us an outline of here are the subjects I am going to address.
And I remember, when he was done, saying, Here are the subjects I am going to address, saying, Good, and he goes off and writes the opinion.
Addington goes on to describe himself as "essentially ... the client on this opinion." So we know that Addington (unsurprisingly) had direct conversations with Yoo about this opinion and
(as the rest of his testimony makes clear) others.
Now, when he testified before HJC, Steven Bradbury refused to answer questions about his contacts with Addington and others during the drafting of the torture memos. But the Comey
emails released earlier this year make it clear that Bradbury did have direct conversations with Addington as he was drafting the May 2005 memos (and that Addington was pressuring
him to get them done).
The AG explained that he was under great pressure from the Vice President to complete both memos, and that the President had even raised it last week, apparently at the
VP's request and the AG had promised they would be ready early this week. He added that the VP kept telling him "we are getting killed on the Hill." (Patrick [Philbin] had
previously reported that Steve [Bradbury] was getting constant similar pressure from Harriet Miers and David Addington to produce the opinions. Parenthetically, I have
previously expressed my worry that having Steve as "Acting"--and wanting the job--would make him susceptible to just this kind of pressure.
But Levin's ousting--and related ascension of Alberto Gonzales to be Attorney General--does appear to have had that effect.
Spotlight
When you cover Addington my eyes read your post as though they are in ALL CAPS.
Reply
skdadl September 6th, 2009 at 2:56 pm
2
This discussion will be halted for an indeterminate time while Mr Addington waves off his questioners, including the chair, and makes notes to himself on the documents in question, after
which he will speak flatteringly of Mr Yoo, seated to his left, in such a way as also to shift to Mr Yoo all responsibility for the opinions Mr Addington is being questioned about.
Reply
Boston1775 September 6th, 2009 at 2:56 pm
3
Reply
emptywheel September 6th, 2009 at 3:01 pm
4
Reply
rincewind September 6th, 2009 at 3:14 pm
5
Im struck by a (relatively) small point that I hadnt remembered from the testimony: that Addington claimed to be essentially the client of OLC for Bybee One less than a minute
after reading from the copy of the memo,
It is August 1, 2002, memorandum for Alberto Gonzales, counsel of the President, re: standards of conduct for interrogation under 18 USC Sections 2340 and 2340(a).
So did Addington essentially admit that Cheney was essentially the Pres, and he (Addington) was essentially Counsel to the Pres?
Reply
Boston1775 September 6th, 2009 at 3:27 pm
6
In response to emptywheel @ 4
Must see TV
Reply
bmaz September 6th, 2009 at 3:50 pm
7
You know, it strikes me that all of this, and the bigger picture surrounding the memos, and question of WH interaction thereon, is exactly why there will not be any but the most
superficial and isolated of prosecutions, and arguably none at all, come out of the big Holder PR review. Any defendant is going to affirmatively allege justification; when they do so, it
then becomes incumbent upon the prosecution to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the conduct was not justified. This in turn involves the orders and memos they were based on. The
government will fight all this tooth and nail and submit affidavits and all kinds of shit to try to prove that everything was done in a regular fashion and properly. But it patently was not.
The defense will question and explore and demand discovery. Federal courts are clearly sick of the crapola pitched by the DOJ and they do not see anything has changed under Obama in
this regard either. This is all a path that will either lead to dismissal by the court, withdrawal of charges by the government and, perhaps most interestingly, the forum for a federal judge to
say Well the court has some serious concerns and questions too and I am going to appoint a special prosecutor from the court to look into this. It is within the courts power (as seen in
the Toobz case). This is all a door that I just do not see Holder/Obama being willing to open.
Reply
plunger September 6th, 2009 at 4:09 pm
8
Effectively standing-in-the-shoes of President Cheney, Addington makes it known that he is the client - who must be 100% pleased with the opinion that he has ordered written on
behalf of the Acting President. It is further understood that failure to deliver said document as proscribed will have severe consequences, for the Client, the Acting President, and the
opinions drafter (more accurately, transcriber).
Reply
Boston1775 September 6th, 2009 at 4:09 pm
9
Reply
Boston1775 September 6th, 2009 at 4:31 pm
10
OMG
Reply
SKIMPYPENGUIN September 6th, 2009 at 4:37 pm
11
Reply
Loo Hoo. September 6th, 2009 at 4:48 pm
12
In response to bmaz @ 7
the forum for a federal judge to say Well the court has some serious concerns and questions too and I am going to appoint a special prosecutor from the court to look into
this. It is within the courts power (as seen in the Toobz case)
Wowsers! So if Durham brings a case(s) to court, we may get a special prosecutor after all? Which court would likely hear the case? DC/Prettyman? And which judges would we hope
for?
Reply
bmaz September 6th, 2009 at 5:08 pm
13
In response to Loo Hoo. @ 12
No, I think EDVA is more likely; but do not get me wrong I am saying that will never be allowed to happen; that is my whole point.
Reply
Rayne September 6th, 2009 at 5:22 pm
14
In response to SKIMPYPENGUIN @ 11
Yeah, raised as a military brat, a foreign service degree and work experience as a lawyer for CIA, Addington has the entire tool kit necessary for Cheneys dirty work.
I think at this point were merely looking for (or waiting for) that one or two pieces of the puzzle which cause this entire thing to cascade into place.
Reply
Loo Hoo. September 6th, 2009 at 5:24 pm
15
Reply
victoria2dc September 6th, 2009 at 5:31 pm
16
EW: Im reading the link you provide to the HJC hearing and Bradburys testimony. I am hoping that you or one of our lawyer types will give this section of that testimony some
thought. Why have we not heard this from Senator Whitehouse or someone like Leahy on this? Is there something in the US Code that prohibits an agency (um. the DOJ) from
investigating itself? I think we need to talk about this:
p. 25 @ http://judiciary.house.gov/hea../40743.PDF
Mr. ELLISON. General Mukasey testified in a Senate Judiciary Committee that he would not order an investigation of waterboarding depicted on the destroyed tapes,
because the OLC had issued opinions regarding torture that were presumably relied upon by those administering the technique.
He gave two reasons. It would not be appropriate for the Justice Department to be investigating itself was one reason. The other reason is it would not be fair to prosecute
persons who relied on
OLC opinions.
As to the first reason, this is precisely the conflict situation for which the special counsel regulations of the Department call for pointing to someone outside of the Department
to conduct important investigations.
But I want to focus on the second reason, which has certain implications I would like you to focus on. At a minimum, we need to investigate whether their actions exceeded
the legal advice that
OLC gave them, or whether they would have knowthat waterboarding could not be legal.
Reply
eCAHNomics September 6th, 2009 at 5:45 pm
17
In response to victoria2dc @ 16
From someone who is not a lawyer and not into the weeds of the torture investigation. I think the narrow scope of the investigation is a political decision by Holder. He was shocked by
what was done (blahblahblahblah, are we supposed to think he cares?), so wants to suage his conscience by doing something, but doesnt want to offend his boss, who is totally against
doing anything.
Reply
fatster September 6th, 2009 at 5:49 pm
18
The worlds most powerful bankers said on Sunday they had agreed on a package of measures to strengthen on a global scale the supervision of finance industries, raising liquidity
requirements for all the G20 member nations and pushing smaller institutions to develop countercyclical cash buffers to prevent future collapses.
The measures should substantially reduce the probability and severity of economic and financial stress, a statement released by the Basel-based Bank for International Settlements
(BIS) said.
More.
Reply
WarOnError September 6th, 2009 at 5:54 pm
19
Addington was Cheneys hand puppet. I think that man sized safe in Cheneys office may have been for housing puppets.
Reply
libbyliberal September 6th, 2009 at 5:55 pm
20
Worthy of Monty Python. But they brought up the Inquisition a lot, too.
You know the line in All the Presidents Men where the accounting assistant for Hugh Sloan says, If you could get Mitchell, that would be beautiful!
Reply
eCAHNomics September 6th, 2009 at 5:56 pm
21
In response to fatster @ 18
Just wait until the financial bets on people dying crash and burn. I wouldnt be surprised if Wall St. arranges hit squads to make sure people die soon enough to make their financial
instruments profitable. We aint anywhere near plumbing the depths of financial depravity.
Reply
alinaustex September 6th, 2009 at 6:06 pm
22
skimpypenguin@ 10
Glad to see you back - So if I follow you the careerist at Langley will be leaking material evidence that Addington on behalf of Cheney was making the illegal toture legally good -and that
kept the torture chambers open in various locales. Moreover if I also follow your discussion -that this leaking is done in the context of pushback to forestall any future Sec Defense from
further poaching on traditional CIA functions and missions -particularly intelligence gathering that could lead to affirmative actions being tasked and ordered - ( IE the illegal occupation
of Irak ) . Could these leaks from the line officers at Langley also include documents -such as working email threads talking about the Team B at the OVP s office ie Cambone, Feith ,
among others talking up the EIT s as a good way to get actionable intelligence that would lash al Qaida and Saddam togather -to futher future 9-11 type attacks against CONUS ? This
is all being discussed at about the same time frame -hellbells PappaDick is still out there talking up Atta s meet and greet in Prague with Baathist intelligence operatives .
Im asking Skimpypenguin in your best assesment will there be any smoking gun documentation come out linking directly the OVP with the promulgation /promotion and actual
carrying out of torture - ?(A smoking gun email detailing how the OVP pushed Gen Miller into illegal torture at Gitmmo - boy that would be a pretty good pushback from the OGA ers !)
Just trying to keep up with this whole shebang - sure looks like the criminal conspiracy aka Cheneys OVP , gwb43 , sure are counting on a whole bunch of eletronically generated and
transmitted information remainig lost and never resurrected . BTW skimpypenguin - what is a SAP report ?
Again skimpy thank you for your service -and thanks for contributing here .
Reply
emptywheel September 6th, 2009 at 6:07 pm
23
In response to libbyliberal @ 20
I repeat, again, my judgment that the most surprising moment (to me) at the Libby Trial is the way Fitz had Addington purring like a kitty. To this day I dont know how that happened.
Reply
bmaz September 6th, 2009 at 6:36 pm
24
In response to emptywheel @ 23
I dont think it was that shocking. Addington thinks he is the smartest guy in the room and he wants to let others know it too. Ask him the right questions, set up in the proper manner, and
he will blab I think. This is actually a fairly common phenomenon with lawyers suddenly on the stand answering questions instead of asking them. Fitzgerald did a very good job with
Addington in how he crafted the examination.
Reply
emptywheel September 6th, 2009 at 6:50 pm
25
That said, what surprised me was NOT that Fitz asked the right questions, but that Addy offered up so much totally damning answers.
Reply
BMcGarth September 6th, 2009 at 6:52 pm
26
Reply
Rayne September 6th, 2009 at 6:54 pm
27
Dammitall, I cant figure out how I got down the rabbit hole Im in, but I think I tripped on something while poking around in all things Addington. Theres no direct line between
Addington and this stuff that I can see, just found a bunch of stuff and saw a possible pattern.
Remember the hullabaloo about John Bolton requesting NSA intercepts? It seems one of them was about Libyan stuff, and it was blown off at the time because it appeared to be under his
purview (unlike North Korea).
Apparently Bolton asked about William Burns, Asst. Secy of State for Near East Affairs. Burns was named ambassador to Russia in August 2005; he held the ambassadorship until late
spring of 2008.
Youll recall that Liz Cheney became Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of State For Near Eastern Affairs as of Feb. 2005 upon her return from working for Bush/Cheney 2004. She
supported C. David Welch as Asst. Secy of State for Near East Affairs; Welch was named to this position in March 2005.
Note the gap: Burns is shown as stepping down and being replaced in March 2005 by Welch, but Burns has no apparent formal role with DoS until August 2005.
Welch ultimately is responsible for the agreement signed in 2008 between Libya and the U.S. to settle past claims, allowing Libya to restore a diplomatic relationship with the U.S.
In the background, there is the case of Ibn al-Shaykh al-Libi, who had been rendered and held as a ghost detainee until his apparent death this year in a Libyan prison. A speech by
Bush in October 2002 and Colin Powells report of Feb. 2003 to the UN were allegedly based on information from al-Libi. al-Libi had been shipped to Egypt and tortured some time in
early 2002 after hed already been interrogated with some success by the FBI in late 2001; he is shifted around, ghosted, located at some points in time in Pakistan and in Poland, until
he is identified as being moved to a black site in Mauritania in November 2005. al-Libi disappears from American control between November 2005 and September 2006, eventually
being repatriated to Libya sometime in 2006.
Keep in mind that the continent of Africa is part of the portfolio under the Asst. Secy of State of Near East Affairs.
Reply
libbyliberal September 6th, 2009 at 6:59 pm
28
In response to emptywheel @ 23
Addington was described by U.S. News & World Report as the most powerful man youve never heard of.
The omnipresent permission giver. Would have liked to have seen your Fitz wipe away that teflon smugness.
Reply
bmaz September 6th, 2009 at 7:03 pm
29
In response to emptywheel @ 25
The structure of Waltons courtroom and a pro asking tailored questions is a hell of a lot different than the bozos at HJC. For all the bad about Addington, he strikes me as a laced up guy
when it comes to real authority over him; he was disdainful to HJC, but sure as heck not with Walton sitting next to and above him and an USA/AG designate examining him. I was
always bummed NSA/CREW didnt do more to put him in the chair, even for custodian testimony, but they probably wouldnt have done much anyway I suppose.
Reply
rincewind September 6th, 2009 at 7:03 pm
30
In response to emptywheel @ 25
I remember thinking at the time that Addington reminded me of a couple of Aspergers friends they just dont seem to have any internal inhibitor on saying whatevers in their mind
(and they DO think theyre the smartest people in the room ;> ) But yeah, Fitz played him very very well.
Reply
emptywheel September 6th, 2009 at 7:40 pm
31
In response to bmaz @ 29
I think it was all seeded in whatever GJ/depositions he did. And it comes down to an absolute command of the facts.
Thats the kind of authority that makes David Addington heed, I think.
Reply
emptywheel September 6th, 2009 at 7:40 pm
32
In response to rincewind @ 30
I said Aspergers at the time not really knowing what that meant. But yeahno filter, no understanding of social rules.
Reply
Rayne September 6th, 2009 at 7:49 pm
33
In response to emptywheel @ 32
Pretty sure I asked about Aspies during your live blog of his testimony; your description at the time sounded like he was absolutely compelled to dump, no inner voice telling him to stop.
Reply
fatster September 6th, 2009 at 7:56 pm
34
I remembered that had been discussed here at some time in the past, and googled. Used addington asperger as the search item. You popped right up when I did that.
Reply
STTPinOhio September 6th, 2009 at 8:06 pm
35
Reply
Rayne September 6th, 2009 at 8:18 pm
36
In response to fatster @ 34
Yeah, I found my query during the second session of EWs liveblogging of Addington, at comment (51).
BTW, didnt realize that SourceWatch had put together a timeline of all the liveblogging of the Libby Trial how groovy is that??
Reply
SKIMPYPENGUIN September 6th, 2009 at 8:33 pm
37
In response to alinaustex @ 22
Yes, I think the field guys, not the career desk jockeys, will sink the whole OVP crowd.
Folks, this is survival of the fittest. This isnt going to end up with someone being fired or embarrassed in the 24 hour news cycle. Were talking federal indictments. CIA paramilitaries are
normal people like you and I. Set aside the partisan/ideological differences for a second. They have families, they have mortgages on nice houses in McLean and Chantilly, and they have
cars and college to pay for.
They are not going to let some CIA lawyer (Addington) and a draft-dodger (Cheney) get away with this unscathed. Many of them are ex-military and take this personally. They put their
lives, careers and freedom on the line to execute orders directly from the White House. And this is how theyre repaid?
Youre going to see so many leaks Empywheel is going to have to start a spin-off blog just to dissect it all. These people create counterinsurgencies, raise rebel armies and sneak around
the globe for a living. They arent going to let Cheney get away. And FYI: if the Obama Administration tries to block this investigation quietly (or pardon people who threaten to detail
operations that started during the Clinton years, which WILL come to light) theyll obliterate him in 2012, too.
These people do this for a living in hostile places all over the globe. Theyre not going to go down without a fight. Many of them are like me: if I got guidance from the White House -
directly - I wouldnt ask any questions. Neither would any of you. That kind of involvement and proximity to the Presidency/Vice Presidency is intoxicating. I met General Powell once in
Arlington, and I was speechless.
Cheney abused that power and the respect brave men and women have for the office of the Presidency and the Office of the Vice President. He manipulated the CIA to interrogate,
knowing he would hang them out to dry when the media caught on to it. But before that, he launched a parallel effort within JSOC to do all that in more, with the explicit intention of
subverting Congressional oversight.
I know the cliche is that CIA went rogue. Even JSOC and the contractors deserve a pass here. They trusted the OVP that this was legal and aboveboard. Did some of them relish operating
extra-legally? Some did.
Most did it because the Vice President asked them to. And now, they feel betrayed.
Reply
greenbird4751 September 6th, 2009 at 8:38 pm
38
In response to SKIMPYPENGUIN @ 11
again, hoping my dkos sig theft to be officially permitted by its author, wherever you are:
The Addington perpwalk is the trailhead for accountability in this wound on our national psyche.Sachem
and i use it wherever else i can.
I will be alert to your insights, sp, they are valuable.
Reply
SKIMPYPENGUIN September 6th, 2009 at 8:42 pm
39
In response to alinaustex @ 22
The man was a born-again recovering alcoholic who dabbled with cocaine and barely graduated from college. He failed at everything he ever did and embarrasses probably the coolest
dad ever (his dad was a Navy pilot, the CIA director and the Vice President. What the fuck?)
Cheney, on the other hand, has stated on the record he felt the Presidency was diminished after Nixons administration. No conspiracy theory needed: He was planning to be the most
powerful VP for over 30 years. He didnt want to be President. He wanted to be VP and have the intelligence and defense portfolios. Cheney (and Addington) are all about ego and
revenge, not greed and power. The power was a means to an end. They had certain ideas of how the Presidential power should be expanded, and he conned Bush into delegating all the
boring stuff to him. Happened in Iran-Contra, happens every day in the military.
Reply
Rayne September 6th, 2009 at 8:47 pm
40
In response to SKIMPYPENGUIN @ 37
Were in territory now where we are neophytes, much as people getting orders were in new territory a few years ago. Were going to need guidance and tools.
Reply
SKIMPYPENGUIN September 6th, 2009 at 8:49 pm
41
In response to greenbird4751 @ 38
The key here is Addington. And I say that, because previously Addington, Libby, Flanigan, Cheney, Haynes and Yoo all played this really dangerous game called mutual assured
destruction.
One of them flipped, or grew a conscience, and theyd throw that person to the wolves.
The interesting thing to see is how much they all start to distance themselves from one another. Cheney may turn on Libby, Libby on Addington, or vice versa. And remember that
EVERYONE - except for Cheney - is a certified, actual lawyer. If it comes down to saving their own skin (especially Libby) they will turn on each other. Libby, Addington and Haynes
are the ones to watch, because they did the dirty work. Not even Cheney is as complicit as Addington. I was the guy that drew up plans and strategies for days on end when I started out.
Addington drafted complex four and five page legal memos in less than a day. He was driven and he was completely cognizant of the evil he was doing. And they didnt care if they
manipulated or burned CIA or the military, which is really going to bite them in the arse.
Reply
fatster September 6th, 2009 at 8:49 pm
42
In response to SKIMPYPENGUIN @ 37
We the People are betrayed. The persons who tortured violated law, international agreements, the Constitution, and humanitys collective conscience (though, apparently, not their own).
I recognize the comfort of thinking it was ordered by the OVP, but that excuse didnt pass in Nuremburg and rightly so. The overriding goal is to bring to justice those who orchestrated
and implemented these horrendous things.
Reply
Loo Hoo. September 6th, 2009 at 8:55 pm
43
In response to Rayne @ 36
It was fun looking through the comments there (not to mention the Addington spill)!
Reply
SKIMPYPENGUIN September 6th, 2009 at 9:02 pm
44
In response to Rayne @ 40
Expect leaks after the first major Obama policy victory. That way its all over the teevee and the bloggers spread it. It wont be this week because of the health care/school noise.
Business ties, affairstheyll start with that to knock them off balance and then start getting former military at GTMO and SOUTHCOM to go on the record about GTMO being ordered
to use the same guidance the black sites fell under.
Simultaneously, there will be an intensive campaign to show no links between Iraq and Syria, and Iraq and AQ. Former Iranian sources theyve flipped, guys they were running out of
Mosul who used to work for Saddam, those types of people will come forward with their blessing and protection. The idea will be to discredit Cheney and the crew in preparation for the
big finale:
Faulty intelligence. Raids on places that dont exist, missed chances to find people in Pakistan, etc. Theyll tie it into the EIT program and show why it was ineffective. Some will stay
silent and try to angle for a pardon, others will come completely clean. Look for the logistical and operations personnel more than the paramilitaries themselves to have the best testimony.
If they were smart, they knew this day would come and kept all copies of cables, etc even if it was classified, to protect themselves. That stuff will start to come out when they know they
can blanket the airwaves with it. Think a media shock and awe, by insiders, and then open warfare at the hearings. A lot of it will closed-session but the staffers will leak most of that (the
money from WaPo, NYT, Newsweek is too good).
Reply
SKIMPYPENGUIN September 6th, 2009 at 9:07 pm
45
In response to fatster @ 42
I have said on EW many times that it was not CIA, it was JSOC that did the truly horrible stuff. CIA stuck to the EITs (which themselves are indefensible) and contractors conducted the
waterboarding(s).
JSOC is the most guilty party. Followed by the contractors, and, finally, the least culpable and willing to go that far: college-educated, politically astute CIA paramilitaries.
Seeing as Xes indictments have dovetailed with this special prosecutor appointment, Id wager they will collide, if they havent already.
Reply
bmaz September 6th, 2009 at 9:11 pm
46
In response to SKIMPYPENGUIN @ 41
Well, you better tell your buddies to hurry up then, because a new statute of limitation expires every day; some are five year statutes, some are eight year statutes. The death cases have
no statute, but they will be the hardest to prosecute and will not be amenable to traveling up the chain to the top as you describe. The offenses and conspiracy charges that could be
extrapolated from the overt acts of the offenses are starting to fritter away.
Reply
Rayne September 6th, 2009 at 9:20 pm
47
In response to bmaz @ 46
The only other out is crimes which have not yet been discovered and recognized as such, yes? once publicized, the clock begins ticking.
Reply
fatster September 6th, 2009 at 9:27 pm
48
In response to SKIMPYPENGUIN @ 44
Reply
bmaz September 6th, 2009 at 9:39 pm
49
In response to Rayne @ 47
Unlikely. Statutes of limitation are presumed applicable and are effectively jurisdictional. You would have to show active concealment or an inability to discover the conduct, and courts
do not favor this and have a high burden for establishing it. For statutes such as most conspiracy charges, which require an overt act in furtherance of the conspiracy, the statute of
limitations begins to run on the date of the last substantive overt act. As the basic fact set that these specific crimes has been known, especially to the government (after all the govt. was
committing them), it would be hard to argue that the statutes of limitation should be tolled (i.e. suspended) simply because the government refused to properly investigate. I would say the
chances of that are about zero,
Reply
Mary September 6th, 2009 at 9:54 pm
50
In response to SKIMPYPENGUIN @ 37
They trusted the OVP that this was legal and aboveboard.
I dont buy that. You dont kidnap someone into torture and watch how the whole thing is hidden and how foreign govs are desparate to have their roles kept secret - you dont listent to
Bush parrot our commitment to humane treatment publically while you torture disappeared persons privatley and think it is aboveboard.
Im hoping you are right on the rest, but its hope, not belief. There has been a lot of remorselessness over the better part of a decade by now, and a lot of people who rely on the
protection of power of the offices of OVP and WH, no matter how much they may be angry over some things. And those people who need that protection have friends and colleagues
who wont want to rock the boat if it may damage them.
There may be a lot of people with mortgages and kids on the soccer team, but they are also people who grown accustomed to working with the torturers and they have had years now of
that subtle reinforcement hammering at them, that torture was patriotic and necessary and Cheney is the guy who will protect the torturers, their colleagues, themselves. Obamaco isnt
going to - they know that, theyve seen what happens with Bush whistleblowers under Obama. Its the Kappes and Brennans that Obama plays to, not the Moras and Tamms and
Tagubas.
With no real prosecutor and no real power, I really dont think anything will come of any of this and if it starts to go down a path where something may come of it, Obama will rush in
with claims of states secrets to cover things up. All someone will have to do is threaten to blow the foreign gov associations and theres no place Obama wont go to lock it down IMO.
But Ill hope Im wrong and wait to see if I can believe. I like believing and I dont get to do it much. Rachel Alexandra I believed in - Obama and his DOJ notsomuch and the concept of
a lot of good and decent people who worked in the torture cesspool for the better part of a decade just waiting to get an opportunity to expose themselves and their colleagues, I dont buy
that. I tried to buy the dominos of Goldsmith, Comey, Levin as good guys really trying to draw a line, but the more that comes out, the less you can believe any of that.
Reply
bmaz September 6th, 2009 at 10:08 pm
51
I tried to buy the dominos of Goldsmith, Comey, Levin as good guys really trying to draw a line, but the more that comes out, the less you can believe any of that.
Heh heh, I do not recall you being willing to spend much, if anything, on those unfit for use intended goods though.
Reply
readerOfTeaLeaves September 6th, 2009 at 10:31 pm
52
In response to SKIMPYPENGUIN @ 37
Cheney abused that power and the respect brave men and women have for the office of the Presidency and the Office of the Vice President. He manipulated the CIA to
interrogate, knowing he would hang them out to dry when the media caught on to it. But before that, he launched a parallel effort within JSOC to do all that in more, with the
explicit intention of subverting Congressional oversight.
Third, if they allow themselves to get rolled by Mr Five Deferments, the Draft Dodger Extraordinaire Richard Cheney, then they should find other means of employment.
Fourth, I just want it to be legal and public. I want the law to work, because that would be the ultimate fuck you! for Cheney, Addington, Yoo, Cambone, Feith, Wolfowitz, Perle,
Gonzo, et al. Getting these bastards legally would be the ultimate payback. Heres hoping
Reply
readerOfTeaLeaves September 6th, 2009 at 10:41 pm
53
In response to rincewind @ 30
Hes aggressive, and he appears to have an incredibly inflated sense of his own importance; its a toxic combo.
Reply
Auduboner September 6th, 2009 at 11:35 pm
54
Ah, but this might be the Genius of Holders limited investigation, not that he knows it now.
Any tenacious defense counsel for an indicted low-level operative is going to DEMAND full discovery of the justifying documents, in order to buttress the defense that the President
authorized the (despicable) actions in question. That Discovery process will produce more damning evidence than all of the congressional hearings put together. Holders DoJ wont
jeopardize the prosecution case by limiting the Defenses access to White house documents, and can lay the blame for their disclosure at the feet of those Pesky Defense Attorneys.
Political retribution is achieved, and the present Administration can say, the Judge made us do it! Win-win.
Of course, all this assumes competent Defense Counsel is involved Can we all start contributing now to the Low Level CIA Torturer Defense Fund? Ive got the first $100
Reply
Styve September 6th, 2009 at 11:44 pm
55
As I have said over the past week, its all in the book by Gellman, Angler! Arrest these motherfuckers!!
Reply
readerOfTeaLeaves September 6th, 2009 at 11:52 pm
56
Mind you, this is only proof that Addington had direct communication with Yoo and Bradbury, but not Levin. It doesnt prove that Levin was ousted to make it easier for
Addington to direct the OLC opinion writing process.
From SSCI Report: Release of Declassified Narrative Describing The DoJ OLCs Opinions on the CIAs Detention and Interrogation Program [22 April 2009, Sen John D
Rockefeller, IV]:
PREFACE: an initial narrative of the history of the opinions of the DoJs OLC from 2002 to 2007, on the legality of the CIAs detention and interrogation program
p. 3: In April 2002, attys from the CIAs Office of Gen Counsel began discussions with the Legal Advisor to the NSC and OLC concerning the CIAs proposed interrogation plan for
Abu Zubaydah and legal restrictions on that interrogation. CIA records indicate that the Legal Advisor to the NSC briefed the National Security Advisor [Rice?], Deputy National Security
Advisor [Hadley], and Counsel to the Pres. [Gonzo], as well as the AG [Ashcroft] and the head of the Criminal Division of DoJ [Chertoff?].
p. 7 In the spring of 2003, the DCI asked for a reaffirmation of the policies and practices of the interrogation program. In July 2003**, according to CIA recrods, the NSC Principals
met to discuss the interrogation techniques employed in the CIA program. According to CIA records, the DCI and the CIAs General Counsel attended a meeting with the Vice
President, the National Security Advisor [Rice], the AG [Ashcroft], the Acting Asst AG for the OLC [?? Levin???], the Counsel to the President [Gonzo], and the Legal Advisor to teh
NSC to describe the CIAs interrogation techniques, including waterboarding. According to CIA records, at the conclusion of the meeting, the Principals reaffirmed that the CIA
program was lawful and reflected administration policy.
p. 8: In May 2004, after the issuance of the IG review, CIA records indicate that the CIAs General Counsel met with the Counsel to the President [Gonzo], the Counsel to the VP
[Addington], the NSC Legal Advisor, and senior DoJ officials about the CIAs program and IG review.
And from the SSCI Report on Intelligence Activities Relating to Iraq Counducted By PCEG adn the OSP within DoD/Policy
Dec 2001: Rome meetings, in which Hadley and Wolfowitz tell Larry Franklin and Harold Rhodes to go to the meeting with Ghorbanifar and Iranians in Italy, and to tell no one,
including the CIA because the Iranians dont trust the CIA. Michael Ledeen sets up the meeting. (The Iranians are said to have distrusted the CIA, probably b/c the CIA knew they
were full of shit and it was the only way the Iranians could get away with feeding info into DoD-OVP.)
p. 6: The tasking later came back to [Rodman] through senior DoD channels as a request from NSA Hadley for the DoD to pursue the meeting with Iranians. Mr. Ledeen advised
[SSCI] that he had contacted Mr. Hadley, who he described as an old friend, and subsequently met with Mr Hadley and another NSC official to present Mr. Ghorbanifars## offer to
arrange meetings with Iranian officials.
p. 9: The US Govt officials involved in approving the Rome meeting had the authority to do so, even if it was considered an intelligence activity. Under the National Security Act of
1947, the NSC is given broad authority to identify intelligence needs, establish priorities to meet those intelligence needs, and establish policies relating to the conduct of intelligence
activities of the US
p. 9: Thus, Mr Hadley, who received concurrence from NSA Rice, had the authority to request Dep Sec Wolfowitz, who coordinated with Sec Rumsfeld, to dispatch two DoD employees
to Rome to meet with Iranians
p. 9: While the DoD had the authority to conduct the meeting in Rome, there was limited advance coordination of the activity outside the Department. Mr Hadley had advised DoD
to pursue the matter on a close-hold basis due to its unusual nature and Dep Sec Wolfowitz had reiterated that guidance [i.e., the totally cut the CIA, the FBI, the DIA, or any other
intel agency out of the meeting]
p. 14: it genuinely seemed to be Mr Franklins perception that [the info he received from the Iranians about attacks on US fighters in Afghanistan] had saved American lives. [I
include this bit because these are precisely the words Cheney uses to excuse torture.]
p. 22: Mr. Franklin recalled being approached by an official of the OVP in early 2002 requesting his opinion of Mr. Ghorbanifars plan and his judgements of its prospects for
success.
Both the SSCI report on the OCL memos, and the SSCI report on OSP (Feiths shop within DoD, set up by the neocons) have repeated references to the OVP, which brings Addington
into sharp relief drawing up the intertwining policies that led to the OLC memos and the activity in DoDs OSP office.
The OLC memos are only part of the story, but when one realizes that they were being written at the same period when Ledeen was putting together secret meetings in Italy (where DoD
employees were to meet with Iranians, but keep the meetings secret not even sharing intel with the CIA), its clear that all of this nonsense looks a bit Keystone Cops-ish, but it would
have required a legal ediface so complex that it would make baroque church organs look like simple gizmos.
Reply
bmaz September 7th, 2009 at 12:17 am
57
In response to Auduboner @ 54
Reply
Rayne September 7th, 2009 at 12:38 am
58
And once they get through the layer of lawyers, theres going to be a layer of management which will claim they are covered under USC Title 10 (military actions under direction of
executive without Congressional oversight) versus USC Title 50 (intel operations subject to Congressional oversight).
This is teed up early with Addington and/or Yoo wrt to powers of president as C-in-C during a time of war. But it will be the little guys who are going to argue this point, that they were
told this was a military op and therefore not subject to any additional disclosure and oversight, ollie-ollie-oxenfree and all that.
Reply
x174 September 7th, 2009 at 1:51 am
59
thanks for staying on top of this festering heap of lies, distortions, untruths, misrepresentations, falsehoods, deceptions and, of course, crimes.
until the DOJ commences to actually DO something meaningful about the steaming heap of atrocities, i find it difficult to pay attention to all the legalistic shenanigans.
Reply
nanute September 7th, 2009 at 3:59 am
60
In response to Audoboner@53: Any good defense lawyer will demand full discovery.
Call me a cynic, but they wont produce all the relevant docs. Didnt a very prominent govt case against a Senator from Alaska just get overturned for this very same reason?
Reply
drational September 7th, 2009 at 5:19 am
61
I suspect Levin was predisposed to standing in the way of coverup. I bet you can compile a list of people they wanted out of the way to deal with the torture issue from the Comey
Testimony on warrantless wiretapping:
James Comey, Jack Goldsmith, Patrick Philbin, Chuck Rosenberg, Daniel Levin, James Baker, David Ayres, were all listed by Comey as DOJ folks prepared to resign from the
Government if the Warrantless Surveillance program continued illegally in 2004. Besides Levin, Philbin and Comey, I am not sure who else was around to resist the torture immunity
memos in 2005.
Reply
alinaustex September 7th, 2009 at 6:01 am
62
skimpypenguin@ 38.
Maybe you can make an agument for Dubyas not being prosecuted for war crimes - but only if the Bush family promises to go after the Cheney clan hammer & tong. Hammer & Tong
meaning telling us where all the bodies are buried , or at least giving us guidance where to go seek that information.Furthermore the Bushies would have to give the ongoing investigation
political credence too -maybe send one of the the family lawyers/mouthpieces-like former Attorney General Thornburgh out to talk on the bobblehead shows -explaining why we
needed to bring Cheney and his unitarian neocon possee to Justice ! Then and only then would I consider giving President Cod Piece any semblance of a pass..
Again skimpypenguin thank you for still posting here -and I for one have full faith and confidence you are who you say you are -because frankly your insights track favorable with some
other formers I have been blessed to get to know.
So carry on -skimpypenguin -and God Speed
And ps ..bmaz if you are reading this you might want to go read a short book Operation Hotel California to get a sense in just how pissed off the spooks at the pointy end of the spear
have become , and for what reasons,,,,
Reply
JohnnyTable70 September 7th, 2009 at 6:17 am
63
In response to libbyliberal @ 20
Your quote makes me recall the scene in Annie Hall where Woody Allen produced Marshall McCluhan and says something like, if only life could be like this.
Reply
bmaz September 7th, 2009 at 6:20 am
64
In response to alinaustex @ 62
Where were these heroic and patriotic spooks the last eight years? Why are they suddenly going to come out and do the right thing after it is so late? Why do they wait until statutes of
limitation are expiring? When exactly are they going to manifest and execute this grand plan? When before has the rule of law been saved by a bunch of spooks (they are pretty effective
at breaking the law and lying and dissembling about it though)? Who is going to execute on this fantastical plan - the DOJ that is still corrupted and complicit? Obama and Holder who
have been quite consistently clear they do not intend to do anything of the sort? I have not read Operation Hotel California, but I am familiar with it and have heard an NPR interview
with the author.
Reply
SKIMPYPENGUIN September 7th, 2009 at 6:52 am
65
In response to bmaz @ 64
Theyre coming out because now they might burn for someone elses arrogance.
Reply
bmaz September 7th, 2009 at 7:07 am
A fair answer perhaps, and always a solid default explanation in such criminal and quasi-criminal situations. Although I have to wonder what real exposure these folks have at this point.
There are likely no more than a handful, maybe two, that have any exposure to the limited review underway, and there is no reason whatsoever to believe it will go any further than that.
Reply
Rayne September 7th, 2009 at 7:14 am
67
In response to bmaz @ 66
Umm, dont discourage them, bmaz. We certainly cant see the future, either.
Reply
rincewind September 7th, 2009 at 7:17 am
68
In response to bmaz @ 49
For statutes such as most conspiracy charges, which require an overt act in furtherance of the conspiracy, the statute of limitations begins to run on the date of the last substantive overt
act.
But bushco was obstructing and lying right up until Jan 20, and hold-overs have continued till today (with ample assistance from Obama/Holder/Panetta) are those substantive overt
acts?
Reply
behindthefall September 7th, 2009 at 7:25 am
69
Perhaps SKIMPYPENGUIN has made this clear and Ive just missed it, but what is heating up the tin roof on which these cats who might sing are sitting? Are they about to be let go? (SP
mentioned that they have everyday lives that depend on regular paychecks, not family fortunes.) But whos going to fire them? Who finds their continued employment inconvenient? Isnt
the wind just going to bend over the tops of the trees, not uproot trunks? (Sorry been following too many tropical depressions, I guess ) But isnt it very hard to change the
lower-downs in an organization? Isnt it usually the case that a few higher-ups get blown away, but little else happens, even with the best of will?
Reply
ondelette September 7th, 2009 at 7:31 am
70
In response to Mary @ 50
Goldsmith wrote an OLC memo justifying rendition and looking for loopholes in Article 49 of the 4th Geneva Convention. He argued that a prisoner who had not been charged was not
legally a civilian prisoner under 4th Geneva yet, so they could be deported as long as they were brought back after interrogation. Daniel Levin wrote a memo on how to make
waterboarding legal under the Torture Act for James Comey. There are more, Michael J. Garcia (U.S.A. S.D.N.Y. for 3 years, prosecuting terrorists) wrote more memoes justifying
rendition with respect to Geneva. There was a whole cottage industry in circumventing Geneva by people who have gone on either to undue respectability (Goldsmith), or at least lack of
scrutiny (Garcia) while people got imprisoned, shipped, or tried and convicted using torture data.
Reply
rincewind September 7th, 2009 at 7:33 am
71
In response to readerOfTeaLeaves @ 53
What I remember was having such a sense of deja vu watching Addington, and puzzling over what it was reminding me of, and then when ?Rayne? first mentioned Aspergers the light
went on a college prof/dept head (IT), a friend of mine in the dept (whos most likely either developing neural networks or a homeless loonie, could go either way), and my dad (a
recovering lawyer and a total putz at relationships).
Reply
Rayne September 7th, 2009 at 8:12 am
72
In response to rincewind @ 71
Hes surely without any awareness of how dickish he is; the video from the HJC committee linked above is quite good as we can see he has complete disregard for others social rank,
being focused only on his own agenda.
I can think of a manager I knew like that, an engineer by education who was completely blind to social ramifications of his assholishness. Got promoted to management for being a
technical whiz and definitely not for his people skills. (I swear to God that many of the problems with GM often the last several decades were because of placing assholes like this in
places where numbers mattered more than people.)
Reply
readerOfTeaLeaves September 7th, 2009 at 8:36 am
73
In response to Rayne @ 72
Reply
Mary September 7th, 2009 at 8:37 am
74
In response to ondelette @ 70
and bmaz @ 50
I did actually try, even if it seems like Ive been standing on the other side of the line for a long time. Its like when a client comes in and tells their story and they are always the hero of
every story. And you want to believe that, because it is going to make everything easier. But you have that ugly part in your job description where you have to keep asking them the next
question and the next one and the answers always change the story and it never ever finishes with, and they all lived happily everafter.
Even though Ive been anklebiting for a long time, I have hung on to bits and pieces and in particular on the actual torture front waiting to see the memos or emails or any of it where
theres a no from someone, or anyone. That no that the planted pieces in Newsweek and WaPo etc. keep seeming to promise are there, *if only* we *knew* more, knew what the
Ondelette - I completely agree and have been saying some of that for a long time, but I still was willing to buy that there was this kind of titanic struggle, even though every question
answered shows there was not. Not only did Goldsmith write that crap - but he has gone on to persistently and prominently editorialize for keeping the victims of his original, imo criminal,
opinions disappeared and to try to further legitimize disappearing innocent people into depravity as a *sound policy* to *keep us safe.*
Sitting on the knowledge of the old men on walkers sold into shackles and drugging and stripping and hooding and assaults and abuse and human experimentation, and the children stolen
from their parents and shipped out of country to someplace like GITMO or disappeared into Bagram or Camp Cropper or elsewhere - sitting on the full pictorals and videos of what
happens with the chaos of Executive whim that the has promoted - the existing results arent enough for him. He has to editorialize for more, longer, more invovled, more people
interwoven in the process; a wider torture tent; a more public embrace of torture. Thats what he finds to be a worthwhile way to spend time. Its how his interaction with torture and
power shaped him and the frightening part is that its a face he proud to show and one that an institution like Harvard is willing to put on display. And in the end what you have is
someone like Katyal being seduced by it too, giving more and more the luster of acceptablity.
Some of the rest, the Thompsons at Pepsico (amazing Canadians are ok with that), the Comeys at Lockheed, the Ashcrofts raking in millions from Christies and elsewhere as lobbyists and
consultants, the Philbins and Levins Kirklands and White & Cases - at least a lot of those have made their contribution to torture regimes then kept quiet. Goldsmith, like Yoo, cant kick
back and be satsified with what theyve already destroyed. Thats just the chum on the water that draws them. They dont want the feeding frenzy to end. They want to make torture an
academic exercise in every way - and almost no one flinches from it. Certainly not Obama, who rushed to pick an Solicitor Gen from the ranks of those charmed by, and defensive of, the
torture consultants who were architects of massive fraud on the courts.
Its why I cant really buy into what Skimpy is floating, as much as I wanted, anymore than I could buy into what Newsweek floated or Goldsmith floated etc. I do think that people will
leak from self defense, but I think with Obamaco in office, and the strength of hands held by Cheney and torturers (with Kagan, who would ultimately argue the cases before the Sup Ct a
Goldsmith fan) the best self defense for a lot of those guys is keeping quiet for even longer. Or mentioning a foreign nations interaction as a surefire way to get high level states secrets
invocations and walk away.
Anyone who was going to be a hero I think already made their effort. And what has happened is that Obamaco used their leaks and whistleblowing to get into office, but has now hung
them out to dry. Watching what has happened to the Bush whistleblowers under Obama isnt really a great motivator for anyone else to step forward. And watching Obama adopt the
same policies doesnt help build the pool either. Theres not likely to be anyone out there with the goods who begins to buy into Soufans now we arent going to do that when they
know why Obama is reserving rights to torture renditions. They know that al-Libis suiciding happened on Obamas watch because he wouldnt do anyting about it. They knew Obama
wouldnt move troops to protect Dostums mass grave site. They knew Obama wont make a real commitment to doing the right thing and theyre biding their time bc thats been the
historic way to win and Obamas not a game changer on that. IM kinda depressed and tired today opinion.
Reply
Mary September 7th, 2009 at 8:42 am
75
In response to rincewind @ 71
He actually reminded me of other lawyers and business guys Ive known who have that same style. Im kind of refreshed to hear that for a lot of people they would think someone like
Addington falls into a a severe personality disorder group instead of something they hit up against in any big deal and too often in small deals.
Reply
bmaz September 7th, 2009 at 9:05 am
76
In response to rincewind @ 68
Impossible to tell without specific facts and charges laid out in a charging document; but that said, no I do not think those will serve as proper substantive overt acts. Look at it this way as
a overly rudimentary example, if the concept is conspiracy to commit torture, you are looking for the last act of torture as your last overt act for starting the running of the statute of
limitations. Is it really that simple, no; but that kind of gives an idea.
Reply
bmaz September 7th, 2009 at 9:12 am
77
In response to Mary @ 74
Yep.
Reply
fatster September 7th, 2009 at 9:22 am
78
Theyre ALL connected at the roots (=the root of all evil, or money).
Ring Prosecutors: Top Ashcroft Aide Helped Abramoff Client, Didnt Disclose Hoops Tix
Zachary Roth | September 7, 2009, 11:18AM
We told you on Friday that David Ayres, a close John Ashcroft ally, looks set to plead the fifth in the latest corruption trial of a Jack Abramoff underling. And over the weekend we got
fresh detail on what looks like Ayress cozy relationship with Team Abramoff.
In documents filed yesterday in the corruption trial of Abramoff aide Kevin Ring, and examined by TPMmuckraker, prosecutors asserted that Ayres who at the time was Ashcrofts
chief of staff at the Justice Department helped Ring win federal money for a prison to be built on the reservation of the Choctaw Indians, an Abramoff client. Prosecutors also asserted
that Ring then gave Ayres tickets to the 2002 NCAA basketball tournament in Washington D.C. And, they say, the following year, Ring gave Ayress wife tickets to a pro hoops game
after she had said that she wanted them as a birthday gift for her husband. Ayres didnt report any of these tickets on financial disclosure forms, say the Ring prosecutors.
More.
Reply
Cheryl September 7th, 2009 at 9:26 am
79
In response to emptywheel @ 32
How about Narcissistic personality disorder? Sounds like a pretty good match.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N.....y_disorder
Reply
Nell September 7th, 2009 at 10:10 am
80
The CIA and special forces have been involved with torture engaging in it and training military and paramilitary clients for decades. The agency spent millions of dollars and many
years developing and refining a program of coercive interrogation. The frequency with which the CIA has incorporated special forces in its activities makes it hard to draw a line between
the two (as you yourself pointed on on a previous thread).
The picture of heroic field operatives utterly uninvolved with torture until led astray by the evil OVP is neither convincing nor useful in tracing the torture program as it existed from 2001
to early 2009.
Reply
Nell September 7th, 2009 at 10:12 am
81
In response to SKIMPYPENGUIN @ 39
Right. The skyrocketing Halliburton stock was just a happy, accidental by-product.
Reply
Nell September 7th, 2009 at 10:19 am
82
In response to Rayne @ 47
For the sake of 98% of those who are reading along, it would be good to avoid this becoming a milspeakfest.
Reply
Rayne September 7th, 2009 at 12:39 pm
83
In response to Nell @ 82
Reply
Mary September 7th, 2009 at 1:23 pm
84
Sometimes running like a girl beats being Macho, again and again and again.
@77 During Ashcroftian days the acting USA for Guam, Black, who was pushing on a lot of things, was fired and a report that he and another DOJ employee (Meissner, who also got
*demoted*) prepared for Congress got deep sixed and never sent on to Congress. The Black firing seems like a trial run for the USA firings, but they managed to get an IG report done
with Gonzales at the DOJ helm in 2006. It relied pretty heavily on things Kyle Sampson told the inspectors (Hello????? NORA?!) and pretty much left out all the nifty little things that
were, oh, say, in actual freakin emails sent by Abramoff.
This older article in The Nation has some background and a dkos poster, dengre, has a lot of stuff on this in multiple posts.
So Black sees issues and his info get directed to Gonzales who is WH Counsel at the time. Meissner takes issues to his boss, this guy named McNulty, then at the ED VA. You know, the
guy whose crew got the criminal investigation referrals for torture and the guy who had such a convincing line during the USAtty firings hearings. Oddly enough, they didnt get their
backs covered much by Gonzales and McNulty and then Gonzales and McNulty go on to end up as AG and DAG. Go figure. But the real disgrace is the IG report that was coughed up by
DOJ.
It just pretended there was no such thing as Abramoffs emails, despite everything going on with them. In particular, it ignored this email:
http://www.talkingpointsmemo.c.....ultpage=2&
The other immediate (next two weeks) challenge is the Justice Department.
Last week the bad guys who still work there (the ones who got that bad letter on Murkowski issued) started a drum beat that the CNMI had to be taken over, because it was
a loophole in the federal immigration network, and that, as such, was a threat on terrorism. They have been spending a week or so telling everyone who will listen that the
CNMI, if it is not taken over, will be a major entry point for terrorists. This, of course, is patently ridiculous, actually just the opposite, and we have been working to counter
this, but they are not backing down. We had the COS of the Justice Department [that would be David Ayres] in our box at todays Redskins game and it seems that
there might be a classified document floating in the department which deals with this matter. Making it classified, if that is indeed the case, was a good idea by our
opponents, since that means we cannot get it[darnit, all they can get is a chit chat about it from Ayers - that classified thingy works real well]. Hopefully Babauta has some
connections there and can get a copy (perhaps at least on a redacted version), which he can pass on to you to draft a response. If this is at a stage where it is gaining
momentum, he will need to leak into the press that they are considering this and how it is exactly the opposite of what should be happening. This is a real potential threat. It
will require some major action from the Hill and a press attack to get this back in the bottle. He should just follow the example we have used in the past, where we get the
press out front carefully and push the Administration back.
I am supposed to see the Attorney General next week (the Thursday after Simchas Torah) and Kevin was slated to play basketball with him before then. We will
both mention this to him. The AG will be fine, but the underlings are a worrisome matter. I am not sure what to suggest on this one, other than well pass on what we get
from the COS, and you guys should do your best to hook up with as many of the Asst AGs as possible and the political folks there. There are, I believe, some former travelers
(folks who visited the CNMI during Froilans time) among them. Well hope that the higher ups will take some time to squash this on their own. If not, it could get to be a
fire fight.
Ring was Ashcrofts staffer when Ashcroft was a Senator and was, with Coughlin, hired on by Abramoff for - well, for what he got. Access. Ayres chats about classified memos involving
Abramoffs clients to Abramoff, while Ayres is at a Redskins game favor of Abamoff; Abramoff sends out his emails, underlings like Black and Meissner get whacked hard on the job
front with something less than protection from Gonzales and McNulty, Ring and Abramoff are going to meet with and play hoops with Ashcroft to get the report squashed and voila -
not only do the authors get whacked hard but the DOJ takes it upon itself to make sure the report doesnt make it Congress. And there it sits until well after Abramoffs emails are made
public and the Congressional committee can push to get it.
All of which makes the things that are being pushed in the trials seem small potatoes and you have to wonder how many statutes vis a vis Ashcroft are being run out while DOJ changes
their game from PIG to HORSE to ELEPHANT to YELLOW THROATED EUPHONIA. But at least they are keeping Ashcroft distracted by having Christie throw money at him. Good
job guys.
Reply
radiofreewill September 7th, 2009 at 5:37 pm
85
In response to Mary @ 84
Mary - There was a Judge, iirc, also involved in the Black/Meissner/CNMI affair - and, at about the same time that Black got fired and Meissner got demoted, again iirc, the Judge was
promoted onto a lifetime Bench seat. The Bush Administration said his promotion was the normal course of affairs at that point in the Judges career, or something like that.
Do we know who that Judge was? And, where do Judges for Territories, like CNMI, actually sit? Ever since the story dropped-off the radar, Ive wondered if the Judge was somehow
connected to Abramoff and/or Rove, or otherwise caught-up in manipulation by Noel Hillmans PIN (Public Integrity Section,) the same group that is said to have been involved in the
Judge-selection in the Seigelman Affair.
Reply
timbo September 7th, 2009 at 5:47 pm
86
Yeah, cynicism may be the order of the daybut it is not the best play. Rather than prepare folks for disappointment, how about continuing to cover whatever legal issues you feel might
increase the chances of legal consequences for the tortures, thugs, etc? Not questioning your credentials with that question, just making an observation that once your view has been
expressed that it does nothing to further accountability by outlining ways that Holder and Obama might take to get out of actually enforcing the laws and the Constitutionunless you
have a plan to thwart that? So, I keep my fingers crossed that there is indeed a plan. If not a plan, than at least an incling that burying justice isnt the only likely outcome of War On
Terror.
Reply
bmaz September 7th, 2009 at 6:55 pm
87
In response to timbo @ 86
I call em as I see em, for better or worse. It is not my job to be overly and patronizingly optimistic when there is no factual basis for the same. In the same vein, exposing the ways in
which this is all being shunted and gamed does, in fact, further the cause of accountability by exhibiting how the craven will try to escape it. A citizenry better informed of the avenues of
escape is a citizenry better prepared to foreclose them.
Reply
Mary September 7th, 2009 at 7:45 pm
88
In response to radiofreewill @ 85
Im not sure if I know which judge you mean (on the complicated Abramoff intersections dengre is about the best there is) but Hillman himself got put on the District Court bench after
his activities as head of Public Integrity were well received by RNC/White House/Abramoff and seemed to make Canary crew happy as well.
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,182793,00.html
Anyway, when Hillman got his slot the WH tried to say it had all been in the works and appearances making it look like a payoff were coincidental and the similarity to Bybee giving
away the torture farm and then getting his judicial appointment were also coincidental.
Reply
fatster September 7th, 2009 at 8:42 pm
89
In response to Mary @ 88
Thanks, Mary and radiofreewill @ 84. Despite all my frustration and anger about the Seigelman thing, I had forgotten the Hillman portion of this sorry mess. So, frustration and anger up
by many more notches now. Sigh.
Reply
Jeff Kaye September 7th, 2009 at 9:18 pm
90
In response to Nell @ 80
I also believe that SPs scenario doesnt fit all the facts. I agree with SP that JSOC is far more culpable than typically discussed. However, the interpenetration of SO and CIA is
something even less discussed. You are correct to emphasize the previous existence of a long-standing torture program. To my knowledge, it has never been totally disassembled, and
lived on within OTS at CIA, and perhaps J9 at JFCOM, if not at Ft. Huachuca. Cheney/Addington woke the tiger, and rode it, but the bureaucrats at these agencies have seen POTUSs
and Veeps come and go. They remain. They get promoted. They go into industry, or start their own companies. The military-intelligence-industrial complex does not boil down to Cheney
and Addington, no matter how you slice it. The latter may be indictable, and I certainly hope so, but we are looking at a many-headed hydra.
Reply
Garrett September 7th, 2009 at 9:43 pm
91
Im interested to see whether they prosecute the death of Asad Jaleel in Iraq.
It is the most brutal of all the deaths. It seems a very prosecutable case, without the evidence problems. He had official EPW status.
It was Special Forces and regular soldiers who beat him, at separate times.
Two Special Forces interrogation notes before his deaths have notations like this guy is too dangerous to ever let out. He was already badly beaten, with the distinct ring of bruising
around his abdomen and some teeth knocked out, no longer able to stand, then they broke his neck and broke all his ribs and stuck a gag in his mouth.
Its very much the sort of case they say they are intending to reconsider. Clearly beyond anything like an authorization. But the Special Forces involvement raises awkward questions.
Reply
SKIMPYPENGUIN September 7th, 2009 at 11:04 pm
92
In response to Jeff Kaye @ 90
it being torture.
Reply
Boston1775 September 8th, 2009 at 2:52 am
93
In response to SKIMPYPENGUIN @ 65
bmaz asked you where were all of these heroic spooks for the last eight years.
Theyre coming out because now they might burn for someone elses arrogance.
This is exactly how the head of the CIA, Admiral Stansfeld Turner, handled himself in front of the MKULTRA committee in 1977 after Kennedys committee was apprised of seven
boxes of information of CIA subprojects which were not destroyed - accidentally.
Until the recent discovery, it was believed that all of the MKULTRA files dealing with behavioral modification had been destroyed in 1973 on the orders of the then retiring Chief of the
Office of Technical Service, with the authorization of the DCI, as has been previously reported. Almost all of the people who had had any connection with the aspects of the project
which interested Senate investigators in 1975 were no longer with the Agency at that time. Thus, there was little detailed knowledge of the MKULTRA subprojects available to CIA
during the Church Committee investigations. This lack of available details, moreover, was probably not wholly attributable to the
destruction of MKULTRA files in 1973; the 1963 report on MKULTRA by the Inspector General notes on page 14: Present practice is to maintain no records of the planning and
approval of test programs.
Heres the information that WASNT intentionally destroyed - and mind you, the following acts were performed on Americans:
19 subprojects probably including tests on human volunteers. While not known, some of these subprojects may have included tests on unwitting subjects as well;
4. Aspects of magicians art useful in covert operations: e.g., surreptitious delivery of drug-related materials: 4 subprojects.
5. Studies of human behavior, sleep research, and behavioral changes during psychotherapy: 9 subprojects.
6. Library searches and attendance at seminars and international conferences on behavioral modification: 6 subprojects.
10. Research on drugs, toxins, and biologicals in human tissue; provision of exotic pathogens and the capability to incorporate them in effective delivery systems: 6 subprojects.
11. Activities whose objectives cannot be determined from available documentation: 3 subprojects.
12. Subprojects involving funding support for unspecified activities connected with the Armys Special Operations Division at Fr. Detrick, Md. This activity is outline in Book I of the
Church Committee Report, pp. 388-389. (See Appendix A, pp. 68-69.) Under CIAs Project MKNAOMI, the Army Assisted CIA in developing, testing, and maintaining biological agents
and delivery systems for use against humans as well as against animals and crops. The objectives of these subprojects cannot be identified from the recovered material beyond the fact
that the money was to be used where normal funding channels would require more written or oral justification than appeared desirable for security reasons or where operational
considerations dictated short lead times for purchases. About $11,000 was involved during this period 1953-1960: 3 subprojects.
13. Single subprojects in such areas as effects of electro-shock, harassment techniques for offensive use, analysis of extrasensory perception, gas propelled sprays and aerosols, and four
subprojects involving crop and material sabotage.
Blood Grouping research, controlling the activity of animals, energy storage and transfer in organic systems; and
15. Three subprojects canceled before any work was done on them having to do with laboratory drug screening, research on brain concussion, and research on biologically active
materials to be tested through the skin on human volunteers.
Now, as to how much new the recovered material adds to what has previously been reported to the Church Committee and to Senator Kennedys Subcommittee on Health on these topics,
the answer is additional detail, for the most part: e.g., the names of previously unidentified researchers and institutions associated on either a witting or unwitting basis with MKULTRA
Financial disbursement records for the period 1960-1964 for 76 of the 149 numbered MKULTRA subprojects had been recovered from the Office of Finance by CIA and were made
available to the Church Committee investigators in August or September 1975.
The 1963 Inspector General report on MKULTRA made available to both the Church Committee and Senator Kennedys Subcommittee mentions electro-shock
and harassment substances (pp. 4, 16); covert testing on unwitting U.S. citizens (pp. 7, 10-12); the search for new materials through arrangements with specialists in universities,
pharmaceutical houses, hospitals, state and federal institutions, and private research organizations (pp. 7, 9); and the fact that the Technical Service Division of CIA had initiated 144
subprojects related to the control of human behavior between 1953-1963 (p. 21).
Reply
Boston1775 September 8th, 2009 at 3:14 am
94
In response to SKIMPYPENGUIN @ 65
Theyre coming out because now they might burn for someone elses arrogance.
In 1977, while Stan Turner was testifying under oath in front of Ted Kennedys committee, he was hiding the hideous fact that children were being tortured in dissociative states and
trained to be spies and sex-slaves.
The following is from a 1995 Presidential Hearing on Radiation and Mind Control Experiments done on American Citizens.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iflBkRlpRy0
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eXDASDDrDkM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F-ES8Bv0_8w
Reply
Boston1775 September 8th, 2009 at 3:26 am
95
Project Paperclip was organized to bring over Nazi scientists and doctors to the United States at the end of WWII.
The list of hospitals, universities, military sites, prisons and NASA facilities in which these experiments were done has been declassified. At the time of Ted Kennedys hearing, that list
was classified and Stan Turner said he would notify them privately. Hmmmm..
The way that the CIA obtained children for experimentation is told to you by the second youtube above.
You see, she was sexually abused by her family and exploited. When the CIA found the pictures or films which were spread through the pedophile rings, rather than arrest the families
and find homes for the children, the CIA allowed the children to be sold to them.
No jail time.
No jail time.
For a corroborating story, and interestingly, a CIA agent that actually apparently did something to save a child, Kelly is her name, read this pdf:
http://www.freedrive.com/file/.....1;c-obrien
Reply
Boston1775 September 8th, 2009 at 3:41 am
96
And if you are wondering where they got their supply of boys, google Boys Town, sexual abuse, CIA
Reply
Jeff Kaye September 8th, 2009 at 7:39 am
97
In response to SKIMPYPENGUIN @ 92
Since JPRA only goes back to 1999, do you mean the survival programs in general?
Reply
Sorry but the comments are closed on this post
What al-Nashiri and KSM Didnt Tell Us
Bad Max Provides More Details
We're launching a campaign to raise $150,000 to support Marcy Wheeler. All the money donated on this page will go directly to those efforts.
Register
Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Emptywheel
Advanced search
LATEST POSTS
BLOG ROLL
CREW
TIMELINE COLLECTION
Torture Timeline
Share This!
Blogmarks
del.icio.us
Digg
Furl
Netscape
Yahoo! My Web
StumbleUpon
Google Bookmarks
Technorati
Newsvine
ma.gnolia
reddit
Windows Live
Tailrank
Washington: The
Intelligence Community
Invests in Video
Biometrics: Washington
Develops Facial Recognition
Technology
Intelligence Technologies:
Full Steam Ahead for Mass
Data Processing Market
Washington: Bush
Overhauls PFIAB but Keeps
Room for His Friends
Counter-Proliferation: Has
China the Resources to
Control its Exports?
Washington: Energy
Independence the Latest Copyright 1982-2009 Indigo Publications.
Battle Cry Reproduction et diffusion interdites (photocopie,intranet,web,...) sans autorisation crite
Information Technology:
European Groups Team Up
to Create Standards
The Central Intelligence Agency secretly spent nearly $3,900 in 1956 on dog research at the University of
Maryland to develop a drug to alleviate human hypertension, according to documents released to the school
yesterday by the agency.
Dr. John Krantz, a former head of the university's pharmacology department who got the money, said he was
never told the funds came from the CIA. A research collegue at the school suggested he apply for the funds,
Krantz said, and he received the money from the Geschikter Fund for Medical Research, a frequent covert
conduit for money used in the CIA's mind control experiments during the 1950s and 1960s known as Project
MK-ULTRA.
"I took a dim view of the whole Geschikter operation then," said Krantz, who is retired, "and I take an even
dimmer view now."
Krantz, who lives near Baltimore, said he met with Charles F. Geschikter, founder of the fund, during
discussions on the project and found him "a superficial scientist." Geschikter ran a cancer research program at
Georgetown University and also administered the fund with money from private philanthropic sources and from
the CIA.
Geschikter has been unavailable for comment since information about MK-ULTRA was made public by the CIA
earlier this month.
The documents on the hupertension experiment were turned over to University of Maryland officials yesterday.
The school was one of about 80 notified in the past week by the CIA that they were part of MK-ULTRA either
with or without their knowledge.
The hypertension experiment at Maryland was among "special studies embracing pharmacological testing and
evaluation of drugs of interest to TSD [the CIA's tehcnical services division]," according to the documents.
Specifically, they noted the experiment dealt with "the effect on blood vessels of the camphoric acid
derivatives," the documents said. The fragmentary records released to the university give no indication of what
use the intelligence agency made of the information.
Maryland is the first institution among those which were part of MK-CLTRA to receive documents from the CIA.
A university spokesman said yesterday that he was told by CIA officials that the dog experiment was the only
part of the program conducted there.
Several other schools, including Georgetown, George Washington and Harvard, have said they were also part of
the program and have requested additional information from the CIA.
Documents obtained by The Washington Post reveal that senior directors of the National Institute of Mental
Health "probably" knew that the CIA funneled money to the institute to administer LSD and other drugs to
federal prisoners at Lexington, Ky.
It has been reported that drug addicts at the Addiction Research Center in Lexington were given drugs as
rewards for taking part in CIA experiments. The CIA supplied $300,000 through the Office of Naval Research
between 1954 and 1962 to pay for the experiments.
An October, 1975, report on involvement in LSD testing by the Alcohol, Drug Abuse and Mental Health
Administration, which includes NIMH, said knowledge of the source of funds was limited to senior staff members
at the Addiction Research Center and "was probably discussed with the NLMH scientific directors."
The report said that Dr. Harris Isbell, then director of the center, was approached by Sidney Gottlieh, the CIA
man in charge of MK-ULTRA, who told him that his research with LSD "was important to national interests." The
report goes on to say that "without specifying a precise interest on the part of the CIA, Mr. Gottlieb stated that
the CIA would provide money to continue these studies."
Home / President
FOXNews.com
Friday, September 18, 2009
ShareThis
Seven former directors of the Central Intelligence Agency on Friday urged President Obama to reverse Attorney
General Eric Holder's decision to hold a criminal investigation of CIA interrogators who used enhanced techniques
on detainees.
The directors, whose tenures span back as far as 35 years, wrote a letter to the president saying the cases have
already been investigated by the CIA and career prosecutors, and to reconsider those decisions makes it difficult for
agents to believe they can safely follow legal guidance.
"Attorney General Holder's decision to re-open the criminal investigation creates an atmosphere of continuous
jeopardy for those whose cases the Department of Justice had previously declined to prosecute," they wrote.
"Those men and women who undertake difficult intelligence assignments in the aftermath of an attack such as
September 11 must believe there is permanence in the legal rules that govern their actions," the seven added.
The letter was signed by former directors Michael Hayden, Porter Goss, George Tenet, John Deutch, R. James
Woolsey, William Webster and James R. Schlesinger.
Last month, Holder appointed special prosecutor John Durham to examine allegations that terror suspects were
abused at the hands of their CIA interrogators. The highly controversial decision comes as the Department of
Justice released a 2004 report from the CIA's inspector general detailing allegations of harsh interrogation
practices, which Holder cited in his decision.
The report was accompanied by conclusions that the interrogations of the detainees had yielded valuable
information that had prevented further progress by terrorists.
After Holder's announcement, the White House said the president had no choice but to let the legal ramifications
play out. The CIA then said it would pay for the legal expenses of the agents should they be prosecuted.
Current CIA Director Leon Panetta responded by a spokesman saying he appreciates Obama's "strong support for
the men and women of the CIA," and suggested while he was in league with the sentiment of the directors, he is
bound to the administration.
"The director has stood up for those who followed legal guidance on interrogation, and he will continue to do so,"
said spokesman Paul Gimigliano.
"The CIA is cooperating with the official reviews now in progress, in part to see that they move as expeditiously as
possible. The goal is to ensure that current agency operations-on which the safety of our country depends-center
on protecting the nation," Gimigliano added.
But in their letter to Obama, the directors wrote that not only is there a significant personal burden put on agents
forced to defend themselves, "but this approach will seriously damage the willingness of many other intelligence
officers to take risks to protect the country."
They added that the president has the authority to decide which legal recommendations to permit for interrogation
methods, but at no time is public disclosure helpful for intelligence officers trying to protect the U.S. from further
attacks.
The directors also warned that if the investigations are opened up, they fear that the assistance given to the United
States by foreign intelligence agencies may jeopardize future cooperation.
"Foreign services are already greatly concerned about the United States' inability to maintain any secrets. They
rightly fear that, through these additional investigations and the court proceedings that could follow, terrorists may
learn how other countries came to our assistance in a time of peril," they wrote. "As a result of the zeal on the part
of some to uncover every action taken in the post-9/11 period, many countries may decide that they can no longer
safely share intelligence or cooperate with us on future counter-terrorist operations.
Advertise on FOXNews.com, FOX News Channel , and FOX News Radio, Advertising Specifications (PDF)
Terms of Use Privacy Statement For FOXNews.com comments, write to foxnewsonline@foxnews.com; For FOX News Channel comments, write
Home / President
FOXNews.com
Friday, September 18, 2009
ShareThis
The President
Washington, D.C.
We have served as directors of Central Intelligence or directors of the CIA for presidents reaching back over 35
years. We respectfully urge you to exercise your authority to reverse Attorney General Holder's August 24 decision
to re-open the criminal investigation of CIA interrogations that took place following the attacks of September 11.
The post-September 11 interrogations for which the attorney general is opening an inquiry were investigated four
years ago by career prosecutors. The CIA, at its own initiative, forwarded fewer than 20 instances where agency
officers appeared to have acted beyond their existing legal authorities.
Career prosecutors under the supervision of the US Attorney for the Eastern District of Virginia determined that one
prosecution (of a CIA contractor) was warranted. A conviction was later obtained. They determined that
prosecutions were not warranted in the other cases. In a number of these cases the CIA subsequently took
administrative disciplinary steps against the individuals involved.
Attorney General Holder's decision to re-open the criminal investigation creates an atmosphere of continuous
jeopardy for those whose cases the Department of Justice had previously declined to prosecute. Moreover, there is
no reason to expect that the re-opened criminal investigation will remain narrowly focused.
If criminal investigations closed by career prosecutors during one administration can so easily be reopened at the
direction of political appointees in the next, declinations of prosecution will be rendered meaningless. Those men
and women who undertake difficult intelligence assignments in the aftermath of an attack such as September 11
must believe there is permanence in the legal rules that govern their actions.
They must be free, as the chairman of the Senate Homeland Security Committee, Senator Lieberman, has put it:
"to do their dangerous and critical jobs without worrying that years from now a future attorney general will
authorize a criminal investigation of them for behavior that a previous attorney general concluded was authorized
and legal." Similar deference needs to be shown to fact-based decisions made by career prosecutors years ago.
Not only will some members of the intelligence community be subjected to costly financial and other burdens from
what amounts to endless criminal investigations, but this approach will seriously damage the willingness of many
other intelligence officers to take risks to protect the country. In our judgment such risk-taking is vital to success in
the long and difficult fight against the terrorists who continue to threaten us.
Success in intelligence often depends on surprise and deception and on creating uncertainty in the mind of an
enemy. As president you have the authority to make decisions restricting substantive interrogation or any other
intelligence collection method, based on legal analyses and policy recommendations.
But, the administration must be mindful that public disclosure about past intelligence operations can only help Al
Qaeda elude U.S. intelligence and plan future operations. Disclosures about CIA collection operations have and will
continue to make it harder for intelligence officers to maintain the momentum of operations that have saved lives
and helped protect America from further attacks.
Finally, another certain result of these reopened investigations is the serious damage done to our intelligence
community's ability to obtain the cooperation of foreign intelligence agencies. Foreign services are already greatly
concerned about the United States' inability to maintain any secrets. They rightly fear that, through these
additional investigations and the court proceedings that could follow, terrorists may learn how other countries came
to our assistance in a time of peril.
The United States promised these foreign countries that their cooperation would never be disclosed. As a result of
the zeal on the part of some to uncover every action taken in the post-9/11 period, many countries may decide that
they can no longer safely share intelligence or cooperate with us on future counter-terrorist operations. They simply
cannot rely on our promises of secrecy.
We support your stated commitment, Mr. President, to look to the future regarding these important issues. In our
judgment the only way that is possible is if the criminal investigation of these interrogations that Attorney General
Holder has re-opened is now re-closed.
Sincerely,
Michael Hayden
Porter Goss
John Deutch
R. James Woolsey
William Webster
James R. Schlesinger
ADVERTISEMENTS
FOXNews.com, FOX News Channel , and FOX News Radio, Advertising Specifications (PDF)
Terms of Use Privacy Statement For FOXNews.com comments, write to foxnewsonline@foxnews.com; For FOX News Channel comments, write
to yourcomments@foxnews.com
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. 2008 FOX News Network, LLC. All rights reserved. All market data
delayed 20 minutes.
FTI has developed a proven track record for having the capability to
rapidly deploy resources from its well-developed global network of
experienced intelligence, security and special operations professionals.
Regardless of the task, FTI accomplishes your priorities in accordance with
policies, and regulations of the US Government, and appropriate
International law in an effective and efficient manner. FTI provides a broad
range of Intelligence and Special Operations support services, including:
FTI recruits and employs the most highly qualified and experienced
intelligence personnel, all with the requisite security clearances. More
importantly, were able to keep these professionals by establishing and
maintaining close working relationships while deployed. Because of FTIs
demonstrated ability to hire, expeditiously deploy, and retain talented
personnel, we consistently meet the customers quick response
requirement, which ensures a steady flow of quality, actionable intelligence
to operating forces worldwide. Today, FTI supports:
Intelligence Analysis
Contact Information:
Biographical Information:
Bill Tangney is the former Commander of US Army SOCOM and the Deputy
CINC USSOCOM. He has over 40 years of military and business
experience.
Don Latella is a retired Special Operations and Aviation Officer who has
commanded at all levels through Brigade. He has over 40 years of military
and business experience.
OUR LEADERSHIP
Leadership Bios
Mr. Ram N. Gupta, President/CEO
Ram N. Gupta is the President and CEO of Future Technologies, Inc. (FTI). He founded
FTI in 1992. As President and CEO of FTI he has managed the companys growth from a
start-up firm of one employee to one with approximately 180 employees and annual
revenues of about $18 million. Mr. Gupta has a M.S. in Business from Kurukshetra
University, an MBA from George Mason University.
The new site is part of our rights The head of Iran's Atomic Energy Organization NYT
Search
The Gaggle
Latest
Featured
RSS
Author
Holly Bailey
Email |
Bio |
Twitter
Katie Connolly
Email |
Bio |
Twitter
Barack Obama
Unturnings
Checkpoint Baghdad
The Gaggle
The Human Condition
Pop Vox
Readback
Wealth of Nations
Links
The Caucus
The Fix
Hotline Blog
First Read
The Page
Wonkette
The Note
Ben Smith
Defamer
Swampland
Hendrik Hertzberg
Jonathan Martin
FiveThirtyEight
Grist
Gawker
Mother Nature Network
Jezebel
The Daily Beast
Crikey
Huffington Post
New Matilda
Mental Floss
The Onion
Chaser
White House Correspondents Insider
Sponsored by
When he was a police officer in Elizabeth, New Jersey, Sergeant Eddie owned the wisdom
of the street. He would say, If you have to look at something twice, something is
wrong, and things tell you things.
Stephen Band, Chief, Behavioral Science Unit, FBI Training Academy.
The work cited by the Nobel committee was done jointly with the late Amos Tversky. . . .
together, we explored the psychology of intuitive beliefs and choices and examined their
bounded rationality. Daniel Kahneman, from his Nobel Prize Lecture, December 8,
2002.
What is intuition? When we make a decision based on gut instinct, how often are we
right? Why are some people more intuitive than others? Is intuition something that we should
encourage and even, teach? These were some of the issues discussed at a one and one-half day
meeting of some 50 members of the law enforcement, intelligence, legal and academic commu-
nities last July 2004 in Arlington, Virginia.
The goal of this meeting, sponsored by the National Institute of Justice (NIJ) and the
Training Academy of the FBI, was to construct a research agenda that could be taken up by the
NIJ and other agencies or organizations for the investigation of intuition, which then could be
used to inform both practice and training of police officers, intelligence agents, border guards,
airport screeners and all the other local, state and federal workers who are tasked with detecting
people who pose a threat to the American populace. Oftentimes, these individuals have little op-
portunity to gain information about a person or group of people who may have the capacity to
inflict harm; often, these agents must act quickly and decisively. Their actions may determine
the life or death of a single person, as in a police chase, or hundreds or even thousands of people,
as in entry onto an airplane or into a large sports arena. What can science do to facilitate those
agents who seem to have a 6th sense about what people are likely to do, or to teach those
agents who routinely fail to notice the important details about a person that signal intent to harm?
What do we know about cognitive and emotional processing, perception and memory that can be
made useful to the next border guard who encounters a man or woman crossing into the U.S.
plotting the next terrorist attack? What do we know about implicit cognition, the use of decision
heuristics, and stereotyping that can make the next soldier smarter about interactions with a civil-
ian populace in peace keeping operations?
Several themes repeated themselves in the discussions. There was widespread agreement
that intuition is real and that it plays a significant role in the everyday life of police officers,
whether they are stopping a car for a search, taking in the details of a crime scene, or watching
people get in and out of cars in a restaurant parking lot. There was, at the same time, little
agreement on how to define intuition, and comparisons were made to complex pattern recogni-
tion, complex emergent processes, the sense of dread that came with some police calls and
not others, the hairs standing up on the back of your neck, and feeling the eyes of an animal
on you in the woods. Questions were raised about the reliability of the phenomenon: do we
only remember the 10% times we were right and forget the 90% times we were wrong (and can
someone have a wrong intuition?). There was concurrence that some young officers appear to
have good intuitive skills virtually from the beginning of their tenure as a police officer or intel-
ligence agent, and others never seem to be able to even acquire an intuitive sense. Almost in
contrast to this, there was agreement as well that much of good decision-making depends on ex-
perience, and that people learn what to look out for. Participants agreed that they frequently
made use of their gut instinct about, for example, whether to stop a car, but then faced the
challenge of finding sufficient cause for that stop because I had a gut feeling about the guy
would not be considered sufficient probable cause in a court of law.
Social and cognitive scientists have been studying intuitions for at least 30 years. A great
deal is known about intuitions the thoughts and preferences that come to mind quickly and
without much reflection (Kahneman, 2002) that may be applicable to the needs of the agents,
officers and operatives present at the meeting, and, of course, to their coworkers, current and fu-
ture. The questions raised by the men and women with experience in the streets resonated
with the programmatic research data collected largely in laboratories. The challenge ahead of us
is how to assess what we know that can be immediately translated into effective practice, how to
affect that translation from an organizational and policy point of view, and how to determine
what is still unknown and needs further scientific analysis.
A sample of the conversations is offered below. What can be seen is that the opera-
tional community has access to technical information and on-the-street experiences; the scien-
tific community has access to controlled laboratory conditions and years of good science. The
challenge is to find a way bring these groups together, for the advancement of science and to
make our streets safer for both those who patrol them and those who walk along them.
In police chases, we construct things after We know that memories are changed with
the fact and depending, at least in part, on each experience, and that way we recall
what the law and our instructors demanded. things is changed by what else happens.
This is not intentional, and happens without
Intuition might actually be heightened vigi-
our awareness. We dont always even have
lance.
conscious access to the information that we
use to make decisions. There also are some
Cognitive biases create problems in investi-
things for which we dont have articulation,
gative processes. Many times cases went off
for example, how to describe a highly prac-
the rails because someone had a gut instinct
ticed action such as a batter hitting a 90-
and acted on it and then the whole thing
mile-an-hour ball.
goes down the tube. We need to be able to
let go of intuition.
Both attitudes and cognitions can be im-
plicit, and vulnerable to perceptual biases
produced by cultural norms and stereotypes.
The guys that are most often right about
things based on gut instincts are usually
We need to identify levels of motivation so
that 20% of the force who do 80% of the
that intuition isnt conflated with good moti-
work, and are the ones that are most likely to
vation and that bad intuition isnt associated
get into trouble and not keep their mouth
with poor motivation. Successful officers
shut.
may also be good communicators, and have
good social and emotional skills, which may
Practitioners who have very good intuition
be confounded with successful intuitive deci-
tend also to have good social skills and great
sions.
enthusiasm for their jobs, and to be extro-
verted and highly motivated.
Positive mood supports intuitive decision
making. When people are depressed, they
have a narrower way of seeing the world.
Studies show that people who practice at
something report that they are better at it,
How can we identify people are actually whether or not they are.
have good gut instincts? Maybe we can use
arrest rates or search results as a metric. How do we study characteristics or habits
that are critical but so rarely used that they
could hardly be learned? If you get shot at
Can people have good gut instincts about once in five years, then you cant learn when
something they have never before experi- someone is going to pull a gun because it
enced? The average cop doesnt have much hardly ever happens. We have to think
experience with a terrorist. about training for the impossible.
New Haven police took mental health practi-
In the old days, when patrols were made in tioners in research ride-alongs, so that the
pairs, there was more chance for mentoring. psychologists could observe directly.
Charles A. Morgan III, Behavioral Science, CIA Andrew Silke, Home Office, London
Tom Morgan, Deputy County Counsel, Kern Marco Strano, Italian State Police
County Sheriffs Department
Bryan Vila, Director, Crime Control and Preven-
Geoffrey K. Mumford, Office of Science Policy, tion Research Division, National Institute of Jus-
American Psychological Association tice
Drew Outten, New Castle County Police De- Aldert Vrij, University of Portsmouth
partment, New Castle, Delaware
Gary Wells, Iowa State University
George Palermo, Director for the Center for Fo-
rensic Psychiatry and Risk Assessment Paul Whitesell, Ft. Wayne Police Department
John Pearse, Anti-Terrorist Branch, New Scot- Javan Wilson, U.S. Attorneys Office
land Yard
Bernd Wittenbrink, University of Chicago
Anthony J. Pinizzotto, Behavioral Science Unit,
FBI Training Academy
llOTH CONGRESS
2nd Session
}
COMMITTEE PRINT {
REPORT
OF THE
INVESTIGATION STAFF
(II)
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) Contents
Note on Source Material Used in the Preparation of the Report (U) viii
B. Department of Defense Office of General Counsel Seeks Information from the Joint
Agency (U) 23
JPRA (U) 24
III. Guantanamo Bay as a "Battle Lab" for New Interrogation Techniques (U) 38
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
B. Behavioral Science Consultation Team (BSCT) Personnel Contact the U.S. Army Special
Techniques" (U) 63
C. Chain of Command Considers the Requestfor Interrogation Techniques as CITF and FBI
E. Department ofDefense General Counsel Quashes Joint Staff Legal Review (U) 70
UNCLASSIFIED
ii
UNCLASSIFIED
B. JTF-GTMO Develops Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) for the Use ofSERE
C. SERE School Trainers Provide Instruction for GTMO Interrogators (U) 103
E. National Security Council (NSC) Principals Discuss DoD Interrogations (U) 109
E. JPRA Briefs Members ofthe Working Group on SERE Techniques, Including Physical
F. The Working Group Finalizes Its Report and the Secretary of Defense Issues a New
UNCLASSIFIED
iii
UNCLASSIFIED
3. Interrogation Begins Before the Special Interrogation Plan Is Approved (U)....... 138
8. GTMO Seeks Approvalfor Two Additional Special Interrogation Plans (U) 143
X. DOJ Office of Legal Counsel Withdraws March 14,2003 Legal Opinion Governing DoD
c. Questions Raised About Task Force Participation in OGA Interrogations (U) 152
UNCLASSIFIED
iv
UNCLASSIFIED
4. Iraq Survey Group Concerns with SMU TF Detainee Treatment (U) J62
6. Interrogation OIC at Abu Ghraib Resubmits the Proposed Interrogation Policy for
51yh MI BN(U) J69
1. Special Mission Unit Task Force in Iraq Seeks Assistancefrom JPRA (U) J 70
3. JPRA Provides Interrogation Support to the Special Mission Unit Task Force in Iraq
(U) J73
J2. U.S. Joint Forces Command (JFCOM) Reviews JPRA Concept Of Operations
(CONOP) (U) J 87
J3. JFCOM Verifies Team Chief's Account of Events in Iraq (U) J88
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
D. Major General Geoffrey Miller Leads GTMO Assessment Team to Iraq (U) 189
4. GTMO Team Visits Special Mission Unit Task Force (U) 193
2. Interrogation and Counter Resistance Policy Implemented at Abu Ghraib (U)....... 201
XIII. Interrogation Techniques and Detainee Mistreatment at Abu Ghraib (U) 207
2. Assessment Team Visits Abu Ghraib and CJTF-7 Headquarters (U) 217
UNCLASSIFIED
vi
UNCLASSIFIED
C. March 2004 Interrogation SOP for Conventional Forces in Afghanistan (U) 221
c. U.S. Joint Forces Command Issues Policy Guidance For JPRA "Offensive" Support (U)...230
UNCLASSIFIED
vii
UNCLASSIFIED
Note on Source Material Used in the Preparation of the Report
(U) Over the course ofthe its inquiry into the treatment of detainees in U.S. custody, the
Committee reviewed more than 200,000 pages of classified and unclassified documents,
including detention and interrogation policies, memoranda, electronic communications, training
manuals, and the results of previous investigations into detainee abuse. The majority ofthose
documents were provided to the Committee by the Department of Defense. The Committee also
reviewed documents provided by the Department of Justice, documents in the public domain, a
small number of documents provided by individuals, and a number of published secondary
sources including books and articles in popular magazines and scholarly journals.
(U) The Committee interviewed over 70 individuals in connection with its inquiry. Most
interviews were of current or former Department of Defense employees, though the Committee
also interviewed current and/or former employees ofthe Department of Justice and the Federal
Bureau of Investigation. The Committee issued two subpoenas and held two hearings to take
testimony from subpoenaed witnesses. The Committee also sent written questions to more than
200 individuals. The Committee held public hearings on June 17, 2008 and September 25, 2008.
(U) Military personnel referred to in the report are identified by their rank at the time the
events in question took place.
UNCLASSIFIED
viii
Advanced Media Group Page 62 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 81Page
of 2413
82 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
List of Acronyms (U)
UNCLASSIFIED
ix
Advanced Media Group Page 63 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 82Page
of 2413
83 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
IROE Interrogation Rules of Engagement
ISG Iraq Survey Group
ISN Internment Serial Number
J-2 Intelligence directorate within a joint organization, e.g. Joint Staff
J-2X Counterintelligence and Human Intelligence officer or organization
J-3 Operations directorate within ajoint organization, e.g. Joint Staff
JAG Judge Advocate General
JFCOM U.S. Joint Forces Command
JIOC Joint Interrogation and Debriefing Center
JIG Joint Interrogation Group
JPRA Joint Personnel Recovery Agency
JSOC Joint Special Operations Command
JTF-160 Joint Task Force 160 at U.S. Naval Base Guantanamo Bay
JTF-170 Joint Task Force 170 at U.S. Naval Base Guantanamo Bay
JTF-GTMO Joint Task Force Guantanamo Bay
MWD Military Working Dog
NCIS Naval Criminal Investigative Service
OEF Operation Enduring Freedom
OGA Other Government Agency
01 Operating Instruction
OIC Officer in Charge
OIF Operation Iraqi Freedom
OLC Department of Justice Office of Legal Counsel
OSD Office of the Secretary of Defense
OSI Air Force Office of Special Investigations
OSO Operational Support Office (JPRA)
OTJAG Office of The Judge Advocate General
PAD Psychological Applications Directorate
POW Prisoner of War
PRA Personnel Recovery Agency
ROE Rules of Engagement
S-3 Anny operations directorate at brigade level or below
SERE Survival Evasion Resistance Escape
SJA StaffJudge Advocate
SMU Special Mission Unit
SOILIC Special Operations/Low Intensity Conflict
SOCOM U. S. Special Operations Command
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
SOP Standard Operating Procedure
SOUTHCOM U. S. Southern Command
S-V91 Department of Defense High Risk Survival Training
TF Task Force
TJAG The Judge Advocate General
TTPs Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures
UCMJ Uniform Code of Military Justice
USASOC U. S. Army Special Operations Command
USDI Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence
VTC Video Teleconference
WMD Weapons of Mass Destruction
UNCLASSIFIED
xi
Advanced Media Group Page 65 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 84Page
of 2413
85 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
Executive Summary
"What sets us apart from our enemies in this fight ... is how we behave. In
everything we do, we must observe the standards and values that dictate that we
treat noncombatants and detainees with dignity and respect. While we are
warriors, we are also all human beings. "
May 10,2007
(U) The collection oftimely and accurate intelligence is critical to the safety of U.S.
personnel deployed abroad and to the security ofthe American people here at home. The
methods by which we elicit intelligence information from detainees in our custody affect not
only the reliability ofthat information, but our broader efforts to win hearts and minds and attract
allies to our side.
(U) AI Qaeda and Taliban terrorists are taught to expect Americans to abuse them. They
are recruited based on false propaganda that says the United States is out to destroy Islam.
Treating detainees harshly only reinforces that distorted view, increases resistance to
cooperation, and creates new enemies. In fact, the April 2006 National Intelligence Estimate
"Trends in Global Terrorism: Implications for the United States" cited "pervasive anti U.S.
sentiment among most Muslims" as an underlying factor fueling the spread ofthe global jihadist
movement. Former Navy General Counsel Alberto Mora testified to the Senate Armed Services
Committee in June 2008 that "there are serving U.S. flag-rank officers who maintain that the fITst
and second identifiable causes of U. S. combat deaths in Iraq - as judged by their effectiveness in
recruiting insurgent fighters into combat - are, respectively the symbols of Abu Ghraib and
Guantanamo."
(U) The abuse of detainees in U.S. custody cannot simply be attributed to the actions of
"a few bad apples" acting on their own. The fact is that senior officials in the United States
government solicited information on how to use aggressive techniques, redefined the law to
create the appearance oftheir legality, and authorized their use against detainees. Those efforts
damaged our ability to collect accurate intelligence that could save lives, strengthened the hand
of our enemies, and compromised our moral authority. This report is a product ofthe
Committee's inquiry into how those unfortunate results came about.
UNCLASSIFIED
xii
Advanced Media Group Page 66 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 85Page
of 2413
86 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) On February 7,2002, President Bush signed a memorandum stating that the Third
Geneva Convention did not apply to the conflict with al Qaeda and concluding that Taliban
detainees were not entitled to prisoner of war status or the legal protections afforded by the Third
Geneva Convention. The President's order closed off application of Common Article 3 ofthe
Geneva Conventions, which would have afforded minimum standards for humane treatment, to
al Qaeda or Taliban detainees. While the President's order stated that, as "a matter of policy, the
United States Armed Forces shall continue to treat detainees humanely and, to the extent
appropriate and consistent with military necessity, in a manner consistent with the principles of
the Geneva Conventions," the decision to replace well established military doctrine, i.e., legal
compliance with the Geneva Conventions, with a policy subject to interpretation, impacted the
treatment of detainees in U.S. custody.
(U) In December 2001, more than a month before the President signed his memorandum,
the Department of Defense (DoD) General Counsel's Office had already solicited information on
detainee "exploitation" from the Joint Personnel Recovery Agency (JPRA), an agency whose
expertise was in training American personnel to withstand interrogation techniques considered
illegal under the Geneva Conventions.
(U) JPRA is the DoD agency that oversees military Survival Evasion Resistance and
Escape (SERE) training. During the resistance phase of SERE training, U.S. military personnel
are exposed to physical and psychological pressures (SERE techniques) designed to simulate
conditions to which they might be subject if taken prisoner by enemies that did not abide by the
Geneva Conventions. As one JPRA instructor explained, SERE training is "based on illegal
exploitation (under the rules listed in the 1949 Geneva Convention Relative to the Treatment of
Prisoners of War) of prisoners over the last 50 years." The techniques used in SERE school,
based, in part, on Chinese Communist techniques used during the Korean war to elicit false
confessions, include stripping students oftheir clothing, placing them in stress positions, putting
hoods over their heads, disrupting their sleep, treating them like animals, subjecting them to loud
music and flashing lights, and exposing them to extreme temperatures. It can also include face
and body slaps and until recently, for some who attended the Navy's SERE school, it included
waterboarding.
(U) Typically, those who play the part of interrogators in SERE school neither are trained
interrogators nor are they qualified to be. These role players are not trained to obtain reliable
intelligence information from detainees. Their job is to train our personnel to resist providing
reliable infonnation to our enemies. As the Deputy Commander for the Joint Forces Command
(JFCOM), JPRA's higher headquarters, put it: "the expertise of JPRA lies in training personnel
how to respond and resist interrogations - not in how to conduct interrogations." Given JPRA's
role and expertise, the request from the DoD General Counsel's office was unusual. In fact, the
Committee is not aware of any similar request prior to December 2001. But while it may have
been the fast, that was not the last time that a senior government official contacted JPRA for
UNCLASSIFIED
xiii
Advanced Media Group Page 67 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 86Page
of 2413
87 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
advice on using SERE methods offensively. In fact, the call from the DoD General Counsel's
office marked just the beginning of JPRA's support of U.S. government interrogation efforts.
Senior Officials Seek SERE Techniques and Discuss Detainee Interrogations (U)
(U) Beginning in the spring of 2002 and extending for the next two years, JPRA
supported U.S. government efforts to interrogate detainees. Duringthat same period, senior
government officials solicited JPRA's knowledge and its direct support for interrogations. While
much ofthe information relating to JPRA's offensive activities and the influence of SERE
techniques on interrogation policies remains classified, unclassified information provides a
window into the extent ofthose activities.
(U) JPRA's Chief of Staff, Lieutenant Colonel Daniel Baumgartner testified that in late
2001 or early 2002, JPRA conducted briefings of Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) personnel
on detainee resistance, techniques, and information on detainee exploitation.
(U) On April 16, 2002, Dr. Bruce Jessen, the senior SERE psychologist at JPRA,
circulated a draft exploitation plan to JPRA Commander Colonel Randy Mouhon and other
senior officials at the agency. The contents of that plan remain classified but Dr. Jessen's
initiative is indicative ofthe interest of JPRA's senior leadership in expanding the agency's role.
(U) One opportunity came in July 2002. That month, DoD Deputy General Counsel for
Intelligence Richard Shiffrin contacted JPRA seeking information on SERE physical pressures
and interrogation techniques that had been used against Americans. Mr. Shiffiin called JPRA
after discussions with William "Jim" Haynes II, the DoD General Counsel.
(U) In late July, JPRA provided the General Counsel's office with several documents,
including excerpts from SERE instructor lesson plans, a list of physical and psychological
pressures used in SERE resistance training, and a memo from a SERE psychologist assessing the
long-term psychological effects of SERE resistance training on students and the effects of
waterboarding. The list of SERE techniques included such methods as sensory deprivation,
sleep disruption, stress positions, waterboarding, and slapping. It also made reference to a
section ofthe JPRA instructor manual that discusses "coercive pressures," such as keeping the
lights on at all times, and treating a person like an animal. JPRA's Chief of Staff, Lieutenant
Colonel Daniel Baumgartner, who spoke with Mr. Shiffiin at the time, thought the General
Counsel's office was asking for the information on exploitation and physical pressures to use
them in interrogations and he said that JFCOM gave approval to provide the agency the
information. Mr. Shiffiin, the DoD Deputy General Counsel for Intelligence, confmned that a
purpose ofthe request was to "reverse engineer" the techniques. Mr. Haynes could not recall
what he did with the information provided by JPRA.
(U) Memos from Lieutenant Colonel Baumgartner to the Office of Secretary of Defense
General Counsel stated that JPRA would "continue to offer exploitation assistance to those
government organizations charged with the mission of gleaning intelligence from enemy
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) Mr. Haynes was not the only senior official considering new interrogation techniques
for use against detainees. Members ofthe President's Cabinet and other senior officials attended
meetings in the White House where specific interrogation techniques were discussed. Secretary
of State Condoleezza Rice, who was then the National Security Advisor, said that, "in the spring
of2002, CIA sought policy approval from the National Security Council (NSC) to begin an
interrogation progTam for high-level al-Qaida terrorists." Secretary Rice said that she asked
Director of Central Intelligence George Tenet to briefNSC Principals on the program and asked
the Attorney General John Ashcroft "personally to review and confrrm the legal advice prepared
by the Office of Legal Counsel." She also said that Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld
participated in the NSC review ofthe CIA's program.
(U) Asked whether she attended meetings where SERE training was discussed, Secretary
Rice stated that she recalled being told that U.S. military personnel were subjected in training to
"certain physical and psychological interrogation techniques." National Security Council (NSC)
Legal Advisor, John Bellinger, said that he was present in meetings "at which SERE training was
discussed."
(U) On August 1, 2002, just a week after JPRA provided the DoD General Counsel's
office the list of SERE techniques and the memo on the psychological effects of SERE training,
the Department of Justice's Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) issued two legal opinions. The
opinions were issued after consultation with senior Administration attorneys, including then
White House Counsel Alberto Gonzales and then-Counsel to the Vice President David
Addington. Both memos were signed by then-Assistant Attorney General for the Office of Legal
Counsel Jay Bybee. One opinion, commonly known as the first Bybee memo, was addressed to
Judge Gonzales and provided OLe's opinion on standards of conduct in interrogation required
under the federal torture statute. That memo concluded:
[F]or an act to constitute torture as defmed in [the federal torture statute], it must
inflict pain that is difficult to endure. Physical pain amounting to torture must be
equivalent in intensity to the pain accompanying serious physical injury, such as
organ failure, impairment of bodily function, or even death. For purely mental
pain or suffering to amount to torture under [the federal torture statute], it must
result in significant psychological harm of significant duration, e.g., lasting for
months or even years.
(U) In his book The Terror Presidency, Jack Goldsmith, the former Assistant Attorney
General of the OLC who succeeded Mr. Bybee in that job, described the memo's conclusions:
UNCLASSIFIED
xv
Advanced Media Group Page 69 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 88Page
of 2413
89 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
Violent acts aren't necessarily torture; if you do torture, you probably have a
defense; and even if you don't have a defense, the torture law doesn't apply if you
act under the color of presidential authority.
(U) The other OLC opinion issued on August 1,2002 is known commonly as the Second
Bybee memo. That opinion, which responded to a request from the CI~ addressed the legality
of specific interrogation tactics. While the full list oftechniques remains classified, a publicly
released CIA document indicates that waterboarding was among those analyzed and approved.
CIA Director General Michael Hayden stated in public testimony before the Senate Intelligence
Committee on February 5, 2008 that waterboarding was used by the CIA And Steven Bradbury,
the current Assistant Attorney General ofthe OLC, testified before the House Judiciary
Committee on February 14,2008 that the CIA's use of waterboarding was "adapted from the
SERE training program."
(U) Before drafting the opinions, Mr. Y 00, the Deputy Assistant Attorney General for the
OLC, had met with Alberto Gonzales, Counsel to the President, and David Addington, Counsel
to the Vice President, to discuss the subjects he intended to address in the opinions. In testimony
before the House Judiciary Committee, Mr. Y00 refused to say whether or not he ever discussed
or received information about SERE techniques as the memos were being drafted. When asked
whether he had discussed SERE techniques with Judge Gonzales, Mr. Addington, Mr. Yoo, Mr.
Rizzo or other senior administration lawyers, DoD General Counsel Jim Haynes testified that he
"did discuss SERE techniques with other people in the administration." NSC Legal Advisor
John Bellinger said that "some of the legal analyses of proposed interrogation techniques that
were prepared by the Department of Justice... did refer to the psychological effects ofresistance
training."
(U) In fact, Jay Bybee the Assistant Attorney General who signed the two OLC legal
opinions said that he saw an assessment of the psychological effects of military resistance
training in July 2002 in meetings in his office with John Yoo and two other OLC attorneys.
Judge Bybee said that he used that assessment to inform the August 1, 2002 OLC legal opinion
that has yet to be publicly released. Judge Bybee also recalled discussing detainee interrogations
in a meeting with Attorney General John Ashcroft and John Y 00 in late July 2002, prior to
signing the OLC opinions. Mr. Bellinger, the NSC Legal Advisor, said that "the NSC's
Principals reviewed CIA's proposed program on several occasions in 2002 and 2003" and that he
"expressed concern that the proposed CIA interrogation techniques comply with applicable U. S.
law, including our international obligations."
(U) As senior government lawyers were preparing to redefine torture, JPRA - responding
to a request from U.S. Southern Command's Joint Task Force 170 (JTF-170) at Guantanamo Bay
(GTMO) - was finalizing plans to train JTF-170 personnel. During the week of September 16,
2002, a group of interrogators and behavioral scientists from GTMO travelled to Fort Bragg,
North Carolina and attended training conducted by instructors from JPRA's SERE school. On
September 25, 2002, just days after GTMO staff returned from that training, a delegation of
UNCLASSIFIED
xvi
Advanced Media Group Page 70 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 89Page
of 2413
90 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
senior Administration lawyers, including Mr. Haynes, Mr. Rizzo, and Mr. Addington, visited
GTMO.
(U) A week after the visit from those senior lawyers, two GTMO behavioral scientists
who had attended the JPRA-Ied training at Fort Bragg drafted a memo proposing new
interrogation techniques for use at GTMO. According to one ofthose two behavioral scientists,
by early October 2002, there was "increasing pressure to get 'tougher' with detainee
interrogations." He added that ifthe interrogation policy memo did not contain coercive
techniques, then it "wasn't going to go very far."
(U) JPRA was not the only outside organization that provided advice to GTMO on
aggressive techniques. On October 2, 2002, Jonathan Fredman, who was chief counsel to the
CIA's CounterTerrorist Center, attended a meeting ofGTMO staff. Minutes of that meeting
indicate that it was dominated by a discussion of aggressive interrogation techniques including
sleep deprivation, death threats, and waterboarding, which was discussed in relation to its use in
SERE training. Mr. Fredman's advice to GTMO on applicable legal obligations was similar to
the analysis ofthose obligations in OLC's first Bybee memo. According to the meeting minutes,
Mr. Fredman said that ''the language ofthe statutes is written vaguely ... Severe physical pain
described as anything causing permanent damage to major organs or body parts. Mental torture
[is] described as anything leading to permanent, profound damage to the senses or personality."
Mr. Fredman said simply, "It is basically subject to perception. If the detainee dies you're doing
it wrong."
(U) On October 11,2002, Major General Michael Dunlavey, the Commander of JTF-170
at Guantanamo Bay, sent a memo to General James Hill, the Commander of US. Southern
Command (SOUfHCOM) requesting authority to use aggressive interrogation techniques.
Several of the techniques requested were similar to techniques used by lPRA and the military
services in SERE training, including stress positions, exploitation of detainee fears (such as fear
of dogs), removal of clothing, hooding, deprivation of light and sound, and the so-called wet
towel treatment or the waterboard. Some ofthe techniques were even referred to as "those used
in US. military interrogation resistance training." Lieutenant Colonel Diane Beaver, GTMO's
Staff Judge Advocate, wrote an analysis justifYing the legality of the techniques, though she
expected that a broader legal review conducted at more senior levels would follow her own. On
October 25, 2002, General Hill forwarded the GTMO request from Major General Dunlavey to
General Richard Myers, the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. Days later, the Joint Staff
solicited the views of the military services on the request.
UNCLASSIFIED
xvii
Advanced Media Group Page 71 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 90Page
of 2413
91 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
Military Lawyers Raise Red Flags and Joint Staff Review Quashed (D)
(U) In early November 2002, in a series of memos responding to the Joint Staff's call for
comments on GTMO's request, the military services identified serious legal concerns about the
techniques and called for additional analysis.
(U) The Air Force cited "serious concerns regarding the legality of many ofthe proposed
techniques" and stated that "techniques described may be subject to challenge as failing to meet
the requirements outlined in the military order to treat detainees humanely..." The Air Force
also called for an in depth legal review ofthe request.
(U) CITF's Chief Legal Advisor wrote that certain techniques in GTMO's October 11,
2002 request "may subject service members to punitive articles of the [Uniform Code of Military
Justice]," called "the utility and legality of applying certain techniques" in the request
"questionable," and stated that he could not "advocate any action, interrogation or otherwise, that
is predicated upon the principle that all is well if the ends justify the means and others are not
aware of how we conduct our business."
(U) The Chief ofthe Army's International and Operational Law Division wrote that
techniques like stress positions, deprivation of light and auditory stimuli, and use of phobias to
induce stress "crosses the line of 'humane' treatment," would "likely be considered
maltreatment" under the UCMJ, and "may violate the torture statute." The Army labeled
GTMO's request "legally insufficient" and called for additional review.
(U) The Navy recommended a "more detailed interagency legal and policy review" of the
request. And the Marine Corps expressed strong reservations, stating that several techniques in
the request "arguably violate federal law, and would expose our service members to possible
prosecution." The Marine Corps also said the request was not "legally sufficient," and like the
other services, called for "a more thorough legal and policy review."
(U) Then-Captain (now Rear Admiral) Jane Dalton, Legal Counsel to the Chairman of
the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said that her staff discussed the military services' concerns with the
DoD General Counsel's Office at the time and that the DoD General Counsel Jim Haynes was
aware ofthe services' concerns. Mr. Haynes, on the other hand, testified that he did not know
that the memos from the military services existed (a statement he later qualified by stating that he
was not sure he knew they existed). Eliana Davidson, the DoD Associate Deputy General
Counsel for International Affairs, said that she told the General Counsel that the GTMO request
needed further assessment. Mr. Haynes did not recall Ms. Davidson telling him that.
(U) Captain Dalton, who was the Chairman's Legal Counsel, said that she had her own
concerns with the GTMO request and directed her staffto initiate a thorough legal and policy
review ofthe techniques. That review, however, was cut short. Captain Dalton said that General
Myers returned from a meeting and advised her that Mr. Haynes wanted her to stop her review,
UNCLASSIFIED
xviii
Advanced Media Group Page 72 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 91Page
of 2413
92 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
in part because of concerns that people were going to see the GTMO request and the military
services' analysis of it. Neither General Myers nor Mr. Haynes recalled cutting short the Dalton
review, though neither has challenged Captain Dalton's recollection. Captain Dalton testified
that this occasion marked the only time she had ever been told to stop analyzing a request that
came to her for review.
(U) With respect to GTMO's October 11, 2002 request to use aggressive interrogation
techniques, Mr. Haynes said that "there was a sense by the DoD Leadership that this decision
was taking too long" and that Secretary Rumsfeld told his senior advisors "I need a
recommendation" On November 27, 2002, the Secretary got one. Notwithstanding the serious
legal concerns raised by the military services, Mr. Haynes sent a one page memo to the
Secretary, recommending that he approve all but three ofthe eighteen techniques in the GTMO
request. Techniques such as stress positions, removal of clothing, use of phobias (such as fear of
dogs), and deprivation oflight and auditory stimuli were all recommended for approval.
(U) Mr. Haynes's memo indicated that he had discussed the issue with Deputy Secretary
of Defense Paul Wolfowitz, Under Secretary of Defense for Policy Doug Feith, and General
Myers and that he believed they concurred in his recommendation. When asked what he relied
on to make his recommendation that the aggressive techniques be approved, the only written
legal opinion Mr. Haynes cited was Lieutenant Colonel Beaver's legal analysis, which senior
military lawyers had considered "legally insufficient" and "woefully inadequate," and which
LTC Beaver herself had expected would be supplemented with a review by persons with greater
experience than her own.
(U) SERE school techniques are designed to simulate abusive tactics used by our
enemies. There are fundamental differences between a SERE school exercise and a real world
interrogation. At SERE school, students are subject to an extensive medical and psychological
pre-screening prior to being subjected to physical and psychological pressures. The schools
impose strict limits on the frequency, duration, and/or intensity of certain techniques.
Psychologists are present throughout SERE training to intervene should the need arise and to
help students cope with associated stress. And SERE school is voluntary; students are even
given a special phrase they can use to immediately stop the techniques from being used against
them.
(U) Neither those differences, nor the serious legal concerns that had been registered,
stopped the Secretary of Defense from approving the use of the aggressive techniques against
detainees. Moreover, Secretary Rumsfeld authorized the techniques without apparently
providing any written guidance as to how they should be administered.
UNCLASSIFIED
xix
Advanced Media Group Page 73 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 92Page
of 2413
93 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) Following the Secretary's December 2, 2002 authorization, senior staff at GTMO
began drafting a Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) specifically for the use of SERE
techniques in interrogations. The draft SOP itself stated that "The premise behind this is that the
interrogation tactics used at U.S. military SERE schools are appropriate for use in real-world
interrogations. These tactics and techniques are used at SERE school to 'break' SERE detainees.
The same tactics and techniques can be used to break real detainees during interrogation" The
draft "GTMO SERE SOP" described how to slap, strip, and place detainees in stress positions. It
also described other SERE techniques, such as "hooding," "manhandling," and "walling"
detainees.
(U) On December 30,2002, two instructors from the Navy SERE school arrived at
GTMO. The next day, in a session with approximately 24 interrogation personnel, the two
SERE instructors demonstrated how to administer stress positions, and various slapping
techniques. According to two interrogators, those who attended the training even broke off into
pairs to practice the techniques.
(U) ExemplifYing the disturbing nature and substance ofthe training, the SERE
instructors explained "Biderman's Principles" - which were based on coercive methods used by
the Chinese Communist dictatorship to elicit false confessions from U.S. POWs during the
Korean War - and left with GTMO personnel a chart ofthose coercive techniques. Three days
after they conducted the training, the SERE instructors met with GTMO's Commander, Major
General Geoffrey Miller. According to some who attended that meeting, Major General Miller
stated that he did not want his interrogators using the techniques that the Navy SERE instructors
had demonstrated. That conversation, however, took place after the training had already
occurred and not all ofthe interrogators who attended the training got the message.
(U) At about the same time, a dispute over the use of aggressive techniques was raging at
GTMO over the interrogation of Mohammed al-Khatani, a high value detainee. Personnel from
CITF and the Federal Bureau ofInvestigations (FBI) had registered strong opposition, to
interrogation techniques proposed for use on Khatani and made those concerns known to the
DoD General Counsel's office. Despite those objections, an interrogation plan that included
aggressive techniques was approved. The interrogation itself, which actually began on
November 23,2002, a week before the Secretary's December 2,2002 grant of blanket authority
for the use of aggressive techniques, continued through December and into mid-January 2003.
(U) NSC Legal Advisor John Bellinger said that, on several occasions, Deputy Assistant
Attorney General Bruce Swartz raised concerns with him about allegations of detainee abuse at
GTMO. Mr. Bellinger said that, in tum, he raised these concerns "on several occasions with
DoD officials and was told that the allegations were being investigated by the Naval Criminal
Investigative Service." Then-National Security Advisor Condoleezza Rice said that Mr.
Bellinger also advised her "on a regular basis regarding concerns and issues relating to DoD
detention policies and practices at Guantanamo." She said that as a result she convened a "series
UNCLASSIFIED
:1:1:
Advanced Media Group Page 74 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 93Page
of 2413
94 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
of meetings ofNSC Principals in 2002 and 2003 to discuss various issues and concerns relating
to detainees in the custody ofthe Department of Defense."
(U) Between mid-December 2002 and mid-January 2003, Navy General Counsel Alberto
Mora spoke with the DoD General Counsel three times to express his concerns about
interrogation techniques at GTMO, at one point telling Mr. Haynes that he thought techniques
that had been authorized by the Secretary of Defense "could rise to the level oftorture." On
January 15,2003, having received no word that the Secretary's authority would be withdrawn,
Mr. Mora went so far as to deliver a draft memo to Mr. Haynes's office memorializing his legal
concerns about the techniques. In a subsequent phone call, Mr. Mora told Mr. Haynes he would
sign his memo later that day unless he heard defmitively that the use ofthe techniques was
suspended. In a meeting that same day, Mr. Haynes told Mr. Mora that the Secretary would
rescind the techniques. Secretary Rumsfeld signed a memo rescinding authority for the
techniques on January 15,2003.
(U) That same day, GTMO suspended its use of aggressive techniques on Khatani.
While key documents relating to the interrogation remain classified, published accounts indicate
that military working dogs had been used against Khatani. He had also been deprived of
adequate sleep for weeks on end, stripped naked, subjected to loud music, and made to wear a
leash and perform dog tricks. In a June 3, 2004 press briefing, SOUTHCOM Commander
General James Hill traced the source oftechniques used on Khatani back to SERE, stating: "The
staff at Guantanamo working with behavioral scientists, having gone up to our SERE school and
developed a list of techniques which our lawyers decided and looked at, said were OK." General
Hill said "we began to use a few ofthose techniques ... on this individuaL."
(U) On May 13, 2008, the Pentagon announced in a written statement that the Convening
Authority for military commissions "dismissed without prejudice the sworn charges against
Mohamed al Khatani." The statement does not indicate the role his treatment may have played
in that decision.
DoD Working Group Ignores Military Lawyers and Relies on OLC (D)
(U) On January 15, 2003, the same day he rescinded authority for GTMO to use
aggressive techniques, Secretary Rumsfeld directed the establishment of a "Working Group" to
review interrogation techniques. For the next few months senior military and civilian lawyers
tried, without success, to have their concerns about the legality of aggressive techniques reflected
in the Working Group's report. Their arguments were rejected in favor ofa legal opinion from
the Department of Justice's Office of Legal Counsel's (OLC) John Yoo. Mr. Yoo's opinion, the
final version of which 'was dated March 14,2003, had been requested by Mr. Haynes at the
initiation ofthe Working Group process, and repeated much of what the first Bybee memo had
said six months earlier.
(U) The first Bybee memo, dated August 1, 2002, had concluded that, to violate the
federal torture statute, physical pain that resulted from an act would have to be "equivalent in
intensity to the pain accompanying serious physical injury, such as organ failure, impairment of
UNCLASSIFIED
xxi
Advanced Media Group Page 75 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 94Page
of 2413
95 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
bodily function, or even death." Mr. Yoo's March 14, 2003 memo stated that criminal laws,
such as the federal torture statute, would not apply to certain military interrogations, and that
interrogators could not be prosecuted by the Justice Department for using interrogation methods
that would otherwise violate the law.
(U) Though the final Working Group report does not specifically mention SERE, the list
ofinterrogation techniques it evaluated and recommended for approval suggest the influence of
SERE. Removal of clothing, prolonged standing, sleep deprivation, dietary manipulation,
hooding, increasing anxiety through the use of a detainee's aversions like dogs, and face and
stomach slaps were all recommended for approval.
(U) On April 16, 2003, less than two weeks after the Working Group completed its
report, the Secretary authorized the use of24 specific interrogation techniques for use at GTMO.
While the authorization included such techniques as dietary manipulation, environmental
manipulation, and sleep adjustment, it was silent on many ofthe techniques in the Working
Group report. Secretary Rumsfeld's memo said, however, that "If, in your view, you require
additional interrogation techniques for a particular detainee, you should provide me, via the
Chairman ofthe Joint Chiefs of Staff, a written request describing the proposed technique,
recommended safeguards, and the rationale for applying it with an identified detainee."
(U) Just a few months later, one such request for "additional interrogation techniques"
arrived on Secretary Rumsfeld's desk. The detainee was Mohamedou QuId Slahi. While
documents relating to the interrogation plan for Slahi remain classified, a May 2008 report from
the Department of Justice Inspector General includes declassified information suggesting the
plan included hooding Slahi and subjecting him to sensory deprivation and "sleep adjustment."
The Inspector General's report says that an FBI agent who saw a draft ofthe interrogation plan
said it was similar to Khatani's interrogation plan. Secretary Rumsfeld approved the Slahi plan
on August 13, 2003.
(U) Shortly after Secretary Rumsfeld's December 2,2002 approval ofhis General
Counsel's recommendation to authorize aggressive interrogation techniques, the techniques
and the fact the Secretary had authorized them - became known to interrogators in Mghanistan.
A copy of the Secretary's memo was sent from GTMO to Mghanistan. Captain Carolyn Wood,
the Officer in Charge ofthe Intelligence Section at Bagram Airfield in Mghanistan, said that in
January 2003 she saw a power point presentation listing the aggressive techniques that had been
authorized by the Secretary.
(U) Despite the Secretary's January 15,2003 rescission of authority for GTMO to use
aggressive techniques, his initial approval six weeks earlier continued to influence interrogation
policies.
(U) On January 24, 2003, nine days after Secretary Rumsfe1d rescinded authority for the
techniques at GTMO, the Staff Judge Advocate for Combined Joint Task Force 180 (CJTF-180),
UNCLASSIFIED
xxii
Advanced Media Group Page 76 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 95Page
of 2413
96 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
u.s. Central Command's (CENTCOM) conventional forces in Afghanistan, produced an
"Interrogation techniques" memo. While that memo remains classified, unclassified portions of
a report by Major General George Fay stated that the memo "recommended removal of clothing
- a technique that had been in the Secretary's December 2 authorization" and discussed
"exploiting the Arab fear of dogs" another technique approved by the Secretary on December 2,
2002.
(U) From Afghanistan, the techniques made their way to Iraq. According to the
Department of Defense (DoD) Inspector General (lG), at the beginning ofthe Iraq war, special
mission unit forces in Iraq "used a January 2003 Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) which had
been developed for operations in Afghanistan." According to the DoD IG, the Afghanistan SOP
had been:
(U) Techniques approved by the Secretary of Defense in December 2002 reflect the
influence of SERE. And not only did those techniques make their way into official interrogation
policies in Iraq, but instructors from the JPRA SERE school followed. The DoD IG reported that
in September 2003, at the request ofthe Commander ofthe Special Mission Unit Task Force,
JPRA deployed a team to Iraq to assist interrogation operations. During that trip, which was
explicitly approved by U.S. Joint Forces Command, JPRA's higher headquarters, SERE
instructors were authorized to participate in the interrogation of detainees in U.S. military
custody using SERE techniques.
(U) In September 2008 testimony before the Senate Armed Services Committee, Colonel
Steven Kleinman, an Air Force Reservist who was a member ofthe interrogation support team
sent by JPRA to the Special Mission Unit Task Force in Iraq, described abusive interrogations he
witnessed, and intervened to stop, during that trip. Colonel Kleinman said that one ofthose
interrogations, which took place in a room painted all in black with a spotlight on the detainee,
the interrogator repeatedly slapped a detainee who was kneeling on the floor in front ofthe
interrogator. In another interrogation Colonel Kleinman said the two other members ofthe
JPRA team took a hooded detainee to a bunker at the Task Force facility, forcibly stripped him
naked and left him, shackled by the wrist and ankles, to stand for 12 hours.
(U) Interrogation techniques used by the Special Mission Unit Task Force eventually
made their way into Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) issued for all U.S. forces in Iraq. In
the summer of2003, Captain Wood, who by that time was the Interrogation Officer in Charge at
Abu Ghraib, obtained a copy ofthe Special Mission Unit interrogation policy and submitted it,
virtually unchanged, to her chain of command as proposed policy.
UNCLASSIFIED
xxiii
Advanced Media Group Page 77 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 96Page
of 2413
97 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) Captain Wood submitted her proposed policy around the same time that a message
was being conveyed that interrogators should be more aggressive with detainees. In mid-August
2003, an email from staffat Combined Joint Task Force 7 (CJTF-7) headquarters in Iraq
requested that subordinate units provide input for a "wish list" of interrogation techniques, stated
that "the gloves are coming off," and said "we want these detainees broken." At the end of
August 2003, Major General Geoffrey Miller, the GTMO Commander, led a team to Iraq to
assess interrogation and detention operations. Colonel Thomas Pappas, the Commander ofthe
20S th Military Intelligence Brigade, who met with Major General Miller during that visit, said
that the tenor of the discussion was that "we had to get tougher with the detainees." A Chief
Warrant Officer with the Iraq Survey Group (ISG) said that during Major General Miller's tour
ofthe ISG's facility, Major General Miller said the ISG was "running a country club" for
detainees.
(U) In his report of his investigation into Abu Ghraib, Major General George Fay said
that interrogation techniques developed for GTMO became "confused" and were implemented at
Abu Ghraib. For example, Major General Fay said that removal of clothing, while not included
in CJTF-Ts SOP, was "imported" to Abu Ghraib, could be ''traced through Mghanistan and
GTMO," and contributed to an environment at Abu Ghraib that appeared "to condone depravity
and degradation rather than humane treatment of detainees." Major General Fay said that the
policy approved by the Secretary of Defense on December 2,2002 contributed to the use of
aggressive interrogation techniques at Abu Ghraib in late 2003.
OLC Withdraws Legal Opinion - JFCOM Issues Guidance on JPRA "Offensive" Support
(U)
(U) As the events at Abu Ghraib were unfolding, Jack Goldsmith, the new Assistant Attorney
General for the Office of Legal Counsel was presented with a "short stack" of 0 Le opinions that
were described to him as problematic. Included in that short stack were the Bybee memos of
August 1,2002 and Mr. Yoo's memo of March 2003. After reviewing the memos, Mr.
Goldsmith decided to rescind both the so-called fIrst Bybee memo and Mr. Yoo's memo. In late
December 2003, Mr. Goldsmith notifIed Mr. Haynes that DoD could no longer rely on Mr.
Yoo's memo in determining the lawfulness of interrogation techniques. The change in OLe
guidance, however, did not keep JPRA from making plans to continue their support to
interrogation operations. In fact, it is not clear that the agency was even aware ofthe change.
UNCLASSIFIED
xxiv
Advanced Media Group Page 78 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 97Page
of 2413
98 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) In 2004, JPRA and CENTCOM took steps to send a JPRA training team to
Afghanistan to assist in detainee interrogations there. In the wake of the public disclosure of
detainee abuse at Abu Ghraib, however, that trip was cancelled and JFCOM subsequently issued
policy guidance limiting JPRA's support to interrogations.
(U) On September 29, 2004 Major General James Soligan, JFCOM's Chief of StatI,
issued a memorandum referencing JPRA's support to interrogation operations. Major General
Soligan wrote:
Recent requests from [the Office of the Secretary of Defense] and the Combatant
Commands have solicited JPRA support based on knowledge and information
gained through the debriefing of former U.S. POWs and detainees and their
application to U.S. Strategic debriefmg and interrogation techniques. These
requests, which can be characterized as 'offensive' support, go beyond the
chartered responsibilities of JPRA... The use of resistance to interrogation
knowledge for 'offensive' purposes lies outside the roles and responsibilities of
JPRA
(U) Lieutenant General Robert Wagner, the Deputy Commander of JFCOM, later called
requests for JPRA interrogation support "inconsistent with the unit's charter" and said that such
requests "might create conditions which tasked JPRA to engage in offensive operational
activities outside of JPRA's defensive mission."
(U) Interrogation policies endorsed by senior military and civilian officials authorizing
the use of harsh interrogation techniques were a major cause of the abuse of detainees in U.S.
custody. The impact ofthose abuses has been significant. In a 2007 international BBC poll,
only 29 percent of people around the world said the United States is a generally positive
influence in the world. Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo have a lot to do with that perception. The
fact that America is seen in a negative light by so many complicates our ability to attract allies to
our side, strengthens the hand of our enemies, and reduces our ability to collect intelligence that
can save lives.
(U) It is particularly troubling that senior officials approved the use of interrogation
techniques that were originally designed to simulate abusive tactics used by our enemies against
our own soldiers and that were modeled, in part, on tactics used by the Communist Chinese to
elicit false confessions from U.S. military personnel. While some argue that the brutality and
disregard for human life shown by al Qaeda and Taliban terrorists justifies us treating them
harshly, General David Petraeus explained why that view is misguided. In a May 2007 letter to
his troops, General Petraeus said "Our values and thelaws governing warfare teach us to respect
human dignity, maintain our integrity, and do what is right. Adherence to our values
distinguishes us from our enemy. This fight depends on securing the population, which must
understand that we - not our enemies - occupy the moral high ground."
UNCLASSIFIED
xxv
Advanced Media Group Page 79 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 98Page
of 2413
99 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
Conclusion 2: Members of the President's Cabinet and other senior officials participated in
meetings inside the White House in 2002 and 2003 where specific interrogation techniques were
d~scussed. National Security Council Principals reviewed the CIA's interrogation program
during that period.
Conclusion 3: The use oftechniques similar to those used in SERE resistance training - such
as stripping students of their clothing, placing them in stress positions, putting hoods over their
heads, and treating them like animals - was at odds with the commitment to humane treatment of
detainees in U.S. custody. Using those techniques for interrogating detainees was also
inconsistent with the goal of collecting accurate intelligence information, as the purpose of SERE
resistance training is to increase the ability of U. S. personnel to resist abusive interrogations and
the techniques used were based, in part, on Chinese Communist techniques used during the
Korean War to elicit false confessions.
Conclusion 4: The use oftechniques in interrogations derived from SERE resistance training
created a serious risk of physical and psychological harm to detainees. The SERE schools
employ strict controls to reduce the risk of physical and psychological harm to students during
training. Those controls include medical and psychological screening for students, interventions
by trained psychologists during training, and code words to ensure that students can stop the
application of a technique at any time should the need arise. Those same controls are not present
in real world interrogations.
Conclusion 5: In July 2002, the Office ofthe Secretary of Defense General Counsel solicited
information from the Joint Personnel Recovery Agency (JPRA) on SERE techniques for use
during interrogations. That solicitation, prompted by requests from Department of Defense
General Counsel William J. Haynes II, reflected the view that abusive tactics similar to those
used by our enemies should be considered for use against detainees in U.S. custody.'
Conclusion 6: The Central Intelligence Agency's (CIA) interrogation program included at least
one SERE training technique, waterboarding. Senior Administration lawyers, including Alberto
UNCLASSIFIED
xxvi
Advanced Media Group Page 80 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITED UN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 99
Page
of 2413
100 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
Gonzales, Counsel to the President, and David Addington, Counsel to the Vice President, were
consulted on the development oflegal analysis of CIA interrogation techniques. Legal opinions
subsequently issued by the Department of Justice's Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) interpreted
legal obligations under u.s. anti-torture laws and determined the legality of CIA interrogation
techniques. Those OLC opinions distorted the meaning and intent ofanti-torture laws,
rationalized the abuse of detainees in U.S. custody and influenced Department of Defense
determinations as to what interrogation techniques were legal for use during interrogations
conducted by u.s. military personnel. .
Conclusion 8: Detainee abuse occurred during JPRA's support to Special Mission Unit (SMU)
Task Force (TF) interrogation operations in Iraq in September 2003. JPRA Commander Colonel
Randy Moulton's authorization of SERE instructors, who had no experience in detainee
interrogations, to actively participate in Task Force interrogations using SERE resistance training
techniques was a serious failure in judgment. The Special Mission Unit Task Force
Commander's failure to order that SERE resistance training techniques not be used in detainee
interrogations was a serious failure in leadership that led to the abuse of detainees in Task Force
custody. Iraq is a Geneva Convention theater and techniques used in SERE school are
inconsistent with the obligations of U.S. personnel under the Geneva Conventions.
Conclusion 9: Combatant Command requests for JPRA "offensive" interrogation support and
U.S. Joint Forces Command (JFCOM) authorization ofthat support led to JPRA operating
outside the agency's charter and beyond its expertise. Only when JFCOM's Staff Judge
Advocate became aware of and raised concerns about JPRA's support to offensive interrogation
operations in late September 2003 did JFCOM leadership begin to take steps to curtail JPRA's
"offensive" activities. It was not until September 2004, however, that JFCOM issued a formal
policy stating that support to offensive interrogation operations was outside JPRA's charter.
Conclusion 10: Interrogation techniques in Guantanamo Bay's (GTMO) October 11, 2002
request for authority submitted by Major General Michael Dunlavey, were influenced by JPRA
training for GTMO interrogation personnel and included techniques similar to those used in
SERE training to teach U.S. personnel to resist abusive enemy interrogations. GTMO Staff
Judge Advocate Lieutenant Colonel Diane Beaver's legal review justifying the October 11, 2002
GTMO request was profoundly in error and legally insufficient. Leaders at GTMO, including
Major General Dunlavey's successor, Major General Geoffrey Miller, ignored warnings from
UNCLASSIFIED
xxvii
Advanced Media Group Page 81 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 100
Page
of 2413
101 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
DoD's Criminal Investigative Task Force and the Federal Bureau ofInvestigation that the
techniques were potentially unlawful and that their use would strengthen detainee resistance.
Conclusion 11: Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff General Richard Myers's decision to cut
short the legal and policy review of the October 11,2002 GTMO request initiated by his Legal
Counsel, then-Captain Jane Dalton, undermined the military's review process. Subsequent
conclusions reached by Chairman Myers and Captain Dalton regarding the legality of
interrogation techniques in the request followed a grossly deficient review and were at odds with
conclusions previously reached by the Anny, Air Force, Marine Corps, and Criminal
Investigative Task Force.
Conclusion 12: Department of Defense General Counsel William 1. Haynes II's effort to cut
short the legal and policy review of the October 11,2002 GTMO request initiated by then
Captain Jane Dahon, Legal Counsel to the Chairman ofthe Joint Chiefs of Staff, was
inappropriate and undermined the military's review process. The General Counsel's subsequent
review was grossly deficient. Mr. Haynes's one page recommendation to Secretary of Defense
Donald Rumsfeld failed to address the serious legal concerns that had been previously raised by
the military services about techniques in the GTMO request. Further, Mr. Haynes's reliance on a
legal memo produced by GTMO's Staff Judge Advocate that senior military lawyers called
"legally insufficient" and "woefully inadequate" is deeply troubling.
Conclusion 14: Department of Defense General Counsel William 1. Haynes II's direction to the
Department of Defense's Detainee Working Group in early 2003 to consider a legal memo from
John Yoo ofthe Department of Justice's OLC as authoritative, blocked the Working Group from
conducting a fair and complete legal analysis and resulted in a report that, in the words ofthen
Department ofthe Navy General Counsel Alberto Mora contained "profound mistakes in its
legal analysis." Reliance on the OLC memo resulted in a final Working Group report that
recommended approval of several aggressive techniques, including removal of clothing, sleep
deprivation, and slapping, similar to those used in SERE training to teach U. S. personnel to resist
abusive interrogations.
Conclusion 15: Special Mission Unit (SMU) Task Force (TF) interrogation policies were
influenced by the Secretary of Defense's December 2,2002 approval of aggressive interrogation
teclmiques for use at GTMO. SMU TF interrogation policies in Iraq included the use of
aggressive interrogation techniques such as military working dogs and stress positions. SMU TF
UNCLASSIFIED
xxviii
Advanced Media Group Page 82 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 101
Page
of 2413
102 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
UNCLASSIFIED
policies were a direct cause of detainee abuse and influenced interrogation policies at Abu
Ghraib and elsewhere in Iraq.
Conclusion 16: During his assessment visit to Iraq in August and September 2003, GTMO
Commander Major General Geoffrey Miller encouraged a view that interrogators should be more
aggressive during detainee interrogations.
Conclusion 17: Interrogation policies approved by Lieutenant General Ricardo Sanchez, which
included the use of military working dogs and stress positions, were a direct cause of detainee
abuse in Iraq. Lieutenant General Sanchez's decision to issue his September 14,2003 policy
with the knowledge that there were ongoing discussions as to the legality of some techniques in
it was a serious error in judgment The September policy was superseded on October 12,2003
as a result oflegal concerns raised by U.S. Central Command. That superseding policy,
however, contained ambiguities and contributed to confusion about whether aggressive
techniques, such as military working dogs, were authorized for use during interrogations.
Conclusion 18: U.S. Central Command (CENTCOM) failed to conduct proper oversight of
Special Mission Unit Task Force interrogation policies. Though aggressive interrogation
techniques were removed from Combined Joint Task Force 7 interrogation policies after
CENTCOM raised legal concerns about their inclusion in the September 14, 2003 policy issued
by Lieutenant General Sanchez, SMU TF interrogation policies authorized some ofthose same
techniques, including stress positions and military working dogs.
Conclusion 19: The abuse of detainees at Abu Ghraib in late 2003 was not simply the result of a
few soldiers acting on their own. Interrogation techniques such as stripping detainees oftheir
clothes, placing them in stress positions, and using military working dogs to intimidate them
appeared in Iraq only after they had been approved for use in Afghanistan and at GTMO.
Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld's December 2,2002 authorization of aggressive
interrogation techniques and subsequent interrogation policies and plans approved by senior
military and civilian officials conveyed the message that physical pressures and degradation were
appropriate treatment for detainees in U.S. military custody. What followed was an erosion in
standards dictating that detainees be treated humanely.
UNCLASSIFIED
xxix
Advanced Media Group Page 83 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 102
Page
of 2413
103 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
(U) On January 18,2002, White House Counsel Alberto Gonzales advised the President
ofthe Department of Justice (Dol) opinion. 4 After being briefed by Judge Gonzales, the
President concluded that the Third Geneva Convention did not apply to the conflict with al
Qaeda or to members of the Taliban, and that they would not receive the protections afforded to
Prisoners Of War (POWS).5
1According to Jack Goldsmith, Special Counsel in the Department of Defense (2002-2003) and Assistant Attorney
General, Office of Legal Counsel (2003-2004): "never in the history of the United States had lawyers had such
extraordinary influence over war policies as they did after 9/11. The lawyers weren't necessarily expert on al
Qaeda, or Islamic fundamentalism, or intelligence, or international diplomacy, or even the requirements of national
security. But the lawyers---especially White House and Justice Department lawyers-seemed to 'own' issues that
had profound national security and political and diplomatic consequences." These Administration lawyers
"dominated discussions on detention, military commissions, interrogation, GlMO, and many other controversial
terrorism policies." Jack Goldsmith, The Terror Presidency: Law and Judgment Inside the Bush Administration
(New York: W.w. Norton & Company 2(07) at 130-31 (hereinafter "Goldsmith, The Terror Presidency").
2 Memo from Deputy Assistant Attorney General John Y 00 and Special COl.D'lsel Robert Delahunty of Defense
General Counsel William 1. Haynes IL Application ofTreaties and Laws to al Qaeda and Taliban Detainees
(January 9, 2002).
3Ibid.; Department of Defense News Brieftng (December 27,2(01), available at
http://www.defnselink.mil/TranscriptsfTranscript.aspx?TranscriptID=2696 (Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld
announced plans to hold detainees at the U.S. Naval Station at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba in a news conference).
4M~mo from White House Counsel Alberto Gonzales to President George W. Bush, Decision Re Application Of
The Geneva Convention on Prisoners OfWar To The Corfflict With Al Qaeda And The TaIwan (January 25, 2(02).
, In a memo to the President, White House Counsel Gonzales noted "I understand that you decided that the [Third
Geneva Convention] does not apply [to the conflicts with al Qaeda or the Taliban] and, "accordingly, that al Qaeda
and raliban detainees are not prisoners of war" under the [Third Geneva Convention]. See Memo from White
House Counsel Alberto Gonzales to President George W. Bush, Decision Re Application OfThe Geneva Convention
on Prisoners OfWar To The Conflict WithAl QaedaAnd The Taliban (January 25,2002).
(U) During the next few weeks - after Secretary of State Colin Powell asked the
President to reconsider his decision - Administration attorneys debated the rationale for denying
legal protections under the Geneva Conventions to members of al Qaeda and the Taliban. 9 On
January 25,2002, Judge Gonzales argued in a memorandum to the President that the war on
terror had "render[ed] obsolete Geneva's strict limitations on questioning of enemy prisoners and
render[ed] quaint some of its provisions ..." He recommended that the President stand by his
order to set aside the Geneva Conventions. 10
(U) On February 7,2002, President Bush signed a memorandum stating that the Third
Geneva Convention did not apply to the conflict with al Qaeda and concluding that Taliban
detainees (designated as ''unlawful combatants" in the memorandum) were not entitled to POW
status or the legal protections afforded by the Third Geneva Convention. 11 While the President
also found that Common Article 3 (requiring humane treatment) did not apply to either al Qaeda
or Taliban detainees, his order stated that as "a matter of policy, the United States Armed Forces
6Memo from Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld to Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff General Richard
Myers Status.ofTaliban and Al Qaeda (January 19, 2002).
7 Ibid.
SCable from the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Richard Myers to U.S. MilitaIy Unified Commands and
Services (January 21, 2002).
9Memo from White House Counsel Alberto Gonzales to President George W. Bush, Decision Re Application Of
The Geneva Convention on Prisoners OfWar To The Coriflict WithAl Qaeda And The Taliban (January 25,2002).
10Judge Gonzales dismissed as ''unpersuasive''legal and policy arguments that such an order would reverse
longstanding U.S. policy and practice; undermine the protections afforded to U.S. or coalition forces captured in
Afghanistan; limit prosecution of enemy forces under the War Crimes Act (which only applies if the Geneva
Conventions apply); provoke widespread international condemnation, even if the U.S. complies with the core
humanitarian principles of the treaty as a matter of policy; may encourage other countries to look for "technical
loopholes" to avoid being bound by the Geneva Conventions; may discourage allies from turning over terrorists to
the U.S. or providing legal assistance to the U.S.; may undermine U.S. militaIy culture which emphasizes
maintaining the highest standard of conduct in combat; and could introduce an element of uncertainty in the status of
adversaries. According to Gonzales, the "positive" consequences of setting aside the Third Geneva Convention
included "preserving flexibility" in the war and "substantially reduc[ing] the threat of domestic criminal prosecution
under the War Crimes Act." Memorandum from White House Counsel Alberto Gonzales to President George W.
Bush, Decision Re Application OfThe Geneva Convention on Prisoners OfWar To The Conflict With Al Qaeda And
The Taliban (January 25, 2002).
11 Memo from President George W. Bush, Humane Treatment ofal Qaeda and Taliban Detainees (February 7,
2002).
shall continue to treat detainees humanely and, to the extent appropriate and consistent with
military necessity, in a manner consistent with the principles ofthe Geneva Conventions." 12
(U) The President's policy statement was directed at the United States Armed Forces.
The Committee is unaware ofa similar Presidential policy statement governing other agencies'
treatment of detainees. A February 2, 2002 State Department memo reflected that
Administration lawyers involved in the discussion about the application ofthe Third Geneva
Convention to the Taliban and al Qaeda had "all agree[d] that the CIA is bound by the same legal
restrictions as the U.S. military.,,13 The memo also stated, however, that "CIA lawyers
believe[d] that, to the extent that the [Third Geneva Convention's] protections do not apply as a
matter of law but those protections are applied as a matter of polici" it is desirable to
circumscribe that policy so as to limit its application to the CIA,,1 According to the memo,
"other Administration lawyers involved did not disagree with or object to the CIA's view."IS
Months later, in an October 2, 2002 meeting with DoD officials at Guantanamo Bay, Chief
Counsel to the CIA's CounterTerrorist Center (CTC) Jonathan Fredman reportedly stated that the
"CIA rallied" for the Conventions not to apply.16
(U) Several military officers, including members ofthe Judge Advocate General (JAG)
Corps, have described difficulties in interpreting and implementing the President's February 7,
2002 order. A former Staff Judge Advocate (SJA) for the Joint Forces Command (JFCOM)
stated that he thought the President's order was a tough standard for the Department of Defense
(DoD) to apply in the field because it replaced a well-established military doctrine (legal
compliance with the Geneva Conventions) with a policy that was subject to interpretation. 17 The
President's order was not, apparently, followed by any guidance that defined the terms
"humanely" or "military necessity." As a result, those in the field were left to interpret the
President's order. .
12 Memo from President George W. Bush, Humane Treatment ofal Qaeda and TaMan Detainees (February 7,
2002).
13The State Department memo reflected the views of lawyers from the Department of Justice, Department of
Defense, Department of State, White House Counsel's office, Office of the Vice President, Joint Chiefs of StafT, and
the Central Intelligence Agency. Memorandum from State Department Legal Adviser William Taft, IV to White
House Counsel Alberto Gonzales, Comments on Your Paper on the Geneva Convention (February 2,2002).
14 Ibid.
H Ibid.
16 Counter Resistance Strategy Meeting Minutes (undated) at 4, attached to email from Blaine Thomas to Sam
McCahon, and Mark Fallon (October 24, 2002) (hereinafter "Counter Resistance Strategy Meeting
Minutes')
17 Committee staff interview of Daniel Donovan (November 28, 2007).
Joint Personnel Recovery Agency (JPRA), headquartered at Fort Belvoir, Virginia, for
infonnation about detainee "exploitation.,,18 .
(U) JPRA is an agency of the Department of Defense under the command authority ofthe
U.S. Joint Forces Command (JFCOM). Part of JPRA's mission is to oversee military Survival
Evasion Resistance and Escape (SERE) training. 19 In the "resistance" phase of SERE training,
students are subject to physical and psychological pressures (SERE techniques) designed to
simulate conditions to which they might be subject if captured by an enemy that did not abide by
the Geneva Conventions. Exposing U.S. military personnel to these physical and psychological
pressures in a highly controlled environment equips them with the skills needed to increase
resistance to hostile interrogations. Among the physical and psychological pressures used at
SERE schools are stress positions, sleep deprivation, face and abdomen slaps, isolation,
degradation (such as treating the student like an animal), and "walling." Until November 2007,
waterboarding was also an approved training technique in the U.S. Navy SERE school. 20
The SERE schools employ a number of strict controls to limit the physical
or psychological impact ofthese techniques on their students. 21 For example, there are limits on
the frequency, duration, and/or intensity of certain techniques. Instructors are also required to
consider the extensive medical and/or psychological screening records of each student before
administering any technique. 22 Students are even given a phrase they can use to make the
instructor immediately cease application of all pressures. 2
(U) SERE instructors are themselves psychologically prescreened prior to hiring, and
must submit to a nearly year-long training process, annual psychological screening, and
extensive monitoring and oversight during practical exercises. These requirements are designed
to prevent instructor behavioral drift, which ifleft unmonitored, could lead to abuse of
students. 24
(U) JPRA's expertise lies in training U.S. military personnel who are at risk for capture,
how to respond and resist interrogations (a defensive mission), not in how to conduct
interrogations (an offensive mission). 25 The difference between the two missions is of critical
importance. SERE instructors play the part of interrogators, but they are not typically trained
interrogators. SERE instructors are not selected for their roles based on language skills,
intelligence training, or expertise in eliciting infonnation. 26
Because of the danger involved, very few SERE instructors are allowed to
actually use physical pressures. It is extremely easy for U.S. Army instructors,
training U. S. Army soldiers, to get out of hand, and to injure students. The
training, from the point ofthe student, appears to be chaotic and out of control. In
reality, everything that is occurring [in SERE school] is very carefully monitored
and paced; no one is acting on their own during training. Even with all these
identifying people who could be provided preventative interventions in order to increase their probab[ility] of
success in training.'')
23 The Origins of Aggressive Interrogation Techniques: Part I of the Committee's Inquiry Into the Treatment of
Detainees in u.s. Custody, Senate Committee on Armed Services, 110lh Congo (June 17, 2008) (hereinafter "SASC
Hearing (June 17,2008)"); FASO Detachment Brunswick Instruction 3305.C (January 1, 1998).
24 According to Dr. Jerald Ogrisseg, the former Chief of Psychology Services at the Air Force SERE school and
current JPRA Chief Human Factors, instructors are constantly monitored by other JPRA personnel, command staff,
and SERE psychologists to minimize the potential for students to be injured. These oversight mechanisms are
designed to ensure that SERE instructors are complying with operating instructions and to check for signs that
instructors do not suffer from moral disengagement (e.g., by becoming too absorbed in their roles as interrogators
and starting to view u.s. military SERE students as prisoners or detainees). These oversight mechanisms are also
designed to watch students for "indications that they are not coping well with training tasks, provide corrective
interventions with them before they become overwhelmed, and if need be, re-motivate students who have become
overwhelmed to enable them to succeed." Responses of Jerald Ogrisseg to Questions for the Record (July 28,
2008); Committee staff interview of Jerald Ogrisseg (June 26, 2007).
2' Department of Defense Office of the Inspector General, Review o/DoD-Directed Investigations o/Detainee
Abuse (U) (August 25, 2006) at 24 (hereinafter "DoD IG Report'').
:l6 A trained interrogator is expected to be familiar with the social, political and economic institutions and have an
understanding of the geography, history and language of "target" countries. Additionally, the more proficient an
interrogator is with languages the "better he will be able to develop rapport with his source" and "follow up on
source leads to additional information." Army Field Manual (FM) 34-52, 1-14.
safeguards, injuries and accidents do happen. The risk with real detainees is
increased exponentially. 27
(U) Despite the differences between the simulated interrogations at SERE school and real
world interrogations of detainees, in December 2001, the DoD General Counsel's office sought
JPRA's advice on the "exploitation" of detainees. The Committee is not aware of JPRA
activities in support ofany offensive interrogation mission prior to that request from the General
Counsel's office. In response to the request, JPRA Chief of Staff Lt Col Daniel Baumgartner
sent Deputy General Counsel for Intelligence Richard Shiffiin a memorandum on the
"exploitation process" and a cover note offering further JPRA assistance on "exploitation and
how to resist it.,,28
(U) The memo provided the JPRA perspective on how their SERE school staff
would handle the "initial capture," "movement," and "detention" of prisoners. 30 It also provided
advice on interrogation and recommended various approaches, including the use ofundefined
"deprivations. ,,31
_ The memo cautioned, however, that while "[p]hysical deprivations can and
do work in ahering the prisoners' mental state to the point where they will say things they
normally would not say," use of physical deprivations has "several major downfalls.,,32 JPRA
warned that physical deprivations were "not as effective" a means of getting information as
psychological pressures, that information gained from their use was "less reliable," and that their
use "tends to increase resistance postures when deprivations are removed.',33 JPRA also warned
that the use of physical deprivations has an "intolerable public and political backlash when
discovered. ,,34
28 Fax cover sheet from LTC Daniel Baumgartner to Richard Shiffrin (December 17, 2001).
29 Exploitation Process at 1, attached to fax from LTC Daniel Baumgartner to Richard Shiffrin (December 17,
2001).
31 Ibid. at 3-4.
32 Ibid. at 4.
33 Ibid.
34 Ibid.
_On
and countermeasures to defeat that resistance.
February 12,2002, Dr. Jessen sent the paper to JPRA Commander Colonel
John "Randy" Moulton, who in tum, emailed the paper to his chain of command at JFCOM with
a recommendation that it be forwarded to the Joint Stafffor dissemination. 36 In his email, Col
Moulton wrote:
_ ( Col Moulton also recommended in his email that a JPRA team travel to
Guantanamo Bay, Cuba to "provide instruction on basic and advanced techniques and methods"
that JPRA had found effective in countering resistance in students at SERE courses. 38 Col
Moulton suggested that JPRA create a "short course" to teach relevant U. S; personnel about
"interrogation from the resistance side" notin that JPRA had alread received an informal
request to conduct training for the whose fersonnel were
supporting interrogation operations at Guantanamo Bay and in Mghanistan. 3 The JPRA
Commander described the potential collaboration between JPRA a n . a s a "win-win
opportunity.,,40
3~ Committee staff interview of Bruce Jessen (July 11, 2007); Email from Col John R. (Randy) Moulton to MAl
Jack Holbein, BGen Thomas Moore, CAPT Darryl Fengya, and (February 14, 2002).
36 Email from Bruce Jessen to Col Randy Moulton (February 12, 2002).
37 Email from Col Randy Moulton to MAl Jack Holbein, BGen Thomas Moore, CAPT Darryl Fengya,
(February 14, 2002).
38 Ibid.
39 Ibid.; Memo from Col Mary Moffitt (via BG Ronald Burgess) to BGen Thomas Moore (undated) at 1.
40 Email from Col Randy Moulton to MAl Jack Holbein, BGen Thomas Moore, CAPT Darryl Fengya,
(February 14, 2002).
41 Email from BGen Thomas Moore to BG Galen Jackman et al. (February 14, 2002).
Email from LTC Michael McMahon to Lt Col Steven Ruehl, COL Jim Sikes, COL Daniel Bolger, Steve Wetzel,
42
CAPT Bill Pokorny, COL Cos Spofford, COL Edward Short, Col Kevin Kelley (February 14, 2002).
The two week class was described as an "ad hoc 'crash' course on
interrogation" for the "next crew (rotation) going to SO HCOM.,,46 The JPRA team also
participated in a s arate video teleconference with leadership and GTMO interrogation
staffwhere issues were discussed. 47 Dr. Jessen said
that he and Mr. Witsch went to make a "pitch" to about how JPRA could assist. 48
~ Witsch stated that he worked with Dr. Jessen to develop a set of briefing
slides ~training.49 The Department of Defense provided the Committee with slide
presentations that appeared to have been produced b JPRA for the March 8 2002 trainin . Mr.
Witsch testified that two slide presentations (l)
Based on Recently Obtained AI Qaeda Documents" and (2) "Exploitation"
appeared to be the same as those used by JPRA in the March 8, 2002 trainin~essen told
the Committee that he did not recognize the slides as those that he presented _ _ but that the
vast majority of the slides were consistent with what he would have taught at the training
session. 51
_ The "AI Qaeda Resistance Contingency Training" presentation described methods
used by al Qaeda to resist interrogation and exploitation and
43 Memo from Col Mary Moffitt (via BG Ronald Burgess) to BGen Thomas Moore (undated).
44 Ibid.
4'Email from Bruce Jessen to Col Randy Moulton (March 12, 2002); see also SASC Hearing (June 17, 2008)
(Testimony of Lt Col Daniel Baumgartner) ("DIA accepte~ [JPRA's] help ... with their deploying groups" and
JPRA instruction "centered on resistance techniques, questioning techniques, and general information on how
exploitation works.")
46 Email from Jim Perna to Christopher Wirts, Bruce Jessen, and Joseph Witsch (February 20,2002).
47 Email from Bruce Jessen to Col Randy Moulton (March 12, 2002).
48 Committee staff interview of Bruce Jessen (November 13, 2007).
49Hearing to Receive Information Relating To The Treatment of Detainees, Senate Committee on Armed Services,
110th Congo (September 4,2(07) (Testimony of Joseph Witsch) at 20 (hereinafter "Testimony of Joseph Witsch
(September 4, 2(07)'').
( The.
At SERE school, each ofthese terms has special meaning.
Mr. Witsch, the JPRA instructor who led the March 8, 2002 training, told the Committee that
. ~tsch could not recall what the JPRA team discussed as part of the instruction
to _ relating to degradation. 61
II ( JPRA materials also describe "sensory deprivation" and its place in the
exploitation process. 62 In testimony to the Committee, Mr. Witsch described hooding (placing a
hood over the head of a student) and white noise (such as radio static) as sensory deprivation
methods used on students in SERE school. 63 In materials provided to Department of Defense
lawyers in July 2002, JPRA explained that "[w]hen a subject is deprived of sensory input for an
[un]interrupted period, for approximately 6-8 hours, it is not uncommon for them to experience
training. 6
II Mr. Witsch could not recall the discussion of "sensory deprivation" at the.
visual, auditory and!or tactile hallucinations. If deprived of input, the brain will make it up." 64
(U) When used in the context of simulated interrogations conducted at SERE school,
JPRA uses the term "physiological pressures" synonymously with approved physical pressures. 66
III
Mr. Witsch could not recall what the discussion of "physiological and psychological
pressures" at 7 He said that he provided" personnel with a ''vision of how
we (JPRA) prepare, train, and equip our personnel" in SERE school. 68 Mr. Witsch could not
recall if physical pressures were discussed at the training. 69 Dr. Jessen, the senior SERE
psychologist who also provided instruction t o . personnel, said that physical pressures were
to_
not discussed at the March 8, 2002 training. 70
62 Physical Pressures Used In Resistance Training and Against American Prisoners and Detainees.
63 Testimony of Joseph Witsch (September 4, 2007) at 23-24.
64 Physical Pressures Used In Resistance Training and Against American Prisoners and Detainees; See Section II
D, infra.
6' Testimony of Joseph Witsch (September 4, 2007) at 22.
66 Committee staff interview of Bruce Jessen (July 11,2002).
67 Testimony of Joseph Witsch (September 4, 2007).
68 Ibid. at 44.
69 Ibid. at 25.
70 Committee staff interview of Bruce Jessen (July 11,2002).
71 Email from Bruce Jessen to Col Randy Moulton (March 12, 2002).
72 Ibid.
10
not have known at the time if isolation, degradation, sensory deprivation, or other topics
referenced in the slides would have been within the confmes ofthe Geneva Conventions. 73
_ Days later, Dr. Jessen sent Col Moulton another email with his thoughts about
additional training for interrogators. Dr. Jessen explained that for future training, one day would
be sufficient to "cover the basics of DOD Level 'C' Resistance training and the special
contingency information" that they addressed_ However, he said that if he added "role
play" to the curriculum, he would need at least four days. 74
73 Dr. Jessen told the Committee that, at the time, he did not know that the scope of the Geneva Conventions
protections were different for Prisoners of War than they were for al Qaeda or Taliban detainees. Committee staff
interview of Bruce Jessen (November 13, 2(07).
74 Email from Bruce Jessen to Col Randy Moulton et a1. (March 18, 2002).
75 Ibid.
76 Ibid.
77Memo forCol Cooney, Prisoner Handling Recommendations (February 28,2002), attached to email from Bruce
Jessen to Joseph Witsch (March 13,2002).
78 Email from Bruce Jessen to Joseph Witsch (March 13,2(02). Committee staff interview of Bruce Jessen
(November 13, 2007).
79 Memo for Col Cooney, Prisoner Handling Recommendations (February 28,2002).
~emo for Col Cooney, Prisoner Handling Recommendations (February 28,2002), attached to email from Bruce
Jessen to Joseph Witsch (March 13,2002).
11
(U) At the time of COL Herrington's visit, the mission at Guantanamo was under the
control oftwo different task forces, each commanded by a different Major General: ITF-170 for
intelligence exploitation and ITF160 for detention and security operations. s3 COL Herrington
noted in his assessment that there was ''unanimity among all military and interagency
participants in TF-170 that the security mission is sometimes the tail wagging the intelligence
dog" and stated:
To effectively carry out its intelligence exploitation mission, TF 170 and its
interagency collaborators need to be in full control of the detainees' environment.
Treatment, rewards, punishment, and anything else associated with a detainee
should be centrally orchestrated by the debriefing team responsible for obtaining
information from that detainee. 84
(U) COL Herrington also expressed concern that actions (positive or negative) which
guards might take as routine, such as singling a detainee out for a shakedown or providing an
extra chaplain's visit, might impact the ability of interrogators and debriefers from setting the
tone ofthe questioning sessions. 85
(U) COL Herrington found that facilities and procedures at GTMO for handling detainees
posed serious problems. He said that design flaws at GTMO's current and planned detention
sites hampered intelligence collection, noting that the "open" facilities, for example, facilitated
communications among the detainees and discouraged detainee cooperation by permitting
detainees to support each other's resistance efforts. 86
81COL Herrington had acquired experience in interrogation and debriefIng during more than thirty years of military
service. Memo from COL Stuart Herrington to MG Michael Dunlavey, Report ofVisit and Recommendations
(March 22,2002) at 8.
82See COL Herrington, Report ofVisit and Recommendations; COL Herrington also provided an additional list of
"suggestions" for MG Dunlavey and his 12, LTC Ron Buikema. See Memo from COL Stuart Herrington to MG
Michael Dunlavey, Suggestions (March 25, 2002)
83 ITF-160was established at Guantanamo Bay in the mid-l 990s to support relief and migrant processing centers for
Haitian and Cuban migrants.
84 COL Herrington, Report of Visit and Recommendations at 1-2.
8' Ibid. at 2.
86 Ibid. at 3.
12
(U) COL Herrington also warned that certain security procedures in place at the time
could have a negative impact on intelligence collection, stating:
The austere nature ofthe facilities and the rigorous security movement procedures
(shackles, two MPs with hands on the detainee, etc.) reinforces to detainees that
they are in prison, and detracts from the flexibility that debriefers require to
accomplish their mission... These views have nothing to do with being "soft" on
the detainees. Nor do they challenge the pure security gains from such tight
control. The principal at work is that optimal exploitation of a detainee cannot be
done from a cell ... 87
(U) Specifically, COL Herrington recommended that MPs not be in the room during
interrogations and warned that, while shackling a detainee might make sense from a security
standpoint, it could be counterproductive to intelligence collection:
Shackling one of the detainee's feet to the floor during interrogation might make
sense from a security perspective (although, with one or two MPs present, it is
arguable overkill). However, such shackling is either a) humiliating, or b) sends a
message to the detainee that the debriefer is afraid of him, or c) reminds him of
his plight as a prisoner. 88
(U) COL Herrington observed that most of the interrogators at GTMO lacked the
requisite training in strategic elicitation or the experience required to be effective with the
detainees. 89 He said that, ofthe 26 interrogators present at the time, only one had enough Arabic
language experience to interrogate without an interpreter. 9o
II
A memo written by Colonel Mike Fox (SOUTHCOM's Director ofIntelligence
Operations) just a month after COL Herrin on's r ort, also discussed how conditions at GTMO
inhibited successful interrogations.
87 Ibid. at 4.
88COL Herrington also identified additional deficiencies in intelligence collection, which he said could be improved
by arming GTMO with the ability to translate and review relevant documents onsite and monitor interrogations
using video technology. Ibid.
89 Ibid. at 6.
90COL Herrington's report also criticized the screening criteria in place, which may have resulted in detainees with
less intelligence value being sent to GTMO and those with more valuable detainees being set free. COL Herrington,
Report o/Visit and Recommendations at 6.
91 COL Mike Fox, JTF-170 Methods and Techniques Info Paper (April 22, 2002).
13
_ ( The first option was for JPRA to field, deploy, direct, and sustain an
entire interrogation team. 98 The plan recommended that JPRA not pursue this course stating,
"No - Too much ofa manpower drain and we [JPRA] are not prepared to provide this kind of
support infrastructure.,,99 A second option was for JPRA to field a "lead captivity/ exploitation
expert (JPRA Senior SERE Psychologist) to advise and support" the exploitation process and to
92 Ibid.
93 Ibid.
94 Email from Dr. Bruce Jessen to Christopher Wirts, Mike Dozier and Randy Moulton (April 16, 2002).
9~Joint Personnel Recovery Agency, Exploitation Draft Plan (undated), attached to email from Bruce Jessen to Col
Randy Moulton, Christopher Wirts, and Mike Dozier (April 16, 2002) (hereinafter "JPRA, Exploitation Draft
Plan'").
96 Ibid
98 Ibid
99 Ibid.
14
Advanced Media Group Page 97 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 116
Page
of 2413
117 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
have a "sponsor" provide all other personnel and direct the process. This option was also
rejected as "ineffective," noting that if JPRA could "direct" the exploitation process, there would
bea
"good chance of [JPRA] making a real difference," but "if not," there are "too many other
responsl"b"l"
1 Ittes t 0 expend "." energy on. ,,100
JPRA fields and deploys core captivity/exploitation team - This team directs the
process under the lead of the JPRA Senior SERE Psychologist and receives all
additional specified support from a sponsor - Those sponsor individuals who
directly assist in the exploitation process will receive training from the JPRA
cadre. 101
_ Dr. Jessen's draft exploitation plan described the means by which JPRA would
implement that recommendation, and included requirements for an undisclosed exploitation
facility and the means by which detainees would be transported and held there. 103
(l'he only restricting factor should be the Torture Convention), [7] Established
latitude and ocess to offer and validate information for concessions
100 Ibid.
101 Ibid.
102 Ibid.
103The plan also described requirements for the management of the facility identical to those included in the
"Prisoner Handling Recommendations" previously prepared by JPRA for SOUTHCOM. Ibid.; Memo for Col
Cooney, Prisoner Handling Recommendations (February 28,2002).
104 JPRA, Exploitation Drqft Plan (emphasis added).
15
_ ( When asked about the plan, which his email referred to as "my" plan,
Dr. Jessen said that there are elements that he did not draft. 105 For example, he told the
Committee that he did not believe that the Torture Convention was the only controlling authority
for exploitation Rules of Engagement. 106 Dr. Jessen, however, did not reject the idea of having
JPRA support the exploitation process. Dr. Jessen said that he knew how to set up training
programs, had observed numerous "interrogations" at SERE school, and thought that some JPRA
instructors could make excellent interrogators. 107 He also told the Committee that he supported
having SERE psychologists observe interrogations and provide advice and assistance to
interrogators, but that that he did not support having SERE psychologists in the interrogation
booth with interrogators and detainees.
(U) Upon receiving the plan, JPRA Commander Col Randy Moulton asked Dr. Jessen to
craft a briefmg to ''take up for approval," which included "why we (USG) need it, how it falls
within our chartered responsibilities (or if not, why we should do it) and then make a
recommendation,,108 Col Moulton testified to the Committee that he did not recall any
subsequent JPRA briefmgs for U.S. Joint Forces Command on Dr. Jessen's draft exploitation
plan and did not remember whether or not the plan was implemented. 109
10~ The Department of Defense confmned that the "Exploitation Draft Plan" in the Committee's possession was, in
fact, attached to Dr. Jessen's April 16,2002 email, making it the same document Dr. Jessen referred to as "my initial
draft plan."
106 Committee staff interview of Bruce Jessen (July 11,2007).
107 Committee staff interview of Bruce Jessen (November 13, 2007).
108 Email from Col Randy Moulton to Bruce Jessen, Christopher Wirts, Mike Dozier (April 17, 2002).
109 The Authorization of Survival Evasion Resistance and Escape (SERE) Techniques for Interrogations in Iraq: Part
II of the Committee's Inquiry Into the Treatment of Detainees in U.S. Custody, Senate Committee on Armed
Services, 110 Congo (September 25,2008) (hereinafter "SASC Hearing (September 25,2008)").
110 George Tenet, At The Center Of The Storm (New York: Harper Collins Publishers 2007) at 241.
III Condoleezza Rice answers to July 31, 2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (September 12, 2008).
112 John Bellinger answers to July 31, 2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (September 12, 2008).
16
legality of the proposed program. ll3 She said that all ofthe meetings she attended on the CIA's
interrogation program took place at the White House and that she understood thatDoJ's legal
advice "was being coordinated by Counsel to the President Alberto Gonzales.,,114
(U) According to President Bush, the agency developed an "alternative set" of ,"tough"
interrogation techniques, and put them to use on Zubaydah and other HVDs. 115 Though virtually
all ofthe techniques that were used on Zubaydah remain classified, CIA Director Michael
Hayden confirmed that waterboarding was used on Zubaydah. 116 Assistant Attorney General for
the Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) Steven Bradbury testified before Congress that the "CIA's
use ofthe waterboarding procedure was adapted from the SERE training program.,,117 When
asked whether she was present for discussions about physical and/or psychological pressures
used in SERE training, Secretary Rice recalled "being told that U. S. military personnel were
subjected in training to certain physical and psychological interrogation techniques." 118 Mr.
Bellinger, the NSC Legal Advisor, stated that he was "present in meetings at which SERE
training was discussed.,,119
(U) Public reports have identified a retired U.S. Air Force SERE psychologist, Dr. James
Mitchell, as having participated in the CIA's interrogation ofZubaydah. 120 Dr. Mitchell, who
retired from the Air Force in 2001, agreed to speak to the Committee about his time at DoD.
113 Secretary Rice said that in 2002-2003, she 'participated in a number of discussions of specific interrogation
techniques proposed for use by the CIA" Condoleezza Rice answers to July 31, 2008 written questions from
Senator Carl Levin (September 12, 2008). .
114 Ibid.
115 In a September 6,2006 speech, President Bush stated that since September 11, 2001, a "small number of
suspected terrorist leaders and operatives captured during the war have been held and questioned outside the United
States, in a separate program operated by the Central Intelligence Agency." The President stated that the CIA used
"an alternative set of procedures" in interrogating the detainees. According to the President, the CIA techniques
"were tough, and they were safe, and lawful, and necessary." The President identified Abu Zubaydah as one
detainee who was subject to the CIA's alternative techniques. Press Briefmg with President George W. Bush
(September 6,2(06); see also Tenet, At The Center Of The Storm at 241.
116 Current and Projected National Security Threats, Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, 1lOth Congo (February
5,2008).
117 Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel, House Committee on the Judiciary, Subcommittee on the
Constitution, Civil Rights, and Civil Liberties, 110th Congo (February 14, 2008).
118 Condoleezza Rice answers to July 31, 2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (September 12, 2008).
119 John Bellinger answers to July 31, 2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (September 12, 2008).
120 Jane Mayer, The Experiment, The New Yorker (July 11-18,2005); Jane Mayer, The Black Sites, The New Yorker
(August 13, 2007) ("According to an eyewitness, one psychologist advising on the treatment of Zubaydah, James
Mitchell, argued that he needed to be reduced to a state of 'learned helplessness.' (Mitchell disputes this
characterization)."); Katherine Eban. Rorschach and Awe, Vanity Fair Online (July 17, 2007), available at
http://www.vanityfair.com/politics/features/2007107Itorture200707.
121 Committee staff interview of James Mitchell (July 10, 2007); Letter to Senator Carl Levin (June 22,2007).
17
(U) An unclassified version of a May 2008 report by the Department of Justice (Dol)
Inspector General (IG) confirmed that FBI agents "initially took the lead in interviewing
Zubaydah at the CIA facility," but that "CIA personnel assumed control over the interviews"
when they arrived at the facility. 125
123 Ibid.
124 Ibid.
(December 21,2007).
128 Ibid.
18
(U) The FBI Special Agent told the DoJ Inspector General that he also "raised objections
to these techniques to the CIA and told the CIA it was 'borderline torture. ",130 According to the
unclassified DoJ Inspector General's report, a second FBI agent present did not have a "'moral
objection'" to the techniques and noted that he had "undergone comparable harsh interrogation
techniques as part ofthe U.S. Army Survival, Evasion, Resistance and Escape (SERE)
training. ,,131
(U) According to the DoJ Inspector General's report, FBI Counterterrorism Assistant
Director Pat D' Amuro gave the instruction to both FBI agents to "come home and not participate
in the CIA interrogation." The first FBI Special Agent left immediately, but the other FBI agent
remained until early June 2002. 133 The report said that around the time of Zubaydah's
interrogation, FBI Director Robert Mueller decided that FBI agents would not participate in
interrogations involving techniques the FBI did not normally use in the United States, even
though the OLC had determined such techniques were legal. 134 Then-National Security Advisor
Condoleezza Rice said that she had a "general recollection that FBI had decided not to
participate in the CIA interrogations" but "was not aware that FBI personnel objected to
interrogation techniques used or proposed for use with Abu Zubaydah." 135
B.
As.
JPRA Assistance to Another Government Agenq' (U)
interro ation of Abu Zubaydah was ongoing,
The Chief of JPRA's Operational Support
ittee that he had five or fewer meetings withlll
interrogations. 136
130 U. S. Department of Justice, Office of the Inspector General, A Review ofthe FBI's Involvement in and
Observations ofDetainee Interrogations in Guantanamo Bay, Afghanistan, and Iraq (May 2008) at 68 (hereinafter
"DoJ IG Report'').
131 Ibid. at 69.
131 Committee staff interview ofFEI Special Agent (December 21,2007).
133 DoJ IG Report at 69; see also Counter Resistance Strategy Meeting Minutes at 4. (Months later, in an October 2,
2002 meeting with DoD officials at Guantanamo Bay, Chief Counsel to the CIA's CounterTerrorist Center (CTC)
reportedly Jonathan Fredman conftrmed that "[w]hen the CIA has wanted to use more aggressive techniques in the
past, the FBI has pulled their personnel from theater.")
134 DoJ IG Report at 73.
m Condoleezza Rice answers to July 31, 2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (September 12, 2008).
136 Committee staff interview of Christophe (Janumy 4, 2007); see also JPRAlOSO,. conca
Operationsfor JPRA support to anticipate re uirements (October 3,2002). The memo states, has made
informal requests for JPRA support to prepar to use exploitation/interrogation techniques ... Five
separate meetings have been conducted betwee and JPRArepresentatives..."
_ _ At some noint in the first six months of 2002, JPRA assisted with the
preparation of~sent to interrogate a high level al Qaeda operative. 137 In a June
20,2002 memo to JPRA's Commander Randy Moulton, JPRA's Deputy Commander Col John
Prior, characterized the assistance as ''training'' and noted that the psychologist had suggested
"exploitation strategies" to officer. 138
11_ Dr. Bruce Jessen JPRA's senior SERE psychologist, told the Committee
that he had met with a who was en route to an interrogation L39 He said h e .
have offered the but that he did not discuss
I~Memofrom Col John Prior II to JPRNCC (Col Randy Moulta1), Requestfrom"or Interrogation
Training Support (J\U1e 20, 2002).
l]8lbid.
13ll.Initially, the s~or SERE psychologist could not recall ifhe provided this assistance to the
while he was still working at JPRA or if the assistance had ~r
he left JPRA After he left JPRA in 2002.
the senior SERE psychologist began working as a contractor t but was restricted from discussing the
nature of his work with the Committee. Committee staff interview ofBrucc Jessen (November 13, 2(07).
20
. . . Having the true exploitation and captivity environment experts and specialists,
JPRA may be called upon in extremis to actually participate in fhture exploitation
offoreign prisoners; this request would clearly fall outside JPRA's chartered
responsibilities; ifthis request is made, JPRA would require a SecDefpolicy
.. 146
detennmabon ...
_ C o l Prior's memo stated that the JFCOM J-3 or his office had be~sed of
support requests. 147 A Joint Staff Action Processing Fonn indicated that_ _ request
was endorsed by JPRA, JFCOM, Joint Staff, and the Office ofthe Undersecretary of Defense for
Policy and approved on June 27, 2002. 148
1 4 6 " Memo from Col John Prior II to JPRAlCC (Col Randy Moulton), Requestjrom_jor Interrogation
Training Support (June 20, 2002).
14~Memo from Col John Prior II to JPRAlCC (Col Randy Moulton), Requestjrom~orInterrogation
Training Support (June 20, 2002). Although Col John Prior told the Committee that he could not recall the June 20,
2002 memo, JPRA Commander Col Randy Moulton recalled receiving it at the time. Since the Committee's
interview of Col Prior, the Department of Defense has provided the Committee with a copy of the memo that was
signed by him.
148 11
Joint Staff Action Processing Form, (U) JPRA Personneljor Training (June 27, 2002).
149 Testimony of Joseph Witsch (September 4,2007) at 63-64,69.
150 Ibid. at 64-69.
~~mo from Joseph Witsch to Col Randy Moulton and Christopher Wirts, Exploitation TrainingjoJ.
_ ( J u l y 16,2002).
152 Ibid.
21
Percival, a JPRA instructor at the training, said that in their demonstration of ph~sical pressures,
JPRA instructor Joseph Witsch acted as the "beater" while he was the "beatee." 53
(D) At the time, waterboarding was only used by the U.S. Navy SERE school and its use
was prohibited at the JPRA, Anny, and Air Force SERE schools. 155 The U.S. Navy has since
abandoned its waterboarding at its SERE schools. None ofthe JPRA personnel who provided
the assistance had ever conducted waterboarding and would not have been qualified to do so at
SERE school. 156
_ The JPRA instructors who conducted the training did not recall_lawyers
providing any further guidance about how to seek approval for use ofthe waterboard in an
. . 160
mterrogallon.
m Memo from Dr. Percival to JPRA CC (Col Moulton), Comments on Physical Pressures usedfor cae Training
22
reportedly explaining that "[t]he CIA makes the call internally on most ofthe types of
techniques," but that "[s]ignificantly harsh techniques are approved through the DOJ.,,161
( III In his memo, Mr. Witsch also commented on JPRA's future support to
interrogations, writing:
I believe our niche lies in the fact that we can provide the ability to exploit
personnel based on how our enemies have done this type of thing over the last
five decades. Our enemies have had limited success with this methodology due to
the extreme dedication of [American] personnel and their harsh and mismanaged
application of technique. The potential exists that we could refine the process to
achieve effective manipulation/exploitation. We must have a process that goes
beyond the old paradigm of military interrogation for tactical information or
criminal investigation for legal proceedings. These methods are far too limited in
scope to deal with the new war on global terrorism.,,164
_ Mr. Witsch recommended that JPRA develop two courses for future JPRA
customers - a basic course and an advanced course to deal with "senior, hardcore, and resistance
trained detainees. ,,165 The courses, he said, will need "immediate attention and will require a
total role reversal from current methodology and our standard approaches to training. It will take
a cross section of SERE experienced personnel-SERE instructors, psychologists, MDs and
intelligence personnel to effectively develop this new approach to captive handling and
manipulation.,,166
II
In July 2002, after the JPRA training f o r _ the senior SERE
psychologist, Dr. Bruce Jessen was detailed to~S.167 At the conclusion of
23
this assignment, Dr. Jessen retired from the Department of Defense and began working as an
independent contractor t~ 168
(U) Dr. Jessen did tell the Committee that, in some circumstances, physically coercive
techniques are appropriate for use in detainee interrogations. He said that the use of physically
coercive techniques may be appropriate when (1) there is good reason to believe that the
individual has perishable intelligence, (2) the techniques are lawful and authorized, (3) they are
carefully controlled with medical and psychological oversight, (4) someone (who is not
otherwise involved in the interrogation) can stop the use ofthe techniques, and (5) the techniques
do not cause long-term physical or psychological harm. 170 Dr. Jessen acknowledged that
empirically, it is not possible to know the effect of a technique used on a detainee in the long
term, unless you study the effects in the long-term. However, he said that his conclusion about
the long-term effects of physically coercive techniques was based on forty years oftheir use at
SERE school. 171
(U) Subsequent to his retirement from DoD, Dr. Jessen joined Dr. Mitchell and other
former JPRA officials to form a company called Mitchell Jessen & Associates. Mitchell Jessen
& Associates is co-owned by seven individuals, six of whom either worked for JPRA or one of
the service SERE schools as employees and/or contractors. I72 As of July 2007, the company had
between 55 and 60 employees, several of whom were former JPRA employees. 173
168 Ibid.
169 Ibid.; Letter to Chainnan Levin (June 22,2(07).
Iii) Committee staff interview of Bruce Jessen (November 13, 2007). Lawyers for Dr. Mitchell informed the
Committee that he shares the same view as his colleague, Dr. Jessen.
171 Committee staff interview of Bruce Jessen (November 13, 2007).
172 Committee staff interview of James Mitchell (July 10, 2007); Committee staff interview of Bruce Jessen (July II,
2007).
173 Committee staff interview of James Mitchell (July 10, 2(07); Committee staff interview of Christopher Wirts
(January 4, 2008).
174 Email from Lt Col Dan Baumgartner to Col Randy Moulton et al. (July 25, 2002).
24
the request after several conversations with General Counsel Jim Haynes. 175 Mr. Shiffiin later
said that everything he asked for from JPRA was to respond to requests from Mr. Haynes. 176 Mr.
Haynes testified to the Committee that he could not remember "specifically" asking Mr. Shiffiin
for infonnation on SERE techniques, but that he "asked generally" about that subject sometime
in the summer of2002. He also said that he remembered being "interested" in that infonnation,
and that ifhe had requested it, he would have requested it through Mr. Shiffrin. 177 Although Mr.
Haynes did not say why he was interested in this infonnation, when asked whether he had
discussed "SERE techniques with [] Messrs. Gonzales, Addington, Rizzo, Y 00, or any ofthe
other senior lawyers" he met with "regularly," Mr. Haynes testified to the Committee that he
"did discuss SERE techniques with other people in the administration. ,,178
(U) JPRA Chief of Staff Lt Col Daniel Baumgartner said that when the request from the
General Counsel's office came in, he called Col Moulton and Brig Gen Thomas Moore, the
JFCOM Director for Operations (13), and received pennission to provide the requested
infonnation to the General Counsel's office. 179 JPRA initially responded to the General
Counsel's inquiry on July 25,2002 with a memorandum signed by Lt Col Baumgartner. 180
II ( The JPRA memorandum stated that "JPRA has arguably developed into the
DoD's experts on exploitation." It continued:
(U) JPRA attached several lesson plans on exploitation and interrogation to the memo. 182
In closing, the memo stated:
25
(U) The memorandum and its attachments were delivered to the Deputy General Counsel
Richard Shiffrin by a JPRA employee and were emailed to relevant personnel at both JPRA and
Brig Gen Moore's office at JFCOM. I84 DoD General Counsel Jim Haynes did not recall whether
or not he saw the memo at the time, but said that "in all likelihood," he would have received the
memo, and that the timing ofthe memo coincided with his recollection of his meeting with JPRA
personnel. 18S
(U) According to Lt Col Baumgartner, prior to the July 25, 2002 memo being delivered
to the General Counsel's office, Mr. Shiffrin called him to ask for additional information,
including a list of techniques used by JPRA at SERE school. Mr. Shiffrin testified to the
Committee that he was ''under pressure" from Mr. Haynes to get the material to his office as
. k1 Y as pOSSI'bl e. 186
qUlC
(U) Lt Col Baumgartner said that he thought the General Counsel's office was asking for
information on exploitation and physical pressures to use them in interrogations. Mr. Shiffrin
confirmed that one ofthe ~urposes for seeking information from JPRA was to "reverse
engineer" the techniques. 1 7 Lt Col Baumgartner said that he wanted to be helpful, but that he
told Mr. Shiffrin that JPRA's techniques were designed to show Americans the worst possible
treatment that they may face, and that any recommendation for the use oftechniques on
detainees would require Administration approval. 188
(U) On July 26, 2002, JPRA completed a second memorandum with three attachments to
respond to the additional questions from the General Counsel's office. The memo stated that
"JPRA has arguably developed into the DoD's experts on exploitation and as such, has
developed a number of physical pressures to increase the psychological and physical stress on
students ... ,,189
183 Ibid. at 2; see also email from Lt Col Daniel Baumgartner to Col Randy Moulton et al. (July 25, 2002) (Thanking
''the 'exploitation answer stuckee' team" for "an outstanding job answering IJ Mr. Hanes (sic) and Mr. Schiffren
(sic) (OSD Dep GC for Intel) on their question 'what exploitation techniques have worked against Americans?")
184 Email from Lt Col Daniel Baumgartner to Col Randy Moulton et aI., copying Darrell Venture (JFCOM
Directorate of Operations) (July 25,2002).
IS' Committee staff interview of William 1. Haynes II (April 25, 2008) at 51,59.
186 SASC Hearing (June 17, 2008).
187 Ibid.
188 Committee staff interview of Lt Col Daniel Baumgartner (August 8, 2007).
189 Memo from Lt Col Baumgartner to Office of the Secretary of Defense General Counsel, Exploitation and
Physical Pressures (July 26, 2002) at 1.
26
_ ( In the memo, JPRA informed the General Counsel's office that it had
already "assist[ed] in the training of interrogator/exploiters from other governmental agencies
charged with OEF exploitation of enemy detainees.,,190 The memo also stated:
( The ftrst attachment to the July 26,2002 memo was'''Physical Pressures used in
Resistance Training and Against American Prisoners and Detainees.,,192 That attachment
included a list oftechniques used to train students at SERE school to resist interrogation. The
list included techniques such as the facial slap, walling, the abdomen slap, use of water, the
attention grasp, and stress positions. 193 The ftrst attachment also listed techniques used by some
ofthe service SERE schools, such as use of smoke, shaking and manhandling, cramped
conftnement, immersion in water or wetting down, and waterboarding.
( Attachment one also listed tactics derived from JPRA SERE school lesson plans
that were designed to "induce control, dependency, complia[n]ce, and cooperation," including
isolation or solitary conftnement, induced physical weakness and exhaustion, degradation,
190 Ibid.
191 Memo from Lt Col Baumgartner to Office of the Secretary of Defense Geneml Counsel, Exploitation and
Physical Pressures (July 26, 2002) at 1.
192 JPRA, Physical Pressures Used In Resistance Training and Against American Prisoners and Detainees, attached
to memo from Lt Col Baumgartner to Office of the Secretary of Defense General Counsel (July 26,2(02).
193 Ibid.
Compare FASO Detachment Brunswick Instruction 3305.C (January 1, 1998) at E-5 with Physical Pressures
194
Used In Resistance Training and'Against American Prisoners and Detainees at 3-4.
27
conditioning, sensory deprivation, sensory overload, disruption of sleep and biorhythms, and
. IatIon
manlpu 0 fdIe.t 195
(U) DoD General Counsel Jim Haynes told the Committee that although he could not
recall ifhe had seen the specific list of SERE physical pressures sent to his office on July 26,
2002, he knew that he had seen a list of physical pressures used in JPRA resistance training. 196
II Mr. Haynes also recalled that he may have been "asked that information be given to
the Justice Department for something they were working on," which he said related to a program
he was not free to discuss with the Committee, even in a classified setting. 197
(U) A second attachment to the July 26, 2002 JPRA memo to the General Counsel's
office was entitled "Operational Issues Pertaining to the use of Physical/Psychological Coercion
in Interrogation.,,198 In attachment two, JPRA stated that the memo did not purport to address
the "myriad legal, ethical, or moral implications oftorture; rather, [the memo focused onJ the key
operational considerations relative to the use of physical and psychological pressures.,,19
(U) Attachment two described operational risks associated with using "physical and/or
psychological duress" (a phrase that JPRA used interchangeably with ''torture'' throughout most
of attachment two) in interrogations. 20o The attachment said that one risk was that the use of
these methods would increase the "prisoner's level of resolve to resist cooperating.,,201 JPRA
explained that "[0 ]nce any means of duress has been purposefully applied to the prisoner, the
formerly cooperative relationship cannot be reestablished. In addition, the prisoner's level of
resolve to resist cooperating with the interrogator will likely be increased as a result of harsh or
brutal treatment. ,,202
(U) According to attachment two, another risk to using techniques that increase physical
and psychological duress was that it created doubts about the reliability and accuracy of
information obtained. 203 JPRA explained in attachment two that "[i]f an interrogator produces
information that resulted from the application of physical and psychological duress, the
reliability and accuracy ofthis information is in doubt. In other words, a subject in extreme pain
may provide an answer, any answer, or many answers in order to get the pain to stop." 204
195 Physical Pressures Used In Resistance Training and Against American Prisoners and Detainees.
196 Committee staff interview of William 1. Haynes II (April 25, 2008) at 87.
197 Ibid. at 88.
198 JPRA, Operational Issues Pertaining to the Use ofPhysicallPsychological Coercion in Interrogation (undated),
attached to memo from Lt Col Baumgartner to Office of the Secretary of Defense General Counsel (July 26, 2002).
199 Ibid.
200 Ibid.
201 Ibid.
202 Ibid.
203 Ibid.
204 Ibid.
28
(U) A third operational risk was the potential impact that the physical and psychological
duress could have on treatment of US. personnel. 205 JPRA explained in attachment two that:
Another important aspect of the debate over the use of torture is the consideration
of its potential impact on the safety of US. personnel captured by current and
future adversaries. The unintended consequence of a US. policy that provides for
the torture of prisoners is that it could be used by our adversaries as justification
for the torture of captured US. personnel. While this would have little impact on
those regimes or organizations that already employ torture as a standard means of
operating, it could serve as the critical impetus for those that are currently
weighing the potential gains and risks associated with the torture of US. persons
to accept torture as an acceptable option. 206
(U) The third attachment to JPRA's July 26, 2002 memo was a memo from the Chief of
Psychology Services at the Air Force SERE school, Jerald Ogrisseg, on the "Psychological
Effects of Resistance Training.,,207 That memorandum, which was generated in response to a
specific request from the General Counsel's office, described available evidence on the long
term psychological effects of Air Force SERE training on US. personnel and commented from a
psychological perspective on the effects ofusing the waterboard.
(U) JPRA Chief of Staff Daniel Baumgartner said that when the General Counsel's office
requested a memo on the psychological effects ofresistance training, he called Dr. Ogrisseg at
the Department ofthe Air Force's Air Education and Training Command. 208 Dr. Ogrisseg said
that Lt Col Baumgartner asked his opinion during the phone call about his thoughts on
waterboarding the enemy.209 Dr. Ogrisseg recalled asking, "wouldn't that be illegal?,,210
According to Dr. Ogrisseg, Lt Col Baumgartner replied that people were asking "from above"
about using waterboarding in real world interrogations. 211 Dr. Ogrisseg recalled telling Lt Col
Baumgartner, "aside from being illegal, it was a completely different arena that we in the
Survival School didn't know anything about." 212
(U) Subsequent to that call, Dr. Ogrisseg reviewed the data on the effects of Air Force
SERE resistance training on students and produced his memo, concluding that "ifthere are any
long-term psychological effects of [US. Air Force Resistance Training], they are certainly
20' Ibid.
206 Ibid.
Dr. Jerald Ogrisseg, Psychological Effects ofResistance Training (July 24, 2002), attached to memo from Lt Col
'lIY1
Daniel Baumgartner to Office of the Secretary of Defense General Counsel (July 26,2002) (hereinafter
"Psychological Effects ofResistance Training''').
208Dr. Jerald Ogrisseg, the Chief of Psychology Services at the Department of the Air Force's Air Education and
Training Command, told the Committee that he had accepted a position at JPRA prior to writing the memo but had
yet to officially change jobs. Committee staff interview of Jerald Ogrisseg (June 26, 2007).
209 SASC Hearing (June 17,2(08).
210 Ibid.
2ll Ibid.
212 Ibid.
29
minimal." 213 The memo attributed this conclusion to efforts the Air Force SERE program
undertook to minimize the risk oftemporary psychological effects ofresistance training
becoming long-term effects. 214 The Air Force minimized the risk by, among other things,
performing three extensive debriefings during training. Dr. Ogrisseg said that "affording
students these opportunities to discuss their training experiences in open group environments
mitigates the risk ofturning a 'dramatic' experience into a 'traumatic' experience." 215 He told
the Committee that there are numerous controls in place at SERE school to ensure that the
training does not become "traumatic" for its students. 216
(U) Dr. Ogrisseg said that Lt Col Baumgartner also asked him "to comment on both the
physical and psychological effects of the waterboard," which he described in his memo as an
"intense physical and psychological stressor" used at the U.S. Navy SERE school. 217 Although
Dr. Ogrisseg had not used the waterboard himself, he had observed its use in a visit to the Navy
SERE School. He stated that, based on that visit, he did not believe that the ''waterIJ board
posed a real and serious physical danger to the students" who experienced it at the SERE school,
stating that the "Navy had highly qualified medical personnel immediately available to intervene,
and their students had all been medically screened prior to training. Psychologically, however,
the water[] board broke the students' will to resist providing information and induced
helplessness." 218 .
(U) Dr. Ogrisseg said that he was surprised when he found out later that Lt Col
Baumgartner had forwarded his memo to the General Counsel's office along with a list ofthe
physical and psychological techniques used in SERE school. 219 Dr. Ogrisseg said that his
analysis was produced with students in mind, not detainees. He stated that the conclusions in his
memo were not applicable to the offensive use of SERE techniques against real world detainees
and he would not stand by the conclusions in his memo if they were applied to the use of SERE
resistance training techniques on detainees.
(U) In a written response to a question posed by Senator Carl Levin after the
Committee's June 17,2008 hearing, Dr. Ogrisseg elaborated on that point noting several
"important differences between SERE school and real world interrogations that would limit [the]
30
conclusions [in his memo] to the SERE school training population." 220 Among those differences
Dr. Ogrisseg identified were (1) the extensive physical and psychological pre-screening
processes for SERE school students that are not feasible for detainees, (2) the variance in injuries
between a SERE school student who enters training and a detainee who arrives at an
interrogation facility after capture, (3) the limited risk of SERE instructors mistreating their own
personnel, especially with extensive oversight mechanisms in place, compared to the risk of
interrogators mistreating non-country personnel, (4) the voluntary nature of SERE training,
which can be terminated by a student at any time, compared to the involuntary nature of being a
detainee, (6) the limited duration of SERE training, which has a known starting and ending point,
compared to the often lengthy, and unknown, period of detention for a detainee, and (7) the
underlying goals of SERE school (to help students learn from and benefit from their training)
and the mechanisms in place to ensure that students reach those goals compared to the goal of
interrogation (to elicit information).
(U) In addition, Dr. Ogrisseg also stated that, since writing his memo in July 2002, he had
reviewed studies about the effects of near death experiences, and that he had become concerned
about the use of waterboarding even as a training tool. 221 The U.S. Navy SERE school
abandoned its use ofthe waterboard in November 2007.
(U) Lt Col Baumgartner testified to the Committee that, subsequent to sending his two
memos and their attachments - including the list of SERE techniques - to the General Counsel's
office, another government agency asked for the same information. Lt Col Baumgartner said
that he provided that information to the OGA. 222
IIIn his interview with the Committee, Lt Col Baumgartner said that. personnel had
contacted him requesting a copy ofthe same information that had been sent to the DoD General
Counsel. Lt Col Baumgartner recalled speaking to ~ d a psychologist a t _
about the request and sending the information to the - - . 2 2 3
(U) Before drafting the August 1,2002 opinions, Deputy Assistant Attorney General for
the OLC John Y 00 had met with Counsel to the President Alberto Gonzales and Counsel to the
Vice-President David Addington to discuss the subjects that he intended to address. 224 Then
220Dr. Ogrisseg also explained that "[w]hile long-term psychological harm can occur from relatively brief
distressing experiences, the likelihood of psychological harm is generally increased by more lengthy and uncertain
detentions." Responses of Dr. Jerald Ogrisseg to Questions for the Record (July 28, 2008).
221 Committee staff interview of Jerald Ogrisseg (June 26, 2007).
222 SASC Hearing (June 17, 2008).
223 Committee staff interview ofLt Col Daniel Baumgartner (August 8, 2007).
224 According to Mr. Addington, he met "regularly" with a group of lawyers that included DoD General Counsel Jim
Haynes, White House Counsel Alberto Gonzales, and the CIA General Counsel John Rizzo. This group that met
31
National Security Advisor Condoleezza Rice said that she understood that the Department of
Justice's legal advice to the CIA "was being coordinated by Counsel to the President Alberto
Gonzales.,,225
(U) The first ofthe two August 1,2002 OLC memoranda, known to many as the "First
Bybee" memo, presented OLC's narrow interpretation of what constituted torture under U.S.
law. The memo stated that the federal anti-torture statute of 1994 prohibited "only extreme acts"
and that in order to constitute torture, physical pain would have to be equivalent in intensity to
that accompanying "serious physical injury, such as organ failure, impairment of bodily
functions or even death.,,226 For mental pain to rise to the level oftorture, according to the
memo, it would have to result in "si~flcant psychological harm of significant duration, e.g.,
lasting for months or even years.,,22 The First Bybee memo also found that the federal anti
torture statute may not be applicable to interrogations ordered by the President ifhe acted
pursuant to his Constitutional commander-in-chief powers. Further, the memo argued that even
if the federal anti-torture statute could be construed to apply to such interrogations, the defenses
of necessity and self-defense could potentially eliminate criminal liability under the statute. 228
(U) The First Bybee memo also effectively dispensed with the "specific intent"
requirement of the federal anti-torture statute by narrowly defining that requirement. The federal
anti-torture statute states that, in order to constitute torture, an act must be "specifically intended
to inflict severe physical or mental pain or suffering.,,229 The First Bybee memo stated that in
order "for a defendant to have acted with specific intent, he must expressly intend to achieve the
forbidden act.,,230 Under that interpretation, to violate the law, a person must expressly intend to
commit torture and the memo stated that "knowledge alone that a particular result is certain to
occur does not constitute specific intent."
regularly - which Mr. Addington said was referred to as the "War COWlcil" by Mr. Haynes - also included OLC
lawyers John Yoo and Tim Flanigan. According to Mr. Addington, the group of lawyers met about a "range of
issues," including interrogation of enemy combatants in the war on terror. When Mr. Haynes was asked whether he
had discussed "SERE techniques with [] Messrs. Gonzales, Addington, Rizzo, Y00, or any of the other senior
lawyers" he met with "regularly," Mr. Haynes testified to the Committee that he "did discuss SERE techniques with
other people in the administration." These conversations occurred prior to the Decem her 2, 2002 approval of
aggressive interrogation techniques, including those derived from SERE, by the Secretary of Defense. See From the
Department of Justice to Guantanamo Bay: Administration Lawyers and Administration Interrogation Rules, Part
III, House Committee on the JudiciaI)', Subcommittee on the Constitution, Civil Rights, and Civil Liberties, 11 Oth
Congo (JWle 26, 2008) (Testimony of David Addington); SASC Hearing (JWle 17, 2008) (Testimony of William 1.
Haynes II); The Terror Presidency at 22.
125 Condoleezza Rice answers to July 31, 2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (September 12, 2008).
226The memo was leaked to the press in JWle 2004 and was rescinded by the OLC later that month. Memo from
Assistant Attorney General Jay Bybee to White House Counsel Alberto Gonzales, Standards o/Conduct/or
Interrogation under 18 U.S.c. 2340-2340A (August I, 2002).
227 Ibid.
228 Ibid.
229 18 U.S.c. 2340(1) (2008).
230 Memo from Assistant Attorney General Jay Bybee to White House Counsel Alberto Gonzales, Standards 0/
Conduct/or Interrogation under 18 U.S.C. 2340-2340A (August I, 2002).
32
(U) Jack Goldsmith, who succeeded Jay Bybee as Assistant Attorney General of the OLC
in 2003, described the First Bybee memo's conclusions and their effect:
[V]iolent acts aren't necessarily torture; if you do torture, you probably have a
defense; and even if you don't have a defense, the torture law doesn't apply if you
act under color of presidential authority. CIA interrogators and their supervisors,
under pressure to get information about the next attack, viewed the opinion as a
'golden shield,' as one CIA official later called it, that provided enormous
comfort. 231
(U) The second August 1,2002 OLC legal opinion was also signed by Assistant Attorney
General Jay Bybee. 232 According to a declaration made to the United States District Court for
the Southern District ofNew York. by the Information Review Officer for the CIA, the so-called
"Second Bybee" memo is an I8-page legal memorandum from the OLC to the Office of General
Counsel ofthe CIA containing "information relating to the CIA's terrorist detention and
interrogation program" and "advice to' the CIA regarding potential interrogation methods." 233
According to the filing, the CIA requested the legal guidance from the Department of Justice. 234
A February 1, 2005 letter from the Justice Department to Senator Arlen Specter, then-Chairman
ofthe Senate Judiciary Committee, stated that the Second Bybee memo gave the CIA "specific
advice concerning specific interrogation practices, concluding that they are lawful." 235 And the
unclassified report of the Department ofJustice Inspector General explained that the opinion
analyzed "specific techniques approved for use on Zubaydah includ[ing] waterboarding ... ,,236
231 Former Assistant Attorney General for the OLC Jack Goldsmith, who rescinded the memo, criticized the First
Bybee memo as legally flawed, redundant and one-sided, tendentious in tone, unnecessarily narrow in its defInition
of torture, and widely broader than necessary in its assessment of Presidential authorities. The Terror Presidency at
143-51.
232 The Second Bybee memo has been withheld from the Committee.
233 Sixth Dec!. of Marilyn A Dorn, ~ 56, American Civil Liberties Union, et aL v. Department ofDefense, et aL, No.
04-Civ. 4151 (January 5, 2007).
234Sixth Dec!. of Marilyn A Dorn, ~ 62, American Civil Liberties Union, et aL v. Department ofDefense, et aL, No.
04-Civ. 4151 (January 5, 2007).
23'Letter from Assistant Attorney General William E. Moschella to Chairman of the Senate judiciary Committee
Arlen Specter (February 1, 2005); see also The Terror Presidency at 150-151 (According to Jack Goldsmith, the
First Bybee memo "analyzed the torture statute in the abstract, untied to any concrete practices" and then the Second
Bybee Memo, "applied this abstract analysis to approve particular" interrogation techniques.)
236 DoJ IG Report at 101, fn. 73; see also From the Department of Justice to Guantanamo Bay: Administration
Lawyers and Administration Interrogation Rules, Part IIL House Committee on the Judiciary, Subcommittee on the
Constitution, Civil Rights, and Civil Liberties, 110lh Congo (June 26, 2008) (prepared testimony of John Y00)
("OLC was asked to evaluate the legality of interrogation methods proposed for use with Zubaydah.")
237 DoJ IG Report.
33
that he "expressed concern that the proposed CIA interrogation techniques comply with
applicable u.s. law, including our international obligations. 238
(U) The Committee has been denied the Second Bybee memo and does not know which
specific interrogation practices, other than waterboarding, were analyzed in the memo. A
heavily redacted version ofthe Second Bybee memo, released on July 24, 2008, provides no
further details about the specific interrogation practices that were analyzed by the OLC. 239 The
unredacted sections only make clear that the OLC applied its analysis in the First Bybee memo to
240
a set of (redacted) facts at issue in the Second Bybee memo. And while public sources have
suggested that the OLC's analysis applied to Zubaydah, then-Deputy Assistant Attorney General
John Yoo suggested in recent testimony that it "perhaps" applied to others "similarly situated.,,241
(U) According to Acting CIA General Counsel John Rizzo, the techniques that the OLC
analyzed in the Second Bybee memo were provided by his office. In his testimony before the
Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, Mr. Rizzo stated that his office was "the vehicle" for
getting the interrogation practices analyzed in the Second Bybee memo to the Department of
Justice.,,242
II
to.
Lt Col Baumgartner, the JPRA Chief of Staff, recalled sending a copy ofthe same
information that he had sent to the DoD General Counsel - including the list of SERE techniques
and Dr. Ogrisseg's memo on the pS1.;chological effects of Air Force SERE training and on
waterboarding - attorney. 43 Mr. Haynes, the DoD General Counsel, recalled that in the
context of reviewing the list of SERE techniques provided to his office, that he may have been
"asked that information be given to the Justice Department for something they were working
on.,,244
(U) With respect to the issues addressed in Dr. Ogrisseg's memo relating to the
psychological effects of resistance training, Mr. Haynes said that he knew that there was a
238 John Bellinger answers to July 31,2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (September 12, 2008).
239 The remainder of the Second Bybee memo has not been released publicly.
240Deputy Assistant Attorney General for the OLC John Y00, who participated in the drafting of the Second Bybee
memo, added that in the context of the Zubaydah interrogation, application of the federal anti-torture statute to the
facts "depend[ed] not just on the particular interrogation method, but on the subject's physical and mental
condition." From the Department of Justice to Guantanamo Bay: Administration Lawyers and Administration
Interrogation Rules, Part llI, House Committee on the Judiciary, Subcommittee on the Constitution, Civil Rights,
and Civil Liberties, 110th Congo (June 26, 2008).
141From the Department of Justice to Guantanamo Bay: Administration Lawyers and Administration Interrogation
Rules, Part III, House Committee on the Judiciary, Subcommittee on the Constitution, Civil Rights, and Civil
Liberties, 11 Oth Congo (June 26, 2008).
141Nomination of John Rizzo to be CIA General Counsel, Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, 110th Congo
(June 19, 2007).
143 Committee staff interview ofLt Col Daniel Baumgartner (August 8, 2007).
144 Committee staff interview of William J. Haynes II (April 25, 2008) at 88.
34
government interest in that subject, but that he did not know if that information was used as
support in any OLC legal analysis, and ifhe did know, he did not recall. 245
(U) Then-NSC Legal Advisor John Bellinger said that some ofthe legal analysis of
proposed interrogation techniques prepared by the DeEartment of Justice referred to ''the
psychological effects of military resistance training." 46 In fact, Jay Bybee, the Assistant
Attorney General who signed the two August 1,2002 opinions, said that he saw an assessment of
the psychological effects of military resistance training in July 2002 in meetings in his office
with John Y 00 and two other OLC attorneys. Judge Bybee said the assessment - which to the
best of his recollection had been provided by the CIA - informed the August 1, 2002 OLC legal
opinion that has not been released publicly.247 In his June 26, 2008 testimony before the House
Judiciary Committee, John Y00 refused to say whether or not he ever discussed or received
information about SERE techniques as the August 1, 2002 memos were being drafted. 248
(U) While Judge Bybee said that he did not recall "any written advice provided to any
governmental agency prior to August 1, 2002, on the meaning of the standards of conduct
required for interrogation under the federal anti-torture statute or on specific interrogation
methods," the August 1,2002 memos were not the only occasion on which DOJ provided legal
advice on the CIA's interrogation program. 249 John Bellinger, the NSC Legal Advisor, said that
he understood that in 2002 and 2003, the OLC provided "ongoing advice to CIA regarding CIA's
interrogation program.,,250 And then-National Security Advisor Condoleezza Rice said that she
was present at "several" meetings in the White House at which Mr. Yoo provided legal advice. 251
Ms. Rice said that she asked Attorney General John Ashcroft "personally to review and confIrm"
DoJ's legal guidance. 252
145Ibid. at 104, 106; see also Redacted version of Memo from Assistant Attorney General Jay Bybee, Interrogation
of[redacted} (August 1,2002) (In the unredacted sections of the Second Bybee memo, the memo states: "Your
review of the litemture uncovered no empirical data on the use of these procedures, with the exception [redacted].")
