Anda di halaman 1dari 15

Mohr plots of up to 4 stress states with a failure envelope and tensile cutoff

sigma 1 sigma 3 sigma 1 sigma 3


Case 1 5 2.5 Case 2 5 2 Case 3

failure

failure
two- normal shear two- normal shear two-
theta traction traction theta traction traction theta

?
1 2.5001904 0.0218155 No 1 2.0002285 0.0261786 No 1
2 2.5007615 0.0436244 No 2 2.0009138 0.0523492 No 2
3 2.5017131 0.0654199 No 3 2.0020557 0.0785039 No 3
4 2.5030449 0.0871956 No 4 Mohr circle plot
2.0036539 0.1046347 No 4
5 2.5047566 0.1089447 No 5 2.005708 0.1307336 No 5
6 2.5068476 0.1306606 No 6 2.0082172 0.1567927 No 6
7 2.5093173 0.1523367 No 7 2.0111808 0.182804 No 7
4
8 2.5121649 0.1739664 No 8 2.0145979 0.2087597 No 8
9 2.5153896 0.1955431 No 9 2.0184675 0.2346517 No 9
10 3.5 0.2170602 No
2.5189903 10 2.0227884 0.2604723 No 10
11 2.522966 0.2385112 No 11 2.0275592 0.2862135 No 11
12 2.52731553 0.2598896 No 12 2.0327786 0.3118675 No 12
13 2.5320374 0.2811888 No 13 2.0384449 0.3374266 No 13
14 2.5371303
2.5 0.3024024 No 14 2.0445564 0.3628828 No 14
15 2.5425927 0.3235238 No 15 2.0511113 0.3882286 No 15
16 2.5484229 0.3445467 No 16 2.0581075 0.413456 No 16
2
shear
17 stress traction
2.5546191 0.3654646 No 17 2.0655429 0.4385576 No 17
18 2.5611794 0.3862712 No 18 2.0734152 0.4635255 No 18
19 1.5 0.4069602 No
2.5681018 19 2.0817221 0.4883522 No 19
20 2.5753842 0.4275252 No 20 2.0904611 0.5130302 No 20
21 2.58302451 0.4479599 No 21 2.0996294 0.5375519 No 21
22 2.5910202 0.4682582 No 22 2.1092242 0.5619099 No 22
23 2.5993689
0.5 0.4884139 No 23 2.1192427 0.5860967 No 23
24 2.6080682 0.5084208 No 24 2.1296818 0.610105 No 24
25 2.6171153 0.5282728 No 25 2.1405383 0.6339274 No 25
0
26 -1 2.62650740 0.5479639 1No 26 2 2.151808930.6575567 4No 26 5 6
27 2.6362418 0.5674881 No 27 2.1634902 0.6809857 No 27
28 2.6463155 0.5868395 No normal
28 stress traction
2.1755786 0.7042073 No 28
29 2.6567254 0.606012 No 29 2.1880704 0.7272144 No 29
30 2.6674682 0.625 No 30 2.2009619 0.75 No 30
31 2.6785409 0.6437976 No 31 2.214249 0.7725571 No 31
32 2.6899399 0.6623991 No 32 2.2279279 0.7948789 No 32
33 2.7016618 0.6807988 No 33 2.2419941 0.8169586 No 33
34 2.713703 0.6989911 No 34 2.2564436 0.8387894 No 34
35 2.7260599 0.7169705 No 35 2.2712719 0.8603647 No 35
36 2.7387288 0.7347316 No 36 2.2864745 0.8816779 No 36
37 2.7517056 0.7522688 No 37 2.3020467 0.9027225 No 37
38 2.7649866 0.7695768 No 38 2.3179839 0.9234922 No 38
39 2.7785675 0.7866505 No 39 2.3342811 0.9439806 No 39
40 2.7924444 0.8034845 No 40 2.3509333 0.9641814 No 40
41 2.806613 0.8200738 No 41 2.3679356 0.9840885 No 41
42 2.821069 0.8364133 No 42 2.3852828 1.0036959 No 42
43 2.8358079 0.852498 No 43 2.4029694 1.0229975 No 43
44 2.8508252 0.868323 No 44 2.4209903 1.0419876 No 44
45 2.8661165 0.8838835 No 45 2.4393398 1.0606602 No 45
46 2.881677 0.8991748 No 46 2.4580124 1.0790097 No 46
47 2.897502 0.9141921 No 47 2.4770025 1.0970306 No 47
48 2.9135867 0.928931 No 48 2.4963041 1.1147172 No 48
49 2.9299262 0.943387 No 49 2.5159115 1.1320644 No 49
50 2.9465155 0.9575556 No 50 2.5358186 1.1490667 No 50
51 2.9633495 0.9714325 No 51 2.5560194 1.1657189 No 51
52 2.9804232 0.9850134 No 52 2.5765078 1.1820161 No 52
53 2.9977312 0.9982944 No 53 2.5972775 1.1979533 No 53
54 3.0152684 1.0112712 No 54 2.6183221 1.2135255 No 54
55 3.0330295 1.0239401 No 55 2.6396353 1.2287281 No 55
56 3.0510089 1.036297 No 56 2.6612106 1.2435564 No 56
57 3.0692012 1.0483382 No 57 2.6830414 1.2580059 No 57
58 3.0876009 1.0600601 No 58 2.7051211 1.2720721 No 58
59 3.1062024 1.0714591 No 59 2.7274429 1.285751 No 59
60 3.125 1.0825318 No 60 2.75 1.2990381 No 60
61 3.143988 1.0932746 No 61 2.7727856 1.3119296 No 61
62 3.1631605 1.1036845 No 62 2.7957927 1.3244214 No 62
63 3.1825119 1.1137582 No 63 2.8190143 1.3365098 No 63
64 3.2020361 1.1234926 No 64 2.8424433 1.3481911 No 64
65 3.2217272 1.1328847 No 65 2.8660726 1.3594617 No 65
66 3.2415792 1.1419318 No 66 2.889895 1.3703182 No 66
67 3.2615861 1.1506311 No 67 2.9139033 1.3807573 No 67
68 3.2817418 1.1589798 No 68 2.9380901 1.3907758 No 68
69 3.3020401 1.1669755 No 69 2.9624481 1.4003706 No 69
70 3.3224748 1.1746158 No 70 2.9869698 1.4095389 No 70
71 3.3430398 1.1818982 No 71 3.0116478 1.4182779 No 71
72 3.3637288 1.1888206 No 72 3.0364745 1.4265848 No 72
73 3.3845354 1.1953809 No 73 3.0614424 1.4344571 No 73
74 3.4054533 1.2015771 No 74 3.086544 1.4418925 No 74
75 3.4264762 1.2074073 No 75 3.1117714 1.4488887 No 75
76 3.4475976 1.2128697 No 76 3.1371172 1.4554436 No 76
77 3.4688112 1.2179626 No 77 3.1625734 1.4615551 No 77
78 3.4901104 1.2226845 No 78 3.1881325 1.4672214 No 78
79 3.5114888 1.227034 No 79 3.2137865 1.4724408 No 79
80 3.5329398 1.2310097 No 80 3.2395277 1.4772116 No 80
81 3.5544569 1.2346104 No 81 3.2653483 1.4815325 No 81
82 3.5760336 1.2378351 No 82 3.2912403 1.4854021 No 82
83 3.5976633 1.2406827 No 83 3.317196 1.4888192 No 83
84 3.6193394 1.2431524 No 84 3.3432073 1.4917828 No 84
85 3.6410553 1.2452434 No 85 3.3692664 1.494292 No 85
86 3.6628044 1.2469551 No 86 3.3953653 1.4963461 No 86
87 3.6845801 1.2482869 No 87 3.4214961 1.4979443 No 87
88 3.7063756 1.2492385 No 88 3.4476508 1.4990862 No 88
89 3.7281845 1.2498096 No 89 3.4738214 1.4997715 No 89
90 3.75 1.25 No 90 3.5 1.5 No 90
91 3.7718155 1.2498096 No 91 3.5261786 1.4997715 No 91
92 3.7936244 1.2492385 No 92 3.5523492 1.4990862 No 92
93 3.8154199 1.2482869 No 93 3.5785039 1.4979443 No 93
94 3.8371956 1.2469551 No 94 3.6046347 1.4963461 No 94
95 3.8589447 1.2452434 No 95 3.6307336 1.494292 No 95
96 3.8806606 1.2431524 No 96 3.6567927 1.4917828 No 96
97 3.9023367 1.2406827 No 97 3.682804 1.4888192 No 97
98 3.9239664 1.2378351 No 98 3.7087597 1.4854021 No 98
99 3.9455431 1.2346104 No 99 3.7346517 1.4815325 No 99
100 3.9670602 1.2310097 No 100 3.7604723 1.4772116 No 100
101 3.9885112 1.227034 No 101 3.7862135 1.4724408 No 101
102 4.0098896 1.2226845 No 102 3.8118675 1.4672214 No 102
103 4.0311888 1.2179626 No 103 3.8374266 1.4615551 No 103
104 4.0524024 1.2128697 No 104 3.8628828 1.4554436 No 104
105 4.0735238 1.2074073 No 105 3.8882286 1.4488887 No 105
106 4.0945467 1.2015771 No 106 3.913456 1.4418925 No 106
107 4.1154646 1.1953809 No 107 3.9385576 1.4344571 No 107
108 4.1362712 1.1888206 No 108 3.9635255 1.4265848 No 108
109 4.1569602 1.1818982 No 109 3.9883522 1.4182779 No 109
110 4.1775252 1.1746158 No 110 4.0130302 1.4095389 No 110
111 4.1979599 1.1669755 No 111 4.0375519 1.4003706 No 111
112 4.2182582 1.1589798 No 112 4.0619099 1.3907758 No 112
113 4.2384139 1.1506311 No 113 4.0860967 1.3807573 No 113
114 4.2584208 1.1419318 No 114 4.110105 1.3703182 No 114
115 4.2782728 1.1328847 No 115 4.1339274 1.3594617 No 115
116 4.2979639 1.1234926 No 116 4.1575567 1.3481911 No 116
117 4.3174881 1.1137582 No 117 4.1809857 1.3365098 No 117
118 4.3368395 1.1036845 No 118 4.2042073 1.3244214 No 118
119 4.356012 1.0932746 No 119 4.2272144 1.3119296 No 119
120 4.375 1.0825318 No 120 4.25 1.2990381 No 120
121 4.3937976 1.0714591 No 121 4.2725571 1.285751 No 121