246 John Bellinger answers to July 31, 2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (September 12, 2008).
147 Jay Bybee answers to July 31, 2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (October 14, 2008).
148From the Department of Justice to Guantanamo Bay: Administmtion Lawyers and Administmtion Interrogation
Rules, Part ill, House Committee on the Judiciary, Subcommittee on the Constitution, Civil Rights, and Civil
149 Jay Bybee answers to July 31, 2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (October 14, 2008).
250 John Bellinger answers to July 31, 2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (September 12, 2008).
251 Condoleezza Rice answers to July 31, 2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (September 12, 2008).
252 Ibid.
35
[I]nformation that your organization has already provided, coupled with our
officers' experience confIrms our opinion that JPRA assets are more than capable
of rovidin the necess trainin that we need to start our initiatives. Basically,
consisting
of academic training and practical exercises aimed at learning both interrogation
and resistance to interrogation techniques. 255
_ ( _ draft described four areas of"trainin
(1) "Academic Training," including legal perspectives,'
(2)
'Resistance Training," including academic lessons in interrogation and resistance to
interrogation techniques, such as psychological or physiological pressures; (3) "Practice
InterrogationslResistance to [I]nterrogations/[F]eedback," including practice on "[p]hysical
pressures techniques and training"; and (4) "Review and Training of Resistance Training
Operating Instructions. ,,256
m_ Memo from_to Chief of Staff, JPRA (Lt Col Daniel Baumgartn~hief, Mission Support
(Christopher Wirts), Requestfor Training Support (August 12, 2002) (hereinafter _ t o JPRA, Requestfor
Training Support (August 12, 2002)").
254 Ibid. (emphasis added).
255 Ibid.
2 5 6 _ to JPRA, Requestfor Training Support (August 12, 20~ did not have the
~o teach "legal perspectives" and in his discussions w i t h " - " ' - about the training,
_ _ indicated that JPRA would not be expected to teach that topic. Committee staff interview of Christopher
Wirts (January 4, 2008).
2 5 7 _ to JPRA, Requestfor Training Support (August 12, 2002).
258 Ibid.
259 Ibid.
260 Ibid.
261 Ibid.
262 Ibid.
36
(U) The Operating Instruction used to implement DOD directive 1300.7 are those
instructions that JPRA uses to implement its SERE-school training program.
26.l Ibid.
164 Ibid. (emphasis in original).
26~ Ibid.
266 Memo from JPRAlCC (Col Randy Moulton) to JPRA B/J7/PRA, II Support t . Project 22B (August 13,
2002) at 1.
267 Ibid.
268 Ibid.
269 Ibid.
270 Memo from JPRA asa, I Concept ofOperationsfor JPRA support to anticipated. requirements (October
3,2002).
37
described in that CONOP was "injury [to JPRA personnel] as a result of physical pressures
administered by during the training.,,271
(U) At the August 12, 2002 meeting, JPRA created a special program which it called
Project 22B, to "limit JPRA distribution of sensitive activities in support ofliliiiil,,272
_ In his memo, Col Moulton wrote that protecting information associated with these
activities was "of paramount concern" t o _ and noted that~anticipatesa
congressional investigation into this activity at some time in the future."
III. Guantanarno Bay as a "Battle Lab" for New Interrogation Techniques (U)
(U) Just weeks after the JPRA training at Fort Bragg, two GTMO personnel who attended
the Fort Bragg training drafted a memo proposing the use of physical and psychological
pressures in interrogations at GTMO, including some pressures used at SERE schools to teach
U.S. soldiers how to resist interrogation by enemies that do not follow the Geneva Conventions.
Joint Task Force 170 (JTF-170), submitted a modified version ofthat memo for approval by his
271 Ibid.
Memo from JPRNCC (Col Randy Moulton) to JPRA J3/J7IPRA,.SuPPOrl t o . Project 22B (August 13,
272
2002) at 1.
273 Ibid.
38
u. S. soldiers dealing with deployment-related stress. 274 In a written statement provided to the
Committee, MAJ Burney described the assignment:
(U) MG Dunlavey told the Committee that he was in the hospital for much ofthe month
of June and did not know who initiated the creation of the ITF-170 BSCT. 276
(U) Prior to their arrival at GTMO, neither MAJ Burney n~ had any training
to support interrogations and there was no standard operating procedure in place for the team at
GTMO. 277 MAJ Burney told the Committee that the team was "very aware of how little we
knew about the whole spectrum of detention and interrogation, we decided we needed help.278
174Committee staff interview of MAJ Paul Burney (August 21, 2007); Committee staff interview of
(September 12, 2007).
175 Written statement of MAJ Paul Burney (August 21, 2007).
176 Committee staff interview ofMG Michael Dunlavey (November 30, 2007).
177. A standard operating procedure was drafted in November 2002, several months after the BSCT was
established. It described BSCT tasks including: consulting on interrogation approach techniques, conducting
detainee file reviews to construct personality profiles and provide recommendations for interrogation strategies;
observing interrogations and providing feedback to interrogators on detainee behavior, flow of the interrogation
process, translator and cultural issues and possible strategies for further interrogation; and providing
consultation/training on specific behavioral science interviewing and observational techniques that promote
productive interrogation. The November SOP also stated that the BSCT "does not conduct medical evaluation or
treatment of detainees and does not participate in determining medical treatment protocols for detainees." While the
Committee does not know whether the SOP was ever approved, it comports with what BSCT members told the
Committee about their activities. J1F GTMO-BSCT Memoran~ord,BSCT Standard Operating
Procedures (November 11, 2002); Committee staff interview o~ (September 12, 2(07); Committee staff
interview of Paul Burney (August 21,2007).
178 Written statement ofMAJ Paul Burney (August 21,2007).
179 Committee staff interview o~(September 12, 2007).
39
II LTC Banks told the Committee that it was apparent to him that the BSCT28olacked the
proper training for the mission and that, when asked to help, he felt obliged to assist. LTC
Banks contacted the Joint Personnel Recovery Agency (JPRA) for assistance in organizing
training for the BSCT. 281 After speaking to Col Moulton, the JPRA Commander, LTC Banks
informed the BSCT that JPRA was willing to modify its prior interrogation
training sessions to suit the BSCT's needs. 282
(U) BSCT members told the Committee that they sought the training to better understand
the interrogation process. 283 They also told the Committee, however, that GTMO's Director for
Intelligence (J-2), LTC Jerald Phifer, approved their trip with the expectation that the BSCT
would learn about and bring back interrogation techniques that could be considered for use in
interrogations at GTMO; a point that the LTC Phifer confirmed in his testimony to the
Department ofthe Army Inspector General (Army IG).284 The Staff Judge Advocate at GTMO,
LTC Diane Beaver, confmned LTC Phifer's account, but said that MG Dunlavey told staffhe
had been considering a request for authority to use additional interrogation techniques and that
MG Dunlavey'S purpose in sending the staffto the training was to "fmd out what could be
used.,,28s
(U) MAJ Burney said that he a n d _ made LTC Banks "aware that there was
interest within JTF-170 to see if we could use' SERE tactics' to try to elicit information from
detainees.,,286 _ t o l d the Committee that he believed that the two discussed the GTMO
command's interest in obtaining a list ofresistance training techniques with LTC Banks. 287 The
JPRA Operational Support Office Chief Christopher Wirts, told the Committee that he believed
that he and LTC Banks also talked about the need to demonstrate physical pressures used in
SERE schools at the Fort Bragg training. 288 LTC Banks, however, told the Committee that he
did not recall a discussion of physical pressures at the training and that he was surprised when he
later learned that the BSCT had expected to become familiar with resistance training techniques
used in SERE school while at the training session. 289
40
(D) At the time, there was a view by some at GTMO that interrogation operations had not
yielded the anticipated intelligence,29O MAl Burney testified to the Army IG regarding
interrogations:
[T]his is my opinion, even though they were giving information and some of it was
useful, while we were there a large part ofthe time we were focused on trying to establish
a link between AI Qaeda and Iraq and we were not being successful in establishing a link
between AI Qaeda and Iraq. The more frustrated people got in not being able to establish
this link .. , there was more and more pressure to resort to measures that might produce
.
more Imme d'late resu Its. 291
_The GTMO Interrogation Control Element (ICE) Chief, David Becker told the
Committee that at one oint interro ation personnel were required to question
but that he was unaware ofthe source of that
requirement. 292 Others involved in IfF -170 interrogation operations agreed that there was
pressure on interrogation personnel to produce intelligence, but did not recall pressure to identify
links between Iraq and al Qaeda. 293
( Mr. Becker told the Committee that during the summer of 2002, the IfF -170
Commander, MG Dunlavey, and his Director for Intelligence (J-2), LTC Phifer, had urged him
to be more aggressive in interrogations. 294 Mr. Becker also told the Committee that MG
Dunlavey and LTC Phifer repeatedly asked him during this period why he was not using stress
positions in interrogations, even though the August 2002 Standard Operating Procedure for IfF
170 expressly prohibited the use ofthe technique. 295 MG Dunlavey told the Committee that he
did not recall asking his staff why they were not using stress positions or telling them that they
should be more aggressive. 296
II
Mr. Becker also told the Committee that, on several occasions, MG Dunlavey had
advised him that the office of Deputy Secretary of Defense Wolfowitz had called to express
concerns about the insufficient intelligence production at GTMO. 297 Mr. Becker recalled MG
Dunlavey telling him after one ofthese calls, that the Deputy Secretary himself said that GTMO
290Army IG, Interview of MAl Paul Burney (April 28, 2006) at 6; Committee staff interview o~
(September 12, 2007).
291 Army IG, Interview of MAl Paul Burney (April 28, 2006) at 6.
292The ICE Chief told the Committee that interrogators identified only "a couple of nebulous links." Committee
staff interview of David Becker (September 17, 2007).
293 Committee staff interview of LTC Jerald Phifer (June 27, 2007); Committee staff interview o~
(September 12, 2007).
294 Committee staff interview of David Becker (September 17, 2007).
295 .JTF-170J2 Interrogation Section Standard Operating Procedures (August 20, 2(02) (emphasis in original)
(Detainees being interrogated will "remain seated and secured to the floor. DETAINEES WILL NOT BE PLACED
IN STRESS POSITIONS"); see also Committee staff interview of David Becker (September 17,2007).
296 Committee staff interview ofMG Michael Dunlavey (November 30,2007).
2Y1 Committee staff interview of David Becker (September 17, 2007).
41
should use more aggressive interrogation techniques. 298 MG Dunlavey told the Committee that
he could not recall ever having a phone call with Deputy Secretary Wolfowitz or his staff 299
II Just as the JTF-170 BSCT was reaching out to LTC Banks for assistance,
SOUTHCOM was looking for advice to improve GTMO operations. In June 2002, Major
General Gary Speer, the Acting Commander of SOUTHCOM, requested that the Joint Staff
conduct an external review of intelligence collection operations at Guantanamo Bay.300 In
response, the Joint Staff directed COL John P. Custer, then-assistant commandant of the U.S.
Army Intelligence Center and School at Ft. Huachuca, Arizona, to lead a review team.
COL Custer's team visited GTMO in August and submitted its findings to the Joint
Staff on September 10,2002. 301 Like COL Herrington's assessment six months earlier, the
Cst" "d ffi d b f' ha .
. ~ GTMO" t 11' .:. 11 ct'
II
COL Custer recommended that SOUTHCOM, in coordination with JTF-170, provide
written guidance "delineating what tools and measures are available and permissible to leverage
control over the detainees while providing acceptable guidelines for questioning.,,304 He also
recommended combining the FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit and the JTF-170 BSCT to use both
military and law enforcement approaches to create an environment that would be "conducive to
extracting information by exploiting the detainee's vulnerabilities.,,305
198 Ibid.
299 Committee staff interview ofMG Michael Dunlavey (November 30,2007).
300 _ COL John Custer,. CJCS Extemal Review ofGuantanamo Bay Intelligence Operations (U) (September
2002) (hereinafter "Custer Report"); see also BriefIng Slides, GTMO Review: Joint StaffExtemal Review of
Intelligence Operations at Guantanamo Bay. Cuba (September 10, 2002).
Custer's team included subject matter experts from Fort Huachuca, the Joint Staff, and Office of the Secretary of
301
Defense.
302 With respect to personnel, Custer cited a dearth of linguists, noted a lack of cultural training among interrogators,
42
II
In his report, COL Custer referred to GTMO as "America's 'Battle Lab'" in the
global war on terror, observing that "our nation faces an entirely new threat framework," which
must be met by an investment of both human capital and infrastructure. 306
(U) Several witnesses expressed concerns to the Committee about using the term "Battle
Lab" to describe operations at GTMO. 307 In written answers to questionnaires from Senator Carl
Levin, COL Britt Mallow, the Commander of the Criminal Investigative Task Force (CITF),
stated:
(U) CITF's Deputy Commander, Mark Fallon, echoed the CITF Commander's concern.
Mr. Fallon stated that CITF did not concur with the Battle Lab concept because the task force
"did not advocate the application ofunproven techniques on individuals who were awaiting
trials.,,309 He emphasized that the CITF position was that "there were many risks associated with
this concept ... and the perception that detainees were used for some'experimentation' of new
unproven techniques had negative connotations.,,310
(U) MG Dunlavey told the Committee he did not think he would have used the term to
describe GTMO. 311 MG Miller told the Committee that he did not recall using the term and that
it would be inappropriate to apply it to an operational unit. 312
306 Ibid. at 2.
307Committee staff interviews ofMAJ Sam McCahon (June 15, 2007); COL Britt Mallow (May 7, 2007); Timothy
308Responses of COL Britt Mallow to questionnaire of Senator Carl Levin (September 15, 2006). Two other
witnesses also told the Committee that the term "Battle Lab" was used by Major General Dunlavey to describe
GTMO operations. Committee staff interview of LTC Jerald Phifer (June 27, 2007); Committee staff interview of
Tim James (May 18, 2007).
309 Responses of Mark Fallon to questionnaire of Senator Carl Levin (November 15, 2006).
310 Ibid.
3ll Committee staff interview ofMG Michael Dunlavey (November 30,2007).
312 Committee staff interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (December 5, 2007).
313 Memo from Joseph Witsch to Col Randy Moulton, Col John Atkins, Lt Col Baumgartner and Christopher Wirts,
_ USASOC Requirement to Provide Exploitation Instruction in Support ofOperation Enduring Freedom
43
Command (JFCOM) was formally notified on September 5, 2002 that JPRA intended to provide
training support to Army psychologists, but did not mention Guantanamo Bay or interrogation. 314
(U) JPRA sent senior SERE psychologist Gary Percival, who had recently assumed that
position after Dr. Jessen's departure, and two instructors to conduct the training at Fort Bragg.
II Dr. Percival and one ofthe two trainers, Joseph Witsch, had been instructors at the
exploitation training f o r . in July, where they had discussed and demonstrated physical
pressures. 315 In testimony before the Committee, the other JPRA trainer, Terrence Russell,
stated that the team had designed the training to provide attendees a "familiarization with the
academic or the theoretical application of exploitation from a SERE perspective.,,316 A
contemporaneous email from JPRA Operational Support Office (OSO) Chief Christopher Wirts,
who was involved in planning the training, explained that it was intended to be "similar in nature
to what we did for OGA on the last iteration." 317 None ofthe three instructors sent by JPRA to
Fort Bragg was a trained interrogator. 318
_ According to a JPRA plan of instruction dated August 28, 2002, the fIrst day of
training included instruction on the stages 0
The next three da s oftrainin in the
_(
including one called
A slide from that presentation stated that ''the
exploitation process is fairly simple but needs to be adhered to [to] be successful ifthe goal is to
increase the likelihood of obtaining useful intelligence information from enemy prisoners... ,,320
The esentation listed a number of"Critical 0 erational Ex loitation Princi les" includin
(OEF) (September 24, 2002) (hereinafter "USASOC Requirement to Pravide Exploitation Instruction (September
24, 2002)").
314 JPRA to USClNCSOC, RequestJPRA Support, DTG: 052135ZSEP02 (September 5, 2002).
~ Memo from Joseph Witsch to Col Randy Moulton and Christopher Wirts, Exploitation Trainingfo'"
III(Ojjfcers (July 16, 2(02); Committee staff interview of Dr. Gary-Percival (July 25,2(07).
318 Testimony of Joseph Witsch (September 4, 2(07) at 14; Testimony of Terrence Russell (August 3, 2007) at 25.
319 Memorandum from Joseph Witsch to JPRNCC, JPRNCD, JPRNCOS, JPRNOSO, Plan ofInstruction (POI)
320"
for USASOC Training Support (U) (August 28, 2002).
Joint Personnel Recovery Agency, Exploitation ofCaptive, presentation to GTMO personnel at Fort
321 Ibid. at 4.
44
were substantially the same as those described in the Exploitation Draft Plan, circulated by Dr.
Jessen in April, which described a JPRA-directed exploitation process. 322
_ Though GTMO was a facility that dealt with detainees after they had been
removed from the battlefield, the presentation also included information on "Tactical
estionin "statin that tactical interro ators should
,,323 Mr. Witsch, the JPRA instructor
who acted as Team Chief for the training, testified to the Committee:
Rough handling is you would pull the person up to their feet, you would move
them rapidly in the direction that you were going to take them... basically, they
have no control. They would feel like the person that has them is in total control
ofthem. That's what we mean by rough handling. 324
_ Presentation slides used for the trainin also listed a number of other
recommendations for handling detainees including
,,325 Mr. Witsch testified to the Committee that he did not
know what was meant by those statements and he could not recall any discussion about what
punishments might be culturally undesirable for Arab or Islamic detainees. 326
32l Compare JPRA, Exploitation ofCaptive with JPRA, Exploitation Drqft Plan.
324Hearing to Receive Information Relating To The Treatment of Detainees, Senate Committee on Armed Services,
110th Congo (September 6,2(07) (Testimony of Joseph Witsch) at 12, 34 (hereinafter "Testimony of Joseph Witsch
(September 6, 2(07)").
330JPRA, Counter Measures to Defeat al-Qa 'ida Resistance, presentation to GTMO personnel at Fort Bragg
(September 2(02) (hereinafter "JPRA, Counter A-!easures to Defeat al-Qa 'ida Resistance").
45
that situation.,,331 He testified that lPRA might have become aware that the invasion of the
personal space by a female might make an Arab detainee uncomfortable while conducting
research m preparatIon
. lor
J!:
t h e trammg.
.. 332
would have on a detainee's resistance - whether it would make the detainee more or
less likely to cooperate. 334
(U) In his testimony to the Army IG, MAl Burney, the GTMO BSCT psychiatrist who
attended the training, stated that JPRA personnel at Fort Bragg, "described some of the stuffthat
they would do in SERE school as far as keeping people in some sort of solitary confinement for a
period of time" or "finding out what their fears were before they came so that they would try and
use those against them, whether it was fear of spiders, of the dark or whatever...,,335 An
interrogator from GTMO who attended the training also recalled a discussion about the use of
phobias. 336
(II Members ofthe GTMO BSCT who attended the Fort Bragg training
recalled discussions with the JPRA instructors about how they administered physical
pressures. 337 MAl Burney told the Committee that instructors talked about techniques the SERE
schools used to teach resistance to interrogation, such as walling, and exposing students to cold
until they shiver. 338 _ t o l d the Committee that hooding and hitting in a way that was not
injurious were both mentioned at Fort Bragg. 339 An interrogator from JTF-170 who attended the
training also recalled a discussion about the use of physical pressures. 340
(U) That same interrogator said that the instructors spoke about using existing procedures
at GTMO to enhance interrogations. 341 For example, the interrogator told the Committee that
there was a discussion with lPRA personnel that military working dogs, already present at
46
GTMO for security, could enhance detainee exploitation. Similarly, the interrogator said that the
instructors pointed out that hoods, goggles, and ear muffs were already in use with detainees at
GTMO for security purposes, and that existing processes utilizing those techniques could also be
used to enhance interrogations. The interrogator also recalled requesting additional JPRA
training for GTMO personnel on the use of physical pressures.
(U) Neither LTC Banks nor any ofthe JPRA instructors from the Fort Bragg training
could recall if there were discussions of physical pressures. 342 LTC Banks told the Committee
that using physical pressures desiFed for students at SERE school in actual interrogations would
almost always be unproductive. 34 For example, he told the Committee that slapping a person
would harden their resistance.
(U) Despite the apparent instruction on physical pressures, MAJ Burney told the Army
IG that instructors at Fort Bragg believed that the techniques used in SERE training should not
be brought back for use at GTMO and that "interrogation tactics that rely on physical pressures
or torture, while they do get you information, do not tend to get you accurate information or
reliable information.,,344 In a written statement provided to the Committee, MAJ Burney
reiterated that point, stating that "[i]t was stressed time and time again that psychological
investigations have proven that harsh interrogations do not work. At best it will get you
information that a prisoner thinks you want to hear to make the interrogation stop, but that
information is strongly likely to be false.,,34s
(II During the Fort Bragg training, the GTMO personnel also discussed
conditions at GTMO that they felt were hampering intelligence collection efforts. In his after
action report summarizing the training, JPRA instructor and trainin Team Chief Jos h Witsch
described some of those conditions statin for exa Ie that
,346 Mr. Witsch also stated in his after action report that "[a] lot of interrogation
techniques used in the past are no longer effective against the individual detainees because they
have developed an awareness and countermeasures to deal with them.,,347 Mr. Witsch added that
some ofthe interrogators had become "frustrated over the controls placed on their ability to
extract actionable information," such as restrictions on bringing detainees together in a room to
confront inconsistencies or on interrogating detainees for "12-15-20 hours at a time.,,348 While
Mr. Witsch noted that rapport building had proved to be the most effective interrogation
technique in eliciting information and that the positive treatment of detainees at GTMO was
342LTC Banks added that he was not present for all of the training sessions. Committee staff interview of LTC
Morgan Banks (June 15,2007); Testimony of Terrence Russell (August 3,2007) at 79; Testimony of Joseph Witsch
(September 4,2007) at 99.
343 Committee staff interview of LTC Morgan Banks (June 15, 2007).
344 Army IG, Interview ofMAJ Paul Burney (April 28, 2006) at 8.
345 Written statement ofMAJ Paul Burney (August 21,2007).
Memo from Joseph Witsch to Col Moulton, Col Atkins, Lt Col Baumgartner, Mr. Wirts, U.s. Army Special
346
Operations Command (USASOC), Requirement to Provide Exploitation Instruction (September 24, 2002).
347 Ibid.
348 Ibid.
47
having some effect, he stated that the positive effect appeared limited to the "younger,
inexperienced" detainees. ,,349 .
( II In his after action report, Mr. Witsch expressed concerns about JPRA
involvement in GTMO operations, writing:
I highly recommend we continue to remain in an advisory role and not get directly
involved in the actual operations - GITMO in particular. We have no actual
experience in real world prisoner handling. The concepts we are most familiar
with relate to our past enemies and we have developed our Code of Conduct
procedures based on those experiences. Without actual experience with current
[Designated Unlawful Combatants] we are making the assumption that
procedures we use to exploit our personnel will be effective against the current
detainees. 350
( A week later, Mr. Witsch prepared a follow up memo for Mr. Wirts, JPRA's
OSO chief, expressing concern about lPRA's involvement with detainee exploitation, stating:
What do we bring to the table? We are Code of Conduct instructors with a vast
amount of experience training highly intelligent, disciplined, and motivated DoD
personnel to resist captivity... We base our role-play laboratories on what we
know our fonner enemies have done to our personnel in captivity. It is based on
illegal exploitation (under the rules listed in the 1949 Geneva Convention
Relative to the Treatment of Prisoners of War) of prisoners over the last 50
years...
I believe the techniques and tactics that we use in training have applicability.
What I am wrestling with is the implications of using these tactics as it relates to
current legal constraints, the totally different motivations of the detainees, and the
lack of direction of senior leadership within the [U.S. Government] on how to
unifonnly treat detainees.
349 Ibid.
3'0 Ibid.
not spend our time trying to motivate the operators at the lower levels to sway
their bosses. This is running the train backwards and that is a slow method to get
somewhere. There are a lot of people in the USG intelligence community that
still believe in the old paradigm and wonder just what we're doing in their
business. 351
_ T h e memo concluded with the warning, "[w]e don't have an established track
record in this type of activity and we would present an easy target for someone to point at as the
problem. The stakes are much higher for this than what you and I have done in any activity
before.,,352
m_Memo from Joseph Witsch to Christopher Wirts, (U) Concerns withJPRA Involvement in Operation
Enduring Freedom Exploitation o/Detained Unlawful Combatants (October 1, 2002).
mIbid.
3~3 JTF-GTMO Distinguished Visitors Roster (September 27, 2002). Col Terrence Farrell, Trip Report - DoD
General Counsel Visit to GTMO (September 27, 2002). While the September 27, 2002 trip report states that the
visit occurred on September 25 th, Jack Goldsmith, another senior official on the trip, recounts that the visit took
place on September 26, 2002. Goldsmith notes that Patrick Philbin. then-Chertoff Chief of Staff Alice Fisher, and
"several Pentagon lawyers" also went on the trip. The Terror Presiden2)' at 99-100.
3~4 Col. Terrence Farrell, Trip Report - DoD General Counsel Visit to GTMO (September 27,2002).
m Ibid.
356 Ibid.
m Committee staff interview of MG Michael Dunlavey (November 30, 2007).
3~8 Committee staff interview of William J. Haynes n (April 25, 2008) at 139-42.
49
(U) The JTF-170 Director for Intelligence, LTC Jerald Phifer, told the Committee that
MG Dunlavey wanted to get new techniques on the table and that MG Dunlavey pressured him
to draft a memo requesting additional techniques. 36o LTC Phifer asked the BSCT to draft an
interrogation policy that could be formally submitted up the chain of command for review. 361
According to MAJ Burney, the BSCT psychiatrist, "by early October there was increasing
pressure to get 'tougher' with detainee interrogations but nobody was quite willing to define
what 'tougher' meant.,,362 MAJ Burney added that there was "a lot ofpressure to use more
coercive techniques" and that if the interrogation policy memo that LTC Phifer had asked him to
write did not contain coercive techniques, then it "wasn't going to go very far.,,363
362 Ibid.
363 Army IG, Interview ofMAJ Paul Burney (April 28, 2006) at 11.
364 Ibid.
36'Committee staff interview ofMN Paul Burney (August 21, 2007). However, in testimony to the Army IG, MAJ
Burney said he did not know whether the memo incorpomted tactics from the Fort Bragg training. Army!G,
Interview of MAJ Paul Burney (April 28, 2006) at 11.
366 Committee staff interview o~ (September 12, 2007).
_ The memo identified a number of conditions at GTMO that the BSCT judged to
be hindering intelligence collection and stated:
_ Category II techniques were designed for 'lligh priority" detainees, defined in the
memo as "any detainee suspected of having significant information relative to the security ofthe
United States.,,372 Category II techniques included stress positions; the use of isolation for up to
30 days (with the possibility of additional 30 day periods, if authorized by the Chief
Interrogator); depriving a detainee of food for up to 12 hours (or as long as the interrogator goes
without food during an interrogation); the use of back-to-back 20 hour interrogations once per
week; removal of all comfort items including religious items; forced groominfi; handcuffmg a
detainee; and placing a hood on a detainee during questioning or movement. 3
36~ MAl Paul Burney and Memorandum for Record, Counter-resistance Strategies (October
2,2002) at 1 (hereinafter "BSCT, Counter-resistance Strategies").
368 Ibid. at 2.
369 Ibid.
370 Ibid.
371 Ibid.
312 Ibid.
Ibid. at 2-3. There is evidence that stress positions were used at GTMO prior to the BSCT memo. Lt. Col.
373
Ronald Buikema, who served at Guantanamo from January 2001 until Jme 2001 as the ITF-170 J2 and
Commanding Officer of the Joint Interagency Interrogation Facility (JIIF) indicated in his response ~o a Navy IG
questionnaire that stress positions were used in some interrogations at GTMO. Email from Lt. Col. Ron Buikema to
Victoria Gnibus (July 21,2004). .
51
_ The memo reserved Category III techniques "ONLY for detainees that have
evidenced advanced resistance and are suspected of having significant infonnation pertinent to
national security.,,374 Category III techniques included the daily use of20 hour interrogations;
the use of strict isolation without the right of visitation by treating medical professionals or the
International Committee ofthe Red Cross (ICRC); the use of food restriction for 24 hours once a
week; the use of scenarios designed to convince the detainee he might experience a painful or
fatal outcome; non-injurious physical consequences; removal of clothing; and exposure to cold
weather or water until such time as the detainee began to shiver. 375
52
(U) The BSCT provided a copy oftheir memo to LTC Banks at U.S. Anny Special
Operations Command (USASOC), who had helped organize their JPRA training. Upon
reviewing the memo, LTC Banks praised the BSCT for their "great job" on the memo, but also
raised concerns about the suggested use of physical pressures in interrogation, noting that
physical pressures are used with students in SERE school to increase their resistance to
interrogation, not break. it down. 380
380 Email from LTC Morgan Banks to MAl Paul Burney an~(October 2, 2002).
381 Ibid.
382 Counter Resistance Strategy Meeting Minutes at 2. The meeting minutes stated that questions and comments
from the meeting were paraphrased.
53
(U) Mr. Fredman's visit took place just a week after the acting CIA General Counsel
John Rizzo and DoD General Counsel Jim Haynes's September 25,2002 visit to GTMO. Mr.
Haynes did not recall discussing with Mr. Rizzo during their visit the possibility of having a CIA
lawyer travel to GTMO to talk to DoD personnel there. 383 Mr. Haynes said he later found out in
a discussion with Mr. Rizzo that a CIA lawyer had gone to GTMO and discussed legal
authorities applicable to interrogations, but said he could not recall when he ftrst learned ofthat
CIA lawyer's visit.
(U) While LTC Beaver could not recall what she or others said, the minutes ofthe
October 2, 2002 meeting indicate that it began with a brieftng by the BSCT on the JPRA training
at Fort Bragg. 384 The BSCT briefer told the group that rapport building and the "friendly
approach" were proven methods to overcome resistance, while "fear based approaches" were
''unreliable'' and "ineffective in ahnost all cases.,,385 According to the meeting minutes,
however, the BSCT did report that psychological stressors such as sleep deprivation, withholding
food, isolation, and loss oftime were "extremely effective." 386 The BSCT also identified "camp
wide, environmental strategies designed to disrupt cohesion and communication among
detainees" as potentially helpful to improve the effectiveness of interroations and explained that
the detention "environment should foster dependence and compliance." 87
(U) Despite the BSCT comment on the effectiveness of rapport building, the meeting
minutes reflect little discussion ofthat approach. In fact, according to the meeting minutes, the
GTMO Director for Intelligence LTC Jerald Phifer questioned the BSCT assessment, stating that
"harsh tec~d on our service members have worked and will work on some, what about
those?,,388 _ _ responded that force was "risky, and may be ineffective.,,389
Nevertheless, the remainder ofthe meeting appears to have revolved around a discussion of
aggressive interrogation techniques and how to obtain the approval to use them.
(U) Interrogation Control Element (ICE) Chief David Becker noted at the meeting that
there were many reports about sleep deprivation used at Bagram in Afghanistan. 390 According to
the meeting minutes, LTC Beaver agreed but stated that "officially it is not happening.,,391
Nevertheless, LTC Beaver suggested that sleep deprivation could be used on GTMO detainees
''with approval.,,392 The group also discussed ways to manage the detainees' sleep cycles, i.e., by
383 Committee staff interview of William J. Haynes II (April 25, 2008) at 145-47.
384 SASC Hearing (June 17,2008); Counter Resistance Strategy Meeting Minutes at 3.
38' Counter Resistance Strategy Meeting Minutes at 3.
386 Ibid.
387 Ibid.
388 Ibid.
389 Ibid. at 2.
390 Ibid
391 Ibid. at 3. It is unclear how and when JTF-170 personnel became aware of the use of sleep deprivation at
Bagram, though LIC Beaver told the Committee that she had seen a version of a standard operating procedure for
interrogations in use at Bagram on a classified DoD internet system.
392 Ibid.
54
letting the detainee rest ''just long enough to fall asleep and wake him up about every thirty
minutes and tell him it's time to pray again.,,393
(U) According to the meeting minutes, LTC Beaver suggested that the IfF might "need
to curb the harsher operations while [the International Committee ofthe Red Cross (ICRC;~ is
around," and that it would be "better not to expose them to any controversial techniques."
LTC Beaver explained that "[t]he ICRC is a serious concern. They will be in and out,
scrutinizing our operations, unless they are displeased and decide to protest and leave. This
would draw a lot of negative attention.,,395 The minutes reflect that the CIA lawyer added his
view:
In the past when the ICRC has made a big deal about certain detainees, the DOD
has 'moved' them away from the attention of the ICRC. Upon questioning from
the ICRC about their whereabouts, the DOD's response has repeatedly been that
the detainee merited no status under the Geneva Convention. 396
(U) At the meeting, the minutes reflect that CIA lawyer Jonathan Fredman also discussed
whether or not the techniques in the BSCT memo complied with applicable legal standards. Mr.
Fredman explained:
(U) According to the minutes, when the participants of the meeting discussed whether or
not to videotape the "aggressive sessions or interro&ations," Mr. Fredman said that videotaping
of "even totally legal techniques will look 'ugly. ,,,3 8 Mr. Becker, who agreed with the CIA
lawyer's assessment, added that "videotapes are subject to too much scrutiny in court." 399
393 Ibid. at 5.
394 Ibid. at 3.
395 Ibid.
396 Ibid.
397According to the meeting minutes, the CIA lawyer added "The Torture Convention prohibits torture and cruel,
inhumane and degrading treatment. The US did not sign up to the second part, because of the 8th amendment ..
.That gives us more license to use more controversial techniques." Ibid.
398 Ibid. at 5.
399 Ibid. at 3.
55
(U) When an attendee at the meeting mentioned that law enforcement agents (presumably
referring to CITF and FBI) had concerns about the use of aggressive tactics, the minutes reflect
that Mr. Fredman responded that "[w]hen CIA has wanted to use more aggressive techniques in
the past, the FBI has pulled their personnel from theatre. In those rare instances, aggressive
techniques have proven very helpful.,,4O LTC Beaver added that there was no legal reason why
law enforcement personnel could not participate in those operations. 401
(U) While LTC Beaver testified in 2008 that she was aware that SERE training was not
designed for offensive use with detainees, the minutes of the October 2,2002 meeting reflect that
she nevertheless asked about use ofthe "wet towel" technique in SERE school. 402 The CIA
lawyer replied:
If a well-trained individual is used to perfonn this technique it can feel like you're
drowning. The lymphatic system will react as if you're suffocating, but your
body will not cease to function. It is very effective to identify phobias and use
them (i.e., insects, snakes, claustrophobia). The level of resistance is directly
related to person's experience. 403
(U) According to the meeting minutes, ICE Chief David Becker asked whether GTMO
could get blanket approval for the use of techniques or whether techniques would be approved on
a case-by-case basis. 404 Mr. Fredman responded that the "CIA makes the call internally on most
ofthe techniques found in the BSCT" memo and referenced in their meeting, but that
"significantly harsh techniques are approved through the DOl,,405 As to whether Geneva
Conventions would apply, Mr. Fredman noted that the "CIA rallied for it not to.,,406
(U) The meeting minutes also reflect Mr. Fredman thoughts on other interrogation
techniques, such as threats of death. Mr. Fredman noted that such threats "should be handled on
a case by case basis. Mock executions don't work as well as friendly ~proaches, like letting
someone write a letter home, or providing them with an extra book.,;40
400 Ibid.
401 Ibid.
402 SASC Hearing (June 17, 2(08); BSCT, Counter-resistance Strategies at 4.
403
11Counter Resistance Strategy Meeting Minutes at 4. LTC Beaver said that she had learned about the wet towel
technique from a Navy doctor who had been assigned to the Hospital at Guantanamo and who described to her its
use at the Navy SERE school. It is unclear, however, to whom LTC Beaver is referring. The Committee
interviewed a Navy Lieutenant Commander who was deployed to GTMO and who had previously worked at the
Navy SERE school at the Naval Air Station in Brunswick, Maine. The Lieutenant Commander told the Committee
that he discussed with ITF-GTMO staff physical pressures used to teach students at SERE school how to resist
interrogations. However, the Lieutenant Commander was not deployed to GTMO until November 2002.
Committee staff interview of LTC Diane Beaver (October II, 2007); see Committee staff interview of
(August 22, 2007); Travel voucher.
404 Counter Resistance Strategy Meeting Minutes at 4.
40' Ibid.
406 Ibid.
407 Ibid. at 3.
56
(U) Weeks later, CITF Deputy Commander Mark Fallon wrote an email to CITF's Chief
Legal Counsel Major Sam McCahon regarding the meeting minutes:
Quotes from LTC Beaver regarding things that are not being reported give the
appearance of impropriety. Other comments like "It is basically subject to
perception. If the detainee dies you're doing it wrong" and "Any of the
teclmiques that lie on the harshest end of the spectrum must be performed by a
highly trained individual. Medical personnel should be present to treat any
possible accidents." Seem to stretch beyond the bounds of legal propriety. Talk.
of "wet towel treatment" which results in the lymphatic gland reacting as if you
are suffocating, would in my opinion; shock the conscience of any legal body
looking at using the results of the interrogations or possibly even the
interrogators. Someone needs to be considering how history will look back at
thiS. 408
II
The October 2, 2002 meeting minutes indicated that the group discussed Mohammed
al Khatani, a high value detainee suspected of being connected to the September 11, 2001
attacks. A week before the meeting, JTF-170 had assumed the lead on Khatani's
interrogation. 409 By the October 2, 2002 meeting, JTF-170 had already developed an aggressive
interrogation plan for Khatani. .
IITwo days after the meeting, BSCT psychiatrist MAl Paul Burney sent an email to
LTC Banks, stating that "persons here at this operation are still interested in pursuing the
potential use of more aversive interrogation teclmiques ... Were more aversive teclmiques
approved for use in the future by appropriate people, the operation would like to have a few task
force personnel specifically trained in various techniques.,,410 MAl Burney asked whether LTC
Banks knew "where task force personnel could go to receive such training" and whether he knew
of"any consultants who could assist ifany ofthese measures are eventually approved.,,411
_ LTC Banks replied "I do not envy you. I suspect I know where this is coming from.
The answer is no, I do not know of anyone who could provide that training... The training that
SERE instructors receive is designed to simulate that of a foreign power, and to do so in a
manner that encourages resistance among the students. I do not believe that traininf
interrogators to use what SERE instructors use would be particularly productive.,,41
408 Email from Mark Fallon to MAl Sam McCahon et aI. (October 28, 2002).
409 _ LTG Joseph Jnge, DEPSECDEF Inquiry Regarding Location o/Inte"ogation Plan/or ISN 063 (August
24, 2006) at 5 (hereinafter "Jnge Report'').
410 Email from MAl Paul Burney to LTC Morgan Banks (October 4, 2002).
411 Ibid.
412 Email from LTC Morgan Banks to MAl Paul Burney (October 4, 2002).
57
413
turned him over to U.S. forces on December 26, 2001. He was transferred to Guantanamo
Bay on February 13,2002, where he was initially interrogated by JTF170, CITF and FBI
personnel at Camp X-Ray.
(U) On September 23, 2002, the CITF Special Agent in Charge sent a memorandum to
CITF's Deputy Commander raising concerns about JTF-170's proposed interrogation plan for
Khatani. The memo stated:
413Memo from COL John Redis (ITF-GlMO Chief ofStafl) to SOUTRCOM Chief of Staff (March 14, 2005),
attached as Tab 1 to Inge Report (August 24,2006).
414Khatani was identified as a possible twentieth highjacker after it was determined that he had tried to enter the
U.S. in August 2001 but was detained at the Orlando, Florida airport and later deported. When Khatani arrived at
the Orlando airport. Mohammed .Atta was waiting. JTF-GlMO, Analyst Support Summary (March 18, 2003),
attached as Tab 22 to Inge Report (August 24, 2006).
415 Inge Report at 5.
416Memo from COL John Redis (ITF-GlMO Chief of Stafl) to SOUTRCOM Chief of Staff (March 14, 2005),
attached as Tab 1 to Inge Report (August 24, 2006); Inge Report at 5.
417 Memo from J.K. Sieber (CITF SAC) to CITF Deputy Commander, CITF Operations Officer, CITF SJA, DOD
Interrogation Techniques Issue (September 23, 2002).
418 Committee staff interview of David Becker (September 17, 2007).
58
(U) While MG Dunlavey's memo stated that the request had "been reviewed by my Staff
Judge Advocate and determined to be legally sufficient," the SJA, LTC Diane Beaver, told the
Committee that she had not been consulted on the interrogation plan and did not recall reviewing
the memo or providing the Commander with guidance regarding the legal sufficiency of the
request. 42S Major General Dunlavey said that he did not recall whether or not he personally
consulted with LTC Beaver, that the letter would likely have been drafted by his Director for
Intelligence, LTC Jerald Phifer, and that it was possible that the statement in the letter that LTC
Beaver had been consulted was based on a representation by his staff. 426
419The memo was provided to the Committee as an appendix to the AR-15-6 Report completed by Lieutenant
General Randall Schmidt and Brigadier General John T. Furlow into FBI allegations of abuse at Guantanamo Bay
(hereinafter "Schmidt-Furlow Report''). The memo is unsigned but contains a handwritten notation "/I//signed on 1
Oct 02////." Committee staff requested the Department of Defense provide a signed copy or advise the Committee of
any reason why the Committee should not rely on the document. The Department provided neither.
420 Memo from MG Michael Dunlavey to ITF-160 Commander, Inte"ogation Plan for ISN 063 (October 1, 2002),
attached as exhibit 40 to Schmidt-Furlow Report.
421 Ibid.
422 Ibid.
423 Ibid.
424 Ibid.
42'Ibid.; Committee staff interview of LTC Diane Beaver (October 11, 2007); see also Memo from lK. Sieber
(CITF SAC) to CITF Deputy Commander, CITF Operations Officer, CITF SJA, DOD Interrogation Techniques
Issue (September 23, 2002) ("the JTF 170 SJA had not been briefed on the plan prior to her contact with the FBI
SSA When she learned of the plan, she sought guidance from up her chain of command and also sought guidance
from DOD legal and other intelligence agencies. She wants to ensure that even if these techniques are not legally
objectionable, her chain of command is aware that these types of techniques are being utilized and that the personnel
on the ground are properly trained to conduct these techniques.")
426 Committee staff interview ofMG Michael Dunlavey (November 30,2007).
59
II Mr. Becker told the Committee that he had authorized dogs entering the interrogation
room on two occasions and that the dog barked but was not pennitted to place its paws on
Khatani. 430 ~lr. Becker also told the Committee that LTC Phifer provided verbal authority for
the dogs to be used in this manner. LTC Phifer recalled discussing dogs with Mr. Becker as a
teclmique because Arabs "saw dogs as a dirty animal and they didn't like them," not because
they should be "used as a fear factor.,,431 LTC Phifer told the Army IG, however, that Mr.
Becker never told him that he had approved the use of a dog during the Khatani interrogation.
However, in written answers to questions posed by Vice Admiral Church, LTC Phifer stated that
dogs were used in the Khatani interrogation and that "[w]e would bring the dog around to within
10 feet [of Khatani] and he would be somewhat Ulmerved by it. We did it to keep him off
balance as well as to enhance security.'.432 Major General Dunlavey said that he did not recall
being aware that a dog was used in the interrogation of Khatani. 433
II( In an October 8,2002 email to his colleague, an FBI agent described ITF
170's interrogation of Khatani, stating that DoD had tried "sleep deprivation," "loud music,
bright lights, and 'body placement discomfort,' all with negative results" and that DoD
interrogators planned to stop the interrogation. 434 Mr. Becker told the Committee that the
interrogation plan did not work and that ITF-170 ceased the interrogation after approximately a
week and moved Khatani back to the Navy brig. 435
427Summarized witness statement of David Becker (March 3, 2005), exhibit 21 to Schmidt-Furlow Report~
summarized witness statement of ENS Mary Travers (February 23,2005), exhibit 33 to Schmidt-Furlow Report;
summarized witness statement of Agent Robert Morton (January 20, 2005), exhibit 36 to Schmidt-Furlow Report;
summarized witness statement of Agent Charles Dorsey (January 20,2005), exhibit 41 to Schmidt-Furlow Report.
428 Summarized witness statement of Agent Charles Dorsey (January 20,2005), exhibit 41 to Schmidt-Furlow
Report.
429 Army IG, Interview of David Becker (September 20,2005) at 30.
430 Committee staff interview of David Becker (September 17,2007).
431 Army IG, Interview of LTC Jerald Phifer (March 16, 2006) at 13.
432Responses of LTC Jerald Phifer to questionnaire of VADM Church (July 16, 2004). It is not clear from those
written answers whether LTC Phifer was referring to the use of dogs in ITF-170's October 2002 interrogation of
Khatani or in the subsequent interrogation of Khat ani that began in late November.
433 Committee staff interview of Major General Michael Dunlavey (November 30, 2007).
434 Email from FBI Special Agent to FBI Special Agent (October 8, 2002).
m Committee staff interview of David Becker (September 17, 2007).
60
(U) Another FBI agent reflected upon the failed interrogation in his own email of October
8, 2002, observing that "I think we should consider leaving him alone, let him get healthy again
and do something 'different. ",436
(U) On October 11, 2002, just days after the JTF-170 moved Khatani back to the Navy
Brig and shortly after meeting with the ChiefCounsel ofthe CIA's CounterTerrorist Center
Jonathan Fredman, LTC Phifer submitted a memorandum to JTF-170 Commander MG Dunlavey
requesting approval to use "counter-resistance" interrogation techniques. 437 LTC Phifer's
memo was largely drawn from the October 2, 2002 memorandum that the GTMO Behavioral
Science Consultation Team (BSCT) had written upon their return from the JPRA training at Fort
Bragg. 438 The memo requested approval for three categories of progressively more aggressive
interrogation techniques, many of which were similar to techniques used at SERE schools to
increase U.S. soldiers' resistance to illegal enemy interrogation. 439
(U) Ofthe three categories of proposed techniques, those in Category I were the least
aggressive. Category I proposed yelling at the detainee and using certain "techniques of
deception," such as using multiple interrogators or having an interrogator "identifY himself as a
citizen of a foreign nation or as an interrogator from a country with a reputation for harsh
treatment of detainees. ,,4040
(U) The proposed Category II techniques were more aggressive and included several
techniques similar to those used in SERE schools, such as stress positions, isolation, deprivation
oflight and auditory stimuli, using a hood during transport and questioning, removal of clothing,
and using detainees' individual phobias to induce stress. 441
II
An August 19,2002 email from LTC Beaver reflected discussions among JTF-170
staff about stress positions, which she said resulted in an agreed upon policy of "no stress
436 Email from FBI Special Agent to FBI Special Agent (October 8, 2(02).
437Memo from LTC Jerald Phifer to MG Michael Dunlavey, Requestfor Approval ofCounter-Resistance Strategies
(October II, 2(02) (hereinafter LTC Phifer to MG Michael Dunlavey, Requestfor Approval ofCounter-Resistance
Strategies').
438MAl Burney told the Army IG that the October II, 2002 memo "wasn't the exact same document that we had
written but the general structure and overall organization-a lot of the things did remain intact from our original
brainstorm to what was eventually requested." Army IG, Interview of MAl Paul Burney (August 21, 2(07) at 11.
439 The October 11 memo also stated that "current guidelines for interrogation procedures at GTMO limit the ability
of interrogators to counter advanced resistance." LTC Phifer to MG Michael Dunlavey, RequestforApproval of
Counter-Resistance Strategies".
440 Ibid
441Additional Category II techniques included use of falsified documents or reports, interrogating the detainee in an
environment other than the standard interrogation booth, use of 20 hour interrogations, removal of all comfort items
(including religious items), switching the detainee from hot rations to MREs, and forced grooming. Ibid
61
positions" at GTMO. 442 When asked how stress positions came to be included in LTC Phifer's
memo, given the agreement referenced in her earlier email, LTC Beaver said that she did not
know, but added that LTC Phifer later advocated for their use. 443 LTC Beaver said that she
relied on Mr. Becker and LTC Phifer to decide which techniques to put in the memo and that she
never commented or changed their drafts. 444
(U) The proposed Category III techniques in the October 11, 2002 request were the most
aggressive and included the use of scenarios designed to convince the detainee that death or
severely painful consequences were imminent for him and/or his family; exposure to cold
weather or water; the use ofa wet towel and dripping water to induce the misperception of
suffocation; and the use of mild, non-injurious physical contact such as grabbing, poking in the
chest with the fmger, and light pushing. 44S According to the October 11,2002 memo, Category
III techniques "and other aversive techniques, such as those used in u.s. military resistance
training or by other U.S. government agencies" would be utilized to interrogate "exceptionally
resistant detainees," which LTC Phifer estimated as "less than 3%" of the detainees held at
GTMO. 446
(U) Two ofthe Category III techniques in LTC Phifer's memo - the use of phobias and
the use ofthe wet towel and dripping water to induce the misperception of suffocation - were not
derived from the October 2,2002 BSCT memo. 447 CIA lawyer Jonathan Fredman, however, had
reportedly discussed both ofthese techniques during his October 2, 2002 meeting with GTMO
personnel, noting that the use ofphobias was "very effective" and that the use ofthe "wet towel
technique" makes a body react as is if it's suffocating. 448 Mr. Becker told the Committee that he
(the ICE Chief) may have recommended adding those two techniques to the request for
authority. 449
4So
(U) LTC Phifer said that he drafted his memo with Mr. Becker.Mr. Becker, however,
told the Committee that he was provided a draft only after it was nearly complete. He said that
442Vice Admiral Albert T. Church, Review ofDepartment ofDefense Detention Operations and Detainee
Inte"ogation Techniques (March 7,2005) (hereinafter "Church Reporfj at 109 (citing email from LTC Beaver
(August 19, 2002)).
443 LTC Beaver told the Committee that LTC Phifer advocated the use of stress positions in the interrogation of
Mohammed al Khatani (discussed below). Committee staff interview of LTC Diane Beaver (November 9,2007).
444 Ibid.
44' LTC Phifer to MG Michael Dunlavey, Requestfor Approval ofCounter-Resistance Strategies.
446 Ibid.
447 The use of a wet towel and dripping water to induce the misperception of drowning appears to describe
waterboarding. The Navy is the only service that used waterboarding in SERE training. which it ceased in
November 2007.
448Counter Resistance Strategy Meeting Minutes at 5 (The CTC Chief Counsel explained that if a "well-trained
individual is used to perform" the "wet-towel technique," it can "feel like you're drowning. The lymphatic system
will react as if you're suffocating but your body will not cease to function.")
449 Committee staff interview of David Becker (September 17, 2007).
4'0 Committee staff interview of LTC Jerald Phifer (June 27, 2007).
he thought the techniques memo was "stupid," though he did not share his view with LTC Phifer
at the time. 451 LTC Phifer told the Committee that he was uncomfortable with the idea of using
some ofthe techniques in his memo but that MG Dunlavey pressured him to fmish the request. 452
(U) The October 11, 2002 techniques memo was accompanied by a cover memo and
legal briefwritten by GTMO's Staff Judge Advocate (SJA) LTC Diane Beaver. The cover
memo stated simply that ''the proposed strategies do not violate applicable federal law.,,453
(U) LTC Beaver told the Committee that she drafted the legal brief with her staff over the
course of the 2002 Columbus Day weekend. 454 She told the Committee that she had not seen
either ofthe legal memoranda produced by the Department of Justice Office of Legal Counsel on
August 1, 2002 and that she did not receive input on the legal brief from anyone outside of
GTMO. The minutes ofthe October 2, 2002 meeting with CIA lawyer Jonathan Fredman,
however, reflect that LTC Beaver was present when he discussed the Torture Convention (and
the federal law implementing the treaty). In that discussion, Mr. Fredman described "severe
physical pain" as "anything causing permanent damage to major organs or body partS.,,455 The
idea that "severe physical pain" constituting torture had to rise to the level of "organ failure,
irnpainnent of bodily functions or even death" had been discussed in the OLC legal memo of
August 1 2002, known as the First Bybee memo. 456
(U) LTC Beaver began her analysis ofthe "aggressive" techniques by stating that the
"detainees currently held at Guantanamo Bay ... are not protected by the Geneva
Conventions.'.457 LTC Beaver stated that the Office ofthe Secretary of Defense "had not
adopted specific guidelines regarding interrogation techniques for detainee operations at GTMO"
and she dismissed the longstanding guidance on interrogation of detainees contained in the Army
Field Manual (FM) 34-52 as not binding. 458
63
(U) In her memo, LTC Beaver stated that U. S. obligations under the Convention Against
Torture restricted only those cruel, inhuman, or degrading acts that were also prohibited by the
"current standard articulated in the Eighth Amendment" against "cruel and unusual
punishment. ,,459 The memo concluded that the proposed interrogation techniques would be
consistent with the Eighth Amendment standard so long as any force used could "plausibly have
been thought necessary ... to achieve a legitimate governmental objective and it was applied in a
good faith effort and not maliciously or sadistically for the very purpose of causing harm.,,460
(U) LTC Beaver also concluded that the proposed interrogation techniques would not
violate the federal anti-torture statute so long as they were not specifically intended to cause
severe physical pain or suffering or prolonged mental harm. LTC Beaver conducted her analysis
with the "assum[ption] that severe physical pain [would not be] inflicted" and "absent any
evidence that any ofthese strategies [would] in fact cause prolonged and long lasting mental
harm.,,461 LTC Beaver told the Committee that she did not conduct any research to determine
whether the use of the techniques described in the accompanying request for authority would, in
fact, result in long-term mental harm. 462
II ( The October 2, 2002 BSCT memo, however, had specifically cautioned that
the techniques "could affect the short term and/or long term physical and/or mental health ofthe
detainee ... [and that] physical and/or emotional harm from the ... techniques may emerge
months or even years after their use.,,463
(U) LTC Beaver also found that some ofthe proposed tactics would constitute a "per se
violation" ofthe Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) Article that prohibits military
personnel from committing assault, and could violate the Article that prohibits military personnel
from communicating a threat.464 As a result, LTC Beaver said it would be "advisable to have
permission or immunity in advance from the convening authority for military members utilizing
these methods.,,465 In a November 4,2002 letter to the Joint StaffJ-5, the Marine Corps
commented on the SJA's recommendation to convey "permission or immunity in advance,"
noting that "[w]e are unaware of any authority that would allow a convening authority to give
'permission or immunity' in advance to commit a criminal violation.,,466 Likewise, military
lawyers from the Judge Advocate General's Legal Center and School later said that LTC
Beaver's "proposal to immunize interrogators, given that a number ofthe proposed techniques in
64
issue constituted violations of the UCMJ, was not only unprecedented, but lacked any basis in
law.,,467
(U) Based on her legal review, LTC Beaver recommended that the "proposed methods of
interrogation be approved," but that interrogators be trained to use the methods and that
"interrogations involving category II and III methods" undergo a legal, medical, behavioral
science, and intelligence review prior to commencement.468
(U) LTC Beaver told the Committee that she called the SOUTHCOM Staff Judge
Advocate COL Manny Supervielle, like?, on Sunday, October 10, 2002 and sent SOUTHCOM a
draft of the legal memo that same day.46 She said that she told COL Supervielle that she "really
needed some help" but that she received no comments from SOUTHCOM prior to submitting the
final memo the next day. 470 LTC Beaver said that she also talked to the Legal Counsel to the
Chainnan of the Joint Chiefs of Staff CAPT Jane Dalton and asked for her help, but was told that
she should talk to COL Supervielle. 471 CAPT Dalton said that she did not recall that
conversation with LTC Beaver.472 LTC Beaver also told the Committee that MG Dunlavey did
not comment on drafts of the memo and that she did not discuss it with him after it was
completed. 473
(U) On October 11, 2002, MG Dunlavey submitted LTC Phifer's memo and LTC
Beaver's legal analysis to General James Hill, the Commander ofthe United States Southern
Command (SOUfHCOM). He also sent his own memo requesting approval to use the
interrogation techniques. 474 MG Dunlavey wrote:
467Lt Col Kantwill et al., Improving the Fighting Position, A Practitioner's Guide to Operational Law Support to
the Interrogation Process, 2005 Army Lawyer (July 2(05) at 12, 14.
468 LTC Beaver, Legal Briefon Proposed Counter-Resistance Strategies at 7.
469 Committee staff interview of LTC Diane Beaver (November 9, 2(07).
4'71l SASC Hearing (June 17, 2(08); Committee staff interview of LTC Diane Beaver (November 9,2007).
471 SASC Hearing (June 17, 2(08).
471 Ibid.
473 Committee staff interview of LTC Diane Beaver (November 9, 2(07) .
474Memo from MG Michael Dunlavey to USSOUTHCOM Commander GEN James Hill, Counter-Resistance
Strategies (October 11, 2002) (hereinafter "MG Dunlavey to GEN Hill, Counter-Resistance Strategies. '')
65
SJA, I have concluded that these techniques do not violate u.s. or international
475
laws.
(U) On October 25,2002, GEN Hill forwarded the JTF-170 request to Chairman of the
Joint Chiefs of Staff, Gen Richard Myers, with a memorandum stating that "despite our best
efforts, some detainees have tenaciously resisted our current interrogation methods.,,476 He
continued: "[0]ur respective staffs, the Office of the Secretary of Defense, and Joint Task Force
170 have been trying to identify counter-resistant techniques that we can lawfully employ.'.477
When later asked, GEN Hill could not recall whether SOUTHCOM ~roduced a written opinion
analyzing the GTMO request separate from LTC Beaver's opinion. 4 8
(U) As to techniques in the GTMO request for interrogation techniques, GEN Hill said
that he "did discuss the topic of SERE training in a general manner with MG Dunlavey.,,479
Years later, in a June 3, 2004 press briefing, GEN Hill noted the influence ofthe Fort Bragg trip
and SERE school techniques on the request, stating:
(U) In his October 25, 2002 memo, GEN Hill stated that, although he believed Categories
I and II techniques were "legal and humane," he was uncertain about techniques in Category III
and was "particularly troubled by the use of implied or expressed threats of death ofthe detainee
or his family.'.481 Nevertheless, GEN Hill said that he "desire[d] to have as many options as
possible at [his] disposal" and asked that Departments of Defense and Justice attorneys review
the Category III techniques. 482
66
(U) One SOUTHCOM Assistant Staff Judge Advocate LTC Mark Gingras testified to the
Army IG that lawyers for SOUTHCOM had concerns about Category II and Category III
techniques. 483 Regarding the GTMO request for techniques, LTC Gingras told the Anny IG:
As lawyers we're talking about adherence to the rule of law being important, and
that's what we're trying to tell everybody as we travel around the world to these
other countries. That's paramount to democracy. And so suddenly we look like
we're brushing this aside or we're twisting the law. The feeling was that decision
makers within the Pentagon didn't much care about that. They cared about
winning the War on Terrorism. And ifthat meant you had to pull out fmgernails
you'd pull out fmgernails, figuratively speaking.484
(U) On October 30,2002, after receiving Gen Hill's memo and the GTMO request, the
Joint Staff J-5 requested that the military services comment on the request. 485
(U) On November 1,2002, the Air Force responded, expressing "serious concerns
regarding the legality of many ofthe proposed techniques" and stating that "some ofthese
techniques could be construed as 'torture,' as that crime is defmed by 18 U.S.C. 2340.'.486 The
Air Force memorandum added that, with respect to potential prosecutions, the use ofCatego~
III techniques would "almost certainly" result in any statements obtained being inadmissible. 87
The memorandum stated that admissibility of evidence obtained using Categories I and II
techniques, the latter of which included stress positions, the use of dogs, removal of clothing, and
deprivation oflight and auditory stimuli, among other techniques, would be "fact specific, but
the same concerns remain. ,,488 The Air Force memo continued: "Additionally, the techniques
described may be subject to challenge as failing to meet the requirements outlined in the military
order to treat detainees humanely... Implementation of the proposed techniques would require a
change in Presidential policy.,,489 The memo stated that the Air Force "concurs in the need to
conduct an in-depth legal and policy assessment, as recommended by [the SOUTHCOM
Commander], prior to implementation of the proposed counter-resistance interrogation
techniques.,,490
(U) On November 4, 2002, the Navy responded to the Joint Staff's request for comment,
stating that it "concur[red] with developing a range of advanced counter-resistance techniques,"
483 Army IG, Interview of LIe Mark Gingras (October 11, 2005) at 20.
484 Ibid.
48~ Joint Staff Action Processing Form (SJS 02-06697), Counter-Resistance Techniques (October 30,2002).
Department of the Air Force Memo for UN and Multilateral Affair Division (1-5), Joint Staff, Counter-Resistance
486
Techniques (November 1, 2002).
487 Ibid. at 1.
488 Ibid.
489 Ibid. at 2.
490 Ibid. at 1.
but recommending "a more detailed interagency legal and policy review be conducted on the ...
proposed techniques.,,491
(U) That same day, the Marine Corps submitted its written comments, which concluded
that "several ofthe Category II and III techniques arguably violate federal law, and would
expose our service members to possible prosecution.,,492 The Marine Corps memo stated that the
use ofthe techniques would also create "exposure to criminal prosecution under the UCMJ.,,493
Again, Category III techniques included the use of scenarios designed to convince the detainee
that death or severely painful consequences were imminent for him or his family, exposure to
cold weather or water, use of a wet towel and dripping water to induce the misperception of
suffocation, and non-injurious physical contact such as grabbing, poking and light pushing. 494
Category II included such techniques as stress positions, deprivation oflight and auditory
stimuli, the use of a hood during questioning, 20 hour interrogations, removal of clothing, and
the use of detainee phobias, such as dogs, to induce stress. The memo also stated the Marine
Corps "disagree[d] with the position that the proposed plan is legally sufficient.,,495
(U) A few days later, the Army submitted comments from both the Office of the Judge
Advocate General (OTJAG) and the CITF. 496 The Army's cover memo stated that "Army
interposes significant legal, policy and practical concerns regarding most of the Category II and
all ofthe Category III techniques proposed" and that the Army "concurs in the recommendation
for a comprehensive legal review ofthis proposal in its entirety by the Department of Defense
and the Department of Justice.,,491 The OTJAG's memorandum, which was attached, stated that
Category III techniques "violate the President's order [on humane treatment] and various UCMJ
articles" and that the use of scenarios designed to convince the detainee that death or severely
painful consequences are imminent for him and/or his family and the use of a wet towel and
dripping water to induce the misperception of suffocation "appear to be clear violations ofthe
federal torture statute.,,498 The OTJAG memorandum also stated that Category II techniques of
stress positions, deprivation oflight and auditory stimuli, and using individual phobias to induce
stress "crosses the line of 'humane' treatment, would likely be considered maltreatment under
491 Department of the Navy Memo for the Director for Strategic Plans and Policy Directorate (1-5) Joint Staff, Navy
Planner's Memo WRT Counter-Resistance Techniques (SJS 02-06697) (November 4, 2002).
492 Memo from Marine Corps Service Planner to Director, J-5, The Joint Staff, Counter-Resistance Techniques
(November 4,2002).
493 Ibid.
494 LTC Phifer to MG Dunlavey, Requestfor Approval ofCounter-Resistance Strategies.
m Memo from Marine Corps Service Planner to Director, J-5, The Joint Staff, Counter-Resistance Techniques
(November 4, 2002).
496Memo from the Army Deputy to the Assistant Deputy Chief of Staff for Operations and Plans (Joint Affairs) to
the Joint Staff, J-51UNMA [UN and Multilateral Affairs Division], SJS 02-06697 (November 7,2002); Memo from
Department of the Army, Office of the Judge Advocate (International and Operational Law) to The Office of the
Army General Counsel, Review-Proposed Counter-Resistance Techniques (undated) (hereinafter "DAJA(IO)
Memo for Army General Counsel. Proposed Counter-Resistance Techniques.")
497 DAJA(IO) Memo for Army General Counsel, Proposed Counter-Resistance Techniques.
498 Ibid.
68
Article 93 of the [Uniform Code of Military Justice], and may violate the Federal torture
statute.,,499 The memo continued that that removal of clothing and forced grooming "may be
considered inhumane" if done only for interrogation pu~oses and stated "if we mistreat
detainees, we will quickly lose the moral high ground." 0 The Army concurred with GEN
Hill's request for a legal review before techniques were adopted. 501
(U) Military lawyers were not the only personnel to object to GTMO's request for
aggressive techniques. CITF Deputy Commander Mark Fallon told the Committee that it was
CITF's view that the techniques proposed by JTF-170 would actually strengthen, rather than
weaken, detainee resistance. He explained:
Our view was that employing techniques that validated [the detainees] prior
training and adverse views would serve to harden resistance and reinforce what
they had been told to expect... We pointed out that SERE school tactics were
developed to better prepare U.S. military personnel to resist interrogations and not
as a means of obtaining reliable information. CITF was troubled with the
rationale that techniques used to harden resistance to interrogations would be the
basis for the utilization oftechniques to obtain information. 502
(U) CITF's legal view was reflected in a November 4,2002 memo from CITF Chief
Legal Advisor MAJ Sam McCahon, which was also attached to the Army's response to the Joint
Staff. MAJ McCahon wrote:
[Category] III and certain [Category] II techniques may subject service members
to punitive articles of the UCMJ... CITF personnel who are aware of the use or
abuse of certain techniques may be exposed to liability under the UCMJ for
failing to intercede or report incidents, if an inquiry later determines the conduct
to be in violation of either the Eighth Amendment to the U. S. Constitution, the
Uniform Code of Military Justice or 18 U.S.C. 2340. 503
(U) MAJ McCahon also raised concerns about the impact ofthe techniques on
evidentiary proceedings:
One detainee subjected to these techniques could taint the voluntary nature of all
other confessions and information derived from detainees not subjected to the
aggressive techniques. 504
499 Ibid.
500 Ibid.
501 Ibid.
502 Responses of Mr. Mark Fallon to questionnaire of Senator Carl Levin (September 15, 2006) at 7.
503 Memo from CITF Chief Legal Advisor MAl Sam McCahon to CITF Commander, Assessment of.TFF-170
Counter-Resistance Strategies and the Potential Impact on CrrF Mission and Personnel (November 4, 2002)
(hereinafter "McCahon to CDR CITF, Assessment of.TFF-170 Counter-Resistance Strategies.'j
504 McCahon to CDR CITF, Assessment of.TFF-170 Counter-Resistance Strategies.
69
(U) MAl McCahon added that "[b]oth the utility and legality ofapplying certain
techniques" in the October 11, 2002 memo are "questionable," and recommended that CITF
personnel not participate in or even observe the use of aggressive techniques. 505 MAl McCahon
concluded:
(U) MAl McCahon told the Committee that his memorandum prompted a subsequent
meeting at the Pentagon. 507
(U) When the October 11,2002 GTMO request arrived in the DoD General Counsel's
office, DoD Associate Deputy General Counsel for International Affairs Eliana Davidson said
that she was asked to provide her thoughts on the request. Ms. Davidson said that she had a brief
conversation with Mr. Haynes where she told him that the GTMO request needed further
assessment. 508 Mr. Haynes stated that he did not "recall that specifically.,,509
(U) When the October 11,2002 GTMO request arrived at the Joint Staff, CAPT Jane
Dalton, the Legal Counsel to the Chainnan ofthe Joint Chiefs of Staff, said it was "obvious to
[her] that there were some legal issues" with the request. 510 She said that techniques in Category
II ofthe request "needed to be looked at closely" and that Category III techniques "had
significant, significant concerns." 511 CAPT Dalton found LTC Beaver's legal analysis
''woefully inadequate" and said it relied on a methodology and conclusions that were "very
strained.,,512 Rather than simply deny the request, however, CAPT Dalton said that "she owed it
to the combatant commander to do a full and complete review.,,513 She subsequently directed her
staffto set up a secure video teleconference with representatives from the Defense Intelligence
Agency (DIA), the Army's intelligence school at Fort Huachuca, U.S. Southern Command
(SOUTHCOM), and GTMO to find out more infonnation about the techniques in the request and
to "begin discussing the legal issues to see if we could do ... our own independent legal
analysis.,,514
505 Ibid.
506 Ibid.
507 Committee staff interview ofMAJ Sam McCahon (June 15,2(07).
508 Committee staff interview of Eliana Davidson (May 23, 2008).
509 SASC Hearing (June I7, 2(08).
510 Committee staff interview ofRADM Jane Dalton (April 10, 2(08) at 33.
m Ibid. at 45.
m Ibid. at 41.
m Ibid. at 33.
514 Ibid. at 34.
70
(U) CAPT Dalton recalled making Chairman ofthe Joint Chiefs of Staff General Richard
Myers aware of the concerns expressed by the military services. 515 The Chairman said, however,
that he did "not specifically recall the objections ofthe Services being raised" to his attention at
that time. 516
(U) CAPT Dalton also recalled that her staff briefed the DoD General Counsel's office
about the concerns submitted by the military services and that the General Counsel himself "was
aware ofthe concerns.,,517 In a February 2008 interview, DoD Associate Deputy General
Counsel for International Affairs Eliana Davidson recalled that the service comments were made
available to the General Counsel's office. 518 DoD General Counsel Jim Haynes stated, however,
that he "did not recall seeing" the memos at that time and "didn't know they existed.,,519 He
stated that he did not recall being infonned by anyone that the military services had concerns
about the legality of Category II techniques in the request and that he did not have a "specific
recollection" of CAPT Dalton making him aware that there were concerns about the legality of
techniques in the GTMO request. 520
(U) According to CAPT Dalton, after she and her staff initiated their analysis, CJCS GEN
Myers directed her to stop that review. CAPT Dalton said that GEN Myers returned from a
meeting and "advised me that [DoD General Counsel] Mr. Haynes wanted me ... to cancel the
video teleconference and to stop" conducting the review because of concerns that "people were
going to see" the GTMO request and the military services' ana1~sis of it. 521 According to CAPT
Dalton, Mr. Haynes "wanted to keep it much more close hold." 22 When CAPT Dalton "learned
that [the DoD General Counsel] did not want that broad based legal and policy r.eview to take
place," she and her staff stopped their review. 523 This was the only time that CAPT Dalton had
ever been asked to stop analyzing a request that came to her for her review. 524
_ CAPT Dalton recalled that prior to bein~ directed to stop the review, her staffhad
begun writing draft comments on the GTMO request. 52 An undated draft of a memorandum
from GEN Myers to SOUTHCOM Commander GEN Hill, analyzing the October 11, 2002
71
GTMO request, stated "We do not believe the proposed plan is legally sufficient.,,526 The draft
memo stated that "several ofthe Category III techniques arguably violate federal law, and could
expose interrogators to possible prosecution" under the federal anti-torture laws. 527 The draft
stated that techniques in the request "may be subject to challenge as failing to meet the
requirements outlined in the military order to treat detainees humanely" and recommended an
"in-depth technical, policy, and legal assessment" ofthe techniques prior to their
implementation. 528
(U) GEN Myers said that he had "no specific recollection" of discussing with CAPT
Dalton her efforts to conduct an analysis of the October 11, 2002 GTMO request. 529 He said
that while he "did not dispute" asking her to stop working on her analysis and acknowledged that
Joint Staffrecords indicated that she did stop work on her analysis, he had "no recollection or
doing so" and did "not recall anyone suggesting" to him that she stop her review. 530 DoD
General Counsel Jim Haynes said that while it was "possible" that the issue could have come up
in a conversation with the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, he did not "recall that specific
conversation" or expressing any opinion ofany kind with respect to CAPT Dalton's review. 531
_ While GTMO's request for approval to use aggressive interrogation techniques was
pending, JPRA staff was developing an agenda for possible follow-up training for interrogation
personnel at GTMO.
(FODO) David Becker, the GTMO ICE Chief, told the Committee that once they
received authority to use the techniques in the October 11, 2002 memo, GTMO interrogators
would need training on the techniques. 534 A draft message order circulated between GTMO and
JPRA staff in late October requested "mission critical training support" for "approximatelyll
'26 Draft memo from CJCS Richard Myers to Commander, United States Southern Command, Counter-Resistance
Techniques (undated).
mIbid.
,:zs Ibid.
'29 Responses of GEN (Ret.) Richard Myers to April 16, 2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (April 30,
2008).
'30 Ibid.
m Committee staff interview of William 1. Haynes II (April 25, 2008) at 168.
m Memorandum From Joseph Witsch to JPRNCC, JPRNCD, JPRNCOS, JPRNOSO, Plan ofInstruction (POI)
for TF-170 Training Support (October 16, 2002).
'33 See Section III D, supra; Plan ofInstruction (pOI)for TF-170 Training Support (October 16, 2002).
'34 Committee staff interview of David Becker (September 17, 2007).
72
personnel" at GTMO. 535 The draft message order stated that the training would "provide the
necessary tools ITF-GTMO interrogators require to accomplish their mission critical tasks. 536
_( A November 15,2002 staffmemo to the Joint Staff J-2 stated that ITF
GTMO had requested training on the SERE school techniques and that the trainers were
expected to arrive in the ftrst week of December.537 The JPRA Operational Support Office
(OSO) Chief Christopher Wirts told the Committee that the requirement for JPRA to provide the
training was never approved and that his agency never conducted the training. 538 However, in
January 2003, two instructors from the Navy SERE school, John Rankin and Christopher Ross,
travelled to GTMO to train interrogators on the use of physical pressures, including slapping,
walling, and stress positions. 539
(U) In November 2002 a new Commander, MG Geoffrey Miller, took command of ITF
GTMO. At the time, MG Miller had no ftrst-hand experience with detainees or
interrogations.540
(U) MG Miller told the Committee that prior to taking command, he met with
SOUTHCOM Commander GEN Hill and his staff. 541 During those meetings, MG Miller got the
impression that MG Dunlavey, the previous Commander, had bypassed the chain of command
by raising issues directly with the Joint Chiefs of Staff and Department of Defense staff. MG
Miller told the Committee that GEN Hill authorized him to speak directly with the Joint Staff
and the Office ofthe Secretary of Defense, but that he told SOUTHCOM he would keep
SOUTHCOM informed ofthose communications.542
(U) MG Miller said that, while he was in Command at GTMO, he had direct discussions
with the DoD General Counsel's office and the Office of the Assistant Secretary of Defense for
Special Operations and Low Intensity Conflict (ASD SO/LIC).543 MG Miller also testifted to the
Army IG that he and Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz ''talked once a week when I
m Email from Chris Wirts to , Richard Driggers, Joseph Witsch, and Gary Percival
(October 29,2002) (hereinafter ..Email from Chris Wirts (October 29,2002).")
536 Email from Chris Wirts (October 29,2(02).
m ITF-170 and ITF-l60 were combined to form JIF-GTMO in October 2002; Memo from to
[Joint Stafl], GTMO Detainee (November 15, 2002).
m Committee staff interview of Chris Wirts (Januaty 4, 2008).
m See Section VII C, infra.
540 Army IG, Interview of MG Geoffrey Miller (October 20, 2005) at 5.
541 Committee staff interview of MG Geoffrey Miller (December 6, 2007).
542 Ibid.
543 Ibid.
73
was in Guantanamo.,,544 Lt Col Ted Moss, the ITF-GTMO ICE Chiefwho began his tour of
duty at GTMO in December 2002, said that Deputy Secretary Wolfowitz was in phone contact
with MG Miller "a 101.,,545 However, MG Miller told the Committee that he misspoke when he
testified to the Army IG and that, to the best of his knowledge, he did not speak to Deputy
Secretary Wolfowitz on the phone while he was at GTMO, but only briefed him quarterly, in
person, on GTMO operations.546
(U) Shortly after MG Miller arrived at GTMO, the Director for Intelligence (J-2) LTC
Phifer informed him ofthe October 11,2002 request 547 Although he later approved an
interrogation plan that included reference to Category III techniques, MG Miller told the Army
IG that he believed that the techniques in Category III and some techniques in Category II were
"overly aggressive" and that he had not intended to use them. 548 MG Miller said he had concerns
with stress positions, removal of clothing, and use of dogs, among other techniques.
Nevertheless, there is evidence that those techniques were used at GTMO while he was in
command. MG Miller told the Committee that he thought he discussed his concerns about the
techniques with LTC Beaver in early November before the Secretary approved their use, but that
he did not raise it with SOUfHCOM because he wanted to see which techniques would be
approved.549
(U) MG Miller told the Army IG that when he arrived at GTMO, there was significant
tension between JTF-GTMO, CITF, and FBI and that he sought to get all three organizations to
work in concert. 550 Despite MG Miller's stated intent, his decision to approve an interrogation
plan for Mohammed al Khatani that was opposed by the CITF and FBI, drove a deeper wedge
between his organization and both CITF and FBI.
(U) After their unsuccessful interrogation of Khatani in October 2002, JTF-GTMO staff
spent several weeks drafting an extensive new interrogation plan. The plan was the first "Special
Interrogation Plan" at GTMO and it would encounter strong resistance from both CITF and the
FBI. One FBI Special Agent told the Committee that he thought Khatani's interrogation would
defme the conduct of future interrogations at GTMO and therefore they "had to get it right.,,551
74
to have been finalized on November 22, 2002. Both drafts are discussed here because each
provides insight on the range of interrogation techniques considered by senior officials at
GTMO. In addition, there is evidence that both draft plans were approved by MG Miller.
Finally, there is evidence that techniques which were included in the "draft" circulated on
November 12,2002 but removed from the purported "final" plan, were nevertheless used during
Khatani's interrogation.
liThe next day, GTMO ICE Chief David Becker emailed the plan, which he referred to
as the "[l]atest approved by MG Miller," to a GTMO interrogator. 555 According to the plan, the
interrogation was scheduled to begin on November 15, 2002. 556 Mr. Becker told the Committee
that the plan was developed by his interrogators with input from him and LTC Phifer. 557 In
2005, MG Miller testified to the Army IG that he thought the plan circulated on November 12,
2002 was part of the fmal version ofthe plan that he approved. 558 However, in a subsequent
investigation, MG Miller identified a later version as the final plan. 559 He told the Committee
that he never approved the version ofthe plan circulated on November 12,2002.560 However,
contemporaneous documents indicate that others believed the plan circulated on November 12,
2002 had been approved by both MG Miller and SOUTHCOM and expected it to be
implemented on November 15,2002:
H7 Committee staff interview of David Becker (September 17, 2007). One FBI agent who was a member of the
FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit told the Committee that multiple versions of the plan were actually circulated at
GTMO during this period. Committee Staff interview of FBI Special Agent (November 8, 2007).
558 Army!G, Interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (October 20,2005) at 7.
559 Inge Report.
560 Committee staff interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (December 6, 2007).
75
II ( The November 12,2002 email from the Director for Intelligence LTC Phifer
to MG Miller stated, "[h]ere is the Interrogation Plan for ISN: 063 as approved by you.
Request you fwd to Gen Hill, info J2/J3/COS. We will begin at 0001 15 Nov per your
gUldance. 561
II The November 13,2002 email from the GTMO ICE Chief David Becker referred to
the November 12,2002 plan, which was attached to his email, as the "[l]atest approved
by MG Miller.,,562
_ A November 14,2002 email from the GTMO Staff Judge Advocate LTC
Diane Beaver to CITF lawyer stated, "[c]oncerning 63
[Khatani] my understanding is that NSC has weighed in and stated that intel on
this guy is utmost matter of national security... We are drivin forward with
support ofSOUTHCOM. Not sure anything else needs to be said." 64
_ A November 15,2002 staff memorandum for the J-2 ofthe Joint Staff stated that
"interrogators were preparing to interrogate [Khatani] beginning at 15 0001 November
2002 .. .'.565
.( According to the November 12, 2002 plan, the purpose ofthe interrogation
was to "break the detainee and establish his role in the attacks ofSept[ember] 11,2001.,.566 The
interrogation would be conducted for "20-hour sessions" and at the completion of each session,
Khatani would be permitted four hours of rest, and then "another 20 hour interrogation session
[would] begin.,,567
'61 Email from LTC Jerald Phifer to MG Geoffrey Miller (November 12, 2002) (emphasis added), attached as
exhibit 7 to the Inge Report.
'62 Email from David Becker to [Interrogation Control Element Staff Sergeant] (November 13, 2002).
'63 Notes of FBI Special Agent, Timeline Regarding Interrogation Plans/or Detainee #063, entry at "1111212002"
(emphasis added).
'64Email from LTC Diane Beaver to (November 14, 2002) (emphasis added). Then-National
Security Advisor Condoleezza Rice said that she was neither briefed on, nor did she review, the Khatani
interrogation plan. Similarly, then-NSC Legal Advisor John Bellinger said that, to the best of his recollection, he
too was neither briefed on, nor did he review the plan. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice and John Bellinger
answers to July 31,2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (September 12,2008).
'6' Memo from to [Joint Staff], GTMO Detainee (November 15, 2002)
(emphasis added).
'66 Interrogation Plan for I S N : _ t a n i ] (November 12, 2002).
'67 Ibid.
76
Prior to the fIrst interrogation, we would like to have the detainee's head and
beard shaved. This is to be done for both s cholo .cal and h iene purposes.
During the
interrogations the detainee will at times be placed in stress positions and
blindfolded. If necessary the detainee may have his mouth taped shut in order to
keep him from talking. Written approval for the tape and for the presence of dogs
will be submitted and obtained prior to implementation.569
II
The November 12, 2002 plan went on to describe four phases for the interrogation.570
During Phase I, interrogators would increase the pressure on Khatani while not permitting him to
speak, with the expectation that Khatani, when later presented with the opportunity to speak to
an interrogator, would "provide his whole story.,,571
II
Phase II of the plan was to lace a coo erative detainee or a native lin ist at Cam
X-Ra in full view of Khatani. 572
II Phase III of the plan, which was entitled "Level III techniques," was to utilize
techniques based on those used at SERE school. The plan slated:
The third phase of the plan to exploit 063 requires OSD approval for the SERE
interrogation technique training and approval of the level three counter
interrogation resistance training submitted by JTF-GTMO. Once the approvals
are in place, those interro ation techni ues will be im lemented to encoura e 063
to coo erate.
'68 Ibid.
'69 Ibid. A third draft of the plan which appears to have been produced after November 12 stated that "written
approval for use of gauze and for the presence of dogs have been approved by [MG Miller]" and was sent from an
attorney in the DoD General Counsel's office to an attorney at the Department of Justice's Office of Legal Counsel
in May 2003. January 31, 2008 SASC staff notes on Vaughn declaration documents.
'70 Interrogation Plan for ISN [Khatani] (November 12, 2002).
m Ibid.
mIbid.
m Ibid.
77
II The plan's final phase, Phase IV, was entitled "Coalition Exploitation" and stated
that:
The fourth phase ofthe plan to exploit 063 requires that he be sent off island either
temporarily or permanently to either [two specified third countries], or another country to
allow those countries to employ interrogation techniques that will enable them to obtain
the requisite information. 57
(U) On November 14,2002, CITF Commander COL Britt Mallow sent an email to MG
Miller raising concerns about both the Khatani interrogation and the October 11, 2002 request
for authority to use aggressive interrogation techniques. 575 He stated:
I strongly disagree with the use of many of the proposed [Category] 3 and some
[Category] 2 techniques. I feel they will be largely ineffective, and that they will
have serious negative material and legal effects on our investigations. I also am
extremely concerned that the use of many of these techniques will open any
military members up for potential criminal charges, and that my agents, as well as
other [military personnel] will face both legal and ethical problems if they become
aware oftheir use. 576
(U) COL Mallow told the Committee that in addition to his email, he raised concerns
about the Khatani interrogation in conversations with MG Miller and in "several meetings with
the DoD [General Counse1].,,577 COL Mallow said that MG Miller told him in a meeting that "if
[CITF] did not want to participate in interrogations with the intelligence community because of
our objections to methods, that [CITF] would not have the benefit of information resulting from
any ofthose interrogations.,,578 .
(U) MG Miller told the Committee that, while he did not recall the CITF Commander's
November 14, 2002 email specifically, he did recall communications from COL Mallow to that
effect. 579 DoD General Counsel Jim Haynes stated that he did not recall seeing a copy of the
Khatani interrogation plan at that time and did not "specifically" recall his staff advising him that
CITF and FBI had concerns with interrogation techniques in the Khatani interrogation plan. 580
m Ibid.
m Email from COL Britt Mallow to MG Geoffrey Miller (November 14, 2002).
"6 Ibid.
m Responses of COL (Ret.) Britt Mallow to questiomaire of Senator Carl Levin (September IS, 2006).
578 Ibid.
'79 Committee staff interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (December 6, 2007).
'so Committee staff interview of William 1. Haynes II (April 25, 2008) at 221, 228.
78
said that "the reliability of any information gained from aggressive techniques will be
highly questionable" and objected to all "physical stresses intended for use" in Phase III ofthe
interrogation plan. 581 also objected to Phase IV ofthe plan, stating that it implied
"that third country nationals with harsher interrogation standards could be used to convey threats
to persons of family or inflict harm contrary to the Convention Against Torture.,,582
(U) In his November 14,2002 email to MG Miller, COL Mallow proposed that ITF
GTMO and CITF develop a mutually acceptable interrogation plan for Khatani. 586 On
November 20,2002, FBI personnel, who were working closely with CITF, met with ITF-GTMO
staff to discuss developing such a plan 587
'81 Memo from for Major General Geoffrey Miller, Objection to Aggressive Interrogation
Techniques (November 15, 2002).
'82 Ibid.
'83 Memo from to J-2, Joint Staff, GTMO Detainee _ 0 6 3 . (November 15, 2002).
'84 Committee staff interview of MG Geoffrey Miller (December 6, 2007).
'8' Email from LTC Diane Beaver to (November 14, 2002) (emphasis added).
'86 Email from COL Britt Mallow to MG Geoffrey Miller (November 14, 2002).
'87 FBI memo to Major General Miller, VTC 21 November 2002 (undated).
'88 Committee staff interview of FBI Special agent (November 8, 2007).
79
.OnNovember 21,2002, MG Miller, LTC Phifer, and representatives from the FBI,
CITF, SOUTHCOM, and the DoD General Counsel's office all participated in a video
teleconference (VTC) to discuss the Khatani interrogation. 591
II
LTC Phifer told the Committee that he and MG Miller briefed the group on the
Khatani plan and that during the VTC, DoD Associate Deputy General Counsel for International
Affairs Eliana Davidson stated that the Department was comfortable with what ITF-GTMO had
planned. 592 MG Miller told the Committee that he did not recall the VTC. 593 Ms. Davidson said
that she recalled participating in VTCs where the Khatani interrogation was discussed, but she
did not recall if she had a copy of the interrogation plan itself and did not recall saying that the
~ fDefense was comfortable with what ITF-GTMO proposed for the interrogation. 594
- - - . the psychiatrist with the GTMO Behavioral Science Consultation Team, said that
in the context ofthe Khatani interrogation, ''we were routinely told that the interrogation strategy
was approved up to [the Secretary of Defense] level.,,595
(U) Subsequent to the VTC, the FBI sent a memo to MG Miller alerting him to FBI
"misgivings about the overall coercive nature and possible illegality" ofthe Khatani
interrogation plan and informing him that the FBI had presented ITF-GTMO staffwith "an
alternative interrogation approach based on long-term rapport building.,,596 A draft ofthat
alternative approach, which was the product of both the FBI and CITF, stated that Khatani's
negative interactions with interrogators "only reinforces Al-Qaeda stereotypes about evil
Americans and validates their expectation of harsh treatment and potential torture.,,597
(U) On November 22, 2002, Naval Criminal Investigative Service (NCIS) Chief
Psychologist Michael Gelles drafted a formal review of a ITF-GTMO draft plan. 598 Dr. Gelles
concluded that the interrogation plan "lack[ed] substantive and thoughtful consideration.,,599
Among other concerns, Dr. Gelles stated:
m Notes of FBI Special Agent, Timeline Regarding Interrogation Plansfor Detainee #063, entry at "11/21/2002."
m.Committee staff interview of LTC Jerry Phifer (June 27, 2007). Notes taken by an FBI Special Agent who
participated in the VIC indicate that, in briefIng the Defense HUMINT Service (DHS) plan, LTC Phifer
"portray[ed] the DHS Interrogation Plan to SOUTHCOM and the General Counsel at the Pentagon as a unifIed
FBIIDHS Interrogation Plan." The FBI Special Agent's notes state that the LTC Phifer characterization was "in
direct contradiction" to what the Special Agent had told Phifer the previous day. See notes of FBI Special Agent,
Timeline Regarding Interrogation Plansfor Detainee #063, entry at "11/21/2002."
'93 Committee staff interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (December 6,2007).
80
Strategies articulated in the later phases reflect techniques used to train US forces
in resisting interrogation by foreign enemies... [These techniques] would prove
not only to be ineffective but also border on techniques and strategies deemed
unacceptable by law enforcement professionals... 600
(U) Dr. Gelles noted that '"the choice to use force with this adversary in an interrogation
may only reinforce his resistance" and stated that ifthe plan were implemented he would "have
trouble not finding myself from a professional perspective, being forced into an adversary
position through cross examination in a military tribunal as an expert in interrogation.,,601
(U) Notwithstanding the CITF and FBI concerns, MG Miller authorized interrogators to
proceed with the Khatani interrogation beginning November 23, 2002.
( II MG Miller identified a version ofthe Khatani plan that had been written on
November 22, 2002 as the "final" plan that he authorized to be implemented on November 23,
2002. 602 While similar to the plan circulated on November 12,2002, the November 22,2002
plan contained notable differences from the earlier version that contemporaneous documents
indicated had also been approved.
_ ( Although there is evidence that both stress positions and dogs were
used in the Khatani interrogation, the November 22,2002 plan does not mention either ofthese
two techniques. 603 MG Miller said the stress positions and use of dogs were removed from the
plan at his direction. 604
III( With respect to dogs, MG Miller said that neither LTC Phifer, nor LTC
Beaver objected to the use of dogs and that his ICE Chief, Mr. Becker, actually favored the use
of dogs in interrogations. 605 MG Miller said, however, that he only approved the use of dogs for
security around the perimeter of Camp X-Ray, where the interrogation was to take place, and
that he made that view absolutely clear to Mr. Becker. CAPT Jane Dalton, the Legal Counsel to
the Chairman ofthe Joint Chiefs of Staff said, however, that she met with MG Miller in early
November and discussed the use of dogs for interrogation purposes. 606 She said that the "theory
was that certain individuals are afraid of dogs" and that, while MG Miller talked about dogs
600 Ibid.
601 Ibid.
601 Inge RePort at 9.
603Interrogation Plan for ISN: [Khatani] (November 22,2002) (hereinafter "Khatani interrogation
plan (November 22, 2002).").
604 Committee staff interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (December 6, 2007).
605 Ibid.
606 Committee staff interview of RADM Jane Dalton (April 10, 2008) at 84.
being outside the interrogation room, they discussed the purpose of the dogs' presence during
interrogations was that it "exploits [the detainee's] fear.,,607
( II Mr. Becker told the Committee that MG Miller told him to remove dogs
from the plan. Nevertheless, a document describing interrogation techniques used in the
Khatani interrogation and a witness account (both discussed below) suggest that dogs were used
during the interrogation to shock and agitate Khatani. 609
II( With respect to stress positions, Mr. Becker told the Committee that,
notwithstanding the fact that they were included in the earlier plan, there was never an intent to
use stress positions with Khatani. 610 A document that appears to have been produced during the
Khatani interrogation, however, stated that stress positions would "be employed.,,611 In addition,
a 2005 memo from the ITF-GTMO Chief of Staff referencing the 2002 interrogation stated that
Khatani had "slight abrasions caused by stress positions and shackle restraints.,,612
II ( The November 22, 2002 plan identified by MG Miller as the final plan
described five phases to the interrogation. 613 Phase I, which was added after November 12,
called for the interrogators to "Induce and exploit Stockholm Syndrome" by establishing "an
isolated, austere environment where the detainee becomes completely dependent on the
interrogators and the interrogator presents himself as a 'caretaker' of the detainee.,,614 Dr. Gelles
.said that the idea of inducing the Stockholm syndrome implied that '<the subject feels that he is to
be killed and the infonnation provided may in fact be distorted.,,61s
II( Phase II ofthe November 22, 2002 plan (which is largely the same as Phase
I of the earlier plan) stated that prior to the start of the first Phase II interrogation session,
Khatani's head and beard would be shaved for "safety, hygiene and psychological purposes.,,616
In addition, the plan stated that MG Miller had approved the use of hospital gauze to restrain the
detainee's mouth to prevent him from becoming argumentative and verbally abusive.
6111 Ibid.
608 Committee staff interview of David Becker (September 17,2007).
~,MethodsEmployed X-Ray Interrogation ISN 63(S) (January 17,2003). Army IG, Interview of
_ ( A p r i l 28, 2006).
610 Committee staff interview of David Becker (September 17, 2007).
611 Memo, 063 Plan ofAttack: Phase I Bravo (undated).
612 Memo from COL John ~f Staff, USSOUTHCOM, Executive Summary on Information
Concerning Detainee ISN:~(Ilj (March 14, 2005).
613 Khatani interrogation plan (November 22, 2002).
Khatani interrogation plan (November 22, 2002). The Stockholm Syndrome refers to a psychological event
614
where hostages begin to identify with and grow sympathetic to their captors. The syndrome draws its name from a
bank robbery and hostage situation in Stockholm, Sweden in 1973.
615 Review ofJI'F-GTMO Interrogation Plan Detainee 063 (November 22, 2002).
616 Khatani interrogation plan (November 22, 2002).
82
Phase III ofthe November 22,2002 plan was largely the same as Phase II of
the earlier plan and proposed having a native linguist translator play the role of a detainee to
elicit information from Khatani. 617
The fourth phase of the plan to exploit 063 [Khatani] requires [Office of the
Secretary of Defense] approval for the SERE interrogation technique training and
approval of the level three counter interrogation resistance training submitted by
ITF-GTMO. Once the approvals are in place, those interrogation techniques will
be implemented to encourage 063 to cooperate. The intent of raising the stakes to
this level is to convince 063 that it is futile to resist. Success of Phase III is when
his sense of futility is raised to a high enough level that source gives in and
provides the necessary information. Phase III ends with success or a standstill,
after the exhaustion of all tools ITF GTMO has to offer. 618
II Despite having approved the plan, MG Miller testified to the Army IG that he knew
"little about SERE" and "wasn't comfortable" with SERE techniques. 619 However, MG Miller
acknowledged to the Committee that these techniques were included in the approved plan and
that, if the fIrst three phases of the Khatani plan were unsuccessful, that he was willing to
consider the use of SERE techniques. 620
liThe plan's final phase, Phase V, maintained the same title "Coalition Exploitation" as
Phase IV ofthe earlier plan but did not explicitly state an intention to render Khatani to a third
country, as did the earlier plan. 621 Instead, under "Coalition Exploitation" the November 22,
2002 plan stated that:
The fifth phase of the plan to exploit 063 will be determined at the national,
interagency level where the future disposition of 063 will be determined. 622
617Interrogation Plan for ISN: [Khatani] (November 15, 2002) (hereinafter "Khatani interrogation
plan (November 15, 2002)"); Khatani interrogation plan (November 22,2002).
618 Khatani interrogation plan (November 22, 2002).
619 Army IG, Interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (March 26,2006).
620 Committee staff interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (December 6, 2007).
621 Khatani interrogation plan (November 22,2002).
621 Ibid.
623 Committee staff interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (December 6,2007).
:<
(U) On November 22, 2002 the FBI sent MG Miller a memo that outlined FBI's
continuing concerns about ITF-GTMO interrogation techniques. The FBI also requested a
(U) The memo stated further that the "FBI/CITF strongly believes that the continued use
of diametrically opposed interrogation strategies in GTMO will only weaken our efforts to obtain
valuable infonnation. ,,630
(U) In late November, FBI agents at GTMO asked that their concerns about ITF-GTMO
interrogation techniques be relayed to Marion "Spike" Bowman, a senior attorney in the FBI's
Office of General Counsel. 631 Mr. Bowman said that "[a]s soon as I heard from the [the FBI
agents] I talked with (now retired) Executive Assistant Director Pat D'Amuro who immediately
said we (the FBI) would not be a party to actions of any kind that were contrary to FBI policy
and that individuals should distance themselves from any such actions.,,632 Mr. Bowman also
recommended to FBI General Counsel Kenneth Wainstein that FBI relay the concerns to the
DoD General Counsel's office. Mr. Bowman subsequently called the acting DoD Deputy
General Counsel for Intelligence and believes he also spoke with the DoD Principal Deputy
624 Ibid.
625 See Section VB 5, irifra.
626 Khatani interrogation plan (November 22,2002).
627 Ibid.; Committee staff interview of MG Geoffrey Miller (December 6,2007).
628 FBI Memorandum to JTF-170 Commander MG Geoffrey Miller (November 22, 2002). Despite the heading on
the memorandum, JTF-GTMO had replaced JTF-170 by the time this memo was written.
629 Ibid.
630 Ibid.
631 Committee staff interview of FBI Special Agent (November 8,2007).
632 Responses of Marion Bowman to questionnaire of Senator Carl Levin (August 7, .2006).
COMPLAINT
Page 186
Page
of 2413
187 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
General Counsel. DoD General Counsel Jim Ha;res said that he did not recall being aware that
the FBI had contacted his office with concerns. 63
(U) On December 2, 2002, an FBI Special Agent, who was also an attorney, sent his own
legal analysis of the October 11,2002 GTMO request to another Special Agent for forwarding to
Mr. Bowman. 634 The FBI Special Agent referred to several techniques - such as all the Category
III techniques and several Category II techniques, including stress positions, hooding, removal of
clothing, 20 hour interrogations, and use of individual phobias (such as fear of dogs) to induce
stress - as "coercive interrogation techniques which are not permitted by the U.S.
Constitution.,,635 The Special Agent's analysis also identified several techniques - including all
Category III techniques and two Category II techniques, Le. hooding and use of phobias - as
"examples of coercive interrogation techniques which may violate 18 U.S.C. 2340, (Torture
Statute)" and warned that "it is possible that those who employ these techniques may be indicted,
prosecuted, and possibly convicted if the trier of fact determines that the user had the requisite
intent.,,636
(U) The following day, Mr. Bowman sent an email to another FBI Special Agent, stating
"[i]t is irrelevant whether these detainees are considered prisoners of war, they are still entitled to
minimal conditions of treatment - many ofthe techniques addressed appear to move well beyond
the minimal requirements ... I concur that we can't control what the military is doing, but we
need to stand well clear of it and get as much information as possible to D' Amuro, Gebhart, and
Mueller as soon as possible.,,637 Director Mueller said that he was not aware of the FBI's
concerns with DoD interrogation techniques at GTMO until May 2004. 638
633 Committee staff interview ofWilliam J. Haynes II (April 25, 2008) at 236.
635 FBI Memo, Legal IssuesRe Interrogation Techniques, attached to Email from FBI Special ABent (December 2,
2002).
636 Ibid.
637 Email from Marion Bowman (December 3,2002).
638 Current and Projected National Security Threats to the United States, Senate Select Committee on Intelligence,
85
(U) CITF Deputy Commander Mark Fallon said that FBI proposed to CITF the idea of
rendering Khatani to a third country but that CITF "considered it possibly unlawful" and
opposed the proposal. 649 He said CITF staff made Mr. Cobb aware oftheir concerns and that
Mr. Cobb supported the CITF position.
86
(U) The same day the VTC took place, FBI's on-site supervisor and two Special Agents
met with MG Miller where they again raised their concerns about JTF-GTMO interrogation
techniques. 650 One FBI Special Agent told the Committee that MG Miller thanked the FBI
personnel for their views, but told them that JTF-GTMO staffknew what they were doing. 651
(U) On December 9, 2002, another FBI Special Agent who attended the meeting sent an
email stating, "when I return to D.C., I will bring a copy ofthe military's interview plan [for
Khatani] ... You won't believe it!,,652 Several months later he characterized the December 5,
2002 meeting with MG Miller:
_ JTF-GTMO ICE Chief David Becker told the Committee that MG Miller asked him
at one point why the JTF was not using the FBI's approach, to which Mr. Becker replied that the
JTF had already tried the FBI approach, that it did not work., and that he wanted to be more
aggressive. 654
(U) On November 23, 2002, ITF-GTMO personnel took Khatani to Camp X-Ray to
begin Phase I ofthe interrogation. 655 Two days later, CITF attorney sent the
GTMO Staff Judge Advocate, LTC Diane Beaver, an email indicating that "CITF is not on board
with aggressive techniques including 20 hour [plus] interrogations. Therefore, according to our
policy, we will 'stand clear' and not offer participation, advisements, support or
recommendations as to its implementation,,656 CITF later drafted formal guidance for its agents
stating that "Detainees will be treated humanely. Physical torture, corporal punishment and
mental torture are not acceptable interrogation tactics and are not allowed under any
circumstances... CITF personnel will not participate in any interrogation that employs tactics
inconsistent with or in direct violation ofthis pOlicy.,,657
(U) Khatani was interrogated from November 23,2002 through January 16,2003.662 In
June 2004, SOUTHCOM Commander GEN Hill, described the origin of some ofthe
interrogation techniques used in the interrogation:
88
II ( MG Miller told the Committee that he informed his Director for Intelligence,
LTC Phifer, that he opposed the forced removal of clothing as an interrogation technique
and in a 2004 sworn statement stated that "to the best of my knowledge JTF-GTMO
never used [removal of clothing]" during the six week period in late 2002 early 2003
when it was authorized. 669
LTC Phifer and his replacement, COL Richard Sanders (who was given the title of Joint
Intelligence Group (JIG) Commander) told the Committee that they were not aware that
Khatani was strip searched. 670
Both Mr. Becker, the ICE Chief present for the development ofthe Khatani plan, and his
successor Lt Col Ted Moss, who assumed the position when the interrogation was
already underway, told the Committee that they were unaware of Khatani being stripped
at the direction or suggestion of interrogation personnel. 671
the Chief of the Psychological Applications Directorate (pAD) at the u.s. Army's Special Operations Command
(USASOC).
Testimony of Joseph Witsch (September 4, 2007) at '22; Level C Peacetime Governmental Detention Survival
666
JPRA Instructor Guide, Exploitation: Threats and Pressures, Module 6.0, Lesson 6.1, para 5.3.3 (Version GOl.l).
669Committee staff interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (December 6,2007); Sworn Statement ofMG Geoffrey Miller
89
_ ( The January 17,2003 memo stated that Khatani's head and beard
were shaved "for hygienic purposes and to assert control over the detainee," that Khatani's hands
were shackled to a chair to prevent him from praying, and that pra~er was denied in
circumstances where prayer was ''used as a resistance technique." 72 The memo stated that up to
eight ounces of water was poured over Khatani's head as a "method of asserting control" when
Khatani exhibited ''undesired behavior.,,673 And it said Khatani was forced to "sit, stand, lay
down, walk or other non-stress position activities by guards to enforce the control ofthe
interrogator.,,674 MAJ Burney said that Khatani was "made to stand for several hours at a time or
sit on a hard chair for several hours at a time. 675 The January 17, 2003 memo also stated that
Khatani was ridiculed and berated ''to elicit an adversarial response.,,676
_ The memo stated that "K-9 units [were] present during interrogation but
outside of booth to provide barking in order to agitate the detainee and provide shock value. ,,678
One interrogator who participated in the Khatani interrogation told the Committee
that he understood that dogs could be used in a manner consistent with the description in the
January 17, 2003 memo, i.e. they could be present during interrogation but outside the booth in
order to agitate Khatani and provide shock value. 679 The interrogator told the Committee that
during one of his shifts interrogating Khatani, an MP brought a dog to the outside ofthe room in
which the interrogation was taking place and that the MP got the dog to bark. 680 The interrogator
said that he did not ask the MP to do so and told the MP not to do it again.
(U) MAJ Burney, who was present for portions ofthe interrogation, testified to the Army
IG that a dog was brought into the Khatani interrogation during late November or early
December an estimated "half dozen times.,,681 MAJ Burney testified:
90
[The] dog was never allowed to bite the detainee but would be ordered to bark
loudly close to the detainee, to sort of sniff or muzzle the detainee, to put paws up
on the detainee. 682
(U) MAl Burney said that interrogators stopped using the dog "not because anybody had
necessarily objected to [the use ofthe dog]," but because ''the initial shock value had worn off"
and "it just wasn't felt to be effective anymore.,,683 None ofthe other witnesses interviewed by
the Committee stated that they were aware of a dog being brought into the interrogation booth.
who was present for portions of the interrogation, stated that at one point
during an in~, either a guard or an interrogator suggested that a dog be used to scare
Khatani. 684 _ s a i d that he informed Mr. Becker, who intervened before the dogs were
used. 685
(U) As discussed above, MG Miller told the Committee that dogs were present at Camp
X-Ray solely for securing the perimeter and that he was absolutely clear with ICE Chief David
Becker that dogs were not to be used in interrogations. 686 He testified to the Army IG that he
"rejected [using dogs in interrogations] as an acceptable technique" and that dogs "were not to be
used during active interrogation. ,,687 In written answers to questions posed by Vice Admiral
Church, however, the Director for Intelligence, LTC Phifer stated that dogs were used in the
Khatani interrogation and that "We would bring the dog around to within 10 feet [of Khatani]
and he would be somewhat unnerved by it. We did it to keep him off balance as well as to
enhance security.,,688 Despite the testimony ofthe BSCT psychiatrist and LTC Phifer, Mr.
Becker stated that the Commander "refused to allow dogs" in interrogations while he was in
command of ITF-GTMO and told the Committee that dogs were not at the Khatani
interrogation. 689
682 Ibid.
683 Ibid.
684 Committee staff interview of (August 13, 2007).
68~ Ibid.
686 Committee staff interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (December 5, 2007).
688LTC Jerry Phifer written answers to Church Report Questionnaire (July 16, 2004). It is not clear from those
written answers whether the Director for Intelligence [Phifer] was referring to the use of dogs in the interrogation of
Khatani that began in November or the interrogation that took place in October 2003. See section B supra.
689 Army IG, Interview of David Becker (September 20, 2005) at 31.
690 Email from Christopher Wirts to Joe Witsch, Gary Percival, and Terry Russell (November 12, 2002).
91
_ The training session also included a demonstration of physical pressures. 698 This
was in accordance with the requirement, approved b~ JFCOM and Joint Staff, for "practical
exercise[s] in interrogation and physical pressures." 99 Mr. Witsch recalled that he "participated
in a couple ofthose demonstrations," which included role play sessions, where JPRA personnel
demonstrated the SERE physical pressur~ck interrogation[s].,,7oo Another JPRA
instructor, Terrence Russell, recalled t h a t ' " rather than JPRA, led the demonstration of
physical pressures. 701
692 Ibid.
693 Joint Staff Action Processing Form (November 12, 2002).
694 Email from Christopher Wirts to Joe Witsch, Gary Percival, and Terry Russell (November 12,2002).
69' Committee staff interview of Christopher Wirts (January 4, 2008).
696 Ibid.
697 Testimony of Joseph Witsch (September 6,2007) at 37.
698 Testimony of Terrence Russell (August 3, 2007) at 85.
699 Ibid.
700 Testimony of Joseph Witsch (September 6,2007) at 38.
701 Testimony of Terrence Russell (August 3,2007) at 85.
92
was em~hasized in bold and in all capital letters in the Navy SERE school's instruction
manual. 11
(U) On November 27, 2002, Mr. Haynes sent a memo to Secretary of Defense Donald
Rumsfeld recommending that the Secretary authorize the Commander of SOUTHCOM to
employ, at his discretion, all Category I and II techniques and one Category III technique (''use
of mild, non-injurious physical contact such as grabbing, poking in the chest with the finger, and
light pushing") in the JTF-GTMO October 11,2002 request. 717
(U) Mr. Haynes's memo stated that he had discussed the issue with Deputy Secretary of
Defense Paul Wolfowitz, Undersecretary of Defense for Policy Doug Feith, and Chairman ofthe
Joint Chiefs of Staff (CJCS) General Richard Myers and that they concurred with his
recommendation 718 According to Mr. Haynes, his recommendation came after the Secretary of
Defense expressed "some exasperation that he didn't have a recommendation" on the October
11,2002 GTMO request and told his senior advisors "I need a recommendation.,,719
711 Ibid.
71l Testimony of Terrence Russell (August 3. 2007) at 87-88.
713 Ibid.
714 Ibid.
m Ibid.
716 Ibid.
Action Memorandum from William J. Haynes II to Secretary of Defense, Counter-Resistance Techniques.
717
(November 27, 2002), approved by the Secretary of Defense on December 2, 2002 (hereinafter "Secretary of
Defense Approval of Counter-Resistance Techniques (December 2, 2(02)").
718 Secretary of Defense Approval of Counter-Resistance Techniques (December 2,2002).
719 Committee interview of William J. Haynes II (April 25, 2008) at 193; SASC Hearing (June 17,2(08).
94
(U) Mr. Haynes's memo concluded that while "all Category III techniques may be legally
available, we believe that a blanket approval of Category III techniques is not warranted at this
time.,,720 While the CJCS, General Myers, said that he "did not recall seeing the November 27,
2002 memo before it was presented to the Secretary," his Legal Counsel, CAPT Dalton, said that
she and the Chairman were "satisfied with" the techniques that were recommended to the
Secretary for approval. 721 CAPT Dalton also said, however, that she did not think the statement
in the DoD General Counsel's memo that "all Category III techniques may be legally available"
''was an appropriate legal analysis.,,722 She did not raise that concern with the Chairman. 723
(U) Mr. Haynes stated that he "probably" read LTC Beaver's legal analysis ofthe request
prior to making his recommendation but that he could not recall his opinion of it. 724 He could
not recall whether he asked anyone on his staffto review or comment on the analysis or whether
his office conducted its own legal review. 725
(U) As discussed above, General HilI, the SOUTHCOM Commander, had requested in
his October 25,2002 memorandum that Department of Justice and Department of Defense
lawyers review Category III techniques included in the October 11, 2002 GTMO request. 726
While the Department of Justice's Office of Legal Counsel (OLe) had issued an opinion on
August 1,2002 evaluating standards of conduct for interrogations required under the anti-torture
statute, Mr. Haynes testified in July 2006 that he "did not have a copy" ofthat opinion and that
the OLC "had not expressed a view [to him] at that time. 727 In April 2008, however, Mr. Haynes
stated that it was "very, very likely" that he had read the OLC opinion prior to making his
recommendation to the Secretary and recalled it being "very permissive.,,728 Two months later,
in June 2008, Mr. Haynes testified that he did not "remember when he ftrst read" the OLC
memo. 729 The General Counsel said that he did not know whether anyone in his office consulted
the Department of Justice about the October 11, 2002 GTMO request and he did not believe OOJ
reviewed the techniques "in the context of [the GTMO] request." 730
(U) Other than his November 27, 2002 memo to Secretary Rumsfeld recommending that
the techniques be approved, Mr. Haynes said that he "did not write anything down" to support
95
his legal analysis. 731 GTMO Staff Judge Advocate Diane Beaver stated that she "fully expected"
that her legal review would be 'carefully reviewed by legal and policy experts at the highest
levels before a decision was reached" and was "shocked" that her opinion became the opinion
upon which the Department of Defense relied. 732 LTC Beaver stated that she did not expect that
her opinion "would become the final word on interrogation policies and practices within the
Department of Defense" and that for her "such a result was simply not foreseeable." 733 She
stated that she "did not expect to be the only lawyer issuing a written opinion on this
monumentally important issue" and that in hindsight, could not "help but conclude that others
chose not to write on this issue to avoid being linked to it.,,734
(U) Despite the fact that his memo recommended the Secretary of Defense authorize the
use of aggressive interrogation techniques including stress positions, deprivation of light and
auditory stimuli, hooding, removal of clothing, the use of dogs to induce stress, and pushing and
poking detainees, Mr. Haynes stated that he was not recommending blanket approval of other
aggressive techniques in the GTMO request (like the use of a wet towel and dripping water to
induce the misperception of drowning) because "Our Anned Forces are trained to a standard of
interrogation that reflects a tradition of restraint."735
(U) While several techniques included in the request were similar to techniques used in
SERE training and provided by JPRA to the General Counsel's office in the July 26,2002
memo, Mr. Haynes said that he did not "specifically recall" making a connection between the
request and SERE. 736 In comments submitted to the DoD IG's August 25,2006 report, the DoD
General Counsel's office even stated that "There is no evidence that SERE techniques were ever
adopted at Guantanamo or anywhere else.,,737 Those comments were submitted two years after
the SOUfHCOM Commander, General Hill, had said that ''the staff at Guantanamo" had
traveled to "SERE school," where they "developed a list of techniques ..." and despite the fact
that some ofthe techniques in the October 11,2002 GTMO request were specifically identified
as ''those used in U.S. military interrogation resistance training.,,738
(U) Mr. Haynes said that he raised legal concerns about the October 11, 2002 GTMO
request with the Secretary prior to making his recommendation. 739 On December 2, 2002,
however, Secretary Rumsfeld approved Mr. Haynes's recommendation that SOUfHCOM be
96
given authority to use all Categories I and II techniques and one Category III technique in
interrogations at GTMO. 740 In approving the techniques, the Secretary added a handwritten note
at the bottom of the memo that questioned one of the limitations in the ITF-GTMO request, 741
In reference to ''the use of stress positions (like standing) for a maximum of four hours," the
Secretary wrote: "However, I stand for 8-10 hours a day. Why is standing limited to 4 hours?,,742
Despite having previously approved the Khatani plan, which included a phase to
employ Category III techniques, MG Geoffrey Miller told the Committee that shortly after the
authorization was issued, he told the SOUTHCOM Commander that he did not intend to use the
Category III techniques at GTMO. 743
III ( On December 14, 2002,just prior to a staff meeting, GTMO's Director for
Intelligence, LTC Phifer, gave Mr. James, the CITF Special Agent in Charge, a document
entitled "JTF-GTMO 'SERE' Interrogation Standard Operating Procedure" and asked for his
comments on the document. 745 The techniques described in the draft SOP, such as stress
positions, non-injurious physical contact, removal of clothing, and hooding, had all been
authorized by the Secretary of Defense on December 2, 2002. 746
97
... Note that all tactics are strictly intended to be non-lethal. 748
(D) The December 18, 2002 draft stated that "interrogators will undergo training by
certified SERE instructors prior to being approved for use of any of the techniques described in
this document" and stated that the draft SOP was "applicable to military and civilian
interrogators assigned to Joint Task Force Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.,,749
(U) In addition, the December 18, 2002 draft included a section describing "interrogation
control and safety" that listed safeguards to "avoid injuries to the detainee, especially his head
and/or neck" and stated that a "corpsman or medic should be onsite, and a doctor on-call should
medical care be necessary.,,750 The December 18,2002 draft was unsigned but contained
signature blocks for the JTF-GTMO's new ICE Chief, Lt Col Moss, the new JIG Commander,
COL Sanders, and the JTF-GTMO Commander, MG Miller.
II( Under "Degradation Tactics" the draft SOPs described the "shoulder slap,"
the "insult slap," the "stomach slap," and "stripfting," all of which were included in the Secretary
of Defense's December 2, 2002 authorization. 7 1
( Regarding the shoulder slap, John Rankin, a Navy SERE Training Specialist
who reviewed the draft SOPs at the time, noted that the SOPs' description of the shoulder slap
differed from the technique as applied at the Navy SERE school. 752 The Navy instruction
manual described the shoulder slap ,,753
However, the draft GTMO SOPs described the shoulder slap as
,754
( The draft SOPs described how to administer "insult slap[s]" and "stomach
slap[s]" to "shock and intimidate the detainee."m The draft SOPs explained that the use of
"stripping" involved the "forceful removal of detainees' c1othing.,,756 The drafts also stated that
748 JTF-GTMO SERE SOP (undated); JTF-GTMO SERE SOP (December 18, 2002).
754 JTF-GTMO SERE SOP (undated); JTF-GTMO SERE SOP (December 18, 2002).
755 JTF-GTMO SERE SOP (undated); JTF-GTMO SERE SOP (December 18, 2002).
756 Ibid.
98
"[i]n addition to degradation of the detainee, stripping can be used to demonstrate the
omnipotence of the captor or to debilitate the detainee.,,757
(l1li Under "Physical Debilitation Tactics" th~ draft SOPs described various
stress positions and said the purpose of using them was to" unish detainees."758 Among the
stress ositions listed was the "kneelin osition,'
(U) In an email sent shortly after the December 14, 2002 staff meeting where LTC Phifer
provided him the draft SOP, CITF Special Agent in Charge Timothy James said that LTC Phifer
briefed MG Miller and his staff on the draft SOP at the meeting. 764
Several senior GTMO staff reviewed drafts ofthe GTMO SERE SOP. On December
14, LTC Beaver sent an email to LTC Phifer, U Col Moss (the newly arrived ICE Chief) and
members ofthe GTMO Behavioral Science Consultation Team (BSCT) proposing changes to the
draft SERE SOP. 765 LTC Beaver recommended:
[S]trictly prohibiting use of force to the head such as when detainee looks away.
Pressure to head and neck must be avoided. Guiding chin up with two fmgers for
example or using other techniques to make detainee comply. This would avoid
inadvertent injury... We can gain some control with use of pressure to shoulder
and arms or upper body and less charge of injury to face, neck or head. 766
7'7 Ibid.
7'8 Ibid.
7'9 Ibid.
760 Ibid.
761 Ibid.
762 Ibid.
763 Ibid.
764 Email from Timothy James to Mark Fallon et al (December 17, 2002).
76~ Email from LTC Diane Beaver to Lt Col Ted Moss and LTC Jerald Phifer (December 14, 2002).
766 Ibid.
(U) LTC Beaver later testified to the Committee that she might have recalled seeing a
SERE SOP at the time but that she "had nothing to do" with drafting the December 18, 2002
version of the SOP and did not participate at all in drafting it. 767
The environment down here is much different than at SERE school. There is not
a cadre of experienced SERE instructors. The interrogators have not gone
through SERE school or been subjected to this treatment themselves. There is not
a psychiatric screening process in place. The interrogators are away from home,
family, friends and are under a lot more stress than SERE instructors at the SERE
school. The detainees being questioned are the enemy and are not U.S. personnel
posing as the enemy... All these factors make using this kind of pressure much
more dangerous in this environment compared to at the SERE school. 771
_As
to the utility ofthe SERE resistance techniques, MAJ Burney also stated that "[i]t
is quite possible that employing these techniques exactly as employed in SERE school may
actually strengthen a detainee's ability to resist interrogation rather than overcome it."772 MAJ
Burney stated that he was "not suggesting that the use of physical pressures should be totally
abandoned," but recommended that they should bring an experienced senior SERE trainer to
GTMO to discuss the issue stating "the interrogation element feels these tools will greatly assist
the interrogations process. It would be very interesting to me to know if senior SERE trainers...
agree with this assessment or not."773 MAJ Burney also recommended that, if IfF-GTMO
determined the techniques might be effective, then they should institute the same screening
processes that SERE schools use and that SERE school instructors be "sent to GTMO to help
with the interrogation process.,,774
100
(U) Mr. Becker, the ICE Chiefwho left GTMO in December 2002, told the Committee
that prior to his departure he had begun drafting the SOP and had discussed it with LTC
Phifer. 775
(U) As discussed above, contemporaneous documents suggest that LTC Phifer gave a
copy ofthe draft SERE SOP to Timothy James, the CITF Special Agent in Charge, and briefed
the draft to a JTF-GTMO staff meeting. 776 LTC Phifer was also a recipient ofthe December 14,
2002 email from LTC Beaver that proposed changes to the draft SERE SOP.777 However, LTC
Phifer testified to the Army IG that he had "never heard of [the SOP] or saw [the SOP]."778 He
later told the Committee that he did not recall the SOP or the December 14, 2002 staff meeting
and said that he would not have been comfortable briefing the SOP. 779
(U) LTC Phifer was replaced on or about December 17, 2002 by COL Richard Sanders,
who was given the title of Joint Intelligence Group (nG) Commander. 780 COL Sanders, whose
signature block was included on the December 18, 2002 draft SERE SOP, did not recall seeing
the SOP, but said he vaguely recalled discussions about it. 781 Lt Col Moss, the new ICE Chief
whose signature block was also on the draft SERE SOP, told the Committee that he recalled the
draft SOP but that he never signed it. 782
(U) LTC Beaver told the Committee that she did not know who directed the development
ofthe SOP and could not recall whether she discussed it with MG Miller. 783 MAJ Burney told
the Committee that he recalled being provided a copy ofthe Navy SERE school's SOP but did
not recall seeing a document drafted by GTMO personnel. 784
IIDespite having approved an interrogation plan that included SERE techniques and
telling the Committee that, in the context ofthe Khatani interrogation, he was "willing to
consider" SERE tactics, MG Miller testified to the Army IG that the techniques in the SOP
''were too aggressive and not appropriate for use [at GTMO].,,785
(U) While a contemporaneous document suggests that LTC Phifer briefed MG Miller on
the SOP, MG Miller told the Army IG that the SOP was never brought to his attention and that
716 Email from Timothy James to Mark Fallon et a!. (December 17, 2002).
TrTEmail from LTC Diane Beaver to Lt Col Ted Moss and LTC Jerald Phifer (December 14, 2002).
m Army!G, Interview of LTC Jerald Phifer (March 16,2006) at 9.
T79 Committee staff interview of LTC Jerald Phifer (June 27, 2007).
7llO Ibid.
781 Committee staff interview of COL Richard Sanders (August 10, 2007).
782 Committee staff interview of LTC Ted Moss (October 17, 2007).
783 Committee staff interview of LTC Diane Beaver (November 9, 2007).
784 Committee staff interview of MAl Paul Burney (August 21, 2007).
Army !G, Interview of MG Geoffrey Miller (March 28, 2006); Committee staff interview of MG Geoffrey Miller
785
(December 5,2007).
101
he had no knowledge of it. 786 MG Miller later told the Committee that he did not recall being
briefed on the draft SOP. 787 As noted above, he also told the Committee that he opposed stress
positions, removal of clothing, and the use of non-injurious physical contact - all techniques
described in the draft SERE SOP - and that he had made his opposition clear to his staff prior to
the time that the SOPs were drafted. 788
(U) In response to LTC Phifer's request for comments on the draft SERE SOP, CITF
raised concerns about the SOP verbally to LTC Phifer and drafted written comments about the
SOP. 789 A draft ofCITF's written comments (which they coordinated with FBI) was addressed
to LTC Phifer and stated:
[There is a] fundamental difference between the military and [CITF and FBI]
regarding which style of interrogation should be used... the military model is
based on SERE tactics ...This school teaches coercion and aggressive
interrogation techniques as a way to "break" soldiers who are being trained in
methods to resist interrogation by a foreign power... [CITF and FBI~ believe
these techniques discourage, rather than encourage, detainee cooperation. 90
(U) CITF and FBI also argued that the use ofthe methods "only serves to reinforce" the
negative perception ofthe detainees toward Americans and would create "real potential for
mistreatment" of detainees. 791 CITF and FBI called the SERE techniques "unsuitable" and
"ineffective" and said there were "serious concerns about the legal implications ofthe
techniques.,,792
(U) On December 18, 2002, CITF Special Agent in Charge Timothy James sent an email
to Mr. Fallon stating "at this moment the ITF-GTMO staff is working the SOP issue, and [MG
Miller] will most likely make a decision in the next day or SO.,,793
(U) Individuals interviewed by the Committee stated that the SOP was never signed or
implemented at GTMO. 794 Less than two weeks after the December 18, 2002 draft SERE SOP
Email from CITF Special Agent in Charge (December 18, 2002); Army IG, Interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller
186
102
was written, however, two instructors from the Navy SERE school traveled to GTMO to train
interrogators on how to perform some ofthe physical pressures authorized by the Secretary of
Defense and contained in the draft SERE SOPs.
(U) On December 30, 2002, a SERE Training Specialist, John Rankin, and a SERE
Coordinator, Christopher Ross from the Navy SERE school in Brunswick, Maine arrived at
GTMOto "provide [ITF-GTMO Interrogation Control Element] personnel with the theory and
application ofthe physical pressures utilized during [Navy SERE school] training evolutions.,,795
U Col Moss told the Committee that his predecessor, Mr. Becker, had invited the SERE school
trainers to GTMo. 796 MG Miller told the Committee that he was aware ofthe visit. 797
(U) The trainers arrived on December 30, 2002 and met with Lt Col Moss and the ICE
Operations Officer. 798 Lt Col Moss told them that "a high level directive had initiated [their]
subsequent trip for the purpose of providing 'physical pressures' training." According to the
SERE Training Specialist, John Rankin, that directive was a letter from the Secretary of Defense
799
which was shown to him by Lt Col Moss. Lt Col Moss also ~ave the two Navy SERE school
personnel a copy ofthe December 18,2002 draft SERE SOP. 80
(U) The next day, the two Navy SERE school instructors led training for GTMO
interrogators and other ICE personnel at Camp Delta.801 The training included instruction on
"Biderman's Principles," including lessons from a chart that was originally included in a 1957
article about how communists elicited false confessions. 802
(U) The training also consisted of both lectures and instruction on the application of
physical pressures. 803 The SERE Training Specialist John Rankin told the Committee that the
instructors showed interrogators how to administer the insult slap, the shoulder slap, the stomach
slap and demonstrated at least one stress position. 804 Mr. Rankin also said that they discussed the
'195 Memorandum from John Rankin and Christopher Ross to Officer in Charge, FASOTRAGRULANr Det
Bnmswic/c, AfterAction Report Joint Task Force Guantanamo Bay (JI'F-GTMO) Training Evolution (January IS,
2003) (hereinafter "AAR JI'F-GTMO Training Evolution (January IS, 2003)").
?96 Committee staff interview of David Becker (October 17, 2(07).
797 Committee staff interview of MG Geoffrey Miller (December 5, 2007).
798 AARJI'F-GTMO Training Evolution (January 15,2003).
799 Committee staff interview of John Rankin (September 24, 2007).
800 Ibid
801 AARJI'F-GTMO Training Evolution (January 15,2003).
Ibid; Intelligence Science Board, Phase I Report: Educing Information: Interrogation: Science and Art
802
(December 2(06) at 316.
803The Navy SERE instructors fIrst provided a lecture on "Biderman's Chart of Coercion," which described the
effects of various physical and psychological pressures on individuals in captivity. See AAR JI'F-GTMO Training
Evolution (January IS, 2003); Committee staff interviews of JTF-GTMO interrogators (July 12, 2007), (November
6, 2007), and (January 9, 2008).
804 Committee staff interview of John Rankin (September 24, 2007).
103
walling technique but did not demonstrate it because the facility lacked the specially constructed
wall used at SERE school. 805 Two IfF-GTMO interrogators who attended the training stated
that, following the demonstration, the interrogators broke off into pairs and practiced slapping
each other. 806
(U) Two interrogators who attended the training said that they understood that the
techniques were available for interrogators to put in their ''toolbox.,,807 One ofthose
interrogators recalled being told that if interrogators wanted to use the techniques, they would
need to notifY their interrogation team chief. 808 A third interrogator who attended the training
told the Committee that he believed Lt Col Moss said the techniques could not be used while
they were pending approval.809
(U) The JIG Commander, COL Sanders, testified to the Army IG that he attended the
initial portion ofthe training and "made it quite clear, at least I believe I made it quite clear [to
the interrogators] ... the use of physical measures was not one ofthe things that we should
consider was appropriate and would not be ~ermitted. ,,810 COL Sanders also testified that he
expressed the same concerns to MG Miller. 11 Those statements are inconsistent with the
recollections of others.
(U) Ofthe three interrogators interviewed by the Committee who attended the training,
none recalled COL Sanders making such a statement. 812 Lt Col Moss, the ICE Chief at the time,
did not recall COL Sanders being present at the training. 813 MG Miller told the Committee that
no one on his staff expressed concern to him about the training. 814
(U) On the morning of January 2,2003 the Navy SERE school personnel presented
additional instruction on interrogation fundamentals and resistance to interrogation. 815 Later that
day the instructors "presented an abbreviated theoretical physical pressures and peacetime
guidance (government and hostage) to Marine IfF-GTMO personnel and two IfF-GTMO Staff
805 Ibid.
806 Committee staff interviews of JTF-GTMO interrogators (July 12, 2007) and (January 9, 2008).
807 Ibid.
808 Committee staff interview of ITF-GTMO interrogator (July 12, 2007).
809 Committee staff interview of ITF-GTMO interrogator (January 9,2008).
810 Army !G, Interview of COL Richard Sanders (March 14, 2006).
811 Ibid. at 6.
812Committee staff interviews of JTF-GTMO interrogators (July 12,2007), (November 6,2007), and (January 9,
2008).
813 Committee staff interview ofLt Col Ted Moss (October 17, 2007).
814 Committee staff interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (December 5, 2007).
8H AARJI'F-GTMO Training Evolution (January 15, 2003).
104
Judge Advocate (SJA) officials.,,816 LTC Beaver told the Committee that she was not aware the
SERE instructors were coming to GTMO and did not attend any ofthe sessions. 817
(U) In the weeks following the Secretary of Defense's December 2,2002 authorization of
the interrogation techniques, word had spread that serious concerns were emerging about the
techniques. In mid-to-Iate December, prior to the SERE trainers' arrival at GTMO, General Hill,
the SOUTHCOM Commander, alerted MG Miller that a debate had ensued regarding the
Secretary's decision to authorize the techniques. 818
(U) Prior to their departure on January 3, 2003, the two Navy SERE instructors met with
MG Miller. 819 The GTMO Commander told the Committee that he informed the SERE
instructors, in the presence of his staff, that he did not want the techniques they had demonstrated
used in interrogations at GTMO. 820 Others who attended the meeting confIrmed the
Commander's account. 821 Mr. Rankin told the Committee that MG Miller said that he did not
want interrogators using techniques that might "bite them" later on. 822
. ( Before leaving, Mr. Rankin provided a memo for the ICE Operations Chief
on the use ofphysical and psychological pressures during interrogations. The memo stated:
(U) CITF had been established as a joint military organization composed of personnel
from the Anny Criminal Investigative Division (CID), the Naval Criminal Investigative Service
816 Ibid.
817 Committee staff interview of LTC Diane Beaver (November 9, 2007).
818 Committee staff interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (December 6, 2007).
819 AAR JTF-GTMO Training Evo,lution (January 15, 2003).
820 Committee staff interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (December 5, 2007).
821Committee staff interview ofLt Col Ted Moss (October 17,2007); Committee staff interview of John Rankin
(September 24, 2007); Committee staff interview of Christopher Ross (September 24, 2007).
822 Committee staff interview of John Rankin (September 24, 2007).
823Memorandum from John Rankin to Captain Weis, Physical and Psychological Pressures During Interrogations
(January 3, 2003).
105
(NCIS), and Air Force Office of Special Investigations. While CITF's Commander COL Britt
Mallow was an Army Colonel assigned to CITF from CID, Deputy Commander Mark Fallon
was an NCIS civilian employee on detail to the CITF. While COL Mallow reported concerns
about ITF-GTMO interrogation techniques through his Army chain of command, Mr. Fallon also
brought the concerns to NCIS leadership. 824
(U) On December 17, 2002, two weeks after the Secretary authorized the interrogation
techniques for use at GTMO and with the Khatani interrogation underway, David Brant, the
NCIS Director informed Navy General Counsel Alberto Mora about recent objections raised by
CITF. 825 The next day, Mr. Mora met with NCIS Chief Psychologist Dr. Michael Gelles, who
had been to GTMO and was familiar with the interrogation techniques in use there. Dr. Gelles
provided Mr. Mora excerpts of interrogation logs reflecting detainee mistreatment. Dismayed by
what he read and heard, Mr. Mora met with Steven Morello, the Army General Counsel, and for
the first time had the opportunity to review the October 11,2002 GTMO request, LTC Beaver's
legal analysis, and the Secretary of Defense's December 2, 2002 authorization of interrogation
techniques for use in GTMO interrogations, which included stress positions, removal of clothing,
dogs, deprivation of light and auditory stimuli, 20 hour interrogations, forced grooming, and
grabbing, pushi~ and poking detainees. 826 Mr. Mora testified to the Committee: "[W]hen I saw
the December 2 Rumsfeld memo, and then reviewed Lieutenant Colonel Beaver's legal
memorandum, when I saw that the memorandum was completely unbounded concerning the
limit of abuse that could be applied to the detainees, I knew instantaneously ... that this was a
flawed policy based upon inadequate legal analysis.,,827
(U) The following day, Mr. Mora briefed Navy Secretary Gordon England on the NCIS
report of detainee mistreatment and received authorization to meet with DoD General Counsel
Jim Haynes. 828 That afternoon, Mr. Mora met with Mr. Haynes and advised him that in his view
"some ofthe authorized techniques could rise to the level oftorture.,,829 He recalled urging the
DoD General Counsel to "think. about the techniques more closely" questioning him "What did
'deprivation oflight and auditory stimuli' mean? Could a detainee be locked in a completely
dark cell? And for how long? A month? Longer? What precisely did the authority to exploit
phobias pennit? Could a detainee be held in a coffm? Could phobias be applied until madness
set in?,,8~O
814 Responses of Mark Fallon to questionnaire of Senator Carl Levin (September 15,2007).
Memo from Alberto 1. Mora to the Inspector General, Department of the Navy, Statementfor the Record: Office
825
ofGeneral Counsel Involvement in Interrogation Issues (July 7,2004) at 2-3 (hereinafter "Mora, Statementfor the
Record'').
826 The Army General Counsel also "demonstrated great concern with [the Secretary's] decision to authorize the
interrogation techniques." Army lawyers explained to the Navy General Counsel that they had "tried to stop" the
authorization "without success, and had been advised not to question the settled decision further." Mora, Statement
for the Record at 5-6.
827 SASC Hearing (June 17, 2(08).
828 Mora, Statement for the Record at 7.
829 Ibid.
830 Ibid. at 7.
106
(U) Mr. Mora also urged Mr. Haynes not to rely on LTC Beaver's legal analysis,
characterizing it as "an incompetent product oflegal analysis.',s31 Mr. Mora left the meeting
feeling confident that the Secretary's authorization for interrogation techniques would be
suspended. 832
(U) More than two weeks later, on January 6,2003, the NCIS Director informed Mr.
Mora that the Secretary's December 2,2002 memo had not been suspended and that detainee
mistreatment was continuing at GTMO. 833 Two days later, Mr. Mora met with a Special
Assistant to both the Secretary of Defense and the Deputy Secretary of Defense and informed
him ofthe concerns. On January 9,2003, Mr. Mora met again with DoD General Counsel Jim
Haynes, warning him that the "interrogation policies could threaten Secretary Rumsfeld's tenure
and could even damage the presidency.',834 The Navy General Counsel also left Mr. Haynes
with a draft copy of a memo written by a Navy JAG Corps Commander, Stephen Gallotta. 835
II
In that memo, CDR Gallotta summarized and attached comments that the military
Services had submitted in November 2002 in response to the Joint Staff request. 836 CDR
Gallotta's memo also assessed the legality ofthe techniques, concluding that several ofthe
techniques "may violate the President's policy for the treatment of detainees," may violate
international legal standards, and may violate the federal anti-torture statute (18 U.S.C. 2340)
and various articles of the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ).837
831 Ibid.
832 Ibid. at 8.
833 Ibid. at 9.
834 A series of meetings followed between Mr. Mora and senior officials, where Mr. Mora reiterated his concerns.
Mr. Mora met with the Legal Counsel to the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff CAPT Jane Dalton, the Service
General Counsels and senior Judge Advocates General, Army General Counsel Steven MoreUo, Air Force General
Counsel Mary Walker, and the DoD Principal Deputy General Counsel Daniel DeU'Orto. Ibid. at 13- 14.
83' Ibid. at 10.
836Memo by CDR Stephen Gallotta, Counter-Resistance Techniques (January 9, 2003). The Services ~ised legal
concerns about many of the Categories II and ill techniques and called for further legal review of the proposal. See
Section IV D, supra.
837 Gallotta, Counter-Resistance Techniques (January 9, 2003).
107
level where they could be detennined to be torture. Thus, additional analysis with
specific guidance for implementation is recommended. 838
(U) On January 15,2003, "uncertain whether there would be any change to the
interrogation policy," Mr. Mora delivered a draft memorandum to Mr. Haynes stating that "the
majority of the proposed category II and all ofthe proposed category III techniques were
violative of domestic and international legal norms in that they constituted, at a minimum, cruel
and unusual treatment and, at worst, torture.,,839 In a phone call that same day, Mr. Mora told the
DoD General Counsel that he intended to sign the memo that afternoon ifhe had not heard that
the Secretary's December 2, 2002 memo for interrogation techniques had been or was being
suspended. 84o According to Mr. Mora, Mr. Haynes indicated during their conversations that
"Secretary Rumsfeld was 'considerin~' rescinding the interrogation techniques he had previously
authorized for use in Guantanamo.,,84 In light of Mr. Mora's draft memo, Mr. Haynes also
indicated that he would inquire further about the "Secretary's promise to 'consider' the
withdrawal ofthe interrogation techniques.,,842 Mr. Haynes called Mr. Mora later that day to tell
him the Secretary had suspended his authorization for interrogation techniques. 843
(U) On January 15,2003, the Secretary of Defense issued a memorandum for GEN Hill,
the SOUTHCOM Commander, rescinding blanket authority for one Category III and all
Category II techniques at GTMO. 844 GEN Hill said that Secretary Rumsfeld had called him days
before fonnally rescinding authority for the techniques on January 15,2003 and asked whether
the interrogation should continue. GEN Hill said that he told the Secretary that he "would
discuss the question with MG Miller, did so that day and reported back to [Secretary Rumsfeld]
recommending we continue the interrogation.,,845 According to GEN Hill, Secretary Rumsfeld
agreed at that time that the interrogation should continue but subsequently called him back and
directed that it be stopped. 846
(U) Just days after the Secretary of Defense rescinded authority for ITF-GTMO to use the
interrogation techniques he had authorized in December, CITF's Deputy Commander Mark
Fallon and NCIS Chief Psychologist Michael Gelles met with MG Miller to discuss their
concerns about interrogation approaches. Mr. Fallon said MG Miller was "dismissive" oftheir
838 Ibid.
839 Mora, Statementfor the Record at 14.
840 Ibid. at 15.
841 Mora responses to questions for the record from SASC Hearing (June 17, 2008).
842 Ibid.
843Mora, Statementfor the Record at 15; see also Mora responses to questions for the record from SASC Hearing
(June 17, 2008) ("At no time did Mr. Haynes give me any indication that the techniques had been previous
rescinded. Had his been the case, Mr. Haynes could have simply informed me of the fact upon our f1!St conversation
that day.").
Memo from the Secretary of Defense to Commander USSOUTHCOM, Counter-Resistance Techniques (January
844
15,2003) (hereinafter "SECDEF memo to CDR SOUTHCOM (January 15,2003)").
84' GEN James Hill answers to July 31,2008 written questions (August 20, 2008).
846 Ibid.
108
concerns and reported that the GTMO Commander said "'you have got to put on the same jersey
if you want to be on the team. ",847
_Following the Secretary's rescission, Khatani was moved out of Camp X_Ray.848
Beginning on January 15,2003 only Category I techniques were used in his interrogation.
Category I techniques included yelling and techniques of deception. An April 19, 2003 memo
from MG Miller the GTMO Commander said that on A ril 9 2003
" interrogators and analysts attributed his cooperation to his failing a polygraph test,
his being told that his information was becoming less important because other members of al
Qaeda were cooperating, and interro~ators informing Khatani that release or repatriation to Saudi
Arabia depended on his truthfulness. 50
(U) In a June 9, 2008 letter to the DoJ Inspector General, John Bellinger the former NSC
Legal Advisor, stated that he "repeatedly asked the Defense Department about conditions and
detention policies at Guantanamo Bay" and that he "specifically raised concerns about
interrogations practices used at Guantanamo, including concerns raised by the Department of
Justice. ,,851
(U) Mr. Bellinger told the Committee that Deputy Assistant Attorney General Bruce
Swartz raised concerns with him "about allegations of abuse of detainees at Guantanamo.,,852
Mr. Bellinger said that Mr. Swartz called him on "several occasions" to express his concerns and
that, in response, he "raised these concerns on several occasions with DoD officials and was told
that the allegations were being investigated by the Naval Criminal Investigative Service.,,853 He
said that then-National Security Advisor Condoleezza Rice "convened a series of meeting of
NSC Principals in order to ensure that concerns about conditions and other issues relating to
Guantanamo were fully discussed with the Department of Defense and other agencies.,,854
(U) Secretary Rice confirmed Mr. Bellinger's account, stating that he advised her "on a
regular basis" regarding concerns and issues relating to Department of Defense detention policies
and practices at Guantanamo. 855 She said that, as a result she "convened a series of meetings of
847 Responses of Mark Fallon to questionnaire of Senator Carl Levin (September 15,2006) at 16.
848Memo from Major General Geoffrey Miller to Commander, U.S. Southern Command., Techniques Used on ISN
63 Since 15 January 2003 (S) (April 19, 2003).
849 Ibid.
8~O Ibid.
8~1 Letter from John Bellinger, III to Glenn Fine (June 9, 2008).
m John Bellinger answers to July 31,2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (September 12, 2008).
8~3 Ibid.
8~4 Ibid.
8~~ Condoleezza Rice answers to July 31,2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (September 12,2008).
109
NSC Principals in 2002 and 2003 to discuss various issues and concerns relating to detainees in
the custody ofthe Department ofDefense.,,856
(U) When he rescinded authority for GTMO to use aggressive interrogation techniques,
Secretary Rumsfeld directed the DoD General Counsel to set up a "Detainee Interrogation
Working Group" within the Department "to assess the legal, policy, and operational issues
relating to the interrogations of detainees held by the United States Armed Forces in the war on
terrorism.,,857
(U) Two days later, on January 17,2003, Mr. Haynes directed Air Force General Counsel
Mary Walker to convene the Working GrOUp.858 Per the Secretary's guidance, the Working
Group was comprised of representatives from the Office ofthe Undersecretary ofDefense
(Policy), the Defense Intelligence Agency, the General Counsels ofthe Air Force, Army, and
Navy, and Counsel to the Commandant ofthe Marine Corps, the Judge Advocates General ofthe
Air Force, Army, and Navy, the Staff Judge Advocate for the Marine Corps, and the Joint Staff
Legal Counsel and the Joint Staff Directorate for Strategic Plans and Policy (J5).859
856 Ibid.
857 Memorandum from the Secretary of Defense for the General Counsel of the Department of Defense, Detainee
Interrogations (January 15, 2003). In this memo, the Secretary also directed the Working Group to address the
"[l]egal considerations raised by interrogation of detainees held by US. Armed Forces;" "[p]olicy considerations
with respect to the choice of interrogation techniques, including contribution to intelligence collection, effect on
treatment of captured US. military personnel, effect on detainee prosecutions, [and] historical role of US. armed
forces in conducting interrogations;" and "[r]ecommendations for employment of particular interrogation techniques
by DoD interrogators."
858 Memorandum from Department of Defense General Counsel William J. Haynes to Air Force General Counsel
Mary Walker, Working Group to Assess Legat Policy, and Operational Issues Relating to Interrogation of
Detainees Held by the u.s. Armed Forces in the War on Terrorism (January 17, 2003).
859 Department of Defense, Working Group Report on Detainee Interrogations in the Global War on Terrorism:
Assessment ofLegat Historicat Policy, and Operational Considerations (April 4, 2003); Memorandum from the
Secretary of Defense for the General Counsel of the Department of Defense, Detainee Interrogations (January 15,
2003).
860 Proposed Agenda, Working Group Meeting (January 23, 2003).
861 Church Report at 124.
110
about specific interrogation techniques. 862 A proposed agenda for the first Working Group
meeting tasked David Becker with providing an overview of interrogation techniques to the
Group. 863
_Mr.Becker, the former JTF-GTMO Interrogation Control Element (ICE) Chief, had
recently returned from GTMO to a civilian job at DIA Mr. Becker told the Committee that he
discussed interrogation operations as well as particular interrogation techniques with the
Working Group's senior JAG officers and their civilian counterparts. 864 He told the Committee
that he was asked about aggressive techniques and was encouraged to talk about techniques that
inflict pain. 865 He also said that he advised the Working Group to consider SERE resistance
training techniques. 866
_The
Working Group tasked DIA with providing a list of interrogation techniques and
their effectiveness so that the Group could assess their legality.867 DIA relied on Mr. Becker to
produce that list. 868
_ Mr. Becker compiled a list of36 techniques for the Working GrOUp.869 The list
included techniques from Army Field Manual 34-52; techniques from Category II ofthe October
11, 2002 GTMO request, including stress positions, isolation, deprivation of light and auditory
stimuli, hooding, 20 hour interrogations, forced grooming, and use ofphobias, such as dogs; and
862 Ibid.; Proposed Agenda, Working Group Meeting (Janwuy 23, 2003).
863 Proposed Agenda, Working Group Meeting (Janwuy 23, 2(03).
864 Committee staff interview of David Becker (September 17, 2007).
865 Ibid.
866Ibid. The proposed agenda for the Working Group meeting (dated Janwuy 23,2003) includes handwritten
comments that reflect a discussion about "All [service] SEER [sic] guidelines" and "techniques." Since this
document was produced to the Committee as a part of the source materials collected by VADM Church for his
report, the Committee cannot determine whether these handwritten comments are those of a Working Group
867.
participant or VADM Church's team. Proposed Agenda, Working Group Meeting (Janwuy 23, 2(03).
Proposed Agenda, Working Group Meetii(Janwuy 23, 2003); (U) Proposed Detainee Interrogation
Working Group Responsibilities (Initial) (Undated) DIA's role was described in the memo as, "List, describe
and assess the effectiveness of all interrogation techniques that may be effective in obtaining useful information
from detainees in the war on terrorism. Suggest relevant policy considerations affecting each."
868 Committee staff interview of David Becker (September 17, 2007).
869 . . Committee staff interview of David Becker (September 17,2007). The 36 techniques included Direct,
Incentive, Emotional Love, Emotional Hate, Fear Up Harsh, Fear Up Mild, Decreased Fear, Pride and Ego Up, Pride
and Ego Down, Futility, We Know All, Establish Your Identity, Repetition Approach, File and Dossier, Mutt and
Jeff, Rapid Fire, Silence, Change of Scenery, Use of Stress Positions, Use of Falsified Documents and Reports, Use
of Isolation Facility, Interrogating Detainees in an Environment other than the Standard Interrogation Booth,
Deprivation of Light and Auditory Stimuli, Hooding, Use of 20-Hour Interrogations, Switching the Detainee from
Hot Rations to MREs, Removal of All Comfort Items, Forced Grooming, Use of Detainee Phobias, Use of Scenarios
Designed to Convince the Detainees that Death or Severely Painful Consequences are Imminent, Exposure to Cold
Weather or Water, Use of a Wet Towel and Dripping Water, Use of Mild, Non-Injurious Physical Contact, Use of
Drugs, Use of Female Interrogators, and Sleep Deprivation. Defense Intelligence Agency memo, List, describe and
assess the effectiveness ofaU interrogation techniques that may be effective in obtaining useful informationfrom
detainees in the war on terrorism. Suggest relevant policy considerations affecting each (undated) (hereinafter "List
of interrogation techniques compiled by DIA.")
all four techniques from Category III ofthe GTMO request, i.e., use of scenarios to convince the
detainee that death or severely painful consequences are imminent, exposure to cold weather or
water, use of a wet towel and dripping water, and the use of mild, non-injurious physical
contact. 870 Mr. Becker also listed three "less common techniques" for the Working Group's
consideration, i.e., use of drugs, use of female interrogators, and sleep deprivation. ,,871 Mr.
Becker's memo identified each technique, assessed its effectiveness, and in some instances, also
assessed legal and policy considerations. 872
_ ( Mr. Becker's memo stated that the Category III techniques from the
October 11,2002 GTMO request were '"the most aggressive and controversial" techniques. 873
Mr. Becker stated that the techniques were "currently used against U.S. soldiers in SERE
schools, with their consent," but that they would "not comport with the Geneva Conventions" if
applied to Prisoners of War (POWs). 874 His memo recommended that the Working Group
conduct a policy review on the "reciprocity oftreatment of captured U.S. personnel" before
implementing any ofthe Category III techniques. 87s Mr. Becker said that attorneys who
consulted with him on the memo added this recommendation. 876
_ ( Mr. Becker's memo state~may have already been using the
Catego~ III techniques and stated t h a t _ h a d apparently obtained assistance from
JPRA 8 He wrote:
These [Category III] techniques may be employed b Y . against the
detainees they have in custody overseas. We understand office of the
General Counsel did a legal review and established a fmdin similar to the Ie al
review of the GTMO SJA.
The U.S.
military uses standardized SOPs and training in their SERE schools. The SOPs
establish the necessary checks and oversight that make SERE training both safe
and effective. If adopted, those same standards should be applied when
870 _ List of interrogation techniques compiled by DIA. In describing one technique - use of mild, non
injurious physical contact - the ICE Chief explained that "[i]ssues such as grabbing and poking have very minimal
policy issues and playa part in the interrogator's efforts to be sincere. Other non-injurious contact such as a face
slap or stomach slap are effective in gaining compliance and are used at SERE school. UCMJ policy issues should
be resolved. "
871 List of interrogation techniques compiled by DIA.
871 Ibid.
87J Ibid. at 3.
874 Ibid.
87S Ibid.
876 Committee staff interview of David Becker (September 17, 2007).
877 List of interrogation techniques compiled by DIA at 3.
112
interrogating detainees in the GWOT. The SERE SOPs should resolve most of
the policy issues regarding the use of the Category [III] counter-resistance
techniques. 878
878 Ibid.
879 Ibid.
880 Ibid.
882.
881 Ibid. at 4.
( "[1] Use of Drugs: Drugs such as sodium pentothal and demero1 may be used with some
effectiveness. Significant policy issues must be resolved. [2] Use of Female Interrogators: One al-Qaida resistance
method is to pray during interrogations. Prayer is only allowed if the detainee is clean.' Having a woman rub
scented oil on the detainee's arms and face makes the detainee perceive that he is unclean and he cannot pray until
he cleans himself, which he is unable to do until he returns to his cell. The use of female interrogators to put oil on a
detainee does not exceed limits already established by DoD policy or the Geneva Conventions. [3] Sleep
Deprivation: This can be effective; however there are obvious policy considerations. Guidelines as to the use of
sleep deprivation would have to be established." List of interrogation techniques compiled by DIA at 4.
883 Committee staff interview of David Becker (September 17, 2007).
884Proposed Detainee Interrogation Working Group Responsibilities (Initial) (undated) at 1; Proposed Agenda,
Working Group Meeting (January 23, 2003).
113
21, 2003 on the effectiveness oftechniques that had been rescinded by the Secretary of Defense
earlier that month. 885 In his memo, MG Miller stated that "[t]he command must have the ability
to conduct interrogations using a wide variety oftechniques" and listed nine techniques as
"essential to mission success." Those nine included use of an isolation facility; interrogating the
detainee in an environment other than the standard interrogation room at Camp Delta such as
Camp X-Ray; varying levels of deprivation of light and auditory stimuli to include the use ofa
white room for up to three days; the use of up to 20-hour interrogations; the use of a hood during
transportation and movement; removal of all comfort items (including religious items); serving
of meals ready to eat (MREs) instead of hot rations; forced grooming, to include shaving of
facial hair and head; and the use of false documents and reports. 886
_ MG Miller's January 21, 2003 memo stated that he believed that those nine
techniques were lawful and stated:
These techniques are not intended to cause gratuitous, severe, physical pain or
suffering or prolonged mental harm, but are instead intended to induce
_MG
cooperation over a period of time by weakening the detainee's mental and
physical ability to resist. 887
Miller attached another memo to his January 21,2003 memo for General
Hill. That attached memo, also dated January 21, 2003 and entitled "Methods Employed X-Ray
Interrogation ofISN 63," bore the same title as a memo dated January 17,2003. (The earlier
memo is described in detail above). Despite describing the same events and being written just
days apart, the January 21, 2003 and the January 17,2003 memos contain substantive
differences.
_( Several interrogation techniques that the January 17,2003 memo
identified as techniques used in the Khatani interrogation were omitted from the January 21,
2003 version. Among the techniques left out ofthe latter memo were "fhysical posturing,"
"search/strip search," and the presence of"K-9 military police" dogs. 88 In addition, the
description of certain techniques differed in the two versions ofthe memo. For example, in the
latter version, "denial of prayer" was removed and replaced with "postponement of prayer" and
88' Memo from MG Geoffrey Miller for Commander, u.s. Southern Command, Effectiveness ofthe Use ofCertain
Category n COWJter-Resistance Strategies (January 21,2003) (hereinafter "MG Miller memo, Effectiveness of
Certain Category II Strategies (January 21,2(03)").
886.MG Miller, Effectiveness ofCertain Category II Strategies (January 21,2003). Although MG Miller
identified only nine "essential" techniques on January 21,2003, a subsequent memo sent by the SOUfHCOM
Commander GEN Hill called all the Category II and the one Category ill technique (non-injurious physical contact
such as poking and pushing) that the Secretary had authorized in December "critical to maximizing our ability to
accomplish the mission, now and in the future." See Church Report at 135 and Section VIII D, infra.
887 MG Miller, Effectiveness ofCertain Category II Strategies (January 21,2003).
888 Methods EmployedX-Ray Inte"ogation ISN 63. (January 17, 2003); Methods EmployedX-Ray Inte"ogation
ISN 63 (S) (January 23, 2003), attached to MG Milr;-'memo, Effectiveness ofCertain Category II Strategies
(January 21, 2003).
114
III CENTCOM sent the Working Group's request for a list oftechniques to CITF-180, in
Afghanistan. In response, LTC Robert Cotell, the CJTF-180 Deputy Staff Judge Advocate (SJA)
produced a memo on January 24, 2003 describing "current and past" interrogation techniques
used by CJTF-180 interrogators. 89o LTC Cotell's memo was sent to the Working Group and to
the Office ofthe Secretary ofDefense. 891
_ ( LTC Cotell's January 24,2003 memo stated that "[p]rior to their rescission,
CJTF-180 used selected techniques contained in SOlITHCOM's [Category] II and III
techniques. ,,892 He identified interrogation techniques used by CJTF-180, including up to 96
hours of isolation; the use of female interrogators to create "discomfort" and gain more
information; sleep adjustment, defined as "four hours of sleep every 24 hours, not necessarily
consecutive;" use of individual fears; removal of comfort items; use of safety positions;
isolation; deprivation of li~t and sound in living areas; the use of a hood during interrogation;
and mild physical contact. 3 Several ofthese techniques were similar to those approved by the
Secretary of Defense for use at GTMO in December 2002. CITF-180 had obtained a list ofthose
GTMO techniques prior to the time that LTC Cotell had drafted his January 24, 2003 memo. 894
_ ( The January 24, 2003 memo also recommended use of five additional
techniques, including "deprivation of clothing" to put detainees in a "shameful, uncomfortable
situation;" "food deprivation;" "sensory overload -loud music or temperature regulation;"
"controlled fear through the use of muzzled, trained, military working dogs;" and ''use of light
and noise deprivation,,895
(U) LTG John Abizaid, the Deputy Commander (Forward) U.S. Central Command,
stated that the January 24, 2003 memorandum "was thoroughly reviewed" by the Working
Group. 896
889 Ibid.
890Church Report at 1g"/; Memo from LTC Robert Cotell to CENTCOM SJA, CJTF 180 Inte"ogation Techniques
(January 24, 2003) at 1.
891US Central Command Action Processing Form, Approvalfor the Use ofCertain Inte"ogation Techniques in
CJTF-180's AOR (April 4, 2003); Memorandum from GEN John P. Abizaid to VADM Church, Responses to
Requestfor Informotionfrom VADM Church (August 6,2004).
892 Memo from LTC Robert Cotell to CENTCOM SJA, CJTF 180 Inte"ogation Techniques (January 24, 2003) at 1.
m Memo from LTC Robert Cotell to CENTCOM SJA, CJTF 180 Inte"ogation Techniques (January 24, 2003) at 8.
The Church Report called the distinction between stress positions and safety positions at the Bagram Collection
Point "largely academic." Church Report at 200.
Secretary of Defense Approval ofC01mter-Resistance Techniques (December 2,2002); Memo from LTC Robert
894
Cotell to CENTCOM SJA, CJTF 180 Inte"ogation Techniques (January 24, 2003) at 1.
89' Memo from LTC Robert Cotell to CENTCOM SJA, CJTF 180 Inte"ogation Techniques (January 24,2003) at I,
4-5, and 9.
Memorandum from GEN John Abizaid to VADM Church, Responses to Requestfor 1nformationfrom VADM
896
Church (August 6, 2004).
115
_ MAJ Lovelace called Mr. Joseph Witsch, the JPRA instructor who had previously
conducted training for and had served as Team Chief at the September 2002
training for GTMO interrogators and behavioral science personnel at Fort Bragg. 898
_ ( First among his concerns was the potential effect that sharing SERE
school techniques could have on the training of American personnel. Mr. Witsch wrote:
Open source intel and media is flooded with what the USG/OGAs and DOD are
currently doing with [Designated Unlawful Combatants (DUCs)]. How long will
it take before we see some discussion on SERE school methods and techniques
being used to interrogate DUCs. I'll take bets that it will occur in days and weeks
897 Email from Joseph Witsch to Lt Col Dan Baumgartner (January 30, 2003).
898 Ibid.
899The Joint Staff action officer stated that they needed the infonnation immediately, since the" blue ribbon panel'
organized by the AF General Counsel" intended to "work through the weekend to meet this immediate
requirement." Email from Joseph Witsch to Dan Baumgartner (January 30, 2003).
900 Ibid.
901 Ibid.
902 Ibid.
90J Ibid.
904 Email from Joseph Witsch to Lt Col Daniel Baumgartner (January 31,2003).
versus months! It ain't healthy for our operators to expose how we prepare them
to deal with interrogation and captivity in open source media. 905
_ ( Second, Mr. Witsch stated that the SERE techniques violated national
and international laws. He wrote:
Our training is based on simulating our captors' passed [sic] performance while
tapering the physical/psychological severity and harm to our students. The
physical and psychological pressures we apply in training violate national and
international laws. We are only allowed to do these things based on permission
from DOD management and intense oversight by numerous organizations within
DOD. I hope someone is explaining this to all these folks asking for our
techniques and methodology! 906
_( His third concern was that a lack of proper oversight could give rise to
significant drift, which, in tum, could pose a risk of investigation and exposure ofthe
organization. Mr. Witsch asked:
What do you think is more than likely to happen when one of these organizations
gets exposed and because of significant 'drift' and a lack of oversight they go
beyond what we do in the SERE schools? The first question will be 'Where did
you get your guidance?' Then we get investigated and exposed []. 907
_ ( Mr. Witsch's fourth concern was that JPRA would have no control over
how the information would be used. He asked:
What's been handed out in hard copy and electronically from [] us and the SERE
community to meet numerous requests from everybody? We use [sic] to have
some general idea when we were dealing with primarily the SERE community.
Now it's anybody's ~ess where the JTTP has gone and how it's being
incOq>orated and used. 9 8
_ ( Mr. Witsch added:
I know this is cool stuff and may provide some utility when dealing with DUCs.
I'm not saying that we should totally remove ourselves from this endeavor. We
must get a handle on all these people seeking information on our stuff within the
USG and DOD and control the amount [of] exposure our SERE
community/programs are getting. This is getting out of control! ,909
905 Ibid.
906 Ibid.
907 Ibid.
908 Ibid.
909 Ibid.
117
(U) In the early stages ofthe Working Group's deliberations, Working Group members
had set out to develop their own legal analysis and utilize that analysis in the evaluation of
interrogation techniques. 913 A draft ofthat analysis, dated January 25, 2003, was shared with the
DoD General Counsel's office and the OLC. 914
_ The draft reviewed U.S. obligations under international law and concluded that
"obligations under the Torture Convention ... apply to the interrogation of Operation Enduring
Freedom detainees ... ,,915 The draft analysis also included a review of articles ofthe UCMJ and
other U.S. legal standards that were potentially applicable to U.S. interrogators. For example,
the analysis found that unlawful force used against a detainee could constitute an offense under
Article 128 (assault) ofthe UCMJ, and stated that assault:
_ T h e draft analysis also assessed the legality ofthe techniques that had been
requested for approval by GTMO in October 2002, including some ofthose that the Secretary of
Defense had approved for use at GTMO in December 2002. In its draft, the Working Group
910 Committee staff interview ofLt Col Dan Baumgartner (August 8,2007); See Section vm F, infra.
911 Church Report at 124; ProposedAgenda, Working Group Meeting (January 23, 2003).
912 Memorandum from the Secretary of Defense for the General Counsel of the Department of Defense, Detainee
Interrogations (January 15, 2003); Committee staff interview of William 1. Haynes IT (April 25, 2008) at 250;
Hearing on the Nomination of William James Haynes IT to be US. Circuit Judge for the Fourth Circuit, US. Senate
Committee on the Judiciary, 109th Cong. (July 11, 2006) at 14.
913 Church Report at 124.
914"'Committee staff interview of Eliana Davidson (February 21,2008); Detainee Interrogations: Survey of
Legal and Policy Considerations (draft) (undated). The Department of Defense allowed the Committee to review
this document, but would not permit the Committee to keep a copy of the document.
913_Detainee Interrogations: Survey ofLegal and Policy Considerations at 1-8.
916 Ibid. at 10.
118
adopted the conclusion that Navy JAG Corps CDR Stephen Gallotta had reached in his January
9, 2003 memo, writing that:
Category III techniques that threaten death to the detainee or his family (#1) or
which create the misapprehension of suffocation (#3) would likely be judged to
constitute torture under the statute and customary international law. They reflect
conduct specifically defmed as torture in [18 U.S.C.] 2340 and recognized as
torture in international law. Category III, technique #4, mild, non-injurious
grabbing and poking, is an assault under the UCMJ. Absent lawful purpose, these
techniques may be per se unlawful.
_The
specific guidance for implementation is recommended. 917
(U) Within the first two weeks ofthe Working Group's deliberations, the OLe delivered
a draft legal memo to Air Force General Counsel Mary Walker. 921 The OLe's memo, which
would be fmalized on March 14, 2003, was presented to the Working Group as the "controlling
authority for all questions of domestic and internationallaw.,,922 Among the Working Group
members there was a "great deal of disagreement" with the OLC anal~sis and "serious concerns
and objections over some ofthe legal conclusions reached by OLe.,,9 3
119
(U) CAPT Dalton, the Legal Counsel to the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said
she was ''very angry" when told that the Working Group would be governed by the OLC's legal
analysis. 925 She told the Committee: "There was a point [during the Working Group process]
where we were told that we could not argue against the OLC opinion ... that any other legal
ideas that we had would not be accepted, particularly when we commented on the draft
report.,,926 Likewise, Alberto Mora, the Navy General Counsel and a participant in the Working
Group, said that "[s]oon upon receipt of the OLe memo, the Working Group leadership began to
apply its guidance to shape the content of its report.,,927 Mr. Mora stated that "contributions from
the members ofthe Working Group, including [contributions from his office], began to be
rejected if they did not conform to the OLe guidance.,,928
(U) The final OLe memo, signed by John Yoo on March 14, 2003 (and known
commonly as the "Yoo memo"), adopted many of the same conclusions as those of the First
Bybee memo (dated August 1, 2002), in which the OLC had significantly narrowed the scope of
what constituted torture under federal law. For example, Mr. Yoo's memo repeated OLC's
previous analysis ofthe federal anti-torture statute, 18 U.S.C. 2340, finding that the statute
prohibited "only extreme acts" and that in order to constitute torture, physical pain would have to
be equivalent in intensity to that accompanying "serious physical injury, such as organ failure,
impairment of bodily functions or even death.,,929
(U) The final March 14,2003 OLC memo, however, added that general criminal statutes,
such as the federal anti-torture statute, were inapplicable to the military during the conduct of a
war. 930 The OLC concluded that the assault, maiming, interstate stalking, and anti-torture
statutes do not apply to the "properly-authorized interrogation of enemy combatants by the
United States Armed Forces during an armed conflict.,,931
924 Church Report at 126 (citing February 2, 2003 Working Group draft)
925 Committee staff interview of Jane Dalton (April 10,2008) at 167.
926 Ibid. at 165.
921Mora, Statementfor the Record at 17. Other participants of the Working Group conftrmed that "in drafting the
subject report and recommendations, the legal opinions of the [OLC] were relied on almost exclusively." Memo
from Air Force Deputy JAG Jack Rives to Air Force General Counsel, Final Report and Recommendations ofthe
Working Group to Assess the LegaL Policy and Operational Issues Relating to Interrogation ofDetainees Held by
the U.S. Armed Forces in the War on Terrorism (February 5,2003).
928 Mora, Statement for the Record at 17.
Memorandum from John Yoo to William 1. Haynes II, Re: Military Interrogations ofAlien Unlawful
929
Combatants Held Outside the United States (March 14, 2003) at 34-47 (hereinafter "Yoo Memo (March 14,2003)").
930Those canons included "the avoidance of constitutional difficulties, inapplicability of general criminal statutes to
the conduct of the military during war, inapplicability of general statutes to the sovereign, and the speciftc governs
the general." Yoo Memo (March 14, 2003) at 11-19.
931Yoo Memo (March 14, 2003) at 11-19. Despite concluding that such statutes are inapplicable to the military
during the conduct of a war, the OLC memo nonetheless considered whether use of certain speciftc techniques by an
120
(U) The OLC's conclusion was based, in part, on its analysis ofthe President's
Commander in Chief authority. In the First Bybee memo, the OLe had asserted that "any effort
by Congress to regulate the interrogation of battlefield detainees would violate the Constitution's
sole vesting of the Commander-in-Chiefauthority in the President.,,932 In keeping with that
finding, the March 14, 2003 fmal OLC memo held that the power to detain and interrogate
enemy combatants arose out ofthe President's constitutional authority as Commander in
Chief. 933 "In wartime," according to the memo, "it is for the president alone to decide what
methods to use to best prevail against the enemy.,,934
(U) In the March 14, 2003 final opinion, the OLC used its broad reading ofthe
Commander-in-Chiefauthority to conclude that "even if' federal criminal statutes "were
misconstrued to apply" to interrogations, the "Department of Justice could not enforce this law
or any ofthe other [applicable] criminal statutes.,,935 According to the OLC, "[e]ven if an
interrogation method arguably were to violate a criminal statute; the Justice Department could
not bring alrosecution because the statute would be unconstitutional as applied in this
context.,,93
(U) The First Bybee memo and the March 14,2003 final OLe memo were withdrawn in
June 2004 and December 2003, respectively.937 According to Assistant Attorney General for
OLe Jack Goldsmith, the memos were "legally flawed, tendentious in substance and tone, and
,,938
overbroad ...
(U) The Navy General Counsel Alberto Mora called the OLC memo relied on by the
Working Group in 2003 "profoundly in error" and a "travesty ofthe applicable law.,,939
interrogator would constitute an offense under those laws. For example, the OLC memo considered whether
slapping (or attempting to slap) a detainee would constitute assault or run afoul of U.S. constitutional standards. See
Y00 Memo (March 14, 2(03) at 25, 28, 62, 68.
932 According to Assistant Attorney General for the Office of Legal Counsel Jack Goldsmith, who withdrew both the
First Bybee memo and the March 14,2003 fInal OLC memo, "this extreme conclusion has no foundation in prior
OLC opinions, or injudicial decisions, or in any other source of law." Goldsmith continued: "And the conclusion's
signifIcance sweeps far beyond the interrogation opinion or the torture statute. It implies that many other federal
laws that limit interrogation-anti-assault laws, the 1996 War Crimes Act, and the Uniform Code of MilitaJy
Justice-are also unconstitutional, a conclusion that would have surprised the many prior presidents who signed or
ratifIed those laws, or complied with them during wartime." The conclusion was even more "inappropriate,"
according to Goldsmith because "it rested on cursory and one-sided legal arguments that failed to consider
Congress's competing wartime constitutional authorities, or the many Supreme Court decisions potentially in
tension with the conclusion." Goldsmith, The Terror Presidency at 148-149.
933 Y00 Memo (March 14, 2(03) at 2-6.
934 Ibid. at 5.
m Ibid. at 18.
936 Ibid.
937Goldsmith, The Terror Presidency at 159; In December 2003, Assistant Attorney General Jack Goldsmith
advised the Department of Defense General Counsel William 1. Haynes not to rely on the March 14, 2003 fInal OLC
memo. Committee staff interview of Jack Goldsmith (February 4,2008).
938 Goldsmith, The Terror Presidency at 151.
939 Mora, Statementfor the Record at 17; SASC Hearing (June 17, 2008).
121
According to Mr. Mora, the "OLC memo proved a vastly more sophisticated version ofthe
Beaver Legal Brief, but it was a much more dangerous document because of the statutory
requirement that OLC opinions are binding provided much more weight to its virtually
equivalent conclusions.,,940 He stated that it became evident to those on the Working Group that
the "report being assembled would contain profound mistakes in its legal analysis, in large
measure because of its reliance on the flawed OLC Memo." 941 CAPT Dalton likewise said that
"to the extent that [the Working Group report] relied on the OLC memo, it did not include what I
considered to be a fair and complete legal analysis ofthe issues involved.,,942 She added that
being told what their le~al opinion had to be "severely constrained [the Working Group's] ability
to do an adequate job." 3 The report, she said, had been "geared toward a ewarticular
conclusion[]" and the legal analysis was written to support that conclusion.
_ Drafts oftheir report from this time period reflect the influence that SERE had on
the Working Group's consideration of interrogation techniques. In a draft ofthe Working Group
report, dated January 27, 2003, the report identified two categories of "interrogation techniques
proven to be effective" - (1) those techniques that were "currently used by trained interrogators
in accordance with U.S. Military Doctrine and policy" and (2) "additional techniques" deemed
"acceptable for use in accordance with ancillary military training processes such as SERE
schools.,,948
940 Mora, Statement/or the Record at 17. Legal COWlSel to the Joint Chiefs then-CAPT Jane Dalton also noted that
the March 14, 2003 fInal OLC opinion was "similar to the Beaver analysis" in "approaches and methodology."
Committee staff interview ofRADM Jane Dalton (April 10, 2(08) at 171.
941 Mora, Statement/or the Record at 17.
942 Committee staff interview ofRADM Jane Dalton (April 10, 2(08) at 173.
943 Committee staff interview ofRADM Jane Dalton (April 10, 2(08) at 167.
944 Ibid. at 171.
94~ Memorandum from Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld to Department of Defense General COWlSel William
1. Haynes IT, Detainee Interrogations (January 15, 2003).
!l46 Church Report at 130.
947 Ibid.
948 DoD Working Group draft report (January 27,2003) at 25-28.
122
_ The first category ofteclmiques, which the January 27, 2003 draft report
identified as those already in use and "proven to be effective," included techniques not listed in
Army Field Manual 34-52, such as isolation, hooding, use of prolonged interrogations, mild
physical contact, removal of clothing, forced grooming. dietary manipulation, use of phobias to
increase levels of stress, deprivation of light and auditory stimuli, environmental manipulation,
sleep adjustment, prolonged standing, and deception. 949 In describing one of these techniques
deprivation oflight and auditory stimuli - the draft report noted (in an apparent reference to
SERE resistance training) that it was an "effective technique used in military training.,,95o
_While the draft report described the two lists oftechniques as "proven to be
effectiv~d not discuss the purpose for which the techniques were proven effective.
_ As Working Group participants made revisions to the draft report, the list of
interrogation techniques in the report remained largely unchanged. A February 2, 2003 draft
123
report shows virtually the same list of interrogation techniques as the earlier draft. 957 However,
unlike the earlier draft, the February 2,2003 draft excluded almost all references to "SERE
schools" or to techniques used in "military training." 958 For example, the entire category of
techniques previously identified as techniques in use "with ancillary military training processes
such as SERE schools" were instead described in the February 2,2003 draft as techniques
"considered effective by interrogators and for which USSOUTHCOM and USCENTCOM have
requested approval.,,959
- By the time the Working Group issued its draft "Final Report" on February 4,
2003, ~ made no reference to SERE schools or techniques used in "military training,,,96o
despite the fact that most ofthe SERE techniques remained in the report. 961
(U) The report also listed, but did not recommend approval of, three additional
techniques that the Working Group said it lacked sufficient information to evaluate fully - use of
stress positions, deprivation of light and auditory stimuli, and water immersion/wetting down. 963
Two ofthe three techniques that the Working Group lacked enough information to make a
judgment on, i.e., stress positions and deprivation of light and auditory stimuli, were among
those recommended for approval by Mr. Haynes and approved by the Secretary of Defense two
months earlier, on December 2, 2002.
m The one exception was that the "deception" technique in the January 27,2003 draft was replaced with the "false
flag" technique in the February 2,2003 draft. False flag is a type of deception technique used to try and "convince
the detainee that individuals from a country other than the United Sates are interrogating him." DoD Working
Group draft report (February 2, 2003).
9~8 Ibid.
9~9 In the February 2, 2003 draft, the technique known as "deprivation of light and auditory stimuli," which was
identified in the earlier draft as an "effective technique used in military training" was moved into this category.
DoD Working Group draft report (January 27, 2003) at 28; DoD Working Group draft report (February 2,2003).
960 DoD Working Group draft report (February 4,2003) at 60-64.
961 Ibid. at 60-64.
962 Ibid. at 70; Church Report at 130.
963 Church Report at 136.
964 Church Report at 130; Working Group draft report (February 4, 2003).
96~ _According to the Church Report, "The first 19 of the techniques were identical to the 17 specifically
enumerated in FM 34-52, except that the draft added one technique ('Mutt and Jeff,' which the draft described as 'a
124
use with certain limitations. 966 The 10 "exceptional" techniques included isolation, prolonged
interrogations, forced grooming, prolonged standing, sleep deprivation, physical training, face
slap/stomach slap, removal of clothing, increasing anxiety by use of aversions, and the
waterboard. 967
(U) Many ofthe 10 "exceptional" techniques in the report, were similar to techniques
identified in earlier versions ofthe report as either having originated in SERE school or among
those previously approved for use at GTMO and identified by Mr. Becker, the former GTMO
ICE Chief, in his list for the Working Group.
team consisting of a friendly and harsh interrogator') that was in the 1987 version ofFM 34-52 but was not found in
the [then] current version, and the draft also listed Change of Scenery Up and Change of Scenery Down as separate
techniques, rather than using the more general Change of Scene technique listed in FM 34-52." Church Report at
966"
127.
The report stated that use of techniques listed in the report would be subject to conditions, i.e., "Limited
to specified interrogation centers; There is a good basis to believe that the detainee possesses critical intelligence;
The detainee is medically and operationally evaluated as suitable (considering all techniques in combination);
Interrogators are specifically trained for the technique(s); Subject to a special interrogation plan (including
reasonable safeguards, limits on duration, intervals between applications, tennination criteria and the presence or
availability of qualified medical personnel); Appropriate supervision; and Appropriate specified senior level
approval for use with any specific detainee (after considering the foregoing and receiving legal advice)." Working
Group draft report (February 4, 2003) at 60-64, 70.
967Church Report at 1 3 0 ; . Working Group Report at 60-64, 70 (February 4,2003) "Increasing anxiety by use
of aversions" replaced a technique referred to as "use of phobias to increase levels of stress" in previous versions of
the report. Despite their differing names, the techniques were described similarly and included use of dogs as
examples of the technique.
968Green indicated "no significant constraint on use raised by the respective" law or policy under consideration,
assuming adequate procedural safeguards; Yellow indicated that the law or policy under consideration did "not
preclude use," but that there were "problematic aspects that cannot be eliminated by procedural safeguards; and
"Red" indicated a "major issue" in the law or policy under consideration "that cannot be eliminated." Working
Group draft report (February 4,2003).
969 Thid.
971"
970 Church Report at 130; Working Group draft report (February 4, 2003).
The Working Group also rated the waterboard as yellow under the prohibition against torture in the
Torture Convention. Working Group draft report (February 4, 2003).
125
partner nation reviews. In addition, the report indicated that the technique could have an effect
on the treatment of captured U.S. forces, could potentially affect detainee prosecutions; was
"inconsistent with modern U.S. military perceptions in decency in dealing with prisoners" and
was "a significant departure from contemporary American military approach to the laws of
war.,,972 The February 4, 2003 Working Group Report gave the waterboard its only overall red
rating and recommended that the approval authority for the technique be "no lower than the
J:' 973
[Secretary ofDelense]."
(U) The Working Group's assessment ofthe techniques on the stoplight chart was
governed by the Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) memo. The result, according to then-CAPT
(now RADM) Dalton, was that drafts ofthe stoplight chart were "absolutely wrong legally.,,974
According to RADM Dalton:
[T]here was a column originally . . . in the stoplight chart, that was labeled
"Customary International Law." So one ofthe things we were supposed to assess
was whether or not the techniques were consistent with customary international
law. The stoplight chart had all 36 techniques green under customary
international law because the OLC opinion and thus the Working Group report
maintained that customary international law did not impose any constraints on the
actions . . . That green column was absolutely wrong legally . . . it was
embarrassing to have it in there, and one of my comments to the report was ...
You need to delete that column entire?, because it's embarrassing to have it in
there and it's not reflective ofthe law. 97
(U) The OLC opinion, which was relied on almost exclusively by the Working
Group, was "notably silent" on the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ), the
military justice system applicable to U.S. personnel conducting interrogations. 976
126
(U) US. servicemembers may be at risk for criminal prosecution or civil liability in
foreign domestic courts and international fora. 979
(U) Authorization ofthe exceptional techniques will negatively impact US. and
international public support and respect ofthe US. Armed Forces and could have a
negative impact on the public perception ofthe US. military.982
Advocate General RADM Michael Lohr to Air Force General Counsel Mary Walker, Wor/cing Group
Recommendations Relating to Interrogation ofDetainees (February 6,2003) (hereinafter "Lohr to Walker (February
6, 2003)'').
9T1Rives to Walker (February 5,2003); Memo from Air Force Deputy Judge Advocate General MG Jack Rives to
Air Force General Counsel Mary Walker, Comments on Draft Reporl and Recommendations ofthe Wor/cing Group
to Assess the Lega~ Policy and Operational Issues Relating to Interrogation ofDetainees Held by the u.s. Armed
Forces in the War on Terrorism (February 6,2003) (hereinafter "Rives to Walker (February 6, 2003)").
978Rives to Walker (February 5, 2003); Rives to Walker (February 6, 2003); Sandkuhler to Walker (February 27,
2003); Memo from MG Thomas Romig to Mary Walker, Draft Reporl andRecommendations ofthe Wor/cing Group
to Access I sicJ the Lega~ Policy and Operational Issues Related to Interrogation ofDetainees Held by the U.S.
Armed Forces in the War on Terrorism (March 3, 2003) (hereinafter "Romig to Walker (March 3, 2003)").
Rives to Walker (February 5, 2003); Rives to Walker (February 6, 2003); Sandkuhler to Walker (Feb 27, 2003);
9'l9
Romig to Walker (March 3, 2003).
Rives to Walker (February 5, 2003); Rives to Walker (February 6, 2003); Lohr to Walker (February 6, 2003);
980
Sandkuhler to Walker (February 27, 2003).
981 Rives to Walker (February 6,2003); Sandkuhler to Walker (February 27, 2003).
Rives to Walker (February 5, 2003); Rives to Walker (February 6,2003); Sandkuhler to Walker (February 27,
982
2003).
98J Sandkuhler to Walker (February 27,2003).
127
(U) According to DoD General Counsel Jim Haynes, the Secretary of Defense met with
participants of the Working Group and was aware of concerns reflected in the comments made
by the senior military lawyers. 984
(U) On March 6, 2003, the Working Group circulated another version of its report
entitled "Working Group Report on Detainee Interrogations in the Global War on Terrorism:
Assessment of Legal, Historical, Policy and Operational Considerations."
_ According to the Church Report, when circulated, the March 6, 2003 version was
considered final, but at some point, it was later re-characterized as a draft. 985 Over the objections
ofthe military lawyers, all 36 techniques from the February 4,2003 draft report remained a part
ofthe Working Group's recommendations and were included in the March 6, 2003 report. 986
The three techniques that the Working Group could not evaluate fully also remained in the
March 6, 2003 report, but were not recommended for approval. 987 By March 6, 2003, the
Working Group still "had not received adequate information" regarding these three techniques,
including two that had been approved by the Secretary in December 2002, to conduct a "legal or
policyanalysis.,,988
(U) Upon receiving the March 6, 2003 version, senior military lawyers continued to raise
concerns that the recommendations were based on a flawed OLC legal analysis. One JAG noted
that the draft report's introduction, which said it was '''informed' by [the] OLC opinion ...
create[d] an incorrect impression" since "[m]ost (if not all) working group members and TJAGs
disagree[d] with significant portions of [the] OLe opinion, but were forced to accept it.,,989 The
military lawyers also continued to express the view that the recommended techniques would
expose American soldiers to potential prosecution; would invite reciprocal treatment of captured
U.S. personnel; could affect the admissibility of detainee statements in criminal prosecutions,
including military commissions; and were not proven to result in obtaining reliable information
from those being interrogated. 990
984 Committee staff interview of William J. Haynes IT (April 25, 2008) at 263.
986_
985 Church Report at 5.
"An additional caution was incorporated into the March 6, 2003 recommendations regarding technique
36~terboard: 'As a matter of policy, technique 36 should be used only in instances of extreme necessity.
Some members of the working group believed that it should not be used by U. S. Armed Forces personnel.'" Church
Report at 34; Working Group draft report (March 6, 2003) at 68-69.
987 Working Group draft report (March 6,2003) at 68-69.
988 Ibid.
989 Email from Col James Walker to Daniel Ramos (March 10,2003).
990 Church Report at 134-135.
General Counsel for International Affairs Eliana Davidson stating that "we must have
interrogation technique approval immediately and will speak to Mr. Wolfowitz about this. The
hallmark is isolation and up to 20 hour interrogation. Without that we can't be successful in the
community environment. We need commitment from the senior leadership to let us do this
mission. ,,991
_ Three days later, LTC Beaver followed up with the General Counsel's office,
stating that MG Miller "was informed by DEPSECDEF that we would have interrogation
techniques (isolation and up to 20 hours) approved by Wednesday [February 19,2003]. We
hope this happens.,,992
IIA
month later, on March 12,2003, a Deputy Staff Judge Advocate at SOUTHCOM
sent LTC Beaver an email informing her about a March 11, 2003 meeting that was attended by
Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, SOUTHCOM Commander GEN James Hill, and
Chairman ofthe Joint Chiefs of Staff (CJCS) Gen Richard Myers, where interrogation
techniques were discussed. 993 According to the Deputy SJA at SOUTHCOM, during the
meeting, Gen Myers, raised a concern that some ofthe techniques discussed for GTMO "could
be illegal depending on how far they were used.,,994 The Deputy SJA informed LTC Beaver that
GEN Hill "promised the Chairman a paper discussing the techniques we want" and that
SOUTHCOM wanted to get a draft memo to GEN Hill by close of business March 20,2003. 995
LTC Beaver forwarded the email to DoD Associate Deputy General Counsel Eliana Davidson
and told her "This email is not good news. It appears something went wrong.,,996 Ms. Davidson
replied that Mr. Haynes had been at the meeting where interrogation techniques were discussed
and that she was trying to get some clarification on the meeting. 997
_ On March 21, 2003, GEN Hill sent a memorandum to Gen Myers regarding the
interrogation techniques that had been rescinded in January. While MG Miller's January 21,
2003 letter to General Hill had listed only nine Category II techniques as "essential," General
Hill's March 21, 2003 memo stated that both he and MG Miller felt that approval of all ofthe
previously authorized techniques (in Categories I, II and III) was "essential.,,998 General Hill
stated that"both Geoff Miller and I believe that we need as many appropriate tools as possible"
and called Category II and the one previously authorized Category III technique "critical to
maximizing our ability to accomplish the mission, now and in the future.,,999 The "critical"
techniques referred to by General Hill included stress positions, deprivation oflight and auditory
991 Email from LTC Diane Beaver to Eliana Davidson (February 12, 2003).
m Ibid.
993 Email from COL Terrence Farrell to LTC Diane Beaver (March 12, 2003).
994 Ibid.
99' Ibid.
996 Email from LTC Diane Beaver to Eliana Davidson (March 13,2003).
997 Email from Eliana Davidson to LTC Diane Beaver (March 13, 2003).
998Memo from GEN Hill to Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Information on Interrogation Techniques (March
21,2003).
999 Ibid.
stimuli, removal of clothing, use of detainee phobias such as dogs, and the one Category III
technique the Secretary had authorized, which included grabbing, poking, and light pushing.
_ Prior to issuing a final report on April 4, 2003, members ofthe Working Group
again sought infonnation from JPRA on SERE techniques. The JAG of the Air Force, Maj Gen
Thomas Fiscus, and two other military officers, visited JPRA and were briefed on SERE physical
pressures. IOOO At the briefing, JPRA described its previous support to "high value target"
interrogations, discussed the processes and procedures used in SERE training, and reviewed the
"application of physical pressures in an operational environment. ,,1001 JPRA Chief of Staff
Daniel Baumgartner told Maj Gen Fiscus that JPRA had previously provided information on
techniques used in SERE schools to DoD Deputy General Counsel Richard Shiffrin. 1oo2
F. The Working Group Finalizes Its Report and the Secretary ofDefense Issues a
New Interrogation Policy For GTMO (U)
II On March 28, 2003, the Secretary of Defense met with a number of senior advisors
including Deputy Secretary Paul Wolfowitz, DoD General Counsel Jim Haynes, and Chairman
ofthe Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen Richard Myers, to discuss the interrogation techniques being
considered by the Working Group. 1003 After that meeting, the Secretary decided to expressly
authorize 24 interrogation techniques, including five that were not listed in the Army Field
Manual (one ofthese five was classified as an "exceptional" technique). 1004
The Joint Chiefs of Staff met on March 31,2003, and were briefed about Secretary
Rumsfeld's decision. According to CAPT Dalton, the Legal Counsel to the Chairman ofthe
Joint Chiefs of Staff, the "Chiefs recognized that the approved strategies would not hamper the
combatant commander in the accomplishment of his mission, because the door was o~en to
request additional strategies on a case-by-case basis if needed in compelling cases.,,10 S
_ The last and final version ofthe Working Group report was issued on April 4,
2003. The report was similar to the March 6, 2003 version, except that it did not recommend
waterboarding or list the three other exceptional techniques that the Working Group could not
evaluate fully - stress positions, deprivation of light and auditory stimuli, and water
130
immersion/wetting down. 1006 At the direction ofthe DoD Principal Deputy General Counsel
Daniel Dell'Orto, the April 4, 2003 report was not circulated to the participants of the Working
Group. 1007
(U) In fact, when it came to finalizing the report, some participants of the Working Group
who had raised objections to the report were excluded from the process and did not even know
that the report had been completed. 1008 According to Alberto Mora, the Navy General Counsel,
"Neither I, [the Navy Office ofthe General Counsel], nor - to my knowledge - anyone else in
the [Department of Navy] ever received a completed version ofthe Working Group report. It
was never circulated for clearance. Over time, I would come to assume that the report had never
been fmalized.,,1009 Mr. Mora said that he only learned ofthe final report nearly a year later
while watching a "televised congressional hearing on the Abu Ghraib scandal."lOlO
_ On April 5, 2003, Gen Myers forwarded a memo proposing that the Secretary of
Defens~ze24 ofthe interrogation techniques reviewed during the Working Group
process. 1011 In response, Marshall Billingslea, the Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of
Defense for Special Operations/ Low-Intensity Conflict sent a memo to the Secretary of Defense
raising concerns about the omission of certain techniques and recommending that the Secretary
approve all 35 techniques "endorsed by the Working GrOUp.,,1012 Mr. Billingslea's memo stated:
The current memo omits some interrogation techniques that are not controversial
from either a legal, or policy standpoint. For instance, blindfolding ('hooding'),
lightly touching a detainee, and threatening transfer to a 3rd country all seem
reasonable techniques to approve.
The draft memo also omits some techniques which the Working Group found to
be legally-permissible, but which should 'be done only with appropriate oversight.
While the Working Group felt that the Combatant Commander could approve
these measures, we recommend requiring that you be notified prior to their use.
1006 Department of Defense, Working Group Report on Detainee Interrogations in the Global War on Terrorism:
Assessment ofLega~ Historica~ Policy, and Operational Considerations (April 4, 2003).
131
(U) On April 16, 2003, the Secretary of Defense authorized the Commander of
SOUTHCOM to use 24 interrogation techniques. 1014 Of the 24 techniques, four - Mutt and Jeff,
incentive/removal of incentive, pride and ego down, and isolation - required that the
SOUTHCOM Commander make a determination of "military necessity" and notify the Secretary
in advance of using them. lOIS The Secretary authorized the use ofthe other 20 techniques with
all detainees at GTMO so long as GTMO personnel adhered to certain safeguards. Those
authorized techniques included dietary manipulation, environmental manipulation, sleep
adjustment, and false flag, none of which were listed in the Army Field Manual.
(U) In addition to expressly authorizing the 24 techniques listed in his April 16, 2003
memorandum, Secretary Rumsfeld wrote in his memo: "If, in your view, you require additional
interrogation techniques for a particular detainee, you should provide me, via the Chairman of
the Joint Chiefs of Staff, a written request describing the proposed techni~ue, recommended
safeguards, and the rationale for applying it with an identified detainee."l 16
(U) CAPT Dalton told the Committee that all ofthe techniques recommended by the
Working Group were available for request. 1017 That understanding was shared by the Joint
Chiefs, who she said believed that the door was open to request additional strategies on a case
by-case basis ifneeded in compelling cases. ,,1018 The GTMO Commander would soon seek and
receive authority to use additional techniques that went beyond the 24 expressly approved in the
Secretary's April 16, 2003 memo.
1013 Ibid.
Memorandum from Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld to GEN James T. Hill, Counter-Resistance
1014
Techniques in the War on Terrorism (April 16, 2003) (hereinafter "Secretary Rumsfeld to GEN Hill (April 16,
2003)").
101' Secretary Rumsfeld to GEN Hill (April 16,2003).
1016 Ibid
1017 Committee staff interview ofRADM Jane Dalton (April 10,2008) at 225.
1018 Memo from RADM Jane Dalton to VADM Church, Requestfor Information (August 10, 2004) at 5.
1019 Memo for Record from ACS Contractor, Possible Inappropriate Activities (undated).
132
II
On May 2, 2003, MG Miller directed the Director ofthe Joint Intelligence Group
(JIG), John Antonitis, to "cease ofthe use of the 'Fear-Up Harsh' interrogation technique," and
said the inquiry had identified a need for re-training and corrective action to "ensure
[interrogators1 understand the approved interrogation techniques and practices and their
+~t
Itmll410ns. " 1d2S '
II
The memo said the inquiry was too limited and found that the disciplinary action "did
not address the command failures that allowed such activity to take place, despite apparent
command sanctionin ofthe incidents.,,1027 In fa the Commander's in ui failed to
lOll Ibid
1023 Ibid
1024 Ibid at 2.
ll)z~ Memo from MG Geoffre Miller for Commander USSOUTHCOM, Commander's Inquiry, Allegation of
Inhumane Treatment 0 (May 3, 2(03).
1026 Memo, Historic Look at Inappropriate Interrogation Techniques Used at GTMO (undated) (hereinafter
"Historic Look at Inappropriate Interrogation Techniques ").
1027 Ibid.
1028An April 2003 Memorandum for Record drafted by a contractor at GTMO alleged the technique was used on
several occasions, including in late March 2003 as well as on April 7, 2003, and April 17, 2003. Memo for Record
from ACS Contractor, Possible Inappropriate Activities (undated).
133
Advanced Media Group Page 216 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 235
Page
of 2413
236 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
"making sexual affiliated movements with her chest and pelvis while again speaking sexually
oriented sentences.,,1029
(U) The second incident involved a female military interrogator who wiped what she told
the detainee was menstrual blood on a detainee's face and forehead. l033
II
The "Historic Look at Inappropriate Interrogation Techniques Used at GTMO" memo
found that there was "no clear information indicating disciplinary action for the 'lap dance' and
simulated blood incidents.,,1034 .
II
The same memo concluded that ''the incidents occurring during the Spring of 2003
signif[ied] a consistent problem at GTMO. ,,1035 It stated that it was "clear" that interrogators
"may use several ifnot all ofthe techniques that require SECDEF notification.,,1036 The memo
also concluded that "interpretation ofthe SECDEF approved techniques has resulted in
variations on how techniques are applied (i.e., is yelling, loud music and strobe lights
environmental manipulation?)" and "[d]espite these revelations by interrogators, the supervisory
chain of command reports that these techniques are not used.,,1037 An FBI Special Agent serving
at GTMO stated that ''there was a time period where the interrogations were obtrusive enough
that the interview rooms for an entire trailer were not available if one ofthese techniques were
bemgu liZ ed .,,1038
t'l'
Other contemporaneous documents indicate that in addition to the use of strobe lights
and loud music, techniques such as forced shaving, sensory deprivation and even implied threats
1029 Ibid
1030 Historic Look at Inappropriate Inte"ogation Techniques at 2.
1031 Ibid
1032 Ibid.
1033 Ibid
1034 Ibid.
103~ Ibid
1036 Ibid
1037 Ibid. at 3.
1038 Email from FBI Special Agent (July 14, 2004).
134
.
of death were either used or planned for use in specific ITF-GTMO interrogations even after MG
~ .
B. Special Interrogation Plans Modeled on Khatani Interrogation (U)
(U) Despite their repeated objections, law enforcement had been unable to stop ITF
GTMO from proceeding with its aggressive interrogation of Mohammed al Khatani in November
2002. An FBI Special Agent told the Committee that law enforcement believed at the time that
the Khatani interrogation would defme the conduct of future interrogations at GTMO. 1039
Documents relating to ITF-GTMO's plans for interrogating other high value GTMO detainees
substantiated the belief of the FBI Special Agent
_ A memo dated on January 16, 2003 - the day after the Secretary of Defense
rescinded interrogation techniques he had previously authorized for GTMO - described a plan
for the interrogation ofMohamadou Walid Slahi. While Slahi's interrogation does not appear to
have begun until July 2003, the January 16,2003 memo described specific techniques ITF
GTMO intended to use in his interrogation, many of which mirrored those used in the Khatani
interrogation. For example, the memo stated that interrogations would be conducted for up to 20
hours per day on Slahi, just as they had been for Khatani. 1040 The memo said that interrogators
could pour water on Slahi's head to "enforce control" and "keep [him] awake.,,1041 Interrogators
had also poured water over Khatani's head as a "method of asserting control.,,1042
The January 16,2003 memo stated that "K-9 dogs can be present and made
to bark to agitate [Slahi].,,1043 Similarly, military workingdogs had been used in Khatani's
interrogation ''to agitate the detainee and provide shock value."1044 The presence of dogs in the
Slahi memo is notable as MG Miller said that, months earlier, he had "rejected [using dogs in
interrogations] as an acceptable technique" and that dogs "were not to be used during active
interrogation" 1045
The January 16, 2003 memo also described techniques directed at breaking
down Slahi's ego, including ridiculing him, making him wear a mask and signs labeling him a
"liar," a "coward," or a "dog."1046 The memo stated that interrogators would also instruct Slahi
135
to bark and perfmm dog tricks "to reduce the detainee's ego and establish control."1047 Khatani
had also been forced to wear a dog collar and perform dog tricks, and interrogators had placed
signs on him such as "liar," "coward," and "dog.,,1048
The January 16,2003 memo described shaving Slahi's head and beard,
making him wear a burka, and subjecting him to strip search ''to reduce [his] ego by assaulting
his modesty.,,1049 Likewise, ITF-GTMO interrogators had shaved Khatani's head and beard and
he had also been strip searched. 1050
The memo stated that Slahi would be denied the opportunity to pray and
described techniques to exploit "religious taboos," such as using a female interrogator in "close
physical contact."IOSl The memo also stated that interrogators would play music to "stress
[Slahi] because he believes music is forbidden" and that light in Slahi's interrogation booth
would be filtered "with red plastic to produce a stressful environment.,,10S2 Khatani had also
been denied ~rayer and a female interrogator touched him during his interrogation to increase his
stress level." 053 Khatani too had been isolated, a red filter was placed over the light in his
interrogation booth, and music was used in his interrogation to create stress. 1054
_ The January 16, 2003 memo indicated that ITF-GTMO interrogators planned
to make use ofa completely white room during Slahi's interrogation "to reduce outside stimuli
and present an austere environment," that interrogators would use a strobe light in his
interrogation booth to "disorient [Slahi] and add to [his] stress level," and that a hood would be
placed on Slahi in the booth" ''to isolate him and increase feelings of futility. ,,1055
136
2003 memo and stated that ''the single most important aspect ofthese techniques is the initial
shock ofthe treatment... [the] detainee will have the perception that his situation has changed
drastically and that life can still become worse than what he is experiencing. ,,1057
_ The first three to five days of interrogation were planned for Camp Delta. 1058 If
Slahi was not cooperative, the plan proposed that military police in full riot gear take him from
his cell, place him on a watercraft, and drive him around to make him think he had been taken
off ofthe island. In reality, Slahi would be taken to Camp Echo where the interrogation was to
continue. A memo describing that part of the plan said that military police working dogs would
be used during his movement to "assist developing the atmosphere that something major is
happening and add to the tension level ofthe detainee.,,1059
_The
Michael Gelles, had said that the idea of inducing the Stockholm syndrome implied that "the
subject feels that he is to be killed and the information provided may in fact be distorted.,,1062
GTMO plan stated that, while in the interrogation room at Camp Echo,
Slahi would sit in a basic chair and "be shackled to the floor and left in the room for up to four
hours while sound is playing continually.,,1063 His time in the room was intended to "disorient
him and establish fear ofthe unknown" and emphasize to Slahi that '''the rules have changed'
and nobody knows he is there."I064 The practice of shackling him to the floor and subjecting
him to loud music was to be repeated over several days, interrupted by actual interrogations.
Slahi was to be permitted four hours of sleep every sixteen hours. 1065
_ The plan stated that an interrogation room would be "modified in such a way
as to reduce as much outside stimuli as possible. The doors will be sealed to a point that allows
no light to enter the room. The walls may be covered with white paint or paper to further
137
eliminate objects the detainee may concentrate on. The room will contain an eyebolt in the floor
and speakers for sound.,,1066 The plan said that the "interrogation team will make detainee feel
_On
psychologically uncomfortable, emotionally uncomfortable, assert superiority over detainee,
escalate stress, play loud music, and continue to condition detainee to menial tasks.,,1067
II On July 24, 2003, Marshall Billingslea, the Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of
Defense for Special Operations / Low-Intensity Conflict (SOLIC), forwarded a memo notifYing
the Secretary of Defense that JTF-GTMO intended to isolate Slahi and recommending that he
approve the use of "sleep deprivation" and "sound modulation at decibel levels not harmful to
hearing.,,1070 A handwritten note on the memo stated that "OGC concurs that this is legal. We
don't see any policy issues with these interrogation techniques. Recommend you authorize.,,1071
Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz approved the memo on July 28,2003 and
forwarded it to Secretary Rumsfeld, who added his approval on August 13, 2003. 1072
~ The Slahi plan stated that it would "not be implemented until approved by
higher authority." 073 Despite that statement, memoranda for the record suggest techniques for
which JTF-GTMO sought authority were used at least a month before the Secretary's written
approval.
3. Interrogation Begins Before Special Interrogation Plan Is Approved (U)
IISeveral memoranda for the record documenting Slahi's interrogation were written by
JTF-GTMO personnel in July and August 2003. These memoranda indicate that at least one
technique for which JTF-GTMO sought authority to use with Slahi, i.e., sound modulation, was
used before written authority was actually granted by the Secretary of Defense. 1074 The
1070 Memo from Marshall Billingslea to Secretary of Defense, Mohamadou Walid Slahi. (July
24,2003).
1071 Ibid
1072 Ibid
1073 ISN 760 Interrogation Plan (July I, 2003) at 3.
1074 Memo for Record, OUHAMADOO OULD SLAHI// (July 17, 2003).
138
memoranda also suggest the use of some techniques, such as forcing Slahi to stand for prolonged
periods, for which no re~uest for authority from SOUTHCOM or OSD appears to have been
made by ITF_GTMO. 107 In addition, while MG Miller had, more than two months earlier, said
that interrogators were not to use the fear up harsh approach, the memoranda indicate that
increasing Slahi's level offear was an integral part of his interrogation and that one interrogator
even implied to Slahi that he could be tortured or killed.
III The memoranda indicate that, on several occasions from July 8 through July 17, Slahi
was interrogated by a masked interrogator called "Mr. x." On July 8, 2003 Slahi was
interrogated by Mr. X and was "exposed to variable lighting patterns and rock music, to the tune
of Drowning Pool's 'Let the Bodies Hit [the] Floor'. ,,1076 On July 10, 2003 Slahi was placed in
an interrogation room handcuffed and standing while the air conditioning was turned off until the
room became "quite warm.,,1077 The next day, Slahi was brought into the interrogation booth
and again remained standing and handcuffed while the air conditioning was again turned off. 1078
After allowing Slahi to sit, the interrogator later ''took [Slahi's] chair and left him standing for
several hours." 1079 According to the memo, Slahi was ''visibly uncomfortable and showed signs
of fatigue. lbis was 401 day of long duration interrogations.,,1080
(U) On July 17, 2003, the masked interrogator told Slahi about a dream he had had where
he saw "four detainees that were chained together at the feet. They dug a hole that was six feet
long, six feet deep, and four feet wide. Then he observed the detainees throw a plain, unpainted,
pine casket with the number 760 [Slahi's internment serial number (lSN)] painted on it in orange
on the ground.,,1081
_ On August 2, 2003 an interrogator told Slahi ''to use his imagination and think up
the worst possible thing that could happen to him" and asked him "what scares him more than
anything else.,,1082
(U) That same day, the interrogator told Slahi that to ''use his imagination to think up the
worst possible scenario he could end up in.,,1083 The interrogator told Slahi that "beatings and
physical pain are not the worst thing in the world. After all being beaten for a while, humans
tend to disconnect the mind from the body and make it through. However, there are worse things
-than physical pain.,,1084 The interrogator told Slahi that he would ''very soon disappear down a
107' Memo for Record, G1MO-0598~OUH.AU4DOO OULD SLAB/// (July 10, 2003).
1076 Memo for Record, G1MO-0598~OUHAMADOO OULD SLAB/// (July 17, 2003).
1077 Memo for Record, G1MO-0598_0UHAMADOO OULD SLAB/// (July 10, 2003).
1078 Memo for Record, G1MO-0598~OUIi4MADOO OULD SLAB/// (July 11, 2003).
111'79 Memo for Record, G1MO-0598.-..uOUH.AU4DOO OULD SLAB/// (July 11, 2003).
1080 Ibid.
1081 Schmidt-Furlow Report at 24.
1082 Memo for Record, G1MO-0598~OUH.AU4DOO OULD SLAB/// (August 2, 2003).
1083 DoJIG report at 123
1084 Schmidt-Furlow Report at 25.
very dark hole. His very existence will become erased ... no one will know what happened to
him and, eventually, no one will care.,,1085
(U) At one point in his interrogation, Slahi was also shown a fictitious letter that had been
drafted by the Interrogation Team Chief stating that his mother had been detained, would be
interrogated, and if she were uncooperative she might be transferred to GTMO. 1086 The letter
pointed out that she would be the only female detained at '"this previously all-male prison
environment.,,1087
~on August 7, 2003, Slahi informed an interrogator that he had made a decision to
cooperate. 088 After questioning Slahi, his interrogator "congratulated [him] on his decision to
tell the whole truth.,,1089
_An
October 17,2003 email from a JTF-GTMO interrogator to LTC Diane Zierhoffer,
a ITF-GTMO Behavioral Science Consultation Team (BSCT) Psychologist, stated that '"Slahi
told me he is "hearing voices' now... He is worried as he knows this is not normal .... By the way
... is this something that happens to people who have little external stimulus such as daylight,
lOS' Ibid
1086 DoJ IG report.
1087 Ibid
human interaction etc???? Seems a little creepy."I094 LTC Zierhoffer responded "sensory
deprivation can cause hallucinations, usually visual rather than auditory, but you never know ...
In the dark you create things out of what little you have ...,,1095 .
liThe view that the use ofthe aggressive techniques could affect Slahi's potential
prosecution turned out to be accurate. LtCol Stuart Couch, a military prosecutor assigned to the
Slahi case wrote in March 2004 that "prosecutors in our office are very concerned about the
allegations of detainee abuse at GTMO and Afghanistan, and we have individually taken steps to
address this issue. The techniques employed by the intelligence community in obtaining
information is a policy decision that obviously affects our prosecution efforts, yet we are
powerless to influence such activities."lloo After becoming aware ofinterrogations techniques to
which Slahi had been subject, LtCol Couch refused to participate in the prosecution. HOI
1094 Email from JTF-GTMO Interrogator to LTC Diane Zierhoffer (October 17, 2003).
109' Ibid
1096 Email from FBI Special Agent (December 5, 2003).
1097 Ibid
1098 Ibid
1099 FBI Electronic Communication from Counterterrorism MLDU to Counterterrorism (May 18, 2004).
Memo from LtCol Stuart Couch to Brigadier General Scott Black, Office o/Military Commissions Prosecution
1100
Operational Assessment (March 18, 2004).
1101 Committee staff interview of LtCol Stuart Couch (June 21, 2007).
Wolfowitz. 1102 MG Miller said that Deputy Secretary Wolfowitz was interested in the reports
and his office would occasionally call GTMO to inquire about particular detainees.
[CITF personnel will] not participate in any interrogation that violates this policy.
When CITF personnel are conducting a joint interrogation with another U.S.
government organization, and a member of that other organization employs
tactics that are, or appear to the investigator to be, inhumane or cruel and unusual,
the CITF personnel will immediately disengage from the interrogation, report the
incident to their CITF chain of command, and document the incident in a
memorandum for record. 1111
IllO DoD CITF', Memo for All Personnel Assigned to the DoD Criminal Investigative Task Force, Inte"ogation
Procedures Guidance (U) (October 3,2003).
1111 Ibid.
liiiiiiIIiIuestfor Approval ofIP for ,. MG Miller, Requestfor Approval ofIP for ISN
1114 Ibid at 4.
1115 Ibid.
1116 Ibid at 2.
1117 Ibid at 5.
1118 Ibid at 6.
1119 Ibid. at 7.
1120 Ibid at 11.
1121 MG Miller, RequestforApproval ofIPfor ISN at 2.
1122 Ibid at 8.
1123 Ibid. at 1.
1124 Ibid. at 7.
112~ Ibid.
1126 Ibid. at 9.
1127 Ibid. at 10.
1128 Ibid. at 9.
1129 Ibid. at 10.
145
II
Tom O'Connell, the Assistant Secretary of Defense for Special Operations / Low
Intensity Conflict (SOLIC), attached a cover memo to the SOUTHCOM Commander's request,
recommending to the Secretary of Defense that he approve the plans. 1132 A coordination sheet
attached to that memo indicated that Daniel Dell '0110, the Principal Deputy DoD General
Counsel, had approved the plan on December 31, 2003 and Chairman ofthe Joint Chiefs of Staff
Gen Myers had approved the plan on January 2, 2004. The date ofthe Chairman's approval (and
possibly that ofthe Deputy DoD General Counsel) occurred after the Office of Legal Counsel
(OLe) at the Department of Justice withdrew its March 14, 2003 legal memo upon which DoD
had been relying for interrogation techniques. 1133 The OLC's notification to DoD General
Counsel Jim Haynes ofthat withdrawal occurred between December 25 and December 31,
2003. 1134 Mr. Haynes told the Committee that "the fact that the Department didn't have that
opinion to rely on... didn't mean that Mr. Dell'Orto or somebody ... could not [have] concluded
that something was legal in the absence ofthat memo. ,,1135
x. DOJ Office of Legal Counsel Withdraws March 14,2003 Legal Opinion Governing
DoD Interrogations (U)
(U) In the final week of2003, the OLC notified the Department of Defense that the
March 14, 2003 OLC legal opinion, upon which DoD had been relying for interrogations, was
being withdrawn. 1136 According to the then-Assistant Attorney General for the OLe Jack
Goldsmith, the March 2003 memo was one ofa "short stack" of OLe opinions that his OLe
colleague Patrick Philbin had identified, shortly after Mr. Goldsmith arrived at DoJ, as
problematic and possibly containing "serious errors."ll37 Also included in that "short stack"
were the two August 1,2002 "Bybee" memos - the "First Bybee" memo, which presented
OLe's narrow interpretation of what constituted torture under U.S. law and the "Second Bybee"
memo, which included OLC's "advice to the CIA regarding potential interrogation methods. ,,1138
1131 Ibid .
1134 Assistant Attorney General Goldsmith stated that he called the DoD General Counsel between Christmas and
113~ Committee staff interview of William 1. Haynes II (April 25, 2008) at 295.
1137 Ibid. at 142; Committee staff interview of Jack Goldsmith (February 4, 2008).
1138 Committee staff interview of Jack Goldsmith (February 4, 2008); Sixth Decl. of Marilyn A. Dom, ~ 56,
American CiviLLiberties Union, et aL v. Department ofDefense, et aL, No. 04~Civ. 4151 (January 5,2007).
146
(U) After reviewing the opinions, Mr. Goldsmith identified two that he ultimately
rescinded, the March 14,2003 "oo Memo" (withdrawn in December 2003) and the August 1,
2002 "First Bybee" memo (withdrawn in June 2004).1139
(U) Mr. Goldsmith told the Committee that he called Jim Haynes in December 2003 and
told him the March 14,2003 OLC opinion was under review and could not be relied on by the
Department. 1140 That opinion had been presented to the Working Group as the controlling
authority for all questions of domestic and international law and was the legal foundation for the
Secretary's April 2003 authorization oftechniques for GTMO. Mr. Goldsmith told the
Committee that he informed Mr. Haynes in December 2003 that he had detennined that only 20
ofthe 24 techniques authorized b(' Secretary Rumsfeld were lawful, and that the remaining four
techniques were under review. 114 Mr. Goldsmith also advised Mr. Haynes in December that the
Department should come back to OLC for additional legal guidance before approving any
technique not among those 24 specifically identified in the Secretary's April 2003 memo. 1142
Mr. Goldsmith told the Committee that Mr. Haynes did not inquire about the use of additional
techniques during his tenure at OLC, which ended in June 2004. 1143
II
Notwithstanding the late December direction from the head of the OLC that DoD
could not rely on the March 14 2003 OLe memo a March 26 2004 memorandum for the record
su e ed that
1139 Assistant Attorney General Goldsmith said that his personal standard for rescinding prior OLC memos was to
rescind opinions only after he determined they were legally flawed and he could affumatively provide guidance on
"precisely what interrogation practices were legally available under a proper analysis." Goldsmith reiterated the
second part of this standard when asked ifhe considered withdrawing the third "problematic" opinion. known as the
"Second Bybee" memo. He told the Committee that he had not completed his analysis of the Second Bybee memo
by the time he submitted his resignation and left the Department. Committee staff interview of Jack Goldsmith
(February 4,2008); Goldsmith, The Terror Presidency at 152.
1140 In his book, Goldsmith stated that he placed the call between Christmas and New Years 2003. Goldsmith, The
Terror Presidency at 153.
In his interview with Committee staff, Mr. Goldsmith said he eventually determined that all 24 were lawful.
1141
That account differs slightly from Goldsmith's account in his book, in which he said that he told Mr. Haynes in
December that all 24 techniques were lawful. Ibid. at 154; Committee staff interview of Jack Goldsmith (February
4,2008).
1142 Committee staff interview of Jack Goldsmith (February 4,2008).
1143 Ibid.
1144 Schmidt-Furlow Report at 10.
1145 Memo for Record, Continuous Cell Transfer (Frequent Flyer Program) (March 26, 2004).
III Continuous cell transfer was discussed at least as early as August 2003. An August 3,
2003 email from GTMO's ICE Operations Officer described interrogating a detainee for 15
hours, allowing him 5 hours of uninterrupted rest in his cell and then moving the detainee to a
new cell every half hour until the 24 hour period expired whereby, according to the Operations
Officer the cycle would restart and "the fun begins again.,,1146
(U) According to an FBI agent who was on assignment to GTMO in fall 2003, the agent
received a briefing "that non cooperative detainees could be placed on a list for a specific
interrogation technique involving interruption of sleep pattern, called the 'frequent flyer
program.",1147 The agent stated that detainees were moved with all oftheir personal belongings
and that the duration ofthe program for detainees "seemed to depend on the cooperativeness of
the detainee.,,1148 In fact, an investigation by the Department of Justice Inspector General found
that "many FBI agents described a program of sleep disruption employed by the military as
designed to disorient detainees and thereby obtain their cooperation, which was known as the
'frequent flyer program.,,1149
(U) Keeping detainees awake except for a period of four-hours of uninterrupted sleep
using "Continuous cell transfer" or other means was not on the list of24 techniques OLC
advised the DoD General Counsel were permitted. The Committee is unaware of a request from
DoD to OLC for legal guidance on whether that technique comported with techniques on that list
of24 approved by the Secretary.
(U) Prior to that point, SMU personnel had observed interrogations conducted by
Combined Joint Task Force 180 (CITF-180), which had assumed control of U.S. and coalition
1146 Email from Maj. James Rogers to COL Jack Farr (August 3, 2003).
1147 FBI Electronic Communication from Administrative Services (SAAPU) to Inspection Division (July 15, 2004).
1148 Ibid.
1130"
1149 DoJ IG Report at 183.
Department of Defense, Interrogation Special Focus Team Report on Special Mission Unit Interrogation
Practices in Operation EndUring Freedom and Operation Iraqi Freedom (October 28, 2004) at 3 (hereinafter
"Church Special Focus Team Report"). As part of his investigation of detention operations and detainee
interrogation techniques, Vice Admiral Albert Church examined interrogation techniques used by SMU in the
USCENTCOM area of responsibility. VADM Church's main report, released in March 2005, did not discuss the
SMUs. Rather an Interrogation Special Focus Team, Wlder the auspices of VADM Church's review, issued a
separate, classified annex that discussed SMU interrogation practices in both Afghanistan and Iraq. Though
completed in October, 2004, the SMU annex was not provided to the Senate Armed Services Committee Wltil July
26,2006.
148
forces in Mghanistan at the end of May 2002. 1151 In addition to tactical questioning and
screening on the battlefield, CITF-180 personnel conducted more thorough interrogations at
detention facilities at Kandahar and Bagram. Between October 2001 and January 2003, the only
written guidance for interrogators operating in Mghanistan appears to have been Army Field
Manual 34-52. There were no Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs), however, to guide the
implementation ofthe doctrine outlined in the Field Manual.
1152 Memo for the Record, GITMO Assessment Visit (October 11, 2002)
1153 Ibid at 3; LTC Phifer to MG Michael Dunlavey, Request/or Approval of Counter-Resistance Strategies.
1154 Memo for the Record, GITMO Assessment Visit (October 11, 2002).
1m USASOC ReqUirement to Provide Exploitation Instruction (September 24, 2002); BSCT, Counter-resistance
Strategies.
1156 Memo for the Record, GITMO Assessment Visit (October 11, 2002)
for interrogators to have "SERE instructors' training for legal aspects of prisoner handling" and
stated that a "JPRA [Mobile Training Team] appears to be the best option" for the training. 1157
_ A memo entitled "Detainee Operations," dated October 27,2002 (the day after
the SMU TF proposal was briefed), described the SMU team's visit to GTMO as well as the
team's assessment of interrogation operations at Bagram. 1l63 With respect to operations at
GTMO, the memo stated that "Due to a lack of effective national-level guidance, the GTMO
staff is analogous to a weak. set of parents unsure oftheir role and parental skills who get
manipulated by elever and strong-willed children.,,1164 The memo stated that the SMU TF team
"assisted the [GTMO] staff in seeking advice and training from the JPRA staffregarding
effective interrogation techniques.,,1165
1H7 Ibid. LTC Beaver, the GTMO SJA, specifically recommended in her review of the October II, 2002 techniques
memo submitted by ITF-170 (GTMO) to SOUTHCOM, that "the interrogators be properly trained in the use of the
approved methods of interrogation," which included techniques similar to those used in SERE programs. LTe
Beaver, Legal Briefon Proposed Counter-Resistance Strategies at 5.
lU8 Church Special Focus Team Report at 6.
1H~ Battlefield Exploitation Proposal (undated) at 2.
1160 Ibid at 4.
1161 Ibid at 5.
1162 LTC Phifer to MG Michael Dunlavey, Requestfor Approval ojCounter-Resistance Strategies.
116.1 Memo, Detainee Operations (October 27,2002) at 1.
1164 Ibid.
116' Ibid. at 1-2.
1166 Ibid. at 2.
150
_ The October 27,2002 memo also outlined a rationale for the SMU to conduct
its own interrogations.
_ The SMU TF also developed a "Decision Briefmg" with the goal of gaining the
CITF-180 Commanding General LTG Dan McNeil's approval for the SMU TF to construct and
operate its own interrogation facility for high value detainees co-located at the Bagram
Collection Point. un The briefing stated that CITF-180 was focused on the detention mission
rather than the interrogation mission, that "no advanced interrogation techniques" including
"sensory deprivation/overload, sleep deprivation, psychological manipulation" were employed
by CITF-180, and that current procedures were having only "limited success[es].l173
_ While the SMU briefing noted that "advanced interrogation techniques" were not
in use at Bagram prior to November 2002, Army investigations into the deaths oftwo detainees
at Bagram in early December revealed that, by early December 2002, at least one ofthe
techniques, sleep deprivation, was apparently in wide use there.
1167 Ibid. at 3.
U69.
1168 Memo, Detainee Operations (October 27,2002) at 3.
Battlefield Detainee Exploitation CONOP (November 3, 2002).
1170 Ibid. at 5. It is not clear from the slides whether any of the interrogation training was formal or informal
training. There is no indication that any of the SMU personnel available for the mission had any formal DoD
interrogation or debriefmg training.
1171. Battlefield Detainee Exploitation CONOP (November 3, 2002) at 7-8.
un_Interrogations Operations Decision Briefing (undated).
U7'J Ibid.
policy at Bagram, Army investigators concluded that the use of stress positions and sleep
deprivation combined with other mistreatment at the hands ofBagram personnel, caused or were
direct contributing factors in the two homicides. 1174 In the wake ofthe deaths of Habibullah and
Dilawar, CITF-180 and the SMU TF began developing written standard operating procedures
(SOPs) for interrogations.
_On
C. Questions Raised About Task Force Participation in OGA Intt!n'ogations (U)
November 1, 2002, a month before the two detainee deaths at Bagram, the
SMU TF Staff Judge Advocate (SJA) analyzed legal authorities and constraints relevant to SMU
TF personnel's participation in interrogations 1175 The
SJA's analysis is reflected in a memo which was provided to the Committee in redacted fonn.
Although the particular interrogation techniques in use were redacted from the
version ofthe memo shared with the Committee, unredacted portions ofthat memo discuss the
SMU TF's concerns about those techniques. 1176
_Although the memo stated that while, in the author's opinion, "none ofthe
interrogation techniques used or observed by ~redacted] personnel constitutes 'torture,'" it also
stated that "another observer might disagree." 177 In addition, the memo stated that one ofthe
[redacted]. techniques "could rise to the level oftorture ifapplied in such a way and for such
a period of time that it rises to the level of severe physical pain or suffering. ,,1178 It also said that
"although the interrogation techniques may not constitute 'torture' they may rise to the level of
cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment proscribed by international law.,,1179
humane treatment of detainees and noted that although they might not apply to _ _
1174 U.S. Army Criminal Investigation Command Bagram Branch Office Memo, CID Report ofInvestigation
1175 Memorandum for [Redacted], Legal Analysis of[Redacted] Personnel Participating in Interrogation _ _
Detention Facility [Redacted] (November 1, 2(02) at 1 (hereinafter "Personnel Participating in Interrogation at
Detention Facility").
1176 Personnel Participating in Interrogation at _Detention Facility.
1177 Ibid at 4.
1178 Ibid. at 5.
1179 Ibid. at 2.
1180 Ibid. at 1.
1181 Ibid. at 4.
to the memo, '"these requirements arguably extend to military personnel even if 'detailed'
to_,1182
_ The memo warned that "we are at risk as we get more 'creative' and stray from
standard interrogation techniques and procedures taught at DoD and DA schools and detailed in
1182 Ibid.
1183 Ibid at 6.
1184 Memo from USSOCOM Staff Judge Advocate for the Naval Inspector General, Response to Questionsfor the
Record (U) (June 18, 2004).
Department ofDefense_Battlejield Interrogation Team Standing Operating Procedures (10 January
1185
2003); Church Special Focus Team Report at 7.
1186Two of those techniques - stress positions and sleep deprivation - were already in use by cm -180
interrogators prior to the approval of the SMU TF SOP. Church Special Focus Team Report and Committee staff
interview of CPT Carolyn Wood (February 8,2008).
1187 Church Special Focus Team Report at 8.
l1SS Church Special Focus Team Report, SecretaIy of Defense Approval of Counter-Resistance Techniques
(December 2, 2002).
Summary of Statement of SMU Member with Church Special Focus Team Report Investigator (September 15,
1189
2004).
the SMU SOP, an investigation completed by the Department of Defense Inspector General in
2006 concluded that the SMU SOP "was influenced by the counter-resistance memorandum that
the Secretary of Defense approved on December 2,2002.,,1190
_ The SMU TF Legal Advisor concluded that the interrogation SOP proposed for
use by the SMU was in accordance with their "guidance and constraints," and therefore, "legally
sufficient.,,1194 In addition, the Legal Advisor recommended that the SMU "continue to
approach CENTCOM for clarifying guidance on whether the techniques apparently approved for
use at GITMO by SECDEF ... are applicable or can become applicable for use in the CENTCOM
AOR [area ofresponsibility]. If so incorporate those Category II techniques that are deemed
necessary for [the SMU's] success.,,1195
154
directed the establishment ofthe DoD Working Group on Interrogations. 1196 As discussed
above, the Working Group requested that the Joint Staff provide a list of interrogation techniques
"currently in effect or previously employed in CENTCOM and SOUfHCOM, techniques the
combatant commanders have found to be effective, and techniques the combatant commanders
desire to implement with accompanying rationale.,,1197 CENTCOM sent the Working Group's
request to CITF-180 and, in response, the CITF-180 Deputy Staff Judge Advocate (SJA) LTC
Robert Cotell produced a January 24, 2003 memo describing "current and past" interrogation
techniques used byCITF-180 interrogatorsy98 LTC Cotell's memo was sent to the Working
Group and to the Office ofthe Secretary of Defense. 1199
_ In his January 24, 2003 memo, LTC Cotell identified interrogation techniques
used by CITF-180, including up to 96 hours of isolation; the use of female interrogators to create
"discomfort" and gain more information; sleep adjustment, defmed as "four hours of sleep every
24 hours, not necessarily consecutive;" use of individual fears; removal of comfort items; use of
safety positions; isolation; deprivation oflirt and sound in living areas; the use of a hood during
interrogation; and mild physical contact. 120
(U) LTC Cotell's memo included techniques that were among those Secretary Rumsfeld
had authorized for use at GTMO in December 2002. CITF-180 had obtained a list ofthose
techniques prior to LTC Cotell drafting his January 24,2003 memo. 1202
(U) ITF-GTMO's Interrogation Control Element (ICE) ChiefLt Col Ted Moss stated that
sometime in January 2003, CPT Carolyn Wood, the Officer in Charge (OIC) of the Intelligence
Section at the Bagram Collection Point asked ITF-GTMO about their "parameters" for
interrogation. 1203 According to Lt Col Moss, the GTMO Operations Officer faxed the Secretary
of Defense's December 2,2002 memo authorizing interrogation techniques to CITF-180. CPT
155
Wood said that, in early January, she saw a "secret power point presentation" containing the
techniques authorized for use at GTMO but did not recall where she had obtained the power
point presentation. 1204 Lt Col Moss did not know if JTF-GTMO had also sent CJTF-180 the
Secretary's letter that rescinded the use ofthose techniques. 1205
II In his January 24, 2003 memorandum, LTC Cotell, the CJTF-180 Deputy Staff Judge
Advocate acknowledged that the Secretary of Defense had rescinded authority to use similar
interrogation techniques at GTMO, stating that "[p]rior to their rescission, CJTF-180 used
selected techniques contained in SOUTHCOM's Cat II & III techniques ...,,1206
Notwithstanding that knowledge, however, the Church Report concluded that "in the absence of
any contrary guidance from CENTCOM, JCS, or OSD," CJTF-180 "considered the techniques in
their [January 24,2003] memo as available for use.,,1207 A summary of an interview with the
Deputy SJA at CENTCOM stated that ''the methodologies approved for GTMO... would appear
to me to be legal interrogation processes. [The Secretary of Defense] had approved them. The
General Counsel had approved them... I believe it is fair to say the procedures approved for
Guantanamo were legal for Mghanistan.,,1208
(U) In 2004, the Deputy Commander (Forward) U.S. Central Command LTG (later GEN)
John Abizaid stated that the January 24, 2003 memorandum had been '"thoroughly reviewed" by
the Working Group. 1209
III
Within three weeks ofthe January 24, 2003 memo, the SMU TF in Mghanistan
added the use of dogs to its interrogation policy.1210 Just over two months after the Secretary had
authorized dogs for use in interrogations at JTF-GTMO, the technique had become part of
interrogation SOPs for both the conventional forces and the SMU TF in Mghanistan.
1204 Army!G, Interview of CPT Carolyn Wood (August 15, 2006) at 15; Committee stafTinterview of CPT Carolyn
Wood (Febroary 11, 2008).
1205 Committee staff interview ofLt Col Ted Moss (October 17, 2(07).
1206 CJTF 180 Inten'ogation Techniques (January 24, 2(03) at 10.
1207 Church Special Focus Team Report, see also Church Report at 6 for an unclassified accounting of the January
24, 2003 CJTF -180 memorandum for CENTCOM and the Joint Staff.
1208 Summary of Church Report interview of CENTCOM Deputy Staff Judge Advocate (July 15, 2004).
1209 Memorandum from Deputy Commander (Forward) u.s. Central Command, Responses toRequestfor
Informationfrom VADM Church (August 6, 2004).
1210 Church Special Focus Team Report at 11.
1211 Memo for the Vice Chairman Joint Chief of Staff (April 11, 2003).
.The request came shortly after CAPT Jane Dalton, Legal Counsel for the Chairman of
the Joint Chiefs of Staff had informed Barry Hammill, CENTCOM's Deputy Staff Judge
Advocate (SJA), that the Secretary of Defense's guidance on interrogation techniques would
likely apply only to GTMO. 1212 CAPT Dalton had been informed by DoD General Counsel Jim
Haynes that he would only concur in providing the techniques to SOUTHCOM, not to
CENTCOM. 1213 CAPT Dalton recalled that CENTCOM had requested techniques in their
January 24,2003 memo and told CENTCOM's lawyers that she could ask the Chairman to
engage with the Secretary of Defense on their behalf, ifthey were interested in using the
techniques authorized for GTMO. 1214
_ In his memorandum to Gen Pace, dated April 11, 2003, LTG DeLong said that
CENTCOM understood that "OSD may be close to making a decision that would be unfavorable
to the use ofthe requested interrogation techniques at the [Bagram Collection Point]" and was
concerned that disapproval ofthe techniques requested by CITF-180 would "lead to mission
degradation."l2lS The memo noted that the Commander of ITF-180, LTG McNeill, had
"specifically endorsed" the CITF-180 request to use aggressive techniques, including individual
fears, black out goggles, deprivation of light and sound, sleep adjustment, threat oftransfer to
another agency or country, and safety positions. 1216 Lt Gen DeLong requested the assistance of
VCJCS Gen Pace "in ensuring OSD approval" for the requested techniques. 1217
(U) As previously described, for more than a year after the onset ofthe war in
Afghanistan, the only written guidance for interrogators appears to have been Army Field
Manual 34-52 (FM 34-52). When written policies were fmally established for interrogators in
Afghanistan in January 2003, those policies included some interrogation techniques that were not
listed in the Field Manual but had been previously authorized for use at Guantanamo Bay.
1212 Email from CAPT Jane Dalton to William Hammill, CAPT Shelley Young, William Gade (April 2, 2003).
1213 Memo from CAPT Jane Dalton to VADM Church, Requestfor Information (August 10,2004) at 5.
1214 Email from CAPT Jane Dalton to William Hammill, CAPT Shelley Young, William Gade (April 2, 2003).
1m Ibid.
1216 Ibid.
1217 Ibid
121S_Memorandum for A l I _ Personnel, Policy No. 1- Battlefield Interrogation Team and Facility
(BITIF) Policy (July 15, 2003) (hereinafter "BITIF Policy (July 15,2003)").
(U) By comparison, the Special Mission Unit (SMU) Task. Force (TF) in Iraq had an
interrogation policy in place before the beginning ofOIF. This policy was identical to the
February 2002 policy in use at the SMU Task Force in Mghanistan and reflected the influence of
techniques authorized for use at GTMO. 1219 The first policy to guide interrogations conducted
by conventional forces in Iraq, however, was not established until September 2003, more than
five months after that war began. That September 2003 policy was also influenced by techniques
authorized for use at GTMO.
(U) According to a review completed by the DoD Inspector General in August 2006, the
SMU TF based its first interrogation policy on the SOP used by the SMU TF in Mghanistan.
The DoD Inspector General stated:
At the commencement of Operation Iraqi Freedom, the special mission unit forces
used a January 2003 Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) which had been
developed for operations in Mghanistan. The Mghanistan SOP was influenced
by the counter-resistance memorandum that the Secretary of Defense approved on
December 2, 2002. . . and incorporated techniques designed for detainees who
were identified as 'unlawful combatants. 01223
_ Specifically, in February 2003, prior to the invasion of Iraq in March, the SMU
Task Force designated for operations in Iraq obtained a copy ofthe interrogation SOP in use by
the SMU personnel in Mghanistan, changed the letterhead, and adopted the SOP verbatim. 1224
This SOP, which included stress positions, sleep deprivation, and the use of dogs, governed
1219 Notwithstanding differences between the legal status of detainees held in Iraq and those in Afghanistan, the
SMU IF used the same interrogation approaches in both theaters. In addition, the cm -7 interrogation policies
included techniques that had been authorized for use at GTMO. By September 2003, interrogation approaches
initially authorized for a war in which the President had determined that the protections of the Geneva Conventions
did not apply, would be authorized for all U.S. forces in Iraq.
1DO Church Special Focus Team Report at 3.
1221
11 BITffi' Po&y (July IS, 2003).
1m DoD IG, Interview ofMG Keith Dayton (May 25, 2oo5)~eml Officer Questionnaire for
158
SMU interrogations in Ira~ from the start of Operation Iraqi Freedom in March 2003 until it was
replaced later that year. 122
interrogation policy drafted specifIcally by the SMU TF in Iraq. 231 The list of interrogation
techniques in that SOP included "vary comfort positions" (sitting, standing, kneeling, prone);
122~ . .Although the Church Special Focus Team Report concluded that the SOP the SMU IF had acquired
from its sister unit in Afghanistan before the invasion of Iraq remained in effect for the SMU IF in Iraq until it was
replaced on October 25, 2003, the Committee was advised that an unsigned July 15, 2003 SOP was in effect for the
SMU IF in Iraq. Church Special Focus Team Report at 12. Committee staff interview of SMU Legal Advisor 1
(May 29,2008).
1226 Email from CAPT Jane Dalton to CAPT Shelley Young and Mr. William Hammill (April 2, 2003).
1227_Memo from the"Legal Advisor to Staff Judge Advocate, USCENTCOM, Joint Task Forces"
Battlefield Interrogation Techniques (June 8, 2003); Church Special Focus Team Report at 12.
1128~Memo from the_Legal Advisor to Staff Judge Advocate, USCENTCOM, Joint Task Forces
attlefield Interrogation Techniques (June 8, 2003).
1229 Ibid.; Church Special Focus Team Report at 12.
1230 Message from CENTCOM Deputy Commander (June 10, 2003).
1231 BITIF Policy (July 15, 2003) at 1.
159
presence of mili~ working dogs; 20-hour interrogations; isolation; and yelling, loud music,
and light control. 12 2
(U) While the SOP described some techniques as having a "foundation" in Army Field
Manual 34-52, Lieutenant General Anthony Jones and Major General George Fay, who
conducted an investigation into the 205th MI Brigade at Abu Ghraib, described techniques in the
July 15, 2003 SMU SOP as "inconsistent with Army doctrine on detainee treatment or
. . . ,,1233
mterrogation tactics.
II( The SMU Counterintelligence and Human Intelligence officer (J2X) who
served at the SMU facility told the Committee that a list of authorized interrogations approaches
1232 Ibid. at 5.
BITIF Policy (July 15, 2(03) at 5; Review of Department of Defense Detention and Interrogation Operations,
1233
Senate Committee on Armed Services, 108th Cong., S. Hrg. 108-868 (May 7, 11, 19; July 22; September 9,2004) at
1294.
1236 Ibid
1237 Committee staff interview of SMU Legal Advisor 1 (May 29, 2008).
1238 The SMU IF Legal Advisor added that he would be surprised if the Committee found anything wi~
_ signature on it. Committee staff interview of SMU IF Legal Advisor 2 (March 12, 2008).
1239 Ibid
1240 Ibid
160
was posted on a wall at the SMU TF facility.1241 He specifically recalled stress positions, loud
music, light control, isolation, allowing a minimum amount of time for sleep, and military
working dogs as techniques authorized for use in interrogations. He stated that, although
military working dogs were not typically present at the SMU TF facility, he recalled making a
phone call to arrange for a military working dog to be present for an interrogation.
_( While neither the January 10,2003 nor the July IS, 2003 SMU policies
included "removal of clothin " there is evidence that it was used as an interrogation technique at
the SMU TF. who took command at the SMU TF in October 2003,
stated that when he arrived on site he "discovered that some ofthe detainees were not allowed
clothes" as an interrogation technique ''to gain control over the detainee.,,1242
stated that he did not know where the technique came from and that he was u~
stripping detainees even though "arguably, it was an effective technique.,,1243 _
said he terminated the practice in December 2003 or January 2004. 1244
_ However, the SMU TF Legal Advisor who served at the SMU T~ from
December 2003 until February 2004 stated that he attended a meeting called by _ _
_ in December 2003 or January 2004 to discuss the use of stripping prisoners as part of
interrogations. 1245 The Legal Advisor stated that stripping detainees gave him pause but said that
the technique was 'widespread" at that time. 1246 He said that he advised the Commander that, if
stripping were to be authorized, it should be limited to males only and that naked detainees
should not be paraded through the Task Force facility. The Le~thattwo SMU
TF behavioral scientists who also attended the meeting advised...__not to pennit
interrogators to strip detainees because of the implications of nudity in Arab culture. The Legal
Advisor stated that the Commander nevertheless decided at the meeting that the SMU TF would
continu~an interrogation techni~ Advisor stated that he
t h o u g h t _ m a y have said that he~ould have to approve its
use.
lIIsoth LTG Ricardo Sanchez, the Commander of Combined Joint Task Force 7 (CJTF
7), and COL Thomas Pappas, the Commander of the 20S th Military Intelligence Brigade (20S th
MI BDE) in Iraq told the Committee that they were unaware of what interrogation techniques
were authorized for use at the SMU TF facility.1247 Interrogators from the 20Sth MI BDE,
however, served at the SMU TF in support of interrogation operations there. In mid-June 2003,
at the request ofthe SMU TF, CJTF-7 assigned two Arabic-speaking interrogators to the
SMU. 1248 COL Pappas recalled sending a second set of approximately two to four interrogators
from the 20S th MI BDE to the SMU TF around November 2003 to replace the 20S th MI BDE
personnel already serving at the SMU. 1249
(U) According to LTG Sanchez, CITF-7 would have retained UCMJ authority over the
interrogators and the interrogators would have been re~uired to conduct interrogations under the
CITF-7 authorities rather than those at the SMU TF. 12S COL Pappas, however, believed that
once his interrogators were sent to the SMU TF, they were that they were bound by the rules of
the SMU TF and not CITF-7 interrogation guidance. 12S1
(U) MG Dayton told the DoD Inspector General that "as our interrogators started getting
into the swing of things at Camp Crogper... some ofthe prisoners were alleging that they had
been roughed up" by the SMU T ~ o nstated that his Joint Interrogation and
Debriefing Center (JIDC) Chie~haddescribed the situation as "a disaster
waiting to happen" and believed that ISG needed to "slam some rules on this place right away to
basically ke~ ourselves from getting in trouble and make sure these people are treated
properly. ,,12
1148 USCENTCOM to CDR CJTF7, CFC FRAGO 09-278 Arabic Linguist Interrogator SupportlDTG 141543Z
ruN 03 (June 14, 2003).
1249Committee staff interview of COL Thomas Pappas (October 12, 2007). An interrogator with the haq Survey
Group (ISG) who visited the Task Force facilities regularly recalled that at some point after June 2003 he saw
interrogators from the 323 n1 MI BN (which was also providing interrogators to Abu Ghraib) whom he knew as he
had trained some of them in Kuwait prior to the war. Committee staff interview of CWO Brian Searcy (June 4,
2007).
1150 Committee staff interview of LTG Ricardo Sanchez (December 20, 2007).
1151 Committee staff interview of COL Thomas Pappas (October 12, 2007).
1151 DoD IG. Interview ofMG Keith Dayton (May 25,2(05) at 10, 12, 19,30,52.
1153 DoD IG, Interview ofMG Keith Dayton (May 25,2005) at 18.
1154 Ibid. at 19.
1155 Statement of (August 9, 2(04).
162
told him that a detainee she was interrogating ha~ical abuse during his capture and
subsequent interrogation by SMU TF personnel. _ stated that "by mid-June 2003. a
pattern ofreports ofabuse of prisoners (abuse primarily attributed to [the SMU TF] during their
capture and interrogation of [high value targets] and other detainees, was coming to me...,,1256
liMO Dayton described what he called a "notorious case" ofalleged detainee abuse, in
which a badly burned detainee was brought to the ISO facility.1257 MG Dayton stated that
according to the "special forces guys," the detainee had been captured on a very hot day. was
thrown down on the metal floor on the Humvee, and during the long drive back from the
operation, the detainee had "burned himself lying on the floor ofthe Humvee.,,125S
(U) Throughout the summer and autumn of 2003, ISO personnel continued to be
concerned about the treatment of detainees by SMU TF personnel. stated that,
during the last week in June 2003, a British interrogator reported to him that a detainee who had
been captured and interrogated by the SMU TF 6'was beaten so severely, that he had the MPs at
Camp Cropper note the [detainee's] condition.,,1259 _ said he was told that the
detainee's "back was almost broken, his nose was probably broken, and he had two black eyes,
plus multiple contusions on his face.',1260
II According to the SMU TF Legal Advisor who served at the facility in July and
~ g one ofthe nightly briefmgs held at the SMU TF Joint Operations Center,
_ t h e SMU TF Commander, said "continue to work him over" and 66work him
hard" in reference to a particular detainee being interr~U TF. 1261 The Legal
Advisor said that about SO people were present w h e n _ m a d e that statement, that
he (the Legal Advisor) was concerned about the message it co~ subsequently
spoke to the Commander about it. The Legal Advisor said that~ade a similar
statement on a video teleconference,
12!6 Ibid. at 9.
1151 DoD 10, Interview orMO Keith Dayton (May 25, 2(05) at 20.
12J8 Ibid at 2I.
11511 Statement of (August 9, 2004) at 9.
1uoIbid.
1~1 Committee staff int.crview of SMU TF Legal Advisor I (May 29, 2008).
1262 DoD 10, Interview of MO Keith Dayton (May 25, 2005) at 50.
1161 Ibid. at 29.
163
Advanced Media Group Page 246 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 265
Page
of 2413
266 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
(U) LTO Sanchez stated that by July 2003, it was evident "that CJTF-7 was engaged in a
counterinsurgency operation that would be difficult if not impossible to win without significant
1266 Army IG, Interview of LTG Ricardo Sanchez (October 26, 2004) at 2-3.
1267 Ibid. at 10.
164
improvements in the intelligence capabilities of [CJTF_7].,,1268 LTG Sanchez said that he was
particularly concerned about his HUMINT capabilities, including the level of interrogation
expertise within CJTF-7, and that he "seriously questioned the training and experience of our
interrogators. 1269
(U) LTG Sanchez said he posed a challenge to his staff: "How do we ensure that we have
the right mechanisms in place that allow our interrogators to push the limit of our authorities yet
prevent a violation ofthe Geneva Convention and our duty to treat detainees humanely?,,127o He
said that "references to the [Field Manuals] and doctrine were common responses but the issues
being faced were beyond the scope ofthe Army's limited doctrine.,,1271 LTG Sanchez added that
there was frustration about the ability to get a handle on the insurgency and that he put a
tremendous amount of pressure on his intelligence officers. 1272
(U) The Commander of the 205 th Military Intelligence Brigade, COL Pappas, said that
soon after arriving in theater in July 2003, CJTF-7's Chief ofStaffBG Daniel Hahn directed him
1273
to attend a meeting to brief LTG Sanchez on interrogation operations. COL Pappas told the
Committee that he learned at that meeting that LTG Sanchez was concerned that interrogations
1274
had not generated the expected intelligence infonnation. COL Pappas said that LTG Sanchez
"believed that ifthe brigade improved its interrogation tactics, techniques, and procedures, that
we would get the information necessary to stop the insurgency.,,127S COL Pappas agreed and
told LTG Sanchez that his interrogators would need the authority to use additional interrogation
techniques to accomplish that goal. 1276
1168 Ibid at 5.
1269 Ibid at 6.
1210 Ibid at 7.
1171 Ibid.
1272 Committee staff interview of LTG Ricardo Sanchez (December 20, 2001).
1273 The cm -7 Commander, his senior staff, and division Commanders attended the meeting. Committee staff
interview of COL Thomas Pappas (October 12, 2001).
1274 Ibid.
127~ Army IG, Interview of COL Thomas Pappas (August 24, 2006) at 6.
1276 Committee staff interview of COL Thomas Pappas (October 12, 2001).
1277 DoD News Briefing (August 7, 2003).
1278 Army IG, Interview of CPT Carolyn Wood (May 8, 2006) at4.
165
Officer in Charge (OIC) at the facility.1279 In late 2002, she had served as the Interrogation
Operations Officer at the Bagram detention facility in Mghanistan.
(U) According to CPT Wood, no SOP was in place for interrogations when she took
command, but interrogations were conducted "within the approved ~proaches within the Field
Manual 34-52 only, with the possible addition of stress positions.,,12 0 CPT Wood stated that
interrogators had used sleep deprivation and stress positions in Mghanistan and that she
"perceived the Iraq experience to be evolving into the same operational environment as
Mghanistan,,1281 She said that she used her "best judgment and concluded [the techniques]
would be effective tools for interrogations at [Abu Ghraib].,,1282 She also said that she later put
together a request for additional interrogation options because "the winds of war were changing"
and there was "mounting pressure from higher for 'actionable intelligence' from interrogation
operations.,,1283 CPT Wood said that she did not want to repeat her experience in Mghanistan,
where interrogators lacked written guidance. 1284
A lot of the interrogators and analysts also served in Guantanamo Bay and
Mghanistan where some other techniques were approved for use ... I understood
the Mghanistan rules were a little different because the detainees were not
classified as EPWs. It was, ''use techniques in the spirit of the Geneva
convention," not, ''you will apply the Geneva Convention." In order to use those
similar techniques from GTMO and Mghanistan in Iraq, we sought approval from
the higher command. 1285
(U) COL Pappas, CPT Wood's superior officer, said he knew that CPT Wood believed
she needed additional techniques and told her to submit a request. 1286
12'19 Ibid at 3.
1280 Sworn Statement of CPT Carolyn Wood (December 17, 2004); Committee staff interview of CPT Carolyn
Wood (February 11, 2008).
1281 Sworn Statement of CPT Carolyn Wood (May 21, 2004).
1282 Ibid
1283 Ibid
1284 Committee staff interview of CPT Carolyn Wood (February 11, 2008).
128'Sworn Statement of CPT Carolyn Wood (December 17, 2004) at 3. Additionally, cm -7 Commander LTG
Sanchez said a key pwpose of his eventually issuing an interrogation policy was to regulate approach techniques
believed derived, in part, from techniques used in Guantanamo Bay and Afghanistan. Statement by LTG Ricardo
Sanchez to the Department of the Army Inspector General (October 2004) at 7.
1286 Committee staff interview of COL Thomas Pappas (October 12, 2007).
166
(U) On July 26, 2003, CPT Wood submitted a proposed interrogation policy to her chain
of command. The proposed policy was based on the interrogation policy in use at the SMU TF
facility in Iraq. 1287 CPT Wood said that she and her staff simply "cleaned up some ofthe
grammar, changed the headin~ and signature block, and sent it up" to CJTF-7 as a proposed
policy for the 519 th MI BDE. 1 88
IIMirroring the SMU TF policies, CPT Wood's proposed policy included sleep
management, ''vary comfort positions" (sitting, standing, kneeling, prone), presence of military
working dogs, 20-hour interrogations, isolation, and yelling, loud music, and light control. 1289
The proposed policy stated that "EPWs that refuse to answer may not be threatened, insulted, or
exposed to unpleasant or disadvantageous treatment of any kind.,,1290 The prohibition against
threats, insults and exposure to unpleasant or disadvantageous treatment, however, was limited to
EPWs and CPT W cod stated that, to her knowledge, there were no EPWs held at Abu Ghraib. 1291
(U) CPT Wood stated that submitting the proposed interrogation policy seemed a "natural
progression" to her as she understood the teclmiques were already approved for use at the SMU
TF in Iraq, and the policy was "similar to that ofa document that was drafted in Afghanistan for
the [Bagram Collection Point] as well as ... GTMO.,,1292 CPT Wood did not hear back from
CJTF-7 at that time. 1293 Just a few weeks later CJTF-7 itself solicited a "wish list" of
interrogation techniques.
1287 Army IG, Interview of CPT Carolyn Wood (May 8,2006) at 10. The Interrogation orc had received the policy
from one of her Chief Warrant Officers who had, in turn, received the policy from the LTC Robert Whelan,
Commander of the 519tb Ml BN.
1288 Army IG, Interview of CPT Carolyn Wood (May 8,2006) at 4; Committee staff interview of CPT Carolyn
Wood (February 11, 2008). CPT Wood explained that even though the memorandum was dated July 26,2003,
which was before she took over the position at Abu Ghraib, she thought that one of her Chief Warrant Officers
might have sent it up the chain knowing that she would be on board shortly.
1289 Memo from CPT Carolyn Wood to C2X, cm -7 (IRAQ) ABU GHURA. YB, Saddam Fedayeen Interrogation
Facility (SFIF) Detainee Interrogation Policy (July 26, 2003) (hereinafter "SFIF Interrogation Policy (July 26,
2003)"); see also BfflF Policy (July 15, 2003) at 3.
1290 SFIF Interrogation Policy (July 26, 2003) at 2.
1291 Sworn Statement of CPT Carolyn Wood (December 17, 2004) at 4.
1292 Army IG, Interview of CPT Carolyn Wood (August 15, 2006).
1293 Army IG, Interview of CPT Carolyn Wood (May 8,2006) at 10.
1294 Email from CPT (P) William Ponce Jr. to CS 165MI, HECC (August 14, 2003).
importantly, what techniques would they feel would be effective techniques that
SJA could review (basically provide a list). 1295
...The gloves are coming off gentleman regarding these detainees. Col. Boltz has
made it clear that we want these individuals broken. Casuahies are mounting and
we need to start gathering info to help protect our fellow soldiers from any further
attacks. 1296
(U) The Commander ofthe 205 th MI BDE, COL Pappas, said he thought that CPT
Ponce's email soliciting "interrogation techniques wish lists" was the result ofthe
meeting he attended with LTG Sanchez shortly after arriving in theater. 1297 He called the
Battle Captain's use ofthe ~hrase ''the gloves are coming off' a "dumb" thing to say and
a "poor choice of words.,,1 8 LTG Sanchez told the Committee that he expected his
intelligence staff to send out the request for interrogation techniques, but stated that the
use ofthe phrase ''the gloves are coming off' was "not good.,,1299 LTG Sanchez believed
that the email reflected frustration on the part of intelligence personnel at not being able
to meet his intelligence requirements.
(U) Chief Warrant Officer (CWO) Lewis Welshofer, who was with the 3rd Annored
Cavalry Regiment responded to CPT Ponce's email with his own assessment ofthe interrogation
situation:
Today's enemy, particularly those in [Southwest Asia], understand force, not
psychological mind games or incentives. I would propose a baseline interrogation
technique that at a minimum allows for physical contact resembling that used by
SERE schools (This allows open handed facial slaps from a distance of no more
than about two feet and back handed blows to the midsection from a distance of
about 18 inches. Again, this is open handed.) ...Other techniques would include
close confinement quarters, sleep deprivation, white noise, and a litany of harsher
fear-up approaches. . . fear of dogs and snakes appear to work nicely. I fIrmly
agree that the gloves need to come o:ff. I3OO
(U) Maj. Nathan Hoepner, the Operations Officer (S-3) ofthe 501 st MI Battalion took
issue with the language in CPT Ponce email, stating in an email of his own:
1295 Ibid.
1296 Ibid.
1297 Committee staff interview of COL Thomas Pappas (October 12, 2007).
1298 Ibid.; Sworn Statement of COL Thomas Pappas (January 25,2006) at 15.
1299 Committee staff interview of LTG Ricardo Sanchez (December 20,2007).
1300Email from CPT (P) William Ponce Jr. to CSI65MI, HECC (August 14, 2003). CWO Lewis Welshoferwas
later tried and convicted of negligent homicide and negligent dereliction of duty in connection with the November
26, 2003 killing of an Iraq detainee.
168
As for "the gloves need to come off... " we need to take a deep breath and
remember who we are. Those gloves are most defmitely NOT based on Cold War
or WWII enemies-they are based on clearly established standards of
international law to which we are signatories and in part the originators. Those in
tum derive from practices commonly accepted as morally correct, the so-called
"usages of war." It comes down to standards of right and wrong -something we
cannot just put aside when we find it inconvenient, any more than we can declare
that we will "take no prisoners" and therefore shoot those who surrender to us
simply because we find prisoners inconvenient.
"The casualties are mounting... " we have taken casualties in every war we have
ever fought-that is part of the very nature of war. We also inflict casualties,
generally more than we take. That in no way justifies letting go of our
standards. We have NEVER considered our enemies justified in doing such
things to us. Casualties are part of war-if you cannot take casualties then you
cannot engage in war. Period. BOTTOM LINE: We are American soldiers, heirs
ofa long tradition of staying on the high ground. We need to stay there. 1301
(U) CPT Wood said that two days after she submitted the proposed policy, two lawyers
from cm-7 visited Abu Ghraib with a copy of her memo. 130S According to CPT Wood, the
1301 Email from 4ID 104 MI ICE to various recipients (August 14, 2003) (emphasis in original).
1302 Sworn Statement of CPT Carolyn Wood (December 17, 2004) at 2.
1303 Memo from CPT Carolyn Wood to C2X, CJTF-7 (IRAQ), ABU GHURAYB, Saddam Fedayeen Interrogation
Facility (SF/F) Detainee Interrogation Policy (August 27, 2003) at 4.
1304 Ibid
Army IG, Interview of CPT Carolyn Wood (May 8, 2006) at 4; Committee staff interview of CPT Carolyn
1305
Wood (February II, 2007).
169
two attorneys said that "they did not see anything wrong with it and that they would add their
approval and forward it higher to CITF-7 for consideration and review.,,1306
(U) Techniques in CPT Wood's proposed policy can be traced back though the SMU TF
in Iraq to Mghanistan and, ultimately, to techniques authorized for use at GTMO by Secretary
Rumsfeld in December 2002. The GTMO techniques were, in tum, influenced by techniques
used by the Joint Personnel Recovery Agency and the military service SERE schools to train
U.S. personnel to resist illegal enemy interrogations. In the summer of2003, as CPT Wood was
seeking approval for her proposed policy, the SMU TF in Iraq was soliciting JPRA's advice on
interrogations.
_ On Aumst 25, 2003, the SMU Task Force in Iraq formally requested a JPRA
"interrogation team." 08 The request asked that JPRA send two or more individuals to the TF
for three weeks to "provide assistance to current interro ation efforts ofke . value
1ar~1309 On August 27, 2003,
_request for support, forwarded it to JFCOM, and asked that JFCOM task JPRA to
support the request. l3lO That same day, the JFCOM Operations Directorate (J-3) authorized
JPRA to provide the requested support to the SMU TF.
1306 Ibid.
1307 Memo from Lt Col Arlene McCue for the Force Judge Advocate, Results ofTelephordc Interview With Colonel
Randy Moulton, (USA Ret), former Commanding Officer, JPRA (Septem~fter "McCue,
Results!!Ilnterview with Colonel Moulton'''); Committee staff interview o f _ _ . _ ( O c t o b e r 10,
2007). The Chief of the Operational Support Office (OSO) at JPRA told the Committee that in the process of
ovi' defensive SERE trajping to Special Mission Units, JPRA personnel who had conducted offensive training
also consulted with the Special Mission Units to determine how they could be
helpful in training. Committee staff interview of Chris Wirts (January 4, 2007).
1308 Priority Message, Request JPRA Assistance in Interrogation Support, Date
Time Group (DTG) 252059Z AUG 03 (August 25, 2003).
1309 Ibid
~ t oHQ JPRA, Interrogator Support, DTG 272054Z AUG 03 (August 27, 2003); HQ
_ t o CDR USJFCOM, Requestfor Interrogator Support, DTG 271004Z AUG 03 (August 27,2(03).
170
complete the team, Mr. Wirts chose Lenny Miller, a contract SERE instructor who also lacked
interrogation experience but who the SMU TF had specifically requested. The team's
deployment date was set for September 1,2003. 1311
(U) Lt Col Kleinman said that, before being deployed, he thought he was being sent to
Iraq to identify problems in the TF interrogation program. 1312 More than a year earlier, Lt Col
Kleinman had drafted a paper identifying challenges faced by interrogators at GTMO. 1313 In the
draft paper, Lt Col Kleinman identified "fundamental systemic problems" at GTMO that
undermined operational effectiveness. 1314
._ Chiefamong the problems identified in the draft paper was the lack oftrained
personnel with experience in strategic interrogations. 131S Lt Col Kleinman recommended a
number of options in his draftRaper to enhance DoD's ability to conduct strategic interrogation,
including additional training. 1 16 He recommended having experienced "survival, intelligence,
and human factors specialists" conduct an "in-depth assessment" of operations at GTMO and
provide a "comprehensive reR0rt that would set forth concrete steps to improve operational
effectiveness and security.,,1 17 Lt Col Kleinman's paper did not recommend teaching
interrogators at GTMO how to use SERE techniques in interrogations and he said that he did not
believe that was the purpose ofthe Iraq trip. 1318 .
1311 Details of the three-week JPRA trip to Iraq are reflected in trip reports that Lt Col Kleinman and Mr. Russell
submitted ><upon their return from Iraq in late September 2003." Lt Col Kleinman's trip report is annotated with the
comments of Mr. Russell. See DoD IG Memorandum for the Record, 4 January 2005 Meeting with Mr. Lt Col
Steve Kleinman ~005) at 4; Memorandum from Mr. Terry Russell for Lt. Col. Reichert, Mr. Wirts,
JPRA Support to,--(undated) (hereinafter "Russell Trip Report"); Memorandum from Lt Col Steven
Kleinman, Trip Report - TDY to CENfCOMAOR. 1-24 Sep 03 (undated) (hereinafter "Kleinman Trip Report").
1312 Jane Mayer, The Dark Side (New York: Doubleday) at 246.
1313 Maj Steven Kleinman, Support to DoD Interrogation Operations (May 17, 2002).
1314 Ibid
131' Ibid at 1-2.
1316 Ibid at 4-6.
1317 Ibid at 5.
1318 Committee staff interview of Lt Col Steven Kleinman (March 14, 2008).
1319 (SIFP) CDR USJFCOM to HQ JPRA, Interrogator Support, DIG 272054Z AUG 03 (August 27, 2003).
1320 Committee staff interview of Col Randy Moulton (November 26, 2007).
171
previous "offensive" training sessions completed his assignment as the J3 at JFCOM in early to
mid-August and was replaced by RADM John Bird. 1321
(U) On September 4, 2003, just as the JPRA team was arriving in Iraq, Col Mouhon
emailed a JPRA "Weekly Report" to the JFCOM Command Group and others stating:
(U) In response, the JFCOM Deputy Commander LTG Robert Wagner, questioned
whether JPRA was operating within its charter. He wrote: "I'm not sure I see the connection
between your assigned responsibilities and this task ... [W]hat charter places JPRA in the
business of intelligence collection?,,1323 Col Moulton responded "There is nothing in our charter
or elsewhere that points us towards the offensive side of captivity conduct nor are we requesting
to take this on as a new responsibility.,,1324 He added, however, that JPRA had a role to play in
helping to educate and assist offensive operations, stating;
[Those conducting interrogations] have already demonstrated the need for our
understanding and knowledge of captivity environment and psychology. We are
also well aware of the problems associated with crossing the Rubicon into intel
collection (or anything close). There may be a compromise position (my gut
choice) whereby we could provide/assist in oversight, training, analysis, research,
and [tactics, techniques, and procedures] development, while leavin~ the actual
debriefmglinterrogation to those already assigned the responsibility. 132
(U) In a subsequent email to RADM Bird, Col Moulton stated that while he was
concerned about "mission creep" and departing too far from JPRA's traditional role, it was his
view that "no DoD entity has a firm grasp on any comprehensive approach to strategic
debriefmglinterrogation.,,1326 Col Moulton wrote:
1321 Committee staff interview of RADM John Bird (March 17, 2008)
1322Email from JPRA J2 to weekly report distribution list., JPRA Weekly Report (September 4, 2003). The JPRA
Commander also updated JFCOM in JPRA's subsequent weekly reports. See September II, 2003 Weekly Report
(the JPRA team "deployed to Baghdad continues to support [redacted] with strategic debriefmg.") September 25,
2003 Weekly Report (the JPRA team "deployed to Baghdad to support [redacted] with strategic debriefmg" returned
on September 24,2003.)
1323 Email from LTG Wagner to Col Moulton (September 6, 2003).
1324 Email from Col Moulton to LTG Wagner (September 8, 2003).
132' Ibid.
172
Our subject matter experts (and certain Service SERE psychologist[sD currently
have the most knowledge and depth within DoD on the captivity environment and
exploitation. I think that JPRAlJFCOM needs to keep involved for reasons of
TTP development and information sharing. Weare NOT looking to expand our
involvement to active participation. The current support was intended to be
limited to advice, assistance, and observation. Our potential participation is
predicated solely on the request ofthe Combatant Commander. 1327
(U) Col Moulton testified to the Committee that before he sent the JPRA team to Iraq he
talked to the SMU Task Force commander and was told that SMU TF detainees "were detained
unlawful combatants and not covered under the Geneva Conventions." 1328 Col Moulton later
said, referring to a subsequent call with the SMU TF Commander, that he did not know ifthe
SMU TF Commander had "specifically" told him that. 1329
~errence Russell the team also met that day with the SMU TF
C o m m _ and discussed expectations for the JPRA
team. 1334 Mr. Russell said that "expected [the JPRA team] to become fully
engaged in interrogation operations" and "encouraged [the team] to receive modified" rules of
engagement (ROEs) from JPRA, since their ROEs at that time permitted the team to "advise and
assist" but not to "engage in direct interrogations.,,133S
173
_ Over the next week, Lt Col Kleinman spoke by phone with Col Moulton at least
twice. While accounts by the three JPRA team members of those calls differed in some respects,
all agree that the calls resulted in Col Moulton (1) authorizing the team to participate in SMU
Task Force interrogations and (2) authorizing the team to use the full range of SERE school
physical pressures in those interrogations. Col Moulton confIrmed that the team's understanding
of his guidance was correct. 1336
_ _ _ _ _ Col Moulton said that, after getting the call from Lt Col Kleinman, he called.
~ o confIrm and inquire about the new request.,,1339 In s ~ sand
communications, Col Moulton has consistently stated that he relayedllllllllllllll.request
to JFCOM and got JFCOM's authorization to permit the JPRA team to participate in
interrogations. Col Moulton's recollection of who at JFCOM provided that authority, however,
has varied.
Commander, Col Moulton "relayed the request to the [JFCOM] J3 and got the verbal OK to
allow active participation, but only for one or two demonstrations and then the team was to go
(U) In a 2006 email to the DoD IG, however, Col Moulton could not recall exactly whom
at JFCOM he had spoken with, stating:
During the deployment I received a call from the Task Force commander
requesting that our personnel participate in the debriefIng. I notifIed JFCOM
leadership of the request (either BG Moore or LTG Wagner I can't remember, but
think it was [LTG] Wagner since this was late on a weekend night) and was told
that they could support, but that any activities had to be approved through the task
forces legal rep (we were chopped to them). 1341
_ In interviews with Committee staff in 2007, Col Moulton said that he had tried
but had been unable to reach BGen Moore, so instead he called LTG Wagner whom he reached
at home. 1342 According to that account, LTG Wagner told Col Moulton that he needed aEproval
from his boss, JFCOM Commander ADM Giambastiani, to approve the JPRA re~est. 13 3
According to Col Moulton, LTG Wagner called him back and gave his approval. 1 44
_ BGen Moore, whom Col Moulton referenced in his September 2005 interview,
was no longer assigned to JFCOM in September 2003. 1345 RADM Bird, who replaced BGen
Moore, stated that he did not recall receiving a call from the JPRA Commander. RADM Bird
said that he thought it unlikely he would have received the call on the weekend as it would have
had to have occurred over a secure line and he did not have that capability at home. LTG
Wagner told the Committee that he could not recall if he received a call from Col Moulton. 1346
_ According to Terrence Russell, one ofthe JPRA team in Iraq, the JPRA team
received permission from Col Moulton "to become fully engaged in all BIF operations.,,1347 The
next day, team members met with the SMU TF staff and "outlined the exploitation cycle and
how [the staff] could incorporate [SERE Training, Tactics, and Procedures] to support their
current interrogation operations.,,1348
While it is not known when it occurred, the Chief ofHuman Intelligence and
Counterintelligence (J-2X) for the SMU stated that members ofthe JPRA team demonstrated
interrogation techniques, including the "attention slap," which he said was described as an open
handed slap to focus the detainee on the interrogation, and walling, which was described as a
push up against the wall. 1349 The J-2X could not recall if all members ofthe JPRA team were
present during that lesson. 1350 Lt Col Kleinman said that he was not aware of such a lesson. 1351
1342 Committee staff interview of Col Randy Moulton (JlD'le 19, 2007); Committee staff interview of Col Randy
Moulton (November 26, 2007). LTG Wagner, however, to which the JPRA Commander referred had already left
JFCOM in August 2003, well before the JPRA team deployed to Iraq. In testimony to the Senate Armed Services
Committee, Col Moulton said that he was unable to reach RADM Bird or Maj Gen Soligan so he "went up the chain
and spoke with General Wagner." SASC hearing (September 25, 2008).
1343 Committee staff interview of Col Randy Moulton (JlD'le 19, 2007).
1344 Ibid
134' Committee staff interview of RADM John Bird (March 17, 2008).
1349 With the walling technique, the J-2X stated that instructions were given to use a wood wall and to pick a spot on
the wall in between any metal braces. Committee staff interview of SMU TF J2X (February 5, 2008).
175
II The J-2X stated that he was unsure if techniques taught to the staff were pennitted
under SMU TF policy and that, after the JPRA demonstration, he raised this matter with the
SMU TF J2, which at the time was 1352
(U) Lt Col (now Colonel) Kleinman described that same interrogation in testimony
before the Senate Armed Services Committee. Lt Col Kleinman said:
I walked into the interrogation room, all painted in black with [a] spotlight on the
detainee. Behind the detainee was a military guard... with a[n] iron bar...
slapping it in his hand. The interrogator was sitting in a chair. The interpreter
was - was to his left... and the detainee was on his knees ... A question was asked
by the interrogator, interpreted, the response came back and, upon interpretation,
the detainee would be slapped across the face... And that continued with every
question and every response. I asked my colleagues how long this had been going
on, specifically the slapping, they said approximately 30 minutes. 1355
(U) Lt Col Kleinman said that his two JPRA colleagues, who were present during
the interrogation, "didn't seem to think there [was] a problem, because in SERE
training... there's a facial slap, but it's conducted in very specific ways ... This was not
conducted in that fashion.,,1356 In fact, Lt Col Kleinman described the environment at the
Task Force facility as ''uncontrolled.,,1357
_ Members ofthe JPRA team had differing views on the appropriate response to the
interrogator's use ofthose techniques. Mr. Russell stated that he and Mr. Miller "saw nothing
wrong with" the interrogator forcing the detainee to kneel or his slapping the detainee during the
interrogation. 1358 Lt Col Kleinman had a different reaction.
_ Lt Col Kleinman considered forcing the detainee to kneel and repeatedly slapping
him to be "direct violations ofthe Geneva Conventions and [actions that] could constitute a war
crime." 1359 Upon witnessing the abusive conduct, Lt Col Kleinman sought out the SMU TF J
176
2X 1360 Lt Col Kleinman told the J-2X what he had witnessed and recommended ''that the
session be halted immediately.,,1361 Lt Col Kleinman said the J-2X told him "[y]our judgment is
my judgment. Do what you think. is right.,,1362
_ Following his conversation with the J-2X, Lt Col Kleinman asked the two
members of his team to step out ofthe interrogation booth. According to Mr. Russell:
In the hallway [Lt Col] Kleinman asked us our impression of the use of the
kneeling and slaps. We both indicated that we saw nothing wrong with what was
going on. He asked us our opinion of the slapping and we said they were only
insult slaps and were not inflicting any pain to the detainee. [Lt Col] Kleinman
indicated his disagreement and that both the slaps and kneeling were direct
violations of the Geneva Conventions and could constitute a war crime. He
further indicated that he wanted to intervene and stop the interrogation at that
point. 1363
_ Over the objections of the other two members ofJPRA team. Lt Col Kleinman
then asked the SMU TF interrogator to step out ofthe booth. He explained to the interrogator
"how and why [the interrogator's] methods were a violation ofthe Geneva Convention and TF
[POlicy].,,1364 According to Lt Col Kleinman, "[the interrogator] accepted my direction without
reservation.,,1365 .
I think the clear violation of the TF policy was of a minor nature - that being a
10-minute extension of the kneeling policy. The use of insult slaps was, in the
opinion of [Lt Col] Kleinman, serious enough to stop the interrogation - an action
I did not then or now feel warranted his direct intervention. 1366
II In subsequent testimony to the Committee, Mr. Russell claimed that the use ofthe
"insult slap" was consistent with the facility's operating instructions:
Under their operating instructions at that BIF, at that time and place, we did not
see anything wrong with [the use of physical pressures]. It may not have been
177
y
applied the way we would have done it, but we didn't see anythin wrong with it.
We advised [Lt Col] Kleinman ofthe same. He disagreed with us. 367
III Despite Mr. Russell's previous statement that he "saw nothing wrong with what was
going on," he testified to the Committee that he found the SMU TF interrogator's repeated use of
the insult slap to be "odd" and "in excess" of what would be used in resistance training at
JPRA 1369 Mr. Russell also testified that the technique, as applied by the TF interrogator, was
ineffective:
[The] insult slap is just that, it's an insult. After you do it two or three times it
loses its effectiveness because the [sic], in our world, the student is anticipating
the slap. It loses its effectiveness if you do it more than two or three or four
times. 1370
_( While he did not raise any objection to their use in the interrogation, Mr.
Russell stated that the techniques used at the SERE school, such as the insult slap, were not
designed to elicit information from individuals but rather to "guide the student" to an appropriate
resistance posture. 1371 According to his testimony, "history has shown us that physical pressures
are not effective for compelling an individual to give information or to do something" and are
not useful in gaining accurate, actionable intelligence. 1372 There is no indication in Mr.
Russell's trip report, however, that he told anyone on the J-2X staffthat the SMU TF's use of
repeated slaps would be ineffective or that use of other SERE physical pressures, such as
''walling'', which were reportedly described for the J-2X staff, would be ineffective.
Mr. Russell stated that when physical pressures are applied in the resistance phase of
SERE training, medical and psychological personnel are present to observe interrogations and
protect SERE school students,1373 Mr. Russell testified that there were no medical or
psychological personnel present during the interrogations he witnessed while at the SMU TF
Co 'l'ty . 1374
laCll
178
(U) Lt Col Kleinman said that he also told the SMU TF Commander that the use of SERE
techniques in interrogations was ''unlawful'' and "a violation ofthe Geneva Convention.,,1378 He
said that the SMU TF Commander agreed with him but there were "no orders ever issued" by the
Commander not to use the techniques. 1379
(U) Lt Col Kleinman also testified to the Committee that Col Moulton told him that the
JPRA team was "cleared hot to use SERE methods" in interrogations. 1381 Lt Col Kleinman
testified that he told Col Moulton that he considered this instruction to be an illegal order and
that he would not carry it out. Col Moulton said that Lt Col Kleinman "was adamant about that
he thought it was against the Geneva Convention.,,1382
1375 'The record is unclear as to exactly what date the call occurred.
1376 SASC Hearing (September 25, 2008).
1377 Ibid.
13'711 Ibid.
1379 Ibid
13~ Kleinman Trip Report at 3; Russell Trip Report at 2 ("The JPRA Commander had cleared Lenny Miller and
me to use our normal and usual range of physical pressures while interrogating detainees''); Committee staff
interview of Steven Kleinman (February 14, 2007); Testimony of Terrence Russell (August 3,2007) at 99.
1381 SASC Hearing (September 25,2008).
1382 Ibid.
1383 Kleinman Trip Report at 4; Russell Trip Report at 6.
179
JPRA Commander's order that they could use ''the normal and usual range of physical rsressures"
during interrogations and to alert them of his concerns about the legality ofthat order. 1 84 Mr.
Russell wrote in his trip report:
[Lt Col] Kleinman indicated that he felt [it was] ' ... an illegal order' and we were
exposing ourselves to possible future difficulties if we used any pressure
inconsistent with the Geneva Conventions. 1385
(U) Lt Col Kleinman also testified to the Committee that he relayed his conversation with
Col Moulton to his two lPRA colleagues, informing them that he told Col Moulton that the
authority to use SERE techniques "was an unlawful order" and that he "wasn't going to have any
involvement with it, and [he] didn't think that they should either.,,1386
_ Both Mr. Russell and Mr. Miller, the JPRA contractor, disagreed with Lt Col
Kleinman's assessment. 1387 According to Mr. Russell, the two "indicated that the use of these
moderate physical pressures, when used appropriately, were consistent with proper handling and
interrogation.,,1388 In testimony to the Committee, Mr. Russell added that he understood that the
individuals held by the Task Force were considered "detained unlawful combatants" and "not
automatically provided the protections ofthe Geneva Conventions," though he could not recall
who told him this. 1389
_( Shortly after Col Moulton told Lt Col Kleinman that the team was
"cleared hot" to employ the full range of JPRA methods, Lt Col Kleinman recommended that the
TF Legal Advisor arrange a formal briefing with the SMU TF interrogation staff and the lPRA
team 1390 In that meeting, Lt Col Kleinman reported that the TF Legal Advisor "set forth legal
limitations that essentially excluded most ofthe [JPRA methods] (with the use of certain stress
positions, such as kneeling on a hard floor for up to 30 minutes, cited as an acceptable
method).,,1391
(U) Lt Col Kleinman testified to the Committee that although the SMU TF lawyer agreed
with him that it was unlawful to use SERE techniques in interrogations, when the lawyer later
briefed interrogators on the techniques, there was no longer "any clarity" about whether or not
they were illegal. 1392
_ M r . Russell also described the TF Legal Advisor's briefing in his trip report:
180
The [TF Legal Advisor] discussed the [TF Commander's] expectations versus the
methods of exploitation and physical pressures he had heard were being used in
the BIF - including those prior to his recent arrival (2-3 weeks on site). He also
discussed the status of the detainees and the fact that the BIF's detainees were not
identified to the ICRC. He discussed the assumption of risk being taken by the
[SMU] command if BIF personnel engaged in 'beat down' tactics or while
, .. ,1393
engagmg 10 torture.
_ The TF Legal Advisor told the Committee that the SMU TF did not make status
determinations for detainees, but that he advised in his briefing that the protections of Common
Article 3 ofthe Geneva Conventions applied to those detainees under the control ofthe SMU
TFY94
(U) Lt Col Kleinman testified to the Committee that after he told his two JPRA
colleagues that Col Moulton had "cleared hot" their use of SERE techniques in interrogations,
his colleagues decided to "demonstrate the way you handle an interrogation.,,139S
_ ( Around the time that Lt Col Kleinman met with the SMU TF Legal
Advisor, Mr. Russell and Mr. Miller met separately with the SMU TF Director ofIntelli1ence (J
2), COL Brian Keller, and his J-2X and participated in interrogations with J-2X staff. 139 In one
instance, Mr. Russell and Mr. Miller took the lead in the interrogation of a detainee. 1397 The
interrogation began with the simulated release of the detainee - the detainee was permitted to
clean up, leave the facility, and was escorted to a bus stop, when he was "captured" again. 1398
When the detainee was brought back to the SMU TF facility, Mr. Russell and Mr. Miller took
physical control ofthe detainee and led him into a holdin cell. 1399 Once in the holding cell, one
or both ofthe men forcibl stri ed the detainee naked. 14 0 8
,,1401 He told the Committee: "we [had] done this 100 times, 1000 times with
our [SERE school] studentS.,,1402
181
(U) Lt Col Kleinman also described that interrogation intestimony to the Senate Armed
Services Committee. He said the detainee was driven away from the Task Force's interrogation
facility to make him think he was being released and then brought back to a "bunker that was
about a story ... into the ground - cement, cold, dark.,,1403 He said:
[The detainee] was literally carried by two of the guards into the bunker
struggling against them. He was taken down there. My two JPRA colleagues
took over from that point. .. [T]hey ripped his Abaya off - not cut - they ripped it
off... ripped off his underwear, took his shoes, they'd hooded him already, then
they - they had shackled him by the wrist and ankles - being screamed at the
entire time in his ear in English about essentially... what a poor specimen of
human that he was ... And then the orders were given that he was to stand in that
position for 12 hours no matter how much he asked for help, no matter how much
he pleaded, unless he passed out, the guards were not to respond to any requests
for help. 1404
(U) Lt Col Kleinman said that he told his colleagues that what they did was
''unlawful'' and he stopped the interrogation. l40s
Mr. Russell testified to the Committee that the detainee was naked only for "however
long it took to have his clothes taken offand put the new dish-dash on again.,,1406
_ In his trip report, Lt Col Kleinman reported that he told the two other JPRA team
members that he disagreed with their approach. 1407 Mr. Russell stated that the exploitation
scenario was conducted after coordination with the J-2X staff and that the techniques, including
isolation and sleep deprivation, were "employed in accordance with existing TF guidance and
pOlicy.,,1408 While Col Kleinman testified that he intervened to stop the interrogation, Mr.
Russell said that Lt Col Kleinman never raised an objection to the interrogation. 1409
182
plan which had been posted in plain view and described a schedule for keeping the detainee
awake and placing him in stress positions. 1412 The plan listed the following schedule:
*2130-2230 Sleep
*2230-2300 On Knees
*2330-0030 Sit Up
*0100-0130/0200 On Knees
(U) Another photograph showed the same detainee in his cell and hooded. His hands
appear handcuffed behind his back. 1414 Lt Col Kleinman said that his photograph did not reflect
the fact that the detainee also had his ankles shackled. 1415
Committee staff interview ofLt Col Steven Kleinman (February 14,2007); Committee staff interview ofLt Col
1412
Steven Kleinman (March 14, 2008). Lt Col Kleinman told the Committee that the IF Commander gave him
permission to take photographs.
1413 Untitled Photograph taken by Lt Col Steven Kleinman, (September 2003).
1414 Ibid
141' Committee staff interview of Lt Col Steven Kleinman (March 14, 2008).
1416 In his trip report, Terrence Russell wrote that he had learned about Lt Col Kleinman's intervention from the 12
X. Russell Trip Report at 3.
1417 Ibid
1418 Ibid. at 4.
1419 Ibid.
183
(U) Lt Col Kleinman testified that he told Mr. Russell that he would not participate in
drafting the CONOP because he "absolutely disagreed with that type of expansion ofthe use of.
SERE methods," and that his "contribution would be nothing but contrary.,,1425
_ While the JPRA team was still in Iraq, the draft was shared with and edited by
JPRA eersonnel in the U.S., including Christopher Wirts, JPRA's Operations Support Office
Chief. 426 The CONOP, called "Concept of Operations for HVT exploitation," provided JPRA's
"recommendations and guidance to USG forces conducting exploitation operations. 1427
_ The September 2003 CONOP was similar to the April 2002 "Exploitation Draft
Plan" that Dr. Bruce Jessen, JPRA's former senior SERE psycholo~st, had drafted shortly
before JPRA's support t o _ the DoD General Counsel. 14 8 As had the April 2002
exploitation draft plan, the CONOP described a JPRA-directed exploitation process and included
recommendations for exploitation and captivity operations, such as "tailoring detainee
punishment consequences to maximize cultural undesirability.,,1429
184
_ Those exploitation principles were similar to those that had been included in the
exploitation draft plan nearly a year and a half earlier. In addition, the September 2003 JPRA
CONOP listed specific interrogation techniques and incorporated portions ofthe March 6, 2003
DoD Interrogation Working Group draft report. JPRA ~ersonnel considered the Working Group
report authoritative guidance on U.S. policy and law. 143
185
(U) According to the DoD Inspector General's August 2006 report, when it "became
apparent that friction was developing" between the SMU TF and the JPRA team, ''the decision
was made to pull the team out [ofIraq] before more damage was done to the relationship
between the two organizations.,,1436 Lt Col Kleinman referred to the DoD IG report's statement
that "friction was developing" as an understatement and said that he felt his life was being
threatened at the SMU TF. 1437 He recalled one instance (after he stopped what he believed to be
in violation ofthe Geneva Conventions) in which an SMU TF member told him, while
sharpening a knife, to "sleep lightly," noting that they did not "coddl[e] terrorists" at the SMU
TF. 1438
_The SMU TF Legal Advisor told the Committee that JPRA had no business at the
SMU TF facility either assisting in or conducing interrogations and that he sought to have the
team removed 1439 The Legal Advisor said that he met with the SMU TF
Commander, and told him that SERE training was not meant for detainees and that JPRA's
presence had the potential to lead to abuse. He also recalled telling the Commander that JPRA
was not qualified or trained to perform interrogations. The Legal Advisor said that_
_ did not act on his concerns.
_ Mr. Russell wrote in his trip report that the SMU TF Operations Officer (J-3) also
recommended to that the JPRA team should leave the facility, noting that the J
3 ''was particularly concerned over the [JPRA] CONOP having been sent [to JPRA headquarters]
without his staff's security review.,,1440 On September 22, 2003, the JPRA Commander directed
Lt Col Kleinman and Mr. Miller to return to the U.S., but told Mr. Russell to remain in place for
''the possible arrival of a follow-up team.,,1441 On September 23, 2003, the team's original
186
scheduled departure date, JPRA infonned the team that all three team members should leave
Iraq. 1442
(U) The same day the JPRA team returned home from Iraq, a copy of the JPRA HVT
exploitation CONOP was sent to CAPT Donovan, the JFCOM SJA 1443 CAPT Donovan
commented on the CONOP in a September 26, 2003 email to Col Moulton, JPRA Deputy
Commander John Atkins, OSO Chief Christopher Wirts and others, and circulated a version of
the CONOP with his edits and comments.
(U) In his email, CAPT Donovan stated that JPRA should not rely on the March 6, 2003
Working Group report as "authoritative DoD guidance." He wrote that, although the Secretary
had approved certain counter-resistance techniques during interrogations of unlawful combatants
at GTMO, not all ofthe techniques listed in the Working Group report had been approved for
use. l444 CAPT Donovan also raised serious concerns about the legality ofthe interrogation
techniques in the CONOP emphasizing that, unlike in Mghanistan and at GTMO, the Geneva
Conventions applied in Iraq. He wrote:
Unlike OEF-Mghanistan, in which the Taliban and Al-Qaida enemy 'forces'
were all deemed to be UNLAWFUL combatants NOT legally entitled to the full
protections of the Geneva conventions, Operation Iraqi Freedom (OIF) was
executed as a CONVENTIONAL armed conflict in which the vast majority of
enemy forces were LAWFUL combatants. Therefore, almost all captured
personnel within Iraq are legally entitled to either prisoner of war (POW) or
civilian internee (CI) status which means they get the full protections of the
Geneva Conventions. Many of the counter-resistance techniques approved by
SECDEF for use on UNLAWFUL combatants detained at GTMO would not/not
be legal under the Geneva Conventions if applied to POWs or CIs in Iraq. 1445
_ I n editing the CONOP, CAPT Donovan not only struck references to several
interrogation techniques that had been included in the March 6, 2003 draft Working Group
Col Moulton also stated that he had pitched the idea to JFCOM:
Having said that, I think the request needs to come from CENTCOM, not just _ I can
support, and have already presented the concept to JFCOM. We just need the invite. Long-term
is to identify the need for an OSD OPR [Office of Primary Responsibility] for strategic
debrieftng/interrogation. To put it into football terms, we (JPRA) are the quarterback for
defensive resistance operations - there is no quarte~iveresistance opemtions.
Where that responsibility would ultimately fall (JP~ is not the issue, but mther
that someone has to take the lead.
Email from Col Moulton to JPRA CENTCOM LNO (September 3, 2(03).
1442 Russell Trip Report at 6; see also email from Mike Lampe to David Ayres (August 28, 2003).
1443 Email from CAPT Donovan to Col Moulton, Col Atkins, Mr. Wirts, and Mr. Jagielski (September 26, 2(03).
1444 Ibid
1445 Ibid
187
report, but also noted that even those techniques approved by the Secretary of Defense for use at
GTMO might not be lawful for use on detainees in Iraq. 1446
_ Days later, CAPT Donovan raised his concerns about the CONOP to LTG
Wagner, JFCOM's Deputy Commander, and Maj Gen James Soligan, JFCOM's Chief of Staff,
in anticipation of a scheduled visit by the two to JPRA 1449 CAPT Donovan stated that while it
made "a certain amount of sense to seek JPRA's advice regarding interrogation techniques that
[had] been successfully used against us by our enemies," he was concerned that the SMU TF
"may have gone a bit further by asking JPRA to develop a CONOP for "more effective"
interrogations [by the SMU] ofHVTs captured in Iraq.,,14S0 He expressed particular concerns
with the "interrogation techniques" included in the CONOP:
188
been reported up the chain of command to JFCOM. 1453 On September 23, 2005, after JFCOM
concluded its inquiry, JFCOM's Deputy Commander LTG Wagner sent a memo to the DoD IG
stating:
This command looked into the information flow between the requesting unit, Joint
Personnel Recovery Agency, (JPRA) and the chain of command at USJFCOM
with regard to JPRA's participation in the two subject missions to assist in the
global war on terror. While most requests and decisions were verbal, I concluded
that information did flow up the chain of command to the appropriate authority.
Action was taken based on JPRA Commanding Officer's (CO) judgment and.
input from the chain of command ... 1454
The actions Lt Col Kleinman witnessed did occur. However, all others involved,
including the JPRA [Commanding Officer] and the [Commanding Officer] of the
task force believed them to be authorized actions under the existing decisions by
DoD General Counsel. The [Commanding Officer] conveyed this to Lt Col
Kleinman both during and after the deployment. Lt Col Kleinman did not seek
any other response or relief, nor take any issue up his chain of command. 1455
D. Major General Geoffrey MilJer Leads GTMO Assessment Team to Iraq (U)
1. CJTF-7 Commander ItkntifleS DefICiencies (U)
(U) During the summer of2003 Combined Joint Task Force 7 (CJTF-7) ass~ed control
of coalition forces in Iraq from its predecessor, the Combined Forces Land Component
Command (CFLCC). The Commander of CJTF-7, LTG Sanchez, said that when he took over
from CFLCC he identified deficiencies with existing intelligence operations. 1456 LTG Sanchez
said that he participated in regular video teleconferences and phone calls with CENTCOM and
the Office ofthe Secretary of Defense (OSD) during which he shared his concerns about his
command's intelligence capabilities and asked for assistance. LTG Sanchez stated:
I was very concerned about our ability to really push the envelope to the limits of
our authority in interrogations. I went back to Washington and said "You've got
to send us some help because this is a problem that is way beyond an~hing we
could imagine and it's a problem that hasn't been faced by our Army.,,14 7
1453 Committee staff interview of CAPT Alan Kaufman (September 17, 2(07).
1454 The ''two'' missions refer to the September 2003 trip to Iraq and the September 2002 JPRA training at Fort
Bragg. Memo from LTG Robert Wagner, Follow up response to June 2003 USJFCOM IG Meeting on DoD 10
Inquiry to USJFCOM of27 May 2005 (September 23,2005)
1455 Ibid
189
(U) Even before the CITF-7 Commander sought assistance, however, discussions had
apparently taken place about whether to send MG Geoffrey Miller, the GTMO Commander, to
Iraq to assess operations there. In May 2003, before CITF-7 took command in Iraq from
CFLCC, LTG Ronald Burgess, the Director for Intelligence (J-2) at the Joint Stafftold MG
Miller that a request would be forthcoming for him to lead an assessment trip to Iraq. 1458
According to an investigation conducted by MG George Fay and LTG Anthony Jones, the Joint
Stafflater requested that SOUTHCOM send a team to assist CENTCOM and the Iraq Survey
Group "with advice on facilities and operations specific to screening, interrogations, HUMINT
collection, and interagency integration in the short and long term.,,1459
(U) The.Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence (USDI) Stephen Cambone said that
MG Miller was asked to go to Iraq "at my encouragement, to take a look at the situation as it
existed there.,,1460 LTG William Boykin, the Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence
and Warfighter Support said that the decision to send MG Miller to Iraq was made in a meeting
that included USDI Cambone and the Secretary ofDefense. 1461
(U) The day after arriving in Iraq, MG Miller met with LTG Sanchez and described the
purpose ofthe assistance visit, 1464 MG Miller said that his team was aware that the Geneva
Conventions applied in Iraq and told LTG Sanchez that he would have to decide what
recommendations were applicable to his command. MG Miller also met with MG Barbara Fast,
the CITF-7 Director of Intelligence, and gave her the same briefing.
14~ Anny IG, Interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (October 20,2005) at 65; AR 15-6 Investigation of the Abu Ghraib
Detention Facility and 205 tb Military Intelligence Brigade (August 24, 2004) at 57 (hereinafter "Fay Report").
1459 Fay Report at 57.
Allegations of Mistreatment of Iraqi Prisoners, Senate Committee on Anned Services, 108th Congress, S. Hrg.
1460
108-868 (May 7, 2004, May 11, 2004) at 41,98.
1461 Anny IG, Interview of LTG William Boykin (November 17, 2(05) at 3.
1462 MG Geoffrey Miller, Assessment ofDoD Counterterrorism Interrogation and Detention Operations in Iraq (U)
1463 Anny IG, Interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (October 20,2005) at 65.
1464 Committee staff interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (December 6,2007).
190
(U) Chief Warrant Officer Brian Searcy, who was Chief ofInterrogation at the ISG
accompanied MG Miller and his team on the tour. CWO Searcy told the Committee that during
the tour, MG Miller remarked that the ISG was "running a country club" and suggested that they
were too lenient with detainees. 1469 He said that MG Miller recommended the ISG shackle
detainees and make them walk on gravel rather than on concrete pathways to show the detainees
who was in control. CWO Searcy also recalled that the IfF-GTMO Commander suggested that
the ISG "GTMO-ize" their facility. 1470
146'Several members of the assessment team recalled the conditions at the Corps Holding Area. LTC Beaver
described the facility as "grotesque" and recalled telling lawyers at cm -7 about "stagnant water, maggots, feces
approximately 6 inches tall on the toilets and running down the sides of the toilets." She told the Committee that she
saw senior non-commissioned officers who were oblivious to their surroundings and that she recalled one guard tell
the visiting team "I don't give an. [expletive] if [the Iraqi prisoners] die."
MG Miller said he was "dismayed and shocked at the operations" at Camp Cropper, referring to them as
"inappropriate, unprofessional, and not humane." MG Miller also called it "shocking'" that "the guards didn't even
know the rules of engagement for use ofdeadly force." MG Miller said that he told LTG Sanchez: "you have a
major problem at Camp Cropper and you need to take action now." According to MG Miller, LTG Sanchez asked
him to share his assessment with the 800th MP BDE Commander BG Janis Karpinski and direct that "corrections be
made in the next 48 hours." MG Miller said that, in a subsequent meeting with BG Karpinski, he met with
"significant pushback." He recalled his reaction in that meeting. "[I] kind of cleared the room and told General
Karpinski, 1said these are the fmdings, if you don't agree with them, let's you and 1go see General Sanchez because
he has directed that you take action to have corrective action be taken and in place within 48-hours. And so she
called the staff back in and started to go forward with it."
MG Miller told the Committee that BG Karpinski accepted the guidance, but not willingly. According to LTC
Beaver, the Corps Holding Area at Camp Cropper was closed shortly after the team left Iraq. Sworn Statement of
LTC Diane Beaver (December 10, 2004) at 1; Committee staff interview of LTC Diane Beaver (November 9, 2(07);
Army!G, Interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (June 28, 2(05) at 68.
1466 DoD!G, Interview of LTG Keith Dayton (May 25,2(05) at 10.
1467 Ibid. at 52.
1468 Committee staff interview of Brian Searcy (June 4,2007).
1469 Ibid
14'70 Ibid.
191
(U) MG Miller did not recall referring to the ISG as a "country club" and said that, as far
as he knew, he "never used the word GTMO_ize.,,1471 However, he did recall telling ISG
personnel that he was troubled that the ISG were treating detainees with too much respect, which
was not, in his opinion, how prisoners ought to be treated. 1472
(U) Mike Kamin, the ISG's Collection Manager said that LtCol Ken Rapuano, the ISG's
Joint Interrogation and Debriefing Center (JIOC) Chief, was "energized" after meeting with MG
Miller and said that the GTMO Commander had told him about techniques like temperature
manipulation and sleep deprivation. 1473 Ac~Mr. Kamin, ISG JIDC personnel balked at
the idea of implementing such techniques. _ an ISG strategic debriefer said that he
wrote a letter to his chain of command stating that he would resign ifthe techniques were
. Iemented 1474
unp
(U) LtCol Rapuano said that he met with MG Miller and members of his team in a
meeting with MG Keith Dayton, the ISG Commander, and other members ofISG's leadership.
UCol Rapuano said that he did not recall a discussion of specific interrogation techniques but
did recall "some discussion of procedures for air conditioning cells.,,147S LtCol Rapuano said did
not recall any discussions of sleep deprivation as an interrogation technique.
(U) At the end of the visit, MG Miller met with MG Dayton and members of his staff.
MG Dayton said that MG Miller told him that the ISG was "not getting much out ofthese
people" and was "not getting the maximum.,,1476 MG Dayton said he asked what was meant by
that and was told "you haven't broken [the detainees]" psychologically. 1477 MG Dayton said that
MG Miller told him that he would "get back to you with some ideas of how you can Rerhaps deal
with these people where you can actually break them, some techniques you can use." 478 The
ISG Commander stated:
I remember very clearly saying, "Geoff, slow down. We're not changing anything right
now. You know, we think we're within the rules. If you want me to change something,
1471 Committee staff interview of MG Geoffrey Miller (December 6, 2007); Interview of MG Geoffrey Miller for
Javal Davis trial (August 21,2004). The former JTF-GlMO ICE Chief David Becker, who was present during the
ISG visit did not recall the MG Miller using the term UG lMO-ize." Committee staff interview of David Becker
(September 17, 2007).
1472 Committee staff interview 0 f MG Geoffrey Miller (December 6, 2007).
1473 Committee staff interview of Mike Kamin (May 30, 2007).
1474 Committee staff interview of _ (May 23, 2007).
147~ LtCol Rapuano said that "the issue discussed, without decision, was if it was appropriate that detainees were
being provided cooler living conditions than most Coalition personnel had in their living quarters and work areas,
and whether only the cooperative detainees should be rewarded with cooler cells." Kenneth Rapuano answers to
September 3,2008 written questions from Senator Carl Levin (September 16, 2008).
1476 DoD!G, Interview ofMG Keith Dayton (May 25, 2005) at 33.
1477 Ibid.
1478 Ibid
192
you give me something in writing that you think needs to be changed. I'll have my
lawyers look at it. 1479
(U) Although MG Miller recalled saying that he was troubled that detainees at the ISG
were being treated with too much respect, he did not recall using the term "break.,,1480 As to
techniques to get more information from detainees, MG Miller said he only recalled discussing
the possibility ofISG interrogating detainees more frequently. According to MG Dayton, MG
Miller never followed up with him after the trip. 1481
II
MG Miller said that he and two other members of his team met with~
and a few of his operators for about 45 minutes to an hour at the SMU TF facility. The ITF
GTMO Commander did not see an SOP for SMU TF interrogations and recalled that the SMU
TF Commander told him the SMU TF was using operators as interrogators. MG Miller said that
he told that he needed to establish interrogation authorities and obtain qualified
interrogators. For several month~ing with MG Miller, SMU TF Legal Advisors
had tried, without success, to get _ to sign an interrogation policy for the facility
under his command. 1485
While she did not accompany the ITF-GTMO Commander on his visit to the SMU
TF, LTC Beaver, the former ITF-GTMO SJA, said that a Legal Advisor for the SMU TF
contacted her and arranged to meet with her at Camp Victory. 1486 According to LTC Beaver, the
SMU TF Legal Advisor raised concerns with her about physical violence being used b SMU TF
personnel during interrogations, including punching, choking, and beating detainees. 14 7 He toldt
1419 Ibid at 34.
1480 Committee staff interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (December 6,2007).
1481 DoD IG, Interview of MG Keith Dayton (May 25, 2005) at 34~ Committee staff interview of LTG Keith Dayton
(June I, 2007).
1482 Committee staff interview o _ C O c t o b e r 10,2007).
1483 Committee staff interview of MG Geoffrey Miller (December 6, 2007).
1484 Ibid
1485 See Section XII A, supra.
1486 Sworn Statement of LTC Diane Beaver (December 10, 2004) at 1.
1487 Committee staff interview of LTC Diane Beaver (November 9,2007).
193
her that he was "risking his life" by talking to her about these issues. 1488 LTC Beaver told the
Committee that the S M U ~ i dhe had also raised these issues with the Commander
ofthe SMU TF, but that was not receptive to his concerns.
II
LTC Beaver told the Committee that she infonned both COL Marc Warren (the
CITF-7 SJA) and MG Miller about her conversation with the SMU TF Legal Advisor. 1489
When he met with the Committee, MG Miller did not recall LTC Beaver bringing those concerns
to his attention. 1490 A slide presentation summarizing the GTMO assessment team's visit to
Iraq, however, stated that there were "concerns about [SMU TF] interrogation practices such as
physical contact and choking.,,1491 The same presentation noted that other governmental
agencies "won't interrogate at [the SMU TF] facility because of current treatment concerns.,,1492
(U) CPT Wood, the Interrogation Officer in Charge (OIC) at Abu Ghraib said her
conversations with the ITF-GTMO Commander "centered on renovations and improvements of
facilities, challenges of interrogation operations, and the need for increased [Military
Police/Military Intelligence] cooperation.,,1495 CPT Wood believed that MG Miller and his team
wanted to build a "miniature Guantanamo Bay.,,1496 In her view, however, the GTMO concept
was not applicable to Abu Ghraib. She stated:
... Abu Ghraib wasn't GTMO. The prison was an austere environment; it was not
conducive to interrogation operations like GMTO. That was actually built and
designed to facilitate interrogation operations. We didn't have the MP force that
was necessary for such a high population and we were frequent targets of small
arms and mortar attacks. We worked in a hundred and thirty degree weather
1488 Ibid
1489 Ibid
14llO Committee staff interview 0 f MG Geofli'ey Miller (Decem her 6, 2007).
1491 Slide presentation, The GTMO Commander- Team Visit to Iraq (undated).
1492 Ibid
COL Pappas stated that the discussions were broad but focused on the understanding that "interrogation is what
1493
drives the train," as well as developing a "singular unified purpose that was to extract information" from detainees.
Army IG,lnterview of COL Thomas Pappas (April 12, 2006) at 10, 12, 15.
1494 Ibid at 10.
149~ Sworn Statement of CPT Carolyn Wood (May 21, 2004) at 2.
1496 Army IG,lnterview ofCPT Carolyn Wood (May 8,2006) at 12.
194
without air conditioning and we went throu~ the winter without heat. Most of
the detainees were not of intelligence value. 1 97
(U) MG Miller said that he spent parts ofthree days at Abu Ghraib with COL Pappas and
CPT Wood discussing how to improve operations. 1498 LTG Sanchez recalled that the team
"recommended the creation of a command policy" on interrogations and the team provided
CITF-7 with electronic copies of SOPs and a copy ofa Joint Staffpolicy memorandum entitled
"Interrogation Techniques in the War on Terrorism,,1499 According to MG Miller, members of
his assessment team also discussed interrogation authorities and techniques during their meetings
with CITF-7 personnel. 1500
(U) CPT Wood said that members ofthe GTMO assessment team had, in their
possession, copies ofthe proposed interrogation policy she had copied from the SMU Task
Force's interrogationpolicy and submitted to her chain of command prior to the assessment
team's visit. 1501 That proposed policy included presence of military working dogs, stress
positions, sleep management, 20-hour interrogations, isolation, and yelling, loud music, and light
control. 1502 CPT Wood said that a member ofthe GTMO assessment team referred to her
proposal as a "good start," but told her that CITF-7 "should consider something along the lines
of what's approved for use in [GTMO].,,1503 LTC Beaver recalled reviewing CPT Wood's
proposed SOP. LTC Beaver said that she was concerned about the SOP because she knew that,
"in a Geneva setting, it was potentially a problem," that she brought it to the attention of COL
Marc Warren, the CITF-7 SJA and recommended that he review it 1504
(U) David Becker, the former ITF-GTMO ICE Chief, recalled discussing stress positions,
dogs, and nudity with COL Pappas during the visit. Mr. Becker said:
[W]hat I told Pappas was, look I understand they're doing all kinds of different
approaches out there. And I talked about the memo that was approved for
Guantanamo at one point. I said look, when you use stress positions; when you
use dogs; when you use - I mean when you use stress positions, dogs, nakedness .
. . the concept ofthe conversation was as you develop these techniques, talk to the
interrogators. Figure out what they want to use and put it in writing. And you
have to establish left and right lanes in the road for the conduct of interrogations.
And you've got to do it in writing. And then you've got to build the interrogation
1497 Army !G, Interview of CPT Carolyn Wood (August 15, 2(06) at 45.
1498 Army IG, Statement ofMG Geoffrey Miller (June 19,2004) at 2.
1499 Statement of LTG Ricardo Sanchez (October 2004) at 7.
1'00 Army!G, Statement ofMG Geoffrey Miller (June 19,2004) at 2.
1'01 Sworn Statement of CPT Carolyn Wood (May 21,2004) at 6; see Section XII B, supra.
1'02 Alpha Company, 519th MI BN SFIF Interrogation TIPS (August 27,2(03).
UOJ Sworn Statement of CPT Carolyn Wood (May 21,2004) at 6.
1~ SASC Hearing (June 17, 2008); Committee staff interview of LTC Beaver (October 11, 2007).
195
plan and you've got the interrogators to stick to it. And that's what I said. And
the "use of dogs" came up in that conversation. 1505
(U) COL Pappas recalled discussions with the GTMO assessment team about do~s being
"effective in doing interrogations with Arabs" and talk of"Arabs being fearful of dogs." 506
COL Pappas said that while no one from MG Miller's team said "okay, use the dogs while
you're doing an interrogation" there was discussion "about 'setting conditions for
interrogations. ",1507 COL Pappas later authorized the use of dogs in interrogations at Abu
Ghraib. 1508
(U) COL Pappas also recalled discussing dogs with MG Miller during the visit. In a
February 2004 interview, COL Pappas said that the use of dogs had been "a technique that [he]
had discussed with Miller" during the IfF-GTMO assistance visit to Iraq.1509 COL Pappas
stated that MG Miller "said that they used military working dogs, and that they were effective in
setting the atmosphere for which ... you could get information.,,1510 In a later interview, COL
Pappas again described his discussions with MG Miller:
There was never any discussion [with the IfF-GTMO Commander] of the
execution of how the dogs would be used Now he did say that dogs were an
effective technique to use with the detainees. He did say we want to make sure
we control the detainee at all times. The I-bolts in the floor came from MG
Miller's team ... He did meet with some of the interrogators and told them to be
more aggressive, but he never told them how. His overtone was to be more
aggressive, but I never heard him say take dogs into the booths or anything like
that. 15H
(U) MAT David DiNenna, the Operations Officer (8-3) ofthe 320 th MP BN also recalled
a discussion with MG Miller about dogs. According to MAT DiNenna, during a meeting at Abu
Ghraib, MG Miller asked him whether or not they had military working dogs. 1512 MAT DiNenna
196
told MG Miller that they did not, but that he had "requested them when [he] first arrived at Abu
[Ghraib], and since that time, had made numerous requests.,,1513 MAJ DiNenna said:
MG Miller then looked at COL Pappas and stated that dogs have been extremely
useful at GITMO. He stated, "These people are scared to death of dogs, and the
dogs have a tremendous affect.,,1514
(U) MAJ DiNenna said that he was "concerned that [MG Miller] was implying MI would
receive the dogs at Abu [Ghraib], yet I desperately needed them as a force multiplier for the
facilities. ,,1515
(U) MGMiller maintained that he and COL Pappas "never discussed using dogs in
interrogations.,,1516 He stated that his discussions about dogs with COL Pappas were "in the
context of security operations and force protection.,,1517 MG Miller said, however, that he did
not discuss the use of dogs at all with BG Janis Karpinski, the Commander of the 800th MP BDE
or anyone else in her unit, which was responsible for security operations and force protection at
the prison. ISIS
(U) During his assessment visit, the JTF-GTMO Commander provided an "interim
update" to LTG Sanchez and recommended that CJTF -7 "establish interrogation authorities so
the interrogators understand what their limits are.,,1519 MG Miller stated that he also directed
LTC Beaver to "let [CJTF-7] see what we use at Guantanamo as a template," referring to the
Secretary of Defense's April 16, 2003 guidance for SOUTHCOM. 1520 MG Miller stated that,
with respect to GTMO's guidance from the Secretary, he told LTG Sanchez:
[T]he first caveat was that the Geneva Convention applied here. You must use
only Geneva Convention authorities. You may not use anything other unless you
get approval from SecDef to go about doing that. And so if you're going to ask
for any of those, you got to go through the CENTCOM Commander and up to
JCS and OSD to get approval from there. 1521
1m Ibid
1514 Ibid
ljlj Ibid at 21.
1516 Army!G, Interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (October 20,2005) at 71.
1m Ibid
(U) LTG Sanchez said that he instructed his SJA to develop an interrogation policy, the
"key purpose" of which was to "unequivocally establish as policy adherence to the Geneva
Convention and to regulate approach techniques that we believed were derived from multiple
sources" including the Army Field Manual, and techniques used in Guantanamo Bay and
Afghanistan. 1S22
(U) LTC Beaver said that she left the April 16, 2003 memo from Secretary Rumsfeld
with the CITF-71egal staff She also said that she told COL Marc Warren, the CITF-7 SJA, and
other lawyers on the CITF-7 staffthat while the policy had worked at Guantanamo, that CITF-7
"would need to evaluate what was permissible in Iraq and what the command thought would
. th
work 10 i'
s enVlfonment. "IS23
(U) According to COL Pappas, CITF-7 be~an drafting an interrogation policy while MG
Miller and his assessment team were still in Iraq.l 24 He said that LTC Beaver, and several
CITF-7lawyers worked on a memo at Camp Victory. MG Miller said that, while he did not
know who actually drafted the memo, LTC Beaver told him that she worked on the issue with
COL Warren and his staff. 1S2S LTC Beaver did not recall working on an interrogation policy
during the assessment visit. IS26
198
(U) Subsequent to the assessment trip, six GTMO personnel- three interrogators and
three analysts - were sent to Abu Ghraib to assist in implementing the GTMO recommendations
and in establishing a Joint Intelligence and Debriefmg Center. 1530
(U) While MG Miller said that Under Secretary Cambone attended the briefing, Under
Secretary Cambone testified on May 11, 2004 before the Senate Armed Services Committee that
he was, in fact "not briefed" by the GTMO Commander on the trip report. 1534 In his written
answer to a question for the record following his testimony, Under Secretary Cambone stated
that, in fact, he "was never officially briefed on MG Miller's report."m5 Just over a week after
Under Secretary Cambone's testimony, MG Miller testified before the Committee that he had
"no direct discussions" with Under Secretary Cambone following his visit to Iraq. 1536
(U) In August 2004, however, MG Miller told Army Investigators that, followinf his
return from Iraq he "gave an outbriefto both Dr. Wolfowitz and Secretary Cambone.,,15 7 The
GTMO Commander went on to state ''the meeting that I had with Secretary Cambone had
occurred after I returned... The discussion generally was about how we could improve the flow
of intelligence from Iraq through and in interrogations."m8
199
(U) More than a year later, in October 2005, the Army IG asked MG Miller about his
testimony to the Committee that he had not had "direct discussions" with Under Secretary
Cambone. Despite previously describing a "discussion" with Under Secretary Cambone, MG
Miller told the IG that when asked at [the Senate Armed Services Committee] about discussions
with Under Secretary Cambone after his trip, "I said no because I didn't have discussions with
Cambone.,,1539 MG Miller also told the Army IG that he didn't even know that the person
attending the meeting was Dr. Cambone until Deputy Secretary Wolfowitz used his name.,,1540
The Army IG also asked MG Miller about the smaller meeting that he attended with Deputy
Secretary Wolfowitz and Under Secretary Cambone immediately following his briefing. MG
Miller said that the reason for the smaller meeting was so that he could give the ''unvarnished
truth" about his visit and said that he told Deputy Secretary Wolfowitz and Under Secretary
Cambone during that smaller meeting that CJTF-7 was at risk for "mission failure. ,,1541
(U) Under Secretary Cambone stated in December 2006 that his records indicated that he
"did attend MG Miller's briefing to Deputy Secretary Wolfowitz," but that he did "not remember
participating in any substantive discussions." Under Secretary Cambone said that he had "no
personal recollection" ofthe smaller meeting that took place subsequent to MG Miller's
briefing. 1542
(U) During his December 20, 2007 interview with Committee staff, MG Miller said that
he did not learn that Under Secretary Cambone was in attendance at the briefing until someone
referred to him by name either during or after his briefmg. 1543 He stated that, when he was asked
at the May 2004 Committee hearing about discussions with Under Secretary Cambone, he had
forgotten that Under Secretary Cambone had actually attended the briefing. MG Miller said his
use ofthe word "discussion" in his August 2004 testimony to describe his interaction with
Undersecretary Cambone was an imprecise use of words. MG Miller stated that, in the smaller
meeting he attended following his briefing with Deputy Secretary Wolfowitz and Undersecretary
Cambone, that Deputy Secretary Wolfowitz simply thanked him for his work.
1~39 Army IG, Interview ofMG Geoffrey Miller (October 20.2005) at 79.
1~40 Ibid
1~41 Ibid. at 82.
1~42 Letter from Under Secretary Stephen Cambone to Senator John Warner (December 19, 2006).
B43 Committee staff interview of MG Geoffrey Miller (December 6, 2007).
B44 CITF-7 Interrogation and Counter-Resistance Policy (September 14, 2003).
200
that he issued the policy because FM 34-52 left the "universe of approaches to the imagination of
the interrogator" and demanded additional structure. 1545
(U) According to LTG Sanchez, the September 14,2003 policy "drew heavily" on the
Secretary of Defense's April 16, 2003 guidance for GTMO. I546 Indeed, the September 14,2003
policy included all 24 interrogation techniques that were in that guidance, as well as techniques
that CPT Wood had copied from the SMU TF in Iraq's interrogation policy and submitted for
approval. The latter included the presence of military working dogs, stress positions, sleep
management, loud music, and light control. 1547 The techniques CPT Wood had copied from the
SMU TF policy had, in tum, been based on techniques included in the interrogation policy used
by the SMU TF in Afghanistan. That policy was influenced, in turn, by the Secretary of
Defense's December 2,2002 approval of aggressive interrogation techniques for use at
GTMO. 1548
(U) Although some ofthe techniques authorized by the September 14, 2003 CITF-7
policy required the CITF-7 Commander's approval before they could be used on Enemy
Prisoners of War (EPWs), LTG Sanchez stated that "with few exceptions, persons captured after
May 1, 2003 were not entitled to EPW status as a matter oflaw.,,1549 CPT Wood said that, to her
knowledge, there were no EPWs held at Abu Ghraib. 1550
(U) LTG Sanchez stated that CITF-7 forwarded the September 14, 2003 policy to
CENTCOM with a cover memorandum stating that the policy was based on that used at
Guantanamo Bay, but "modified for applicability to a theater of war in which the Geneva
Conventions apply.,,1551 LTG Sanchez stated that his intent, unless otherwise directed, was to
"immediately implement the policy outlined in the memo.,,1552
201
of] interrogators and analysts working for her. She stated that during the briefin~, "the
interrogators took turns reading [the September 14 policy] line by line aloud." 15 3 She stated
that each interrogator present signed a document noting that he or she had received training on
the policy. CPT Wood said that personnel who arrived at Abu Ghraib after CITF-7 issued the
policy were briefed on it during in-processing.
(U) CPT Wood also developed a Memorandum for Record on CITF-7 Interrogation
Rules of Engagement (IROE) to be signed by all personnel at Abu Ghraib in contact with
detainees. 1554 The IROE stated that the interrogation approaches specified in Army FM 34-52, as
well as yelling, light control, loud music, deception, and false flag were "approved for all
detainees, regardless of status (security detainees, civilian internees, or EPWs).,,1555 Use of other
approaches authorized by the September 14,2003 CITF-7 memorandum, including stress
positions, presence of dogs, dietary manipulation, environmental manipulation, sleep adjustment,
and sleep management, were to be approved by the interrogation officer in charge or the non
commissioned officer in charge.
(U) At least one version ofthe IROE used a September 10, 2003 CJTF-7 draft policy as
its basis, rather than the September 14 approved policy. 1556 That IROE also listed sensory
deprivation as "approved in accordance with the CITF-7 policy.',1557 While CPT Wood had
requested sensory deprivation and the technique had been included in a September 10, 2003 draft
policy, it was not among those listed in the September 14,2003 policy approved by CJTF-7.
CPT Wood acknowledged that she may have used the wrong policy as a basis for her IROE. 1558
1554 Memorandum for Record, CJI'F-7 Interrogation Rules ojEngagement (October 9, 2003) (hereinafter "CJTF-7
Interrogation Rules ojEngagement (October 9, 2003)").
1m Ibid
1556 CJTF-7 Interrogation and Counter-Resistance Policy (September 10,2003).
1m CJTF-7 Interrogation Rules ojEngagement (October 9, 2003).
ms Committee staff interview of CPT Carolyn Wood (February 11,2008); CJTF-7 Interrogation and Counter
Resistance Policy (September 10, 2003).
m9 Committee staff interview of LTG Ricardo Sanchez (December 20, 2007).
_ LTG Sanchez stated that when the September 14, 2003 policy reached .
CENTCOM, it "energized the legal community there and that COL Fred Pribble [the
CENTCOM SJA] had concerns.,,1561 LTG Sanchez said that CENTCOM lawyers thought some
techniques in the September 14 policy came too close to the boundary.1562 COL Marc Warren,
the CJTF-7 SJA, stated that the CENTCOM SJA "raised concerns to us that the policy was
objectionable in that aspects ofthe approved approaches were impermissibly coercive.,,1563
II On September 15,2003, the day after the policy was issued, COL Warren sent a copy
to COL Pribble and William "Barry" Hammill, CENTCOM's Deputy SJA, stating "this is pretty
tame stuff, largely a direct lift from the Army Interrogation FM. The genesis of this product was
the visit by MG Miller's GITMO team.,,1564 The next day, Mr. Hammill asked Major Carrie
Ricci, the Chief of International Law at CENTCOM to review the policy. 1565 That same day,
MAJ Ricci responded in an email stating that "Many of the techniques appear to violate [Geneva
Convention] III and IV and should not be used on [enemy prisoners of war] or [civilian
internees]. The [Geneva Conventions] prohibits all coercive interrogation techniques.,,1566
.On September 17,2003, COL Pribble sent a copy ofMAJ Ricci's email to COL
Warren who responded that "almost all ofthese techniques are right out of the Field Manual and
are in use now.,,1567 That same day, MAJ Ricci responded:
Gentlemen, it's the techniques that are not in the field manual that concern me.
Techniques such as dietary manipulation, environmental manipulation, sleep
adjustment, sleep management, yelling, loud music, light control, stress positions,
etc. many of these techniques appear to violate [Geneva Convention] III, Article
17: ''No physical or mental torture, nor any other form of coercion may be
inflicted on prisoners of war to secure from them information of any kind
whatever. Prisoners of war who refuse to answer may not be threatened, insulted,
or exposed to unpleasant or disadvantageous treatment of any kind."
believe we should still seek SECDEF approval- and I am doubtful some of these
techniques will be approved. The policy as written is troublesome. 1568
_Later that day, MAl Ricci spoke with COL Warren by phone. 1569 In a subsequent
email to Mr. Hammill she said that COL Warren was "going to try and re-work the policy. He
is understandably unhappy that the policy was already signed by the [Commanding General] and
now the SJA has the regrettable task oftellin~ the [Commanding General] the policy has
problems - but that's what we get paid for."l 70
In a September 22,2003 email to MAl Ricci, CENTCOM SJA COL Fred Pribble
said "During my sitdown with COL Warren in Baghdad, he was pretty quick to admit that we
(read you) had made the right call and that they would scrub the policy."l571
_ L T G Sanchez said that after CJTF-7 and CENTCOM lawyers began to debate the
policy that he and COL Warren again reviewed the memo. LTG Sanchez stated that COL
Warren told him:
"Yes, they are legal. There is some dissent and different opinions within the legal
community. Some of these may be harsher than others, and in order for us to
eliminate debate and get consensus, we probably ought to put some ofthese aside,
and oh, by the way, they probably wouldn't get us too much anyway if we
implemented them." I said "Okay, fine let's get consensus. Go ahead and
constrain it (the September policy). ,,1572
Email from MN Carrie Ricci to COL Marc Warren, COL Fred Pribble, and William Hammill (September 16,
1568
2(03).
1569 Email from MN Carrie Ricci to William Hammill (September 17, 2003).
m'OIbid
1m Email from COL Fred Pribble to MAJ Carrie Ricci and William Hammill (September 22, 2003).
1m Statement of LTG Ricardo Sanchez (November 23,2004) at 4.
1573The October 12, 2003 policy also eliminated two Army FM techniques - change of scenery up and change of
scenery down. CJTF-7 Memorandum for C2, Combined Joint Task Force Seven, C3, Combined Joint Task Force
Seven, Commander, 205 tb Military Intelligence Brigade, c.rrF-7 Interrogation and Counter-Resistance Policy
(October 12, 2(03) (hereinafter "c.rrF-7 Interrogation and Counur-Resistance Policy (October 12, 2003)").
204
stated that the CITF-7 Commanding General had to approve se~egation in all cases exceeding
"30 days in duration, whether consecutive or nonconsecutive.,,1 74
(U) CITF-7 removed ''the presence of military dogs" from the list of interrogation
techniques in the October 12,2003 policy, but added a line in the "General Safeguards" section
ofthe policy stating that "Should working dogs be present during interro~ations, they will be
muzzled and under the control of a handler at all times to ensure safety." 575 Despite references
to dogs in both the September 14,2003 interrogation policy and the October 12,2003
interrogation policy, LTG Sanchez said that the "intent for the use of dogs was always focused
on the security contributions they make in a detention facility" and that there was "no explicit
direction, guidance, or condoning ofthe use of unmuzzled dogs in the conduct of
interrogations.,,1576 LTG Sanchez acknowledged that placement of "presence of military
working dogs" in the interrogation techniques section ofthe September 14 policy was
"confusing.,,1577 He said that he removed the "presence of military working dogs" from the list
of interrogation techniques in the October policy and put it in the general safeguards section to
make it "clear that using dogs for the deliberate purpose of frightening a detainee was not
pennitted.,,1578
(U) LTG Sanchez stated that "It is certainly clear under the October 2003 policy that the
use of military working dogs in interrogations would require an exception to policy granted by
me.,,1579 COL Pappas stated, however, that he believed that the October 12,2003 interrogation
policy "delegated to me the authority to approve the use of muzzled dogs. ,,1580
(U) The October 12,2003 policy also stated that requests to use interrogation approaches
not listed in the policy "will be submitted to [the CITF-7 Commander] through CITF-7 [Director
for Intelligence] and will include a description ofthe proposed approach and recommended
safeguards." 1581
(U) CPT Wood at Abu Ghraib said that when the October 12,2003 policy was issued, her
interrogators signed a new Interrogation Rules of Engagement Memorandum (IROE).1582 The
new IROE listed all ofthe techniques identified in the October 12, 2003 policy and stated that
they were "approved for all detainees, regardless of status."1583 The IROE also listed approaches
205
not explicitly approved in the October 12, 2003 policy, but which had to be requested through
the Interrogation Officer in Charge to the CJTF-7 Commanding General. The IROE listed nine
examples of such techniques, presence of military working dogs, stress positions, sensory
deprivation, dietary manipulation, environmental manipulation, sleep adjustment, isolation, sleep
management, and change of scenery down. 1584
_ According to the Church Special Focus Team Report, however, the October 25,
2003 SMU TF policy included ten interrogation techniques not listed in the Army Field
Manual. 1587 Those techniques included controlled fear (muzzled dogs), stress positions, sleep
deprivation/adjustment, environmental manipulation, yelling, loud music, and light control,
removal of comfort items, isolation, false documents/report, multiple interrogator, and repeat and
control. 1588 Less than two weeks before the policy was finalized, several of these techniques,
including environmental manipulation, stress positions, muzzled dogs, and sleep adjustment
had been removed from CJTF-Ts interrogation SOP after CENTCOM raised legal concerns
about them. 1589
B84 Ibid.
1 5 8 5 _estionnaire (June 29, 2004) at 2.
1586. The Department of Defense produced two documents to the Committee in response to the request for the
October SOP. Neither of those two documents is dated and one appears to be a draft written sometime after
December 18 2003. See Department of Defense Headquarters, Joint Task Force_Baghdad Airbase,
Iraq,_Battlefield Inte~tyrreamStanding Oper~dures; Department of Defense
Headquarters, Joint Task Force _ _ Baghdad Airbase, Iraq, _ _ Battiefield Interrogation Team and
temporary Facility Standing Operating Procedures. The Department stated in a March 10, 2008 letter that the
documents provided in response to the Committee's request for the October 25,2003 SOP were "reasonably close to
the time frame and location requested." Letter from ASD Robert Wilkie to Chairman Carl Levin (March 10, 2008).
The Department has also informed the Committee that after "multiple searches we were unable to locate an SOP
with the exact October 25, 2003 date." Email from Thomas Alexander to Committee staff (April 9, 2008).
1587 Church Special Focus Team Report at 12-13.
B88. Although the Church Special Focus Team Report identified "repeat and control" as a technique that went
beyond the Army FM, it could also arguably be classified as a Field Manual technique.
1589 CJTF-Ts September 14, 2003 SOP included "sleep management" and "sleep adjustment." See SectionXll E,
supra.
206
(U) Two Army investigations, one conducted by MG Taguba and the other conducted by
Major General George Fay would later find that abuses at Abu Ghraib were perpetrated directly
by both military police (MP) and military intelligence (MI) personnel. 1598 In addition to the
direct participation of MI personnel in incidents of detainee abuse, MG Fay's investigation also
identified situations where MI pe~onnel solicited MPs to engage in detainee abuse, using such
1'_
H91
1'92
Questionnaire (June 29, 2004) at 4.
Church Special Focus Team Report atl3;
Questionnaire (June 29, 2004) at 3.
l'I)4.Ibid
1'9' Ibid.
207
methods as "isolation with sensory deprivation, removal of clothing and humiliation, [and] the
use of dogs as an interrogation tool to induce fear, and physical abuse. ,,1599
(U) Interviews conducted by investigators for both MG Fay and MG Taguba contain
evidence that the use of aggressive interrogation techniques like use of military working dogs,
stress positions, and removal of clothing, was not limited to the specific incidents described in
those reports. In fact, those interviews appear to indicate that the use of some ofthese
techniques was widespread at Abu Ghraib.
(U) The dog teams arrived at Abu Ghraib on November 20,2003. 1605 According to MG
Fay's report, "abusing detainees with dogs started almost immediately after the dogs arrived"
with the first incident occurring on November 24,2003. 1606 Major General Fay's report
documented seven other times over the next six weeks when dogs were used, including three
occasions in which they were used in interrogations, one occasion the report referred to as "an
1604 See Deployment Order 231, referencing U.S. CENTCOM October 9,2003 request for forces.
1606 Ibid
apparent [Military Intelligence] directed use of dogs in detainee abuse," and one incident
described as dogs being used likely as a '''softening up' technique for future interrogations.,,1607
(U) One intelligence analyst stated that it was "common knowledge" that one soldier
used "dogs while he was on his special projects" working directly for COL Pappas after the
capture of Saddam Hussein.,,1612 And an MP said that dogs could be used in interrogations "with
the proper authorization," and that "dogs were used to scare the detainee into confessing or
producing intelligence.,,1613
(U) An Army dog handler said that "MI would ask me to use my dog as a psychological
and physical deterrent. It would consist of a dog walking up to a prisoner and the dog barking at
a prisoner.,,1614 The same dog handler said that "Someone from MI gave me a list of cells, for
me to go see, and pretty much have my dog bark at them... Having the dogs bark at detainees
was psychologically breaking them down for interrogation purposes. ,,1615
(U) On February 19,2004, after MG Taguba had begun his investigation into the abuses
at Abu Ghraib, the Commander of the S04th MI Brigade issued a memorandum stating that
"military working dogs will not be present during the interrogation or debriefing ofany detainees
at the Abu Ghraib facility.,,1616
209
(U) CPT Wood at Abu Ghraib said that stress positions and forced exercise regimens
(also called compulsory physical training) were used in interrogations and the September 14,
2003 CITF-7 policy explicitly authorized the use of stress positions. 1620 CPT Wood's October 9,
2003 Interrogation Rules of Engagement (IROE) for interrogators listed stress positions as an
approved technique. 1621 While the October 12,2003 CITF-7 policy removed stress positions
from the list of authorized interrogation techniques, a subsequent IROE for interrogators
continued to list the technique, with the caveat that its use "must be approved by the
[Commanding General], CITF-7 prior to employment.,,1622
(U) MG Fay's report stated that "What started as nakedness and humiliation, stress and
physical training (exercise) carried over into sexual and physical assaults... ,,1623 The report
described one incident where a detainee was ''forced to stand while handcuffed in such a way to
dislocate his shoulder" and described a photograph of an interrogation 1?eing conducted while
another detainee was squatting on a chair which MG Fay called "an unauthorized stress
position.,,1624
(U) One MP said he "saw MI use stress positions" at Abu Ghraib. 1625 Similarly, the
warden of the Hard Site at Abu Ghraib stated that military intelligence made detainees engage in
physical training and he saw "detainees holding buckets, arms out, and other drillS.,,1626 An MP
Platoon leader stated that he also "observed [military intelligence personnel] making detainees
do physical training.,,1627
210
(U) When asked whether he had ever been directed by MI or another government agency
(OGA) to "soften up" a prisoner, one MP said "Yes, I would have them do physical training to
tire them out.,,1628 Another MP stated that military intelligence personnel insinuated that MP
soldiers should abuse detainees telling them to "'Loosen this guy up for us.' 'Make sure he has a
bad night.' 'Make sure he gets the treatment. ",1629
(U) One interrogator confIrmed the practice of having MPs "soften up" detainees, stating
that the "MPs did prepare prisoners prior to interrogations by having them do physical exercises
and yelling at them. The interrogators would verbally discuss, with an MP, a detainee and his
cooperativeness and various methods to deal with a detainee such as physical exercise at random
hours ofthe night and yelling.,,1630 Other MI soldiers confmned the use of stress positions by
interrogators at Abu Ghraib. One interrogation analyst stated that he witnessed the use of a
stress position where a detainee was "handcuffed to the floor." 1631 The same soldier referred to
that use ofthe stress position as "in following with the interrogation Elan.,,1632 An interrogator
likewise stated that she "did use a stress position" in interrogations. 1 33 Another interrogator who
was deployed from GTMO to Abu Ghraib following the MG Miller assistance visit said that
"stress positions were authorized" when he first got to Abu Ghraib in October 2003 and that he
.
wltnesse d use 0 f t he techni que. 1634
II The Special Mission Unit (SMU) Task Force (TF) in Iraq also used "removal of
clothing" as an interrogation technique in the fall of 2003, just as the Abu Ghraib abuses were
takin lace. While not included in the SMU TF interrogation SOP, the SMU TF Commander
stated that when he took command in October 2003 he "discovered
that some ofthe detainees were not allowed clothes" as an interrogation technique_
211
(U) Though it never appeared in CITF-Ts interrogation policy, MG Fay stated in his
report that removal of clothing was "imported" to Abu Ghraib and could be "traced through
Mghanistan and GTMO.,,1639 MG Fay's report stated that removal of clothing was "used to
humiliate detainees" and said the practice "contributed to an environment that would appear to
condone dePravity and degradation rather than the humane treatment of detainees.,,1640 His
report identified several specific incidents of detainees being stripped or partially stripped at the
direction of interrogation personnel at Abu Ghraib.
(U) Statements by military police and military intelligence personnel who served at Abu
Ghraib indicated that removal of clothing was widely used for interrogations. COL Jerry
Philabaum, the Commander ofthe 320th MP BN at the facility, recalled seeing "between 12-15
detainees naked in their own individual cells.,,1641 He said that when he raised the issue with the
JIDC Commander, LTC Steven Jordan, he was told it "was nonnal practice for detainees to be
naked in their cells, but that usually they didn't have that many naked and that it was a technique
[military intelligence] used.,,1642 CPT Donald Reese, the Commander ofthe 37200 MP Company,
stated that LTC Jordan also told him that stripping detainees was "an interrogation method that
we use.,,1643 CPT Reese said the fact that detainees were naked as an interrogation method was
"known by everybody" and stated that it was "common practice to walk the tier and see
detainees without clothing and bedding."I644
(U) Similarly, an intelligence analyst at Abu Ghraib stated that it was "common that the
detainees on [military intelligence] hold in the hard site were initially kept naked and given
clothing as an incentive to cooperate with US.,,1645 One interrogator stated that "it was practice,
especially for [military intelligence] holds to take their clothes in a possible attempt to renew the
'capture shock' of detainees who had been in custody for an extended period oftime or were
transferred from other facilities. ,,1646 Another interrogator said that "it was common to see
1637
Questionnaire (June 29 2004) at 3.
1638 Ibid
1639 Fay Report at 87.
1640 Ibid at 70.
1641 Statement of Commander 320th MP BN (May 26, 2004).
1642 Ibid
1643 Statement of 372"" MP Company Commander (May 3, 2004); Interview of 372"" MP Company Commander
(February 10, 2004) at 48.
Interview of372"" MP Company Commander (February 10, 2004) at 48-49; Statement of 372Dd MP Company
1644
Commander (February 21,2004); Statement of 372"" MP Company Commander (January 18, 2(04) at 1-2.
164' Statement of Intelligence Analyst (May 25, 2004).
1646 Statement of MI soldier (June IS, 2004).
212
detainees in cells without clothes or naked" and said that it was "one of our approaches.,,1647 The
interrogator said that "any officer who would walk the area at night should have seen the
detainees naked.,,1648
(U) One military police (MP) soldier stated that MI "would tell us to take away [the
detainees'! mattresses, sheets, and clothes" and that ''the detainees would sleep in their cells
naked."I64 Another MP stated that MI used "clothing removal as an interrogation technique in
Tier lA,,1650 Major Michael Sheridan, who was Executive Officer ofthe 320th MP Battalion at
Abu Ghraib, said that he stopped permitting MPs to escort detainees to interrogations after an
incident where a male detainee "was being interrogated naked and then my MPs had to escort
him back to his cell in 45 degree temps with nothing but a bag over his head, and one ofthe MPs
was female.,,1651
(U) One Abu Ghraib interrogator stated that another interrogator who was deployed from
GTMO to Abu Ghraib, told him that he "was Ptermitted as the interrogator to strip a detainee
completely naked in the interrogation booth." 652 Another GTMO interrogator deplored to Abu
Ghraib said that he oversaw the interrogation of a detainee who had been stripped. 165 The
interrogator said that the technique was approved by a superior officer. 1654 A third interrogator
who had previously served at GTMO recalled asking an MP at Abu Ghraib ''to strip [a detainee]
naked for us for the interrogation.,,1655
IIA
January 24,2003 memo from the CITF-180 Deputy SJA stated that "sleep
adjustment," which the memo described as "generally 4 hours of sleep per every 24 hours," was
used as an interrogation technique in Afghanistan. 1657 The SMU TF interrogation policy for Iraq
listed "sleep management" as an authorized technique and described the technique as "four hours
1647 Unsigned interrogator statement (May 13. 2004). The statement was contained in a memorandum for the record
which the interrogator declined to sign based on advice from cOW1Sel.
1648 Ibid
1649 Taguba Report at 19; Article 32 Transcript U.S. v Davis (April 7. 2004) at 11.
16~ Statement of MP soldier (June 6, 2004)
1651 Interview of Major Michael Sheridan (February 14. 2004) at 8.
1652 Statement of M! soldier (May 25. 2004).
1653 Statement ofM! soldier (June 4, 2004).
1654 Ibid
1655 Statement of M! soldier (July 20. 2004).
1656 Secretary of Defense Approval of Counter-Resistance Techniques (December 2,2002).
1657 Memo from LTC Robert Cotell to CENTCOM SJA, CJTF 180 Inte"ogation Techniques (January 24, 2003) at
4.9.
213
of sleep during [a] 24 hour period" - the same way that CITP -180 had described "sleep
ad~ustment ,,'In Afi'nl.
O',amstan. 1658
.
(U) The September 14, 2003 CITP-7 policy authorized both sleep management and sleep
adjustment for interrogations, defining the former as "adjusting the sleep times of a detainee"
and the latter as "4 hours of sleep per 24 hour period,,1659 CPT Wood's October 9,2003 IROE
also listed both "sleep adjustment" and "sleep management" as approved techniques. 1660 CITP
7's October 12, 2003 policy did not include either sleep adjustment or sleep management as
authorized interrogation techniques. 1661 However, an October 16, 2003 IROE written by CPT
Wood continued to list both techniques, saying that their use "must be approved by the
[Commanding General], CITP-7 prior to employment.,,1662
(U) MG Pay's report stated that the "'sleep adjustment' technique was used by [military
intelligence] as soon as the Tier 1A block opened" at Abu Ghraib. 1663 Interviews of MI and MP
soldiers, however, indicated a lack of clarity among MI and MP as to what "sleep adjustment,"
"sleep management," and "sleep deprivation" actually meant. In any case, MPs were integral to
carrying out each of those techniques for MI personnel.
(U) One contract interrogator stated that "During a typical SMMP [sleep and meal
management program], the MPs are responsible for administering the written program provided
by the interrogator... In addition, the MPs are advised that during the awake time period of an
approved SMMS program, the MPs are allowed to do what is necessary to keep the detainee
awake in the allotted period oftime as long as it adheres to approved rules of engagement and
proper treatment of detainee.,,1664 An MI non-commissioned officer stated that he provided sleep
adjustment schedules included in interrogation plans written by interrogators he was supervising
. to the MP Sergeant ofthe Guard. 1665 Similarly, an intelligence analyst said that the process for
using sleep management was "for the interrogator to request it in writing and submit the request
with the interrogation plan... Once it was approved, a memo was given to the MPs showing the
schedule."I666
(U) COL Jerry Philabaum, the Commander ofthe 320lh MP BN, said that "When
[military intelligence] wanted a detainee on sleep deprivation, they would tell the MP guard that
prisoner 'X' was on sleep deprivation. They would give instructions that the detainee was to
16'8 _Memorandum for a l l _ Personnel, SUBJECT: Policy No. 1 - Battlefield Interrogation Team and
214
sleep four hours within a 24 hour period... I don't believe MPs were given specific instructions
on how to keep the detainees awake. It was left to the MPS.,,1667 Another MP Officer stated that:
When Ml needed our assistance with detainees, they did their request through
memorandums. The memorandums would dictate what Ml wanted. The
memorandums were signed by COL Pappas and given to the NCOlC [Non
Commissioned Officer in Charge] of the wing. The memorandums would give
instructions on diet patterns, sleep patterns, music playing, and various other
techniques that MI requested the MPs to carry out. 1668
(U) CPT Wood said that "sleep management was approved by the [Commanding
General] about a dozen times" during her time at Abu Ghraib. 1671 She stated that she
"personally remember[ed] seeing LTG Sanchez's signature on some approvals for sleep
management.,,1672 COL Pappas said that he believed the October 12,2003 CJTF-7 policy gave
him the authority to authorize sleep management. 1673
IIA December 14,2003 memo for LTG Sanchez signed by COL Pappas approved
"sleep management" for three detainees captured in conjunction with Saddam Hussein. 1674 COL
Pappas stated that he "couldn't say for sure" whether he actually sent the memo to LTG Sanchez
but that he "signed it with the intent ofit going to him.,,1675 LTG Sanchez said that, other than
requests to approve segregation in excess of30 days, he did "not recall signing any other
memos" approving other interrogation techniques. 1676
167J Committee staff interview of COL Thomas Pappas (October 12, 2007).
1674 Memorandum from COL Thomas Pappas for LTG Ricardo Sanchez, Exception to ClTF-7 Inte"ogation and
Counter Resistance Policy (December 14, 2003).
167~ Statement of COL Thomas Pappas (January 25,2006) at 9.
1676 Statement of LTG Ricardo Sanchez (November 23,2(04) at 6.
1677 Secretary ofDefense Approval of COWlter-Resistance Techniques (December 2,2002).
215
_ A January 24,2003 memo from the CITF-180 Deputy SJA stated that
"deprivation oflight and sound in the living areas" had been utilized and recommended that ''use
of light and noise deprivation" (not limited to living areas) be approved for im~lementation.1678
The technique was subsequently considered available for use in Mghanistan. l 79
(U) Sensory deprivation was never listed in CITF-7 policy as an approved technique. It
was listed, however, as an approved technique in an October 9, 2003 interrogation rules of
engagement (IROE) document for interrogators at Abu Ghraib. 1680 A subsequent IROE also
listed the technique but said its use "must be approved by the [Commanding General], CITF-7
prior to employment.,,1681
(U) Major General Fay's report identified several specific instances where detainees at
Abu Ghraib were placed in a small room in Tier lA of Abu Ghraib that was referred to as "the
hole" and where they were subject to total isolation and light deprivation. 1682 The report said
that conditions for isolating detainees "sometimes included being kept naked in very hot or very
cold, small rooms, and/or completely darkened rooms, clearly in violation ofthe Geneva
Conventions.,,1683
(U) MG Fay stated that the "environment created at Abu Ghraib contributed to the
occurrence" of detainee abuse there. 1684 But MG Fay was not the first to note the environment at
Abu Ghraib as problematic. An assessment of Abu Ghraib by a retired Army Colonel Stuart
Herrington in late 2003 had referred to Abu Ghraib as a "pressure cooker" and cited an urgent
need to improve conditions at the facility. 1685
1678 Memo from LIC Robert Cotell to CENTCOM SJA, CJTF 180 Inte"ogation Techniques (January 24, 2003) at
4,9.
1679 Church Report at 7.
1680 CJTF-7 Inte"ogation Rules ofEngagement (October 9, 2003).
1681 CJTF.7 Inte"ogation Rules ofEngagement (October 16, 2003).
1682 Fay Report at 94.
1683 Ibid at 28.
1684 Ibid at 9.
168~ Herririgton to Fast, Report ofCI/HUMlNT Evaluation Visit (December 12, 2003) at 2.
216
retired Army Colonel Stuart Herrington to assess U.S. intelligence operations in Iraq.I686 COL
Herrington had also assessed intelligence operations at Guantanamo Bay in March 2002. 1687
(U) In his written report of the visit, COL Herrington cited an urgent need to improve
conditions at Abu Ghraib. 1690 He cited overpopulation ofthe facility as a problem that could
lead to further rioting and danger to U.S. personnel. He commented that the leadership at Abu
Ghraib felt the facility was a "pressure cooker" and that it was "only a matter oftime before
prisoners staged an uRrising" and that "bad things" such as "death, injury, or hostage situations"
were likely to occur. 691 COL Herrington also assessed that shortages of interro~ators and
equipment had resulted in a failure to interrogate detainees of intelligence value. 692 He
concluded that Abu Ghraib was simply ''unsuitable for the exploitation of high value
detainees.,,1693
(U) COL Herrington also expressed concern with the practice of not assigning Internment
Serial Numbers (ISNs) to certain detainees. He wrote in his assessment report that the creation
of"ghost" detainees who were not in the accounting system carried certain risks "not the least of
which is that it may be technically illegal.,,1694
(U) On December 9,2003, COL Herrington met with MG Barbara Fast, CJTF-7's
Director for Intelligence (CJ_2).1695 He later described her as "astonished" by his observations of
1686 Department of Defense Office of Inspector General, Detainee Abuse Evaluation Memorandum for the Record,
October 20, 2004 meeting with Col (Ret) Stuart A. Herrington (undated) at 1 (hereinafter DoD!G, Herrington
Interview).
1687 See Section IF, supra.
1688 DoD !G, Herrington Interview at 1.
1689 Herrington to Fast. Report ofCIIHUMINT Evaluation Visit (December 12, 2003) at 3.
1690 Ibid
1691 Ibid
1692 Ibid at 8.
1693 Ibid at 2-3.
1694 Ibid at 4.
1695 Army !G, Interview of COL (Ret) Stuart Herrington (November 3, 2004) at 17; DoD !G, Herrington Interview.
217
Abu Ghraib. 1696 He said that "in a couple of cases she said, 'I was unaware ofthat. I didn't
know that' or 'I thought we fixed that. ",1697 COL Herrington added that, "It was very evident to
me that she was not being well informed" by her staff. 1698
(U) COL Herrington wrote in his report that an OGA representative told him that OGA
personnel had been instructed not to have any involvement with interrogation operations at the
SMU TF as the "practices there were in contravention to his Agency's guidance on what was and
what was not permissible in interrogating detainees.,,1701 He added that he had been told by his
CITF-7 escort that it would be "difficult, ifnot impossible" to visit the SMU TF facilities. His
written report stated that:
1696 Army IG, Interview of COL (Ret) Stuart Herrington (November 3, 2004) at 17.
1697 Ibid
1698 Ibid at 16.
1699 Herrington to Fast, Report ojCI/HUMINT Evaluation Visit (December 12, 2003) at 7.
1700 Herrington to Fast, Report ojCI/HUMINT Evaluation Visit (December 12, 2003) at 7.
1701 Ibid.
1702 Ibid
1703 DoD IG, Herrington Interview at 3.
1704 Ibid. at 4.
218
(U) COL Herrington told the DoD IGthat he expected that CITF-7 and the Army G2
would investigate the issues he raised. 1705 However, he said they never contacted him and he
was notified by CITF-7 in April of2004 that there had been "insufficient evidence to
substantiate" what he had heard from the former ISG nDC Chief about detainee mistreatment in
Iraq.1706 The Office ofthe Staff Judge Advocate at CITF-7 stated in an April 7, 2004 letter to
COL Herrington that the investigating officer had not been able to "recreate those conversations
upon which [COL Herrington'sJ report was based" and that it had been difficult to "pin down
timelines and events in time.,,17 7
(U) The allegations raised by COL Herrington were the subject of an investigation
conducted by CITF-7 in early 2004. In what VADM Church described as an "extremely brief,
three-page report," the CITF-7 investigating officer found no proofto substantiate the allegations
1708
against the SMU TF. VADM Church criticized the CITF-7 r~ort as "extremely brief and
cursory" with "obvious gaps in the investigation methodology.,,17o VADM Church called the
failure to more thoroughly investwate the allegations a "lost opportunity to address potential
detainee abuse in Iraq early on.,,1 0
. .
AP) operated under the tactical command ofCITF-7. CJSOTF-AP contained units from the 5th
- - - -- - - --- - - - -
1'105 Ibid
1i06 Ibid.
1'107 Letter from Office of the Staff Judge Advocate to COL Stuart Herrington (April 7, 2004).
1709 Ibid.
1710 Ibid
1711 AR-lS-6 Investigation ofCJSOTF-AP and Sth SF Group Detention Operations (November 8, 2004) at 13, IS, 71
219
.On
concerns with techniques in the earlier policy.I714
Febm
an interrogation policy for
Commander, issued
using the September 14,2003 CJTF-7 policy as its basis
and authorizing the use of aggressive interrogation techniques, including the presence of military
working dogs, stress positions, sleep management, loud music, and light control, and
environmental manipulation. 1715 The policy stated that certain techniques, such as presence of
military working dogs, stress positions, and loud music and light control, required approval by
the CJTF-7 Commander ifthey were to be used against enemy prisoners of war. The use of
those techniques against all other detainees, however, was permitted with the written approval of
a Deputy Commander or Commander.
_ The March 23, 2004 policy stated that "you should consider the fact that some
interrogation techniques are viewed as inhumane or otherwise inconsistent with intemationallaw
220
before applying each technique. These techniques are labeled with a [CAUTION].,,1720
Environmental manipulation, the use of power tools, stress positions, and the presence of
working dogs were all marked with the word "CAUTION."I721
BG
Formica also found that some detainees held by a tactical unit were "kept naked for the initial
interrogation" and fed only bread or crackers and water "ifthey did not cooperate with ...
interrogators.,,1723 He said that a detainee held by another tactical unit under CJSOTF-AP
command "may have been fed just bread and water for 17 days.,,1724
1720 Ibid at 6.
1721 Ibid at 4.
1721 Formica Report at 8.
1723 Ibid. at 74.
1714 Ibid at 8.
172~ THT 160 ( ). Camp Honesty Interrogation Plan (undated).
1726 Ibid
1727 Ibid.
1728 Ibid.
221
use" at Bagram. 1729 That list included the use of "safety positions," "sleep adjustment," "sensory
overload," invading a detainee's personal space to "increase psychological discomfort," "dietary
manipulation," adjusting temperature or introducing an unpleasant smell to "create moderate
discomfort," and using blacked out goggles as an interrogation technique. 1730
Prior to March 2004, however, each operated under a distinct interrogation SOP. On March 26,
2004 the SMU TF implemented a single interrogation policy that covered SMU TF operations in
both Iraq and Afghanistan. 1731
_ According to the Church Special Focus Team Report, the March 26, 2004 SMU
TF SOP included a larger number of interrogation techniques outside ofFM 34-52 than the SOPs
of any other military organization at the time. 1733 In fact, many ofthe techniques in that SOP had
been abandoned by conventional forces in Afghanistan months earlier, after CENTCOM
identified legal concerns with the techniques. 1734 Although the authority in the March SOP to
use "muzzled dogs" was rescinded on April 22, 2004, the remainder ofthe techniques remained
authorized until May 6, 2004, when GEN John Abizaid, the CENTCOM Commander, suspended
use of all non-FM 34-52 techniques. 1735 The Church Special Focus Team report said the
techniques were suspended as a result of detainee abuse at Abu Ghraib. 1736 GEN Abizaid stated
172S1cm-180 SJA Memorandum for Record, CTJ'F-180 Detainee Operations Standard Operating Procedures
(March 27, 2004).
1730 Ibid
222
that neither he nor his staff "reviewed or approved" the March 2004 SMU TF SOP "prior to its
issuance.,,1737
_ Several interrogation techniques authorized for use by the SMU Task Force prior
to GEN Abizaid's suspension, including stress positions, sleep adjustment/management, sensory
overload, and sensory deprivation were similar to techniques used in the resistance phase of
SERE training. In fact, undated SMU TF SOPs from this period suggest a connection between
SMU TF interrogation techniques and SERE. The SOPs state, under interrogation "Standards,"
that "[i]nterrogations will be done [in accordance with] all applicable rules and regulations to
include... SurvivallEvasioniResistance/and Escape regulations. ,,1738
_(
sent a messa e to
SLEEP MANAGEMENT,
ENVIRONMENTAL MANIPULATION (LIGHT AND NOISE), EXTENDED
INTERROGATIONS, VARYING COMFORT POSITIONS AND THE USE OF
HOODS TO INDUCE A PSYCHOLOGICAL SENSE OF ISOLATION AND
DEPENDENCE ON THE INTERROGATORS ARE PARTICULARLY
USEFUL. 1740
1737 Memorandum from General John Abizaid, Responses to Request for Information from VADM Church (August
17Ja"
6,2004).
See Department of Defense Headquarters, Joint Task Force 121 (ITF-121), Baghdad Air Base, Iraq
17J9 Message from Commander_to Commander DTG 231006Z MAY 04 (May 23,
2004) at 1.
1741 Ibid. at 1.
223
stated that control positions - defmed as "requiring the detainee to stand, sit, kneel, squat,
maintain sitting position with back against the wall, bend over chair, lean with head against wall,
lie prone across chairs, stand with arms above head or raised to shoulders, or other normal
physical training positions" - could also "be used in order to implement sleep management" and
that "in the most exceptional circumstances, and on approval from [the SMU TF Commander],"
interrogators could ''use handcuffs to enforce the detainee's position.,,1743 An interrogator could
require a detainee to remain in a control position for "no more than 45 minutes in one hour and
for no more than six hours in a 24 hour period.,,1744
(U) Notwithstanding the May 6, 2004 suspension of all non-FM 34-52 techniques, on
June 4, 2004, GEN Abizaid approved the use of slerE management, environmental manipulation,
separation, and change of scenery for the SMU TF. 1 45 He delegated the approval authority for
the use of those techniques to the "fIrst general officer in the chain of command," and specifIed
that none of the techniques could be used beyond a 72 hour period "without a review by [the
SMU TF Commander] or the fIrst general officer in the chain of command.,,1746
In the May 12,2004 request, CENTCOM asked that JFCOM provide a Joint
Personnel Recovery Agency (JPRA) team to "conduct an on-site assessment of [Bagram
Collection Point] operations in Bagram and Kandahar to assist in the development and
1747.Emai1 from Christopher Wirts to Thomas Markland, John Huffstutter, David Ellis (January 19, 2005). Mr.
Wirts's email stated "Initially when the mission was tentatively approved we went to HQ CENTCOM and
reviewedlbriefed the J2X on how we intended to support. They were satisfied with our methods and intent. After
the CENTCOM visit, we were called to JFCOM and met with ADM [Giambastiani], Gen S01igan, Gen Wagner,
JFCOM Legal and a host of other personnel. In the days following the meeting, the mission was turned off. "
224
_That same day, JPRA personnel briefed JFCOM Deputy Commander LTG Wagner,
JFCOM Chief of Staff Maj Gen James Soligan, and JFCOM Commander ADM Giambastiani,
about the planned support. 1750
(U) Materials prepared for those briefm s stated that after September 11, 2001, JPRA
was "requested to support [Defense Intelligence Agency],"
GTMO, Fort Huachuca, and ,,1751
III
( The briefmg materials specifically highlighted JPRA's September 2003 trip
to Iraq in support ofthe Special Mission Unit Task Force there and described JPRA's intended
support for CENTCOM in Afghanistan. 1752 Among JPRA's "key tasks" for the planned
Afghanistan trip was to observe "exploitation procedures" used by CENTCOM personnel and to
"identifY areas for improvement" and "assist and advise on alternate approaches.,,1753 The
briefing materials stated that JPRA intended to provide "on the spot recommendations to the
[CENTCOM] staffif appropriate" on these alternate approaches. 17S4
1748 Message from CENTCOM, Request for USJFCOM Support, DTG: 121729Z May 04 (May 12, 2004).
1749 Ibid.
1750 Email from Randy Moulton to Steven Johns and Fred Milburn (May 10, 2004); Committee staff interview of
Christopher Wirts (January 4, 2007)
1m Email from Randy Moulton to , James Soligan. Robert Wagner, Fred Milburn, et al., attaching
Briefing Slides and Executive Summary with Iraq CONOP; Committee staff interview of Christopher Wirts (January
4,2007).
1752As part of the briefmg materials, an executive summary of the September 2003 trip identified the JPRA
identified deficiencies as the SMU TF's "lack of clear legal guidance on status of captured personnel," "lack of
established [Rules of E~ent or Standard Operating Procedure]," "lack of training and preparation," and "lack
of information sharing." _ See Executive Summary; see also Briefing Slides at 5-8.
1753 Briefing slides at 6-8.
1754 Ibid
1755Several drafts of a Concept of Operations (CONOP) for the planned trip by JPRA personnel to Afghanistan were
provided to the Committee. While those drafts are not dated, communications between and/or among JPRA and
JFCOM personnel discussing revisions to the drafts suggest when those drafts were produced and how the CONOP
evolved
225
CAPT Donovan had recommended removing these techniques from the Iraq
_( Col Moulton, the JPRA Commander, had earlier defended the inclusion
ofthe full range of SERE techniques in the Iraq CONOP by saying that "all the techniques
discussed [in the CONOP] are ones that [JPRA] (or other services) employ in our training (with
considerable oversight - only the Navy uses the waterboard)." He continued: "In discussions
with [the Office of Secretary of Defense General Counsel] last year, they specifically requested
what type of techniques we found most effective against our personnel. Our intent is to provide
a prioritized list of what works on our folks, and let the lawyers and Combatant Commanders
decide to what degree and which target audience they apply these, if any, techniques. ,,1758
When [Col Mouhon] says that the Navy uses [waterboarding], he means that they
use it against our own people during survival, evasion, resistance and escape
(SERE) training. In other words, qualified Navy SERE instructors use this to
demonstrate to our own people what the. ENEMY is likely to do to them in the
even they are captured, and (hopefully) to train our people how to resist or cope
with such techniques.
JPRA and SERE folks will swear that the "water board" does not actually
physically harm subjects if it is administered by properly trained SERE
instructors, under close supervision, etc. For that reason, some argue that the
17'6 Ibid
1757.Shortly after the briefing. a JFCOM action officer sent JPRA leadership a list of action items for LTG II
W~er and MG Soligan. Among those were JPRA (1) locating the after action report from JPRA's support to
and (2) preparing a message to the Chainnan of the Joint Chiefs of Staff "to provide policy/guidance on
possibility of extending JPRA roles/responsibilities to the offensive vice defensive preparations/practices." In
response, Col. Moulton told the JFCOM action officer that "[t]here was no [after action report] for t h e "
support" and instead directed him to the "executive summary" of the trip provided in the briefing materials. Col.
Moulton also stated that it was JPRA's understanding that "[Admiral Giambastiani] would approve our participation
[in the Afghanistan trip] with a [Voice Command] from the Joint Staff regardless of the status of the policy guidance
(he has previously approved and we are currently supporting other 'offensive' efforts)." Email from Randy Moulton
to Steven Johns, Fred Milburn, Christopher Wirts, and Dan Donovan (May 13, 2004).
ms Email from Col. Randy Moulton to Maj Gen James Soligan, CAPT Dan Donovan, RADM John Bird, LTG
Robert Wagner et al. (September 30, 2003).
226
II( On May 13,2004, the day after Col Moulton briefed the JFCOM leadership,
he circulated a revised CONOP for the Mghanistan trip. The revised CONOP stated that IPRA
would "not recommend or train physical pressures," however, it also stated that a "key task" of
the mission was to observe "exploitation procedures at the site to assist in identifyin~
improvements" and develop "alternate approaches to meet exploitation objectives.,,1 60 CAPT
Donovan immediately expressed his concern with that "key task" in an email to ADM
Giambastiani and LTG Wagner, stating:
CAPT Donovan also expressed his concerns about the intended mission to Col
Moulton, writing in a May 13, 2004 email:
175~mail from CAPT Dan Donovan to ADM Edmund Giambastiani, LTG Robert Wagner and Maj Gen James
Soligan (May 13, 2004) (emphasis in original).
1760. Draft Concept of Operations in Support of Pending CENTCOM Joint Interrogation Facility Observation and
Assessment Requirement.
1761 Email from CAPT Dan Donovan to ADM Edmund Giambastiani, LTG Robert Wagner, Maj Gen James Soligan.
(May 13, 2004) (emphasis in original).
227
III The next day, CAPT Donovan sent another email to ADM Giambastiani, LTG
Wagner, and Maj Gen Soligan pointing out the "potential risk to the entire JPRA mission
if they are in any way implicated in the current mess in Ira~."1763 JPRA's planned May
2004 mission to Afghanistan was subsequently called off 1 64
_ When the request arrived at JFCOM, CAPT Donovan again raised concerns with
Maj Gen Soligan about the scope ofthe request. In a June 21, 2004 email, he asked "whether
JPRA is really the appropriate choice" for the mission described in the CENTCOM request, i.e.,
to "observe exploitation procedures at the site and identify improvements or develop alternate
approaches to meet exploitation objectives.,,1768 Maj Gen Soligan subsequently raised the issue
with Maj Gen John Sattler, the CENTCOM Director of Operations (13), who Maj Gen Soligan
said told him that CENTCOM had made a "conscious decision on what capability they want.,,1769
_CAPT Donovan also raised his concerns directly with lawyers at CENTCOM and
the Joint Staff. In an email to the lawyers, he wrote:
1762 Email from CAPT Dan Donovan to Col. Randy Moulton and Col Fred Milburn (May 13, 2004).
1763 Email from CAPT Dan Donovan to Maj Gen James Soligan. copying ADM Edmund Giambastiani and LTG
Robert Wagner (May 14, 2004).
1764_According to Mr. Wirts, JPRA's OSO Chief, "[W]e went to HQ CENTCOM and reviewedlbriefed the
J2X on how we intended to support. They were satisfied with our methods and intent. After the CENTCOM visit,
we were called to JFCOMand met with [Admiral Giambastiani, Maj Gen Soligan. LTG Wagner], JFCOM Legal
and a host of other personnel. In the days following the meeting, the mission was turned off." Email from
Christopher Wirts to Lt Col Thomas Markland, copying Lt Col John Huffstutter, Col David Ellis (January 19, 2005).
1765 CENTCOM Request for USJFCOM Operational Support, DTG: 200800Z JUN 04 (June 20, 2004).
1766 Ibid
1767 Ibid
1768 Email from CAPT Dan Donovan to Maj Gen James Soligan and LTG Robert Wagner (June 21, 2004).
1769 Email from Maj Gen James Soligan to CAPT Dan Donovan (June 21, 2004).
228
I'm concerned that the folks from our Joint Personnel Recovery Agency (JPRA)
who oversee training US military personnel how to resist interrogations by our
enemies (e.g., SERE training) - are the wrong guys to be advising US
interrogators how to more effectively exploit PUCs. JPRA considers themselves
to be the exploitation experts, but in many ways my view is that their expertise is
in training US personnel how to best resist ILLEOAL techniques. This kind of
advice may be the last thing you all want/need in Afghanistan right now. 1770
_ Over the next month, JFCOM senior leadership discussed the proposed trip with
JPRA and the Joint Staff. At JFCOM's request, JPRA developed and provided JFCOM with a
training plan for the mission 1771 On June 30, 2004, Maj Oen Soligan told JPRA in an email to
prepare for the trip, but directed them not to deploy until the trip was approved by JFCOM's
Commander ADM Edmund Oiambastiani. 1772 JFCOM also discussed working with Joint Staff
to fmd a capability outside JPRA to send to CENTCOM to assist with their detainee operations,
but expected a "nonconcur" with any "recommendation to use other resources.,,1773
II
As discussions about the CENTCOM request continued within JFCOM, Col Kenneth
Rollins, a SERE psychologist added his perspective on the advisability of sending JPRA
personnel to assist with interrogations. The psychologist said:
[W]e need to really stress the difference between what instructors do at SERE
school (done to INCREASE RESISTANCE capability in students) versus what is
taught at interrogator[] school (done to gather information). What is done by
SERE instructors is by definition ineffective interrogator conduct, and
interrogator school, not SERE school is the appropriate focus and model for
investigating interrogators. Simply stated, SERE school does not train you on
how to interrogate, and things you "learn" there by osmosis about interrogation
are probably wrong if copied by interrogators. 1774
II
As Col Rollins's comments were circulated at JFCOM, LtCol Richard Posey, one of
the JFCOM JAOs added that "[i]t would be difficult to come up with a stronger argument against
concurring in this request.,,1775 LtCol Posey added: "CENTCOM needs interrogation experts.
JPRA is telling us ... that their instructors are ineffective interrogators and probably do it wrong
because their focus is on increasing resistance not decreasing it. For the same reasons, this does
1770 Email from Dan Donovan to Joint Staff and CENTCOM lawyers (June 21, 2004) (emphasis in original).
1 7 7 1 _ The training plan was intended to provide the JFCOM Commander an idea of how JPRA would satisfy
the request to "conduct on-site assessments" at Bagram and Kandahar and "assist the commands in . . . developing
and implementing an indoctrination program and other interrogation / exploitation options ..." Email from Maj Gen
James Soligan to Col Randy Moulton, RADM John Bird, LTG Robert Wagner (June 23,2004).
1772 Email from Maj Gen James Soligan to RADM John Bird, Col. Randy Moulton, et aI. (June 30, 2004).
1m Email from LtCol Richard Posey to CAPT Alan Kaufman, copying LTC John Jones, CAPT Daniel Donovan
(June 30, 2004); Email from LtCol Richard Posey to Maj Paul Voss, copying Col Fred Milburn, Lt Col Steven
Johns, CAPT Alan Kaufman, LTC John Jones (July 12, 2004).
1774 Email from LtCol Richard Posey to Maj Paul Voss, copying Col Fred Milburn, Lt Col Steven Johns, CAPT Alan
Kaufman, LTC John Jones (July 12, 2004) (emphasis in original).
1m Ibid.
229
not pass the Washington Post test. DoD already has enough egg on its face concerning detainee
operations. ,,1776
(U) The trip to Mghanistan was subsequently cancelled. Christopher Wirts, JPRA
Operations Support Office (OSO) Chief, told the Committee that although he did not know why
JFCOM cancelled the trip, he recalled discussing the negative media attention from Abu Ghraib
with LTG Wagner and Maj Gen Soligan. l777
c: U.S. Joint Forces Command Issues Policy Guidance For JPRA "Offensive"
Suppon(U)
. . In July 2004, following JFCOM's cancellation ofthe proposed trip by JPRA
personnel to Mghanistan, ADM Giambastiani issued guidance to JPRA about "offensive"
interrogation support. In a July 21, 2004 email to Col Moulton and RADM John Bird, the
JFCOM J-3, Maj Gen Soligan wrote:
ADM Giarnbastiani has given specific guidance that JPRA will not conduct any
activities on or make any recommendations on offensive interrogation techniques
or activities without specific approval from the JFCOM Commander, [Deputy
Commander, or Chief of Staff] All JPRA actions and recommendations related
to interrogations of enemy detainees will be conducted in accordance with
JPRA's current mission statement and limited to defensive actions and
recommendations. 1778
_ A few days after that email, a draft memo containing the guidance was sent to Col
Moulton. In a July 26, 2004 email to Maj Gen Soligan and RADM Bird, Col Moulton
questioned why the policy was necessary and offered his view on JPRA's prior support to
interrogation operations:
Immediately following 9/11 JPRA was approached by~
~SD General Council [sic] (and l a t e r - , - ,
. . . . . - USA strategic debriefmg school in Ft Huachuca, and ITF 170)
regarding U.S. training on resistance to interrogation techniques. All requests for
information or support were coordinated through JFCOM, and all interested
agencies were directed to make formal requests through JFCOM. All external
requests for support have been unsolicited. From the very beginning I expressed
concern that supporting these requests would go outside the JPRA charter and
provided an honest assessment of the potential risk associated with the support.
All CONOPS and actions have been fully vetted through JFCOM. Ifthe message
is to relay that we won't play in "offensive" ops - that has been received loud and
1776 Ibid
230
(U) As the Department of Defense Inspector General continued its inquiry into JPRA's
prior "offensive" interrogation su~ort, the DoD Inspector General asked JFCOM about the
September 2004 policy memo. 178 In a February 2005 memo to the DoD Inspector General,
LTG Wagner stated that the purpose ofthe September 2004 policy was to provide "clear
guidance" and to "prevent use of JPRA outside the command's mission scope.,,1783 Knowing
that CENTCOM and Joint Staffhad expressed interest in JPRA to assist or support "in-theater
1779 Email from Col Randy Moulton to Maj Gen James Soligan, RADM John Bird, Maj Gen Jack Holbein (July 26,
2004).
1780 Memo from Maj Gen James Soligan to Col Randy Moulton, Joint Personnel Recovery Agency Mission
Guidance (September 29,2004).
1781 Ibid
1782 Memorandum for the Department of Defense Inspector General, signed by LTG Robert Wagner (February 10,
2005).
1783 Ibid
231
interrogations," LTG Wagner said that JFCOM sought to clarify that "JPRA is primarily a school
house, not an intelligence gathering activity.,,1784 He added that "JPRA does not have not have
personnel assigned to be interrogators," and that ''the expertise ofJPRA lies in training personnel
how to respond and resist interrogations - not in how to conduct interrogations.,,1785
(U) According to LTG Wagner, JFCOM issued the September 2004 policy statement ''to
ensure that JPRA activities remained within the scope ofthat Agency's mission charter.,,1786 He
stated that JFCOM considered requests for JPRA "interrogator support" to be "inconsistent" with
JPRA's charter. 1787 He stated, however, that the memorandum was not "issued in response to
suspected or known inappropriate JPRA activities, as no such activities were known by this
headquarters to have been conducted.,,1788 Notwithstanding that statement, however, by
September 2004, when JFCOM issued the policy, JFCOM had already approved a trip by JPRA
personnel to Iraq as well as other "offensive" interrogation support - activities that fell outside
JPRA's roles and responsibilities.
1784 Ibid
178~ Ibid.
1786 Ibid
1787 Ibid
1788 Ibid
232
Aiding Torture:
Health Professionals
Ethics and Human Rights Violations
Revealed in the May 2004
CIA Inspector Generals Report
A Report by
Physicians for Human Rights
August 2009
Advanced
HEALTHMedia Group
PROFESSIONALS Page 318REVEALED
Ethics and Human Rights Violations of 727 in the May 2004 CIA Inspector GeneralS
October 2, 2009
Report 1
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 337
Page
of 2413
338 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
that the Agencys technique is different because it is for 2. Hooding
real and is more poignant and convincing. 2
Detainees were blindfolded or hooded to instill in them a
Analysis of New Approved Techniques Revealed sense of fear, disorientation and dependency on their captors.
in Inspector Generals Report According to the February 2004 report of the International
The additional approved techniques listed in the Inspector Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) on treatment of detainees
Generals report and not previously analyzed by PHR include in Iraq:
shaving, hooding, restricted diet, prolonged diapering, wall- Hooding [was] used to prevent people from seeing and to
ing and confinement boxes. disorient them, and also to prevent them from breathing
freely. One, or sometimes two bags, sometimes with an
As with the previously reviewed techniques, while these elastic blindfold over the eyes which, when slipped down,
techniques can have harmful physical as well as mental health further impeded proper breathing. Hooding was some-
effects, their chief objective is to produce psychological im- times used in conjunction with beatings thus increasing
pact, and their chief risk is prolonged mental pain and suffer- anxiety as to when blows would came. The practice of
ing. hooding also allowed the interrogators to remain anony-
mous and thus to act with impunity. Hooding could last
for periods from a few hours to up to 2 to 4 consecutive
1. Forced shaving days, during which hoods were lifted only for drinking,
Forced shaving of the head and beard was alleged by two eating or going to the toilets.5
of the fourteen detainees interviewed by the ICRC for its 2007
report. PHR reported in Broken Laws, Broken Lives that according
Mr. Ramzi Bin-al-Shib alleged that, in his eighth place of to former detainees medically evaluated by PHR, hooding was
detention, first his head was shaved and then some days used both during transportation and during interrogation.
later his beard was also shaved off. He was particularly
distressed by the fact that the people who shaved him al- Medical Analysis:When not used in transport, hooding is
legedly deliberately left some spots and spaces in order a form of sensory deprivation aimed at causing dislocation and
to make him look and feel particularly undignified and confusion. Research shows that prolonged sensory depriva-
abused.3 tion can result in depression, depersonalization and psychosis.
According to the ICRC report, hooding, and other observed
In 2007, PHR physicians examined a former US detainee, sensory deprivation techniques resulted in
who reported: signs of concentration difficulties, memory problems,
When they finished hitting me they shaved my hair. verbal expression difficulties, incoherent speech, acute
The only hair I had was in the middle. This was only to anxiety reactions, abnormal behavior and suicidal
humiliate me. 4 tendencies.6
5. Walling He went on to say that a cover was placed over the boxes
Six of the fourteen high-value detainees interviewed by the while he was inside making it hot and difficult to breathe.
ICRC reported being placed in a neck collar or roll and then
slammed against a wall. According to the CIA guidelines, Medical Analysis: Confinement in a box is an extreme ex-
8 ICRC Report.
ample of stress positions, with the added effect of decreased
9 The purpose of all coercive techniques is to induce psychological access to fresh air, temperature changes, light deprivation and
regression in the subject by bringing a superior outside force to bear on his isolation. Stress positions have been associated with permanent
will to resist. Regression is basically a loss of autonomy, a reversion to an
earlier behavioral level. As the subject regresses, his learned personality traits 10 CIA guidelines as reproduced in Inspector Generals report, p. 15.
fall away in reverse chronological order Human Resource Exploitation 11 ICRC Report.
Manual, CIA, 1983 12 Leave No Marks.
Advanced
HEALTHMedia Group
PROFESSIONALS Page 320REVEALED
Ethics and Human Rights Violations of 727 in the May 2004 CIA Inspector GeneralS
October 2, 2009
Report 3
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 339
Page
of 2413
340 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
joint and ligamentous injury, and both acute and prolonged harmful interrogationtechniques.15 Such medical participation
musculoskeletal pain. In addition, use of stress positions fol- in torture is a clear violation of medical ethics. Furthermore,
lowing blunt trauma carries the risk of deep vein thrombosis health professionals were complicit in selecting and then ra-
(clotting) and associated and potentially fatal pulmonary em- tionalizing these abusive methods whose safety and efficacy
boli. This is not a theoretical risk, as at least two detainees in in eliciting accurate information have no valid basis in sci-
US Custody in Afghanistan died of pulmonary emboli due to ence. The severe physical and psychological pain and endur-
use of stress positions in interrogation settings.13 ing harms associated with these techniques make it evident that
they constitute torture and ill treatment. Monitoring of interro-
Confinement in a box was devised as a direct appropriation
gation techniques by medical professionals to determine their
of Martin Seligmans research on learned helplessness. In
effectiveness uses detainees as human subjects without their
fact, on at least two occasions, Seligman presented his learned
consent, and thus also approaches unlawful experimentation.16
helplessness research to CIA contract interrogators referred to
in the Inspector Generals report. In Seligmans experiment, According to CIA guidelines, health professionals including
dogs were confined to boxes in which they discovered that fa- a psychologist and doctor were required to be present during
miliar mechanisms of control would no longer have an effect in the use of enhanced interrogation techniques.17 The required
avoiding pain. presence of health professionals did not make these methods
safer, and in fact only served to sanitize their use and enable
Like their canine counterparts, humans subjected to similar the abuse to escalate, thereby placing health professionals in
confinement develop psychomotor and cognitive responses the untenable position of calibrating harm rather than serving
that would be clinically diagnosed as depression and, in cer- as protectors and healers as required by their ethical oath.
tain cases, PTSD. Such symptoms include apathy, helpless-
ness, hopelessness, foreshortened sense of future, and a (in this The report also documents the role of health professionals in
case justified) lack of belief in their ability to affect their future participating in initial psychological and physical assessments
prospects. In Seligmans experiments, these symptoms were of detainees in an intake process closely linked to the process
severe and lasting, in that a change to an environment where of interrogation. By requirement, all interrogations were moni-
the dogs could have an effect did not change the symptoms of tored in real-time by health professionals. Previous reports,
learned helplessness. including the ICRC report, document allegations that a medi-
cal device called a pulse oximeter (a device to measure oxygen
saturation in a subjects blood) was placed on the finger of a
Unapproved and Improvised Techniques
15 Several months earlier, in late 2001, CIA had tasked an independent
The Inspector Generals Report contains numerous accounts contractor psychologist, who had [redacted] experience in the US Air
of interrogation techniques that were not approved for use, in- Forces Survival, Evasion, resistance, and Escape (SERE) training program,
cluding threats with a gun and power drill, threats of harm to to research and write a paper on Al-Qaidas resistance to interrogation
loved ones, and choking and carotid artery pressure. techniques. This psychologist collaborated with a Department of Defense
(DoD) psychologist who had [redacted] SERE experience in the US
Air Force and DoD to produce the paper Recognizing and Developing
Threats of harm to the detainee or loved ones are reviewed Countermeasures to Al-Qaidas Resistance to Interrogation Techniques:
in Leave No Marks. The risks of choking and carotid artery A Resistance Training Perspective. Subsequently, the two psychologists
pressure should be self-evident. They include risk of choking developed a list of new and more aggressive EITs [enhanced interrogation
death and stroke, as well as high risk of psychological trau- techniques] that they recommended for use in interrogations. Inspector
Generals Report p. 13. CIAs OTS obtained data on the use of the proposed
ma from a near-death experience. Near-death experiences are EITs and their potential long-term psychological effects on detainees.
highly correlated with the risk of developing post traumatic OTS input was based in part on information solicited from a number of
stress disorder. psychologist and knowledgeable academics in the area of psychopathology
and OTS also solicited input from DoD/Joint Personnel Recovery Agency
(JPRA) regarding techniques used in SERE training and any subsequent
Role of Health Professionals in Torture psychological effects on students. Inspector Generals Report p. 14.
16 The Office of Medical Services guidelines for waterboarding state A
Health professionals played central roles in developing, im- rigid guide to the medically approved use of the waterboard is not possible, as
plementing and providing justification for torture. safety will depend on how the water is applied and the specific response each
time it is used. The following general guidelines are based on very limited
Healthprofessionals in the Office of Medical Services and knowledge, drawn from very few subjects whose experience and response
was quite varied. They add NOTE: In order to best inform future medical
psychologist contractors14 engaged in designing and monitoring judgments and recommendations, it is important that every application of the
waterboard be thoroughly documented: how long each application (and the
entire procedure) lasted, how much water was applied, if a seal was achieved,
if the naso- or oropharynx was filled, what sort of volume was expelled, how
long was the break between applications, and how the subject looked between
13 Allen S. Rich J. Bux R. Farbenblum B. Berns M. Rubenstein L. Deaths of each treatment.
Detainees in the Custody of US Forces in Iraq and Afghanistan from 2002 to 17 In 2004, when Daniel B. Levin, then the acting assistant attorney general
2005. Medscape General Medicine: 2006;8(4):46. in the counsels office, sent a letter to the CIA reauthorizing waterboarding,
14 From the DoDs Joint Personnel Recovery Agency (JPRA) and SERE he dictated the terms: no more than two sessions of two hours each, per day,
(Survival, Evasion, Resistance and Escape) Programs. with both a doctor and a psychologist in attendance. Report Shows Tight
CIA Control on Interrogations. Mark Mazzetti and Scott Shane. New York
Times, August 26, 2009. Available at: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/26/
us/26prison.html?_r=1&hpw
Advanced
4 Media
AIDING Group
TORTURE Page 321 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 340
Page
of 2413
341 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
detainee to monitor the effectiveness of his respiration during experts who reportedly concluded that these techniques were
waterboarding.18 In this way, medical professionals were used unlikely to cause significant harm, the notion that these abusive
to calibrate physical and mental pain and suffering. techniques can be used safely has no basis in medical science
and is not supported by an extensive peer-reviewed literature.21
Not only were health professionals involved in designing
From a medical, scientific and common sense perspective the
and monitoring the CIA interrogation program, they also played
idea that such abusive and inhumane techniques can be safe-
an indirect but essential role in the legal justifications for the
ly deployed is unsupportable. The techniques authorized and
program prepared by the Office of Legal Counsel (OLC). The
deployed have long been documented to cause significant and
OLC was asked by the CIA whether certain techniques consti-
long lasting psychological pain and suffering including post-
tuted torture under 18 USC 2340 by causing severe physi-
traumatic stress disorder, anxiety and major depression.22 In
cal or mental pain or suffering. Since the OLC lawyers had
fact, a recent study demonstrates that abusive techniques em-
no direct experience of the techniques, they necessarily relied
ployed during captivity which emphasized psychological tor-
instead on the judgment of health professionals.Yet, in a strik-
ture over physical injury, such as psychological manipulation,
ing example of bootstrapping, they turned for advice about the
forms of deprivation, humiliation and stress positions, cause as
pain caused by the techniques to the very health professionals
much mental pain and traumatic stress as does torture designed
who were implementing them.19
to inflict physical injury. 23
In essence, the lawyers were asked if the techniques consti- The use of these abusive methods violates international hu-
tuted torture and they replied to the CIA that they only did so if man rights standards. The likely illegality of the program was
the CIA Office of Medical Services (OMS) informed them that known to the agency and debated within the agency. Those ad-
the techniques reached the defined standard of pain.The OMS vocating for the use of abusive techniques such as waterboard-
health professionals obligingly passed on through CIA chan- ing should have known that the US had prosecuted these same
nels their opinion that the pain was not in fact severe techniques as torture. Health professionals who were involved
in its justification, design and implementation should have
In an egregious example of this circular process, one OLC known that professional ethics prohibit health professionals
memo concludes that waterboarding is not torture because from complicity in such harmful acts against prisoners or de-
however frightening the experience may be, OMS personnel tainees. It is precisely to avoid such complicity that health pro-
have informed us that the waterboard technique is not physi- fessionals have recourse to professional codes of ethics, as well
cally painful. Scores of similar references to OMS medical as international standards of medical conduct. Familiarity with
judgments about pain and the safeguarding effects of medical these codes not to mention basic human decency should
monitoring appear throughout the memos. Although OMS did preclude such conduct, making clear to health professionals
express some concern about some techniques, those objections and government institutions both its essentially unethical na-
were limited. Without the cooperation of health professionals ture and illegal status under international law.
in making these assessments, the OLC memos could not have
reached the conclusions they did and could not have so easily Not only should interrogators be subject to an investiga-
justified torture. tion of alleged criminal conduct. Health professionals who
were involved in this program should be the subject to inde-
The intent of the CIA interrogation program was to cause pendent investigation for both criminal and unprofessional
severe psychological distress.20 Despite citation of unnamed conduct. Professionals who have violated professional ethics
or the law must be held accountable through criminal pros-
18 ICRC report. Note that the use of a pulse oximeter, and the requirement ecution, loss of license and professional society membership,
that an emergency tracheostomy kit be kept ready is even more evidence that where appropriate.
the procedure is intentionally harmful, risky and potentially lethal.
19 In certain cases the very same JPRA psychologists who designed the
torture and implemented the techniques, and, who, as private contractors,
profited from the operation, also provided the research that justified the
techniques: You have informed us that your on-site psychologists, who have
extensive experience with the use of the waterboard in Navy training, have
not encountered any significant long-term mental health consequences from
its use. Your on-site psychologists have also indicated that JPRA has likewise 21 See Leave No Marks and Broken Laws, Broken Lives. Although these
not reported any significant mental health consequences from the use of the reports were published in 2007 and 2008 respectively, they summarized
waterboard. scientific literature that was well established in 2001. In a bizarre justification
20 CIA Inspector Generals Report. Appendix F. Captured terrorists turned for the safety of the techniques, the OLC report states, You have also
over to the CIA for interrogation may be subjected to a wide range of legally reviewed the relevant literature and found no empirical data on the effect of
sanctioned techniques, all of which are also used on US military personnel in these techniques with the exception of sleep-deprivation. OLC August 1,
SERE training programs. These are designed to psychologically dislocate 2002, p. 6. Yet, there is a large body of research on the effects of these and
the detainee, maximize his feelings of vulnerability and helplessness, and similar techniques, much of it supported by the CIA. See for example The
reduce or eliminate his will to resist our efforts to obtain critical intelligence. Search for the Manchurian Candidate (c) 1979 by John Marks. Published by
In addition, the sanction techniques include so-called Standard measures Times Books.
or those deemed to be without physical or substantial psychological pressure 22 PHR and HRF previously reported on the harmful effects of many of these
and so-called Enhanced measures, or those deemed to cause physical or techniques in their report Leave No Marks: Enhanced Interrogation and the
psychological pressure beyond Standard measures. (p. 1). In all instances, Risk of Criminality.
the goal of these techniques is psychological impact and are designed to 23 Basoglu M. et al. Torture vs. Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment:
induce shock, surprise and/or humiliation. (p. 2). Is the Distinction Real or Apparent? Archives Gen. Psychiatry 277 (2007).
Advanced
HEALTHMedia Group
PROFESSIONALS Page 322REVEALED
Ethics and Human Rights Violations of 727 in the May 2004 CIA Inspector GeneralS
October 2, 2009
Report 5
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 341
Page
of 2413
342 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
Conclusion
The newly released version of the May 2004 CIA The Inspector Generals report confirms much of what had
Inspector Generals report on Counterterrorism Detention been reported about the essential role played by health profes-
and Interrogation Activities reveals the use of a number of sionals in designing, deploying, monitoring and legitimizing
previously undescribed techniques including: the program of torture, but also raises disturbing new questions
Forced Shaving which require further investigation. The possibility that health
Hooding professionals monitored techniques to assess and improve their
Dietary Manipulation effectiveness, constituting possible unethical human experi-
mentation, urgently needs to be thoroughly investigated.
Prolonged Diapering
Walling PHR has long called for full investigation and remedies in-
Confinement in a box cluding accountability for war crimes, and reparation such as
compensation, medical care and psycho-social services. PHR
These techniques used alone or in combination may meet the also calls for health professionals who have violated ethical
definition of torture under US and international law. Legality standards or the law to be held accountable through criminal
aside, they are associated with high risk of physical and psy- prosecution, loss of license and loss of professional society
chological harm, including harm that is enduring, in those sub- membership where appropriate.
jected to these techniques. They also represent clear violations
of well-established medical ethics governing the behavior of
health professionals.
Advanced
6 Media
AIDING Group
TORTURE Page 323 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 342
Page
of 2413
343 of 2593
CIA IG Report on MKULTRA 1963 http://cryptome.org/mkultra-0003.htm
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
18 May 2001: Link to CIA description of the biological and chemical warfare program at Ft Detrick,
Maryland, redacted from the report below: http://nl.cryptome.org/mkultra-0004.htm
17 May 2001
Source: MKULTRA digital files from IntellNet.org
This report was extensively used for questioning CIA officials in two US Senate hearings on MKULTRA in
1975 and another by the Senate in 1977.
See also a shorter 1957 report by the CIA Inspector General on MKULTRA: http://nl.cryptome.org/mkultra-
0001.htm
xxxxx indicates redactions. EYES ONLY derived from another description of this document.
[41 pages.]
[EYES ONLY]
xxxxxxxxx 185209/1
26 July 1963
1. In connection with our survey of Technical Services Division, DD/P, it was deemed advisable to prepare
the report of the MKULTRA program in one copy only, in view of its unusual sensitivity.
3. The MKULTRA activity is concerned with the research and development of chemical, biological, and
radiological materials capable of employment in clandestine operations to control human behavior. The end
products of such research are subject to very strict controls including a requirement for the personal approval
of the Deputy Director/Plans for any operational use made of these end products.
4. The cryptonym MKULTRA encompasses the R&D phase and a second cryptonym MKDELTA denotes
the DD/P system for control of the operational employment of such materials. The provisions of the
MKULTRA authority also cover xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx [probably chemical and biological warfare
research with the US Army]. The administration and control of this latter activity were found to be generally
satisfactory and are discussed in greater detail in the main body of the report on TSD.
5. MKULTRA was authorized was authorized by then Director of Central Intelligence, Mr. Allen W. Dulles,
in 1953. The TSD was assigned responsibility thereby to employ a portion of its R&D budget, eventually set
at 20%, for research in behavioral materials and xxxxxxxxxxxxx under purely internal and compartmented
controls, (further details are provided in paragraph 3 of the attached report). Normal procedures for project
approval, funding, and accounting were waived. However, special arrangements for audit of expenditures
have been evolved in subsequent years.
6. The scope of MKULTRA is comprehensive and ranges from the search for and procurement of botanical
and chemical substances, through programs for their analysis in scientific laboratories, to progressive testing
for effect on animals and human beings. The testing on individuals begins under laboratory conditions
employing every safeguard and progresses gradually to more and more realistic operational situations. The
program requires and obtains the services of a number of highly specialized authorities in many fields of
natural science.
7. The concepts involved in manipulating human behavior are found by many people both within and outside
the Agency to be distasteful and unethical. There is considerable evidence that opposition intelligence
services are active and highly proficient in this field. The experience of TSD to date indicates that both the
research and the employment of the materials are expensive and often unpredictable in results. Nevertheless,
there have been major accomplishments both in research and operational employment.
8. The principal conclusions of the inspection are that the structure and operational controls over this activity
need strengthening; improvements are needed in the administration of research projects; and some of the
testing of substances under simulated operational conditions was judged to involve excessive risk to the
Agency.
9. Attached for the signature of the Deputy Director of Central Intelligence is a memorandum transmitting the
report to the Deputy Director/Plans requesting a summary of action taken or comments on the
recommendations contained herein.
[Signature]
J. S. Earman
Inspector General
Attachments - as stated
[EYES ONLY]
xxxxxxxxx - 185209
Cy 2 See D
I. Introduction
1. Technical Services Division (TSD), (the Technical Support Staff). received authorization from the then
Director of Central Intelligence, Mr. Allen dulles, on 3 April 1953 to develop and maintain continuing
Advanced Media Group Page 325 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 344
Page
of 2413
345 of 2593
2 of 19 10/2/2009 2:54 AM
CIA IG Report on MKULTRA 1963 http://cryptome.org/mkultra-0003.htm
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
operational capabilities in the fields of a) [one line reacted] and b) chemical and biological materials capable
of producing human behavioral and psychological changes, (see Tab A). The cryptonym MKULTRA was
assigned to encompass TSD's research, development and equipment activities in these two fields. The
cryptonym MKDELTA had already been assigned by DD/P Notice No. 229-1 on 20 October 1952 (since
revised - see Tab B) as the indicator covering DD/P policy and procedure for the use of biochemicals in
clandestine operations.
2. The MKULTRA charter provides only a brief presentation of the rationale of the authorized activities. The
sensitive aspect of the program as it has evolved over the ensuing ten years are the following:
b. Some MKULTRA activities raise questions of legality implicit in the original charter.
c. A final phase of the testing of MKULTRA products places the rights and interests of U.S.
citizens in jeopardy.
d. Public disclosure of some aspects of MKULTRA activity could induce serious adverse
reaction in U.S. public opinion, as well as stimulate offensive and defensive action in this field on
the part of foreign intelligence services.
3. In recognition of the sensitivity of MKULTRA, TSD was authorized exclusive control of the
administration, records, and financial accountings of the program. Simple statements of certification were all
that were required of TSD to obtain advances of funds from Finance Division. The DCI's memorandum also
exempted MKULTRA from audit, but this provision was modified to permit limited audit before the end of
the first year. Funding of MKULTRA was eventually stabilized at 20 percent of TSD's annual research and
development budget. It has fallen in the neighborhood of xxxxxxxxxx per year over the ten-year history of
the program, of which about 30 percent has been allocated to support of the xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, cf. Tab
C for MKULTRA funding record FY 60-63.
4. The inspection of TSD activities in the field of xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx noted below in the section of the
Inspector General's Survey dealing with the xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx of TSD, cf.
discussions beginning with paragraphs xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx. The security considerations
applying to xxxxxxxxxxxx were found to be significantly different from those governing manipulation of
human behavior. a) Many xxxxx external projects in support of the xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx are being funded
and managed securely outside the MKULTRA mechanism. b) Chief, Support, TSD, believes that it may also
be possible in the future to fund xxxxx MKULTRA projects by secure methods more compatible with DD/S
responsibilities. c) The very nature of the xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx requires that a high percentage of
staff contribute and be witting of each operation. xxxxx security practices are tight and the Inspector
General's Survey recommends further refinements in security procedures.
5. The inspection of MKULTRA projects in biochemical controls of human behavior raised questions in the
following area of policy and management which are dealt with in the balance of this report:
(1) Over the ten-year life of the program many additional avenues to the control of
human behavior have been designated by the TSD management as appropriate to
investigation under the MKULTRA charter, including radiation, electro-shock,
various fields of psychology, psychiatry, sociology, and anthropology, graphology,
(2) Various projects do not appear to have been sufficiently sensitive to warrant
waiver of normal Agency procedures for authorization and control.
(3) Other secure channels for establishment and funding of Agency-sterile activities
have been evolved over the past ten years by Deputy Director/Support (DD/S) and
in some cases could reasonably be employed by TSD in lieu of MKULTRA
procedures.
In view of these developments there is substantial agreement among all parties concerned that
redefinition of the scope of MKULTRA is now appropriate.
(1) The original charter documents specified that TSD maintain exacting control of
MKULTRA activities. In doing so, however, TSD has pursued a philosophy of
minimum documentation in keeping with the high sensitivity of some of the projects.
Some files were found to present a reasonably complete record, including most
sensitive matters, while others with parallel objectives contained little or no data at
all. The lack of consistent records precluded use of routine inspection procedures
and raised a variety of questions concerning management and fiscal controls.
(b) What researcher was selected to perform the research, and why?
(c) When was work begun, where, involving what costs, at what rate of
progress, based on what tests?
(d) What are the present capabilities and limitations of the substance for
clandestine operations?
(3) MKULTRA records afforded no such approach to inspection. There are just two
individuals in TSD who have full substantive knowledge of the program and most of
that knowledge is unrecorded. Both are highly skilled, highly motivated,
professionally competent individuals. Part of their competence lies in their command
of intelligence tradecraft. In protecting the sensitive nature of the American
intelligence capability to manipulate human behavior, they apply "need to know"
doctrine to their professional associates and to their clerical assistants to a maximum
degree. Confidence in their competence and discretion has been a vital feature of the
management of MKULTRA.
It is the firm doctrine in TSD that testing of materials under accepted scientific procedure fails to
disclose the full pattern of reactions and attributions that may occur in operational situations.
TSD initiated a program for covert testing of materials on unwitting U.S. citizens in 1955. The
present report reviews the rationale and risks attending this activity and recommends termination
of such testing in the United States, cf. paragraphs 10-18 below.
6. The research and development of materials capable of producing behavioral or physiological change in
humans is now performed within a highly elaborate and stabilized MKULTRA structure. The search for new
materials; e.g., psilocybin from Mexican mushrooms, or a fungi occurring in agricultural crops, is conducted
through standing arrangements with specialists in universities, pharmaceutical houses, hospitals, state and
federal institutions, and private research organizations who are authorities in the given field of investigation in
their own right. Annual grants of funds are made under ostensible research foundation auspices to the
specialists located in the public or quasi-public institutions. This approach conceals from the institution the
interest of CIA and permits the recipient to proceed with his investigation, publish his findings (excluding
intelligence implications), and account for his expenditures in a manner normal to his institution. A number of
grants have included funds for the construction and equipping of research facilities and for the employment of
research assistants. Key individuals must qualify for top secret clearance and are made witting of Agency
sponsorship. As a rule each specialist is managed unilaterally and is not witting of Agency support of parallel
MKULTRA research in his field. The system in effect "buys a piece" of the specialist in order to enlist his aid
in pursuing the intelligence implications of his research. His services typically include systematic search of the
scientific literature, procurement of materials, their propagation, and the application of test dosages to animals
and under some circumstances to volunteer human subjects. No quarrel is found with the rationale of this
program tot the extent that it fits the original MKULTRA charter. However, for inspection purposes, there
were lacking records, year by year, of the progress of each project and the recorded judgments of the project
monitors on operational benefits vis-a-vis costs.
7. The funding of sensitive MKULTRA projects by sterile grants in aid as noted in the preceding paragraph
disclosed one of the principal controversial aspects of the program. The original charter of MKULTRA
assumed that the sensitivity of activities would be sufficient to justify both a) special protection for the
researcher; and b) compartmentation of MKULTRA knowledge within the Agency. On this basis the inherent
safeguards of DD/S procedures were waived, the DD/S was not consulted in the design of the MKULTRA
management system, and established Agency audit procedures were waived. In the subsequent administration
of the program, however, TSD has found it feasible to contract with some of the research on MKULTRA
objectives in accordance with prescribed DD/S procedures. The DD/S, in turn, has evolved various secure
systems for the funding of sensitive activities. It appears feasible and appropriate, therefore, to propose that
the DD/S be consulted during the re-chartering of MKULTRA in the design of an administrative system that
does justice to his responsibilities as well as to the management and security requirements of TSD. The
Inspector General accordingly has recommended at the end of this report that the DD/S be consulted in the
re-design of the system; that the Chief, Support, TSD, be assigned responsibility for the day-to-day support of
MKULTRA; and that the latter constitute a bridge to the DD/S for monitoring the future evolution of the
system.
8. The next phase of the MKULTRA program involves physicians, toxicologists, and other specialists in
mental, narcotics, and general hospitals and in prisons, who are provided the products and findings of the
basic research projects and proceed with intensive testing on human subjects. These specialists are also
recipients for testing purposes of the flow of new products from pharmaceutical laboratories. Materials and
procedures with intelligence potential may be identified through this relationship. The testing programs are
conducted under accepted scientific procedures including the use of control populations, the employment of
Advanced Media Group Page 328 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 347
Page
of 2413
348 of 2593
5 of 19 10/2/2009 2:54 AM
CIA IG Report on MKULTRA 1963 http://cryptome.org/mkultra-0003.htm
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
placebos, and the detailed observation, measurement, recording, analysis, and publication of findings. Where
health permits, test subjects are voluntary participants in the program.
9. A current development in the testing of new products is the tightening of controls over dosages and
procedures by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Since MKULTRA files contained no documentation
on this subject, it was not possible to appraise the significance of this development for MKULTRA objectives.
However, interviews with the TSD officers concerned indicated that that the new rules are affecting
procedures and causing controversy in research hospitals and pharmaceutical houses. The TSD officers have
close relationships with key individuals in many of the leading U.S. pharmaceutical houses and count on their
continued close cooperation in obtaining materials and services deemed vital to U.s. intelligence.
10. The final phase of testing of MKULTRA materials involves their application to unwitting subjects in
normal life settings. It was noted earlier that the capabilities of MKULTRA substances to produce disabling or
discrediting effects or to increase the effectiveness of interrogation of hostile subjects cannot be established
solely through testing of volunteer populations. Reaction and attribution patterns are clearly affected when
the testing is conducted in an atmosphere of confidence under skilled medical supervision.
11. TSD, therefore, entered into a formal arrangement with certain cleared and witting individuals in the
Bureau of Narcotics in 1955 which provided for the released of MKULTRA materials for such testing as
those individuals deemed desirable and feasible. The initial arrangement obtained the services of a senior
representative of the Bureau and one of his assistants on the West Coast. A parallel arrangement was
established on the East Coast in 1961. The Director of the Bureau has been briefed on the activity, but the
Deputy Chief, TSD, who has guided MKULTRA from its inception, is of the opinion that the former would
disclaim all knowledge and responsibility in the event of a compromise. The MKULTRA program director
has, in fact, provided close supervision of the testing program from the beginning and makes periodic visits to
the sites. A sum of $10,000 has been provided annually to each of the two projects to cover cost of
cultivation of targets and maintenance of a safehouse in each area for the observation of effects of substances
on selected test individuals.
12. The particular advantage of these arrangements with the Bureau of Narcotics officials has been that test
subjects could be sought and cultivated within the setting of narcotics control. Some subjects have been
informers or members of suspect criminal elements from whom the Bureau has obtained results of operational
value through the tests. On the other hand, the effectiveness of the substances on individuals at all social
levels, high and low, native American and foreign, is of great significance and testing has been performed on a
variety of individuals within these categories.
13. A significant limitation on the effectiveness of such testing is the infeasibility of performing scientific
observation of results. The Bureau agents are not qualified scientific observers. Their subjects are seldom
accessible beyond the first hours of the test. The testing may be useful in perfecting delivery techniques, and
in identifying surface characteristics of onset, reaction, attribution, and side-effect. In a number of instances,
however, the test subject has become ill for hours or days, including hospitalization in at least on case, and the
agent could only follow-up by guarded inquiry after the test subject's return to normal life. Possible sickness
and attendant economic loss are inherent contingent effects of the testing.
14. The MKULTRA program officer stated that the objectives of covert testing concern the field of
toxicology rather than medicine; further, that the program is not intended to harm test individuals, and that
the medical consultation and assistance is obtained when appropriate through separate MKULTRA
arrangements. The risk of compromise of the program through correct diagnosis of an illness by an unwitting
medical specialist is regularly considered and is stated to be a governing factor in the decision to conduct a
given test. The Bureau officials also maintain close working relations with local police authorities which could
be utilized to protect the activity in critical situations.
15. There have been several discussions in the public press in recent months on the use of certain
MKULTRA-type drugs to influence human behavior. Broadly speaking, these have argued that research
knowledge of possible adverse effects of such substances on human beings is inadequate, that some
applications have done serious harm, and that professional researchers in medicine and psychiatry are split on
the ethics of performing such research. Increasing public attention to this subject must be expected.
16. The final step in the research and development sequence is the delivery of MKULTRA materials into the
MKDELTA control system governing their employment in clandestine operations. The subject is discussed
further in the next section; however, it is appropriate here to note that the employment of MKDELTA
materials remains an art rather than a scientific procedure. A significant number of variable in the target
individual, including age, sex, weight, general health, social status, and personality structure, may account for
widely varying and unpredictable reactions to a given drug in a given dosage.
17. The final stage of covert testing of materials on unwitting subjects is clearly the most sensitive aspect of
MKULTRA. No effective cover story appears to be available. TSD officials state that responsibility for covert
testing is transferred to the Bureau of Narcotics. Yet they also predict that the Chief of the Bureau would
disclaim any knowledge of the activity. Present practice is to maintain no records of the planning and
approval of test programs. The principal responsibility for the propriety of such testing rests with the
MKULTRA program director and the Deputy Chief of TSD. The handling of test subjects in the last analysis
rests with the Narcotics agent working alone. Suppression of knowledge of critical results from the top TSD
and CIA management is an inherent risk in these operations.
18. Final phase testing of MKULTRA substances or devices on unwitting subjects is recognized to be an
activity of genuine importance in the development of some but not all MKULTRA products. Termination of
such testing would have some, but an essentially indeterminate, effect on the development of operational
capability in this field. Of more critical significance, however, is the risk of serious damage to the Agency in
the event of compromise of the true nature of this activity. As now performed under Bureau of Narcotics
auspices, non-Agency personnel are necessarily fully witting of the true nature and significance of their
assignments, and of the sponsorship of CIA. Compromise of this information intentionally or unwittingly by
these individuals at some time in the future is a hazard that cannot be ruled out. A test subject may on some
occasions in the future correctly attribute the cause of his reaction and secure independent professional
medical assistance in identifying the exact nature of the substance employed, and by whom. An extreme
reaction to a test substance could lead to a Bureau request for cooperation from local authorities in
suppressing information of the situation. This would in turn broaden the circle of individuals who possessed at
least circumstantial evidence of the nature of the activity. Weighing possible benefits of such testing against
the risk of compromise and of resulting damage to CIA has led the Inspector General to recommend
termination of this phase of the MKULTRA program. Existing checks and balances on the working level
management of such testing do not afford the senior command of CIA adequate protection against the high
risks involved.
19. It does not follow that termination of cover testing of MKULTRA materials on unwitting U.S. citizens will
bring the program to a halt. Some testing on foreign nationals has been occurring under the present
arrangements. Various U.S. deep cover agents overseas would appear to be more favorably situated than the
U.S. narcotic agents to perform realistic testing. Finally, the operational use of the substances clearly serves
the testing function in view of the lack of predictability of human reactions.
20. The present Deputy Chief of TSD, Dr. Sidney Gottlieb, in his then capacity of scientific advisor to the
Deputy Director/Plans (DD/P), released a study (hereafter referred to as the Gottlieb report) on 21 April
1960, covering his six-month investigation of "Scientific and Technical Problems in Covert Action
Operations". Appendix B of the report was entitled, "The Applicability of Special Chemicals and biologicals
Advanced Media Group Page 330 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 349
Page
of 2413
350 of 2593
7 of 19 10/2/2009 2:54 AM
CIA IG Report on MKULTRA 1963 http://cryptome.org/mkultra-0003.htm
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
to Clandestine Operations". The inspectors found this Appendix to be a carefully prepared and very useful
treatment of the subject. The remaining paragraphs draw on the Gottlieb report, take account of
developments since that date, and discuss management and funding aspects of MKULTRA.
21. The author opened his discussion with the question of what the operational returns had been from an
eight-year program involving an investment of approximately xxxxxxxxxx. He observed that the Clandestine
Services had encouraged TSD on various occasions to develop and maintain the operational capability in
special drugs and chemicals but that TSD had received little or no guidance in directing the work and that the
Clandestine Services had up to that time shown little inclination to use the end products operationally. He
indicated that there had been approximately 100 operations over the eight years employing harassment
materials (not controlled under the MKDELTA regulation) and only nine operations employing disabling
drugs, (NB: two-thirds of these involved the use of drugs in interrogations). No use of lethal substances was
reported.