122 4.4123991 1.0600601 No 122 4.2948789 1.2720721 No 122
123 4.4307988 1.0483382 No 123 4.3169586 1.2580059 No 123
124 4.4489911 1.036297 No 124 4.3387894 1.2435564 No 124
125 4.4669705 1.0239401 No 125 4.3603647 1.2287281 No 125
126 4.4847316 1.0112712 No 126 4.3816779 1.2135255 No 126
127 4.5022688 0.9982944 No 127 4.4027225 1.1979533 No 127
128 4.5195768 0.9850134 No 128 4.4234922 1.1820161 No 128
129 4.5366505 0.9714325 No 129 4.4439806 1.1657189 No 129
130 4.5534845 0.9575556 No 130 4.4641814 1.1490667 No 130
131 4.5700738 0.943387 No 131 4.4840885 1.1320644 No 131
132 4.5864133 0.928931 No 132 4.5036959 1.1147172 No 132
133 4.602498 0.9141921 No 133 4.5229975 1.0970306 No 133
134 4.618323 0.8991748 No 134 4.5419876 1.0790097 No 134
135 4.6338835 0.8838835 No 135 4.5606602 1.0606602 No 135
136 4.6491748 0.868323 No 136 4.5790097 1.0419876 No 136
137 4.6641921 0.852498 No 137 4.5970306 1.0229975 No 137
138 4.678931 0.8364133 No 138 4.6147172 1.0036959 No 138
139 4.693387 0.8200738 No 139 4.6320644 0.9840885 No 139
140 4.7075556 0.8034845 No 140 4.6490667 0.9641814 No 140
141 4.7214325 0.7866505 No 141 4.6657189 0.9439806 No 141
142 4.7350134 0.7695768 No 142 4.6820161 0.9234922 No 142
143 4.7482944 0.7522688 No 143 4.6979533 0.9027225 No 143
144 4.7612712 0.7347316 No 144 4.7135255 0.8816779 No 144
145 4.7739401 0.7169705 No 145 4.7287281 0.8603647 No 145
146 4.786297 0.6989911 No 146 4.7435564 0.8387894 No 146
147 4.7983382 0.6807988 No 147 4.7580059 0.8169586 No 147
148 4.8100601 0.6623991 No 148 4.7720721 0.7948789 No 148
149 4.8214591 0.6437976 No 149 4.785751 0.7725571 No 149
150 4.8325318 0.625 No 150 4.7990381 0.75 No 150
151 4.8432746 0.606012 No 151 4.8119296 0.7272144 No 151
152 4.8536845 0.5868395 No 152 4.8244214 0.7042073 No 152
153 4.8637582 0.5674881 No 153 4.8365098 0.6809857 No 153
154 4.8734926 0.5479639 No 154 4.8481911 0.6575567 No 154
155 4.8828847 0.5282728 No 155 4.8594617 0.6339274 No 155
156 4.8919318 0.5084208 No 156 4.8703182 0.610105 No 156
157 4.9006311 0.4884139 No 157 4.8807573 0.5860967 No 157
158 4.9089798 0.4682582 No 158 4.8907758 0.5619099 No 158
159 4.9169755 0.4479599 No 159 4.9003706 0.5375519 No 159
160 4.9246158 0.4275252 No 160 4.9095389 0.5130302 No 160
161 4.9318982 0.4069602 No 161 4.9182779 0.4883522 No 161
162 4.9388206 0.3862712 No 162 4.9265848 0.4635255 No 162
163 4.9453809 0.3654646 No 163 4.9344571 0.4385576 No 163
164 4.9515771 0.3445467 No 164 4.9418925 0.413456 No 164
165 4.9574073 0.3235238 No 165 4.9488887 0.3882286 No 165
166 4.9628697 0.3024024 No 166 4.9554436 0.3628828 No 166
167 4.9679626 0.2811888 No 167 4.9615551 0.3374266 No 167
168 4.9726845 0.2598896 No 168 4.9672214 0.3118675 No 168
169 4.977034 0.2385112 No 169 4.9724408 0.2862135 No 169
170 4.9810097 0.2170602 No 170 4.9772116 0.2604723 No 170
171 4.9846104 0.1955431 No 171 4.9815325 0.2346517 No 171
172 4.9878351 0.1739664 No 172 4.9854021 0.2087597 No 172
173 4.9906827 0.1523367 No 173 4.9888192 0.182804 No 173
174 4.9931524 0.1306606 No 174 4.9917828 0.1567927 No 174
175 4.9952434 0.1089447 No 175 4.994292 0.1307336 No 175
176 4.9969551 0.0871956 No 176 4.9963461 0.1046347 No 176
177 4.9982869 0.0654199 No 177 4.9979443 0.0785039 No 177
178 4.9992385 0.0436244 No 178 4.9990862 0.0523492 No 178
179 4.9998096 0.0218155 No 179 4.9997715 0.0261786 No 179
180 5 1.53E-016 No 180 5 1.84E-016 No 180
tensile cutoff Failure Envelope
sigma 1 sigma 3 sigma 1 sigma 3 intercept slope
5 1.5 Case 4 5 1 0.55 30