22. The factors accounting for the low rate of use of this capability were considered to be the following:
As of 1960 no effective knockout pill, truth serum, aphrodisiac, or recruitment pill was known to exist.
MKDELTA was described as inherently a high-risk, low-yield field of operations. Three years later the
situation remains substantially unchanged with the exception that real progress has been made in the use of
drugs in support of interrogation. Ironically, however, the progress here has occurred in the development of a
total psychological theory of interrogation, in which the use of drugs has been relegated to a support role.
[Nine and one-half lines redacted]
The subject has been discussed above, beginning with paragraph 10. It should also be noted that testing on
operational targets overseas is considered by some operations officers to be quite impracticable. Unilateral
operations are imperative which substantially complicates the delivery problem. The possibilities of
unexpected or critical reactions in test subjects and of ensuring compromise of the activity make most senior
command personnel unwilling to take the risks involved.
25. Limitations on the dissemination of pertinent information to case officers; organizational and
administrative restrictions on operations:
The present-day situation concerning both these problem areas is improved over 1960. TSD now regularly
briefs a variety of senior officers on its MKDELTA capability. Approval of the use of MKDELTA materials
is now accomplished within the chain of command of the DD/P. The DD/P may consult, for example, with
the Chief, Medical Staff, concerning medical risks involved in MKDELTA operations, but the latter surely
would not expect to exercise final authority for the disapproval of operations.
26. TSD has found that TDY visits of MKULTRA officers to the field in support of specific operations
increases the awareness of the MKDELTA capability and stimulates proposals for additional projects. Of
equal significance, however, has been the TSD decision in 1961 to station in the
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx officer who is informed on MKDELTA matters. A second
officer is scheduled to move PCS to xxxxxxx during the summer of 1963 to support xx and adjacent stations.
While the principal responsibility of these officers lies in the field xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx the
arrangement in the xxxxxxxxx has proved useful in the MKDELTA field -- notably in interrogation -- as well.
It now appears that increased reliance can be placed on this approach to promoting responsible use of the
MKDELTA capabilities.
27. Negative attitudes toward the use of MKDELTA materials; problems in the training of case officers in this
field:
The Gottlieb report observed that some case officers have basic moral objections to the concept of
MKDELTA and therefore refuse to use the materials. Some senior officers were reported to believe that the
proper employment of the capability required more sophistication than most case officers possessed and that
there would be a tendency toward over-reliance on and misuse of drugs in lieu of perfecting classic espionage
techniques. Finally, it was suggested that MKDELTA controls were so restrictive as to have generated a
general defeatism among case officers concerning the chances of getting approval for the use of materials in
routine rather than extreme situations. These matters will be reviewed in future field inspections of DD/P area
divisions. In the meanwhile, the stationing of qualified TSD consultants in the field and increasing operational
experience will tend to develop over time a category of case officers who have acquired direct appreciation
of the potential and limitations of MKDELTA capability.
28. The risk of stimulating increase use of MKDELTA materials by opposition intelligence services:
The Gottlieb report stated that opposition intelligence services are active in the MKDELTA field and
recommended that the CI Staff of the DD/P conduct a systematic study of the evidence. This
recommendation has not been implemented. It is a subject of increasing significance as new materials and
techniques become available.
It is recommend that:
Deputy Director/Plans instruct Chief, CI Staff, to perform a study of the evidence of the use of MKDELTA
materials by opposition intelligence services and recommend appropriate measures for training DD/P case
officers to recognize and counter hostile activity in this area.
29. In summary, present evidence concerning the operational value of MKDELTA capability would appear to
confirm the principal judgments of the 1960 Gottlieb report. There is an extremely low rate of operational use
of the controlled materials. On the other hand, significant progress has been achieved in the development of
an interrogation theory employing chemical substances, and in providing competent guidance to the field in
MKDELTA matters through TSD officers working overseas.
30. TSD has initiated 144 projects relating to the control of human behavior; i.e,
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx during the ten years of operation of the MKULTRA
program. Twenty-five (25) of these projects remain in existence at the present time, while a number of others
31. Active projects may be groups under the following arbitrary headings. Many projects involve activity in
two or more of the areas listed.
f. miscellaneous projects; e.g., (1) petroleum sabotage, (2) defoliants, (3) devices for remote
measurement of physiological processes
32. The current management of TSD has initiated a policy of directing the activities of MKULTRA and of the
Behavioral Activities Branch towards operations and away from long-range research. Prior to this change in
policy which occurred in 1962, MKULTRA sponsored a large number of projects in the fields of applied
psychology, sociology, anthropology, and graphology. The present management is unlikely to return to these
fields of research under the MKULTRA charter. The inspectors concluded that many of these projects were
of insufficient sensitivity to justify waiver of normal Agency control procedures. It is recommended at the end
of this report that projects falling outside the authorized scope of MKULTRA henceforth require the prior
written approval of the DD/P to qualify for MKULTRA processing.
33. The TSD chain of command for administration of the MKULTRA program comprises the following:
b. Deputy Chief, TSD, (a trained scientist) providing top substantive guidance for the
MKULTRA program
c. Assistant Chief, TSD, for Research and Development, contributing management but not
substantive guidance
d. Chief Scientist (reporting to c., above), (a trained scientist), contributing substantive guidance
in some areas and responsible for the technical administrative processes of MKULTRA. He is
supported by a GS-12 budget officer.
e. program manager for MKULTRA, also serves as Chief of Biology Branch, (a trained scientist)
f. project monitors located in various branches of TSD and specialized in the subject fields of the
specific projects for which they are assigned responsibility
To date this chain of command has relied primarily on oral communications in the management of
MKULTRA. Files are notably incomplete, poorly organized, and lacking in evaluative statements that might
give perspective to management policies over time. A substantial portion of the MKULTRA record appears to
rest in the memories of the principal officers and is therefore almost certain to be lost with their departures.
The senior officers in the MKULTRA chain of command who are not substantively qualified need better
records to measure the validity of projects through time and to identify key area in which to require detailed
periodic briefings from working specialists.
34. It will be noted that the Chief of Support, TSD, does not participate in the MKULTRA administration. The
predecessor of the present Chief of Support served in TSD throughout the life of the program until 1962
without ever being associated with the management. In his stead, the Chief Scientist and a GS-12 budget
officer have provided administrative support. The Chief Scientist has set policy on the funding of MKULTRA
projects in all respects including salaries, overhead rates, fees, material, equipment, facilities, travel and the
like. The support officer was only added in 1962 under pressure of critical audit findings. This use of the
Chief Scientist in a field where Chief of Support possesses superior qualifications and facilities constitutes a
misuse of talent. The proposed new charter for MKULTRA should take account of this anomaly and also
provide that Chief of Support advise in the future on decisions to fund projects under the MKULTRA
authority and thereby to waive the application of DD/S procedures.
It is recommended that:
Deputy Director/Plans draft and submit for the approval of the Director of Central Intelligence a revision and
re-confirmation of the authority granted him in 1953 (Tab A) to operate the MKULTRA program,
incorporating the following provisions:
b. Deputy Director/Plans arrange with Deputy Director/Research for the coordination of research
relating to MKULTRA objectives to control duplication of effort and to provide for exchange of
information of new capabilities.
c. Chief, Technical Services Division, consistent with established policy, may negotiate for
research in MKULTRA materials and techniques to be conducted by Deputy Director/Research
and by other component offices of CIA. He shall consult regularly with the appropriate officers
of such components to control duplication of effort.
d. Chief, Technical Services Division shall approve the addition of MKULTRA developed
materials to the list of operationally available MKDELTA substances and keep the Deputy
Director/Plans advised of such additions. (cf. Clandestine Services Instruction No. 220-10,
MKDELTA MATERIALS, dated 22 July 1960 -- Tab B -- which governs the employment of
behavioral control materials in clandestine operations.)
e. Deputy Director/Plans, jointly with Deputy Director/Support, establish policy for the
administration of support functions under MKULTRA. Such policy shall seek to limit the
maximum waiver of established Agency support procedures for activities of unusual sensitivity.
f. Chief, Technical Services Division shall maintain exacting internal controls and records of all
substantive and support matters within each MKULTRA project. Records shall include:
(3) An annual written review by the project monitor setting forth in reasonable detail
the nature of the work performed, the prospects for results of eventual operational
significance, and a recommendation for continuance or termination of the project.
g. Testing of MKULTRA materials and devices shall only be performed in accredited research
institutions under accepted scientific procedures.
h. Chief, Technical Services Division, shall brief the Deputy Director/Plans at least semi-annually
on MKULTRA activities. The Deputy Director/Plans after each briefing shall promptly notify the
Deputy Director of Central Intelligence that he has personally conducted a semi-annual review of
the program.
i. The MKULTRA program be audited in accordance with the provisions of HR 31-1, including
auditor access to substantive as well as administrative records.
TAB A
xxxxxxx 87624
Copy # 1 of 5 copies
3 April 1953
1. Approximately 6% of the TSS research and development effort lies in two highly sensitive fields in which it
is not possible to conduct the work through the customary contracts for security reason and other
considerations.
b) xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
3. Permission of the DCI is requested to handle work in these two fields in the manner outlined in Tab A
without contracts and with reimbursement to be made against invoices properly certified by TSS.
4. All controls established in the PRC approval of the original Research Program (other than signing a
contract) would remain unchanged. Periodic financial and progress reports will be made. All documents will
be retained by TSS.
5. No new funds are involved. This procedure would apply to funds xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx previously
approved for research.
6. Tab B is a memorandum to the Deputy Director (Administration) for your signature authorizing this
procedure.
[Signature]
Richard Helms
Acting Deputy Director (Plans)
Attachments: (2)
Tab A - Description of Project MKULTRA and the controls which will be exercised over its
execution
Tab B - Suggested Memorandum from DCI to DD/A authorizing payment of invoices under
Project MKULTRA
Distribution:
xxxxxxx 87624
Copy # 1 of 5 copies
TAB A
PROJECT MKULTRA
1. On 5 June 1952, the Project Review Committee approved the TSS Research Program for Fiscal Year 1953.
[Three lines redacted]
2. The PRC approval authorized the Director of Research, at his discretion and with the approval of the
Research Chairman, to apportion and obligate the research funds among individual projects, such projects to
be subject to the usual Agency procedures and administrative controls.
3. This Research Program has been actively underway since the middle of 1952 and has gathered
considerable momentum during the past few months. It is now evident on the basis of work currently
underway that approximately 94% of the projects contemplated can be handled through regular procurement
channels by means of customary contracts signed jointly by the Agency and the organization undertaking to
carry out the work. It has also become apparent that approximately 6% of the projects are of such ultra-
sensitive nature that they cannot and should not be handled by means of contracts which would associate CIA
or the Government with the work in question. This 6% of the current research effort now lies entirely within
two well-defined fields of endeavor, namely:
(a) Research to develop a capability in the covert use of biological and chemical materials. This area involves
the production of various physiological conditions which could support present or future clandestine
operational. Aside from offensive potential, the development of a comprehensive capability in this field of
covert chemical and biological warfare gives us a thorough knowledge of the enemy's theoretical potential,
thus enabling us to defend ourselves against a foe who might not be as restrained in the use of these
techniques as we are. For example: we intend to investigate the development of a chemical material which
Advanced Media Group Page 336 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 355
Page
of 2413
356 of 2593
13 of 19 10/2/2009 2:54 AM
CIA IG Report on MKULTRA 1963 http://cryptome.org/mkultra-0003.htm
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
causes a reversible non-toxic aberrant mental state, the specific nature of which can be reasonably well
predicted for each individual. this material could potentially aid in discrediting individuals, eliciting
information, implanting suggestion and other forms of mental control.
4. It is highly undesirable from a policy and security point of view that contracts should be signed indicating
Agency or government interest in either of these two fields. In a great many instances the work in field (a)
must be conducted by individuals who are not and should not be aware of our interest. In all cases dealing
with field (b), it is mandatory that any connection with the Agency should be known only to an absolute
minimum number of people who have been specifically cleared for this purpose. In no case should any
manufacturer or supplier be aware of Government interest.
5. In many cases in field (a) where the researcher can be cleared and may be aware of our interest in the
program, he is unwilling to have his name on a contract which remains out of his control in his files.
Experience has shown that qualified, competent individuals in the field of pharmacological, physiological,
psychiatric and other biological sciences are most reluctant to enter into signed agreements of any sort which
connect them with this activity since such a connection would jeopardize their professional reputations.
6. Even internally in CIA, as few individuals as possible should be aware of our interest in these fields and of
the identity of those who are working for us. At present this results in ridiculous contracts, often with
cut-outs, which do not spell out the scope or intent of the work and which contain terms which the cut-out
cannot incorporate in his contract with the researcher without revealing Government interest. Complete
Government audits of such contracts are impossible for the same reason.
7. It is, therefore, requested that the DCI authorize TSS to handle 6% xxxxxxxx of the previously approved
research budget for FY '53 without the establishment of formal contractual relations. This program will be
known as Project MKULTRA.
8. It is suggested that payment of invoices under Project MKULTRA forwarded by TSS be authorized,
provided that:
(a) the total of such invoices does not exceed 6% for Fiscal Year 1953;
(b) the invoices carry a certification by the TSS Research Director that payment of funds is
authorized and that the invoices represent work accomplished within the program approved by
the DCI under Project MKULTRA as outlined in this memorandum;
(c) the invoices carry the certification of the Executive Secretary of the Research Board that the
scope of the program has been approved;
(d) the invoices carry the certification of the cognizant TSS Division Chief that the work has been
satisfactory from a technical point of view.
9. It should be emphasized that this authorization does not involve any new allocation of funds, but merely
applies to a portion of a previously approved budget. The TSS certifications mentioned above will mean that:
(a) the project is being handled under the conditions set forth in this description and specifically
falls within one of the two ultra-sensitive field mentioned above;
(b) the project has been approved in the manner provided for in the PRC document which
originally set up and approved the over-all TSS Research Program. Each project will thus have
been presented by the Chief of the Division monitoring the work to the Research Director and to
Advanced Media Group Page 337 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 356
Page
of 2413
357 of 2593
14 of 19 10/2/2009 2:54 AM
CIA IG Report on MKULTRA 1963 http://cryptome.org/mkultra-0003.htm
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
the Research Chairman and will have, as in the past, to be approved by both before any
expenditures are made;
(c) technical control over the project will be exercised by the TSS Division Chief and Project
Engineers to the same extent now applying to projects handled in the normal fashion. Technical
reports will be rendered when necessary and advisable and will be available for inspection in TSS
files at any time;
(d) in the case of each project, TSS will reach an understanding with the individuals who will
perform the work as to the conditions under which the work will be performed and
reimbursement arranged. No standard contract will be signed. In some cases when possible, a
memorandum of agreement will be signed and retained in the TSS files. Under no circumstances
would copies of such agreements leave TSS files where they will be kept available for inspection;
(e) the manner in which the work will be handled and methods of maintaining Agency and
Government sterility will be worked out with the Inspection & Security Office as in the past, and
clearance of individuals to the extent deemed necessary by TSS and I & SO will be obtained;
(f) invoices, when received by TSS, will be forwarded to Finance Division for payment and will
be certified as outlined in Paragraph 8 above. Whenever documents are available supporting a
portion or all of a given invoice, such as cancelled checks, receipted bills, etc., these will be
requested by TSS and retained in TSS files in support of the invoice, where they will at all times
be available for inspection. They will not be forwarded with the invoices. Such documents at best
will cover only a portion of the total expenditures, and regular audit procedures will not be
followed;
(g) other provisions and controls over the Research Program specified in the original PRC
approval will remain unaltered. Technical progress under the separate projects handled under
Project MKULTRA will be included whenever necessary in the regular progress reports now
submitted by the Director of Research. The monthly budget and financial report being submitted
by TSS to DD/A will include full financial information on these projects, including how much of
the 6% has been committed, how much has been spent and how much remains.
20. The establishment and approval of Project MKULTRA will allow TSS to undertake highly desirable and
necessary research in these two sensitive fields which would not be possible unless the work can be handled
in this manner.
Distribution:
[Another copy of the Dulles letter shows the 6" %"as $300,000.]
87624
TAB B
APR 13 1953
1. On 6 June 1952, the Project Review Committee approved the DD/P/TSS Research Program
xxxxxxxxxxxxxx for Fiscal Year 1953. [2 lines redacted]
2. The PRC approval authorized the Director of Research, at his discretion and with the approval of the
Research Chairman, to obligate the research funds and apportion them among individual projects, such
projects to be subject to the usual Agency procedures and administrative controls.
3. A small part of the Research Program contemplated by TSS and discussed with me consists of ultra-
sensitive work. The nature of the research and teh security consideration involved preclude handling the
projects by means of the usual contractual arrangements.
4. I have, therefore, approved the obligation and expenditure by TSS of 6% of the total budget
already approved by the PRC for research for FY '53 without the signing of the usual contracts or other
written agreements.
5. This 6% will be handled as Project MKULTRA. Would you please make the necessary
arrangements so that invoices forwarded by TSS applying to MKULTRA will be paid, provided that:
a) in the aggregate, they do not exceed 6% for FY '53 without further authorization from
me;
b) each invoice bear a certification by the Chief, DD/P/TSS, as the Research Director, that the
invoice applies to Project MKULTRA and that the conditions outlined in the DD/P memorandum
for DCI dated 3 April have been complied with. The certification will also request that payment
be made;
c) the invoice shall bear the certification of the Executive Secretary of the Research Board that
the scope of the program has been approved;
d) the invoice shall bear the certification of the cognizant TSS Division Chief that the work has
been satisfactorily performed from a technical point of view and has been carried out in
accordance with the understandings reached between TSS and the individual or concern doing
the work.
6. No further documents will be required to justify payment of the invoices. Exacting control will be
maintained over the Project by TSS. Although no formal contract will be signed, it will occasionally be
possible for TSS to sign an informal agreement with the individual or concern performing the work. In such
cases, TSS will retain in its files all documents. TSS will endeavor wherever possible to obtain documentary
support of invoices, such as cancelled checks, receipted bills, etc., and these will remain in TSS files. Such
documents at best will only cover a portion of the total expenditures, and teh regular audit procedure will not
be followed.
7. Other provisions and control over the Research Program specified in the original PRC approval remain
unaltered. The monthly budget and financial record being submitted by TSS to DD/A will include financial
information on the work being conducted under Project MKULTRA, showing how much of the 6% has
been committed, how much has been spent, and how much remain.
/S/
ALLEN W. DULLES
Director, Central Intelligence
Distribution:
Not transcribed: 3-page Memorandum for File, 21 April 1953, on Project MKULTRA, showing sample
certification form for approval of projects by the Research Chairman and the Research Director, and stating
procedures for keeping records and accounting for expenditure of funds, as set forth in the Helms and Dulles
letters.
1 July 1963
1. I called xxxxxxxxxxx to acknowledge receipt of Dr. Gottlieb's comments on John Vance's report of
inspection of MKULTRA, TSD. I said I felt this reply was very helpful in explaining the TSD position on the
most critical points on our IG recommendations, [one line redacted] testing on unwitting subjects, [one line
redacted]. I reminded xxxxxxxxxxx that his rebuttal dealt with only three of the ten specific
recommendations we had made in our IG report. He replied that the balance of these recommendations really
all related to tightening up the administration of the charter and that he personally welcomed the opportunity
to have this spelled out in greater detail. I said I felt that our recommendations went quite beyond the field of
administration and cited in particular the problem of [one line redacted] -- I said this was much more than an
administration problem, and that would like to know what solution he and Dr. Gottlieb proposed to improve
[half-line redacted]. xxxxxxxxxxx tended to dismiss this problem partially on the grounds that it was a
function of a personal relationship between him and who ever might be the DD/R at any given time, and
partially because he didn't think there was any dogmatic or systematic solution.
2. I told xxxxxxxxxxx that we would prefer not to submit our MKULTRA paper to the DD/P without some
more explicit statement from him on the problem of [one-half line redacted] and that we also felt Dr.
Gottlieb's three page endorsement failed to comment on our detailed proposals for tightening up the
administration of MKULTRA activities. Mr. xxxxxxxxxxx appreciated this but felt that they had registered
their views on the most important points at issue, and they urged us at this state to go ahead and submit our
report with the Gottlieb endorsement as it now stands to the DD/P.
3. Recommendation: I think we have little to gain by massaging this report any further and recommend that
we submit it to the DD/P with a request for his specific comments on our recommendations. I recommend
that we redraft the last recommendation on the audit function in accordance with the proposal of
xxxxxxxxxxx .
[Signature]
E. J. Applewhite
29 November 1963
1. A meeting was held in General Carter's office on 29 November 1963 to discuss the subject program. Those
present, in addition to General Carter, were Messrs. Helms, Kirkpatrick, xxxxxxxx, Gottlieb and Earman. The
main thrust of the discussion was the testing of certain drugs on unwitting U.S. citizens. Dr. Gottlieb gave a
brief history of the MKULTRA program which was not in any way at variance with the IG report of August
1963 on this subject.
2. Messrs. Gottlieb and xxxxxxxx argued for the continuation of unwitting testing, using as the principal point
that controlled testing cannot be depended upon for accurate results. General Carter, Mr. Kirkpatrick, and I
do not disagree with this point. We also accept the necessity for having a "stable of drugs" on the shelf and
the requirement for continued research and development of drugs -- not only for possible operational use but
also to give CIA insight on the state of the art in this field and in particular to alert us to what the opposition is
or might be expected to do in the R&D and employment of drugs.
3. xxxxxxxxxx noted that there was no disagreement with the recommendations of the IG survey on
MKULTRA with the exception of the unwitting testing problem. In response to a query from General Carter,
he stated that since the IG report such testing has been held in abeyance.
4. General Carter made it clear that he understood the necessity for research and development of all types of
drugs, to include their testing. However, he was troubled ty the "unwitting aspect". This led to a brief
discussion on the possibility of unwitting tests on foreign nationals, but according to xxxxxxxx this had been
ruled out as a result of several conversations he recently had with senior chiefs of stations -- too dangerous
and the lack of controlled facilities. (This seemed an odd conclusion to me since the same dangers exist in the
U.S. and from what we were able to find out during our survey, the facilities we have for uncontrolled testing
leave much to be desired -- I made a point of this.)
a. That the charter of MKULTRA would be revised along the lines recommended in the IG
Survey.
b. The procedures for testing drugs are to be reviewed and new alternative proposals submitted.
c. If it is concluded by the DD/P that unwitting testing on American citizens must be continued to
operationally prove out these drugs, it may become necessary to place this problem before the
Director for a decision.
6. I made the point that the IG survey had found other problems with the MKULTRA program in addition to
the unwitting testing, but stated if the charter is rewritten along the lines recommended, I believe these
problems would be corrected.
7. NOTE: the IG Survey of MKULTRA was handed to xxxxxxxx after the meeting for his use in redrafting
the charter.
[Initials]
J. S. Earman
Inspector General
JSE:cm
UserName Login
Not registered yet?
discussion of spraying Castros broadcasting studio with a hallucinogenic Receive weekly email updates
chemical. The plan is taken of the shelf because the chemical is deemed summarizing what contributors
unreliable. During this period, the TSD laces a box of cigars with a chemical have added to the History
Commons database
that would produce temporary disorientation, hoping that he will smoke one
of the cigars before giving a speech. In another instance, the TSD comes up Email Address Here Go
with a scheme to dust Castros shoes with thallium salts during a trip outside
of Cuba. The salts would cause his beard to fall out. The plan is abandoned Donate
when Castro cancels the trip. [US CONGRESS, 12/18/1975] Developing and maintaining
Entity Tags: Fidel Castro, Technical Services Division (TSD) this site is very labor
Timeline Tags: US-Cuba (1959-2005) intensive. If you find it useful,
please give us a hand and
donate what you can.
Donate Now
August 1960-February 1963: CIA Plans to Poison Cuban Leaders
The CIA plans an operation to poison Fidel Castro, as well as his brother Raul
Volunteer
and Che Chevarra, with pills containing botulinum toxin. The plan drags on for
more than two years, but is ultimately aborted. [US CONGRESS, 12/18/1975; CENTRAL If you would like to help us
INTELLIGENCE AGENCY INSPECTOR GENERAL, 1/1996] with this effort, please contact
Entity Tags: Technical Services Division (TSD), Robert E. Maheu, William Harvey, Sheffield us. We need help with
Edwards, Richard Bissell, Raul Castro, James O Connell, Ch Guevara, Fidel Castro programming (Java, JDO,
Timeline Tags: US-Cuba (1959-2005) mysql, and xml), design,
networking, and publicity. If
you want to contribute
information to this site, click
Early 1963: CIA Plans to Assassinate Castro with Exploding Sea the register link at the top of
Shell and Poisoned Diving Suit the page, and start
contributing.
The CIAs Task Force W devises two plans to assassinate Fidel Castro. The first
Contact Us
one, involving an exploding sea shell that would be placed where Castro
regularly dives, is dismissed by the CIAs Technical Services Division (TSD) as
impractical. In the second plan, James Donovan (who has been negotiating
with Castro for the release of prisoners taken during the Bay of Pigs
operation) would present Castro with a contaminated diving suit. TSD decides
to give the plan a try. It purchases a diving suit and laces its breathing
apparatus with tubercule bacillus. The suit itself is dusted with a fungus that
is known to cause a chronic skin disease. But the suit never leaves the
laboratory. [US CONGRESS, 12/18/1975; CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY INSPECTOR GENERAL,
1/1996]
Entity Tags: Technical Services Division (TSD), James Donovan, Fidel Castro
Timeline Tags: US-Cuba (1959-2005)
Except where otherwise noted, the textual content of each timeline is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-
NonCommercial-ShareAlike
v. :
AND NOW on this 2nd day of October, 2009, Advanced Media Group and Stan J. Caterbone do
hereby file the attached Exhibit A-37 to the above captioned case. ( 23 Pages)
Stanley J Caterbone
1250 Fremont St
Lancaster, PA 17603
Dear Mr.cetertonerr-
We would like to thank you for sending your psychiatric abuse report to the Citizens
Commission on Human Rights International (CCHR). After reviewing your information, it is
evident that you experienced many psychiatric abuses. However, it has been determined that
CCHR is unable to take any action on the information.
Unless you request otherwise, your confidential information will remain on file with CCHR and
could potentially be used in the future. For instance, because we receive hundreds of abuse
reports each year, it is possible that other people might file reports on the same practitioner or
facility. CCHR can use such data to show a pattern of abuse.
Please understand that CCHR is not a law enforcement or legal agency in any way. We are
not an attorney referral service, cannot bring lawsuits against individuals and do not have law
enforcement powers.
humanrights@cchr.org
s~
Lura Schmiedeke,
6616 SUNSET BOULEVARD. LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90028. (323) 467-4242. FAX (323) 467-3720
Internet Address: http.z/www.cchr.org s E-Mail Address: humanrights@cchr.org
Advanced Media Group Page
Page
525
3 of
of 23
727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 544
Page
of 2413
545 of 2593
nsored MindCase
Control
No. and
-
CI-08-13373
the 2009 Lancaster
Senate Investigations
County Courtinto
of Common
CIA Interrogation
Pleas Exhibit
Programs
A-37
-.-
-
.-
";
_J -
N
~1
~ ~::.
,.
--
--
f"i ,....
'1'"':
If I
!~t
~l
I"
~
'"
-
--
N
it~
'"
:t 0...
uJ
1. (.;';
!II
C;
8:'1 -'--
r
t,J
~
':1 "
'\
MASSIVE FRAUD
PSYCHIATRY'S CORRUPT INDUSTRY
ClTIZENS COMMISSION
ON HUMAN RIGHTS
The Citizens Commission on Human
Rights (CCHR) was established in 1969 by
the Church of Scientology to investigate
and expose psychiatric violations of human
rights, and to clean up the field of mental
healing. Its co-founder is Dr. Thomas
Szasz, professor of psychiatry emeritus and
1
an internationally renowned author. Today,
CCHR has more than 130 chapters in over
30 countries. Its board of advisors, called
Commissioners, includes doctors, lawyers,
educators, artists, business professionals,
and civil and human rights representatives.
CCHR has inspired and caused many
hundreds of reforms by testifying before
legislative hearings and conducting public
hearings into psychiatric abuse, as well as
working with media, law enforcement and
public officials the world over.
-
Advanced MediaPage
Group
Page
528
6 of
of 23
727October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 547
Page
of 2413
548 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored MindCase
Control
No. and
CI-08-13373
the 2009 Lancaster
Senate Investigations
County Courtinto
of Common
CIA Interrogation
Pleas Exhibit
Programs
A-37
Derrick, I sent the following to Jay Ingram of the Lancaster Film Commission. Jay moved here
from Los Angeles some years ago after working in Hollywood and LA in the movie business. I had met
Jay a few years ago. He was interested in working with me on opening the Theater at Hotel
Brunswick. He was going to look for an investor so he could show local independent films that he and
the Lancaster Film Commission were working on, and to host an Independent Film Festival. I'll try to
call him today and set up a meeting.
Stan.
Jay, do you think you could help me find someone? In case you haven't followed, the Hotel Brunswick
has been shut down now for months, it is a good thing we were stalled in our efforts for the
development of the Theater at Hotel Brunswick. I'll give you a call to see if you have some time for
me.
Thanks,
Stan
Lancaster, Pennsylvania; Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group have been selected for the
Outreach Committee of the Freedom From Covert Harassment and Surveillance Organization, or
FFCHS in order to " to seek out high-profile people to support our cause" according the Executive
Director Derrick Robinson. FFCHS is an international organization formed to "Seeking Freedom and
Justice worldwide for those targeted with organized stalking and electronic torture" according
to it's website. As stated on it's website FREEDOM FROM COVERT HARASSMENT AND
SURVEILLANCE (FFCHS) was formed to address these atrocities and seek justice for those who are
victims of harassment group activities which stem from corrupt elements of the US military intelligence
and the US investigative agencies, certain defense contractors, corporations, as well as individuals and
teams of private citizens.
The CIA MKULTRA hearings which were held in the 70's revealed the existence of secret mind control
experimentation programs being conducted by the government. After the hearings, the CIA officially
abandoned these programs. However, many are reporting a variety of effects and abuses consistent
with the findings of the Church Committee investigation regarding the privacy abuses conducted by the
CIA, FBI, and NSA at that time. And nowadays, because of the secrecy and lack of congressional
oversight during the intervening decades, the research and development of mind control and
Advanced Media Group Page
Page
530
8 of
of 23
727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 549
Page
of 2413
550 of 2593
1 of 3 10/1/2009 7:04 AM
Print http://us.mg4.mail.yahoo.com/dc/launch?.gx=1&.rand=e7fnqgnk5rvfb
U.S. Sponsored MindCase
Control
No. and
CI-08-13373
the 2009 Lancaster
Senate Investigations
County Courtinto
of Common
CIA Interrogation
Pleas Exhibit
Programs
A-37
surveillance technology have advanced far beyond what most Americans would imagine.
The Advanced Media Group is a Lancaster based company that was formed in 1990 as an information
technologies company that began as a joint venture partner with American Helix Technology Company
and High Industries in order to develop CD-ROM technologies. Advanced Media Group has worked with
the following list of companies and organizations -
U.S. Based Companies include: Donnelly Geo Systems (Mapquest); Mansco, Inc.; National Assoc Of
Watch & Clock; Parsons & Brinkerhoff Engineers; Ford New Holland; Mobil Oil, Inc.; Indiana Bell;
Congressional Info Systems; Microsoft, Inc; Bell Atlantic; Tandy Electronics, Inc; Exxon Research And
Production; Compaq, Inc; Ipsoa; Veda, Inc.; Cbis, Inc; Library Of Congress; Commodore Business
Machines, Inc; Amp, Inc, Now Tandy Corporation; U. S. Postal Service; Arthur Anderson; At&T / Data
Devision; Bancroft And Whintney; American Bankers Association; Pa Blue Shield; American Bond
Buyers; HEARST Publications; NASA Goddard Space Flight Center; Defense Mapping Agency (DMA) of
Department of Defense; Central Intelligence Agency (CIA); National Institute of Standards &
Technology (NIST)/Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA); AIM Mutual Funds ; Power
Station Studios; MIT; Microsoft; IBM; U.S. Department of Commerce; The Hearst Corporation; SONY
DADC; DRI McGraw Hill; Capitol Records; NEC Corporation.
Lancaster Based Companies include: The Hotel Brunswick; Gallo Rosso Restaurant; Mazzi
Restaurant; B2B Communications; Pflumm Contractors, Inc.; The Jay Group; Lancaster Container;
American Helix Technology Corporation/High Industries; Cross Microwave; S.N.Lombardo Development;
Sprecher Management (Excelsior Place); Contact ONE.
Stan J. Caterbone
Advanced Media Group
www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com
Notice and Disclaimer: Stan J. Caterbone and the Advanced Media Group have been slandered, defamed, and publicly discredited since 1987
due to going public (Whistle Blower) with allegations of misconduct and fraud within International Signal & Control, Plc. of Lancaster, Pa. (ISC
pleaded guilty to selling arms to Iraq via South Africa and a $1 Billion Fraud in 1992). Unfortunately we are forced to defend our reputation
and the truth without the aid of law enforcement and the media, which would normally prosecute and expose public corruption. We utilize our
communications to thwart further libelous and malicious attacks on our person, our property, and our business. We continue our fight for
justice through the Courts, and some communications are a means of protecting our rights to continue our pursuit of justice. Advanced
Media Group is also a member of the media. Reply if you wish to be removed from our Contact List. How long can Lancaster County and
Lancaster City hide me and Continue to Cover-Up my Whistle Blowing of the ISC Scandel?
Greetings! I've contacted each of you about participating in a committee to seek out high-profile
people to support our cause. I believe that if we were to make good contact with someone who is
sympathetic or often supports charitable causes, it could help our issues and our organization
Advanced Media Group Page
Page
531
9 of
of 23
727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 550
Page
of 2413
551 of 2593
2 of 3 10/1/2009 7:04 AM
Print http://us.mg4.mail.yahoo.com/dc/launch?.gx=1&.rand=e7fnqgnk5rvfb
U.S. Sponsored MindCase
Control
No. and
CI-08-13373
the 2009 Lancaster
Senate Investigations
County Courtinto
of Common
CIA Interrogation
Pleas Exhibit
Programs
A-37
immensely.
So, when would be a good time to meet for everyone? Weekends are best for me. Or daytime hours
until around 2 pm EST, since I work in the evenings. I'll attend the first meeting or so to get things
started. After that, I'll hope that you all can meet weekly and/or exchange communications regularly
to do this. Let me know at your earliest convenience what works best for each of you.
Bing brings you maps, menus, and reviews organized in one place. Try it now.
WASHINGTON High-ranking government officials are usually protected from claims that they Photo 1 of 3
violated a person's civil rights. In lawsuits stemming from law enforcement and intelligence
efforts after the Sept. 11 attacks, three federal courts have left open the possibility that former
Attorney General John Ashcroft and a lieutenant may be held personally liable.
In two cases, judges appointed by Republican presidents have refused at an early stage to
dismiss lawsuits that were filed against Ashcroft and former Justice Department official John
Yoo. One complaint challenges Ashcroft's strategy of preventive detention. The other seeks to
hold Yoo accountable for legal memos he wrote supporting detention, interrogation and
presidential power.
In a third case, the full federal appeals court in New York is reconsidering an earlier decision by
three of its members to toss out a lawsuit by a man who was changing planes in the United
States when he was mistaken for a terrorist and sent to Syria, where he claims he was
tortured.
FILE - In this June 26, 2008 file
Senior officials are accustomed to having their actions in office judged by history, not the photo, John Yoo testifies on
courts. Exposing them to legal risk might complicate recruitment as top prospects shun Capitol Hill in Washington.
positions that could land them in personal trouble. It also could make officials think twice about
aggressive use of executive authority. Former Attorney General John
Ashcroft and Yoo face the rare
The cases have been uncomfortable for the Obama administration, which inherited the task of prospect of being held
representing Ashcroft and Yoo from the Bush administration, even though President Barack personally liable for alleged
Obama opposed some of the homeland-security practices under his predecessor. As well, both
the Obama and Bush administrations renounced some of Yoo's legal positions. violations of individuals' rights in
the aggressive aftermath of the
Among the Yoo memos retracted was his Oct. 23, 2001, opinion that the Fourth Amendment's 2001 terrorist attacks.(AP
protections against unreasonable searches did not apply to domestic military operations aimed Photo/Susan Walsh, File)
at terror suspects so soldiers could enter and search homes without warrants in pursuit of
terrorists.
The Obama administration has yet to spell out its views on when people may be detained
because of suspected terrorism links but without evidence of criminal activity.
No attorney general has ever been held personally liable for official actions, said Yeshiva
University law professor Alexander Reinert, who represents another post-9/11 detainee who is
suing Ashcroft. Other federal officials, particularly at a lower level, have been held personally
liable for their actions. It's just very rare.
Supreme Court rulings allow high-ranking officials to be held liable but set a high bar: An official
must be tied directly to a violation of constitutional rights and must have clearly understood the
action crossed that line.
Even when officials are held personally liable, their agencies still may agree to pay damages
assessed against them unless there is blatant wrongdoing, like clear racial prejudice. And
for many plaintiffs, the chance to saddle a top official with the shame of a court's condemnation
is more important than collecting cash from the officeholder. Map
Critics of George W. Bush's administration see the recent actions of the courts as a chance to
wring a measure of accountability from the Bush White House at a time when Obama
expresses reluctance to look backward and Congress has shown little appetite for investigating
the past.
"It shows a willingness on the part of the courts to hold those who authorized illegal action
responsible, not only those who carry it out," said David Cole, a constitutional law professor at
Georgetown University.
But Ashcroft's former chief spokesman, Mark Corallo, said there is good reason to protect
officials from damages for actions they take in the course of their duties.
"People are not going to want to serve in government if they have to hire a battery of lawyers
the minute they take their oath of office," Corallo said.
Most lawsuits seeking personal liability of officials are dismissed early. Either a plaintiff hasn't
made a strong enough case or a judge finds the officeholder can't be held liable for those
official actions.
In these three cases, however, judges have considered arguments from both sides and still
allowed the lawsuits to proceed or, in the case of the man sent to Syria, are weighing the
arguments now.
"This is frustrating for judges," said Orin Kerr, a constitutional law professor at George
Washington University. "The law is not that clear and it's hard to get rulings that clarify it."
But Kerr said the Ashcroft case has enough important elements that it could be reviewed by the
Supreme Court, where a ruling might clarify the law.
First, though, the Justice Department has to decide whether to appeal an early September
ruling by a panel of the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
The appeals court said a Muslim U.S. citizen could pursue his lawsuit to hold Ashcroft
personally liable for his arrest in 2003
Advanced Media Group Page
Page534
12 of 23
727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 553
Page
of 2413
554 of 2593
2 of 3 10/2/2009 12:56 AM
U.S. Sponsored MindCase
Control
No. and
CI-08-13373
the 2009 Lancaster
Senate Investigations
County Courtinto
of Common
CIA Interrogation
Pleas Exhibit
Programs
A-37
Editors note: Click here to listen to Jeffrey Kaye discuss his groundbreaking report with radio talk
show host Peter B. Collins.
A number of new articles have been published recently that have highlighted evidence of illegal
human experimentation on U.S.-held terrorism prisoners undergoing torture. These articles
followed the release of a white paper by Physicians for Human Rights [PHR], Aiding Torture: Health
Professionals Ethics and Human Rights Violations Demonstrated in the May 2004 Inspector Generals
Report.
This report looks at those recent charges, and reveals that experiments by a CIA researcher on
human subjects undergoing SERE training went unreported in the legal memos the Bush
administration drafted to approve their torture program. It will also connect major military and
intelligence figures to the SERE experiments, and tie some of them to major science and
experimental directorates at the CIA and Special Operations Command.
An article by veteran journalist William Fisher, looking at PHRs white paper, asks, Did physicians
and psychologists help the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency develop a new research protocol to
assess and refine the use of waterboarding or other harsh interrogation techniques?
[PHR] also raises questions about the ethics of medical note-taking during some of the
interrogations. Medical doctors and psychologists colluded with the CIA to keep
observational records about waterboarding, which approaches unethical and unlawful
human experimentation, Scott Allen, lead study author and PHR medical advisor, said
in a prepared statement.
Finally, a story in Wednesdays UK Guardian discussed the significance of the charges of unlawful
human experimention:
Human experimentation without consent has been prohibited in any setting since 1947,
when the Nuremberg Code, which resulted from the prosecution of Nazi doctors, set
down 10 sacrosanct principles. The code states that voluntary consent of subjects is
essential and that all unnecessary physical and mental suffering should be avoided.
The Geneva conventions also ban medical experiments on prisoners and prisoners of
war, which they describe as grave breaches.
After describing how [h]ealth professionals in the Office of Medical Services and psychologist
contractors engaged in designing and monitoring torture, as selecting and then rationalizing the
use of various harmful interrogation techniques, the PHR report goes on to say:
The possibility that health professionals monitored techniques to assess and improve
their effectiveness, constituting possible unethical human experimentation, urgently
needs to be thoroughly investigated.
The CIAs Office of Medical Services was supposed to be in charge of monitoring detainee health
under interrogation. However their instructions, described in an annex to the CIA Inspector General
report, exemplifies the dual nature of the monitoring, as this example from the report shows:
If there is any possibility that ambient temperatures are below the thermoneutral
range, they should be monitored and the actual temperatures documented. [2 or 3
redacted lines]
Rather than make changes to ambient temperatures, to prevent harm to prisoners, medical
professionals are instructed to monitor and document the situation. The torture techniques used by
SERE are known to cause endocrine and metabolic disorders (see section on CIA research below),
prisoners tortured and subjected to cold are at higher risk of hypothermia, which for a normal person
can set in at an ambient temperature of 60 degrees F. The monitoring in this case seems to be as
much about experimentation as it is any concern for a prisoners health. (For what other possible
reason could this section be mostly redacted?) Parallels to the experiments on hypothermia by Nazi
scientists at Dachau are chilling, as is the fact that some of these scientists were later imported,
along with their data, to the United States.
Questions were raised around possible human experimentation in an article last May at Firedoglake
on The Zubaydah Torture Experiment, noting, Of the many fascinating details coming out of [the
May 2009 Senate] Judiciary hearing the references to the application of an experiment by the
ex-SERE CIA contractor, most likely James Mitchell, seemed especially important.
The experimentation was not limited to high-value CIA prisoners. Last April, another article at
Firedoglake reported how the Senate Armed Services Committee report (PDF) on prisoner abuse
described the creation of an experimental battle lab at Guantanamo, demonstrating support for the
torture program from the main Army intelligence school at Ft. Huachuca.
According to the Levin report, in August 2002, COL John P. Custer, then-assistant
commandant of the U.S. Army Intelligence Center and School at Ft. Huachuca, Arizona
conducted a review of interrogations operations at Guantanamo. Custer called
Guantanamo Americas Battle Lab in the war on terror, and recommended combining
FBI and military techniques to extract information by exploiting the detainees
vulnerabilities. The Battle Lab label stuck, though some, like Colonel Britt Mallow, of
the Criminal Investigative Task Force, objected.
MG Dunlavey and later MG Miller referred to GTMO as a Battle Lab meaning that
interrogations and other procedures there were to some degree experimental, and their
lessons would benefit DOD in other places. While this was logical in terms of learning
lessons, I personally objected to the implied philosophy that interrogators should
experiment with untested methods, particularly those in which they were not trained.
Later, Dunlavey denied using the term, and Miller testified he couldnt remember.
The experiments on the effects of SERE-torture techniques began even earlier upon SERE trainees
themselves. An April 2009 AlterNet article reported on the history of experimentation on soldier
subjects undergoing SERE training. (SERE is a military program, the acronym standing for Survival,
Evasion, Resistance, Escape.) The article explained how the Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) and the
CIA ignored a wealth of other published information about the effects of SERE stress inoculation,
citing a June 2000 article, Assessment of Humans Experiencing Uncontrollable Stress: The SERE
Course, in Special Warfare (PDF). Special Warfare is The Professional Bulletin of the John F.
Kennedy Special Warfare Center and School (emphases added to following quote):
Results
As shown in the charts on page 7, SERE stress caused significant changes in students
hormone levels. Recorded changes in cortisol levels were some of the greatest
ever documented in humans. In some cases, the changes noted among the
trainees were greater than the changes noted in patients undergoing heart
surgery.
The Alternet article also quoted from a May 2000 article in Biological Psychiatry, Hormone profiles in
humans experiencing military survival training (emphasis added):
Looking beyond more than physiological symptoms, other studies have looked at purely
psychological data. Consider this oft-quoted study from the August 2001 edition of the American
Journal of Psychiatry, which looked at dissociative symptoms, such as depersonalization,
derealization, psychic or emotional numbing, and general cognitive confusion, produced in military
subjects exposed to SERE torture techniques (emphasis added):
The current study was designed to assess the nature and prevalence of dissociative
symptoms in healthy humans experiencing acute, uncontrollable stress during U.S.
Army survival training. METHOD: In study 1, 94 subjects completed the Clinician-
Administered Dissociative States Scale after exposure to the stress of survival
training. In study 2, 59 subjects completed the Brief Trauma Questionnaire before
acute stress and the dissociative states scale before and after acute stress. A randomly
selected group of subjects in study 2 completed a health problems questionnaire after
acute stress. RESULTS: In study 1, 96% of subjects reported dissociative
symptoms in response to acute stress. Total scores, as well as individual item
scores, on the dissociation scale were significantly lower in Special Forces soldiers
compared to general infantry troops. In study 2, 42% of subjects reported dissociative
symptoms before stress and 96% reported them after acute stress.
Other research results include the effects of SERE-style torture upon the immune system and other
biological markers. The findings regarding high levels of cortisol upon subjects was corroborated by a
SERE psychologist at the Navy Brunswick, Maine, SERE school, who according to an unclassified,
undated Talking Paper from the Joint Personnel Recovery Agency found empirical medical data
[of] elevated levels of cortisol in the brain stem caused by stress levels incurred during water-
boarding. The Brunswick school subsequently discontinued waterboarding as part of its SERE
training, as it created a negative learning environment. The other Navy SERE school, in North
Island, California, refuses to eliminate exposure to waterboarding as part of its training program,
despite the opposition of JPRA and the other SERE schools, which believe it can induce a learned
helplessness state in students.
One of the lead researchers in a number of these studies is Yale psychiatrist Charles A. Morgan, III.
According to one source, Over the past 10 years, Dr. Morgan has served as a Subject Matter Expert
to the US Special Operations Command. But at a June 2004 symposium on The Nature and
Influence of Intuition in Law Enforcement, sponsored by the U.S. Department of Justice, the
Behavioral Analysis Unit of the FBI, and the American Psychological Association, Dr. Morgan is listed
as affiliated with Behavioral Science, CIA.
Additionally, in the Information Science Board (ISB) document, Educing Information which was
heavily drawn upon by President Obamas task force on interrogations, for recommendations on the
interrogations issue Dr. Morgan is identified as a member of the 11-person Government Experts
Committee, and listed as affiliated with the Intelligence Technology Innovation Center (ITIC).
According to Intelligence Online, ITIC is a research organization under the CIAs authority, which
answers directly to the CIAs Science and Technology directorate.
The Obama Interrogations Task Force recently made clear they found a lot to value in the ISB study
(emphasis added):
The Task Force concluded that the United States could improve its ability to
interrogate the most dangerous terrorists by forming a specialized interrogation group,
or High-Value Detainee Interrogation Group (HIG), that would bring together the most
effective and experienced interrogators and support personnel from across the
Intelligence Community, the Department of Defense and law enforcement. The
creation of the HIG would build upon a proposal developed by the Intelligence
Science Board.
Whatever the fate of the HIG, what is noteworthy here is that the Office of Technical Services (OTS),
which was cited in the recently released 2004 CIA Inspector General report as having vetted the
aggressive SERE interrogation techniques, is, along with the ITIC, also a part of the Science and
Technology directorate. OTS, formerly the Technical Services Division (or Technical Services Staff),
was the branch of the CIA in charge of torture and assassination. It was also in charge of the
experimental mind control and interrogation program known as MKULTRA.
Dr. Morgans online profile states that between 1998 and 2002 he received over $400,000 in research
grants from the Army and the Office of Naval Research (ONR) for studies on Psychobiological
Assessment of High Intensity Military Training and Neuro endocrine assessment of Survival School
Training. A 1977 Washington Post expose those were the days of scandalous revelations
surrounding the CIAs MKULTRA program describes CIA use of ONR to funnel funds for secret
experiments in the 1950s and 1960s. The same relationship was also explored during a 1977 Senate
Intelligence Committee hearing. This is not evidence that Morgans research was paid for by the CIA,
but along with his institutional affiliation, it is suggestive of possible CIA involvement.
While it is unknown to what degree the CIA was directly involved in the SERE research (outside of Dr.
Morgans affiliation), Special Operations Command reportedly was a major supporter.
The co-author of the Special Warfare article referenced above, and working with Dr. Morgan on a
number of other SERE research papers looking at physiological and psychological effects of SERE
techniques, was Gary Hazlett, a clinical psychologist with the Psychological Applications Directorate at
U.S. Army Special Operations Command. Moreover, Morgan and Hazlett cited the approval and
support [for their research] of Lieutenant General William Tangney, Major General Kenneth Bowra,
Major General William G. [B]oykin and many others
Maj. Gen. Bowra retired from the military in 2003, after serving as Commanding General of Army
Special Operations Command South, U.S. Southern Command. Following the military, he went to
work as Senior Program Director with Oak Ridge National Laboratory, serving as national laboratory
liaison to U.S. Joint Forces Command, J9 Directorate. Another source states that currently Bowra is
senior mentor/concept developer at USJFCOM J9 for Joint Urban Operations and Homeland Security
experimentation. J9 stands for the Joint Concept Development and Experimentation Directorate
(JCD&E). It leads the development of emerging joint concepts, conducts and enables joint
experimentation, and coordinates DoD JCD&E efforts in order to provide joint capabilities to support
the current and future joint force commander in meeting security challenges.
The possible involvement of USJFCOMs J9 in research upon SERE follows upon the revelation,
discussed above, that CIAs OTS, part of CIAs Science and Technology directorate, was heavily
involved in the implementation of the SERE techniques for use by the CIA. While the use of the term
experimentation appears to have a broad meaning in military usage, beyond that of conducting
scientific experiments, given the charges surrounding human experimentation upon torture victims,
any connections between these secretive experimental directorates and the SERE torture program,
or research upon it, is worrisome.
Maj. Gen. Boykin was the controversial former commander of Special Operations Command at Fort
Bragg, North Carolina, who resigned over statements that indicated he saw the war on terror as a
religious war. At the time he was Special Operations commander at Fort Bragg, according to a recent
New York Times article, SERE psychologist James Mitchell was completing his last military
assignment as psychologist to an elite special operations unit in North Carolina. Boykin previously
served as CIA Deputy Director of Special Activities, and in June 2003, became Deputy
Undersecretary of Defense for Intelligence under Donald Rumsfeld right-hand man, Stephen
Cambone.
Lt. Gen. Tangney is yet another former commanding general at Army Special Operations Command.
Also retired from the military, he is currenly Senior Vice President for Intelligence, Security, and
Special Operations, at Future Technologies, Inc., a supplier of, among other things, a well-
developed global network of experienced intelligence, security and special operations professionals
working with Special Operations, the Defense Intelligence Agency, and other military customers.
While Dr. Morgan appears to be well-connected among the military and intelligence elite, it is
important to remember that there is no reason to conclude that Dr. Morgan or his co-researchers
have ever been involved in torture or experiments meant to be used for torture. (We cannot say the
same for CIA or military medical or psychological personnel, however.) In fact, it is possible that Dr.
Morgans research has led him to oppose coercive interrogation techniques, as his published research
documents the debilitating effects of SERE torture, which utilized against a prisoner could only be
considered cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment, if not torture. (Although, at the 2007 convention
of the American Psychological Association, Dr. Morgan indicated he was against the idea of removing
psychologists from national security interrogations, which was being considered in a motion before
APA at that time.)
Many SERE veterans were appalled at the reverse engineering of their methods, said
Charles A. Morgan III, a Yale psychiatrist who has worked closely with SERE trainers for
a decade.
Dr. Morgans comments appear to put him at odds with other members of the CIAs Science and
Technology directorate, particularly those who work for OTS, as well as individuals within the
Pentagon and Special Operations Command, who have been tied to elements of the U.S. torture
program.
What is clear is that the CIA and the Pentagon had plenty of experimental evidence from the
peer-reviewed, published research of Dr. Morgan and his associates (and possibly others), both
before and after 9/11, that SERE techniques had serious, debilitating effects on individuals subjected
to them. As this research is never cited in any of the Office of Legal Counsel memos issued to the
CIA around their torture program, it appears such research was deliberately withheld from
government attorneys as the CIA sought approval for the use of SERE-style torture. Nor was this
obscure research, but had been funded by the government at a minimum of hundreds of thousands of
dollars, and promoted by some of the Pentagons highest generals.
The frenzied search for data on waterboarding, sleep deprivation, isolation, confinement in a small
box, etc., to submit to OLC attorneys making legal determinations on whether proposed
interrogation techniques constituted torture, was a kabuki organized by the CIA. The OLC attorneys
involved John Yoo, Stephen Bradbury, Jay Bybee, and others were witting or unwitting partners
in suppression of CIA research on torture (as future investigations will disclose). Given the
participation of members of the Office of the Vice President, particularly David Addington and Vice
President Cheney himself, in the promulgation of the torture program, and the composition of the
memos, it seems likely they were also involved in the suppression of this material. As a result, the
memos produced authorizing the enhanced interrogation techniques were composed as the result of
fraud and bad faith, the result of a criminal conspiracy to implement illegal torture techniques.
The public response to the recent white paper by Physicians for Human Rights shows there is great
interest in following up on charges of human experimentation upon torture victims of the U.S.
government. The Congress and Department of Justice should move swiftly to initiate full, open
investigations and charges against those involved.
Jeffrey Kaye, a psychologist living in Northern California and a regular contributor The Public Record,
has been blogging at Daily Kos since May 2005, and maintains a personal blog, Invictus. E-mail Mr.
Kaye at sfpsych at gmail dot com.
21 retweet
A close reading of the CIAs Inspector General Report and the Senate Intelligence Committees
narrative on the Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) torture memos reveals a more detailed picture of the
CIAs involvement in the construction of those documents.
What emerges is consistent with recent charges of CIA experimentation on prisoners, and of the
overall experimental quality of the torture program itself.
It also points to a crucial piece of analysis by the CIAs Office of Technical Services, a memo which
may or may not include damning medical and psychological evidence of the damaging effects of SERE
techniques, and which the IG report maintains was utilized in substantial part in the drafting of the
August 1, 2002 Bybee memos. If one is looking for a smoking gun in the torture scandal, in my
opinion, one doesnt have to look much further than this.
The quote below is from the April 22, 2009 Senate Intelligence Committee narrative of the Office of
Legal Counsels opinions on the CIAs interrogation program. Please keep in mind as you read the
quote and the added bolded emphasis, that recent documentation has shown that for years the CIA
and Special Operations had researchers studying the effects of SERE training.
Moreover, the research had been published in peer-reviewed journals, in part because the research
was also meant to add to the psychiatric communitys understanding of the mechanisms of
Post-traumatic Stress Disorder. Some of the research had also been published in the June 2000
edition of Special Warfare, The Professional Bulletin of the John F. Kennedy Special Warfare Center
and School.
So, keeping this all in mind, consider the following from the Intel Committees narrative (emphasis
added):
According to CIA records, because the CIA believed that Abu Zubaydah was withholding
imminent threat information during the initial interrogation sessions, attorneys from the
CIAs Office of General Counsel met with the Attorney General, the National Security
Adviser, the Deputy National Security adviser, the Legal Adviser to the National Security
Council, and the Counsel to the President in mid-May 2002 to discuss the possible use of
alternative interrogation methods that differed from the traditional methods used by the
The CIAs Office of General Counsel subsequently asked OLC to prepare an opinion about
the legality of its proposed techniques. To enable OLC to review the legality of the
techniques, the CIA provided OLC with written and oral descriptions of the proposed
techniques. The CIA also provided OLC with information about any medical and
psychological effects of DoDs Survival, Evasion, Resistance and Escape
(SERE) School, which is a military training program during which military personnel
receive counter-interrogation training.
While the fact that the OLC accepted at face value the CIAs statements regarding the safety or the
effects of the interrogation procedures they were proposing is no surprise to anyone who has read the
torture memos and evidence of the unprofessionalism and bias of the memos authors the
degree to which the conspiracy (by CIA or OLC, or both) to withhold evidence of the real effects of the
Enhanced Interrogation Techniques (EITs) by the CIA has never been made more concrete than
now.
To my knowledge, we do not have the specific document wherein the CIA provides the medical and
psychological effects of SERE school. I have been told that this document is still classified. But it
seems possible that the CIA did pass on the details of the research that was available to it, including
the debilitating effects of SERE techniques, which sent stress hormone levels, according to one
research report, some of the greatest ever documented in humans. Another report cited
neuroendocrine changes [that] may have significant implications for subsequent responses to
stress.
One of the authors of these reports, Charles A. Morgan, III, M.D., who has identified himself in
certain settings as a Senior Research Scientist on the CIAs Behavioral Science Staff, has criticized
my coverage of CIA experiments on the psychological and physiological effects of SERE training upon
human subjects. While he could not specify what aspects of this coverage he felt were inaccurate and
misleading, he did insist:
The research conducted by our research team at the National Center for Post Traumatic
Stress Disorder is not, and never has been, conducted for any other purpose than to help
us understand the pathophysiology of stress disorders and we might better help in the
treatment of veterans.
In making his mea culpa, Dr. Morgan never mentions that some of this research was funded (over
$400,000) by the Army and the Office of Naval Research. He doesnt mention his acquaintance with
great people who do military interrogations. He also forgets to cite his book contribution, where he
states (emphasis added):
The SERE training environment affords the military services the opportunity to
collaborate with various other government agencies in exploring old and new
techniques in gathering human intelligence.
Of course, he neither confirms nor denies his affiliation with the CIA, an affiliation which I have traced
to the CIAs Science and Technology directorate, through his association (large PDF) with the
Intelligence Technology Innovation Center, which is a research organization under the CIAs
authority that answers directly to the CIAs Science and Technology directorate.
But most of all, Dr. Morgans arrows fall way short of his target, as I have never accused him of
personal involvement in the reverse-engineering of SERE techniques for use in the torture program.
What is disturbing is his seeming lack of concern over the possiblity that the research he helped
conduct was either used to further experiments upon torture victims in the CIAs clandestine prisons,
or contrariwise, was withheld from Office of Legal Counsel lawyers who relied upon CIA advice
concerning the effects of techniques derived from the SERE schools.
What is indisputable is that by virtue of his position, Dr. Morgan had access to CIA officials just at the
time that another department of the CIA, one to which he is affiliated, was, according to the CIAs
own Office of Inspector General Report (large PDF) involved in vetting the SERE techniques for use in
interrogations. The other department was the Office of Technical Services (OTS), part of the CIAs
Science and Technology Directorate. This, by the way, is the same division that was responsible for
the MKULTRA experiments of the 1950s and 1960s. From the OIG report:
CTC [CIA's Counter-Terrorism Center], with the assistance of the Office of Technical
Service (OTS), proposed certain more coercive physical techniques to use on Abu
CIAs OTS obtained data on the use of the proposed EITs and their potential long-term
psychological effects on detainees. OTS input was based in part on information solicited
from a number of psychologists and knowledgeable academics in the area of
psychopathology.
OTS also solicited input from DoD/Joint Personnel Recovery Agency (JPRA) regarding
techniques used in its SERE training and any subsequent psychological effects on
students. DoD/JPRA concluded no long-term psychological effects resulted from use of
the EITs, including the most taxing technique, the waterboard, on SERE students. The
OTS analysis was used by OGC [DoD's Office of General Counsel] in evaluating the
legality of techniques.
OTSs solicitation of information on SERE from JPRA elicited some sort of feedback from JPRA, which
supposedly told OTS that SERE training caused no long-term effects. The IG Report does not say if
this was in the form of a memo and only speaks of OTSs analysis. In any case, we should not confuse
any OTS analysis with the information provided by JPRA itself to the Office of General Counsel,
which produced a number of memorandum and attachments in late July 2003. Marcy Wheeler has
been analyzing the timing of these JPRA items, including the fact that one of these key documents is
missing.
The CIA IG Report is relating a story whose emphasis differs from that produced in the narrative of
the Senate Armed Services Committee investigation (PDF) into SERE torture. In the latter, JPRA is
the main culprit in providing cover for the supposed safety of using SERE techniques. Yet, in the OIG
account it looks like the CIA used DOD/JRRA as a cover for the safety of techniques that it knew were
in fact harmful from their own analysis of the data. Moreover, it was the OTS analysis that was used
in substantial part as the basis of the August 1, 2002 memo approving the Enhanced
Interrogation Techniques (EITs).
That legal opinion was based, in substantial part, on OTS analysis and the experience
and expertise of non-Agency personnel and academics concerning whether long-term
psychological effects would result from use of the proposed techniques.
Moreover, the CIAs Office of Medical Services was frozen out of the initial analysis of the risk and
benefits of EITs, and not even provided with a copy of the OTS report given to the White House
Office of Legal Counsel. Such compartmentalization of information is indicative of a covert operation,
such as a Special Access Program (SAP). This SAP would have included personnel in CIAs CTC, OTS,
OGC, and Directorate of Operations, also portions of DOD (JPRA and Special Operations Command),
and probably the White Houses OLC, Office of the Vice President, and National Security Council.
It seems highly likely that the CIA report to the OLC on the medical and psychological effects of the
SERE school program, mentioned in the Senate Intelligence Committee narrative quote above, is in
fact the OTS report, which came from the same CIA directorate to which Dr. Morgan belongs. This
does not speak to Morgans foreknowledge of what would be used, nor to the amount of his
involvement. But it does speak to the likelihood that the government research he conducted (with
others) was available and likely used by his associates in the CIA.
To what purpose was this information used? It seems Dr. Morgan has serendipitously given us the
answer himself: exploring old and new techniques in gathering human intelligence. The CIA appears
to have used torture to conduct what Physicians for Human Rights, in a white paper (PDF) recently
published, called possible unethical human experimentation, [which] urgently needs to be thoroughly
investigated. The government should declassify the OTS report, and bring the process of
investigating the CIAs role in the torture conspiracy fully into public purview.
Jeffrey Kaye, a psychologist living in Northern California and a regular contributor The Public Record,
has been blogging at Daily Kos since May 2005, and maintains a personal blog, Invictus. E-mail Mr.
Kaye at sfpsych at gmail dot com.
14 retweet
WASHINGTON High-ranking government officials are usually protected from claims that they Photo 1 of 3
violated a person's civil rights. In lawsuits stemming from law enforcement and intelligence
efforts after the Sept. 11 attacks, three federal courts have left open the possibility that former
Attorney General John Ashcroft and a lieutenant may be held personally liable.
In two cases, judges appointed by Republican presidents have refused at an early stage to
dismiss lawsuits that were filed against Ashcroft and former Justice Department official John
Yoo. One complaint challenges Ashcroft's strategy of preventive detention. The other seeks to
hold Yoo accountable for legal memos he wrote supporting detention, interrogation and
presidential power.
In a third case, the full federal appeals court in New York is reconsidering an earlier decision by
three of its members to toss out a lawsuit by a man who was changing planes in the United
States when he was mistaken for a terrorist and sent to Syria, where he claims he was
tortured.
FILE - In this June 26, 2008 file
Senior officials are accustomed to having their actions in office judged by history, not the photo, John Yoo testifies on
courts. Exposing them to legal risk might complicate recruitment as top prospects shun Capitol Hill in Washington.
positions that could land them in personal trouble. It also could make officials think twice about
aggressive use of executive authority. Former Attorney General John
Ashcroft and Yoo face the rare
The cases have been uncomfortable for the Obama administration, which inherited the task of prospect of being held
representing Ashcroft and Yoo from the Bush administration, even though President Barack personally liable for alleged
Obama opposed some of the homeland-security practices under his predecessor. As well, both
the Obama and Bush administrations renounced some of Yoo's legal positions. violations of individuals' rights in
the aggressive aftermath of the
Among the Yoo memos retracted was his Oct. 23, 2001, opinion that the Fourth Amendment's 2001 terrorist attacks.(AP
protections against unreasonable searches did not apply to domestic military operations aimed Photo/Susan Walsh, File)
at terror suspects so soldiers could enter and search homes without warrants in pursuit of
terrorists.
The Obama administration has yet to spell out its views on when people may be detained
because of suspected terrorism links but without evidence of criminal activity.
No attorney general has ever been held personally liable for official actions, said Yeshiva
University law professor Alexander Reinert, who represents another post-9/11 detainee who is
suing Ashcroft. Other federal officials, particularly at a lower level, have been held personally
liable for their actions. It's just very rare.
Supreme Court rulings allow high-ranking officials to be held liable but set a high bar: An official
must be tied directly to a violation of constitutional rights and must have clearly understood the
action crossed that line.
Even when officials are held personally liable, their agencies still may agree to pay damages
assessed against them unless there is blatant wrongdoing, like clear racial prejudice. And
for many plaintiffs, the chance to saddle a top official with the shame of a court's condemnation
is more important than collecting cash from the officeholder. Map
Critics of George W. Bush's administration see the recent actions of the courts as a chance to
wring a measure of accountability from the Bush White House at a time when Obama
expresses reluctance to look backward and Congress has shown little appetite for investigating
the past.
"It shows a willingness on the part of the courts to hold those who authorized illegal action
responsible, not only those who carry it out," said David Cole, a constitutional law professor at
Georgetown University.
But Ashcroft's former chief spokesman, Mark Corallo, said there is good reason to protect
officials from damages for actions they take in the course of their duties.
"People are not going to want to serve in government if they have to hire a battery of lawyers
the minute they take their oath of office," Corallo said.
Most lawsuits seeking personal liability of officials are dismissed early. Either a plaintiff hasn't
made a strong enough case or a judge finds the officeholder can't be held liable for those
official actions.
In these three cases, however, judges have considered arguments from both sides and still
allowed the lawsuits to proceed or, in the case of the man sent to Syria, are weighing the
arguments now.
"This is frustrating for judges," said Orin Kerr, a constitutional law professor at George
Washington University. "The law is not that clear and it's hard to get rulings that clarify it."
But Kerr said the Ashcroft case has enough important elements that it could be reviewed by the
Supreme Court, where a ruling might clarify the law.
First, though, the Justice Department has to decide whether to appeal an early September
ruling by a panel of the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
The appeals court said a Muslim U.S. citizen could pursue his lawsuit to hold Ashcroft
personally liable for his arrest in 2003
Advanced Media Group Page 546 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 565
Page
of 2413
566 of 2593
2 of 3 10/2/2009 12:56 AM
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
HAARP,TheUnitedStatesGovernment,MindControl
and
TheAdvancedMediaGroup
September24,2009
Advanced Media Group Page 547 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 566
Page
of 2413
567 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
TABLEOFCONTENTS
1. U.S. PATENT ISSUED FOR MIND CONTROL THROUGH. HAARP TYPE
ELECTROMAGNETIC WAVES.
13. Lancaster Newspapers Headlines of October 31, 1991 "U.S. Indicts Geurin on $1 Billion
Fraud..Selling Arms to Iraq".
16. Admiral Bobby Ray Inman, Director of Navy Intelligence 1974 to 1976, Director of the
NSA 1977 to 1981, Deputy Director of the CIA 1981 to 1982, Board of Directors ISC
1983 to ?.
17. MK ULTRA The Navy Mental Telepathy by Thomas Porter 1996 re Bobby Ray Inman
and Para Normal Research.
23. September 7, 2009 Letter to Derrick Robinson, Director of Freedom From Covert
Harassment & Surveillance re Is Lancaster County Ground Zero?
Advanced Media Group Page 548 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 567
Page
of 2413
568 of 2593
U.S. PATENT ISSUED FOR MIND CONTROL THROUGH HAARP TY... http://www.cuttingedge.org/News/n1345.cfm
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
Title: U.S. PATENT ISSUED FOR MIND CONTROL THROUGH HAARP TYPE
ELECTROMAGNETIC WAVES -- CONNECTION TO SCHOOL SHOOTINGS --
PART 2
The New World Order is coming! Are you ready? Once you understand what this New World Order really is,
and how it is being gradually implemented, you will be able to see it progressing in your daily news!!
Stand by for insights so startling you will never look at the news the same way again.
NEWS BRIEF: "United States Patent 5,159,703, Lowery, October 27, 1992 Silent Subliminal Presentation
System, Inventors: Lowery, Oliver M. Appl. No. 458339 Filed December 28, 1989.
"Abstract: A silent communications system in which nonaural carriers, in the very low or very high audio
frequency range or in the adjacent ultrasonic frequency spectrum, are amplitude or frequency modulated with
the desired intelligence and propagated acoustically or vibrationally, for inducement into the brain, typically
through the use of loudspeakers, earphones or piezoelectric transducers. The modulated carriers may be
transmitted directly in real time or may be conveniently recorded and stored on mechanical, magnetic or
optical media for delayed or repeated transmission to the listener."
In the beginning of our Seminar 3 discussion of HAARP technology to control the weather and to use weather
as a weapon against us, we present the United Nations' Treaty prohibiting such warfare and ask the rhetorical
question: If man cannot control the weather and use it as a weapon, why do you need an international treaty
prohibiting such a weapon? Laws on the books in every state in the Union regulating cars prove the existence
of cars; laws on the international books prohibiting weather warfare prove the ability to control the weather
first and the ability to use weather as a weapon secondly.
Likewise, this patent to allow the inventor the exclusive right to create, and market, the technology to use
certain frequencies for "inducement into the brain" prove the technology exists and is being used in one form
or another for Mind Control. We suspect that the Illuminist government of ours currently is able to control
the minds electromagnetically of people whom they have individually programmed, such as is the case in the
school shootings, where the shooters had been previously heavily involved in the occult. However, our
government is also moving full-speed ahead to the point where they can program minds enmasse prior to the
time they want to actually begin controlling minds of entire populations. From the U.S. Patent website we can
see that this inventor references scientific work done as far back as 1962 [Ibid.]. Therefore, we know that
certain segments of science have been working steadily on this project, to control the minds of people.
Certainly, a "silent subliminal presentation system" utilizing electromagnetic radio which no one can see,
hear, or smell would certainly hold the promise of controlling people's minds. Further, if none of the slaves
knew that they were being manipulated, or how they were being manipulated , you have the potential of
people living lives of slavery without realizing they were slaves! How delicious this prospect must be to the
Illuminists who want so desperately to control the entire population of Mother Earth!
Advanced Media Group Page 549 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 568
Page
of 2413
569 of 2593
1 of 7 9/23/2009 4:04 AM
U.S. PATENT ISSUED FOR MIND CONTROL THROUGH HAARP TY... http://www.cuttingedge.org/News/n1345.cfm
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
When we published NEWS1344, depicting the occult map of the six school shootings and then tied those
shootings in with elevated levels of HAARP, we received some skeptical emails. People just could not, would
not, or did not want, to believe that the human mind could be so manipulated. And, I completely understand
their reluctance to so believe; they did not want the terror of thinking that they could be controlled by leaders
hostile to their well-being. People in the Nazi era similarly reacted to overwhelming evidence that Hitler was
achieving dictatorial power and that he was deadly serious in his published threats [in Mein Kampf ] to
murder Jews, Christians, and others.
In the news group, NewsHawk, we have found corroborating evidence that this type of "Silent Sound"
electromagnetic radio transmissions was culpable in at least one of the school shootings on this Satanic map.
"This could well be going on in other regions of the U.S. as well. In fact, we at NewsHawk believe this is
almost certainly the case and is very likely a factor in the unheard-of, unprecedented spate of mass murders
which have been occurring throughout the U.S. in recent years. Highly respected author Alex Constantine,
one the the preeminent researchers into the covert government's MANY 'mind-control' projects, specifically
told NewsHawk that "Silent Sound" transmissions were directly involved in the Jonesboro, Ark. mass school
shootings in March, 1998." [http://mercury.spaceports.com/~persewen/silent_sound.htm ]
As we demonstrated in our article, above, on the Satanic School Shooting Map, highly elevated HAARP
levels preceded most of the school shootings at least 3 1/2 to 13 hours prior to the beginning of the shootings.
In the couple of shootings where the elevated levels were moderate, they were still elevated over the norm.
Our webmaster viewed dozens of days to see what "normal" HAARP levels were, and discovered that the
norm was for the signal to remain very flat horizontally. Even slight elevations of electromagnetic levels
seemed to be able to produce a killing response in the person previously programmed.
We discovered, earlier this year as we were doing research into school shootings, that the shooters had one
factor in common: they were participating in occult activities. In fact, most of them were so into the occult
that they were feared by the rest of the student population. I have spoken with Christian author, Cisco
Wheeler, who has co-authored several books on Mind Control with Fritz Springmeier, about this situation of
the shooters previously being occultists. Cisco said that these shooters were not only into Satan worship
themselves, but were victims of Generational Witchcraft. This term means that someone on either side of
the family had been practicing witchcraft at some point in their genealogy. Maybe the culprit was Mom or
Dad, or maybe the Grandparents, but each of these shooters were in Generational Witchcraft families. The
Bible speaks to this issue when God says: "Thou shalt not bow down thyself to them [Satanic idols], nor
serve them [witchcraft]: for I the LORD thy God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon
the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate me. [Generational Witchcraft ]" [Exodus
20:5]
In an effort to bring this whole subject a little closer to home, let us continue with this story, quoted above, on
this microwave technology being used for Mind Control. This time, we move from the subject of certain
individuals who might have been programmed [which is frightening enough] to entire populations being
controlled [which is the stuff of horror shows]. http://mercury.spaceports.com/~persewen/silent_sound.htm
"NewsHawk is at this very moment investigating the use of "Silent Sound" transmissions and/or related
EM/RF technology applied as a mass mood/mind control operation in Northern California: apparently
intended to induce (violent) psychosis in targeted subjects. Targeted subjects, in this case, would include
upwards of probably two million human beings!!"
Now let us make sure we get this information straight! Northern Californians, maybe as many as 2,000,000
people, are being silently bombarded with HAARP-type radio transmissions in exactly the same frequency as
all human brains normally function, in an effort to perfect the capability to control the moods and/or minds of
entire subjected populations! If this scenario sounds like Science Fiction, or like Orwell's 1984 , you are right
on target. But, will these signals affect normal, ordinary people? Listen to more of this article:
"Experts we have spoken with believe that such mentally destabilizing signals would, naturally, most strongly
and primarily affect individuals whose grip on mental/emotional equilibrium is less than solid; but
EVERYONE within range of the transmissions would have distinctly negative reactions to some extent or
other." [Emphasis was in the original]
While these "mentally destabilizing signals" would primarily affect people who are on the fringe of mental
stability, everyone will feel somewhat mentally distressed. How many jobs in Northern California have been
lost because people could not function anymore at the consistent level demanded by the employer? How
many marriages have been ruined? How many careers have been ruined? How many teenagers, who are
normally mentally and emotionally stressed anyway as they are going through these trying years, have been
pushed overboard into real emotional or mental disturbance? We shall never know, and the Mass Media will
never report a story like this.
Most people want to believe their elected and unelected officials have their best interests at heart. People
will believe heinous acts by government officials might occur because of negligence, or selfishness, or by
criminal acts; but, no one wants to believe their government officials have a specific agenda designed to
destroy the lives of its citizens. To believe this is to stay up all night, every night, worrying about whether you
might be the next target.
Normal, everyday Germans during the time of Adolf Hitler found themselves in the same quandary. Despite
the fact that Adolf had publicly published Mein Kampf , in which he told the Jews and others he was going to
murder them all, most Jews refused to believe. They found all sorts of excuses to not believe. When the
killing began in earnest, and many non-Jewish Germans came face-to-face with some of the evidence, most of
them refused to even consider the possibility that such murder on such a scale could ever take place. Even
German citizens living in close proximity to the mass murder facilities refused to even believe that the smell
of burning human flesh that was pouring forth from the chimneys 24 hours per day could possibly be human.
They discounted the sightings of countless railcars going to these facilities full of people and leaving
empty. Just before the end of the war, when the Allies broke the story of such atrocities, one German woman
wrote to her friend that "someone should tell Adolf of these terrible things; he surely does not know"!
What is your reaction to these truths being shared with you now? Are you going to be a believer or are you
going to bury your head in the sand deeper and deeper?
When were these experiments being carried out against the unsuspecting tax-paying citizens of Northern
California? Let us return back to this article. "This activity has been ongoing for most of 1999--with a pause
of a couple of months or so during the summer (the perpetrators were obviously busy elsewhere!). These
signals, primarily in the ULF (ultra-low-frequency) and ELF frequency range, have been recorded on a
variety of equipment by several researchers and are in the process of being analyzed. During the many
months these signals have been broadcast, they have been transmitting TWENTY-FOUR hours a day,
EVERY DAY!!" [Emphasis was in the original]
One of the details of these experiments that need to be "analyzed" is the fact that, once a specific frequency
for a certain type of brain function is proven, that frequency of transmission can be recorded on a computer.
NewsHawk explains the science behind this insidious effort. "The purpose of all this high technology is to plot
and display a moving cluster of periodic brainwave signals. The illustration shows an EEG display from a
single individual, taken of left and right hemispheres simultaneously ... By using these computer-enhanced
EEGs, scientists can identify and isolate the brain's low-amplitude 'emotion signature clusters', synthesize
them and store them on another computer. In other words, by studying the subtle characteristic brainwave
patterns that occur when a subject experiences a particular emotion, scientists have been able to identify the
concomitant brainwave pattern and can now duplicate it . These clusters are then placed on the Silent
Sound[TM] carrier frequencies and will silently trigger the occurrence of the same basic emotion in another
human being!" [Ibid]
In layman's language, once these specific frequencies that causes a certain emotion or thought is precisely
identified so exactly that a "fingerprint" of it can be made and stored on a computer, then this "fingerprint"
can be sent out over other types of Mass Media! In other words, the frequency of brain wave that is proven
to cause suicidal thoughts, for example, can be recorded by computer and then subliminally sent out via radio
programs or TV shows! Or, if the government wants to cause huge numbers of people to suddenly go into
depression, or into euphoria, they can emit the recorded signals via radio or TV and reach the entire
population over a period of time!
This capability can even implant specific thoughts or commands into the minds of people. Huge numbers of
people within a population can suddenly receive simultaneous thoughts or commands, causing many numbers
of them to suddenly carry out the command. If the command is to "kill anyone", you suddenly might have
large numbers of unexplained violent assaults by people who have never committed crimes before. Of
course, the application to Biblical prophecy is direct and very serious for citizens living in the End Times.
Listen:
"And I saw one of his heads as it were wounded to death; and his deadly wound was healed: and all the world
wondered after the beast." [Revelation 13:3] Notice the word, "all" in this sentence. All the peoples of the
world looked upon the Beast [Antichrist] with amazement and awe. The Bible then tells us exactly what "all
" the peoples of the world were saying in unison.
"And they worshipped the dragon which gave power unto the beast: and they worshipped the beast, saying,
Who is like unto the beast? who is able to make war with him?" [Revelation 13:4]
"All" the peoples of the world will be simultaneously amazed and thrilled by Antichrist. This admiration will
lead "all" the peoples of the world to "worship" the dragon [Satan] and his man, the beast [Antichrist]. As I
have read the volumes of material on the New World Order Plan, I realized that their #1 goal was to
successfully stage their New Age Christ -- Maitreya is his name. Their #1 goal after Maitreya is successfully
staged is to lead all the peoples of the world into a worship of him, a worship of him as God. New Age author,
David Spangler, stated this part of the Plan most succinctly.
"No one will enter the New World Order unless he or she will make a pledge to worship Lucifer. No
one will enter the New Age unless he will take a Luciferian Initiation", David Spangler,Director of
Planetary Initiative, United Nations. [
But, then, Spangler chills the s oul of any Born Again Christian who knows their Bible
generally a nd p rophecy o f R evelation s pecifically. " The lig ht t hat r eveals t o u s t he
presence of the Christ comes from Lucifer. He is the light-giver, he is aptly named the
Morning Star b ecause it is h is lig ht t hat h eralds fo r m an t he d awn o f a g reat
consciousness. He stands as the Great Initiator, the one who hands the soul over to
the Christ." [Ibid]
Did you get that last sentence? Lucifer is the "one who hands the soul over to the Christ" for worship. Wow!
How much more bold and Biblical can you get? The New Age Plan of the New World Order Kingdom of
Antichrist is to so prepare mankind through the workings of Lucifer as the "Great Initiator" so that he can
hand each soul of each person over to Antichrist. Isn't this just what prophecy declares?
"If any man worship the beast and his image, and receive his mark in his forehead, or in his hand, The same
shall drink of the wine of the wrath of God, which is poured out without mixture into the cup of his
indignation; and he shall be tormented with fire and brimstone in the presence of the holy angels, and in the
presence of the Lamb: And the smoke of their torment ascendeth up for ever and ever: and they have no rest
day nor night, who worship the beast and his image, and whosoever receiveth the mark of his name."
[Revelation 14:9-11]
"And the first [Angel] went, and poured out his vial upon the earth; and there fell a noisome and grievous sore
upon the men which had the mark of the beast, and upon them which worshipped his image." [Revelation
16:2]
"And the fifth angel poured out his vial upon the seat of the beast; and his kingdom was full of darkness; and
they gnawed their tongues for pain, And blasphemed the God of heaven because of their pains and their
sores, and repented not of their deeds." [Revelation 16:10-11] We can see here that God considers all people
who have had their souls delivered to The Christ [Antichrist] as being of "his kingdom", and they are all
brought into Divine Judgment.
Conversely, we see the reward God heaps on those who refuse to follow the Antichrist. "... I saw the souls of
them that were beheaded for the witness of Jesus, and for the word of God, and which had not worshipped
the beast, neither his image, neither had received his mark upon their foreheads, or in their hands; and they
lived and reigned with Christ a thousand years." [Revelation 20:4]
CONCLUSION
We must conclude that, if Antichrist has the capability to condition entire populations and to trigger the
response they wish on most of the people, the fact that significant numbers of people refuse to give in to this
efficient Mind Control must mean that God is Divinely protecting His own. We see huge numbers of people
being saved in the 7-year Tribulation Period, and we see those people getting specific rewards for just such
resistance. Therefore, God has to be protecting His own people.
At the conclusion of NEWS1344, concerning the occult map of the USA being used in the school shootings,
we presented three Scriptures promising that God does "seal" His own people from Satan. Let us look now at
Psalm 91 for other such reassurances.
Read carefully verses 1 and 2, for the promises God gives below are reserved for someone who carefully and
daily fulfills the conditions in these two verses. These promises are reserved for someone who "dwells" in the
"secret place of the Most High", who depends solely on the power of the Lord for protection.
"Surely he shall deliver thee from the snare of the fowler, and from the noisome [deadly] pestilence." [Verse
3] Notice the firm promise word, "shall", not "might" or "maybe", but "shall".
"Thou shalt not be afraid for the terror by night; nor for the arrow that flieth by day; Nor for the pestilence
that walketh in darkness; nor for the destruction that wasteth at noonday." [Verses 5-6] We are instructed
not to be afraid of anything the enemy of our souls -- Satan -- can throw our way, including the most powerful
Illuminist Witchcraft in the world, or their high technology.
"A thousand shall fall at thy side, and ten thousand at thy right hand; but it shall not come nigh thee. Only
with thine eyes shalt thou behold and see the reward of the wicked." A thousand people may fall at our side,
and ten thousand may fall at our right side, but the true believer in Jesus Christ shall not be affected.
"Because you have made the Lord your refuge, and the Most High your dwelling place, there shall no evil
befall you, nor any plague or calamity come near your tent. For He will give His angels special charge over
you to accompany and defend and preserve you in all your ways of obedience and service. They shall bear
you up on their hands, lest you cast your foot against a stone. You shall tread upon the lion and the adder;
the young lion and the serpent shall you trample underfoot." [Psalm 91:9-13, Parallel Bible, KJV/Amplified
Bible Commentary].
God will prevent His people from falling prey to these insidious technological breakthroughs. Make no
mistake about the fact that Satan is revealing these secrets to massive Mind Control just as fast as God allows
him to reveal them. But, this "calamity shall not come near you", God promises.
With King David, "I give myself unto prayer." [Psalm 109:4]
Truly, the sudden advent of population-wide Mind Control in the hands of the Satanic Illuminati is one more
sign of the End of the Age. Are you spiritually ready? Is your family? Are you adequately protecting your
loved ones? This is the reason for this ministry, to enable you to first understand the peril facing you, and then
help you develop strategies to warn and protect your loved ones. Once you have been thoroughly trained, you
can also use your knowledge as a means to open the door of discussion with an unsaved person. I have been
able to use it many times, and have seen people come to Jesus Christ as a result. These perilous times are also
a time when we can reach many souls for Jesus Christ, making an eternal difference.
If you have accepted Jesus Christ as your personal Savior, but have been very lukewarm in your spiritual
walk with Him, you need to immediately ask Him for forgiveness and for renewal. He will instantly forgive
you, and fill your heart with the joy of the Holy Spirit. Then, you need to begin a daily walk of prayer and
personal Bible Study.
If you have never accepted Jesus Christ as Savior, but have come to realize His reality and the approaching
End of the Age, and want to accept His FREE Gift of Eternal Life, you can also do so now, in the privacy of
your home. Once you accept Him as Savior, you are spiritually Born Again, and are as assured of Heaven as
if you were already there. Then, you can rest assured that the Kingdom of Antichrist will not touch you
spiritually.
If you would like to become Born Again, turn to our Salvation Page now.
We hope you have been blessed by this ministry, which seeks to educate and warn people, so that they can
see the coming New World Order -- Kingdom of Antichrist -- in their daily news.
Subscribe to our email updates and messages from our editor by entering your email address below
Email:
Return to:
Quick Links
Home Page
HAARP FAQ
Site Map
Glossary of Terms
How to Contact HAARP
Privacy Statement
Questions of a technical
nature may be submitted
via e-mail to:
HAARP Cam
HAARP Cam 2
HAARP is often confused with Project HARP, the High Altitude Research Project (a joint project of the
Pentagon and the Canadian Department of National Defense).
The High Frequency Active Auroral Research Program High Frequency Active Auroral Research Program Research
Station
(HAARP) is an investigation project jointly funded by the
United States Air Force, the United States Navy, the
University of Alaska, and the Defense Advanced Research
Projects Agency[1] (DARPA) which aims to "provide a
research facility to conduct pioneering experiments in
ionospheric phenomena... used to analyze basic ionospheric
properties and to assess the potential for developing
ionospheric enhancement technology for communications
and surveillance purposes."[2] Started in 1993, the project is Established 1990-1993
proposed to last for a period of twenty years. The system Research Type Ionospheric
was designed and built by Advanced Power Technologies Director John Heckscher
(APTI) and since 2003, by BAE Systems Inc. Location Gakona, Alaska
The facility currently operates VHF and UHF radar, a Website http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/
fluxgate magnetometer, a ionospheric digisonde, and an
induction magnetometer alongside the transmitter facilities.
The project site (622330N 1450903W) is north of Gakona, Alaska, just West of the Wrangell-Saint Elias
National Park. An environmental impact statement led to permission for an array of up to 180 antennas to be
erected. The HAARP has been constructed at the previous site of an over-the-horizon radar (OTH) installation.
A large structure, built to house the OTH now houses the HAARP control room, kitchen, and offices. Several
other small structures house various instruments.
The HAARP site has been constructed in three distinct phases (http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/haarp/phases.html)
.
The Developmental Prototype (DP) had 18 antenna elements, organized in three columns by six rows. It was
fed with a total of 360 kilowatts (kW) combined transmitter output power. The DP transmitted just enough
power for the most basic of ionospheric testing.
The Filled Developmental Prototype (FDP) had 48 antenna units arrayed in six columns by eight rows, with
960 kW of transmitter power. It was fairly comparable to other ionospheric heating facilities. This was used for
a number of successful scientific experiments and ionospheric exploration campaigns over the years.
The Final IRI (FIRI) will be the final build of the IRI. It has 180 antenna units, organized in 15 columns by 12
rows, yielding a theoretical maximum gain of 31 dB. A total of 3600 kW (3.6 MW) of transmitter power will
feed it. The total ERP (effective radiated power) will be 3,981 MW (96 dBW). As of March 2007, all the
antennas were in place, but the final quota of transmitters had not yet been installed, the final phase was
completed and the antenna array was undergoing testing aimed at fine-tuning its performance to comply with
safety requirements required by regulatory agencies.
The Ionospheric Research Instrument (IRI) is the primary instrument at HAARP, which is a high-frequency
(HF) transmitter system used to temporarily energize a portion the ionosphere. Study of this modified volume
yields important information for understanding natural ionospheric processes.
During active ionospheric research, the signal generated by the transmitter system is delivered to the antenna
array, transmitted in an upward direction, and is partially absorbed, at an altitude between 100 to 350 km
(depending on operating frequency), in a small volume a few hundred meters thick and a few tens of kilometers
in diameter over the site. The intensity of the HF signal in the ionosphere is less than 3 W/cm, tens of
thousands of times less than the Sun's natural electromagnetic radiation reaching the earth and hundreds of times
less than even the normal random variations in intensity of the Sun's natural ultraviolet (UV) energy which
creates the ionosphere. The small effects that are produced, however, can be observed with the sensitive
scientific instruments installed at the HAARP facility and these observations can provide new information about
the dynamics of plasmas and new insight into the processes of solar-terrestrial interactions. [1]
(http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/haarp/tech.html)
HAARP can transmit between 2.8 and 10 MHz. This frequency range lies above the AM radio broadcast band
and well below Citizens' Band frequency allocations. The HAARP is licensed to transmit only in certain
segments of this frequency range, however. When the IRI is transmitting, the bandwidth of the transmitted
signal is 100 kHz or less. The IRI can transmit continuously (CW) or pulses as short as 100 microseconds (s).
CW transmission is generally used for ionospheric modification, while short pulses are frequently repeated, and
the IRI is used as a radar system. Researchers can run experiments that use both modes of transmission,
modifying the ionosphere for a predetermined amount of time, then measuring the decay of modification effects
with pulsed transmissions.
Current facilities
The United States has three ionospheric heating facilities: the HAARP, the HIPAS, near Fairbanks, Alaska, and
(currently offline for modifications) one at the Arecibo Observatory in Puerto Rico. The European Incoherent
Scatter (http://www.eiscat.se/about.html) Scientific Association (EISCAT) operates an ionospheric heating
facility, capable of transmitting over 1 GW [4] (http://www.kurasc.kyoto-u.ac.jp/s-ramp/abstract/s19.txt)
(1,000,000,000 watts) effective radiated power (ERP), near Troms in Norway. Russia has the Sura ionospheric
heating facility, in Vasilsursk near Nizhniy Novgorod, capable of transmitting 190 MW ERP.
A fluxgate magnetometer built by the University of Alaska Fairbanks Geophysical Institute is available to chart
variations in the Earth's magnetic field. Rapid and sharp changes may indicate a geomagnetic storm. A digisonde
provides ionospheric profiles, allowing scientists to choose appropriate frequencies for IRI operation. The
HAARP makes current and historic digisonde information available online. An induction magnetometer,
provided by the University of Tokyo, measures the changing geomagnetic field in the ULF (ultra low frequency)
range of 05 Hz.
Another site, operated by military sub-contractor under unknown arrangement between the US and Canadian
government, is located near Cape Race, Newfoundland, Canada, at N46 38.649' W53 9.010' There is minimal
or no grid power available at this site, so this may be a passive listening post for the transmissions emitted by
other HAARP sites.
HAARP's main goal is basic science research of the uppermost portion of the atmosphere, known as the
ionosphere. Essentially a transition between the atmosphere and the magnetosphere, the ionosphere is where the
atmosphere is thin enough that the sun's x-rays and UV rays can reach it, but thick enough that there are still
enough molecules present to absorb those rays. Consequently, the ionosphere consists of a rapid increase in
density of free electrons, beginning at ~70 km, reaching a peak at ~300 km, and then falling off again as the
atmosphere disappears entirely by ~1000 km. Various aspects of HAARP can study all of the main layers of the
ionosphere.
The profile of the ionosphere, however, is highly variable, showing minute-to-minute changes, diurnal changes,
seasonal changes, and year-to-year changes. This becomes particularly complicated near the Earth's poles,
where a host of physical processes (like auroral lights) are unlocked by the fact that the alignment of the Earth's
magnetic field is nearly vertical.
On the other hand, the ionosphere is traditionally very difficult to measure. Balloons cannot reach it because the
air is too thin, but satellites cannot orbit there because the air is still too thick. Hence, most experiments on the
ionosphere give only small pieces of information. HAARP approaches the study of the ionosphere by following
in the footsteps of an ionospheric heater called EISCAT near Troms, Norway. There, they pioneered
exploration of the ionosphere by perturbing it with radio waves in the 2-10 MHz range, and studying how the
ionosphere reacts. HAARP performs the same functions but with more power, and a more flexible and agile HF
beam.
1. Generation of very low frequency radio waves by modulated heating of the auroral electrojet, useful
because generating VLF waves ordinarily requires gigantic antennas
2. Production of weak luminous glow (below what you can see with your eye, but measurable) from
absorption of HAARP's signal
3. Production of ultra low frequency waves in the 0.1 Hz range, which are next to impossible to produce any
other way
4. Generation of whistler-mode VLF signals which enter the magnetosphere, and propagate to the other
hemisphere, interacting with Van Allen radiation belt particles along the way
5. VLF remote sensing of the heated ionosphere
1. Ionospheric heating
2. Plasma line observations
3. Stimulated electron emission observations
4. Gyro-frequency heating research
5. Spread F observations
6. Airglow observations
7. Heating induced scintillation observations
8. VLF and ELF generation observations (http://www-star.stanford.edu/~vlf/publications/2008-03.pdf)
9. Radio observations of meteors
10. Polar mesospheric summer echoes: Polar mesospheric summer echoes (PMSE) have been studied using
the IRI as a powerful radar, as well as with the 28 MHz radar, and the two VHF radars at 49 MHz and
139 MHz. The presence of multiple radars spanning both HF and VHF bands allows scientists to make
comparative measurements that may someday lead to an understanding of the processes that form these
elusive phenomena.
11. Research on extraterrestrial HF radar echos: the Lunar Echo experiment (2008).[3][4]
12. Testing of SS-Spread Spectrum Transmitters 2009
The HAARP project aims to direct a 3.6 MW signal, in the 2.8-10 MHz region of the HF band, into the
ionosphere. The signal may be pulsed or continuous wave. Then effects of the transmission and any recovery
period will be examined using associated instrumentation, including VHF and UHF radars, HF receivers, and
optical cameras. According to the HAARP team, this will advance the study of basic natural processes that
occur in the ionosphere under the natural but much stronger influence of solar interaction, as well as how the
natural ionosphere affects radio signals. This will enable scientists to develop techniques to mitigate these
effects in order to improve the reliability and/or performance of communication and navigation systems, which
would have a wide range of applications in both the civilian and military sectors.
The project is funded by the Office of Naval Research and jointly managed by the ONR and Air Force Research
Laboratory, with the principal involvement of the University of Alaska. Fourteen other universities and
educational institutions have been involved in the development of the project and its instruments, namely the
University of Alaska, Penn State University (ARL), Boston College, UCLA, Clemson University, Dartmouth
College, Cornell University, Johns Hopkins University, University of Maryland, College Park, University of
Massachusetts, MIT, Polytechnic Institute of New York University, Stanford University, and the University of
Tulsa. The project's specifications were developed by the universities, which are continuing to play a major role
in the design of future research efforts. There is both military and commercial interest in its outcome, as many
communications and navigation systems depend on signals being reflected from the ionosphere or passing
through the ionosphere to satellites. Thanks to the more penetrating properties of VLF and ELF, advancements
in underwater and underground research and applications are now possible. This may lead to improved methods
for submarine communication and the ability to remotely sense the mineral content of the terrestrial subsurface,
among other things.
The HAARP project offers annual open days to permit the general public to visit the facility, and makes a public
virtue of openness; according to the team, "there are no classified documents pertaining to the HAARP." Each
summer, the HAARP holds a summer-school for visiting students, including foreign nationals, giving them an
opportunity to do research with one of the world's foremost research instruments.
Supporters
Power emitted
The critics' views have been rejected by HAARP's defenders, who have pointed out that the amount of energy
at the project's disposal is minuscule compared to the colossal energies dumped into the atmosphere by solar
radiation and thunderstorms. A University of Alaska Fairbanks Geophysical Institute scientist has compared the
HAARP to an "immersion heater in the Yukon River."
Since the ionosphere is inherently a chaotically turbulent region, HAARP's defenders state any artificially
induced changes would be "swept clean" within seconds or minutes at the most. Ionospheric heating
experiments performed at the Arecibo Observatory's ionospheric heater and incoherent scatter radar have
shown that after periods of modification (up to an hour), the ionosphere returns to normal within about the same
period of time it had been heated.
For instance, HAARP generates 3.6 megawatts (MW) of power. 3.6 MW is considered a minuscule percentage
of the energy compared to all of the energy constantly injected into the Earth, and the ionosphere, by the sun.
Open activities
Furthermore, supporters of HAARP argue that its activities have been, since its establishment, extremely open.
All activities are logged and publicly available. Scientists without security clearances, even foreign nationals, are
routinely allowed on site. The HAARP facility regularly hosts open houses, during which time any civilian may
tour the entire facility.
In addition, scientific results obtained with HAARP are routinely published in major research journals (such as
Geophysical Research Letters, or Journal of Geophysical Research), written both by university scientists (both
US and foreign) or by Department of Defense research lab scientists.
Waste
HAARP was constructed at the site of an obsolete over-the-horizon radar facility for reasons of cost reduction.
Critics
Waste
The cost of building the HAARP has exceeded the dollar-adjusted cost of similar facilities around the world.
Weapon
The objectives of the HAARP project became the subject of controversy in the mid-1990s, following claims that
the antennas could be used as a weapon. A small group of American physicists aired complaints in scientific
journals such as Physics and Society[5], charging that the HAARP could be seeking ways to destroy or disable
enemy spacecraft or disrupt communications over large portions of the planet. The physicist critics of the
HAARP have had little complaint about the project's current stage, but have expressed fears that it could in the
future be expanded into an experimental weapon, especially given that its funding comes from the Office of
Naval Research and the Air Force Research Laboratory.
These concerns were amplified by Bernard Eastlund, a physicist who developed some of the concepts behind
the HAARP in the 1980s and proposed using high-frequency radio waves to energize the ionosphere in order to
disable incoming missiles, thus "knocking out" out enemy satellite communications. The US military became
interested in the idea as an alternative to the laser-based Strategic Defense Initiative. However, Eastlund's ideas
were eventually dropped as SDI itself mutated into the more limited National Missile Defense of today. The
contractors selected to build HAARP have denied that any of Eastlund's patents were used in the development
of the project.
After the physicists raised early concerns, the controversy was stoked by local activism. In September 1995, a
book entitled Angels Don't Play This HAARP: Advances in Tesla Technology by the former teacher Nick
Begich, Jr., son of the late Congressman Nick Begich (D-AK) and brother of U.S. Senator Mark Begich (D-AK),
claimed that the project in its present stage could be used for "geophysical warfare."
HAARP has been referenced twice by the History Channel series That's Impossible, once in regards to its
supposed weather control capabilities and later for its claimed connection to mind control.
In August 2002, a critical mention of HAARP technology came from the State Duma (parliament) of Russia.
The Duma published a critical report on the HAARP written by the international affairs and defense
committees, signed by 90 deputies and presented to then President Vladimir Putin. The report claimed that "the
U.S. is creating new integral geophysical weapons that may influence the near-Earth medium with
high-frequency radio waves ... The significance of this qualitative leap could be compared to the transition
Advanced Media Group Page 561 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 580
Page
of 2413
581 of 2593
6 of 9 9/23/2009 3:01 PM
High Frequency Active Auroral Research Program - Wikipedia, the free e... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Frequency_Active_Auroral_Research...
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
from cold steel to firearms, or from conventional weapons to nuclear weapons. This new type of weapons
differs from previous types in that the near-Earth medium becomes at once an object of direct influence and
its component."However, given the timing of the Russian intervention, it is possible that it was related to a
controversy at the time concerning the US withdrawal in June 2002 from the Russian-American Anti-Ballistic
Missile Treaty. This high level concern is paralleled in the April 1997 statement by the U.S. Secretary of
Defense over the power of such electromagnetic weaponry. Russia owns and operates an ionospheric heater
system as powerful as the HAARP [6], called 'Sura,' which is located roughly 150 km from the city of Nizhny
Novgorod.
1. Ionosphere
2. Ionospheric reflection
3. Conspiracy theories
4. European Incoherent Scatter Scientific Association
5. HIPAS-HIgh Power Auroral Stimulation
6. Sura Ionospheric Heating Facility
7. SuperDARN
8. Poker Flat Research Range
9. Ionospheric Observatory, subsidiary of Kharkiv Polytechnical Institute, located near Zmiiv, Ukraine
(494037N 361732E) [5] (http://www.kpi.kharkiv.edu/iion/) [6] (http://tourist.kharkov.ua
/review_niceplaces/index.php?viewtopic=16)
10. Platteville, Colorado
11. Hansell, Clarence W., U.S. Patent 2,389,432 (http://www.google.com/patents?vid=2389432) ,
"Communication system by pulses through the Earth." 1945.
12. Tanner, R. L., U.S. Patent 3,215,937 (http://www.google.com/patents?vid=3215937) , "Extremely
low-frequency antenna." 1965.
13. Leydorf, G. F., U.S. Patent 3,278,937 (http://www.google.com/patents?vid=3278937) , "Antenna near
field coupling system." 1966.
14. Eastlund, Bernard J., U.S. Patent 4,686,605 (http://www.google.com/patents?vid=4686605) , "Method
and apparatus for altering a region in the earth's atmosphere, ionosphere, and/or magnetosphere."
1987.
15. Eastlund, Bernard J., U.S. Patent 5,038,664 (http://www.google.com/patents?vid=5038664) , "Method
for producing a shell of relativistic particles at an altitude above the earths surface." 1991.
1. ^ http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/haarp/factSheet.html
2. ^ http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/haarp/prpeis.html
3. ^ Reeve, W.D. (2008). "The Lunar Echo Experiment (Part 1)". Radio User 3 (8): 5658. ISSN 1748-8117
(http://worldcat.org/issn/1748-8117) .
4. ^ Reeve, W.D. (2008). "The Lunar Echo Experiment (Part 2)". Radio User 3 (9): 5657. ISSN 1748-8117
(http://worldcat.org/issn/1748-8117) .
5. ^ [THE IMPRUDENCE OF "PRUDENT AVOIDANCE"; Physics and Society, Vol. 24, No. 3]
6. ^ USA and Russia supposedly develop secret meteorological weapons Pravda.Ru (http://english.pravda.ru
/science/19/94/379/16227_hurricanes.html)
US Air Force, US Navy, University of Alaska, Raytheon research history, construction, utilization, association
Corporation, BAE Systems/ Marconi Electronics (Tesla's w/ Marconi Company / GE, and future ionospheric
NY 'long-range weapon' financeer), General Dynamics heater plans (http://uncletaz.com/library/scimath/tesla
Robotics /weapon.html) "
Hggstrm, Christian, "European Incoherent
"High Frequency Active Auroral Research Program SCATter's ionospheric Heating facility
(http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/) ." haarp.Alaska.edu. (http://www.eiscat.se/heating/) including
"About ELF (http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/haarp Dynasonde." eiscat.se, 4 July 2003.
/elfindex.html) ." haarp.Alaska.edu, July 2, 1996. Zabotin, Nikolay, "Evidence for Precipitation of
(ELF Generation Using HAARP) Energetic Particles by Ionospheric Heating
HAARP (http://www.darpa.mil/ucar/programs Transmissions (http://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/stp/IONO
/haarp.htm) from a Military Point Of View /Dynasonde/SpEatHeating.htm) ." noaa.gov,
From radio telescopes to electromagnetic weapons. December 7, 2004.
Russian researches (http://en.rian.ru/analysis "Boeing, Lockheed Martin, BAE Systems, and
/20070511/65348455.html) Raytheon to create B2B exchange for the aerospace
"Ionospheric Interaction Research References and defense industry, powered by Microsoft
(http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/haarp/imref.html) , by (http://www.lockheedmartin.com
U.S. Authors: 19801999." haarp.Alaska.edu, June /wms/findPage.do?dsp=fec&ci=12498&rsbci=0&
24, 1999. fti=112&ti=0&sc=400) "
"HAARP Cam (http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/haarp "The Weather Modification Operations and Research
/cam.fcgi) ." haarp.Alaska.edu. (live HAARP Board (passed Oct.2005) in corporate cooperation
antenna array daylight pictures) with BAE Systems (HAARP apparatus & facility
"HAARP (http://www.bariumblues.com owner) and Raytheon Corporation (HAARP patent
/haarp_executive_summary.htm) : HF Active owner) (http://commerce.senate.gov/public
Auroral Research Program." Joint Services Program /index.cfm?FuseAction=PressReleases.Detail&
Plans and Activities: Air Force, Geophysics PressRelease_Id=248556)
Laboratory; Navy, Office of Naval Research. "the Weather Modification Operations and Research
(Executive Summary) Board on Wiki"
"Raytheon Aircraft Company (Owner of HAARP
patents, and, NOAA-funded aerosol weather Information
modification/AESA radar weather weapons)
(http://www.raytheonaircraft.com/government "HAARP Completed! news compilation
/multi_jets.shtml#main) " (http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2006/05
"BAE Systems (program and apparatus-owner of the /06/18214461.php) "
HAARP facility, Railgun technology, electromagnetic "President Bush's National Response Plan
armor, and, a sub-corporation partner with Raytheon (http://www.dhs.gov/xprepresp/committees
via British Aerospace Corporation /editorial_0566.shtm) "
(http://www.na.baesystems.com Demirkol, Characterization of the Modified and
/releasesDetail.cfm?a=477) Ambient Lower Ionosphere for HAARP using VLF
"General Dynamics Robotics (owned by Raytheon diagnostics (http://www-star.stanford.edu
Corp) military contractor/manufacturer of /~vlf/HAARP/) ."leland.stanford.edu. (Impact of
Unmanned Autonomous Vehicles (UAV) aircraft HAARP on VLF signals, a 2% effect.)
designed for "all-weather", computer-controlled Hagfors, T., "Early Ionospheric HF Modification
weapons defense progams (http://www.gdrs.com Work in Arecibo (http://www.eiscat.uit.no/heating
/news/) /abs7.html) ". Max Planck Institut fr Aeronomie,
"Boeing, Lockheed Martin, BAE Systems, and Katlenburg-Lindau, Germany.
Raytheon to create B2B exchange for the aerospace McQuerry, Shawn, "Platteville Heating Experiments
and defense industry, powered by Microsoft (http://grison.colorado.edu/pao-lower/History
(http://www.lockheedmartin.com /index.html) " References (http://grison.colorado.edu
/wms/findPage.do?dsp=fec&ci=12498&rsbci=0& /pao-lower/History/history_references.html) .
fti=112&ti=0&sc=400) " DLC, "VLF Group Science Background (http://www-
star.stanford.edu/~vlf/Science/Science.html) ."
Other facilities and agencies nova.stanford.edu, June 13, 1995. (VLF Tutorial)
Inan, U. S., and T. F. Bell, "Polar Aeronomy and
"Tesla's Wardenclyffe Tower 'Long Range Weapon' Radio Science (http://www-star.stanford.edu
The High-frequency Active Auroral Research Program (HAARP) is a congressionally initiated program
jointly managed by the U.S. Air Force and U.S. Navy. The program's goal is to provide a state-of-the-art
U.S. owned ionospheric research facility readily accessible to U.S. scientists from universities, the
Quick Links private sector and government. This facility would be the most advanced in the world and would attract
international scientists and foster cooperative research efforts. The program's purpose is to provide a
research facility to conduct pioneering experiments in ionospheric phenomena. The data obtained from
the proposed research would be used to analyze basic ionospheric properties and to assess the potential
for developing ionospheric enhancement technology for communications and surveillance purposes.
Home Page
HAARP FAQ The layer of the earth's atmosphere called the ionosphere begins approximately 30 miles above the
Site Map surface and extends upward to approximately 620 miles. In contrast to the layers of the atmosphere
Glossary of Terms closer to the earth, which are composed of neutral atoms and molecules, the ionosphere contains both
How to Contact HAARP
Privacy Statement
positively and negatively charged particles known as ions and electrons. These ions and electrons are
created naturally by radiation from our sun.
Please read the
Cautionary statement The ionized gas in the ionosphere behaves much differently from the neutral atmosphere closer to the
earth. A major difference is that although radio signals pass through the lower atmosphere undistorted,
Questions of a technical the signals directed through the ionosphere may be distorted, totally reflected or absorbed. For example,
nature may be submitted
via e-mail to:
communication links from the ground to earth-orbiting satellites can experience fading due to
ionospheric distortion; an AM radio signal sometimes can reflect, or "skip", off the ionosphere and be
heard at locations hundreds of miles distant from the broadcasting radio station; the characteristic fading
on the high-frequency (HF) or "shortwave" band is due to ionospheric interference. Because of its
Page updated May 17, 2007
strong interaction with radio waves, the ionosphere also interferes with U.S. Department of Defense
(DOD) communications and radar surveillance systems, which depend on sending radio waves from one
location to another.
Ionospheric disturbances at high latitudes also can act to induce large currents in electric power grids;
these are thought to cause power outages. Understanding of these and other phenomena is important to
maintain reliable communication and power services. HAARP is needed to continue and expand basic
research efforts on the properties and potential uses of the ionosphere for enhanced communications and
surveillance. To meet the project's research objectives, the HAARP facility would utilize powerful, high
frequency (HF) transmissions and a variety of associated observational instruments to investigate
naturally occurring and artificially induced ionospheric processes that support, enhance or degrade the
propagation of radio waves.
Investigations conducted at the HAARP facility are expected to provide significant scientific
advancements in understanding the ionosphere. The research facility would be used to understand,
simulate and control ionospheric processes that might alter the performance of communications and
surveillance systems. This research would enhance present civilian and DOD capabilities because it
would facilitate the development of techniques to mitigate or control ionospheric processes.
Civilian applications from the program's research could lead to improved local and world-wide
communications such as satellite communication. Furthermore, and possibly more significant is the
potential for new technology that could be developed from a better understanding of ionospheric
processes.
These and many other research applications are expected to greatly enhance present DOD technology.
There are several HF transmitters located throughout the world which conduct research similar to that
proposed by HAARP. However, no facility, located either in the U.S. or elsewhere, has the transmitting
capability needed to address the broad range of research goals which HAARP proposes to study. The
most capable HF transmitters currently operating are located in Russia and Norway and have effective
radiated powers (ERP) of roughly one billion watts (1 gigawatt). One gigawatt of ERP represents an
important threshold power level, allowing significant radio wave generation and analysis of key
ionospheric phenomena. The HAARP facility is designed to have an ERP above one gigawatt. This
would elevate the United States to owning and operating the world's most capable ionospheric research
instrument.
The High frequency Active Auroral Research Program (HAARP) is a program focused on the study of
upper atmospheric and solar-terrestrial physics and Radio Science. The HAARP program operates a
Quick Links major Arctic ionosphere research facility on an Air Force owned site near Gakona, Alaska. Principal
instruments installed at the HAARP Research Station include a high power, high-frequency (HF) phased
array radio transmitter (known as the Ionosphere Research Instrument (IRI), used to stimulate small,
well-defined volumes of ionosphere, and a large and diversified suite of modern geophysical research
instruments including an HF ionosonde, ELF and VLF receivers, magnetometers, riometers, a UHF
diagnostic radar and optical and infrared spectrometers and cameras which are used to observe the
Home Page
Site Map complex natural variations of Alaska's ionosphere as well as to detect artificial effects produced by the
Glossary of Terms IRI. Future plans include completion of the UHF radar to allow measurement of electron densities,
How to Contact HAARP electron and ion temperatures, and Doppler velocities in the stimulated region and in the natural
Privacy Statement ionosphere using incoherent scatter techniques.
Please read the
Cautionary statement Is HAARP Unique?
Questions of a technical Ionosphere research facilities have been in continuous use since the 1950s to investigate fundamental
nature may be submitted
via e-mail to: physical principles which govern the earth's ionosphere, so that present and future transmission
technologies may take into account the complexities of this highly variable medium. In addition to
HAARP, the United States has operated two other ionosphere research sites in recent years, one in
Puerto Rico, near the Arecibo Observatory, and the other (known as HIPAS) in Alaska near Fairbanks.
HAARP Cam Both of these facilities were built with both active and passive radio instrumentation similar to those at
the HAARP facility. Interest in the ionosphere is not limited to the US: a five-country consortium
operates the European Incoherent Scatter Radar site (EISCAT), a premier ionosphere research facility
located in northern Norway near Tromso. Facilities also are located at Jicamarca, Peru; near Moscow,
Nizhny Novgorod ("SURA") and Apatity, Russia; near Kharkov, Ukraine and in Dushanbe,
Tadzhikistan. All of these installations have as their primary purpose the study of the ionosphere, and
most employ the capability of stimulating to a varying degree small, localized regions of the ionosphere
HAARP Cam 2 in order to study methodically, and in a detailed manner what nature produces randomly and regularly
on a much larger scale. HAARP is unique to most existing facilities due to the combination of a research
tool which provides electronic beam steering, wide frequency coverage and high effective radiated
power collocated with a diverse suite of scientific observational instruments.
Technical expertise and procurement services as required for the management, administration and
evaluation of the program are being provided cooperatively by the Air Force (Air Force Research
Laboratory), the Navy (Office of Naval Research and Naval Research Laboratory), and the Defense
Advanced Research Projects Agency. Since the HAARP facility consists of many individual items of
scientific equipment, both large and small, there is a considerable list of commercial, academic and
government organizations which are contributing to the building of the facility by developing scientific
diagnostic instrumentation and by providing guidance in the specification, design and development of
the IRI. BAE Advanced Technologies (BAEAT) is the prime contractor for the design and construction
of the IRI. Other organizations which have contributed to the program include the University of Alaska,
Stanford University, Cornell University, University of Massachusetts, UCLA, MIT, Dartmouth
University, Clemson University, Penn State University, University of Tulsa, University of Maryland, SRI
The ionosphere begins approximately 35 miles above the earth's surface and extends out beyond 500
miles. In contrast to the dense atmosphere close to the earth, which is composed almost entirely, of
neutral gas, the thin ionosphere contains both neutral gas and a small number of charged particles known
as ions and electrons. This ionized medium can distort, reflect and absorb radio signals, and thus can
affect numerous civilian and military communications, navigation, surveillance and remote sensing
systems in many varied ways. For example, the performance of a satellite-to-ground communication link
is affected by the ionosphere through which the signals pass. AM broadcast programs, which in the
daytime can be heard only within a few tens of miles from the station, at night sometimes can be heard
hundreds of miles away, due to the change from poor daytime to good nighttime reflection from the
ionosphere. A long-range HF communication link which uses multiple hops or reflections from the
ionosphere and ground, often experiences amplitude fading caused by interference between signals
which have traveled from the transmitter to the receiver by two (or more) different ionosphere paths.
Since the sun's radiation creates and maintains the ionosphere, sudden variations in this radiation such as
those caused by solar flares can affect the performance of radio systems. Sometimes these natural
changes are sufficient to induce large transient currents in electric power transmission grids, causing
widespread power outages. Lightning is known to cause substantial heating and ionization density
enhancement in the lower ionosphere, and there are indications that ground-based HF transmitters,
including radars and strong radio stations, also modify the ionosphere and influence the performance of
systems whose radio paths traverse the modified region. Perhaps the most famous example of the latter
is the "Luxembourg" effect, first observed in 1933. In this case a weak Swiss radio station appeared to
be modulated with signals from the powerful Luxembourg station, which was transmitting at a
completely different frequency. Music from the Luxembourg station was picked up at the frequency of
the Swiss station.
The continual growth in the number of civilian and military satellite systems whose performances can be
affected by changes in ionosphere conditions stimulates research on characterizing and understanding
those effects, whether they be natural (solar related) or the result of controlled local modification of the
ionosphere, using ground HF transmitters. The HAARP facility is capable of supporting research in both
these areas of interest, by utilizing its flexible HF transmitting array and its suite of radio and optical
diagnostic instruments for active experimental research. Effectively, the diagnostic instruments alone
constitute a space-weather observatory (on the ground), which provides real-time data on the state of
the dynamic ionosphere over much of Alaska.
The Department of Defense (DoD) conducts Arctic research to ensure the development of the
knowledge, understanding and capability to meet national defense needs in the Arctic. Interest in
ionosphere research at HAARP stems both from the large number of communication, surveillance and
navigation systems that have radio paths which pass through the ionosphere, and from the unexplored
potential of technological innovations which suggest applications such as detecting underground objects,
communicating to great depths in the sea or earth, and generating infrared and optical emissions.
Expanding our knowledge about the interactions of signals passing through or reflecting from the
ionosphere can help to solve future problems in the development of DoD systems, and could as well
enhance the utilization of commercial systems which rely on the expedient transfer of real-time
communications.
During HAARP's environmental impact study, Gakona was identified as one of two DoD-owned,
Alaskan locations which satisfied the site selection criteria of being within the auroral zone, near a major
highway for year-round access, away from densely settled areas and their electrical noise and lights that
could interfere with sensitive research measurements, on relatively flat terrain, of realistic and
reasonable construction and operation costs, as well as minimal environmental impacts. On October 18,
1993 following the July 15, 1993 issuance of the Air Force's Environmental Impact Statement which
evaluated potential environmental effects of constructing and operating the HAARP facility, a Record
of Decision (ROD) signed by the Deputy Assistant Secretary of the Air Force for Installations selected
The access road is located at Milepost 11.3 on the Tok highway. The geographic coordinates of the HF
antenna array are approximately 62.39 degrees (North) latitude, 145.15 degrees (West) longitude. The
geomagnetic coordinates for the facility are 63.09 degrees (North) latitude and 92.44 degrees (West)
longitude.
Basically, the IRI is what is known as a phased array transmitter. It is designed to transmit a narrow
beam of high power radio signals in the 2.8 to 10 MHz frequency range. Its antenna is built on a gravel
pad having dimensions of 1000' x 1200' (about 33 acres). There are 180 towers, 72' in height mounted on
thermopiles spaced 80' apart in a 12 x 15 rectangular grid. Each tower supports near its top, two pairs of
crossed dipole antennas, one for the low band (2.8 to 8.3 MHz), the other for the high band (7 to 10
MHz). The antenna system is surrounded by an exclusion fence to prevent possible damage to the
antenna towers or harm to large animals. An elevated ground screen, attached to the towers at the 15'
level, acts as a reflector for the antenna array while allowing vehicular access underneath to 30
environmentally-controlled transmitter shelters spaced throughout the array. Each shelter contains 6
pairs of 10 kW transmitters, for a total of 6 x 30 x 2 x 10 kW = 3600 kW available for transmission. The
transmitters can be switched to drive either the low or high band antennas. Electric prime power is
provided from an on-site power plant housing five, 2500 kW generators, each driven by a 3600 hp diesel
engine. Four generators are required for operation of the IRI and the fifth is held as a spare. From a
control room within the Operations Center, the transmission from each of the 180 crossed-dipole
antennas is adjusted in a precise manner under computer control. In this manner, the complete array of
antennas forms a narrow antenna pattern pointed upward toward the ionosphere. The transmitted signal
diverges (spreads out) as it travels upward and is partially absorbed, at an altitude which depends on the
transmitted HF frequency, in a small volume several tens of miles in diameter and a few hundred meters
thick directly over the facility. The remainder of the transmitted signal either reflects back toward the
earth or passes through the ionosphere into space, continuing to diverge as it does so. By the time it
reaches the ionosphere, the intensity of the HF signal is less than 3 microwatts (0.000003 watt) per cm2,
thousands of times less than the Sun's natural electromagnetic radiation reaching the earth and hundreds
of times less, even, than the variations in intensity of the Sun's natural ultraviolet (UV) energy which
creates the ionosphere.
Because the antenna pattern of the IRI array has been tailored to transmit its signal upward rather than
toward the horizon, radio field strengths at ground level, including areas directly under the antenna
array, are calculated to be smaller than Radio Frequency Radiation (RFR) standards allow for human
exposure. This is possible because the individual transmitters are spaced apart over 33 acres so that the
concentration of radio fields never exceeds these nationally recognized safety standards.
Electromagnetic field strength measurements have been made throughout the development of the
facility, beginning in 1994 and regularly thereafter. Measurements on the ground, directly under and
around the array and at multiple points on-site and off-site have verified compliance with RFR standards
as well as with all requirements for safety mandated in the EIS Record of Decision. At the point of
closest public access on the Tok Highway, for example, the measured fields are ten-thousand times
smaller than permitted by the RFR standards and hundreds of times smaller than typically found near
AM broadcast station antennas in many urban areas. The strength of these fields continues to decrease
in a rapid manner at greater distances from the facility.
While the signals along the ground are well-below adopted safety levels, the signals transmitted above
the antenna array may have sufficient strength to interfere with electronic equipment in aircraft flying
nearby. Therefore, to ensure the safety of all flight operations in the vicinity of HAARP, the facility
employs an aircraft alert radar (AAR) to automatically shut off appropriate transmissions when aircraft
are detected either within or approaching a defined safety zone around the facility. Flight tests are
conducted regularly to demonstrate the capability of the HAARP radar to detect even very small targets.
Research operations are not conducted unless the AAR is operating satisfactorily.
Every radio transmitting facility has the potential to interfere with other radio spectrum users. To
determine the potential for HAARP's transmissions to interfere inadvertently with other spectrum users
such as Alaskan TV, AM/FM radio, ham radio, or even with HAARP's own sensitive radio receiving
equipment, a comprehensive RFI study was conducted during the environmental impact study phase.
Theory predicted that in several worst-case scenarios, interference may be encountered by some nearby
users sharing the RF spectrum. On the other hand, the real world experiences of similar ionosphere
research instruments and radar diagnostics employed elsewhere in the world have shown that compatible
operations are practical. Included in HAARP's Spectrum Certification from the National
Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) are commitments to a mitigation program
that includes the use of state-of-the-art transmitters with stringent requirements for minimizing
out-of-band transmissions; proper orientation of the HF antenna array and adoption of operating
procedures, including beam steering, to minimize array side-lobes; employing special techniques such as
waveform shaping, filtering and antenna null placement; and working with affected spectrum users, if
any, to reach mutually agreeable solutions. A local phone number (907) 822-5497 permits anyone
believing they have interference from HAARP to contact the Gakona site operations center. In addition,
an automated spectrum monitor is installed to allow the HAARP control operator to monitor nearby
spectrum usage to assist in frequency selection for avoiding potential interference.
The Record of Decision stipulated than an RFI Resolution Committee ("Committee") would be formed
with local representation, to help mitigate potential RFI issues. The local community-appointed resident
would serve as an ombudsman to ensure community satisfaction with the RFI mitigation approaches
undertaken by HAARP. The purpose of the Committee is to provide a forum for the thorough review of
confirmed RFI reports. This Committee has met at least yearly since December 6, 1994. Committee
members are from the following organizations (one from each): Community-appointed resident, Aircraft
Owners and Pilots Association (AOPA), ALASCOM, Alaska Department of Environmental
Conservation, Alyeska Pipeline Service Co., American Radio Relay League (ARRL), Coast Guard,
Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), Fish & Wildlife (Federal), Fish & Game (State), National Park
Service, HAARP Environmental Liaison Officer, HAARP operational staff (site supervisor or delegate),
HAARP Program-appointed chairperson, National Park Service, Naval Research Laboratory (NRL),
and the combined Alaska military command (ALCOM) frequency coordinator.
To ensure that all concerns, including aircraft safety as well as radio frequency interference issues, are
addressed completely, a Developmental Prototype (DP) was completed in 1994. The DP consisted of a 6
x 8 (48 antenna element) array of crossed dipole antennas. A 3 x 6 (18 antenna elements) subset of
these antennas was energized by 18 pairs of 10 kW transmitters contained in three separate shelters,
thus supplying up to a maximum of 360 kW. Prime power for this initial array was obtained from three
portable 350 kW diesel generators.
During 1998, the DP was upgraded to include transmitters for all 48 of the antenna elements that were
originally installed. This Filled Developmental Prototype (FDP) was capable of producing 960 kW of
total transmitter power. Measurements of the HF fields in the vicinity of the FDP antenna array showed
that field intensities everywhere, including within the FDP beam, were below recommended
international safety limits for fly-by-wire aircraft. Nonetheless, the FDP was only operated in
conjunction with the aircraft alert radar, to insure that no high power transmissions occurred when there
was local flight traffic. Operation and test of the FDP verified the system engineering design and helped
develop interference mitigation procedures that are now integrated into all research operations involving
the IRI.
HAARP Diagnostics
HAARP has developed an extensive set of diagnostic instrumentation to support ionosphere research at
auroral latitudes, to characterize the processes produced in the upper atmosphere and ionosphere by
high power radio waves and to assess the potential of emerging ionosphere/radio technology for DoD
applications. While some of these scientific instruments are collocated with the IRI at the research
facility, others, due to geometrical considerations, are located off-site at various distances from the
facility. One of the primary active on-site instruments is the HF ionosonde, which transmits in the 1-30
MHz band and is used to provide scientists with information about the electron density profile in the
ionosphere. Another is the UHF ionosphere radar which transmits radio wave signals in the 430 - 450
MHz band and which will eventually be expanded to provide incoherent scatter capability.
Among the passive on-site instruments are two magnetometers for the measurement of the earth's
magnetic field and its variations, and two riometers (relative ionosphere opacity meter) to sense
ionosphere absorption of the celestial background electromagnetic radiation. The radio spectrum from
100 kHz to 1 GHz is being recorded to determine frequency of usage and to monitor HAARP
transmissions to ensure adherence to FCC and NTIA requirements. Other passive on-site instruments
include sensitive optical imagers and photometers, ELF/VLF receivers, and Total Electron Content
receivers. Data obtained from these scientific instruments are readily accessible on the internet in near
real time, allowing scientists to observe and participate in the investigations directly from their
laboratories. In addition to the instruments specifically developed by HAARP, a number of diagnostics
potentially are available through other federal agencies and the University of Alaska's Geophysical
Institute.
The Geophysical Institute of the University of Alaska Fairbanks (UAF) has played a major role in the
development of diagnostics and coordination of Arctic programs with the US scientific community. UAF
led a consortium of universities and industries which provided support in the design and development of
the Gakona facility and its associated scientific instruments. BAE Advanced Technologies, the prime
contractor for the IRI, utilized Eric Goozen for initial site survey work. Ahtna Construction, Inc., a
Glennallen based contractor, has contributed very extensively to the development of the facility. Ahtna
currently provides housekeeping and security services. Anchorage-based engineering firms Duane Miller
& Associates and USKH prepared the civil and pad design work and conducted the on-site testing and
evaluation. Arctic Foundation of Anchorage designed and manufactured, and Kiewit Pacific Company
installed thermopiles in the pad, using Amtec, Inc. to survey the thermopile locations and Tester Drilling
and EBA Engineering to provide drilling support. Acme Fence Company installed fencing, using the
services of Mark Lappi to survey the fence lines and B&B Plumbing to steam thaw the ground for
drilling. City Electric, Inc. erected the towers, antennas, and ground screen. Pacific Detroit Diesel and
Valley Diesel refurbished and installed the 2.5 MW diesel generators which are used to power the HF
transmitters. Service Oil provides fuel oil. Copper Valley Telephone installed the telephone lines, and
Copper Valley Electric supplies commercial housekeeping power. Bishop & Sons Enterprises supplies
water, while CBS Service provides trash removal and sewage disposal. Harley McMahon flew sorties to
test the capabilities of the aircraft alert radar and provide the opportunity for aerial photography.
Construction of the full IRI was completed in early 2007. In the near term, emphasis is being placed on
validating the performance of the complete IRI to include compliance with all specifications for
interference mitigation and safety of operations. Initial IRI testing began during March 2007.
Both on- and off-site scientific, observational instruments are now providing data on the natural high
latitude ionosphere. A complete listing of these scientific instruments is available.
Environmental Process
In accordance with the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), an environmental impact statement
(EIS) evaluated the consequences of constructing and operating the HAARP research facility in Alaska.
The EIS discusses impacts on such diverse topics as electromagnetic and radio frequency interference,
vegetation, wetlands, wildlife, air quality, subsistence, cultural resources, atmosphere and others.
State and federal environmental regulatory agencies were consulted to identify issues, and additional
input was solicited from the public during scoping meetings held in Anchorage and Glennallen, Alaska in
August 1992. A draft of the EIS was prepared and distributed to the public and to specific organizations
on March 12, 1993. Public hearings were held in Glennallen and Anderson, municipalities close to the
sites under consideration. The final EIS was released to the public on July 15, 1993 and the Record of
Decision selecting Gakona, Alaska as the site for the HAARP Ionosphere Research Facility was signed
on October 18, 1993.
In addition to the NEPA process described above, the HAARP facility complies with all applicable state
and federal regulations that are appropriate for its construction and operation.
Additional Information
An updated version of this fact sheet will be issued as often as program changes warrant to keep
interested parties appraised of significant developments in regard to HAARP. Any individual seeking
additional information about HAARP, or wishing to provide comments regarding HAARP, may contact:
The United States Secretary of Defense (SecDef) is United States Secretary of Defense
the head of the U.S. Department of Defense (DoD),
concerned with the armed services and military matters.
This position roughly corresponds to Minister of
defense in other countries. The role of the Secretary of
Defense is to be the principal defense policy advisor to
the President and is responsible for the formulation of Official Seal
general defense policy related to all matters of direct
and primary concern to the DoD, and for the execution
of approved policy.[1] The Secretary is appointed by
the President with the approval of the Senate, and is a
member of the Cabinet. By statute (10 U.S.C. 113
(http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/10/113.html) ) the
secretary must be a civilian who has not served in the
active component of the armed forces for at least 10
years.[2] The Secretary of Defense is sixth in the
presidential line of succession. The Secretary of
Incumbent:
Defense earns a salary of $191,300 per year. Robert Gates
since: December 18, 2006
The position was created in 1947 when the Navy, Army, and newly created Air
Force were merged into the new National Military Establishment. In the same massive reorganization, the
Secretary of War was replaced by the Secretary of the Army and, along with the Secretary of the Navy and the
new Secretary of the Air Force, became non-Cabinet positions placed under the Secretary of Defense. In 1949,
the National Military Establishment was renamed the Department of Defense, which remains the current name
of the department.
In the U.S. Armed Forces, the Secretary of Defense is often referred to as SecDef.
The Secretary of Defense and the President together constitute the National Command Authorities (NCA),[3]
which has sole authority to launch strategic nuclear weapons. All nuclear weapons are governed by this
dual-authority - both must concur before a strategic nuclear strike may be ordered.
The Secretary of Defense heads the United States Office of the Secretary of Defense and is assisted by a Deputy
Secretary and five Under Secretaries in the fields of Acquisition, Technology & Logistics; Comptroller/Chief
Financial Officer; Intelligence; Personnel & Readiness; and Policy. All of these positions require Senate
confirmation.
The Secretary of Defense also supervises the six members of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and the commanders of
the ten Unified Combatant Commands.
Along with the Secretary of State, the Attorney General and the Secretary of the Treasury, the Secretary of
Defense is generally regarded as one of the Big Four important cabinet officials.
September 19,
1 James Vincent Forrestal March 19, 1949
1947
September 19,
2 Louis Arthur Johnson March 28, 1949
1950
Harry S. Truman
9 Clark McAdams Clifford March 1, 1968 January 20, 1969 Lyndon B. Johnson
Richard Nixon
November 20,
13 Donald Henry Rumsfeld January 20, 1977 Gerald Ford
1975
14 Harold Brown January 21, 1977 January 20, 1981 Jimmy Carter
Ronald Reagan
George H. W. Bush
17 Richard Bruce Cheney March 21, 1989 January 20, 1993
19 William James Perry February 3, 1994 January 24, 1997 Bill Clinton
December 18,
21 Donald Henry Rumsfeld January 20, 2001 George W. Bush
2006
In an Executive Order of December 22, 2005, President George W. Bush modified the line of succession
regarding who would act as Secretary of Defense in the event of a vacancy or incapacitation as follows:
1. ^ http://www.dod.mil/odam/omp/pubs/GuideBook/DoD.htm#Secretary%20of%20Defense
2. ^ George Marshall was legislatively waived by Congress; he had only been a civilian for five years before his
appointment in 1950. See Defenselink bio (http://www.defenselink.mil/specials/secdef_histories/bios/marshall.htm)
, retrieved 11/15/2008.
3. ^ http://www.encyclopedia.com/doc/1O63-NationalCommandAuthoritis.html
2002.
"Executive Order: Providing An Order of Succession Within the Department of Defense
(http://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/news/releases/2005/12/20051222-7.html) ". Office of the
Press Secretary. http://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/news/releases/2005/12/20051222-7.html.
Retrieved December 22 2005.
"The Department of Defense Organizational Structure (http://www.dod.mil/odam/omp/pubs/GuideBook
/DoD.htm#Secretary%20of%20Defense) ". U.S. Department of Defense. http://www.dod.mil/odam/omp
/pubs/GuideBook/DoD.htm#Secretary%20of%20Defense. Retrieved November 13 2006.
There have been forty-three people sworn into office, and forty-four presidencies, due to the fact that Grover
Cleveland served two non-consecutive terms and is counted chronologically as both the twenty-second and the
twenty-fourth president. Of the individuals elected as president, four died in office of natural causes (William
Henry Harrison, Zachary Taylor, Warren G. Harding, and Franklin D. Roosevelt), one resigned (Richard M.
Nixon), and four were assassinated (Abraham Lincoln, James A. Garfield, William McKinley, and John F.
Kennedy). The first president was George Washington, who was inaugurated in 1789 after a unanimous
Electoral College vote. William Henry Harrison spent the shortest time in office at 31 days in 1841. At over
twelve years, Franklin D. Roosevelt spent the longest time in office, and is the only president to serve more than
two terms, but he died shortly into his fourth term in 1945. The current president is Barack Obama; he assumed
the office on January 20, 2009.
1 Presidents
2 Notes
3 See also
4 References
5 External links
Parties
Took Vice
Presidency[n 1] President
office
Left office Party
President
Term
1
Not formally
George April 30, March 4, affiliated
1 Washington John Adams
1789 1797 with any
[2][3][4][5]
party
2
Aaron Burr 4
Thomas
Jefferson March 4, March 4, Democratic-
3
[10][11] 1801 1809 Republican
[12][13] George
5
Clinton
George
Clinton[n 2]
March 4, 1801 -
April 20, 1812 6
vacant[n 3]
April 20, 1812 -
James March 4, 1813
Madison March 4, March 4, Democratic- Elbridge
4
[14][15] 1809 1817 Republican
[16][17] Gerry[n 2]
March 4, 1813 -
November 23,
1814 7
vacant [n 3]
November 23,
1814 - March 4,
1817
8
James
Monroe March 4, March 4, Democratic- Daniel D.
5
[18][19] 1817 1825 Republican Tompkins
[20][21]
9
John C.
Calhoun [n 4]
March 4, 1829 -
December 28,
Andrew 1832 11
Jackson March 4, March 4, [n 3]
7 Democratic vacant
[26][27] 1829 1837
[28][29] December 28,
1832 - March 4,
1833
Martin Van
12
Buren
William
Henry March 4, April 4,
9 Whig John Tyler 14
Harrison 1841 1841[n 2]
[34][35]
[36][37]
Andrew
Johnson
Andrew Democratic 20
Johnson April 15, March 4, National [n 3]
17 vacant
[66][67] 1865 1869
[68][69] Union[n 8]
Schuyler
21
Colfax
Henry
Ulysses S. Wilson[n 2]
March 4, March 4, March 4, 1869 -
18 Grant Republican November 22,
[70][71] 1869 1877
[72][73] 1875 22
[n 3]
vacant
November 22,
1875 - March 4,
1877
Rutherford
B. Hayes March 4, March 4, William A.
19 Republican 23
[74][75] 1877 1881 Wheeler
[76][77]
James A. September
Garfield March 4, 19, Chester A.
20 Republican
[78][79] 1881 [n 7] Arthur
[80][81] 1881
24
Chester A.
September March 4,
21 Arthur
19, 1881 1885
Republican vacant [n 3]
[82][83]
[84][85]
Thomas A.
Hendricks[n 2]
March 4, 1885 -
Grover November 25,
Cleveland March 4, March 4, 1885
22 Democratic 25
[86][87] 1885 1889
[88][89] vacant [n 3]
November 25,
1885 - March 4,
1889
Benjamin
Harrison March 4, March 4, Levi P.
23 Republican 26
[90][91] 1889 1893 Morton
[92][93]
Grover
Cleveland March 4, March 4, Adlai E.
24 (2nd term) Democratic 27
1893 1897 Stevenson I
[86][87]
[88][89]
Garret
Hobart[n 2]
March 4, 1897 -
November 21,
William September 1899 28
McKinley March 4,
25
[94][95] 1897
14, Republican vacant [n 3]
[96][97] 1901[n 7] November 21,
1899 - March 4,
1901
Theodore
Roosevelt
29
[n 3]
vacant
Theodore
Roosevelt September March 4,
26 Republican
[98][99] 14, 1901 1909
[100][101] Charles W.
30
Fairbanks
vacant [n 3]
October 30,
1912-March 4,
1913
32
Woodrow
Wilson March 4, March 4, Thomas R.
28 Democratic
[106][107] 1913 1921 Marshall
[108][109]
33
Warren G.
Harding March 4, August 2, Calvin
29 Republican
[110][111] 1921 1923[n 2] Coolidge
[112][113]
34
vacant [n 3]
Calvin
Coolidge August 2, March 4,
30 Republican
[114][115] 1923 1929
[116][117] Charles G.
35
Dawes
Herbert
Hoover March 4, March 4,
31 Republican Charles Curtis 36
[118][119] 1929 1933
[120][121]
Alben W.
41
Barkley
42
Dwight D.
Eisenhower January January Richard
34 Republican
[130][131] 20, 1953 20, 1961 Nixon
[132][133]
43
John F. November
Kennedy January 22, Lyndon B.
35 Democratic
[134][135] 20, 1961 [n 7] Johnson
[136][137] 1963
44
vacant [n 3]
Lyndon B.
Johnson November January
36 Democratic
[138][139] 22, 1963 20, 1969
[140][141] Hubert
45
Humphrey
Spiro 46
Agnew[n 4]
January 20, 1969
- October 10,
Richard 1973
Nixon January August 9,
37 Republican
[142][143] 20, 1969 1974[n 4] vacant [n 3]
[144][145] October 10,
1973 - December
6, 1973
Gerald Ford
47
vacant [n 3]
August 9, 1974 -
December 19,
1974
Gerald Ford August 9, January
38 [146][147] Republican Nelson
[148][149] 1974 20, 1977
Rockefeller
December 19,
1974 - January
20, 1977
49
Ronald
Reagan January January George H. W.
40 Republican
[154][155] 20, 1981 20, 1989 Bush
[156][157]
50
George H.
W. Bush January January
41 Republican Dan Quayle 51
[158][159] 20, 1989 20, 1993
[160][161]
52
Bill Clinton January January
42 [162][163] Democratic Al Gore
[164][165] 20, 1993 20, 2001
53
54
George W.
Bush January January
43 Republican Dick Cheney
[166][167] 20, 2001 20, 2009
[168][169]
55
Barack January
44 Obama Incumbent Democratic Joe Biden 56
20, 2009
[170][171][172]
1. ^ A presidency is defined as consecutive time in office served by a single person. For example, George Washington
served two consecutive terms and is counted as the first president (not the first and second). Gerald Ford assumed
the presidency after the resignation of Richard Nixon, serving out the remainder of what would have been Nixon's
second term. The fact that Ford was not voted into office does not affect the numbering, which makes him the 38th
president. In addition, under this numbering, Grover Cleveland is counted as having two separate presidencies,
having served two non-consecutive terms.
2. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Died in office of natural causes.
3. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r Prior to ratification of the Twenty-fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution
in 1967, there was no provision for filling a vacancy in the Vice Presidency. Richard Nixon was the first president
to fill such a vacancy under the provisions of the Twenty-fifth Amendment when he appointed Gerald Ford. Ford
later became the second president to fill a vice presidential vacancy when he appointed Nelson Rockefeller to
succeed him.
4. ^ a b c Resigned.
5. ^ Being the first vice president to assume the presidency, Tyler set a precedent that a vice president who assumes
the office of president becomes a fully functioning president who has his own presidency, as opposed to just a
caretaker president. His political opponents attempted to refer to him as "Acting President", but he refused to allow
that. The Twenty-fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution put Tyler's precedent into the Constitution.
6. ^ Former Democrat who ran for Vice President on Whig ticket. Clashed with Whig congressional leaders and was
expelled from the Whig party in 1841.
7. ^ a b c d Assassinated.
8. ^ a b Abraham Lincoln and Andrew Johnson were, respectively, a Republican and a Democrat who ran on the
National Union ticket in 1864.
9. ^ This term was shortened by 43 days due to the Twentieth Amendment to the United States Constitution going into
effect, moving inauguration day from March 4 to January 20.
Agency overview
Formed 4 November 1952
Preceding Armed Forces Security
agency Agency
Jurisdiction United States
Headquarters Fort Meade, Maryland
Employees Classified
Annual budget Classified
Agency Lieutenant General Keith B.
executives Alexander, USA, Director
1 AFSA directors
2 NSA directors
3 External links
4 References
The Armed Forces Security Agency was the predecessor to the National Security Agency and existed from 1949
to 1952.
John F. Kennedy
4 Lt Gen Gordon Blake USAF 19621965
Lyndon B. Johnson
Lyndon B. Johnson
5 LTG Marshall Carter USA 19651969
Richard Nixon
6 VADM Noel Gayler USA 19691972 Richard Nixon
7 Lt Gen Samuel C. Phillips USAF 19721973 Richard Nixon
Richard Nixon
8 Lt Gen Lew Allen USAF 19731977 Gerald Ford
Jimmy Carter
Jimmy Carter
9 VADM Bobby Ray Inman USN 19771981
Ronald Reagan
10 Lt Gen Lincoln Faurer USAF 19811985 Ronald Reagan
11 LTG William Odom USA 19851988 Ronald Reagan
Ronald Reagan
12 VADM William Studeman USN 19881992
George H. W. Bush
George H. W. Bush
13 VADM John M. McConnell USN 19921996
Bill Clinton
14 Lt Gen Kenneth Minihan USAF 19961999 Bill Clinton
Bill Clinton
15 Lt Gen Michael Hayden USAF 19992005
George W. Bush
George W. Bush
16 LTG Keith B. Alexander USA 2005present
Barack Obama
Michael Vincent Hayden, (born March 17, 1945 in Michael Vincent Hayden
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania) is a retired United States Air
Force four-star general and former Director of the
National Security Agency and Director of the Central
Intelligence Agency. From April 21, 2005May 26, 2006
he was the Principal Deputy Director of National
Intelligence, a position which once made him "the highest-
ranking military intelligence officer in the armed
forces."[1]
Michael Vincent Hayden was born on St. Patrick's Day in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania to an Irish-American couple,
Sadie and Harry Hayden, Jr. who worked as a welder for a Pennsylvania manufacturing company. He has a
younger brother, Harry III, and a sister, Margaret.
He graduated from Pittsburgh's North Catholic High School. While at Duquesne University he earned a B.A. in
history in 1967 and was commissioned as a second lieutenant. He then attended graduate school at Duquesne
for an M.A. in modern American History.
He is a graduate of the Air Force Reserve Officer Training Corps program. Hayden entered active military
service in 1969.
Hayden has served as commander of the Air Intelligence Agency and Director of the Joint Command and
Control Warfare Center, both headquartered at Lackland Air Force Base. He also has served in senior staff
positions in the Pentagon; Headquarters U.S. European Command, Stuttgart, Germany; the National Security
Council, Washington, D.C., and the U.S. Embassy in the then-People's Republic of Bulgaria. Prior to his current
assignment, the general served as deputy chief of staff for United Nations Command and U.S. Forces Korea,
Yongsan Garrison. He has also worked in intelligence in Guam.
He is married to Jeanine Carrier, and they have a daughter and two sons.
Then Commander, Hayden directed an agency of 16,000 charged with defending and exploiting the
"information domain."[4]
Hayden served as the Director of the National Security Agency and Chief of the Central Security Service at Fort
George G. Meade, Maryland from March 1999 to April 2005. As the Director of NSA and Chief of CSS, he was
responsible for a combat support agency of the Department of Defense with military and civilian personnel
stationed worldwide.[5]
Hayden and the NSA have a strategy to increase their use of American industry for domestic surveillance.[6][7]
[8][9]
In May 2006, USA Today reported that, under Hayden's leadership, the NSA created a domestic telephone call
database. During his nomination hearings, Hayden defended his actions to Senator Russ Feingold and others,
stating that he had relied upon legal advice that the White House order to build the database was supported by
Article Two of the United States Constitution executive branch powers (in which the President must "take care
that the laws be faithfully executed"), overriding legislative branch statutes forbidding warrantless surveillance
of domestic calls, which included the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA). Previously, this action would
have required a warrant from a FISA court. The stated purpose of the database was to eavesdrop on
international communications between persons within the U.S. and individuals and groups overseas in order to
locate terrorists [10][11][12]
Hayden is not the first active member of the military to be appointed to run the
Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). Those previously holding the position of
Director of Central Intelligence while simultaneously holding a military rank George W. Bush announces his
were: nomination of Hayden as the
next Director of the CIA as
Director of National
Rear Admiral Sidney Souers, a Navy officer, who was the first man to Intelligence John Negroponte
hold the position when the nascent organization was known as the looks on.
Central Intelligence Group; then-Lieutenant General (later General)
Hoyt S. Vandenberg, an Air Force officer, also Director of the CIG; Rear
Admiral Roscoe H. Hillenkoetter, a Navy officer who was just prior to his appointment was a Captain and
Commanding Officer of the USS Missouri and who was the first DCI of the CIA; General Walter Bedell
Smith, an Army officer
President Lyndon B. Johnson appointed Vice Admiral William Raborn, a Navy officer
President Jimmy Carter appointed Admiral Stansfield Turner, a Navy officer and a classmate of President
Carter at the United States Naval Academy
Military awards
Military badges
Dates of rank
1. ^ Biographies : GENERAL MICHAEL V. HAYDEN testimony that, "One senior executive confided that
(http://www.af.mil/information the data management needs we outlined to him were
/bios/bio.asp?bioID=5746) larger than any he had previously seen"
2. ^ Hayden announces his retirement from the Air 9. ^ Gen. Hayden Statement to Congress - see section
Force (https://www.cia.gov/news-information/press- 27 (http://intelligence.senate.gov/0210hrg/021017
releases-statements/cia-director-hayden-announces- /hayden.pdf)
airforce-retirement.html) , April 23, 2008 10. ^ Transcript of (http://www.globalsecurity.org/intell
3. ^ Chertoff Group (2009). General Michael V. /library/news/2006/intell-060123-dni01.htm) National
Hayden (http://www.chertoffgroup.com/general- Press Club interview of General Hayden regarding
michael-v-hayden.html) . Retrieved August 9, 2009. wiretaps
4. ^ [July 1997 Popular Science] Information Warriors 11. ^ "Hayden, Likely Choice for CIA Chief, Displayed
of the 609th (needs expanding)] Shaky Grip on 4th Amendment at Press Club"
5. ^ Hayden Faces Senate and CIA Hurdles if Named: 12. ^ Does Michael Hayden Understand the Fourth
General Has Streak Of Independence And Amendment? (http://www.orinkerr.com/2006/05
Nonconformity (http://www.washingtonpost.com /10/does-michael-hayden-understand-the-fourth-
/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/05 amendment/) May 10, 2006
/06/AR2006050601069.html?nav=rss_email 13. ^ Hayden named as Bush CIA choice
/components) May 7, 2006 (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/4750357.stm) 8
6. ^ Gen. Hayden Statement to Congress - see section May 2006
27 (http://intelligence.senate.gov/0210hrg/021017 14. ^ U.S. Senate: Legislation & Records Home > Votes
/hayden.pdf) ) > Roll Call Vote (http://www.senate.gov/legislative
7. ^ EFF class action suit (http://www.eff.org/legal /LIS/roll_call_lists
/cases/att/) /roll_call_vote_cfm.cfm?congress=109&session=2&
8. ^ [1] (http://www.globalsecurity.org/intell/library vote=00160) May 26, 2006
/news/2006/intell-060123-dni01.htm) Remarks By 15. ^ Bush says U.S. not 'trolling through personal lives'
General Michael V. Hayden: What American (http://www.cnn.com/2006/POLITICS/05/11
Intelligence & Especially The NSA Have Been /nsa.phonerecords/index.html) May 12, 2006
Doing To Defend The Nation] Jan 23, 2006, his
Government offices
Preceded by Director of the National Security Agency Succeeded by
Kenneth A. Minihan 19992005 Keith B. Alexander
Preceded by Principal Deputy Director of National
Succeeded by
Initial Principal Deputy Intelligence
Ronald L. Burgess, Jr. (acting)
Director 20052006
Director of the Central Intelligence
Preceded by Succeeded by
Agency
Porter Goss Leon Panetta
20062009
Retrieved from "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Hayden"
Categories: 1945 births | American Roman Catholics | Directors of the Central Intelligence Agency | Directors of
the National Security Agency | George W. Bush Administration personnel | Duquesne University alumni | Irish-
Americans in the military | Living people | Recipients of the Distinguished Service Medal (United States) |
Recipients of the Legion of Merit | Recipients of the Bronze Star Medal | United States Air Force generals |
United States Deputy Directors of National Intelligence
Out of office during the Clinton presidency, Cheney was 46th Vice President of the
chairman and CEO of Halliburton Company from 1995 to United States
2000. In office
January 20, 2001 January 20, 2009
Cheney joined the Bush administration in 2000, after President George W. Bush
Bush selected him as his running mate. After becoming Preceded by Al Gore
Vice President, Cheney remained a very public, influential Succeeded by Joe Biden
and controversial figure.
17th United States Secretary of Defense
In office
March 20, 1989 January 20, 1993
President George H. W. Bush
Deputy Donald J. Atwood, Jr.
1 Early life and education
Preceded by Frank Carlucci
2 Early White House appointments
3 Congress Succeeded by Les Aspin
3.1 Votes
3.2 House Minority Whip 15th United States House of Representatives
Minority Whip
4 Secretary of Defense
In office
4.1 Early tenure
January 3 March 20, 1989
4.2 Budgetary practices
Leader Robert H. Michel
4.3 Political climate and agenda
4.4 International situations Preceded by Trent Lott
4.4.1 Iraqi invasion of Kuwait Succeeded by Newt Gingrich
4.4.1.1 US and world reaction
In November 1962, at the age of 21, Cheney was convicted of driving while intoxicated (DWI). He was arrested
for DWI again the following year.[12] Cheney said that the arrests made him "think about where I was and
where I was headed. I was headed down a bad road if I continued on that course."[13]
In 1964, he married Lynne Vincent, his high school sweetheart, whom he had met at age 14.
When Cheney became eligible for the draft, during the Vietnam War, he applied for and received five draft
deferments.[14][15] In 1989, The Washington Post writer George C. Wilson interviewed Cheney as the next
Secretary of Defense; when asked about his deferments, Cheney reportedly said, "I had other priorities in the
'60s than military service."[16] Cheney testified during his confirmation hearings in 1989 that he received
deferments to finish a college career that lasted six years rather than four, owing to sub par academic
performance and the need to work to pay for his education. Initially, he was not called up because the Selective
Service System was only taking older men. When he became eligible for the draft, he applied for four
deferments in sequence. He applied for his fifth exemption on January 19, 1966, when his wife was about 10
weeks pregnant. He was granted 3-A status, the "hardship" exemption, which excluded men with children or
dependent parents. In January 1967, Cheney turned 26 and was no longer eligible for the draft.[17]
Cheney was Assistant to the President under Gerald Ford. When Rumsfeld was
named Secretary of Defense, Cheney became White House Chief of Staff, succeeding Rumsfeld.[12] He later
was campaign manager for Ford's 1976 presidential campaign as well.[20]
In 1978, Cheney was elected to represent Wyoming in the U.S. House of Representatives and succeed retiring
Congressman Teno Roncalio, having defeated his Democratic opponent, Bill Bailey. Cheney was reelected five
times, serving until 1989. He was Chairman of the Republican Policy Committee from 1981 to 1987 when he
was elected Chairman of the House Republican Conference. The following year, he was elected House Minority
Whip.[21]
Votes
Among the many votes he cast during his tenure in the House, he voted in 1979
with the majority against making Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.'s birthday a
national holiday, but then voted with the majority in 1983 when the measure
passed.[20] He voted against the creation of the U.S. Department of Education,
citing his concern over budget deficits and expansion of the federal
government, and claiming that the Department was an encroachment on states'
rights.[22] He voted against funding Head Start, but reversed his position in
Cheney meets with President
2000.[23] Ronald Reagan, 1983
In 1986, after President Ronald Reagan vetoed a bill to impose economic sanctions on South Africa for its
policy of apartheid, Cheney was one of 83 Representatives to vote against overriding Reagan's veto.[24] In later
years, he articulated his opposition to unilateral sanctions against many different countries, stating "they almost
never work"[25] and that in that case they might have ended up hurting the people instead.[26]
In 1986, Cheney, along with 145 Republicans and 31 Democrats, voted against a non-binding Congressional
resolution calling on the South African government to release Nelson Mandela from prison, after the Democrats
defeated proposed amendments that would have required Mandela to renounce violence sponsored by the
African National Congress (ANC) and requiring it to oust the communist faction from its leadership; the
resolution was defeated. Appearing on CNN, Cheney addressed criticism for this, saying he opposed the
resolution because the ANC "at the time was viewed as a terrorist organization and had a number of interests
that were fundamentally inimical to the United States."[27]
Cheney also served as ranking minority member of the Congressional committee investigating the Iran-Contra
affair.[12][28] He promoted Wyoming's petroleum and coal businesses as well,[29] and as a result, the federal
building in Casper, a regional center of the fossil fuel industry, is named the Dick Cheney Federal Building.[30]
In December 1988, the House Republicans elected Cheney as Minority Whip, the second spot under the
Minority Leader.[21] He served for two and a half months before he was appointed Secretary of Defense instead
of former Texas Senator John G. Tower, whose nomination had been rejected by the Senate in March 1989.[31]
Early tenure
Cheney worked closely with Pete Williams, Assistant Secretary of Defense for Public Secretary of Defense
Affairs, and Paul Wolfowitz, Under Secretary of Defense for Policy, from the Dick Cheney
beginning of his tenure. He focused primarily on external matters, and left most
internal Pentagon management to Deputy Secretary of Defense Donald J. Atwood,
Jr.[31]
Budgetary practices
programs as the B-2 stealth bomber, the V-22 Osprey tilt-wing helicopter, the Aegis destroyer and the MX
missile, totaling approximately $4.5 billion in light of changed world politics.[31] Cheney opposed the V-22
program, which Congress had already appropriated funds for, and initially refused to issue contracts for it before
relenting.[34] When the 1990 Budget came before Congress in the summer of 1989, it settled on a figure
between the Administration's request and the House Armed Services Committee's recommendation.[31]
In subsequent years under Cheney, the proposed and adopted budgets followed
patterns similar to that of 1990. Early in 1991, he unveiled a plan to reduce
military strength by the mid-1990s to 1.6 million, compared with 2.2 million
when he entered office. Cheney's 1993 defense budget was reduced from
1992, omitting programs that Congress had directed the Department of
Defense to buy weapons that it did not want, and omitting unrequested reserve
forces.[31]
Secretary of Defense Cheney
delivering a speech before the Over his four years as Secretary of Defense, Cheney downsized the military
launch of a new destroyer.
and his budgets showed negative real growth, despite pressures to acquire
weapon systems advocated by Congress. The Department of Defense's total
obligational authority in current dollars declined from $291 billion to $270 billion. Total military personnel
strength decreased by 19 percent, from about 2.2 million in 1989 to about 1.8 million in 1993.[31]
Cheney publicly expressed concern that nations such as Iraq, Iran, and North Korea, could acquire nuclear
components after the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991. The end of the Cold War, the fall of the Soviet
Union, and the disintegration of the Warsaw Pact obliged the first Bush Administration to reevaluate the North
Atlantic Treaty Organization's (NATO's) purpose and makeup. Cheney believed that NATO should remain the
foundation of European security relationships and that it would remain important to the United States in the long
term; he urged the alliance to lend more assistance to the new democracies in Eastern Europe.[31]
Cheney's views on NATO reflected his skepticism about prospects for peaceful social development in the
former Eastern Bloc countries, where he saw a high potential for political uncertainty and instability. He felt that
the Bush Administration was too optimistic in supporting Soviet Premier Mikhail Gorbachev and his successor,
Russian President Boris Yeltsin.[31] Cheney worked to maintain strong ties between the United States and its
European allies.[35]
Cheney persuaded the Saudi Arabian aristocracy to allow bases for US ground troops and war planes in the
nation. This was an important element of the success of the Gulf War, as well as a lightning-rod for Islamists
who opposed having non-Muslim armies near their holy sites.[36]
International situations
Using economic sanctions and political pressure, the United States mounted a campaign to drive Panamanian
ruler General Manuel Antonio Noriega from power after he fell from favour.[31] In May 1989, after Guillermo
Endara had been duly elected President of Panama, Noriega nullified the election outcome, drawing intensified
pressure. In October, Noriega suppressed a military coup, but in December, after soldiers of the Panamanian
army killed a US serviceman, the United States invasion of Panama began under Cheney's direction. The stated
reason for the invasion was to seize Noriega to face drug charges in the United States, protect US lives and
property, and restore Panamanian civil liberties.[37] Although the mission was controversial,[38] US forces
achieved control of Panama and Endara assumed the Presidency; Noriega was convicted and imprisoned on
racketeering and drug trafficking charges in April 1992.[39]
In 1991, the Somali Civil War drew the world's attention. In August 1992, the
United States began to provide humanitarian assistance, primarily food,
through a military airlift. At President Bush's direction, Cheney dispatched the
first of 26,000 US troops to Somalia as part of the Unified Task Force
(UNITAF), designed to provide security and food relief.[31] Cheney's
successors as Secretary of Defense, Les Aspin and William J. Perry, had to
contend with both the Bosnian and Somali issues.
Secretary of Defense Cheney
during a press conference on
Iraqi invasion of Kuwait the Gulf War
On August 1, 1990, Iraqi President Saddam Hussein sent invading forces into
neighboring Kuwait, a small petroleum-rich state long claimed by Iraq as part of its territory.[40] An estimated
140,000 Iraqi troops quickly took control of Kuwait City and moved on to the Saudi Arabia/Kuwait border.[31]
The United States had already begun to develop contingency plans for the defense of Saudi Arabia by the US
Central Command, headed by General Norman Schwarzkopf, because of its important petroleum reserves.
Shortly after the Iraqi invasion, Cheney made the first of several visits to Saudi
Cheney meets with Prince Arabia where King Fahd requested US military assistance. The United Nations
Sultan, Minister of Defence and took action as well, passing a series of resolutions condemning Iraq's invasion
Aviation in Saudi Arabia to of Kuwait; the UN Security Council authorized "all means necessary" to eject
discuss how to handle the
invasion of Kuwait Iraq from Kuwait, and demanded that the country withdraw its forces by
January 15, 1991.[40] By then, the United States had a force of about 500,000
stationed in Saudi Arabia and the Persian Gulf. Other nations, including
Britain, Canada, France, Italy, Syria, and Egypt, contributed troops, and other allies, most notably Germany and
Japan, agreed to provide financial support for the coalition effort, named Operation Desert Shield.[31]
On January 12, 1991, both Houses of Congress authorized Bush to use military force to secure Iraq's compliance
with UN resolutions on Kuwait.[40]
Military action
The first phase of Operation Desert Storm, which began on January 17, 1991, was an air offensive to secure air
superiority and attack Iraq's forces, targeting key Iraqi command and control centers, including Baghdad and
Basra. Cheney turned most other Department of Defense matters over to Deputy Secretary Atwood and briefed
Congress during the air and ground phases of the war.[31] He flew with Powell to the region (specifically
Riyadh) to review and finalize the ground war plans.[40]
After an air offensive of more than five weeks, the UN coalition launched the ground war on February 24.
Within 100 hours, Iraqi forces had been routed from Kuwait and Schwarzkopf reported that the basic objective
expelling Iraqi forces from Kuwait had been met on February 27.[41] After consultation with Cheney and
other members of his national security team, Bush declared a suspension of hostilities.[40]
Aftermath
A total of 147 U.S. military personnel died in combat, and another 236 died as a result of accidents or other
causes.[31][41] Iraq agreed to a formal truce on March 3, and a permanent cease-fire on April 6.[31] There was
subsequent debate about whether the UN coalition should have driven as far as Baghdad to oust Saddam
Hussein from power. Bush agreed that the decision to end the ground war when they did was correct, but the
debate persisted as Hussein remained in power and rebuilt his military forces.[31] Arguably the most significant
debate concerned whether U.S. and coalition forces had left Iraq too soon.[42][43] In an April 15, 1994 interview
with C-SPAN, Cheney explained that occupying and attempting to take over the country would have been a
"bad idea" and would have led to a "quagmire."[44][45]
Cheney regarded the Gulf War as an example of the kind of regional problem the United States was likely to
continue to face in the future.[46]
We're always going to have to be involved [in the Middle East]. Maybe it's part of our national character,
you know we like to have these problems nice and neatly wrapped up, put a ribbon around it. You deploy a
force, you win the war and the problem goes away and it doesn't work that way in the Middle East it never
has and isn't likely to in my lifetime.
Between 1987 and 1989, during his last term in Congress, Cheney was a director of the Council on Foreign
Relations foreign policy organization.[47]
With the new Democratic administration under President Bill Clinton in January 1993, Cheney left the
Department of Defense and joined the American Enterprise Institute. He also served a second term as a Council
on Foreign Relations director from 1993 to 1995.[47] From 1995 until 2000, he served as Chairman of the Board
and Chief Executive Officer of Halliburton, a Fortune 500 company and market leader in the energy sector.
Cheney's record as CEO was subject to some dispute among Wall Street analysts; a 1998 merger between
Halliburton and Dresser Industries attracted the criticism of some Dresser executives for Halliburton's lack of
accounting transparency.[48] During Cheney's tenure, Halliburton changed its accounting practices regarding
revenue realization of disputed costs on major construction projects.[49] Cheney resigned as CEO of Halliburton
on July 25, 2000. As vice president, he argued that this step removed any conflict of interest. Cheney's net
worth, estimated to be between $30 million and $100 million, is largely derived from his post at Halliburton, as
well as the Cheneys' gross income of nearly $8.82 million.[50]
In 1997, along with Donald Rumsfeld, William Kristol and others, Cheney founded the Project for the New
American Century, a neoconservative think tank whose self-stated goal is to "promote American global
leadership."[51] He was also part of the board of advisors of the Jewish Institute for National Security Affairs
(JINSA) before becoming vice president.[36]
2000 election
In early 2000, while serving as the CEO of Halliburton, Cheney headed George
W. Bush's vice-presidential search committee. On July 25, after reviewing
Cheney's findings, Bush surprised some pundits by asking Cheney himself to
join the Republican ticket.[12] Halliburton reportedly reached agreement on
July 20 to allow Cheney to retire, with a package estimated at $20 million.[52]
While the election was undecided, the Bush-Cheney team was not eligible for public funding to plan a transition
to a new administration. So, Cheney opened a privately funded transition office in Washington. This office
worked to identify candidates for all important positions in the cabinet.[54] According to Craig Unger, Cheney
advocated Donald Rumsfeld for the post of Secretary of Defense to counter the influence of Colin Powell at the
State Department, and tried unsuccessfully to have Paul Wolfowitz named to replace George Tenet as director
of the Central Intelligence Agency.[55]
First term
Following the September 11, 2001 attacks, Cheney remained physically apart from Bush for security reasons.
For a period, Cheney stayed at an undisclosed location, out of public view.[56]
On the morning of June 29, 2002, Cheney served as Acting President of the United States under the terms of the
25th Amendment to the Constitution, while Bush was undergoing a colonoscopy. Cheney acted as President
from 11:09 UTC that day until Bush resumed the powers of the presidency at 13:24 UTC.[57][58]
Iraq War
cynical and pernicious falsehoods to gain political advantage while U.S. soldiers died in Iraq. In response,
Senator John Kerry asserted, It is hard to name a government official with less credibility on Iraq [than
Cheney]."[64]
Second term
Bush and Cheney were re-elected in the 2004 presidential election, running
against John Kerry and his running mate, John Edwards. During the election,
the pregnancy of his daughter Mary and her sexual orientation as a lesbian
became a source of public attention for Cheney in light of the same-sex
marriage debate.[65] Cheney has stated that he is in favor of gay marriages but
that each individual state should decide whether to permit it.[66]
President of Lithuania Valdas
Cheney's former chief legal counsel, David Addington,[67] became his chief of Adamkus (right) meets with
staff and remained in that office until Cheney's departure from office. John P. Vice President Cheney in
Vilnius, May 2006
Hannah served as Vice President Cheney's national security adviser.[68] Until
his resignation in 2005, I. Lewis "Scooter" Libby, Jr. served in both roles.[69]
On the morning of July 21, 2007, Cheney once again served as Acting President for about two and a half hours.
Bush transferred the power of the presidency prior to undergoing a medical procedure, requiring sedation, and
later resumed his powers and duties that same day.[70]
After his term began in 2001, Cheney was occasionally asked if he was interested in the Republican nomination
for the 2008 elections. However, he always maintained that he wished to retire upon the expiration of his term,
and indeed he did not run in the 2008 presidential primaries, the GOP nominating Arizona Senator John McCain
instead.[71]
Disclosure of documents
of 1978 and cannot be destroyed, taken or withheld from the public without proper review.[78][79][80]
On October 18, 2005, The Washington Post reported that the vice president's
office was central to the investigation of the Valerie Plame CIA leak scandal,
for Cheney's former chief of staff, Lewis "Scooter" Libby, was one of the
figures under investigation.[81] Following an indictment, Libby resigned his
positions as Cheney's chief of staff and assistant on national security affairs.
On September 8, 2006, Richard Armitage, former Deputy Secretary of State, Handwritten note above Joe
Wilson's editorial by Vice
publicly announced that he was the source of the revelation of Plame's status. President Cheney referring to
Armitage said he was not a part of a conspiracy to reveal Plame's identity and the covert agent before the leak
did not know whether one existed.[82] took place.
In February 2006, The National Journal reported that Libby had stated before a grand jury that his superiors,
including Cheney, had authorized him to disclose classified information to the press regarding Iraq's weapons
intelligence.[83]
On March 6, 2007, Libby was convicted on four felony counts for obstruction of justice, perjury, and making
false statements to federal investigators.[84]
Hunting incident
On February 11, 2006, Cheney accidentally[85] shot Harry Whittington, a 78-year-old Texas attorney, in the
face, neck, and upper torso with birdshot pellets when he turned to shoot a quail while hunting on a southern
Texas ranch.[86]
Whittington suffered a mild heart attack, and atrial fibrillation due to a pellet that embedded in the outer layers
of his heart. The Kenedy County Sheriff's office cleared Cheney of any criminal wrongdoing in the matter, and
in an interview with Fox News, Cheney accepted full responsibility for the incident.[87] Whittington was
discharged from the hospital on February 17, 2006. Later, Whittington apologized to the vice-president for the
trouble the event had caused him and his family. Cheney reiterated that it was an honest accident.[88]
Assassination attempt
On February 27, 2007, at about 10 a.m., a suicide bomber killed 23 people and
wounded 20 more outside Bagram Air Base in Afghanistan during a visit by
Cheney. Qari Yousef Ahmadi, a Taliban spokesman, claimed responsibility for
the attack and said Cheney was its intended target. The Taliban claimed that
Osama Bin Laden supervised the operation.[89] The bomb went off outside the
front gate, however, while Cheney was inside the base and half a mile away.
Cheney speaks to the press
He reported hearing the blast, saying "I heard a loud boom...The Secret Service flanked by fellow Republicans
came in and told me there had been an attack on the main gate."[90] The Mitch McConnell (left) and
purpose of Cheney's visit to the region had been to press Pakistan for a united Trent Lott, April 2007
front against the Taliban.[91]
Policy formulation
Cheney has been characterised as the most powerful and influential Vice
President in history.[92][93] Both supporters and detractors of Cheney regard
him as a shrewd and knowledgeable politician who knows the functions and
intricacies of the federal government. A sign of Cheney's active policy-making
role was then-House Speaker Dennis Hastert's provision of an office near the
House floor for Cheney[94] in addition to his office in the West Wing,[95] his
ceremonial office in the Old Executive Office Building,[96] and his Senate
Pope Benedict XVI, Vice
offices (one in the Dirksen Senate Office Building and another off the floor of President Dick Cheney and
the Senate).[94][97] Mrs. Lynne Cheney at a
farewell ceremony for the Pope
Cheney has actively promoted an expansion of the powers of the presidency, at John F. Kennedy
International Airport in New
saying that the Bush administrations challenges to the laws which Congress
York.
passed after Vietnam and Watergate to contain and oversee the executive
branch the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, the Presidential Records
Act, the Freedom of Information Act and the War Powers Resolution are, in Cheney's words, a restoration,
if you will, of the power and authority of the president.[98][99]
In June 2008, Cheney allegedly attempted to block efforts by Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice to strike a
controversial US compromise deal with North Korea over the communist state's nuclear program.[105]
In July 2008, a former Environmental Protection Agency official stated publicly that Cheney's office had pushed
significantly for large-scale deletions from a Centers for Disease Control and Prevention report on the health
effects of global warming "fearing the presentation by a leading health official might make it harder to avoid
regulating greenhouse gases."[106] In October, when the report appeared with six pages cut from the testimony,
The White House stated that the changes were made due to concerns regarding the accuracy of the science.
However, according to the former senior adviser on climate change to Environmental Protection Agency
Administrator Stephen Johnson, Cheney's office was directly responsible for nearly half of the original testimony
being deleted.[106]
Cheney and former United States Attorney General Alberto Gonzales were indicted by a Texas grand jury for
conflict of interest in his role as Vice President and "at least misdemeanor assaults" via his investments in
private company that runs detention centers in Texas.[107] The grand jury indictment was related to Cheney's
financial involvement with Vanguard Group, a company that contracts with the United States Government to
operate Federal prisons and detention centers.[108] The charges specifically related to prisoner abuse in those
centers.[109] The prosecutor, Juan Guerra, also brought indictments against several special prosecutors and
judges that were involved in investigating his office for misconduct over the past several years. Guerra did not
appear in court.[110][111] The indictments were dismissed by the judge as invalid on December 1, 2008.[112]
After leaving office, Cheney purchased a home in McLean, Virginia (Washington suburbs), and maintains
homes in Wyoming and on Maryland's Eastern Shore.[113]
Said to be writing a book,[114] his memoirs are likely to be published in spring 2011. It is thought the book will
charge that in his second term George W. Bush ignored Cheney's advice and, in a word, went soft. According to
a front page article in The Washington Post, Cheney "felt Bush was drifting away from him. Cheney said Bush
was shackled by public reaction and the criticism he took. The Cheney doctrine was cast iron strength at all
times - never apologise, never explain while Bush moved towards a conciliatory approach." Personal factors
also contributed to the growing distance between the two men. Cheney was dismayed when Mr. Bush forced his
old friend and mentor Donald Rumsfeld out of the Pentagon in 2006. Cheney reportedly further accused Bush
of abandoning Lewis "Scooter" Libby, likening his action to leaving a soldier on the battlefield. [115] Cheney
maintained a visible public profile after leaving office,[116] being especially critical of Obama administration
policies on national security.[117][118]
In May 2009, Cheney spoke of his support for same-sex marriage, becoming one of the most prominent
Republican politicians to do so. Speaking to the National Press Club, Cheney stated: "People ought to be free to
enter into any kind of union they wish, any kind of arrangement they wish. I do believe, historically, the way
marriage has been regulated is at a state level. It's always been a state issue, and I think that's the way it ought to
be handled today."[119]
Although, by custom, a former Vice President receives unofficial six month protection from the United States
Secret Service, President Obama reportedly extended the protection period for Cheney[120].
On 11 July, 2009 CIA Director Leon E. Panetta told the Senate and House intelligence committees that the CIA
withheld information about a secret counter-terrorism program from Congress for eight years on direct orders
from Dick Cheney. Intelligence and Congressional officials have said the unidentified program did not involve
the CIA interrogation program and did not involve domestic intelligence activities. They have said the program
was started by the counter-terrorism center at the CIA shortly after the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, but never
became fully operational, involving planning and some training that took place off and on from 2001 until this
year.[121] Wall Street Journal reported, citing former intelligence officials familiar with the matter, that the
program was an attempt to carry out a 2001 presidential authorization to capture or kill al Qaeda operatives.[122]
Cheney's long histories of cardiovascular disease and periodic need for urgent health care raised questions of
whether he was medically fit to serve in public office.[123] Once a heavy smoker, Cheney sustained the first of
four heart attacks in 1978, at age 37. Subsequent attacks in 1984, 1988, and 2000[124] have resulted in moderate
contractile dysfunction of his left ventricle. He underwent four-vessel coronary artery bypass grafting in 1988,
coronary artery stenting in November 1994, and urgent coronary balloon angioplasty in December 1994.[125]
As vice president, Cheney was cared for by the White House Medical Unit (WHMU).[126] Staff from the
WHMG accompany the president and the vice president while either is traveling, and make advance contact
with local emergency medical services to ensure that urgent care is available immediately should it be necessary.
He has undergone a number of procedures during his tenure.
In 2001, an examination of Cheney with a Holter monitor revealed the presence of brief episodes of
(asymptomatic) ectopy. An electrophysiologic study was performed, at which Cheney was found to have an
unsteady and potentially fatal heartbeat.[127] An implantable cardioverter-defibrillator (ICD) was therefore
implanted in his left upper anterior chest.[128]
On September 24, 2005, Cheney underwent a six-hour endo-vascular procedure to repair popliteal artery
Advanced Media Group Page 620 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 639
Page
of 2413
640 of 2593
13 of 25 9/23/2009 3:59 AM
Dick Cheney - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dick_Cheney
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
aneurysms bilaterally, a catheter treatment technique used in the artery behind each knee.[125] The condition
was discovered at a regular physical in July, and was not life-threatening.[127] Cheney was hospitalized for tests
after experiencing shortness of breath five months later. In late April 2006, an ultrasound revealed that the clot
was smaller.[125]
On March 5, 2007, Cheney was treated for deep-vein thrombosis in his left leg at George Washington University
Hospital after experiencing pain in his left calf.[125] Doctors prescribed blood-thinning medication and allowed
him to return to work.[129]
CBS News reported that during the morning of November 26, 2007, Cheney was diagnosed with atrial
fibrillation and underwent treatment that afternoon.[125]
On July 12, 2008 Cheney underwent a cardiological exam, and doctors reported that his heartbeat was normal
for a 67-year-old man with a history of heart problems. As part of his annual checkup, he was administered an
electrocardiogram and radiological imaging of the stents placed in the arteries behind his knees in 2005. Doctors
said that Cheney had not experienced any recurrence of atrial fibrillation and that his special pacemaker had
neither detected nor treated any arrhythmia.[130]
On October 15, 2008, Cheney returned to the hospital briefly to treat a minor irregularity.[131]
On January 19, 2009, Cheney strained his back "while moving boxes into his new house". As a consequence, he
was in a wheelchair for two days, including his attendance at the 2009 United States presidential
inauguration.[132]
In the beginning of the Bush administration, Cheney's public opinion polls were more favorable than
unfavorable. In the wake of the September 11, 2001 attacks, both Bush's and Cheney's approval ratings rose,
with Cheney reaching 63 percent[133] and the president with 90 percent.[134] The polling numbers for both men
declined after the September 11 attacks, however.[133][135] Cheney's Gallup poll figures are consistent with
those from other polls:[133][136]
In April 2007 Cheney was awarded an honorary doctorate of public service from Brigham Young University,
where he delivered the commencement address.[137] His selection as graduate commencement speaker was
controversial. The college board of trustees issued a statement explaining that the invitation should be viewed
"as one extended to someone holding the high office of vice president of the United States rather than to a
partisan political figure."[138] BYU permitted a protest to occur so long as it did not "make personal attacks
against Cheney, attack (the) BYU administration, the church or the First Presidency."[139]
Cheney is a member of the United Methodist Church,[140] and was "the first Methodist Vice President to serve
under a Methodist president".[141]
His wife, Lynne Cheney, was Chair of the National Endowment for the Humanities from 1986 to 1996. She is
now a public speaker, author, and a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. The couple have two
children, Elizabeth and Mary, and six grandchildren. Elizabeth, his eldest daughter, is married to Philip J. Perry,
General Counsel of the Department of Homeland Security. Mary Cheney, a former employee of the Colorado
Rockies baseball team and Coors Brewing Company and campaign aide to the Bush re-election campaign,
currently lives in Great Falls, Virginia with her longtime partner Heather Poe.[142]
(PDF). North Hall News "Murtha and the Mudslingers 20. ^ a b "People in the News: Dick
(Madison, Wisconsin: (http://www.washingtonpost.co Cheney (http://www.chiff.com
University of Wisconsin- m/wp-dyn/content/article /pop-culture/news-people/dick-
Madison): 4. Fall 2006. /2006/01 cheney.htm) ". Chiff.com.
http://polisci.wisc.edu /16/AR2006011600913.html) ". http://www.chiff.com
/documents The Washington Post /pop-culture/news-people/dick-
/AlumniNewsletterFall06.pdf. (Washington, DC). cheney.htm. Retrieved
Retrieved 2008-01-01. http://www.washingtonpost.com 2008-01-01.
12. ^ a b c d e Lindsay G. /wp-dyn/content/article/2006/01 21. ^ a b c "The Board of Regents
McCollough (Producer), Barton /16/AR2006011600913.html. (http://www.si.edu/about/regents
Gellman (Narrator). The Life Retrieved 2008-01-01. /members.htm) ". Smithsonian
and Career of Dick Cheney 17. ^ "Cheney's Five Draft Institution. http://www.si.edu
(http://www.washingtonpost.co Deferments During the Vietnam /about/regents/members.htm.
m/wp-srv/photo/gallery/070622 Era Emerge as a Campaign Retrieved 2008-01-01.
/GAL-07Jun22-78887/) . Issue (http://www.nytimes.com 22. ^ "Dick Cheney on Education
[Narrated slideshow]. The /2004/05/01/politics/campaign (http://www.issues2000.org
Washington Post. /01CHEN.html?ex=1398830400 /2004/Dick_Cheney_Education.
http://www.washingtonpost.com &en=1c0259e620183dd6& htm) ". OntheIssues.com.
/wp-srv/photo/gallery/070622 ei=5007&partner=USERLAND) http://www.issues2000.org
/GAL-07Jun22-78887/. ". The New York Times. /2004/Dick_Cheney_Education.
Retrieved 2007-12-18. 2004-05-01. htm. Retrieved 2007-12-12.
13. ^ Lemann, Nicholas (2001). http://www.nytimes.com 23. ^ McIntyre, Robert S.
"The Quiet Man /2004/05/01/politics/campaign (2000-07-28). "Dick Cheney,
(http://web.archive.org /01CHEN.html?ex=1398830400 Fiscal Conservative?
/web/20040918102730/http: &en=1c0259e620183dd6& (http://www.commondreams.org
//www.newyorker.com/archive ei=5007&partner=USERLAND. /views/072800-101.htm) ". The
/content/?040906fr_archive06) Retrieved 2007-12-11. New York Times.
". The New Yorker (New 18. ^ "Hersh on secret White House http://www.commondreams.org
York). 2001-05-07. plot to bomb Iran /views/072800-101.htm.
http://web.archive.org (http://www.rollingstone.com Retrieved 2007-12-12.
/web/20040918102730/http: /politics/story/14010621 24. ^ Booker, Salih (2001). "The
//www.newyorker.com/archive /national_affairs_cheneys_neme Coming Apathy: Africa Policy
/content/?040906fr_archive06. sis_seymour_hersh_reveals_whi Under a Bush Administration
Retrieved 2006-08-02. te_houses_secret_plan_to_bom (http://www.fpif.org
14. ^ Noah, Timothy (2004). b_iran/print) ". Rolling Stone. /commentary/0012africa.html) ".
"Elizabeth Cheney, Deferment 2007-04-02. http://www.fpif.org/commentary
Baby - How Dick Cheney http://www.rollingstone.com /0012africa.html. Retrieved
dodged the Vietnam draft. /politics/story/14010621 2007-12-18.
(http://www.slate.com /national_affairs_cheneys_neme 25. ^ "Defending Liberty in a
/id/2097365/) ". Slate sis_seymour_hersh_reveals_whi Global Economy
(Washington, D.C.). te_houses_secret_plan_to_bom (http://www.cato.org/speeches
2004-03-18. b_iran/print. Retrieved /sp-dc062398.html) ". Cato
http://www.slate.com 2007-12-12. Institute. 1998-06-23.
/id/2097365/. Retrieved 19. ^ Lowell Bergman and Marlena http://www.cato.org/speeches
2009-05-25. Telvick (2007-02-13). "Dick /sp-dc062398.html. Retrieved
15. ^ Nichols, John (2004). "Dick's Cheney's Memos from 30 Years 2007-12-12.
Vietnam Hypocrisy Ago (http://www.pbs.org 26. ^ "Cheney Slips in Explaining
(http://www.thenation.com /wgbh/pages/frontline/newswar A Vote on Freeing Mandela
/doc/20040517/nichols) ". The /preview/documents.html) ". (http://query.nytimes.com
Nation (New York, NY). Public Broadcasting System /gst/fullpage.html?res=9C07E1
2004-04-29. FRONTLINE: News War. DB173DF93BA15754C0A9669
http://www.thenation.com http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages C8B63) ". The New York
/doc/20040517/nichols. /frontline/newswar/preview Times. 2000-07-28.
Retrieved 2009-05-25. /documents.html. Retrieved http://query.nytimes.com
16. ^ Dionne, E.J. Jr. (2006-01-17). 2008-02-13. /gst/fullpage.html?res=9C07E1
Advanced Media Group Page 623 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 642
Page
of 2413
643 of 2593
16 of 25 9/23/2009 3:59 AM
Dick Cheney - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dick_Cheney
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
(http://transcripts.cnn.com 64. ^ "Cheney calls war critics 71. ^ Barnes, Fred (2005-03-07).
/TRANSCRIPTS/0206/29 "opportunists" "President Cheney?
/bn.02.html) ". (http://www.msnbc.msn.com (http://www.weeklystandard.co
http://transcripts.cnn.com /id/10078197/) ". MSNBC. m/Content/Public/Articles
/TRANSCRIPTS/0206/29 2005-11-17. /000/000/005/295zkwpw.asp) ".
/bn.02.html. Retrieved http://www.msnbc.msn.com 10. The Weekly Standard.
2006-06-04. /id/10078197/. Retrieved http://www.weeklystandard.com
59. ^ "Cheney asserts Iraq-al 2007-12-11. /Content/Public/Articles
Qaeda link 65. ^ Cheney describes same-sex /000/000/005/295zkwpw.asp.
(http://news.bbc.co.uk marriage as state issue Retrieved 2007-12-18.
/2/hi/americas/6533367.stm) ". (http://www.cnn.com 72. ^ "Dick Cheney on Energy &
BBC. 2007-04-06. /2004/ALLPOLITICS/08/24 Oil: Member of Bushs National
http://news.bbc.co.uk /cheney.samesex/) . CNN. 2004 Energy Policy Development
/2/hi/americas/6533367.stm. (published 2004-08-25). Group
Retrieved 2007-12-11. http://www.cnn.com (http://www.issues2000.org
60. ^ "Cheney Reasserts al-Qaida- /2004/ALLPOLITICS/08/24 /2004/Dick_Cheney_Energy_+_
Saddam Link (http://sfgate.com /cheney.samesex/. Retrieved Oil.htm) ". National Energy
/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/n/a/2007 2006-08-02. Policy Report. 2001-05-02.
/04/05/national 66. ^ http://news.yahoo.com http://www.issues2000.org
/w222503D69.DTL& /s/ap/20090601/ap_on_re_us /2004/Dick_Cheney_Energy_+_
type=politics) ". Hearst /us_cheney Oil.htm. Retrieved 2008-01-02.
Communications. 2007-04-06. 67. ^ "FRONTLINE: Cheney's Law 73. ^ "Judicial Watch, Inc. vs.
http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin (http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages National Energy Policy
/article.cgi?f=/n/a/2007/04/05 /frontline/cheney/etc/script.html) Development Group
/national/w222503D69.DTL& ". Public Broadcasting System. (http://www.judicialwatch.org
type=politics. 2007-10-16. http://www.pbs.org /printer_1270.shtml) ". Judicial
61. ^ Mark Mazzetti and Scott /wgbh/pages/frontline/cheney Watch, Inc. 2004.
Shane (2008-06-06). "Bush /etc/script.html. Retrieved http://www.judicialwatch.org
Overstated Iraq Evidence, 2008-02-13. /printer_1270.shtml. Retrieved
Senators Report 68. ^ Dreyfuss, Robert 2007-12-18.
(http://www.nytimes.com (2006-04-17). "Vice Squad 74. ^ Michael Isikoff (2007-12-24).
/2008/06/06/world/middleeast (http://www.prospect.org "Challenging Cheney
/06intel.html?pagewanted=print) /cs/articles?articleId=11423) ". (http://www.newsweek.com
". The New York Times. The American Prospect. /id/81883/output/print) ".
http://www.nytimes.com http://www.prospect.org Newsweek.
/2008/06/06/world/middleeast /cs/articles?articleId=11423. http://www.newsweek.com
/06intel.html?pagewanted=print. Retrieved 2008-02-29. /id/81883/output/print.
Retrieved 2008-06-17. 69. ^ Jehl, Douglas (2005-11-05). Retrieved 2008-02-25.
62. ^ "Frontline: The Dark Side "In Cheney's New Chief, a 75. ^ Ragavan, Chitra
(http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages Bureaucratic Master (2007-02-08). "Cheney Tangles
/frontline/darkside/view/) ". (http://www.nytimes.com With Agency on Secrecy
Public Broadcasting System. /2005/11/02/politics (http://www.usnews.com
2006-06-20. http://www.pbs.org /02aide.html?pagewanted=print) /usnews/news/articles/070208
/wgbh/pages/frontline/darkside ". The New York Times. /8cheney.htm?s_cid=rss:site1)
/view/. Retrieved 2008-02-06. http://www.nytimes.com ". U.S. News & World Report.
63. ^ "Cheney: Iraq will be /2005/11/02/politics http://www.usnews.com/usnews
'enormous success story' /02aide.html?pagewanted=print. /news/articles/070208
(http://www.cnn.com 70. ^ "Bush has 5 polyps removed /8cheney.htm?s_cid=rss:site1.
/2005/POLITICS/06/23 during colonoscopy 76. ^ Baker, Peter (2007-06-22).
/cheney.interview/) ". CNN. (http://www.msnbc.msn.com "Cheney Defiant on Classified
2005-06-25. /id/19872260/) ". MSNBC. Material
http://www.cnn.com 2007-07-21. (http://www.washingtonpost.co
/2005/POLITICS/06/23 http://www.msnbc.msn.com m/wp-dyn/content/article
/cheney.interview/. Retrieved /id/19872260/. Retrieved /2007/06
2007-12-11. 2007-12-18. /22/AR2007062201322.html?hp
Works by
Professional Military Education: An Asset for Peace and Progress : A Report of the Crisis Study Group
on Professional Military Education (Csis Report) 1997. ISBN 0-89206-297-5
Kings of the Hill: How Nine Powerful Men Changed the Course of American History 1996. ISBN
0-8264-0230-5
Works about
Andrews, Elaine. Dick Cheney: A Life Of Public Service. Millbrook Press, 2001. ISBN 0-7613-2306-6
Gellman, Barton. Angler: The Cheney Vice Presidency. Penguin Press, 2008. ISBN 9781594201868
Hayes, Stephen. Cheney: The Untold Story of America's Most Powerful and Controversial Vice
President. HarperCollins, 2007. ISBN 0060723467
Mann, James. Rise of the Vulcans: The History of Bush's War Cabinet. Viking, 2004. ISBN
0-670-03299-9
Nichols, John. Dick: The Man Who is President. New Press, 2004. ISBN 1-56584-840-3
Political offices
Preceded by White House Chief of Staff Succeeded by
Donald Rumsfeld 1975 1977 Hamilton Jordan
The Office of United States Director of Central Intelligence (DCI) was established by U.S. President Harry
Truman on January 23, 1946 with Admiral Sidney Souers occupying the position. The DCI was coordinating
intelligence activities among and between the various United States intelligence agencies, also called the
American Intelligence Community.
Until April 2005, the DCI also served as de-facto Director of the Central Intelligence Agency and was often
referred to colloquially as the "CIA Director." After the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks on the United
States and the subsequent investigation by the 9/11 Commission, a movement grew to re-organize the
Intelligence Community. That movement prompted the creation, on April 21, 2005, of the Office of the Director
of National Intelligence (DNI), in whose purview was the job portfolio that had been performed previously by
the Director of Central Intelligence. The latter position then ceased to exist.
Porter J. Goss was the 19th and final CIA Director to serve in the position of DCI.
Director Tenure
RADM Sidney Souers, USN January 23, 1946June 10, 1946
LTG Hoyt Vandenberg, USA June 10, 1946May 1, 1947
RADM Roscoe H. Hillenkoetter, USN May 1, 1947October 7, 1950
GEN Walter Bedell Smith, USA October 7, 1950February 9, 1953
Allen W. Dulles February 26, 1953November 29, 1961
John McCone November 29, 1961April 28, 1965
VADM William Raborn, USN (Ret.) April 28, 1965June 30, 1966
Richard M. Helms June 30, 1966February 2, 1973
James R. Schlesinger February 2, 1973July 2, 1973
William E. Colby September 4, 1973January 30, 1976
George H. W. Bush January 30, 1976January 20, 1977
ADM Stansfield Turner, USN March 9, 1977January 20, 1981
William J. Casey January 28, 1981January 29, 1987
William H. Webster May 26, 1987August 31, 1991
Robert M. Gates November 6, 1991January 20, 1993
R. James Woolsey February 5, 1993January 10, 1995
John M. Deutch May 10, 1995December 15, 1996
George J. Tenet July 11, 1997July 11, 2004
Porter J. Goss September 24, 2004April 21, 2005
Position replaced by Director of the Central Intelligence Agency and Director of National Intelligence.
During the first years of its existence, other branches of government did not exercise much control over the
Central Intelligence Agency; justified by the desire to match and defeat Soviet actions throughout the globe, a
task many believed could be accomplished only through an approach similar to the Soviet intelligence agencies,
under names including NKVD, MVD, NKGB, MGB, and KGB. Those Soviet organizations also had domestic
responsibilities.
The rapid expansion of the CIA, and a developed sense of independence under the Director of Central
Intelligence (DCI) Allen Dulles added to US intelligence not having a great deal of independent review. After
the Bay of Pigs Invasion in 1961, President John F. Kennedy dismissed Dulles. Dulles was an OSS veteran. His
autobiography,[2] is more noteworthy as a way of understanding the mindset of key people in the field than it is
a detailed description of the CIA.
Kennedy exercised greater supervision, and appointed a Republican with a general engineering background.
McCone, despite a lack of intelligence background, is often considered one of the most competent DCIs and
excellent managers. He directed the IC during the Cuban Missile Crisis. The agency stepped up its activity in
Southeast Asia under President Lyndon B. Johnson. McCone resigned from his position of DCI in April 1965,
believing himself unappreciated by Johnson. McCone's final policy memorandum to Johnson argued that
expansion of the war in Vietnam would arouse national and world discontent over the war before it brought
down the North Vietnamese regime.
Raborn, a distinguished naval officer who directed the creation of ballistic missile submarines, had a short and
unhappy tenure as DCI. His background included no foreign relations experience, and intelligence only as it
pertained to naval operations. CIA historians said "Raborn did not 'take' to the DCI job".[3] Raborn resigned on
June 30, 1966, having served for only fourteen months as DCI; he was replaced by his deputy Richard Helms.
Helms was an OSS and CIA veteran, and the first DCI to have risen through the ranks at CIA. Helms became
Advanced Media Group Page 635 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 654
Page
of 2413
655 of 2593
3 of 13 9/23/2009 2:39 PM
Director of Central Intelligence - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Director_of_Central_Intelligence
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
Director of the OSO after the CIA's disastrous role in the attempted Bay of Pigs Invasion of Cuba in 1961]].
After falling out with the Kennedys, he was sent off to Vietnam where he oversaw the coup to overthrow
President Ngo Dinh Diem. Following the assassination of John F. Kennedy, Helms was made Deputy Director of
Central Intelligence under Admiral William Raborn. A year later, in 1966, he was appointed Director.
In the early 1970s, partially as a result of the Watergate break-ins under President Richard M. Nixon, the United
States Congress took a more active role in intelligence agencies, as did independent commissions such as the
1975 United States President's Commission on CIA activities within the United States, also called the
Rockefeller Commission after its chairman. Revelations about past CIA activities, such as assassinations and
attempted assassinations of foreign leaders, illegal domestic spying on U.S. citizens, drew considerable
congressional oversight that had not been previousy exercised. It was determined, by several investigating
committees, that the CIA had given inappropriate assistance to persons affiliated with the White House and the
1972 Nixon reelection campaign. Certain of the individuals involved in the Watergate breakins had worked, in
the past, for the CIA. In an audio tape provoking President Nixon's resignation, Nixon ordered his chief of staff,
H.R. Haldeman, to tell the CIA that further investigation of Watergate would "open the whole can of worms"
about the Bay Of Pigs of Cuba, and, therefore, that the CIA should tell the FBI to cease investigating the
Watergate burglary, due to reasons of "national security".[4] CIA did not comply.
The ease of Helms's role under President Lyndon Johnson changed with the arrival of President Richard Nixon
and Nixon's national security advisor Henry Kissinger. After the debacle of Watergate, from which Helms
succeeded in distancing the CIA as far as possible, the Agency came under much tighter congressional control.
Nixon, however, considered Helms to be disloyal, and fired him as DCI in 1973. Helms was the only DCI
convicted for irregularities in office; his autobiography describes his reactions to the charges[5]
On 2 February 1973 he became Director of Central Intelligence, after Richard Helms, the previous director, had
been fired for his refusal to block the Watergate investigation. Schlesinger's first words upon becoming DCI
were, reportedly, "I'm here to make sure you don't screw Richard Nixon." Although his CIA service was short,
barely six months, it was stormy as he again undertook comprehensive organizational and personnel changes. He
became so unpopular at CIA Headquarters in Langley, Virginia that a security camera was installed opposite his
official portrait for fear that it would be vandalized. By this time he had a reputation as a tough, forthright, and
outspoken administrator. Schesinger's appointment as Secretary of Defense cut short his tenure as DCI.
He commissioned reports known as the "Family Jewels" on illegal activities by the Agency.
Colby was another intelligence professional who was promoted to the top job. His autobiography was entitled
"Honorable Men", and he believed that a nation had to believe such people made up its intelligence service.[6]
In December 1974, Investigative journalist Seymour Hersh broke the news of the "Family Jewels" in a
front-page article in The New York Times, revealing that the CIA had assassinated foreign leaders, and had
conducted surveillance on some seven thousand American citizens involved in the antiwar movement
(Operation CHAOS).
Congress responded to the "Family Jewels" in 1975, investigating the CIA in the Senate via the Church
Committee, chaired by Senator Frank Church (D-Idaho), and in the House of Representatives via the Pike
Committee, chaired by Congressman Otis Pike (D-NY). President Gerald Ford created the aforementioned
Rockefeller Commission, and issued an Executive Order prohibiting the assassination of foreign leaders.
Colby's tenure as DCI congressional investigations into alleged U.S. intelligence malfeasance over the preceding
twenty-five years. Colby cooperated, not out of a desire for major reforms, but in the belief that the actual scope
of such misdeeds was not great enough to cause lasting damage to the CIA's reputation. He believed that
cooperating with Congress was the only way to save the Agency from dissolution. Colby also believed that the
CIA had a moral obligation to cooperate with the Congress and demonstrate that the CIA was accountable to
the Constitution. This caused a major rift within the CIA ranks, with many old-line officers such as former DCI
Richard Helms believing that the CIA should have resisted congressional intrusion.
Colby's time as DCI was also eventful on the world stage. Shortly after he assumed leadership, the Yom Kippur
War broke out, an event that surprised not only the American intelligence agencies but also the Israelis. This
intelligence surprise reportedly affected Colby's credibility with the Nixon Administration. Meanwhile, after
many years of involvement, South Vietnam fell to Communist forces in April 1975, a particularly difficult blow
for Colby, who had dedicated so much of his life and career to the American effort there. Events in the arms
control field, Angola, the Middle East, and elsewhere also demanded attention.
William Colby's death, officially in a boating accident, happened on the same date when a New York prosecutor
got permission to set up a grand jury to investigate the role of the CIA in the death of Frank Olson who worked
at Fort Detrick, Maryland and was involved in chemical warfare research. Frank Olson was one of the
experimental subjects in the CIA MKULTRA experiments with LSD and other drugs. He did not give informed
consent for the CIA to experiment on him, as would be ethically required under the medical research principles
of the Declaration of Helsinki. The CIA claimed that he committed suicide by jumping out of a hotel window
but the family did not believe this explanation. An autopsy of the remains of Frank Olson had found blunt force
trauma to the head, which might have come from the fall, or been inflicted before the fall. The Olson matter
remains unresolved and continues to arise in reviews of questionable activities.
Bush's confirmation as Director of Central Intelligence was opposed by many pundits and politicians still reeling
from the Watergate scandal (when Bush was head of the Republican National Committee, and a steadfast
defender of Nixon) and the Church Committee investigating whether CIA-ordered foreign assassinations were
being directed towards domestic officials, including President Kennedy. Many arguments against Bush's initial
confirmation were that he was too partisan for the office. The Washington Post, George Will, and Senator Frank
Church were some notable figures opposed to Bush's nomination. After a pledge by Bush not to run for either
president or vice president in 1976, opposition to his nomination died down.
Bush served in this role for 355 days, from January 30, 1976 to January 20, 1977.[7] The CIA had been rocked
by a series of revelations, including disclosures based on investigations by the Senate's Church Committee,
about the CIA's illegal and unauthorized activities, and Bush was credited with helping to restore the agency's
morale.[8] On February 18, 1976, President Ford issued Executive Order 11905, which established policy
guidelines and restrictions for individual intelligence agencies, and clarified intelligence authorities and
responsibilities. Bush was given 90 days to implement the new order, which called for a major reorganization of
the Intelligence Community and firmly stated that intelligence activities could not be directed against U.S.
citizens.[9] In his capacity as DCI, Bush gave national security briefings to Jimmy Carter both as a presidential
candidate and as President-elect, and discussed the possibility of remaining in that position in a Carter
administration.[10]
An Annapolis classmate of Jimmy Carter, Turner enjoyed White House confidence, but his emphasis on
technical collection methods such as SIGINT and IMINT, and his apparent dislike for, and firing of, HUMINT
specialists made him extremely unpopular. Under Turner's direction, the CIA emphasized IMINT and SIGINT
more than HUMINT. Turner eliminated over 800 operational positions in what was called the "halloween
massacre." This organizational direction is notable because his successor William Casey was seen to have a
completely opposite approach, focusing much of his attention on HUMINT. Turner gave notable testimony to
Congress revealing much of the extent of the MKULTRA program, which the CIA ran from the early 1950s to
late 1960s. Reform and simplification of the intelligence community's multilayered secrecy system was one of
Turner's significant initiatives, but produced no results by the time he left office. He also wrote a book on his
experience at CIA.[11]
During Turner's term as head of the CIA, he became outraged when former agent Frank Snepp published a book
called Decent Interval which exposed incompetence among senior American government personnel during the
fall of Saigon.[12] accused Snepp of breaking the secrecy agreement required of all CIA agents, and then later
was forced to admit under cross-examination that he had never read the agreement signed by Snepp.[13]
Regardless, the CIA ultimately won its case against Snepp at the U.S. Supreme Court. The Court forced Snepp
to turn over all his profits from Decent Interval and to seek preclearance of any future writings about
intelligence work for the rest of his life. The ultimate irony was that the CIA would later rely on the Snepp legal
precedent in forcing Turner to seek preclearance of his own memoirs, which were highly critical of President
Ronald Reagan's policies.[13] Turner, who was not a lawyer, did not understand the concept of precedent, and
did not grasp the broader implications of pushing the U.S. Department of Justice to take an aggressive stance
against Snepp.[14]
In the documentary "Secrets of the CIA" Admiral Turner commented the MK ULTRA project.
"It came to my attention early in my ten years as director, and I felt it was a warning sign that if you're not
alert, things can go wrong in this organization."
During his tenure at the CIA, Casey played a large part in the shaping of Reagan's foreign policy, particularly its
approach to Soviet international activity. Based on a book, The Terror Network, Casey believed that the Soviet
Union was the source of most terrorist activity in the world, in spite of CIA analysts providing evidence that this
was in fact black propaganda by the CIA itself. Casey obtained a report from a professor that agreed with his
view, which convinced Ronald Reagan that there was a threat.[15]
Casey oversaw the re-expansion of the Intelligence Community, in particular the CIA, to funding and human
resource levels greater than those before resource cuts during the Carter Administration. During his tenure
restrictions were lifted on the use of the CIA to directly, covertly influence the internal and foreign affairs of
countries relevant to American policy.
This period of the Cold War saw an increase of the Agency's anti-Soviet activities around the world. Notably he
oversaw covert assistance to the mujahadeen resistance in Afghanistan, with a budget of over $1 billion by
working closely with Akhtar Abdur Rahman (the Director General of ISI in Pakistan), the Solidarity movement
in Poland, and a number of coups and attempted coups in South- and Central America.
Casey was also the principal architect of the arms-for-hostages deal that became known as the Iran-Contra
affair.
Hours before Casey was scheduled to testify before Congress about his knowledge of Iran-Contra, he was
reported to have been rendered incapable of speech, and was later hospitalized. In his 1987 book,[16]
Washington Post reporter Bob Woodward, who had interviewed Casey on numerous occasions, said that he had
gained entry to Casey's hospital room for a final, four-minute long encounter a claim that was met with
disbelief in many quarters, and adamant denial by Casey's wife, Sofia. According to Woodward, when he asked
Casey if he knew about the diversion of funds to the Nicaraguan Contras, "His head jerked up hard. He stared,
and finally nodded yes."[17]
Webster came from a legal background, including serving as a judge and the director of the FBI. He was
expected, with this background, to clean up legal irregularities at CIA. Repercussions from the Iran-Contra arms
smuggling scandal included the creation of the Intelligence Authorization Act in 1991.[16] It defined covert
operations as secret missions in geopolitical areas where the U.S. is neither openly nor apparently engaged. This
also required an authorizing chain of command, including an official, presidential finding report and the
informing of the House and Senate Intelligence Committees, which, in emergencies, requires only "timely
notification".
Gates was nominated (for the second time) for the position of Director of Central Intelligence by President
George H. W. Bush on May 14, 1991, confirmed by the United States Senate on November 5, and sworn in on
November 6, becoming the only career officer in the CIA's history (as of 2009) to rise from entry-level
employee to Director.[18]
The final report of the Independent Counsel for Iran/Contra Matters, issued on August 4, 1993, said that Gates
"was close to many figures who played significant roles in the Iran/contra affair and was in a position to have
known of their activities. The evidence developed by Independent Counsel did not warrant indictment..."[19]
As Director of Central Intelligence, Woolsey is notable for having a very limited relationship with President Bill
Clinton. According to journalist Richard Miniter:
Never once in his two-year tenure did CIA director James Woolsey ever have a one-on-one meeting with
Clinton. Even semiprivate meetings were rare. They only happened twice. Woolsey told me: "It wasn't that I
had a bad relationship with the president. It just didn't exist."[20]
Another quote about his relationship with Clinton, according to Paula Kaufman of Insight Magazine:
Remember the guy who in 1994 crashed his plane onto the White House lawn? That was me trying to get an
appointment to see President Clinton.[21]
David Halberstam notes in War in a Time of Peace that Clinton chose Woolsey for CIA director because the
Clinton campaign had courted neoconservatives leading up to the 1992 election, promising to be tougher on
Taiwan, Bosnia, and human rights in China, and it was decided that they ought to give at least one
neoconservative a job in the administration.
In 1995, President Bill Clinton appointed him Director of Central Intelligence (cabinet rank in the Clinton
administration). However, Deutch was initially reluctant to accept the appointment. As head of the CIA, Deutch
continued the policy of his predecessor R. James Woolsey to declassify records pertaining to U.S. covert
operations during the Cold War.[22] He put restraints on what he considered to be politically incorrect agent
recruitment and sought to encourage more diversity at the Agency in order to include more women and
minorities in its ranks.[23]
In 1996, the U.S. House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence issued a congressional report estimating
that: "Hundreds of employees on a daily basis are directed to break extremely serious laws in countries around
the world in the face of frequently sophisticated efforts by foreign governments to catch them. A safe estimate is
that several hundred times every day (easily 100,000 times a year) DO officers engage in highly illegal activities
(according to foreign law) that not only risk political embarrassment to the US but also endanger the freedom if
not lives of the participating foreign nationals and, more than occasionally, of the clandestine officer himself."
[24][25]
In the same document, the committee wrote, "Considering these facts and recent history, which has shown that
the [Director of the Central Intelligence Agency], whether he wants to or not, is held accountable for overseeing
the [Clandestine Service], the DCI must work closely with the Director of the CS and hold him fully and directly
responsible to him."[25]
Soon after Deutch's departure from the CIA in 1996 it was revealed that classified materials were being kept on
several of Deutch's laptop computers designated as unclassified. In January 1997, the CIA began a formal
security investigation of the matter. Senior management at CIA declined to fully pursue the security breach.
Over two years after his departure, the matter was referred to the Department of Justice, where Attorney
General Janet Reno declined prosecution. She did, however, recommend an investigation to determine whether
Deutch should retain his security clearance.[26] President Clinton pardoned Deutch on his last day in office.[27]
Tenet was appointed Deputy Director of Central Intelligence in July 1995. After John Deutch's abrupt
resignation in December 1996, Tenet served as acting director until he was officially appointed the position on
July 11, 1997, after a unanimous confirmation vote in the Senate. This was followed by the withdrawal of
Anthony Lake, whose nomination had been blocked by Republicans in Congress. While the Director of Central
Intelligence has typically been replaced by an incoming administration ever since Jimmy Carter replaced DCI
George H. W. Bush, Tenet served through the end of the Clinton administration and well into the term of
George W. Bush.
Tenet embarked on a mission to regenerate the CIA, which had fallen on hard times since the end of the Cold
War. The number of agents recruited each year had fallen to an all-time low, a 25-percent decline from the Cold
War peak. Tenet appealed to the original mission of the agency, which had been to "prevent another Pearl
Harbor". The trick was to see where danger might come from in the post-Cold War world. Tenet focused on
potential problems such as "the transformation of Russia and China", "rogue states" like North Korea, Iran and
Iraq, and terrorism.[28]
In 1999 Tenet put forward a grand "Plan" for dealing with al-Qaeda. This effort placed the CIA in a better
position to respond after the September 11, 2001 attacks. As Tenet put it in his book,[29]
How could [an intelligence] community without a strategic plan tell the president of the United States just
four days after 9/11 how to attack the Afghan sanctuary and operate against al-Qa'ida in ninety-two
countries around the world?
On September 15, 2001. Tenet presented the Worldwide Attack Matrix, a blueprint for what became known as
the War On Terror.[30] He proposed firstly to send CIA teams into Afghanistan to collect intelligence on, and
mount covert operations against, al-Qaeda and the Taliban. The teams would act jointly with military Special
Operations units. "President Bush later praised this proposal, saying it had been a turning point in his
thinking."[31]
After the September 11 attacks, many observers criticized the Intelligence Community for numerous
"intelligence failures" as one of the major reasons why the attacks were not prevented.[30] In August 2007, a
secret report written by the CIA inspector general was made public (originally written in 2005 but kept secret).
The 19-page summary states that Tenet knew the dangers of Al Qaeda well before September 2001, but that the
leadership of the CIA did not do enough to prevent any attacks. Tenet reacted to the publication of this report
by calling it "flat wrong".[32]
Bob Woodward, in his book Plan of Attack,[33] wrote that Tenet privately lent his personal authority to the
intelligence reports about weapons of mass destruction (WMDs) in Iraq. At a meeting on December 12, 2002,
he assured Bush that the evidence against Saddam Hussein amounted to a "slam dunk case." After several
months of refusing to confirm this statement, Tenet later stated that this remark was taken out of context. (Tenet
indicated that the comment was made pursuant to a discussion about how to convince the American people to
support invading Iraq, and that, in his opinion, the best way to convince the people would be by explaining the
dangers posed by Iraq's WMD i.e., the public relations sale of the war via the WMD, according to Tenet, would
be a "slam dunk").[34] The search following the 2003 invasion of Iraq by U.S., British and international forces
yielded no stockpiles of WMDs, however. Tenet and his Director of Operations resigned at approximately the
same time, and it was suggested this was in penance over the WMD issue in Iraq.
In his junior year at Yale, Goss was recruited by the CIA. He spent much of the 1960s roughly from 1960
until 1971 working for the Directorate of Operations, the clandestine services of the CIA. There he first
worked in Latin America and the Caribbean and later in Europe. The full details are not known due to the
classified nature of the CIA, but Goss has said that he had worked in Haiti, Santo Domingo, and Mexico. Goss,
who has said that he has recruited and trained foreign agents, worked in Miami for much of the time. Goss was
involved in the Cuban Missile Crisis in 1962, telling the Washington Post in 2002 that he had done some
"small-boat handling" and had "some very interesting moments in the Florida Straits."
He served in Congress for 16 years until his appointment as Director of the CIA. While in the House, Goss
consistently and emphatically defended the CIA and supported strong budget increases for the Agency, even
during a time of tight budgets and Clintonian slashes to other parts of the intelligence budgets. In mid-2004,
Goss took a very strong position, during what had already been announced as his last congressional term, urging
specific reforms and corrections in the way the CIA carried out its activities, lest it become "just another
government bureaucracy."
After growing pressure, Congress established the Joint Inquiry into Intelligence Community Activities before
and after the Terrorist Attacks of September 11, 2001, a joint inquiry of the two intelligence committees, led by
Goss and Senator Bob Graham. Goss and Graham made it clear that their goal was not to identify specific
wrongdoing: Graham said the inquiry would not play "the blame game about what went wrong from an
intelligence perspective,", and Goss said, "This is not a who-shall-we-hang type of investigation. It is about
where are the gaps in America's defense and what do we do about it type of investigation."[35] The inquiry's
final report was released in December 2002 and focused entirely on the CIA and FBI's activities, including no
information on the White House's activities. Ray McGovern, a 27-year veteran of the CIA and a frequent
commentator on intelligence issues, believed the report showed that Goss gave "clear priority to providing
political protection for the president" when conducting the inquiry. Goss chiefly blamed President Bill Clinton
for the recent CIA failures. He confided in a reporter: "The one thing I lose sleep about is thinking what could I
have done better, how could I have gotten more attention on this problem sooner." When asked whether he ever
brought up his concerns with the administration, Goss claimed he had met three times with Clinton to discuss
"certain problems". The upshot? "He was patient and we had an interesting conversation but it was quite clear
he didnt value the intelligence community to the degree President Bush does."
Goss was nominated to become the new director on August 10, 2004. The appointment was challenged by some
prominent Democrats). Sen. John D. Rockefeller IV (D-WV), vice chairman of the Senate Intelligence
Committee, expressed concerns that Goss was too politically partisan, given his public remarks against
Democrats while serving as chairman of the House Intelligence Committee. Another Democratic member of the
committee, Ron Wyden (D-OR), expressed concerns that given Goss's history within and ties to the CIA, he
would be too disinclined to push for institutional change. In an interview carried out by Michael Moore's
production company on March 3, 2004, Goss described himself as "probably not qualified" for a job within the
CIA, because the language skills the Agency now seeks are not languages he speaks and because the people
applying today for positions within the CIA's four directorates have such keen technical and analytic skills,
which he did not have when he applied to the Agency in the early 60s.
He brought with him five personal staff that were to implement change that became unpopular with CIA
professionals. Steve Kappes the Director of Operations and his subordinates including Michael Sulick,
Kappes' then-deputy. Although Kappes came back to a responsible position, it has been reported that he quit the
Agency rather than carry out a request by Goss to reassign Michael Sulick. Following Goss's departure, both
Kappes and Sulick have returned to positions of higher authority in the U.S. Intelligence Community. Kappes is
the Deputy Director of the CIA and Sulick was appointed Director of the National Clandestine Service on
September 14, 2007.
Speculations on the reason for his departure include a desire to have military agency heads, or, perhaps more
likely,
For many analysts, Goss' departure was inevitable, given the widespread perception that the White House
had lost confidence in his ability to reorganise the CIA. Goss' departure appears to have been due, at least in
part, to his repeated clashes with John Negroponte who was appointed in 2005 as the US Director of
National Intelligence, a new post created to co-ordinate all 16 of the US intelligence agencies in the aftermath
of the Al-Qaeda attacks.
[36]
A claim that the black sites existed was made by The Washington Post in
November 2005 and before by human rights NGOs.[37] US President George
W. Bush acknowledged the existence of secret prisons operated by the CIA
during a speech on September 6, 2006.[38][39]
On 27 June 2007 the CIA released two collections of previously classified documents which outlined various
activities of doubtful legality.
The first collection, the "Family Jewels," consists of almost 700 pages of responses from CIA employees to a
1973 directive from Director of Central Intelligence James Schlesinger requesting information about activities
inconsistent with the Agency's charter.
The second collection, the CAESAR-POLO-ESAU papers, consists of 147 documents and 11,000 pages of
research from 1953 to 1973 relating to Soviet and Chinese leadership hierarchies, and Sino-Soviet relations.[40]
On January 5, 2009, Barack Obama nominated Leon Panetta for the post of Director of the Central Intelligence
Agency. After his selection, journalists, politicians, and media agenciessuch as The Economistraised
concerns about his lack of intelligence experience.[41] Time Magazine commented that "[m]ore than a few
eyebrows went up when word broke".[42]
The magazine also speculated that Obama selected Panetta because he needed a CIA director "untainted" by the
Bush Administration's policies on torture and its handling of the Iraq War.[42] David Ignatius says Obama
advisers have told him he was picked to provide political defense for the CIA: "Panetta is a Washington
heavyweight with the political clout to protect the agency and help it rebuild after a traumatic eight years under
George Bush, when it became a kind of national pincushion." Ignatius further explains that Panetta does have
tangential exposure to intelligence operations as director of the OMB and as Chief of Staff for President Clinton,
where he "sat in on the daily intelligence briefings as chief of staff, and he reviewed the nation's most secret
intelligence-collection and covert-action programs in his previous post as director of the Office of Management
and Budget." Panetta also served on the Iraq Study group.
Former DCI R. James Woolsey, Jr. is supportive of Leon Panetta, whom he has compared favorably with
Kennedy-era leader John McCone. He described Panetta as "a very able individual with a successful
career".[41]
1. ^ "U.S. Department of State: Foreign Relations of 3. ^ "John McCone and William Raborn: New Kind of
the United States, 19451950, Emergence of the DCI" (https://www.cia.gov/library/center-for-the-
Intelligence Establishment (http://www.state.gov study-of-intelligence/csi-publications/books-
/www/about_state/history/intel/290_300.html) ", and-monographs/directors-of-central-intelligence-
state.gov: Document 292, Section 5, as-leaders-of-the-u-s-intelligence-community
http://www.state.gov/www/about_state/history/intel /chapter_3.htm) , Directors of Central Intelligence
/290_300.html, retrieved 2007-04-15 as Leaders of the U.S. Intelligence Community,
2. ^ Dulles, Allen W. (1963). The Craft of Douglas F. Garthoff, CIA's Center for the Study of
Intelligence. Harper & Row. Intelligence
4. ^ "Transcript of a recording of a meeting between 17. ^ Zoglin, Richard (October 12,1987), "Did A Dead
President Richard Nixon and H. R. Haldeman in the Man Tell No Tales? (http://www.time.com
oval office (http://www.hpol.org /time/printout/0,8816,965712,00.html) ]", Time,
/transcript.php?id=92) ". hpol.org. 1972-06-23. http://www.time.com/time/printout
http://www.hpol.org/transcript.php?id=92. Retrieved /0,8816,965712,00.html
2007-04-15. 18. ^ Gates, Robert (1996). From the Shadows.
5. ^ Helms, Richard; Hood, William (2003). A Look Touchstone. ISBN 0-684-81081-6.
over My Shoulder: A Life in the Central Intelligence 19. ^ Lawrence E. Walsh, Final report of the independent
Agency. Random House. counsel for Iran/Contra matters (http://fas.org
6. ^ Colby, William; Peter Forbath (1978). Honourable /irp/offdocs/walsh/) , August 4, 1993, and in
Men: My Life in the CIA. London: Hutchinson. ISBN particular Chapter 16, "Robert M. Gates"
009134820X. OCLC 16424505 (http://worldcat.org (http://www.fas.org/irp/offdocs/walsh/chap_16.htm)
/oclc/16424505) . 20. ^ Lopez, Kathryn Jean (September 11, 2003),
7. ^ The George Bush Center for Intelligence "Clintons Loss? How the previous administration
(https://www.cia.gov/cia/information/bush.html) - fumbled on bin Laden.
CIA, accessed February 26, 2006 (http://www.nationalreview.com/interrogatory
8. ^ George Herbert Walker Bush /interrogatory091103b.asp) ", National Review
(http://worldroots.com/brigitte/bush.htm) - Online, http://www.nationalreview.com/interrogatory
WorldRoots.com, accessed February 26, 2006 /interrogatory091103b.asp
9. ^ "Fifteen DCIs' First 100 Days 21. ^ Kaufman, Paula (June 3, 2002), "Woolsey wary of
(https://www.cia.gov/library/center-for-the-study- more attacks; former CIA director James Woolsey
of-intelligence/csi-publications/csi-studies/studies says the U.S. could ensure a more peaceful world by
/95unclass/100Days.html#top) ". Central Intelligence toppling Iraq's Saddam Hussein and ceasing its
Agency Center for the Study of Intelligence. toleration of Mideast tyrants
https://www.cia.gov/library/center-for-the-study- (http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1571
of-intelligence/csi-publications/csi-studies/studies /is_20_18/ai_87460042/pg_5) ", Insight on the
/95unclass/100Days.html#top. Retrieved News, http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles
2008-05-01. /mi_m1571/is_20_18/ai_87460042/pg_5
10. ^ "CIA Briefings of Presidential Candidates; Chapter 22. ^ "CIA's Historical Review Program", National
5: In-Depth Discussions With Carter Archives (NARA) electronic collections
(https://www.cia.gov/library/center-for-the-study- (http://www.foia.cia.gov/special_collections.asp)
of-intelligence/csi-publications/books- 23. ^ "PC and the CIA", jewishworldreview.com, Mar.
and-monographs/cia-briefings-of-presidential- 2, 2005 (http://www.jewishworldreview.com
candidates/cia-8.htm) ". Central Intelligence Agency: /cols/chavez030205.asp)
Center for the Study of Intelligence. 24. ^ "The CIA Commits Over 100,000 Serious Crimes
https://www.cia.gov/library/center-for-the-study- Per Year (http://www.thememoryhole.org
of-intelligence/csi-publications/books- /ciacrimes.htm) ". www.thememoryhole.org.
and-monographs/cia-briefings-of-presidential- 2006-07-16. http://www.thememoryhole.org
candidates/cia-8.htm. Retrieved 2007-10-11. /ciacrimes.htm. Retrieved 2007-04-15.
11. ^ Turner, Stansfield (1985). Secrecy and Democracy 25. ^ a b "The Intelligence Community in the 21st
- The CIA in Transition. Houghton Mifflin Company. Century, Staff Study, Permanent Select Committee
ISBN 0-395-35573-7. on Intelligence, House of Representatives, One
12. ^ Snepp, Frank (1977). Decent Interval: An Insider's Hundred Fourth Congress (http://www.loyola.edu
Account of Saigon's Indecent End. Random House. /dept/politics/intel/ic21_files/ic21009.html) ". One
13. ^ a b Snepp, Frank (1999). Irreparable Harm: A Hundred Fourth Congress. 2006-07-16.
Firsthand Account of How One Agent Took On the http://www.loyola.edu/dept/politics/intel/ic21_files
CIA in an Epic Battle Over Secrecy and Free /ic21009.html. Retrieved 2007-04-15.
Speech. Random House. 26. ^ Central Intelligence Agency Inspector General
14. ^ Snepp v. US, 444 U.S. 507 Report of Investigation Improper Handling of
(http://supreme.justia.com/us/444/507/case.html) Classified Information By John M. Deutch
(Supreme Court of the United States 1980). (http://www.fas.org/irp/cia/product/ig_deutch.html) ,
15. ^ The Power of Nightmares Part 1 'Baby it's cold Feb. 18, 2000
outside' 27. ^ Ross, Sonya, "Clinton Pardons More Than 100"
16. ^ a b Woodward, Bob (1987). Veil: The Secret Wars (http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/aponline
of the CIA 1981-1987. Simon & Schuster. /20010120/aponline104904_000.htm) , Washington
Advanced Media Group Page 644 of 727 October 2, 2009
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 663
Page
of 2413
664 of 2593
12 of 13 9/23/2009 2:39 PM
Director of Central Intelligence - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Director_of_Central_Intelligence
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
Post, Jan. 20, 2001 36. ^ ) Yet more turmoil at the CIA"
28. ^ Coll,Steve (2005). Ghost Wars. Penguin. pp. 317, (http://www.janes.com/security
354, 35962.. /international_security/news/jid
29. ^ Tenet, George (2007). At the Center of the Storm: /jid060511_1_n.shtml) , Janes, 11 May 2006,
My Years at the CIA. HarperCollins. pp. 1212; cf. http://www.janes.com/security/international_security
p.178.. /news/jid/jid060511_1_n.shtml
30. ^ a b Porch, Douglas; Wirtz, James J. (September 37. ^ "CIA Holds Terror Suspects in Secret Prisons
2002), "Surprise and Intelligence Failure (http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content
(http://www.ccc.nps.navy.mil/si/sept02 /article/2005/11/01/AR2005110101644.html) ".
/homeland.asp) ", Strategic Insights I (7), Washington Post. 2005-11-02.
http://www.ccc.nps.navy.mil/si/sept02/homeland.asp http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content
31. ^ 9/11 Commission Report, chapter 10 /article/2005/11/01/AR2005110101644.html.
(http://www.9-11commission.gov/report Retrieved 2007-02-19.
/911Report_Ch10.pdf) , p.332 (HTML version 38. ^ "Bush: Top terror suspects to face tribunals
(http://www.9-11commission.gov/report (http://www.cnn.com/2006/POLITICS/09/06
/911Report_Ch10.htm) ) /bush.speech/index.html) ". CNN / AP. 2006-09-06.
32. ^ "CIA criticises ex-chief over 9/11 http://www.cnn.com/2006/POLITICS/09/06
(http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/6957839.stm) ". /bush.speech/index.html. Retrieved 2006-09-06.
BBC. 2007-08-21. http://news.bbc.co.uk 39. ^ "Bush admits to CIA secret prisons
/2/hi/americas/6957839.stm. Retrieved 2007-08-21. (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/5321606.stm) ".
33. ^ Woodward, Bob (2004). Plan of Attack. Simon & BBC News. 2006-09-07. http://news.bbc.co.uk
Schuster. /2/hi/americas/5321606.stm. Retrieved 2007-04-15.
34. ^ Scott Shane, Mark Mazzetti (27 April 2007), 40. ^ "CIA Releases Two Significant Collections of
"Ex-C.I.A. Chief, in Book, Assails Cheney on Iraq Historical Documents (http://www.foia.cia.gov/) ".
(http://www.nytimes.com/2007/04/27/washington cia.gov. http://www.foia.cia.gov/. Retrieved
/27intel.html?ex=1335326400& 2007-06-02.
en=e6f2a5232d75afb5&ei=5090& 41. ^ a b Intelligence and Security with James Woolsey
partner=rssuserland&emc=rss) ", New York Times, (http://www.hoover.org/multimedia
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/04/27/washington /uk/38245979.html) . Uncommon Knowledge.
/27intel.html?ex=1335326400& Filmed on January 14, 2009. Retrieved July 6, 2009.
en=e6f2a5232d75afb5&ei=5090& 42. ^ a b Pickert, Kate. "CIA Director: Leon Panetta
partner=rssuserland&emc=rss (http://www.time.com/time/specials/packages/article
35. ^ Patrick Martin (2002-03-06). "Further delay in US /0,28804,1863062_1863058_1869817,00.html) ".
congressional investigation into September 11 Time Magazine. http://www.time.com/time/specials
attacks (http://www.wsws.org/articles/2002/mar2002 /packages/article
/prob-m06.shtml) ". World Socialist Web Site. /0,28804,1863062_1863058_1869817,00.html.
http://www.wsws.org/articles/2002/mar2002/prob- Retrieved July 6, 2009.
m06.shtml. Retrieved 2006-11-27.
Retrieved from "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Director_of_Central_Intelligence"
Categories: United States intelligence agencies
advisor to the President and the NSC. Appointer the President of the United States
Inaugural Porter J. Goss
The post of DCI was established in 1946 by President Harry holder September 24, 2004
Truman; it thus predates the establishment of the Central
Formation Intelligence Reform and Terrorism
Intelligence Agency (created by the National Security Act of
Prevention Act of 2004,
1947). After the end of World War II, the Office of Strategic December 17, 2004
Services was dismantled and its functions were split between
Website http://www.cia.gov
the Departments of State and War (now Defense). President
Truman soon recognized the inefficiency of this arrangement
and created the Central Intelligence Group, which could be considered a smaller precursor to the National
Security Council. The following year the National Security Act of 1947 created the Central Intelligence Agency
and National Security Council, while formally defining the duties of the Director of Central Intelligence. The
duties of the DCI had been further defined over the years by tradition, congressional acts, and Executive
Orders.
What follows is a list of Directors of the Central Intelligence Agency (in chronological order).
115th Year - No. 35,880 METROPOLITAN *** LANCASTER, PA., THURSDAY, OCTOBER 31,1991 Home Delivered
$2 10 a week Price 358
William L. Fleisher, deputy special agent with the U.S. Customs Ser-
vice, stands in the federal courthouse in Philadelphia today with some UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 667Page
of 2413
668 of 2593 created $1billion worth of fake business to pump up the value
of the equipment impounded in the Guerin investigation. JAMES H. GUERIN of ISC.
\ w' -
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
And yet, in just three weeks from that date, on January 16, Bobby Ray
Inman, reeling from bitter attacks by New York Times columnist Bill
Safire, attacks seconded by a couple of other media people, decided to
withdraw from the fray. He waited a couple of weeks to tell the
president, until Clinton's mother's funeral and his Russian trip were
out of the way, and then Inman went out in a blaze of fury, in a
remarkable televised press conference on January 18, less than a week
before his Senate confirmation hearings were slated to begin.
The almost monolithic response by the media was the most instructive
and revealing aspect of the Inman Affair. Almost exclusively, the
media focused on speculations of the supposedly odd psychological
state of mind of Admiral Inman. How could Inman retreat just
because Bill Safire and a couple of other columnists were criticizing
him? How could he possibly conjure up a "conspiracy" between Safire
and Senator Dole to attack him and besmirch his character? Inman
talked about "sources" but he couldn't prove his charges, could he?
Inman was denounced as remarkably "thin-skinned," his behavior in
charging conspiracy treated as "weird" and "bizarre," and the general
reaction echoed that of Senator Dole: that someone harboring
"fantasies" of this sort was not really equipped to be the captain at the
helm of America's defenses. In the psychobabble beloved by the
media, it was noted (which Inman had never denied) that Inman was
always reluctant about taking the job, and that therefore these
fantasies and this thin skin were really excuses for Inman's not taking
the position.
Amidst all the stress on Bobby Ray's supposedly fragile psyche, it was
overlooked that very little space was devoted to the content of the
charges that Safire and the others were leveling against Bobby Ray;
and virtually no space to Bobby Ray's explanation of the hostility that
Safire and the others had long harbored against him, and which led to
their anti-Inman campaign.
The media accounts all stress that no Senators were opposing the
Inman nomination; but the Senate staffers were preparing detailed
and thorough "scrutiny" of Inman's affairs. The media all imply that
Inman was "paranoid" and engaging in fantasies. But if Bobby Ray,
formerly Deputy Director of the CIA and head of the National Security
Agency, is not equipped to distinguish between "paranoia" and
genuine conspiracies, who is? Surely, "Mr. Intelligence" is better
equipped for this task than reporters for the New York Times or the
Wall Street Journal.
So let's stop the juvenile psychoanalyzing of Bobby Ray and cut to the
content. The charges about to surface against Inman in the hearings
included possible financial and even criminal peccadilloes in the
private sector, centering around two companies. One was Inman's role
as a member of the board of International Signal and Control, a firm
found by a federal district judge to be a criminal enterprise engaged in
illegal arms dealing, money laundering, and business fraud on a
massive scale. The other firm was Tracor, Inc., an Austin, Texas
military contractor of which Bobby Ray was chief executive, but not
before Inman received nearly $1 million in executive compensation.
Then, of course, there was Inman's Nannygate, in which he hastily
paid $6,000 in back Social Security taxes for an aged part-time
housekeeper only after he had been nominated for secretary of
defense.
Furthermore, Bill Safire was not above ridiculing Inman's name in his
widely influential column. Brushing aside the knowledge that a name
like "Bobby Ray" is common in Texas and throughout the South,
Safire ridiculed such a name for a grown man.
There was also a particularly ugly side to the media campaign against
Inman. One of the points dredged up against Inman was that, while a
high official in intelligence in 1980, he had acted to keep a gay in the
National Security Agency from being fired from his post. Part of the
anti-Inman tactic was a vicious whispering campaign to the effect that
Inman himself, though married, is a secret gay. Before he dropped
out, Inman told friends that no less than four reporters had called him
up to ask him if he is gay.
The most fascinating, but oddly enough the least reported, aspect of
the Inman Affair, is the source of the implacable hostility that Safire
and his allies have borne for many years toward Bobby Ray Inman.
Inman revealed the source in his famous January 18 press conference,
but he failed to bring out the background. The source: In early 1981,
Israel suddenly bombed Iraq's nuclear reactor. Puzzled, Inman, then
deputy head of the CIA, realized that Israel could only have known
where the nuclear reactor was located by having gotten access to U.S.
satellite photographs. But Israel's access was supposed to be limited to
photographs of direct threats to Israel, which would not include
Baghdad. On looking into the matter, furthermore, Inman found that
Israel was habitually obtaining unwarranted access to photographs of
regions even farther removed, including Libya and Pakistan. In the
absence of Reagan's head of the CIA, Bill Casey, Inman ordered
Israel's access to U.S. satellite photographs limited to 250 miles of its
border. When Casey returned from a South Pacific trip, his favorite
journalist and former campaign manager, Bill Safire, urged Casey to
reverse the decision, a pressure that coincided with complaints from
Israeli Defense Minister General Ariel Sharon, who had rushed to
Washington to try to change the new policy.
Cut to the present, and the conspiracy charge by Inman against Safire
and Company begins to make sense. For one point rarely mentioned
in the media accounts is that Inman, in his press conference, did not
only mention Safire and Senator Dole. He also mentioned, as part of
the campaign against him, not only the editors of the New York
Times, but three other media powers: New York Times columnist
Anthony Lewis, Boston Globe columnist Ellen Goodman, and
Washington Post cartoonist Herblock (Herbert Block). On the face of
it, a concerted campaign by these people against Inman would seem
implausible; after all, Safire is a neocon, whereas the New York
Times, Tony Lewis, Ellen Goodman, and Herblock are all notorious
left-liberals. What could they all possibly have in common?
The answer is that they all have one important thing in common, one
tie that binds. They are all ardent Zionists, and the source of the
hostility to Inman at not being sufficiently pro-Israel now makes sense
in underpinning the vendetta when Inman reluctantly agreed to
Clinton's and Talbott's importuning to return in triumph to
Washington.
In a fuller perspective, then, Admiral Bobby Ray Inman does not seem
to be a paranoid nut after all. On the contrary, no one can blame him
for saving himself and fleeing back to the warmer milieu of Austin,
Texas. It is no wonder that Bobby Ray feels more "comfortable" in
Austin than in Washington, to use one of his favorite words. But it
would have been far healthier for America, and for Americans'
knowledge of the political forces at work in this country, if Bobby Ray
had stood fast, and had forced a knock-down drag-out confrontation,
in the course of which much of the truth might have come to the
surface. As it is, it is inevitable that Safire & Company will be accorded
near-legendary political influence from now on. In a town that
worships Power, Bill Safire has now virtually attained the status of a
Rajah.
March 1994
Bobby R. Inman (born 4 April 1931 in Rhonesboro, Texas) Bobby Ray Inman
is a retired United States admiral who held several influential Born 4 April 1931 (aged 78)
positions in the U.S. Intelligence community.
1 Career
2 Political appointment
3 Statements
4 References
5 External links
Inman has been influential in various advisory roles. Notably, he chaired a commission on improving security at
U.S. foreign installations after the Marine barracks bombing and the April 1983 US Embassy bombing in Beirut,
Lebanon. The commission's report has been influential in setting security design standards for U.S. Embassies.
Since 2001, Inman has been the LBJ Centennial Chair in National Policy at The University of Texas at Austin
Lyndon B. Johnson School of Public Affairs, and in 2005 was the school's interim dean [1]. Inman graduated
from Texas with a bachelor's in history in 1950.
Inman has also served on the Board of Directors of the Council on Foreign Relations, Dell Computer, SBC
Corporation (now AT&T) [2] and Massey Energy.
Inman was announced as President Bill Clinton's choice to succeed Les Aspin as Secretary of Defense on 1993
December 16, initially receiving broad bipartisan support. He accepted the post at first, but withdrew his
nomination during an unusual press conference on 1994 January 18 that shocked members of both major
political parties.
During the press conference, Inman made angry remarks about perceived mistreatment by New York Times
columnist William Safire.[3] Safire wrote paragraphs on Inmans "anti-Israel bias shown", and ended in a four
point list of other negative qualifications. Inman suggested that Safire had recruited Senator Bob Dole of Kansas
to engage in a "vitriolic attack" on Inman, and also claimed that Dole and Senator Trent Lott were planning to
"turn up the heat" on his nomination.
Dole's reaction was to state that "I have no idea what's gotten into Bobby Inman... Admiral Inman's letter doesn't
make any sense to me." Lott appeared even more surprised, saying that "I am floored by [Inman's] bizarre press
conference," while an unnamed White House aide added: "Most of us were glued to the tube, our mouths open
in shock."[4]
In 2006, Inman criticized the Bush administration's use of warrantless domestic wiretaps, making him one of the
highest-ranking former intelligence officials to criticize the program in public [5][6]
Government offices
Preceded by Director of the National Security Agency Succeeded by
Lew Allen, Jr. 1977 1981 Lincoln D. Faurer
Preceded by CIA Deputy Director Succeeded by
Frank Charles Carlucci III 1981 1982 John N. McMahon
Retrieved from "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bobby_Ray_Inman"
Categories: 1931 births | Living people | People from Upshur County, Texas | Directors of the National Security
Agency | People of the Defense Intelligence Agency | United States Navy admirals | University of Texas at
Austin alumni
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License; additional terms may
apply. See Terms of Use for details.
Wikipedia is a registered trademark of the Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., a non-profit organization.
Mind Control
CIA MK-Ultra Program
Started during WWII with research on hypnosis for interrogation, secure courier duties, and reducing
fatigue. Also research into effects of primitive drugs like barbiturates and cannabis as far as drug-
assisted interrogation goes.
George Estabrooks was the leading proponent of hypnosis as the be-all and end-all of manipulating
peoples minds. His book, 'Hypnotism', published in the early forties, has been decried as too fantastic
and improbable in terms of describing the capabilities of hypnosis with certain very suggestible subjects,
but his arguments and examples remain valid to this day.
Start of Cold War and Korean War in particular gave a big boost to mind control research with the
emergence of 'Brain Washing' as a common term. Supposedly a development of the dastardly Chi-
Coms, the term was actually coined by a magazine writer later found to be on the CIA payroll as an
agent of influence. Postulating a 'brainwashing gap' The CIA got the go-ahead for research into
countering communist mind control efforts and developing their own to aid in the espionage wars.
Hypnosis, drugs, and psycho-surgery; separately and combined, were the tools of this quest for the
ultimate truth serum on the one hand, and the capability to create an agent who could not have his or her
mission tortured out of them, or even be aware that they were carrying secret information given to them
in an altered state of consciousness. More and more sophisticated drugs were experimented with, such as
LSD, Ketamine, and Psilocybine. Lobotomy and the implantation of electrodes were considered as
methods for creating a compliant agent. Electro-Convulsive Shock, combined with LSD, sedation for
days at a time, and constantly replaying the patient's own voice through helmet-mounted headphones
was a notorious Canadian researcher's recipe for mind control.
One of the most remarkable cases of mind control involves a famous model of the late 40's and 50's
named Candy Jones. In the book, "The Control of Candy Jones" the author reviewed hours of tapes
made by Candy Jones and her husband which revealed a systematic program to create and manipulate
alter personalities as the foundation for programmed couriers resistant to torture, where the primary
personality would not even be aware of the secret information being carried. The information could be
summoned forth via a post-hypnotic command or response to a pre-programmed cue.
Research continued into early 70's by CIA's own admission during the Church hearings. John Marks,
author of the best study of CIA mind control experiments, makes the subtle differentiation that the CIA
congressional witnesses might truthfully say that all research done by the TSS Directorate had ended,
since the programs were moved into other areas once operational techniques had been developed. Many
of the names mentioned in reference to mind control research turn up in the few references to supposed
dead-end research in ESP.
There have been persistent rumors of Navy research involving attempts at telepathy from submarines
under water, the Nautilus being the most famous of these. Detection of enemy submarines, and
communicating with our own, has continued to be an important area of conventional research for the
Navy, so it is no surprise that researching the use of ESP for these purposes would be of interest.
Communicating with a submerged submarine is the only kind of communications where the very act of
receiving puts the receiver in danger, since submarines must normally stick an antenna out of the water
for high speed radio traffic, or rely on trailing a long wire antenna under water relatively near the surface
to receive very slow speed traffic using ELF radio waves. Newer techniques may involve the use of
blue-green wavelength lasers, but evidently penetration to any depth is still a problem.
If you look at telepathy as a problem in the transfer of information in a very noisy environment, then
certain existing solutions suggest themselves: There have already been experiments in the transmission
of five distinct symbols via telepathy, namely Zener card symbols. I suggest that there is already a way
of transmitting information using two symbols only, namely Morse Code. Current ELF or VLF radio
transmission methods for communicating with fleet ballistic missile submarines to issue them their
launch orders involve very low data transfer rates, on the order of 3 to 30 bits per minute, if I am not
mistaken. Messages are very short, consisting of pre-formulated action or targeting codes. I suggest that
telepathic 'Zener Morse' is an operational technique for information transfer under severe signal to noise
conditions. In fact the use of five Zener symbols would increase data transfer rates, but at the expense of
a higher error rate due to the problems in discriminating between five and just two symbols.
Reports of Project SCANNATE in 70's, most likely done by Swann, since his method for RV is very
similar to that reportedly used in this project; namely providing latitude and longitude coordinates and
telling what is there. Later changed to assigning random number for unique session number and Swann
picked up location anyway.
"The New Age Army:" Over the past 10 - 15 years a number of military personnel, most in significant
positions in Military Intelligence, have expressed interest in and directed programs or projects that have
explored paranormal activities and capabilities. Several government studies on Enhancing Human
Performance took place during this time. Most, if not all of them, were savaged in the NRC study on
Enhancing Human Performance, but recent critiques and rebuttals of this study have indicated severe
irregularities in the evaluation procedures for papers submitted to the NRC study, suppression of
favorable results, and a definitely one-sided evaluation panel.
Much modern research in parapsychology tends to support the idea that Enhanced Perception is a
survival-related trait from our distant past, not the tip of the iceberg as far as new emerging human
powers go. This is supported by the observation that many psychic episodes center around catastrophic
or traumatic events. Studies of Siberian and Eskimo shamans also show the development of ESP or
similar shamanic powers due to injury, exposure to cold, and isolation. Dissociation with tendencies
towards Multiple Personality Disorder also occurs in these Shamans due to their ordeals. This is in
contrast to the experiences of most tropical shamans who tend to find their powers through exposure to
mind-altering drugs.
The Vietnam war, with its exceedingly stressful combat environment of no clear-cut enemies combined
with ambush being the normal way of making contact, produced a large body of individual reports
stressing enhanced perception and awareness. This showed up as detecting ambushes and booby-traps
before they were sprung; detecting the presence of enemy soldiers without any conscious sign of them;
time dilation when bullets could be seen slowly traveling around the battlefield, and even reports of
soldiers avoiding those bullets by jumping out of their paths as they were shot at.
Dr. Ian Wickramasekera of Eastern Virginia Medical School has studied the expansion of sensory input
during trauma which would lead to time dilation, etc. This gentleman has also studied the effects of
sensory deprivation on hypnotic susceptibility in young women.
In a recent article in U.S. News & World Report, John Gittinger, a CIA psychologist associated with a
CIA front organization, the Human Ecology Society admitted to knowledge of experiments in
developing ESP by giving electric shocks to subjects when they gave wrong answers.
Recently, a Russian researcher in psychotronics, Dr. Igor Smirnov, has helped to start up a new Virginia
company, called Psycho-Technologies, I believe. It is supposed to conduct research on various kinds of
LTL technology, with a concentration on Soviet-developed psychotronic warfare capabilities involving
the use of electromagnetic and sonic waves to influence and disable individuals or crowds. Supposedly
this ranges from simply falling to influencing peoples thoughts via audio or visual subliminal messages.
The Monroe Institute, located near Charlottesville, Virginia. Bob Monroe, author of many books on Out
of Body experiences, has long and close ties with the C.I.A. James Monroe, Bob's father, if I'm not
mistaken, was involved with the Human Ecology Society, a C.I.A. front organization of the late 50's and
60's. The Monroe Institute has done research on accelerated learning and foreign language learning
through the use of altered states of consciousness for the C.I.A. and other government organizations.
Government interest in the more radical research going on at the institute remains only tantalizing
speculation. Official classified document storage boxes have been seen at their mail-order outlet located
in Lovingston, VA.
Albert Stubblebine and John Alexander. Both retired Army officers, a General and Colonel respectively.
Both worked at U.S. Army Intelligence & Security Command, or INSCOM, Stubblebine as its head at
one time. Stubblebine has publicly stated that an enlisted man under his command inadvertently
'mentally fried' an intelligence gathering computer located in Augsberg Germany. This was Lynn
Buchanan, discussed later.
Alexander wrote the rebuttal to the NRC paper on Enhancing Human Performance. He used this rebuttal
as the basis for a book he co-authored called "The Warrior's Edge" which describes various techniques
for enhancing performance and perception utilizing the power of the mind. (Alexander headed up
research on Less Than Lethal weapons at Los Alamos National Laboratories until 'retiring.')
Jack Houk, Aerospace Engineer, and his Spoon bending parties, done for last 12 - 15 years. Stubblebine,
Alexander, and others have attended and hosted these parties. While even Houk admits that much of the
bending activity that occurs is due to hysterical strength, people getting excited, etc. there are always a
few really perplexing feats of bending at each party. Curled and twisted hacksaw blades comes to mind,
since these normally snap if they are bent.
S.A.I.C. involvement in 1993 American Parapsychological Association meeting arrangements, via their
'Cognitive Sciences Laboratory'. Science Applications International Corporation is a big time defense
contractor, has held the largest number of research contracts of any defense contractor. Bobby Ray
Inman is on its board of directors, among others.
Startup of TREAT, Center for Treatment and Research into Experienced Anomalous Trauma, by Rima
Leibow. Leibow is a psychiatrist who started studying trauma associated with alien abductions, noting
its similarities to PTSD. She has hosted open and closed meetings for the past six years. Leibow is a
close friend of/or married to Stubblebine, which certainly raises some interesting questions. Another
abduction researcher and friend is Victoria Lacas, who happens to be married to Alexander.
One other TREAT hanger-on, and friend of Stubblebine's, is Lynn Buchanan. Buchanan offers services
similar to PSI-TECH and has worked with Ed Dames on a contract basis. He taught a Remote Viewing
workshop at the latest TREAT conference. Also offers continued training in RV skills to those whom he
decides to work with. Veteran of INSCOM, and the famous 'computer frier' mentioned by Stubblebine.
A real mystery man in all of this is C.B. Scott Jones: Ex-Navy Intelligence officer, one time aide to
Senator Claiborne Pell, founder of the Human Potential Foundation; Jones appears to have his fingers in
every 'weird' pie around. He has been involved with several UFO research organizations, dolphin-human
communications research, served on the boards of several scholarly parapsychological research
organizations. Jones strikes many people as a 'Cardinal Richelieu' figure, manipulating events behind the
scenes, but rarely emerging into the spotlight.
There is literally no conference on parapsychology that he does not attend. He has traveled and done
research with Alexander and Rima Leibow. He works at keeping very well informed about the 'pulse' of
the New Age community and about UFO and parapsychological research in particular. He rarely writes
anything for print, but keeps in contact with many of the players in the fields. He has presented papers to
many conferences, most of the examples I have seen are complex, lengthy, and elaborate pieces of dis-
information which leave the listeners more confused than when he started. This is an individual who
bears watching.
On November 3, 2003, Kenneth C. Dahlberg was named the CEO of SAIC, ending Beyster's 30+ years of
leadership. In May 2005, under the new CEO, the company changed its external tagline from An
Employee-Owned Company to From Science to Solutions, retaining the former for internal communications.
The company has had as part of its management, and on its Board of Directors, many well known
ex-government personnel including Melvin Laird, Secretary of Defense in the Nixon administration; William
Perry, Secretary of Defense for Bill Clinton; John M. Deutch, President Clinton's CIA Director; Admiral Bobby
Ray Inman who served in various capacities in the NSA and CIA for the Ford, Carter and Reagan
administrations; and David Kay who led the search for weapons of mass destruction for the U.N. following the
1991 Gulf War and for the Bush Administration following the 2003 Iraq invasion.
SAIC conducted an initial public offering of common stock on October 13, 2006. The IPO raised US$1.7 billion.
After the proposed IPO, existing employee-owners would retain between 80% and 90% of the new company,
meaning that the employee ownership would be substantially preserved.
On September 27, 2006, during a special meeting of stockholders, employee-owners voted by a margin of 86%
to proceed with the IPO. The initial stock price is estimated at $1315 per share, with a public offering of 75
million shares. If the underwriters, Bear Stearns and Morgan Stanley, exercise overallotment options, an
additional 11.25 million shares will be offered. The company also plans to pay a special dividend to existing
stockholders, upon completion of the IPO, of $1.6 billion to $2.4 billion.
The Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) transitioned a Remote Viewing Program to SAIC in 1991 and it was
renamed Stargate Project.
In January 1999, new SAIC consultant Steven Hatfill and his collaborator, SAIC vice president Joseph Soukup,
commissioned William C. Patrick (a retired leading figure in the old U.S. bioweapons program) to report on the
possibilities of terrorist anthrax mailings in the United States. (There had been a spate of hoax anthrax mailings
in the previous two years.) Barbara Hatch Rosenberg said that the report was commissioned "under a CIA
contract to SAIC". However, SAIC said Hatfill and Soukup commissioned it internallythere was no outside
client.
Patrick produced his 28-page report in February 1999. Some subsequently saw it as a "blueprint" for the 2001
anthrax attacks. The report suggested the maximum amount of anthrax powder2.5 gramsthat could be put
in an envelope without producing a suspicious bulge. This was just a little more than the actual amounts2
grams eachin the letters sent to Senators Tom Daschle and Patrick Leahy. But the report also suggested that a
terrorist might produce a spore concentration of 50 billion spores per gram. This was only one-twentieth of the
actual concentration1 trillion spores per gramin the letters sent to the senators.[7]
In 2002, SAIC was chosen by the NSA to produce a technology demonstration platform for the agency's
Trailblazer program in a contract worth $280 million. Trailblazer is a "Digital Network Intelligence" system,
intended to analyze data carried on computer networks. Project participants included Boeing, Computer
Sciences Corporation, and Booz Allen Hamilton. SAIC had also participated in the concept definition phase of
Trailblazer, beginning March 2001.[8] According to science news site PhysOrg.com, Trailblazer was a
continuation of the earlier ThinThread program.[9] In 2005 NSA director Michael Hayden told a Senate hearing
that the Trailblazer program was several hundred million dollars over budget and years behind schedule.[10]
bd Systems
Bechtel SAIC Company, LLC, a joint venture between SAIC and Bechtel
Benham, a subsidiary of SAIC and its subsidiaries
Danet
Eagan, McAllister Associates, Inc a wholly owned subsidiary of SAIC under the C4I business unit.
Hicks & Associates
SAIC-Frederick, Inc.
SAIC International Subsidiaries
SAIC Venture Capital Corporation
Varec
Applied Marine Technology Corporation, A SAIC Operation
EAI Corporation, a wholly owned subsidiary
May 8, 2000 - Science Applications International Corporation (SAIC), through its wholly owned United
Kingdom subsidiary SAIC Ltd., and ScottishPower's Information Systems Division announced the formation of a
joint venture (JV) between the two organizations.
The JV company, called CALANAIS, was 50 percent owned by ScottishPower and 50 percent owned by SAIC
Ltd. The new company exploited the growing demand for information technology (IT) expertise in the rapidly
changing global utilities sector. While continuing to focus on providing IT services to ScottishPower, the JV
sought to develop external IT service business with customers within the multi-service utility sector.
CALANAIS, exploiting the combined strengths of both companies, also marketed expertise in business change
and Internet-enabling strategies aimed specifically at the utility sector. Initially based in Glasgow, Scotland and
Chester, England, CALANAIS employed approximately 600 people, mainly drawn from existing ScottishPower
staff who transferred to work in the new enterprise.
29 August 2002 Science Applications International Corporation (SAIC) announced that Calanais, SAIC`s
wholly-owned subsidiary, will trade and market under the global SAIC brand. The existing Calanais brand and
logo was phased out through a planned transition period. The Calanais entity became recognised as SAIC Ltd`s
Utilities Group.
The group, now employs around 1500 people in the UK, 450 of whom are at its Scottish headquarters in East
Kilbride.
Its East Kilbride facility currently acts as a centre of excellence serving the UK utilities sector and as the call
centre base responsible for handling all UK clients.
SAIC has development centers in Delhi and Bangalore, India. Scicom Technologies Noida was acquired by
SAIC in September 2007.
AMSEC LLC, a business partnership between SAIC and Northrop Grumman subsidiary Newport News
Shipbuilding divested on July 13, 2007. Network Solutions was acquired by SAIC in 1995,[11] and subsequently
was acquired by VeriSign, Inc. for $21 billion.[12]
In June 2001 the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) paid SAIC $122 million to create a virtual case file
system (VCF) software to speed up the sharing of information among agents. But the FBI abandoned VCF when
it failed to function adequately. Robert Mueller, FBI Director, testified to a congressional committee, "When
SAIC delivered the first product in December 2003 we immediately identified a number of deficiencies 17 at
the outset. That soon cascaded to 50 or more and ultimately to 400 problems with that software ... We were
indeed disappointed."
SAIC executive vice president Arnold L. Punaro claimed that the company had "fully conformed to the contract
we have and gave the taxpayers real value for their money." He blamed the FBI for the initial problems, saying
the agency had a parade of program managers and demanded too many design changes. During 15 months that
SAIC worked on the program, 19 different government managers were involved and 36 contract modifications
were ordered, he said.
"There were an average of 1.3 changes every day from the FBI, for a total of 399 changes during the period,"
Punaro said. [13]
Joseph Tate
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Joseph Tate is an American attorney who has represented Lewis Libby in the CIA leak grand jury
investigation. Tate is a partner with the law firm Dechert, LLP in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. He specializes in
defending clients against charges of complex white collar, in particular, anti-trust and other regulatory issues.
Previously, Tate worked in the Antitrust Division of the United States Department of Justice.
Contents
1 Education
2 Involvement with the CIA leak grand jury investigation
3 Letter related to CIA leak investigation
4 See also
5 External links
Education
Tate graduated from Villanova University in 1963 and Villanova University School of Law in 1966. He was a
member of the Villanova University Law Review.
1 ofAdvanced
2 Media Group Page 668 of 727 October 2, 2009
6/28/2007 8:01 PM
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 687
Page
of 2413
688 of 2593
U.S.
Joseph Tate - Wikipedia, the free Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigationshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Tate
encyclopedia into CIA Interrogation Programs
See also
CIA leak grand jury investigation
Plame Affair
Judith Miller
External links
Dechert LLP (http://www.dechert.com/index.jsp)
Categories: Year of birth missing | Living people | American federal lawyers | Pennsylvania lawyers
2 ofAdvanced
2 Media Group Page 669 of 727 October 2, 2009
6/28/2007 8:01 PM
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 688
Page
of 2413
689 of 2593
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation Programs
-
1
1
II
i
Cl
Ilvm
i
I
. -"
I . :I*
I
. .
. ..
. .
i
\ lS 4101 AEV 185
Guerin arrives
:o testify on
12.75-million
pay dispute
1y Ernest Schwlber
bnd Tlm Mekeel
3ew Era Stafi Writers
sion of a third degree felony, punishable by up to County Judge Michael A. ~ e o r g e l t6 ~ sappear for
seven years in jail andlor a $15,000 fine, according
to Lancaster County DistrictAttorney Henry S.
the deposition by Jan. 15. to provid -py&
the laves and toanswer any and all aues Ions L a r
Kenderdine Jr. asked-. '
"I am watching the case," said Kenderdine Tate, to no avail d u r ~ n goral arguements several
Tuesday when asked if his office was considerjng
prosecution. "I do not want to take criminal action
days earlier, had t r ~ e dto get Georgelis to postpone 1'
the depositions or, at thevery least, limit Clark's
(against Guerin) at this time that might interfere
with the civil action pending but, as I said, I am
auestionine to the issue of the agreement. savine
Guerin fac;d possible criminal &arges and&ula
.
watching the case." not defend the civil suit without compromising his
,~. ....
In October .
~ , . 1989,
. when Clark - . .first
" questioned
.. the criminal defense
Guerin is expected
to testify ~uesday
?ewn mEraMekeel
StaflWrlter
James H.Guerin is scheduled to give preliminary testimony Tues-
day in his $2.75 million severance dispute with his former corporate
attorney.
If Guerin appears, it would be the first time his whereabouts have
been established since September.
Guerin. the founder of International Signal & Control, is disputing
the validity of the deal with William A. Clark, formerly its vlce
president and general counsel.
ns.hlie
rUU....
-~ ~
-
Guerin's deposition is set for 9:30 a.m. in the office of Clark's
attorney, Joseph F. Rod? 36
.~~
I'Eideoosition
~..~~~~
.- E. King
-.- ----
S m s i o n is closed to the
was scheduled in December at the order of Judge
~~~ ~~
/
-..r..>4n OUlrll,llL1Ci), -LLu
criminal charges have been biggest defense in Europe, but one of the ,nost g; $
t;$
;l-
: ; ;1 Programs
filed. U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and the 2009 Senate Investigations into CIA Interrogation
Guerin has steadfastlv" denied cleverly orchestrated 99 ucts wcre actual\\
any wrongdoing.
~~ ~~~
"illegal" products
Guerin's attorney. Joseph A. a former Ferranti financial official looking at whether
Tate, said this week it is impossi-
ble to provide a detailed rebuttal - /-5-98 products were ship
biled military purp
to the fraud allegations because Whatev~r
~.. ~- .. t. h r.-
... ~a
of the ongoing criminal investi- suit as Lerwick Holdings S.A. ifying the French Mirage fightcr ranti bcgan raisi
gation. He said he cannot allow Marwick, an outside auditipg jet that would carry the missiles, about the Tech Ltc
Guerin to present his explanation firm that regularly checked In- the missiles were not shipped to ments from South i
of the alleged fraud. Nor, hesaid, ternational Signal's figures, took the Middle East kingdom. a sudden halt.
is there anyone who can steps to verify thecontract. Turning that delay to its advan- Ferranti has wri
knowledgeably give Gucrin's Ferranti auditors and officials tage, Tech Ltd. signed the UAE $50 million that it
side at present. even visited Pakistan, where to a contract for a more sophisti-
Shireman, the Marietta man they interviewed a man believed cated version of the Hakim, and
who was head of finance at Tech to be Major Gen. Talat Masood, sold, or supposedly sold, the old Fcrranli-is cxnec
Ltd.. was out of town this week then in charge of Army ord- missiles to the People's Republic
and could not be reachedfor com- nance, and received satisfactorv of China.
ment on the detailed fraud ac- answers to their questions, iim- Durine those
count. His attorney didnot return pany officials say. Ferranti officials say auditors Guerin and the 0th
phonecalls. from Peat Manvick ins~ected
The alleged fraud began to un- portions of the old mi~silc . will have an oppo
vr(1c.r.
The other two employees ravel as Guerin left the company orwhat they though1 a a s t h c mis- fend themselves
named in the suit, Radcliife of in May to organize a Leveraged sile order, in a warehouse in 19nh. their Pass
explanation (
contract.
Lancaster, and Resch, of San buyout that would have returned But afte'r the missiles were Meanwhile, the c
Clemente, Calif., have declined several divisions - including shipped from the warehouse, tigation into Intet
comment on their lawyers' ad- TechLtd. -to hisownership. they vanishcd. Private investiga-
vice. Radcliffe has told the Brit- That deal collapsed when Gue- tors hired by Ferranti to find nal's business deal
ish court that he intends to o p rin was unable to get financing, them have beenunsuccessful. uing.
pose Ferranti's lawsuit. after being turned down by Drex- Federal author?
el Burnham, Citibank and Fer- During a chairman's commit- are working "in c
f the three losses iden-
0
tion" with their cc
tified by Ferranti, the ranti itself. Had the buyout been tee meeting, however, Sir Derek Britain's Serious :
fictitious "Khyber completed, investigators believe Alun-Jones, Ferranti chairman,
Pass" contract was the alleged contract fraud might of congratulated Guerin on the sale Taking part in the
by f a r the most dam- not have come to light. the missiles, which were then U.S. Attorney's 01
aging. accounting for about $250 The first substantial sign that code-named Project Alpha, one Department, IRS,
something was amiss came when director recalls. and other agencies.
~ 1 1 l i k othe
f totdloss. SO, wherever those missiles
The contract, brought to the Ferranti officials noticed a lack
company in late 1986 by Guerin of consistency on dates on con- are today, Ferranti says it had to
nersonall\~.called for delivery of tract documents. swallow a loss on them totaling
Further financial discrepan- about $100 miltion.
broductiin systems for at least The final shortage discov-
three missile systems - air-to- cies came to tight in summer, ered by Ferranti financial inves- theAnspeech incorrect date
Retire,
air, air-to-ground and ground-to- andin mid-July, the front compa-
air. nies abruptly were dissolved. At tigators is the smallest - under Richard Scott will
$50 million - and the simplest to Lancaster Histori
Tech Ltd.'s S U.D. D O S ~role
~ was month's end, payments on the understand. about his escape frc
t u pnll the pieces together. in this Pakistan deal stopped altogeth-
rase buyins h;~rd\vareand tech- e
..r. ~ Since the late 1970s. Ferranti prisoner of war ca
Ferranti officials now are con- officials say, Tech Ltd. and its rect day is Tuesdaj
n o l o ~ from
r South Africa. and as-
sembling the systems for resale vinced the Pakistan1 contract predecessor ISC companies had New Era regrets the
been selling large volumes of
to Pakistan. wasenttrely f~ct~ttous.
Its contract called for supply of They say the front companies electronics - integrated cir- Joseph C. Kauff
tooling, technological "how-to" were all controlled by Guerinand cuits, antennas and other high- been re-appointed
tech communication equipment ship roadmaster by
data, test facilities and missile had no ties to the CIA or South -
to South Africa, a nation supervisors. A stor
prototypes, all supplied by an Africa.
The contract managers, a shunned by many U.S. eorpora- day's New Era inco:
arms subsidiarv of Barlow- tions because of its racial segre- that another towr
Rand, a South ~ j r i c a ncorpora- high-level Ferranti official says.
gationpolicies. had been named to
tion, and a second as-yet uniden- wcre people simply posing in that Those. sales were based on New Era regrets thc
tified company. role.
The major general either was
Even by Tech Ltd.'s normal another impostor, paid by the ~ ~ * ~ = 5 3 s s ~
standards for high secrecy, the Perpetrators, or was a genuine rll
"Khyber Pass" contract had ex- official mistakenly responding to
ccptionalsecurity safeguards. questions about a different mis-
$,irkel's o f New Y
First, it was not accompanied sile project, company officials
by a letter of credit -
a bank's now suspect. BUXTON WALLE
-guarantee that Tech Ltd. would All the known contract docu-
be paid. Supposedly, Pakistan ments were fabricated for the au-
objected to such a letter, fearing ditors' benefit, a former Ferranti
news of the deal might - leak official says, Other documents
f
through the bank. that would have supported a real
Second, Pakistan's payments contract are nowhere to be found.
were routed indirectly to Tech "If you'rean accountant, ev-
Ltd. through a Swiss bank ac- erything is there for you. But the Route 340
-
Clutches Billfolds- French P
o n The P l a ~ n& Fancy Far
count managed by a front compa- only paper is what was generated O p e n Dally 9-5,Frl 9-8. Closed Sun 7~
ny. identified in Ferranti's law- for the financial people." another h s a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
I.'
'
' creation of more than $1 billion valved in the governmentinvesti- being probed by the British Se- a r
worth of false defense contracts gation of ISC, Ferranti Interna- riousFraudOffice. th
during the mid-1980s in an effort tional and their subsidiaries. U.S. officials from the Justice d
fa inflate the value of his ISC To permit the government Department, Defense Depart- a
stock and the company's borrow- to file the specific f a c t s s u ~ o u n d - ment, Customs, FBI and IRS also ni
ing capability. ing the racketeering charge a t a are investigating charges of iUe-
Guerin then traded his alleged- later, unspecified date. gal weapons sales to South Afri- b
ly inflated stock for solid stockin The agreement, signed by Gue- ca.
Ferranti International, the Brit- rin attorneysJoseph A. Tate and
ish defense conglomerate, during Stephen D. Brown, but not by
a 1987 merger with that compa- Guerin himself, will be filed in
! ny, Zelnik and assistant U.S. At- court at a later date, Ms. Zelnik
torney Sonia C. Jaipaul said. said.
"As a result of the fraud he During the past year, as the
! (Guerin) perpetrated on Ferran- government has pursued its mn-
ti," in Ms. Jaipaul's words, Gue- vestigation of ISC, Parent Indus-
rin received well over 30 million tries went through a senes of
shares of Ferranti stock, she and rapid ownership changes, ending
Ms. Zelnik said. up back under Guerin's personal
After those shares were trans- ownership.
ferred to Parent Industries, the The company was transferred
holding company "obtained fi- by Guerin to his wife Helen in i
nancing from numerous finan- June 1989, who sold it to then
cia1 institutions using the stock company president Michael A. )
as collateral," said Ms. Zelnik. Peck for $2.4 million in August.
The loans ranged in size from Peck sold the company back to
$500,000to $39 million, she said. Guerininlate April.
The government allegations of
a massive contract fraud by Gue- '
Outburst rin-controlled companies against
Ferranti echo charges raised by
Ferranti officials in civil court
Continuedfrom Page One actions in Great Britain.
The British defense company
, breakdown in s e v e r a l hadchargedlastNov.30inacivil
jurors. ~ l pale,~,,bvi- ~ lawsuit ~ that
d it lost
~ $350 million
ously tired, some dissolved through fraud because of bogus
into tears. one juror, her contracts on the books of ISC
face awash in tears, put her when the two Companies merged
arms around another sobb- in1987. I~
Place
- of
Conference: 2323 New Danville Pike
Conestoga, PA 17512
0 Relationship to
James Guerin: ISC Shareholder
Debtor to Parent Federal Savings and Loan
The following transcriptsd represent a few of the converstions recorded during the meeting.
0
Stan Caterbone - " Chem Con is the big local minority-held corporation that was doing a lot
of Defense contracts-it was associated with ISC. They went under last
spring, beginning of the summer, and there was a lot of criminal auegations
made, none of them substantiated. And I was connected with that. They
sent a board member in to see me a week before this happened. Why. I
don't know."
Stan Caterbone - -
"Jim Christian owned it now I hear rumors that I was tied to ISC and I am
close to several people in that organization. Why they sent someone'in to
California to see me, I don't know. They wobt answer me."
Stan Caterbone - "they wanted me to talk to a guy from D.C., New York, a guy from the
Caribbean. I don't know what the hell is going on."
Howard Eisler - "the supposition was - I don't know how true it was a front for ISC."
Stan Caterbone - "It was, I'll tell you why. Because when Chem Con was started, back to their
inception, you look at ISC's books. They didn't have any money. Well, the
f i s t thing Chem Con did was they went and got all that free money from the
government and you look where that money went. I bet I know where it
went."
Stan Caterbone "this guy named Geurin, James Geurin. And I know that they were selling
contracts back. He runs ISC and he also has his fmgers pretty deeply into
Chem Con. He's the one who started Chem Con, Guerin is the one who
started it."
Howard Eisler - " Wasn't there some allegations about a tie to Wedteck?" (Defence
Contractor of New York)
Stan Caterbone - "You bet. They were tied, you'd better believe they were tied with Wedtech.
The same guys in Wedtech were invoked with ISC and Chem Con."
Stan Caterbone - "ISC is sold over the London Exchange. (I bought my shares from Gib
Armstrong) I owned a thousand shares."
(I
Stan Caterbone - " I sold it when things started to hit the "
Stan Caterbone - -
N
" iust did a multimillion dollar merger with a company in London.
They probably think this is going to cover their tracks.',
'C\ Stan Caterbone - "What they did was, they fronted all that money and started the contracts,
went bankrupt, and now the government is stuck for $18,000,000."
Stan Caterbone - "I know right now in this town's viewpoint, I stole money, I am insane, and
I am a lunatic I tell you I will not condemn Jmi Christian until he tells to
my face what happened."
C)
Stan Caterbone - "I was framed and set up...-....."
Stan Caterbone - "I don? know maybe Jim Christian doesn't have the money. Maybe Guerin
has it or somebody else"
$.fibne of the items in the column (newspaper column) is the reporting of your - somehow
/? somebody associated with - oh, someone associated - in your District Office? Yea. Of
course you were also one of the principals in the - I still am the minor one - yes, the
0" Financial Management Group - there is about 50 names I am dealing with here and they
are all very similar so I have to be --- Financial Management Group Ltd. filed for 202B
exemption. Now all the security sold in PA had to be registered. Some securities are
exempt but you have to apply the detention type of thing. It is a registration, not a
registration that so the 203D exemption was filed for. Of course we have
added the security statement - explanation of where the money is going to be spent, how
it is going to be run, who runs the corporation and all that sort of thing. Now under
the umbrella of this Financial Management Group there is a whole (now I a m repeating
what is in the 203D which I spent some time Friday reading) - there is about 15, 14 - I
guess under that there is about 5 other corporations which are going to be an insurance
agency, an investment advising agency, a group - now a lot of these things have not
come about. Well we simplified it. What do you mean simplified it? They are operating
but because of the accounting procedures they would have been a nightmare with all
those stubs. So, they a r e operating - the only one that's separate distinction is the IRA.
Everything else is operating under Financial Management Group Limited. So these other
, corporations have not really come into being. Technically, legally, no.
I seen also; I guess there is an application for a n investment advisor. Now, if you are
selling securities or dealing with . Now that came in under your name ...at
that time I was President, but now there is another application i n that is being acted on
now by somebody else. There is? I don't know who. Is that for the advisor? Yes, the
investment advisor.
Do your current records in Harrisburg indicate that he is still an executive with FMG?
Yes, because this offering memorandum was given back last March I think, - last August
- when I initially did it. Oh, no, pardon me. We are talking about two different
things. You a r e talking about your application for the investment advisor. No, I a m
talking about FMG - the offering memorandum was done last August because that's when
I started raising the money. August of 1986 is when I did the initial filing for the
offering memorandum - the 144 . Coming up this October is the 203D. 15 months
after conception. Alright, yea. There is a report that is due a year after - Right,
that's what is coming up - to explain how much money was raised and where it was
spent with the idea then of protecting investors. The idea of the your are
limited to like 35 investors. You can't sell to 105 - you are limited. What the state
does is comes in and says, how are you going to raise the money in your offering
memorandum. Then a year after it is raised, or a year after they comc i n
and say, now what did you do with the money. You raised 4 hundred and some odd
thousand, now how did you spend it? Now that has not been filed yet. It is due, in
fact I think it is overdue. It is due October 20. I got the letter right here. They just
sent me the letter. You guys just sent me the letter, I have it right here.
I have nothing to do with that end of it. I just came. well whenever I called you
I didn't get a hold of you the next day; it was the following day which was
Friday t h a t w e made contact.
Our idea in coming here was to let you ask whatever questions you had in terms of the
investigation. Of my limited knowledge of the type of securities these guys deal with
and securities in general, the things that came t o interest me was the fact that there
are stock certificates in here in force with names on them that , that there
are with the annual report, his name is forged by someone else. This gentleman has
some involvement with the original group and the President suggested that he make false
reports to the bonding company so that he can get money back. They are the three
things that stuck out to me as a regular criminal attorney, that I thought you might be
interest in because, but like I say. we a r e here to have you ask questions of anything
that you might.
O.K., this offering then - when Financial Management Group limited applied for their
203D, I get the idea they were going to raise four hundred and some odd thousand
dollars. At that time, they listed Bob Kauffman a t 60,000 shares and you and Hartlett
40,000 a piece. So, Kauffman a t this point is the main factor? Or, when 1 was talking
to you, it was really your idea that put this whole thing together. I put i t all together.
I brought him up from Atlanta to be president because I have a lot of business interests
and I didn't want to be tied down to the day-to-day operation. Plus, I never had any
management experience. Most of my work was consulting, business deals, this and that,
so I actually brought him up from Atlanta to be president. And, Hartlett - is he a
complete local person. He's local. We all started together in IDS back in 1982. That's
your connection with Kauffman. you know him through IDS? He's the one that got me
started in business. I am the one who took him to FSC, that was our broker/dealer and
C 2
we started putting it together. Are they registered as FSC? Yes, that's John Keegel.
This similarity in names is a hassle; you are going to have to bear with me because you
throw these names out at me -----.
So then, you had the public offering which you were going to sell another 120,000 shares
and raise $435,000. That would be in addition to what yon people put in. We put in 20
grand a piece. Well, we had 5 people. You were allowed 5 shareholders - so we put in
5. Five put in 100,000 - five a t 20,000 yon mean? No, it was a little bit more than
that. Three of us put in 20; two put in 25. What we are talking roughly is one half
million dollars? Right. Financial Management Group now is responsible for maintaining
proper control over that money and it would be invested as 5 - now I don't know how
many people - there is roughly 18-25 - that was sold as a result of the public offering.
I have that here. Do you mind if I look at it. That's 0.k. I went through a half hour
of frustration to get here. I wasn't running late until I got caught in the . The
way you described it, I assumed it was going to be in the country and I knew ...I stopped
a t the Post Office. I said where is 2300 New Danville Pike. I don't know. I was here
on Friday and I drove past it this morning. You'll bear with me then.
c This is interesting. I've got about 40 shareholders. Is this as a result of the 203 deal?
Yes. Did you know about that. These are all the ones that are forged by the other
guys? No, no, just one is forged.
Now, yon people were acting as your own sales . Were those funds all
properly accounted for? Were they all collected and put in the bank and the people
received their stock certificates. Uh, huh. Who all would have been in charge of that.
Mainly me. I was in charge of just about everything. Now, we have one-half a million
dollars or there about in the bank account. Where? They never would show me the
book - my partners - never. They never showed anyone the books to this day. I got
shut out literally. What brought that about? They were trying to take the company
from me from day one. I had too much power, too much control. They wanted to cheat
and be dishonest and I wouldn't. What happened was we had to acquire a n interest in a
broker/dealer to assume our equity, to realize our equity potential. So back in January,
we drummed u p this deal with a broker/dealer called and Brown out of DC.
The deal was we were going to acquire 20% of their broker/dealer in return for aligning
our group with them. What I found was - I went down there after about 3 weeks of
them not doing what we needed, I got scared. I had so much money and time into this
company. I went down there myself and found an empty shell - nothing. Now, as a
corporate office, I know how liable I am, for everything, personally. Then what I find
out is that Hebron is a born-again, just like Kauffman. Oh, Kauffman is - yes. And,
is a Jehovah Witness. I get pissed off, so I swing the whole bore, change
everything and I line us with Planner's Security Group in Atlanta - Bill Kaker. Now, in
that group is Wade Webster. Bill Carter - all the former IFP presidents. ISP?
International Association for Financial Planners - the big guys. So, I swing everything
around, turned the whole board over, aligned up with them. The day after I get back
from Atlanta, Kauffman calls me into his office and goes through this spiel with I
thought I was president, who's running the company? I said 1 don't care who runs it, it
just got to be run right and for the right reason. Two weeks later, I am in New Jersey
working on a movie and doing some things - I had my lock changed in my office for
security reasons. I find that they have all these stock certificates and everything that
were in my office. You had the locks changed? You had them changed yourself, but
they still got into your office? I don't know how. They stole my files. July 1, I went
in and took all my files out of the office and went to an attorney, Joe Roda, and
explained what happened. Nothing. I met with attorneys in New York, New Jersey,
Boston. I found all these security violations and everything else, but no one could help
me. Then, about four weeks later. I called the FBC, the NAFC, the FBI, the Attorney
General, Senator, Governor, everybody. And, they all think I am bluffing.
Actually, they all thought he was crazy. They all thought I was crazy. And that was
started because of Robert Kauffman. That's what he did. The day after I went out and
got my files out, he spread rumors that I left the company, that I was thrown out, that
I was mentally unstable, that I was spending money. At that same time, I get
blackballed by all the local lending institutions. They repossessed my claim three weeks
before my first payment, with the files in it, of which a brother of the broker in FMG
is one of the lending officers. It gets ugly. That was before he spent the 5 days in
jail. I tried to get arrested. I had to. Then after you were arrested, you were in the
hospital at St. Joseph. I was coerced into going there.
No, that was my idea. I wanted him in a place where we were going to satisfy the
victim so to speak, and the police a t one point, that he would still be able to work with
them. In reality, he was in the hospital but had his car in the parking lot. He was
going to play basketball and come back. He was not committed. He was just there. I
walked in to satisfy the bail. Are you on medication? No.
One of the police officers mentioned to me that he was and that you are
alright now. Again, this might be one of these stories coming from FMG. What
Kauffman did was, back when they started doing this I had a psychiatrist that was my
client. I was depressed. I mean they were making a fool out of me in public; they were
firing people that were very close to me for no reason other than they were close to
me. So I went to A1 Schultz, a psychiatrist, because I was depressed. Very normal,
given the environment I was thrown in after putting this big thing together then having
these guys slam i t in my face, then take all the credit for what I did. He diagnosed me
as having biphola, depression. My father was schizophrenic and my brother committed
suicide two years ago. The reason he diagnosed that was because I was on a low, and
a t previous'times he thought I was on a high when I put this company together. So,
what I did was, three weeks before July 1, this previous July 1, I told Kauffman that I
went to see a psychiatrist because of how depressed I was because of what he and
Hartlett were doing. They fed on that, and tried to use that to use as their alibi for
what they have done to me.
' Again, t h e r a y 1 am getting this - I didn't know anything to start with - I just haven't
to make inquiry a t the police office and one said that you were taken I was
not. See, that was all started by Kauffman. He actually h e had meetings
with my family to have me committed and take guardianship over my assets so he could
buy the stocks from them a t what ever price he felt like it.
Incidentally, you may want to point out that as late as mid-August of this year,
Kauffman wanted t o buy you out for $2.50 a share or something like that. We have that
documented. Eight weeks prior t o that, I was working with the attorneys to do a 5 to 1
split. That makes the stock worth $25. Either he is ripping me off or he is ripping the
people off who are paying $25 a share.
The offering as you people had it was 3 prices. It was $5 a share. Was that
issue completely sold - that 120,000 shares? No. Was the best part of it? There was
4 hundred and some thousand sold. Did you buy any of that stock? No, I was in the
organizational sale. You don't know how that money is being accounted f o r now. I have
the corporate books. When I went in there June 30, I mean I was in there. I mean it
is not like I went in from the outside; I had a plane and was flying back and forth for
me. In fact, what happened was, I was granted a 60-day leave of absence late June with
pay. Really, what I wanted to do was meet with legal counsel and find out how I was
going to resolve all these problems that I was finding. What happened was, in June I
copied everything in that office (June 30th). and I copied the books. You see, I
developed a computer system. So I just took one of the copies - it was a big system.
I've got the books. I don't know how accurate they are because the way that the guys
kept the records, the accounting is all screwed up too. I have an idea, but I found a
lot of money going to people that should not have been. In what way? What they did
was, there was a lot of Jehovah Witnesses that were hired in that firm - receptionist,
cleaning, etc. Then what they did was replace all the staff people that I brought in
with their own. Then, there was money going out to a fellow by the name of Tom
Turner in Minneapolis. Now Tom Turner was the biggest divisional manager in IDS. Hc
was terminated by IDS in February because of religious convictions - another born-again.
Then I find this guy was making $750,000 a year with IDS and I find FMG loaning him
money? Is that what they are going after - in the form of loans? Yes. And, how much
money are we talking about going to Tom. 12-15 grand. Then. I find checks going to
Kauffman's wife. Large amounts? Are you talking a hundred dollars? No, a thousand
(-1
here, $800 here.
FSC, which is a registered broker/dealer, was an entity started by you? No. What
happened was, back in 1983 I had a dinner meeting - I was running the local chapter of
the IAFC - and I drummed up a business meeting and had Alex Armstrong. Do you know
who Alexandria Armstrong is? Yea. She was one of the most prominent financial
planners in the company, a woman from DC. I brought her up to speak a n d I told her
that I wanted to get out of thc proprietary business. She said, go talk to John
FSC. Now, this is when Kauffman, Hartlctt, everybody was still a t IDS. So, I went a n
had a meeting a t FSC in Atlanta. At this time, Bob Kauffman was the Divisional
Manager for IDS in Atlanta. The next thing I know. I left; then he was hired by FSC to
be an officer and to run their sales force.
Then the idea of the company you a r e forming up here is to invest other people's
money? No, it is a one-stop financial entity - provides services in mortgage backing,
investment backing, insurance, real estate, taxes, lending, portfolio management,
(--') &:how did you get into this? You were an initial investor? No. I've been with Stan
/ since he started in business in 1982. I had come into some money and I was investing. I
had lent Stan some money and things got really screwed up with and all. FMG
told me that they were responsible f o r the money because Stan was an officer of the
company and that they would . Then, after several me
with them, they more or less asked me to say to the bonding company (that they took
out after June 30th of this year) - t h e y wanted me to tell the bonding company that I
gave Stan the money to invest for me and &fm
with the funds, which I flat our
refused to do. As a matter of fact, I damn near punched Kauffman in the mouth when
he was asking me to commit a very serious crime.
February this year. Plus, his salary is in violation of the offering memorandum. Two
weeks before I left, he had the Board approve a salary of about 2-3 times what is in the
offering memorandum.
Maybe this is why the 203D - they're dragging their feet on this. They don't know
what to do. I did all that legal work; they don't know how to do it. This offering
memorandum we are talking about - I just copied this. This is just happens to be page
9 and 10 because the type of information that is in it. That is the only thing we do
not have a copy here of. Well, we have a copy in the office if you need one. It is
public information; there is no problem with it. So are the books public - I got thrown
in jail for trying to get them. Well, we will try to resolve this; it is not going to
happen overnight.
Who is Kauffman connected with here. He called up everybody I know and told them I
left the company; told them I was stealing money from clients; told them I was mentally
insane. I was doing business everywhere. I was doing business with the Japanese; I was
doing business with the President, Stoney; I was doing business with High at New York,
Boston, Houston. Everybody all over the country heard that I was insane. Everybody.
I've been 4 months without money. I haven't paid a bill since June 30. What do I do?
f'\- i
No one believes me. I tried going to the unemployment office. Do you know what they
did? When 1 was in the hospital, that was over $3,000. They called up the insurance
carried and told them to terminate me - my hospitalization. I have nothing. The only
thing I have is what is in this house.
Well, Kauffman comes up here from Atlanta, and he's a born-again Christian, so he
comes together with a group up here somehow. You see. he's hiring born-again people ...
Jehovah Witnesses. Hartlett is a Jehovah. There were more Jehovah Witnesses than
there was anybody. But Hartlett was somebody you brought in though, wasn't he? Well,
what happened was I put everything together. But would it not be right to say that
Hartlett would be your person as opposed to Kauffman's person. Well, it is those two
against me. They are the two that are trying to take the company from me. See, I
controlled everything. Everyone went with what 1 said because I did things that were
right for business and right for people. I treated people fairly and honestly. People
respected me more than anybody.
Did Kauffman in the initial offering that you had, the preorganizational offering - each
of you put up $20,000 - did Kauffman put up 20? He got more stock; he never paid the
other 10 for the remainder of the shares. He was supposed to put in 30 for his 50 -
$50 a share. The three of you put in 20. Then, he had a back agreement with me to
sell me 10; so we both would have 50,000 shares. I got that contract and he never
fulfilled that. I said no way are you getting more shares than me when 1 put it
together. I said you can be equal with me. But how did that come about? We signed a
back agreement so Hartlett wouldn't get mad. I had to write to buy about 10,000 shares
from Kauffman, 50, to give us both 50 a t anytime a t $.50 a share. You have that
agreement? Yes, he never signed it after he got his 50. It was a bad move on your
part. There is nothing wrong with the idea but do you think a t that point he was
conniving to d o - he was conniving from day one. When we put this thing together, I
was in the middle constantly between Kauffman and Hartlett. In fact, a t one time
Kauffman was going over an idea - this was over a year ago before we moved into the
office - about how he could set Hartlett up to get him out. Then, when he couldn't get
Hartlett out then the two of them tried to get me out.
Now, everything is in place and it is operational? But obviously you have a lot of
Ci contacts to make this thing go. I'm out. I haven't talked to anybody? But you did
have initially. You already made them and they now have the - yea, spent 5 years.
But now they've picked up your contacts really, so to speak? Exactly right. They are
acting as mortgage bankers, etc. The whole bit - everything I put into place, they just
stole away from me. See, I never communicated with people. I couldn't, only because I
couldn't find competent legal counsel to tell me what to do. All they did, was send me
bills. I didn't even want to send a letter to everyone explaining the situation until I got
a competent legal counsel to tell me what is right, what is wrong, and what to do. I
went to 3 attorneys and they tell me there is no violation - and I'm in jail for 5 days
for what they did to me 3 months previous.
Even according to FMG, Stan was with the company until July 1, is that right?
Here are 2 certificates, June 25th, signed by Bob Long, Secreta~
I wasn't Secretary, I was a Board Member. And, this is April 24th. 1987 Semi-Annual
Report in which someone - forged my name. I never even saw that. They never even
had an Annual Shareholder's Meeting; they never let people examine the books that have
wanted to.
Of course, all of this would boil down to their getting money from somewhere, extracting
money. Either they are cheating somebody and putting it in their pockets or taking
exorbitant salaries - is business that good that it could stand that? We are paced to do
$4,000,000 PC1 a year, that's a lot of money passing through your hands.
Now the people that are , doesn't it affect those people? Are they
skeptical of what's happening? I have no idea. I know the clients that 1 have talked to
to, that came down from New Jersey to find out what really went on ran the other way
as soon as they talked to me. In fact, one woman got so sick, she went downstairs and
threw up when I told her.
Well, you know the corporation, regardless of what the situation is when there is a
problem like this with you, or anyone, the corporation has to continue to function? The
fact that somebody has signed your signature to a financial management semi-annual
report. I don't know if that is a security violation, in that end of it. If it would be
corporate law, it may be, but not at the security end of it. Well, someone changed my
address. Who knows who gets my mail? I never changed it. From where? From 1755
Oregon Pike, FMG. It goes here; it goes down to New Jersey. 1 never did it; who did
it. They go through all my mail - open all my mail, then send i t to me in bunches 10
days later. This is the Financial Management Group that does this? Of course, it is
coming to you as one of the principals in the corporation, and if i t comes in from their
standpoint, they wouldn't know if it had to do with corporate business or your business
personally. The fact that they opened it may not be ethical, but I don't know that -.
If you change my address, that is forgery. You got to go to the Post Office and sign to
change an address, don't you? Well, I don't know. If you are no longer associated with
them - who says, I am no longer associated with them. The Post Office doesn't know
that. If somebody comes in and says you are no longer here, you're over there - I don't
know that the Post Office - somebody there should not have done it.
These are things that show this is not fabricated or something; they are actually
happening. I got so desperate I already wrote 60 Minutes.
How much money are we talking? Millions. That they have taken? I was Executive
Producer of the first digital movie ever, in the world. I was to get 40% of the profits.
I could have made 100-200 million dollars. I was ready to do a deal with the owner of
Turkey Hill. I was supposed to receive a check in July for $200,000; after he heard the
rumor, he backed off. How much have they squandered? How do I know? I can't get
at their books.
These stock certificates that you Scott Robinson, for instance, bought
42,000 shares. Stock certificates wouldn't - In June of 1987, he bought
2,000 shares of stock. Now the signature that is forged on yours is the secretary. It
should have been yours, but there is nothing wrong with the certificate as such - aside
from the secretary signing the certificate? There is something shady about that stock
deal too. You see this is a year, not quite a year. Would this be part of the of 203
offering? Yes, everything is. All stock is part of the 2030. What I a m saying is, Scott
Robinson bought the 2,000 at $5 a share or whatever; he put up $10,000 and he was
entitled to get a certificate. If you weren't there to sign i t -
Telephone call - someone for Bob Kauf f man
' If Scott Robinson put up the money and Peter Ponderose put up 8,000 shares, if he paid
$5 a share - they didn't pay $5; they paid $2.50. Regardless, they were entitled to the
shares. If they can't get at you to sign the shares -- why couldn't they get me? I was
in that office. Oh, you were still there in June. Yes. Even according to them. When
were you actually locked out? July 1. That's when I went in there and took my files,
when I found out they were doing that. Because they only way they could get the
certificates was to break into my office, because I had them. You had the stock
certificate book? Yes, I did everything - they didn't even know how to d o any of that
stuff. That's how I caught them. I knew the law because I did it. I did the
memorandum and everything.
The thing that is wrong with these certificates basically is the fact that Long is signing
as secretary and at that point, on the 25th of June, you're the secretary. As f a r a s we
know, these things could have really been negotiated a t the end of July a n d backdated.
I am not trying to beat you down. I got them July 1 - my attorney copied them for me.
That's how I got those copies. What you are saying, prior to your being locked out of
this place, they were already bypassing you. They found out that I was talking to an
attorney. Now what would they be afraid of when you were talking to the attorneys.
(- 11
What they were doing. Of course, they do have control of the corporation - between
Hartlett and - I did, I controlled the Board. That is why they threw me out. When I
made a decision, the Board followed it. But now, they are gaining control of the Board
I have no idea. I have never heard of a Board Meeting. Who is on the Board of
Directors? Me, Bob Kauffman, Mike Hartlett, Bob Long and Alan Loss. I heard those
names; I can't remember where. They were the signatures on the semi-annual report. Is
Long a born-again Christian. No, he is the accountant who hired from Main Herdman.
Were you a party to hiring all of these. Everybody. Pete was terminated by
Shearson and I was the only person in time to give him a job. He already had some
trouble with the NASD. He was suspended; it took about 5 months just to get him
relicensed - they had charges against him, allegations - forgery - in fact what he did in
June was he went and used another persons rep number a t FSC to do options trading and
that person supposedly reported him, or wanted to report him - Dick Sherbach. Is he
from Lancaster? - Greek. But he is from Lancaster? Yes, but he was working in
Harrisburg a t Shearson. They fired him in November. I saw his name but I can't
connect it. So many names came up as a result of this - I'm sort of swimming trying to
get everybody straight. It's not easy, believe me. Time is one thing that I have a lot
of - so do I. I can't d o anything else, what can I do?
Did you ever hear of a or organization? Some years ago, there was
some outfit - New Environmental Technology - Remember when that was floating around.
They had a big shindig down a t the Strasburg Inn. A lot of people from New York came
in. The whole thing fell through although Environmental Technologies are is a local
corporation in business a n d they were trying to merge with Shell
Corporation out of New York. I a m not familiar with it. Again, it was a lot of born-
again people that would meet; they would push on the idea that all things stock up.
Well, I know h e is running advertisements on the radio that deals with the religious
sect.
Now, that they are set up, does the Financial Management Group need money or do they
have enough money to operate. No, they've got money. They are a self-sustaining
operation then; anything they get from selling securities they will pick up the
commission, if there is brokers mortgages they will pick up the commission on the
mortgages, and that's enough to keep them going, right? Oh, yea. They a r e not pressed
for money? No. Have the handled the customers/investor's money correctly. No. You
.
i 12
have mentioned they've given money to Tom Turner and Kauffman's wife, what else
have they mishandled? I know the Federal people wanted to investigate Kauffrnan's
books, of his stock book that he was managing. This is when he was down at Atlanta?
No, this is now. That's why they wanted him to liquidate his mutual funds so he could
manage it f o r him. They wanted you to liquidate your mutual funds? I told him that 1
was a little unhappy with the performance of the mutual funds that I had; he wanted me
to liquidate it and go into the stock market and let him work it for me. He was going
to act as your financial planner? I would imagine, yea, broker, buy and sell stock.
Have they acted as financial planners? - Now there license has not been approved yet.
Is the one that you - there is over $100,000 of our RIA fees that they have collected
last year - illegally. Did you say IRA? Registered Investment Advisor. Do you want to
see it? Yea, let me. Who is registered now? No one is registered. I was that close to
getting it registered when I got shut it. It was all ready set to go; I got the papers. I
think it was just some questions. Were you working with Jamino? Yea, he is the
corporate attorney that I got - and I think he is very . He is good. There's
no problem with him. No, Jeff's a good guy. He taught me securities law. I am trying
to think, this application here? Paul Short is who I was working with. I asked to see
the file quickly on Friday - I didn't know it was there. Now I am still President of
C'! FMG Advisory. O.K., now wait a minute - let me see, FMG Advisory comes in yet.
They threw me out of the Financial Management Group; they never mentioned FMG
Advisory which I was President of. Is this the one that applied to - oh, alright, you're
using the initials FMG. that's Financial Management Group? Right. I set up an umbrella
so it would be consistent. What threw me off was. when Financial Management Group
was registered there was a whole lot of other entities involved which used the initial
FMG Advisory Service, Accounting Service. That was for continuity. O.K., then FMG
Advisory Service was never really, up to now. was never really registered a s an
investment advisor, right? Correct. They were registered but not with the
state? Right
But, now, during this time - from the time they are in business, from August of 1986
until now. they have done investment advisory services a n d these a r e the fees that they
collected? I charged some. You are allowed to charge up to, what is it - 14 people? I
think it is only 5. I was careful about that one. I know I only charged 5 clients, I am
sure of it. T h e FCC really gave me a rough time getting that thing filed - I couldn't
even understand their questions half of the time. They are a mess, they really are. I
13
must have spent 100 hours. I agree with you, there is a lot of attorneys work in the
Harrisburg, and the question is the application - the question is about that long and the
answer is Not Applicable. Yea, it takes you 3 hours to figure out that you don't answer
it. I agree with you. I have a tendency to want to throw it away. Well, after 5
months of fooling with it myself, I called Jeff up and said, Jeff, you got to help me get
through this thing. I got to get this registered. I called Jeff on the RIA probably in
January - no, probably February or March.
So, June 1987 was the last correspondence you had. Yea, right there it is. Right there,
it was done on June 23. I am going to want a copy of this. I need to get a copier in
here and copy it for you. I can't leave these out of here without copying them. These
files are just to valuable to me - if they get lost or whatever. You can attach it to
whatever you want, but I want to get a copier in here and make copies f o r you and you
can just run. I don't know where I am going to get money for a copier but --.Well,
these files have been literally all over the country. In fact, most of these files are in 2
law firms in California and New Jersey. I was all over the place.
This is the application for your registration as an investment advisor. I would like to
see what the new one says on it. As you can see, they are all like a standard form.
Like I said, I have difficulty looking a t these things. If I am looking a t something I can
find it, but~justto look over and say its alright or whatever. But I would like to see
who they have listed on as officers. I just looked at it Friday and didn't take particular
notice other than I knew that Kauffman and Hartlett were some of the people. My name
wasn't on it. Oh, no, no, your name wasn't on it. Well if they are using FMG
Advisory, I am still President of that company. Well, I don't know in corporate law
what it takes to do away with a President at the Board of Directors meeting. I'll tell
you what it takes. ----- that's exactly right, but they didn't have a Board of Directors
Meeting. No, the shareholders must vote on the Board. Shareholders must vote and
approve, and shareholders must exempt people on the Board. Shareholders have to vote
to remove someone from the Board. Yes, but the Board of Director would be elected for
a year to two years, whatever the situation would be. So that corporate officer would
be there for that entire period. The three of us were elected to the board for a period
of 3-5 years. The initial Board members - this was one of Kauffman's move to gain
control over a one-year term. Me, Kauffman, and Hartlett were 3-5 year terms. When
did that take place? We did that back in June of 86 when we started the company.
I
. 14
Your only connection with the company now is the fact that? I have no connection.
They will not let me - and I have personal belongings in that office, and they owe me
money. That is something that you two are going to iron out. See, my involvement is
criminal charges - that's how I am involved. And my involvement is going to be the
mishandling of investor's money.
Well, all of these other financial management groups are 100% stock holders - FMG
Advisory Inc - 100% stockholders? Yea, what it is, the shareholders own Financial
Management Limited; Financial Management Limited owns all the other subs. O.K., 100%
- there is no other involvement? That's right.
Financial Management Group's Semi Annual Report - I think there would be some
financial information - that's right, they won't give it to anybody - not even me. You
had mentioned that there are offices throughout the country. How are those people
connected here? Shareholder and they are aligned with us through the broker/dealer.
They go through us to the brokerjdealer, rather than direct. We own 5% of Planner's
Security Group in Atlanta. We get the same deal that we 're supposed to with
Brown with this outfit in Atlanta. They are a fairly large broker/dealer. They are
doing about 15-20 million dollars a year right now, gross commission and
Is it Heubert? No, they are the born-agains that I left, I moved away from. What's the
name of the Atlanta Group? Planners Security Group - Bill Kegler. There's nothing
wrong with that group? Yea. they terminated me for no reason. As a registered rep?
Yep. I am sure they will come up with a reason; there is a reason why they did i t
because with the NFAC they had to file. I would like to know why? You know, you
were termed because you were sick or, you know there is going to be a reason.
Whether it is true or not. Lying has become a n accepted norm for all of this. Well, in
their compliance department, all of these broker/dealers should and generally do keep
very good close track of their sales people. How can they when 1 did the deal? But
Financial Management Group owns 5% of Planners Security? Bill Kegler was with FSC
and got angry when he couldn't run FSC 3 years ago. Then he started his own
broker/dealer. This is with Planners Security? That's right. He left John Keebel
because of a power struggle with them.
But now, other than terminating you when they shouldn't have, they are not doing
anything bad? How do I know? Do you suspect they are? Yea, they terminated me,
you bet. You better believe I suspect. If they are doing that to me, what are they
doing to the poor clients who don't know anything. The same thing with FMG - if they
are doing all this to me, what are they doing to the clients that don't know anything.
My clients are pissed.
So, what they could do is withdraw their money from the organization whether its in the
form of stock or whatever, but there is nobody making investments
Your money is invested through ? I've got the former Medical Director (
St. Joseph Hospital that owns 10,000 shares with FMG that is very upset about all of
this. He,is away; I couldn't get him last night to come to the meeting. They got 35,000
of his. He went through everything from that company - but he still owns the stock?
What did they offer you $2 a share or something? They didn't offer me anything. But
in that letter they did. They offered me when it came time for me to get the check
because they knew what I was going to do. Well, you wouldn't have taken the $2 a
share would you, because you were talking about a 5-1 split. I would have taken i t but
I would have pursued my civil and legal rights and sued them for the rest. I went 5
days without food - I was starving. I had no money - 5 days without food - people
look at me a n d laugh. Did you ever go 5 days without food? when you are worth a
considerable amount of money?
Kauffman told me that he was going to offer Stan $1-1.25 a share to settle it out, to
buy his and out of the proceeds of that he was going to pay me the money
that is owed to me first, right off the top, I was his first consideration - that he
wouldn't buy the stock unless my note was satisfied. You have a note with First
Financial Group claiming they are liable for it. So you took the money and put it into ?
No, I don't know who has the money. A bank either has it or Lancaster Aviation. It
was embezzled from me, I don't know who has it. But they are acknowledging that they
have custody of it? They were acknowledging liability for it. We don't know who has
it. Either Commonwealth Bank has it or Lancaster Aviation, I don't know. But you put
it in the bank? No, I didn't put it anywhere. He gave you the money, what did you do
with it? I gave it to Lancaster Aviation for the airplane. Then they repossessed the
airplane before my first payment for, I don't know why. And I don't know where the
$25,000 down payment is. He don't have it and I don't have it. But the $25,000 went to
7
him, not as an officer of the corporation? To me personally. The airplane is not part
of this corporate complex? No. But now Financial Management Group is saying they
will pay you back that $25,000? Uh, huh. They sent letters to all my creditors. They
told me that on 3 different occasions - before they suggested I go to the bonding
company. Then they gave me a letter saying basically that if 1 wanted to talk about it,
talk to their attorney. Well, did you tell him about the bonding company? Yea. They
wanted you to sort of make the allegation that I gave Stan the money to invest f o r me
and that he had scuffled the money - they wanted me to tell the bonding company that,
which I refused to do. They took out the bond after July 1. I got a thing in the mail
about a bond; I thought what is going on. Then he told me about a week later - I said
that's what that is - a $4,000,000 bond. You know the bonding company? Fidelity.
Of course, I a m thinking from their standpoint - Financial Management Group has not
seen the $25,000. No, I don't know, maybe they have it. They might have it. Well, the
only way they could get it is if it were a reimbursement made on the airplane. They
were the ones calling the bank and the Aviation Company about the plane, asking what I
was doing with it, where I was going? They were the ones that initiated all the
conspiracy with the lending institutions. My credit rating was excellent up until August
I : (
- 01 down the line, never owed anybody anything.
This-is going to drag out; I will keep in touch with you. Now. you also have
investments through mutual funds through Financial Management Group? And how much
money are we talking about roughly? About 170,000. Now. do you have the certificates
for this. No, they were never issued. They are held in with the broker, and
the broker in this case was? His probably weren't transferred yet, it was probably FSC.
So, it would still be a monthly statement from them - so there is no problem with it
disappearing. I don't get anything from FSC, I get it from Keystone - FSC is noted as
the broker/dealer, I a m sure. I doubt that they were yet to Planners Security. I get
the interest off that money, I get a check every month. But your investment is not in
jeopardy now, as f a r as you know.? No, but he is on disability a n d 25 grand meant a lot
to him.
Now, Kauffman wants you to sell these the mutual funds a n d give him t h e $100,000 to
invest as a broker? Right. Of course, you are reluctant to do that because you still
have confidence in Stan. I have confidence with Stan and I am not very comfortable
dealing in the stock market just now. I like more settled investments - the stock
market idea and I don't get along very well. I am looking for safety of my investments.
Like Stan said, I a m on disability a n d I d o need income. And K a u f f m a n promised you a
fortune if you made this transaction? He didn't come right out and promise me a
fortune but he insinuated that I could d o a lot if I let him work the stock market.. He
was doing all options, that's all he does. Well, I don't want no d a m n parts of options.
You look a t his client files; they are all option accounts. All of them, little old ladies
down to --.
Here again, which you know, the broker when he is talking to you, or the registered rep
when he is talking to you, should file a form as to what you want. Now you just
mentioned to me that you are a conservative of man. I had him in government
securities. - And they should have these on file. Now, if you are conservative and you
give him the moncy and he starts dealing in options, he is really violating the trust that
the government and the NAFC is trying to establish between the client. I tell you what.
I feel sorry f o r you guys. You guys got a hell of a nightmare. Stan always backed me
up; there were times I pulled my investments out and put them in CDs for a while
because I was just not comfortable with what was happening. And, I tell him what CDs
to buy a t local banks. I have the utmost confidence in Stan. Mr. Kauffman tried
extremely hard to shake that confidence.
He tried to shake up my own family. He had my own family believing. Do you want to
know something. I n August, I was on my way to Hollywood to the film studio and to
see some legal clients I was working with one day - that night I come back to my house
to get a night's rest. I get thrown in - I go to the police station to get a restraining
order against my family that didn't understand what was going on - I get retained in the
police station f o r two hours, get taken to a hospital. That day, someone called the
Stone Harbor police and said I had a gun and was running to the beach to kill myself.
This thing is ugly.
As a matter of fact, I would believe I am the only one left to believe Stan is still sane.
Well, I caught on real ~ u i c k . I don't believe he had anyone to talk to except me. I
didn't. 1 could talk to him every other day since April; someone had to believe what
was going on. I have tapes - I have a tape of Bob Kauffman July 3 telling a, supposedly
client of mine - it was actually my brother - that I was mentally ill, spending money
that I shouldn't been, and wasn't taking care of my clients. He told me the same thing.
- that Stan had wasted away somewhere between $45,000 and $70,000 of his own money,
just throwing it away on frivolous things.
Every minute I have ever spent and every dollar I have ever spent, I've made money on
anything. I got my brothers in profootball - held my own free agent camp. And, they
were both picked up last week, as a matter of fact. I was involved in that too. Right
there. I thought I heard - is he connected with the Eagles? Eagles and Dauphins. I
r
just heard it on the news - one of those things - I heard the name mentioned, it is not
that common a name, and I heard the name mentioned in the newscast of the NFL strike
and it was like - what was that, but it was too late. That Thursday, right after I called
you, was when I got the call.
Stan held his own free agent camp so that the players who didn't get chances in the
bigger camps had an opportunity to do it. 50 people showed up, from all over the
country. The most innovative camp - I taped the camp, sent the tape to all 3 leagues -
55 teams. When was that, 84? Yes, right there it is. And some of them got picked up
as a result of this? Only one, my brother. I guess they had to have some body. Yea,
that was a fun day that day. That camp cost me 5 grand and generated so f a r
$200,000.00 in salaries for my brother.
That airplane that 1 bought would have made me $3,000 net profit a month, leasing it
out. I had a t least 20 hours of leasing every month for 350 a month a t $7,000, and my
payment was $1500.00. You were leasing it to? My contacts, my network. With you as
a pilot, you mean? No. It's a big plane. I hired my own pilot. When I'm doing
business all over the country I can't fly commercially. I three weeks, my charter bill
was 4 grand for using another person's plane 5 times. Then, you bought this. and before
the first payment was due they grabbed it back. Can they do that? No they can't.
Why do you think I've got a large lawsuit against 3 banks. One of the reasons they said
they did it was because it wasn't properly insured, but he had insurance. The other
reason they said, he took it to Florida. Now I don't know why you would buy $100,000
airplane and leave it a t the airport. Do you know why I was taking it to Florida? I
bought a place on a n island, another very good investment. Now they are suing me
because I couldn't settle because I got blackmailed 2 months later. They said I was
going to Florida to run away and hide. I was going to Florida to settle my property.
They had to come up with a reason so that's the reason that was around I guess. But,
Pete brother works for Commonwealth National Bank. Plus, do you know
anything about United ChemCon? They are being investigated right now by the FBI and
Attorney General. Chemcon is the big local minority-held corporation that was doing a
lot of defense contracts - it was associated with ISC. They went under last Spring,
beginning of the summer, and there was a lot of criminal allegations made, none of them
substantiated. And I was connected with that. They sent a Board Member in to see me
a week before this happened. Why, I don't know. Is this Lancaster based. Yes, Jim
Christian owned it - now I hear rumors that I was tied to ISC and 1 am close to several
people in that organization. Why they sent someone to California to see me, I don't
know. They won't answer me. Who is this, the FBI? No, this is Chemcon. I said if
you ever come back or you have someone else call me, I want a $10,000 retainer fee.
Never heard from them since. Then, two weeks ago, Jim Christian called me while I
was in the hospital. That guy hated my guts for five years. Why, he called me, I don't
know. What did he want? I don't know. You didn't speak to him to find out? I spoke
to him, he said nothing. The same thing the Board Member said when he came from
California. Asked if I could go get ChemCon another building; asked if I would be
interested in saving the company from bankruptcy - I was working with a guy from
Belgium, they wanted me to talk to, a guy from DC and New York, a guy from the
Caribbean. I don't know what the hell is going on. Then I find out the Commonwealth
Bank went and nailed ChemCon. Commonwealth Meridian said Christian personally signed
for the $18,000,000 that was invested or lost of the governments money for these
contracts. I don't know. I am sick of asking questions and people lying to me.
You don't have any connection with that, other than you knew some people? No, I've
got their files, I got their financial statement, everything - they wanted me to do
0 something. But you're not connected with the company? You're not an investor? No, 1
sold my ISC stock June 8.
A lot of people were saying that ChemCon. which is a minority - Christian is a black
guy - was getting all the minority government contracts because he was one of the
leading minority defense contractors around, and actually the supposition was - I don't
know how true it would be - is that it was a front for ISC. It was, I'll tell you why.
Because when ChemCon was started, back to their inception, you look at ISC's book.
They didn't have any money. Well. the first thing ChemCon did, was they went and got
all that free money from the government and you look and see where that money went.
I bet you I know where it went.
This guy named Geurin, James Geurin. And I know that they were selling contracts
back. He runs ISC and he also has his fingers pretty deeply in ChemCon. He's the one
who started ChemCon, Geurin is the one who started it. Wasn't there some allegations
about a tie with Wedtack You bet. They were tied, you'd better believe they were tied
with Wedtack. The same guys in Wedtack were involved with ISC and ChemCon. ISC is
i
. 21
You were going to make copies of these. I can't make copies. I can f a x them to you.
I will make copies for you, in fact, what I should do is get everything copied for you.
Well, no, because that is a tremendous expense. I would rather, if you have the time, or
can stick me in the corner somewhere, maybe say, this and this, a n d this, I a m sure we
can eliminate half of it. O.K.but you should tell me what you want and I will make
copies. I just don't want this stuff to leave my hands anymore. I can get them to you
overnight. Well, there is nothing we can do overnight. I can't elevate your problem as
far as being out of the corporation - oh, I thought you were going to give me a check
before you leave. So, anything that I would be involved in is going to be long and
drawn out; it is not going to be a n answer to your immediate problem.
I know, but I had to get someone involved. I had to get authorities to start taking
action for me.
the FCC - well, he is the one I am talking about mostly. They said
they were sending 2 guys up here last week for 2 days. Did you talk to them about
what was going on? How did you happen to talk the FCC. I was just trying to get m y
money back. They promised me my money and they didn't come up with it. So, I called
them. So basically, you have . If they came there, I think their attitudc
would be well, ------ no, they were curious as to some of the other things that were
going on. I talked to them a couple of times. They were curious for one thing,
Kauffman wanting to take my investment and putting i t in the stock market and working
it for me, they were curious about that. They were curious about the allegations of
Stan's alleged insanity and forcing him out of the corporation, and I think they were a
little confused about why they would accept liability for the money if it wasn't there
liability. That would be a question that I would ask. I think that aroused their
curiosity, but he also said that they have never been checked, and they are about due,
so we might just as well go up there and dig into it and find out what was going on.
As f a r as I know, that is what they did, what they call a compliance examination. I
don't know that they were there looking -. Sincc your allegations were made, I am sure
they looked into some items like that, but I think basically it was just a compliance
examination. What did they find? I don't know. They were there though? There was
two people supposed to be up there. Were they there last week? Well, it was recent,
the report isn't even written, but the report I think will be more on the lines that they
don't have a client complaint form filed - compliant type examination. Proper
procedures, etc.
I am still interested as to how you wcrc alerted to it. I have yet to get it - I was
coming down as an appointment last Tuesday o r Wednesday, which ever day, it was the
next day I called you. I had an appointment here i n Lancaster. I had gotten a call
about 4 3 0 in the afternoon from the Phila office, and my supervisor down there said
there is a newspaper clipping of your break-in of the Financial Management Group. I
don't know whether to make a n investigation out of it or not. It seems there are some
securities involved. The only 2 articles that appeared are right over there and none of
them say anything about it. They just know my name, right? They just knew that I
was involved with the company? - it doesn't say anything about securities there.
Nothing a t all? Then how it came to our office I don't know, unless somebody sent it.
Even if they sent the articles, there is nothing i n there to indicate who - they just
called me an ex-worker. That is the interesting thing about it. "burglary, theft,
unlawful restraint, robbery, unlawful use of computer, criminal mischief, and terroristic
threats." I've never seen the article. There it is, pull them down. No, that's alright.
They were supposed to send it up to me and they didn't. I'm leasing that building and
accused of burglarizing his own building.
See, he called me and said, you are going down to Lancaster. See if we should start an
investigation. Stop up to the -- exemployee. Christian, I think was the arresting
officer? Mathias, they said Lancaster Detective Mathias. He's not, he's Manheim Twp.,
fortunately I found that out. I called Township 2 months ago and they didn't help me.
Then they throw me in jail when my partners call.
So anyhow, I stopped up that evening, Tuesday or Wednesday night, the next day I called
you but did not get you until Thursday or Friday, so that is my association. They were
supposed to send up the newspaper clipping or whatever it was they had. But the only
thing I know is that your name was associated in our office computer file with Financial
Management Group. Your not telling me anything new. But you see I was supposed to
have this. Why I don't, I don't know because they were supposed to send it up. But
the state in their own way to save a .40 postcard, they have a messenger service to
Harrisburg. So, its alright if you get it in the mail, like if I was in the office this
morning and put it in the mail before 10:OO it goes to the central office and gets
distributed - then the next day i t goes down and would be there the next day. But if
you miss that 10:OO mail, it don't leave our office until the next day then the next day
in the central file. then somebody drives it down to Philadelphia. I should buy you
guys some stamp. I had to deal with the State that long so you know these are just
little quirks that keep popping up every now and then.
1'11 tell you an interesting part that I had when I went out to view - they had to
- a n d Manheim Twp. called in t o Hartlett as I was there. I was there to
get property returned to Stan, and Hartlett started going through things and paying a lot
of attention to what was there, and had already admitted wasn't his. There was a lot of
correspondence there, he was very interested in, and the policeman even came to my aid
and made him not be nosey. even its yours or it isn't, and he released everything to me.
Do you know what I took out of the office was on the books, everything that I wanted
to see. Did they let you keep that? No, no, in fact the inventory from the service
warrant, just about everything on here is Stan's files, even labeled as such. Then I
found a checking account, K & H Enterprises, Kauffman-Hartlett Enterprises,
they returned that to Kauffman. K & H, what do you think that stands for? Kauffman
and Hartlett. Well, that's what the initials stand for but what type of business? I
never heard of it. You don't know what it would be? I can imagine what it would be.
A brokers business somehow? It's something fishy. I can't remember the bank, I think
it was Hamilton Bank., Probably Hamilton or Farmers First.
In looking a t these, the only thing I can say, as far as I know Philadelphia is the only
information they had. Now maybe i t came in anonymously. I know a lot of people in
Philadelphia. This involves Financial Management Group or something or involves
securities, because the guy I talked to said, you know, should we be involved in it at
all? Ask what it is, see if there is securities involved? And that's what I did and
that's when I came up Mathias and of course he mentioned -
Well, who mentioned to you about medicine. I t wasn't Mathias; Seigler was involved.
Why, how did they get wind of that? Harlctt and I were there and Hartlett was talking
!
about you taking your medicine. What medicine? , that's a bunch of crap.
That's what Hartlett was telling him. And Hartlett was saying is he taking care of
himself and all of this stuff. That son of a bitch. He is really painting a nice picture.
Well, the cops didn't really buy it because they asked Hartlett to leave and they gave me
the information that they told Hartlett they weren't going to give me.
Yea, well they mentioned the things that you had taken, a couple of items, that they had
given back and allowed you to have them. They gave all the files back to FMG before
we were involved and then he gave me the personal correspondences, but they kept his
camera. Apparently, Stan was doing the policeman's work when he was in there the
night he was accused of burglarizing the place. He took pictures of all his files i n their
office and they said they had better keep that.
This is June 30th. It is my files in their office. That's the night I left. Who's taking
the pictures? A friend of mine. You were with someone? This was 3 o'clock in the
morning. Oh, you weren't arrested on the premises, were you? No, but this is when I
was in the office. This is when they stole my files out of my locked doors. He was
arrested September 3rd I believe it was - this is June 30th. They don't know he was in
there then, I guess. These aren't the films that you are talking about? No, the films he
is talking about I took of my files again in their office, and attorneys say they didn't do
anything wrong - explain why 1 was in jail for 5 days.
This is the stock certificate book here, this big black book? Yea. You are still
connected with the company here? This is June 30th. The funny thing is, even the
second one is not breaking in - well, the girl left me in and she's a friend of mine. He
is still President and a t the time he was still Secretary I guess. I don't think the police
feel too awfully strong that they have a burglary type charge. I know. Well, I tell you
what, they abused me the night they arrested me. Well, the cop that picked
me up here left me ride on the front seat and everything. When I get to Township,
handcuffed me, put my hands to the belt, threw me in a cell, bounced me around the
car. They wouldn't even listen to who I was. I had all the documents to hold them
that I was lease holder of the building - wouldn't even look at it. They didn't ask me
anything. I know why they a r e acting nice now. They are going to hear from my
attorney.
0 I don't know who even made the complaint, whether it was the girl who made the
complaint. You were arrested the next day? No, that night. I told 5 people that I
wanted to arrested that night: I had to. But then somebody had to call the Manheim
police. Do you know what they did? They called up the police that day and said 3 days
previous t o that, that I made a bomb threat to that building - that's what the police
picked me up for. Oh. really? That's what the police picked me up
for. Then, while I was there they charged me with the burglary. They initially picked
me up for a terroristic bomb threat, that took FMG three days to report, they couldn't
even remember when the phone call was, and the person that reported it, I don't even
know who she is - never saw her, never heard of her. You were a t the premises there
roughly what time? I went there about 10:30 Thursday night; you were there an hour?
Not even that, about a half hour. I left and dropped off at , had a drink,
and got a girl to take the car I had, I borrowed somebody's car because my cars were in
New Jersey - I flew back, and got this girl to drive me here and as soon as I pulled in
Conestoga police were right behind me. I said, great, they're here. And when the
Conestoga Twp. cop, I said, let me take all these files with me so I can show you guys
who I a m and what I was doing. Well, they just took everything and threw me in the
. 26
Well, let me get started. I didn't read these letters yet. Read that one letter right
there.
That's right we have that other thing now. Yea, he's being sued civilly f o r this office
furniture here which was purchased from FMG. But FMG then tells the Office Supply
Store that he has not connection with us. When they have my suite of furniture in that
building. Oh, that what the pictures, is that your personal furniture? You bet. I
purchased this in June to go down to Stone Harbor; see the movie that I was working
on, FMG was to get 15% of the profit f o r my endeavors down there. This was purchased
as a n agent of Financial Management Group.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
copyright 2009
HISTORY
In 1987 Stan J. Caterbone went public with allegations of fraud within International Signal
and Control, or ISC as they were commonly referred. After discussions with ISC and United
Chem Con officials (an ISC/James Guerin straw company), and as a shareholder of record since
1983 of ISC, Stan J. Caterbone had a meeting with an ISC executive on June 23, 1987, which
resulted in a 22 year legal odyssey. The discussions involved a joint venture with his company,
Financial Management Group, Ltd., or FMG, Ltd., but ended in disclosure of his recent public
allegations of fraud. Four years later, ISC founder and chairman James Guerin, and other officials
and companies pleaded guilty to a $1 Billion Dollar Fraud and export violations including the
selling of arms through South Africa to Iraq and Sadaam Hussein. However, money, power,
influence and public corruption had been used to cover-up the activities and Federal False Claims
Act violations of Stan J. Caterbone for the next eighteen years. There ensued a total blockade of
all United States Courts for all redress and remedy available in accordance with federal, state,
and local laws. This included recovery of his business interests; intellectual property; real estate;
personal and business real property; his unblemished and impressive reputation; and his most
valuable asset - the ability to produce income. This might be legally referred to as the Right-To-
Work under federal statutes. Notwithstanding, Stan J. Caterbone has never made a bad
investment or developed a business that did not make a profit over the next 22 years. This
includes two real estate properties that were illegally seized through foreclosure proceedings.
Since 1987 Stan J. Caterbone has been a prisoner and enemy of the state. ISC was a
Department of Defense (DOD) Contractor and a partner with United States Intelligence Agencies
since it's beginings in the early 1970's. One of it's first contracts was Project X with the National
Security Agency or NSA of Ft. Meade, Maryland.
In summary, the following are facts and part of the public record regarding
INTERNATIONAL SIGNAL & CONTROL OR ISC:
Once the third (3rd) largest employer in the County of Lancaster, Pennsylvania, with
over 5,000 employees.
James Guerin, founder and CEO was once the largest philanthropist to charitable
organizations in the County of Lancaster, Pennsylvania.
The ISC/Ferranti Scandal was the third (3) largest white-collar fraud within the United
States as of 1992.
The following are some of the public officials and politicians associated with ISC:
George H.W. Bush, former U.S. President, and Director of the Central Intelligence
Agency (CIA).
Robert Gates, former Director of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) and current
Secretary of Defense.
Bobby Ray Inman, former Board of Directors if ISC, former Director of the NSA, and
currently associated and directly involved with Mind Control Research organizations.
Alexander Haig, former U.S. Secretary of State, and ISC lobbyist and Board of Directors?
Carlos Cardoen/Cardoen Industries, a joint venture partner with ISC and arms
merchant for the cluster bomb who eventually sold to Iraq and other Middle Eastern
Countries under U.S. sanctions.
ISC was credited with the design of the cluster bomb, and has patents filed in the U.S.
Patent Office.
In 1987 ISC completed the merger with the 3rd largest defense contractor of Great
Britain, Ferranti International; who paid $1 billion dollars for ISC and all of it's subsidiaries.
ABC News/Financial Times aired 3 episodes on ABC Nightline with Ted Koppel regarding
the ISC/CIA defense weapons; technologies; and cluster bombs to Iraq story and lead into
the allegations that then nominee for the Director of CIA Robert Gates was involved with
ISC and the selling of arms to Iraq.
ABC News 20/20 aired a story on the ISC/CIA efforts to sell cluster bombs to Saadam
Hussein and Iraq on February 1, 1991 days after the start of the Persian Gulf War I, with
the initial bombing raid destroying a cluster bomb factory built in Iraq by Carlos Cardoen.
On July 1st and 2nd of 1987 Stan J. Caterbone solicited the legal counsel of Lancaster
Attorney Joseph Roda for counsel regarding, FMG, Ltd., International Signal & Control
(ISC); Commonwealth Bank, etc., and was billed for his services. Joseph Roda did
absolutely nothing but refute Stan J. Caterbone's claims and would not believe him.
Not only did the allegations of fraud within ISC have to be silenced at a time when merger
negotiations were ongoing with Ferranti, but all of the fraud; extortion; public corruption;
burglaries; civil rights violations; anti-trust and intellectual property right violations; lender
liability torts; false arrests; false imprisonments; as well as other civil and criminal activities had
to be covered up and buried in bureaucratic red tape. Information and findings are still being
uncovered and discovered to this day. Contrary to popular belief, up until 1996 a grand jury
investigation into ISC was still ongoing. It is not known whether it has closed or not. All of these
activates constitute a RICO crime due to the pattern and organization of the perpetrators. The
pattern and source of the activities can be traced back to 1987, with subgroups changing over
time, but still engaging in the same practices. The following plan of action was followed in order
to perpetrate the cover-up:
Totally discredit Stan(ley) J. Caterbone and any and all allegations in every way
possible.
Extort and maintain his net worth to $ zero or load him with debts.
Keep him out of any profession and or occupation when and where possible.
Totally isolate him and disenfranchise him from his friends, colleagues, and family
into a life of solitaire.
Somehow persuade the community of Lancaster County to buy into this plan of
action through money, favors, etc.,
Always keep attorneys and anyone remotely involved with the legal community
away at times when efforts for justice are pursued.
When attempts to enter the U.S. legal system arise, isolate, harass, and extort any
monies and/or possessions of value.
For eighteen years, (from 1987 until 2005) it has always been fairly easy to keep these
issues from court dockets and judges. During these years Stan J. Caterbone had solicited at least
twenty attorneys, some from large firms with national recognition in their respective fields of
specialties. Attorneys from New York City to Santa Barbara and San Diego California were visited
and consulted as well as a group of ex FBI agents who specialized in white collar crime that are
now globally recognized. However, the money and influence of persons and entities that wanted
these issues silence always prevailed. The issues were so complex and convoluted, and involved
such high profile politicians and U.S. agencies, it was far easier to state that there was no case, or
their were no claims that would result in remedy or redress. Between the Republican Party and
the Department of Defense, the CIA and the NSA, there was not an attorney that could not be
influenced. The obstruction of justice and due process in this case is most likely unprecedented in
nature and in malice.
However in 2005 that all changed when Stan J. Caterbone appeared as a pro se litigant
representing himself, without any counsel, in the United States District Court for the Eastern
District of Pennsylvania in CATERBONE v. The Lancaster County Prison, et. al., or case no. 05-cv-
2288. This case is still not settled and has been withdrawn by plaintiff Stan J.
Caterbone in October of 2008 after a successful ruling in the U.S. Third Circuit Court of
Appeals (07-4474) in September of 2008. The case will be continued upon the security
of evidence and the cease and desist of obstruction of justice and due process. On May
16, 2005 at the Federal Courthouse in Philadelphia, Stan J. Caterbone filed the case under seal.
One week later in the United States Bankruptcy Court for Eastern Pennsylvania in Reading,
Pennsylvania, again appearing as pro se, Stan J. Caterbone filed a petition for protection under
the Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Code, in case no. 05-23059.
These acts of entering the United States legal system with these issues triggered yet
another round of attempts to keep these cases from the courts and judges - Organized Stalking
with Directed Energy Devices and Weapons, built on a foundation of mental telepathy or total
Mind Control.
suicide. As far back as the late 1980's Stan J. Caterbone knew that his mind was being read, or
"remotely viewed". This was verified and confirmed when information only known to him, and
never written, spoken, or typed, was repeated by others. In 1998, while soliciting the counsel of
Philadelphia attorney Christina Rainville, (Rainville represented Lisa Michelle Lambert in the Laurie
Show murder case), someone introduced the term remote viewing through an email. That was
the last time it was an issue until 2005. The term was researched, but that was the extent of the
topic. Remote Viewers may have attempted to connect in a more direct and continuous way
without success.
In 2005 the U.S. sponsored mind control turned into an all-out assault of mental
telepathy; synthetic telepathy; and pain and torture through the use of directed energy devices
and weapons that usually fire a low frequency electromagnetic energy at the targeted victim.
This assault was no coincidence in that it began simultaneously with the filing of the federal action
in U.S. District Court, or CATERBONE v. Lancaster County Prison, et. al., or 05-cv-2288. This
assault began after the handlers remotely trained Stan J. Caterbone with mental telepathy. The
main difference opposed to most other victims of this technology is that Stan J. Caterbone is
connected 24/7 with a person who declares that she is Interscope recording artist Sheryl Crow of
Kennett Missouri. Stan J. Caterbone has spent 3 years trying to validate and confirm this person
without success. Most U.S. intelligence agencies refuse to cooperate, and the Federal Bureau of
Investigation and the U.S. Attorney's Office refuse to comment. See attached documents for
more information.
In 2006 or the beginning of 2007 Stan J. Caterbone began his extensive research into
mental telepathy; mind control technologies; remote viewing; and the CIA mind control program
labeled MK ULTRA and it's subprograms.
FAMILY HISTORY
If you listen to the propaganda machine and the community of Lancaster County,
Pennsylvania, including professionals, the family history of Stan J. Caterbone goes something like
the following:
Father, Samuel Caterbone, Jr., Schizophrenic who ran out on his family because
of nervous breakdowns while trying to run a small dry cleaning business. He
traveled the world looking for the Blessed Mother Mary and Space Aliens. He ended
up living in government subsidized housing broke and with a severe mental illness.
Brother, Samuel A. Caterbone, suffered from the very same illness has his
father, Schizophrenia, who finally killed himself trying to live in California.
Brother, Thomas W. Caterbone, suffered from the very same mental illness as
his brother, Stan J., Bipolar Mood Disorder, who ran a lawn business and finally
committed suicide at an early age.
Stan J. Caterbone, suffered from Bipolar Mood Disorder, or Manic Depression and
had a nervous breakdown in 1987 trying to compete in the financial services
industry. When he has his nervous breakdowns, he always threatens to sue
everyone in court and is deeply paranoid in thinking the whole world is against him.
He always spends all of his money during his fits of mania and has delusions about
his success as a businessman.
The Family History was formulated back in the 1960's when Samuel Caterbone, Jr.,
father of Stan J. Caterbone, became engaged in a black budget mind control program that began
during his service in the United States Navy as a radioman and air gunner. Samuel Caterbone,
Jr., was most likely a direct product of MK ULTRA or one of it's subprograms. His brother, Samuel
A. Caterbone, was most likely part of the LSD experiments of MK ULTRA. Stan J. Caterbone is
most likely part of a program sponsored by the Department of Defense Agencies, such as DARPA
or the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA). The facts of Stan J. Caterbone's intimate discussions
with both his father and brother over the years before they died, the totality of documents that
were preserved in thier estate, including service records; letters; official court papers; high school
documents; and the like - all will prove that they were in fact part of MK ULTRA or one of it's
subprograms.
The following are the facts and the real record of the family history:
Samuel P. Caterbone, Jr., (Father) served in the Navy from 1943 to 1946 and
graduated with honors from Air Gunners School in Jacksonville, Florida. He was an exceptional
student/athlete while attending Lancaster Catholic High School, participating in the band as well
as sports. He was also his senior class secretary/treasurer. After the Navy, he went on to build a
successful dry cleaning business, which he is credited with inventing a filtration system for the
solvents. He also developed a very good investment in real estate along the Manheim Pike,
owning several properties. By his own writings and from his personal accounts to me, he was
definitely a remote viewer for some U.S. Agency with telepathic abilities. His viewing is
documented to have begun back in the early 1970's. He also suffered from organized stalking,
and was considered an enemy and prisoner of the state. Back in the 1960's, he was a world
traveler, this is documented by his passports. Samuel P. Caterbone, Jr., may have been a covert
carrier for someone in intelligence. Samuel P. Caterbone, Jr., had his mental health history laced
with electro shock therapy. Electro Shock Therapy Experiments is another subprogram of MK
ULTRA. In addition, and especially disturbing is his criminal record with the Lancaster City Police
Department and the Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas. In 1973 Samuel P. Caterbone, Jr.
was convicted of forging a 2 checks from the Caterbone Cleaners, Inc., checking account. The
one check to Joe the Motorists Store at the Manor Shopping Center was never entered into
evidence, it was for a total of $70.00. The other check was made out to Lancaster Attorney
James Coho for $200.00 with "divorce proceedings" written in the memo. This was his only
criminal record. Samuel P. Caterbone, Jr., was sentenced to one year probation by President
Judge William Johnstone. However, on August 29, 1973 after nine months, Judge Johnstone
wrote an ORDER releasing him from probation and ordering him to "leave the vicinity of the
County of Lancaster, Pennsylvania". The President Judge of Lancaster County Court of Common
Pleas literally threw my father out of Lancaster County for forging 2 checks from his own
corporation. In 1987 I was arrested for stealing my own files from my own company, Financial
Management Group, Ltd., You can research the life of Candy Jones and Kate O'Brien to learn
more on this topic. Samuel Caterbone, Jr., has left enough writings and documentation to know
that his life fits the model for targeted individuals, complete with economic ruin, isolation,
disenfranchised from family and friends, and of course a fabricated mental illness history. You
can view most of his record online.
Samuel A. Caterbone, (Brother) served in the United States Air Force in 1968 to 1970.
In 1991, Stan J. Caterbone accused the United States Government of using his brother, Samuel
A. Caterbone for part of the LSD experiments on mind control, or MK ULTRA. A notarized letter of
October 23, 1991 was sent certified mail to the California Attorney General on the subject matter,
with a return letter from the California Attorney General on January 14, 1992. By his own
admission before his death, Samuel A. Caterbone disclosed to Stan J. Caterbone of the "bad LSD"
trips while in the Air Force. Since his death of December 25, 1984, Stan J. Caterbone and others
questioned the classification of suicide, and made allegations of foul play that was ultimately
responsible for his death. Finally in a meeting in Santa Barbara, California with the Santa Barbara
Public Guardian's Office, an office admitted that the death was more likely due to foul plan than
suicide. Samuel A. Caterbone was also an exceptional student and athlete while attending
Lancaster Catholic High School. After playing varsity football as a sophomore, he had an
unfortunate accident while deer hunting the following November. While in the woods in
Bellefonte, Pennsylvania, his hunting pants caught fire trying to stay warm. It left him in the
Lancaster General Hospital for months, going through painful skin grafts and isolation. The
hunting accident interrupted his athletic career and scared his legs for life. The Schizophrenia
diagnosis was a combination of LSD flashbacks and organized stalking and harassment.
Thomas P. Caterbone, (Brother) had an unfortunate transaction at Fulton Bank that set
a course of action that resulted in a suicide. Although diagnosed with Bipolar Disease and Manic
Depression -- embezzled and extorted monies were most likely the reason for his suicide in 1996.
Fulton Bank was involved in a fraud that took $72,000 from a real estate settlement closing and
lead to his total financial ruin and collapse in June of 1995. The funds were never recovered and
Fulton Bank is a defendant for a wrongful death claim in the United States District Court for the
Eastern District of Pennsylvania in CATERBONE v. Lancaster County Prison, et. al., 05-cv-2288.
FULTON BANK triggered a severe and lethal death blow to Thomas P. Caterbone, and as of this
day has refused to acknowledge any wrongdoing or remorse. Thomas P. Caterbone was also an
exceptional athlete. Playing for Lancaster Catholic High School, Franklin and Marshall College, the
Harrisburg Patriots, and even the Philadelphia Eagles. Tom also coached football at J.P.
McCaskey and Franklin and Marshall College. Thomas P. Caterbone had a very successful lawn
and landscaping business before joining forces with John DePatto of United Financial Services and
selling residential mortgages. John DePatto was the former head of Parent Bank, owned by
James Guerin and ISC. Parent Bank, owned by ISC also foreclosed on 2323 New Danville Pike,
Conestoga, Pennsylvania in 1988, which was owned by Stan J. Caterbone. Thousands of dollars
of equity was extorted in the process, despite still being short sold for a profit to Mr. Keith
Kirchner, an executive of Lancaster Newspapers and former graduate of Lancaster Catholic High
School.
foreclosures, Stan J. Caterbone has amassed a portfolio of impressive real estate deals that have
always paid off in profits, no matter how or when they were sold. The same was true of his
businesses. Financial Management Group, Ltd., was a $20,000 dollar investment in 1986 and
was still sold for approximately $100,000 two years later, despite the false arrests and the
extortion of most of it's real value and equity.
The mental health history and the criminal records were completely fabricated, and a
close review and investigation into the actual court records and hospital records can prove that in
very short fashion. There are TWO (2) ways to quickly dispute the Mental Health History and
Record:
One - Review the word "Delusional; delusions; etc.,; every instance of the word
used by mental health professionals, and the false reports by friends and family were associated
with facts, and matters of the official record, the complete opposite of the meaning of the word
"delusional". And they still exist to this very day.
Two - Review the 3 Fabricated Suicide Allegations of the following dates: August
10(?), 1987 at Burdette Tomlin Hospital (Cape May County New Jersey); February 18th(?), 2005
by Kerry Egan and the Southern Regional Police Department; and July 19, 2009 for the 302
Commitment by the Lancaster City Police Department at Lancaster General Hospital.
The Criminal Record is very similar, since 1987 Stanley J. Caterbone has had 31 false
arrests; formal charges and convictions dismissed prior to court proceedings or won on summary
appeals in the County of Lancaster, Pennsylvania; most of which Stan J. Caterbone appearing as
pro se (representing himself). These have resulted in civil complaints filed in 2008 in CATERBONE
v. The County of Lancaster, Pennsylvania in U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of
Pennsylvania.
The Public Record is comprised of court filings and exhibits in U.S. Federal Courts;
Pennsylvania State Courts; and the Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas. In all some
40,000 pages of documents are now filed and electronically scanned or microfilmed in
prothonotary offices. In addition in both the U.S. Federal Courts and the Lancaster County Court
of Common Pleas there are more than 11 hours of audio recordings; some 3,000 scanned
images; and several video broadcasts of the ISC News broadcasts all stored on a CD-ROM and
filed as an exhibit to some of the law suits filed by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group,
as plaintiffs. Stan J. Caterbone has over 100 court docket sheet numbers in federal, state, and
local courts.
For Samuel A. Caterbone, my brother, there are United States Air Force service
records; Lancaster Catholic High School transcripts; Millersville University transcripts; Social
Security Administration records; Santa Barbara County Guardian and Public Defender records;
and papers and documents persevered from his estate.
For Samuel P. Caterbone, my father, there are United States Naval records, Lancaster
Catholic High School transcripts; Social Security Administration records; Lancaster County
Assistance Office records; Local Real Estate Tax records; Lancaster County Tax Assessment
records; Samuel Caterbone Cleaners, Inc., corporate records; Real Estate Deeds and Mortgages;
Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas civil and criminal records; and of course papers and
documents persevered from his estate
WWW.AMGGLOBALENTERTAINMENTGROUP.COM
WWW.ADVANCEDMEDIAGROUP.WORDPRESS.COM
WWW.ADVANCEDMEDIAGROUPRESEARCH.WORDPRESS.COM
WWW.ADVANCEDMEDIAGROUP.YOUTUBE.COM
WWW.FREEDOMFFCHS.COM
WWW.AMGGLOBALENTERTAINMENTGROUP.COM/NEW DOCUMENT LIBRARY
often the evolution of most technologies born out of the U.S. Department of Defense.
Top Secret experiments and the resulting technological advancements can stay
secretive for so long. This has recently been used in a NBC story of the Television
drama "Medium" this last season. On July 9, 2008 I had recorded an AM radio live
broadcast on WHAN Coast to Coast with a guest that was one of the leading Physicist
turned Remote Viewer and expert that testified to this same notion.
September 7, 2009
Stan J. Caterbone
Advance Media Group
1250 Fremont Street
Lancaster, Pennsylvania 17603
Derrick Robinson
Freedom From Covert Harassment and Surveillance
P.O. Box 9022
Cincinnati, Ohio 45209
Phone 1-800-571-5618
Fax 1-866-433-4170
email: info@freedomfchs.com
Derrick,
My pleasure. Derrick, I was trying to get group rates at our new Lancaster
Convention Center Marriot Hotel last week, just as a little fact finding mission. I
have a theory that I would like to send your way. I thought it would be very
fruitful to bring some TI's together for a conference, unless you think the
exposure would be harmful.
I believe that they try new models for harassment; organized stalking and
surveillance on me here in Lancaster. Remember, Lancaster is now one of the
most "Watched Communities" in the country. "With those cameras, the Safety
Coalition will operate and monitor 165 cameras across Lancaster City making
Lancaster the most watched city of its size in the nation." See article attached,
Watching you: City to add 105 more cameras.
I believe that Lancaster may be ground zero for some of the models of organized
stalking and harassment that we TI's experience and wanted to get some
reaction from Lancaster. Some history on the Lancaster Convention Center. Dale
High of High Industries is the lead partner in our new convention center/hotel. It
is first class all the way. Now in the late 1980's I was a joint venture partner with
Dale High in American Helix Technology Company/Advanced Media Group.
American Helix was a cd manufacturer and I and my company Advanced Media
Group was the CD-ROM division of American Helix. I was one of a handful of CD-
ROM manufacturers in the domestic United States back then. Also in 2005 I filed
a civil action against the lead hotel, the Eden Resort Inn, for trying to block the
development and building of the Hotel/Convention Center, see attached.
Now, some history about Lancaster and the intelligence community. Back in the
1980's there were several defense contractors located in Lancaster, the main
being International Signal & Control, which I, of course, blew the whistle on a
billion dollar fraud and arms to Iraq.
Click here to view the live video of the WGAL-TV News Broadcast of October 31,
1991 the evening of the ISC indictments. The U.S. Department of Justice and
other U.S. Agencies held a Press Conference in the Philadelphia Federal
Courthouse to announce the indictments and $ Billion Dollar Fraud.
Now, Robert Gates, presently the Secretary of the United States Defense
Department, and his relationship to Lancaster. First of all, the attached video is
the authentic transcript of Robert Gates' confirmation hearing in September of
1991 for the Director of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). If you fast forward
to approximately 9:00:00 you will see the back and forth questions from Senator
Murkowski to Robert Gates regarding the allegations by several members of the
U.S. Senate Select Committee on Intelligence regarding his alleged involvement
with ISC and the Arms deals with Carlos Cardoen and the shipping of cluster
bombs through South Africa and on to Iraq. Of course, he denied all of the
allegations.
Robert Gates also has relatives that live in Lancaster County, if fact he attended a
wedding here a few months ago, on May 3, 2009 at St. John Neuman Catholic
Church in Manhiem Township, Lancaster County. His wife has a niece that lives in
Manheim Township.
Now, I'll give you the ABC News Nightline May 23, 1991 excerpt regarding ISC
and the NSA, National Security Agency:
"It all started legally, if covertly, back in 1974. That's when the National Security
Agency, a super-secret U.S. Intelligence unit asked ISC to help complete project
X, a chain of electronic listening posts based at South Africa's Simonstown Naval
Station. South Africa was using these posts to follow Soviet submarine traffic off
of the Cape of Good Hope. To ensure secrecy, ISC and the NSA made sure
shipments could not be tracked back to them. They created a company called
Gamma Systems Associates. In fact, this company was nothing more than a post
office box at John F. Kennedy Airport. Gamma was a cut-out. ... But this
sanctioned covert operation was stopped in 1977 when President Carter, a strong
opponent of South Africa's apartheid regime, told U.S. firms to stop any military-
related business with Pretoria. But ISC continue shipping electronics, some
civilian, some military, to South Africa. The in the early 1980's, South Africa
began to intensify its efforts at ballistic missile development. For ISC, that was a
golden opportunity because on of its top executives was a man named Clyde
Ivey, an American electronics expert who has been the father of South Africa's
missile program. Ivey had extraordinary contacts in the nations defense
structure. Begining in 1984, federal investigators say, senior ISC exeutives,
including Ivey, began regular contacts with CIA officials." You can read the rest.
The entire transcript of the May 23, 1991 ABC News/Nightline broadcast.
Now remember, George H. Bush was director of CIA. "He served in this role for
357 days, from January 30, 1976 to January 20, 1977.[22] The CIA had been
rocked by a series of revelations, including those based on investigations by
Senator Frank Church's Committee regarding illegal and unauthorized activities
by the CIA, and Bush was credited with helping to restore the agency's
morale.[23] In his capacity as DCI, Bush gave national security briefings to
Jimmy Carter both as a Presidential candidate and as President-elect, and
discussed the possibility of remaining in that position in a Carter
administration[24] but it was not to be," according to Wikipedia.
Now, lets get to Bobby Ray Inman, former Navy, Director of the National Security
Agency (NSA), former Director of International Signal & Control (ISC), and
currently part of the Mind Control industry. The following appears on the
Welcome page of my website:
"shadow board" of the company which was allegedly either negligent or approved
the exports." by Wikipedia on International Signal and Control, (ISC).
Next we get to Jim Guerin's attorney back in 1989 through at least 1992. His
name was Joseph Tate, of Philadelpha. This link will take you to a document
regarding Joseph Tate, James Guerin and Joseph Roda, Esq., of Lancaster, my
former attorney who said I fabricated everything back in 1987. The document
contains a letter of September 12, 2005 from Special Prosecutor Patrick
Fitzgerald regarding Scooter Libby, Former Vice President Dick Cheney's Chief of
Staff. the letter involves Scooter Libby's Grand Jury Indictment for leaking
Covert CIA Operative Valerie Plame and eventually outing her.
Now in Austin Texas in July of 2005 I was detained by 2 Agents from The Defense
Intelligence Agency. I was merely visiting a Military Museum, that had old and
vintage helicopters and airplanes. near where my brother, Dr. Phillip Caterbone
lived. I was visiting on my way to California. While inside the museum 2 Agents
from the Department of Defense Defense Intelligence Agency escorted me
outside to my Honda Oddesey and interrogated me making me confirm that I was
visiting and staying with my brother. They caused a problem for my brother's
Medical Practice by shaking up one of his secretaries. The reviewed my court
documents for CATERBONE v. Lancaster County Prison, et. al., Case No. 2005-cv-
0288 filed in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. The
demanded that I stay off all military bases before releasing me.
In 2006 I was telepathic with an older NSA executive on many occasions who
wanted to meet me at the Clipper Stadium who told me he wanted to rent a
facility in Lancaster for a training exercise. I told him to to and see Dale High and
the High Group for space at the Greenfield Industrial Park. He said he was
retiring and that our discussions were keeping him a few weeks longer than
expected. We had intimate discussions of my history and the Chesapeake Bay
Area. We also discussed Sheryl Crow, and he told me his wife was a fan. I turned
him on to her new album, Wildflower, and he said she liked it. We had to
disengage because he was being harassed by other telepathic assailants.
Stan J. Caterbone
Advanced Media Group, Targeted Individual
Member Freedom From Covert Harassment and Surveillance Organizations
Pro Se Litigant, U.S. District & Commonwealth of PA
1250 Fremont Street
Lancaster, PA 17603
Scaterbone@Live.com
www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com
717-826-5354
888-533-3606 Facsimile
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 747
Page
of 2413
748 of 2593
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 748
Page
of 2413
749 of 2593
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 749
Page
of 2413
750 of 2593
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 750
Page
of 2413
751 of 2593
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 751
Page
of 2413
752 of 2593
Settlements for Victimizations and Torture From U.S. Sponsored Mind Control Technologies and Programs
%
!"" # $
&! ! '" !
(- &
#. 0= N
000 &&" " ! & 1#
# 2& !" #
-(-3..A3)(./
5 5 5 J , 5
5 5 5 3 5 , 55, 5 '
# ! 1 1 !" ()$ )+(-7
J, 5
) ! , 5 5
'# 5 , J 5 D , 5 J, # 3 3 , 1 L
,) ?, 9 +
! $ # 4 !5 > ) " ! # (-
& # #. 0= N ' ! -2 ! $ # !
" '# 5 "
! " ! # > ) "
$ : # ! 1$ : 5 '
" "! ) $ @
$@ " # $ $! " $ "6 ! " !# #
# # # 6 # $ : # ! 1$ :
5 ' " % "! 4 # # !# $
$ # 5 ' 5 ' + , # ! '
"!# $ : ! 5 0 :!1 "!# $ : &! " "!# $ " D ;
!& ! $ ' ;;!# $ '" ! ' ;;!# $ , # '
! !# '$ , # ! ' ' ;;!# # ' '" !
' "$ ! ;;!# $ !H " M ;;!# $ " 1 # $ D
' ; 0 L 'K D ! " $ ' #
" . ! : " !# # 6
involuntary psychiatric commitments, and the endorsement and the support for my perpetrators
to continue the assaults.
I, Stan J. Caterbone and the Advanced Media Group, the AFFIANT have, been
arrested, forcibly placed in a mental hospital, physically harmed, assaulted by countless officials,
military, and civilians. I, Stan J. Caterbone and the Advanced Media Group, the AFFIANT
states that my life has been ruined as I am no longer employable, I am workplace mobbed, my
work is being damaged, my family is being threatened, etc.
I, Stan J. Caterbone and the Advanced Media Group, the AFFIANT am or have
become a victim of (torture, attacks, assaults, harassment, sexual abuse, police abuse,
government funded technology abuse, etc., and am now aware that these technologies are
being funded by the United States government with most of these technologies being developed
for war are also now being tested and evaluated per Department of Defense Directive 5240.1-r
Procedure 13 Human Experimentation (on U.S. Persons and others) for Intelligence Purposes.
As a human being and with Human Rights I have not given approval for the use or abuse of my
body in any form to anyone or to any entity within or outside of the United States government
to include any corporation, researcher, scientist, military agency or anyone affiliated within or
outside of any agency, corporation or individual that has resulted in the harms that my body,
life, property, career and or finances have endured. To further state that military training
documents such as the Department of Defense Joint Targeting Publication
https://www.aclu.org/files/dronefoia/dod/drone_dod_jp3_60.pdf; DOD Joint Targeting of
Individual and Groups that involves the United States Joint Chiefs of Command and the United
States (HHS) Health and Human Services involvement, an agency that oversee the medical
records of every citizen along with citizens who are being used illegally for testing and evaluation
of war technologies;
I, Stan J. Caterbone and the Advanced Media Group, the AFFIANT of this Affidavit
do object to such treatment and abuse of my body and life. In addition to the above noted
military training documents that is resulting in the harm to myself and to millions of citizens of
this country I do as well object to the Department of Defense Directive 5240.1-r Procedure 13
that has resulted in the destruction of my health as will where this document has existed for
decades with no oversight yet it still exists as a published and available document resulting in
harm to myself and millions of citizens. The chapter 13 reads as follows:
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 756
Page
of 2413
757 of 2593
Stan J. Caterbone
ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP
Freedom From Covert Harassment &
Surveillance,
Registered in Pennsylvania
1250 Fremont Street
Lancaster, PA 17603
www.amgglobalentetainmentgroup.com
stancaterbone@gmail.com
717-528-2200
APRIL 8, 2017
I have been intimately involved with the affairs of the Middle East since back in 1987 when
I was forced to become a Federal Whistleblower on a company that was for all practical
purposes performing their patriotic duty but unfortunately became a casualty of a
politicized intelligence mission gone bad. I am sure you are all to familiar with what I am
talking about. The company was International Signal and Control, Plc., of which I was a
shareholder and solicited to help fund some operations through the financial firm that I built,
Financial Management Group, Ltd., If you care to investigate, the book titled THE
SPIDERS WEB HOW THE WHITEHOUSE ARMED IRAQ by Alan Freidman of the
Financial Times, you will get a glimpse of the legal quagmire that ensued.
Even more damming is the fact that Former President Bill Clinton's first choice for
Secretary of Defense, Bobby Ray Inman (Former Secretary of Navy and Director of the
NSA) was forced to withdraw his nomination due to the ISC scandal. Attached is a
Farwell Letter from Jim Guerin to the Lancaster Community, which to me, is a
testament to who Jim Guerin was as a man and patriot. I know Jim Guerin and had the
pleasure of having a relationship with his daughter, Bev in 1992. I have nothing but praise and
admiration for the Guerin family. I was born and raised catholic, and still am a practicing catholic,
and the only time I was in a Protestant Church was with Bev Guerin, the church where Jim taught
Sunday School.
Enclosed are DVD's for you and/or your staff, if you care to intervene on my
behalf. If not, I understand. More importantly, last year I watched with frustration and
dismay when the little boy from Aleppo made a video begging for help from the constant bombing
of his home and village. It was one of the saddest things I have ever witnessed. The UN and the
Red Cross were even neutralized in getting in to help. I was happy to watch the breaking news
the other night of the attack on the Syrian regime. I immediately thought it was a very careful,
calculating and impressive military strike, that hopefully will help mend the political divide in
Washington, which so far, it looks like it is. I hope the mended fences don't fall by the wayside in
short fashion. The time after 911 was similar, and it went to Hell fast. Hopefully it will be a
In Addition, would you respectfully take into consideration Political Asylum For My
Friend and Colleague Soleilmavis Liu of China, Soleilmavis is A Victim of Mind Control
Living In China Who Started Peacepink? Soleilmavis is a brilliant author and would be
an asset to our country. Her book, A QUEEN OF THE SOUTH IN MATHEW 1242 is an
enlightening and brilliant read on the beginning of civilization and the migration of
people.
Dear Stan, I like your letter (To President Trump on April 6, 2017). However, I
felt that the following story is also important, which I have been using it to request the
USA government to take the responsibility to investigate my case.
"On the third day after I arrived in Hong Kong, the voices started harassing me
again. They sounded as if they were in the rooms adjacent to mine. Even though my
physical symptoms were significantly reduced, I still had blurred vision and poor
hearing and my thoughts seemed to be tied up again. Why could I still hear their
voices? Did they follow me to Hong Kong? At night, I heard those voices say that Hu and
Bi had arranged the visa for me at the USA Embassy. The voices said that all officers in
the USA Embassy had known me and that if I went to the USA Embassy, they would
receive me immediately.
They even told me that the USA Embassy had prepared a Permanent Residence
for me and if I wanted, they would even prepare a temporary USA passport for me. This
sounded weird because that if I got a Permanent Residence or a USA passport in Hong
Kong, there would be a lot of trouble in the future when I would go to China. I just
wanted a visa to go to the USA. Still, I decided to go to the USA Embassy to apply for a
visa. The next morning, I got up very early. The voices were still harassing me. I still
had blurred vision and poor hearing and my thoughts were tied up tightly by invisible
strings since last night.
I took a taxi to the USA Embassy in Hong Kong. It was only 6AM. I sat in a small
restaurant opposite the USA Embassy and had my breakfast. After finishing my
breakfast, I sat outside the restaurant, watching people on the street. I also paced up
and down the street for a while. Suddenly a man approached me while I was lingering
in front of the restaurant and I heard a low voice say, Follow me! so I followed the
man. I was exactly like a robot, with a complete empty mind as I walked into the USA
Embassy. Even though there were many security guards standing in front the iron
barriers door, they just opened the door for me. Nobody stopped me or asked me
anything. When I entered the main building inside the US Embassy, I noticed there was
a small room on the right side and a man (with black skin color) wearing uniform was
sitting there. It was the security guard. I thought I should register, so I walked toward
the man. When he saw me walking toward him, he stood up and asked politely, Can I
help you? I responded, I want to apply for a visa to America. I showed my passport
to him. He had a look at my passport and told me, The visa office is outside of the US
Embassy. You need go out, turn right and walk about fifty meters.
When I was talking to the security guard, I heard those voices coming from the
room upstairs. They said, Why do you not come upstairs to get your Permanent
Resident card? My brain could not think straight, but I knew my purpose today was to
apply for the visa in the US Embassy. Instead of going upstairs, I walked out of the USA
Embassy and went to the visa office which was in the north part of the building. In the
Soleilmavis went to the police in January, 2002 to report that someone was
following her and using technology to read her thoughts. Soleilmavis told the police that
their voices sounded as if they came from the neighbors. The police responded that it was illegal
to use mind-reading technologies in Australia. In February, 2002, Soleilmavis moved to a new
one-story house. An increase in the symptoms was noted: diarrhea for almost a month,
involuntary hand tremors,
inability to stand firmly on her legs, alternation of cold and hot sensations, excessive perspiration,
and more. As usual, the symptoms disappeared, without any medication.
On April 5 2002, Soleilmavis could not bear any more suffering, so Soleilmavis left Australia
.However, even after Soleilmavis left, Soleilmavis still could hear those voices. Soleilmavis
went to Hong Kong, Thailand, Shanghai and China, but the voices still sounded as if they came
from the neighbors. The same symptoms came back all the time and her belongings were often
stolen when Soleilmavis was not in her hotels.
In August, 2002, Soleilmavis went to New Zealand. Again, Soleilmavis experienced the same
symptoms. In April 2003, Soleilmavis had already spent all her money, so Soleilmavis came
back to China and stayed with her parents. Soleilmavis had more symptoms such as
constipation, faece and piss incontinence and sexual harassment. Torturers started to prevent her
from sleeping at night, or they would wake her up at midnight. Sometimes, the tormentors also
forced her to sleep when Soleilmavis did not want to or they would force her to have "dreams".
Soleilmavis knew those "dreams" were totally artificial and transmitted to her brain via an
external medium, presumably through electromagnetic weapons. The principle was the same as
with a silent sound device which could transmit sounds into a person's skull.
At the end of 2004, her tormentors forced her to have "dreams" every night. These people could
use electromagnetic technologies to transmit their voices directly to her brain. They could make
their voices sound as if they came from the neighbors or from a nearby person. They could also
use their devices to morph the voices to sound like those of her friends or family members. Upon
her return to China, the voices still sounded as if they came from neighbors, but Soleilmavis
knew they were not her neighbors' voices. After 2005, they no longer used the "voice trick",
although sometimes they even tried to make her believe that they were the TV announcers'
voices.
Upon her return to China, the voices still sounded as if they came from neighbors, but
Soleilmavis knew they were not her neighbors' voices. After 2005, they no longer used the
"voice trick", although sometimes they even tried to make her believe that they were the TV
announcers' voices.
Soleilmavis thought that they mostly used their own voices. When they started to torture and
harass her in Australia, most of them only spoke in English. Only one or two spoke in Mandarin
without any dialects. During the second month, more people who spoke in Mandarin joined them.
They also asked whether Soleilmavis could speak Cantonese. Other victims said they could hear
the voices speaking in Cantonese. Since leaving Australia, most of the voices were only in
Mandarin.
About ten people who spoke Mandarin had been torturing and harassing her 24/7 between May
2002 and April 2003. After April 2003, about ten Mandarin voices were used and only occasional
voices were in English. Soleilmavis thought they might have employed more Mandarin-speaking
people to join them.
Soleilmavis efforts of the past few years For the past few years, Soleilmavis has been
working hard to stop these fascist atrocities. Soleilmavis reported these crimes to the police
when Soleilmavis was in Australia in January and February, 2002. Soleilmavis wrote letters to
the United Nations after Soleilmavis left Australia.
Respectfully,
___________/S/____________
Stan J. Caterbone, Pro Se Litigant
ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP
Freedom From Covert Harassment & Surveillance,
Registered in Pennsylvania
1250 Fremont Street
Lancaster, PA 17603
www.amgglobalentetainmentgroup.com
stancaterbone@gmail.com
717-528-2200
ENCLOSURES - DVD'S
Notice and Disclaimer: Stan J. Caterbone and the Advanced Media Group have been slandered, defamed, and
publicly discredited since 1987 due to going public (Whistle Blower) with allegations of misconduct and fraud
within International Signal & Control, Plc. of Lancaster, Pa. (ISC pleaded guilty to selling arms to Iraq via
South Africa and a $1 Billion Fraud in 1992). Unfortunately we are forced to defend our reputation and the
truth without the aid of law enforcement and the media, which would normally prosecute and expose public
corruption. We utilize our communications to thwart further libelous and malicious attacks on our person, our
property, and our business. We continue our fight for justice through the Courts, and some communications
are a means of protecting our rights to continue our pursuit of justice. Advanced Media Group is also a
member of the media. Reply if you wish to be removed from our Contact List. How long can Lancaster County
and Lancaster City hide me and Continue to Cover-Up my Whistle Blowing of the ISC Scandel (And the Torture
from U.S. Sponsored Mind Control)?
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 762
Page
of 2413
763 of 2593
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 763
Page
of 2413
764 of 2593
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 764
Page
of 2413
765 of 2593
re Eric Cohen and Ft. Lauderdale Shooter INVOICE FOR RESEARCH
Stan J. Caterbone
ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP
Freedom From Covert Harassment &
Surveillance,
Registered in Pennsylvania
1250 Fremont Street
Lancaster, PA 17603
www.amgglobalentetainmentgroup.com
stancaterbone@gmail.com
717-528-2200
re: INVOICE AND FEE SCHEDULE January 20, 2017 - ERIC COHEN, Federal Public
Defender for Esteban Santiago, Ft. Lauderdale Shooter
Enclosed is an invoice and a flash drive containing research materials regarding the
Estaban Santiago Defense Using U.S. Sponsored Mind Control. As noted in the following
copy of the original invoice to Eric Cohen, I spoke directly to Eric Cohen and he wanted to review
the attached research materials. Although we never discussed the invoice and fee, I had been
trying to contact Mr. Cohen without success over the past few months, lastly, the past week. My
messages went unanswered.
You must understand, I too have a long history of visiting the offices of the FBI over the
last 12 years. My letters to Director Comey are enclosed.
I feel that the federal government owes me for the torture, obstruction of justice, anti-trust
violations, federal false claims act rewards, not to mention punitive damages for my victimization
of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control. For the record, I have been receiving Social Security Disability
Benefits since 2008 for symptoms and illnesses directly related to my victimization of U.S.
Sponsored Mind Control.
Respectfully,
_______________________
Stan J. Caterbone, Pro Se Litigant
ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP
Freedom From Covert Harassment & Surveillance,
Registered in Pennsylvania
1250 Fremont Street
Lancaster, PA 17603
www.amgglobalentetainmentgroup.com
stancaterbone@gmail.com
717-528-2200
Letter To The Honorable Judge Bloom Page 1 of 10 Monday April 10, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 765Page
of 2413
766 of 2593
re Eric Cohen and Ft. Lauderdale Shooter INVOICE FOR RESEARCH
Notice and Disclaimer: Stan J. Caterbone and the Advanced Media Group have been slandered, defamed, and
publicly discredited since 1987 due to going public (Whistle Blower) with allegations of misconduct and fraud
within International Signal & Control, Plc. of Lancaster, Pa. (ISC pleaded guilty to selling arms to Iraq via
South Africa and a $1 Billion Fraud in 1992). Unfortunately we are forced to defend our reputation and the
truth without the aid of law enforcement and the media, which would normally prosecute and expose public
corruption. We utilize our communications to thwart further libelous and malicious attacks on our person, our
property, and our business. We continue our fight for justice through the Courts, and some communications
are a means of protecting our rights to continue our pursuit of justice. Advanced Media Group is also a
member of the media. Reply if you wish to be removed from our Contact List. How long can Lancaster County
and Lancaster City hide me and Continue to Cover-Up my Whistle Blowing of the ISC Scandel (And the Torture
from U.S. Sponsored Mind Control)?
Letter To The Honorable Judge Bloom Page 2 of 10 Monday April 10, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 766Page
of 2413
767 of 2593
re Eric Cohen and Ft. Lauderdale Shooter INVOICE FOR RESEARCH
Stan J. Caterbone
ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP
Freedom From Covert Harassment &
Surveillance,
Registered in Pennsylvania
1250 Fremont Street
Lancaster, PA 17603
www.amgglobalentetainmentgroup.com
stancaterbone@gmail.com
717-528-2200
FEBRUARY 15, 2017
Notice and Disclaimer: Stan J. Caterbone and the Advanced Media Group have been slandered, defamed, and
publicly discredited since 1987 due to going public (Whistle Blower) with allegations of misconduct and fraud
within International Signal & Control, Plc. of Lancaster, Pa. (ISC pleaded guilty to selling arms to Iraq via
South Africa and a $1 Billion Fraud in 1992). Unfortunately we are forced to defend our reputation and the
truth without the aid of law enforcement and the media, which would normally prosecute and expose public
corruption. We utilize our communications to thwart further libelous and malicious attacks on our person, our
property, and our business. We continue our fight for justice through the Courts, and some communications
are a means of protecting our rights to continue our pursuit of justice. Advanced Media Group is also a
member of the media. Reply if you wish to be removed from our Contact List. How long can Lancaster County
and Lancaster City hide me and Continue to Cover-Up my Whistle Blowing of the ISC Scandel (And the Torture
from U.S. Sponsored Mind Control)?
Letter To The Honorable Judge Bloom Page 3 of 10 Monday April 10, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 767Page
of 2413
768 of 2593
re Eric Cohen and Ft. Lauderdale Shooter INVOICE FOR RESEARCH
Letter To The Honorable Judge Bloom Page 4 of 10 Monday April 10, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 768Page
of 2413
769 of 2593
re Eric Cohen and Ft. Lauderdale Shooter INVOICE FOR RESEARCH
1. ERIC COHEN AND ROBERT BERUBE, Federal Public Defender for Esteban Santiago, Ft.
Lauderdale Shooter, INVOICE AND FEE SCHEDULE January 20, 2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/337072519/ERIC-COHEN-Federal-Public-
Defender-for-Esteban-Santiago-Ft-Lauderdale-Shooter-INVOICE-AND-FEE-
SCHEDULE-January-20-2017
5. Video: Media Blacks Out Edward Snowdens Talk On COINTELPRO & History Of Mass
Surveillance
http://www.mintpressnews.com/video-media-blacks-out-edward-snowdens-talk-
on-cointelpro-history-of-mass-surveillance/224222/
6. Letters: Snowden deserves pardon by John and Bonnie Raines, Philadelphia of the
Citizens Commission to Investigate the FBI in 1971
http://www.philly.com/philly/opinion/20170119_Letters__Snowden_deserves_pa
rdon.html
Letter To The Honorable Judge Bloom Page 5 of 10 Monday April 10, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 769Page
of 2413
770 of 2593
re Eric Cohen and Ft. Lauderdale Shooter INVOICE FOR RESEARCH
9. That time the CIA was convinced a self-proclaimed psychic had paranormal abilities
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2017/01/19/that-time-
the-cia-was-convinced-a-self-proclaimed-psychic-had-paranormal-abilities/?
postshare=8421484844095309&tid=ss_tw&utm_term=.b487b6ae00e7
10. Obama's most enduring legacy may be the establishment of the modern US
surveillance state
http://www.businessinsider.com/obamas-most-enduring-legacy-the-modern-us-
surveillance-state-2017-1
11. The Extortion of 220 Stone Hill Road, Conestoga, Pa by COINTELPRO PROGRAMS
January 17, 2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336832214/The-Extortion-of-220-Stone-Hill-
Road-Conestoga-Pa-by-COINTELPRO-PROGRAMS-January-17-2017
12. AMG LEGAL SYSTEMS PROTOTYPE Mastered on April 16, 1991 at Commadore Inc.,
January 17, 2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336787897/AMG-LEGAL-SYSTEMS-
PROTOTYPE-Mastered-on-April-16-1991-at-Commadore-Inc-January-17-2017
13. Stan J. Caterbone, Controller of Pflumm Contractors, Inc., 1993 to 1998 January 17,
2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336787739/Stan-J-Caterbone-Controller-of-
Pflumm-Contractors-Inc-1993-to-1998-January-17-2017
14. Sam Lombardo and Raolph Mazzochi Charlotte Street Proposal by Advanced Media
Group and Stan J. Caterbone January 17, 2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336787416/Sam-Lombardo-and-Raolph-Mazzochi-
Charlotte-Street-Proposal-by-Advanced-Media-Group-and-Stan-J-Caterbone-January-
17-2017
16. 1999 Excelsior Place Business Plan by Stan J. Caterbone January 16, 2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336719627/1999-Excelsior-Place-Business-Plan-
by-Stan-J-Caterbone-January-16-2017
17. Stan J. Caterbone AIM MUTUAL FUNDS Consulting From 1999 to 2002 January 16,
2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336738750/Stan-J-Caterbone-AIM-MUTUAL-
FUNDS-Consulting-From-1999-to-2002-January-16-2017
18. Pro Financial Group Brochure and Eastern Regional Free Agent Camp by Stan J.
Caterbone January 16, 2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336704842/Pro-Financial-Group-Brochure-and-
Eastern-Regional-Free-Agent-Camp-by-Stan-J-Caterbone-January-16-2017
Letter To The Honorable Judge Bloom Page 6 of 10 Monday April 10, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 770Page
of 2413
771 of 2593
re Eric Cohen and Ft. Lauderdale Shooter INVOICE FOR RESEARCH
19. STAN J. CATERBONE ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP JOINT VENTURE WITH DALE HIGH
January 15, 2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336637179/56-STAN-J-CATERBONE-ADVANCED-
MEDIA-GROUP-JOINT-VENTURE-WITH-DALE-HIGH-January-15-2017
21. 1987 JOINT VENTURE - Tony Bongiovi, Power Station Studios, and Flatbush Films
with Stan J. Caterbone January 15, 2017
https://www.scribd.com/document/336637176/55-1987-JOINT-VENTURE-Tony-
Bongiovi-Power-Station-Studios-and-Flatbush-Films-with-Stan-J-Caterbone-January-
15-2017
22. STAN J. CATERBONE'S Financial Management Group, Ltd., Anti-Trust Litigation File
of October 17, 2015
https://www.scribd.com/document/336637173/57-STAN-J-CATERBONE-S-Financial-
Management-Group-Ltd-Anti-Trust-Litigation-File-of-October-17-2015
24. Letter REQUEST for COMMUTATION of the Sentence of Lisa Michell Lambert to
President Obama, November 15, 2016
25. Stan J. Caterbone and Conflicts With the Trump Administration - Monday November
14, 2016 | False Claims Act | Military
26. STAN J. CATERBONE and the DEPARTMENT of DEFENSE Documents and Evidence of
Conspiracy to .... Saturday November 12, 2016
27. Feds Probe Fulton Bank and 3 Other Subsidiary Banks of Fulton Financial With Stan
J. Caterbone Civil Actions and Mind Control Research of Monday November 9, 2016 |
29. Letter to James Comey, Director of FBI Re Cointelpro Used to Obstruct Justice
Monday November 28, 2016 | Federal Bureau Of Investigation | Central Intelligence
Agency
30. VITALLY IMPORTANT - LETTER and DOCUMENT to Cappello & Noel, LLP of Santa
Barbara, CA Friday November 25, 2016
32. Pro Se Legal Representation In The United States | Motion In United States Law
33. Lancaster Mayor Rick Gray Says There is Room for Improvement in Police
Letter To The Honorable Judge Bloom Page 7 of 10 Monday April 10, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 771Page
of 2413
772 of 2593
re Eric Cohen and Ft. Lauderdale Shooter INVOICE FOR RESEARCH
34. Communication - CATERBONE v. Lancaster City Police Bureau, et.al., November 22,
2016 | Central Intelligence Agency
35. Chapter 12 - ROHYPNOL AND SATELLITE and Chapter 11 - NEIGHBORS FROM HELL,
from Satellite Terrorism in America, by Dr. John Hall Copyright 2009
37. JIM GUERIN, FOUNDER OF ISC, FAREWELL LETTER OF 1989 December 26, 2016 |
Justice | Government
38. CHRISTOPHER PATTERSON Candidate for JUDGESHIP and His 1987 EFFORT FOR MY
GUARDIANSHIP Friday December 16, 2016
39. ANOTHER LANCASTER COVER-UP THE SALE OF THE MASONIC HALL IN THE CITY OF
LANCASTER, by The Advanced Media Group, December 15, 2016 | Fraternal Service
Organizations
41. My Friend and Colleague Soleilmavis Liu of China a Victim of Mind Control Living in
China Who Started Peacepink- August 28, 2016
42. TD Ameritrade TRADEKEEPER PROFIT-LOSS FOR 2004 TRADES and 2017 FULTON
STOCK January 9, 2017
43. POLICE INCIDENT REPORTS OF PHYSICAL ASSAULTS FOR STAN J. CATERBONE 2005
TO 2016 January 6, 2017
44. Judiciaries
48. Torture
49. Stan J. Caterbone on Twitter: "I'm reading FALSE IMPRISONMENT AND ILLEGAL
INTERROGATIONS by U.S. Intelligence... on @Scribd! https://t.co/T3D9nIYvMt
#ReadMore"
50. Lancaster County Court Case No. 08-CI-13373 re PRAECIPE TO ADD DEFENDANTS
COMEY AND TRUMP REMOVE OBAMA January 23, 2017
51. INVOICE AND Letter to James Comey, Director of FBI Re Pro Se Billings Invoice
Wednesday November 30, 2016
Letter To The Honorable Judge Bloom Page 8 of 10 Monday April 10, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 772Page
of 2413
773 of 2593
re Eric Cohen and Ft. Lauderdale Shooter INVOICE FOR RESEARCH
52. Kathy Harrison (KATHLEEN HARRISON NAMED IN SAVAGE SUIT v. Dave Brown)
Email Re Bi Polar March 10, 2005
54. LANCASTER COUNTY COURT OF COMMON PLEAS Cases No. CI-17-00210 and CI-17-
00206 BOWMAN and SAVAGE v. BROWN, et.al.,
55. REQUEST FOR APPEARANCE and AMICUS BRIEF January 25, 2017.pdf | Amicus
Curiae | National Security Agency
56. Family of Karlie Hall files suit against Millersville University, others; calls death
preventable January 25, 2017 | Law Reference | Government
57. Stan J. Caterbone Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Case Filled in Forms January 27, 2017
58. U.S. BANKRUPTCY COURT ISSUANCE LETTER FOR NEW CASE NO. 17-10615-ref To
Judge Fehling Friday January 27, 2017
59. Stan J. Caterbone Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Case No. 17-10615 Judge Fehling Filed On
January 27, 2017 - CASE FILE | Plea | Defamation
60. Lancaster County Court Case No. 08-CI-13373 EXHIBIT re THE DONALD TRUMP
PRESIDENCY and STAN J. CATERBONE as of January 28, 2017 - electronically filed |
Federal Bureau Of Investigation | Nasa
61. ACCIDENT REPORT NO. 1701-029468 LANCASTER CITY POLICE OFFICER REPPERT
SATURDAY JANUARY 28, 2017
62. Lancaster County Court Case No. 08-CI-13373 PRAECIPE TO AMEND COMPLAINT
January 29, 2017 - FILED ELECTRONICALLY January 29, 2017
64. 16-cv-2513 Preliminary Injunction for Emergency Relief in Middle District NOTICE
OF APPEAL TO USCA THIRD CIRCUIT January 26, 2017 | Defamation
66. Stanley J. Caterbone, Pro Se, U.S.C.A. Third Circuit BRIEF STATEMENT OF JUDICIAL
MISCONDUCT OR DISABILITY of February 1, 2017
69. Jeremy Scahill on Donald Trump and the Military-Industrial Complex - Truthdig
In an interview with acTVism, the investigative journalist also discusses the
Letter To The Honorable Judge Bloom Page 9 of 10 Monday April 10, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 773Page
of 2413
774 of 2593
re Eric Cohen and Ft. Lauderdale Shooter INVOICE FOR RESEARCH
71. Pennsylvania State Police Liquor Control Enforcement Formal Complaint AGAINST
DOWNTOWN LANCASTER BARS, August 12, 2016 | Lawsuit | United States Courts Of
Appeals
73. Torture LAW and the United States - Wikipedia by Stan J. Caterbone and ADVANCED
MEDIA GROUP, February 4, 2017
74. CI-16-08472 DOCKET SHEET February 3, 2017 and Torture LAW and the United
States - Wikipedia by Stan J. Caterbone and ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP, February 4,
2017
75. LIP News - CORRUPTION IN THE LANCASTER CITY POLICE DEPARTMENT AND LNP -
February 4, 2017
78. 16-Cv-2513 Preliminary Injunction for EMERGENCY RELIEF in Middle District ORDER
by JUDGE KANE TRANSFER to EASTERN DISTRICT PHIL January 31, 2017
82. Third Circuit Senior Judge Maryanne Trump Barry, who is President Donald
Trump’s older sister, decided this week to go inactive on the bench, relinquishing
her staff and chambers despite being scheduled to hear cases this year.
83. STAN J. CATERBONE June 18, 2008 US District Court Case 08-02982 CATERBONE v.
Lancaster City Police Bureau, et.al., CASE FILE | Complaint
Letter To The Honorable Judge Bloom Page 10 of 10 Monday April 10, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 774Page
of 2413
775 of 2593
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 775
Page
of 2413
776 of 2593
by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
Stan J. Caterbone
ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP
Freedom From Covert Harassment &
Surveillance,
Registered in Pennsylvania
1250 Fremont Street
Lancaster, PA 17603
www.amgglobalentetainmentgroup.com
stancaterbone@gmail.com
717-528-2200
Eric Cohen
Robert Berube
Federal Public Defenders
150 W. Flagler Street
Suite 1700
Miami, FL 33130-1556
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
TESTIMONY CHANGED TO RESEARCH SJC
EXPERT TESTIMONY FEE SCHEDULE - $50,000.00
Following is attached File List of 1209 files and over 13,000 BOOKMARKS of RESEARCH
MATERIALS WITH AUDIO AND VIDEOS sent via US Priority Mail 9505 5165 0616 7019
0008 77 and the letter to Eric Cohen. Phone calls were made on Thursday January 19,
2017 regarding the information submitted.
INVOICE FEE - Estaban Santiago Defense Page 1 of 415 Friday January 20, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 776Page
of 2413
777 of 2593
by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
___________/S/____________
Stan J. Caterbone, Pro Se Litigant
ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP
Freedom From Covert Harassment & Surveillance,
Registered in Pennsylvania
1250 Fremont Street
Lancaster, PA 17603
www.amgglobalentetainmentgroup.com
stancaterbone@gmail.com
717-528-2200
Notice and Disclaimer: Stan J. Caterbone and the Advanced Media Group have been slandered, defamed, and
publicly discredited since 1987 due to going public (Whistle Blower) with allegations of misconduct and fraud
within International Signal & Control, Plc. of Lancaster, Pa. (ISC pleaded guilty to selling arms to Iraq via
South Africa and a $1 Billion Fraud in 1992). Unfortunately we are forced to defend our reputation and the
truth without the aid of law enforcement and the media, which would normally prosecute and expose public
corruption. We utilize our communications to thwart further libelous and malicious attacks on our person, our
property, and our business. We continue our fight for justice through the Courts, and some communications
are a means of protecting our rights to continue our pursuit of justice. Advanced Media Group is also a
member of the media. Reply if you wish to be removed from our Contact List. How long can Lancaster County
and Lancaster City hide me and Continue to Cover-Up my Whistle Blowing of the ISC Scandel (And the Torture
from U.S. Sponsored Mind Control)?
INVOICE FEE - Estaban Santiago Defense Page 2 of 415 Friday January 20, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 777Page
of 2413
778 of 2593
by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
Estaban Santiago
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page31of
of415
40 Thursday
Friday January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 778
Page
of 2413
779 of 2593
by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
Estaban Santiago
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page42of
of415
40 Thursday
Friday January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 779
Page
of 2413
780 of 2593
by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
Estaban Santiago
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page53of
of415
40 Thursday
Friday January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 780
Page
of 2413
781 of 2593
by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
Estaban Santiago
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page64of
of415
40 Thursday
Friday January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 781
Page
of 2413
782 of 2593
1209 Files
Number Name Date created Extension by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page75
1of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 782Page
of 2413
783 of 2593
19.01.2017 mp3 by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
00000036 4. Audio of Call to KENS TV5 re Broadcast of Dr. John Hall March 8, 2010.mp319.01.2017 mp3
00000037 5. Audio of FFCHS Conference Call with Orville re Survey of TI's on Surge of EXTREME PAIN and TERROR on
March 11, 2010.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000038 6. AUDIO of Fulton Bank Harassment on EXTREME PAIN and TERROR on March 11, 2010.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000039 7. Audio Recordings of 1987 - PA SEC-PA Atty Gen-Gamillion Film Studios-Power Station Studios-Sandra Gray
Atty.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000040 8. Call to Assistant U.S. Attorney Chrystie Fawcett During Serving of 302 Petition on April 8, 2010.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000041 9. Conversation and Plea for Help with Pennsylvania Attorney Bodan on October 19, 1987.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000042 10. Conversation With Attorney David Drubner on July 10, 1987.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000043 11. Conversation With Lancaster Aviation President Chuck Smith re Illegal Reposession of Aircraft on _0.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000044 12. Dr. John Hall Radio Show of FFCHS Press Conference of April 19, 2010 in Louisville Kentucky.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000045 13. FFCHS Conference Call re Takeover December 15, 2015.WAV 19.01.2017 wav
00000046 14. Harassment and Malic at NovaCare Rehabilitation for Physical Therapy on April 1, 2010.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000047 15. Meeting With Attorney Sandra Grey in San Diego on February 24, 1988.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000048 16. Meeting with Howard Eisler, Investigator With The Pennsylvania Securities Commission re ISC of September
29, 1987.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000049 17. Meeting With Pennsylvania Securities Commission Agent Howard Eisler of September 29, 1987.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000050 18. Message from Liapatt Attorney Julie Cooper re Email March 15, 2010.WAV19.01.2017 wav
00000051 19. Message From Lt. Detective Clark Bearinger re Psychiatric Appointment of April 23, 2010.WAV
19.01.2017 wav
00000052 20. My Appearence on FFCHS Talkshoe Conference with Orville April 1, 2010 Online Chat.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000053 21. Phone Conversation With Pennsylvania Securities Commission Agent Howard Eisler on October 17,
1987.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000054 22. Recording of Dale Graff on Coast to Coast re Remote Viewing - Project Stargate - DIA with My Commentary
February 17, 2010.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000055 23. Return Call from U.S. Attorney Christie Fawcett on February 22, 2010 9-58AM.mp3 19.01.2017
mp3
00000056 24. Second Conversation With Atty Drubner & Meeting With Film Studio Gamillion Studios of Hollywood
Jul_0.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000057 25. Segments of My Appearence and Interview on FFCHS Talkshoe Conference with Orville April 1, 2010.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000058 26. Sgt. Busser of Southern Regional Police 302 Fleeing Arrest AUDIO Recording With Commentary of
Apr_0.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000059 27. The Jim Guest Show Week 3 with Dr. Hall and Dr. Robertson re Electromagnetic Weapons November 29,
2009.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000060 29. TS-340595 4-01-2010-My Appearence on FFCHS Talkshoe Conference with Orville April 1, 2010 Online
Chat.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000061 30. FMG Video St Joseph Hospital George Werner April 1987.avi 19.01.2017 avi
00000062 31. FMG Video II St Joseph Hospital George Werner April 1987.avi 19.01.2017 avi
00000063 32. Julianne McKinney interview by Greg Syzmanski, Gang Stalking and Electronic Torture April 2006.WAV
19.01.2017 wav
00000064 33. Tour of Sam Caterbone Cleaners 1470 Manhiem Pike, Lancaster, PA August 11, 2016.mp4
19.01.2017 mp4
00000065 34. Video of the Movie IN YOUR EYES about 2 People That Are Telepathic Made In 2013, Published June 18,
2016.mp4 19.01.2017 mp4
00000066 35. Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 9 Capabilities Profile video-2010-02-06-14-33-28.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
00000067 36. Karen Stewert NSA Whistleblower Describing the ATTEMPT TO MURDER Certain TI's Like Me (Stan
Caterbone) Using Electromagnetic Weapons May 9, 2016.mp4 19.01.2017 mp4
00000068 37. James Doran, Suspected TI, Breaking and Entering 220 Stone Hill Road on April 7, 2006 by Security
Camera.avi 19.01.2017 avi
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page86
2of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 783Page
of 2413
784 of 2593
December 5, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
00000071 1-The Surreptitious Reincarnation of COINTELPRO with the COPS Gang-Stalking Program - Lancaster City Police
Stregic Plan, August 24, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000072 2-STAN J. CATERBONE and CONFLICTS WITH THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION - Monday November 14, 2016.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000073 3-FALSE IMPRISONMENT AND ILLEGAL INTERROGATIONS by U.S. Intelligence Agencies November 12, 2016.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000074 4-Amici Curiae Filed by Stan J. Caterbone 2007 to 2016 - Kathleen Kane - The National Security Agency NSA -
Lisa Michelle Lambert - Mehgan Liappatt - May 18, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000075 5-FEDS PROBE FULTON BANK and 3 other SUBSIDIARY BANKS of FULTON FINANCIAL with STAN J. CATERBONE
CIVIL ACTIONS and Mind Control Research of November 7, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000076 6-Stan J. Caterbone LOCAL, STATE, and FEDERAL COURT DOCKET SHEETS as of November 12, 2016.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000077 7-Stan J. Caterbone United Nations Human Rights Council of Geneva Switzerland Complaint and Exhibit re U.S.
Sponsored Mind Control, Oct 4, 2009.pdf.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000078 8-CATERBONE v. the United States of America, et.al., COMPLAINT July 20, 2016 ver 3.0 July 22, 2016.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000079 9-MEMORANDUM FOR PRESIDENT OBAMA re Leniency for Edward Snowden by 15 FORMER INTELLIGENCE
MEMBERS November 28, 2016 with Director Comey Letter December 1, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000080 10-Superior Court Case No. Case No. 1219 MDA 2016 BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF APPEAL AND GRANTING OF
INJUNCTION Thursday December 1, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000081 11-Superior Court Case No. Case No. 1219 MDA 2016 MOTION TO CLARIFY RECORD FROM LOWER COURT
December 2, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000082 12-Superior Court of Pennsylvania Case No. 3576 EDA 2016 REQUEST FOR APPEARANCE re Kathleen Kane
Amicus in Support of Motion to DISMISS November 30, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000083 13 - Advanced Media Group ORIGINAL INVOICES and ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLES for November 30, 2016
Updated December 1, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000084 14-Invoice to SECRETARY OF DEFENSE ASH CARTER for Victimization of U.S. Sponsored Torture Program
December 2, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000085 15-LETTER and DOCUMENT to Cappello & Noel, LLP of Santa Barbara, CA Friday November 25, 2016.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000086 16 - Southern Regional Police Incident Reports of 2004 to 2006 at 220 Stone Hill Road May 27 2006.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000087 16-Federal False Claim Act Filing of October 19 2006 4200 AUTHENTIC ORIGINAL DOCUMENTS November 26,
2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000088 17-Stan J. Caterbone BOOKMARKS and HISTORY January 17, 2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000089 18-Supreme Court of the United States Case No. 16-8822 COMPLETE FILE re CATERBONE v. Allison Hallet, re
Lisa Lambert Habeus November 22, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000090 19-Samuel Caterbone Jr Naval Air Gunners School Honors 1943.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000091 20-Samuel Caterbone Jr Naval Air Gunners School Certificate 1.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000092 21-Naval Air Gunners Training Manual June 1 1943.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000093 22-Samuel P. Caterbone (My Father) Criminal Charges.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000094 23-Naval Air Technical Training Center Photo Album.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000095 24-Samuel Caterbone Naval Air Gunners Honors 1943.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000096 25-Dismissed Criminal Charges April 6 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000097 26-1975 United States Senate Select Hearings on MKultra.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000098 27-ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP - Mark Zuckerberg and his FACEBOOK MIND CONTROL STRATEGIES and KNOWN
ATHEIST Tuesday August 30, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000099 28-Authentic and ORIGINAL Documents of 1987 RESTORED ON DECEMBER 15, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000100 29-Calhoun Private Criminal Complaint Sept 22 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000101 30-Dave Plummer offers counsel in a crisis.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000102 31-David Schuyler Franklin & Marshall - Reunion 2007 Schedule of Events.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000103 32-Electronic Mind Control & Timothy McVeigh jan 3 2008.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000104 33-Email to Paul Cambell re 3179-06 Appeal April 5 2008 CORRUPTION IN THE FLEEING CRIMINAL CASE AND
APPEAL June 28, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000105 34-Exhibit D of Duke Street Samuel Caterbone Criminal File Mar 4, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000106 35-Letter to Epic Card re Complaint of Bonnie Lee Polygraph Solutions August11, 2015.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000107 36-JIM GUERIN, FOUNDER OF ISC, FAREWELL LETTER OF 1989 December 26, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000108 37-LETTER to Bishop Nicholas C. Dattilo re PAIN AND SUFFERING of February 19, 1998.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000109 38-STAN J. CATERBONE and ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP LITIGATION VALUATION SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS as
of December 27, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000110 39-UPDATED - EXCLUSIVE Transcripts of Whistleblower Testimonies as Targeted Individuals of U.S. Sponsored
Mind Control and Related Lectures, December 27, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000111 40-UPDATED STATEMENT OF FACTS re CATERBONE v. Lancaster City Police Department US District Court Case
08-cv-08982 December 28, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page97
3of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 784Page
of 2413
785 of 2593
00000112 41-15 FACTS TO SUPPORT THE EVIDENCE by Stan J. Caterbone
OF U.S. andMIND
SPONSORED Advanced Media
CONTROL Group - CONFIDENTIAL
THRIVING IN LANCASTER,
PENNSYLVANIA - December 29, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000113 42-CHRISTOPHER PATTERSON Candidate for JUDGESHIP and His 1987 EFFORT FOR MY GUARDIANSHIP Friday
December 16, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000114 43-Mental Illness Argument with Descriptions of Illneses and Complete Mental Health Record December 30,
2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000115 44-SHERYL CROW DOCUMENTS January 2, 2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000116 45-POLICE INCIDENT REPORTS OF PHYSICAL ASSAULTS FOR STAN J. CATERBONE 2005 TO 2016 January 6,
2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000117 46-U.S. FEDERAL COURT DOCKET REPORTS AS OF JANUARY 4, 2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000118 47-Case No. 16-2513 Preliminary Injunction Middle District EXHIBIT re FT. LAUDERDALE SHOOTER AND U.S.
SPONSORED MIND CONTROL January 9, 2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000119 48-AMICUS FILE - Ft. Lauderdale Airport shooting of Friday January 6, 2017 suspect complained of mind control
- by STAN J CATERBONE and Advanced Media Group January 9, 2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000120 49-Blue Lives Matter bill would make crimes against police a hate crime in Pa., advocacy groups push back by
State Rep David Zimmerman R-Lancaster County LNP January 10, 2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000121 50-TD Ameritrade TRADEKEEPER PROFIT-LOSS FOR 2004 TRADES and 2017 FULTON STOCKE January 9,
2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000122 51-Usage Statistics for www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com TOTALS and MONTHLY From May of 2016 to
January 2017 - January 10, 2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000123 52-WHISTLEBLOWERS KAREN STEWART AND STAN CATERBONE A Candid Discussion of Electronic Harassment
Protocols, January 11, 2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000124 53-Social Security Application For Benefits April 8, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000125 54-PRESIDENT OBAMA DEFENDANT EXHIBIT of October 23, 2015 RECONSTRUCTED JANUARY 14, 2017.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000126 55-1987 JOINT VENTURE - Tony Bongiovi, Power Station Studios, and Flatbush Films with Stan J. Caterbone
January 15, 2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000127 56-STAN J. CATERBONE ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP JOINT VENTURE WITH DALE HIGH January 15, 2017.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000128 57-STAN J. CATERBONE'S Financial Management Group, Ltd., Anti-Trust Litigation File of October 17, 2015.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000129 58-Institutional Investors Mortgage Banking Business Development of 1987 January 15, 2017.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000130 59-Pro Financial Group Brochure and Eastern Regional Free Agent Camp by Stan J. Caterbone January 16,
2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000131 60-1999 Excelsior Place Business Plan by Stan J. Caterbone January 16, 2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000132 61-Stan J. Caterbone AIM MUTUAL FUNDS Consulting From 1999 to 2002 January 16, 2017.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000133 62-Sam Lombardo and Raolph Mazzochi Charlotte Street Proposal by Advanced Media Group and Stan J.
Caterbone January 17, 2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000134 63-B2B Consulting From 1999 to 2002 January 16, 2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000135 64-LETTER TO U.S. CONGRESSMAN ROBERT WALKER and PLEADING of July 7, 1991 Bookmarked January 17,
2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000136 65-AMG LEGAL SYSTEMS PROTOTYPE Mastered on April 16, 1991 at Commadore Inc., January 17, 2017.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000137 66-Legal Implications of the 1959 Soviet Microwave Bombardment of the U.S Embassy January 17, 2017.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000138 67-Stan J. Caterbone, Controller of Pflumm Contractors, Inc., 1993 to 1998 January 17, 2017.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000139 68-THE EXTORTION of 220 Stone Hill Road, Conestoga, PA by COINTELPRO PRGRAMS January 17, 2017.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page10
8
4 of 24
40
415 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 785Page
of 2413
786 of 2593
00000146 7. dated January 12, 2017 RESPONSE by Stan J.
LETTER to Caterbone
the Judicialand Advanced
Conduct Board Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
for COMPLAINT No. 2016-788 for
JUDGE ASHWORTH and 2016-789 for JUDGE REINAKER.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000147 8. JANUARY 13, 2017 Lancaster County Court Case No. 08-CI-13373 re EXHIBIT.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000148 9. Superior Court of Pennsylvania Case No. 3575 EDA 2016 EXHIBT 16-cv-4014 AMENDED COMPLAINT DVD re
Kathleen Kane Amicus January 18, 2017.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page11
9
5 of 24
40
415 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 786Page
of 2413
787 of 2593
00000195 Coast to Coast by Stan
- Sep 03 2009 - Dr. Laurie J. Caterbone
Nadel Hour 2.mp3and Advanced Media
19.01.2017 mp3 Group - CONFIDENTIAL
00000196 Coast to Coast - Sep 03 2009 -Dr. Laurie Nadel Hour 3.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000197 Coast to Coast - Sep 03 2009 -Joshua P. Warren Hour 4.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000198 Coast to Coast AM - Military Technology & War Scenarios December 29, 2009 - Hour 2.mp3 19.01.2017
mp3
00000199 Coast to Coast AM - Military Technology & War Scenarios December 29, 2009- Hour 3.mp3 19.01.2017
mp3
00000200 Coast to Coast AM - Military Technology & War Scenarios December 29, 2009- Hour 4.mp3 19.01.2017
mp3
00000201 Coast to Coast AM - Military Technology & War Scenarios December 29, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000202 Coast to Coast AM - Remote Viewing Updates Show January 4, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000203 Coast to Coast AM - Remote Viewing Updates Show With Ed Dames January 4, 2010 - Hour 1.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000204 Coast to Coast AM - Remote Viewing Updates Show With Ed Dames January 4, 2010 - Hour 2.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000205 Coast to Coast AM - Remote Viewing Updates Show With Ed Dames January 4, 2010 - Hour 3.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000206 Coast to Coast AM - Remote Viewing Updates Show With Ed Dames January 4, 2010 - Hour 4.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000207 Coast to Coast AM - The Antidepressant Myth January 23, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000208 Coast to Coast AM Dr. Nick Begich June 3, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000209 Coast to Coast AM Electronic Harassment - Show with Dr. John Hall Feb 08 2010 - Hour 1.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000210 Coast to Coast AM Electronic Harassment - Show with Dr. John Hall Feb 08 2010 - Hour 2.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000211 Coast to Coast AM Electronic Harassment - Show with Dr. John Hall Feb 08 2010 - Hour 3.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000212 Coast to Coast AM Electronic Harassment - Show with Dr. John Hall Feb 08 2010 - Hour 4.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000213 Coast to Coast AM Electronic Harassment - Show with Dr. John Hall February 9, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000214 Coast to Coast AM Electronic Harassment - Show with Dr. John Hall on Monday, February 8, 2010 Important.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000215 Coast to Coast AM Electronic Harassment - Show with Dr. John Hall on Monday, February 8, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000216 Coast to Coast AM Intuition & Frequencies December 3, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000217 Coast to Coast AM Malinda Leslie ET Abductions & Milatary Covert Ops Dad January 21, 2010 Hour 1.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000218 Coast to Coast AM Malinda Leslie ET Abductions & Milatary Covert Ops Dad January 21, 2010 Hour 2.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000219 Coast to Coast AM Malinda Leslie ET Abductions & Milatary Covert Ops Dad January 21, 2010 Hour 3.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000220 Coast to Coast AM Malinda Leslie ET Abductions & Milatary Covert Ops Dad January 21, 2010 Hour 4.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000221 Coast to Coast AM Malinda Leslie ET Abductions & Milatary Covert Ops Dad January 21, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000222 Coast to Coast AM with George Noory and David Wilcock October 6, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000223 Coast to Coast AM with George Noory Schedule for February 8, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000224 Coast to Coast AM with Mind and Evolution Show September 15, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000225 Coast to Coast Dan Browns Lost Symbols 1st Hour September 23, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000226 Coast to Coast -Dr. Nick Begich DARPA and Telepathy Jun 03 2009 - Hour 1.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000227 Coast to Coast Global Government & Planet X - Dec 14 2009 - Hour 1.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000228 Coast to Coast Global Government & Planet X - Dec 14 2009 - Hour 2.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000229 Coast to Coast Global Government & Planet X - Dec 14 2009 - Hour 3.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000230 Coast to Coast Inside the Bermuda Triangle - Dec 06 2009 - Hour 2.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000231 Coast to Coast -Penney Peirce Intuition and Frequencies Dec 03 2009 - Hour 3.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000232 Coast to Coast Psi Research and Telepaty February 4, 2008.xps 19.01.2017 xps
00000233 Coast to Coast re DARPA with Michael Belfiore - Nov 08 2009 - Hour 3.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000234 Coast to Coast re DARPA with Michael Belfiore - Nov 08 2009 - Hour 4.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000235 Coast to Coast re DARPA with Michael Belfiore - Nov 08 2009 - Hour 2.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000236 Coast to Coast re Mind Control and the New World Order - Feb 04 2010 - Hour 2.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000237 Coast to Coast re Mind Control and the New World Order - Feb 04 2010 - Hour 3.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000238 Coast to Coast re Mind Control and the New World Order - Feb 04 2010 - Hour 4.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000239 Coast to Coast Russell Targ - Jul 08 2009 - Hour 1.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000240 Coast to Coast Russell Targ July 8, 2009.xps 19.01.2017 xps
00000241 Coast To Coast Tickets - Order Confirmed.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page
Page12
10
6 of
of24
415
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 787 Page
of 2413
788 of 2593
00000242 Conference Call with Lynn Weed of FFCHS by Stan J. Caterbone
in April and Advanced
of 2010.mp3 Media Group
19.01.2017 mp3- CONFIDENTIAL
00000243 Connick Urges Feds To Rebuild Gulf Coast.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000244 DARPA Project Pegasus Time Travel - Coast to Coast AM November 11, 2009 Hour 1.mp3 19.01.2017
mp3
00000245 DARPA Project Pegasus Time Travel - Coast to Coast AM November 11, 2009 Hour 2.mp3 19.01.2017
mp3
00000246 DARPA Project Pegasus Time Travel - Coast to Coast AM November 11, 2009 Hour 3.mp3 19.01.2017
mp3
00000247 DARPA Project Pegasus Time Travel - Coast to Coast AM November 11, 2009 Hour 4.mp3 19.01.2017
mp3
00000248 DARPA Project Pegasus Time Travel - Coast to Coast AM November 11, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000249 Dr. Hall and Jim Robertson on Jim Guest Show of November 22, 2009.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000250 Dr. John Hall Radio Show of FFCHS Press Conference of April 19, 2010 in Louisville Kentucky.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000251 Dr. Nick Begich Coast to Coast AM Telepathy Technology & DARPA June 3, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000252 Dr. Nick Begich DARP and Telepathy June 3, 2009.xps 19.01.2017 xps
00000253 Email from Dr. John Hall re Electromagnetic Weapon Attacks and Coast to Coast AM Broadcast, February 12,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000254 Email to All Contacts re Dr. John Hall on Coast to Coast with Ed Dames and Russell Targ of February 8, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000255 Global Government & Planet X Coast to Coast December 14, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000256 Gmail - FFCHS Press Conference for Louisville KY and Russell Targ on Coast to Coast March 4, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000257 Inside the Bermuda Triangle Coast to Coast AM December 6, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000258 Jim Guest Show of Mind Control November 15, 2009.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000259 Laura Ingle on Bill O'Reilly re Computer Hacking Case of Sara Palin and Criminals Convictions April 27,
2010.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000260 LGH Pain Assault Retaliation for Recording Russell Targ, Remote Viewer on Coast to Coast on July 8, 2009
Authored on February 6, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000261 Lost Symbols of US Capitol by William Henry Coast to Coast September 22, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000262 Memo and Call to My Brother Steve re Fulton Safety Deposit Box and Motives of April 6, 2010.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000263 Part 2-Call to Set Up New Account With PP&L Electric to Restore Electric on April 26, 2010.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000264 PDF File - Remote Viewing & ESP - Russell Targ on Coast to Coast March 2, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000265 Power of Intention With Lynn Taggert Coast to Coast Sept 2, 2009.xps19.01.2017 xps
00000266 Predictions on Coast to Coast AM with Art Bell's New Years Predictions show of December 30, 2009.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000267 Prophetic Dreams & ET Disclosure October 6, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000268 Psi Dreams Coast to Coast AM with Dale Graff of DIA re Remote Viewing and PSI Exploration February 17,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000269 Remote Viewing Program on Coast to Coast with Writer and physicist Russell Targ July 8, 2009 Important.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000270 Richard Dolan - 12 Government Documents re UFO Taken Seriously Coast to Coast February 2, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000271 Secrets of Math - Shows - Coast to Coast AM September 12, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000272 Stan J. Caterbone's Executive Summary and Biography.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000273 The Jim Guest Show Week 3 with Dr. Hall and Dr. Robertson re Electromagnetic Weapons November 29,
2009.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000274 The Jim Guest Show Week 4 with Dr. Hall and Dr. Robertson re Electromagnetic Weapons December 6,
2009.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page
Page13
11
7 of
of24
415
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 788 Page
of 2413
789 of 2593
00000285 by Stan
43 articles matching Daniel Groff and Dave J. Caterbone
Pflumm and Advanced
Feb 28, 2008.pdf Media Group
19.01.2017 pdf - CONFIDENTIAL
00000286 470px-Admiral_Bobby_Ray_Inman,_official_CIA_photo,_1983.JPEG 19.01.2017 jpeg
00000287 1248 Dawn Sutton Doc_ DEED 5721277 (3 pages) February 12, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000288 1975 United States Senate Select Hearings on MKultra.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000289 2008 Yearly Box Office Results Mama Mia $650 Million 26 Percent Domestic January 13, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000290 3179-2006 Sentencing Transcript of October 24, 2007 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000291 26201347-Photographs-Haiti-Earthquake-2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000292 A 360 spin into prison Lancaster County Initiative for Drug Dealers January 17, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000293 A journey into darkness and light Consultant Laura Schanz January 24, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000294 A New Breed - Satellite Terrorism In Amercia by Dr. John Hall April of 2009 With Coast to Coast Interview.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000295 A New Breed - Satellite Terrorism In Amercia by Dr. John Hall April of 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000296 A New Breed - Satellite Terrorism In Amercia by Dr. John Hall Book Cover.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000297 A NEW BREED - SATELLITE TERRORISM IN AMERICA by Dr. John Hall April of 2009 Important.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000298 A NEW BREED - SATELLITE TERRORISM IN AMERICA by Dr. John Hall April of 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000299 A real dogfight for DA - Craig Stedman Will Go Down January 10, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000300 A Study In Mind Invasive Technology & The Government October 18 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000301 A Study In Mind Invasive Technology & The Government October.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000302 A Study of Mind Invasive Technology & the Government Oct 31.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000303 A Study of Mind Invasive Technology & the Government Oct 31.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000304 A Timeline of CIA Atrocities March 11, 2009 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000305 Abby Pflumm with a Gun.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000306 About Jesselyn Radack.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000307 Acatemy.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000308 ACLU v. NSA_ The Challenge of the U.S. Government Spying on Americans January 1, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000309 Advanced Media Group & Ben Bamford of High Real Estate Group re The Crossings at Conestoga Shopping
Center March 29, 2006.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000310 ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP 8 Year Investment in Downtown Lancaster Oct 10 2007 Saved January 9, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000311 ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP 8 Year Investment in Downtown Lancaster Oct 10 2007 Saved January 9, 2010-2.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000312 ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP BLOG STATS as of February 1, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000313 Advanced Media Group Downtown Lancaster Action Plan January 9, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000314 Advanced Media Group Research Blog 1st Post November 13 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000315 ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP RESEARCH BLOG STATS as of February 1, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000316 Advanced Media Group Scribd Stats for January 2010 February 1, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000317 Advanced Media Group Website Statistics MONTHLY as of January 31, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000318 Advanced Media Group You Tube Statistics for January 2010 February 1, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000319 Advanced Media Press Release Organized Stalking and Directed Energy Devices and Weapons Bill May 20,
2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000320 All Time Box Office Records by Record Holder as of January 13, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000321 All Time Box Office Records on January 13, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000322 Alley Kat & Brett Stabley Emails 2005-2007 dec 6 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000323 Amazon Book List re Community Stalking and Videos by Felix on February 4, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000324 American Society for Psychical Research.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000325 American Taliban Whistleblower joins CIA Tapegate Furor dec .PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000326 AM-FM-PB Radio with WHAN for Coast to Coast AM on July 12, 2009 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000327 Apple Sees New Money in Old Media with the Tablet January 22, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000328 Application for Writ of Habeus Corpus to US District Court May 16, 2009.odt 19.01.2017 odt
00000329 Are they that sick Did U.S. weather weapon destroy Haiti January 30, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000330 Aruba suspends search of Skeleton Remains of Natalie Holloway from Lead from Lancaster County March 25,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000331 August 11 Patty Wilson Email Sept 24 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000332 Authority must reinstate deed restrictions (Jim Warner Executive Director) and PALE January 18, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000333 Babylon X - Sheryl Crow Nude January 27, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000334 Bedford County PA Sex Slaves and MK-Ultra & RICO April 5, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000335 Ben Bamford wants a government of the people in Lancaster Township January 9, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000336 Benjamin Franklin faced off with area farmers Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000337 Best Psychic Mediums August 15 2007.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000338 Beyond Space and Time by Martin Ebron 1967.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000339 Bible Belt - Wikipedia Lancaster County Part of It.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page
Page14
12
8 of
of24
415
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 789 Page
of 2413
790 of 2593
00000340 Big Brother (DARPA) is Watching Us Allby Stan
Sept 17J.2007.PDF
Caterbone and Advanced Media
19.01.2017 pdf Group - CONFIDENTIAL
00000341 Big Brother and DARPA on Book Records.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000342 Big Brother DARPAs Control Freak Technology Dec 12 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000343 Big Brother DARPAs Control Freak Technology Dec 12 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000344 BillOReilly Premium Membership Reciept February 26, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000345 Birth of the Modern Writ of Habeus Corpus.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000346 bookmarks February 6, 2010.html 19.01.2017 html
00000347 Brain wave technology could change lives CNBC Important.pdf19.01.2017 pdf
00000348 Break the CIA in Two 1963 Editorial by President Harry Truman.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000349 Brett Stabley - Sheryl Crow - Dave Pflum - Mental Torture and Electromagnetic Weapon Attacks on Stan
Caterbone January 9, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000350 Bush Lawyers Discussed Fate of CIA Tapes Dec 20 2007.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000351 Bush Top Lawyers Authored Memos Purporting to Authorize Torture January 11, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000352 Call to Senate Judiciary Committee re Mind Control October 2, 2009.WAV 19.01.2017 wav
00000353 Captain of My Ship Remote Viewing Excerpt.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000354 CATERBONE v. Lancaster County Sheriff Dept. How It All Started - Sheriff Bergman 2005 Email Exchange May
6, 2005 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000355 Chapter 11 05-23059 Amended Recievables May 11, 2009 State Farm Claim.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000356 Chapter 11 05-23059 Motion to File Reorganization Plan January 11, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000357 Chapter 11 05-23059 Reorganization Plan January 11, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000358 Chapter 11 05-23059 Reorganization Plan Table of Contents January 11, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000359 Cheney's `Spoon-Benders' PSYOP ESP Telepathy Jeffrey Steinberg 2005.odt 19.01.2017 odt
00000360 Cheney's `Spoon-Benders' PSYOP ESP Telepathy Jeffrey Steinberg 2005.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000361 Chloroform Toxicological Profile Book I Ordered from the CDC in 2006.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000362 Churches react to Fox News Host Glen Beck - Fr. Goodman of St. Mary's March 18, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000363 CIA Documents Telepathy 2002.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000364 CIA erased interrogation tapes.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000365 CIA Tape Furor Echoes Watergate.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000366 CIA Torture Investigations - EIT Program - SERE and U.S. Sponsored Mind Control by Stan Caterbone October
2, 2009 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000367 CIA Torture Investigations - EIT Program - SERE and U.S. Sponsored Mind Control by Stan Caterbone October
2, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000368 cia-brainwashing.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000369 Coast to Coast AM - Remote Viewing Updates Show January 4, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000370 Coast to Coast AM - The Antidepressant Myth January 23, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000371 Coast to Coast AM Electronic Harassment - Show with Dr. John Hall on Monday, February 8, 2010 Important.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000372 Coast to Coast AM Electronic Harassment - Show with Dr. John Hall on Monday, February 8, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000373 Coast to Coast AM with George Noory Schedule for February 8, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000374 Complaint re Psychiatric Abuses From Citizens Commission For Human Rights CCHR September 25, 2009
Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000375 Complaint to Lancaster City Police Officer's Association April 29, 2009.odt 19.01.2017 odt
00000376 Congressman Robert Walker Pleading July 7 1991 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000377 Constantine Report on Remote Viewing Very Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000378 Corbett campaigns here for new 'firsts' January 9, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000379 Counterterrorism In Shambles; Why January 6, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000380 Creating Fabricated Audio Recordings and Videos Psyops Project Article by the Washington Post.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000381 Dangerous Crossroads- U.S. Moves Missiles And Troops To Russian Border January 25, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000382 DARPA & The Thought Police.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000383 DARPA Developing Sleep Agent Orexin A.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000384 DARPA Developing Sleep Agent Orexin A.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000385 DARPA email of Feb 26 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000386 DARPA goal Psychic Doctors.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000387 DARPA Human Interface Program.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000388 DARPA Human Interface Program.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000389 DARPA Interview Nov 18 2006.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000390 DARPA is it time for a REAL PDA.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000391 DARPA is it time for a REAL PDA.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000392 DARPA Mission And Projects.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000393 DARPA Predictive Simulation.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000394 darpa-r-zook-judge-james-cullen-psychiatrist-jerome-gottlieb-sept-5-2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000395 DARPA's Propoganda Covering Up New Project XY.jpg 19.01.2017 jpg
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page
Page15
13
9 of
of24
415
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 790 Page
of 2413
791 of 2593
00000396 by Stan of
Dave Pflumm arrest record of 2004 Possesion J. Marijuana.pdf
Caterbone and Advanced Media Group
19.01.2017 pdf - CONFIDENTIAL
00000397 Dave Plummer offers counsel in a crisis Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000398 Dear Dr. Franklin, I've sad news to impart January 23, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000399 Death in Camp Delta Report by Seton Hall Policy Research re MK ULTRA Dick Cheney December 9, 2009.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000400 December 18, 2009 Letter to the Editor re Social Engineering and Destruction of our Civil Liberties and
Freedoms.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000401 Defense Intelligence Manual & ABC News Nightline on Remote Viewing May 6, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000402 Dereck Dipaolo the Freak What are the Dipaolo's-Pflumm's-Hobday's Guilty Of - January 11, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000403 DIA Interrogation of July 27, 2005(4).pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000404 Dimm Family Stalkers Ray Dimm Lancaster City Cop (Pig) January 12, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000405 Directed Energy Weapons Aimed At American Targets Conference in April of 2010 by the Human Rights
Examinar February 5, 2010.pdf19.01.2017 pdf
00000406 Disclaimers on the Finding-of-Facts (Incident Reports) Web-page January 27, 2010 Important.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000407 Disclaimers on the Finding-of-Facts (Incident Reports) Web-page January 27, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000408 Dispute over direction, control of PAM leads 9 trustees to resign February 17, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000409 Do Some Pets Not Know They Are Pets mental telepathy.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000410 Documentation of Weekend Torture and Pain Surge by Lancaster County March 5 to March 7, 2010 New.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000411 Documents of Negotiations for Mediation at the Lancaster Mediation Center.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000412 Dossier Iraqgate 2003.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000413 Dr Ross & The CIA Mind Control Experiments July 17 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000414 Dr Ross & The CIA Mind Control Experiments July 17 2007.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000415 Dr. John Hall Handout February 8, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000416 Dr. John Hall Interview Replayed Thurday Night February 18, 2010 on FFCHS Chat Forum Talkshoe.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000417 Dr. John Hall Radio Show of FFCHS Press Conference of April 19, 2010 in Louisville Kentucky.mp3
19.01.2017 mp3
00000418 Dr. John Hall's Book Review by Stan J. Caterbone February 20, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000419 Duke Street Business Center 08-13373 Preacipe to File Exhibit A-49 Audio CD-ROM December 8, 2009
Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000420 Duke Street Business Center 08-13373 Preacipe to File Exhibit A-55 February 5, 2010 Important.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000421 Duke Street Business Center 08-13373 Preacipe to File Exhibit A-55 February 5, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000422 Duke Street Business Center Movie Research Nov 14 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000423 Duke Street CI-08-13373 Exhibit A-33 re Russell Targ, Remote Viewer September 3, 2009 Important.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000424 Dynamics of Bioenergetics of OBE Sex - Telepathic Sex January 27, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000425 Edgar Cayce.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000426 Electromagentic Aspects of Mind Control Mind Justice.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000427 Electromagnetic pulse (Weapons) threat to be analyzed By Navy Sea Systems Command April 3, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000428 Electronic Mind Control & Timothy McVeigh jan 3 2008.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000429 Electronic Mind Control & Timothy McVeigh jan 3 2008.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000430 Email from Ben Bamford of High Real Estate Group re The Crossings at Conestoga Shopping Center March 29,
2006.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000431 Email From Bob Levin, Targeted Individual and Whistleblower of February 14, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000432 Email from Dr. John Hall re Electromagnetic Weapon Attacks and Coast to Coast AM Broadcast, February 12,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000433 Email from Eric Zager of CBS News 21 January 12, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000434 email from Tome re Mind Control Cover May 16, 2008.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000435 Email re Christy Fawcett of U.S. Attorney's Office in Harrisburg and Cocaine Ring Bust February 20, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000436 email to all contacts re DARPA Psychic Doctors Oct 13 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000437 Email to All Contacts re Dr. John Hall on Coast to Coast with Ed Dames and Russell Targ of February 8, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000438 email to All Contacts re Mind Invasion Technology by Global .doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000439 email to All Contacts re Mind Invasion Technology by Global .pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000440 email to All Contacts re Sheryl Crow Mentalis Forum Post Aug.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000441 Email to All Contacts re Updated - Stan J. Caterbone, The DIA, Psychic Spies and the Men That Stare At Goats
March 27, 2010x.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000442 email to all re Sammy & CIA Involved in Testing Dangerous JUNE 26 2007 .pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000443 Email to Jenny Joyce of CBS News 21 re Eric Zager's Call of January 12 January 14, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page16
14
10of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 791Page
of 2413
792 of 2593
00000444 by Stan
email to Jere Sullivan re Mind Control May J. Caterbone and
18 2008.PDF Advanced Media
19.01.2017 pdf Group - CONFIDENTIAL
00000445 email to John Spiziri re Shadow Government Dec 1 2007 record.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000446 email to John Spiziri re Shadow Government Dec 1 2007 record.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000447 email to John Spiziri re Shadow Government Dec 1 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000448 email to Judge Farina-FBI-Random-Landis re Mind Control May 18 2008.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000449 email to kreskin april 21 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000450 Email to Phil Wenger, COO of Fulton Financial re Cancel Meeting with Fernando of Manor Branch March 24,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000451 email to research at GAO July 10 2007.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000452 Email to Rush Limbaugh re Simulated Heart Attack of December 30, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000453 Email to Senator Arlen Specter of January 24, 2009.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000454 Enough Room Video CIA Mind Control Dr. Colin A. Ross January 5, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000455 ESP - Mental Telepathy - Remote Viewing & The US Government .pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000456 ESP - Mental Telepathy - Remote Viewing & The US Government Research Documents Sept 11 2007.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000457 ESP & Mental Telepathy Research Documents November 13 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000458 European International Commission Complaint Application for Human Rights Violation by Ron Angell April 12,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000459 Exhbit A-63 10-Day Surge of Electromagnetic Weapon Attacks - Stalking - Harassment March 14, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000460 Exhibit A-57 Electromagnetic Weapons Attacks Documented on Twitter.com and Research February 19, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000461 Facebook _ George Noory Fan Club Proof of Psychic Ability December 30, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000462 Facebook Chat with Ron Harper on March 30, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000463 Facsimile to Government Accountability Project (GAP) for Whistelblowers February 26, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000464 Facsimile to Judge Mary A. McLaughlin re Fulton Financial Grand Larceny Preliminary Emergency Injunction of
April 1, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000465 Facsimile to the Pennsylvania Criminal Intelligence Center March 21, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000466 Facsimile to U.S. Rep Jan Schawkoski re United States Postal Inspection Service on March 15, 2010 - Degraded
by Hacker.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000467 Facsimile to Wendell Crow re Emergency Injunction and Sheryl January 3, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000468 FBI IC3 Cyber Crimes Complaint ID - I0909141752127141 February 1, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000469 Federal 05-2288 Legal Research Notes of Sept 18 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000470 Federal False Claim Act Filing of October 19 2006 ver Feb 23 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000471 Federal Habeas Corpus A Review for Congress April 26, 2006 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000472 FFCHS Conference Call Newsletters ARCHIVED from May 2, 2009 to September 15, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000473 FFCHS PR - New Wave of Criminal Behavior Called Organized Stalking and Electronic Torture, Apr 5, 2010.odt
19.01.2017 odt
00000474 FFCHS Press Release for April 19th Press Conference.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000475 Final Judgment Microsmeti Corporation DOJ February 2, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000476 FMG Ltd (Financial Management Group, Ltd.,) Phone List & 1st Shareholder Meeting 1986 IMPORTANT.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000477 FOIA Request for OPR Report from Robert Jackson Steering Committee re Bush Administration and Torture
January 11, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000478 FOIA Transmittal Letter from Robert Jackson Steering Committee re Bush Administration and Torture January
11, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000479 Form Letter for FOIA Request to CIA for Mind Control CD.txt 19.01.2017 txt
00000480 Former Secretary of State Alexander M. Haig dies on February 20, 2010 and his ISC Connection by Advanced
Media Group.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000481 Former Secretary of State Alexander M. Haig dies on February 20, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000482 Fraud suspect (Former NSA Agent) spins tale of Obama overthrow plot January 9, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000483 French want to arrest Landis for Computer Hacking February 16, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000484 Friends - Landis No Cheat Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000485 Fulton & Abstract Arguement Prepared for Steve in Tom Caterbone Estate Matters in 1998.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000486 Fulton Bank Post of January 7, 2010 re Stan J. Caterbone & Patriotism and the Global War on Terrorism.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000487 George Bush The CIA & Mind Control May 5 2003.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000488 Gitmo Lawyers v. NSA re Surveillance during Representing Gitmo Prisinors OPINION for Appeal of District Court
January 1, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000489 Glen Beck and How Americans Got This Way - KGB Brainwashing - January 11, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000490 GlobalResearch.ca - Centre for Research on Globalization(1).log 19.01.2017 log
00000491 GlobalResearch.ca - Centre for Research on Globalization(1).pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000492 GlobalResearch.ca - Centre for Research on Globalization.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page17
15
11of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 792Page
of 2413
793 of 2593
00000493 Gmail - FFCHS PR - New Wave of Criminal by Stan J. Caterbone
Behavior andStalking
- Organized AdvancedandMedia Group
Electronic - CONFIDENTIAL
Torture of April 5,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000494 GOP backs Aument in 41st - This Is How They Cover Me Up - Supporting The Corrupt February 17, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000495 Government Accountability Project- Bill Would Streamline Whi.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000496 GSA Minutes Jan. 10.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000497 Haiti Earth Quake HAARP Diversion With Comment January 15, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000498 Harleysville Claim Report July 9 2006 update 8 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000499 Harleysville Claim Report July 9 2006 update 8.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000500 Harleysville Claims of 2004 and 2005.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000501 Harleysville Insurance Claims and Invoices to Date Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000502 Harleysville Notorized Settlement Sept 24 2007 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000503 Harleysville Settlement Check Sept 26 2007 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000504 He owes court costs, got stimulus money When it comes to housing needs, backgrounds not checked..pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000505 Holding Judges Feet to the Fire With Good Ole Fashon Reasoning and Logic by Jurisdictionary February 1,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000506 Honda thinks up mind-controlled robots Using TELEPATHY.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000507 How US Arms and Technology Were Transferred to Iraq ABC Nightline Transcript Sep 13 1991 Important.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000508 Hugo Mnsterberg Hypnosis and Metal Telepathy Dec 19 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000509 Human Target by Human Rights Examinar January 29, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000510 IFCC-I06010506177009 re Puerto Vallerte Mexico harleysville jan 27 2006 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000511 Illegal Programs Proliferate Under Obama- Court Rules, Illegal NSA Spying Continues April 11, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000512 IMAX Theater Coming to Lancaster's Penn Cinema - Penn Ketchum Former Lancaster County Mental Health
Director - Anti-Trust.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000513 Impeachment Documents of Stanley Caterbone 2006 to 2007 July 3 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000514 In a plea deal over his son's death, a doctor loses his license Heidi Eiken March 21, 2010 Part 1.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000515 Incident Reports of Harassment, Vandalism, Hacking, & Thefts From 1987 to March 22, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000516 injunction-basics-and-sample-form.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000517 Inspiring Stories by Apple Computer Founder Steve Jobs February 11, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000518 Intell Headlines Courthouse Divided dec 6 2005 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000519 Intelligencer Journal Editorial CIA Tapes.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000520 Intelligencer Journal- Losing trust in our government.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000521 Investigate This! With Alex...pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000522 Investigations Press Releases of Department of Justice and Office of Inspector General January 9, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000523 Is DARPA the Mad Scientist of the DOD.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000524 Is Fulton Bank Trying To Induce Me Into Suicide Like My Brother Tom Who Did on April 29, 1996.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000525 Is Pennsylvania leading the national race to be the world's greatest prison state.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000526 ISC and Alexander Haig jan 24 1990 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000527 J.D. Salinger dies, was renowned, reclusive Catcher in the Rye Conspiracy Theory January 29, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000528 Jack Anderson & Nightline - Mind Control and the Secret State by Name Base 1996.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000529 James F Marino Mind Control Research January 10, 2009.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000530 January Invoice to Department of Defense Secretary Gates Certified Mailed 7009 2250 0001 4191 7165
December 23, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000531 Jersey Shore TV Show a Hit on MTV February 21, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000532 JFKcountercoup_ Francis W. and Arlen Specter's Single Bullet Theory January 7, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000533 Job Applications Portfolio for Stan J. Caterbone 2005 to 2009 May 26, 2009 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000534 John F. Kennedy Campaigning in Penn Square in 1962.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000535 Jonathan Turley & Meghan Lippiatt Page july 10, 2008.jpg 19.01.2017 jpg
00000536 Jonathan Turley Biography Only July 10, 2008.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000537 Judge Anderson in Vance v. Rumsfeld Case No. 06-C 6964 COMPLIANT 2nd Amended Complaint April 20,
2006.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000538 Judge Farina East Lampeter 2843-06 Transcript Dec 5 2006 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000539 Judge Georgelis S-158-06 Transcript Oct 22 2007 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000540 Judge Mary McLaughlin 05-2288 AMENDMENT TO COMPLAINT October 15 2007 Important.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000541 Judge rebukes Bush-Obama state secrets and rules spying on group violated fed'l law April 1, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page18
16
12of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 793Page
of 2413
794 of 2593
00000542 Judge Vance OPINION re Rumsfeld Torture by Stan J. Caterbone
Case and Advanced
06-C 6964 March Media Group
5, 2010.pdf - CONFIDENTIAL
19.01.2017 pdf
00000543 JurisDictionary BasicFlowchart of a Lawsuit January 29, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000544 JurisDictionary Basics of Evidentiary Materials February 7, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000545 Justice, is it a word veterans get in their lives Vets. v. CIA re Mind Control January 25, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000546 Kreskin Protoge Makes Film.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000547 Kreskin Protoge Makes Film.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000548 Kreskin video and Peterson Case jan 4 2008.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000549 Kreskin video.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000550 Lancaster County Aims At Conservatorship For Cover-Up Advanced Media Group Blog of February 18, 2008.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000551 Lancaster County Assistance Office Denial Letter for PA Medical Assistance November 16, 2009.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000552 Lancaster County Library System - FABRICATION of March 9, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000553 Lancaster General Hospital Series by Newslanc October 24, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000554 Lancaster Living Arts Village February 28, 2010.jpg 19.01.2017 jpg
00000555 Lancaster Newspaper Headlines Catholic French Want to Arrest Floyd Landis Rosboro Apeals February 16,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000556 Lancaster Newspapers Headlines A Blizzard This Time February 10, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000557 Lancaster Newspapers Headlines CLOSED, Blizzard of February 10 February 11, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000558 Lancaster Newspapers Headlines Local Headlines Nancy Pelosi Coming to Speak in Lancaster January 9,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000559 Lancaster Newspapers Headlines Local Headlines PA Attorney General Campaigns in Lancaster January 9,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000560 Lancaster Newspapers Headlines Local Headlines PA Governor Ed Rendell's Humiliated, Again! January 8,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000561 Lancaster Newspapers Headlines Misplaced Faith - A Mennonite Investment Scam of 65 Million Dollars January
24, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000562 Lancaster Newspapers Headlines Muddying The Waters (Cheasapeake Bay) Article Sunday February 14,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000563 Lancaster Newspapers Headlines The Big Digout February 11, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000564 Lancaster Newspapers Headlines White Out, Blizzard of February 10 February 11, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000565 Lancaster Newspapers Perspective Headlines Obama - A Movement or a Moment Article Sunday February 14,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000566 LancasterOnline Eateries chose to go smoke free.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000567 Lance and Sheryl Engaged sept 5 IMPORTANT.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000568 Lance Armstrong Atheist IMPORTANT.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000569 Landis Get Back on that Pony and ride Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000570 Landis Rejects International Courts ruling Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000571 Last Meeting with Psychiatrist Dr. Al Shulz Transcript of January 1998 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000572 Law Suit against 4 US Presidents for Torture in Spain February 12, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000573 Letter from Law Firm of Jere Spence re Solicitation for Representation of March 26, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000574 Letter from Third Circuit Clerk of Courts re Exhibit of Reorganization in Bankruptcy Case January 15, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000575 Letter to Alen Specter July 12 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000576 Letter to CCHR Lorita O'Leary Abuse Case Documentor jan 4 20.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000577 Letter to FBI July 16 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000578 Letter to FBI re DARPA July 16 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000579 Letter to Mike re PP&L Utility Bills and Computer Hacking March 31, 2008.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000580 Letter to R Scott Smith Fulton Bank Dec 3 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000581 Letter to R Scott Smith Fulton Bank Dec 3 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000582 Letter to Richard Boylan PhD LLC re Shadow Dec 3 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000583 Letter to Richard Gray re 1252 Fremont Dec 3 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000584 Letter to the Dr Phil Show September 18, 2008.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000585 Letter to the Dr Phil Show September 18, 2008[1].doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000586 Letter to the United States Postal Inspection Service of March 15, 2010 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000587 Letter to United Nations Council for Human Rights October 4, 2009 IMPORTANT.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000588 Letterman Faces Restraining Order for Mental Telepathy.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000589 Letters to Lorita O'Leary of CCHR to 2008 jan 6 2008.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000590 Letters to Obama and Senators re National Whistleblowers Law February 24, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000591 Liberty Has Been Lost by Craig Roberts January 6, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000592 Limit CIA Role To Intelligence Gathering by Harry Truman Washington Post 1963.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000593 LNP Intel Headlines Landis No Cheat July 1, 2008 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000594 Look alike on January 14, 2010 beside Billy Sprecher at O'Hollorans.jpg 19.01.2017 jpg
00000595 Making the world safe for (Chinese) investment Time Magazine Article December 29, 2009.pdf
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page19
17
13of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 794Page
of 2413
795 of 2593
19.01.2017 pdf by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
00000596 Mamma Mia _ Abba Number One Hits January 13, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000597 Man with the leading edge Tom Corbett brings GOP gubernatorial campaign January 17, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000598 Mariuuana Research dec 27 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000599 Mariuuana Research dec 27 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000600 Mark Hough and State Farm Claim to Date Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000601 Massive Human Rights Abuses Letterman Telepathy.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000602 Master Harleysville Insurance & Parula Properties March 19 2007 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000603 Mayoral Candidate Connie Marshall of FFCHS Alleges Surveillance, Assault January 22, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000604 Medication Log of Simulated Heart Pain of December 30, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000605 MEMRI - Middle East Media Research - Conspiracy Theories In Iranian Media Outlets February 2, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000606 MENTAL HEALTH PROCEDURES ACT.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000607 MENTAL HEALTH PROCEDURES ACT.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000608 Mental Hope News Why Was Lippiatt Freed by Judge Cullen dec .PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000609 Mentalist offers help to state cops.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000610 Message from Liapatt Attorney Julie Cooper re Email March 15, 2010.WAV 19.01.2017 wav
00000611 Metropolitan Reporting Bureau and Chief John Fiorill of Southern Regional Police July 3, 2007.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000612 Microsoft Word - The calculated and technological entry into another personmid Oct 18 2007.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000613 Millersville University Grad Program Documents for Litigation September 16, 2009 IMPORTANT.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000614 Millersville University No Tresspass Poster with Photo from Fulton Bank Message Board December 15, 2009.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000615 Mind Control & One World Order February 4, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000616 MIND CONTROL AND THE NEW WORLD ORDER by Glenn Krawczyk.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000617 Mind Control Civil Actions January 10, 2009.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000618 Mind Controle and the Secret State Remote Viewing June 2008.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000619 Mind Justice Congressional Testimony re Financial Ruin May 1.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000620 Mind Justice Organization & Research dec 10 2007.doc19.01.2017 doc
00000621 Mind Justice Organization & Research dec 10 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000622 Misplaced Faith - A Mennonite Investment Scam of $65 Million Dollars January 24, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000623 MK-Ultra - The Navy - Mental Telepathy by Thomas Porter 1996.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000624 MK-Ultra - The Navy's Project With Mental Telepathy (My Father) by Thomas Porter 1996 Important.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000625 MKULTRA - Veterans Sue CIA Over Past Chemical Tests on Soldiers January 7, 2009.doc 19.01.2017
doc
00000626 MK-ULTRA CIA Testimony to The U.S. Senate with PA Senator Schweiker.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000627 MK-Ultra ESP Subprogram 136.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000628 MK-Ultra Victim Claims Tortured by Mengele March 7, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000629 mkultraindex of FOIA Documents.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000630 Muddying The Waters (Cheasapeake Bay) Article Sunday February 14, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000631 Mutant Mania Digital Movie June 1987 with Tony Bongiovi; Power Station Studios, and Flatbush Films by
Advanced Media Group.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000632 My Appearence on FFCHS Talkshoe Conference with Orville April 1, 2010 Online Chat.odt 19.01.2017 odt
00000633 My Appearence on FFCHS Talkshoe Conference with Orville April 1, 2010 Online Chat.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000634 My Surveillance - Southern Regional Police and Lancaster County Sheriff At My House at 220 Stone Hill Road in
2006.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000635 NashuaTelegraph.com - CIA and MK ULTRA April 12, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000636 National_Stalking_Awareness_Month_-_Promote_the_Month_-_2009-12-17.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000637 Navy Sea Systems Command Center Confirms TI Reports of Electromagnetic Weapons April 3, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000638 NBC_Report_Spring_Summer06 Col Brian Groft of Lancaster Married to Bonnie Spietel Parents Were Clients of
Mine.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000639 Neuroimaging Fails To Demonstrate ESP Is Real.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000640 Neuroimaging Fails To Demonstrate ESP Is Real.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000641 New health chief aims for growth, stability at Lancaster Regional Medical Center in Lancaster March 28,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000642 New Holland police chief resigns January 13, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000643 New York Times - Judge rebukes Bush-Obama state secrets and rules spying on group violated fed'l law April 1,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000644 Newslanc.com Comment re The Crossings at Conestoga and Park City Shopping Mall January 7, 2010.pdf
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page20
18
14of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 795Page
of 2413
796 of 2593
19.01.2017 pdf by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
00000645 Nice Work Creating New Terrorists, You Morons by OpEd News January 9, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000646 No GOP backing for Former Lancaster County GOP Chairman Beiler Lt. gov. endorsement goes to Jim Cawley
Feb 14, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000647 Notes and Legal Research from Lancaster County Prison During False Imprisonement Oct 30 to Dec 29,
2006.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000648 Obituary for Louis Pflumm who Passed Saturday, December 26, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000649 On the Need for New Criteria of Diagnosis of Psychosis in th.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000650 On the Need for New Criteria of Diagnosis of Psychosis in the Light of Mind Invasive Technology.doc
19.01.2017 doc
00000651 On the Need for New Criteria of Diagnosis of Psychosis in the...pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000652 ONE OF THE MOST PAINFUL (PHYSICAL) DAYS EVER - April 2, 2010 With Photos.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000653 ONE OF THE MOST PAINFUL (PHYSICAL) DAYS EVER - April 2, 2010.odt 19.01.2017 odt
00000654 ONE OF THE MOST PAINFUL (PHYSICAL) DAYS EVER - April 2, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000655 OPed News - Spying for Dollars - Military Contractors and Security Firms Reap Huge Profits February 16,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000656 operation-mind-control- The Manchurian Candidate Book.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000657 Order Government Mind Control Records of MKULTRA.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000658 Orlikow, et al. v. United States Mind Control Suit Page 2.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000659 Orlikow, et al. v. United States Mind Control Suit.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000660 Outrageous Gutting of U.S. Law Referencing Mind Control Bill By Denis Kucinich of Ohio.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000661 Page 2 LNP Headlines 10 Best Stories of 2009 December 31, 2009.pdf19.01.2017 pdf
00000662 Pages from Telepathy and the Etheric Vehicle - Telepathic Se.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000663 Pages from Tom Caterbone Estate Keeney Transaction and Fulton Bank With Grant Street Memos Important.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000664 Parapsychology.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000665 Pennsylvania State Police Pennsylvania Criminal Intelligence Center March 21, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000666 Petition for Administrator of Thomas Caterbone 36-1996-0729 Jan 17 2008 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000667 Photos At Fulton Bank Manor Branch Converting SSA Check to Cashiers Check March 19, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000668 Physical Effects of Electromagnetic Weapons on April 6, 2010 Listening to Dr. Nick Begich on Coast to CoastAM
in my Hot Tub.jpg 19.01.2017 jpg
00000669 PI3 - 3 Strikes You're OUT - LANCASTER! March 28, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000670 Police Identify 2 Who Died in Snowmobile Accident in Lancaster City (Gary Funk) February 12, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000671 Pope- Apology but no changes for Sexual Abuse Scandal Spreading Across Europe March 21, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000672 Preliminary Emergency Injunction 09-5205 ORDER by Judge McLaughlin of November 19, 2009 Important.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000673 President Bush Transcript from Jay Group Oct 3 2007.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000674 President Judge Farina & My Father - May, Grove, Stork & Blakinger Ha Ha You Fools.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000675 Presidential Candidate Obama at Buchanan Park September 4, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000676 Prevention of Torture - A Lot Still Needs to be Done.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000677 Probation Worksheet Erica Wietzel Nov 9 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000678 Project Open Mind CIA Reading List Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000679 Proof and Evidence That Fulton Bank Is A Criminal Enterprise February 10, 2010.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000680 Proof and Evidence That Fulton Bank Is A Criminal Enterprise February 10, 2010.odt 19.01.2017 odt
00000681 Psychanalyse-Paris.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000682 Psychosis in the Light of Mind Invasion Technology October 1.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000683 PsychRights whistleblower lawsuit against psychiatrists unsealed Defendents listed January 26, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000684 Question and Answer from Terry Robertson of Jim Guest Show re Is Mind Control Legal December 1, 2009
Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000685 Remote control brain sensor BBC 2002.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000686 Remote Viewing and the US Government sept 8 2007.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000687 Remote Viewing Program on Coast to Coast with Writer and physicist Russell Targ July 8, 2009 Important.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000688 Remote Viewing Television Demonstration.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000689 Report - Nonlethal Weapons Could Target Brain; Mimic Pschizophrenia Febraury 18, 2008.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000690 Republic Broadcasting Network Jim Guest Show Week 4 of Electromagnetic Weapons Important.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000691 Richard Dolan - 12 Government Documents re UFO Taken Seriously Coast to Coast February 2, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000692 Roseboro appeals to state court - Wants a New Trial February 16, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000693 russian_psychotronic_war_and_security.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page21
19
15of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 796Page
of 2413
797 of 2593
00000694 Samuel P Caterbone UFO Research June by 27
Stan J. Caterbone
2007.pdf and Advanced
19.01.2017 pdf Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
00000695 Santa Barbara Business Permits Mental Telepathy Oct 5 2007.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000696 Science fiction-Scientology-Telepathy.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000697 Science fiction-Scientology-Telepathy.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000698 Scientific Opinion re Electromagnetic Weapons Harmful Effects on The Human Body March 8, 2001.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000699 Sheriff Sale 220 Stone Hill Road Sold To Central Penn Property Services NOT Parula Properties January 19,
2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000700 Sheryl Crow And Her Sexual Exploitations Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000701 Sheryl Crow Mentalist Post August 2 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000702 Sheryl Crow Mentalist Post August 2 2007.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000703 Snyder Funeral Home adding crematory February 5, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000704 Snyder Funeral Home Condolences for Louis Pflumm who Passed Saturday, December 26, 2009.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000705 Society for Psychical Research.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000706 Stan Caterbone & Sheryl CrowStock Certificates With Fulton Bank Proxy March 10, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000707 Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group Computations For Litigation Valuations January 10, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000708 Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group Income Revenue Streams for Litigation Valuations January 10,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000709 Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group Property and Assets for Litigation Valuations January 10,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000710 Stan J. Caterbone Meeting with Lancaster Human Relations Commission re Discrimination Transcript
Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000711 Stan J. Caterbone, The DIA, Psychic Spies and the Men that Stare at Goats With Documents November 7,
2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000712 Stan J. Caterbone's Executive Summary and Biography.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000713 State and Regional Fusion Centers Information by State March 21, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000714 State Crimes Against Democracy, Global Research March 7, 2010 Website Version.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000715 Station Info - CBS 21 News Jenni Joyce Bio January 14, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000716 Submission to U.S. Department of Defense Website re U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert Gates April 7, 2009-
GATES.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000717 Suicide Bomber in Afganastan that Killed 7 CIA Agents at CIA Installation was a Double Agent January 5,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000718 Synthetic Telepathy and Psychotronics Blog May 24 2008 Very Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000719 SYNTHETIC TELEPATHY and PSYCHOTRONICS RESEARCH February 17, 2009.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000720 Targeted Individuals of Electromagnetic Mind Center.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000721 Telepathic Communication Between Two People.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000722 Telepathic Sex and Telepathic Communications Research from 2007 Adobe.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000723 Telepathy and the Etheric Vehicle -Telepathic Communications 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000724 Telepathy and the Etheric Vehicle -Telepathic Sensitivity - .doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000725 Telepathy and the Etheric Vehicle -Telepathic Sensitivity.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000726 Telepathy and the Etheric Vehicle.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000727 Telepathy and the Etheric Vehicle.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000728 Telepathy From Wikipedia jan 25 2008.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000729 The Amazing Kreskin Bio jun 6 2006 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000730 The Amazing Kreskin Bio jun 6 2006.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000731 The Belief Engine article Mental Telepathy.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000732 The Belief Engine article Mental Telepathy.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000733 The Belief Engine article Psychic Vibrations.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000734 The Belief Engine article Psychic Vibrations.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000735 The Belief Engine article Whats going on at Temple Universit.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000736 The Belief Engine article Whats going on at Temple Universit.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000737 The Belief Engine.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000738 The Belief Engine.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000739 The Book A New Breed - Satellite Terrorism In Amercia by Dr. John Hall April of 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000740 The calculated and technological entry into another persons .doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000741 The Case for Impeachment of President Barack Obama, By Dave Lindorff April 1, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000742 The CIA Created The Hippie Movement in the 1960s February 14, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000743 The Facts of the Pollard Case.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000744 The Facts of the Pollard Case.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000745 The FFCHS Press Conference in Louisville, Kentucky - April 16, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000746 The Hippocratic Oath Applied to Intelligence January 26, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000747 The Indus Valley Drafidian Civilization $ Mental Telepathy n.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000748 The Military-Industrial Complex is Ruining the Economy January 11, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page22
20
16of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 797Page
of 2413
798 of 2593
00000749 The oil reserve below Haiti are Larger by Stan
Than J. Caterbone
Venezuala and Advanced
With HAARP Media
by Ron Angel Group25,
January - CONFIDENTIAL
2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000750 The Pentagon Plan to Drug Troops.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000751 The Role of the Media in a Democracy.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000752 THE SHADOW GOVERNMENT ITS IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS by Ric.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000753 The Surge in U.S. Personal Bankruptcies, Foreclosures and Job Losses January 10, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000754 The United States Government & Mind Invasion Technology.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000755 Thefts and Vandalism Documents for Video Part 24 Mental Telepathy and Electromagnetic Weapons February 16,
2010_opt.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000756 Things Are Cooking at Lime Spring Marylyn Berger Sunday January 24, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000757 Tom Caterbone Estate & Fulton Bank Fraud Documents March 22, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000758 Tommye Global Research Dec 4 2007.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000759 Tom's Legacy January 16 1997 Lancaster Newspaper Article.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000760 Treason in America 911, the Wars & Our Broken Constitution Conference Flyer.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000761 TS-340595 4-01-2010-My Appearence on FFCHS Talkshoe Conference with Orville April 1, 2010 Online
Chat.mp3 19.01.2017 mp3
00000762 Twitter Page for Stan Caterbone re Counter Attacks During Assults of January 31, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000763 U.S. Attorney Complaint of April 25, 2009 re Mind Control & Lancaster County, Pennsylvania Very Important.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000764 U.S. District Court Preliminary Injunction Case No. 09-05205 DOCKET Sheet Filed October 30 as of December
16, 2009 Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000765 U.S. Preliminary Emergency Injunction USPSOctober 28, 2009 IMPORTANT.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000766 U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert Gates and DOD Invoice of January 1, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000767 U.S. Speaker of the House, Nancy Pelosi will speak in Lancaster County on February 5, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000768 U.S. State Dept Official Questions Acquittal of UAE Royal Sheikh in Torture Trial January 11, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000769 Upcoming Radio Appearances by FFCHS January 31, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000770 US Attorney in Philadelphia Indicted for using false identification.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000771 US Electromagnetic Weapons and Human Rights.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000772 US Secretary of Defense Robert Gates Biography April 7, 2009-GATES.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000773 USDOJ AnitiTrust Conference Presentation February 15, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000774 Velma Orlikow Sued CIA for Mind Control and Won Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000775 Velma Orlikow Sued CIA for Mind Control and Won Very Important.pdf19.01.2017 pdf
00000776 Velma Orlikow Sued CIA for Mind Control and Won.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000777 Victims Accounts of Mind Control dec 10 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000778 Victims Accounts of Mind Control dec 10 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000779 Video of Computer Hacking During Updating to Windows 7 For HP February 1, 2010.3gp 19.01.2017
3gp
00000780 WARNING To all Shore Points in New Jersey, Delaware, Maryland and New York re Hybrid Lives March 14, 2010
with Docs.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000781 Water & Sewer Shut-Off Notice for 1250 Fremont Street, Lancaster, of February 1, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000782 Water Shut-Off and Condemnation of 1252 Fremont of May 8, 2008.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000783 WGAL Video Request Form.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000784 What Caused Britney.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000785 What Is Adult Internet Bullying April 11, 2010 - Is It Illegal by Human Rights Examiner Editor Debra Dupre'.odt
19.01.2017 odt
00000786 What Is Adult Internet Bullying April 11, 2010 - Is It Illegal.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000787 What Torture Is and Why It's Illegal and Not Poor Judgment Watch David Margolis - March 15, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000788 When The Going Gets Tough The Tough Get Going - LCHS Coach Tony DiPaolo 1973-1975 Football Season
GOTCHA.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000789 Whistleblower is accused of masterminding fraudulent scheme .pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000790 Whistleblower Laura Magdalene Eisenhower, Ikes great-granddaughter, outs secret Mars colony project
February 12, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000791 Who Owns Facebook and Twitter by Advanced Media Group on February 14, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000792 Why so many Americans today are 'mentally ill'.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000793 William Lefty Plank Died January 10 Obituary January 12, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000794 William Lefty Plank Obituary January 12, 2010 Page 1.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000795 William Lefty Plank Obituary January 12, 2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000796 William Plank Arrest & Convictions Record Important.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000797 Wishing Limbaugh Dead except for the Sarah Factor by Rob Krall of OpEd News December 31, 2009.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000798 Word Beyond Space and Time - Mark Twain & Mental Telepathy 1.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000799 Writ of Mandamus for MDJ Leo Eckert and MDJ Mary Commins December 8, 2006.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page23
21
17of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 798Page
of 2413
799 of 2593
00000800 by Rome
Yacht Havens of the Mediterranean from Stan J.
toCaterbone and Advanced
Barcelona Millersville MediaAlumni
University GroupTour
- CONFIDENTIAL
January 17,
2010.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page24
22
18of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 799Page
of 2413
800 of 2593
00000853 CIA Documents Telepathy 2002.pdf by Stan J. Caterbone
19.01.2017 pdf and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
00000854 CIA erased interrogation tapes.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000855 CIA Stansfield Turner Statement to Senate Select Committee 1977-1.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000856 CIA Tape Furor Echoes Watergate.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000857 Congressional Inquiry Form.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000858 Congressional Inquiry Form.rtf 19.01.2017 rtf
00000859 Constantine Report on Remote Viewing.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000860 DARPA Developing Sleep Agent Orexin A.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000861 DARPA Developing Sleep Agent Orexin A.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000862 DARPA email of Feb 26 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000863 DARPA goal Psychic Doctors.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000864 DARPA Human Interface Program.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000865 DARPA Human Interface Program.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000866 DARPA is it time for a REAL PDA.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000867 DARPA is it time for a REAL PDA.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000868 DARPA Mission And Projects.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000869 DARPA Predictive Simulation.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000870 darpa-r-zook-judge-james-cullen-psychiatrist-jerome-gottlieb-sept-5-2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000871 Dave Plummer offers counsel in a crisis.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000872 Do Some Pets Not Know They Are Pets mental telepathy.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000873 Dossier Iraqgate 2003.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000874 Dr Ross & The CIA Mind Control Experiments July 17 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000875 Dr Ross & The CIA Mind Control Experiments July 17 2007.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000876 Duke Street Business Center Movie Research Nov 14 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000877 Edgar Cayce.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000878 Electromagentic Aspects of Mind Control Mind Justice.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000879 Electromagnetic pulse (Weapons) threat to be analyzed By Navy Sea Systems Command April 3, 2010.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000880 Electromagnetic Weapons Transcript by CNN in 1985.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000881 Electronic Mind Control & Timothy McVeigh jan 3 2008.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000882 Electronic Mind Control & Timothy McVeigh jan 3 2008.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000883 email to all contacts re DARPA Psychic Doctors Oct 13 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000884 email to All Contacts re Mind Invasion Technology by Global .doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000885 email to All Contacts re Mind Invasion Technology by Global .pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000886 email to All Contacts re Sheryl Crow Mentalis Forum Post Aug.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000887 email to John Spiziri re Shadow Government Dec 1 2007 record.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000888 email to John Spiziri re Shadow Government Dec 1 2007 record.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000889 email to John Spiziri re Shadow Government Dec 1 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000890 email to kreskin april 21 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000891 email to research at GAO July 10 2007.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000892 ESP - Mental Telepathy - Remote Viewing & The US Government .pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000893 ESP & Mental Telepathy Research Documents November 13 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000894 Federal 05-2288 Legal Research Notes of Sept 18 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000895 George Bush The CIA & Mind Control May 5 2003.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000896 GlobalResearch.ca - Centre for Research on Globalization(1).log 19.01.2017 log
00000897 GlobalResearch.ca - Centre for Research on Globalization(1).pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000898 GlobalResearch.ca - Centre for Research on Globalization.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000899 Government Accountability Project- Bill Would Streamline Whi.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000900 Guidelines National Commission on Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research.pdf
19.01.2017 pdf
00000901 Holder Sworn in as Attorney General February 3, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000902 Hugo Mnsterberg Hypnosis and Metal Telepathy Dec 19 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000903 Intelligencer Journal Editorial CIA Tapes.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000904 Intelligencer Journal- Losing trust in our government.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000905 Is DARPA the Mad Scientist of the DOD.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000906 John Aniston Biography.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000907 Judge Allison Opinion in Caterbone v. Totaro, et al., CI- 00366 July 16, 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000908 Judicial Retaliation.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000909 Kreskin Protoge Makes Film.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000910 Kreskin Protoge Makes Film.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000911 Kreskin video and Peterson Case jan 4 2008.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000912 Kreskin video.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000913 LancasterOnline Eateries chose to go smoke free.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000914 Letter to Alen Specter July 12 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000915 Letter to CCHR Lorita O'Leary Abuse Case Documentor jan 4 20.doc 19.01.2017 doc
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page25
23
19of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 800Page
of 2413
801 of 2593
00000916 by Stan J.
Letter to FBI July 16 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdfCaterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
00000917 Letter to FBI re DARPA July 16 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000918 Letter to R Scott Smith Fulton Bank Dec 3 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000919 Letter to R Scott Smith Fulton Bank Dec 3 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000920 Letter to Richard Boylan PhD LLC re Shadow Dec 3 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000921 Letter to Richard Gray re 1252 Fremont Dec 3 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000922 letter to United States Attorney Genereral re Samuel Caterbone February 9, 2009-2.doc 19.01.2017
doc
00000923 Letter to US Attorney Magid with Complaint Form December 5, 2008.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000924 Letterman Faces Restraining Order for Mental Telepathy.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000925 Mariuuana Research dec 27 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000926 Mariuuana Research dec 27 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000927 Massive Human Rights Abuses Letterman Telepathy.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000928 Medical_Records_Release Form Burdette Tomlin Hospital.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000929 MENTAL HEALTH PROCEDURES ACT.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000930 MENTAL HEALTH PROCEDURES ACT.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000931 Mentalist offers help to state cops.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000932 Mind Controle and the Secret State Remote Viewing June 2008.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000933 Mind Justice Congressional Testimony re Financial Ruin May 1.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000934 Mind Justice Organization & Research dec 10 2007.doc19.01.2017 doc
00000935 Mind Justice Organization & Research dec 10 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000936 MK-Ultra - The Navy - Bobby Ray Inman on Board of SAIC and ISC Feb 3, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000937 MK-Ultra - The Navy - Mental Telepathy by Thomas Porter 1996.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000938 MK-Ultra ESP Subprogram 136.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000939 National Commission on Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000940 Neuroimaging Fails To Demonstrate ESP Is Real.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000941 Neuroimaging Fails To Demonstrate ESP Is Real.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000942 Ohio Style Diciplinary Case.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000943 On the Need for New Criteria of Diagnosis of Psychosis in th.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000944 Orlikow, et al. v. United States Mind Control Suit Page 2.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000945 Orlikow, et al. v. United States Mind Control Suit Page 3.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000946 Orlikow, et al. v. United States Mind Control Suit Page 4.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000947 Orlikow, et al. v. United States Mind Control Suit Page 5.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000948 Orlikow, et al. v. United States Mind Control Suit Page 6.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000949 Orlikow, et al. v. United States Mind Control Suit Page 7.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000950 Orlikow, et al. v. United States Mind Control Suit Page 8.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000951 Orlikow, et al. v. United States Mind Control Suit Page 9.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000952 Orlikow, et al. v. United States Mind Control Suit Page 10.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000953 Orlikow, et al. v. United States Mind Control Suit.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000954 Pages from Telepathy and the Etheric Vehicle - Telepathic Se.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000955 Pakistan in Crisis dec 28 2007.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000956 Parapsychology.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000957 Psychosis in the Light of Mind Invasion Technology October 1.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000958 Remote Viewing Television Demonstration.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000959 Robert Walker backs Thompson.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000960 Samuel P Caterbone UFO Research June 27 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000961 Santa Barbara Business Permits Mental Telepathy Oct 5 2007.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000962 Science fiction-Scientology-Telepathy.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000963 Science fiction-Scientology-Telepathy.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000964 Sheryl Crow and Navy Seal Stalker Trial re Telepathy.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000965 Sheryl Crow Mentalist Post August 2 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000966 Sheryl Crow Mentalist Post August 2 2007.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000967 Society for Psychical Research.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000968 Stan J. Caterbone's Executive Summary and Biography.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000969 Targeted Individuals of Electromagnetic Mind Center.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000970 Telepathic Communication Between Two People.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000971 Telepathy and the Etheric Vehicle -Telepathic Sensitivity - .doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000972 Telepathy and the Etheric Vehicle -Telepathic Sensitivity.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000973 Telepathy and the Etheric Vehicle.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000974 Telepathy and the Etheric Vehicle.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000975 The Amazing Kreskin Bio jun 6 2006.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000976 The Belief Engine article Mental Telepathy.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000977 The Belief Engine article Mental Telepathy.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000978 The Belief Engine article Psychic Vibrations.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000979 The Belief Engine article Psychic Vibrations.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page26
24
20of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 801Page
of 2413
802 of 2593
00000980 The Belief Engine article Whats going onby at
Stan J. Caterbone
Temple and Advanced
Universit.doc Media Group
19.01.2017 doc - CONFIDENTIAL
00000981 The Belief Engine article Whats going on at Temple Universit.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000982 The Belief Engine.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000983 The Belief Engine.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000984 The calculated and technological entry into another persons .doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000985 The Facts of the Pollard Case.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000986 The Facts of the Pollard Case.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000987 The Indus Valley Drafidian Civilization $ Mental Telepathy n.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000988 THE SHADOW GOVERNMENT ITS IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS by Ric.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000989 The United States Government & Mind Invasion Technology.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000990 Title 45 CFR Part Protection of Human Subjects.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000991 Tommye Global Research Dec 4 2007.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00000992 U.S. and international Classified Law on Human Experiments by Cheryl Welsh 2005.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000993 Velma Orlikow Sued CIA for Mind Control and Won.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000994 Victims Accounts of Mind Control dec 10 2007.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000995 Victims Accounts of Mind Control dec 10 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000996 WGAL Video Request Form.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000997 What Caused Britney.doc 19.01.2017 doc
00000998 Whistleblower is accused of masterminding fraudulent scheme .pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00000999 Why so many Americans today are 'mentally ill'.PDF 19.01.2017 pdf
00001000 Word Beyond Space and Time - Mark Twain & Mental Telepathy 1.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001001 www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com Welcome Page February 11, 2009.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page27
25
21of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 802Page
of 2413
803 of 2593
00001035 by Stan
02Samuel Caterbone Jr. Passport Renewal J. Caterbone
February and Advanced
3 1964b.pdf Media Group
19.01.2017 pdf - CONFIDENTIAL
00001036 03Samuel Caterbone Jr. Passport Renewal February 3 1964 bw.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001037 04Samuel Caterbone ID Comparison jan 22 2008.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001038 05Samuel Caterbone Jr Naval Air Gunners School Honors 1943.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001039 06Samuel Caterbone Jr Naval Air Gunners School Certificate 1.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001040 07Naval Air Gunners Training Manual June 1 1943.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001041 08Naval Air Technical Training Center Photo Album.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001042 09Samuel Caterbone Naval Air Gunners Honors 1943.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001043 10Samuel Caterbone Jr Navy Photos.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001044 11John Lehman On Seas of Glory Book & Autograph of Feb 7 200.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001045 12Sam Caterbone Cleaners Documents Feb 14 2008.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001046 13Samuel Caterbone Jr 1973 Tax Return & Docs jan 21 2008.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001047 14President Judge Farina & My Father Samuel Caterbone.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001048 15Samuel P. Caterbone (My Father) Criminal Charges.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001049 16Samuel P. Caterbone 1942 LCHS Diploma.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001050 17Tree Top Stables Uncle Jim Caterbone Winners Circle 1963-1.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001051 18Samuel Caterbone Jr and Yolanda Roda Caterbone.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001052 19Samuel Caterbone Jr Childhood Photos.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001053 20Samuel Caterbone Family Photos.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001054 433 West Marion Street Deed of Stan J. Caterbone and Transfers 1983.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001055 1470 Caterbone Drycleaners Deed July 25, 2008-2.pdf19.01.2017 pdf
00001056 camp4.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001057 camp5.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001058 Dadlet1.pzp 19.01.2017 pzp
00001059 family1.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001060 MAVICA.HTM 19.01.2017 htm
00001061 momdad.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001062 mtgretna1.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001063 MVC-001F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001064 MVC-002F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001065 MVC-003F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001066 MVC-004F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001067 MVC-005F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001068 MVC-006F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001069 MVC-007F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001070 MVC-008F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001071 MVC-009F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001072 MVC-010F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001073 MVC-011F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001074 MVC-012F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001075 MVC-013F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001076 MVC-014F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001077 MVC-015F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001078 MVC-016F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001079 MVC-893X.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001080 MVC-894X.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001081 MVC-895F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001082 MVC-896F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001083 MVC-897F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001084 MVC-898F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001085 MVC-899F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001086 MVC-900F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001087 MVC-901F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001088 MVC-902F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001089 MVC-903F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001090 MVC-904F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001091 MVC-905F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001092 MVC-906F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001093 MVC-907F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001094 MVC-908F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001095 MVC-909F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001096 MVC-910F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001097 MVC-911F.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001098 NewYork.pza 19.01.2017 pza
00001099 NewYork.pzs 19.01.2017 pzs
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page28
26
22of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 803Page
of 2413
804 of 2593
00001100 Page1.pzp 19.01.2017 pzp by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
00001101 plant1.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001102 plant2.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001103 plant3.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001104 plant4.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001105 plant5.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001106 plant6.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001107 plant7.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001108 plant8.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001109 plant9.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001110 plant10.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001111 plant11.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001112 President Judge Farina & My Father.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001113 R 2nd Gold Record Feb 14 1975.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001114 Sam Caterbone Cleaners Brochure Color jan 21 2008.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001115 Sam Caterbone Cleaners Flyer.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001116 SamCleaners.bmp 19.01.2017 bmp
00001117 samhunt.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001118 Samuel Caterbone, Jr. (Father) Photo Collection Published on May 9, 2016.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001119 Samuel P Caterbone UFO Research June 27 2007.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001120 Samuel P. Caterbone (My Father) Criminal Charges.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001121 Samuel P. Caterbone 1942 LCHS Diploma.pdf 19.01.2017 pdf
00001122 sastfish.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
00001123 xmasmomom.JPG 19.01.2017 jpg
C:\Users\Stan J. Caterbone\Desktop\Eric Cohen\U.S. Sponsored Mind Control\Video - Mental Telepathy and Electromagnetic
Weapons\
00001124 Advanced Media Group February 5, 2010 Surge of Community Stalking Part 1 video-2010-02-05-10-26-21.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
00001125 Advanced Media Group February 5, 2010 Surge of Community Stalking Part 2 video-2010-02-05-10-27-01.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
00001126 Advanced Media Group February 5, 2010 Surge of Community Stalking Part 3 video-2010-02-05-12-18-43.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
00001127 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 1 video-2010-02-03-04-57-57.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001128 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 2 video-2010-02-03-05-08-24.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001129 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 3 ES Segment 1 video-2010-02-03-10-54-55.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
00001130 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 4 ES Segment 2 video-2010-02-04-06-01-13.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
00001131 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 5 ES Segment 3 video-2010-02-04-06-19-46.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
00001132 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 6 ES Segment 4 video-2010-02-04-06-34-16.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
00001133 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 7 ES Segment 5 video-2010-02-04-06-52-55.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
00001134 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 8 ES Segment 6 video-2010-02-04-07-22-00.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
00001135 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 10 Lambert A&E Segment 1 video-2010-02-09-09-58-52.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
00001136 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 11 Lambert A&E Segment 2 video-2010-02-09-10-14-31.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
00001137 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 12 Lambert A&E Segment 3 video-2010-02-09-10-26-02.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
00001138 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 13 Lambert A&E Segment 4 video-2010-02-09-10-36-14.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
00001139 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 14 Lambert A&E Segment 5 video-2010-02-09-10-47-03.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
00001140 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 15 Fulton Bank Stole 220 Stone Hill Road video-2010-02-06-
14-55-46.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001141 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 16 1987 Photo Gallary Part 1 video-2010-02-06-15-08-
20.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001142 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 17 1987 Photo Gallary Part 2 video-2010-02-06-15-19-
29.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001143 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 18 1998 Affidavit Segment 1video-2010-02-13-21-48-36.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page29
27
23of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 804Page
of 2413
805 of 2593
00001144 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic by StanPart
Weapons J. Caterbone and Advanced
19 1998 Affidavit Media
Segment Group - CONFIDENTIAL
2 video-2010-02-13-21-15-
34.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001145 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 20 1998 Affidavit Segment 3 video-2010-02-13-21-26-
00.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001146 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 21 Emergency Injunction Segment 1 video-2010-02-15-06-
50-03.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001147 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 22 Emergency Injunction Segment 2 video-2010-02-15-07-
02-25.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001148 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 23 Emergency Injunction Segment 3 video-2010-02-15-07-
26-49.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001149 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 25 Coast to Coast AM Dale Graff Project Stargate of Feb 17,
2010-1.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001150 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 26 Coast to Coast AM Dale Graff Project Stargate of Feb 17,
2010-2.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001151 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 27 Coast to Coast AM Dale Graff Project Stargate of Feb 17,
2010-3.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001152 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 28 Coast to Coast AM Dale Graff Project Stargate of Feb 17,
2010-4.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001153 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 29 More Damaged Clothing March 9, 2010.3gp
19.01.2017 3gp
00001154 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 30 Reign of Terror March 12, 2010.3gp 19.01.2017
3gp
00001155 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 31 Segment 1 SSA Cashiers Check & Fulton Bank Fraud of
March 24, 2010.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001156 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 32 Segment 2 SSA Cashiers Check & Fulton Bank Fraud of
March 24, 2010.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001157 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 34 Segment 3 SSA Cashiers Check & Fulton Bank Fraud of
March 24, 2010.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001158 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 35 ABC News 20-20 ARMS to Iraq by ISC of Feb 1, 1991 April
22, 2010.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001159 Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 36 CNN Video of Robert Gates & ISC in Confirmation
Hearings.3gp 19.01.2017 3gp
00001160 Thumbs.db 19.01.2017 db
Estaban Santiago
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE - Estaban
Defense
Defense
Santiago Defense Page
Page30
28
24of
of415
24
40 Thursday
Thursday
Friday January
January
January20,
19,2017
2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 805Page
of 2413
806 of 2593
by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
Stan J. Caterbone
ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP
Freedom From Covert Harassment & Surveillance,
Registered in Pennsylvania
1250 Fremont Street
Lancaster, PA 17603
www.amgglobalentetainmentgroup.com
stancaterbone@gmail.com
717-528-2200
v. USA DVD\
16-cv-4014 U.S. District Court CATERBONE v. United States, et.al., AMENDED COMPLAINT DVD FILE LIST January 18, 2017
1. Case No. 16-cv-4014 CATERBONE v. the United States of America, et.al. AMENDED COMPLAINT December 30, 2016.pdf 30.12.2016
A. AMENDED - 16-cv-2513 PLAINTIFF Stanley J. Caterbone PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR EMERGENCY RELIEF MIDDLE DISTRICT of
PENNSYLVANIA on December 23, 2016.pdf 24.12.2016
B. Stan J. Caterbone, Pro Se - CASE LAW LIBRARY CONSTRUCTED DECEMBER 23, 2016 FROM FILES.pdf 24.12.2016
C. RESEARCH MATERIALS USED - Stan J. Caterbone BOOKMARKS and HISTORY December 23, 2016.pdf 24.12.2016
D. Advanced Media Group ORIGINAL INVOICES and ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLES for November 30, 2016.pdf 24.12.2016
E. Docket Number 3576 EDA 2016 ORDER DISMISSED TO DOCKET 3575 EDA 2016 KATLEEN KANE SUPERIOR COURT DOCKET SHEET
Friday December 23, 2016.pdf 24.12.2016
F. Superior Court of Pennsylvania Case No. 3575 EDA 2016 REQUEST FOR APPEARANCE re Kathleen Kane Amicus in Support of
Motion to DISMISS Charges December 23, 2016.pdf 24.12.2016
G. Docket Number 3575 EDA 2016 DOCKET SHEET STAN CATERBONE NEW AMICUS RECORDED ON KATHLEEN KANE APPEAL IN
SUPERIOR COURTDecember 29, 2016.pdf 29.12.2016
H. 16-cv-2513 EXHBIT KATHLEEN KANE WAS RIGHT - Judge Paul K. Allison Letter of May 8, 2007 Filed on December 23, 2016.pdf
24.12.2016
I. Case No. 16-2513 Preliminary Injunction Middle District CATERBONE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION With EXHIBIT Thursday
January 5, 2017.pdf 05.01.2017
16-cv-4014
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE
AMENDED
- Estaban
Defense
COMPLAINT
Santiago Defense
DVD FILE LISTPage
Page
Page31
29
1of
of415
6
40 Wednesday
Thursday
Friday January
January20,
18,2017
19, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 806Page
of 2413
807 of 2593
by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
DOCUMENTS\
0-LETTER to JAMES COMEY, DIRECTOR of FBI re PRO SE BILLINGS INVOICE Wednesday November 30, 2016.pdf 06.01.2017
01-COINTELPRO - Case Law The Assassination of Fred Hampton 47 Years Later , by Flint Taylor Attorney, December 5, 2016.pdf
06.01.2017
1-The Surreptitious Reincarnation of COINTELPRO with the COPS Gang-Stalking Program - Lancaster City Police Stregic Plan, August
24, 2016.pdf 06.01.2017
2-STAN J. CATERBONE and CONFLICTS WITH THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION - Monday November 14, 2016.pdf 06.01.2017
3-FALSE IMPRISONMENT AND ILLEGAL INTERROGATIONS by U.S. Intelligence Agencies November 12, 2016.pdf 06.01.2017
4-Amici Curiae Filed by Stan J. Caterbone 2007 to 2016 - Kathleen Kane - The National Security Agency NSA - Lisa Michelle Lambert -
Mehgan Liappatt - May 18, 2016.pdf 06.01.2017
5-FEDS PROBE FULTON BANK and 3 other SUBSIDIARY BANKS of FULTON FINANCIAL with STAN J. CATERBONE CIVIL ACTIONS and
Mind Control Research of November 7, 2016.pdf 06.01.2017
6-Stan J. Caterbone LOCAL, STATE, and FEDERAL COURT DOCKET SHEETS as of November 12, 2016.pdf 06.01.2017
7-Stan J. Caterbone United Nations Human Rights Council of Geneva Switzerland Complaint and Exhibit re U.S. Sponsored Mind
Control, Oct 4, 2009.pdf.pdf 06.01.2017
8-CATERBONE v. the United States of America, et.al., COMPLAINT July 20, 2016 ver 3.0 July 22, 2016.pdf 24.12.2016
9-MEMORANDUM FOR PRESIDENT OBAMA re Leniency for Edward Snowden by 15 FORMER INTELLIGENCE MEMBERS November 28,
2016 with Director Comey Letter December 1, 2016.pdf 24.12.2016
10-Superior Court Case No. Case No. 1219 MDA 2016 BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF APPEAL AND GRANTING OF INJUNCTION Thursday
December 1, 2016.pdf 24.12.2016
11-Superior Court Case No. Case No. 1219 MDA 2016 MOTION TO CLARIFY RECORD FROM LOWER COURT December 2, 2016.pdf
24.12.2016
12-Superior Court of Pennsylvania Case No. 3576 EDA 2016 REQUEST FOR APPEARANCE re Kathleen Kane Amicus in Support of
Motion to DISMISS November 30, 2016.pdf 24.12.2016
13 - Advanced Media Group ORIGINAL INVOICES and ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLES for November 30, 2016 Updated December 1,
2016.pdf 24.12.2016
14-Invoice to SECRETARY OF DEFENSE ASH CARTER for Victimization of U.S. Sponsored Torture Program December 2, 2016.pdf
24.12.2016
15-LETTER and DOCUMENT to Cappello & Noel, LLP of Santa Barbara, CA Friday November 25, 2016.pdf 24.12.2016
16-Federal False Claim Act Filing of October 19 2006 4200 AUTHENTIC ORIGINAL DOCUMENTS November 26, 2016.pdf 24.12.2016
18-Supreme Court of the United States Case No. 16-8822 COMPLETE FILE re CATERBONE v. Allison Hallet, re Lisa Lambert Habeus
November 22, 2016.pdf 06.01.2017
27-ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP - Mark Zuckerberg and his FACEBOOK MIND CONTROL STRATEGIES and KNOWN ATHEIST Tuesday
August 30, 2016.pdf 06.01.2017
28-Authentic and ORIGINAL Documents of 1987 RESTORED ON DECEMBER 15, 2016.pdf 06.01.2017
16-cv-4014
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE
AMENDED
- Estaban
Defense
COMPLAINT
Santiago Defense
DVD FILE LISTPage
Page
Page32
30
2of
of415
6
40 Wednesday
Thursday
Friday January
January20,
18,2017
19, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 807Page
of 2413
808 of 2593
by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
31-David Schuyler Franklin & Marshall - Reunion 2007 Schedule of Events.pdf 06.01.2017
33-Email to Paul Cambell re 3179-06 Appeal April 5 2008 CORRUPTION IN THE FLEEING CRIMINAL CASE AND APPEAL June 28,
2016.pdf 06.01.2017
34-Exhibit D of Duke Street Samuel Caterbone Criminal File Mar 4, 2009.pdf 06.01.2017
35-Letter to Epic Card re Complaint of Bonnie Lee Polygraph Solutions August11, 2015.pdf 06.01.2017
36-JIM GUERIN, FOUNDER OF ISC, FAREWELL LETTER OF 1989 December 26, 2016.pdf 06.01.2017
37-LETTER to Bishop Nicholas C. Dattilo re PAIN AND SUFFERING of February 19, 1998.pdf 06.01.2017
38-STAN J. CATERBONE and ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP LITIGATION VALUATION SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS as of December 27,
2016.pdf 06.01.2017
39-UPDATED - EXCLUSIVE Transcripts of Whistleblower Testimonies as Targeted Individuals of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and
Related Lectures, December 27, 2016.pdf 06.01.2017
40-UPDATED STATEMENT OF FACTS re CATERBONE v. Lancaster City Police Department US District Court Case 08-cv-08982
December 28, 2016.pdf 06.01.2017
41-15 FACTS TO SUPPORT THE EVIDENCE OF U.S. SPONSORED MIND CONTROL THRIVING IN LANCASTER, PENNSYLVANIA -
December 29, 2016.pdf 06.01.2017
42-CHRISTOPHER PATTERSON Candidate for JUDGESHIP and His 1987 EFFORT FOR MY GUARDIANSHIP Friday December 16, 2016.pdf
06.01.2017
43-Mental Illness Argument with Descriptions of Illneses and Complete Mental Health Record December 30, 2016.pdf 06.01.2017
45-POLICE INCIDENT REPORTS OF PHYSICAL ASSAULTS FOR STAN J. CATERBONE 2005 TO 2016 January 6, 2017.pdf 06.01.2017
47-Case No. 16-2513 Preliminary Injunction Middle District EXHIBIT re FT. LAUDERDALE SHOOTER AND U.S. SPONSORED MIND
CONTROL January 9, 2017.pdf 11.01.2017
48-AMICUS FILE - Ft. Lauderdale Airport shooting of Friday January 6, 2017 suspect complained of mind control - by STAN J
CATERBONE and Advanced Media Group January 9, 2017.pdf 11.01.2017
49-Blue Lives Matter bill would make crimes against police a hate crime in Pa., advocacy groups push back by State Rep David
Zimmerman R-Lancaster County LNP January 10, 2017.pdf 11.01.2017
50-TD Ameritrade TRADEKEEPER PROFIT-LOSS FOR 2004 TRADES and 2017 FULTON STOCKE January 9, 2017.pdf 11.01.2017
51-Usage Statistics for www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com TOTALS and MONTHLY From May of 2016 to January 2017 - January
10, 2017.pdf 11.01.2017
52-WHISTLEBLOWERS KAREN STEWART AND STAN CATERBONE A Candid Discussion of Electronic Harassment Protocols, January
11, 2017.pdf 11.01.2017
54-PRESIDENT OBAMA DEFENDANT EXHIBIT of October 23, 2015 RECONSTRUCTED JANUARY 14, 2017
55-1987 JOINT VENTURE - Tony Bongiovi, Power Station Studios, and Flatbush Films with Stan J. Caterbone January 15, 2017
56-STAN J. CATERBONE ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP JOINT VENTURE WITH DALE HIGH January 15, 2017
57-STAN J. CATERBONE'S Financial Management Group, Ltd., Anti-Trust Litigation File of October 17, 2015
58-Institutional Investors Mortgage Banking Business Development of 1987 January 15, 2017
59-Pro Financial Group Brochure and Eastern Regional Free Agent Camp by Stan J. Caterbone January 16, 2017
16-cv-4014
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE
AMENDED
- Estaban
Defense
COMPLAINT
Santiago Defense
DVD FILE LISTPage
Page
Page33
31
3of
of415
6
40 Wednesday
Thursday
Friday January
January20,
18,2017
19, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 808Page
of 2413
809 of 2593
by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
60-1999 Excelsior Place Business Plan by Stan J. Caterbone January 16, 2017
61-Stan J. Caterbone AIM MUTUAL FUNDS Consulting From 1999 to 2002 January 16, 2017
62-Sam Lombardo and Raolph Mazzochi Charlotte Street Proposal by Advanced Media Group and Stan J. Caterbone January 17, 2017
64-LETTER TO U.S. CONGRESSMAN ROBERT WALKER and PLEADING of July 7, 1991 Bookmarked January 17, 2017
65-AMG LEGAL SYSTEMS PROTOTYPE Mastered on April 16, 1991 at Commadore Inc., January 17, 2017
66-Legal Implications of the 1959 Soviet Microwave Bombardment of the U.S Embassy January 17, 2017
67-Stan J. Caterbone, Controller of Pflumm Contractors, Inc., 1993 to 1998 January 17, 2017
68-THE EXTORTION of 220 Stone Hill Road, Conestoga, PA by COINTELPRO PRGRAMS January 17, 2017
AUDIO FILES\
1. ALTANA Rooftop Bar June 25, 2016 - Conspiracy to Commit......mp3 24.12.2016
2. Appointment with Dr. Brian Sullivan of Abbeyville Family Medicine-LGH re Pain Management of March_0.wma 24.12.2016
3. Audio Appointment with Psychiatrist Al Shulz in January of 1998 in his Office in York, Pennsylvania.mp3 24.12.2016
4. Audio of Call to KENS TV5 re Broadcast of Dr. John Hall March 8, 2010.mp3 24.12.2016
5. Audio of FFCHS Conference Call with Orville re Survey of TI's on Surge of EXTREME PAIN and TERROR on March 11, 2010.mp3
24.12.2016
6. AUDIO of Fulton Bank Harassment on EXTREME PAIN and TERROR on March 11, 2010.mp3 24.12.2016
7. Audio Recordings of 1987 - PA SEC-PA Atty Gen-Gamillion Film Studios-Power Station Studios-Sandra Gray Atty.mp3 24.12.2016
8. Call to Assistant U.S. Attorney Chrystie Fawcett During Serving of 302 Petition on April 8, 2010.mp3 24.12.2016
9. Conversation and Plea for Help with Pennsylvania Attorney Bodan on October 19, 1987.mp3 24.12.2016
10. Conversation With Attorney David Drubner on July 10, 1987.mp3 24.12.2016
11. Conversation With Lancaster Aviation President Chuck Smith re Illegal Reposession of Aircraft on _0.mp3 24.12.2016
12. Dr. John Hall Radio Show of FFCHS Press Conference of April 19, 2010 in Louisville Kentucky.mp3 24.12.2016
14. Harassment and Malic at NovaCare Rehabilitation for Physical Therapy on April 1, 2010.mp3 24.12.2016
15. Meeting With Attorney Sandra Grey in San Diego on February 24, 1988.mp3 24.12.2016
16. Meeting with Howard Eisler, Investigator With The Pennsylvania Securities Commission re ISC of September 29, 1987.mp3
24.12.2016
17. Meeting With Pennsylvania Securities Commission Agent Howard Eisler of September 29, 1987.mp3 24.12.2016
18. Message from Liapatt Attorney Julie Cooper re Email March 15, 2010.WAV 24.12.2016
19. Message From Lt. Detective Clark Bearinger re Psychiatric Appointment of April 23, 2010.WAV 24.12.2016
20. My Appearence on FFCHS Talkshoe Conference with Orville April 1, 2010 Online Chat.mp3 24.12.2016
21. Phone Conversation With Pennsylvania Securities Commission Agent Howard Eisler on October 17, 1987.mp3 24.12.2016
22. Recording of Dale Graff on Coast to Coast re Remote Viewing - Project Stargate - DIA with My Commentary February 17,
2010.mp3 24.12.2016
23. Return Call from U.S. Attorney Christie Fawcett on February 22, 2010 9-58AM.mp3 24.12.2016
24. Second Conversation With Atty Drubner & Meeting With Film Studio Gamillion Studios of Hollywood Jul_0.mp3 24.12.2016
16-cv-4014
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE
AMENDED
- Estaban
Defense
COMPLAINT
Santiago Defense
DVD FILE LISTPage
Page
Page34
32
4of
of415
6
40 Wednesday
Thursday
Friday January
January20,
18,2017
19, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 809Page
of 2413
810 of 2593
by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
25. Segments of My Appearence and Interview on FFCHS Talkshoe Conference with Orville April 1, 2010.mp3 24.12.2016
26. Sgt. Busser of Southern Regional Police 302 Fleeing Arrest AUDIO Recording With Commentary of Apr_0.mp3 24.12.2016
27. The Jim Guest Show Week 3 with Dr. Hall and Dr. Robertson re Electromagnetic Weapons November 29, 2009.mp3 24.12.2016
29. TS-340595 4-01-2010-My Appearence on FFCHS Talkshoe Conference with Orville April 1, 2010 Online Chat.mp3 24.12.2016
30. FMG Video St Joseph Hospital George Werner April 1987.avi 27.12.2016
31. FMG Video II St Joseph Hospital George Werner April 1987.avi 27.12.2016
32. Julianne McKinney interview by Greg Syzmanski, Gang Stalking and Electronic Torture April 2006.WAV 08.01.2017
33. Tour of Sam Caterbone Cleaners 1470 Manhiem Pike, Lancaster, PA August 11, 2016
34. Video of the Movie IN YOUR EYES about 2 People That Are Telepathic Made In 2013, Published June 18, 2016
35. Mental Telepathy & Electromagnetic Weapons Part 9 Capabilities Profile video-2010-02-06-14-33-28
36. Karen Stewert NSA Whistleblower Describing the ATTEMPT TO MURDER Certain TI's Like Me (Stan Caterbone) Using
Electromagnetic Weapons May 9, 2016
37. James Doran (TI) Breaking and Entering 220 Stone Hill Road on April 7, 2006 by Security Camera
RECENT FILINGS\
1. January 3, 2017 CASE FILE-PLAINTIFF Stanley J. Caterbone PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR EMERGENCY RELIEF MIDDLE DISTRICT
of PENNSYLVANIA
2. January 4, 2017 Case No. 16-2513 Preliminary Injunction Middle District CATERBONE RESONSE and Report and Reccomendation By
JUDGE MARTIN CARLSON With EXHIBIT Wednesday
3. Thursday January 5, 2017 Case No. 16-2513 Preliminary Injunction Middle District CATERBONE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION
With EXHIBIT WITH STAMP
4. Jan 5, 2017Case No. 16-2513 Preliminary Injunction Middle District REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION By JUDGE MARTIN CARLSON
January 3, 2017 Mailed Copy
5. January 9, 2017 STAMPED-Case No. 16-2513 Preliminary Injunction Middle District EXHIBIT re FT. LAUDERDALE SHOOTER AND
U.S. SPONSORED MIND CONTROL
6. January 12, 2017 U.S. Third Circuit 16-3284 MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION re ORDER In Forma Pauperis DENIED
7. dated January 12, 2017 RESPONSE LETTER to the Judicial Conduct Board re Additional Information for COMPLAINT No. 2016-788
for JUDGE ASHWORTH and 2016-789 for JUDGE REINAKER
8. JANUARY 13, 2017 Lancaster County Court Case No. 08-CI-13373 re EXHIBIT
_______/S/____________
Stan J. Caterbone, Pro Se Litigant
ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP
Freedom From Covert Harassment & Surveillance,
Registered in Pennsylvania
1250 Fremont Street
Lancaster, PA 17603
www.amgglobalentetainmentgroup.com
stancaterbone@gmail.com
717-528-2200
Notice and Disclaimer: Stan J. Caterbone and the Advanced Media Group have been slandered, defamed, and publicly
discredited since 1987 due to going public (Whistle Blower) with allegations of misconduct and fraud within
International Signal & Control, Plc. of Lancaster, Pa. (ISC pleaded guilty to selling arms to Iraq via South Africa and a $1
Billion Fraud in 1992). Unfortunately we are forced to defend our reputation and the truth without the aid of law
enforcement and the media, which would normally prosecute and expose public corruption. We utilize our
communications to thwart further libelous and malicious attacks on our person, our property, and our business. We
continue our fight for justice through the Courts, and some communications are a means of protecting our rights to
continue our pursuit of justice. Advanced Media Group is also a member of the media. Reply if you wish to be removed
from our Contact List. How long can Lancaster County and Lancaster City hide me and Continue to Cover-Up my Whistle
Blowing of the ISC Scandel (And the Torture from U.S. Sponsored Mind Control)?
16-cv-4014
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE
AMENDED
- Estaban
Defense
COMPLAINT
Santiago Defense
DVD FILE LISTPage
Page
Page35
33
5of
of415
6
40 Wednesday
Thursday
Friday January
January20,
18,2017
19, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 810Page
of 2413
811 of 2593
by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - CONFIDENTIAL
ACTIVE COURT CASES
J.C. No. 03-16-90005 Office of the Circuit Executive, United States Third Circuit Court of Appeals - COMPLAINT
OF JUDICIALMISCONDUCT OR DISABILITY re 15-3400 and 16-1149; 03-16-900046 re ALL FEDERAL LITIGATION
TO DATE
U.S. Supreme Court Case No. 16-6822 PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI re Case No. 16-1149 MOVANT for Lisa
Michelle Lambert
U.S.C.A. Third Circuit Court of Appeals Case No. 16-1149 MOVANT for Lisa Michelle Lambert;15-3400 MOVANT for
Lisa Michelle Lambert;; 16-1001; 07-4474
U.S. District Court Eastern District of PA Case No. 16-4014 CATERBONE v. United States, et.al.; Case No. 16-cv-49;
15-03984; 14-02559 MOVANT for Lisa Michelle Lambert; 05-2288; 06-4650, 08-02982;
U.S. District Court Middle District of PA Case No. 16-cv-1751 PETITION FOR HABEUS CORPUS
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Judicial Conduct Board Case No. 2016-462 Complaint against Lancaster County
Court of Common Pleas Judge Leonard Brown III
Pennsylvania Supreme Court Case No. 353 MT 2016; 354 MT 2016; 108 MM 2016 Amicus for Kathleen Kane
Superior Court of Pennsylvania Summary Appeal Case No. CP-36-SA-0000219-2016, AMICUS for Kathleen Kane
Case No. 1164 EDA 2016; Case No. 1561 MDA 2015; 1519 MDA 2015; 16-1219 Preliminary Injunction Case of 2016
Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas Case No. 08-13373; 15-10167; 06-03349, CI-06-03401
U.S. Bankruptcy Court for The Eastern District of Pennsylvania Case No. 16-10157
16-cv-4014
Estaban
INVOICE Santiago
FEE
AMENDED
- Estaban
Defense
COMPLAINT
Santiago Defense
DVD FILE LISTPage
Page
Page36
34
6of
of415
6
40 Wednesday
Thursday
Friday January
January20,
18,2017
19, 2017
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 811Page
of 2413
812 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
15.Super Bowl Katy Perry Halftime Show Performance 2015 ORIGINAL - YouTube katy
perry super bowl 2015 performance - YouTube
14.Dido - Live 8 concert (London 2005) - YouTube dido live 8 - YouTube dido live -
YouTube
13.Madonna - Like A Prayer - Live 8 - 2005 - YouTube madonna live 8 like a prayer -
YouTube
10.Cat Stevens - Peace Train (live) - YouTube cat stevens peace train -
7.YouTube Green Day - American Idiot lyrics [1080p] - YouTube green day american
idiot -
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page39
1 of
of377
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 812Page
of 2413
813 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
5.YouTube Crosby Stills Nash & Young - Teach Your Children - YouTube youtube teach
your children -
3.The Black Eyed Peas - Where Is The Love? - YouTube youtube black eyed peas where
is the love - Google Search black eyed peas youtube - Google Search
Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on Twitter USPS Delivery Confirmation and
Letter of Sentence Recommendation for Kathleen Kane to Honorable Judge Wendy
Demchick-Alloy October 22, 2016 USPS Delivery Confirmation Re Letter of Sentence
Recommendation for Kathleen Kane to Honorable Judge Wendy Demchick-Alloy October
22, 2016 USPS.com - USPS Tracking USPS Item Delivered, PO Box for Shipment
9405503699300411473669 - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Stan, a few Google+
posts you may like - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Zuckerberg proves he is
Facebook's editor by allowing Trump's hate speech | Technology | The
Guardian Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on Twitter Usage Statistics for
www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com TOTALS and MONTHLY to October 22, 2016
With 30 of 40 TOP COUNTRIES October 22, 2016 Russian man charged with hacking
LinkedIn and other tech firms | Technology | The Guardian Logout - Omnis Network -
Account Manager Usage Statistics for www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com -
September 2016 Usage Statistics for www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com - October
2016 Usage Statistics for www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com - Summary by Month
Web Site Statistics and Logs - Omnis Network - Account Manager Home - Omnis
Network - Account Manager Login - Omnis Network - Account Manager Everything
Hosting by Omnis Network Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on Twitter Trump
says countries are turning on US because 'the world hates Obama' | US
news | The Guardian The Guardian today: Trump says countries are turning on US
because 'the world hates Obama' - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
Lancaster County man electrocuted after coming into contact with high-voltage wire in
Berks County | Local News | lancasteronline.com Evening Update: The Latest News
Headlines - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page40
2 of
of377
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 813Page
of 2413
814 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
OCTOBER HISTORY
Stan J. Caterbone (@SCaterbone) | Twitter Online Banking | Members 1st Federal Credit
Union Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on Twitter Stan J. Caterbone Members
1st Federal Credit Union ACCOUNT ACTIVITY August 23, 2016 to October 22, 2016
BARRY MILLER CHECK.pdf Scribd Upload a Document | Scribd View Account | Members
1st Federal Credit Union View Account | Members 1st Federal Credit Union My Accounts
| Members 1st Federal Credit Union Online Banking | Members 1st Federal Credit Union
Online Banking | Members 1st Federal Credit Union Keeper - Password vault and online
file storage Local Pennsylvania Susquehanna Valley Breaking News and Live Alerts -
WGAL News 8 Inbox - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail LNP Game of the Week
highlights: Manheim Township at Wilson | Football | lancasteronline.com Man killed in
Manor Township crash | Local News | lancasteronline.com Lancaster CRIZ earns city
$3.4 million for development | Local News | lancasteronline.com Trump to make
campaign's closing arguments Saturday morning in Gettysburg | Politics |
lancasteronline.com Lancaster County tops in state for renewable energy and solar
panels | Insider | lancasteronline.com First Read: Morning Local News Headlines -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Google Alert - Mind Control -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail The Donalds Five-Point Plan to Defeat Islam - Juan
Cole - Truthdig Patty Hearst, Double Agents and the Symbionese Liberation Army -
Truthdig Massive Cyberattack Hits U.S. Servers, Affects Twitter, Reddit and Other Sites
- Truthdig Robert Scheer and David Dayen Uncover Untold Stories of the Mortgage Crisis
- Truthdig Robert Scheer and David Dayen Uncover Untold Stories of the Mortgage Crisis
- stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Katy Perry - Firework "Best
Performance"(Victoria's Secret Fashion Show 2010) - YouTube Super Bowl Katy
Perry Halftime Show Performance 2015 ORIGINAL - YouTube katy perry super bowl
2015 performance - YouTube Dido - Live 8 concert (London 2005) - YouTube dido live 8
- YouTube dido live - YouTube Madonna - Like A Prayer - Live 8 - 2005 - YouTube
madonna live 8 like a prayer - YouTube Coldplay And Richard Ashcroft - Bittersweet
Symphony (Live 8) - YouTube Yusuf Islam - Peace Train - OUTSTANDING! - YouTube
CNN.com - Detained Cat Stevens heading home - Sep 22, 2004 Cat Stevens - Peace Train
(live) - YouTube cat stevens peace train - YouTube Lady Gaga - "What's Up" 4
Non Blondes Live Cover at #artRaveVienna - YouTube Green Day: "Boulevard Of Broken
Dreams" - [Official Video] - YouTube Green Day - American Idiot lyrics [1080p] -
YouTube Green Day - American Idiot lyrics [1080p] - YouTube green day american idiot
- YouTube Dixie Chicks - I Hope (Telethon) - YouTube Crosby Stills Nash & Young -
Teach Your Children - YouTube youtube teach your children - YouTube The Cranberries -
Zombie - YouTube The Black Eyed Peas - Where Is The Love? - YouTube youtube black
eyed peas where is the love - Google Search black eyed peas youtube - Google Search
NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden: 'I don't want to live in a society that
does these sort of things' - YouTube JFK Secret Societies Speech (full version) -
YouTube President John F Kennedy Secret Society Speech version 2 - YouTube Your
Tweet has been posted! Share a link on Twitter USPS Delivery Confirmation and Letter
of Sentence Recommendation for Kathleen Kane to Honorable Judge Wendy Demchick-
Alloy October 22, 2016 USPS Delivery Confirmation Re Letter of Sentence
Recommendation for Kathleen Kane to Honorable Judge Wendy Demchick-Alloy October
22, 2016 USPS.com - USPS Tracking USPS Item Delivered, PO Box for Shipment
9405503699300411473669 - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Stan, a few Google+
posts you may like - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Zuckerberg proves he is
Facebook's editor by allowing Trump's hate speech | Technology | The
Guardian Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on Twitter Usage Statistics for
www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com TOTALS and MONTHLY to October 22, 2016
With 30 of 40 TOP COUNTRIES October 22, 2016 Russian man charged with hacking
LinkedIn and other tech firms | Technology | The Guardian Logout - Omnis Network -
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page41
3 of
of377
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 814Page
of 2413
815 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page42
4 of
of377
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 815Page
of 2413
816 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page43
5 of
of377
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 816Page
of 2413
817 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page44
6 of
of377
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 817Page
of 2413
818 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page45
7 of
of377
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 818Page
of 2413
819 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page46
8 of
of377
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 819Page
of 2413
820 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Dylan wins Nobel prize in literature | Music | The Guardian Trump faces a torrent of
sexual misconduct allegations - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail PA Atty General Ol
Boy Bruce Beemer is likely to edit or bury #porngate report to influence election -
YouTube Defend A Child: "PA Atty General Ol Boy Bruce Beemer is likely to edit or bury
#porn..." - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail NEXT WEBINAR: Movie night with "Citizen
Four" - Oct. 24! Clinton may have taken performance-enhancing drugs before debate
Trump | US news | The Guardian The Guardian today: Offshore secrets of Brexit backer
Arron Banks revealed in Panama Papers - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Alexander
Reed Kelly: Photo of the Week: Rockets Explode as Media Spin Escalation of a U.S. War
in Yemen - Truthdig Eric Ortiz: WikiLeaks Should Be Applauded for Removing the Mask
of U.S. Power - Truthdig WikiLeaks Should Be Applauded for Removing the Mask of U.S.
Power - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail USPS Item Arrived at Hub for Shipment
9505513422366286014053 - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Your Tweet has been
posted! Share a link on Twitter Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on Twitter
Chef Cedric Barberet runs Lancaster eatery; worked at Le Bec-Fin and Donald Trump
estate | Local News | lancasteronline.com Welcome to LancasterHistory.org
http://lancasterhistory.org/ thaddeussquare.png childrenatwheatlandslider.png
epson15786.exe Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on Twitter LancasterHistory
exhibit explores freedom: 'What theme could be more gripping?' | Together
| lancasteronline.com Family seeks justice, transparency after slaying; DAs office says
it has been forthcoming | Local News | lancasteronline.com Your Tweet has been
posted! Share a link on Twitter PUBLIC CORRUPTION by CLERK of COURTS Re Case No.
CP-36-SA-0000219-2016 Summary Appeal in the Lancaster County Court of Common
Pleas - October 16, 2016 Samuel P Caterbone (My Father) MIND CONTROL and PUBLIC
CORRUPTION Documentation and EVIDENCE October 15, 2016 First Read: Morning Local
News Headlines - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Google Alert - Mind Control -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Label-386704597.pdf USPS.com - Print Shipping
Labels Jeremy Ibrahim Chadds Ford PA Lawyer, Attorney Criminal Defense Jeremy H.
Gonzalez Ibrahim, Esq. - Google Search Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on
Twitter PUBLIC CORRUPTION by CLERK of COURTS Re Case No. CP-36-SA-0000219-
2016 Summary Appeal in the Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas - October 15,
2016 Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on Twitter Syria talks in Switzerland
produce only a decision to keep talking - The Washington Post Syria GOOGLE NEWS -
Google Search GOOGLE NEWS - Google Search Staples Scan.pdf Scan from Staples -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Scan from Staples - stancaterbone@gmail.com -
Gmail Epson America, Inc. - Downloading File Page Epson WorkForce WF-2630, Drivers
& Downloads - Technical Support - Epson America, Inc. epson workhorse 2630 - Google
Search Google Alert - Mind Control - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Your Tweet has
been posted! CourtSummaryReport.ashx CPReport.ashx Common Pleas Docket Sheet
Obama, National Security Team Huddle on Syrian Civil War - ABC News
http://abcn.ws/2dqdF1e Lancaster County scholars, musicians weigh in on Bob
Dylan's Nobel Prize win | Insider | lancasteronline.com Evening Update: The
Latest News Headlines - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Google Alert - keith sadler -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Robert Downey Jr offers to voice Mark
Zuckerberg's digital assistant | Technology | The Guardian The Guardian today:
No extra money for NHS, Theresa May tells health chief - stancaterbone@gmail.com -
Gmail Rayyan Al-Shawaf: The Return - Truthdig Sarah Wesley: Maya Angelou: And Still
I Rise Weaves a Rich Fabric From the Authors Lived History - In the News - Truthdig
Dylan, the American Left, and What We Have Lost - Juan Cole - Truthdig Robert Scheer
and Petros Papadakis Discuss the Joys and Dangers of College Football -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Man charged with attempted homicide in Lancaster
city shooting arrested | Local News | lancasteronline.com Mike Pence landed Thursday
at Lancaster Airport | Local News | lancasteronline.com Game of the Week: Lancaster
Catholic routs Pequea Valley in Rossmere Stadium finale | Football |
lancasteronline.com LNP Game of the Week highlights: Pequea Valley at Lancaster
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page47
9 of
of377
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 820Page
of 2413
821 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 48
10 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 821Page
of 2413
822 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 49
11 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 822Page
of 2413
823 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
LAMBERT Habeus Corpus PETITION for WRIT of CERTIORARI to the United States
Supreme Court October 12, 2016 Claim Documents (0557461720101022) -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Document.pdf Claim Documents
(0557461720101022) - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail caterbone.pdf Consent-to-
Release-2016.pdf 2004 Santa Fe - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Gmail - Amtrak:
eTicket and Receipt for Your 10/13/2016 Trip - STAN CATERBONE Caterbone Stan
201610121833230708.pdf Amtrak: eTicket and Receipt for Your 10/13/2016 Trip -
STAN CATERBONE - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Lewistown, PA Car Rental -
Enterprise Rent-A-Car CAR RENTAL LEWISTOWN PA - Google Search AMTRAK
LEWISTOWN PA - Google Search AMTRAK LEWISTOWN PA - Google Search AMTRAK
LEWISTOWN PA - Google Search AMTRAK LEWISTOWN PA - Google Search Amtrak -
Stations - Lewistown, PA (LEW) AMTRAK LEWISTOWN PA - Google Search LEWISTOWN
PA - Google Search Rash of gunfire rattles some residents but not all after 6th shots
fired incident in 5 days | Local News | lancasteronline.com First Read: Morning Local
News Headlines - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail #votingbecause - Why are you
voting? | From The USATODAY NETWORK Stan J. Caterbone (@SCaterbone) | Twitter
Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on Twitter Is Trump the master of mind
control? Google Alert - Mind Control - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
'Unshackled' Trump goes to war against Republicans -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Lancaster City Council approves $30M Marriott hotel
expansion | Local News | lancasteronline.com With gargoyles, Lancaster city buildings
are always watching you | Together | lancasteronline.com Lancaster city mayor calls 6
shots fired reports over 5 days 'unusual occurrence' | Local News |
lancasteronline.com Rash of gunfire rattles some residents but not all after 6th shots
fired incident in 5 days | Local News | lancasteronline.com lancasteronline.com |
Lancaster County's leading source of news and information Guerin
'home' to complete sentence | News | lancasteronline.com WHY DID THE
AMTRAK POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN TO LEWISTOWN INSTEAD OF HARRISBURG BY
TELLING ME THE WRONG TRACK NO.?? - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Inbox -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail WHY DID THE AMTRAK POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN
TO LEWISTOWN INSTEAD OF HARRISBURG TODAY? - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
WHY DID THE AMTRAK POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN TO LEWISTOWN INSTEAD OF
HARRISBURG TODAY? - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail WHY DID THE AMTRAK
POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN TO LEWISTOWN INSTEAD OF HARRISBURG TODAY? -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail WHY DID THE AMTRAK POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN
TO LEWISTOWN INSTEAD OF HARRISBURG TODAY? - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
WHY DID THE AMTRAK POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN TO LEWISTOWN INSTEAD OF
HARRISBURG TODAY? - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail WHY DID THE AMTRAK
POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN TO LEWISTOWN INSTEAD OF HARRISBURG TODAY? -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail WHY DID THE AMTRAK POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN
TO LEWISTOWN INSTEAD OF HARRISBURG TODAY? - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
WHY DID THE AMTRAK POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN TO LEWISTOWN INSTEAD OF
HARRISBURG TODAY? - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail WHY DID THE AMTRAK
POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN TO LEWISTOWN INSTEAD OF HARRISBURG TODAY? -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail WHY DID THE AMTRAK POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN
TO LEWISTOWN INSTEAD OF HARRISBURG TODAY? - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
WHY DID THE AMTRAK POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN TO LEWISTOWN INSTEAD OF
HARRISBURG TODAY? - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail WHY DID THE AMTRAK
POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN TO LEWISTOWN INSTEAD OF HARRISBURG TODAY? -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail WHY DID THE AMTRAK POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN
TO LEWISTOWN INSTEAD OF HARRISBURG TODAY? - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
WHY DID THE AMTRAK POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN TO LEWISTOWN INSTEAD OF
HARRISBURG TODAY? - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail WHY DID THE AMTRAK
POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN TO LEWISTOWN INSTEAD OF HARRISBURG TODAY? -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail WHY DID THE AMTRAK POLICE PUT ME ON A TRAIN
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 50
12 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 823Page
of 2413
824 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 51
13 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 824Page
of 2413
825 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 52
14 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 825Page
of 2413
826 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 53
15 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 826Page
of 2413
827 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
2030 Fruitville Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601 - Walmart.com Walmart, 2030 Fruitville Pike,
Lancaster, PA 17601 - Walmart.com Sirius Stratus 7 Dock and Play Radio with Car Kit -
Walmart.com siriusxm players - Google Search Sirius XM Deals: Get 68% Off, Discounts
October 2016 siriusxm special offers - Google Search siriusxm special offers - Google
Search Verify Account - SiriusXM Radio SiriusXM Tell Us a Little About
Yourself - SiriusXM Radio Get Started - SiriusXM Radio sirius - Google Search "Ebay and
Online Accounts" (58) - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Pointer v. Texas, 380 U.S.
400, 85 S. Ct. 1065, 13 L. Ed. 2d 923, 1965 U.S. LEXIS 1481 CourtListener.com Pointer
v. Texas, 380 U.S. 400, 85 S.Ct. 1065, 13 L.Ed.2d 923 (1965); - Google Search Site | US
Law | LII / Legal Information Institute 14th Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII /
Legal Information Institute 27th Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute 26th Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute 25th Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute 24th Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute 23rd Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute 22nd Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute 21st Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute 20th Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute 19th Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute 18th Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute 17th Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute 16th Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute 15th Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute 13th Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute 12th Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute 11th Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute Tenth Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute Ninth Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute Eighth Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute Seventh Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute Forum Selection Clause | Wex Legal Dictionary / Encyclopedia |
LII / Legal Information Institute Sixth Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute Fourteenth Amendment | Wex Legal Dictionary / Encyclopedia |
LII / Legal Information Institute constitution right to due process - Google Search
constitution right to appeal - Google Search federal right to appeal - Google Search
PACTS, International Newsletter - Monday, October 10, 2016 -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Stan J. Caterbone on Twitter: "I MEANT AMY JO"
Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on Twitter Recorded Case No. 16-mc-49
Statement Re Third Circuit Case No. 16-1149 Lambert Habeus Corpus Petition for Writ
of Certiorari to the United States Supreme Court October 9, 2016 United States District
Court Eastern District of Pennsylvania-United States District Court Eastern District of
Pennsylvania Activity in Case 2:16-mc-00049-EGS CATERBONE Statement -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail 326663016-Stan-Caterbone-s-Clinton-Global-
Initiative-Invitation-of-July-5-2005.txt Stan Caterbone's Clinton Global Initiative
Invitation of July 5, 2005 Russian Scientists Develop Thought-Controlled Robotic
Interface Google Alert - Mind Control - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Cavulus Direct
Penn State rapid reaction: Nittany Lions 38, Maryland 14 (Happy Homecoming from
Beaver Stadium) | PennLive.com penn state football - Google Search Lower energy
costs should again give homeowners a break on heating bills this winter | Local
Business | lancasteronline.com First Read: Morning Local News Headlines -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail The Age of Decline, Apple Pie and Americas Chosen
Suicide Bomber - Truthdig The Age of Decline, Apple Pie and Americas Chosen Suicide
Bomber - Truthdig Hacked Emails Show Clinton Suggesting She Hides Her True Policy
Positions From the Public - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Hacked Emails Show
Clinton Suggesting She Hides Her True Policy Positions From the Public - Truthdig The
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 54
16 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 827Page
of 2413
828 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Guardian today: John McCain withdraws support for Donald Trump over groping boasts
- stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Sonali Kolhatkar: Destruction Is All We Have to
Show for a 15-Year War in Afghanistan - Truthdig Robert Scheer Interviews Misty K.
Snow, the First Major-Party Transgender Nominee for U.S. Senate -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail First Read: Morning Local News Headlines -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Google Alert - Mind Control -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Enrollment | UPMC for Life View and Compare | Shop
Medicare Plans | UPMC for Life About You | Shop Medicare Plans | UPMC for Life Where
You Live | Shop Medicare Plans | UPMC for Life Shop for Medicare Plans | UPMC for Life
UPMC Health Plan | Affordable Health Care for Individuals & Families Shop for Medicare
Plans | UPMC for Life highmark blue shield medicare advantage plans - Google Search
Stan J. Caterbone on Twitter: "READ THE FILE LIST OF AUDIO TAPES- EXHIBIT for PAIN
MEDICATIONS - Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas - https://t.co/dj75lURWVk
#ReadMore" Manheim Township to replace police chief; board cites 'change in
direction' | Insider | lancasteronline.com
http://lancasteronline.com/insider/manheim-township-to-replace-police-chief-board-
cites-change-in/article_859b576e-8457-11e6-aef9-67572d1ea5c1.html?
utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter&utm_campaign=user-share Yahoo
'secretly monitored emails on behalf of the US government' | Technology |
The Guardian Amicus Curiae Brief NSA BiPolar Mood Diagnosis Mind Control Research
Usage Statistics for www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com - August 2016 Stan J.
Caterbone Bio http://www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com IAM on Twitter: "@ziad8
THIS IIS GIRL FROM ALEPO,SYRIA. ONLY THE MUSLIMS DO THIS TO THERE OWN
BLOOD." GIRL FROM ALEPO - Twitter Search Bana Alabed, la nia que
'tuitea' contra la guerra desde Alepo
http://www.elperiodico.com/es/noticias/internacional/bana-alabed-nina-que-tuitea-
contra-guerra-desde-alepo-5438076 Alepo bana - Twitter Search The Guardian today:
Donald Trump forced to apologise as sex boast tape horrifies Republicans -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
07eb5859b1a34b91978925a92d53f02d_0557461720101022_01_IMPORTANT FOR
GEICO CLAIM OF THEFT OF VEHICLE, Stan J. Caterbone.pdf Documents & Photos Claim
Summary Access Your Claim Your GEICO claim - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
Yahoo 'secretly monitored emails on behalf of the US government' |
Technology | The Guardian Pence rolls with Kaine's punches in veep debate -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail GEICO claim Letter - stancaterbone@gmail.com -
Gmail Deputy sheriff notifies federal authorities of harassment allegations | Insider |
lancasteronline.com Damage from AC incident cost $13.5 million, Lancaster General
Hospital says | Insider | lancasteronline.com Evening Update: The Latest News
Headlines - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail The Guardian today: Theresa May
consigns Cameron to history in populist speech - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
Scott Ritter, Contributor - Truthdig Report - Scott Ritter | Truthdig Articles by Scott
Ritter, Contributor - Truthdig Scott Ritter, Contributor - Truthdig Scott Ritter: The White
Helmets and the Inherent Contradiction of Americas Syria Policy - Scott Ritter - Truthdig
Yahoo Spied on Customers Email at the U.S. Governments Request - Truthdig Whats Behind Time
Magazines Putin Demonizing? - Truthdig Today, 1 p.m. PDT / 4 p.m. EDT: What's Wrong With the
Death Penalty? - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail NSA contractor arrested for alleged theft of top secret
classified information | US news | The Guardian Florida braces for direct hit from Hurricane Matthew -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Webinar Preview - Saturday! - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
Entertainment Lancaster - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Columbia forum to focus on police relations,
racial violence | Local News | lancasteronline.com Evening Update: The Latest News Headlines -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Eastern Aleppo could be destroyed by Christmas, warns UN Syria envoy |
World news | The Guardian Hurricane Matthew: storm weakens but continues to lash Florida and Georgia
live | World news | The Guardian The Guardian today: Hurricane Matthew: Florida hit by
'monster' storm after hundreds killed in Haiti latest - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
Thinkin
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 55
17 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 828Page
of 2413
829 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
SEPTEMBER HISTORY
Stan J. Caterbone (@SCaterbone) | Twitter Scribd Upload a Document | Scribd View
Account | Members 1st Federal Credit Union Keeper - Password vault and online file
storage Inbox - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Direct Express USPS.com - Billing
Information USPS.com - Review Shipping Labels USPS.com - Create Shipping Labels
Twitter / Notifications Direct Express Direct Express Page not found | Comerica
Inbox (1) - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail United States District Court Eastern
District of Pennsylvania-login United States District Court Eastern District of
Pennsylvania United States District Court Eastern District of Pennsylvania-login United
States District Court Eastern District of Pennsylvania-United States District Court
Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District Court PICKUP SCAFFOLDING
BEHIND 1250 FREMONT STREET IN ALLEY! - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
NewsLanc.com: News, Comment and Culture for Lancaster County "ECF Filings" (18) -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail View Account | Members 1st Federal Credit Union
Services | Members 1st Federal Credit Union My Accounts | Members 1st Federal Credit
Union Online Banking | Members 1st Federal Credit Union Online Banking | Members 1st
Federal Credit Union 503 No healthy backends Guerin 'home' to complete
sentence | News | lancasteronline.com Web Authentication Redirect Twitter "Ebay and
Online Accounts" (58) - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Stan J. Caterbone Bio Google
Alert - Mind Control - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Label-385287049.pdf
USPS.com - Print Shipping Labels USPS.com - Create Shipping Labels Redirect to
Print Shipping Labels How to Send Mail | USPS USPS.com - Sign In usps shipping -
Google Search Web Authentication Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on Twitter
DOCUMENTATION For 2004 Hyundai Santa Fe From Barry Miller Quality Cars for $5495
CASH (Check) on Saturday September 17, 2016 324346794-2004-Hyundai-Santa-Fe-
From-Barry-Miller-Quality-Cars-for-5-495-CASH-on-Saturday-September-17-2016.pdf
2004 Hyundai Santa Fe From Barry Miller Quality Cars for $5,495 CASH on Saturday
September 17, 2016 United States District Court Eastern District of Pennsylvania-United
States District Court Eastern District of Pennsylvania Activity in Case 2:16-mc-00049-
EGS CATERBONE Declaration - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Gore Vidal: America
the Great ... Police State - Gore Vidal's Essays - Truthdig The First 2016
Presidential Debate - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail First Read: Morning Local News
Headlines - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Missing last night -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Police seek person in clown mask after fatal stabbing
Sunday in Reading | Local News | lancasteronline.com Manheim Township to replace
police chief; board cites 'change in direction' | Insider |
lancasteronline.com Evening Update: The Latest News Headlines -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Man who jumped front desk at LNP offices suspected
in incident at another downtown business | Local News | lancasteronline.com First
Read: Morning Local News Headlines - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Google Alert -
Mind Control - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail SpaceX founder Elon Musk plans to get
humans to Mars in six years | Technology | The Guardian Wells Fargo executives forfeit
millions and CEO to forgo salary amid inquiry | Business | The Guardian Former Miss
Universe returns to criticize Trump and stump for Clinton - stancaterbone@gmail.com -
Gmail Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on Twitter Your Tweet has been posted!
Share a link on Twitter Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on Twitter Your Tweet
has been posted! Share a link on Twitter Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on
Twitter Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on Twitter Case No. CI-16-08472
Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas CATERBONE v. LGH, et.al., Re MOTION for
CONTINUANCE Re Lancaster City Police Department of September 27, 2016 Case No.
Summary Appeal CP-36-SA-0000247-2016 Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas -
MOTION for CONTINUANCE Re Lancaster City Police Department of September 27, 2016
Case No. 495 - 496 MAL 2016 the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania - MOTION for
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 56
18 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 829Page
of 2413
830 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 57
19 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 830Page
of 2413
831 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 58
20 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 831Page
of 2413
832 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 59
21 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 832Page
of 2413
833 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Google Search uhaul truck rental - Google Search Xport 1 1/4" Hitch 3 Bicycle Rack
lancaster, PA for sale "bicycle rack" - craigslist craigslist: lancaster, PA jobs,
apartments, personals, for sale, services, community, and events craigslist - Google
Search 2007 Hyundai Santa Fe SE lancaster, PA cars & trucks - by owner - craigslist
lancaster, PA cars & trucks - by owner - craigslist craigslist - autos craiglist - Google
Search Google Alert - Mind Control - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Tweets with
replies by Stan J. Caterbone (@SCaterbone) | Twitter Your Tweet has been posted!
Share a link on Twitter What does Gov. Wolf's call for a joint session on opioid
epidemic entail? | Politics | lancasteronline.com First Read: Morning Local News
Headlines - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail This Is The Future Of The Air Force
Reserve - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Pigs! Crusaders!: U.S.-Backed
Fundamentalists Chase American Commandos Out of Syria - Juan Cole - Truthdig
There's No Debate - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Study: For every hour
doctors see patients, they spend two on records & desk work | Local News |
lancasteronline.com With opening of Novara, concierge medicine gains ground in
Lancaster County | Insider | lancasteronline.com Evening Update: The Latest News
Headlines - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Police looking for 28-year-old man
following explosions in New York City, New Jersey; Amtrak issues service alert | Local
News | lancasteronline.com Who's in jail? Lancaster County Prison population by
gender, race, age, mental health status | Insider | lancasteronline.com Lancaster
County judge shows heroin defendants sticky notes with overdose tally | Insider |
lancasteronline.com First Read: Morning Local News Headlines -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Alexander Reed Kelly: Truthdigger of the Week:
Daniel Jones, the Senates Chief Investigator Into Torture by the CIA - Truthdigger of
the Week - Truthdig Truthdigger of the Week: Daniel Jones, the Senate's Chief
Investigator Into Torture by the CIA - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail The Guardian
today: Manhattan explosion: second device is 'pressure cooker with wires
attached to phone' live - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail (no subject) -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail LightForce Lasers | NFL Alumni PA Forms-1.pdf PA
Forms.pdf PA forms for policy ending in 8685 - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail PA
forms for policy ending in 8685 - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail 4430728685_1.pdf
GEICO Policyholder Service Center GEICO Express Your Insurance Documents for policy
ending with 8685, Policy Dates 09/17/2016 - 03/17/2017 - stancaterbone@gmail.com
- Gmail Open Class Action Lawsuit Settlements Archives - Top Class Actions Computer
Hacking Video at 1250 Fremont Street on Early Sunday Morning August 14, 2016 -
YouTube New activity on your video: Computer Hacking Video at 1250 Fremont Street
on Early Sunday Morning August 14, 2016 - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
https://www.scribd.com/document/324346794/2004-Hyundai-Santa-Fe-From-Barry-
Miller-Quality-Cars-for-5-495-CASH-on-Saturday-September-17-2016 Your Tweet has
been posted! Share a link on Twitter 324114361-NEWS-The-District-Attorney-Police-
Shooting-of-Homeless-Man-Was-Clearly-Justified-DECLARATION-of-June-22-2016.pdf
NEWS - The District Attorney- Police Shooting of Homeless Man Was Clearly Justified
DECLARATION of June 22, 2016 https://www.scribd.com/doc/324114361 Your Tweet
has been posted! Share a link on Twitter UPDATED - EXCLUSIVE Transcripts of
Whistleblower Testimonies as Targeted Individuals of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and
Related Hearings and Lectures, September 17, 2016 Your Tweet has been posted! Share
a link on Twitter Stan J. Caterbone Financing Package of Saturday September 17, 2016
Submit a Letter Anonymously | Newslanc.com Your Tweet has been posted! Post a
Tweet on Twitter Twitter - AddToAny Continuing Saga: The Fight to Reveal the CIAs
Torture Secrets - Truthdig Continuing Saga: The Fight to Reveal the CIAs Torture
Secrets - Truthdig U.S. Seeks to Prevent Islamic State From Looting, Selling or
Destroying Antiquities - Truthdig Sonali Kolhatkar: Inmates Launch Series of Work
Stoppages to Protest Slave Labor - Truthdig Inmates Launch Series of Work Stoppages
to Protest 'Slave Labor' - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Lancaster
County considers transition plan to curb mentally ill inmate population | Insider |
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 60
22 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 833Page
of 2413
834 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 61
23 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 834Page
of 2413
835 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 62
24 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 835Page
of 2413
836 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Inbox - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on
Twitter Lancaster Catholic shooting drill will test school, county emergency
preparedness | Local News | lancasteronline.com First Read: Morning Local News
Headlines - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Giuliani defends Trump idea to take
Middle East oil: 'Anything is legal' in war | US news | The Guardian Trump
to release health report as Clinton recovers - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
Snowden makes his case for a pardon - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Stan J.
Caterbone on Twitter: "Motions to dismiss civil rights suit against Lancaster County
police officer, prosecutor denied https://t.co/5svBwTWTVZ via @lancasteronline" What
Did We Buy With the $5 Trillion That the Iraq and Afghanistan Wars Have Cost Us? -
Juan Cole - Truthdig What Did We Buy With the $5 Trillion That the Iraq and
Afghanistan Wars Have Cost Us? - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Return Call from
U.S. Attorney Christie Fawcett in 2010 Uploaded by SCaterbone at Your Listen
http://yourlisten.com/SCaterbone/return-call-from-us-attorney-christie-fawcett-in-
2010 Motions to dismiss civil rights suit against Lancaster County police officer,
prosecutor denied | Local News | lancasteronline.com Evening Update: The Latest News
Headlines - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Will Peace Ever Be the Norm Again in the
United States? - Live at Truthdig - Truthdig Today, 1 p.m. PDT/4 p.m. EDT: Will Peace
Ever Be the Norm in the United States? - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail What Trump
Got Wrong About Veterans Suffering From Chronic Pain What I Learned During My 3-
Year Recovery At Walter Reed - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Gmail - The Common
Wheel Receipt For Order #5417 The Common Wheel Receipt For Order #5417 -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Lancaster County Motors - stancaterbone@gmail.com
- Gmail Online backup, file sync, for pad, PC, Android and iPhone - ASUS WebStorage
WebStorageSyncAgent2.2.11.570.exe Black Lives Don't Matter to Donald Trump
or Hillary Clinton - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Your Tweet has been posted!
Share a link on Twitter Upload Music and Audio on Yourlisten Donate Here | Donation |
American Red Cross Account Twitter / Authorize an application Login to Upload,
Download, Create Playlists, Store and Comment on Audio and Music Your Tweet has
been posted! Share a link on Twitter Dr. Paul Newhart Pain Treatment of Monday
September 12, 2016 Evening Update: The Latest News Headlines -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Stan J. Caterbone on Twitter: "ISC Whistleblowing
Timeline of Events Created on or About 1991 Proofed on September 17, 2015 on
-https://t.co/DsUv2xoTxG" Your Tweet has been posted! CutePDFSetup.exe Atomic
opens rental office in Germany, continuing global expansion | Local Business |
lancasteronline.com Ponessa adds partial hospitalization for children with mental health
needs | Local Business | lancasteronline.com The Latest Business Headlines -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail My Account Sign in to your Microsoft account
Continue My Account Continue Sign in to your Microsoft account Continue Recover your
account Sign in to your Microsoft account Try Office 365 Home free for 1 month TEDx
Lancaster inspires audience to be connected | Local News | lancasteronline.com First
Read: Morning Local News Headlines - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Online
Banking | Members 1st Federal Credit Union Emma Niles: Truthdigger of the Week:
Former British Ambassador and Whistleblower Craig Murray - Truthdigger of the Week -
Truthdig Truthdigger of the Week: Former British Ambassador and Whistleblower Craig
Murray - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Your eStatement is available for viewing! -
stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail Update: 2 shot in Columbia following large fight
outside club early Sunday morning | Local News | lancasteronline.com Car hits 2 houses
on Hershey Avenue in Lancaster city | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Apache_OpenOffice_4.1.2_Win_x86_install_en-US.exe Download Apache OpenOffice
from SourceForge.net Download Apache OpenOffice from SourceForge.net Apache
OpenOffice - Official Download Apache OpenOffice - Official Site - The Free and Open
Productivity Suite 5 free open source alternatives to Microsoft Office | PCWorld free
office suite - Google Search Your Tweet has been posted! Share a link on Twitter School
District of Lancaster officials set meetings to address Friday night shooting | Local
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 63
25 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 836Page
of 2413
837 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 64
26 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 837Page
of 2413
838 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 65
27 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 838Page
of 2413
839 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 66
28 of 415
249
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
October
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
22,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 839Page
of 2413
840 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Bookmarks Menu
Recently Bookmarked
Recent Tags
;laksdjfalskdjf
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 67
29 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 840Page
of 2413
841 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
tabs june 7, 2012
LancasterOnline.com: eEditions
LancasterOnline.com: Your Lancaster County News, Sports & Weather Source
LancasterOnline.com: eEditions
LancasterOnline.com: Your Lancaster County News, Sports & Weather Source
Hotmail - scaterbone@live.com
LancasterOnline.com: eEditions
Hotmail - scaterbone@live.com
LancasterOnline.com: Your Lancaster County News, Sports & Weather Source
LancasterOnline.com: Your Lancaster County News, Sports & Weather Source
Hotmail - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Stan J. Caterbone on Scribd | Scribd
Stan J. Caterbone on Scribd | Scribd
GoFundMe - Dashboard
Stan Caterbone | LinkedIn
Proofed Stan J. Caterbone Biography November 2010
Stan J. Caterbone on Scribd | Scribd
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Stan J. Caterbone on Scribd | Scribd
GoFundMe - Dashboard
Stan Caterbone | LinkedIn
Proofed Stan J. Caterbone Biography November 2010
Stan J. Caterbone on Scribd | Scribd
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 69
31 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 842Page
of 2413
843 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
July 27, 2015
September 1, 2015
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Stan Caterbone
CountySuite Civil Court
bank of lancaster county demise - - Yahoo Search Results
Local News | lancasteronline.com
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
United States District Court Eastern District of Pennsylvania-United States District Court Eastern
District of Pennsylvania
Stan Caterbone
Lisa Lambert Faces Jail Again For Slaying The Lancaster County Woman's Murder Conviction Was
Reinstated By A Federal Appeals Panel. - philly-archives
CountySuite Civil Court
DocumentHandler.ashx
David R. Cook Sr., 64, Founded Penna. Convenience-store Chain - philly-archives
More shootings, more hunger for law and order | Smart Remarks
GAO-12-479, ELECTRONIC WARFARE: DOD Actions Needed to Strengthen Management and
Oversight - 592211.pdf
Digital Angel Corp., Prior to Merger with Applied Digital Solutions, Inc.: Private Company
Information - Businessweek
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 70
32 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 843Page
of 2413
844 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
bank of lancaster county demise - - Yahoo Search Results
bank of lancaster county demise - - Yahoo Search Results
Bookmarks
Outlook.com (8) - scaterbone@live.com
Stan Caterbone
My Account
george lucas and digital movie - - Yahoo Search Results
Linked.com- Linking people, skills and opportunities
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Stan Caterbone
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
stan caterbone and advanced media group - - Yahoo Search Results
Recently Bookmarked
plantation homes
U.S. Department of Homeland Security seal, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services logo
Outlook.com
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 71
33 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 844Page
of 2413
845 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Legal Aid Fund by Stan Caterbone - GoFundMe
CONTACT @ LIP News
stan caterbone advanced media group - Google Search
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com
People You May Know | LinkedIn
Mind Wars - Kindle edition by Marie D. Jones, Larry Flaxman. Religion & Spirituality Kindle eBooks
@ Amazon.com.
stan caterbone advanced media group - Google Search
The Robing Room
LancasterOnline: Local News
LancasterOnline: Local News
Outlook.com
Legal Aid Fund by Stan Caterbone - GoFundMe
LancasterOnline: Local News
CONTACT @ LIP News
The Robing Room
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
People You May Know | LinkedIn
Mind Wars - Kindle edition by Marie D. Jones, Larry Flaxman. Religion & Spirituality Kindle eBooks
@ Amazon.com.
Outlook.com
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Stew Webb | LinkedIn
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Stew Webb Federal Whistlblower-Activist, US Intel Breaking News,News,
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
GoFundMe - Dashboard
peggy steinman lancaster - Google Search
Sheila Corone - Google Search
Stew Webb | LinkedIn
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
peggy steinman lancaster - Google Search
Sheila Corone - Google Search
July 5, 2015
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Jan Schwartz, PhD, CHS-V, IAC | LinkedIn
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 72
34 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 845Page
of 2413
846 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Exposing Judicial Unaccountability and Consequent Riskless Wrongdoing and Launching Judicial
Reform - DrRCordero-Honest_Jud_Advocates.pdf
Scribd
LancasterOnline: Local News
LancasterOnline: Local News
LancasterOnline: Local News
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Colleen Kerwick | LinkedIn
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Disciplined judge's lawyer says "criminal investigation" is over a summary traffic ticket -
LancasterOnline: Local News
Stan J. Caterbone on Scribd | Scribd
without prejudice legal definition of without prejudice
GoFundMe - Dashboard
Murder of Laurie Show - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Colleen Kerwick | LinkedIn
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Stan J. Caterbone on Scribd | Scribd
without prejudice legal definition of without prejudice
GoFundMe - Dashboard
Murder of Laurie Show - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
August 3, 2015
August 8, 2015
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Keeper - Password vault and online file storage
Stan Caterbone
Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Relief v Residents of
County of Lancaster August 16, 2015
Pro Se Sales Journal Billings Feb 12 2008
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Stan Caterbone
Lancaster Court of Common Pleas Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Relief v Residents of County
of Lancaster August 16, 2015
Keeper - Password vault and online file storage
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Stan Caterbone
fuck you
Stan Caterbone
Main MessageCenter Page (View Faxes)
Stan Caterbone
Lisa Michelle Lambert MOTION to File STATEMENT by Movant Case No. 5-14-Cv-02259 August
25, 2015
Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Relief December 27,
2009
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Mind Wars by Jonathan D Moreno review | Books | The Guardian
Jim Jones - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
General Affidavit re Sheryl Crow and History of Relationship - 55cf8548550346484b8c56e7.pdf
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 75
37 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 848Page
of 2413
849 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan Caterbone
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
september 8, 2015
Summer of 2015
Recently Bookmarked
tabs
Sept 1, 2012
42 days after "microwave mind control" complaint, Alexis kills 12 | Washington Times Communities
Alexis complained that persons were ...keep(ing) him awake by talking to himusing some sort of
microwave device.
http://www.foxnews.com/us/interactive/2013/09/17/aaron-alexis-rhode-island-police-report/
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 80
42 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 853Page
of 2413
854 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Activist Post: Report: Was Navy Yard Shooter Gangstalked with Mind Control Microwave Weapons?
My ELF Weapon: More Proof Navy Yard Shooter Targeted with Mind Control Weapons | The Daily
Sheeple
Reports are surfacing that the military contractor had carved My ELF Weapon and Better off this
way into the stock of his shotgun prior to the shootings.
Aaron Alexis and extremely low frequency attacks: Truth or fiction? | Washington Times Communities
Ultra low frequency attack ... [are] what has driven me to this. - Aaron Alexis
Navy Yard killer eyed revenge | New York Post
Navy Yard Shooter Had Mind Control Group Contact - National Human Rights | Examiner.com
phil
News - LancasterOnline.com
How it Works
PayPal download
Recently Bookmarked
Recent Tags
Stan Caterbone
Behind The Blue Wall: [PA] Jill Burella and Rosa Torres-Sadler turn up the volume on police officer-
involved domestic violence
CountySuite Civil Court
* SADLER ABUSED EX-WIFE *** BREAKING NEWS *** @ LIP News
Upload a Document | Scribd
Stan Caterbone
LNP analysis: Police in Lancaster County have paid out $2.4 million to settle allegations of excessive
force | Local News | lancasteronline.com
FMG Head Resigns (Robert Kauffman); Team Takes Reins June 10, 1990
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 81
43 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 854Page
of 2413
855 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Drive Medical Non-Tilt Overbed Table
Non-Tilt Overbed Table
Reference Center - Annuity Advisors
1949 Gardenia Road, Plantation FL - Trulia
Photos, maps, description for 1949 Gardenia Road, Plantation FL. Search homes for sale, get school
district and neighborhood info for Plantation, FL on TruliaDelightfully Smart Real Estate Search.
CountryHomesofColorado.com - Sold Land near Cuchara, Colorado - Huerfano County - 0.09 acres -
1095819
Country Homes for sale in Huerfano County, Colorado with 0.09 acres close to Cuchara
K portable 20041030 - MPK_Manual.pdf
Lancaster County, Pennsylvania (PA) Scanner Frequencies and Radio Frequency Reference
Scanner Frequencies and Radio Frequency Reference for Lancaster County, Pennsylvania (PA)
softub cover, softub chemicals, and softub filters by SpaDuck
SpaDuck offers a full line of softub accessories, softub chemicals, softub filters and softub covers for
hot tubs. All of our spa chemicals work with any hot tub.
STANLEY J. CATERBONE, Appellant v. LANCASTER COUNTY PRISON; MANHEIM
STANLEY J., 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals - search free case law, search by court, citation and area of
law for small law attorneys all found in lexisone
Charles F Snyder Funeral Home - Obituaries and Tributes
form a presidential commission to investigate the covert use of mind control technologies on American
citizens. | The White House
WhiteHouse.gov is the official web site for the White House and President Barack Obama, the 44th
President of the United States. This site is a source for information about the President, White House
news and policies, White House history, and the federal government.
Toyota Corolla Door Handles - Auto Parts Warehouse
Amazon.com: Toyota Corolla Outside Door Handle Front Passenger Side: Automotive
Amazon.com: Toyota Corolla Outside Door Handle Front Passenger Side: Automotive
Pizza trailers spice up traditional dish with flavors from around the world | The Daily Texan
Good Stuff Pipe Tobacco
New smooth pipe tobacco offered by the same company that offered Good Stuff cigarette tobacco!
We've heard that their multi-use pipe tobacco is very similar in taste to their cigarette tobacco. Made in
the USA
Bookmarks Toolbar
Add bookmarks to this folder to see them displayed on the Bookmarks Toolbar
Windows Live
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 82
44 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 855Page
of 2413
856 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
MSN Websites
MSN Autos
MSN Entertainment
MSN Money
MSN Sports
MSN
MSNBC News
Microsoft Websites
IE Add-on site
IE site on Microsoft.com
Microsoft At Home
Microsoft At Work
Microsoft Store
GobiernoUSA.gov
USA.gov
Mozilla Firefox
Customize Firefox
Get Involved
About Us
Help and Tutorials
Get Involved
About Us
Help and Tutorials
Get Involved
Help and Tutorials
Customize Firefox
Help and Tutorials
Customize Firefox
Get Involved
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 83
45 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 856Page
of 2413
857 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Customize Firefox
Get Involved
Customize Firefox
Get Involved
Customize Firefox
Get Involved
Help and Tutorials
Help and Tutorials
Get Involved
Help and Tutorials
About Us
Help and Tutorials
About Us
Customize Firefox
About Us
About Us
Obama v. Snowden
Stan Caterbone
v. City of Lancaster 08-02982
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Stan Caterbone - Samuel P. Caterbone - Sammy a. Caterbone Notarized AFFIDAVIT of U.S.
Sponsored Mind Control August 18, 2015
Bush's Brain:
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
How KarlDefense
BOOKMARKS
Rove
Santiago and
Made George 47
W.ofBush
HISTORY Page 85 272
288
301
312
321
332
377
415
Presidential: Sunday
James
Friday
Moore,
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Wayne
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
Slater:
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 858
Page
of 2413
859 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
0723812622771: Amazon.com: Books
IRAQGATE
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Monthly Tabs
Cell Phones, Smartphones & the Largest 4G LTE Network - Verizon Wireless
Discover the latest Cell Phones, Smartphones, Prepaid Devices, Tablets, Cell Phone Plans and
Accessories from Verizon Wireless. The nation's largest 4G LTE Network.
Direct Express
Check your transaction summary and card balance
Wells Fargo - Personal & Business Banking - Student, Auto & Home Loans - Investing & Insurance
Wells Fargo is a provider of banking, mortgage, investing, credit card, insurance, and consumer
and commercial financial services.
magicJack
Direct Express
Check your transaction summary and card balance
Wells Fargo - Personal & Business Banking - Student, Auto & Home Loans - Investing & Insurance
Wells Fargo is a provider of banking, mortgage, investing, credit card, insurance, and consumer
and commercial financial services.
Comcast Official Site: High-Speed Internet, Cable TV, and Phone Services Deals XFINITY from
Comcast
Comcast Official Site: High-Speed Internet, Cable TV, and Phone Services Deals XFINITY from
Comcast
Comcast Official Site: High-Speed Internet, Cable TV, and Phone Services Deals XFINITY from
Comcast
Unsorted Bookmarks
[Folder Name]
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Stan Caterbone
Stan Caterbone
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Stan Caterbone
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Advanced Media Group Capabilities Statement 1990 Apr 29 2007
NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden: 'I don't want to live in a society that does these sort of things' -
YouTube
Local News | lancasteronline.com
United States District Court Lisa Michelle Lambert Habeus ORDER Summary Judgement DENIED
Case No 5-14-Cv-02559-PD September 15, 2015
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
United States District Court Lisa Michelle Lambert Habeus ORDER Summary Judgement DENIED
Case No 5-14-Cv-02559-PD September 15, 2015
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Local News | lancasteronline.com
Local News | lancasteronline.com
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Stan Caterbone
Stan Caterbone
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
United States District Court Lisa Michelle Lambert Habeus ORDER Summary Judgement DENIED
Case No 5-14-Cv-02559-PD September 15, 2015
Monthly Tabs
Cell Phones, Smartphones & the Largest 4G LTE Network - Verizon Wireless
Discover the latest Cell Phones, Smartphones, Prepaid Devices, Tablets, Cell Phone Plans and
Accessories from Verizon Wireless. The nation's largest 4G LTE Network.
Comcast Official Site: High-Speed Internet, Cable TV, and Phone Services Deals XFINITY from
Comcast
Direct Express
Check your transaction summary and card balance
Wells Fargo - Personal & Business Banking - Student, Auto & Home Loans - Investing & Insurance
Wells Fargo is a provider of banking, mortgage, investing, credit card, insurance, and consumer
and commercial financial services.
Cell Phones, Smartphones & the Largest 4G LTE Network - Verizon Wireless
Discover
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
the latest
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Cell
Defense
Phones, Smartphones,
HISTORY Page 87 49 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377
Prepaid Devices, Tablets,
Sunday
Friday
Friday
CellJanuary
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
Phone
December
Plans
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
and
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 860
Page
of 2413
861 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Accessories from Verizon Wireless. The nation's largest 4G LTE Network.
magicJack
magicJack
Comcast Official Site: High-Speed Internet, Cable TV, and Phone Services Deals XFINITY from
Comcast
Unsorted Bookmarks
Mozilla Firefox
About Us
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 90
52 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 863Page
of 2413
864 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Tabs April 14, 2011
Stan Caterbone
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Nebraska killer contradicted trial testimony to state senator in COINTELPRO case - National
Cointelpro | Examiner.com
Outlook.com
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Stan Caterbone
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Stan Caterbone
Keeper - Password vault and online file storage
Letter to Epic Card Re Complaint of Bonnie Lee Polygraph Solutions and Supporting Documentation
August 11, 2015
Incident Reports of Harassment, Vandalism, Hacking, & Thefts From 1987 to March 22, 2010
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Lydia Canaan | LinkedIn
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Stan Caterbone
Outlook.com
Clinton Global Initiative Invitation July 5 2006
Letter To and From Debbie Fochs of Disclosure Project re Samuel Caterbone ET Experience is Mind
Control Feb 26 2008
AFFIDAVIT to Judge Stewart Dalzall in Authored in 1998 With DOCKET of 5-14-Cv-02559-PD
False Arrests No Trespass Notices August 19, 2015
Stan Caterbone - Samuel P. Caterbone - Sammy A. Caterbone Notarized AFFIDAVIT of U.S.
Sponsored Mind Control August 18, 2015
Stan Caterbone
Lydia Canaan | LinkedIn
Outlook.com
Stan Caterbone
fuck you
DocumentHandler.ashx
DocumentHandler.ashx
Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Relief v Residents of
County of Lancaster August 16, 2015
Main MessageCenter Page (View Faxes)
DocumentHandler.ashx
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 91
53 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 864Page
of 2413
865 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
August 21, 2015
plantation homes
August 3, 2015
Exposing Judicial Unaccountability and Consequent Riskless Wrongdoing and Launching Judicial
Reform - DrRCordero-Honest_Jud_Advocates.pdf
DrRCordero-Honest Judicial Accountability in the U.S. Courts
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 92
54 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 865Page
of 2413
866 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Advanced Media Group Letter to the Editor of Lancaster Newspapers September 6, 2015 Full Version
Lawyer Dr Cordero exposes the fraud in Judiciary, Astounding Discoveries - YouTube
Inbox | LinkedIn
Exposing Judicial Unaccountability and Consequent Riskless Wrongdoing and Launching Judicial
Reform - DrRCordero-Honest_Jud_Advocates.pdf
Outlook.com (3) - scaterbone@live.com
Stan Caterbone
Prothonotary | Lancaster County, PA - Official Website
Local News | lancasteronline.com
Outlook.com (3) - scaterbone@live.com
Stan Caterbone
Local News | lancasteronline.com
DrRCordero-Honest Judicial Accountability in the U.S. Courts
Advanced Media Group Letter to the Editor of Lancaster Newspapers September 6, 2015 Full Version
Prothonotary | Lancaster County, PA - Official Website
Inbox | LinkedIn
Outlook.com (3) - scaterbone@live.com
Stan Caterbone
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Stan J. Caterbone on Scribd | Scribd
Keeper - Password vault and online file storage
Stan J. Caterbone on Scribd | Scribd
Stan Caterbone
request.pdf
Stan J. Caterbone on Scribd | Scribd
Keeper - Password vault and online file storage
Samsung SmartCam HD 1080p Wi-Fi IP Monitoring Camera
Contact | Lyrics & Poetry | Ar
FFCHS Home - Freedom from Covert Harassment and Surveillance
Contact | Lyrics & Poetry | Ar
FFCHS Home - Freedom from Covert Harassment and Surveillance
request.pdf
MKUltra Experience Conference | Keep the Ethical Light Burning
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
pain releif and body healing
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
pain releif and body healing
Keeper - Password vault and online file storage
Samsung SmartCam HD 1080p Wi-Fi IP Monitoring Camera
Contact | Lyrics & Poetry | Ar
pain releif and body healing
FFCHS Home - Freedom from Covert Harassment and Surveillance
MKUltra Experience Conference | Keep the Ethical Light Burning
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Stan Caterbone
request.pdf
MKUltra Experience Conference | Keep the Ethical Light Burning
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 93
55 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 866Page
of 2413
867 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan Caterbone
Samsung SmartCam HD 1080p Wi-Fi IP Monitoring Camera
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
September 1, 2015
July 5, 2015
september 8, 2015
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Keeper - Password vault and online file storage
Judge Cullen Meghan Lippiatt CI-08-09471 Amicus Curiea July 23, 2008
DOCKET and COMPLAINT for 06-4650 in U.S. Disrict Court of Eastern Pennsylvania IMPORTANT
Pacer Download August 13, 2015
123 N Prince St, Lancaster, PA 17603 Directions, Location and Map | MapQuest
EMERGENCY INJUCTION v Fulton Bank Recorded April 14, 2010 Filed on April 1, 2010 in US
District Court
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Keeper - Password vault and online file storage
Stan Caterbone
Stan Caterbone
Judge Cullen Meghan Lippiatt CI-08-09471 Amicus Curiea July 23, 2008
DOCKET and COMPLAINT for 06-4650 in U.S. Disrict Court of Eastern Pennsylvania IMPORTANT
Pacer Download August 13, 2015
123 N Prince St, Lancaster, PA 17603 Directions, Location and Map | MapQuest
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Stan Caterbone
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com
Stew Webb Federal Whistlblower-Activist, US Intel Breaking News,News,
GoFundMe - Dashboard
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 95
57 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 868Page
of 2413
869 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
July 23, 2015
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
tabs
Outlook.com
Nebraska killer contradicted trial testimony to state senator in COINTELPRO case - National
Cointelpro | Examiner.com
Outlook.com
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Incident Reports of Harassment, Vandalism, Hacking, & Thefts From 1987 to March 22, 2010
Letter to Epic Card Re Complaint of Bonnie Lee Polygraph Solutions and Supporting Documentation
August 11, 2015
Mission Complete - Geek Squad
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Keeper - Password vault and online file storage
DOCKET and COMPLAINT for 06-4650 in U.S. Disrict Court of Eastern Pennsylvania IMPORTANT
Pacer Download August 13, 2015
Stan Caterbone
Incident Reports of Harassment, Vandalism, Hacking, & Thefts From 1987 to March 22, 2010
Letter to Epic Card Re Complaint of Bonnie Lee Polygraph Solutions and Supporting Documentation
August 11, 2015
Mission Complete - Geek Squad
Keeper - Password vault and online file storage
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Stan Caterbone
DOCKET and COMPLAINT for 06-4650 in U.S. Disrict Court of Eastern Pennsylvania IMPORTANT
Pacer Download August 13, 2015
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Stan Caterbone
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 96
58 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 869Page
of 2413
870 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
July 6a, 2015
phil
phil
Outlook - scaterbone@live.com
97.jpg - Google Drive
94.jpg - Google Drive
59.jpg - Google Drive
56.jpg - Google Drive
55.jpg - Google Drive
14.jpg - Google Drive
News - LancasterOnline.com
Outlook - scaterbone@live.com
67.jpg - Google Drive
Outlook - scaterbone@live.com
Intelligencer Journal/Lancaster New Era
Intelligencer Journal/Lancaster New Era
93.jpg - Google Drive
37.jpg - Google Drive
97.jpg - Google Drive
94.jpg - Google Drive
67.jpg - Google Drive
55.jpg - Google Drive
14.jpg - Google Drive
93.jpg - Google Drive
67.jpg - Google Drive
37.jpg - Google Drive
97.jpg - Google Drive
94.jpg - Google Drive
55.jpg - Google Drive
14.jpg - Google Drive
59.jpg - Google Drive
56.jpg - Google Drive
93.jpg - Google Drive
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 97
59 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 870Page
of 2413
871 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
59.jpg - Google Drive
56.jpg - Google Drive
37.jpg - Google Drive
Outlook.com
Section 3503 - Title 18 - CRIMES AND OFFENSES
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com
1983 Olympic Silver Dollar Commemorative Coin
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
1983 Olympic Silver Dollar Commemorative Coin
AOPC411-10.PDF - file-78.pdf
Section 3503 - Title 18 - CRIMES AND OFFENSES
Outlook.com
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com
1983 Olympic Silver Dollar Commemorative Coin
Outlook.com
AOPC411-10.PDF - file-78.pdf
Section 3503 - Title 18 - CRIMES AND OFFENSES
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
AOPC411-10.PDF - file-78.pdf
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
GoFundMe - Dashboard
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Proofed Stan J. Caterbone Biography November 2010
Proofed Stan J. Caterbone Biography November 2010
Proofed Stan J. Caterbone Biography November 2010
GoFundMe - Dashboard
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 98
60 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 871Page
of 2413
872 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Mozilla Firefox
About Us
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com
Stan J. Caterbone on Scribd | Scribd
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Stan J. Caterbone on Scribd | Scribd
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Mozilla Firefox
;laksdjfalskdjf
;laksdjfalskdjf
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Sept 1, 2012
News - LancasterOnline.com
Sept 1, 2012
Hotmail - scaterbone@live.com
Intelligencer Journal/Lancaster New Era
Intelligencer Journal/Lancaster New Era
News - LancasterOnline.com
plantation homes
tabs
News - LancasterOnline.com
LancasterOnline.com: eEditions
News - LancasterOnline.com
LancasterOnline.com: eEditions
LancasterOnline.com: eEditions
Hotmail - scaterbone@live.com - Windows Live
Hotmail - scaterbone@live.com - Windows Live
August 8, 2015
ABC News Documentary Reveals Secret Government Mind Control Project MKULTRA - National US
Intelligence | Examiner.com
In 1979, just two years after U.S. Senate hearings revealed disturbing information about a secret
government mind control program code-named Project MKULTRA, AB
Reference Center
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
- Santiago
Annuity Advisors
BOOKMARKS and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page101
63 of
of377
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 874
Page
of 2413
875 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Weichert, Realtors | Search Lancaster PA Homes for Sale | Lancaster PA Real Estate | Lancaster PA MLS
Listings
Search Lancaster PA homes for sale, real estate and MLS listings with Weichert, Realtors - Engle &
Hambright's easy, convenient home search.
Buy BWD Engine Control Computer ECC3595 at Advance Auto Parts
Choose Advance Auto Parts for Engine Control Computer by BWD - ECC3595
PayPal download
Amazon.com: Toyota Corolla Outside Door Handle Front Passenger Side: Automotive
Amazon.com: Toyota Corolla Outside Door Handle Front Passenger Side: Automotive
Pentagon plans telepathic troops that can read each others' minds
Pentagon plans telepathic troops that can read each others' minds
softub cover, softub chemicals, and softub filters by SpaDuck
SpaDuck offers a full line of softub accessories, softub chemicals, softub filters and softub covers for
hot tubs. All of our spa chemicals work with any hot tub.
Frequently Asked Questions - Annuity Advisors
Electronic Harassment: Voices in My Mind - www.kmir6.com
Hundreds of people in the valley say they are hearing voices in their heads, and those voices are being
transmitted by microwave or other methods. Several viewers asked us to investigate what they call
Local veteran to appear on CNN special - - - News Source for Jacksonville, North Carolina - jdnews.com
Pride of Austin Homes Blog Archive 810 Christopher
How it Works
Ending EH - Home
This site lists many ways of ending electronic harassment and lists the link to our social forum of those
working to end electronic harassment.
Toyota Corolla Door Handles - Auto Parts Warehouse
YouTube - Repair Softub leaking motor assembly.
My hot tub started leaking recently from the pump unit. Their are not any videos on you tube that
document how to fix the problem, So I made a video how to r...
Pride of Austin Homes Blog Archive 810 Christopher
1949 Gardenia Road, Plantation FL - Trulia
Photos, maps, description for 1949 Gardenia Road, Plantation FL. Search homes for sale, get school
district and neighborhood info for Plantation, FL on TruliaDelightfully Smart Real Estate Search.
U.S. Department of Homeland Security seal, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services logo
STANLEY J. CATERBONE, Appellant v. LANCASTER COUNTY PRISON; MANHEIM
STANLEY J., 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals - search free case law, search by court, citation and area of
law for small law attorneys all found in lexisone
CM/ECF LIVE - U.S. Bankruptcy Court:flsb
afpbioethicscommission.pdf (application/pdf Object)
18843 nw 54 place miami gardens - Google Search
1991 Dodge Dakota ECM/PCM
This listing is for a rebuilt ECM/PCM for a 1991 Dodge Dakota with a 5.2L V8 Gas motor. The
module will be programmed to your exact VIN and mileage and the latest software updates avaiable
from Chrysler will be installed. There will be no need for any additional programming. When you
receive your part you will be able to plug it in and start your vehicle. We will use the information that
you supply below to program your part, if you are unsure of any information please leave the field
blank and we will call or e-mail you as soon as possible. If you have any questions, feel free to give us
a call or send us an e-mail. All of our contact info can be found by clicking the Contact Us button in the
blue bar at the top of this page. Thank you for visiting our site, we will be looking forward to doing
business with you!
Shopping Cart
Smokers Outlet Online - Your source for make your own (roll your own or stuff your own) cigarette
supplies: pipe tobacco, tubes, papers, machines, and accessories. Great prices on smokeless tobacco,
chewing tobacco, and cigars.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page102
64 of
of377
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 875Page
of 2413
876 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
qwaa rolling machine
Clearance Expect great things at Qwaaq and RYO Cigarette. Save on our large selection of clearance
tobacco supplies and accessories. Remember, any purchase over $100 comes with a free mini-cooler .
Shop around and see what else you need to complete your RYO experience.
Good Stuff Pipe Tobacco
New smooth pipe tobacco offered by the same company that offered Good Stuff cigarette tobacco!
We've heard that their multi-use pipe tobacco is very similar in taste to their cigarette tobacco. Made in
the USA
Charles F Snyder Funeral Home - Obituaries and Tributes
Pennsylvania Real Estate Deed Forms - Fill In The Blank
Pennsylvania has specific guidelines for real estate and deeds and titles. Find and file Pennsylvania real
estate deed forms at Deeds.com today.
Pizza trailers spice up traditional dish with flavors from around the world | The Daily Texan
Lancaster County, Pennsylvania (PA) Scanner Frequencies and Radio Frequency Reference
Scanner Frequencies and Radio Frequency Reference for Lancaster County, Pennsylvania (PA)
4776 Northwest 4th Court, Plantation FL - Trulia
Photos, maps, description for 4776 Northwest 4th Court, Plantation FL. Search homes for sale, get
school district and neighborhood info for Plantation, FL on TruliaDelightfully Smart Real Estate
Search.
18843 nw 54 place miami gardens - Google Search
Drive Medical Non-Tilt Overbed Table
Non-Tilt Overbed Table
1991 Dodge Dakota ECM/PCM
This listing is for a rebuilt ECM/PCM for a 1991 Dodge Dakota with a 5.2L V8 Gas motor. The
module will be programmed to your exact VIN and mileage and the latest software updates avaiable
from Chrysler will be installed. There will be no need for any additional programming. When you
receive your part you will be able to plug it in and start your vehicle. We will use the information that
you supply below to program your part, if you are unsure of any information please leave the field
blank and we will call or e-mail you as soon as possible. If you have any questions, feel free to give us
a call or send us an e-mail. All of our contact info can be found by clicking the Contact Us button in the
blue bar at the top of this page. Thank you for visiting our site, we will be looking forward to doing
business with you!
Shopping Cart
Smokers Outlet Online - Your source for make your own (roll your own or stuff your own) cigarette
supplies: pipe tobacco, tubes, papers, machines, and accessories. Great prices on smokeless tobacco,
chewing tobacco, and cigars.
K portable 20041030 - MPK_Manual.pdf
How it Works
Sanity for Superheroes: O.A.K.: New Physics-Sythetic Telepathy and the Early Mind Wars
qwaa rolling machine
Clearance Expect great things at Qwaaq and RYO Cigarette. Save on our large selection of clearance
tobacco supplies and accessories. Remember, any purchase over $100 comes with a free mini-cooler .
Shop around and see what else you need to complete your RYO experience.
CM/ECF LIVE - U.S. Bankruptcy Court:flsb
PayPal download
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page103
65 of
of377
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 876Page
of 2413
877 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
June 28, 2015 POTUS
Mozilla Firefox
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
Monthly Tabs
Mozilla Firefox
Recent Tags
Recent Tags
Bookmarks Toolbar
Add bookmarks to this folder to see them displayed on the Bookmarks Toolbar
Scribd
Welcome! | LinkedIn
Stan J. Caterbone (@SCaterbone) | Twitter
LancasterOnline.com: Your Lancaster County News, Sports & Weather Source
Netflix
My Page - peacepink
Stan J. Caterbone's Page on peacepink
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page104
66 of
of377
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 877Page
of 2413
878 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Most Visited
stan caterbone and advanced media group - Google Search
Exceptional Interviews on Video Re: U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and Related Technologies | Stan
Caterbone | LinkedIn
Watch Desperate Housewives Online - Pilot | Hulu
Watch Pilot online. Stream Desperate Housewives season 1, episode 1 instantly.
Report - Scott Ritter | Truthdig
Other Bookmarks
Bookmarks Menu
Music Videos
Stan Caterbone
My History as a Victim Of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and Resume - peacepink
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Relief v
Residents of County of Lancaster August 16, 2015
Judge Jeffrey Wright OPINION as Ordered by Superior Court in Case No. 1561 MDA 2015 on
November 23, 2015 for Emergency Injunction Case No. 15-06985
Apple iPhone 5c - 8GB - White (Verizon) Smartphone Great Condition Accesories
Apple iPhone 5c - 8GB - White (Verizon) Smartphone Great Condition Accesories in Cell
Phones & Accessories, Cell Phones & Smartphones | eBay
Apple iPhone 6S (Latest Model) - 64GB - Silver (Verizon) Smartphone - Used 1 day
Apple iPhone 6S (Latest Model) - 64GB - Silver (Verizon) Smartphone - Used 1 day in
Cell Phones & Accessories, Cell Phones & Smartphones | eBay
YouTube Videos
Exceptional Interviews on Video Re: U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and Related Technologies |
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page110
72 of
of377
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 883Page
of 2413
884 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan Caterbone | LinkedIn
November 3, 2015 The following video interviews are some of the most compelling and
most accurate regarding the subject of U.S. Sponsored Mind Contro
The Killing of Laurie Show (Documentary) Pt 1 - YouTube
The true story behind the movie The Stalking of Laurie Show. Part 1
The Neuro Revolution - Full HD - YouTube
The Neuro Revolution is a Book recommendation for victims of Neuroscience research.
The video is based on the Book by the same name by author Zack Lynch. The...
FEDERAL False Claims Act 1991 Video - ISC & THE CIA - YouTube
Section 3729 False claims (a) Liability for certain acts. Any person who (1) knowingly
presents, or causes to be presented, to an officer or employee of the ...
Global Mind Control 2013 - Nick Begich - YouTube
From special assignment news story "Do you believe in government mind control?" by
reporter Ross Blackstone which appeared on KOVR 13 News, Sacramento, Calif...
What Do Gang Stalkers Want And How To Defeat Them, Greensboro,NC - YouTube
I made this video for Targeted Individuals who have not had success in their battle against
gang stalkers and also for the public sector that is unaware that...
Commodore Amiga CDTV Review - YouTube
The CDTV (an acronym for "Commodore Dynamic Total Vision", a backronym of an
acronym for "Compact Disk Television", giving it a double meaning) was a multime...
The TV Mind Control Movie | 2015 - YouTube
Alex welcomes to the Infowars studio Dr. John Hall, anesthesiologist and author of
"Satellite Terrorism" to discuss the facts of the possibilities of Governm...
August 15, 2015 Targeted Individual Awareness 3 - YouTube
YouTube - Dr Scott Johnson- Coming US Holocaust,Digital TV,HAARP,GWEN Towers,Silent
Sound Mind Control 1/21
YouTube - The CIA Doctors: Psychiatry & Mind Control
Coast To Coast AM - February 9, 2015 New World Order & Electronic Harassment - YouTube
Coast To Coast AM - February 9, 2015 New World Order & Electronic Harassment In the
first half, former Minister of National Defense in Canada, Paul Hellyer, ...
Coast To Coast AM - February 9, 2015 New World Order & Electronic Harassment - YouTube
Coast To Coast AM - February 9, 2015 New World Order & Electronic Harassment In the
first half, former Minister of National Defense in Canada, Paul Hellyer, ...
YouTube HAARP Video
Julianne McKinney on microwave harassment and mind control - YouTube
YouTube - Brice Taylor on Mind Control
YouTube - Bill Clinton under Mind Control
YouTube - Mind Control Goes Public 1 of 5
YouTube - Mind Control Goes Public 1 of 5
YouTube - Mind Control Goes Public 2 of 5
YouTube - Mind Control Goes Public 3 of 5
YouTube - Mind Control Goes Public 5 of 5
Do You Believe in Government Mind Control? -- Part 2: Cheryl Welsh - YouTube
From special assignment news story "Do you believe in government mind control?" by
reporter Ross Blackstone which appeared on KOVR 13 News, Sacramento, Calif...
Julianne McKinney on microwave harassment and mind control - YouTube
YouTube - MK-Ultra, CIA Mind Control & Brain Washing to Make Assassins
President John F Kennedy Secret Society Speech version 2 - YouTube
"Listen to this incredible audio recording of a speech made by JFK before the American
Newspaper Publishers Association where he warns the press about the se...
Lawyer Dr Cordero exposes the fraud in Judiciary, Astounding Discoveries - YouTube
Share your videos with friends, family, and the world
Recurring Issues in False Claims Act Litigation - YouTube
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page111
73 of
of377
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 884Page
of 2413
885 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
I have been a Targeted Individual, TI, and Victim since 1987. In 1987 I blew the whistle
(public Allegations and Complaints to State and Federal Authorities ...
"Targeted Individuals" Dr. John Hall and Dr. Terry Robertson - YouTube
Alex welcomes to the Infowars studio Dr. John Hall, anesthesiologist and author of
"Satellite Terrorism" to discuss the facts of the possibilities of Governm...
Coast To Coast AM - February 9, 2015 New World Order & Electronic Harassment - YouTube
Coast To Coast AM - February 9, 2015 New World Order & Electronic Harassment In the
first half, former Minister of National Defense in Canada, Paul Hellyer, ...
NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden: 'I don't want to live in a society that does these sort of
things' - YouTube
Lifetime Movies 2015 | The Stalking of Laurie Show AKA Rivals | Best Lifetime Movies 2015 -
YouTube
The true story behind the movie The Stalking of Laurie Show. Part 3
US Army Intelligence Officer: Gang Stalking Phenomenon is Precursor to Coming Holocaust -
YouTube
Do You Believe in Government Mind Control? -- Part 3: Dr. Nick Begich - YouTube
From special assignment news story "Do you believe in government mind control?" by
reporter Ross Blackstone which appeared on KOVR 13 News, Sacramento, Calif...
Stan Caterbone Channel - YouTube
Share your videos with friends, family, and the world
San Francisco Bay View Cointelpro government agency
The FRONTLINE Interview: Diane Roark | United States of Secrets | FRONTLINE | PBS
Diane Roark served as a top staff member on the House Intelligence Committee from 1985
to 2002. She fought to end the NSA's post-9/11 warrantless wiretapping initiative, telling
FRONTLINE she considered the program "unethical, immoral, politically stupid, illegal
and unconstitutional."
Jay Curtis Corporation Video 1991 - YouTube
I have been a Targeted Individual, TI, and Victim since 1987. In 1987 I blew the whistle
(public Allegations and Complaints to State and Federal Authorities ...
FMG Video St Joseph Hospital George Werner April 1987 - YouTube
I have been a Targeted Individual, TI, and Victim since 1987. In 1987 I blew the whistle
(public Allegations and Complaints to State and Federal Authorities ...
Govt Mind Control Technologies with Dr. John Hall - YouTube
Alex welcomes to the Infowars studio Dr. John Hall, anesthesiologist and author of
"Satellite Terrorism" to discuss the facts of the possibilities of Governm...
Surveillance Of Black Lives Matter Movement Recalls COINTELPRO Tactics
Mind Control - YouTube
From special assignment news story "Do you believe in government mind control?" by
reporter Ross Blackstone which appeared on KOVR 13 News, Sacramento, Calif...
Cheryl Welsh Do You Believe in Government Mind Control? -- Part 2: Cheryl Welsh -
YouTube
From special assignment news story "Do you believe in government mind control?" by
reporter Ross Blackstone which appeared on KOVR 13 News, Sacramento, Calif...
Justin Bieber - What Do You Mean? - YouTube
Roberta Lee Streeter, professionally known as Bobbie Gentry, is an American singer-
songwriter notable as one of the first female country artists to compose a...
"The Mind Has No Firewall" -- Psychotronic Warfare, from the US Army War College -- Alan
Watt - YouTube
The article Alan reads from is
http://www.carlisle.army.mil/USAWC/parameters/Articles/98spring/thomas.htm From
Alan Watt's May 6, 2010 broadcast. Listen to A...
US Army War College
Dr. Phil Sued -- Guest Claims, He Made Me Look Crazy! | TMZ.com
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page112
74 of
of377
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 885Page
of 2413
886 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
A man who says a detective planted crystal meth in his home and appeared on Dr. Phil's
show, has filed a lawsuit claiming the good Doc made him look
Gang Stalking = Counterintelligence - Mike German & Scott Crow - FBI's Domestic
Surveillance Program - YouTube
WHAT THE HELL IS GANG STALKING? http://www.scribd.com/doc/72110691/Gang-
Stalking-Counterintelligence
Slideshow of Trip To California - Kennett, MO; Austin, TX; Little Rock, AR; Santa Barbara,
CA; - YouTube
Trip of July 21, 2005 to August 26, 2005 Visit Sheryl Crow Aquatic Center of Kennett,
MO; Phil Caterbone in Austin, TX; Clinton Library in Little Rock, AR; G...
Richmond Resolution On Space-Based Weaponry Prompts Flood Of Calls To Police From
Targeted Individuals CBS San Francisco
Richmond police have been inundated with calls for help from people who feel under attack
from space-based weaponry because of a City Council resolution passed last month,
according to Mayor Tom Butt.
Another NSA Whistleblower Steps Forward - YouTube
Diane Roark is a former congressional staffer who was assigned to the intelligence
committee. Undaunted by FBI raids on her home and others who also served o...
V2K: Voice to Skull - peacepink
Does the technology exist that could encode speech, transmit it via microwaves, and be
heard inside the human skull... without using a receiver? An investiga...
CIA WhistleBlower Susan Lindauer EXPOSES Everything (Extreme Prejudice) - peacepink
CIA WhistleBlower EXPOSES Everything ( Extreme Prejudice)
DOCUMENTARY: Edward Snowden - Terminal F (2015) - YouTube
NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden: 'I don't want to live in a society that does these sort
of things' Subscribe to the Guardian HERE: http://bitly.com/UvkFpD ...
"60 Minutes" interview: President Obama - YouTube
Is the U.S. taking a backseat to Russia in Syria? Steve Kroft asks President Obama in an
interview for 60 Minutes.
WAYNE MORIN VIDEO'S
Wake Up America - 6/16/14 - Atty Shawn Abrell part 1 - YouTube
Atty Shawn Abrell calls in from Hawaii, talks about lawsuits and his travels meeting
different clients, RFID, microchips, people being targeted by electronic...
Wake Up America - 6/16/14 - Atty Shawn Abrell part 2 - YouTube
Atty Shawn Abrell calls in from Hawaii, talks about lawsuits and his travels meeting
different clients, RFID, microchips, people being targeted by electronic...
Direct Energy Weapons - YouTube
they sure are acting weird. watch the whole video here http://video.google.com/videoplay?
docid=2967542171184509301
Live and Recorded Public meetings of Council Meeting 5192015 for City of Richmond -
YouTube
Richmond police have been inundated with calls for help from people who feel under attack
from space-based weaponry because of a City Council resolution pass...
Lancaster Catholic Football 1974 1975 Season Tri County Champs My Junior Year Number 36,
Dec 7, 2015 - YouTube
Upload - YouTube
Share your videos with friends, family, and the world
Alec Krieder May 12, 2007 David Ludwig Nov 13, 2005 Jessie Wise April 8, 2006 Young
People Mur - YouTube
I have been a Targeted Individual, TI, and Victim since 1987. In 1987 I blew the whistle
(public Allegations and Complaints to State and Federal Authorities ...
Welcome to your electromagnetic concentration camp - YouTube
U.S. NAVY, SPECIAL OPERATIONS DISCLOSURE ON TECHNOLOGIES AND
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page113
75 of
of377
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 886Page
of 2413
887 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
APPLICATIONS BEING USED AGAINST AMERICAN TARGETED INDIVIDUALS
First, all 315 million Americans a...
Richmond City Council ban spaced-based weapons - YouTube
Share your videos with friends, family, and the world
The Neuro Revolution - Full HD - YouTube
The Neuro Revolution is a Book recommendation for victims of Neuroscience research.
The video is based on the Book by the same name by author Zack Lynch. The...
Lawyer Dr Cordero exposes the fraud in Judiciary, Astounding Discoveries - YouTube
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Stan Caterbone
Support Desk
Digital Angel Corp., Prior to Merger with Applied Digital Solutions, Inc.: Private Company
Information - Businessweek
People You May Know | LinkedIn
Wake Up America - 6/16/14 - Atty Shawn Abrell part 1 - YouTube
Julianne McKinney on microwave harassment and mind control - YouTube
Julianne McKinney on microwave harassment and mind control - YouTube
Stan Caterbone
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Finance Calculator
The Historical Rate of Return for the Stock Market Since 1900 | Stock Picks System
Is 1% management fee typical for Wealth Management? Any recommendations on cheaper
alternatives? - Nerdwallet
Institutional Investors Mortgage Banking Business Development of 1987 Very Important
Audio Files
Christmas Songs
Stan Caterbone
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Tim Horstmann | LinkedIn
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page116
78 of
of377
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 889Page
of 2413
890 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
FACEBOOK Postings From July 29 to December 5, 2015
Lancaster County DA Releases Report on Fatal Police Shooting of Mentally Ill Man on North
Queen Street in 2013
Blood Alcohol Calculator Check Yourself Before You Wreck Yourself
Julie McNamara
People You May Know | LinkedIn
1987 Burdette Tomlin Hospital Medical Records with Jim Warner Calling Stone Harbor Police -
Phony Suicide Allegation
Lancaster Newspapers Defamation September 4 1987 - July 10, 2015
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT Re 806
Authentic Original Documents From 1983 to 2006, November 18, 2015
The CGI Mission | Clinton Global Initiative
Advanced Media Group Capabilities Statement 1990 Apr 29 2007
Mobile Bookmarks
Stan Caterbone
Stan J. Caterbone U.S. Federal ELECTRONIC Court Filings for Thursday, December 31, 2015
3...2...1... - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
Kathleen Kane's racism comments challenge her "absolute immunity" to lawsuits. - The Morning
Call
Messaging | LinkedIn
Edit Profile | LinkedIn
Stan J. Caterbone United Nations Human Rights Council of Geneva Switzerland Complaint and
Exhibit re U.S. Sponsored Mind Control, October 4, 2009.pdf
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Self Publishing, Book Printing and Publishing Online - Lulu
adobe epub reader - SecureSearch
Download | Adobe Digital Editions
Advanced Media Group Press Release Re Stalking Legislation With Executive Summary
December 17, 2015
Library | Scribd
Stan J. Caterbone (stan5j.5caterbone) 532 uploads | Scribd
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
GoFundMe: #1 for Crowdfunding & Fundraising Websites
Don Eberly will not challenge Smucker for 16th district | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Lancaster Online
CNN.com - Cheney's top aide indicted; CIA leak probe continues - Oct 28, 2005
CIA: A History: John Ranelagh: 9780563362500: Amazon.com: Books
CIA: A History [John Ranelagh] on Amazon.com. *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers.
This history of America's Central Intelligence Agency traces the organization's 50 years of
existence and the people who made it the world's foremost secret service. Agency directors
Taylor Bradley | LinkedIn
valerie plame - Google Search
Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement and EXHIBIT by Appellant October 23,
2015 With Executive Summary
Special Prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald Letter to Joseph Tate, Jim Guerin Attorney, Re Scooter
Libby October 3, 2005
Tony Blair makes qualified apology for Iraq war ahead of Chilcot report | UK news | The
Guardian
Former British PM admits mistakes and conflicts role in rise of Islamic State but defends
armed intervention in 2003
Ted Koppel Compares Donald Trump To Benito Mussolini | Video | Media Matters for America
President Obama - CBS News
Steve Kroft questions President Obama on topics including Russia's incursion in
Syria, ISIS and the 2016 presidential race
George W Bush provides unlikely ally for Clinton, Obama as they counter Republicans on Islam |
Fox News
Democrats are turning to an unlikely ally, George W.
Legal Aid Fund by Stan Caterbone - GoFundMe
Lancaster Freethought Society - Promoting positive atheism and the separation of church and
state. Lancaster, PA
Promoting positive atheism and the separation of church and state. Lancaster, PA
Loss of Control: Lawyers' Greatest Fear - Attorney at Work - Attorney at Work
When lawyers are surveyed about what keeps them awake at night, their top issue is almost
always feeling that their offices or cases are out of control.
Marjorie Cohn: Want Endless War? Love the U.S. Empire? Well, Hillary Clintons Your Choice
- Truthdig
If the candidates foreign policy record is any guide, a Hillary Clinton presidency would
perpetuate and bolster some of our most hateful national characteristics. - 2016/02/01
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page118
80 of
of377
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 891Page
of 2413
892 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
How U.S. Arms and Technology Were Transferred to Iraq
Julian Assange Arbitrarily Detained, a U.N. Panel Has Found - Truthdig
The panel is expected to announce Friday a finding that the WikiLeaks founders long stay
in Ecuadors London embassy is the result of improper actions by Sweden and Britain. -
2016/02/04
ONLINE REGISTRATION of Pennsylvania Registration of FFCHS or Freedom From Covert
Harassment and Surveillence Ficticious Name by Stan J. Caterbone on March 25, 2016
ONLINE REGISTRATION of Pennsylvania Registration of FFCHS or Freedom From
Covert Harassment and Surveillence Ficticious Name by Stan J. Caterbone on March 25,
2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. ONLINE
REGISTRATION of Pennsylvania Registration of FFCHS or Freedom From Covert
Harassment and Surveillence Ficticious Name by Stan J. Caterbone on March 25, 2016
Gmail - Email to All Contacts Re NOTICE Official Dissolution of FFCHS March 25, 2016
Gmail - Email to All Contacts Re NOTICE Official Dissolution of FFCHS March 25, 2016
- Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Gmail - Email to
All Contacts Re NOTICE Official Dissolution of FFCHS March 25, 2016
TalkShoe - Call - PACTS, International
History-Changing FBI Whistleblowers Reveal Themselves in '1971'
On March 8, 1971, a group of anti-war activists broke into an FBI office in Media, Pa., and
subsequently changed the course of history, blowing the whistle on illegal surveillance and
bully tactics employed by J. Edgar Hoover and his government agency.In spite of one of
the biggest FBI dragnets in history
Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement and EXHIBIT by Appellant October 23,
2015 With Executive Summary
Truthdig Articles
Micah RIP
Obama v. Snowden
Complaint to ICE
Lisa M Release
Love, Murder, and Corruption in Lancaster County: My Story: Lisa Michelle Lambert and David
Brown: 9781933822884: Amazon.com: Books
Love, Murder, and Corruption in Lancaster County: My Story [Lisa Michelle Lambert and
David Brown] on Amazon.com. *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. The police and
prosecutorial misconduct was not only outrageous, but also led directly to the conviction of
a woman we have found by clear and convincing evidence to have been actually innocent
of first-degree murder. So said Philadelphia federal court judge Stewart Dalzell in 1997 as
he overturned Lisa Lambert s 1992 conviction for the murder of her supposed romantic
rival
Advanced Media Group Rebuttal to LNP - In a Killers Words Lisa Michelle Lambert, Nearly 25
Years Since Laurie Shows Murder, LAMBERT Claims Innocence in New Book Published in
Sunday News Front Page on January 31, 2016
President Obama just commuted 95 sentences. How do presidential commutations and pardons
work? - The Washington Post
Here is a simple guide to pardons, commutations and why President Obama has released
dozens of offenders this year.
Amazon.com: Stan J. Caterbone's review of Love, Murder, and Corruption in Lancaster ...
Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Love, Murder, and Corruption in
Lancaster County: My Story at Amazon.com. Read honest and unbiased product reviews
from our users.
Former inmates get lunch with President Obama | Fusion
Wow.
Google Maps
Utility Links
Capitol Copy Services offers premier on-site and off-site litigation support services
Capitol Copy Services offers premier on-site and off-site litigation support services in York
& Lancaster & Harrisburg, PA including e-discovery, document scanning/printing, court
filings & presentations & secure courier services.
Direct Express
Check your transaction summary and card balance
Account Management Home | AEP Energy
AEP Energy makes it easy for customers to buy, manage and use energy. A competitive
supplier of power since 2004, AEP Energy combines an individualized, consultative
approach with the resources of a Fortune 200 company. Nationally, AEP Energy provides
solutions to increase efficiency and take control of costs.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page125
87 of
of377
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 898Page
of 2413
899 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
PNC Bank - Personal Banking
PNC offers a wide range of services for all our customers, from individuals and small
businesses, to corporations and government entities. No matter how simple or complicated
your needs, we're sure to have the products, knowledge and resources necessary for
financial success.
Wells Fargo - Session Time Out
2015 Business Expo
We're sorry..., Social Security
The Lancaster Chamber of Commerce & Industry
Men - BAC Tables (Blood Alcohol Content Tables)
Patient First - Visits
Patient First Patient Portal
Copy and Print-Staples Copy & Print
Uniden UDR744 Digital Wireless Surveillance Video System with 2 Cameras with Night Vision
and Audio - BJ's Wholesale Club
UNIDEN UDR744 2 CAMERA
GoFundMe - Dashboard
114 N Old Stonehouse Rd, Carlisle, PA 17015 is For Sale | Zillow
View 25 photos of this $380,000, 4 bed, 2.5 bath, 2876 sqft Single Family built in 1974.
Nestled behind the trees, your oasis awaits..Pocket doors, wind...
Cultivate Lancaster
Homeowner Rehab Program | City of Lancaster
Facebook
MassTimes - Map
Search Mass Times to find Catholic worship times, mapped locations, and parish contact
information. The Mass Times database/directory contains information on over 117,000
parishes. The original mass times web site. The official web site of the Mass Times Trust.
Pandora Radio - Listen to Free Internet Radio, Find New Music
Pandora is free, personalized radio that plays music you'll love. Discover new music and
enjoy old favorites. Start with your favorite artist, song or composer and Pandora will
create a custom station that plays similar tracks.
Credit One Bank - Official Site
Credit One Bank is one of America's leading issuers of VISA Platinum credit cards.
Browse our VISA and MasterCard credit card offers and apply online today.
Capital One Online Banking | Accounts Summary
Webroot SecureAnywhere
Create or log into your Webroot account here. Manage your security across multiple
devices, with any Webroot product. Get started today!
Warm and welcoming, no matter the temperature.
GEICO-View and Print Your Insurance ID Card
Policy Service Center Logoff - GEICO
Contractor Equipment Rental | Lancaster PA
Contractor equipment rental helps small businesses, instead of investing in a rarely used
equipment piece consider renting, we'll help you complete the task
Titan Avant-Garde Premium Adjustable Base - Sleepy's
Sleepy's
Serta IComfort Gel Savant III Plush Mattress - 1800mattress
1800mattress
radio SiriusXM
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page126
88 of
of377
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 899Page
of 2413
900 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
June 17, 2016
Search
(2) Stan J. Caterbone (@SCaterbone) | Twitter
Stan Caterbone Football Scrapbook Senior Year Season 1975 June 24 2007 Created by Yolanda
Caterbone
Inbox (1) - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
Share petition Facebook: Remove pages that are reported and proven to be fake Change.org
Your Tweet has been posted!
Upload a Document | Scribd
Institutional Investors Mortgage Banking Business Development of 1987 Very Important for the
Pflumms April 30, 2016
U.S. District Court Case No. 06-4734 Federal False Claim Act Filing of October 19 2006
Documents and ORDERS
Owen Kugel, Appellant, v. United States of America, Appellee, 947 F.2d 1504 (D.C. Cir.
1991) :: Justia
Lancaster General Health wants to build a 126-bed mental health facility | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
The Killing of a tI
ISIS
What We Know About The 300 ISIS Sympathizers In The U.S. | ThinkProgress
There is a small but active cadre of individuals infatuated with ISIS ideology in the U.S.
according to a new report from the Program on Extremism at the George Washington
University.
NewsBusters |
The American Police State | Fight "Gang Stalking"
__________________________________________________________ Everyone has
either personally experienced - or witnessed someone else experience - a dog straining
against its leash to the point where the dog is essentially taking its owner for a walk, rather
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page130
92 of
of377
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 903Page
of 2413
904 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
than the other way around. Currently, America is the dog owner, and the dog taking us for a
walk is the
The Irish Mafia : The Oldest Gang In USA [ Crime Documentary ] - YouTube
The Dixie Chicks debuted their song "I Hope" on the telethon raising money for those
caught in Hurricane Katrina. They released an awesome version of the son...
Editorial: Amid political arguments, there are still reasons for optimism and celebration this
Fourth of July | Opinion | lancasteronline.com
As we head into a presidential election, polls show Americans are more frustrated than any
other time in recent memory. Both presidential candidates are historically unpopular. The
debate over issues
The Report of the Iraq Inquiry Executive Summary July 6, 2016
The Report of the Iraq InquiryExecutive Summary Report of a Committee of Privy
Counsellors HC 264
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page
Page131
93 of
of377
272
288
301
312
321
332
415 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 904Page
of 2413
905 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Return to an Addres...
Conspiracy Theories About Dallas Cop Shootings | News One
The conspiracy theories have already started as racial tensions rise over the deaths of two
unarmed Black men, and the Dallas cop shootings
Amicus Stall
From nazis to mind control the 4 craziest O.J. Simpson conspiracy theories Zap2It
Tuesday's episode of "The People v. OJ Simpson" explored the case's conspiracy theories.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 147
109 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 920
Page
of 2413
921 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Here are four of the craziest ones.
Irish Mob - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Mon Dec 7 - Neil Sanders - Modern Mind Control - Art Bell
Pennsylvania Civil Rights Law Network | Working to provide equal justice under the law in
Pennsylvania
Bobby Ray Inman and South Africa
The withdrawal of Bobby Ray Inman?s nomination for Secretary of Defense brought to
public attention the case of International Signal and Control, a defense and technology
company. James Guerin, the company's founder, was recently sentenced to jail for illegal
arms sales to South Africa, as reported in ?Inman Faced Scrutiny on Jailed Arms Dealer?
(news article, Jan. 20, 1994).
Alec Kreider | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderers
Murderpedia, the free online encyclopedic dictionary of murderers. The largest database
about serial killers, mass murderers and spree killers around the world
David Ludwig | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderers
Murderpedia, the free online encyclopedic dictionary of murderers. The largest database
about serial killers, mass murderers and spree killers around the world
Jesse Wise | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderers
Murderpedia, the free online encyclopedic dictionary of murderers. The largest database
about serial killers, mass murderers and spree killers around the world
Man who killed girl, 7, in murder-suicide spoke of mind control - Story | WJBK
"We found evidence that Obeshaw believed someone was trying to control him
through mind control," Chief Sclabassi said. "And other statements
indicating he thought someone was out to get him."
Juan Cole: Donald Trumps Call for Spying on U.S. Muslims Recalls FBI Bugging of MLK and
Black Churches - Juan Cole - Truthdig
As Trump supporters beat a Black Lives Matter protester at a rally in Birmingham, Ala.,
Trump himself reminded us of the days when J. Edgar Hoovers FBI monitored the Rev.
Martin Luther King and Southern Christian Leadership Conference churches. - 2015/11/23
Tom Ridge - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Patriots and Profiteers: Economic Warfare, Embargo Busting, and State-Sponsored Crime -
Kindle edition by R.T. Naylor. Politics & Social Sciences Kindle eBooks @ Amazon.com.
Patriots and Profiteers: Economic Warfare, Embargo Busting, and State-Sponsored Crime -
Kindle edition by R.T. Naylor. Download it once and read it on your Kindle device, PC,
phones or tablets. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading
Patriots and Profiteers: Economic Warfare, Embargo Busting, and State-Sponsored Crime.
Arms Dealer Is Sentenced To 15 Years James H. Guerin Of Lancaster Ran A Billion-dollar
Fraud. In 15 Days, He'll Enter Federal Prison. - philly-archives
A former international arms merchant was sentenced yesterday to 15 years in prison for
masterminding a $1 billion financial fraud and overseeing the shipment of sophisticated
weaponry to South
The Illegal Arms Trade IraqIran War 1980 1988 (Part 4) | Eyre International - Bringing You
The News No One Else Wants To Bring You
Part 4 We can now look into the illegal arms trade to Iraq which in itself became very
sophisticated with its concealed web of distribution. The UK played a major role in support
for Saddam Hussein with one company that really did stand out from the rest. A Scottish
Company called Allivane
A Lancaster Firm, The Cia And Illegal Arms Deals - philly-archives
In the 1980s, James Guerin built a lavish corporate headquarters, became one of this city's
largest employers and ultimately sold his company for a fortune.Not bad for a firm whose
first engineering
Clinton's Pentagon nominee has always been singled out and sought after - tribunedigital-
baltimoresun
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 148
110 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 921
Page
of 2413
922 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
WASHINGTON -- In the early days of the Reagan administration, when few Carter
appointees were held in high esteem, there was one exception: Bobby Ray
Inman.Republicans were competing with each other
A NOMINEE'S WITHDRAWAL - Inman Faced Scrutiny On Jailed Arms Dealer -
NYTimes.com
While Bobby Ray Inman's confirmation as Defense Secretary by the Senate Armed
Services Committee next week was considered a foregone conclusion, he faced potentially
embarrassing questions about his work as a member of an outside board for a corrupt arms
company. His connection with the company, International Signal and Control, was reported
by the press in 1991 and was raised again by several newspaper columnists in the last
month. Their columns so irked Mr. Inman that he cited them on Tuesday as a major reason
for his withdrawal.
Spider's Web: The Secret History of How the White House Illegally Armed Iraq | Democracy
Now!
Tom Porter - Government Research into ESP & Mind Control
Bobby Ray Inman - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Earthpulse Press
Tony Blair says he's sorry for Iraq War 'mistakes' - CNN.com
Former British Prime Minister Tony Blair says he's sorry for "mistakes" made in the U.S.-
led invasion of Iraq in 2003 but doesn't regret ousting Saddam Hussein.
Top 10 Weirdest CIA Programs - Toptenz.net
Over the years, the American Central Intelligence Agency has gained a reputation for being
the most far-reaching, sophisticated, and effective government i
Unjust enrichment legal definition of unjust enrichment
Definition of unjust enrichment in the Legal Dictionary - by Free online English dictionary
and encyclopedia. What is unjust enrichment? Meaning of unjust enrichment as a legal
term. What does unjust enrichment mean in law?
Case No. 15-3400 U.S.Third Circuit Court of Appeals re Lisa Michelle Lambert Habeus
REQUEST for HEARING by Appellant Stanley J. Caterbone, Pro Se October 26, 2015
RECORDED
Case No. 15-3400 U.S.Third Circuit Court of Appeals re Lisa Michelle Lambert Habeus
REQUEST for HEARING by Appellant Stanley J. Caterbone, Pro Se October 26, 2015
RECORDED - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read book online
for free. Case No. 15-3400 U.S.Third Circuit Court of Appeals re Lisa Michelle Lambert
Habeus REQUEST for HEARING by Appellant Stanley J. Caterbone, Pro Se October 26,
2015 RECORDED
BRITISH FIRM CLAIMS IT WAS DUPED BY PA. ARMS MAKER - The Washington Post
HAIG DISCLOSES EARNINGS OF $3 MILLION IN 2 YEARS - The Washington Post
MICROWAVE MIND CONTROL: Modern torture and Control Mechanisms eliminating human
rights and privacy | Riksavisen
by Dr. Rauni Leena Kilde, MD Norsk utgave (Marit Hanssen's side ble plutselig 'dd' etter
at jeg la ut denne artikkel): http://www.maarithanssen.k-nettet.com/main/custom.asp?
wid=357&customID=1904 HELSINGIN
Patriots and Profiteers: Economic Warfare, Embargo Busting, and State ... - R.T. Naylor - Google
Books
Almost everyone assumes that by enforcing trade sanctions and arms embargoes, modern
democracies make tin-pot dictators and rogue states mend their ways - that the application
of economic pressure is easily the most effective way to curb aggression and encourage
respect for human rights. R.T. Naylor demonstrates that economic warfare fails almost
everywhere it is attempted, and that even when it succeeds, it has consequences that are not
only unintended, but also frequently the precise opposite of their advertised result. For
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 149
111 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 922
Page
of 2413
923 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
instance, embargoes drove Cuba into the awkward embrace of the Soviet Union.
Everywhere that economic pressures have been used to either replace or augment military
actions, the result has been confusion leading to criminality. From east to west, from before
WWI to the recent confrontations with Pakistan, Bosnia, and Iraq, the legacy of economic
warfare has been money laundering, gun-running, drug smuggling, and evasion of the rule
of law. Naylor's approach is at once epic and anecdotal. His survey is populated by a
bizarre underworld of warriors and smugglers, gangsters and spies, whose singular careers
would be comic if they weren't absolutely real.
Military secret brain-chipping soldiers program exposed | Examiner.com
The United States is secretly implanting mind control brain chips in soldiers under the guise
of proactively helping to heal battlefield brain injuries, accordi
Seymour M. Hersh - The New Yorker
Seymour M. Hersh wrote his first piece for The New Yorker in 1971 and has been a regular
contributor to the magazine since 1993.
Rick Santorum profited from treasonous US missiles sales to Iran [SECRET TEAM!]
Rick Santorum profited from treasonous US missiles sales to Iran [SECRET TEAM!]
Daniel Inouyes Conscience - The New Yorker
Daniel Inouye had been shocked, and very hurt to face anti-Japanese racism and hatred of
Nips after the war. But over the next decades he seemed more
Juan Cole: Bush Sr. Blames Neocons for Ruining W.s Presidency: Is He Warning Jeb? (Video) -
Juan Cole - Truthdig
In interviews given for a new biography, George H.W. Bush, 91, lets loose against Dick
Cheney and Donald Rumsfeld, whom he clearly blames for many of the failures of the
presidency of his son, George W. Bush. - 2015/11/09
Chris Hedges, Columnist - Truthdig
CNN.com - Cheney's top aide indicted; CIA leak probe continues - Oct 28, 2005
The CIA leak investigation is "not over," special prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald said Friday
after announcing charges against I. Lewis "Scooter" Libby, Vice President Dick Cheney's
chief of staff.
Krysten Ritter Fights Against Mind Control in the Newest Jessica Jones Trailer | Maxim
We're a little more than a week away from the premiere of Marvel's Jessica Jones and
Netflix is keeping the anticipation high with yet another trailer the second full-length
spot amid a seemingly endless parade of teasers.
Project MKUltra - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
COMMONWEALTH v. ZOOK | FindLaw
Case opinion for PA Supreme Court COMMONWEALTH v. ZOOK. Read the Court's full
decision on FindLaw.
American War in the 21st Century: A Scam, a Swindle and a Fraud - Truthdig
In the post-9/11 years, reconstruction and war have really been euphemisms for what,
in other countries, would be recognized as a massive system of corruption. - 2015/11/12
Did Homeland Security Director Tom Ridge Put Stan Caterbone on the Terrorist NoFly List in or
Around 2004 November 16, 2015
Did Homeland Security Director Tom Ridge Put Stan Caterbone on the Terrorist NoFly
List in or Around 2004 November 16, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file
(.txt) or read online for free. Did Homeland Security Director Tom Ridge Put Stan
Caterbone on the Terrorist NoFly List in or Around 2004 November 16, 2015
Keep the Ethical Light Burning | Seeking justice for survivors of nonconsensual human
experimentation
Keep the Ethical Light Burning (KELB) is a non-profit organization. Lynn Bowne Weed is
a NYC Paralegal having done support on many cases including the Microsoft Case in New
York City Member of the Bowne House Historical Society, Flushing, New York David
Beauchamp, Vice President is a music promoter in New York City and former Director
Amazon.com: Abuse Hidden Behind The Badge eBook: Rosaura Torres: Kindle Store
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 150
112 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 923
Page
of 2413
924 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Abuse Hidden Behind The Badge - Kindle edition by Rosaura Torres. Download it once
and read it on your Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets. Use features like bookmarks, note
taking and highlighting while reading Abuse Hidden Behind The Badge.
The National Security States Incestuous Relationship With Islamic State - Truthdig
Paris changed everything; Paris changes nothing. Each view is, in its own way,
undoubtedly true. And heres a third sentence I know to be true: This cant end well. -
2015/11/19
Chris Hedges: States of Terror - Chris Hedges - Truthdig
We waded into conflicts in the Middle East we did not understand, propelled forward by
fantasy. And our folly spawned a death spiral of political, social and economic collapse,
widespread poverty, massive displacement, misery and radical jihadism. - 2015/11/22
Iraq Crisis, 2005
History of Iraq
Iraq Crisis, 20022003
History of Iraq
Does a Koch Intelligence Agency Secretly Keep Tabs on Liberals? - Truthdig
An investigation by Politico suggests that the billionaire right-wing Koch brothers possess
their own high-tech surveillance and intelligence-gathering operation devoted to stealthily
tracking liberal and Democratic groups. - 2015/11/25
Finance Calculator
Free finance calculator! You can define any of the FV, PMT, I/Y, N, and starting
investment to calculate the others. Also find hundreds of other free online calculators here.
Marcia Silen Films Announces Patriotic New Film
As the newest and most socially conscious of their Bloodhounds, Inc. series of films for
young people, Marcia Silen Films announces the release of Bloodhounds the Movie,
Young Citizen Patriots: A Test of Faith and Bravery Part 1. The first in what will be a
series of films centered on the theme of patriotism and tolerance, Young Citizen Patriots
is aimed at young people and focuses on the efforts of popular teen detectives
"Sean" and "Melissa" to save their town from a terrorist threat.
Forget Islamic State: Humanity Itself Is at Stake - Truthdig
The crux of the matter: We either live in dignity together or continue to perish alone, in
warring tribes and grief-stricken nations. This is not just about indiscriminate bombing. Our
humanityin fact, the future of the human race is at stake. - 2015/11/27
Kathleen Kane appoints 'Porngate' prosecutors led by former Md. attorney general |
PennLive.com
Attorney General Kathleen Kane appointed special prosecutors Tuesday to oversee a
review of pornographic and otherwise offensive emails exchanged by state officials.
John Cusack and Arundhati Roy: Things That Can and Cannot Be Said - Truthdig
This is the narrative result of an encounter between Cusack, Roy and whistleblowers
Edward Snowden and Daniel Ellsberg. Cusack and Roy provide their own accounts and
joint conversations. - 2015/12/01
Lancaster County DA releases report on fatal police shooting | News | witf.org
(Lancaster) -- Lancaster Countys top prosecutor is calling a Lancaster City police officer's
fatal shooting of a homeless man who was urinating in public earlier this month justified.
District Attorney Craig Stedman says he would have preferred an independent investigation
into the shooting, but will accept the version of events from the Lancaster City police. On
the morning of June 10th, 35-year-old Gregory Bayne was allegedly urinating in public
when officers confronted him. They said they believed Bayne was mentally ill and he
became aggressive --lunging at them with a nine-inch knife. According to the police, they
chased Bayne down the street, and unsuccessfully tried to taser him. When three officers
cornered him in front of a store on Queen Street, the officers say they repeatedly asked him
to drop the knife. But when he continued towards them, he was fatally shot by Officer Jose
De La Torre. Stedman...
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 151
113 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 924
Page
of 2413
925 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Digital Angel Corp., Prior to Merger with Applied Digital Solutions, Inc.: Private Company
Information - Businessweek
EMF Weapons
Historic St. Marys Church is among 5 pilgrim sites in the Harrisburg diocese in this Jubilee Year
of Mercy | Faith | lancasteronline.com
With the opening of the holy doors at St. Peters Basilica on Tuesday, Pope Francis
launched a yearlong, Extraordinary Jubilee Year of Mercy.
EFI Conspirator From Ala. Gets 45 Months - Suddenlink Communications
Suddenlink Communications delivers breaking news and information on the latest top
stories, weather, business, entertainment, politics, video, photo galleries and more.
Bill Boyarsky: Trumps Muslim Policy Conjures Up Demons From Fascisms History -
Truthdig
If you think its impossible for a demagogue to seize control and destroy American
democracy, think again. Trumps hate-filled call for banning Muslims from entering the
U.S. appeals to many angry and scared Americans. - 2015/12/08
Talk about mind control: Chinese develop a car operated by brain waves - The Washington Post
So far it can only drive straight ahead, but a link with self-driving systems may lie in the
future.
Health Issues - Targeted Individuals 101
This is a site for activism, advocacy and networking for people who are targeted by
organized stalking and electronic harassment as well as people who supports the TI
community and who believe these criminal activities are a violation of human rights
legislations in Canada and around the globe.
KEISLING: Palace coup: what the Kathleen Kane prosecution is really about | NewsLanc.com
Are the criminal charges brought by Republican officials against AG Kane, her subsequent
law license suspension, and efforts by the state senate to remove her from office all simply
a ruse meant to distract voters from what is really going on: an attempt by Republicans to
control policy in the attorney general's office, and throughout state government, without
having won an election?
Sam Katz to produce documentary on Kathleen Kane
Sam Katz is turning his lens away from Philadelphia's history to Pennsylvania's
present.<br/>The three-time mayoral candidate announced Thursday that his next
documentary will focus on the saga of embattled Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen
G. Kane. Katz, who is seeking funding for the project, plans to call it The Kane Mutiny. -
Molly Eichel, Philadelphia Inquirer
Torturing | Define Torturing at Dictionary.com
Torturing definition, the act of inflicting excruciating pain, as punishment or revenge, as a
means of getting a confession or information, or for sheer cruelty. See more.
Mental Illness Diagnosis - Psychotronic and Electromagnetic Weapons: Remote Control of the
Human Nervous System | Global Research - Centre for Research on Globalization
kathleen kane - Google Search
Kathleen Kane's aide convicted of...
Comprehensive up-to-date news coverage, aggregated from sources all over the world by
Google News.
Kathleen Kane's Gay Marriage Mutiny | Philadelphia magazine
How a tough chick from Scranton became Pennsylvania's Attorney Generaland Tom
Corbett's worst nightmare.
Kathleen Kane - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Paranoid schizophrenia - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Bipolar disorder - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Delusional disorder - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
MASONRY PROVEN CONCLUSIVELY TO BE WORSHIP OF LUCIFER, SATAN! Part 1 of
2
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 152
114 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 925
Page
of 2413
926 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Subtitle Now, from their own words and symbols, Freemasonry is proven, beyond a
shadow of a doubt, to be Satanic to the core! You can be deceived no longer.
Former Fulton Bank manager accused of stealing $99,000 from Manor merchants | Local
Business | lancasteronline.com
A former manager of Fulton Banks Manor Shopping Center branch has been accused of
stealing $99,000 from the centers merchants association.
Candy Jones - Mind Control and Hypnosis | Online Universities
Candy Jones - A case of Mind Control? By Brian Haughton
Diary: Lancaster County, The CIA, and U.S. Sponsored Mind Control | OpEdNews
Diary: Lancaster County, The CIA, and U.S. Sponsored Mind Control - Diary: This article
is a 1998 narrative by Stan J. Caterbone before he learned he was a victim of U.S.
Sponsored Mind Control. At the time of this writing Stan J. Caterbone was a federal
whistle-blower dating back to 1987 concerning the Lancaster firm of International Signal &
Control, or ISC. ISC was later indicted in 1991 and plead quilty to a $1 Billion fraud and
selling arms to Iraq.
MICROWAVE MIND CONTROL by Tim Rifat
Murder And Mind Control In The UK
Intrusive Brain Reading Surveillance Technology: Hacking the Mind | Global Research
Dr. Nick Begich - Covert Harassment Conference 2015, Berlin 1-2 October 2015
The Covert Harassment Conference 2015 Berlin is a human rights conference to create
awareness on the Covert Harassment of civilians with the use of non-lethal weaponry and
organized stalking.
Covert Harassment Conference 2015, Berlin 1-2 October 2015
The Covert Harassment Conference 2015 Berlin is a human rights conference to create
awareness on the Covert Harassment of civilians with the use of non-lethal weaponry and
organized stalking.
Chris Hedges: The Illusion of Freedom - Chris Hedges - Truthdig
This deception will exist as long as we stay in our place. Once we call out power for what
it is, once we resist, the chimera will vanish. The iron fist of historys most sophisticated
security and surveillance apparatus will assert itself with a terrifying fury. - 2015/12/27
U.S. Federal Indian Law and Mind Control - ICTMN.com
Lets be clear about something.
Shield: Signal Proof Headwear by Shield Apparel Kickstarter
Shield Apparel is raising funds for Shield: Signal Proof Headwear on Kickstarter! Stylish &
Comfortable Signal Proof Hats That Incredibly Fit And Reflect Electromagnetic Waves.
Soleilmavis Liu | LinkedIn
gmnKen.com | Stuff Kenny's Already Googled For You.Now Go Do Your Homework
I Am A Targeted Individual A Conversation With GMNs Ken Rhoades | gmnKen.com
Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
PACTS, International - Home
TheFuelFilm Deborah Dupre' Peace Peace International Green Fuel Human Rights Green
Consulting Consultant Speaking Projects Youth Family Intervention Environment Biodiesel
Renewable Energy Indigenous Aboriginal Research International Humanitarian Schools
Compassion Louisiana Australia Celebrity
TheFuelFilm Deborah Dupre' Consultant and Associated for EcoPeace Empower through
mission of
2007 Honda CR-V EX Sport Utility 4D Trade In Values - Kelley Blue Book
Get the trade-in value for your 2007 Honda CR-V EX Sport Utility 4D. Find out how to get
the most for your Honda CR-V EX Sport Utility 4D, how to sell it fast, or shop for your
next car.
Monica Lewinsky Is Back, but This Time Its on Her Terms - The New York Times
Once vilified as a predatory White House intern, Ms. Lewinsky has re-emerged, taking
on the fight against cyberbullying.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 153
115 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 926
Page
of 2413
927 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
New wave in tech hacking the brain - Technology - NZ Herald News
The next frontier for the tech sector is the human brain. - New Zealand Herald
Philadelphia police: Man who tried to kill officer pledged allegiance to the Islamic State - The
Washington Post
A police officer in Philadelphia survived being shot multiple times in what officials
described as an ambush.
Hacking the human brain: Company unveils 'mind control' headband to help people with
disabilities | Christian News on Christian Today
When we say the word "hack," the first thing that usually comes to mind is
computers. In reality, though, scientists have long been trying to hack the brain for various
purposes, from offering new healthcare services to providing new ways to control
technological devices.
Safe and Sane? Pondering China's Mind-Controlled Cars - Quoted
On the Need for New Criteria of Diagnosis of Psychosis in the Light of Mind Invasive
Technology | Global Research - Centre for Research on Globalization
On the Need for New Criteria of Diagnosis of Psychosis in the Light of Mind Invasive
Technology by Carole Smith | Stan Caterbone | LinkedIn
"The calculated and technological entry into another persons mind is an act of
monumental barbarism which obliterates perhaps with the twiddling of
The IBM engineer that controlled a 'Star Wars' toy with his mind thinks brain readers could be
the next big thing | Business Insider
Earlier this week Business...
PACTS, International Newsletter, vol. I - Monday, January 18, 2016
Dr. John Halls book A new Breed: Satellite Terrorism in America to become movie
When Dr. John Hall wrote the book A new Breed: Satellite Terrorism in America,
information about the technologies and techniques for remote influencing, where basically
unknown to most people.
DARPA wants to build wetware so we can mind control computers
Hot damn, our Ghost in the Shell future is getting closer by the day. DARPA announced on
Tuesday that it is interested in developing wetware -- implantable brai...
Soleilmavis Liu's Books and Publications Spotlight
DARPA wants to build wetware so we can mind control computers - HueWire
DARPA (Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency) has launched a new project under
which an implantable chip will be developed that will allow th
Timeline of Secret Government Projects
The Executive Summary: Neuropsychological and Electronic No-Touch Torture Report by
Robert Duncan, A.B., S.M., M.B.A., Ph.D.
Control things with your mind: US military wants to build brain modem
THE United States military has grown tired of traditional tactics and is working on a new
technology that promises to revolutionise modern warfare.
PA House of Representatives
The Neurologist Who Hacked His BrainAnd Almost Lost His Mind | WIRED
Neurologist Phil Kennedy set out to build the ultimate brain-computer interface. In the
process he almost lost his mind.
Russia developing mind-controlled 'exoskeletons' for its soldiers | Latest News | Breaking UK
News & World News Headlines | Daily Star
THE era of the 'robo-soldier' is nearing as Russia claims to be perfecting machines that will
revolutionise warfare.
CSUF students develop app, hardware for mind-controlled wheelchairs - The Orange County
Register
Life: CSUF students develop app, hardware for mind-controlled wheelchairs | project,
students, electric, wheelchair, george, controlled, working, brain, pals, application
Mom murdered her autistic son after seeking help from therapist who believes in Satanic mind
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 154
116 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 927
Page
of 2413
928 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
control
HAARP Season 1 Episode 1Conspiracy Theory with Jesse Ventura 2013 - Watch Online |
Conspiracy Theory with Jesse Ventura 2013 - Watch Online
Premiere On: Wed, December 2 at 10PWatch Episode 1- HAARP Conspiracy Theory Jesse
VenturaIs it a communications research project or a doomsday weapon that can change the
weather, shoot satellites
Outrage at U.S. torture dwindles USATODAY.com
Jonathan Turley: The president has kept his promise to not prosecute CIA torturers, leaving
them unaccountable for their actions.
More Than Half the Worlds Population Faces Severe Water Scarcity - Truthdig
A new study indicates that global water shortages are much more severe than previously
thought, finding that 4 billion people suffer water scarcity during at least one month during
the year, while half a billion experience it throughout the year. - 2016/02/13
Pa. Woman Who Killed Her Two Children Found Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity |
JONATHAN TURLEY
Meghan Lippiatt has been found not guilty by reason of insanity in a Lancaster court.
Lippiatt admitted suffocating her infant son and drowning her 2-year-old son in 2004. The
killing two-year-old Silas and his four-month-old brother Miles occurred weeks after a
break-up with her husband. Lippiatt called 911 and told the operator: "I did something
Massive Fraud Threatens to Bring Down Sterling Financial Corporation - Monitordaily
ICYMI: Fast brain upload, mind-control monkeys & more
Today on In Case You Missed It: Researchers at HRL Labs have developed a system to
upload information to your brain using electrical signals already mapped fr...
Court Links
Pennsylvania Wiretapping and Electronic Surveillance Law and Exceptions That Allow Me to
Record November 21, 2015
Pennsylvania Wiretapping and Electronic Surveillance Law and Exceptions That Allow Me
to Record November 21, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read
online for free. Pennsylvania Wiretapping and Electronic Surveillance Law and Exceptions
That Allow Me to Record November 21, 2015
Pa. begins process for sick children to get pot | Pennsylvania | lancasteronline.com
Pennsylvania is about to start allowing children with epilepsy and other conditions to be
treated with medical marijuana.
Third Circuit | United States Court of Appeals
Without Prejudice legal definition of Without Prejudice
Definition of Without Prejudice in the Legal Dictionary - by Free online English dictionary
and encyclopedia. What is Without Prejudice? Meaning of Without Prejudice as a legal
term. What does Without Prejudice mean in law?
Pennsylvania State Police Criminal Background Check January 8, 2016
Pennsylvania State Police Criminal Background Check January 8, 2016 - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Pennsylvania State Police Criminal
Background Check January 8, 2016
CountySuite Civil Court
Petition for Review Docket
United States District Court Eastern District of Pennsylvania-United States District Court Eastern
District of Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania's Unified Judicial System
AppellateCourtReport.ashx
Rule 3. Appeal as of Right | Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure | LII / Legal Information
Institute
(a) Filing the Notice of Appeal. (1) An appeal permitted by law as of right from a district
court to a court of appeals may be taken only by filing a notice of appeal with the district
clerk within the time allowed by Rule 4. At the time of filing, the appellant must furnish the
clerk with enough copies of the notice to enable the clerk to comply with Rule 3(d).
Superior Court ECF Login
U.S. District Search
CM/ECF Appellate Filer Account Update
Duke Street
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 159
121 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 932
Page
of 2413
933 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Superior Court ECF Dashboard
Common Pleas Docket Sheet
Lanc Co File & ServeXpress
Court Case Schedule and Yearly Calendars | Lancaster County Courts, PA - Official Website
Prothonotary | Lancaster County, PA - Official Website
Lancaster County Court Calendar Admin : Court Schedule
Rules & Policies | United States Courts
2011_LAR_Final.pdf
Microsoft Word - clkdir2.doc - clkdir2.pdf
Adult Probation | Lancaster County Courts, PA - Official Website
Learn about Adult Probation & Parole Services.
File & ServeXpress Basic
234 Pa. Code Rule 506. Approval of Private Complaints.
Habeus District Court Eastern District of Pennsylvania
Lambert Habeus District Court Eastern District of Pennsylvania
Third Circuit Search
Federal Kidnapping Act - Federal Statutes on Kidnapping - Abduction and Kidnapping
210 Pa. Code Rule 552. Application to Lower Court for Leave to Appeal In FormaPauperis.
The Polygraph Place - Pennsylvania Polygraph Examiners
Register of Wills | Lancaster County, PA - Official Website
Take a look at services offered by the Register of Wills.
Lancaster County Office of the Recorder of Deeds Home Page
Welcome to the Lancaster County Office of the Recorder of Deeds website! We are located
in Lancaster, PA and serve the residents of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania
Timothy A. Lanza - a Lancaster, Pennsylvania (PA) Criminal Law Law Firm
Timothy A. Lanza, a Lancaster, Pennsylvania (PA) Law Firm - Criminal Law
Electronic Recording Information
These are the companies that Lancaster County Recorder of Deeds currently accepts
electronic recordings from.
Pennsylvania Probate: An Overview | Nolo.com
If you need to shepherd an estate through probate in Pennsylvania, you'll probably get good
help from the local court, including downloadable court forms.
Grant Deed Form - Download - Fill In The Blank Form
State Specific Grant Deed Forms, Downloadable Fill in the Blank Grant Deed Forms, State
Specific
For the Public | Forms | Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania
U.S. District Court Directory
The Robing Room
CountySuite Civil Court
Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General
Are politicians afraid to impeach and openly try A. G. Kathleen Kane? | NewsLanc.com
What's happening with Kane is particularly pernicious in that they are attempting to forego
a full hearing, and instead substitute one limited to the much smaller, sole issue of her law
license.
Senator Camera Bartolotta - PA State Senate
Blood Alcohol Calculator Check Yourself Before You Wreck Yourself
File & ServeXpress Basic
Recording Police Officers and Public Officials | Digital Media Law Project
PA Wiretap - Title 18 - PA General Assembly
PA CAPITOL POLICE
City Of Harrisburg | Bureau of Police
Mayor Eric Papenfuse
National Constitution Center
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 160
122 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 933
Page
of 2413
934 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
IC3 Complaint Information
Learning to Live with Pro Se Opponents
Judicial Nominations - Paul S. Diamond
Pennsylvania Assault and Battery Laws | Criminal Law
In Pennsylvania, misdemeanor simple assault involves intentionally, knowingly, or
recklessly inflicting bodily injury on another, attempting to do so, or putting someone in
fear of imminent bodily injury.
Rule 42. Voluntary Dismissal | Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure | LII / Legal Information
Institute
(a) Dismissal in the District Court. Before an appeal has been docketed by the circuit clerk,
the district court may dismiss the appeal on the filing of a stipulation signed by all parties
or on the appellant's motion with notice to all parties.
Meet the U.S. Attorney | USAO-EDPA | Department of Justice
U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Pennsylvania, Clerk's Office
McDonald at Law Personal Injury Lawyers - Lancaster, PA - Philadelphia, PA
The experienced, compassionate personal injury lawyers at McDonald at Law in Lancaster,
PA, are proud to fight on behalf of victims in our community.
In the Spotlight: Jacquelyn Pfursich begins new job as Lancaster County Clerk of Courts | Local
News | lancasteronline.com
With a new year comes a new job for Jacquelyn Pfursich who is the county's new clerk of
courts.
Dashboard | Credit Karma
Instantly receive your free credit score and free credit report online. Free credit tools to
track and optimize your credit score. No credit card needed & no hidden fees.
Tolling the Statute of Limitations in my Civil Complaints with the RICO Act and the Lambert
Appeal in the U.S. Third Circuit - Judgement Day. | Stan Caterbone | LinkedIn
U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals Reinstates and Protects Claims for CATERBONE v.
Lancaster County Prison, et.al., in Case No. 07-4474 U.S. Distric
5 things to know about Josh Parsons, Lancaster County's newest commissioner | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Josh Parsons, an army infantry veteran, former prosecutor and former clerk of courts, took
the oath of office Monday morning as Lancaster County's newest commissioner.
Bankruptcy Forms | United States Courts
Seeking Guardianship for a Loved One - McAndrews Law Firm
Owen Kugel, Appellant, v. United States of America, Appellee, 947 F.2d 1504 (D.C. Cir.
1991) :: Justia
Owen Kugel, Appellant, v. United States of America, Appellee, 947 F.2d 1504 (D.C. Cir.
1991) case opinion from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
Table of Contents of the Study Judicial Discipline Reform
Chapter 27 - Title 18 - CRIMES AND OFFENSES
Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO) | Nolo.com
Passed in 1970, the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO) is a
federal law designed to combat organized crime in the United States.
Contact Us | USAO-EDPA | Department of Justice
Supreme Court Tie Dooms Obama Immigration Policy - NBC News
The split was reflected in a one sentence statement from the court: "The judgment is
affirmed by an equally divided Court."
IN RE CATERBONE by RICHARD E. FEHLING, Bankruptcy Judge | Leagle.com
In re: STANLEY J. CATERBONE, Chapter 11, Debtor. REVISED2 MEMORANDUM
OPINION SUPPORTING ORDER DATED FEBRUARY 18.2016. DISMISSING
CHAPTER 11 PROCEEDING RICHARD E. FEHLING, Bankruptcy Judge. I...
Court rejects man's claim that Lancaster County's residents are torturing him with mind control |
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 161
123 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 934
Page
of 2413
935 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
PennLive.com
A state Superior Court panel upheld a Lancaster County judge's ruling that Stanley
Caterbone's suit is frivolous.
Government Treaty With Large Gray Aliens Requires Full UFO And ET Disclosure In 2016,
Conspiracy Theorists Say [Video]
A report that emerged last week in the conspiracy theory blogosphere claims that a treaty
between the government and an extraterrestrial species known as the
Supreme Court strikes down Texas abortion law - CNNPolitics.com
In a dramatic ruling, the Supreme Court on Monday threw out a Texas abortion access law
in a victory to supporters of abortion rights who argued it would have shuttered all but a
handful of clinics in the state.
Baby abandoned on an Amish porch 40 years ago now seeks family connection | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Forty years ago, a widowed Amish woman and her daughter watched from their window
late one night as someone in dark clothing walked up to their farmhouse near Gordonville
and
Medical Society elects Simons president for 2-year term | Local Business | lancasteronline.com
The Lancaster City & County Medical Society said Thursday it has elected Dr. David
J. Simons president for a two-year term.
Chester Springs man co-authors murder novel
Lancaster County native, ex-Tour de France winner Floyd Landis to launch cannabis business |
Local News | lancasteronline.com
Floyd Landis is back in business.
Consumer Reports takes on America's student debt crisis | National | lancasteronline.com
"I kind of ruined my life by going to college."
Lancaster City Police Department 302 (Mulslim Brotherhood Email Included) Mental Health
Warrant of July 9, 2015 and COURT ORDER of 303 Hearing
15-03984 EXHIBIT Re Preliminary Injunction for EMERGENCY RELIEF Filed in the
Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas Case No. CI-16-05815 July 3, 2016
15-03984 EXHIBIT Re Lancaster City Police Department 302 (Muslim Brotherhood Email
Included) Mental Health Warrant of July 9, 2015 and COURT ORDER of 303 Hearing July 3,
2016
15-03984 EXHIBIT Re Lancaster City Police Department 302 (Muslim Brotherhood Email
Included) Mental Health Warrant of July 9, 2015 and COURT ORDER of 303 Hearing July
3, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
What is IP Law?
Code of Judicial Conduct: Effective July 1, 2014 | Judicial Conduct Board of Pennsylvania
PA Supreme Court Case No. 354 and 353 MT 2016 Letters and Orders of June 13, 2016 Re
CATERBONE v. Lancaster County Residents and Lancaster City Police OPEN CASES
PA Supreme Court Case No. 354 and 353 MT 2016 Letters and Orders of June 13, 2016 Re
CATERBONE v. Lancaster County Residents and Lancaster City Police OPEN CASES -
Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read book online for free.
Lancaster Convention Center | Lancaster history and culture
Convention hotel and conference center located in charming and sophisticated Downtown
Lancaster Pennsylvania
Incident Reports of Harassment, Vandalism, Hacking, & Thefts From 1987 to March 22, 2010
Christie Brinkley 'wants to make John Mellencamp her FIFTH husband' | Daily Mail Online
The former Sports Illustrated cover girl wants to wed rocker John Mellencamp, 64, is the
fall in his hometown of Daufuskie Island, South Carolina, in the fall, a source told the
publication.
New Lancaster County Sheriffs App connects office to community | WPMT FOX43
16-05815 Docket
Nebraska killer contradicted trial testimony to state senator in COINTELPRO case - National
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 162
124 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 935
Page
of 2413
936 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Cointelpro | Examiner.com
1998 AFFIDAVIT to Judge Stewart Dalzall of the US District Court for Eastern Pennsylvania
Sheryl Crow excited about Nashvilles firework display after performance | WKRN News 2
Sheryl Crows July Fourth performance at Ascend Amphitheater will precede a big
fireworks show, a show Crow has said shes excited for.
jim boyerClassic Tracks: My Life, Billy Joel | Mixonline
Change.org Petition by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group to President Obama March
17, 2016 With Affidavit and Kane Op Ed Letter
Change.org Petition by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group to President Obama
March 17, 2016 With Affidavit and Kane Op Ed Letter - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
Dockets and Stamped Cover Pages U.S. District Court, U.S. Third Circuit Dockets and Reciepts
Fairmount Health Systems Wednesday, July 6, 2016 w Page Numbers
NOW with David Brancaccio. Politics & Economy. Criminalizing Dissent. COINTELPRO
Again? | PBS
In an era where commercial values in journalism risk overwhelming democratic values and
corporate interests can prevail over the public interest, NOW continues to stand apart as the
one program going against the grain.
Summary Appeal Form for MDJ Scott E Albert Vehicle Turning Left of June 10, 2016 Filed on
July 7, 2016
Summary Appeal Form for MDJ Scott E Albert Vehicle Turning Left of June 10, 2016
Filed on July 7, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for
free.
Stewart Dalzell - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
8 local Republicans and Democratic delegates will participate in the conventions; Here's what
they expect | Insider | lancasteronline.com
Barring any surprises, Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton look set to be their party's official
picks to replace President Barack Obama.
Allstate Sworn Testimony of Stan J. Caterbone TRANSCRIPT Volume 2 (June 28, 2016) and
Volume 1 (June 9, 2016) July 12, 2016
AG Kathleen Kane's criminal trial set to begin Aug. 8 | PennLive.com
Despite a raft of pretrial motions this spring, a judge has reaffirmed an Aug. 8 start date for
Attorney General Kathleen Kane's criminal trial.
Recorded 15-03984 STATEMENT Re Court of Common Pleas of Montgomery County Case No.
CP-46-CR-0008423-2015 REQUEST for APPEARANCE and AMICUS in Support of Kathleen
Kane July 12, 2016
Recorded 15-03984 STATEMENT Re Court of Common Pleas of Montgomery County
Case No. CP-46-CR-0008423-2015 REQUEST for APPEARANCE and AMICUS in
Support of Kathleen Kane July 12, 2016 by stan5j.5caterbone in Types > Business/Law >
Court Filings, cia, and dia
Former Reinholds woman admits to drinking three beers before crash that killed Lancaster
woman | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Patricia Halgash admitted to drinking three beers before a fatal car crash in 2014, according
to her own testimony Wednesday afternoon at Lancaster County Courthouse.
Stan J. Caterbone CORROBORATING WITNESS for Former Reinholds Woman Admits to
Drinking Three Beers Before Crash That Killed Lancaster Woman Local News Lancasteronline
September 14, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone CORROBORATING WITNESS for Former Reinholds Woman Admits
to Drinking Three Beers Before Crash That Killed Lancaster Woman Local News
Lancasteronline September 14, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or
read online for free. Stan J. Caterbone CORROBORATING WITNESS for Former
Reinholds Woman Admits to Drinking Three Beers Before Crash That Killed Lancaster
Woman Local News Lancasteronline September 14, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 163
125 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 936
Page
of 2413
937 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
CORRUPT Lancaster County Prothonotary and Judge Leonard G. Brown - EVIDENCE July 14,
2016
CORRUPT Lancaster County Prothonotary and Judge Leonard G. Brown - EVIDENCE
July 14, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
CORRUPT Lancaster County Prothonotary and Judge Leonard G. Brown - EVIDENCE
July 14, 2016
2016-17 Governor Proposed Revenues and Tax Changes
PROPOSED TAX AND REVENUE MODIFICATIONSGovernor Tom Wolf - FY2016-17
Executive Budget GENERAL FUND Effective Date FY...
Surprising New Evidence Shows Bias in Police Use of Force but Not in Shootings - The New
York Times
Contradicting conventional wisdom: When it comes to the most lethal form of force, a
study finds no racial bias.
Former Reinholds woman found guilty of DUI-related vehicular homicide | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
A former Reinholds woman was found guilty Thursday of driving drunk in a 2014 car crash
that killed a Lancaster woman and severely injured her son.
Supervisors meet amid speculation over future of Southern Regional police | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Residents of Pequea and Conestoga townships are expected to turn out in large numbers at
a special meeting Thursday night amid speculation that the Southern Regional Police
Department could soon
Letter From Dauphin County Probation Services Re Fines and Costs for CP-22-0000067SA2016
and RESPONSE July 18, 2016
Letter From Dauphin County Probation Services Re Fines and Costs for CP-22-
0000067SA2016 and RESPONSE July 18, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text
File (.txt) or read online for free. Letter From Dauphin County Probation Services Re Fines
and Costs for CP-22-0000067SA2016 and RESPONSE July 18, 2016
Recorded PA Supreme Court Case No. 353 and 354 MT 2016 Motion for Reconsideration for in
Forma Pauperis Status July 18, 2016
Recorded PA Supreme Court Case No. 353 and 354 MT 2016 Motion for Reconsideration
for in Forma Pauperis Status July 18, 2016 by stan5j.5caterbone in Types > Business/Law
> Court Filings, cia, and dia
Letter to Barry G. Goldman, Attorney at Law Re Altana Rooftop No Tresspass of July 14, 2015
Letter to Barry G. Goldman, Attorney at Law Re Altana Rooftop No Tresspass of July 14,
2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Letter to
Barry G. Goldman, Attorney at Law Re Altana Rooftop No Tresspass of July 14, 2015
16-MC-49 U.S. District Court Chapter 11 MOTION to File Exhibit Re Press Release and
Executive Summary Re CATERBONE v. the United States of America, et.al., July 19, 2016
16-MC-49 U.S. District Court Chapter 11 MOTION to File Exhibit Re Press Release and
Executive Summary Re CATERBONE v. the United States of America, et.al., July 19,
2016 by stan5j.5caterbone in Types > Business/Law > Court Filings, cia, and dia
Recorded 16-MC-49 U.S. District Court Chapter 11 MOTION to File Exhibit Re Press Release
and Executive Summary Re CATERBONE v. the United States of America, et.al., July 19, 2016
Recorded 16-MC-49 U.S. District Court Chapter 11 MOTION to File Exhibit Re Press
Release and Executive Summary Re CATERBONE v. the United States of America, et.al.,
July 19, 2016 by stan5j.5caterbone in Types > Business/Law > Court Filings, cia, and dia
U.S. District Court and Third Circuit Court DOCKET SHEETS for July 19, 2016
U.S. District Court and Third Circuit Court DOCKET SHEETS for July 19, 2016 by
stan5j.5caterbone in Types > Business/Law > Court Filings, cia, and dia
CATERBONE Complaint to Lancaster City Police Union April 29, 2009
CATERBONE Complaint to Lancaster City Police Union April 29, 2009 - Free download
as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. CATERBONE Complaint to
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 164
126 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 937
Page
of 2413
938 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Lancaster City Police Union April 29, 2009
Court of Common Pleas of Montgomery County Case No. CP-46-CR-0008423-2015 REQUEST
for APPEARANCE Re Kathleen Kane Amicus in Support of Motion to DISMISS Charges July
20, 2016
16-1149 (To US Supreme Court for Lisa) Third Circuit Lambert Appeal Order by the Clerk of
Courts Dismissing Appeal Dated July 18, 2016
Signed - Letter to the OFFICE of the EXECUTIVE of the Third Circuit Court of Appeals Re
Judicial Complaint No. 03-16-90007 Lisa Michelle Lambert July 24, 2016 Full Document Sent
231 Pa. Code Rule 240. In Forma Pauperis.
PA JUDICIAL CONDUCT COMPLAINT - Recorded 16-Mc-49 Bankruptcy Appeal
DECLARATION Re Judicial Conduct Board COMPLAINT Re CI-16-05815 Preliminary
Injunction for Relief Filed on July 26, 2016 Signed Copy - UPDATED HACKER DELETED 7
PAGES
Recorded 16-Mc-49 Bankruptcy Appeal DECLARATION Re Judicial Conduct Board
COMPLAINT Re CI-16-05815 Preliminary Injunction for Relief Filed on July 26, 2016
Signed Copy - UPDATED HACKER DELETED 7 PAGES by stan5j.5caterbone
judge edward smith eastern district - Google Search
16-cv-4014 - CATERBONE v. the United States of America,et.al., COMPLAINT July 20, 2016
ver 3.0 Full With Forms July 22, 2016
CATERBONE v. the United States of America,et.al., COMPLAINT July 20, 2016 ver 3.0
Full With Forms July 22, 2016 - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or
read book online for free. CATERBONE v. the United States of America,et.al.,
COMPLAINT July 20, 2016 ver 3.0 Full With Forms July 22, 2016
42 U.S. Code 1983 - Civil action for deprivation of rights | US Law | LII / Legal Information
Institute
Case No. CI-16-05815 EXHIBIT to Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Emergency Relief, Re
Downtown Lancaster Handout Friday August 19, 2016
2016 INJUNCTION
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 165
127 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 938
Page
of 2413
939 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Police Shootings
In the Spotlight: Cross Connections Ministries leader says Its all about relationships | Local
News | lancasteronline.com
Families in New Holland can find a place of community on Franklin Street.
Senseless, chilling: Two Columbia teens charged with trying to kill police officers; bail $2
million each | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Two Columbia teenagers used a scoped sniper rifle in an attempt to gun down police
officers in an early Friday morning shooting in the borough, officials said at a press
Lancaster County police on heightened alert after recent shooting incidents | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
It was only this past Monday when some police chiefs in Lancaster County were discussing
what they should do, or could do, to prevent their officers from being ambushed and
Recent incidents of shots at police in Lancaster County | Local News | lancasteronline.com
At least a half-dozen local police officers have been wounded by gunfire in the past 16
years, according to LNP archives.
Danish prime minister, not presidential nominee Hillary Clinton, caused Friday hubbub in
downtown Lancaster | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Presidential nominee Hillary Clinton was not hitting the hot spots in downtown Lancaster
on Friday, despite plenty of rumors that the former first lady, senator and secretary of state
was
2 in custody, charges expected after shots fired at police in Columbia | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Two males are expected to be charged after shots were fired at police, and residents were
warned to remain in their homes Friday morning in Columbia.
In wake of shootings, Lancaster County police act to ensure officers make it home safely each
day | Insider | lancasteronline.com
Local police, after being targeted in two shootings last week in Lancaster and Columbia,
are taking steps to ensure they remain safe on the job.
Clergy, police, NAACP and civic leaders find new urgency in conversation about escalating
police violence | Local News | lancasteronline.com
The conversation about violence both by and against police took on a new sense of
urgency in Lancaster County last week when gunmen opened fire on officers in
Teen charged in Columbia shooting apparently refers to Lancaster gunfire incident on Facebook |
Insider | lancasteronline.com
A Facebook page apparently belonging to one of two teenagers charged with shooting at
police in Columbia early Friday references last weeks shooting in Lancaster city in which
officers reported
How Cops Are Gearing Up After Mass Killings And Police Shootings
Police are ready in the wake of attacks in France and the United States, and police
shootings in Texas and Louisiana.
Lambert Letter
(4) Amicus Curiae Filed by Stan J. Caterbone 2007 to 2016 - Kathleen Kane - The National
Security Agency NSA - Lisa Michelle Lambert - Mehgan Liappatt - Published May 18, 2016
Connections | LinkedIn
Google Alert - kathleen kane - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
Results of probe into inappropriate...
Results of probe into inappropriate emails to be released - The Washington Post
'Lancaster County': A convicted killer's memoir - but much is missing
Chuck
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban Ardo,
BOOKMARKS theand
Santiago 7th HISTORY
Kathleen Kane
Defense Pagespokesman,272 ran out of 'good
128 of 415
166 288
301
312
321
332
377 answers'
Sunday
Friday
Friday | PennLive.com
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
FridayJanuary
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 939
Page
of 2413
940 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Malcolm Gladwell to Lancaster business community: Think soccer, not basketball | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Stan J. Caterbone (@SCaterbone) | Twitter
Stan J. Caterbone United Nations Human Rights Council of Geneva Switzerland Complaint and
Exhibit re U.S. Sponsored Mind Control, October 4, 2009.pdf
PA Attorney General Mike Fisher Applauds Third Circuit Court Ruling in Lambert Case
16-1001 Third Circuit Habeus DISMISSAL Re Exhaust State Courts Dated May 24, 2016 by
Panel With Fisher
Stan J. Caterbone Mental Health Arguments With Newslanc Editiorial Re Kathleen Kane and
Mental Health Issues December 18, 2015
Confirmation 15-03984 United States District Court Eastern District of Pennsylvania - Letter to
Lisa Michelle Lambert in Framingham Prison, May 28, 2016
Chester Springs man co-authors murder novel
After writing four sports-related books, local author and lawyer, Dave Brown, took a walk
on the dark side.
In a killers words: Lisa Michelle Lambert, nearly 25 years since Laurie Shows murder, claims
innocence in new book | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Lisa Michelle Lambert, serving a life sentence for the 1991 murder of romantic rival Laurie
Show, has painted herself as a victim of ruthless friends, sinister authorities and
unavoidable circumstances
'He got off light': Students ponder verdict after Millersville University's first murder, trial |
Insider | lancasteronline.com
Many students at Millersville University already stressed over final examinations this
week and, for some, graduation this weekend are also remembering Karlie Hall in the
wake of her
Remembering Karlie Hall: Student's death at boyfriend's hands spurs family to tackle domestic
violence issues | Insider | lancasteronline.com
Karlie Halls death at the hands of her boyfriend has left her family mother Jeanette and
sisters Katelyn and Kristen grasping for ways to regain focus in their
LNP
The Classy Crab opens in Lancaster, featuring blue crabs from Louisiana | Local Business |
lancasteronline.com
The small, takeout shop at 3 Ruby St. is in a former laundromat at Ruby Street and
Columbia Avenue. In addition to different sizes of crabs, the shop sells shrimp
PNC Bank to close branches at 4 Lancaster County retirement communities | Local Business |
lancasteronline.com
PNC Bank is closing branches on the campuses of four Lancaster County retirement
communities.
County leaders lock out sheriff amid sexual harassment allegations | Insider | lancasteronline.com
Sheriff Mark Reese is on leave amid sexual harassment allegations
Chief John Fiorill retires from Southern Regional department amid budget woes | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
The chief of Southern Regional police announced his retirement after more than a decade of
leading the department and 42 years working in law enforcement in Lancaster County.
New owner for Mosby's Pub in Mount Joy | Local Business | lancasteronline.com
Earlier this month, John Katras bought Mosbys Pub at 215 E. Main St. for an undisclosed
price from George Vekios, who owned it for nine years.
NY teen who swam in stream that flows through Lancaster County dies from brain-eating
amoeba | Insider | lancasteronline.com
Relatives of Ohio girl think organism entered her nose while swimming near Conowingo,
Md.
Man stabbed to death in Lancaster, person of interest interviewed and released | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
One person has reportedly been stabbed in Lancaster city.
Lancaster city Planners approve of proposal for $30 million Marriott expansion | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
The Lancaster city Planning Commission approves of the city Redevelopment Authoritys
redevelopment proposal for the $30 million, 110-room Marriott hotel expansion.
Police: Two men shot outside McCaskey-York football game in York city | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Two men were shot in a parking lot outside a football game Friday night in York between
J.P. McCaskey and William Penn.
Verdict dispute with county DA goes to state Supreme Court | Local News | lancasteronline.com
A Commonwealth Court judge has ruled that a dispute between Elizabethtown District
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 168
130 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 941
Page
of 2413
942 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Judge Jayne Duncan and Lancaster County District Attorney Craig Stedman should be
heard by the state Supreme Court.
School District of Lancaster officials set meetings to address Friday night shooting | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
School District of Lancaster officials will hold meetings Monday and Tuesday regarding a
shooting at a McCaskey football game in York Friday night.
Car hits 2 houses on Hershey Avenue in Lancaster city | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Driver has to be extricated in early Sunday accident. Is not seriously injured.
TEDx Lancaster inspires audience to be connected | Local News | lancasteronline.com
"I want to connect with ," read the poster in the lobby of the Ware Center. Nearby,
Sharpie markers scattered on tables invited Saturdays attendees of TEDx Lancaster to
Ponessa adds partial hospitalization for children with mental health needs | Local Business |
lancasteronline.com
T.W. Ponessa & Associates Counseling Services Inc. has added a new treatment
option for children with severe emotional, behavioral, or psychiatric disorders.
wyciwyg://94/https://mail.google.com/_/scs/mail-
static/_/js/k=gmail.main.en.HYfHhmCGcLw.O/m=m_i,t/am=OotHAjD_7_3BuJYBQFb6SIV53_
9886n8sMs9_n8fEIW8Cvy_2f8D-D_Yi7ZQ/rt=h/d=1/rs=AHGWq9AWq-
HwYM6sT2yxJmvwyc3SqB-gog
Atomic opens rental office in Germany, continuing global expansion | Local Business |
lancasteronline.com
Atomic Design, which designs and builds sets for the live-event industry, has opened a
rental office in Frankfurt, Germany.
Motions to dismiss civil rights suit against Lancaster County police officer, prosecutor denied |
Local News | lancasteronline.com
A judge has denied motions by a Lancaster County police officer and a former county
prosecutor to have a lawsuit accusing them of violating a man's civil rights dismissed.
Columbia football game evacuated, student in custody for threat | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Columbia High School's home game against York Suburban was postponed and the
stadium evacuated Friday night based on an unspecified threat made by a student.
Lancaster County considers transition plan to curb mentally ill inmate population | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Lancaster County Prison inmates who are mentally ill and awaiting transfer to a state
hospital could soon be temporarily housed and treated in a group setting here under a plan
Lancaster County judge shows heroin defendants sticky notes with overdose tally | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
With a dramatic gesture, Judge Howard Knisely admits he's trying to scare people from
returning to the streets and using heroin.
Who's in jail? Lancaster County Prison population by gender, race, age, mental health status |
Insider | lancasteronline.com
A new effort is underway to create a public, transparent set of data on the operations of the
Lancaster County Prison.
Police looking for 28-year-old man following explosions in New York City, New Jersey; Amtrak
issues service alert | Local News | lancasteronline.com
NEW YORK (AP) 7:45 a.m.
With opening of Novara, concierge medicine gains ground in Lancaster County | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Novara looks more like a spa than a doctors office, and thats on purpose.
Study: For every hour doctors see patients, they spend two on records & desk work | Local News
| lancasteronline.com
Accompanying editorial said the study shows that electronic health records have not yet
fulfilled their promise of improving the efficiency and quality of health care.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 169
131 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 942
Page
of 2413
943 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
What does Gov. Wolf's call for a joint session on opioid epidemic entail? | Politics |
lancasteronline.com
As Pennsylvania hurdles toward the end of another especially deadly year in the opioid
crisis, the governor and state lawmakers are racing against time to contain the epidemic.
Court hearing next stop for Lancaster man in RRTA bus riding dispute | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Bill Horn, the Lancaster man charged with theft of service for riding a Red Rose Transit
Authority bus beyond his zone pass, is receiving community support for his plight.
Refugee lawsuit: Federal judge calls School District of Lancaster back to court | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Attorneys for six refugee students who sued the district this summer say the district is not
fully complying with the court's order regarding where the district places older refugee
students
Lancaster Realtor's brother advances on NBC's 'The Voice' | Entertainment | lancasteronline.com
Lancaster Realtor Handy Cuevas' brother, Christian, chose to join Team Alicia Keys on
Monday night's "The Voice" competition on NBC.
Lancaster city logs its 9,000 public trees in searchable database | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Ever see an unfamiliar tree while walking in Lancaster city and want to know what kind it
is?
Fuss over bus ride gains public support; matter will end up in court | Insider | lancasteronline.com
Bill Horn, the Lancaster man charged with theft of service for riding a Red Rose Transit
Authority bus beyond his zone pass, is receiving community support for his plight.
Benefit to celebrate life of US Marine from Millersville who died in 2015 accidental drowning |
Local News | lancasteronline.com
Jim Livermore and Natascha Gyorke should have been celebrating four months of marriage
Wednesday.
Lower energy costs should again give homeowners a break on heating bills this winter | Local
Business | lancasteronline.com
With the warm days of summer well behind us, residents may soon start thinking about
their winter heating costs.
Among young voters, Lancaster County is a competitive battleground | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
It's no secret that younger voters are more likely to be liberal and older voters skew
conservative.
Kathleen Kane
Pennsylvania's judicial ethics court is giving Attorney General Kathleen Kane two weeks to
produce material for a pending disciplinary case against Supreme Court Justice Michael Eakin
Kane aide sues for wrongful termination
HARRISBURG - A former aide to Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane has sued
her for wrongful termination, contending he was dismissed in retaliation for recommending
the firing of her controversial chief of staff, who had been accused of sexually harassing
female colleagues. - Angela Couloumbis, Philadelphia Inquirer
Senate facing a decision on attorney generals removal - News - Standard Speaker
Kane aide files wrongful termination suit against her
HARRISBURG - A former aide to Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen G. Kane has
sued her over wrongful termination, contending he was dismissed in retaliation for
recommending the firing of her controversial chief of staff, who had been accused of
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 170
132 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 943
Page
of 2413
944 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
sexually harassing female colleagues. - Angela Couloumbis, Philadelphia Inquirer
Kathleen Kane v. The "Good Old Boys" by Stan J. Caterbone and The Advanced Media Group |
Stan Caterbone | LinkedIn
December 15, 2015 "Kane, the first woman and Democrat elected to the position of
Pennsylvania's top prosecutor, has dismissed the case as a backlash
Frank Fina, and possibly Kathleen Kane, to testify in Philadelphia bribery case | PennLive.com
Former state prosecutor Frank Fina will testify Wednesday in a legislative bribery case that
ensnared several top Philadelphia lawmakers. He may be joined by Attorney General
Kathleen Kane
Kane, aides sued by HR analyst with whistleblower claims - The Morning Call
Kane, aides sued by HR analyst with whistleblower claims
Northeast Pa. prosecutor joins pack vying for Kane's job NewsWorks
A Northeast Pennsylvania prosecutor said he'll seek the Democratic nomination for state
Attorney General Kathleen Kane's job. Northampton County District Attorney John
Morganelli said Tuesday...
Allentown, Lehigh Valley news from The Morning Call and mcall.com - The Morning Call
Allentown news, Bethlehem news, Easton news, Poconos news, Lehighton news,
Quakertown news, Lehigh Valley news
PA Senate brandishes 19th-century pseudo mental health laws against Kane | Newslanc.com
Though they live worlds apart, on separate continents, a 54-year-old Armenian woman
named Julietta Amarikian has something in common with Pennsylvania Attorney
Kane's sister received emails mocking Asians, blacks and domestic violence | TribLIVE
PA Senate brandishes 19th-century pseudo mental health laws against Kane | Newslanc.com
Though they live worlds apart, on separate continents, a 54-year-old Armenian woman
named Julietta Amarikian has something in common with Pennsylvania Attorney
The Kathleen Kane chronicles: The mess grows (again) | TribLIVE
Stan J. Caterbone Mental Health Arguments With Newslanc Editiorial Re Kathleen Kane and
Mental Health Issues December 18, 2015
Stan J. Caterbone Mental Health Arguments With Newslanc Editiorial Re Kathleen Kane
and Mental Health Issues December 18, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file
(.txt) or read online for free. Stan J. Caterbone Mental Health Arguments With Newslanc
Editiorial Re Kathleen Kane and Mental Health Issues December 18, 2015
Memo from Kane's top deputy shows dissent within office: report | PennLive.com
The top deputy for embattled Attorney General Kathleen Kane doesn't seem to agree with
his boss's view in the ongoing the controversial email scandal.
AG Kathleen Kane's appointment of special prosecutor raises more questions | PennLive.com
On the same day that a Philadelphia district attorney spoke out on Kathleen Kane's
involvement in the exchange of vulgar emails, the attorney general signed a document
appointing Douglas Gansler as special prosecutor.
The Democrats' Problem in Pennsylvania Is Falling Star Kathleen Kane - Bloomberg Politics
Indicted in August for perjury, the state's attorney general could prove to be a liability for a
Clinton presidential run.
Kane's 'Porngate' prosecutor has baggage of his own: Dennis Roddy | PennLive.com
Attorney General Kathleen Kane on Tuesday appointed a special prosecutor who was
himself sanctioned by the courts, is not licensed to practice law in Pennsylvania, and has
been photographed in the middle of a teen drinking party.
AG Kathleen Kane now faces investigation by State Ethics Commission | PennLive.com
Attorney General Kathleen Kane now faces an investigation by the State Ethics
Commission, in addition to criminal charges, a Senate removal process and various civil
lawsuits.
Attorney General Kathleen Kane's battle with the 'old boys' network' - The Morning Call
Kathleen Kane's year can be summed up with three words: perjury, porn, patronage.
Report: AG Kane now being investigated by state ethics commission | Local News - WGAL
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 171
133 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 944
Page
of 2413
945 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Home
News 8 has learned that state Attorney General Kathleen Kane is being investigated by the
Pennsylvania Ethics Commission.
Pornographic email scandal roils Pennsylvania politics | Newslanc.com
WASHINGTON POST: ...Over the past 15 months, beleaguered Pennsylvania Attorney
General Kathleen Kane has released a steady stream of messages retrieved from a
AG's office makes case for Kathleen Kane's continued leadership | PennLive.com
Attorney General Kathleen Kane's office has responded to a Supreme Court petition
challenging her legal status.
Lancaster blunders and missed opportunities in 2015 | Newslanc.com
By Robert Field Looking back on 2015, we are again reminded of how difficult, most
times impossible, it has been to avoid tragedies and spur
Suspended license puts Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane's re-election bid in
jeopardy | Southeastern PA News - Home
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane acknowledges she may not run for re-
election unless her law license suspension is lifted.
'Porngate' scandal in Pennsylvania: The basics and the background | PennLive.com
The porngate email exchanges include offensive material about domestic violence,
homosexuals and various racial and ethnic stereotypes.
Pa. politics: what lies ahead?
A new political year brings chances for change or the sad possibility of sameness. Here are
key issues and events that will shape state news in 2016. - John Baer, Philadelphia Daily
News
Lancaster County News and Commentary
NewsLanc.com - News from Lancaster County
Kane to skip removal hearing - News - The Times-Tribune
Kane "unlikely" to show for removal hearing | State House Sound Bites | witf.org
Photo by Mary Wilson / WITF State Attorney General Kathleen Kane might be a no-show
at the special hearing scheduled next Tuesday by the Senate committee considering her
ouster. Spokesman Chuck Ardo said Wednesday that the embattled official is still
considering how she will respond to the panel, but it is
Kane to skip removal hearing - News - The Times-Tribune
Pennsylvania AG Kane confidant could face six-month jail sentence | TribLIVE
KEISLING: Senate unwittingly exposes darkest chapter in state legislative history in Kane
removal bid | Newslanc.com
Senate invokes constitutional provision against AG Kathleen Kane tied to era of eugenics,
forced sterilizations, and the Holocaust by Bill
KEISLING: PA AG Kathleen Kane: Gagged, bound, and tied to the sawmill | Newslanc.com
Kathleen Kane posed a tangible threat to the well-entrenched cadre of corrupted officials
from both parties who've been running the state, and who all rely on a
In defense of two prosecutors
I came to appreciate prosecutors Frank Fina and Pat Blessington for their honesty,
intelligence, and diligence as they evenhandedly and without fear or favor uprooted both
Democratic and Republican corruption. - By George Parry, Philadelphia Inquirer
Kane planning to seek another term, aide says | State | cumberlink.com
HARRISBURG Embattled attorney general Kathleen Kane intends to run for a second
term despite facing criminal charges and lacking a law license, but she has not made a final
Kane spokesman: She's running again
She is facing a criminal trial, the Senate might yank her out of office, her poll numbers are
sinking, rivals in her own party are lining up for her job, and the husband who bankrolled
her last campaign is no longer in the picture. - Craig R. McCoy andAngela Couloumbis,
Philadelphia Inquirer
What's the next explosion in the Kane email scandal? | TribLIVE
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 172
134 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 945
Page
of 2413
946 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Kathleen Kane faces ouster vote by Senate panel on Tuesday - The Morning Call
The Special Committee on Senate Address will meet Tuesday to decide whether Kathleen
Kane should be removed from office.
AG Kane plans to skip hearing at which her job is at stake | News | witf.org
Photo by AP Photo/Matt Slocum Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane looks on
while arriving at Benjamin Franklin Parkway ahead of the Papal Mass Sunday, Sept. 27,
2015, in Philadelphia. (Harrisburg) -- State Attorney General Kathleen Kane faces a fourth
and final Senate hearing in a process that could lead to her removal from office on grounds
that she can't perform her duties while her law license remains suspended. Her spokesman
said Friday she doesn't plan to be present when the Special Committee on Senate Address
convenes tomorrow to hear from her. The hearing to get her side is required under an
obscure constitutional provision that could soon be used against her. Her spokesman says
she'll meet a noon deadline today to submit a written statement of some sort. The first-term
Democrat has said the Senate can't remove her on its own. The state Supreme Court
suspended Kane's license as...
Attorney General Kathleen Kane says she'll run for re-election - Philadelphia Business Journal
The Attorney Generals political consultant Ken Smukler believes Kane will run for re-
election this year.
Armstrong County judge rules AG office has authority to continue trying cases | Pittsburgh Post-
Gazette
Ruling upends challenges to the offices authority in wake of Kathleen Kanes suspension.
Kathleen Kane cites 1891 case in response to planned removal hearing | PennLive.com
Kathleen Kane has confirmed what most assumed: That the attorney general would forego
a Senate hearing Tuesday that would be the next step toward her removal from office.
AG Kathleen Kane's future is in the hands of 19th-century lawmakers | PennLive.com
Criminal charges aside, the most urgent threat to Attorney General Kathleen Kane is an
arcane removal provision last used in another headline-grabbing scandal 125 years ago.
Gov. Ed Rendell plans to testify in support of AG Kathleen Kane at hearing | PennLive.com
Gov. Ed Rendell plans to testify in support of Attorney General Kathleen Kane at a Senate
hearing that could lead to her ultimate removal.
Kathleen Kane wants law license back, protests Supreme Court decision - Philadelphia Business
Journal
Kane has no plans to testify at a Senate hearing on her removal.
Pennsylvania committee delays vote on attorney generals removal - Yahoo News
From Yahoo News: A Pennsylvania Senate committee delayed a vote on Tuesday on
whether to recommend removing embattled Attorney General Kathleen Kane from her post
because of a suspended law license. The move to put off the vote followed testimony from
former Pennsylvania Governor Edward Rendell and the attorney general's chief of staff,
Jonathan Decker, who said Kane could continue to perform her job adequately without a
law license. The only time it would be relevant for the attorney general not to be able to go
to court would be if everyone else was wiped out, Rendell said.
Rendell urges Senate not to use direct removal power on Kane - News - Citizens' Voice
Attorney General Kathleen Kanes Ability to Perform Duties, Hearing
Kathleen Kane's law license suspension appeal moving through court - The Morning Call
Kathleen Kane's law license suspension appeal moving through court
Pennsylvania's Office of Attorney General blasted for agent shortfall | TribLIVE
Pa. Senate Presses OAG on Special Prosecutor's Role | The Legal Intelligencer
Doug Gansler, the special prosecutor hired by Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen
Kane to review offensive emails exchanged by government employees, has b...
Drinking the Kane Kool-Aid | TribLIVE
Ron Southwick: Why Kathleen Kane shouldn't run again | Reading Eagle - NEWS
The state Attorney General may launch an improbable re-election bid, even as she fights to
stay out of prison.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 173
135 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 946
Page
of 2413
947 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
On Kane, Senate in wait-and-see mode | State House Sound Bites | witf.org
Photo by Mary Wilson / WITF The state Senate is in a bit of a pickle as it advances its
analysis of whether or not to boot Attorney General Kathleen Kane from office due to the
suspension of her law license last year pending her trial on perjury and other criminal
charges. Last week, the attorney general asked the state Supreme Court to reconsider its
September ruling shelving her legal credential. She argued that sitting Justice Michael
Eakin should not have participated in the discussion, as he has since been suspended from
the bench due to inappropriate e-mails he exchanged that she had released. Kane's petition
to the Supreme Court was filed the evening before a hearing called by the Senate panel
considering her ouster. The next day, at the hearing intended to give Kane a chance to
defend herself, former Governor Ed Rendell testified instead. Rendell noted the...
PA Senate Weighs Whether Or Not To Remove AG Kane From Office | WSKG
The Pennsylvania state Senate is in a bind as it advances its analysis of whether or not to
remove Attorney General Kathleen Kane from office due to the
Board Argues Attorney General Kane's Law License Should Remain Suspended | NBC 10
Philadelphia
The state office that investigates misconduct by lawyers argued Wednesday that
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane waited too long to object to Justice Michael
Eakin's participation with four other...
A top state prosecutor is raising questions about Attorney General Kathleen Kane's hiring of a
team of outside lawyers to investigate a government email scandal
A top state prosecutor is raising questions about Attorney General Kathleen Kane's hiring
of a team of outside lawyers to investigate a government email scandal. Updated 1/21/16
7:44 PM.
Special Committee on Senate Address | Home
Top News | Examiner.com
Read the latest Top News news and view Top News pictures from our team of local
insiders.
KEISLING: Lancaster County newspaper publisher disbarred before becoming state attorney
general | Newslanc.com
AG William Hensel caught Philly Inquirer bribing city treasurer by Bill Keisling Note to
readers: The Pennsylvania Senate plans to invoke a
Misconduct board argues AG Kanes law license should remain suspended | Newslanc.com
WALKILEAKS / AP: The office that investigates misconduct by lawyers is arguing that
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane waited too long to complain
LETTER: Shady Lancaster City | Newslanc.com
This rambling text is copied from the RACL November 17 minutes. Risks: moral hazard
and the American dream. Hyperbole aside, I'm concerned that we
Kane - Crisis of credibility
A report that two more Pennsylvania Supreme Court justices were no strangers to the state's
sprawling electronic profanity exchange shows why the high court has been widely urged
to order an independent investigation of the scandal - and why it hasn't done so.
Senate panel to release Kane report Wednesday - News - The Times-Tribune
Representative Martina A. White - PA House of Representatives
Pornocopia insanity in Harrisburg | TribLIVE
Woes across government branches tarnish Pa.'s image, experts say
House panel take steps to launch impeachment proceedings against AG Kane
HARRISBURG - A key House committee is taking the first steps toward launching
impeachment proceedings against Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen G. Kane, even
as the Senate is poised to decide whether to remove her from office. - Angela Couloumbis,
Philadelphia Inquirer
Panel votes to authorize probe toward possible impeachment of Kane | Reading Eagle - NEWS
If the full House follows suit, a subcommittee investigating the embattled attorney general
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 174
136 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 947
Page
of 2413
948 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
would have subpoena power.
Committee: Senate Should Delay Vote on Kane Removal - Story
A special committee's ruling leaves the embattled AG in doubt
Divided Pa. Senate panel supports Kane removal vote
Divided Pa. Senate panel supports Kane removal vote
RAW VIDEO: Sen. John Gordner on decision not to take impeachment vote on Kane - The
Morning Call
Sen. John Gordner, R-Columbia, says once the state Supreme Court makes a decision on
Kathleen Kane's law license appeal, he would be the first to push for a vote on whether she
should be impeached.
On Kane's removal, Pa. Senate panel equivocates - Philadelphia Business Journal
One local Democrat is not happy with the Senate's latest decision.
Senate panel: Delay vote on Kane removal - News - Citizens' Voice
Political Winners & Losers: Polls, polls and more polls. But what do they tell us? | PennLive.com
Kane up, Wolf down and no one knows how to feel about the U.S. Senate race. Yep, it's
campaign season in Pennsylvania.
Kane ouster not being done in vacuum - News - The Times-Tribune
Court ruling on Sandusky cover-up case presents Kane with complex choices
A long-awaited Superior Court ruling that landed last month did more than just dismiss the
most serious charges against three former Penn State administrators accused of covering up
child sex attacks by Jerry Sandusky. - Susan Snyder and Craig R. McCoy, Philadelphia
Inquirer
Kathleen Kane: The Rise and Fall | Philadelphia Magazine
Attorney General Kathleen Kane was the most promising political figure in Pennsylvania,
until she became obsessed with an enemy she just couldnt destroy.
PA Atty General Website
Pa. Activist Wants Kane's Campaign Spending Investigated - Law360
A Pennsylvania activist again asked the state to take action regarding embattled Attorney
General Kathleen Kane, asking the Office of General Counsel on Wednesday to investigate
her alleged use of campaign funds to pay legal fees related to her indictment and law
license suspension.
Pa. House Leader plans vote to launch Kane impeachment process next week | PennLive.com
Majority Leader David Reed, R-Indiana County, says the floor vote to launch an
investigation will come Monday or Tuesday.
Pa. House set to vote Monday on starting Kane impeachment investigation | TribLIVE Mobile
AG Kathleen Kane: Dismiss federal lawsuit by 'insubordinate' agents | PennLive.com
Whether Kane, who is embattled on several legal fronts, is entitled to immunity from the
suit by Agents Michael Carlson and Michael Cranga will be a call for U.S. Middle District
Chief Judge Christopher C. Conner.
Pennsylvania AG Kathleen Kane has August trial date for alleged perjury charge - King Of
Prussia Courier - Main Line Media News
Pennsylvania AG Kathleen Kane has August trial date for alleged perjury charge -
NORRISTOWN >> Embattled Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kanes trial on
perjury-related charges will get under way with jury selection on Aug. 8, a judge ruled on
Friday.
Pa. Supreme Court Rejects Kane Bid To Restore Law License; Senate Expected To Vote On
Removal CBS Philly
The state Supreme Court has rejected Attorney General Kathleen Kanes bid to lift the
suspension of her law license.
Senate to vote Wednesday on Pennsylvania AG Kane ouster | TribLIVE
HARRISBURGThe Senate plans to vote Wednesday on removing embattled Attorney
General Kathleen Kane from office, the top GOP leader said. Kane, A Democrat elected
statewide in ...
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 175
137 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 948
Page
of 2413
949 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Pennsylvania Senate plans vote this week on AG Kane removal | 6abc.com
The top-ranking Republican in the state Senate said Monday the chamber will vote this
week on whether to remove from office Attorney General Kathleen Kane, a first-term
Democrat who has spent the past two years working to expose an explicit and objectiona
More evidence of Ole boys club desperation to block public hearings | Newslanc.com
February 7, 2016 Featured, News and Commentary Comments Edit By Robert Field As
Porngate hits state high court, Sprague brought in as mediator
Senate to vote Wednesday on whether to oust Pennsylvania AG Kane | TribLIVE
HARRISBURG The Senate plans to vote Wednesday on removing embattled Attorney
General Kathleen Kane from office, the top GOP leader said. Kane, a Democrat ...
AG Kathleen Kane's Senate removal vote may kick off a whole new controversy | PennLive.com
A Senate vote to remove Kathleen Kane from office planned for Wednesday may seem like
an end, but it's probably just the beginning.
Read the Senate's Kathleen Kane removal resolution | PennLive.com
The resolution to remove Attorney General Kathleen Kane that will be considered by the
Pennsylvania Senate on Wednesday.
Senate Poised to Vote on Whether to Remove Attorney General Kane | NBC 10 Philadelphia
Pennsylvania senators planned a Wednesday vote on whether to remove Attorney General
Kathleen Kane on grounds that her suspended law license has rendered it impossible for her
to do the job.
Kathleen Kane impeachment to be considered by state House - The Morning Call
Kathleen Kane impeachment to be considered by Pennsylvania House
PA Senate votes against removing Kathleen Kane as Attorney General | WPMT FOX43
Some Kane staffers disappointed she survived Senate's attempt to oust her | PennLive.com
Press secretary Chuck Ardo says those employees want the spotlight on their agency to end.
Kathleen Kane talks failed ouster in Attorney General's first interview in months - Philadelphia
Business Journal
Kane talked about her supporters and a possible re-election run.
Kathleen Kane manages to keep her job but can't avoid impeachment proceedings
Pennsylvania's embattled attorney general won't run again - Yahoo News
From Yahoo News: SCRANTON, Pa. (AP) The state's embattled attorney general said
Tuesday she will not seek a second term, facing pressure from within her own party after
being hobbled for months by perjury charges and the suspension of her law license.
Capitolwire: Senate vote to remove Kane fails; House starts investigation. | Newslanc.com
By Kevin Zwick & Chris Comisac Capitolwire HARRISBURG (Feb. 10) Attorney
General Kathleen Kane survived a removal attempt Wednesday after the state
Pa. Attorney General Kathleen Kane will not seek re-election
SCRANTON, Pa. >> Pennsylvanias embattled attorney general said Tuesday she will not
seek a second term, facing pressure from within her own party after being hobbled for
months by criminal perjury charges and the suspension of her law li
Media company lawyer objects to handing over original documents in Kane case - Bucks County
Courier Times: Bucks County | Local news | Breaking News
A lawyer for Philadelphia Media Network, which owns the Philadelphia Daily News and
The Philadelphia Inquirer, is battling efforts by the Montgomery County District Attorneys
Office to obtain the original documents of secret grand jury information that state Attorney
General Kathleen Kane allegedly leaked to a news reporter.
D.A., newspaper, at odds over documents in Kane probe
NORRISTOWN >> Lawyers for a Philadelphia newspaper have asked a judge to quash the
request of Montgomery County prosecutors who are seeking original documents leaked to
the newspaper allegedly at the direction of Pennsylvania Attorney General Ka
Democratic leader says Senate moving too fast to remove Kane
News, weather, traffic and sports for Harrisburg, Pa. Also York, Lancaster and Lebanon |
WHTM-TV, ABC
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 176
138 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 949
Page
of 2413
950 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Kane says she won't seek reelection
SCRANTON - Facing criminal charges, a suspended law license, and potential
impeachment, Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen G. Kane on Tuesday said she
would not run for reelection. - Craig R. McCoy and Angela Couloumbis, Philadelphia
Inquirer
Letter: Give Kane credit, not criticism
While praising a panel of the Court of Judicial Discipline for rejecting a proposed deal and
insisting on a public airing of the charges against Supreme Court Justice J. Michael Eakin,
the Inquirer did not lose sight of its overriding principle in all things related to this matter:
to vilify Attorney General Kathleen Kane ("Justice ought to be judged," Friday).
Kane wants her charges tossed, county judges taken off case
News, weather, traffic and sports for Harrisburg, Pa. Also York, Lancaster and Lebanon |
WHTM-TV, ABC
Embattled Pennsylvania Attorney General Says That She Will Not Seek Re-election - The New
York Times
Attorney General Kathleen G. Kane of Pennsylvania said she would continue battling what
she has called a corrupt old-boys network that has plotted to remove her from office.
Kane wants her charges tossed, judges taken off case | Reading Eagle - NEWS
State attorney general's filing comes five months before her scheduled trial.
Kane wants her charges tossed, county judges taken off case | Local News - WTAE Home
A new court filing by Attorney General Kathleen Kane seeks to have the criminal charges
against her thrown out and all the judges in Montgomery County removed from her case.
Kane fights back against leak charges | TribLIVE
HARRISBURG Attorney General Kathleen Kane is fighting back against criminal
charges against her, asking Friday for the case to be thrown out for selective ...
Hotline for Altoona-Johnstown diocese abuse gets 150 calls in first week
News, weather, traffic and sports for Harrisburg, Pa. Also York, Lancaster and Lebanon |
WHTM-TV, ABC
Kane: Ive Done Nothing Wrong (VIDEO) | PoliticsPA
add-later
PoliticsPA: Kane says, 'I've done nothing wrong' - Philadelphia Business Journal
Kane once again asserted that she wont resign.
Politically Uncorrected: The Fall of Kathleen Kane | PoliticsPA
add-later
Porngate: Inside the XXX Emails that Exposed Pennsylvania's Polluted Politics
They should've made Kathleen Kane's career. Instead, they destroyed it.
Passing budget more important than impeaching Kathleen Kane - The Morning Call
If Pennsylvania's House devoted as much time to the budget as it does to Attorney General
Kathleen Kane, perhaps we would have a budget.
Pa. legislators, advocates rally for statute of limitations reform | Centre Daily Times
In the wake of a grand jury report on abuse in the Altoona-Johnstown Diocese released
earlier this month, state representatives, adult victims of child sexual abuse and advocates
gathered Monday at the Capitol to push for statute of limitations reform.
2nd Pennsylvania Justice Resigns Over Raunchy Email Scandal - ABC News
2nd Pennsylvania Justice Resigns Over Raunchy Email Scandal
Kathleen Kane seeks hearing on FBI recording leak about leaks - The Morning Call
Kathleen Kane seeks court hearing on FBI recording leak about leaks
Kathleen Kane wins another court fight to keep porn emails from public - The Morning Call
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane wins another court fight to keep porn emails
from public
Bookmarks
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 177
139 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 950
Page
of 2413
951 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Kathleen Kane hearing scheduled amid accusations of prosecution leaks | PennLive.com
The judge presiding over Kathleen Kane's criminal case declined to rule on pretrial motions
Tuesday amid accusations of leaks from the Montgomery County Prosecutor's Office.
Tempers Flare In Kathleen Kane Pre-trial CBS Philly
The case against Kane revolves around allegations that she leaked grand jury information to
the Philadelphia Daily News that, in turn, was retaliation for leaks about her to the
Philadelphia Inquirer.
Media coalition asks judge to deny Kane's secret motion request - The Morning Call
Media coalition asks judge to deny Kathleen Kane's secret motion request
Williams calls for new ethics legislation for state judges - The Philadelphia Tribune: News
248
Pa. Attorney General Kathleen Kane's hire may be way she can keep exerting power | Pittsburgh
Post-Gazette
Kathleen Kane has hired former Montgomery County District Attorney Bruce Castor to fill
a newly created executive position in her office.
Suit: Kane aide quickly went from ally to outcast
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen G. Kane invited her aide to her home on a Friday
night and offered him a beer from the wet bar. - Craig R. McCoy and Angela Couloumbis,
Philadelphia Inquirer
Federal Prosecutors to File Racketeering Lawsuit Against Pennsylvania Diocese Officials in
connection to Child Sexual Abuse Cover Up : Lawfirm | Lawyer : Lawyer Herald
US attorney David Hickton said, he is consideirng to file racketeering lawsuit against
Altoona-Johnstown diocese in Pennsylvania. It is in connection to former bishops' over ups
of child sexual abuses in the church for more than 40 years by over 50 clergys.
Too many pictures of Kathleen Kane - The Morning Call
Subscribers to your newspaper are much too familiar with Attorney General Kathleen
Kane's looks.
My Dashboard - PENN File
Prosecutors oppose Pennsylvania AG Kanes appeal to state court - King Of Prussia Courier -
Main Line Media News
Prosecutors oppose Pennsylvania AG Kanes appeal to state court - NORRISTOWN >>
Montgomery County prosecutors oppose embattled Pennsylvania Attorney General
Kathleen Kane taking an appeal of a county judges pretrial rulings to a state court.
Kathleen Kane motion to quash
Kathleen Kane motion to quash - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free.
Attorney General Kathleen Kane filed a new motion Wednesday to dismiss the criminal
charges against her.
Montgomery County prosecutors call AG Kanes claim of vindictive prosecution frivolous
NORRISTOWN >> Montgomery County prosecutors maintain embattled Pennsylvania
Attorney General Kathleen G. Kanes claim that she is the victim of selective and
vindictive prosecution is frivolous and not a basis on which to
Prosecutors assail AG Kane's bid to drop charges
The Montgomery County District Attorney's Office on Monday assailed Attorney General
Kathleen Kane's latest bid to dismiss the criminal case against her, calling frivolous and
irrelevant her claim that she is the victim of a selective and vindictive prosecution. - Laura
McCrystal, Philadelphia Inquirer
Prosecutors oppose A.G. Kanes appeal to state court
NORRISTOWN >> Montgomery County prosecutors oppose embattled Pennsylvania
Attorney General Kathleen Kane taking an appeal of a county judges pretrial rulings to a
state court.
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane suspects that prosecutors leaked FBI recordings in
her criminal case to a newspaper
LETTER: LNP remains a lily-white newspaper | Newslanc.com
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 178
140 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 951
Page
of 2413
952 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Re: LNP takes cheap shot at Hillary Clinton by publishing Lewistown Sentinel bogus
editorial NEWSLANC'S editor responded to a comment: EDITOR: We believe
Kathleen Kane to 6abc: Everybody makes mistakes | 6abc.com
Action News anchor Brian Taff sat down with Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen
Kane on Tuesday.
Pennsylvania taxpayers foot hefty legal bill for Kathleen Kane | TribLIVE
HARRISBURG Attorney General Kathleen Kane has charged taxpayers more than
$250,000 to have an outside law firm represent her in three lawsuits filed by ...
PA Attorney General Mike Fisher Applauds Third Circuit Court Ruling in Lambert Case
re><br /> HARRISBURG, Pa., Dec. 29 /PRNewswire/ -- PA Attorney General Mike Fisher
Applauds Third Circuit Court Ruling in Lambert Case. <br />.
Results of probe into inappropriate emails to be released - The Washington Post
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane has announced that preliminary results of an
investigation into inappropriate emails found on state servers will be released Tuesday.
Rampant paranoia in AG Kathleen Kane's office: 'You never knew if they'd come for you' |
PennLive.com
Current and former staffers share their experiences working for Kathleen Kane as she
engaged in a feud with former prosecutors and now faces criminal charges.
Inside the government's secret NSA program to target terrorists | Fox News
EXCLUSIVE: Relentless attacks on American military personnel at the height of the Iraq
war made the U.S. intelligence community confront a dire problem: They needed real-time
intelligence to take Al Qaeda off the battlefield and dismantle its bomb-making factories.
Chuck Ardo, the 7th Kathleen Kane spokesman, ran out of 'good answers' | PennLive.com
"I could no longer in good conscience do the job she had hired me to do," Ardo said,
explaining his decision.
Ardo paints picture of distrust in Attorney General's office | News | witf.org
Photo by AP Photo/ Joseph Kaczmarek (Harrisburg) -- Kathleen Kane lost her seventh
spokesperson in three-and-a-half years after Chuck Ardo's resignation last week. The well-
respected Ardo tells WITF's Smart Talk he simply had finally had enough. He served as
spokesman for former Governor Ed Rendell and former Harrisburg Mayor Linda
Thompson, both of which could be called challenging jobs. Ardo also spent a year in that
same capacity with state Attorney General Kathleen Kane before he stepped down. He says
the tipping point came after a simple and routine office tour.
Kathleen Kane talks past, present, future in interview with Rick Williams | 6abc.com
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane sat down for an interview at our studio with
Rick Williams.
PoliticsPA: AG Kane's office had 'culture of paranoia,' say former staff - Philadelphia Business
Journal
There was almost this sense that every day, theyd shoot another hostage, a former staffer
told McKelvey.
Montgomery DA: Kane's claim of 'selective and vindictive' prosecution does not merit hearing -
Bucks County Courier Times: Bucks County | Local news | Breaking News
Montgomery County prosecutors advised a county judge that she should not waste her time
even holding a hearing on state Attorney General Kathleen Kanes claim that she is a
victim of selective and vindictive prosecution.
In the future, Air Force pilots could control planes with their minds - Business Insider
The military appear interested in the potential for jet fighters to control their planes with
direct thought control, rather than using their arms."
Embattled Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane Accused of Discrimination by Twin
Ellen Granahan
When you've been accused of illegally firing and demoting state employees and possibly
leaking secret grand jury material, it's nice to know you can still count on family to have
your back. Oh,... Politics News Summaries. | Newser
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 179
141 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 952
Page
of 2413
953 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Kathleen Kane's administration hit with discrimination complaint from her twin sister - The
Morning Call
Attorney General Kathleen Kane's twin sister Ellen Granahan files EEOC complaint against
Kane's administration, alleging gender and wage discrimination.
Fed up Lancaster County DA eyes mandatory state prison terms for heroin-related convictions |
Local News | lancasteronline.com
Lancaster County District Attorney Craig Stedman says his office will seek mandatory
prison sentences for anyone convicted of selling heroin in the county.
AG Kane seeks dismissal of agent's lawsuit - News - The Times-Tribune
Frank Fina, prosecutor ensnared in Porngate, leaves Phila. DA's office | Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Fina said he would pursue a second career as a criminal defense lawyer and investigator,
working for corporate clients and others.
Kathleen Kane testifies for change to Pennsylvania's statue of limitations. - YouTube
A man was arrested at a Harrisburg vigil for victims of the Orlando shooting on June 12,
2016.
Kathleen Kane Takes Another Loss | PoliticsPA
add-later
The bizarre tenure of Kathleen Kane continues | Editorials | lancasteronline.com
As if Kathleen Kane didn't have enough to worry about, she's now being sued, in effect, by
her twin sister for discrimination. It is yet another distraction for an office
Judge rejects AG Kathleen Kane's bid to dismiss criminal charges | PennLive.com
Kathleen Kane's bid to have criminal charges against her dropped due to "selective and
vindictive prosecution" has been rejected by a Montgomery County judge.
Pennsylvania Attorney General Exposed 1000s of Pornographic, Racist Government Emails But
Now Faces Her Own Scandal - ABC News
Katheen Kane didn't expect her career to be in jeopardy after outing a scandal.
District Attorney: Police shooting of homeless man was 'clearly justified' | News |
lancasteronline.com
A police officer was justified in fatally shooting a homeless man who lunged at another
officer with a 9-inch knife, the district attorney announced Friday, saying he would not
prosecute
Superior Court Rejects Kane's Criminal Appeal | The Legal Intelligencer
The Pennsylvania Superior Court has quashed an appeal by Attorney General Kathleen
Kane, in which she argued that the charges against her should have been di...
Superior Court rejects Kathleen Kane's attempt to recuse judges from criminal case |
PennLive.com
The Superior Court, in a one-sentence ruling, effectively quashed Attorney General
Kathleen Kane's bid to recuse all 22 judges of the Montgomery County Court of Common
Pleas.
Impeachment of Kane now? - Bucks County Courier Times: Editorials
Last week, the Republican-controlled state House Subcommittee on Courts voted to
authorize subcommittee Chairman Todd Stephens, R-151, to issue subpoenas in connection
with possible impeachment proceedings against state Attorney General Kathleen Kane, a
Democrat.
Investigation of Kathleen Kane moves forward with subpoenas, protection order | PennLive.com
A House investigation of possible misconduct by Attorney General Kathleen Kane took
another step forward Tuesday toward the issuance of subpoenas for current and former
Kane staffers.
what do they have on Kathleen Kane
vindictiveness make sure you vote against those voting for her impeachment.
Kathleen Kane spent at least $160,000 on an email probe that may never see the light of day |
PennLive.com
Will we ever see Kathleen Kane's long-gestating report on offensive and pornographic
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 180
142 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 953
Page
of 2413
954 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
emails circulating through Pennsylvania's halls of power?
Sources: Top-ranking career prosecutor pushed from post in Philadelphia D.A.'s office |
PhillyVoice
A top-ranking career prosecutor, Philadelphias deputy district attorney of investigations,
Curtis Douglas, was fired last week by DA Seth Williams, who had hired him away from
the feds six years ago.
Cost of Kane Email Report Already at $160K | PoliticsPA
add-later
Trial date set for Kathleen Kane
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen G. Kane's criminal trial is set to begin Aug. 8 in
Norristown. Attorneys on both sides emerged from a closed-door conference with
Montgomery County Judge Wendy Demchick-Alloy on Monday afternoon and said they
had resolved all pre-trial matters, paving the way for the case to go before a jury. - Laura
McCrystal, Philadelphia Inquirer
AG Kane's sister gets $16K raise to settle gender discrimination case - News - Citizens' Voice
Defamation case against Pa. AG Kathleen Kane dropped
PHILADELPHIA A federal judge has dismissed a defamation lawsuit filed by former
Pennsylvania attorney general staffers against Attorney General Kathleen Kane, and says
any comments Kane made weren't damaging enough to warrant litigation.
Leak prosecutor sees Kathleen Kane's Williams exclusion and raises her porn | PennLive.com
Court filings are coming fast and furious as Kathleen Kane and her prosecutors lay out a
series of legal maneuvers in advance of the attorney general's criminal trial next month on
charges related to the leak case.
Philadelphia Inquirer - Philly's a Great Place for a Party, But Its Democrats Are a Disgrace, July
24, 2016 (Masons?)
Kathleen Kane in Court - Story | PAHomepage | WBRE and WYOU
MONTGOMERGY COUNTY (WBRE/WYOU) Embattled Attorney General Kathleen
Kane in a Montgomery County Court room this morning. Prosecutors say
Kane leaked secret grand jury information to the press.
Kane in Court for Pretrial Hearing | WNEP.com
At final hearing before Kane trial, prosecutors, defense clash over porn
A prosecutor in Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen G. Kane's looming criminal trial
told a judge Tuesday that Kane's request to tell a jury about her unearthing of offensive
emails would mire jurors in "a distraction, a red herring." - Craig R. McCoy, Philadelphia
Inquirer
Judge: AG Kane can't present 'vindictive prosecution' defense - News - The Times-Tribune
Judge blocks AG Kathleen Kane's 'porn' defense at criminal trial | PennLive.com
A judge ruled Thursday barring Attorney General Kathleen Kane's legal team from using
the ongoing porn email probe as part of her criminal defense.
Consultant said AG Kane directed him to leak grand jury information - News - Standard Speaker
Revenge motive at issue in Kane criminal case
Judge considers motion in Pa. attorney general trial
Resent -Montgomery County Kane AMICUS
Court of Common Pleas of Montgomery County Case No. CP-46-CR-0008423-2015
REQUEST for APPEARANCE and AMICUS in Support of Kathleen Kane July 12, 2016
by stan5j.5caterbone in Types > Business/Law > Court Filings, cia, and dia
Kane case far from one-dimensional - News - Citizens' Voice
Pennsylvania AG asks justices to step in, week before trial
News, weather, traffic and sports for Harrisburg, Pa. Also York, Lancaster and Lebanon |
WHTM-TV, ABC
Judge Blocks 'Porn' Defense in Kathleen Kane Case | NBC 10 Philadelphia
The judge in Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane's criminal case won't allow
jurors to hear as a trial defense that she was prosecuted to stop her from revealing a
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 181
143 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 954
Page
of 2413
955 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
pornographic email scandal her...
AG Kathleen Kane launches 11th-hour bid to throw out criminal charges | PennLive.com
AG Kane's office settles ex-worker's whistle-blower suit | Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
The AGs office settles with a former employee who alleges he was fired in retaliation for
recommending dismissal of a top aide.
Judge: Ex-Penn State coach Jerry Sandusky may testify - The Morning Call
Judge: Ex-Penn State coach Jerry Sandusky may testify
Kathleen Kane is on her way to trial, but the saga is far from over | PennLive.com
With a single word, the state Supreme Court opened the final chapter in the saga of
Kathleen Kane. The trial begins Monday
Term about over, Pennsylvanias top prosecutor goes on trial
News, weather, traffic and sports for Harrisburg, Pa. Also York, Lancaster and Lebanon |
WHTM-TV, ABC
Kathleen Kane, Pennsylvania AG, Starts Trial With Jury Selection
Kathleen Kane, Pennsylvania's attorney general, is set to face trial, with jury selection
beginning Monday.
A.G. Kathleen Kane's trial to begin Monday
Attorney General Kathleen Kane has arrived at Montgomery County Courthouse in
Norristown in the role of defendant for the scheduled start of her criminal trial. - Laura
McCrystal and Craig R. McCoy, Philadelphia Inquirer
'Now is the time for trial' | Editorials | buckscountycouriertimes.com
The long-awaited trial of state Attorney General Kathleen Kane, accused of leaking grand
jury information to embarrass a political rival and then lying about it under oath, is
scheduled to
The revenge texts Kathleen Kane sent before the alleged leak
It was just one of a series of texts she sent to Josh Morrow, the man who ultimately leaked
secret grand jury materials to a reporter in 2014.
Pennsylvania AG Kathleen Kane Wont Testify At Perjury Trial CBS Philly
Kane told Montgomery County judge Wendy Demchick Alloy I dont believe its
necessary for me to testify on my own behalf.
Kane Trial Day 3: Back stabbing, broken trust, and a clown newspaper company | Newslanc.com
Adrian King says his old friend Kathleen Kane is trying to frame him by Bill Keisling
Wednesday, August 10 -- To hear former First Deputy
CHRIS KELLY: Kane v. Kane - Opinion - The Times-Tribune
Attorney General Kathleen Kane will not testify, defense rests in leak trial | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
NORRISTOWN Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane said she will not testify
in her trial as her defense team rested its case without calling witnesses Friday.
What criminal charges are Kathleen Kane's jury considering? | PennLive.com
A Montgomery County jury began deliberating 12 criminal charges Monday against
Kathleen Kane, including two counts of felony perjury.
Kane Trial Day 5: AG Kane declines to testify, and rests her defense without presenting
witnesses | Newslanc.com
Since state Treasurer Budd Dwyer's conviction and tragic death, this type of non-defense at
trial hasn't been used again by state officials facing prosecution,
Ron Southwick: Imagining a different future for Kathleen Kane | Reading Eagle - NEWS
If she would have been a merely adequate attorney general, she could be pursuing higher
office.
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane convicted in perjury and obstruction case related
to grand jury leak | Pennsylvania | lancasteronline.com
Jury: A.G. Kane guilty of perjury, obstruction, all other charges
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane was convicted Monday of perjury,
obstruction and other crimes after squandering her once bright political future on an illegal
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 182
144 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 955
Page
of 2413
956 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
vendetta against an enemy. - Craig R. McCoy Angela Couloumbis and Laura McCrystal,
Philadelphia Inquirer
Jury deliberating Pennsylvania AG Kathleen Kanes fate
COURTHOUSE >> Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kanes fate is in the hands of
a jury after prosecutors and defense lawyers presented their closing remarks during the trial
of the states top law enforcement officer who is acc
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane Found Guilty Of Perjury
She was accused of leaking grand jury information to a reporter.
Letter to Kathleen Kane Attorneys Re Montgomery County Clerk of Courts Letter and Alleged
Misconduct August 4, 2016
Letter to Kathleen Kane Attorneys Re Montgomery County Clerk of Courts Letter and
Alleged Misconduct August 4, 2016 by stan5j.5caterbone in Types > Business/Law > Court
Filings, cia, and dia
PA AG Kathleen Kane Found Guilty On All Counts CBS Philly
In her criminal trial, Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane was found guilty on all
counts.
BREAKING: Attorney General Kane announces resignation - Story
HARRISBURG, DAUPHIN COUNTY (WBRE/WYOU) Pennsylvania Attorney General
Kathleen G. Kane on Tuesday announced that she will resign her position as
Attorney General effective at the close of business tomorrow, August. 17.
PA AG Kathleen Kane Found Guilty in Perjury Case
'Do what is right': Gov. Tom Wolf urges Kathleen Kane to resign | Pennsylvania |
lancasteronline.com
HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) Pennsylvania's attorney general faced growing pressure to
resign Tuesday, hours after her conviction on charges she abused the powers of the state's
top law enforcement office
Gov. Wolf endorses local Democratic candidate Hartman for Congress | Politics |
lancasteronline.com
Gov. Tom Wolf has endorsed the Democratic Lancaster-area congressional candidate
Christina Hartman in the race to replace U.S. Rep. Joe Pitts in the 16th Congressional
District.
Kane Trial Verdict: The night of the long knives | Newslanc.com
Kathleen Kane remained a Rashomon Rorschach test, a carrier of what you believe she
carried, a doer of what you believed she did, a sayer of what you believed
Kathleen Kane Resigns As Pennsylvania Attorney General After Perjury Conviction : The Two-
Way : NPR
Kathleen Kane, once a rising star in the Democratic Party, was convicted on charges that
she leaked grand jury information to target a political rival and then lied about it under
oath.
Kathleen Kane resigns after conviction - YouTube
Kathleen Kane's resignation is mandated by state law. Learn more about this story at
www.newsy.com/62672/ Find more videos like this at www.newsy.com Follow ...
Kane Interrogated At Budget Hearing - YouTube
Kathleen Kane's resignation is mandated by state law. Learn more about this story at
www.newsy.com/62672/ Find more videos like this at www.newsy.com Follow ...
Pennsylvania AG Kathleen Kane to resign Wednesday - UPI.com
The first woman and Democrat ever elected as Pennsylvania's top law enforcement officer
will quit Wednesday after her conviction on a number of criminal counts.
Governor likely to appoint acting AG after Kane resigns | Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Officials said once Ms. Kanes resignation takes effect today, Bruce L. Castor Jr., second-
in-command, will become acting attorney general.
Hon. Wendy Demchick-Alloy - Ratings, reviews, comments, and information - Gavel Bangers
Montgomery County Judge Wendy Demchick-Alloy - Google Search
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 183
145 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 956
Page
of 2413
957 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
AG Kathleen Kane now faces investigation by State Ethics Commission | PennLive.com
Attorney General Kathleen Kane now faces an investigation by the State Ethics
Commission, in addition to criminal charges, a Senate removal process and various civil
lawsuits.
Pa. politics: what lies ahead?
A new political year brings chances for change or the sad possibility of sameness. Here are
key issues and events that will shape state news in 2016. - John Baer, Philadelphia Daily
News
Attorney General Beemer fires 2 top Kane aides | Pennsylvania | lancasteronline.com
HARRISBURG Attorney General Bruce Beemer fired two staffers emblematic of the
controversy under his predecessor, Kathleen Kane, who was convicted of crimes last
month, the attorney general's office said
Outlook.com - scaterbone@live.com
Evidence of a COINTELPRO Program Operating in the County of Lancaster, Pennsylvania. |
Stan Caterbone | LinkedIn
15-3400 Lambert U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals DOCKET for APPELLANT Stan J.
Caterbone, Pro Se in the LISA MICHELLE LAMBERT Case as MOVANT as of November 10,
2015
U.S. District Court Case No. 08-02982 CATERBONE v City of Lancaster Bureau of Police July
2008
Evidence of a COINTELPRO Program Operating in the County of Lancaster, Pennsylvania. |
Stan Caterbone | LinkedIn
Scribd
COINTELPRO - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Cynthia McKinney's Dissertation: Hugo Chavez, White Supremacy, COINTELPRO and
Wikileaks | the narcosphere
Attorney Profile | Claypool Law Firm - Litigation and Civil Rights Law
Litigation and Civil Rights Law
Letter Dated December 10, 2015 - Postmarked December 22, 2015 - Received January 7, 2016
From the U.S. Department of Justice Office of the Inspector General Re Investigative Jurisdiction
Letter Dated December 10, 2015 - Postmarked December 22, 2015 - Received January 7,
2016 From the U.S. Department of Justice Office of the Inspector General Re Investigative
Jurisdiction - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. Letter Dated
December 10, 2015 - Postmarked December 22, 2015 - Received January 7, 2016 From the
U.S. Department of Justice Office of the Inspector General Re Investigative Jurisdiction
Lancaster, Pa., keeps a close eye on itself - latimes
This historic town, where America's founding fathers plotted during the Revolution and
Milton Hershey later crafted his first chocolates, now boasts another distinction.It may
become the nation's
D. Michael Fisher - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Lancaster police chief talks on-duty shootings, threats against his officers after ambush |
PennLive.com
After last week's shooting of a Philadelphia police officer, Lancaster Police Chief Keith
Sadler recalled his own on-duty shootings, threats against his officers and social media's
indispensable role in 21st century policing in an exclusive interview with Pennlive.
Sonali Kolhatkar: Thanks to Donald Trump, Police Brutality and Guns, the United States
Reputation Is Plummeting - Sonali Kolhatkar - Truthdig
When I was visiting abroad recently, my non-American friends were quite candid with me:
They see my country as increasingly intolerant, violent and inhospitable. - 2016/01/15
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 184
146 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 957
Page
of 2413
958 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Nebraska claims Omaha Two have not asked for release from prison | Examiner.com
The Nebraska Board of Pardons claims neither Edward Poindexter nor Mondo we Langa,
former David Rice, have asked for reconsideration of their sentence.
Teac AG 370 2 Home Theater Unit Am FM Receiver Seems to Work Well 0043774016709 |
eBay
Teac AG 370 2 HOME THEATER UNIT AM/FM RECEIVER SEEMS TO WORK
WELL in Consumer Electronics, TV, Video & Home Audio, Home Audio Stereos,
Components | eBay
Rand Paul for President
Make America Great Again! | Donald J Trump for President
Donald J. Trump is the very definition of the American success story, continually setting
the standards of excellence in business, real estate and entertainment. Show support for his
presidential campaign here.
Thanks for signing up! Now, donate to help us build this campaign. | Thank you | Hillary for
America
ACLU of PA Sues Police Over Citations For Profanity | American Civil Liberties Union
State Troopers Issued Over 750 Similar Citations in a Single Year FOR IMMEDIATE
RELEASECONTACT: media@aclu.org PHILADELPHIA The American Civil Liberties
Union of Pennsylvania filed separate federal lawsuits today against the Pennsylvania State
Police (PSP) and the Mahanoy City Police (Schuylkill County) for issuing disorderly
conduct citations to two Pennsylvania residents for using profanity. The ACLU argues that
profanity and profane gestures are constitutionally protected speech.
Philadelphia police: Man who tried to kill officer pledged allegiance to the Islamic State - The
Washington Post
A police officer in Philadelphia survived being shot multiple times in what officials
described as an ambush.
IMPEACH OBAMA - Sign the pledge
28 U.S. Code Chapter 16 - COMPLAINTS AGAINST JUDGES AND JUDICIAL DISCIPLINE
| US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute
Section 2709 - Title 18 - CRIMES AND OFFENSES
Judicial Conduct & Disability | United States Courts
The Judicial Conduct and Disability Act establishes a process by which any person can file
a complaint in federal court alleging that a federal judge has engaged in "conduct
prejudicial to the effective and expeditious administration of the business of the courts" or
has become, by reason of a temporary or permanent condition, "unable to discharge the
duties" of the judicial office. This process cannot be used as a means to collaterally attack a
judge's rulings. An attorney can explain any rights you have as a litigant to seek review of a
judicial decision.
Current Board Members | Judicial Conduct Board of Pennsylvania
U.S. Senate: Constitution of the United States
Constitution of the United States
James Buchanan: Why is he considered Americas worst president? - Yahoo News
From Yahoo News: April 23 marks the birthday of James Buchanan, the man regarded by
many historians as one of the worstif not the worstpresidents of all time. So what did
Buchanan do to earn the disrespect of so many people?
Robert Gates CIA Nomination Hearing - YouTube
Share your videos with friends, family, and the world
Reading's police chief also made an impact in Lancaster | Reading Eagle - NEWS
William Heim served as chief in Lancaster for several years and he left a lasting impression
as a smart, innovative leader.
Pentagon Releases Almost 200 Photos of Bush-Era Military Abuse - Truthdig
After a decade-long legal battle, the Department of Defense releases 198 photos of detainee
abuse at two dozen U.S. military sites across Iraq and Afghanistan. - 2016/02/06
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 185
147 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 958
Page
of 2413
959 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
COINTELPRO, Leonard Peltier and the Limits of Resistance | Global Research - Centre for
Research on Globalization
Obstruction of Justice legal definition of Obstruction of Justice
Definition of Obstruction of Justice in the Legal Dictionary - by Free online English
dictionary and encyclopedia. What is Obstruction of Justice? Meaning of Obstruction of
Justice as a legal term. What does Obstruction of Justice mean in law?
UST - Region 3 | Department of Justice
U.S. Senate: Senators of the 114th Congress
Senators of the 114th Congress
Comcast Business | Get Help & Support
Comcast Business Customer Service is here to provide Help and Support for your Comcast
Business Internet, TV, Voice, and other services.
OnlineFaxes Control Panel
COINTELPRO, Cherokee Freedmen and Survival Tactics: Black History Month For Natives Pt.2
- ICTMN.com
The Thing About Skins: COINTELPRO, Cherokee Freedmen and Black History Month
If Ferguson dissolves police department, who would step in? | National | lancasteronline.com
FERGUSON, Mo. (AP) As Ferguson prepares to do legal battle with the Justice
Department, the city's leaders have acknowledged the possibility that they might someday
disband the police department
Christian Fiction Addiction: A nail-biting story: The Newsmakers by Lis Wiehl
Concert at LNP studios will give a glimpse of this year's Roots & Blues Music Festival |
Entertainment | lancasteronline.com
Audience members will have the chance to win two VIP tickets to this year's music festival.
Castle Doctrine & Stand Your Ground
The U.S. Military Is Working to Turn Your Brain Into a Remote Control | Complex
A real-life brain modem could eventually let people turn their minds into remote controls.
Keith Forsyth Reddit AMA on COINTELPRO - Business Insider
This man helped rein in massive abuses by the FBI.
#Apple Wins Ruling in New York #iPhone #Hacking Order
fairmount hospital philadelphia - Google Search
Behavioral Health Services | Philadelphia | Fairmount BHS
Fairmount is a provider of behavioral health services and is the largest freestanding
behavioral health hospital in southeastern Pennsylvania.
Safe Step Walk-In Tubs
Huge Verdict Regarding The Digital Privacy World: U.S. wrestler Hulk Hogan wins $115
million in sex-tape suit
Lancaster man charged in Jennifer Lawrence hacking scandal | Local News - WGAL Home
The hacking resulted in leaked nude photos of Jennifer Lawrence and other celebrities.
IC3 Complaint Information
Statement and Video of False Imprisonment at NSA National Security Agency at Ft Meade,
Maryland of - YouTube
Statement and Video of False Imprisonment re Handcuffed and Interrogation for an hour at
NSA Headquarters (National Security Agency at Ft. Meade, Maryland) b...
Lancaster Freethought Society (Lancaster, PA) - Meetup
Don't believe in God? You are not alone! It is an exciting time to be a nonbeliever in the
U.S. There are more people shedding dogma and religion in this country than at any other
time in the past. M
Chloroform Usage In Crime On The High
Biggest News Source for News in Uganda and the East African Region ,Breaking news in
Uganda and Daily news and the latest from Uganda
What is torture? - Defining torture
Definition of torture and explanation about its victims, effects and perpetrators
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 186
148 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 959
Page
of 2413
960 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
18 U.S. Code 249 - Hate crime acts | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute
Gaslighting - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Revolution from Above - Kerry Bolton - Google Books
In Revolution from Above, Dr. Bolton demonstrates that the supposed rivalry between
Marxist-inspired movements and capitalism has always been an illusion. Marxism,
Communism and liberalism have been and continue to be exploited by the forces of
international capitalism to further their global agenda, despite their surface disagreements.
Dr. Bolton shows that the ultimate goal of capitalism is to create a worldwide collectivist
society of consumers, and Marxism is merely one means of attaining this. He traces this
idea back to Plato, through the Illuminati, the Freemasons, the French Revolution, and
Communism, and examines the evidence for the existence of a shadowy network of bankers
who control a large portion of the world's political and economic power. He then discusses
the various instruments this network uses to maintain control, such as tax-exempt
foundations and think tanks. Dr. Bolton also reveals how capitalist governments actually
worked closely with Communist regimes and, in fact, frustrated genuinely anti-Communist
efforts during the Cold War. He discusses the impact this has had on Western society,
resulting in such trends as the sexual revolution and the promotion of drug use. Dr. Bolton
then brings us up-to-date by discussing the role of the recent "Arab spring" in these
ongoing developments. One will never be able to view modern history the same way again
after reading Dr. Bolton's arguments and examining the supporting evidence. K. R. Bolton
holds doctorates in Historical Theology and Theology; Ph.D. (Hist. Th.), Th.D. as well as
in other areas. He is a contributing writer for The Foreign Policy Journal, and a Fellow of
the Academy of Social and Political Research in Greece. His papers and articles have been
published by both scholarly and popular media, including the International Journal of
Social Economics; Journal of Social, Political, and Economic Studies; Geopolitika; World
Affairs; India Quarterly; and The Initiate: Journal of Traditional Studies. His work has been
translated into Russian, Vietnamese, Italian, Czech, Latvian, Farsi and French.
The US Department of Justice and the State of Oregon set me up, warrantlessly spied on me, and
tortured me with a microwave weapon. www.obamasweapon.com | Oregon State Hospital: The
abusive and warehouse exposed
Rosaura Torres (@AuthorRTorres) | Twitter
NSA Whistleblower Karen Stewart Speaks Candidly About Illegal and Criminal NSA & FBI
Programs of Organized Stalking and Electronic Harassment in the USA & Abroad Washington's
Blog
Chris Hedges: Revolution Is in the Air - Chris Hedges - Truthdig
The arrests of hundredsincluding mein or near the Capitol have been going on every
day for a week. They presage a growing, nationwide uprising against the corporate state. -
2016/04/16
The Feds Have a Long History of Skirting Probable Cause For National Security | Houston Press
Whether its called domestic investigation, as the FBI prefers, or pre-emptive
prosecution, as critics term it, the bureaus undercover...
Thomas Andrews Drake - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Wheel Of Freedom W.U.A 11/30/15 Bill Binney & Kirk Wiebe - YouTube
NSA whistleblower Karen Stewart tells her story of being fired on false premises, she filed
a complaint & lawsuit, and then became "targeted" by organized st...
Edward Snowdens Father Speaks | News | Philadelphia Magazine
Lon Snowden on his son, on the courage of John and Bonnie Raines, and the price activists
pay for exposing national secrets.
United States of Paranoia: They See Gangs of Stalkers - The New York Times
An online community known as targeted individuals says its members are being
surveilled by groups of stalkers as part of a sprawling conspiracy. But psychiatrists beg to
differ.
FBI Overview
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 187
149 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 960
Page
of 2413
961 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
This Is Your Brain On War
Task & Purpose teamed up with Lt. Col. Dave Grossman to produce this visual guide to
what happens to the mind and body before, during, and after combat.
Assessment ordered for accused Coventry Hills killer after outburst about mind c
Ranting in court about a jailhouse mind control conspiracy helped earn an accused double
killer a psychiatric assessment on Monday.
Hackers Crack Pentagons Cyber Walls More Than 130 Times
Under the Hack The Pentagon program, hackers found 138 vulnerabilities in the
Defense Departments cyber defenses.
Competing with COINTELPRO, NYPD Finds Decades Old Political Surveillance Documents
It Lost
Modiano: How Muhammad Ali helped expose Hoover's FBI - NY Daily News
RIP to Muhammad Ali, the greatest boxer, sports personality, and sports activist who has
ever lived.
Russian Minister Calls Netflix a US-Backed Mind Control Machine
Russian Culture Minister Vladimir Medinsky believes the U.S. has financed its own global
mind controlling device: Netflix
Millersville University - Pete Anders
KEISLING: Sen. Arlen Specter offered to help investigate the murder of Assistant U.S. Attorney
Jonathan Luna | Newslanc.com
One would think that Luna's superiors in the U.S. Justice Department, and the broader
American government, would be interested in solving Luna's murder, and
FBI Jack Anderson Part 10 of 11
Small US Town First to Be Closely Watched by Private Network of Cameras
The growing number of closed-circuit cameras that monitor Lancaster, Pa., are run by a
private group of citizens, unlike the government-run CCTV system in the U.K.
Lancaster is being watched - by private group Police don't operate the surveillance cameras. -
philly-archives
On a sunny afternoon at H.M. Musser Park in Lancaster City, Vilma Caraballo pushed her
grandson on a swing. Marion Young, 60, ate tortilla chips from her bagged lunch. And
Maicol Ortiz, 19, sat on a
Police arrest 'person of interest' following road closure, shots fired incident in Lancaster | Local
News | lancasteronline.com
Several blocks of Manor Street have been shut down because of a police incident.
Manor Street has re-opened after police incident in Lancaster | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Several blocks of Manor Street have been shut down because of a police incident.
Red Rose Exhaust - Is tight credit hurting local small businesses? | Insider | lancasteronline.com
A few years ago, auto mechanic Chris Laboy approached several local banks and a credit
union, seeking a loan to open his own repair shop in Lancaster.
Inquirer editorial: Philly's a great place for a party, but its Democrats are a disgrace
With new flags on the Parkway, new lights on the boathouses, and new efforts to shelter the
homeless, the Democrats who have run Philadelphia for more than half a century have
cleaned up the city for the Democratic National Convention.
Family of local Marine killed in 1983 Beirut bombing part of lawsuit against Iran | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
More than 32 years after a local U.S. Marine was killed in a terror attack in Beirut, his
family is part of a lawsuit against the Islamic Republic of Iran
EMERGENCY INJUCTION v Fulton Bank Recorded April 14, 2010 Filed on April 1, 2010 in
US District Court - Documents
EMERGENCY INJUCTION v Fulton Bank Recorded April 14, 2010 Filed on April 1,
2010 in US District Court
COINTELPRO | Democracy Now!
Targeted Individuals - Are They Really Crazy?
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 188
150 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 961
Page
of 2413
962 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Mind Control Experiments, CIA Hypnosis, Sex Abuse
Mind Control Experiments: Declassified CIA documents (links to originals provided)
reveal CIA hypnosis, sex abuse, disturbing mind control experiments to create super spies,
unsuspecting assassins, and more.
For Pain Meds - Documentation to Obtain Pain Medication From Lancaster Regional Medical
Center - August 21, 2016 - With Table of Contents
Letter to Chrisopher M. Reeser of Marshall Dennehey Warner Coleman & Goggin Re Allstate
Insurance Property Claim of April 16, 2016 on August 21, 2016
2ND Attempt for Pain Meds at Lancaster Regional Medical Ctr. Uploaded by SCaterbone at
Your Listen
2ND Attempt for Pain Meds at Lancaster Regional Medical Ctr. uploaded by SCaterbone
EXCLUSIVE Transcripts of Whistleblower Testimonies as Targeted Individuals of U.S.
Sponsored Mind Control and Related Hearings and Lectures, August 19, 2016
Heres Proof That the U.K. Has Helped Americas National Security Agency With Its Targeted
Killings - Truthdig
The UK flamboyantly touts its death penalty opposition, yet uses [a] (previously) secret
base with the US to target people for due-process-free assassinations, wrote journalist
Glenn Greenwald in a Facebook post linking to a groundbreaking Intercept investigation by
Ryan Gallagher. - 2016/09/06
Scribd Documents
Financial Management Group, Ltd., Anti-Trust Litigation Memo to Counter the Crooks of
Lancaster County May 2, 1987
Financial Management Group, Ltd., Anti-Trust Litigation Memo to Counter the Crooks of
Lancaster County May 2, 1987 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read
online for free. Financial Management Group, Ltd., Anti-Trust Litigation Memo to Counter
the Crooks of Lancaster County May 2, 1987
ISC Whistleblowing Timeline of Events Created on or About 1991 Proofed on September 17,
2015
ISC Whistleblowing Timeline of Events Created on or About 1991 Proofed on September
17, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or view presentation slides
online. ISC Whistleblowing Timeline of Events Created on or About 1991 Proofed on
September 17, 2015
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane & Stan Caterbone Strategic Planning Notes for
2016
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane & Stan Caterbone Strategic Planning Notes
for 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free.
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane & Stan Caterbone Strategic Planning Notes
for 2016
Stamped Superior Court Re in Forma Pauperis Application Case No. 1915 Mda 2015 November
13, 2015
Stamped Superior Court Re in Forma Pauperis Application Case No. 1915 Mda 2015
November 13, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for
free. Stamped Superior Court Re in Forma Pauperis Application Case No. 1915 Mda 2015
November 13, 2015
Complaint and CONFIRMATION of Psychiatric Abuses From Citizens Commission for Human
Rights or CCHR September 25, 2009 Important
Complaint and CONFIRMATION of Psychiatric Abuses From Citizens Commission for
Human Rights or CCHR September 25, 2009 Important - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Complaint and CONFIRMATION of
Psychiatric Abuses From Citizens Commission for Human Rights or CCHR September 25,
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 189
151 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 962
Page
of 2413
963 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
2009 Important
Lisa Michelle Lambert Summary Judgement Filed in Federal Court September 3, 2015
U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals OPINION Reversal & JUDGMENT Case No. 07-4474 and
_0
Electronic Surveillance Project By Julianne McKinney, Director of the National Security Alumni
Electronic Surveillance Project By Julianne McKinney, Director of the National Security
Alumni - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free.
Electronic Surveillance Project and Director of the Association of National Security
Alumni By Julianne McKinney
Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Relief
December 27, 2009
Advanced Media Group Capabilities Statement 1990 Apr 29 2007
ORDER DISMISSAL Preliminary Injunction Case No. CI-15-06985 August 20, 2015
Appeal for Reconsideration Case No. 15-06985 Injunction August 24, 2015
Clinton Global Initiative Invitation July 5 2006
Bonnie Lee Polygraph RESULTS and Social Security Documentation for Stanley Caterbone
August 8, 2015
My Accounting & MIS System for Pflumm Contractors Using Database Software and Peachtree
Accounting Feb 1998
My Accounting & MIS System for Pflumm Contractors Using Database Software and
Peachtree Accounting Feb 1998 - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt)
or read book online for free. My Accounting & MIS System for Pflumm Contractors Using
Database Software and Peachtree Accounting Feb 1998
Disability Benefits and Application File July 7, 2015 No Compression by Hackers
Disability Benefits and Application File July 7, 2015 No Compression by Hackers - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Disability Benefits and
Application File July 7, 2015 No Compression by Hackers
Breaking News Chief Keith Sadler is a Wife Beater - Lancaster Independant Press July 2012
Breaking News Chief Keith Sadler is a Wife Beater - Lancaster Independant Press July
2012 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Breaking
News Chief Keith Sadler is a Wife Beater - Lancaster Independant Press July 2012
Amici Curiae for ACLU v NSA February 18 2007
Amici Curiae for ACLU v NSA February 18 2007 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text
file (.txt) or read online for free. Amici Curiae for ACLU v NSA February 18 2007
Letter to George Werner of Barley Snyder, LLC Re Safety Deposit Boxes of April 23, 2010
Letter to George Werner of Barley Snyder, LLC Re Safety Deposit Boxes of April 23, 2010
- Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Letter to George
Werner of Barley Snyder, LLC Re Safety Deposit Boxes of April 23, 2010
ABC News Nighline July & September 1991 Transcript Re ISC and Sec of Defense Robert Gates
ABC News Nighline July & September 1991 Transcript Re ISC and Sec of Defense Robert
Gates - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. ABC News
Nighline July & September 1991 Transcript Re ISC and Sec of Defense Robert Gates
Judge Farina East Lampeter 2843-06 Transcript Dec 5 2006 Important
Judge Farina East Lampeter 2843-06 Transcript Dec 5 2006 Important - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Judge Farina East Lampeter 2843-06
Transcript Dec 5 2006 Important
Pflumm Contractors American Management Proposal April 26 1996 May 4 2007
Pflumm Contractors American Management Proposal April 26 1996 May 4 2007 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Pflumm Contractors
American Management Proposal April 26 1996 May 4 2007
Sheryl Crow and Mental Telepathy From Advanced Media Group Website December 26, 2009
Sheryl Crow and Mental Telepathy From Advanced Media Group Website December 26,
2009 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Sheryl
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 190
152 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 963
Page
of 2413
964 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Crow and Mental Telepathy From Advanced Media Group Website December 26, 2009
Pro Se Sales Journal Billings Feb 12 2008
Pro Se Sales Journal Billings Feb 12 2008 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file
(.txt) or read online for free. Pro Se Sales Journal Billings Feb 12 2008
Amended COMPLAINT in U.S. District Court Case No. 05-2288 File on October 15, 2007
Amended COMPLAINT in U.S. District Court Case No. 05-2288 File on October 15, 2007
- Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Amended
COMPLAINT in U.S. District Court Case No. 05-2288 File on October 15, 2007
Washington Post Eastern Regional Free Agent Camp March 24 2005
Washington Post Eastern Regional Free Agent Camp March 24 2005 - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Washington Post Eastern Regional
Free Agent Camp March 24 2005
Pro Financial Group Brochure
Pro Financial Group Brochure - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read
online for free. Pro Financial Group, LTD., is a highly sophisticated network of various
professional advisors needed to perform financial advisory services specifically for the
professional athlete. The network consists of several attorneys, accountants, a Financial
Planning Consulting Firm, a Registered Investment Advisor, a Broker Dealer support
organization for some of the most competent Financial Planners in every state, and a group
of investment advisors.
Ananamous Letter Disparaging Fulton Financial Corporation Dec 16 2007
Ananamous Letter Disparaging Fulton Financial Corporation Dec 16 2007 - Free download
as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. Ananamous Letter Disparaging Fulton Financial
Corporation Dec 16 2007
Netwerk Management & Clipper Stadium Agreement for Sara McLachlan July 8, 2005
Netwerk Management & Clipper Stadium Agreement for Sara McLachlan July 8, 2005 -
Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Netwerk
Management & Clipper Stadium Agreement for Sara McLachlan July 8, 2005
Stan Caterbone Family Photo Album Created on October 15, 2015
Stan Caterbone Family Photo Album Created on October 15, 2015 - Free download as PDF
File (.pdf) or view presentation slides online. Stan Caterbone Family Photo Album Created
on October 15, 2015
Amid Russian airstrikes, a Putin craze takes hold in Mideast - The York Daily Record
BEIRUT (AP) Amid the ornate walls of Damascus' famed Omayyad Mosque, preacher
Maamoun Rahmeh stood before worshippers last week, declaring Russian President
Vladimir Putin a "giant and beloved leader" who has "destroyed the myth of the self-
aggrandizing America.
FMG Board - Newletter - Harsco - PA Law Review 1987
FMG Board - Newletter - Harsco - PA Law Review 1987 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. FMG Board - Newletter - Harsco - PA Law
Review 1987
IMPORTANT - All Laptop-Desktop Calenders Migrated Sept 29 2006
IMPORTANT - All Laptop-Desktop Calenders Migrated Sept 29 2006 - Free ebook
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or view presentation slides online.
IMPORTANT - All Laptop-Desktop Calenders Migrated Sept 29 2006
Farimount Behavioral Health Medical Records September 28, 2015
Farimount Behavioral Health Medical Records September 28, 2015 - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. Farimount Behavioral Health Medical Records
September 28, 2015
Clinton Global Initiative (1st) Invitation From Essay July 5, 2006
Clinton Global Initiative (1st) Invitation From Essay July 5, 2006 - Free download as PDF
File (.pdf) or read online for free. Clinton Global Initiative (1st) Invitation From Essay July
5, 2006
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 191
153 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 964
Page
of 2413
965 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Discrimination Complaint to the Lancaster County Human Relations Commission Discrimination
Complaint August 22 2007
Discrimination Complaint to the Lancaster County Human Relations Commission
Discrimination Complaint August 22 2007 - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text
file (.txt) or read book online for free. Discrimination Complaint to the Lancaster County
Human Relations Commission Discrimination Complaint August 22 2007
Advanced Media Press Release Organized Stalking and Directed Energy Devices and Weapons
Bill July 4, 2015
Advanced Media Press Release Organized Stalking and Directed Energy Devices and
Weapons Bill July 4, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read
online for free. Advanced Media Press Release Organized Stalking and Directed Energy
Devices and Weapons Bill July 4, 2015
Lisa Michelle Lambert Summary Judgement Docket No. 9 by Lambert Filed in Federal Court
September 3, 2015
Lisa Michelle Lambert Summary Judgement Docket No. 9 by Lambert Filed in Federal
Court September 3, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online
for free. Lisa Michelle Lambert Summary Judgement Docket No. 9 by Lambert Filed in
Federal Court September 3, 2015
Tom Caterbone Estate & Fulton Bank Fraud Documents March 22, 2010
Tom Caterbone Estate & Fulton Bank Fraud Documents March 22, 2010 - Free download
as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Tom Caterbone Estate & Fulton
Bank Fraud Documents March 22, 2010
Advanced Media Group Invoices for September 3, 2015
Advanced Media Group Invoices for September 3, 2015 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Advanced Media Group Invoices for
September 3, 2015
1998 AFFIDAVIT to Judge Stewart Dalzall of the US District Court for Eastern Pennsylvania
Timeline of 220 Stone Hill Road Illegal Reposession
Timeline of 220 Stone Hill Road Illegal Reposession - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Timeline of 220 Stone Hill Road Illegal Reposession
Why Did Tommy, Sammy, And Samuel Caterbone All Die Out of the State of Pennsylvania -
March 18, 2010
Why Did Tommy, Sammy, And Samuel Caterbone All Die Out of the State of
Pennsylvania - March 18, 2010 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read
online for free. Why Did Tommy, Sammy, And Samuel Caterbone All Die Out of the State
of Pennsylvania - March 18, 2010
Habeus Corpus Petition Case No. 2-06-Cv-05138-Jcj July 12, 2015
Habeus Corpus Petition Case No. 2-06-Cv-05138-Jcj July 12, 2015 - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Habeus Corpus Petition Case No. 2-
06-Cv-05138-Jcj July 12, 2015
New Deed 1250 Fremont St Recorded on July 9, 2015
New Deed 1250 Fremont St Recorded on July 9, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf)
or read online for free. New Deed 1250 Fremont St Recorded on July 9, 2015
Lancaster Newspapers Defamation September 4 1987 - July 10, 2015
Lancaster Newspapers Defamation September 4 1987 - July 10, 2015 - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Lancaster Newspapers Defamation
September 4 1987 - July 10, 2015
Question and Answer From Terry Robertson of Jim Guest Show Re is Mind Control Legal
December 1, 2009 Important
Question and Answer From Terry Robertson of Jim Guest Show Re is Mind Control Legal
December 1, 2009 Important - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read
online for free. Question and Answer From Terry Robertson of Jim Guest Show Re is Mind
Control Legal December 1, 2009 Important
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 192
154 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 965
Page
of 2413
966 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Joseph F Roda Documents for Stan J. Caterbone, Sammy & Guerin June 29 2007
Joseph F Roda Documents for Stan J. Caterbone, Sammy & Guerin June 29 2007 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Joseph F Roda
Documents for Stan J. Caterbone, Sammy & Guerin June 29 2007
No Touch Torture by Cheryl Welsh 2008
No Touch Torture by Cheryl Welsh 2008 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file
(.txt) or read online for free. No Touch Torture by Cheryl Welsh 2008
Lancaster Newspapers Lambert Search Book Jun 10 2006
Lancaster Newspapers Lambert Search Book Jun 10 2006 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Lancaster Newspapers Lambert Search Book
Jun 10 2006
Thomas P. Caterbone Estate Xakellis-Samly Motion for Leave & Discharge August 4 1996
Thomas P. Caterbone Estate Xakellis-Samly Motion for Leave & Discharge August 4 1996
- Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Thomas P.
Caterbone Estate Xakellis-Samly Motion for Leave & Discharge August 4 1996
Letter to Matt Samley-Xekellis Re ISC November 23 1997
Letter to Matt Samley-Xekellis Re ISC November 23 1997 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Letter to Matt Samley-Xekellis Re ISC
November 23 1997
Kerry Kennedy - Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia
Kerry Kennedy - Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Kerry Kennedy - Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia
Mediation Negotiations With Lancaster County Jan 4 2007
Mediation Negotiations With Lancaster County Jan 4 2007 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Mediation Negotiations With Lancaster
County Jan 4 2007
FMG Diary of Events May 2, 2015
FMG Diary of Events May 2, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or
read online for free. FMG Diary of Events May 2, 2015
FMG, Ltd v Fulton Bank & Mellon Bank
FMG, Ltd v Fulton Bank & Mellon Bank - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file
(.txt) or read online for free. FMG, Ltd v Fulton Bank & Mellon Bank
FMG Shareholders of Record May 1987
FMG Shareholders of Record May 1987 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt)
or read online for free. FMG Shareholders of Record May 1987
Millersville University Grad Program Documents for Litigation September 16, 2009
IMPORTANT
Millersville University Grad Program Documents for Litigation September 16, 2009
IMPORTANT - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free.
Millersville University Grad Program Documents for Litigation September 16, 2009
IMPORTANT
Financial Management Group, Ltd. Business Plan and Developing Documents as of May 8, 2010
Financial Management Group, Ltd. Business Plan and Developing Documents as of May 8,
2010 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Financial
Management Group, Ltd. Business Plan and Developing Documents as of May 8, 2010
Yolanda Marie Roda & Samuel P. Caterbone Wedding Memorium September 25, 1948
Yolanda Marie Roda & Samuel P. Caterbone Wedding Memorium September 25, 1948 -
Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. Yolanda Marie Roda & Samuel P.
Caterbone Wedding Memorium September 25, 1948
Samuel Caterbone Effects of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control
Samuel Caterbone Effects of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control 1983 - Free download as PDF
File (.pdf) or read online for free. Samuel Caterbone Effects of U.S. Sponsored Mind
Control 1983
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 193
155 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 966
Page
of 2413
967 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Letter To and From Debbie Fochs of Disclosure Project re Samuel Caterbone ET Experience is
Mind Control Feb 26 2008
1990 AMG Legal Systems Prototype Text From 1987 Criminal Conspiracy
Institutional Investors Mortgage Banking Business Development of 1987 Very Important
Institutional Investors Mortgage Banking Business Development of 1987 Very Important -
Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Institutional
Investors Mortgage Banking Business Development of 1987 Very Important
3rd Circuit "DAD" Exhibit
Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement by Appellant October 22, 2015
Recorded Copy - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read book
online for free. Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement by Appellant
October 22, 2015 Recorded Copy
Federal Whistleblower and Targeted Individual of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control Executive
Summary Updated October 12, 2015
Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION 1 Statement by Appellant October 20, 2015
Recorded
Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION 1 Statement by Appellant October 20, 2015
Recorded - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Third
Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION 1 Statement by Appellant October 20, 2015
Recorded
Third Circuit in Forma Pauperis APPEAL for RECONSIDERATION Case No. 15-3400 October
21, 2015 Recorded Copy
Third Circuit in Forma Pauperis APPEAL for RECONSIDERATION Case No. 15-3400
October 21, 2015 Recorded Copy - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or
read online for free. Third Circuit in Forma Pauperis APPEAL for RECONSIDERATION
Case No. 15-3400 October 21, 2015 Recorded Copy
15-3400 Summary
Lisa Michelle Lambert Habeus Notice of Appeal to Third Circuit September 30, 2015
Lisa Michelle Lambert Habeus Notice of Appeal to Third Circuit September 30, 2015 -
Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Lisa Michelle
Lambert Habeus Notice of Appeal to Third Circuit September 30, 2015
Obama at Bucanan Park Finger Under Eye September 4, 2008
Obama at Bucanan Park Finger Under Eye September 4, 2008 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf) or read online for free. Obama at Bucanan Park Finger Under Eye September 4, 2008
Patient First Medical File to Date October 22, 2015
Duke Street Defendants List
Duke Street Business Center 08-13373 DOCKET AND DEFENDANTS LIST on
Amended Caption DOCKET Sheet Court Record October 7, 2015 - Free download as PDF
File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Duke Street Business Center 08-13373
DOCKET AND DEFENDANTS LIST on Amended Caption DOCKET Sheet Court
Record October 7, 2015
Letter to Dianne Nast Re Fulton Class Action Jan 25 2008
Letter to Dianne Nast Re Fulton Class Action Jan 25 2008 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Letter to Dianne Nast Re Fulton Class Action
Jan 25 2008
Obama ordered hit-list of Targeted Individuals worldwide to cyber-attack | Examiner.com
Barack Obama ordered national security leaders to compile a new targeted individual hit-
list, this one consisting of possible adversaries overseas and, in eme
Congressman Robert Walker Pleading July 7 1991 Important
Congressman Robert Walker Pleading July 7 1991 Important - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Congressman Robert Walker Pleading July 7
1991 Important
Complaint to U.S. Attorney Re Samuel Caterbone Victimization Feb 9, 2009
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 194
156 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 967
Page
of 2413
968 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Complaint to U.S. Attorney Re Samuel Caterbone Victimization Feb 9, 2009 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. Complaint to U.S. Attorney Re Samuel
Caterbone Victimization Feb 9, 2009
Samuel Caterbone ORDER to Vacate County of Lancaster
Samuel Caterbone ORDER to Vacate County of Lancaster - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf) or read online for free. Samuel Caterbone ORDER to Vacate County of Lancaster
Proofed Stan J Caterbone Biography June 29, 2015
Proofed Stan J Caterbone Biography June 29, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Proofed Stan J Caterbone Biography June 29, 2015
Lancaster City Police 302 of July 9, 2015 IMPORTANT
Lancaster City Police 302 of July 9, 2015 IMPORTANT - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf) or read online for free. Lancaster City Police 302 of July 9, 2015 IMPORTANT
LGH Medical File From 302 by Detective Bearinger of Lancaster City Police of July 10, 2015un
LGH Medical File From 302 by Detective Bearinger of Lancaster City Police of July 10,
2015un - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. LGH
Medical File From 302 by Detective Bearinger of Lancaster City Police of July 10, 2015un
St Joseph Hospital Evaluations September 9 1987
St Joseph Hospital Evaluations September 9 1987 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or
read online for free. St Joseph Hospital Evaluations September 9 1987
Last Meeting With Psychiatrist Dr. Al Shulz Transcript of January 1998 Important
Last Meeting With Psychiatrist Dr. Al Shulz Transcript of January 1998 Important - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Last Meeting With
Psychiatrist Dr. Al Shulz Transcript of January 1998 Important
Pennsylvania Mental Health Procedures Act - The Written Law Archived by Stan Caterbone on
July 28, 2009
Pennsylvania Mental Health Procedures Act - The Written Law Archived by Stan
Caterbone on July 28, 2009 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read
online for free. Pennsylvania Mental Health Procedures Act - The Written Law Archived
by Stan Caterbone on July 28, 2009
Lancaster City Police and Fairmount Hospital Section 303 Certificate of the PA Mental Health
Act Executed on July 14, 2015 and Section 302 Executed on July 9, 2015
Lancaster City Police and Fairmount Hospital Section 303 Certificate of the PA Mental
Health Act Executed on July 14, 2015 and Section 302 Executed on July 9, 2015 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Lancaster City Police
and Fairmount Hospital Section 303 Certificate of the PA Mental Health Act Executed on
July 14, 2015 and Section 302 Executed on July 9, 2015
Stan Caterbone's Comment for Article Edward Snowden Clinton Made False Claim About
Whistleblower Protection - Truthdig October 18, 2015
Stan Caterbone's Comment for Article Edward Snowden Clinton Made False Claim
About Whistleblower Protection - Truthdig October 18, 2015 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Stan Caterbone's Comment for Article Edward
Snowden Clinton Made False Claim About Whistleblower Protection - Truthdig October
18, 2015
Detective Clark Bearinger Email Response to Incident Report List of October 15, 2015
Detective Clark Bearinger Email Response to Incident Report List of October 15, 2015 -
Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Detective Clark
Bearinger Email Response to Incident Report List of October 15, 2015
Law Enforcement Extortion of Financial Management Group, Ltd., From Stan Caterbone in 1987
Anti-Trust Litigation File of October 17, 2015
Law Enforcement Extortion of Financial Management Group, Ltd., From Stan Caterbone in
1987 Anti-Trust Litigation File of October 17, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Law Enforcement Extortion of Financial
Management Group, Ltd., From Stan Caterbone in 1987 Anti-Trust Litigation File of
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 195
157 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 968
Page
of 2413
969 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
October 17, 2015
Pflumm Contractors Performance Review 1994-1998
Pflumm Contractors Performance Review 1994-1998 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Pflumm Contractors Performance Review 1994-1998
Email Revised- VANDALISM & THEFT of MY HOME-Updated Oct 14, 2015 With
Attachments
Email Revised- VANDALISM & THEFT of MY HOME-Updated Oct 14, 2015 With
Attachments - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read book online
for free. Email Revised- VANDALISM & THEFT of MY HOME-Updated Oct 14, 2015
With Attachments
CATERBONE v. Dave Pflumm, Brett Stabley, And Mike Caterbone CI-06-07376 2006
CATERBONE v. Dave Pflumm, Brett Stabley, And Mike Caterbone CI-06-07376 2006 -
Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. CATERBONE v. Dave Pflumm,
Brett Stabley, And Mike Caterbone CI-06-07376 2006
Incident Reports of Harassment, Vandalism, Hacking, & Thefts From 1987 to March 22, 2010
Incident Reports of Harassment, Vandalism, Hacking, & Thefts From 1987 to March 22,
2010 - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read book online for free.
Incident Reports of Harassment, Vandalism, Hacking, & Thefts From 1987 to March 22,
2010
Ameritrade History of Transactions From 2002 to April 3, 2010
Ameritrade History of Transactions From 2002 to April 3, 2010 - Free download as PDF
File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Ameritrade History of Transactions From
2002 to April 3, 2010
FMG Head Resigns (Robert Kauffman); Team Takes Reins June 10, 1990
Lancaster Newspapers Defamation September 4 1987 - July 10, 2015
Letter to Chief Sadler
Advanced Media Group Letter to the Editor of Lancaster Newspapers September 6, 2015 Full
Version
Advanced Media Group Letter to the Editor of Lancaster Newspapers September 6, 2015
Full Version - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free.
Advanced Media Group Letter to the Editor of Lancaster Newspapers September 6, 2015
Full Version
Stan J. Caterbone Bio
Advanced Media Group/Global Entertainment Group of Lancaster, Pennsylvania, is an
information technologies company founded by Stan J. Caterbone in 1989
Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement and EXHIBIT by Appellant October 23,
2015 With Executive Summary
Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement and EXHIBIT by Appellant
October 23, 2015 With Executive Summary - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file
(.txt) or read online for free. Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement and
EXHIBIT by Appellant October 23, 2015 With Executive Summary
Petition of Private Criminal Complaint in Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas Clerk of
Court v. Lancaster City Police for 302 Warrant of July 9, 2015 Filed September 23, 2015
Petition of Private Criminal Complaint in Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas Clerk
of Court v. Lancaster City Police for 302 Warrant of July 9, 2015 Filed September 23, 2015
- Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Petition of
Private Criminal Complaint in Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas Clerk of Court v.
Lancaster City Police for 302 Warrant of July 9, 2015 Filed September 23, 2015
Tony Bongiovi's Power Station Studios Avatar Website With Client List
Tony Bongiovi's Power Station Studios Avatar Website With Client List - Free download
as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Tony Bongiovi's Power Station
Studios Avatar Website With Client List
Fulton Bank Letter From Mark Crowe General Counsel March 25 2005
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 196
158 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 969
Page
of 2413
970 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Fulton Bank Letter From Mark Crowe General Counsel March 25 2005 - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Fulton Bank Letter From Mark
Crowe General Counsel March 25 2005
Letter to R Scott Smith Chairman of Fulton Financial Re Rufus Fulton Intelliegence Officer
Interview of Nov 21, 2007 on WGAL-TV 8 News at 6, the letter is dated December 3, 2007
Letter to R Scott Smith Chairman of Fulton Financial Re Rufus Fulton Intelliegence Officer
Interview of Nov 21, 2007 on WGAL-TV 8 News at 6, the letter is dated December 3, 2007
- Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Letter to R Scott
Smith Chairman of Fulton Financial Re Rufus Fulton Intelliegence Officer Interview of
Nov 21, 2007 on WGAL-TV 8 News at 6, the letter is dated December 3, 2007
Stan Caterbone and Advanced Media Group Incident Report of Victimizations of U.S. Sponsored
Mind Control and COINTELPRO of 2015 Updated October 31, 2015
Stan Caterbone and Advanced Media Group Incident Report of Victimizations of U.S.
Sponsored Mind Control and COINTELPRO of 2015 Updated October 31, 2015 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Stan Caterbone and
Advanced Media Group Incident Report of Victimizations of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control
and COINTELPRO of 2015 Updated October 31, 2015
Case No. 15-3400 U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals re: Lisa Michelle Lambert Habeus Corpus
Appeal REQUEST for HEARING by Appellant, Stanley J. Caterbone Dated October 26, 2015
RECORDED Copy With TOC
Case No. 15-3400 U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals re: Lisa Michelle Lambert Habeus
Corpus Appeal REQUEST for HEARING by Appellant, Stanley J. Caterbone Dated
October 26, 2015 RECORDED Copy With TOC - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text file (.txt) or read book online for free. Case No. 15-3400 U.S. Third Circuit Court of
Appeals re: Lisa Michelle Lambert Habeus Corpus Appeal REQUEST for HEARING by
Appellant, Stanley J. Caterbone Dated October 26, 2015 RECORDED Copy With TOC
Excelsior Business Plan 1999
Excelsior Business Plan 1999 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or view
presentation slides online. Excelsior Business Plan Aug 18 1999
Lisa Michelle Lambert MOTION to File STATEMENT by Movant Case No. 5-14-Cv-02259
August 25, 2015
Stan Caterbone Football Scrapbook Senior Year Season 1975 June 24 2007 Created by Yolanda
Caterbone
Stan Caterbone - Samuel P. Caterbone - Sammy a. Caterbone Notarized AFFIDAVIT of U.S.
Sponsored Mind Control August 18, 2015
Advanced Media Group's Lancaster County Historical Society-History of Italian American
History-2
Advanced Media Group's Lancaster County Historical Society-History of Italian American
History-2 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free.
Advanced Media Group's Lancaster County Historical Society-History of Italian American
History-2
Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT of Computer Expertise by
Appellant November 2, 2015
Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT of Computer
Expertise by Appellant November 2, 2015 - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text
file (.txt) or read book online for free. Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION
Statement as EXHIBIT of Computer Expertise by Appellant November 2, 2015
Stan Caterbone and ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP 16 Year Investment in Downtown Lancaster
November 1, 2015
Stan Caterbone and ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP 16 Year Investment in Downtown
Lancaster November 1, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read
online for free. Stan Caterbone and ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP 16 Year Investment in
Downtown Lancaster November 1, 2015
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 197
159 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 970
Page
of 2413
971 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement Re EXHIBITStan Caterbone
and ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP 16 Year Investment in Downtown Lancaster November 3,
2015
Recorded Updated Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT of
Computer Expertise With Video Links by Appellant November 3, 2015
Recorded Updated Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT of
Computer Expertise With Video Links by Appellant November 3, 2015 - Free ebook
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read book online for free. Recorded Updated
Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT of Computer
Expertise by Appellant Stan J. Caterbone November 3, 2015
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal UPDATED SUBMISSION Statement as an EXHIBIT
Re Incendent Reports of Obstruction of Due Process November 4, 2015
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal UPDATED SUBMISSION Statement as an
EXHIBIT Re Incendent Reports of Obstruction of Due Process November 4, 2015 - Free
ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read book online for free. Recorded
Third Circuit Lambert Appeal UPDATED SUBMISSION Statement as an EXHIBIT Re
Incendent Reports of Obstruction of Due Process November 4, 2015
Letter to US Postal Inspection Services Sept 19 2007 With Lancaster Chamber Check for
Leadership Conference November 3, 2015
TransportRoom
Lancaster Chamber & Obama on Duke Street
Duke Street Business Center 08-13373 Reinstatement and DEFENDANTS Lancaster
Chamber of Commerce and Industry, October 8, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Duke Street Business Center 08-13373 Reinstatement
and DEFENDANTS Lancaster Chamber of Commerce and Industry, October 8, 2015
SONY-POWER STATION Joint Venture Proposal & Deal May 1987
Recorded Completed 15-3400 Third Circuit Court of Appeals Documents ORDER and in Forma
Pauperis Application November 4, 2015
Recorded Completed 15-3400 Third Circuit Court of Appeals Documents ORDER and in
Forma Pauperis Application November 4, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text
file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded Completed 15-3400 Third Circuit Court of
Appeals Documents ORDER and in Forma Pauperis Application November 4, 2015
Tabitha Buck and Lisa Michelle Lambert Working Theory August 10, 2015
Advanced Media Group Downtown Lancaster Theater at Hotel Brunswick Evidence December
26, 2009 Important
Advanced Media Group Downtown Lancaster Theater at Hotel Brunswick Evidence
December 26, 2009 Important - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read
online for free. Advanced Media Group Downtown Lancaster Theater at Hotel Brunswick
Evidence December 26, 2009 Important
15-3400 Third Circuit Court of Appeals DOCKET and Letter to Lancaster County District
Attorney Re Electronic Filing November 5, 2015
15-3400 Third Circuit Court of Appeals DOCKET and Letter to Lancaster County District
Attorney Re Electronic Filing November 5, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text
file (.txt) or read online for free. 15-3400 Third Circuit Court of Appeals DOCKET and
Letter to Lancaster County District Attorney Re Electronic Filing November 5, 2015
Advanced Media Group Invoices 1990-1991 Oct 26 2006 for Dale High and High Industries
Advanced Media Group Invoices 1990-1991 Oct 26 2006 for Dale High and High
Industries - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free.
Advanced Media Group Invoices 1990-1991 Oct 26 2006 for Dale High and High
Industries
Advanced Media Group v Lancaster Film Commission June 9, 2008
Advanced Media Group v Lancaster Film Commission June 9, 2008 - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or view presentation slides online. Advanced Media Group
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 198
160 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 971
Page
of 2413
972 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
v Lancaster Film Commission June 9, 2008
ORIGINAL With DETAILES Advanced Media Group Aged Receivables With Invoices May 13
2007
ORIGINAL With DETAILES Advanced Media Group Aged Receivables With Invoices
May 13 2007 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free.
ORIGINAL With DETAILES Advanced Media Group Aged Receivables With Invoices
May 13 2007
Former director of Lancaster Film Commission says position ruined him financially | News |
lancasteronline.com
The defunct Lancaster Film Commission was developed to draw filmmakers and the money
they and their crews would spend to the area.
1915 MDA 2015 DOCKET Statement Re Petition for Review November 5, 2015
1915 MDA 2015 DOCKET Statement Re Petition for Review November 5, 2015 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. 1915 MDA 2015
DOCKET Statement Re Petition for Review November 5, 2015
Amazon.com: Mac Rutherford: Books
Online shopping from a great selection at Books Store.
Superior Court MDA 1561 LETTER to Judge Wright Re Missing Items November 5, 2015
Superior Court MDA 1561 LETTER to Judge Wright Re Missing Items November 5, 2015
- Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Superior Court
MDA 1561 LETTER to Judge Wright Re Missing Items November 5, 2015
Superior Court MDA 1561 Briefing Schedule Order November 5, 2015
Superior Court MDA 1561 Briefing Schedule Order November 5, 2015 - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Superior Court MDA 1561 Briefing
Schedule Order November 5, 2015
Mac Rutherford Luckees Elbow Room of Lancaster PA Project November 5, 2015
Mac Rutherford Luckees Elbow Room of Lancaster PA Project November 5, 2015 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Mac Rutherford
Luckees Elbow Room of Lancaster PA Project November 5, 2015
Finance Calculator
Free finance calculator! You can define any of the FV, PMT, I/Y, N, and starting
investment to calculate the others. Also find hundreds of other free online calculators here.
Its Always the Same War - Truthdig
Barack Obama originally ran for president as the anti-war candidate. Now, as his second
term winds down, the two George W. Bush/Obama wars are winding up, with a third in
Syria. - 2015/11/04
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement Re EXHIBIT Advanced
Media Group and Stan J Caterbone PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS as of November 6,
2015
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement Re EXHIBIT Advanced
Media Group and Stan J Caterbone PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS as of
November 6, 2015 - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read book
online for free. Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement Re
EXHIBIT Advanced Media Group and Stan J Caterbone PROFESSIONAL
QUALIFICATIONS as of November 6, 2015
recorded 15-3400 Third Circuit Lambert Court of Appeal MOTION for Considerations Re
Advanced Media Group Pro Se Billings and Sales Journal From Jauuary 1, 2007 to August 31,
2008 November 9, 2015
recorded 15-3400 Third Circuit Lambert Court of Appeal MOTION for Considerations Re
Advanced Media Group Pro Se Billings and Sales Journal From Jauuary 1, 2007 to August
31, 2008 November 9, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read
online for free. recorded 15-3400 Third Circuit Lambert Court of Appeal MOTION for
Considerations Re Advanced Media Group Pro Se Billings and Sales Journal From Jauuary
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 199
161 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 972
Page
of 2413
973 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
1, 2007 to August 31, 2008 November 9, 2015
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as an EXHIBIT Re Advanced
Media Group and Stan J Caterbone Audio File of Authentic Recordings of 1987 and 1991
November 9, 2015
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as an EXHIBIT Re
Advanced Media Group and Stan J Caterbone Audio File of Authentic Recordings of 1987
and 1991 November 9, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read
online for free. Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as an
EXHIBIT Re Advanced Media Group and Stan J Caterbone Audio File of Authentic
Recordings of 1987 and 1991 November 9, 2015
U.S. District Court Case No. 08-02982 CATERBONE v City of Lancaster Bureau of Police July
2008
U.S. District Court Case No. 08-02982 CATERBONE v City of Lancaster Bureau of Police
July 2008 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. U.S.
District Court Case No. 08-02982 CATERBONE v City of Lancaster Bureau of Police July
2008
Letter to Mike Caterbone Re Response to Email and Lancaster County Ready to Work Graduate
Certification With Job Applications April 2, 2008
Geeg Squad Lenevo Laptop Drop Off November 10, 2015
15-3400 Lambert U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals DOCKET for APPELLANT Stan J.
Caterbone, Pro Se in the LISA MICHELLE LAMBERT Case as MOVANT as of November 10,
2015
15-3400 Lambert U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals DOCKET for APPELLANT Stan J.
Caterbone, Pro Se in the LISA MICHELLE LAMBERT Case as MOVANT as of
November 10, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for
free. 15-3400 Lambert U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals DOCKET for APPELLANT
Stan J. Caterbone, Pro Se in the LISA MICHELLE LAMBERT Case as MOVANT as of
November 10, 2015
Problem Homes of 1200 Block of Fremont Street, Lancaster, PA November 11, 2015
Thomas P. Caterbone Obituary May 1 1996
Thomas P. Caterbone Obituary May 1 1996 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read
online for free. Thomas P. Caterbone Obituary May 1 1996
Judge Mary McLaughlin Order and Memorandum June 13 2006
Judge Mary McLaughlin Order and Memorandum June 13 2006 - Free download as PDF
File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Judge Mary McLaughlin Order and
Memorandum June 13 2006
Letter to Kathleen Kane Re Old Boys Network of November 12, 2015
Letter to Kathleen Kane Re Old Boys Network of November 12, 2015 - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Letter to Kathleen Kane Re Old
Boys Network of November 12, 2015
INCIDENT REPORTS to PALCB Office of General Counsel November 12, 2015
INCIDENT REPORTS to PALCB Office of General Counsel November 12, 2015 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. INCIDENT REPORTS
to PALCB Office of General Counsel with Executive Summary November 12, 2015
Superior Court 1915 MDA 2015 Peitition for Review DOCKETING STATEMENT of
November 12, 2015
Superior Court 1915 MDA 2015 Peitition for Review DOCKETING STATEMENT of
November 12, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. Superior
Court 1915 MDA 2015 Peitition for Review DOCKETING STATEMENT of November
12, 2015
Photos and Documents Re Trip to Harrisburg Pa to Superior Court, General Counsel of PLCB,
And Office of Kathleen Kane on November 12, 2015
Photos and Documents Re Trip to Harrisburg Pa to Superior Court, General Counsel of
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 200
162 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 973
Page
of 2413
974 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
PLCB, And Office of Kathleen Kane on November 12, 2015 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Photos and Documents Re Trip to Harrisburg
Pa to Superior Court, General Counsel of PLCB, And Office of Kathleen Kane on
November 12, 2015
Samuel Caterbone Personal Files From New York June 18, 2015
Samuel Caterbone Personal Files From New York June 18, 2015 - Free download as PDF
File (.pdf) or read online for free. Samuel Caterbone Personal Files From New York June
18, 2015
James Guerin, ISC, Joseph Tate, Chris Underhill, William Clark, Joe Roda, Fulton Bank, Scooter
Libby and CIA Operative Valerie Plame with Direct Ties to Lancaster and Stan J. Caterbone
November 13, 2015
James Guerin, ISC, Joseph Tate, Chris Underhill, William Clark, Joe Roda, Fulton Bank,
Scooter Libby and CIA Operative Valerie Plame with Direct Ties to Lancaster and Stan J.
Caterbone November 13, 2015 - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or
read book online for free. James Guerin, ISC, Joseph Tate, Chris Underhill, William Clark,
Joe Roda, Fulton Bank, Scooter Libby and CIA Operative Valerie Plame with Direct Ties
to Lancaster and Stan J. Caterbone November 13, 2015
TD Ameritrade Fulton Financial Transaction History Own 7 Shares - Bought 2 Shares on July 11,
2006 and Bought 2 Shares on September 17, 2015
TD Ameritrade Fulton Financial Transaction History Own 7 Shares - Bought 2 Shares on
July 11, 2006 and Bought 2 Shares on September 17, 2015 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or view presentation slides online. TD Ameritrade Fulton Financial
Transaction History Own 7 Shares - Bought 2 Shares on July 11, 2006 and Bought 2 Shares
on September 17, 2015
Had Lancaster County Lost It's Sovereignty Before It Lost It's Soul by Stan Caterbone, Authored
in May of 1998
Had Lancaster County Lost It's Sovereignty Before It Lost It's Soul by Stan Caterbone,
Authored in May of 1998 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online
for free. Had Lancaster County Lost It's Sovereignty Before It Lost It's Soul by Stan
Caterbone, Authored in May of 1998
Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT re Letter to Mike
Caterbone Re Response to Email and Lancaster County Ready to Work Graduate Certification
With Job Applications November 10, 2015
DocumeThird Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT re Letter to
Mike Caterbone Re Response to Email and Lancaster County Ready to Work Graduate
Certification With Job Applications November 10, 2015 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. DocumeThird Circuit Lambert Appeal
SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT re Letter to Mike Caterbone Re Response to Email
and Lancaster County Ready to Work Graduate Certification With Job Applications
November 10, 2015
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as an EXHIBIT Re
Linkedin.com Restricted Access and Computer Hacking Documentation November 16, 2015
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as an EXHIBIT Re
Linkedin.com Restricted Access and Computer Hacking Documentation November 16,
2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded
Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as an EXHIBIT Re Linkedin.com
Restricted Access and Computer Hacking Documentation November 16, 2015
Letter From Kathleen Kane Re Good Old Boys November 13, 2015
Letter From Kathleen Kane Re Good Old Boys November 13, 2015 - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. Letter From Kathleen Kane Re Good Old Boys
November 13, 2015
Recorded 3rd Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT Re Important
Documents From 1987 Supporting Claims and Estimate of Monetary Damages and Intellectual
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 201
163 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 974
Page
of 2413
975 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Property Rights November 17, 2005
Recorded 3rd Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT Re Important
Documents From 1987 Supporting Claims and Estimate of Monetary Damages and
Intellectual Property Rights November 17, 2005 - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text file (.txt) or read book online for free. Recorded 3rd Circuit Lambert Appeal
SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT Re Important Documents From 1987 Supporting
Claims and Estimate of Monetary Damages and Intellectual Property Rights November 17,
2005
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT Re 806
Authentic Original Documents From 1983 to 2006, November 18, 2015
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT Re 806
Authentic Original Documents From 1983 to 2006, November 18, 2015 - Free ebook
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read book online for free. Recorded Third
Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT Re 806 Authentic Original
Documents From 1983 to 2006, November 18, 2015
Complaint Re Courthouse Employees - Letter to Judicial Council 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals
and Joseph Massa of the Judicial Conduct Reveiw Board April 26 2007
Complaint Re Courthouse Employees - Letter to Judicial Council 3rd Circuit Court of
Appeals and Joseph Massa of the Judicial Conduct Reveiw Board April 26 2007 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Complaint Re
Courthouse Employees - Letter to Judicial Council 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals and Joseph
Massa of the Judicial Conduct Reveiw Board April 26 2007
recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT re Complaint Re
Courthouse Employees and Prosecutorial and Judicial Misconduct Towards APPELLANT Stan
J. Caterbone Dating Back to 1987, November 19, 2015
recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT re
Complaint Re Courthouse Employees and Prosecutorial and Judicial Misconduct Towards
APPELLANT Stan J. Caterbone Dating Back to 1987, November 19, 2015 - Free ebook
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read book online for free. recorded Third
Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT re Complaint Re
Courthouse Employees and Prosecutorial and Judicial Misconduct Towards APPELLANT
Stan J. Caterbone Dating Back to 1987, November 19, 2015
Stan J. Caterbon's Legal Formation Documents for Financial Management Group, Ltd., Or FMG,
Ltd. in 1986
CIA NO TOUCH TORTURE Makes Sense Out of Mind Control Allegations by Cheryl Welsh
January 2008
recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT re Complaint to
General Counsel of PLCB and Letter to and From Kathleen Kane on November 21, 2015
recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT re
Complaint to General Counsel of PLCB and Letter to and From Kathleen Kane on
November 21, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for
free. recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT re
Complaint to General Counsel of PLCB and Letter to and From Kathleen Kane on
November 21, 2015
Advanced Media Group Press Release Re Stalking Legislation With Executive Summary
November 21, 2015
Advanced Media Group Press Release Re Stalking Legislation With Executive Summary
November 21, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for
free. Advanced Media Group Press Release Re Stalking Legislation With Executive
Summary November 21, 2015
Dave Pflumm Arrest Record of 2004 Possesion of Marijuana IS DAVE PFLUMM A
Confidential Informant?
Dave Pflumm Arrest Record of 2004 Possesion of Marijuana IS DAVE PFLUMM A
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 202
164 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 975
Page
of 2413
976 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Confidential Informant? - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online
for free. Dave Pflumm Arrest Record of 2004 Possesion of Marijuana IS DAVE PFLUMM
A Confidential Informant?
September 21 1987 ISC In $1-5 Billion Dollar Merger November 22, 2015
September 21 1987 ISC In $1-5 Billion Dollar Merger November 22, 2015 - Free download
as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or view presentation slides online. September 21 1987
ISC In $1-5 Billion Dollar Merger November 22, 2015
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal MOTION for CONTINUANCE, November 22, 2015
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal MOTION for CONTINUANCE, November 22,
2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or view presentation slides online.
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal MOTION for CONTINUANCE, November 22,
2015
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT Re FACEBOOK
Postings From July 29 to November 22, 2015 Establishing State of Mind and Daily Activities Re
Stalking and Harassment, November 22, 2015
Recorded Third Circuit Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT Re
FACEBOOK Postings From July 29 to November 22, 2015 Establishing State of Mind and
Daily Activities Re Stalking and Harassment, November 22, 2015 - Free ebook download
as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read book online for free. Recorded Third Circuit
Lambert Appeal SUBMISSION Statement as EXHIBIT Re FACEBOOK Postings From
July 29 to November 22, 2015 Establishing State of Mind and Daily Activities Re Stalking
and Harassment, November 22, 2015
Conducting-Shadow-Wars CIA by F&M Professor
Conducting-Shadow-Wars CIA by F&M Professor - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Conducting-Shadow-Wars CIA by F&M Professor
Stan Caterbone - Samuel P. Caterbone - Sammy A. Caterbone Notarized AFFIDAVIT of U.S.
Sponsored Mind Control August 18, 2015
CI-15-10167 Lancaster County Court MOTION to WITHDRAW WITHOUT PREJUDICE Re
Caterbone v Brunswick-Fitzwater-Lancaster Film November 24, 2015
CI-15-10167 Lancaster County Court MOTION to WITHDRAW WITHOUT PREJUDICE
Re Caterbone v Brunswick-Fitzwater-Lancaster Film November 24, 2015 - Free download
as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. CI-15-10167 Lancaster County
Court MOTION to WITHDRAW WITHOUT PREJUDICE Re Caterbone v Brunswick-
Fitzwater-Lancaster Film November 24, 2015
CI-15-10167 Lancaster County Court MOTION for Leave to File in Forma Pauperis Caterbone v
Brunswick-Fitzwater-Lancaster Film November 24, 2015
FACEBOOK Postings From the First Day July 29 to November 24, 2015
FACEBOOK Postings From the First Day July 29 to November 24, 2015 - Free ebook
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read book online for free. FACEBOOK
Postings From the First Day July 29 to November 24, 2015
Third Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal ORDER Appellant Stan J. Caterbone Motion for
Continuance GRANTED November 24, 2015
United Nations Human Rights Council of Geneva Switzerland Complaint and Exhibit October 4,
2009.pdf
United Nations Human Rights Council of Geneva Switzerland Complaint and Exhibit
October 4, 2009.pdf - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf) or read book online for free.
Letters From US Department of Justice Civil Rights Division Re Email Complaints November
24, 2015
Letters From US Department of Justice Civil Rights Division Re Email Complaints
November 24, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. Letters
From US Department of Justice Civil Rights Division Re Email Complaints November 24,
2015
STATEMENT of MATTERS COMPLAINED Re Private Criminal Complaint v. Lancaster City
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 203
165 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 976
Page
of 2413
977 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Police 1108-2015 November 25, 2015
STATEMENT of MATTERS COMPLAINED Re Private Criminal Complaint v. Lancaster
City Police 1108-2015 November 25, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file
(.txt) or read online for free. STATEMENT of MATTERS COMPLAINED Re Private
Criminal Complaint v. Lancaster City Police 1108-2015 November 25, 2015
FBI IC3 Complaints of June 2015 Naming Dave Pflumm and Brett Stabley and Brochures
November 26, 2015
FBI IC3 Complaints of June 2015 Naming Dave Pflumm and Brett Stabley and Brochures
November 26, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for
free. FBI IC3 Complaints of June 2015 Naming Dave Pflumm and Brett Stabley and
Brochures November 26, 2015
July 6, 2015 Trip to PA Attorney General, PA Legislators and FBI in Harrisburg PA November
26, 2015
July 6, 2015 Trip to PA Attorney General, PA Legislators and FBI in Harrisburg PA
November 26, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or view presentation slides online.
July 6, 2015 Trip to PA Attorney General, PA Legislators and FBI in Harrisburg PA
November 26, 2015
Obstruction of Due Process in the Filing of 1108-2015 and Superior Court Case No. 1915-2015
Statement of Matters Complained on November 25, 2015
Obstruction of Due Process in the Filing of 1108-2015 and Superior Court Case No. 1915-
2015 Statement of Matters Complained on November 25, 2015 - Free download as PDF
File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Obstruction of Due Process in the Filing
of 1108-2015 and Superior Court Case No. 1915-2015 Statement of Matters Complained
on November 25, 2015
Chapter 11 Reorganization Plan for Case No. Case 05-23059 Filed January 12, 2010.pdf
Chapter 11 Reorganization Plan for Case No. Case 05-23059 Filed January 12, 2010.pdf -
Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free.
Recorded 3rd Circuit EXHIBIT Re Chapter 11 Reorganization Plan for Case No. 05-23059 and
50 Million Dollar Valuation Filed January 12, 2010, November 27, 2015
Recorded 3rd Circuit EXHIBIT Re Chapter 11 Reorganization Plan for Case No. 05-23059
and 50 Million Dollar Valuation Filed January 12, 2010, November 27, 2015 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded 3rd Circuit
EXHIBIT Re Chapter 11 Reorganization Plan for Case No. 05-23059 and 50 Million
Dollar Valuation Filed January 12, 2010, November 27, 2015
Judge Jeffrey Wright OPINION as Ordered by Superior Court in Case No. 1561 MDA 2015 on
November 23, 2015 for Emergency Injunction Case No. 15-06985
Judge Jeffrey Wright OPINION as Ordered by Superior Court in Case No. 1561 MDA
2015 on November 23, 2015 for Emergency Injunction Case No. 15-06985 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. Judge Jeffrey Wright OPINION as
Ordered by Superior Court in Case No. 1561 MDA 2015 on November 23, 2015 for
Emergency Injunction Case No. 15-06985
Recorded 3rd Circuit EXHIBIT Re Affidavit of APPELLANT Stanley J. Caterbone Re Judge
Diamond Misconduct, November 28, 2015
Recorded 3rd Circuit EXHIBIT Re Affidavit of APPELLANT Stanley J. Caterbone Re
Judge Diamond Misconduct, November 28, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text
file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded 3rd Circuit EXHIBIT Re Affidavit of
APPELLANT Stanley J. Caterbone Re Judge Diamond Misconduct, November 28, 2015
Recorded 3rd Circuit AFFIDAVITS of APPELLANT Stanley J. Caterbone Re Judge Diamond
and Jeremy H.G. Ibrahim, Sr., Esq Misconduct, November 28, 2015
Recorded 3rd Circuit AFFIDAVITS of APPELLANT Stanley J. Caterbone Re Judge
Diamond and Jeremy H.G. Ibrahim, Sr., Esq Misconduct, November 28, 2015 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. Recorded 3rd Circuit AFFIDAVITS of
APPELLANT Stanley J. Caterbone Re Judge Diamond and Jeremy H.G. Ibrahim, Sr., Esq
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 204
166 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 977
Page
of 2413
978 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Misconduct, November 28, 2015
06-Cv-05012 Third Circuit BRIEF Authored and Filed by APPELLANT Stan J. Caterbone Re
Bankruptcy Case July 2, 2010
06-Cv-05012 Third Circuit BRIEF Authored and Filed by APPELLANT Stan J. Caterbone
Re Bankruptcy Case July 2, 2010 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or
read online for free. 06-Cv-05012 Third Circuit BRIEF Authored and Filed by
APPELLANT Stan J. Caterbone Re Bankruptcy Case July 2, 2010
14-02259 Lambert Habeus MOTION to Recuse Judge Paul Diamond November 29, 2015
14-02259 Lambert Habeus MOTION to Recuse Judge Paul Diamond November 29, 2015 -
Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. 14-02259 Lambert
Habeus MOTION to Recuse Judge Paul Diamond November 29, 2015
Breaking News - Pete Anders on Payroll of Benecon in Caterbone v. Copy Max and Sam
Lombardo CI-07-03924 Case File April 7, 2009 With November 28, 2015 Millersville Review
Breaking News - Pete Anders on Payroll of Benecon in Caterbone v. Copy Max and Sam
Lombardo CI-07-03924 Case File April 7, 2009 With November 28, 2015 Millersville
Review - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read book online for
free. Breaking News - Pete Anders on Payroll of Benecon in Caterbone v. Copy Max and
Sam Lombardo CI-07-03924 Case File April 7, 2009 With November 28, 2015 Millersville
Review
Sam Lombardo and Raolph Mazzochi Charlotte Street Proposal by Advanced Media Group and
Stan J. Caterbone March 10 2007
Sam Lombardo and Raolph Mazzochi Charlotte Street Proposal by Advanced Media Group
and Stan J. Caterbone March 10 2007 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or
read online for free. Sam Lombardo and Raolph Mazzochi Charlotte Street Proposal by
Advanced Media Group and Stan J. Caterbone March 10 2007
Recorded 3rd Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re U.S. District Court Case No. 14-
02559 Judge Diamond Motion to Recuse, November 29, 2015
Recorded 3rd Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re U.S. District Court Case No.
14-02559 Judge Diamond Motion to Recuse, November 29, 2015 - Free download as PDF
File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded 3rd Circuit 15-3400 Lambert
Appeal EXHIBIT Re U.S. District Court Case No. 14-02559 Judge Diamond Motion to
Recuse, November 29, 2015
1108-2015 Superior Court 1915-MDA-2015 STATEMENT of MATTERS COMPLAINED Re
Private Criminal Complaint v. Lancaster City Police 1108-2015 November 25, 2015
1108-2015 Superior Court 1915-MDA-2015 STATEMENT of MATTERS COMPLAINED
Re Private Criminal Complaint v. Lancaster City Police 1108-2015 November 25, 2015 -
Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. 1108-2015
Superior Court 1915-MDA-2015 STATEMENT of MATTERS COMPLAINED Re Private
Criminal Complaint v. Lancaster City Police 1108-2015 November 25, 2015
Recorded 3rd Circuit EXHIBIT Re LNP Article Rogue FBI Agents in Lancaster Killing US
Attorney on February 27, 2007 Are the Still Here - Of Course They Are, November 30, 2015
Recorded 3rd Circuit EXHIBIT Re LNP Article Rogue FBI Agents in Lancaster Killing US
Attorney on February 27, 2007 Are the Still Here - Of Course They Are, November 30,
2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded
3rd Circuit EXHIBIT Re LNP Article Rogue FBI Agents in Lancaster Killing US Attorney
on February 27, 2007 Are the Still Here - Of Course They Are, November 30, 2015
Samuell Caterbone Jr Writings as Evidence of MKULTRA Dates of 1957 and 1943 December 1,
2015
Samuell Caterbone Jr Writings as Evidence of MKULTRA Dates of 1957 and 1943
December 1, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. Samuell
Caterbone Jr Writings as Evidence of MKULTRA Dates of 1957 and 1943 December 1,
2015
Suspicious Charactars Caught on Camera on My Security System on May 29, 2006
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 205
167 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 978
Page
of 2413
979 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
FACEBOOK Postings From July 29 to December 1, 2015
FACEBOOK Postings From July 29 to December 1, 2015 - Free ebook download as PDF
File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read book online for free. FACEBOOK Postings From July 29
to December 1, 2015
ISA Computer Installation 37,000 and 38 Per Hour Proposal for Dave Pflumm Paving and
Excavating March of 1989
ISA Computer Installation 37,000 and 38 Per Hour Proposal for Dave Pflumm Paving and
Excavating March of 1989 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read
online for free. ISA Computer Installation 37,000 and 38 Per Hour Proposal for Dave
Pflumm Paving and Excavating March of 1989
Stan J. Caterbon's LEASE AGREEMENT to 1755 Oregon Pike and Other Documents for
Financial Management Group, Ltd., Or FMG, Ltd. in 1986
Recorded 3rd Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT re Outstanding Receivables with Pro
Se Billings To Date of 4,295,443.24, December 2, 2015
Recorded 3rd Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT re Outstanding Receivables with
Pro Se Billings To Date of 4,295,443.24, December 2, 2015 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded 3rd Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal
EXHIBIT re Outstanding Receivables with Pro Se Billings To Date of 4,295,443.24,
December 2, 2015
Letter to Lancaster City Chief of Police Sam Gatshell June 25 2007
Letter to Lancaster City Chief of Police Sam Gatshell June 25 2007 - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Letter to Lancaster City Chief of
Police Sam Gatshell June 25 2007
Third Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal Docket With Summaries of ALL Recorded Filings as of
December 2, 2015
Third Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal Docket With Summaries of ALL Recorded Filings
as of December 2, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online
for free. Third Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal Docket With Summaries of ALL Recorded
Filings as of December 2, 2015
FACEBOOK Updated Links with Documents and Videos December 3, 2015 (will work from
clicking on this document)
FACEBOOK Updated Links with Documents and Videos December 3, 2015 (will work
from clicking on this document) - Free download as Word Doc (.doc), PDF File (.pdf), Text
file (.txt) or read online for free. FACEBOOK Updated Links with Documents and Videos
December 3, 2015 (will work from clicking on this document)
FACEBOOK Postings From July 29 to December 5, 2015
FACEBOOK Postings From July 29 to December 5, 2015 - Free ebook download as PDF
File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read book online for free. FACEBOOK Postings From July 29
to December 5, 2015
Lancaster County DA Releases Report on Fatal Police Shooting of Mentally Ill Man on North
Queen Street in 2013
Southeast Clinic Physical Invoice December 3, 2015
Southeast Clinic Physical Invoice December 3, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or
read online for free. Southeast Clinic Physical Invoice December 3, 2015
Recorded 3rd Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re Notes - Cards - Receipts From
Lobby Efforts in PA Legislature 2015 December 6, 2015 w DOCKET
Recorded 3rd Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re Notes - Cards - Receipts
From Lobby Efforts in PA Legislature 2015 December 6, 2015 w DOCKET - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded 3rd Circuit
15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re Notes - Cards - Receipts From Lobby Efforts in PA
Legislature 2015 December 6, 2015 w DOCKET
United States District Court Eastern District of Pennsylvania Stan Caterbone Amicus Filed as
MOVANT in the Lisa Michelle Lambert Habeus Corpus Case DOCKET 14-Cv-02559 December
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 206
168 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 979
Page
of 2413
980 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
6, 2015
United States District Court Eastern District of Pennsylvania Stan Caterbone Amicus Filed
as MOVANT in the Lisa Michelle Lambert Habeus Corpus Case DOCKET 14-Cv-02559
December 6, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for
free. United States District Court Eastern District of Pennsylvania Stan Caterbone Amicus
Filed as MOVANT in the Lisa Michelle Lambert Habeus Corpus Case DOCKET 14-Cv-
02559 December 6, 2015
Question and Answer From Terry Robertson of Jim Guest Show Re is Mind Control Legal?
December 1, 2009
Question and Answer From Terry Robertson of Jim Guest Show Re is Mind Control Legal?
December 1, 2009 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for
free. Question and Answer From Terry Robertson of Jim Guest Show Re is Mind Control
Legal? December 1, 2009
Recorded and Docketed 14-02259 Lambert Habeus MOTION to Recuse Judge Paul Diamond
November 29, 2015 Docketed on December 7, 2015 (Small)
Recorded and Docketed 14-02259 Lambert Habeus MOTION to Recuse Judge Paul
Diamond November 29, 2015 Docketed on December 7, 2015 (Small) - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded and Docketed 14-02259
Lambert Habeus MOTION to Recuse Judge Paul Diamond November 29, 2015 Docketed
on December 7, 2015 (Small)
Recorded Copy1561 MDA 2015 Superior Court BRIEF re Preliminary Emergency Injunction v.
Lancaster Residents December 7, 2015
Recorded Copy1561 MDA 2015 Superior Court BRIEF re Preliminary Emergency
Injunction v. Lancaster Residents December 7, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded Copy1561 MDA 2015 Superior Court
BRIEF re Preliminary Emergency Injunction v. Lancaster Residents December 7, 2015
Filed Copy1561 MDA 2015 Superior Court LETTER Re Brief or Oral Argument Form Due by
Dec 27, 2015 - December 7, 2015
Filed Copy1561 MDA 2015 Superior Court LETTER Re Brief or Oral Argument Form
Due by Dec 27, 2015 - December 7, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file
(.txt) or read online for free. Filed Copy1561 MDA 2015 Superior Court LETTER Re Brief
or Oral Argument Form Due by Dec 27, 2015 - December 7, 2015
EBay Order Details Verizon 5 64gb Delivered on December 7, 2015 as a T-Mobile Phone Will
Have To Send Back - They Just Don't Want Me Taking Good Pictures
Recorded 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re in Forma Pauperis FRAUD by the Judiciary of
the Lancaster County Courts, The U.S. District Court, And the PA Superior Court, December 8,
2015
Recorded 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re in Forma Pauperis FRAUD by the
Judiciary of the Lancaster County Courts, The U.S. District Court, And the PA Superior
Court, December 8, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online
for free. Recorded 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re in Forma Pauperis FRAUD by
the Judiciary of the Lancaster County Courts, The U.S. District Court, And the PA Superior
Court, December 8, 2015
ACCIDENT REPORT by Hampden Twp Police Officer Robert Higgens Incident No.
20151200340 of December 8, 2015
ACCIDENT REPORT by Hampden Twp Police Officer Robert Higgens Incident No.
20151200340 of December 8, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or view
presentation slides online. ACCIDENT REPORT by Hampden Twp Police Officer Robert
Higgens Incident No. 20151200340 of December 8, 2015
CONFIRMATION OF IPHONE HACKING - eBay iPhone 5 64GB Delivered on December 7,
2015 as a T-Mobile Phone Instead of a Verizon Phone as Shipped December 8, 2015
CONFIRMATION OF IPHONE HACKING - eBay iPhone 5 64GB Delivered on
December 7, 2015 as a T-Mobile Phone Instead of a Verizon Phone as Shipped December
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 207
169 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 980
Page
of 2413
981 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
8, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free.
CONFIRMATION OF IPHONE HACKING - eBay iPhone 5 64GB Delivered on
December 7, 2015 as a T-Mobile Phone Instead of a Verizon Phone as Shipped December
8, 2015
Recorded Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus to US District Court Judge
Joyner in Case No. 15-03984 December 10, 2015
Recorded Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus to US District Court
Judge Joyner in Case No. 15-03984 December 10, 2015 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ
of Habeus Corpus to US District Court Judge Joyner in Case No. 15-03984 December 10,
2015
Screamin Daisies Guestbook Page with My Comments December 28, 2007
Screamin Daisies Guestbook Page with My Comments December 28, 2007 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Screamin Daisies
Guestbook Page with My Comments December 28, 2007
Recorded 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re Copy of Clerk Recorded Petitioner Stanley J.
Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus to US District Court Judge Curtis Joyner in Case No. 15-
03984 Dec10, 2015 - December 12, 2015
Recorded 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re Copy of Clerk Recorded Petitioner
Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus to US District Court Judge Curtis Joyner in
Case No. 15-03984 Dec10, 2015 - December 12, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re
Copy of Clerk Recorded Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus to US
District Court Judge Curtis Joyner in Case No. 15-03984 Dec10, 2015 - December 12, 2015
Apology by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group of December 11, 2015
Apology by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group of December 11, 2015 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Apology by Stan J.
Caterbone and Advanced Media Group of December 11, 2015
ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION OF MENTAL ILLNESS DIAGNOSIS AND SYMPTOMS of
December 14, 2015
ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION OF MENTAL ILLNESS DIAGNOSIS AND
SYMPTOMS of December 14, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or
read online for free. ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION OF MENTAL ILLNESS
DIAGNOSIS AND SYMPTOMS of December 14, 2015
Recorded 15-3400 Lambert Appeal MOTION to DISMISS December 14, 2015
Recorded 15-3400 Lambert Appeal MOTION to DISMISS December 14, 2015 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded 15-3400
Lambert Appeal MOTION to DISMISS December 14, 2015
Patent First Medical File for December 12, 2015
Patent First Medical File for December 12, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read
online for free. Patent First Medical File for December 12, 2015
Kane Aide Files Wrongful Termination Suit Against Her in Philly.com December 14, 2015
Kane Aide Files Wrongful Termination Suit Against Her in Philly.com December 14, 2015
- Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Kane Aide Files
Wrongful Termination Suit Against Her in Philly.com December 14, 2015
Kane Story Comment of December 15, 2015
Kane Story Comment of December 15, 2015 - Free download as Open Office file (.odt),
PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Kane Story Comment of December
15, 2015
CP-36-MD-1108-2015 Petition for Review OPINION of MEMORANDUM Judge Reinaker
December 9, 2015
CP-36-MD-1108-2015 Petition for Review OPINION of MEMORANDUM Judge
Reinaker December 9, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. CP-
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 208
170 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 981
Page
of 2413
982 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
36-MD-1108-2015 Petition for Review OPINION of MEMORANDUM Judge Reinaker
December 9, 2015
15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus STATEMENT Re Argument in
Opposition of Mental Illness Diagnosis, December 15, 2015
15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus STATEMENT Re
Argument in Opposition of Mental Illness Diagnosis, December 15, 2015 - Free download
as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. 15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J.
Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus STATEMENT Re Argument in Opposition of Mental
Illness Diagnosis, December 15, 2015
15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus DOCKET as of December 16,
2015
15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus DOCKET as of
December 16, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for
free. 15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus DOCKET as of
December 16, 2015
15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT re Outstanding
Receivables with Pro Se Billings To Date of $4,295,443.24, December 16, 2015
15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT re
Outstanding Receivables with Pro Se Billings To Date of $4,295,443.24, December 16,
2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. 15-03984
Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT re Outstanding
Receivables with Pro Se Billings To Date of $4,295,443.24, December 16, 2015
15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re Open Letter to the
Editor of Newslanc.com Re Kathleen Kane and Old Boys Network December 15, 2015
15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re Open Letter
to the Editor of Newslanc.com Re Kathleen Kane and Old Boys Network December 15,
2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. 15-03984
Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re Open Letter to the
Editor of Newslanc.com Re Kathleen Kane and Old Boys Network December 15, 2015
15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re Argument in
Opposition of Mental Illness Diagnosis, December 15, 2015 (Small)
15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re Argument
in Opposition of Mental Illness Diagnosis, December 15, 2015 (Small) - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. 15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J.
Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re Argument in Opposition of Mental Illness
Diagnosis, December 15, 2015 (Small)
ESP & Mental Telepathy Research Documents Before I Learned my In-Depth Knowledge of
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control September 10, 2007
ESP & Mental Telepathy Research Documents Before I Learned my In-Depth Knowledge
of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control September 10, 2007 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text file (.txt) or read online for free. ESP & Mental Telepathy Research Documents
Before I Learned my In-Depth Knowledge of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control September 10,
2007
Clerk Recorded Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus to US District Court
Judge Joyner in Case No. 15-03984 December 16, 2015
Clerk Recorded Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus to US District
Court Judge Joyner in Case No. 15-03984 December 16, 2015 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Clerk Recorded Petitioner Stanley J.
Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus to US District Court Judge Joyner in Case No. 15-03984
December 16, 2015
Advanced Media Group Press Release Re Stalking Legislation With Executive Summary
December 17, 2015
Advanced Media Group Press Release Re Stalking Legislation With Executive Summary
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 209
171 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 982
Page
of 2413
983 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
December 17, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for
free. Advanced Media Group Press Release Re Stalking Legislation With Executive
Summary December 17, 2015
Lancaster General Hospital Medical Records of the 302 Mental Health Warrant of April 6, 2006
Lancaster General Hospital Medical Records of the 302 Mental Health Warrant of April 6,
2006 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. Lancaster General Hospital
Medical Records of the 302 Mental Health Warrant of April 6, 2006
Lancaster General Hospital No Trespass May 25, 2010
Lancaster General Hospital No Trespass May 25, 2010 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf)
or read online for free. Lancaster General Hospital No Trespass May 25, 2010
Kane family email surfaces in 'porngate' - and more NewsWorks
Say what? The twin sister and employee of Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane
herself traded nasty email, and sent one to Kane herself? That stunning revelation has
surfaced, one of...
Lancaster City Police PA Mental Health 302 Petition of Stanley J. Caterbone to Fairmount
Behavioral Health Systems as of April 21, 2010
Lancaster City Police PA Mental Health 302 Petition of Stanley J. Caterbone to Fairmount
Behavioral Health Systems as of April 21, 2010 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text
file (.txt) or read online for free. Lancaster City Police PA Mental Health 302 Petition of
Stanley J. Caterbone to Fairmount Behavioral Health Systems as of April 21, 2010
One of the Most Painful (Physical) Days Ever - April 2, 2010
One of the Most Painful (Physical) Days Ever - April 2, 2010 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. One of the Most Painful (Physical) Days Ever
- April 2, 2010
Recorded in 15-3400 Lambert Appeal as EXHIBIT of COMPLAINT to U.S. Attorney for the
Eastern District of Pennsylvania Re Fulton Bank Criminal Conspiracy December 19, 2015
Recorded in 15-3400 Lambert Appeal as EXHIBIT of COMPLAINT to U.S. Attorney for
the Eastern District of Pennsylvania Re Fulton Bank Criminal Conspiracy December 19,
2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded in
15-3400 Lambert Appeal as EXHIBIT of COMPLAINT to U.S. Attorney for the Eastern
District of Pennsylvania Re Fulton Bank Criminal Conspiracy December 19, 2015
Recorded 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re Samuel Caterbone Jr Evidence of MKULTRA
Dates of 1957 and 1943 December 19, 2015
Recorded 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re Samuel Caterbone Jr Evidence of
MKULTRA Dates of 1957 and 1943 December 19, 2015 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT
Re Samuel Caterbone Jr Evidence of MKULTRA Dates of 1957 and 1943 December 19,
2015
Last Meeting With Psychiatrist Dr. Al Shulz Transcript of January 1998 Important
Last Meeting With Psychiatrist Dr. Al Shulz Transcript of January 1998 Important - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Last Meeting With
Psychiatrist Dr. Al Shulz Transcript of January 1998 Important
ACCIDENT REPORT and STATEMENT With Hampden Twp Police Officer Robert Higgens
Incident REPORT No. 20151200340 of December 18, 2015
ACCIDENT REPORT and STATEMENT With Hampden Twp Police Officer Robert
Higgens Incident REPORT No. 20151200340 of December 18, 2015 - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. ACCIDENT REPORT and
STATEMENT With Hampden Twp Police Officer Robert Higgens Incident REPORT No.
20151200340 of December 18, 2015
Petition for Administrator of Thomas Caterbone 36-1996-0729 Jan 17 2008 Important
Petition for Administrator of Thomas Caterbone 36-1996-0729 Jan 17 2008 Important -
Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Petition for
Administrator of Thomas Caterbone 36-1996-0729 Jan 17 2008 Important
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 210
172 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 983
Page
of 2413
984 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
1987 Burdette Tomlin Hospital Medical Records with Jim Warner Calling Stone Harbor Police -
Phony Suicide Allegation
1987 Burdette Tomlin Hospital Medical Records with Jim Warner Calling Stone Harbor
Police - Phony Suicide Allegation - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or
read online for free. 1987 Burdette Tomlin Hospital Medical Records with Jim Warner
Calling Stone Harbor Police - Phony Suicide Allegation
Recorded 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re Dr. Nick Begich Lecture at the Covert
Harassment Conference in Berlin Germany October 1, 2015, Submitted on December 25, 2015
Recorded 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re Dr. Nick Begich Lecture at the Covert
Harassment Conference in Berlin Germany October 1, 2015, Submitted on December 25,
2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded
15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re Dr. Nick Begich Lecture at the Covert Harassment
Conference in Berlin Germany October 1, 2015, Submitted on December 25, 2015
FBI IC3 Complaint Referral Form Reciept and RECORDED Complaint I1512261722030362[1]
of Decmeber 26, 2015 as per instructions of the Lancaster City Policed Department Meeting of
December 26, 2015
FBI IC3 Complaint Referral Form Reciept and RECORDED Complaint
I1512261722030362[1] of Decmeber 26, 2015 as per instructions of the Lancaster City
Policed Department Meeting of December 26, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text file (.txt) or read online for free. FBI IC3 Complaint Referral Form Reciept and
RECORDED Complaint I1512261722030362[1] of Decmeber 26, 2015 as per instructions
of the Lancaster City Policed Department Meeting of December 26, 2015
https://www.attorneygeneral.gov/Complaints/Civil_Rights_Complaint_Form/
File an Antitrust Complaint
Social Security Benefits Application Documents and Correspondence From SSA Examiners and
Investigators of 2009, December 27, 2015
Social Security Benefits Application Documents and Correspondence From SSA
Examiners and Investigators of 2009, December 27, 2015 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Social Security Benefits Application
Documents and Correspondence From SSA Examiners and Investigators of 2009,
December 27, 2015
15-3400 EXHIBIT Re Social Security Disability Benefits for Mind Control With Application
Documents and Correspondence From SSA Examiners and Investigators of 2009, December 27,
2015
15-3400 EXHIBIT Re Social Security Disability Benefits for Mind Control With
Application Documents and Correspondence From SSA Examiners and Investigators of
2009, December 27, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online
for free. 15-3400 EXHIBIT Re Social Security Disability Benefits for Mind Control With
Application Documents and Correspondence From SSA Examiners and Investigators of
2009, December 27, 2015
Yolies Recipes From Stan J. Caterbone December 23, 2015
Yolies Recipes From Stan J. Caterbone December 23, 2015 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf) or read online for free. Yolies Recipes From Stan J. Caterbone December 23, 2015
Unix Tarpit Article
Advanced Media Group/Global Entertainment Group of Lancaster, Pennsylvania, is an
information technologies company founded by Stan J. Caterbone in 1989
Up-To-Date U.S. Third Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal DOCKET With SUMMARIES of ALL
54 Recorded Filings as of December 29, 2015
Up-To-Date U.S. Third Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal DOCKET With SUMMARIES of
ALL 54 Recorded Filings as of December 29, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Up-To-Date U.S. Third Circuit 15-3400 Lambert
Appeal DOCKET With SUMMARIES of ALL 54 Recorded Filings as of December 29,
2015
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 211
173 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 984
Page
of 2413
985 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Recorded Case No. 15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus NOTICE of
APPEAL to U.S.C.a. in US District Court Judge Joyner Order of December 29, 2015 Submitted
on December 31, 2015
Recorded Case No. 15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus
NOTICE of APPEAL to U.S.C.a. in US District Court Judge Joyner Order of December 29,
2015 Submitted on December 31, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt)
or read online for free. Recorded Case No. 15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ
of Habeus Corpus NOTICE of APPEAL to U.S.C.a. in US District Court Judge Joyner
Order of December 29, 2015 Submitted on December 31, 2015
15-3400 Third Circuit Court of Appeals LETTER to Clerk of Court Re RESCIND Motion to
Dismiss Without Prejudice, December 31, 2015
15-3400 Third Circuit Court of Appeals LETTER to Clerk of Court Re RESCIND Motion
to Dismiss Without Prejudice, December 31, 2015 - Free download as Open Office file
(.odt), PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. 15-3400 Third Circuit Court
of Appeals LETTER to Clerk of Court Re RESCIND Motion to Dismiss Without
Prejudice, December 31, 2015
Stan J. Caterbone U.S. Federal ELECTRONIC Court Filings for Thursday, December 31, 2015
Stan J. Caterbone U.S. Federal ELECTRONIC Court Filings for Thursday, December 31,
2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Stan J.
Caterbone U.S. Federal ELECTRONIC Court Filings for Thursday, December 31, 2015
Stan Caterbone Football Scrapbook Sophmore & Junior Year 1974-1975 June 24 2007 Created
by Yolanda Caterbone
Habeus Corpus Form 15-3984 August 16, 2015 Filed in U.S. District Court
Habeus Corpus Form 15-3984 August 16, 2015 Filed in U.S. District Court - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. Habeus Corpus Form 15-3984 August
16, 2015 Filed in U.S. District Court
Recorded 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re Document Re Mind Control Victims
Symptoms and Demographics Sent From My Friend Soleilmavis Liu of China, Sent Jan 1, 2016
Filed January 2, 2016
Recorded 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re Document Re Mind Control Victims
Symptoms and Demographics Sent From My Friend Soleilmavis Liu of China, Sent Jan 1,
2016 Filed January 2, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read
online for free. Recorded 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re Document Re Mind
Control Victims Symptoms and Demographics Sent From My Friend Soleilmavis Liu of
China, Sent Jan 1, 2016 Filed January 2, 2016
Sammy v County of Santa Barbara October 3, 2015
Sammy v County of Santa Barbara October 3, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or
read online for free. Sammy v County of Santa Barbara October 3, 2015
Snyder Funeral Home Bill for Sammy
Snyder Funeral Home Bill for Sammy - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for
free. Snyder Funeral Home Bill for Sammy
Third Circuit & US District Court LAMBERT Case 14-2559 in Forma Pauperis
Notarized Letter to California State Attorney General Re LSD Experiments in MK ULTRA and
Sammy Notarized October 23, 1991
Notarized Letter to California State Attorney General Re LSD Experiments in MK ULTRA
and Sammy Notarized October 23, 1991 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online
for free. Notarized Letter to California State Attorney General Re LSD Experiments in MK
ULTRA and Sammy Notarized October 23, 1991
RICO - Advanced Media Group and Stan J. Caterbone Legal Document re Tolling the Statute of
Limitations for ALL Claims - Do I Have a Rico Claim Authored on July 9, 2006
Advanced Media Group and Stan J. Caterbone Legal Document re Tolling the Statute of
Limitations for ALL Claims - Do I Have a Rico Claim Authored on July 9, 2006 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Advanced Media Group
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 212
174 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 985
Page
of 2413
986 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
and Stan J. Caterbone Legal Document re Tolling the Statute of Limitations for ALL
Claims - Do I Have a Rico Claim Authored on July 9, 2006
15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re Document Re Advanced Media Group and Stan J.
Caterbone Legal Document Re Tolling the Statute of Limitations for ALL Claims - Do I Have a
Rico Claim Authored on Jul 9, 2006, January 4, 2016
15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT Re Document Re Advanced Media Group and Stan J.
Caterbone Legal Document Re Tolling the Statute of Limitations for ALL Claims - Do I
Have a Rico Claim Authored on Jul 9, 2006, January 4, 2016 - Free ebook download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read book online for free. 15-3400 Lambert Appeal
EXHIBIT Re Document Re Advanced Media Group and Stan J. Caterbone Legal
Document Re Tolling the Statute of Limitations for ALL Claims - Do I Have a Rico Claim
Authored on Jul 9, 2006, January 4, 2016
Third Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal DOCKET With SUMMARIES of ALL Recorded Filings
as of January 5, 2016
Third Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal DOCKET With SUMMARIES of ALL Recorded
Filings as of January 5, 2016 - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or
read book online for free. Third Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal DOCKET With
SUMMARIES of ALL Recorded Filings as of January 5, 2016
Advanced Media Group Letter to Jacquelyn Pfursich, Clerk of Court in Lancaster County
January 6, 2016
Advanced Media Group Letter to Jacquelyn Pfursich, Clerk of Court in Lancaster County
January 6, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. z
Geek Squad Agent Notes of January 6, 2016 for Lenovo Laptop
Geek Squad Agent Notes of January 6, 2016 for Lenovo Laptop - Free download as PDF
File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Geek Squad Agent Notes of January 6,
2016 for Lenovo Laptop
16-1001 U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals Habeus Corpus Notice of Appeal and OPENING
DOCUMENTS of January 7, 2016
16-1001 U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals Habeus Corpus Notice of Appeal and
OPENING DOCUMENTS of January 7, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file
(.txt) or read online for free. 16-1001 U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals Habeus Corpus
Notice of Appeal and OPENING DOCUMENTS of January 7, 2016
December 9, 2015 Letter From Ms. Diana Crone, Contact Claims Associate Re Nationwide
Claim 446004-GC
December 9, 2015 Letter From Ms. Diana Crone, Contact Claims Associate Re Nationwide
Claim 446004-GC - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for
free. December 9, 2015 Letter From Ms. Diana Crone, Contact Claims Associate Re
Nationwide Claim 446004-GC
Jones Body Shop 2007 Honda CRV Repair ESTIMATE From Russ Willis on January 7, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Case Forms January 11, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Case Forms January 11, 2016 - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Stan J. Caterbone Chapter 11
Bankruptcy Case Forms January 11, 2016
FACEBOOK Postings From July 29 to January 9, 2016
FACEBOOK Postings From July 29 to January 9, 2016 - Free ebook download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read book online for free. FACEBOOK Postings From July 29 to
January 9, 2016
Recorded 16-1001 Third Circuit Habeus Appeal EXHIBIT Re Case No. 15-03984 Petitioner
Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus FILING FEE RECEIPT for 5 DOLLARS in US
District Court August 14, 2015
Recorded 16-1001 Third Circuit Habeus Appeal EXHIBIT Re Case No. 15-03984
Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus FILING FEE RECEIPT for 5
DOLLARS in US District Court August 14, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 213
175 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 986
Page
of 2413
987 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded 16-1001 Third Circuit Habeus Appeal EXHIBIT
Re Case No. 15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus FILING
FEE RECEIPT for 5 DOLLARS in US District Court August 14, 2015
Recorded 16-1001 Third Circuit Court of Appeals Habeus Corpus Case - PETITION in Support
of Application for Certificate of Appealability January 11, 2016 With DOCKET
Recorded 16-1001 Third Circuit Court of Appeals Habeus Corpus Case - PETITION in
Support of Application for Certificate of Appealability January 11, 2016 With DOCKET -
Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded 16-1001
Third Circuit Court of Appeals Habeus Corpus Case - PETITION in Support of Application
for Certificate of Appealability January 11, 2016 With DOCKET
Lambert MOTION to File EXHIBIT by Movant Jeremy Email Case No. 5-14-Cv-02259
September 8, 2015
Recorded Third Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal MOTION for IMMEDIATE
REINSTATEMENT OF APPEAL, January 13, 2016
Recorded Third Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal MOTION for IMMEDIATE
REINSTATEMENT OF APPEAL, January 13, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded Third Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal
MOTION for IMMEDIATE REINSTATEMENT OF APPEAL, January 13, 2016
STAN J. CATERBONE v. Commonwealth Bank of Lancaster County (Mellon Bank) Re Illegal
Reposession of Navajo Chieften Airplane in 1987 and Third Circuit Victory on September 30,
2008
STAN J. CATERBONE v. Commonwealth Bank of Lancaster County (Mellon Bank) Re
Illegal Reposession of Navajo Chieften Airplane in 1987 and Third Circuit Victory on
September 30, 2008 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. STAN J.
CATERBONE v. Commonwealth Bank of Lancaster County (Mellon Bank) Re Illegal
Reposession of Navajo Chieften Airplane in 1987 and Third Circuit Victory on September
30, 2008
Recorded Third Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal Motion for Third Circuit Court of Appeals
Judge Michael Fisher to Recuse January 15, 2016
Recorded Third Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal Motion for Third Circuit Court of
Appeals Judge Michael Fisher to Recuse January 15, 2016 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf) or read online for free. Recorded Third Circuit 15-3400 Lambert Appeal Motion for
Third Circuit Court of Appeals Judge Michael Fisher to Recuse January 15, 2016
14-02559 LAMBERT Habeus Corpus NOTICE of APPEAL to Reinstate Appeal 15-3400 in the
U.S. Third Circuit January 17, 2016
14-02559 LAMBERT Habeus Corpus NOTICE of APPEAL to Reinstate Appeal 15-3400
in the U.S. Third Circuit January 17, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file
(.txt) or read online for free. 14-02559 LAMBERT Habeus Corpus NOTICE of APPEAL to
Reinstate Appeal 15-3400 in the U.S. Third Circuit January 17, 2016
14-02559 Re Stan J Caterbone, The MOVANT, The Federal Courts and the New Book - Love,
Murder, And CORRUPTION in Lancaster County My Story by Lisa Michelle Lambert and
Attorney Dave Brown January 18, 2016
14-02559 Re Stan J Caterbone, The MOVANT, The Federal Courts and the New Book -
Love, Murder, And CORRUPTION in Lancaster County My Story by Lisa Michelle
Lambert and Attorney Dave Brown January 18, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text file (.txt) or read online for free. 14-02559 Re Stan J Caterbone, The MOVANT, The
Federal Courts and the New Book - Love, Murder, And CORRUPTION in Lancaster
County My Story by Lisa Michelle Lambert and Attorney Dave Brown January 18, 2016
Dr Phil Caterbone's Career Path to $$$Millions January 18, 2016
Dr Phil Caterbone's Career Path to $$$Millions January 18, 2016 - Free download as PDF
File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Dr Phil Caterbone's Career Path to $$
$Millions January 18, 2016
Open Letter to the Editor of Newslanc.com Re Kathleen Kane and Old Boys Network - January
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 214
176 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 987
Page
of 2413
988 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
20, 2016
Recorded 16-1001 Stan J. Caterbone Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re Stan J. Caterbone and
Advanced Media Group United States Department of Justice Civil Rights Complaint January 19,
2016
Pennsylvania Superior Court Case No. 1915 MDA 2015 - CATERBONE v. Lancaster City
Police re Briefing Schedule Date DUE FEBRUARY 29, 2016
Change of Venue to District Magistrate Barbara Pinaka, January 23, 2016
January 24, 2016 Facebook Post Re Motivatin Factors of Lancaster County v. Stan J. Caterbone
and Advanced Media Group
Stanley J. Caterbone, Pro Se, U.S.C.A. Third Circuit Complaint of Judicial Misconduct or
Disability of January 25, 2016
Samuel Caterbone, Jr. (Father) Naval Air Gunners Honors 1943 January 24, 2016 - Prior To U.S
Sponsored Mind Control Victimization
2016 Chapter 11 New Case for Filing in Eastern District of Pennsylvania Bankruptcy Court,
Reading, PA January 27, 2016 Numbered and Bookmarked
Findings of Facts 1998 - Original Claim Filed in Federal Courthouse, United States Eastern
District of Pennaylvania in Case No. 05-2288 on May 16, 2005
Sorry Lancaster - My Father, Samuell P. Caterbone Jr, Was a Victim of MKULTRA - January
26, 2016
1989 - Radio Science Laboratories (Microwave Technologies) Business Plan by Stan J.
Caterbone, Scribd on January 27, 2016
Recorded and Stamped by DA Office - Private Criminal Complaint v. Southeast Medical Clinic
and Patient First Urgent Care Re Refusal to Prescribe Pain Medications, January 27, 2016
Jan 28, 2016 - Fax Cover Sheet for U.S. Third Circuit Clerk of Court Marcia Waldron Re 16-
1149 LEGAL DIVISION LETTER SENT Possible Dismissal Due to Jurisdictional Defect.
(EAL) January 27, 2016
Pennsylvania State Criminal Background Check of January19, 2016
Department of General Services Press Application Signed January 6, 2016 for Troy Thompson,
Press Secretary January 27, 2016
16-10517 Chapter 11 Bankruptcy OPEN Case Letter of January 27, 2016
Open Letter to the Editor of Newslanc.com Re Kathleen Kane and Good Old Boys Network,
December 15, 2015
Open Letter to the Editor of Newslanc.com Re Kathleen Kane and Good Old Boys
Network, December 15, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read
online for free. Open Letter to the Editor of Newslanc.com Re Kathleen Kane and Good
Old Boys Network, December 15, 2015
Senate will not vote for now to remove Kathleen Kane - The Morning Call
State Senate opts not to remove Attorney General Kathleen Kane from office until the state
Supreme Court rules on request to have her law license reinstated.
Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group Documentation as a Contractor for the
Department of Defense in 1990
EMERGENCY INJUCTION v Fulton Bank Recorded April 14, 2010 Filed on April 1, 2010 in
US District Court
ALL FACEBOOK Postings and Incidents From July 29 to January 28, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group Central Intelligence Agency, Or CIA Contacts
Connected in My LinkedIn Network as of February 1, 2016
HANDOUT - Private Criminal Complaint v. Southeast Medical Clinic and Patient First Urgent
Care Re Refusal to Prescribe Pain Medications, February 1, 2016
CI-15-10167 Lancaster County Court MOTION for Leave to File in Forma Pauperis Caterbone v
Brunswick-Fitzwater-Lancaster Film February 2, 2016
CI-08-13373 Lancaster County Court MOTION for Leave to File in Forma Pauperis Caterbone v
Duke Street Business Center February 2, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group - Pennsylvania Attorney General Consumer
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 215
177 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 988
Page
of 2413
989 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Affairs Complaint Form re Computer Hacking and Pacer.gov February 2, 2016
TOC - Advanced Media Group Version - In a Killers Words Lisa Michelle Lambert, Nearly 25
Years Since Laurie Shows Murder, LAMBERT Claims Innocence in New Book, January 31,
2016
Advanced Media Group and Stan J. Caterbone Obstruction of Justice - A LANDMARK CASE,
re 15-3400; 16-1001; 16-1149 in the Third Circuit - 14-02259; 15-03984; 05-2288; 06-4650; etc.,
in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania - February 3, 2016
Stan J Caterbone, International Signal Control or ISC, The CIA, The NSA, And U.S. Sponsored
Mind Control in Lancaster Pennsylvania - November 18, 2015 Copyright
Trip to Harrisburg - Attorney General Drop Box and Capitol Building, Photos, Itinerary, and
Receipts of February 4, 2016
Social Security Application for Benefits, April 8, 2009, Approved on August 26, 2009 with a
Check for 21,400.00 for 1 Year of Retroactive Benefits - Declared Disabled on December 1,
2005 for Symptoms and Illnesses Related to U.S. Sponsored Mind Control
Photos of Trip to Pennsylvania Capitol for Senate Vote on PA Attorney General Kathleen Kane
Impeachment and Complaint to LCPD Re 1252 Fremont St., February 10, 2016
Superior Court of Pennsylvania Case No. 1915 MDA 2015 CATERBONE v. Lancaster City
Police Department, BRIEF Dated February 12, 2016
Electronic Filing - Recorded 1915 MDA 2015 Form Report 3012 Reply Letter Request Filled
Out Form for ORAL ARGUMENTS or JUST BRIEF February 13, 2016 with Proof of Service
and Verification
Return Letter From James J. Fitzpatrick, Chief Deputy Attorney General of PA Atty General
Office Re Advanced Media Group COMPLAINT to Insurance Fraud Section Re Nationwide
Claim 446004-GC February 8, 2016
Advanced Media Group COMPLAINT to the Office of Attorney General's Insurance Fraud
Section Re Nationwide Claim 446004-GC February 8, 2016
08-13373 DEFENDANT LIST and DOCKET Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas in the
Matter of CATERBONE v Duke Street Business Center February 14, 2016
Original Documents of 1987 Re Lancaster County Prison, Dr. Al Shultz, Unemployment
Compensation, St. Joseph Hospital, And EVIDENCE In The Matter of Anti-Trust Litigation,
Scanned February 16, 2016
Gmail -U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals 16-1149 Lisa Lambert v ORDER DISMISS CASE
for Failure to File Fee Dated February 16, 2016 - SEE COMPLAINTS ON PAGE 2; PA Atty
General and U.S. Third Circuit Judicial Board
Chapter 11 Case No. 16-10517-REF NOTICE Show Cause Hearing Thursday, February 18, 2016
U.S. Courthouse Madison Bldg, Reading PA 11am February 5, 2016
Living Declaration and Statement of Facts in the Matter of CATERBONE v. the County and City
of Lancaster Pennsylvania, Et Al February 18, 2016
Recorded Chapter 11 Case No. 16-10517-REF NOTICE to File Exhibit Re Living Declaration
and Statement of Facts, In Show Cause Hearing of February 18, 2016
Chapter 11 Case No. 16-10517-REF NOTICE to File Exhibit in Show Cause Hearing of
February 18, 2016
Updated IC3 Report to the FBI Re Lowes Non-Delivery of Paid Building Materials for New
Fence and Patio Roof on March 26, 2016
Updated IC3 Report to the FBI Re Lowes Non-Delivery of Paid Building Materials for
New Fence and Patio Roof on March 26, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text
File (.txt) or read online for free. Updated IC3 Report to the FBI Re Lowes Non-Delivery
of Paid Building Materials for New Fence and Patio Roof on March 26, 2016
181 Page U.S. District Court Habeus Case 15-03984 EXHIBIT Re - AFFIDAVIT and State-Of-
Affairs of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control for Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group,
March 27, 2016 with Bookmarks and Table of Contents
181 Page U.S. District Court Habeus Case 15-03984 EXHIBIT Re - AFFIDAVIT and
State-Of-Affairs of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control for Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 216
178 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 989
Page
of 2413
990 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Media Group, March 27, 2016 with Bookmarks and Table of Contents - Free ebook
download as PDF File (.pdf) or read book online for free. 181 Page U.S. District Court
Habeus Case 15-03984 EXHIBIT Re - AFFIDAVIT and State-Of-Affairs of U.S.
Sponsored Mind Control for Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group, March 27,
2016 with Bookmarks and Table of Contents
Information Inventory Assets of all file folders in 1250 Fremont Street on May 17, 2009 and in
1992 with Rick Gray File, March 27 2016
Information Inventory Assets of all file folders in 1250 Fremont Street on May 17, 2009
and in 1992 with Rick Gray File, March 27 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text
File (.txt) or read online for free. Information Inventory Assets of all file folders in 1250
Fremont Street on May 17, 2009 and in 1992 with Rick Gray File, March 27 2016
Recorded Case No. 15-03984 Habeus EXHIBIT Re the Timeline of Secret Government Projects
and Letter to Editor of LNP, March 29, 2016
Recorded Case No. 15-03984 Habeus EXHIBIT Re the Timeline of Secret Government
Projects and Letter to Editor of LNP, March 29, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded Case No. 15-03984 Habeus EXHIBIT Re
the Timeline of Secret Government Projects and Letter to Editor of LNP, March 29, 2016
Section 2709. Harassment and Stalking of the Pennsylvania Crimes Code March 30, 2016
Section 2709. Harassment and Stalking of the Pennsylvania Crimes Code March 30, 2016 -
Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or view presentation slides online.
Section 2709. Harassment and Stalking of the Pennsylvania Crimes Code March 30, 2016
Pennsylvania State Background Check For Stan J. Caterbone as of January 19, 2016
Pennsylvania State Background Check For Stan J. Caterbone as of January 19, 2016 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Pennsylvania State
Background Check For Stan J. Caterbone as of January 19, 2016
March 29, 2016 LETTER From the Office of the Circuit Executive Re PETITION for REVIEW
Re 15-3400 and LAMBERT Judicial Complaint of February 25, 2016 - Filed on March 16, 2016
March 29, 2016 LETTER From the Office of the Circuit Executive Re PETITION for
REVIEW Re 15-3400 and LAMBERT Judicial Complaint of February 25, 2016 - Filed on
March 16, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
March 29, 2016 LETTER From the Office of the Circuit Executive Re PETITION for
REVIEW Re 15-3400 and LAMBERT Judicial Complaint of February 25, 2016 - Filed on
March 16, 2016
Allstate Insurance Claim April 3, 2016
Allstate Insurance Claim April 3, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt)
or read online for free. Allstate Insurance Claim April 3, 2016
Email Re Registration of Freedom From Covert Harassment and Survellience in the State of
Pennsylvania to ALL CONTACTS on April 3, 2016
Email Re Registration of Freedom From Covert Harassment and Survellience in the State
of Pennsylvania to ALL CONTACTS on April 3, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Email Re Registration of Freedom From Covert
Harassment and Survellience in the State of Pennsylvania to ALL CONTACTS on April 3,
2016
Samuel Caterbone Jr. Passport Renewal February 3 1964b Worldwide Stamps in the 1960's -
Covert Courier and Affidavits
Samuel Caterbone Jr. Passport Renewal February 3 1964b Worldwide Stamps in the 1960's
- Covert Courier and Affidavits - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read
online for free. Samuel Caterbone Jr. Passport Renewal February 3 1964b Worldwide
Stamps in the 1960's - Covert Courier and Affidavits
Letter to Craig Stedman Re Private Criminal Complaint v. Southeast Medical Clinic and Patient
First Urgent Care Re Refusal to Prescribe Pain Medications, January 27, 2016 - April 6, 2016
Letter to Craig Stedman Re Private Criminal Complaint v. Southeast Medical Clinic and
Patient First Urgent Care Re Refusal to Prescribe Pain Medications, January 27, 2016 -
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 217
179 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 990
Page
of 2413
991 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
April 6, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
Letter to Craig Stedman Re Private Criminal Complaint v. Southeast Medical Clinic and
Patient First Urgent Care Re Refusal to Prescribe Pain Medications, January 27, 2016 -
April 6, 2016
CONFIRMATION of Pennsylvania Registration of FFCHS or Freedom From Covert Harassment
and Surveillence Ficticious Name by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group on March
25, 2016
CONFIRMATION of Pennsylvania Registration of FFCHS or Freedom From Covert
Harassment and Surveillence Ficticious Name by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media
Group on March 25, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read
online for free. CONFIRMATION of Pennsylvania Registration of FFCHS or Freedom
From Covert Harassment and Surveillence Ficticious Name by Stan J. Caterbone and
Advanced Media Group on March 25, 2016
CONFIRMATION of Pennsylvania Registration of FFCHS or Freedom From Covert Harassment
and Surveillence Ficticious Name by Stan J. Caterbone on March 25, 2016
CONFIRMATION of Pennsylvania Registration of FFCHS or Freedom From Covert
Harassment and Surveillence Ficticious Name by Stan J. Caterbone on March 25, 2016 -
Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
CONFIRMATION of Pennsylvania Registration of FFCHS or Freedom From Covert
Harassment and Surveillence Ficticious Name by Stan J. Caterbone on March 25, 2016
Stan J. Caterbon's Legal Formation Documents for Financial Management Group, Ltd., Or FMG,
Ltd. in 1986
Advanced Media Group Corporate Search by Stan J. Caterbone, April 8, 2016
Advanced Media Group Corporate Search by Stan J. Caterbone, April 8, 2016 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Advanced Media
Group Corporate Search by Stan J. Caterbone, April 8, 2016
Original Advanced Media Group, Ltd., Articles of Incorporation August 28, 1990
Original Advanced Media Group, Ltd., Articles of Incorporation August 28, 1990 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Original Advanced
Media Group, Ltd., Articles of Incorporation August 28, 1990
Ameritrade History of Transactions from 2002 to April 9, 2016
Ameritrade History of Transactions from 2002 to April 9, 2016 - Free download as PDF
File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Ameritrade History of Transactions from
2002 to April 9, 2016
Notice of Summary Appeal and IFP to Dauphin County Courthouse Re MJ-12104-TR0000911-
2016 April 10, 2016
Notice of Summary Appeal and IFP to Dauphin County Courthouse Re MJ-12104-
TR0000911-2016 April 10, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or
read online for free. Notice of Summary Appeal and IFP to Dauphin County Courthouse Re
MJ-12104-TR0000911-2016 April 10, 2016
07-03442 CATERBONE v. Comcast DOCKET Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas 2007
07-03442 CATERBONE v. Comcast DOCKET Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas
2007 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. 07-03442
CATERBONE v. Comcast DOCKET Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas 2007
Recorded MOTION for RECONSIDERATION Re Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of
Habeus Corpus to US District Court Judge Joyner in Case No. 15-03984 April 12, 2016
Recorded MOTION for RECONSIDERATION Re Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of
Habeus Corpus to US District Court Judge Joyner in Case No. 15-03984 April 12, 2016 -
Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read book online for free.
Recorded MOTION for RECONSIDERATION Re Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of
Habeus Corpus to US District Court Judge Joyner in Case No. 15-03984 April 12, 2016
Yolanda Caterbone Home-Care Medical Records January 2011 to Declared Deceased on June 29,
2011 by Hospice of Lancaster County
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 218
180 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 991
Page
of 2413
992 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Yolanda Caterbone Home-Care Medical Records January 2011 to Declared Deceased on
June 29, 2011 by Hospice of Lancaster County - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read
online for free. Yolanda Caterbone Home-Care Medical Records January 2011 to Declared
Deceased on June 29, 2011 by Hospice of Lancaster County
RECORDED 15-03984 Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re Fruadulent Lancaster City Property
Tax Records Re Extortion of 1250 Fremont Street by the City of Lancaster, PA 17603 Reported
on April 14, 2016
RECORDED 15-03984 Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re Fruadulent Lancaster City
Property Tax Records Re Extortion of 1250 Fremont Street by the City of Lancaster, PA
17603 Reported on April 14, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or
read online for free. RECORDED 15-03984 Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re
Fruadulent Lancaster City Property Tax Records Re Extortion of 1250 Fremont Street by
the City of Lancaster, PA 17603 Reported on April 14, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone INCIDENT REPORT With Statement for Threats and Harassment at Aroogas
Bar and Grill 911 Call to Manor Township January 24, 2016 Uploaded April 15, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone INCIDENT REPORT With Statement for Threats and Harassment at
Aroogas Bar and Grill 911 Call to Manor Township January 24, 2016 Uploaded April 15,
2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Stan J.
Caterbone INCIDENT REPORT With Statement for Threats and Harassment at Aroogas
Bar and Grill 911 Call to Manor Township January 24, 2016 Uploaded April 15, 2016
Story and Evidence of a Targeted Individual for Derrick Robinson's Document to the FBI on
April 16, 2016
Recorded 05-03984 EXHIBIT Re Story and Evidence of a Targeted Individual for Derrick
Robinson's Document to the FBI on April 18, 2016
Recorded 05-03984 EXHIBIT Re Story and Evidence of a Targeted Individual for Derrick
Robinson's Document to the FBI on April 18, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Recorded 05-03984 EXHIBIT Re Story and
Evidence of a Targeted Individual for Derrick Robinson's Document to the FBI on April
18, 2016
Superior Court Case No. 1561 MDA 2015 CATERBONE v. Lancaster County Residents
DOCKET and ARGUMENT LETTER for Oral Arguments on May 24, 2016 Filed on April 18,
2016
Superior Court Case No. 1561 MDA 2015 CATERBONE v. Lancaster County Residents
DOCKET and ARGUMENT LETTER for Oral Arguments on May 24, 2016 Filed on April
18, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
Superior Court Case No. 1561 MDA 2015 CATERBONE v. Lancaster County Residents
DOCKET and ARGUMENT LETTER for Oral Arguments on May 24, 2016 Filed on April
18, 2016
Benefit Verification Letter From the Social Security Administration for April 19, 2016
Benefit Verification Letter From the Social Security Administration for April 19, 2016 -
Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Benefit
Verification Letter From the Social Security Administration for April 19, 2016
Superior Court Case No. 1915 MDA 2015 CATERBONE v. Lancaster City Police DOCKET and
ARGUMENT LETTER for Oral Arguments on May 25, 2016 Filed on April 18, 2016 With
Petition for Review
Superior Court Case No. 1915 MDA 2015 CATERBONE v. Lancaster City Police
DOCKET and ARGUMENT LETTER for Oral Arguments on May 25, 2016 Filed on April
18, 2016 With Petition for Review - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or
read online for free. Superior Court Case No. 1915 MDA 2015 CATERBONE v. Lancaster
City Police DOCKET and ARGUMENT LETTER for Oral Arguments on May 25, 2016
Filed on April 18, 2016 With Petition for Review
Letter for Stan's Therapist Erin at Pennsylvania Counseling Services, Pearl Street, Lancaster, PA
From Derrick Robinson on June 2, 2010
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 219
181 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 992
Page
of 2413
993 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Letter for Stan's Therapist Erin at Pennsylvania Counseling Services, Pearl Street,
Lancaster, PA From Derrick Robinson on June 2, 2010 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Letter for Stan's Therapist Erin at Pennsylvania
Counseling Services, Pearl Street, Lancaster, PA From Derrick Robinson on June 2, 2010
15-03984 Recorded - AFFIDAVIT and State-Of-Affairs for Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced
Media Group, April 20, 2016 Filed in Federal Court on March 22, 2016
15-03984 Recorded - AFFIDAVIT and State-Of-Affairs for Stan J. Caterbone and
Advanced Media Group, April 20, 2016 Filed in Federal Court on March 22, 2016 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. 15-03984 Recorded -
AFFIDAVIT and State-Of-Affairs for Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group, April
20, 2016 Filed in Federal Court on March 22, 2016
RECORDED U.S. District Court Case No. 15-03984 Habeus Corpus DECLARATION Re Stan
J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group Biography April 20, 2016
RECORDED U.S. District Court Case No. 15-03984 Habeus Corpus DECLARATION Re
Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group Biography April 20, 2016 - Free download
as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. RECORDED U.S. District Court
Case No. 15-03984 Habeus Corpus DECLARATION Re Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced
Media Group Biography April 20, 2016
Dr. Nick Begich Transcript of Covert Harassment Conference, Belgium Germany October 2,
2015 for April 21, 2016 Due to the Hacker
Dr. Nick Begich Transcript of Covert Harassment Conference, Belgium Germany October
2, 2015 for April 21, 2016 Due to the Hacker - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File
(.txt) or read online for free. Dr. Nick Begich Transcript of Covert Harassment Conference,
Belgium Germany October 2, 2015 for April 21, 2016 Due to the Hacker
Medical Records for Matrix Medical Network Meeting of April 22, 2016 With Section 303
Mental Health Court Orders of 2015 and 2016
Medical Records for Matrix Medical Network Meeting of April 22, 2016 With Section 303
Mental Health Court Orders of 2015 and 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text
File (.txt) or read online for free. Medical Records for Matrix Medical Network Meeting of
April 22, 2016 With Section 303 Mental Health Court Orders of 2015 and 2016
Recorded 05-03984 Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re LAUNCH 2016 Harassment and Stalking
Claims of April 25, 2016
Recorded 05-03984 Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re LAUNCH 2016 Harassment and
Stalking Claims of April 25, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or
read online for free. Recorded 05-03984 Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re LAUNCH 2016
Harassment and Stalking Claims of April 25, 2016
RECORDED 15-03984 Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re Fruadulent Lancaster City Property
Tax Records Re Extortion of 1250 Fremont Street by the City of Lancaster, PA 17603 Reported
on April 14, 2016
U.S. District Court Case No. 06-4734 Federal False Claim Act Filing of October 19 2006
Documents and ORDERS
U.S. District Court Case No. 06-4734 Federal False Claim Act Filing of October 19 2006
Documents and ORDERS - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read
online for free. U.S. District Court Case No. 06-4734 Federal False Claim Act Filing of
October 19 2006 Documents and ORDERS
The Assaults on Stan J. Caterbone's Family Began on November 12, 1904 - According to the
LNP New Era of the Same Date
The Assaults on Stan J. Caterbone's Family Began on November 12, 1904 - According to
the LNP New Era of the Same Date - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File
(.txt) or read book online for free. The Assaults on Stan J. Caterbone's Family Began on
November 12, 1904 - According to the LNP New Era of the Same Date
Recorded Case No. 15-03984 Habeus STATEMENT Re Letter to E. Phillip Wenger, CEO of
Fulton Financial Corporation Re COLLUSION of April 29, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 220
182 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 993
Page
of 2413
994 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Recorded Case No. 15-03984 Habeus STATEMENT Re Letter to E. Phillip Wenger, CEO
of Fulton Financial Corporation Re COLLUSION of April 29, 2016 - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Good Luck, Binderup. This was
filed the morning of April 29. 2016
Recorded Case No. 15-03984 Habeus DECLARATION Re Financial Fraud by the Lancaster
County Tax Claim Bureau, April 28, 2016
Recorded Case No. 15-03984 Habeus DECLARATION Re Financial Fraud by the
Lancaster County Tax Claim Bureau, April 28, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Tell the lady that just called me at 3:06pm to kiss my
ass!
5-Lancaster City Police PA Mental Health 302 Petition of Stanley J. Caterbone to Fairmount
Behavioral Health Systems as of April 21, 2010 for April 29, 2016
5-Lancaster City Police PA Mental Health 302 Petition of Stanley J. Caterbone to
Fairmount Behavioral Health Systems as of April 21, 2010 for April 29, 2016 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. You mean to tell me
that the COURT via the 303 hearing never ORDERED any OUTPATIENT
TREATMENT? All of the 303 Court Orders were for INPATIENT ONLY - April of 2010,
July of 2015, and February of 2016 - That should tell you something!
Latest Human Cloning Claims Leave Sour Taste New Scientist 2009 Article Updated on April
29, 2016
Latest Human Cloning Claims Leave Sour Taste New Scientist 2009 Article Updated on
April 29, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
Institutional Investors Mortgage Banking Business Development of 1987 Very Important for the
Pflumms April 30, 2016
Institutional Investors Mortgage Banking Business Development of 1987 Very Important
for the Pflumms April 30, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read
online for free. Like I said, COINTELPRO works from the TOP down - The Corrupt Feds
put pressure on the STATE (PA) Who then puts pressure on LOCAL law enforcement!
15-03984 Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re Medical Records for Matrix Medical Network
Meeting of April 25, 2016 Version April 30
15-03984 Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re Medical Records for Matrix Medical
Network Meeting of April 25, 2016 Version April 30 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
U.S. District Court Case No. 06-4734 Federal False Claim Act Filing of October 19 2006
Documents and ORDERS
U.S. District Court Case No. 06-4734 Federal False Claim Act Filing of October 19 2006
Documents and ORDERS - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read
online for free. U.S. District Court Case No. 06-4734 Federal False Claim Act Filing of
October 19 2006 Documents and ORDERS Including Owen Kugel's" Owen Kugel,
Appellant, v. United States of America, Appellee, 947 F.2d 1504 (D.C. Cir. 1991)" US
Circuit Opinion
Recorded 15-03984 Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re Medical Records With SS Disability
Evidence for Matrix Medical Network Meeting of April 25, 2016 Version April 30
Recorded 15-03984 Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re Medical Records With SS
Disability Evidence for Matrix Medical Network Meeting of April 25, 2016 Version April
30 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. 15-03984
Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT re Medical Records with SS Disability Evidence for
Matrix Medical Network Meeting of April 25, 2016 Version April 30 Part 1 with all
Section 303 Court Orders of April 2010, July 2015, and February 2016 and Section 302
Mental Health Warrant to Extract 2 Teeth at LGH Intermediate Intensive Care for
$30,000.00
Advanced Media Group-High-American Helix 1989 to 1991 Documents for Anti-Trust Litigation
May 1, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 221
183 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 994
Page
of 2413
995 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Advanced Media Group-High-American Helix 1989 to 1991 Documents for Anti-Trust
Litigation May 1, 2016 - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read
book online for free. Just in case the Marriott people threaten me again this Sunday, May 1,
2016 at the bar for Service Night! Maybe Dale and Tom Smithgall put a hit out on me?
9 US Third Circuit Court of Appeals CASES and FULL DOCKETS for APPELLANT Stan J.
Caterbone as of May 3, 2016
9 US Third Circuit Court of Appeals CASES and FULL DOCKETS for APPELLANT Stan
J. Caterbone as of May 3, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read
online for free. 9 US Third Circuit Court of Appeals CASES and FULL DOCKETS for
APPELLANT Stan J. Caterbone as of May 3, 2016
Private Criminal Complaint - 1252 Fremont Street on March 30, 2016
Private Criminal Complaint - 1252 Fremont Street on March 30, 2016 - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free. This is when they started to flood my basement -
Private Criminal Complaint - 1252 Fremont Street on March 30, 2016
Recorded Judge Mary Mclaughlin 05-2288 Amendment to Complaint Filed on October 12 2007
Recorded
Recorded Judge Mary Mclaughlin 05-2288 Amendment to Complaint Filed on October 12
2007 Recorded - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
Recorded Judge Mary Mclaughlin 05-2288 Amendment to Complaint Filed on October 12
2007 Recorded
The History of Advanced Media Group From 1989 Published May 7, 2016
The History of Advanced Media Group From 1989 Published May 7, 2016 - Free ebook
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read book online for free. The History of
Advanced Media Group From 1989 Published May 7, 2016
Photos of May 7, 2016 Re Downtown Lancaster City Organized Stalking and Harassment by
Perps
Federal Court Case No. 05-2288 CATERBONE v. Lancaster County Prison, Fulton Bank, et. al.,
OPEN Case and U.S. Third Circuit Reversal of Dismissal for May 6, 2016
Federal Court Case No. 05-2288 CATERBONE v. Lancaster County Prison, Fulton Bank,
et. al., OPEN Case and U.S. Third Circuit Reversal of Dismissal for May 6, 2016 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Federal Court Case No.
05-2288 CATERBONE v. Lancaster County Prison, Fulton Bank, et. al., OPEN Case and
U.S. Third Circuit Reversal of Dismissal for May 6, 2016
MedExpress Pain Visit and Prescriptions for Pain on Tuesday, May 10, 2015
Recorded 15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re NSA
Whistleblower Karen Stewart Disclosure of Electromagnetic Weapons Used to Kill May 10,
2016
Recorded 15-03984 Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus EXHIBIT Re
NSA Whistleblower Karen Stewart Disclosure of Electromagnetic Weapons Used to Kill
May 10, 2016 by stan5j.5caterbone
Police Report and Photos for Accident of May 9, 2016 by East Hempfield Township Police
Lawsuit Accuses Pa. Senate Candidate Scott Martin of Using His Influence in Fatal Crash
Aftermath With Prosecutors and Police May 9, 2016
Lawsuit accuses Pa. Senate candidate Scott Martin of using his influence ...
http://lancasteronline.com/insider/lawsuit-accuses-pa-senate-candida...
Stamped-Lancaster County Court Case No. 08-CI-13373 EXHIBIT Re Corroborating Expert and
Former Nsa Whistleblower Karen Stewart's Disclosure of Electromagnetic Weapons Used to Kill
May 12 - Copy
Lancaster County Court Case No. 08-CI-13373 EXHIBIT Re Corroborating Expert and
Former Nsa Whistleblower Karen Stewart's Disclosure of Electromagnetic Weapons Used
to Kill May 12 - Copy - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for
free.
Recorded 15-03984 EXHIBIT re 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT re Corroborating Expert
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 222
184 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 995
Page
of 2413
996 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
And Former NSA Whistleblower Karen Stewart Disclosure Of Electromagnetic Weapons Used
To Kill, May 12, 2016.pdf
15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT re Corroborating Expert And Former NSA
Whistleblower Karen Stewart Disclosure Of Electromagnetic Weapons Used To Kill, May
12, 2016.pdf - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
Superior Court Case No. 1561 MDA 2015 and 1915 MDA 2015 MOTION to File EXHIBIT Re
Recorded 15-03984 Habeus Case EXHIBIT Re Pennsylvania Judge Quashes 650M Government
Mind Control Lawsuit Dated May11, 2016
Superior Court Case No. 1561 MDA 2015 and 1915 MDA 2015 MOTION to File
EXHIBIT Re Recorded 15-03984 Habeus Case EXHIBIT Re Pennsylvania Judge Quashes
650M Government Mind Control Lawsuit Dated May11, 2016 - Free download as PDF
File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
Lancaster man assaulted on sidewalk after words exchanged | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Victim suffers serious head injuries.
Forum finds ways to keep Lancaster a 'great place' | Local News | lancasteronline.com
A forum this week sought input from the business community to develop the county's
comprehensive plan.
Letter From Stepanie Carfley Re FULTON FINANCIAL Ethics Point COMPLAINT to Board of
DirectorsDec 28 2007
Letter From Stepanie Carfley Re FULTON FINANCIAL Ethics Point COMPLAINT to
Board of DirectorsDec 28 2007 by stan5j.5caterbone
Law journal honors Nast with Lifetime Achievement Award | Local Business |
lancasteronline.com
The Legal Intelligencer has selected long-time Lancaster resident Dianne M. Nast for its
2016 Lifetime Achievement Award.
Recorded - Kane Amicus Superior Court Case No. 2016 1164 EDA Kathleen Kane Appeal
DOCKET Sheet With Stan J. Caterbone as AMICUS as of May 17 2016 with AMICUS that was
filed in Person in Philadelphia on May 12, 2016
Superior Court Case No. 2016 1164 EDA Kathleen Kane Appeal DOCKET Sheet With
Stan J. Caterbone as AMICUS as of May 17 2016 with AMICUS that was filed in Person
in Philadelphia on May 12, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read
online for free.
Usage Statistics for www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com for March Thru May of 2016
Reported on May 17, 2016
(4) Amicus Curiae Filed by Stan J. Caterbone 2007 to 2016 - Kathleen Kane - The National
Security Agency NSA - Lisa Michelle Lambert - Mehgan Liappatt - Published May 18, 2016
(4) Amicus Curiae Filed by Stan J. Caterbone 2007 to 2016 - Kathleen Kane - The National
Security Agency NSA - Lisa Michelle Lambert - Mehgan Liappatt - Published May 18,
2016 by stan5j.5caterbone
DefenseNews Story by Joe Pitts ELECTROMAGNETIC Weapons and Founder of the Electronic
Warfare Working Group for Securing Weapons of the Future July 7, 2008
DefenseNews Story by Joe Pitts ELECTROMAGNETIC Weapons and Founder of the
Electronic Warfare Working Group for Securing Weapons of the Future July 7, 2008 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. DefenseNews Story by
Joe Pitts ELECTROMAGNETIC Weapons and Founder of the Electronic Warfare
Working Group for Securing Weapons of the Future July 7, 2008
Chapter 11 Case No. 16-10517 Judge Fehling and Judge Edward Smith Impeachment Case File
of May 18, 2016
Chapter 11 Case No. 16-10517 Judge Fehling and Judge Edward Smith Impeachment Case
File of May 18, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for
free.
Advanced Media Group Letter to Steve, Phil and Mike Re 1250 Fremont Street Taxes December
28, 2015
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 223
185 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 996
Page
of 2413
997 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Advanced Media Group Letter to Steve, Phil and Mike Re 1250 Fremont Street Taxes
December 28, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for
free. Advanced Media Group Letter to Steve, Phil and Mike Re 1250 Fremont Street Taxes
December 28, 2015
Recorded-DefenseNews Story by Joe Pitts ELECTROMAGNETIC Weapons and Founder of the
Electronic Warfare Working Group for Securing Weapons of the Future July 7, 2008 With Karen
Stewart
Recorded-DefenseNews Story by Joe Pitts ELECTROMAGNETIC Weapons and Founder
of the Electronic Warfare Working Group for Securing Weapons of the Future July 7, 2008
With Karen Stewart by stan5j.5caterbone
Changes implemented at county prison after inmate released 17 months late | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Changes are underway at Lancaster County Prison after an clerical error resulted in an
inmate being released 17 months late.
When Will They Return My Property at 554 Berkley Road, Stone Harbor New Jersey, May 26,
2016
Recorded-DefenseNews Story by Joe Pitts ELECTROMAGNETIC Weapons and Founder of the
Electronic Warfare Working Group for Securing Weapons of the Future July 7, 2008
Recorded-DefenseNews Story by Joe Pitts ELECTROMAGNETIC Weapons and Founder
of the Electronic Warfare Working Group for Securing Weapons of the Future July 7, 2008
- Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read book online for free.
Recorded-DefenseNews Story by Joe Pitts ELECTROMAGNETIC Weapons and Founder
of the Electronic Warfare Working Group for Securing Weapons of the Future July 7, 2008
Malcolm Gladwell to Lancaster business community: Think soccer, not basketball | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
From a community standpoint, he said, focusing on superstars is no longer a winning
strategy.
Confirmation 15-03984 United States District Court Eastern District of Pennsylvania - Letter to
Lisa Michelle Lambert in Framingham Prison, May 28, 2016
United States District Court Eastern District of Pennsylvania1 of 1
https://ecf.paed.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/Dispatch.pl?221794745889524 </...
Julianne McKinney Interview of 2007 on Microwave Harassment and Mind Control by the
Advanced Media Group
Where are 17,000 Lancaster County vets buried? This list will tell you | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
James Buchanan who served in the War of 1812 is on the list.
DA: Cultural decline fuels drug abuse | Local News | lancasteronline.com
County official discusses causes of epidemic during public meeting
Pennsylvania bill would ease rules for nurse practitioners | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Would lift doctor supervision requirement after 3,600 hours.
Diary of Workplace Mobbing Pflumm Contractors Feb 1998
Equity crowdfunding promises to 'break the monopoly of the rich' | Local Business |
lancasteronline.com
Can equity crowdfunding change the world?
New 'Blue Lives Matter' bill makes crime against police hate crime | National |
lancasteronline.com
Update:
Recorded - 15-03984 Habeus Case DECLARATION Re Findings of Facts 1998 - Original Claim
Filed in United States Eastern District of Pennaylvania in Case No. 05-2288 on May 16, 2005
Recorded - 15-03984 Habeus Case DECLARATION Re Findings of Facts 1998 - Original
Claim Filed in United States Eastern District of Pennaylvania in Case No. 05-2288 on May
16, 2005 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
Recorded - 15-03984 Habeus Case DECLARATION Re Findings of Facts 1998 - Original
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 224
186 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 997
Page
of 2413
998 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Claim Filed in United States Eastern District of Pennaylvania in Case No. 05-2288 on May
16, 2005
RECORDED 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT re Corroborating Expert And Former NSA
Whistleblower Karen Stewart Disclosure Of Electromagnetic Weapons Used To Kill, May 12,
2016.pdf
RECORDED 15-3400 Lambert Appeal EXHIBIT re Corroborating Expert And Former
NSA Whistleblower Karen Stewart Disclosure Of Electromagnetic Weapons Used To Kill,
May 12, 2016.pdf - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for
free.
Trip to Philadlephia Courthouse COURT DOCKETS and Lisa Michelle Lambert UPS Mailing of
May 31, 2016
Trip to Philadelphia Dockets and FilingsPage 1 of 57 Tuesday, May 31, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 225
187 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 998
Page
of 2413
999 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Trip to Philadelphia Dockets and Filings Page...
We secretly dined at Barberet: Here's a review for our Incogneato series | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Bistro and bakery in downtown Lancaster has it all - a welcoming staff, great atmosphere
and terrific food.
16-Mc-49 u.s. District Court Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Appeal Statement of Issues to Be Presented
on Appeal, June 1, 2016 Complete Doc
16-Mc-49 u.s. District Court Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Appeal Statement of Issues to Be
Presented on Appeal, June 1, 2016 Complete Doc - Free ebook download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read book online for free. 16-Mc-49 u.s. District Court Chapter 11
Bankruptcy Appeal Statement of Issues to Be Presented on Appeal, June 1, 2016 Complete
Doc
Superior Court Case No. 2016 1164 EDA Kathleen Kane Appeal ORDER Re Trial Court Record
Filed With Docket Sheet With Stan J. Caterbone as AMICUS June 2, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 226
188 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITED UNNATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 999
Page
of 2413
1000 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
9:51 A.M.Appeal Docket Sheet Superior Court of Pennsylvania Docket Number: 1164
EDA 2016 Page 1 of 3 May 1...
Regular live music to end at The Lancaster Dispensing Company after Thanksgiving weekend |
Entertainment | lancasteronline.com
After 38 years of regular live music, The Lancaster Dispensing Company will
Superior Court of Pennsylvania Case No. 1915 MDA 2015 ORDER Denying Motion to Quash
by Lancaster County District Attorney Until Time of Disposition April 1, 2016
Superior Court of Pennsylvania Case No. 1915 MDA 2015 ORDER Denying Motion to
Quash by Lancaster County District Attorney Until Time of Disposition April 1, 2016 -
Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Superior Court of
Pennsylvania Case No. 1915 MDA 2015 ORDER Denying Motion to Quash by Lancaster
County District Attorney Until Time of Disposition April 1, 2016
Bar/lounge, bakery/bistro are latest projects on bustling downtown Lancaster block | Local
Business | lancasteronline.com
A French bistro/bakery and a Venetian restaurant with a rooftop terrace are slated to open
in June at 26 E. King St., Lancaster.
Dave Dumeyer to continue as one of longest-serving leaders of Lancaster GOP | Politics |
lancasteronline.com
Dave Dumeyer, one of the longest serving chairmen in the history of the Republican
Committee of Lancaster County, was re-elected to another two-year term Thursday night.
Lancaster man charged with hiding gun his girlfriend used in Weis Markets robberies | Local
News | lancasteronline.com
The boyfriend of a woman charged with two armed robberies at Weis Markets, has been
charged with hiding the gun used in the hold-ups.
You need to make $17.25/hour to afford a 2-bedroom apartment in Lancaster County | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
If youre struggling to make your rent each month, youre not alone far from it.
Hersheypark Stadium's summer lineup: From Bryan to Beyonce to Blink-182 | Entertainment |
lancasteronline.com
Luke Bryan will kick off Hersheypark Stadium's summer lineup on Saturday.
Eight is enough: Parade of spokespersons reveals the dysfunction in Kathleen Kane's office |
Editorials | lancasteronline.com
Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane has had eight count 'em
spokespersons in her tenure in office. People generally dont just walk away from a
$120,000-a-year spokesperson position.
Lancaster County Court Case No. 08-CI-13373 Re PRAECIPE to ADD DEFENDANTS King
Street Bars June 3, 2016
Lancaster County Court Case No. 08-CI-13373 Re PRAECIPE to ADD DEFENDANTS
King Street Bars June 3, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read
online for free. Lancaster County Court Case No. 08-CI-13373 Re PRAECIPE to ADD
DEFENDANTS King Street Bars June 3, 2016
Is Oct. sale of Daniel Groff property the final chapter in tragic story? | News |
lancasteronline.com
Groff's two-acre property, overgrown and strewn with some of his beloved junk, his gray
Dodge Aspen and his trailer home, is scheduled to be auctioned off at a county sale
Child killer is found dead in Arizona canyon | News | lancasteronline.com
A Mount Joy woman who was found not guilty by reason of insanity for killing her two
sons in 2004 has died in a minivan crash in Arizona.
Superior Court 1561 MDA 2015 Petition for Allowance to Pa Supreme Court of June 6, 2016
Superior Court 1915 MDA 2015 Petition for Allowance to Pa Supreme Court of June 6, 2016
www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com mailto:amgroup01@msn.com Stanley J.
Caterbone Advanced Media Group 1250 Fremont Str...
Recorded - US District Court 15-03984 EXHIBIT Re EXCLUSIVE Transcripts of
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 227
189 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1000
Page
of 1001
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Whistleblower Testimonies as Targeted Individuals of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and Related
Hearings and Lectures, June 5, 2015 Wit Bio
Recorded - US District Court 15-03984 EXHIBIT Re EXCLUSIVE Transcripts of
Whistleblower Testimonies as Targeted Individuals of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and
Related Hearings and Lectures, June 5,... by stan5j.5caterbone in Types > Business/Law >
Court Filings, cia, and dia
Pennsylvania attorney general sued by twin sister for discrimination
Superior Court Cases 1915 MDA 2015 and 1561 MDA 2016 Stamped Copies-Invoices-Photos of
Trip to Harrisburg PA to File Appeal to PA Supreme Court on June 7, 2016
Gmail - Attacked by Pitbull at 1252 Fremont While Working on My Fence - My Statement of
June 10, 2016
Gmail - Attacked by Pitbull at 1252 Fremont While Working on My Fence - My Statement
of June 10, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
RECORDED Case No. 15-03984 EXHIBIT Re CERTIFIED LETTER to Steve, Phil, And Mike
Caterboner Re Taxes, Insurance, And Expenses at 1250 Fremont Street - December 28, 2015 on
June 11, 2016
RECORDED Case No. 15-03984 EXHIBIT Re CERTIFIED LETTER to Steve, Phil, And
Mike Caterboner Re Taxes, Insurance, And Expenses at 1250 Fremont Street - December
28, 2015 on June 11, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read
online for free. RECORDED Case No. 15-03984 EXHIBIT Re CERTIFIED LETTER to
Steve, Phil, And Mike Caterboner Re Taxes, Insurance, And Expenses at 1250 Fremont
Street - December 28, 2015 on June 11, 2016
Obama Ordered Hit-list of Targeted Individuals Worldwide to CYBER ATTACK, ISOLATE,
FINANCIALLY RUIN the TARGETED INDIVIDUAL With Supporting Documents - Published
by Debre Dupre in the Examiner on June 8, 2013
Obama Ordered Hit-list of Targeted Individuals Worldwide to CYBER ATTACK,
ISOLATE, FINANCIALLY RUIN the TARGETED INDIVIDUAL With Supporting
Documents - Published by Debre Dupre in the Examiner on June 8, 2013 - Free ebook
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read book online for free. Obama Ordered
Hit-list of Targeted Individuals Worldwide to CYBER ATTACK, ISOLATE,
FINANCIALLY RUIN the TARGETED INDIVIDUAL With Supporting Documents -
Published by Debre Dupre in the Examiner on June 8, 2013
U.S. District Court Case No.49-MC-2016 Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Appeal Re in Forma Pauperis
Application June 13, 2016
Letter to Dave Brown of Pearson, Koutcher Law Firm of June 14, 2016 With Docs
Letter to Dave Brown of Pearson, Koutcher Law Firm of June 14, 2016 With Docs - Free
ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read book online for free. Letter to
Dave Brown of Pearson, Koutcher Law Firm of June 14, 2016 With Docs
MJ 02102-Cv-0000137 Notice to Defend MDJ David Miller June 13, 2016
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIACOURT OF COMMON PLEAS
LANCASTER COUNTY CIVIL DIVISION Mariner Finance, LLC : :...
Lancaster Regional Medical Center Pitt Bull Attack at 1252 Fremont St. Emergency Room
Medical File of June 10, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone Capabilities Marketing Brochure Produced for Pflumm Contractors in 1995
Letter to J.C. Christensen & Associates Re Wells Fargo Collection of June 16, 2016
Letter to J.C. Christensen & Associates Re Wells Fargo Collection of June 16, 2016 by
stan5j.5caterbone in Types > Business/Law > Court Filings, cia, and dia
Stan Caterbone and Advanced Media Group Incident Report of Victimizations of U.S. Sponsored
Mind Control and COINTELPRO of 2015 Updated October 31, 2015 for WELLS FARGO
Stan Caterbone and Advanced Media Group Incident Report of Victimizations of U.S.
Sponsored Mind Control and COINTELPRO of 2015 Updated October 31, 2015 for
WELLS FARGO - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for
free.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 228
190 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1001
Page
of 1002
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Recorded - Case No. 15-03984 Habeus EXHIBIT Re Letter Re Aggrevated Assualt by Rental
Zone of Pennsylvania Franchisee of Lancaster, PA of June 15, 2016
Recorded - Case No. 15-03984 Habeus EXHIBIT Re Letter Re Aggrevated Assualt by
Rental Zone of Pennsylvania Franchisee of Lancaster, PA of June 15, 2016 by
stan5j.5caterbone in Types > Business/Law > Court Filings, cia, and dia
Is Lancaster County Harboring ISIS SYMPATHIZERS - Full Report - What We Know About
the 300 ISIS Sympathizers in the U.S., By Jane Harmon December 2015
By Stan J.Caterbone and Advanced Media Group Is Lancaster County Harboring ISIS
Sypathizers? Page 1 of 506 June 16, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 229
191 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1002
Page
of 1003
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
<p...
Letter to Dr. Sivia Gratz, Fairmount Behavioral Health Systems June 19, 2016
Pusps.com Flat Rate Env 062S0000001307 Click-N-Ship Mailed from 17603 9405 5036
9930 0344 4958 37 006...
For Pain Meds - Documentation to Obtain Whirlpool Spa from Medicare Via Humana
Supplemental Policy June 20, 2016.pdf
Recorded Case No. 15-03984 Habeus Corpus DECLARATIONS in Support of Amended Habeus
Corpus Dated December 16, 2015, Filed on June 21, 2016
15-03984 DECLARATIONSPage 1 of 99 June 21, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 230
192 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1003
Page
of 1004
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
15-03984 DECLARATIONS Page 2 of 99 June 21, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 231
193 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1004
Page
of 1005
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
15-039...
Recorded Letter to Dr. Anthony Mastropietro, System Chief Medical Officer at Lancaster
Regional Medical Center With Medial Records June 22, 2016
Recorded Letter to Dr. Anthony Mastropietro, System Chief Medical Officer at Lancaster
Regional Medical Center With Medial Records June 22, 2016 by stan5j.5caterbone in
Types > Business/Law > Court Filings, cia, and dia
Navy SEAL: The Best Things In Life Arent Things At All, But Relationships
A former Navy SEAL shares the way his perspective has evolved since getting out of the
military.
PA Supreme Court Case No. 354 and 353 MT 2016 Letters and Orders of June 13, 2016
PA Supreme Court Case No. 354 and 353 MT 2016 Letters and Orders of June 13, 2016 by
stan5j.5caterbone in Types > Business/Law > Court Filings, cia, and dia
Recorded Case No. 15-03984 EXHIBIT re Stan J. Caterbone Cash Account Balances as of June
23, 2016 $31,109.00
Recorded Case No. 15-03984 EXHIBIT re Stan J. Caterbone Cash Account Balances as of
June 23, 2016 $31,109.00 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online
for free.
Recorded Case No. 15-03984 Habeus EXHIBIT Re Stan Caterbone and ADVANCED MEDIA
GROUP 16 Year Investment in Downtown Lancaster, June 2, 2007
Case 5:15-cv-03984-JCJ Document 72 Filed 06/24/16 Page 1 of 131Page 1 of 129
Downtonw Investments www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.c...
USPS Priority Mail Confirmations and Letters for CD-ROMS as of June 24, 2016
USPS Priority Mail Confirmations and Letters for CD-ROMS as of June 24, 2016 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. USPS Priority Mail
Confirmations and Letters for CD-ROMS as of June 24, 2016
U.S. District Court Case No.49-MC-2016 Chapter 11 Bankruptcy ORDER of Hearing Date July
19 Re in Forma Pauperis Application June 28, 2016
U.S. District Court Case No.49-MC-2016 Chapter 11 Bankruptcy ORDER of Hearing Date
July 19 Re in Forma Pauperis Application June 28, 2016 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf) or read online for free.
Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Relief June 27,
2016 Work in Progress Ver 6.0 With Exhibits
Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Relief
June 27, 2016 Work in Progress Ver 6.0 With Exhibits - Free ebook download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read book online for free. Lancaster County Court of Common
Pleas Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Relief June 27, 2016 Work in Progress Ver 6.0
With Exhibits
Stan Caterbone OFFICIAL POLICE INCIDENT Reports of Harassment and Vandalism From
Southern Regional Police Department May 27, 2006
Stan Caterbone OFFICIAL POLICE INCIDENT Reports of Harassment and Vandalism
From Southern Regional Police Department May 27, 2006 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
Samuel Caterbone Criminal File From 1973
Samuel Caterbone Criminal File From 1973 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read
online for free.
Letter to Epic Card Re Complaint of Bonnie Lee Polygraph Solutions and Supporting
Documentation August 11, 2015
Executive Summary With Sworn Testimony and Affidavits of Stan J. Caterbone Family
Victimization of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control
Executive Summary With Sworn Testimony and Affidavits of Stan J. Caterbone Family
Victimization of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text File (.txt) or read book online for free.
Stan Caterbone Address Book of the 1970's and 1980's Scanned on July 8, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 232
194 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1005
Page
of 1006
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan Caterbone Address Book of the 1970's and 1980's Scanned on July 8, 2016 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free.
Recorded Case No. 15-03984 EXHIBIT Re Case No. 08-13373 Lancaster County Court of
Common Pleas in the Matter of CATERBONE v Duke Street Business Center, Et.al., July 9,
2016
Case 5:15-cv-03984-JCJ Document 82 Filed 07/09/16 Page 1 of 83PROTHONOTARY OF
LANCASTER COUNTY Katherine Wood-Jacobs Prothonot...
Letter to the Honorable Judge Leonard G. Brown, III Re CI-16-05815 Re Prothonotary Problems
July 10, 2016 With Attachments
Letter to the Honorable Judge Leonard G. Brown, III Re CI-16-05815 Re Prothonotary
Problems July 10, 2016 With Attachments by stan5j.5caterbone in Types > Business/Law >
Court Filings, cia, and dia
Recorded Case No. 15-03984 Habeus EXHIBIT Re Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media
Group Court Docket Matrix and Pro Se Billings July 11, 2016
CD-ROM to PA State Representative Todd Stephens Re Kathleen Kane Impeachment Committee
and PA Supreme Court Dockets and Electronic Filing Passcode Trip on July 11, 2016
CD-ROM to PA State Representative Todd Stephens Re Kathleen Kane Impeachment
Committee and PA Supreme Court Dockets and Electronic Filing Passcode Trip on July 11,
2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or read online for free.
CI-16-05815 Preliminary Injunction in Forma Pauperis ORDER DENIED by Judge Leonard G.
Brown III on July 8, 2016 in the Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas With Docket of July
11, 2016
CI-16-05815 Preliminary Injunction in Forma Pauperis ORDER DENIED by Judge
Leonard G. Brown III on July 8, 2016 in the Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas
With Docket of July 11, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read
online for free.
Stan J. Caterbone Court Schedule for July 12, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone Court Schedule for July 12, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text File (.txt) or view presentation slides online.
Recorded Case No. 15-03984 Habeus COMPLAINT Re IFP Approved by Judge Margaret Miller
in CP-36-SA-0000219-2016 Summary Appeal and DENIED in Preliminary Injunction by Judge
Brown July 11, 2016
Gmail - Activity in Case 5:15-cv-03984-JCJ CATERBONE v.
LANCA...https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?
ui=2&ik=acf0584318&view=pt&sear... ...
CI-16-05815 Preliminary Injunction in the Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas MOTION
for RECONSIDERATION of IFP ORDER of July 8, 2016 Filed on July 12, 2016
MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION OF IFP ORDER OF JULY 8, 2016COURT OF
COMMON PLEAS OF LANCASTER COUNTY Stan J. Caterbone ADVANCED MEDIA
G...
Case No. CI-16-05815 Exhibit to Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Emergency Relief, Re
Allstate Testimony Volume 2 and Volume 1 Filed on July 12, 2016
Case No. CI-16-05815 Exhibit to Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Emergency Relief,
Re Allstate Testimony Volume 2 and Volume 1 Filed on July 12, 2016 - Free download as
PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
Invoice to Secretary of Defense Ash Carter for Victimization of U.S. Sponsored Torture Program
July 15, 2016
Invoice to Secretary of Defense Ash Carter for Victimization of U.S. Sponsored Torture
Program July 15, 2016 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online
for free.
Recorded Case No. 16-Cv-49 Bankruptcy Appeal DECLARATION Re Invoice to Secretary of
Defense Ash Carter for Victimization of U.S. Sponsored Torture Program July 15, 2016
Case No. CI-16-05815 Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Emergency Relief ORDER
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 233
195 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1006
Page
of 1007
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
DISMISSED by Judge Leonard G. Brown on July 8, 2016
16-1001 Third Circuit Court of Appeals Habeus Corpus Case - OrDER Re Petition for Rehearing
DENIED Judge Michael Fisher July 8, 2016 to U.S. Supreme Court
16-1001 Petition to U.S.Supreme Court Page 1 of 89 July 15, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 234
196 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1007
Page
of 1008
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
16-1001 Petition to U.S. Supreme Court Page 2 o...
Kohls Sketchers Reciept July 16, 2016
Kohls Sketchers Reciept July 16, 2016 by stan5j.5caterbone in Types > Business/Law >
Court Filings, cia, and dia
Recorded U.S. District Court Case No. 16-cv-49 Bankruptcy Appeal NOTICE re Press Release re
CATERBONE v. the United States of America, et.al., July 16, 2016
Recorded U.S. District Court Case No. 16-cv-49 Bankruptcy Appeal NOTICE re Press
Release re CATERBONE v. the United States of America, et.al., July 16, 2016 by
stan5j.5caterbone in Types > Business/Law > Court Filings, cia, and dia
Recorded U.S. District Court Case No. 16-Cv-49 Bankruptcy Appeal NOTICE Re Press Release
Re CATERBONE v. the United States of America, Et.al., July 16, 2016
Case 2:16-mc-00049-EGS Document 13 Filed 07/16/16 Page 1 of 2Stan J. Caterbone
ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP Freedom From Covert Harassment ...
Recorded U.S. District Court Case No. 16-Cv-49 Bankruptcy Appeal NOTICE Re Press Release
and Executive Summary Re CATERBONE v. the United States of America, et.al., July 16, 2016
Case 2:16-mc-00049-EGS Document 13 Filed 07/16/16 Page 1 of 2Stan J. Caterbone
ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP Freedom From Covert Harassment ...
USPS Monday DELIVERY CONFIRMATION and Invoice to Secretary of Defense Ash Carter
for Victimization of U.S. Sponsored Torture Program July 15, 2016
Recorded U.S. District Court Case No. 16-cv-49 Bankruptcy Appeal NOTICE re Press Release
and Executive Summary re CATERBONE v. the United States of America, et.al., July 16, 2016
Recorded U.S. District Court Case No. 16-cv-49 Bankruptcy Appeal NOTICE re Press
Release and Executive Summary re CATERBONE v. the United States of America, et.al.,
July 16, 2016 - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read book online
for free.
Linkedin Correspondence With My TI Friend Soleilmavis Liu of China and Her Published Books
- July 18, 2016
List of conversations Active Conversation May 6 Soleilmavis Liu Dear Stan, Thanks for
helping. I am fine. Suffering still. I...
People to People International SELECTED Stan J. Caterbone as an OPTICAL PUBLISHING
EXPERT in 1990 to Tour Russia and Eastern Europe
Stan J. Caterbone Home Now and Since Birth at 1250 Fremont Street Photo Inventory of July 25,
2016
Stan J. Caterbone Home Now and Since Birth at 1250 Fremont Street Photo Inventory of
July 25, 2016 by stan5j.5caterbone
Complaint and CONFIRMATION of Psychiatric Abuses From Citizens Commission for Human
Rights or CCHR September 25, 2009 Important
Complaint and CONFIRMATION of Psychiatric Abuses From Citizens Commission for
Human Rights or CCHR September 25, 2009 Important by stan5j.5caterbone in Types >
Business/Law > Court Filings, cia, and dia
Lancaster City Handout for Friday August 19, 2016
SONY-POWER STATION Joint Venture Proposal & Deal May 1987
August 4, 2016 - Letter From the OFFICE of the EXECUTIVE of the Third Circuit Court of
Appeals Re Judicial Complaint No. 03-16-900046 v. Edward G. Smith and ALL U.S. DISTRICT
COURT JUDGES
Search - Supreme Court of the United States
New Film Exposes Black Magic and CIA Mind Control Connections To Scientology, Hollywood
and More - Press Release Rocket
Josh Reeves - The Spellcasters Volume One - Download Link - YouTube
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 235
197 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1008
Page
of 1009
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Josh Reeves - The Spellcasters Volume One (2016) Purchase The New Film Here.
Download Link - http://store.payloadz.com/details/2501436-movies-and-videos-docu...
Letter to Clerk of U.S. Supreme Court Re a Petition for a Writ of Certiorari, August 9, 2016
Gmail - To Attorney Barry Goldman, Esq., Re Assault by Your Clients, Ben Frank and Altana
Staff, At the Marriott Bar (Penn Square Grill) Last Night Sunday August 8, 2016
Timeline of Kathleen Kane case - News - The Times-Tribune
Mediation Negotiations With Lancaster County and Lancaster City Police Chief Keith Sadler
Through the Lancaster Human Rights Commission, January 4, 2007
Mediation Negotiations With Lancaster County and Lancaster City Police Chief Keith
Sadler Through the Lancaster Human Rights Commission, January 4, 2007 - Free
download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
US SUPREME COURT Rules and Guidance
CT Gov. Malloy Must Address NYPD-CIA and FBI Spying on and "COINTELPRO" Disruption
of Muslims and Left-Wing Activists | Black Star News
Lancaster County sheriff on indefinite leave | Insider | lancasteronline.com
Lancaster County sheriff is on leave.
Barack Obama speech at Democratic National Convention 2016 - YouTube
Barack Obama speech at Democratic National Convention 2016
Statement of Facts Re Lancaster City Police Department v. CATERBONE August 6, 2016
PA Supreme Court Decision On Kane Case | WDAC
One of the Most Painful (Physical) Days Ever - April 2, 2010
One of the Most Painful (Physical) Days Ever - April 2, 2010 - Free download as PDF File
(.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. One of the Most Painful (Physical) Days Ever
- April 2, 2010
Deputy accuses Lancaster County Sheriff Mark Reese of sexual harassment | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
The deputy sheriff, Jessica Padilla, alleges in a complaint filed with county commissioners
Chairman Dennis Stuckey that Sheriff Mark Reese tried to coerce her into a sexual
relationship beginning in
Mike Pence town hall in Lancaster attracts ardent Trump supporters, no protestors | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
The crowd that gathered for the Mike Pence town hall Tuesday in Lancaster had strong
opinions about the man that prompted them to attend the presidential campaign event.
Kathleen Kane's mixed poll results still golden in election
Threats and Assaults at Aroogas, Copper Hill, Jacks and Stalking by Dave Kagel and Millersville
Boro Police (2) Officers at Jacks Door August 9, 2016
Police chief says Lebanon County Philhaven no stranger to law enforcement | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
The Lebanon County Philhaven is no stranger to local law enforcement.
LG Health picks nation's largest mental-health hospital chain for planned 126-bed facility |
Insider | lancasteronline.com
Lancaster General Health has chosen the nations largest provider of inpatient mental health
services as its partner to build and operate the 126-bed psychiatric hospital it is planning in
northwest
U.S. District Court Case No.15-03984 Habeus Corpus NOTICE by STANLEY J. CATERBONE
the U.S. Government is Hiring Irish Mobsters to Assisinate Me August 11, 2016
U.S. District Court Case No.49-MC-2016 Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Appeal NOTICE by
STANLEY J. CATERBONE the U.S. Government is Hiring Irish Mobsters to Assisinate Me
August 11, 2016
Lancaster City Water Payment on Website of 100 ILLEGAL BALANCE OF $269 August 10,
2016 EVIDENCE OF CONSPIRACY TO CONDEM PROPERTY - August 10, 2016
Family awarded $8.4 million payout in malpractice suit | Insider | lancasteronline.com
A Lancaster County jury awarded a family more than $8.4 million Friday, nearly tripling
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 236
198 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1009
Page
of 1010
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
what was believed to be one of the largest medical malpractice lawsuits awarded in the
county
Pennsylvania AG's former top deputy testifies for government | Local News | lancasteronline.com
NORRISTOWN, Pa. (AP) Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane returns to the
defense table and a former boyfriend-turned-top deputy to the witness stand when Kane's
perjury case resumes.
Najib teases ex-DPM; Justo may turn DOJ witness; Salleh warns of mind control - Malaysiakini
JOSH REEVES DOWNLOAD STORE- File Download
New Film Exposes Black Magic and CIA Mind Control Connections To Scientology, Hollywood
and More
<img style=
Recorded-15-03984 u.s. District Court Habeus Corpus Motion to File Exhibit Titled - Lancaster
City Evidence of Conspiracy to Condemn and Extort Property - August 10, 2016 Updated August
11, 2016
Recorded-16-Mc-49 U.S. District Court Chapter 11 Motion to File Exhibit Titled - Lancaster City
Evidence of Conspiracy to Condemn and Extort Property - August 10, 2016 Updated August 11,
2016
4 priests who served in Lancaster County accused of sexually abusing children | Faith |
lancasteronline.com
Four priests who previously served Lancaster County parishes within the Diocese of
Harrisburg are among 15 priests accused of child sexual abuse, according to an
investigation by the York Daily
Consultant: I conspired with attorney general to frame aide | Local News | lancasteronline.com
NORRISTOWN, Pa. (AP) A political consultant told jurors Thursday that he
"conspired" with Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane to pin a grand jury leak on
her top deputy.
August 4, 2016 - Complaint No. 2016-462 (Brown) Letter From the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania Judicial Conduct Board v. Leonard Smith III
Justice Scalia's unexamined death points to a problem - CNN.com
Forensic pathologist Judy Melinek says that the justice's death feeds conspiracy theories
unnecessarily; there should have been an autopsy
More Documents Re Lancaster City Evidence of Conspiracy to Condem and Extort Property -
August 11, 2016
Recorded-16-MC-49 - Lancaster City EVIDENCE of CONSPIRACY to CONDEMN and
EXTORT PROPERTY - With Banking History for PNC, Wells Fargo, And Bank of Bird-In-
Hand - Published August 12, 2016
COINTELPRO action, not "Anonymous" video. : Indybay
Discussion of why the video call for a July 15th "Day of Rage" supposedly from
"Anonymous" was almost certainly a COINTELPRO action.
Jere Gish comes home to anchor WGAL's a.m. news | Entertainment | lancasteronline.com
Who says you can't go home again?
Gmail To All Contacts- (178 Pages in 5 Sections) What Gives You the Right to Torture Me
County of Lancaster, Pennsylvania - August 12, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone's VICTIMIZATION of TORTURE - What Gives You the Right, Lancaster
County? August 12, 2016
TYPED VERSION - US District Case No. 16-Cv-4014 CATERBONE v. United States of
America Et.al., Motion to Withdraw Filed at Clerk of Court Counter on August 5, 2016
Police to hire law firms to tackle cyber criminals in radical pilot project | UK news | The
Guardian
Private firms will use civil courts to seize fraud suspects assets, prompting concerns over
profit motive
New York's JFK airport in chaos after unfounded shooting report and evacuations | US news |
The Guardian
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 237
199 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1010
Page
of 1011
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Reports of shots fired in the departures area of terminal eight appear to be a false alarm but
spark severe delays
USPS Certified Mail Reciepts Re Pennsylvania State Police Liquor Control Enforcement Formal
Complaint of August 12, 2012 - August 13, 2016
Lancaster County Prison Board announces new program aimed at transparency, efficiency | Local
News | lancasteronline.com
Officials are promising an unprecedented view into the inner workings of Lancaster County
Prison as they start implementing a new initiative to improve efficiency, transparency and
accountability.
Jerry Sandusky: 'Not the monster I was made out to be' | Pennsylvania | lancasteronline.com
BELLEFONTE, Pa. - Returning to court four years after the child sex-assault trial that put
him in prison, Jerry Sandusky on Friday decried the flawed defense put on by his
RECORDED 15-03984 EXHIBIT Re the Illegal Arms Trade the Iraq v. Iran War of 1980
James Guerin and Adm. Bobby Ray Inman of the NSA October 25, 2015 and Letters to the
Editors of LNP, Lancaster Newspapers Marc
NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden: 'I don't want to live in a society that does these sort of
things' - YouTube
Edward Snowden: A Timeline - NBC News
From his school days on the East Coast to working for U.S. intelligence and contractors
around the world to leaking documents and fleeing to Russia.
Recorded U.S. District Case No. 15-03984 DECLARATION Re Pennsylvania State Police
Liquor Control Enforcement Formal Complaint of August 12, 2012 Updated
The Districts get ready to come home for Live on Vine | Entertainment | lancasteronline.com
The Districts, which features three Warwick High School graduates, will return home this
weekend to perform at Live on Vine.
Robber strikes Lancaster city bank | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Lancaster police are investigating a robbery at Wells Fargo bank Thursday afternoon.
19 things to know about FOX News anchor Megyn Kelly | PoliticsChatter
A star who has risen to the top of her network at FOX, Megyn Kelly will question and
skewer commentators on both sides of the political spectrum.
Advanced Media Group Letter to Steve, Phil and Mike Re 1250 Fremont Street Taxes December
28, 2015
Letter to Mike Caterbone Re Response to Email and Lancaster County Ready to Work Graduate
Certification With Job Applications April 2, 2008
Recorded-15-03984 - Lancaster City EVIDENCE of CONSPIRACY to CONDEMN and
EXTORT PROPERTY - With Banking History for PNC, Wells Fargo, And Bank of Bird-In-
Hand - Published August 12, 2016
U.S Court Dockets for Monday August 15, 2016 in Philadelphia
Case No. 14-02559 LAMBERT Habeus Judge Diamond ORDER of August 8, 2016 CLOSING
Case
Comcast BROCHURES From Customer Serice Visit on Monday August 15, 2016
Stan J Caterbone-International Signal Control or ISC-The-CIA-The-NSA-And US Sponsored
Mind Control in Lancaster, Pennsylvania - September 25, 2015
Implant Victim?
Convicted killer Robert Zook Jr. dies in state prison | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Robert Zook Jr., serving a life sentence for a double murder in 1985, has died in prison.
Aleppo: Russia ready to 'fight together' with US in shattered Syrian city | World news | The
Guardian
No confirmation from Washington but Russian defence minister talks of fighting together
Im only talking about Aleppo here to bring peace
Man charged with shooting at couple outside of Altana Rooftop Lounge | PennLive.com
Police said bar staff and patrons detained Jafohn Ahmere Carl after he allegedly fired a shot
at two victims at around 1:20 a.m. Aug. 14 on the first block of East King Street.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 238
200 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1011
Page
of 1012
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
SUBMITTED VERSION 16-1001 Third Circuit Court of Appeals Habeus Corpus Case to the
Supreme Court of the United States- A PETITION for a WRIT of CERTIORARI, August 9,
2016
16-cv-4014 - CATERBONE v. the United States of America,et.al., COMPLAINT July 20, 2016
ver 3.0 Full With Forms July 22, 2016
16-cv-4014 - CATERBONE v. the United States of America,et.al., COMPLAINT July 20,
2016 ver 3.0 Full With Forms July 22, 2016 - Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf),
Text File (.txt) or read book online for free. 16-cv-4014 - CATERBONE v. the United
States of America,et.al., COMPLAINT July 20, 2016 ver 3.0 Full With Forms July 22,
2016
Hacking group auctions 'cyber weapons' stolen from NSA | Technology | The Guardian
Group called Shadow Brokers says it infiltrated NSAs elite Equation Group and teases
files including some named in documents leaked by Edward Snowden
Neighbors, LG Health discuss traffic, parking impacts of planned behavioral health hospital |
Insider | lancasteronline.com
Comments appear already to have influenced an important decision about the future
Lancaster Behavioral Health Hospital: The number of vehicular entry points.
Lancaster County sheriff still being paid while under investigation for sexual harassment | Insider
| lancasteronline.com
As an investigation into his alleged sexual harassment of a female subordinate was
underway, Sheriff Mark Reese was signed up to tour a brewing company and take in a
ballgame
19-year-old man suffers graze wound in Lancaster shooting | Local News | lancasteronline.com
A 19-year-old man suffered a minor wound after being grazed by a bullet in Lancaster city
Monday night.
Lancaster city to install accessible pedestrian signals; some wonder why it took so long | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
When Brian Braightmeyer wants to walk between VisionCorps North Queen Street office
and Lancaster Central Market, he relies on his guide dog, Dewey, or a sighted person to
help him
PRESERVED Claims in U.S. Federal Court for Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group
August 16, 2016
The deep ocean: plunging to new depths to discover the largest migration on Earth | Environment
| The Guardian
The deep ocean makes up 95% of Earth, yet only 0.0001% has been explored the
Guardian joined a mission off Bermuda looking deeper than ever before
Mind Control 1979 Project MKUltra documentary CIA LSD experiments movie film - YouTube
This documentary delves into the CIA's secret MKUltra project which experimented with
various purported mind control techniques including giving soldiers and...
Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group International Signal and Control, PLC (ISC) File
of August 17, 2016 Copyright 2016
Recorded Case 16-mc-49 EXHIBIT Re LANCASTER COUNTY Convicted Killer and Now
DECEASED Targeted Individual and MIND CONTROL Victim Robert P. Zook, Jr. - August 17,
2016
Pennsylvania State Background Check for Stan J. Caterbone Re PA Capitol Press Pass of January
19, 2016
Whistleblower rewards | qui tam False Claims Act | attorneys
Whistleblower law firm Phillips & Cohen explains the rewards for qui tam whistleblowers
under the False Claims Act, based on over 28 years of experience.
57 COUNTRIES VISIT Advanced Media Group Website - Statistics for
www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com - May to August 18, 2016
RECORDED August 12, 2016 in Clerk of U.S. Supreme Court re FINAL - 16-1001 Third Circuit
Court of Appeals Habeus Corpus Case to the Supreme Court of the United States- A PETITION
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 239
201 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1012
Page
of 1013
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
for a WRIT of CERTIORARI, August 7, 2016
For Pain Meds - Documentation to Obtain Pain Medication From Lancaster Regional Hospital
August 21, 2016 - With TOC
For Pain Meds - Documentation to Obtain Pain Medication From Lancaster Regional
Hospital August 21, 2016 - With TOC - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt)
or read online for free. For Pain Meds - Documentation to Obtain Pain Medication From
Lancaster Regional Hospital August 21, 2016 - With TOC
How Trolls Are Ruining the Internet | TIME
Jay Curtis Corporation Video 1991 - YouTube
March 9, 2016 - I found cash missing from my safe at Fremont Street..
Washington Post Eastern Regional Free Agent Camp March 24 2005
Pro Football Tryout Camps: a Small Chance at Long OddsBy Christine Brennan
Washington Post Staff Writer The Washington Post (1974-Cu...
Mike Caterbone CFL Player of Week 1986 - YouTube
The quarterback for the Ottawa Roughriders that Mike played with was non other than JC
Watts of Oklahoma, who later would become a very influential member of...
Cheneys Spoon-Benders Pushing Nuclear Armageddon Intellegencer Review 2005 by Advanced
Media Group August 19, 2016
Cheney's 'Spoon-Benders' Pushing Nuclear Armageddon
Incredible | Secrets of United States - New Documentary - YouTube
Incredible | Secrets of United States - New Documentary Follow us on our Facebook page -
https://www.facebook.com/GadjetMania123?ref=hl
The Monetary Hawks | Jacobin
ANN COULTER
HEADER BOOKMARKS
Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus Corpus to US District Court for the MIDDLE
DISTRICT of PENNSYLVANIA on August 22, 2016 Ver 5.0 With Forms
Letter From Steve Caterbone Recieved on Monday August 22, 2016
Nice Try USA - Steve Caterbone Protection From Abuse Form August 23, 2016 BOOKMARKS
(Download)
Recorded Case No. 16-Cv-1751 US District Court Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of Habeus
Corpus to US District Court for the MIDDLE DISTRICT of PENNSYLVANIA on August 23,
2016
The Surreptitious Reincarnation of COINTELPRO With the COPS Gang-Stalking Program
August 22, 2016 Written by Rahul D. Manchanda, Esq.
EXHIBIT for Case No. U.S. District Court 16-Cv-1751 Re Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ
of Habeus Corpus to US District Court for the MIDDLE DISTRICT of PENNSYLVANIA on
August 24,, 2016
Central Italy earthquake: at least 35 dead in Amatrice says mayor live | World news | The
Guardian
Mayor of Amatrice says half of the town is isnt here any more after severe earthquake
hits central Italy and is felt in Rome
Francis of Assisi - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Evolution of Beyonce - Pentatonix - YouTube
Spotify: http://smarturl.it/ButterflyOnSpotify iTunes: http://smarturl.it/ButterflyOniTunz
Google: http://smarturl.it/ButteflyGooglePlay Amazon: http://smart...
CHARMING PENN MANOR AREA 20+/- ACRE ESTATE W/ CONESTOGA RIVER
FRONTAGE - Hess Auction Group
Sylvia H. Rambo - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Judge Sylvia H. Rambo | Middle District of Pennsylvania | United States District Court
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 241
203 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1014
Page
of 1015
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Case No. U.S. District Court 16-Cv-1751 DOCKET SHEET Re Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone
Writ of Habeus Corpus to US District Court for the MIDDLE DISTRICT of PENNSYLVANIA
on August 24, 2016
Facebook forgot the web's birthday and now it's trying to pretend it remembered | Technology |
The Guardian
As Tim Berners-Lee has pointed out, nothing important happened online on August 23
1991
History of the Internet - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Irrevocable Trust Free Legal Forms
HAARP's new owner holds open house to prove facility 'is not capable of mind control' - Alaska
Dispatch News
FBI IC3 Complaint of August 26, 2016
Kane trial wrap-up: Was Kathleen Kanes jury trial rigged? | Newslanc.com
A series of pre-trial decisions rendered against Kane in the weeks and months leading to the
jury verdict helped to seal her fate -- long before a jury was ever
Private Treble Damage Actions Under Federal Antitrust Law | Mahler Law Firm, LLC
Private Treble Damage Actions Under Federal Antitrust Law, Under federal antitrust law,
persons and companies harmed by anticompetitive conduct may seek an award of triple
their damages, an injunction, and costs of the action (including attorney fees) against a
party that violates federal antitrust laws. For example, price fixing or an agreement among
competitors on the price they will charge is considered a per se illegal violation of Section 1
of the Sherman Act, 15 U.S.C.S. 1, that the government may prosecute as a felony. As a
further deterrent to such activity, those harmed by the violation may seek treble damages
and an injunction.
First Digital Movie & Power Station/Tony Bongiovi (99) uploads | Scribd
99 uploads including Letter Dated December 10, 2015 - Postmarked December 22, 2015 -
Received January 7, 2016 From the U.S. Department of Justice Office of the Inspector
General Re Investigative Jurisdiction, Advanced Media Group and Stan J. Caterbone Legal
Document re Tolling the Statute of Limitations for ALL Claims - Do I Have a Rico Claim
Authored on July 9, 2006, Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane & Stan
Caterbone Strategic Planning Notes for 2016, 15-3400 EXHIBIT Re Social Security
Disability Benefits for Mind Control With Application Documents and Correspondence
From SSA Examiners and Investigators of 2009, December 27, 2015, and Social Security
Benefits Application Documents and Correspondence From SSA Examiners and
Investigators of 2009, December 27, 2015
$168 million payout to Johnson & Johnson whistleblowers - Nov. 4, 2013
The $2.2 billion settlement includes millions paid out to whistleblowers in three states.
History of the Internet - DARPA and Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media Group, August 25,
2016
Advanced Media Group Letter to the Editor of Lancaster Newspapers September 6, 2015 Full
Version
Advanced Media Group Letter to the Editor of Lancaster Newspapers September 6, 2015
Full Version - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free.
Advanced Media Group Letter to the Editor of Lancaster Newspapers September 6, 2015
Full Version
GP found dead after being suspended over bipolar disorder blog | UK news | The Guardian
Dr Wendy Potts was suspended after patient complained about blog in which she wrote
about having condition
Stan J. Caterbone v. Lancaster Freethought Society August 27, 2016 With Lawsuit of August 25,
2016 Published on August 27, 2016
Scientists have created nanobots that can release drugs into the body using mind control |
BreakingNews.ie
Scientists believe the bots could be used to dispense drugs in people.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 242
204 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1015
Page
of 1016
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
CrimeReports
CrimeReports helps residents see and understand where crime is happening in their
neighborhood and engage with their local law enforcement agencies. Find out more!
img-160829134718
Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)
Pennsylvania Can Do More to End Marijuana Arrests, Gov. Tom Wolf Says | NBC 10
Philadelphia
Gov. Tom Wolf says Pennsylvania needs to decriminalize small amounts of marijuana
possession in systematic fashion, and remains guarded about the kind of recreational
legalization in several western states.
Facebook mind control experiments linked to DoD research on civil unrest RT America
Facebook's experiment on over half-a-million unsuspecting users has taken a new twist
with the revelation that a researcher connected to a Department of Defense-funded program
to use the military to quell civil unrest also participated in the study.
Facebook - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Advanced Media Group - Mark Zuckerberg and His Facebook Mind Control Strategies and
Known Atheist Tuesday August 30, 2016
PARTIAL LIST of Ameritrade History of DAY TRADING Transactions From 2002 to April 9,
2016
Executive Management Team
The Huntington Executive Management Team is here for you. Learn more about our team.
Historical revision: The Paxton Boys and the Conestoga Massacre | Editorial |
lancasteronline.com
Paxton Boys - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
masons
Advanced Media Group - Mark Zuckerberg and His Facebook Mind Control Strategies and IS A
Known ATHEIST Tuesday August 30, 2016
Letter and Documents to Steve Caterbone Coral Gables Forida Re Coming Home - NO WAY,
Tuesday August 30, 2016
Carisoprodol - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Pat Meehan - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
US Attorney Patrick Meehan announces resignation
PHILADELPHIA - U.S. Attorney Patrick L. Meehan, who as chief prosecutor for
southeastern Pennsylvania cracked down on government corruption in Philadelphia,
announced his resignation on Monday.
Former CIA Officer Evan McMullin Launches Independent Presidential Bid - ABC News
Former CIA Officer Launches Independent Presidential Bid
Gov. Wolf: Decriminalize marijuana - We break up families for reasons we shouldn't | WPXI
Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf told Channel 11’s Cara Sapida on Tuesday that he
thinks marijuana should be decriminalized.
DoD Allowed Government Spending At Casinos And Strip Clubs, According To New Report
A new federal report found DoD workers spent nearly $100,000 at strip clubs and almost
$1 million at casinos from July 2013 through June 2014.
Carisoprodol: Uses, Dosage, Side Effects - Drugs.com
Carisoprodol is a muscle relaxer that works by blocking pain sensations. Learn about side
effects, interactions and indications.
16-3284 Third Circuit Court of Appeals Chapter 11 Appeal Case - Third Circuit Fully Completed
Affidavit of Poverty of August 31, 2016
Shhhh - Alberto Gonzales - Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia
Cee Lo Green - FUCK YOU - YouTube
CeeLo's new album HEART BLANCHE - arriving worldwide on Friday, November 6th
Pre-order on iTunes: https://smarturl.it/iHeartBlanche Pre-order on Amazon: ht...
SpaceX Explosion Destroys Satellite, Sets Back Facebook's Internet Push in Africa - Yahoo
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 243
205 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1016
Page
of 1017
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
From Yahoo: An explosion occurred during a SpaceX fueling operation at its launch site in
Florida around 9:07 a.m. Eastern today, destroying a satellite that Facebook intended to use
to provide internet connectivity to rural Africa, SpaceX officials and local authorities said.
SpaceX was conducting a fueling test on Launch Pad 40 at Cape Canaveral when the
incident took place, an engineer at the Kennedy Space Center told ABC News. The
explosion happened "in preparation for today's static fire," and resulted in "the loss of the
vehicle and its payload," SpaceX said in a statement.
Mind Control And Cyberwarfare: The Russians Are Coming! OpEd Eurasia Review
Filed - Case No. U.S. District Court 16-Cv-04641 Re Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of
Habeus Corpus REQUEST to FILE via ECH September 8, 2016
The human toll of America's public defender crisis | US news | The Guardian
Years of drastic budget cuts have created bottomless caseloads for public defenders the
pack mules of the system and tipped the scales of justice against the poor
The Queen of the South in Matthew 12:42__
Brief introduction of the book "The Queen of the South in Matthew 12:42," which starts
from introducing the Dong-Yi People, Sheba(1)'s o The Queen of the South in Matthew
12:42 QueenOfSouth
My TI Friend From China Soleilmavis Liu Video For Her Book Titled The Queen of the South in
Matthe - YouTube
My TI Friend From China Soleilmavis Liu Video For Her Book Titled "The Queen of the
South in Matthew"
Inside the fight to reveal the CIA's torture secrets | US news | The Guardian
The first part of the inside story of the Senate investigation into torture, the crisis with the
CIA it spurred and the man whose life would never be the same
Oliver Stone: 'I'll eat my (expletive) shirt' if Trump wins
The director of the upcoming 'Snowden' film spoke his mind Thursday.
How The US Military Invented The iPhone
Just about all of the underlying technology in the iPhone can be traced back to military
research projects.
Untold History of United States - Bush & Obama: Age of Terror (Subtitulado Espaol) -
YouTube
"Para cambiar radicalmente la conducta del rgimen debemos pensar con claridad y
valenta, puesto que si algo hemos aprendido, es que los regmenes no quiere...
Robert Scheer: U.S. Pledge of $90 Million to Laos for Cluster Munitions Legacy Is Chump
Change - Truthdig
If the word terrorism has any meaning, it applies to the U.S. bombings in Laos during the
Vietnam War, says Truthdigs editor in chief. - 2016/09/09
US and Russia reach tentative agreement for Syria ceasefire | World news | The Guardian
Pause in fighting to begin on Monday night, allowing humanitarian aid to flow with
Russian and US forces set to launch joint airstrikes against extremists
Twitter Account From August 31, 2016 to September 9, 2016
IC3 Complaint Referral Form of September 9, 2016
Live Chat - XFINITY Chat - Comcast Corporation of Friday September 9, 2016
FBI IC3 Narrative of September 9, 2016
Mark Zuckerberg accused of abusing power after Facebook deletes 'napalm girl' post |
Technology | The Guardian
Norways largest newspaper published a front-page letter to the Facebook CEO lambasting
the companys decision to censor a photograph of the Vietnam war
Guerin 'home' to complete sentence | News | lancasteronline.com
Soon hell come back under quieter conditions.
Bobby Ray Inman - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Washington's $8 Billion Shadow - SAIC
Authentic
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
and Original
Santiago and
Defense
Documents of 206
HISTORY Page 244
1987 Archived
of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377
on October
Sunday
20,Morning
Friday
2015
Friday
January
Sunday
Friday
Reduced
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN
NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1017
Page
of 1018
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Authentic and Original Documents of 1987 Archived on October 20, 2015 Reduced by
stan5j.5caterbone in Types > Business/Law > Court Filings, cia, and dia
Mind Control Missile Murder Madness: Targets In The Unified Field
ISC Whistleblowing Timeline of Events Created on or About 1991 Proofed on September 17,
2015
Update: 2 shot in Columbia following large fight outside club early Sunday morning | Local
News | lancasteronline.com
Two shot after large fight involving night club patrons.
Emma Niles (CIA TORTURE): Truthdigger of the Week: Former British Ambassador and
Whistleblower Craig Murray - Truthdigger of the Week - Truthdig
Murray, who has been denied entry into the United States to travel to an intelligence-
community conference, was removed from the British diplomatic service after he exposed
human rights abuses in Uzbekistan. - 2016/09/10
Dr. Paul Newhart Pain Treatment of Monday September 12, 2016
What Trump Got Wrong About Veterans Suffering From Chronic Pain
We spoke with Rachel Fredericks, whose question to Trump during the recent Commander-
in-Chief Forum raised concerns about his knowledge of veterans suicide.
Will Peace Ever Be the Norm Again in the United States? - Live at Truthdig - Truthdig
Truthdig Editor in Chief Robert Scheer and his team will discuss this question with peace
activist, author and filmmaker Frank Dorrel at 1 p.m. PDT (4 p.m. EDT) on Thursday. -
2016/09/14
What Did We Buy With the $5 Trillion That the Iraq and Afghanistan Wars Have Cost Us? -
Juan Cole - Truthdig
The Iraq War was a government-led Ponzi scheme. As usual, the little people are the ones
who lost big. - 2016/09/13
Giuliani defends Trump idea to take Middle East oil: 'Anything is legal' in war | US news | The
Guardian
Former New York mayor and close Trump ally discusses Republican nominees call to take
Iraqs oil, a move which appears to break international law
Lancaster Catholic shooting drill will test school, county emergency preparedness | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
A training drill will take place at Lancaster Catholic High School Friday.
Recorded U.S. District Court Case No. 16-Mc-0049 Chapter 11 Appeal DECLARATION Re FBI
IC3 Complaint Referral Form of September 9, 2016
STAN J. CATERBONE 13 IMPORTANT US FEDERAL COURT DOCKET SHEETS as of
Friday, September 16, 2016
Sonali Kolhatkar: Inmates Launch Series of Work Stoppages to Protest Slave Labor - Truthdig
The U.S. incarcerates the greatest number of people in the world, and most of them are
expected to work inside the prisons that hold them, usually for well below minimum wage.
- 2016/09/16
U.S. Seeks to Prevent Islamic State From Looting, Selling or Destroying Antiquities - Truthdig
Continuing Saga: The Fight to Reveal the CIAs Torture Secrets - Truthdig
The Guardian released the second and third installments of its inside chronicle of the
struggle between the CIA and the Senate over the 2014 report on torture from the Select
Committee on Intelligence. - 2016/09/16
Stan J. Caterbone Financing Package of Saturday September 17, 2016
2004 Hyundai Santa Fe From Barry Miller Quality Cars for $5,495 CASH on Saturday
September 17, 2016
Alexander Reed Kelly: Truthdigger of the Week: Daniel Jones, the Senates Chief Investigator
Into Torture by the CIA - Truthdigger of the Week - Truthdig
Joneswho became a target of the CIA because he searched for the truththis week spoke
out for the first time. He has been a key force in the disclosure of a scandal that one senator
compared to Watergate. - 2016/09/17
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 245
207 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1018
Page
of 1019
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Pigs! Crusaders!: U.S.-Backed Fundamentalists Chase American Commandos Out of Syria -
Juan Cole - Truthdig
Turning the Americans back across the Turkish border, the Free Syrian Army members
cursed them and asserted that the U.S. is attempting a military occupation of Syria. -
2016/09/19
NOTICE of HEARING October 5, 2016Summary Appeal CP-36-SA0000219-2016 MDJ Scott E
Albert Vehicle Turning Left September 6, 2016 Certified Mail
Members 1st Federal Credit Union Statement as of September 19, 2016 for Santa Fe Auto Check
Payment and DEPOSIT From TD on September 19, 2016
Gun nation: a journey to the heart of America's gun culture video | World news | The Guardian
A revealing and unsettling journey to the heart of Americas deadly love affair with the gun
Emma Niles: Footage in Oklahoma Police Shooting Prompts Nationwide Outrage - Truthdig
Terence Crutcher, an African-American man, was killed by a white police officer in Tulsa
on Friday. A video of the incident has caused many to argue that he was killed in cold
blood. - 2016/09/20
Elizabeth Warren Skewers Wells Fargo CEO, Accusing Him of Greed and Gutless Leadership
(Video) - Truthdig
You should resign, you should give back the money you took while this scam was going
on and you should be criminally investigated by both the Department of Justice and the
Securities and Exchange Commission. - 2016/09/20
Angelina Jolie files for divorce from Brad Pitt citing irreconcilable differences | Film | The
Guardian
Jolies attorney says decision was made for the health of the family after two years of
marriage amid reports Jolie has asked for custody of their six children
PACTS Testimonial - For PAIN MEDICATIONS - Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas
Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Relief September 21, 2016
Case No. U.S. District Court 16-Cv-04641 ORDER Re Petitioner Stanley J. Caterbone Writ of
Habeus Corpus DISMISSED Without Prejudice on September 19, 2016 by Judge Edward Smith
In FORMA PAUPERIS for Pain Medications - Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas
Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Relief September 22, 2016
FINAL FILING - For PAIN MEDICATIONS - Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas
Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Relief September 22, 2016
Directory List & Print: print directory tree, copy to clipboard and export into Word or Excel.
Free software for printing of directory trees, content of drives, MP3 lists, print the drive's
directory structure. Freeware to list, print and export of directory trees.
STAMPS - For PAIN MEDICATIONS - Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas Preliminary
Emergency Injunction for Relief September 22, 2016
FILE EXHIBIT for PAIN MEDICATIONS - Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas
Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Relief September 21, 2016
When Barack met Michelle: the presidential biopic as love story | Film | The Guardian
Southside With You is the latest in a long line of presidential biopics. But since its simply
an account of the Obamas first date, with little reference to their illustrious future, how
will it rate alongside the likes of Young Mr Lincoln and PT 109?
Sonali Kolhatkar: Standing Firm in the Face of Violence - Sonali Kolhatkar - Truthdig
With police killings of unarmed black men almost a weekly occurrence in the U.S., we
must not let our trauma weaken our resolve to insist onand organize forracial justice. -
2016/09/22
Charlotte protests: governor of North Carolina declares state of emergency | US news | The
Guardian
Second night of unrest rocks the city following the fatal police shooting of Keith Scott, a
black man who was mistaken for a suspect
Stamped-FILE EXHIBIT for PAIN MEDICATIONS - Lancaster County Court of Common
Pleas Preliminary Emergency Injunction for Relief September 21, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 246
208 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1019
Page
of 1020
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Sep 22, 2016 - ORDER From the OFFICE of the EXECUTIVE of the Third Circuit Court of
Appeals Re Judicial Complaint No. 03-16-900046 v. Edward G. Smith and ALL U.S. DISTRICT
COURT JUDGES
Women Seeking Refuge: a Crisis Within a Crisis - Truthdig
Sexual violence is part of the price many women and girls fleeing their countries for
Europe must pay. This crisisnotably dire for Africanscan be mitigated if refugee aid
agencies give priority to specific female-centered measures. - 2016/09/23
Washington police hunt gunman who killed five at Burlington mall | US news | The Guardian
Authorities release image of darker complected suspect after fifth victim dies from
wounds suffered at Cascade mall
Curfew imposed in Charlotte as Keith Scott's family view footage of killing | US news | The
Guardian
Protesters block roads on third night of unrest as Scott family says police videos of
shooting sparks more questions than answers
The History of Italian American History - The Migration to Lancaster County and the
Implications of the Intelligence Community by the Advanced Media Group, September 24,
2016
WhistleblowerWeek
Natasha Hakimi: Truthdigger of the Week: CIA Whistleblower Jeffrey Sterling, in Prison and
Fighting for His Life - Truthdig
The Obama administration has made an example of Jeffrey Sterling, the first whistleblower
convicted under the Espionage Act. Now the former CIA agent is being denied proper
medical care in the federal detention center where he is imprisoned after being sentenced to
three years. - 2016/09/24
New fears for 1,000 lone children in Calais refugee camp | World news | The Guardian
French authorities hope Britain will honour pledges and rescue minors when the bulldozers
move in
Post Purchase (PPE) Rate and Review
[Lancaster Congressman Joe Pitts] received the most money from pain killer manufacturers |
Newslanc.com
LEHIGH VALLEY MORNING CALL: A joint investigation by The Associated Press and
the Center for Public Integrity found that drugmakers that produce opioid
Fentanyl Maker Kicks In Half a Million to Defeat Arizona Marijuana Legalization |
Newslanc.com
By Phil Smith DRUG WAR CHRONICLE: Marijuana legalization advocates have long
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 247
209 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1020
Page
of 1021
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
argued that pharmaceutical companies, who could lose out if
LNP EDITORS GOT THIS RIGHT: An answer to the affordable housing crisis | Newslanc.com
LNP EDITORIAL: Salisbury Township supervisors have said their goal isnt to keep
people out, but they simply dont want to build on land set aside for
KEISLING: Is Tom Wolfs moral compass broken? | Newslanc.com
Gov. Tom earolf tries going along to get along with GOP leaders. But what's he getting
from Senate Republicans with whom he's going along? Gov. Wolf isn't
Truthdigger of the Week CIA Whistleblower Jeffrey Sterling - In Prison and Fighting for His
Life by Truthdig September 25, 2016
Truthdig - Truthdigger of the Week: CIA Whistleblower Jeffrey Sterling,
...http://www.truthdig.com/report/print/truthdigger_of_the_week_cia_whis....
Stan Caterbone and Advanced Media Group's ESP & Mental Telepathy Research Documents
September 24, 2016
DARPA - ESP - MENTAL TELEPATHY & THE UNITED STATES
GOVERNMENT'S PROJECTS AND ACTIVITIES copyright 2007The calculated and
technological ent...
Stan Caterbone's Home at 1250 Fremont Street, Lancaster, PA Photo Inventory of September 25,
2016
City of Lancaster, PA Utilities Account for Water and Sewer Account for Stan Caterbone in 2016
Downloaded September 25, 2016
GEICO Auto Insurance ENDORSEMENTS for Policy No. 4430-72!86!85 of September 26,
2016
16-3284 Third Circuit Court of Appeals Chapter 11 Appeal Case - MOTION for
CONTINUANCE of September 27, 2016
Case No. 495 - 496 MAL 2016 the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania - MOTION for
CONTINUANCE of September 27, 2016
16-3284 Third Circuit Court of Appeals Chapter 11 Appeal Case - MOTION for
CONTINUANCE of September 27, 2016
Case No. 16 MDA 1924 Superior Court of Pennsylvania MOTION for CONTINUANCE Re
Lancaster City Police Department of September 27, 2016
Case No. Summary Appeal CP-36-SA-0000219-2016 Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas
- MOTION for CONTINUANCE Re Lancaster City Police Department of September 27, 2016
Case No. 495 - 496 MAL 2016 the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania - MOTION for
CONTINUANCE of September 27, 2016
Case No. Summary Appeal CP-36-SA-0000247-2016 Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas
- MOTION for CONTINUANCE Re Lancaster City Police Department of September 27, 2016
Case No. CI-16-08472 Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas CATERBONE v. LGH, et.al.,
Re MOTION for CONTINUANCE Re Lancaster City Police Department of September 27, 2016
Wells Fargo executives forfeit millions and CEO to forgo salary amid inquiry | Business | The
Guardian
Announcement comes three weeks after Wells Fargo agreed to pay $185m in penalties after
an audit found the bank used aggressive, illegal sales tactics
Manheim Township to replace police chief; board cites 'change in direction' | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Manheim Township commissioners said they will not renew the contract of police Chief
Neil Harkins.
Police seek person in clown mask after fatal stabbing Sunday in Reading | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
The conversation about clowns which has ranged from light-hearted to downright creepy
in recent weeks, as unidentified people dressed like clowns have appeared in mysterious
circumstances across the country
Gore Vidal: America the Great ... Police State - Gore Vidal's Essays - Truthdig
Let us accept that we are no longer a republic governed by lawsonly by armed men and
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 248
210 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1021
Page
of 1022
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
force. This is just like the days of Billy the Kid. You have an armed man going down a
dusty street, and that is authority. And it has come to this for us. - 2016/09/26
DOCUMENTATION For 2004 Hyundai Santa Fe From Barry Miller Quality Cars for $5495
CASH (Check) on Saturday September 17, 2016
Yahoo 'secretly monitored emails on behalf of the US government' | Technology | The Guardian
Company complied with a classified directive, scanning hundreds of millions of Yahoo
Mail accounts at the behest of NSA or FBI, say former employees
Maria Sharapovas reduced ban is good news for her bank balance | Kevin Mitchell | Sport | The
Guardian
Although not exonerated, Maria Sharapova views the cutting of her drug ban to 15 months
as a victory but the biggest benefit will be financial before retirement beckons
Has Obama's White House Tried to Use Mind Control to Push Government Programs?
Maybe not quite. But newly released records reveal that the Obama Administration quietly
hired 120 social and behavioral research experts to help sell policy to the public.
How the White Helmets Became Global Heroes While Pushing for U.S. Military Intervention in
Syria - Truthdig
Backed by Washington and marketed by a top public relations firm, the Syrian civil defense
organization is saving civiliansand lobbying for airstrikes and regime change. -
2016/10/04
The U.S. Breaks Off Military Cooperation With Russia in Syria (Video) - Juan Cole - Truthdig
On Monday, the United States government suspended talks with the Russian Federation on
how to end the Syrian conflict but said the step didnt imply all joint activity would end. -
2016/10/04
7-Year-Old Aleppo Girl Tweets Daily Struggle to Live Amid Bombings - NBC News
With the help of her mother, Bana al-Abed has been "live-tweeting" from the war-torn city
that's being bombarded by the Syrian and Russian governments.
Black Ops Advertising Dissects the Rise of Media Manipulation for Corporate Profit - Book
Excerpt - Truthdig
The currency of maximum importance in our digital world is personal data, personal
relationships and our very identities. - 2016/10/04
Assange Promises Significant Leak Before Election, Urges Journalists to Lend a Hand -
Truthdig
Some are calling it an October surprise that could affect the U.S. voting. But the
WikiLeaks founder says only that the website will release a mass of secret documents on
American foreign policy over the next 10 weeks. And, he adds, with more than a million
documents to get through, WikiLeaks needs all the help it can get. - 2016/10/04
http://lancasteronline.com/insider/lancaster-county-sheriff-s-office-to-undergo-sexual-
harassment-training/article_b2ed94ce-8c0a-11e6-9b33-cb0f6eebec20.html
The training comes on the heels of a female deputy sheriff's recent allegations of "severe
and pervasive sexual harassment" by Sheriff Mark Reese.
Paul Ryan in Lancaster County: Elect Lloyd Smucker to help 'save this country' | Pennsylvania |
lancasteronline.com
U.S. House Speaker Paul Ryan said he needs Republicans like Lloyd Smucker in Congress
to slash business regulations, simplify the tax code and build up the military.
Mike Farrell: Obama Stands Nuremberg on Its Head - Truthdig
President Obamas decision to spare CIA torturers from prosecution is wrong. Good
Germans who were only following orders are not exempt from the bar of justice.
Individuals must be held responsible for war crimes and crimes against humanity. -
2016/10/06
A Path That Could Lead to the Unthinkable: Nuclear War With Russia - Truthdig
The U.S. propaganda campaign against the Russian Federation is rolling downhill with a
dangerous momentum that threatens to drive the world into a catastrophic showdown. -
2016/10/06
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 249
211 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1022
Page
of 1023
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Thinking Dangerously in the Age of Normalized Ignorance - Truthdig
What happens when the spheres of morality and spirituality give way to a savage market
rationality? - 2016/10/06
Hurricane Matthew: storm weakens but continues to lash Florida and Georgia live | World news
| The Guardian
Death toll in Haiti reaches 330, officials say, as Florida governor declares state of
emergency
Eastern Aleppo could be destroyed by Christmas, warns UN Syria envoy | World news | The
Guardian
Staffan de Mistura warns of another Rwanda and offers to personally escort Islamist
fighters out of city to halt bombing
Columbia forum to focus on police relations, racial violence | Local News | lancasteronline.com
The next session in an ongoing public conversation on community-police relations and
racial violence is set for Tuesday, Oct. 11, in Columbia.
NSA contractor arrested for alleged theft of top secret classified information | US news | The
Guardian
Harold Thomas Martin, who worked at same consulting firm as Edward Snowden, may
have stolen codes developed to hack foreign governments
Whats Behind Time Magazines Putin Demonizing? - Truthdig
Russia Wants to Undermine Faith in the U.S. Election, declares a cover of Time
magazine. We should undermine our own faith in the U.S. election system. - 2016/10/05
Yahoo Spied on Customers Email at the U.S. Governments Request - Truthdig
The news proves the failure of U.S. government reforms to curb NSAs tendency to try
and indiscriminately vacuum up the worlds data, say rights groups. - 2016/10/05
Scott Ritter, Contributor - Truthdig
Damage from AC incident cost $13.5 million, Lancaster General Hospital says | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Nearly three months after an air-conditioning malfunction pumped humid air into operating
rooms, Lancaster General Hospital said Tuesday that it caused $13.5 million in damages.
Deputy sheriff notifies federal authorities of harassment allegations | Insider | lancasteronline.com
A Lancaster County deputy sheriff has filed a federal complaint of harassment.
Yahoo 'secretly monitored emails on behalf of the US government' | Technology | The Guardian
Company complied with a classified directive, scanning hundreds of millions of Yahoo
Mail accounts at the behest of NSA or FBI, say former employees
GEOCO - Documents & Photos
Manheim Township to replace police chief; board cites 'change in direction' | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Manheim Township commissioners said they will not renew the contract of police Chief
Neil Harkins.
higmark
Sonali Kolhatkar: Destruction Is All We Have to Show for a 15-Year War in Afghanistan -
Truthdig
Since 2001, the U.S. has spent more than $103 billion on the Asian countrymore than it
spent on the entire European continent after World War II. And there is no end in sight for
the debacle that George W. Bush began and Barack Obama continued. - 2016/10/07
The Age of Decline, Apple Pie and Americas Chosen Suicide Bomber - Truthdig
Thanks to perhaps trillions of words expended on him by nonstop commentators, pundits,
talking heads, retired generals and admirals, former intelligence chiefs and ex-Bush
administration officials, Donald Trump and his remarkable ego have become the wallpaper
of our lives. - 2016/10/08
Penn State rapid reaction: Nittany Lions 38, Maryland 14 (Happy Homecoming from Beaver
Stadium) | PennLive.com
Lions pummel previously unbeaten Maryland for 524 yards.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 250
212 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1023
Page
of 1024
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
14th Amendment | Constitution | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute
Amendment XIVSection 1.All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject
to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they
reside. No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or
immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any state deprive any person of life,
liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its
jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
Site | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute
ART MORRIS: Is a $10.3 million tax break fair to Lancaster residents? | Newslanc.com
Letter to the Editor by former Lancaster mayor Art Morris Art Morris About 10 years ago,
Lancaster Newspapers (LNP) and High Associates (High) were given
Lower energy costs should again give homeowners a break on heating bills this winter | Local
Business | lancasteronline.com
With the warm days of summer well behind us, residents may soon start thinking about
their winter heating costs.
Log Cabin restaurant to close Oct. 31 then reopen in January with new operators | Local Business
| lancasteronline.com
The Log Cabin restaurant in Warwick Township will close at the end of October, then is
expected to reopen in January.
Dale High and the Building of the Marriott Expansion - Is IT FAIR? - The Taxpayer Subsidy
Study by Art Morris and Stan Caterbone - October 6, 2016
Police say they are becoming emergency mental health services | UK news | The Guardian
Chiefs blame cuts in psychiatric care for 50% rise in detentions under Mental Health Act
Facebook revenge pornography trial 'could open floodgates' | Technology | The Guardian
Case of 14-year-old taking social network to court over naked picture has already resulted
in others seeking legal advice
Suzanne Vega: Its taken me a while to say, You are what you are, its fine | Music | The
Guardian
The 80s pop-folk star talks about her confused identity growing up, and her new album
about US writer Carson McCullers
Chris Hedges: The New Slave Revolt - Chris Hedges - Truthdig
The work stoppages and hunger strikes being carried out in prisons across the country show
that many of those locked in cages have a political consciousness we must begin to
emulate. - 2016/10/09
How Far Will Americans Take Anti-Muslim Hate? - Juan Cole - Truthdig
The de facto criminalization of being Muslim or speaking Arabic is proceeding apace
despite being contrary to every core American value and contradicting the First
Amendment. - 2016/10/09
Yemen and Dubai May Be at War, but Both Are Going Solar Big-Time - Juan Cole - Truthdig
There is news on the solar energy front, with the price of panels and installation falling
rapidly and popular adoption for novel purposes on the increase. - 2016/10/09
Saturday Night Live Tackles the VP Debate and Donald Trumps Sexism Scandal (Video) -
Truthdig
Alec Baldwin is really getting the most out of his impression of the Republican presidential
candidate. - 2016/10/09
Local Pennsylvania Susquehanna Valley Breaking News and Live Alerts - WGAL News 8
WGAL News 8 is your source for the latest local headlines and live alerts. Visit Pennsylvania
Susquehanna Valley's most reliable source for breaking news.
Trump says countries are turning on US because 'the world hates Obama' | US news | The
Guardian
The Republican said America and Barack Obama are globally loathed, citing frosty
relations with Rodrigo Duterte, just hours after criticizing the first lady
Russian man charged with hacking LinkedIn and other tech firms | Technology | The Guardian
LinkedIn has suggested the 29-year-olds arrest is tied to a 2012 breach that resulted in
more than 100 million of its users passwords being compromised
Usage Statistics for www.amgglobalentertainmentgroup.com TOTALS and MONTHLY to
October 22, 2016 With 30 of 40 TOP COUNTRIES October 22, 2016
Zuckerberg proves he is Facebook's editor by allowing Trump's hate speech | Technology | The
Guardian
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 261
223 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1034
Page
of 1035
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Deciding to make judgments about the newsworthiness of content is a major shift for the
social media platform whose CEO insists it is not a media company
USPS Delivery Confirmation and Letter of Sentence Recommendation for Kathleen Kane to
Honorable Judge Wendy Demchick-Alloy October 22, 2016
Robert Scheer and David Dayen Uncover Untold Stories of the Mortgage Crisis - Truthdig
In this weeks episode of Scheer Intelligence, the Truthdig editor in chief speaks with the
author of the book Chain of Title: How Three Ordinary Americans Uncovered Wall
Streets Great Foreclosure Fraud. Transcript added. - 2016/10/21
Massive Cyberattack Hits U.S. Servers, Affects Twitter, Reddit and Other Sites - Truthdig
On Friday, dozens of popular websites around the globe were shut down. The identity of
those responsible has not been verified yet, although one hacker group has claimed
responsibility. Updated. - 2016/10/21
Patty Hearst, Double Agents and the Symbionese Liberation Army - Truthdig
Jeffrey Toobins new book about the kidnapping of heiress Patty Hearst by the SLA in
1974 fails to treat the revolutionary group in sufficient detail. - 2016/10/21
The Donalds Five-Point Plan to Defeat Islam - Juan Cole - Truthdig
Kellyanne Conway (pictured), Donald Trumps campaign manager, touted the Republican
presidential candidates plan on MSNBC. - 2016/10/21
Lancaster County tops in state for renewable energy and solar panels | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Growing popularity of solar energy by Plain sects helps drive Lancaster County to the top.
Trump to make campaign's closing arguments Saturday morning in Gettysburg | Politics |
lancasteronline.com
While Hillary Clinton unveiled an emotional television ad featuring the parents of a slain
Muslim American Army captain, Donald Trump assured supporters he would have no
regrets if he loses
Lancaster CRIZ earns city $3.4 million for development | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Lancaster city learned Friday it will receive $3.4 million in state money for downtown hotel
expansions and other projects under the second year of a novel economic development
initiative.
Stan J. Caterbone Members 1st Federal Credit Union ACCOUNT ACTIVITY August 23, 2016
to October 22, 2016 BARRY MILLER CHECK.pdf
Movie: 'Citizenfour' Coming Monday, October 24, 2016
3 Manheim Township school buses crash on I-76 | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Three school buses transporting Manheim Township students to a band exhibition in
Springfield were involved in a crash on I-76 east at about 3:30 p.m., according to state
police.
Attacks on the internet keep getting bigger and nastier | National | lancasteronline.com
NEW YORK (AP) Could millions of connected cameras, thermostats and kids' toys
bring the internet to its knees? It's beginning to look that way.
SNL Final Debate Spoof - Trump Vs Hillary (Round 3) - YouTube
Enjoy the very best of SNL
Donald Trump vs. Hillary Clinton Town Hall Debate Cold Open - SNL - YouTube
The gloves are off. Donald Trump (Alec Baldwin) faces off against Hillary Clinton (Kate
McKinnon) again this weekend on Saturday Night Live. Get more SNL: ht...
Donald Trump vs. Hillary Clinton Debate Cold Open - SNL - YouTube
Donald Trump (Alec Baldwin) and Hillary Clinton (Kate McKinnon) face off in the first
presidential debate, moderated by Lester Holt (Michael Che). Get more S...
Summit teaches School District of Lancaster seventh grade girls about empowerment | Local
News | lancasteronline.com
Nearly 200 seventh-graders gathered Friday at an inaugural event designed to empower
Lancaster city teenage girls of color.
Day care leader confronts loitering, drugs in neighborhood | Insider | lancasteronline.com
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 262
224 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1035
Page
of 1036
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Nina Moragne is fed up with the loitering, panhandling and drug dealing in front of and
on the steps of the Lancaster Early Education Center.
The Military Is Using Artificial Intelligence, But Its Not What You Think
However, the Pentagon is trying to integrate more AI technology into military robots.
Chris Hedges: How Power Works - Chris Hedges - Truthdig
Historian Heather Ann Thompsons book on the 1971 Attica prison uprising details the
governments brutality, lies and propaganda, demonization of the poor, obstruction of
justice and silencing of those who tried to tell the truth. She exposes the American blueprint
for social control. - 2016/10/23
Burnham profits in Q3 plummet 79.4% due to lower sales | Local Business | lancasteronline.com
Burnham Holdings said Wednesday that its third quarter net profits plunged 79.4 percent,
due to a 21.7 percent drop in sales.
Cyber attack: hackers 'weaponised' everyday devices with malware to mount assault | Technology
| The Guardian
Hundreds of thousands of devices such as webcams and DVRs were infected with
malicious code to create a so-called botnet to target leading sites
In the Spotlight: With new job, Jeremy Young is building on the strength of the city | Local News
| lancasteronline.com
In his new job, Lancaster city resident Jeremy Young is helping shape what the city will
look like a decade from now.
Bill in PA Legislature could restrict information coroners could release | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Coroners would no longer be allowed to release circumstances of a persons death under
legislation being considered in Harrisburg.
Race for state Senate: Scott Martin and Greg Paulson would bring different perspectives to
Harrisburg | Pennsylvania | lancasteronline.com
Scott Martin and Greg Paulson are far from freshmen to the Lancaster County political
scene.
Bills concerning police transparency, police use of radar before PA Legislature in final days |
Local News | lancasteronline.com
Pennsylvania senators are scheduled to vote on a House bill Monday that would protect the
identity of officers who fire their weapons or use force.
Ex-Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane faces sentencing - CNNPolitics.com
Back in August, Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane resigned from office in
disgrace after being convicted of multiple felonies stemming from a politically-motivated
act of retribution. Now a judge will decide whether her abuse of her elected office was
enough to send her to prison.
News about KATHLEEN KANE SENTENCING on Twitter
Bill Information - House Bill 1538; Regular Session 2015-2016 - PA General Assembly
CCR News: A victory for torture accountability
Analysis: Notre Dame bye week revelations, from mind control to lessons from Ara | Notre
Dame Insider Football | ndinsider.com
What matters most with Miami rolling into town
Hillary Clinton's record as secretary of state hints at possible presidential role | US news | The
Guardian
The Democratic candidate visited 122 countries and faced crises in Afghanistan, Libya and
Syria but insiders say she defies easy categorisation as a hawk or dove
Supporters | The Guardian Members
Supporters protect our editorial freedom and help us seek out those stories that people are
determined to keep hidden.
Say No again to judges | Newslanc.com
By Dick Miller WE.CONNECT.DOTS: Pennsylvania was once known for the quality of its
judicial system. At least that is the claim of Peter F. Vaira, a
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 263
225 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1036
Page
of 1037
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Recent Russian Events That Are of Significance | Newslanc.com
By Slava Tsukerman The stuffed dummy of Solzhenitsyn hanging on the doors of the
Gulag Museum in Moscow This week three events were most commented upon
Where is Lancaster County most conservative? Most liberal? | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Lancaster County is 52 percent Republican, 32 percent Democrat and 15 percent
independent, voter registration figures show.
Commentary: Beating Ohio State a pivotal moment for PSU football | Football |
lancasteronline.com
STATE COLLEGE The whole thing is a blur right now to be honest with you.
Repairing the damage done by disgraced Attorney General Kathleen Kane | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
When he was sworn in as Pennsylvania's attorney general in August, Bruce Beemer had a
massive task before him: to clean up the mess left behind by Kathleen Kane, who
The Innocent Origins of Todays Corporate Crimes - WSJ
In an excerpt from his new book, Why They Do It: Inside the Mind of the White-Collar
Criminal, Eugene Soltes writes that for much of recorded history, businesses were
financed by a single person or small group. But over time, larger and more ambitious
business ventures began to uproot this basic structure and the personal ties between
executives and investors eroded.
EDITORIAL: What does it take to get Pennsylvanians to wake up to statewide corruption? |
Newslanc.com
Publisher Robert Field and columnist Bill Keisling have long pondered how Pennsylvania
can be consistently rated among the most corrupt five states in the union
LETTER: Paul Ware bemoans losses to his foundation caused by institution he headed |
Newslanc.com
Re: Jamanis Family Concert September 14, 2016 at 4:24 pm Edit Good thing its free. Last
time I contributed to something by Veri & Jamanis, it
Gunshot strikes victim in groin during armed robbery in Manheim Township
The 18-year-old victim told police a man held him up yesterday at gunpoint on the 1000
block of Olde Hickory Road. When the suspect started going through the mans pockets a
gun went off, striking the victim in the groin area.
1 killed, 2 injured in shooting at Fort Lauderdale-area apartment WSVN 7News | Miami News,
Weather, Sports | Fort Lauderdale
Judge to Kathleen Kane: 'extraordinary abuse of the system' warrants 10 to 23 months in prison |
Pennsylvania | lancasteronline.com
NORRISTOWN Former Attorney General Kathleen Kane was sentenced Monday to 10
to 23 months in prison for her conviction on two counts of lying under oath to cover up
Former Pa. Attorney General Kathleen Kane gets 10 to 23 months in jail in revenge, perjury case
- CBS News
Kane was also sentenced to 8 years probation by Montgomery County judge who said her
ego drove her to break the law
kathleen kane - Google Search
Ex-attorney general sentenced to jail, then cuffed in court | Local News - WTAE Home
Former Attorney General Kathleen Kane was sentenced Monday to 10 to 23 months in jail
for illegally disclosing details from a grand jury investigation to embarrass a rival and lying
about it under oath.
Judge hands jail sentence to former Pennsylvania AG Kathleen Kane (+video) - CSMonitor.com
Former Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane was sentenced with 10 to 23 months
in jail on Monday, after she was convicted of perjury and obstruction of justice after
leaking grand jury information and then lying about it under oath.
Kathleen Kane, Former Pennsylvania Attorney General, Is Sentenced to Prison - The New York
Times
Ms. Kanes unlikely political career came to a humiliating close on Monday, when a judge
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 264
226 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1037
Page
of 1038
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
sentenced her to 10 to 23 months in prison for perjury and abuse of her office.
Defendants Sentencing Memorandum
Kathleen Kane, Former Pennsylvania Attorney General, Is Sentenced to Prison - The New York
Times
Ms. Kanes unlikely political career came to a humiliating close on Monday, when a judge
sentenced her to 10 to 23 months in prison for perjury and abuse of her office.
Brad Bumsted - HOME
Who's News: Lancaster County hirings and promotions | Local Business | lancasteronline.com
Here's a roundup of recent hirings and promotions of management-level employees who
live or work in Lancaster County.
The Latest: Ex-attorney general: 2 sons have been suffering - The Washington Post
The Latest on the sentencing of former Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane (all
times local):
Defendant-S.pdf
Former PA Attorney General Kathleen Kane gets prison term - CNNPolitics.com
A judge sentenced former Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane on Monday to 10
to 23 months in prison for committing multiple felonies stemming from a politically
motivated act of retribution.
5 Reasons That Snowden Is Probably A PsyOp | We see as through a glass darkly
1. If he were a real whistleblower, leaking super-secret classified documents and agendas
that posed an existential threat to the tyrannical powers, he would simply be dead.
Typically, honest-to-goodness whistleblowers have a tendency of suddenly committing
"suicide", (often inflicting damage upon themselves that would be quite difficult for a
person to do themselves, such as
CITIZENFOUR Edward Snowden Documentary Film 2014 - YouTube
AT&T Is Spying on Americans for Profit - The Daily Beast
New documents reveal the telecom giant is doing NSA-style work for law enforcement
without a warrantand earning millions a year from taxpayers.
Ex-PA Attorney General Sentenced to Jail for Lying Under Oath, Leaking Docs | Fox News
Insider
Pennsylvania's former top prosecutor has been sentenced to 10 to 23 months in prison,
followed by 8 years probation, after being convicted of leaking grand jury documents to the
press to apparently retaliate against a rival prosecutor, and then lying under oath about it.
Reactions to Kathleen Kanes Sentence | PoliticsPA
add-later
Facebook to consider public interest before removal of posts violating guidelines | Technology |
The Guardian
Move comes after repeated criticism of Facebook from news organisations, charities and
others over important posts being taken down without notice
Input from Community and Partners on our Community Standards | Facebook Newsroom
Top 10 hackers who turned activists TechWorm
You should know these top 10 hackers who turned activists Hacking combined with
activisms aka Hacktivism is an occurrence definite to the digital age, repr
Kathleen Kane sentence: At least 10 months in county jail
When you put your hand on the Bible, the judge told the convicted ex-attorney general,
you werent thinking of [your children]. You were thinking of yourself.
Updated Post Sentencing - USPS Delivery Confirmation and Letter of Sentence
Recommendation for Kathleen Kane to Honorable Judge Wendy Demchick-Alloy October 24,
2016
Kathleen Kane Posts Bail, Out of Jail Tuesday - Story | WETM-TV
Former Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane has posted bail hours after being
sentenced for illegally disclosing details from a grand jury investigation.
Bait and switch - The News
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 265
227 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1038
Page
of 1039
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Dear Editor,
RECIEPTS of Sunday October 23, 2016 - Lowes, Villanova West, Christina Hartman, Marriott at
Penn Square
Bon Jovi Vs: Bongiovi Rages On - MTV
August 27 -- Kissing cousins? Try kiss-off, cousin. A longstanding dispute between Jon
Bon Jovi and his second cousin Tony Bongiovi is in the news. Each is
Bongiovi DPS | Imagine Perfect Audio
A whole new way to enjoy sound on your computer
Quetta attack: Pakistan reels as more than 50 die in assault on police academy | World news | The
Guardian
Terrorists explode suicide vests after storming into Balochistan police college firing
machine guns and throwing hand grenades, say cadets and authorities
Former Pennsylvania attorney general Kathleen Kane sentenced to prison - The Washington Post
The quick rise and even quicker fall of Pennsylvania's former Attorney General.
Lancaster County woman recalls being shot in her neck as she sat in her parents' home | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Why.
Gen Mark Graham On Mental Illness: Be There To Help, And Not Judge
Retired Army Maj. Gen. Mark Graham encourages vets in need to get treatment.
Tom Hayden: Tom Haydens New Port Huron Statement - Articles - Truthdig
From the archives: The veteran social activist wrote a new preface to the manifesto that
helped shape a generations views on racial equality, participatory democracy and the
military-industrial complex. - 2016/10/24
Tom Hayden: How I Became an Activist - Truthdig
In a 20-minute interview, left-wing activist Tom Hayden, who died Sunday at age 76, tells
of his reluctant transformation from journalist to activist following an encounter with
Martin Luther King Jr. - 2016/10/24
On Contact: Chris Hedges and Hamza Yusuf Explore the Islamic World - Truthdig
The Truthdig columnist and the Islamic scholar review how Western interests have shaped
Muslim societies and how terror groups have perverted Islam. - 2016/10/24
'AT&T is Spying' report gets social media up in arms - CNET
Social Cues: Turns out, people aren't too happy with allegations that their privacy may be
jeopardized even more than they already knew.
Kathleen Kane, Former Pennsylvania Attorney General, Is Sentenced to Priso | Newslanc.com
NEW YORK TIMES: The brief, unlikely political career of Kathleen G. Kane,
Pennsylvanias brightest rising star when she was elected attorney general less than
Robert Field of Common Sense for Drug Policy - YouTube
Robert Field, Co-Chairman of Common Sense For Drug Policy; http://www.csdp.org is
intervewed about his contributions to drug policy reform, while in San Fran...
International Signal and Control - Wikipedia
Cluster bomb system and method - ISC Technologies, Inc.
Each bomblet within a cluster bomb is provided with an individually programmable
detonation time delay, such that the bomblets can be programmed to detonate at desired
intervals over a relatively long
Pennsylvania attorney general Kathleen Kane is released on $75,000 bail after two hours in jail |
Daily Mail Online
Kathleen Kane, 50, was freed Monday evening after a Pennsylvania judge sentenced her to
1- to 23 months in prison for leaking grand jury documents and then lying about it under
oath.
Prison Officials Ready To Welcome Kathleen Kane If Appeal Fails CBS Philly
When Kathleen Kane does eventually settle into her new digs at the Montgomery County
lock up, she'll be treated like any other inmate.
Kane Gets Slapped With Prison Time, Then Parking Ticket CBS Philly
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 266
228 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1039
Page
of 1040
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
To say it was a bad day for Kathleen Kane would be an understatement.
Mulberry Street in Lancaster city will again carry 2-way traffic beginning Nov. 1 | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Two-way traffic will resume on much of Mulberry Street on Nov. 1.
Poll: Kathleen Kane will serve up to 23 months, did judge get it right? | lehighvalleylive.com
Former Pennsylvania attorney general sentences for leaking grand jury information, lying
about it under oath.
2004 Hyundai Santa Fe From Barry Miller Quality Cars REGISTRATION and TITLE Dated
October 13, 2016 RECIEVED October 24, 2016
TONY BONGIOVI OFFICIAL WEBSITE
Tony Bongiovi created the Legendary Powerstation Studios and produced artist as
Aerosmith, Jimi Hendrix, Ozzy Ozbourne, The Ramones, Talking Heads, NoEnd,
Scorpions, The Rezillos, Aldo Nova, among many others
Power Station Founder Bob Walters Passes | ProsoundNetwork.com
Power Station Recording Studio
Power Station Recording Studio
The studio of the stars is up for sale - CNN.com
From B.B. King to Lady Gaga and Eric Clapton, Avatar Studios has played host to many of
the most famous names in music -- and produced a string of iconic albums.
Superior Court Re in Forma Pauperis Fraud by the Judiciary of the County of Lancaster and the
Common Pleas Court October 9, 2015
1108-2015 Superior Court 1915-MDA-2015 ORDER by President Judge Dennis e. Reinaker
ADMITTING WRONGDOING AND DEFAMATION Re Private Criminal Complaint v.
Lancaster City Police January 6, 2016
PA RAP (Rules of Procedure) Superior Court Citations Downloaded March 19, 2007
Carter suspends Pentagons demand of the return of cash bonuses to California soldiers | Fox
News
Secretary of Defense Ash Carter announced Wednesday that he was ordering the Pentagon
to suspend its efforts to recover decade-old reenlistment bonuses paid to thousands of
California Army National Guard soldiers who fought in Iraq and Afghanistan.
CIA Declassifies Report On The Man Who Ousted The Australian Government In 1975 |
Gizmodo Australia
There are a lot of different conspiracy theories about what happened to the Australian
government in November of 1975. In a surprise move, the ultra l...
OPINION WikiLeaks must continue to reveal priceless information | Opinion |
dailytoreador.com
On Oct. 12, WikiLeaks released emails hacked from John Podesta, chairman of Hillary
Clintons presidential campaign. These emails joined a string of releases this year that
included emails from the
Why Gov. Wolf is blocking an 'independent' inspector general to investigate waste and fraud |
Insider | lancasteronline.com
HARRISBURG Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf will veto a bill sponsored by two Lancaster
County Republican legislators that would establish what they see as an independent
inspector general to investigate
Chemical Concussions and Secret LSD: Pentagon Details Cold War Mind-Control Tests |
WIRED
More than 30 years after it was written, the Pentagon has released a memorandum detailing
its involvement in the CIAs infamous Cold War mind-control experiments. But a warning
to conspiracy theorists on the lookout for new fodder: This isnt quite Men Who Stare at
Goats II. The 17-page document (.pdf), Experimentation Programs conducted by the
Tech privacy ally Feingold leads in Wisconsin Senate race | Reuters
Next month's Senate election in Wisconsin could gain Silicon Valley a key ally in
Washington in the high-tech industry's battle against the U.S. government's growing
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 267
229 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1040
Page
of 1041
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
appetite for more access to private data.
Real Estate Tax | Berkheimer
The spy who couldnt spell: how the biggest heist in the history of US espionage was foiled |
Yudhijit Bhattacharjee | World news | The Guardian
The Long Read: Ever since childhood, Brian Regan had been made to feel stupid because
of his severe dyslexia. So he thought no one would suspect him of stealing secrets
SecDef Orders Pentagon To Suspend Collection Of Guard Bonuses
The defense chief has ordered the DoD to suspend the collection of bonuses improperly
awarded to California National Guardsmen.
Lancaster Fleet and Auto
Exclusive: Freed Panther Sekou Odinga on Joining the Panthers, COINTELPRO & Assata
Shakur's Escape | Democracy Now!
Former NSA exec: We misjudged potential of insider threats like Snowden | ZDNet
Chris Inglis, former deputy director of the NSA, warns that connected systems mean
malicious insiders can now do damage more quickly and more easily than ever.
AT&T, Time Warner and the Death of Privacy - Truthdig
Where you go, what you watch, with whom you speak, all your internet searches, gathered
and vertically integrated, sold to police and perhaps to corporate customersthis is our
future, unless we stop this merger. - 2016/10/26
Tom Hayden: Tom Hayden: Revolution, Protest and America - Truthdig
From the archives: The social and political activist discusses the war in Iraq, U.S.-Cuba
relations, and Americas war on drugs. (translated from a Cuban newspaper) - 2016/10/26
All-American Slaughter: The Youthful Carnage of Americas Gun Culture - Truthdig
The presence of gangs in neighborhoods where many American children are killed with
guns daily is used as a way to dismiss serious thinking about why this is happening. -
2016/10/26
Tom Hayden on the Vietnam War and Americas Collective Memory - Truthdig
In a speech last year in Washington, D.C., the late activist explained how Americans need
to remember the successes and the failures of the peace movement of the 1960s and
’70s in order to achieve political unity. - 2016/10/26
Meth Smokers Drove To NSA HQ With Guns, Drugs And A Grenade, Government Claims
Meth users rock up to Fort Meade with drugs, a shotgun, a revolver and a grenade,
according to a court filing.
Deputy attorney general fired by Kathleen Kane gets his job back | PennLive.com
A top lieutenant who was fired by former Attorney General Kathleen Kane after he testified
against her in a grand jury leak investigation has been restored to his former position in the
Attorney General's Office.
Artist Kerry Sacco chases the light in new show at Garth Gallery | Entertainment |
lancasteronline.com
Kerry Sacco is not interested in creating exactly what she sees in front of her.
Music for Everyone to take over Tellus360 Thursday | Entertainment | lancasteronline.com
Music for Everyone will host a concert event at Tellus360 to celebrate its 10th year.
Jay Z becomes first rapper nominated for Songwriters Hall of Fame induction | Entertainment |
lancasteronline.com
Jay Z, Madonna, Cat Stevens and Gloria Estefan are among the nominees for the 2017
Songwriters Hall of Fame induction.
Snowden Speaks On the Protection of the People Pepperdine Graphic
Contact Us Lancaster Fleet and Auto
LETTER TO LANCASTER FLEET AND AUTO re: Santa Fe Recovery at Lancaster Fleet and
Auto Tow Yard on October 27, 2016
CATERBONE v. the United States of America, Et.al., COMPLAINT July 20, 2016 Ver 2.0 Full
Recorded-DefenseNews Story by Joe Pitts ELECTROMAGNETIC Weapons and Founder of the
Electronic Warfare Working Group for Securing Weapons of the Future July 7, 2008
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 268
230 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1041
Page
of 1042
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Recorded-DefenseNews Story by Joe Pitts ELECTROMAGNETIC Weapons and Founder
of the Electronic Warfare Working Group for Securing Weapons of the Future July 7, 2008
- Free ebook download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read book online for free.
Recorded-DefenseNews Story by Joe Pitts ELECTROMAGNETIC Weapons and Founder
of the Electronic Warfare Working Group for Securing Weapons of the Future July 7, 2008
Jury rules in favor of ex-Penn State assistant coach in defamation case; $7 million in damages
awarded
A jury has ruled in favor of ex-Penn State assistant coach Mike McQueary in his
defamation case, awarding him over $7 million in damages.
Man who shot, killed ex-girlfriend in Mt. Gretna has died, police say
The man who police say shot and killed his ex-girlfriend at a Mt. Gretna ice cream shop on
Labor Day has died.
Names of Covert Agents Among Documents Stolen From NSA: Feds - NBC News
Documents found in the search of materials stolen by a former NSA contractor included
names of covert intelligence officers, federal prosecutors say.
Ex-Attorney General Gets 10 To 23 Months In Jail For Perjury | 90.5 WESA
Former Attorney General Kathleen Kane was sentenced Monday to 10 to 23 months in jail
for illegally disclosing details from a grand jury investigation to
US Approves Indefinite Gitmo Detention for CIA Torture Victim Abu Zubaydah
The Periodic Review Board at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba has determined that alleged Central
Intelligence Agency (CIA) torture victim Abu Zubaydah should remain in indefinite
detention, according to a Department of Defense release.
What Happens in Gitmo Stays in Gitmo: How CIA Buries its Dirty Secrets
What does the US government do when they can neither charge nor acquit a tortured
person? Evidently, they leave them to die. Radio Sputniks Brian Becker discusses the case
of Guantanamo inmate and torture victim Abu Zabaydah with whistleblower and former
CIA agent John Kiriakou.
Hacker who stole nude photos of celebrities gets 18 months in prison | Technology | The
Guardian
Ryan Collins ran a two-year phishing scam to gain the passwords of more than 100 people,
including Jennifer Lawrence, Rihanna and Avril Lavigne
Jury hands ex-Penn St. assistant over $7M in defamation case | Pennsylvania |
lancasteronline.com
BELLEFONTE, Pa. (AP) A jury awarded a former Penn State assistant football coach
$7.3 million in damages Thursday, finding the university defamed him after it became
public that his
Lyft, app-based ride hailing service, 'exploring interest' in Lancaster | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Lyft has begun recruiting drivers in Lancaster and is showing other signs that it is preparing
to launch its ride-hailing service here.
'Don't believe the polls': Donald Trump's supporters back him against the odds | US news | The
Guardian
At a rally in Geneva, the cries of lock her up! are loud and every negative opinion poll or
media report only entrenches the support of Trump fans
Michelle Obama showers Clinton with praise at joint rally: 'Hillary doesn't play' | US news | The
Guardian
The first lady referred to the Democratic nominee as my girl and the two shared a big hug
during their first campaign appearance together in North Carolina
Vagina Dispatches episode three: the orgasm gap video | Life and style | The Guardian
Women are less likely to orgasm than men but is it really more difficult for women?
Virtual Open House - Lancaster Catholic High School
VERE's Mind Control Robots Give Patients Out-of-Body Experience | Inverse
The VERE project uses an electroencephalogram (EEG) cap to allow paralyzed patients to
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 269
231 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1042
Page
of 1043
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
control robots remotely.
Word of Life: 'Financial crime that went bad'
The Word of Life Christian Church tragedy was a multifaceted case, ranging from financial
coersion to mind control, according to the cases top prosecutor.
Zombies are real! | Science News for Students
Some parasites worm their way into other creatures brains and alter their victims
behavior. Meet zombie ants, spiders, cockroaches, fish and more.
Kathleen Kane goes from rising star to fallen star | Commentary | phillytrib.com
The Kathleen Kane story is a tragedy.
Vet With PTSD, Service Dog Suing Airline After Abusive Treatment
She was denied boarding and grilled by airline employees about her dog and her illness.
Tom Hayden: Tom Hayden on Iraq: Beyond the Horizon, the Storm - Columns - Truthdig
From the archives: In 2006, the veteran social activist warned that an increasingly
mainstream anti-war movement can become unwieldy and prone to loss of focus: We no
longer are a huddling minority. ... We are immersed in the gradual soul-searching currents
of the mainstream, where loss of direction is a constant risk. - 2016/10/27
Federal court asked to invalidate Pa. judge-retirement vote | Newslanc.com
PHILLY.COM: : Two former Pennsylvania Supreme Court chief justices and a
prominent Philadelphia lawyer are now asking a federal court to declare a ballot
Ralph Nader and Noam Chomsky Have Their First Public Conversation (Video) - Truthdig
The renowned activists discuss Americas current electoral extravaganza, climate change,
the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and several other topics. - 2016/10/26
Former NSA contractor to ask to be released from prison at hearing Friday - Baltimore Sun
A former National Security Agency contractor charged with stealing government property
and taking classified information is again asking to be released from prison at hearing in
federal court Friday.
Reciepts - October 26, 2016
U.S. Passport Renewal Check October 28, 2016
USPS Label Clerk of Court and National Passport Processing Center, Philadelphia Pa October
28, 2016
Case No. Cp-36-SA-0000219-2016 Notice of Appeal to Superior Court of Pennsylvania October
28, 2016
US: NSA Contractor, Glen Burnie Resident, St | WBAL Radio 1090 AM
WBAL Radio 1090 AM - US: NSA Contractor, Glen Burnie Resident, Stole Info On
American Spies Abroad
OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE
Leaked email says 'no charges' would be filed in puppy abuse case that has SPCA, DA's office
sparring | Local News | lancasteronline.com
An email from a county detective appears to contradict a statement from the district
attorneys office that the investigation into an animal cruelty case is ongoing.
FBI investigating new emails tied to Hillary Clinton for classified information | National |
lancasteronline.com
WASHINGTON (AP) The FBI is investigating whether there is classified information
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 270
232 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1043
Page
of 1044
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
in new emails uncovered during the sexting investigation of disgraced former congressman
Anthony Weiner, the estranged husband of
Hillary Clinton demands FBI give details on latest email inquiry 'immediately' | US news | The
Guardian
Democratic candidate says sudden announcement with no explanation is not good enough
after FBI director notifies Congress of pertinent discovery
'I was left speechless': Bob Dylan breaks two-week silence over Nobel prize | Music | The
Guardian
After being criticised as arrogant for not responding to his prize, artist says he will attend
award ceremony if possible
KiMi Robinson: Millennials Search for Truth on Election and Distrust Media, Intelligence Firm
Reports - Truthdig
Young voters are using critical thinking, research and social media engagement to decide
whom they want as their next president. The big question is whether they will be motivated
to vote for candidates that anger and disappoint them. - 2016/10/28
Bill Boyarsky: Tom Hayden Fought for the Rights of All Living Things - Truthdig
The progressive activist compiled an impressive record in California and local politics
from 18 years in the state Capitol to a variety of community crusades. Even shelter animals
benefited from his work. - 2016/10/28
Tom Hayden: Tom Hayden: Things Come Around in the Mideast - Truthdig
From the archives: The veteran social activist, drawing upon his own rude political
awakening to the realities of Israeli and Middle East politics during the 1980s, warns that
the Israel lobby in the U.S. aims to roll back the clock and change the map of the region,
and that its neoconservative supporters will probably try to use the current Middle East
crisis to ignite a larger war against Hamas, Hezbollah, Syria and Iran. - 2016/10/28
Iraqs Skies Darken as Islamic State Torches Oil - Truthdig
With many civilians likely to die in the conflict in Iraq and Syria, the fighting also threatens
the environment as ISIS torches oil wells. - 2016/10/28
Paul Von Blum: Invisible Nation - Book Review - Truthdig
Families represent 37 percent of todays homeless population. Entire families live in the
streets, in cars, in temporary shelters and in single motel rooms. A new book examines
family homelessness in five American cities. - 2016/10/28
Democrats pile pressure on FBI's Comey over eleventh-hour Clinton email letter | US news | The
Guardian
Congressional heavyweights demand briefing on decision to bring up unspecified new
material less than two weeks before election
Barnstormers owner accepts Lancaster County's help with stadium rent, eyes more concerts and
amenities | Insider | lancasteronline.com
On Tuesday, the Lancaster County Commissioners agreed to help the owner of the
Lancaster Barnstormers pay its rent on Clipper Magazine Stadium.
Lancaster city man fatally shot in head Friday night | Local News | lancasteronline.com
A Lancaster city man was fatally shot in the head Friday night, according to city police.
Schools focus on policies during election that's been 'a social studies teacher's worst nightmare' |
Insider | lancasteronline.com
On Election Day, Cocalico Middle School students will have an important choice to make:
Should the Ramen Noodle Party or the Cookie Squad rule the school?
Kane sentence: Justice served | TribLIVE
I commend Montgomery County Common Pleas Judge Wendy Demchick-Alloy for
imposing an appropriate prison sentence of 10 to 23 months on disgraced former
Pennsylvania Attorney ...
The Best Way to Save Obamacare | Newslanc.com
NEW YORK TIMES OP-ED: As someone involved in the debate over the Affordable
Care Act from the start, I dont find these unhappy events all that surprising.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 271
233 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1044
Page
of 1045
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
The troubling similarities between Kane and Trump | Columnists | lancasteronline.com
I am hoping this is the last column I write, or need to, about either Kathleen Kane or
Donald Trump.
Plame speaks on career of being a CIA agent
Ask anyone to describe a typical CIA agent, and youll get a furtive figure in a slouch
hat and raincoat, with a pale face from long nights in smoke-filled bars.
Take Action | Global Zero
There are more than 17,000 nuclear weapons in nine countries. Each one is a catastrophe
waiting to happen.
Take Action | Global Zero
There are more than 17,000 nuclear weapons in nine countries. Each one is a catastrophe
waiting to happen.
National conservative groups launch $800,000 effort against Congressional candidate Hartman |
Insider | lancasteronline.com
A pair of influential national conservative organizations are staking big money on an effort
to keep Democratic candidate Christina Hartman out of Congress.
Annual conference brings cops, kids together in positive, proactive ways | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Hand Elementary eighth-grader Cody Marrero had heard police stories before.
CIA to make 11mn declassified docs available to public online RT America
The CIA is finally putting its database of declassified documents up for public access.
Since 2000, the 11 million documents had only been accessible to academic researchers at a
special facility in Maryland.
Ben Carson speaks to Lancaster GOP, sits down with LNP to talk FBI email probe, 'rigged'
election and more | Insider | lancasteronline.com
Ben Carson, while campaigning for Donald Trump in Lancaster County Friday, was
delighted at the news that the FBI would reopen its investigation into Hillary Clintons
private email servers.
LNP Game of the Week highlights: Lancaster Catholic at Donegal | Football |
lancasteronline.com
Read more about Friday night's Crusaders-Indians game.
Clinton email inquiry: FBI gets search warrant as agency head accused of 'partisan' actions | US
news | The Guardian
Senate minority leader accuses Comey of withholding information about email hacks and
says he may have violated Hatch Act with letter to Congress before election
Bruce Springsteen: You can change a life in three minutes with the right song | Music | The
Guardian
The global superstar talks about the masculine facade of Donald Trump, the strength he
inherited from his mother, the philosophy he shares with fans, and the joy he delivers on
stage
Updated - Fulton Bank - ISC - James Guerin - Scooter Libby - William Clark - CIA - Valerie
Plame - Chris Underhill - Joe Roda October 31, 2016
Receipts - Notes - Photos for Friday October 28, 2016 and Saturday October 29, 2016
ME, MY FATHER, AND THE MIDDLE EAST by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media
Group Monday October 31, 2016
Chris Hedges: American Irrationalism - Chris Hedges - Truthdig
We are captive to images and forms of propaganda that make us the most self-deluded
population on the planet. We are driven by manipulated emotions, not fact or reason. And
this is why, even now, Donald Trump could become president. - 2016/10/30
We Must Tell the Truth About the Iraq War - Truthdig
The Peoples Tribunal on the Iraq War wants to expose the lies and human toll of the
ongoing invasion. - 2016/10/30
In a cyberwar - Military Embedded Systems
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 272
234 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1045
Page
of 1046
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
WARFARE EVOLUTION BLOG: This is another broad, sticky, and complex topic, much
like the previous article on cryptology. So, lets get started by offering some definitions.
How the world views the US elections, from Israel to North Korea | US news | The Guardian
While many countries have shown a preference for Hillary Clinton, Donald Trump has
pockets of support, as Guardian journalists around the world explain
Oakland's 'mega-evictor', the landlord who filed over 3,000 eviction notices | US news | The
Guardian
Pro-tenant group says a landlord who has a seat on Oaklands housing cabinet is also the
top evictor in the city, where a housing crunch has reached crisis levels
CCR News: Fighting blacklists and round-ups - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
Google's approach to email
Everything you need to know about the state House races in Lancaster County | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Lancaster County voters will decide which state House members to send back to Harrisburg
in the Nov. 8 election.
Man shot to death Friday night in Lancaster is identified | Local News | lancasteronline.com
The man shot to death Friday night in Lancaster city has been identified.
Shadowbrokers' NSA dirty tricks spill points to compromised servers in China and Russia |
Computing
NSA also partial to exploiting zero-day security flaws in Sun Solaris, Shadowbrokers' leak
indicates,Security ,security,Cloud Computing
Lifeboat News: The Blog
VEREs Mind Control Robots Give Patients Out-of-Body Experience
Hackers threaten to reveal more NSA data | NT News
A group calling itself Shadow Brokers says it has released more from its trove of high-level
hacking tools stolen from the US National Security Agency, potentially offering added
insight into how Americas spies operate online.
Dozens Of Prosecutors Chastise FBI Director Comey In Letter
Former Attorney General Eric Holder and dozens of other former federal prosecutors have
signed a letter critical of FBI Director James Comey. The
Read the Open Letter By Former Federal Prosecutors Criticizing James Comey - Truthdig
Nearly 100 prosecutors and Department of Justice officials, including former Attorney
General Eric Holder, expressed serious concerns over FBI Director Comeys departure
from long-standing department protocols. - 2016/10/31
Donald Kaufman: Update: CNN Announces Donna Braziles Resignation in Light of New
WikiLeaks Revelations - Truthdig
The interim Democratic National Committee chairwoman came under scrutiny as new
evidence points to abuses of power. - 2016/10/31
Dozens of Groups Call on Facebook to End Censorship - Truthdig
As the social media giant comes under fire for its alleged censorship and tracking of
activists and protesters, a coalition of more than 70 groups and individuals has demanded
that it clarify its policy on removing video and other content, especially human rights
documentation, at the request of government actors. - 2016/10/31
On Contact: Chris Hedges and Medea Benjamin on the U.S.-Saudi Alliance - Truthdig
On this weeks episode of RTs On Contact, the Truthdig columnist and the author of
Kingdom of the Unjust: Behind the U.S.-Saudi Connection, explore why Saudi Arabia
remains one of the United States closest allies in the Middle East in spite of the
monarchys record of human rights abuses. - 2016/10/31
Ex-CIA CTO: dont believe everything you hear about hacking | Security | Techworld
Bob Flores, who was CTO of the CIA for three years, tells Techworld what he believes are
the most serious security threats the world faces today - and that it's wiser to follow the
money rather than uncritically believe everything you hear about hacking.
MI5 head: increasingly aggressive Russia a growing threat to UK | UK news | The Guardian
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 273
235 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1046
Page
of 1047
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Exclusive: In first newspaper interview given by a serving spy chief, Andrew Parker talks
of terror, espionage and balance between secrecy and privacy
Embattled Lancaster County SPCA director resigns, citing 'emotional challenge' | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
The executive director of the Lancaster County SPCA is stepping down, effective Nov. 4.
Man shot to death Friday in Lancaster city identified; 9th homicide in county this year | Local
News | lancasteronline.com
The man shot to death Friday night in Lancaster city has been identified as Pedro Flores Jr.
Hackers say they're revealing more from trove of NSA data - WRCBtv.com | Chattanooga News,
Weather & Sports
A group calling itself "Shadow Brokers" says it has released another gem from its trove of
high-level hacking tools stolen from the U.S.'s National Security Agency, potentially
offering...
Shadow Brokers leak second batch of data allegedly from NSA-linked 'Equation Group' hacking
unit
The leak appears to consist of a list of servers compromised by NSA hackers.
ME, MY FATHER, AND THE MIDDLE EAST by Stan J. Caterbone and Advanced Media
Group Monday October 31, 2016 With Supporting EVIDENCE
CIA Releases Draft History of Bay of Pigs |
JUST RELEASED! - Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) Official History of the Bay of Pigs
Operation
Commentary: Dont's be so sure Russia hacked the Clinton emails | Reuters
By James Bamford Last summer, cyber investigators plowing through the thousands of
leaked emails from the Democratic National Committee uncovered a
Clinton campaign dismisses polls putting Donald Trump in the lead | US news | The Guardian
A senior Clinton campaign official says a new ABC News/Washington Post tracking poll
which put Trump one point ahead is not what we see at all
Shadow Brokers hacking group threaten to release top secret spook files
Shadowy organisation says it has a trove of top secret data from the U.S. National Security
Agency.
Deputy sheriffs or constables? Lancaster County officials debate who should serve warrants |
Insider | lancasteronline.com
Lancaster County elected officials discussed whether a new system put in place earlier this
year to serve outstanding warrants is effective.
Defense Contractor Fraud Center
Defense Contractor Fraud Center
The Texas Military Force Museum | Brigadier General John C. L. Scribner Texas Military Forces
Museum
Affidavit Form | Free General Affidavit Template (US) | LawDepot
Quickly create a customized Sworn Affadavit or Statutory Declaration using our online
forms. Print or download for free.
Lancaster Fleet and Auto IMPOUND INVOICE October 27, 2016
UPDATED - ME, MY FATHER, AND THE MIDDLE EAST by Stan J. Caterbone and
Advanced Media Group Wednesday November 2, 2016 With Supporting EVIDENCE
Tony Bongiovi AFFIDAVIT November 2, 2016
Stan J.Caterbone ADVANCED MEDIA GROUP Freedom From Covert Harassment
& Surveillance, Registered in Penns...
Suspect identified in 'ambush-style' killings of Des Moines police officers | US news | The
Guardian
Iowa authorities name Scott Michael Greene as suspect in early Wednesday shootings and
warn of clear and present danger to officers in and around city
FALSE IMPRISONMENT AND ILLEGAL INTERROGATIONS by U.S. Intelligence Agencies
and U.S. Sponsored Mind Control EVIDENCE November 2, 2016
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 274
236 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1047
Page
of 1048
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Director Brennan ushers in sweeping changes at CIA - Reuters.TV
Reuters National Security Investigations Editor David Rohde interviewed Central
Intelligence Agency Director John Brennan about his sweeping reforms to keep up with
rapid changes in global cyber espionage.
16-3284 Third Circuit Case - ADDENDUM and SUPPLEMENTAL BACKGROUND
INFORMATION for Consideration Re Application for in Forma Pauperis November 3, 2016
Barack Obama delivers stinging critique of FBI: 'We don't operate on leaks' | US news | The
Guardian
President censures James Comeys decision to announce review related to Hillary Clinton
days before election as campaigning reaches fever pitch
Facebook isn't looking out for your privacy. It wants your data for itself | Technology | The
Guardian
Dont be fooled by the social networks hostile response to Admirals plan to price car
insurance based on posts
High levels of carbon monoxide prompts Lancaster County Prison lockdown | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Lancaster County Prison was placed on lock down for two hours Wednesday because of
high levels of carbon monoxide.
Lancaster County man flies 4,000 miles in a go-kart with wings, touches down Wednesday in
Smoketown | Local News | lancasteronline.com
David Grabowski, searching for an adventure, found the ultralight trike by accident during
a Google search.
Anti-Black Surveillance Did Not End With COINTELPRO
Even as the Smithsonian Museum is documenting Black history, the US is continuing its
repression of Black life.
" COINTELPRO " AND THE COPS GANG STALKING PROGRAM "
A PERP THAT SAYS IGNORANCE IS BLISS IS A IGNORANT STUPID
PERP!......LMAO!!! IN THE INFORMATION AGE , IGNORANCE IS A CHOICE!
EDUCATE YOURSELF!!! In 1975 Senator Frank Church convened a joint...
Former spy chiefs call for EU-US intelligence hub
Europe and the US need an "intelligence hub to fight terrorism, with grand ideas on EU
military integration unlikely to bear fruit, Germanys former spy chief has said.
LIGHTS OUT by Ted Koppel
The official site for Ted Koppel's book LIGHTS OUT: A Cyberattack, A Nation
Unprepared, Surviving the Aftermath. In this tour de force of investigati...
Chris Hedges and Tavis Smiley Discuss Popular Resistance and the Failure of Mainstream Media
- Truthdig
The talk show host asks Hedges about the current election and about what is in store for the
United States after Nov. 8. - 2016/11/01
Jordan Riefe: Walt Whitmans America Through Edward Westons Eyes - Truthdig
Weston may not have studied Whitmans poetry before embarking on a photographic road
trip for a special edition of Leaves of Grass. Yet while having the time of his life, he also
got the spirit right. - 2016/11/01
windows 10 | eBay
Find great deals on eBay for windows 10 windows 10 software. Shop with confidence.
Xerox WorkCentre 6505/DN Color Multifunction Printer- Automatic Duplexing 95205849189 |
eBay
Introducing the Phaser 6500 and WorkCentre 6505. Style: Printer. Up to 24 ppm color and
black and white. Item model number: 6505/DN. Learn More. | eBay!
Feds probe Fulton Bank, 3 others for possible fair-lending violations | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Fulton Bank, the biggest bank in Lancaster County, and three sister banks are being
investigated for possible violations of federal fair-lending laws.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 275
237 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1048
Page
of 1049
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Inside the CIA, sweeping reforms during the age of cyberwar | INFORUM
Here are all of Donald Trump's and Hillary Clinton's campaign stops in Pennsylvania since June |
Insider | lancasteronline.com
Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton have spent more time in Pennsylvania than almost
anywhere else in the country since becoming presumptive presidential nominees last
summer.
Ivanka Trump visit to Lancaster Sunday afternoon canceled | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Update at 10:45 a.m. Sunday: Ivanka Trump's Lancaster stop has been canceled, a
spokesman for the Republican Committee of Lancaster County said Sunday morning.
Julian Assange Speaks About Hillary Clinton, the U.S. Election and the Litany of Charges
Against Him - Truthdig
In a 25-minute interview, WikiLeaks founder gives an analysis of the emails he published
from the personal account of John Podesta (Hillary Clintons presidential campaign
chairman), and much more. - 2016/11/05
Allen Barra: America the Ingenious - Book Review - Truthdig
Truthdigs Allen Barra speaks with Kevin Baker, author of America the Ingenious: How a
Nation of Dreamers, Immigrants, and Tinkerers Changed the World, which explores the
incredible diversity of inventions and innovations that arose from our country. - 2016/11/05
Beyond Bob Dylan: authors, poets and musicians pick their favourite songwriter | Books | The
Guardian
Dylans Nobel prize win sparked a debate about lyrics as literature. Here, Andrew Motion,
Carol Ann Duffy, Johnny Marr, Naomi Alderman and others nominate songwriters whose
verse has the power of poetry
Joseph Kennedy III speaks to Democratic rally near spot where JFK campaigned in 1960 | Local
News | lancasteronline.com
Fifty-six years after his great-uncle, John F. Kennedy, spoke in Penn Square during a 1960
presidential campaign stop, U.S. Rep. Joseph P. Kennedy III addressed a get-out-the-vote
rally for local
ON MENTAL ILLNESS: Donald Trump's Conspiracy Theories Resemble Psychosis. Category:
Columns from The Berkeley Daily Planet
The East Bay's Non-commercial Voice
Guess who came to the wedding? | News | lancasteronline.com
"Uncle Bob" slipped quietly into the Manheim Township suburbs last weekend.
A Passion for Leadership Audiobook | Robert M Gates | Audible.com
Listen to A Passion for Leadership Audiobook by Robert M Gates, narrated by George
Newbern.
Bill Blum: James Comey, Hillary Clinton, Anthony Weiner and Our Descent Into Pulp Fiction
Democracy - Truthdig
Forget WikiLeaks, speeches to Goldman Sachs and the behind-the-scenes machinations of
John Podesta. The FBI directors letter to Congress was the ultimate October surprise. -
2016/11/04
Invoice US Secretary of Defense Ash Carter Re Mind Control July 5,2015
Invoice US Secretary of Defense Ash Carter Re Mind Control July 5,2015 - Free download
as PDF File (.pdf), Text file (.txt) or read online for free. Invoice US Secretary of Defense
Ash Carter Re Mind Control July 5,2015
Madeleine Albright in Lancaster to boost Hartman's campaign and talk foreign policy | Local
News | lancasteronline.com
Madeleine Albrights brooches are said to signify her mood. During a Sunday roundtable
discussion on foreign policy at Lancasters Characters Pub with Democratic congressional
candidate Christina Hartman and area college
Brother of Amish schoolgirl shooter uses photographs to reconcile the past | Together |
lancasteronline.com
Photo exhibit of Zachary Roberts opens at Mulberry Art Studios in Lancaster.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 276
238 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1049
Page
of 1050
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
TD Ameritrade
'The FBI is Trumpland': anti-Clinton atmosphere spurred leaking, sources say | US news | The
Guardian
Highly unfavorable view of Hillary Clinton intensified after James Comeys decision not to
recommend an indictment over her use of a private email server
Penn State faces $2.4m fine for handling of Jerry Sandusky case and other crimes | US news |
The Guardian
US Department of Education hopes to extract record fine against university for long-term
history of sustained noncompliance, including in 2011 scandal
Lancaster Regional Medical Center installs touch-screen tablets at patients' bedsides | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Move aside, wall-mounted TV.
Feminism is still necessary, Gloria Steinem tells Lancaster County audience | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
At the first of her stops in Lancaster Thursday, feminist icon Gloria Steinem doubled down
on her signature call for equality.
November supermoon will be biggest in nearly 70 years | National | lancasteronline.com
You may want to mark Nov. 13 and 14 down on your calendar.
For 10 years, Central Market Trust has steered its namesake Lancaster landmark | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
When the Central Market Trust took over management of Lancasters city-owned Central
Market a decade ago, many standholders were suspicious at first, said Valerie Moul, the
nonprofits chair.
Teen accused of threatening to 'go Columbine' at Conestoga Valley High School | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
A Conestoga Valley High School student threatened to "go Columbine" and "shoot people
who p--- him off," according to East Lampeter Township police.
Partnership for Civil Justice Fund - Timeline | Facebook
Partnership for Civil Justice Fund, Washington, DC. 3,250 likes 4 talking about this. The
Partnership for Civil Justice Fund is a charitable and...
NYPD used undercover officers to spy on activists: Mara Verheyden-Hilliard interview on RT -
Partnership for Civil Justice Fund
Newly obtained documents indicate the New York Police Department may have committed
constitutional violations by deploying undercover officers to monitor peaceful Black Lives
Matter protests, following the death of Eric Garner in 2014.
Aussie and the Fox and Trust Performing Arts Center come together for special night in the city |
Entertainment | lancasteronline.com
In a New York state of mind? Missing the glamour and the glitz of Manhattan? Want to
hear some show tunes?
Beyonce teams up with the Dixie Chicks at CMA Awards | Entertainment | lancasteronline.com
The superstar will perform at the CMAs tonight, multiple news outlets report.
Lancaster band Carousel Kings sign to Victory Records | Entertainment | lancasteronline.com
The pop-punk band was on Lancaster's C.I. Records before signing to Victory Records.
U.S. Arms Transfers to Saudi Arabia and the War in Yemen | Research | Center for International
Policy
Advocating a U.S. foreign policy based on cooperation, demilitarization and respect for
human rights
Chicago Cubs defeat Cleveland Indians to win first World Series title since 1908 | Sport | The
Guardian
The most famous drought in US sports is over. The Chicago Cubs are World Series
champions for the first time since 1908
Barack Obama delivers stinging critique of FBI: 'We don't operate on leaks' | US news | The
Guardian
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 277
239 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1050
Page
of 1051
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
President censures James Comeys decision to announce review related to Hillary Clinton
days before election as campaigning reaches fever pitch
Facebook's profits soar as it continues to swallow online advertising market | Technology | The
Guardian
Near tripling of the social media giants profits comes at a time when traditional news
publishers are hemorrhaging ad dollars and announcing cutbacks
Conspiracy theorists claim The Asgardia will be used 'for mind control and evil purposes' | Daily
Mail Online
Asgardia was announced by the Aerospace International Research Centre in Vienna.
Conspiracy theorists claim that the Eye of Horus symbol used by the group, is linked to the
Illuminati.
Two Arrested in Georgia for Planning to Attack HAARP Facility in Alaska
The American Radio Relay League (ARRL) is the national association for amateur radio,
connecting hams around the U.S. with news, information and resources.
Hillary Clinton, The Real October Surprise. : ThyBlackMan.com
Neil Brick Celebrates Twenty Five Years of Research, Education and Advocacy in the Child
Abuse Prevention Field | WebWire
Neil Brick neilbrick.com is celebrating twenty five years of research, education and
advocacy in the child abuse prevention field. Prior to 1995, Neil Brick wrote articles for
newsletters and distributed information about child and ritual abuse at conferences. In 1995,
Neil Brick started the S.M.A.R.T. child abuse and ritual abuse newsletter, printing and
mailing out the first copy in March 1995. In 1996, the S.M.A.R.T. newsletter started being
published online. These child and ritual...
Say goodbye to the fingerprint; its your digital footprint the FBI wants | Jordan Times
WASHINGTON The era of the fingerprint has given way to the digital footprint.
Counterterrorism investigators still rely heavily on tools such as surveillance cameras,
licence plate readers and facial recognition software to track potential terror plots in the
physical realm. But they now delve with as much vigour into the social media activity of
suspects.
Alicia Keys: I want to make sure all the issues about race are addressed | Music | The Guardian
At a home town launch for her new album, Here, the New York singer-songwriter talks
about the US election, Black Lives Matter, and modern family life
LETTER: The fix was in, and the people are still paying for it | Newslanc.com
The contributor refers to Bill Keisling's and NewsLanc's forthcoming book on decades of
corruption in Pennsylvania: I hope your 50 corruptions include the
Democrats never learn | Newslanc.com
By Dick Miller WE.CONNECT.DOTS: In this years presidential battle of first time
evers, history still repeats. Not surprising, the story about
Former Fulton Bank manager sentenced for embezzling $99,100 | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
A former manager of Fulton Banks Manor Shopping Center branch has been sentenced to
15 months in federal prison for embezzling about $99,100 from an account with the bank.
Chinas New Cybersecurity Law Rattles Foreign Tech Firms - WSJ
Chinas government has approved a broad new cybersecurity law aimed at tightening and
centralizing state control over information flows and technology equipment, raising
concerns among foreign companies.
FBI has found no criminal wrongdoing in new Clinton emails, says Comey | US news | The
Guardian
James Comey says batch of emails have not changed conclusion but Trump doubts
review, saying: You cant review 650,000 emails in eight days
Trump rally protester: I was beaten for a 'Republicans against Trump' sign | US news | The
Guardian
Exclusive: Self-declared Republican who sparked Nevada security scare says he was
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 278
240 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1051
Page
of 1052
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
attacked for silently showing a sign he printed from the web
Janet Reno, first female US attorney general, dies aged 78 | US news | The Guardian
One of the highest profile figures of President Clintons presidency, whose tenure included
the Waco raid and Lewinsky scandals
US seeks Turkish backing for Kurdish-led operation in Raqqa | World news | The Guardian
Senior military officials meet in Ankara after Turkey expressed alarm at Kurdish role in
move to retake Isis stronghold
Chris Hedges: Defying the Politics of Fear - Chris Hedges - Truthdig
The major political parties offer us nothing but continued corruption and oppression. A
simple act of citizen defiance can be a first step on a road to profound change. - 2016/11/06
How a Former District Attorney Finally Agreed With Activist Mike Farrell on the Death Penalty
- Truthdig
Ira Reiner, who served Los Angeles County as D.A. for eight years, and Mike Farrell,
president of the board of Death Penalty Focus, have publicly and respectfully debated
capital punishment many times over the years. But it wasnt until now, with the proposed
Justice That Works Act of 2016 on the California ballot, that they see eye to eye. -
2016/11/06
Eden Resort to drop Best Western flag, operate independently | Local Business |
lancasteronline.com
For the management of the Eden Resort & Suites, being a Best Western Premier hotel
has become more hassle than its worth.
Pa. Treasury puts Wells Fargo on suspension | Pennsylvania | lancasteronline.com
The Pennsylvania Treasury has suspended dealings with Wells Fargo for a year due to the
bank's fraudulent accounts scandal.
Lancaster General Health opens sports medicine practice in Lititz | Local Business |
lancasteronline.com
Lancaster General Health Physicians has opened its first sports medicine practice, in
Warwick Township.
Cashier's check - Wikipedia
Edward Snowden Explains How FBI Could Review Clinton Emails So Fast - SFGate
Edward Snowden needed only 140 characters to shoot down the Donald Trump campaigns
theory that FBI Director James Comey couldnt have thoroughly reviewed Hillary
Clintons new emails in such a short period of time. Comey has been at the center of the
Clinton email scandals, clearing the Democratic candidate last summer before bringing a
new investigation last week that turned out to be, well, nothing really. Comey announced
yesterday that the new evidence doesnt change the agencys opinion that Clinton shouldnt
face criminal charges. [...] Read: FBI Director Says Hillary Clinton Shouldn't Be Charged
Over New Emails The Washington Post recently shocked journalists when its editorial
board came out in opposition to a pardon for Snowden, but the papers media columnist
Margaret Sullivan sided with the former NSA contractor. Sullivan wrote that President
Obamas administration has an unfortunate record of prosecuting whistleblowers, and he
can fix that legacy by pardoning Snowden.
Net Politics Do U.S. Efforts to Deter Russian Cyberattacks Signal the End of Cyber Norms?
CFR experts investigate the impact of information and communication technologies on
security, privacy, and international affairs.
City Council to consider ban on aggressive panhandling | Insider | lancasteronline.com
Lancaster city is looking to crack down on panhandlers.
120 people gather in Lancaster with message of peace on eve of divisive election | Pennsylvania |
lancasteronline.com
On the eve of the most divisive election in modern history, more than 120 people of varied
faiths, races and political beliefs joined together in downtown Lancaster for a message
Amid Clinton Controversy, FBI Documents Show Why Americans Should Worry About
Intelligence Gathering
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 279
241 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1052
Page
of 1053
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Lancaster city man acquitted on charges he sexually assaulted a 15-year-old girl | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
A Lancaster city man accused of sexually assaulting a 15-year-old girl in 2014 was
acquitted of all charges in a three-day jury trial held last week at Lancaster County
Courthouse.
Prosecutors: Quarryville woman beat, bound and burned, fed laxatives and hot sauce to
boyfriend's toddler | Local News | lancasteronline.com
A Quarryville woman fed her boyfriends young son hot sauce and laxatives, burned, beat
and berated him and would bind his legs and lock him in a closet, apparently resentful
Recietps and Notes for First Friday November 4, 2016
Receipts and Members1st With ATM Balances Re Fulton Lnp Article Fed Probe for Sunday
November 6, 2016
RECEIPTS for Saturday Night City Cab Home November 5, 2016
Reciepts and Notes for First Friday November 4, 2016
Advanced Media Group and Stan J. Caterbone Project X - By Kathy Perry November 8, Election
Day 2016
Chef Cedric Barberet runs Lancaster eatery; worked at Le Bec-Fin and Donald Trump estate |
Local News | lancasteronline.com
Cedric Barberet runs Cafe Barberet & Bistro on East King Street.
Cluster munition - Wikipedia
TD Ameritrade
Donald Trump wins US election: Obama offers congratulations live | US news | The Guardian
The US is waking up to a new president after Trump won a shock victory, and Hillary
Clinton is expected to make her concession speech this morning
How Trump won the election: volatility and a common touch | US news | The Guardian
The former Apprentice host has pulled off the most astonishing victory in US history,
harnessing a disgruntled electorate to beat an unpopular opponent
Why Hillary Clinton lost the election: the economy, trust and a weak message | US news | The
Guardian
As Democrats grapple with their loss to such an unpopular and divisive rival, persistent
problems with Clintons campaign offer some explanation
World leaders react to Donald Trump's US election victory | US news | The Guardian
Politicians past and present, plus officials from the European Union, have been responding
to the Republican nominees win
Donald Trump becomes 1st Republican to win Pennsylvania since 1988 | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Donald Trump has won Pennsylvania and its prize of 20 electoral votes.
Donald Trump wins Lancaster County, gets more votes than Romney or McCain | Pennsylvania |
lancasteronline.com
Republican Donald Trump, buoyed by rural and working-class voters and an anti-
establishment fervor, won Lancaster County with more votes than either of the last two
GOP presidential nominees.
How Donald Trump Won The White House And Stunned The World
Donald Trump won by harnessing deep discontent with Washington and deep-seated
loathing of Democrat Hillary Clinton.
Dow Jones to fall after Trump election victory stuns stock markets - live updates | Business | The
Guardian
Wall Street expected to drop after US presidential election shocks world markets
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 280
242 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1053
Page
of 1054
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Fewer patients means fewer employees for 2 Lancaster County hospitals | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Danielle Gilmore, spokeswoman for Lancaster Regional Medical Center and Heart of
Lancaster Regional Medical Center, said in an email Monday that a small number of our
employees are being placed
Marijuana wins big on election night - The Washington Post
But it faces considerable uncertainty under a presumptive Trump administration.
Transcript: Donald Trumps Victory Speech - The New York Times
Donald J. Trump addressed supporters at a hotel in New York early Wednesday.
Feds Probe Fulton Bank and 3 Other Subsidiary Banks of Fulton Financial With Stan J.
Caterbone Civil Actions and Mind Control Research of Monday November 9, 2016
East Lampeter police officer on paid administrative leave following allegations he
inappropriately touched teen girl | Local News | lancasteronline.com
An East Lampeter police officer, facing allegations he inappropriately touched a 13-year-
old girl, was placed on paid administrative leave in August, township officials said
Wednesday.
U.S. spy agencies to begin top secret Trump briefings within days | Reuters
U.S. intelligence agencies will soon begin giving President-elect Donald Trump the same
top secret national security briefings they give President Barack Obama, current and former
intelligence officials said Wednesday.
Team Trump Struggling to Fill National Security Jobs - The Daily Beast
Turned down by top talent, Trumps administration-in-waiting is trying to find someone to
operate the agencies tasked with stopping hackers and terrorists.
Trump Election Ignites Fears Over U.S. Encryption, Surveillance Policy
Technology companies and civil libertarians are alarmed by Trump's election victory.
Worries and uncertainty cloud outlook for digital privacy under President Trump | PCWorld
When President-elect Donald Trump officially takes office, hell inherit a powerful U.S.
surveillance apparatus, including the National Security Agency, thats already been accused
of trampling over privacy rights.
Trump set to get spy agency briefings, visit Oval Office | The Japan Times
President Barack Obama will host Donald Trump in the Oval Office Thursday, hoping to
ease a smooth transition of power and steady nerves after an election
Stan J. Caterbone FEDERAL COURT DOCKETS Sheets as of November 10, 2016
Canadian spy agency concealed mass data intelligence-bank from courts - World Socialist Web
Site
The Federal Court criticized Canadas premier spy agency for lying about its retention and
use of metadata from persons not considered security threats.
US elections: protests held against president-elect as it happened | US news | The Guardian
Peaceful protests took place in cities across the country after Donald Trump won a shock
victory in the US election
Hillary Clinton's concession speech in full video | US news | The Guardian
Clinton, who had been widely believed to be the frontrunner in the race going into election
day, thanked her family and campaign staff and encouraged supporters to press onward
The world's newspapers react to Trump's election victory | US news | The Guardian
Some predict disaster while others focus on the enormity of the challenge ahead as the
world reels from the shock of the new president-elect
Clinton and Obama lead calls for unity as US braces for Trump presidency | US news | The
Guardian
President-elect insists he will deal fairly with everyone the day after stunning victory that
left Americans bitterly divided and the world uncertain
Weed is Going to Win Big in November | Newslanc.com
Home Drug War Chronicle Issue #947 by Phil Smith This article was produced in
collaboration with AlterNet and
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 281
243 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1054
Page
of 1055
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Listen: Kara Newhouse talks to Stevens' Sherri Linetty for Women in STEM podcast | Local
News | lancasteronline.com
In 2007, Sherri Linetty was the first woman graduate at Thaddeus Stevens College of
Technology to receive the Technology Competency Award, which recognizes the highest
GPA in each field. For
Lancaster city councilman on Trump-Pence win: 'I don't want people to be afraid' | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
At the end of City Councils meeting Wednesday, Councilman James Reichenbach took a
few moments to reassure any city residents worried by the outcome of Tuesdays election.
Stan J. Caterbone LOCAL, STATE, and FEDERAL COURT DOCKET SHEETS with PRO SE
BILLINGS as of November 10, 2016
Goodbye Obama, hello Trump: how will the presidential handover work? | US news | The
Guardian
The transition of power from Barack Obamas administration to Donald Trumps has
begun. We answer the when, what and how
More anti-Trump action planned after second night of protests across US | US news | The
Guardian
Activists say they are weighing up their next moves, as hundreds of people take to the
streets again following election of Donald Trump
Nuclear weapons: how foreign hotspots could test Trump's finger on the trigger | US news | The
Guardian
From North Korea to Iran to Russia, a president-elect with civilisation-ending weaponry at
his fingertips will face an in-tray of potential international crises
Syrian opposition left with nowhere to turn after Trump's victory | World news | The Guardian
US president-elect likely to endorse Russias policy of bombing rebels to the negotiating
table
Silicon Valley critics cautiously open their arms to Donald Trump | Technology | The Guardian
Most tech industry leaders railed against the Republican, but some are now changing their
tune as they consider what his presidency will mean
Hillary Clinton seen hiking day after conceding US election | US news | The Guardian
Democratic presidential nominee went for a hike with her husband near their New York
home, hugging a supporter and exchanging some sweet pleasantries
Facebooks failure: did fake news and polarized politics get Trump elected? | Technology | The
Guardian
The company is being accused of abdicating its responsibility to clamp down on fake news
stories and counter the echo chamber that defined this election
Dow hits record high after Trump win but investors warn of volatility | Business | The Guardian
Warning of muddled trading as Dow Jones rallies, FTSE 100 dips and concern grows
over new presidency effect on global economy
Defense Intelligence Agency assessment of damage done by Edward Snowden leaks read the
report | US news | theguardian.com
A top-secret Pentagon report on Edward Snowden's leaks concluded that 'the scope of the
compromised knowledge related to US intelligence capabilities is staggering'
UPDATED - EXCLUSIVE Transcripts of Whistleblower Testimonies as Targeted Individuals of
U.S. Sponsored Mind Control and Related Hearings and Lectures, September 17, 2016
Retired physician, judge became 'Legends of Lancaster' by pushing for progress | Faith |
lancasteronline.com
Dr. Harold White and Louise B. Williams share a commitment to serving others.
To President Elect Donald Trump With Stan J. Caterbone Civil Actions and Mind Control
Research of Friday November 11, 2016
Life with PTSD: Army combat veteran works to move past drug use, homelessness | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
You can see the excitement emanating from Art Westerfer as he talks about his 9-month-
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 282
244 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1055
Page
of 1056
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
old son.
Family traditions: Lancaster County veteran opens up about WWII service, following in footsteps
of dad, brothers | Insider | lancasteronline.com
Jack McSherry Jr. was admiring 30-foot-high waves shortly before midnight in the North
Atlantic when a particularly aggressive swell broke over the bow of his ship and washed
him overboard.
NSA/DHS officials designate institutions as National Centers of Academic Excellence in Cyber
Defense - Military Embedded Systems
FORT MEADE, MD. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and National Security
Agency (NSA) officials designated the following eight institutions as NSA/DHS National
Centers of Academic Excellence in Cyber Defense: Augusta University, Embry-Riddle
Aeronautical University, Florida International University, Middle Georgia State University,
University of Delaware, Clark State Community College, Lake Superior College, and Red
Rocks Community College.
Snowden Prompts Americans to Focus on 'Broad Social Issues' After US Election
National Security Agency (NSA) whistleblower Edward Snowden said that the outcome of
the 2016 US presidential election should be about social issues rather than individual cases
like his own.
President-elect Trump to soon receive intel 'crown jewels' | The Siasat Daily
Mainstream media mind control failed so the establishment vows to dismantle alternative
sources - Personal Liberty
Election 2016: What Happened? Whats Next? - Live at Truthdig - Truthdig
Truthdig sat down with journalist Bill Boyarsky on Thursday to discuss the stunning results
of Tuesdays election and the future of the United States. - 2016/11/10
Abolish the Electoral College - Truthdig
For the sixth time in our history, a candidate for president of the United States may have
won the popular vote and lost the White House. - 2016/11/10
Resistance Movements Can Be More Powerful Than President Trump - Truthdig
Millions of people around the world are committed to opposing the Republicans dangerous
and divisive agenda. Their work, like the work of the incoming administration, has just
begun. - 2016/11/10
Politics Is the Solution to Our Problems - Truthdig
We cant move to Canada or hide under the bed. This is a moment to embrace democratic
politics, not repudiate them. - 2016/11/10
Here It Comes: Trumps 100-Day Plan to Make America Great Again - Truthdig
Republican control of Congress means much of the partys regressive agendaalong with
some of Trumps radical proposalscould pass. - 2016/11/10
Meet the Trumps: a look at America's new first family | US news | The Guardian
The Donald Trump clan is headed to the White House. Heres what we know about each of
them
Modest shifts, no major redraft in Lancaster County's red electoral map | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Republican Donald Trump racked up large majorities in rural Lancaster County on
Tuesday, and he won by 10 percentage points in Columbia Borough, a hardscrabble
Democratic river town that backed
Lancaster city councilman on Trump-Pence win: 'I don't want people to be afraid' | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
At the end of City Councils meeting Wednesday, Councilman James Reichenbach took a
few moments to reassure any city residents worried by the outcome of Tuesdays election.
The president is commander in chief? Yes, but it's complicated - CSMonitor.com
In his campaign, Trump promised to kill family members of Islamic State and institute
torture in interrogations. But presidents often find it tough to get the national security
bureaucracy to carry out their programs.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 283
245 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1056
Page
of 1057
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
WSJ CEO Council Assembles Worlds Top Chief Executives for 2016 Annual Meeting
Soleilmavis' Letter to President Donald Trump | Soleilmavis Liu | Pulse | LinkedIn
Joshua D. Lock - Goldberg KatzmanGoldberg Katzman
STAN J. CATERBONE and the DEPARTMENT of DEFENSE Documents and Evidence of
Conspiracy to .... Saturday November 12, 2016
Lancaster County has the highest healthcare.gov premiums in the state | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Lancaster County has a new dubious distinction.
Chris Hedges: Its Worse Than You Think - Truthdig
The election of Donald Trump, whose appeal to voters is based on magical thinking,
assures the rise of a police state unlike anything seen in American history. Its fangs will
appear the moment Trumps base realizes it has been betrayed. - 2016/11/11
Chris Hedges, Columnist - Truthdig
Emma Niles: Donald Trump Promised to Drain the Swamp but His Transition Team List Raises
Doubts - Truthdig
A leaked document of 41 potential cabinet appointments is rife with figures who have close
ties to big business and special interest groups. - 2016/11/11
Eric Ortiz: Donald Trump Praises Protesters After First Blaming Media for Inciting Them -
Truthdig
The president-elect expressed an appreciation for dissent and called for unity in an early
morning Twitter message on Friday. But dont expect the protests to stop or protesters to be
silenced. - 2016/11/11
Vladimir Putin Targets East Aleppo RebelsDid Donald Trumps Election Victory Doom
Them? - Juan Cole - Truthdig
With Obama a lame duck and Trump a buddy of Putin, Russia and Syria may feel they have
a free hand to defeat the rebels completely in east Aleppo. - 2016/11/11
Elizabeth Warren: Democracy Demands That We Work Together on Americas Agenda -
Truthdig
The Massachusetts senator is ready to help President-elect Trump rebuild the U.S.
economy. But if Republicans attempt to remove Wall Street regulations or gut the
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, she will fight them. - 2016/11/11
GOP National security world seeking dtente with President-elect Trump - CNNPolitics.com
The Republican Party's most senior national security experts denounced their presidential
candidate during the campaign as too reckless to lead the nation safely.
Terror-Funding Conviction in San Diego Under Fire Over NSA Phone Data Collection
Anti-Trump protesters gear up for weekend demonstrations across the US | US news | The
Guardian
One man shot and wounded during rowdy protests in Portland, Oregon while more than
10,000 sign up for Saturday march in New York
Democrats begin fight against Trump: his election 'does not feel like America' | US news | The
Guardian
Harry Reid issues blistering statement decrying president-elects forces of hate and
bigotry as Elizabeth Warren urges voters to put in the work to resist Trump
Facebook's fake news: Mark Zuckerberg rejects 'crazy idea' that it swayed voters | Technology |
The Guardian
Those who think fake news is why someone voted for Trump show profound lack of
empathy and fail to internalize the president-elects message, he said
Donald Trump May Select an Architect of Bushs Torture Program to Run CIA
Porter Goss Fast Facts - Honolulu, Hawaii news, sports & weather - KITV Channel 4
Here is a look at the life of Porter Goss, former CIA director and Florida congressman.
CIA Launches Signature School Program at the University of New Mexico - Albuquerque
Business First
The program will deepen cooperation between the CIA and UNM.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 284
246 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1057
Page
of 1058
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
New JFK assassination theory: Cuban double agent led plot | New York Post
More than 50 years after President John F. Kennedy was gunned down in Dallas, new
evidence uncovered in the secret diaries of a Cold War spy and assassin implicates another
clandestine figure believed to be working as a double agent for Cuba, an explosive new
book claims. The never-before-revealed diaries of Douglas DeWitt Bazata, a decorated
officer for the United States Office of Strategic Services the forerunner of the Central
Intelligence Agency claim that his longtime close friend and fellow spy, Ren Alexander
Dussaq, was a primary organizer and plotter of Kennedys assassination on Nov. 22,
1963. The diaries reveal that Dussaq might even have fired the fatal shot or shots that
killed the 35th president of the United States, according to author Robert K. Wilcoxs latest
book, <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Target-JFK-Spy-Killed-
Kennedy/dp/1621574873/" target="_blank">Target: JFK, The Spy Who Killed Kennedy?
</a>, which goes on sale Nov. 14. Douglas Bazata was deeply embedded in the world of
secrets, especially those surrounding JFKs death, Wilcox writes. He was there at the
birth of the CIA as an early and major player in that murkiest of worlds He was an
insider. In his diaries, Bazata wrote that the two men first met in Havana, Cuba, during the
early 1930s, when Bazata, a US Marine, was given his first mission as a hitman: to
assassinate a Cuban revolutionary. The mission failed, but the pair's bond was sealed
forever after Dussaq saved Bazatas life. The bond deepened in 1944, when both men were
part of WWII's Operation Jedburgh, in which more than 250 American and Allied
paratroopers jumped behind enemy lines across France, the Netherlands and Belgium to
fight against German occupation. Dussaqs larger-than-life legend began here: He was
nicknamed Captain Bazooka for demonstrating the Armys new anti-tank rocket
launchers to the Maquis, French resistance guerrillas. Hes also credited with bluffing a
German general into believing he was surrounded by American troops, leading to the
capture of up to 500 Nazis. Dussaq who was born in Buenos Aires and educated in
Geneva and Cuba became a naturalized US citizen in 1942. The son of a Cuban
diplomat, he had tried to enlist after the Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor but was deemed a
potential security risk. However, the US Army was desperate for infantrymen at the time
and ultimately accepted him. Dussaq quickly rose through the ranks, becoming a lieutenant
instructor for the elite 101st Airborne Division, the "Screaming Eagles." One top-ranked
OSS official told his counterparts in London that Dussaq, who spoke six languages, was an
exceptional athlete and a master of unusual and hazardous work of a physical nature,
references to earlier work as a deep-sea diver, treasure hunter and Hollywood movie
stuntman. He is keen, adaptable intelligent and a dirty fighter conversant with jujitsu
and the commando type of close combat fighting, the OSS official wrote. Waldo
Logan [of Chicagos Adventurers Club and backer of some of Dussaqs earlier seaborne
expeditions] says that he is the only man he has ever known who is entirely without fear.
Following the war, Bazata became a world-class spy and underground operative working
for the CIA and other intelligence agencies. Dussaq, meanwhile, took a job as a Prudential
insurance agent in Los Angeles. Within two years, according to Freedom of Information
Act requests, he began infiltrating community groups in Hollywood and Mexico, if not
elsewhere, on behalf of the FBI, Wilcox writes. Around this time, Dussaq, according to
Bazatas diaries, grew increasingly angry with the United States dominance and
exploitation of Cuba. Dussaq, according to Bazata's diaries, launched the assassination plot
to make a point to America about its leaders manipulation of smaller countries. Bazata was
designated his historian. He delegated Bazata, when the time was right after the
assassinations shock had dissipated to tell the public the truth about what happened in
hopes Americas leaders would change and allow sovereign nations like Cuba to decide
their own fate rather than have America decide it for them," Wilcox writes. The CIA-
sponsored Bay of Pigs invasion in 1961 and continued attempts by Kennedys
administration to kill Fidel Castro finally prompted Dussaq to put his sinister Hydra-K
assassination plot into motion, according to Bazatas diaries. [Cuba] could not determine
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 285
247 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1058
Page
of 1059
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
its own destiny and this was so big with Dussaq, Wilcox told The Post. He was a guy
who believed that every person should determine their own destiny and every country
should do the same. Wilcox told The Post he believes the coded diaries that Bazata gave
him in 1999 prior to his death several thousand handwritten pages in all clearly
indicate Dussaq was a double agent working for Cuba. In fact, Bazata writes that one of the
reasons the Bay of Pigs invasion failed was because Dussaq was informing Cuba all along.
Dussaqs second wife, Charlotte, also told Wilcox that Dussaq was asked by the CIA to
help plan the operation, but he declined. Bazata and Dussaq would later begin plotting and
rehearsing Kennedy's assassination at meetings in the United States and Europe, including
at the upscale Tremoille Hotel in Paris, where Bazata told Dussaq about his failed attempts
to get US officials to take his warnings about the impending execution seriously. Wilcoxs
book contains a memo he found among Bazatas secret papers indicating that he and
legendary CIA spy Lucien Conein discussed Operation Hydra-K long before the
assassination. This Hydra-K document is hard evidence of what Bazata alleges, Wilcox
writes. There is very little other outside documentation that supports his story
although one can argue lack of documentation would be expected in such a secret and
monumental conspiracy. Dallas was selected as the location for the assassination as far
back as 1961, according to Bazata, since it was an anti-Kennedy hothouse for murder
with one of the most corrupt police departments in the country. Dussaq ordered five
triggers for the assassination, with a second commander-manager (COs) standing behind
each gunman, according to Bazatas diaries. And if anything went wrong, each CO had a
cyanide inflictor, unavailable even to the CIA at the time, that would kill instantly. The
shooters included Dussaq, Lee Harvey Oswald, an assassin code-named Piatogorsky and
two unidentified CIA hitmen. Bazatas diaries also cite other fringe players in the plot,
including backup shooters, five body doubles for Oswald and random pointers and
shouters designed to confuse police and witnesses. On November 22, 1963, half past
high noon, Hydra-K commenced, Wilcox writes. As the motorcade approached, Ren,
preparing to shoot, readied his weapon. Bazata doesnt say where he is, only that he was a
great distance from his target. He is in front of the motorcade. His soon-to-be-fired shot,
however, would not be the first. It would be the second. Oswald, according to the Warren
Commission, acted alone. The United States House of Representatives Select Committee
on Assassinations (HSCA) later found a high probability that two gunmen fired at
Kennedy. But according to Bazatas account, Oswald fired the first shot from above and
behind Kennedys lurching motorcade. Wilcox notes that Bazatas account then deviates
from the standard, adding that Dussaq didnt trust or want to include Oswald, the
unstable former Marine. He was, after all, tabbed to be the patsy, Wilcox writes.
Dussaq surreptitiously had Oswalds rifle armed with duds, blanks, which Oswald would
fire harmlessly at Kennedy. This ploy, this red herring, Dussaq believed, would later be
discovered and serve to exonerate the patsy and undermine and thus misdirect all official
investigations, clearing a path for Bazatas subsequent planned revelations. Oswalds CO,
according to Bazatas diaries, secretly inserted the dummy cartridges but Oswald
instinctively realized something was off after firing the first shot: the signal that the
execution was under way. Oswald then intentionally let a clip fall from his rifle and
inserted a real cartridge into the gun and fired a second, authentic shot before the CO
wrestled it away. Oswalds first dummy shot, as planned, distracted the droves of onlookers
in Dealey Plaza. That allowed Dussaq, a superb shot, to fire the first lethal shot from his
undisclosed location in front of the motorcade. At nearly the same time Dussaq fired,
another shooter identified only as a CIA operative fired from the rear, just as Oswald had
done seconds earlier. The unidentified assassin and Dussaq were essentially aiming for the
exact same hole and the third shot was slightly higher in the head, Bazata wrote.
According to Bazata, four shots were fired in all, including Oswald's dummy. All shooters
wore gloves and face coverings to protect their skin from powder debris, and their weapons
and incriminating evidence were removed by experts as a squad extracted all involved.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 286
248 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1059
Page
of 1060
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Dussaq left Dallas shortly afterward and fled to Mexico by private boat, while the others
stayed behind with solid cover-reasons to be there. Bazata, for his part, says he was in
Europe when Kennedy was killed. Wilcox acknowledges that means Bazata's description of
the assassination if true is second-hand in nature at best, most likely coming from
Dussaq himself. To protect his friend, Bazata referred to Dussaq throughout his diaries as
Peter or, more often, Paul, a play on the biblical transformation of Saul to Paul. But he
occasionally slipped and identified Dussaq outright, Wilcox said. Long have I kept Pauls
story in my heart, one of Bazatas diaries read. Paul never spoke to me from bragging or
compulsion. He spoke in tears and hope He chose me to [tell the story] You either
believe me or you dont. I care not one fig either way. I merely set down here a story 50
years in the making. It is all totally true I change only the names of those I love [Dussaq
and other clandestine brothers involved] and those I fear. Although Bazatas diaries do not
include, according to Wilcox, a smoking gun or a direct link to Castro, they point to
Dussaq being the mastermind behind the assassination who led the operation in Dallas.
Dussaq referred to Castro as boss at one point in planning, according to Bazata. There
are only four scenarios: It was the rogue CIA, it was Cuba, it was Russia or it was the
Mafia, Wilcox told The Post. Or, its a combination of all of those and my book fits into
that because the real finger is pointed toward Castro and Cuba, but there are CIA players
and Mafia involved. Wilcox said Bazata gave him the diaries during a series of interviews
for his 2008 book on Gen. George Patton at Bazatas home just before his death at the age
of 88. He never wouldve given them to me at the time unless he had a stroke, Wilcox
said. All of his defenses were down. I found these down in his basement and I said, Can I
have these? Upon realizing the monumental find he might have made in Bazatas diaries,
Wilcox tracked down Dussaq and realized he lived just miles away. Dussaq had died of
cancer just three months earlier, but his second wife, Charlotte, gave Wilcox the spys
secret stuff, including an unpublished autobiography that was crucial to the book. In
1994, Dussaq was among a group of WWII veterans who re-enacted their invasion of
German-held France 50 years earlier. At 83, he was the oldest of the bunch. Prior to the
jump, Dussaq told The Post's Kyle Smith from his home in Encino, Calif., that he was not a
worrying person. Those of us who were paratroopers have a very strong feeling of
oneness with each other, Dussaq said. And we have a very strong awareness of those who
went with us and didnt make it We are doing it to commemorate those who were not
lucky enough to survive it. As usual, nothing was simple or predictable for Dussaq, whose
extraordinary life also included feats like walking on his hands atop the Empire State
Building and witnessing one of the first atomic bomb tests on Bikini Atoll in the Marshall
Islands. Strong winds during the re-enactment jump blew Dussaq miles from the drop zone.
He was later found in a nearby French town, drinking a glass of wine, <a
href="http://articles.latimes.com/1996-06-15/local/me-15379_1_world-war-ii"
target="_blank">the Los Angeles Times reported</a>. Dussaq <a
href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/1994/02/21/the-golden-
parachutists/3e10e66a-0f0a-4922-8ea1-64ce758d82c5/" target="_blank">told the
Washington Post</a> at the time that he had been coming to pieces of late, being treated
for cancer, a collapsed lung, a hernia and asthma. Dussaq, who said he was once a man of
violence, suggested to a reporter that maybe he was there to redeem his youth, before
saying he found enough adventure of late by simply tending his garden. You know what
they say: When the devil gets old, he retires to a monastery, Dussaq said. <a
href="https://www.amazon.com/Target-JFK-Spy-Killed-Kennedy/dp/1621574873/"
target="_blank">Target: JFK, The Spy Who Killed Kennedy?</a> by Robert K.
Wilcox will be available Nov. 14.
Former attorney general Kane hires new attorney for appeals - WFMJ.com News weather sports
for Youngstown-Warren Ohio
Former Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane has hired a new attorney to handle
the appeals of her perjury and obstruction conviction and related jail sentence.
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 287
249 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1060
Page
of 1061
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Stan J. Caterbone - The Department of Defense - The Intelligence Community - Finding of Facts
Re Isc Whistleblowing Activities as of Saturday November 12, 2016
False Imprisonments and Illegal Interrogations by U.S. Intelligence Agencies November 12, 2016
Lancaster County taxpayers have paid $36k for sheriff facing impeachment over sexual
harassment allegations | Insider | lancasteronline.com
Lancaster County commissioners do not have the power to remove Sheriff Mark Reese, an
elected official, from office but County Solicitor Chris Hausner said officials have been in
touch with
Trump picks Jeff Sessions for attorney general and Mike Pompeo for CIA chief | US news | The
Guardian
Sessions is a rightwing, anti-immigration senator while Pompeo supports NSA bulk data
collection, as Trump also taps Michael Flynn for national security team
Michael Flynn said to be offered job of Trump national security adviser | US news | The
Guardian
Retired general called for more aggression towards Isis, as ex-CIA chief David Petraeus
reportedly in race for secretary of state
Former attorney general Kane hires new attorney for appeals - WFMJ.com News weather sports for
Youngstown-Warren Ohio
Former Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane has hired a new attorney to handle the
appeals of her perjury and obstruction conviction and related jail sentence.
Emma Niles: Truthdigger of the Week: The Thousands Who Are Peacefully Protesting Trumps
Election - Truthdigger of the Week - Truthdig
In the days since Donald Trump won the presidency, demonstrators around the country
have banded together to oppose the sexism and racism he condoned on the campaign trail. -
2016/11/12
LETTER: It is getting clearer every day | Newslanc.com
EDITORS NOTE: We don't want to censure thoughtful communications because it is
politically incorrect to speak critically about the President Elect so soon
Emma Niles: Thousands of Anti-Trump Protesters March in Los Angeles - Truthdig
A massive crowd gathered at MacArthur Park on Saturday morning and marched several
miles through the heart of downtown. - 2016/11/12
Trump voters hope for more jobs, immigration control, cheaper health plans | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
The more than 130,000 Lancaster County residents who voted for Donald Trump are
hoping the next president will deliver on his promises.
Trump critics fear deportation, racism, losing health coverage, end of marriage equality | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Many local residents say they are afraid of how President-elect Trumps policies may affect
their health and safety.
America will not be at the heart of a new world order | Fintan OToole | Opinion | The Guardian
The free world was built on US military, economic and ideological power. But it is no
longer fit to bear that burden and nor does it want to
What you need to know about The Lancaster County Community Foundation's Extraordinary
Give | Local News | lancasteronline.com
The Lancaster County Community Foundation is gearing up for its fifth annual
Extraordinary Give a 24-hour online fundraising event for nonprofits in Lancaster
County.
Donald Trump and the Normalization of Torture - Lawfare
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 288
250 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1061
Page
of 1062
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
US backflip on China policy likely, says ex-CIA director
The first sign of a striking new approach to China from the Donald Trump administration
has come with the suggestion the US may now reverse its opposition to the China-created
Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank.
Lancaster Chamber honors Gene Garber with Delp Award for ag work | Local Business |
lancasteronline.com
The Lancaster Chamber of Commerce & Industry has honored Gene Garber with its
George C. Delp Award, for making a significant contribution to the agricultural community
here.
The Flying Pig Deli & Gourmet opens in Lancaster city | Local Business | lancasteronline.com
The Flying Pig Deli & Gourmet has opened in Lancaster, offering a variety deli
sandwiches as well as gourmet grocery items and options for meat and cheese boards.
Albert Wohlsen - Wikipedia
New Deed 1250 Fremont St Recorded on July 9, 2015
New Deed 1250 Fremont St Recorded on July 9, 2015 - Free download as PDF File (.pdf)
or read online for free.
Former CIA chief: Trump's presidency could damage economy - CNNPolitics.com
When political populists ride to victory on a wave of economic disaffection, as Donald
Trump did so effectively last Tuesday, they often create more damage than they relieve,
says the former acting director of the Central Intelligence Agency.
Fixated by iPhones and Snapchat, will kids ever again read for pleasure? | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Two hundred kids and parents attended the 8th annual Lititz Kid-Lit Festival.
Avenues - Nov/Dec 2016 - Powered by PageTurnPro.com
Stephen Bannon and Reince Priebus to lead Trump's White House | US news | The Guardian
Chief of staff rewarded for campaign loyalty and former executive chair of far-right
Breitbart News is senior counselor
Stan J. Caterbone and Conflicts With the Trump Administration - Monday November 14, 2016
3 million 'criminal' immigrants to be deported, says Donald Trump video | US news | The
Guardian
President-elect Donald Trump maintains his pre-election pledge to build a wall on the US
border with Mexico
Obama made progress on criminal justice reform. Will it survive the next president? | US news |
The Guardian
Gridlock and opposition in Congress forced Obama to resort to executive orders during his
pronounced late-presidency focus on prisons, sentencing and policing an ultimately
limited course of action
Julian Assange faces Swedish prosecutor in London over rape accusation | Media | The Guardian
WikiLeaks founders Swedish lawyer says he has been barred from attending interview,
which is scheduled to take three days
Times Leader | State Rep. Tarah Toohil testifies against former state AG Kathleen Kane
CP-36-SA-0000219-2016 Concise Statement of the Errors Complained of on Appeal November
14, 2016
Case No. 16-08472 Exhibit for Pain Medications - Re Case No. CP-36-SA-0000219-2016
Concise Statement of the Errors Complained Filed on November 15, 2016
War crimes of torture: ICC prosecutor signals charges against US armed forces, CIA RT
News
The US may have committed war crimes of torture, cruel treatment and rape, when it
interrogated dozens of people in Afghanistan between 2003 and 2004, the International
Criminal Courts chief prosecutor says.
10 most shocking facts we found in CIA torture report RT America
The so-called torture report released by the Senate this week contains only a fraction of
the findings on how the CIA aimed to gather intelligence from detainees through
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 289
251 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1062
Page
of 1063
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
interrogation. Still, it contains more than a few shocking revelations.
Facebook staff mount secret push to tackle fake news, reports say | Technology | The Guardian
Employees allegedly formed a task force to tackle the problem, while others say executives
are reviewing products to eliminate appearance of political bias
Effort underway to prevent Kathleen Kane from ever again holding public office | Pittsburgh
Post-Gazette
House panel that was considering the former attorney generals impeachment hears
testimony about damage done to the AGs office.
Recorded Case No. 16-mc-49 Declaration Re Case No. CP-36-SA-0000247-2016 No Parking
Ticket - Motion to Dismiss November 15, 2016
Letter REQUEST for COMMUTATION of the Sentence of Lisa Michell Lambert to President
Obama, November 15, 2016
NSA Director asks American CEOs to prioritize cybersecurity
NSA Director Michael Rogers told a room full of corporate executives Tuesday that they
play a role strengthening the entire country's cybersecurity posture.
Amid signs of transition trouble, Trump huddles with Pence | Politics | lancasteronline.com
NEW YORK (AP) Hidden from the public in his Manhattan high-rise, Donald Trump
huddled Tuesday with Vice President-elect Mike Pence as he tried to fill out key posts in
Release of Kathleen Kane's email report delayed until next week | PennLive.com
An office spokesman said AG Bruce Beemer had planned to release the report Wednesday
but has delayed it in order to attend the funeral of a police officer shot dead last week in
Canonsburg.
Inquirer Editorial: Trump can't deny that the dog-whistle language of his election campaign has
incited racism
In the days immediately after Donald Trump was elected president, more than 100 black
freshmen at the University of Pennsylvania received racist text messages; a black female
student at Villanova was knocked to the ground by a group of white males yelling "Trump,
Trump, Trump," and racist graffiti and swastikas with references to Trump were spray-
painted on a storefront in South Philadelphia.
Donald Trumps Transition Team Reshaped - WSJ
Another round of staff changes buffeted President-elect Donald Trumps transition team
Tuesday amid resistance from within the Republican Party over a top choice for secretary
of state.
What a Trump administration means for space - SpaceNews.com
A space policy of President-elect Trump is likely to focus on human spaceflight,
technology development and commercialization, and less on Earth science.
Op-ed | Donald Trumps peace through strength space vision - SpaceNews.com
Trump senior policy advisers Robert Walker and Peter Navarro say a Trump administration
would "lead the way on emerging technologies that have the potential to revolutionize
warfare," such as constellations of micro-satellites.
Trump transition team in disarray after key adviser 'purged' | US news | The Guardian
National security adviser Mike Rogers leaves in Stalinesque purge as talks at Trump
Tower continue amid uncertainty over role of president-elects children
Ours Is a Hope of Action - Truthdig
In the movement for equality, justice and peace, we smile at trouble and gather strength
from distress. We grow brave by reflection and do not shrink. - 2016/11/14
Trump in the White House: An Interview With Noam Chomsky - Truthdig
Chomsky warned years ago that the U.S. was ripe for the rise of an authoritarian. Now he
speaks about the election, the state of the U.S. political system and the threat Donald Trump
poses to the world. - 2016/11/14
Former state prosecutor says Kane interfered with investigations - News - Citizens' Voice
Donald Trump is going to appear on Alex Jones InfoWars - Salon.com
The president-elect rejects his ties to the alt-right movement, but his embrace of Alex Jones
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 290
252 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1063
Page
of 1064
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
suggests otherwise
RECORDED - Lancaster County Court Case No. 08-CI-13373 CATERBONE v. Duke Street
Business Center, et.al., Re PRAECIPE to ADD DEFENDANTS Filed on November 16, 2016
Democrat Christina Hartman reflects on congressional bid that came closer than ever | Insider |
lancasteronline.com
Democrat Christina Hartmans 11-point loss to Republican Lloyd Smucker in the
Lancaster-based congressional race is decisive in a traditionally red district but also a
milestone for the Democratic Party.
Drug delivery resulting in death charge yet to provide results in Lancaster County following 2011
law change | Insider | lancasteronline.com
Five years after a Pennsylvania law targeting people accused of dealing drugs that results in
someone's death was updated, no one in Lancaster County has gone to trial on the
Missing Quarryville man found safe | Local News | lancasteronline.com
A missing Quarryville man was found safe Tuesday night.
Officers
McCaskey students march against Trump | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Madi Janz, a McCaskey High School junior, said the election of Donald Trump as president
has made many of her fellow students angry and fearful.
Trump shuffles transition team, eyes loyalists for Cabinet | Business Standard News
Read more about Trump shuffles transition team, eyes loyalists for Cabinet on Business
Standard. Trump team still needs to provide more paperwork before detailed agency-by-
agency briefings can take place
I Used Mind Control to Fly a Honeywell Plane | WIRED
With no flight experience and 15 minutes of training, I use my thoughts and a brain-
computer interface to swoop through the air.
Truthdig - A Genuine U.S. Reset With Russia Is Long Overdue
President-elect Trumps willingness to rewrite the foreign and national security
establishments playbook, and seek to normalize relations with Russia, is a welcome
development. - 2016/11/15
A Genuine U.S. Reset With Russia Is Long Overdue - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
Google's approach to email
Spies Use Tinder, and It's as Creepy as You'd Think | Motherboard
The story of the Tinder infiltrator.
Trump transition team in disarray after top adviser 'purged' | US news | The Guardian
National security adviser Mike Rogers leaves in Stalinesque purge as talks at Trump
Tower continue amid uncertainty over role of president-elects children
Lets revisit a relevant moment in US history | Newslanc.com
By Robert Field Harry Truman was a great president but the country was bitterly divided
over many of his proposals. Dwight Eisenhower became President and
LETTER: 389 suicides and rising over election results | Newslanc.com
I read an article today which stated that 389 Americans have already committed suicide
since the announcement of Trump's presidency in fear for their lives and
CCR News: Resistance is our civic duty
Search - Supreme Court of the United States
Supreme Court of the United States Case No. 16-8822 DOCKET and COMMUTATION
LETTER to OBAMA Re CATERBONE v. Allison Hallet, Re Lisa Lambert Habeus November
17, 2016
Trump Says Transitions Going Smoothly, Disputing Disarray Reports - The New York Times
The president-elect used Twitter to assure Americans that the handover of power was going
well, despite accounts of infighting on his team.
Hillary Clinton: 'There have been times when I wanted never to leave the house again' | US news
| The Guardian
In first public appearance after Trump victory, Hillary Clinton says America is worth
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 291
253 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1064
Page
of 1065
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
fighting for, as Bernie Sanders calls for Democrats to leave centre ground
18 U.S. Code 1512 - Tampering with a witness, victim, or an informant | US Law | LII / Legal
Information Institute
Lancaster County Court Case No. 08-Ci-13373 Exhibit Re Current State of Affairs and Motion
for Summary Judgment November 17, 2016
Realscreen Archive Laura Poitras Project X to open in New York on Nov 18.
Realscreen - the best in non-fiction, is about the global business of factual entertainment
US intelligence chief Clapper resigns
US Director of National Intelligence James Clapper said Thursday that he had submitted
his resignation, stepping down as President-elect Donald Trump begins to assemble his new
administration. Clapper, whose job is to coordinate the work of 17 disparate agencies like
the Central Intelligence Agency
MedExpress 5 for PAIN VISITS for 2016 and Patient First 1 for PAIN VISIT for 2015 1 for
Pneumonia - November 17, 2016
Hackers mind controlled a Tesla Model S in hackathon project | Electrek
Rep. Mike Sturla of Lancaster city will lead policy committee for House Democrats for fifth time
| Pennsylvania | lancasteronline.com
Rep. Mike Sturla, Lancaster Countys lone Democratic state lawmaker, will serve his fifth
term as the partys top policy official in the new two-year session starting in January.
Ephrata Main Theatre struggles to pay digital projection costs as ticket sales decline | Local News
| lancasteronline.com
The Ephrata Main Theatre one of the last small, independent moviehouses in the area
faces a double threat that could sink the 78-year-old business at the heart of
New administration will be willing to alter American policy Trump adviser Woolsey to RT
RT News
Donald Trumps administration will be made up of individuals willing to make changes to
American policy, former CIA director James Woolsey, his senior adviser, told RT.
Twitter suspends several accounts in alt-right 'purge' | Fox News
Twitter has suspended a number of prominent accounts associated with the so-called alt-
right movement, in an apparent purge.
James Clapper, of NSA-scandal fame, is stepping down - CNET
A remark to Congress by Clapper provided a key moment during the uproar over NSA
spying.
Dark tower in lower Manhattan outed as NSA nerve center
A telecommunications hub built in 1969 to withstand a nuclear attack, now "appears" to
serve as a surveillance site for the National Security Agency (NSA).
US intelligence chief James Clapper resigns | Daily Mail Online
US intelligence chief James Clapper, whose 2013 denial that the US collects personal
communications data on millions of citizens led to the stunning Snowden ...
Spy critic Wyden attacks as Clapper resigns | TheHill
USPS.com - USPS Tracking
USPS Delivery Confirmation - Request for Commutation of the Sentence of Lisa Michell
Lambert to President Obama, November 17, 2016
Extraordinary Give: Events are held throughout the county | Together | lancasteronline.com
Events are being held throughout Lancaster County as the entire community comes together
to raise money for worthy organizations.
RECORDED Case No. 16-mc-49 Chapter 11 DECLARATION Re LETTER to Judy Astacio,
Consumer Services Investigator, Pennsylvania Department of Insurance November 18, 2016
Trump National Security Adviser Pick Has Medals and Baggage - NBC News
The choice to offer Michael Flynn the post is sure to thrill those who want a shakeup, but
others worry that foreign policy needs a calm hand.
Michael T. Flynn - Wikipedia
Defense Intelligence Agency - Wikipedia
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 292
254 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1065
Page
of 1066
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
Director of the Defense Intelligence Agency - Wikipedia
Lowell E. Jacoby - Wikipedia
Director of National Intelligence James Clapper resigns amidst dramatic transition process
The Director of National Intelligence DNI James Clappernbsphas submitted his resignation
to Barack Obama
Inquirer Editorial: What else did Kathleen Kane do wrong as attorney general?
Former Attorney General Kathleen Kane is headed to jail, but questions remain about the
apparent misdeeds and botched cases she left behind.
Barack Obama on fake news: 'We have problems' if we can't tell the difference | Media | The
Guardian
The US president denounced the spate of misinformation across social media platforms,
including Facebook, suggesting American politics can be affected
Blarney: Snowden files expose NSA spying on EU, UN World Bank and IMF
Court orders were obtained to spy on countries around the world, files show.
Top WikiLeaks Editor: Democrats Should Be Happy About the Organizations Commitment to
Transparency - Truthdig
Writing in The New York Times, Sarah Harrison defended the publication against
accusations that it abett[ed] the candidacy of Donald J. Trump by publishing
information about Hillary Clintons campaign and its influence over the Democratic
National Committee. - 2016/11/17
Honeywell Develops Mind Control for Airplanes | Flying Magazine
An engineer at Honeywell Aerospace has developed a "brain-computer interface that
allows pilots to fly an airplane using only their thoughts.
Kansas Republican Rep. Mike Pompeo would be partisan, strong-willed CIA director |
McClatchy DC
Rep. Mike Pompeo wants NSA turncoat contractor Edward Snowden put to death, and
thinks waterboarding is acceptable. But hell have his hands full steering the CIA if he is
confirmed as its director.
Former Pa. attorney general sentenced to jail time in perjury, obstruction case | WPXI
Former Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane was sentenced to --- --- Channel
11's Gordon Loesch is covering the sentencing. He'll have any additional developments on
Channel 11 News at 5:00 and...
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court Will Likely Be Democratic for the Next 6 Years |
Newslanc.com
PHILADELPHIA MAGAZINE: On Tuesday, voters in Pennsylvania approved a state
constitutional amendment that raises the retirement age for judges to 75
Stan Caterbone Twitter Account FROM November 14 to November 19, 2016
Officials seek guidance from state Supreme Court before resentencing Lancaster County juvenile
lifers | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Lancaster County officials are looking to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court for direction
before re-evaluating the life without parole sentences of 13 local convicted killers.
Who are Trump's attorney general, national security adviser and CIA chief? | US news | The
Guardian
The president-elect has appointed Jeff Sessions, Michael Flynn and Mike Pompeo. None
are without controversy
Factbox: Trump makes picks to fill security, legal posts
Republican U.S. President-elect Donald Trump on Friday announced his selections for his
top security posts, including the head of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), his national
security adviser and attorney general. An official with Trump's transition team told Reuters
that Trump had chosen
Look Inside the Windowless New York Skyscraper Linked to the NSA
Mike Pompeo: 5 Fast Facts You Need to Know | Heavy.com
Mike Pompeo, who has defended the NSA's spying, has accepted Donald Trump's offer to
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 293
255 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1066
Page
of 1067
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
become the new CIA director, following in the footsteps of John Brennan.
Christopher P. Lyden, Shareholder at Miller Lyden Attorneys
Christopher P. Lyden in Lancaster is an experienced trial and appellate attorney who has
served clients in Pennsylvania courts for over 15 years.
Miller Lyden P.C. OUr Team
Our team: The attorneys and staff at Miller Lyden P.C.
Case No. SA-247-2016 ORDER by Judge Howard F. Knisely for Motion to Dismiss Dated
Wednesday, November 16, 2016
Michel Flynn, Trumps national security advisor, believes fake news and partisan conspiracy
theories - Vox
And now his job is telling Donald Trump what to believe.
Proposed Anti-Stalking Legislation UPDATE With Federal Whistleblower and Targeted
Individual of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control Executive Summary Edited November 21, 2016
Pentagon, intelligence leaders reportedly seeking NSA chief's ouster | The Times of Israel
Admiral Michael Rogers, seen as possible National Intelligence pick for Trump, under fire
from defense and intel heads, prompting House hearing
Lancaster city sells 2 historic West King Street buildings | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Two historic city-owned buildings in the heart of downtown Lancaster are set to return to
private hands.
Fire heavily damages My Place/Rosa Rosa Pizzeria on Harrisburg Pike | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
A fire heavily damaged My Place/Rosa Rosa Pizzeria in Manheim Township Sunday
evening.
Chris Hedges: We Are All Deplorables - Chris Hedges - Truthdig
Liberals have no moral authority to preach to a dispossessed white working class about
racism, multiculturalism, identity politics or diversity. The abject failure by liberals to fight
for economic justice triggered the protofascist backlash embodied by Donald Trumps
election victory. - 2016/11/20
Donald Trump Assembling Team of Swamp Creatures, Says Democratic Lawmaker Keith
Ellison - Truthdig
The progressive congressman said its clear the president-elect is not doing what hes said
hes gonna do for average working Americans. - 2016/11/20
Local Pennsylvania Susquehanna Valley Breaking News and Live Alerts - WGAL News 8
Chris Hedges: We Are All Deplorables - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
Peter Richardson: The Crisis of Conservative Intellectuals? - Truthdig
Fire heavily damages My Place/Rosa Rosa Pizzeria on Harrisburg Pike | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Lancaster city sells 2 historic West King Street buildings | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Proposed Anti-Stalking Legislation UPDATE With Federal Whistleblower and Targeted
Individual of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control Executive Summary Edited November 21,
2016
Stan J. Caterbone (@SCaterbone) | Twitter
Feds Probe Fulton Bank and 3 Other Subsidiary Banks of Fulton Financial With Stan J.
Caterbone Civil Actions and Mind Control Research of Monday November 9, 2016
Supreme Court of the United States Case No. 16-8822 DOCKET and COMMUTATION
LETTER to OBAMA Re CATERBONE v. Allison Hallet, Re Lisa Lambert Habeus
November 17, 2016
New Tab
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 294
256 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1067
Page
of 1068
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
masons
Barack Obama says reality will force Trump to adjust his approach | US news | The Guardian
Outgoing president does not intend to be his successors constant critic but will speak out if
policies breach certain values
Dreams of undocumented young people start to crumble after Trump victory | US news | The
Guardian
Donald Trump has promised to overturn Obamas Daca program that protects the children
of undocumented immigrants, a group known as the Dreamers
Manheim investors hope $1.55M incubator can help replicate Lititz's buzz in their borough |
Local Business | lancasteronline.com
Manheim businessman T.J. Mousetis sees the advantages that Lititz Borough and Lancaster
city get from their bustling downtowns.
After 28 years in downtown Lancaster, Here to Timbuktu begins closing sale | Local Business |
lancasteronline.com
A retirement sale has begun at Here to Timbuktu, a downtown Lancaster clothing and gift
shop, whose owner hopes to close by the end of the year.
Original Nino's Pizza & Grille opens in Millersville | Local Business | lancasteronline.com
The Original Ninos Pizza & Grill has opened in Millersville after an extensive
renovation of a building that was most recently the home of a different Ninos pizza shop.
Shifting US policy to right, Trump taps Sessions, Flynn
Kane impeachment panel wrapping up work - News - Citizens' Voice
Facebook announces new push against fake news after Obama comments | Technology | The
Guardian
Mark Zuckerberg says site has been working on problem for a long time and penalizes
misinformation on news feeds to reduce chances it will spread
Alexander Reed Kelly: Truthdigger of the Week: Radical Political Strategist Micah White -
Truthdigger of the Week - Truthdig
To withstand and ultimately overcome the imminent Trump regime, American activists
must move from detached indignation to revolutionary engagement by using the techniques
of social movement creation to dominate elections, says the co-creator of Occupy Wall
Street. - 2016/11/19
The Boat Rocker: An Unsettling Book About the Moral Dimensions of Modern Journalism -
Truthdig
How timely it is to read this strange, intense novel from Ha Jin about the glories and limits
of the press. A former soldier in the Chinese army who chose to stay in the U.S. after the
Tiananmen Square massacre, Ha Jin has lived and worked under two very different sets of
rules. - 2016/11/19
Free app to help Park City shoppers find parking during holidays | Insider | lancasteronline.com
Youre driving slowly past rows of parked cars, your head on a swivel.
Lancaster County Prison seeks funds for inmate bracelet program | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Lancaster County Prison officials say wristbands will help the facility to move away from
paper-based tracking system.
NSA Director Faces Firing Calls From Pentagon, U.S. Intelligence Elites | The Huffington Post
Rogers has faced criticism over security lapses in the post-Edward Snowden era.
Fears of government spying under Trump spur encryption use - San Francisco Chronicle
The day Donald Trump ascends from president-elect to commander in chief, he will assume
control over U.S. intelligence agencies and some of the most advanced surveillance systems
in the world. The surge is prompted by concerns of how Trump, a reality-TV star and real
estate mogul who forged an unconventional and controversial path in politics filled with
personal attacks and feuds, may use this countrys intelligence apparatus. Years before
former contractor Edward Snowden revealed that the National Security Agency was
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 295
257 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1068
Page
of 1069
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
engaged in widespread domestic surveillance, the government had been bolstering its
ability to gather and keep massive amounts of data on peoples communications and online
activities. [...] Trumps election, which has stoked fears of marginalization and violence
among communities of color, Muslims, LGBT people and immigrants, has brought
concerns over digital privacy to the public. The Obama administration drastically
expanded and codified a lot of these programs that are now being handed over to Donald
Trump, said Evan Greer, the campaign director at activist group Fight for the Future.
During the Republican primaries, Trump said he would absolutely keep a database of
Muslims in the U.S. an idea that has since evolved into a national security registry of
immigrants from countries with known terror cells. The president-elect has called social
justice group Black Lives Matter a threat and told conservative talk show host Bill
OReilly over the summer that at a minimum, were going to have to be watching. In
2015, Congress passed the USA Freedom Act that constrained how the government can
obtain records using the Patriot Act and largely limited the NSAs ability to request data,
like the private Internet and phone communications of Americans, from telecom companies
en masse. Weakening protections from government spying could also open doors to others
who want eyes on Americans data, said Gabe Rottman, a deputy director at the nonprofit
Center for Democracy and Technology. Pressuring tech companies to build more secure
devices and protect user information, Snowden said, is a safer bet than relying on the
integrity of government officials. Earlier this year, Trump loudly criticized Apple for
refusing to build special software to unlock an iPhone used by Syed Rizwan Farook, the
gunman who killed 14 and injured 22 people in a mass shooting in San Bernardino last
September. [...] Apple was cheered by many of its customers, tech professionals and
security experts for its decision to resist the governments demands. Yahoo reportedly built
a program last year that allowed U.S. intelligence officials to scour hundreds of millions of
peoples emails to find a signature associated with a terrorist group, according to Reuters.
On Friday, news reports indicated Trump had asked retired Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn, a three-
star general who specialized in intelligence gathering, to serve as his national security
adviser. The app, which was created by nonprofit Open Whisper Systems, offers a slew of
privacy features including disappearing messages. Encryption helps prevent text messages,
emails, phone calls and video chats from being intercepted during transmission, which is
often how governments, law enforcement and hackers can spy on peoples communication.
When messaging or phone calls are encrypted, that means the communication is scrambled
during transmission and then unscrambled by the intended recipient using a secret key,
typically held by the sender, recipient and the app maker.
Edward Snowden Live From Russia - YouTube
People Who Control America ? Mind Blowing Documentary HQ - YouTube
Who Controls United States Of America? Answer is here ! The Waiting Room is a
documentary film and social media project directed by Peter Nicks that follows ...
Oliver Stones Untold History of the United States Prequel A - YouTube
Link to Prequel B here :
http://www.filedropper.com/oliverstonesuntoldhistoryoftheunitedstatesprequelb
Full Documentary: "Edward Snowden" 2016 - YouTube
Full Documentary: "Edward Snowden" 2016 This movie briefly covers NSA analyst-turned
whistleblower Edward Snowden and his escape from American authorities to...
Local Pennsylvania Susquehanna Valley Breaking News and Live Alerts - WGAL News 8
Inbox (1) - stancaterbone@gmail.com - Gmail
Full Documentary: "Edward Snowden" 2016 - YouTube
Oliver Stones Untold History of the United States Prequel A - YouTube
Stan J. Caterbone
INVOICE FEE - Estaban
BOOKMARKS
Santiago and
Defense
HISTORY Page 296
258 of 415
272
288
301
312
321
332
377 Sunday
Friday
Friday
Morning
January
Sunday
Friday
Monday
Tuesday
January
Friday
January
December
1,January
December
13,
January
20172017
NEW
6, 20,
2017
17,
23,
18,
5,2017
YEAR
2017
2016
-
UNITEDUN NATIONS
COMPLAINT
COMPLAINT
Page 1069
Page
of 1070
2413 of 2593
by Stan J.Published
Caterboneby
and
ADVANCED
Advanced MEDIA
Media Group
GROUP - CONFIDENTIAL
Copyright 2017
2016
People Who Control America ? Mind Blowing Documentary HQ - YouTube
Edward Snowden Live From Russia - YouTube
Fears of government spying under Trump spur encryption use - San Francisco Chronicle
NSA Director Faces Firing Calls From Pentagon, U.S. Intelligence Elites | The Huffington
Post
Officials seek guidance from state Supreme Court before resentencing Lancaster County
juvenile lifers | Local News | lancasteronline.com
Lancaster County Prison seeks funds for inmate bracelet program | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
The Boat Rocker: An Unsettling Book About the Moral Dimensions of Modern
Journalism - Truthdig
Alexander Reed Kelly: Truthdigger of the Week: Radical Political Strategist Micah White -
Truthdigger of the Week - Truthdig
Facebook announces new push against fake news after Obama comments | Technology |
The Guardian
Kane impeachment panel wrapping up work - News - Citizens' Voice
Shifting US policy to right, Trump taps Sessions, Flynn
Dreams of undocumented young people start to crumble after Trump victory | US news |
The Guardian
Barack Obama says reality will force Trump to adjust his approach | US news | The
Guardian
Peter Richardson: The Crisis of Conservative Intellectuals? - Truthdig
Fire heavily damages My Place/Rosa Rosa Pizzeria on Harrisburg Pike | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Lancaster city sells 2 historic West King Street buildings | Local News |
lancasteronline.com
Proposed Anti-Stalking Legislation UPDATE With Federal Whistleblower and Targeted
Individual of U.S. Sponsored Mind Control Executive Summary Edited November 21,
2016
(1) Stan J. Caterbone (@SCaterbone) | Twitter
Feds Probe Fulton Bank and 3 Other Subsidiary Banks of Fulton Financial With Stan J.
Caterbone Civil Actions and Mind Control Research of Monday November 9, 2016
Supreme Court of the United States Case No. 16-8822 DOCKET and COMMUTATION
LETTER to OBAMA Re CATERBONE v. Allison Hallet, Re Lisa Lambert Habeus
November 17, 2016
New Tab
masons