failure

failure
normal shear two- normal shear normal shear
traction traction theta traction traction traction traction

?
1.5002665 0.0305417 No 1 1.0003046 0.0349048 No -0.668333 0.1641376
1.5010661 0.0610741 No 2 1.0012183 0.069799 No -0.636667 0.1824203
1.5023983 0.0915879 No 3 Explanation:
1.0027409 This sheetNo
0.1046719 plots up-0.605
to 4 Mohr0.2007031
circles representing 4
1.5042629 0.1220738 No 4 states (in 2D) simultaneously,
1.0048719 0.1395129 No each labeled as case 1 through cas
-0.573333 0.2189858
plot. A failure envelope and a tensile cut off are also plotted. Inpu
1.5066593 0.1525225 No 5 1.0076106 0.1743115
are in the outlined boxes No- simply
-0.541667
change 0.2372686
the default values to tho
1.5095867 0.1829248 No 6 1.0109562 0.2090569 No -0.51
desire. They should all be in the same units. 0.2555514
Make sure that sigm
1.5130442 0.2132714 No 7 always greater
1.0149077 than sigma
0.2437387 No 3 (sigma 1 and 0.2738341
-0.478333 3 referring to the two p
1.5170309 0.2435529 No 8 stress being
1.0194639 plotted. No
0.2783462 -0.446667 0.2921169
1.5215454 0.2737603 No 9 1.0246233 0.3128689 No -0.415 0.3103996
You can use this sheet to model stress state evolution that leads
1.5265864 0.3038843 No 10 1.0303845
(i.e. to model loading paths). If one of the 0.3286824
0.3472964 No -0.383333 circles 'touches' the fai
1.5321524 0.3339157 No 11 1.0367456
envelope or 0.381618 No then-0.351667
tensile cutoff failure should0.3469652
occur. In this partic
1.5382417 0.3638455 No 12 what is modeled
1.0437048 0.4158234 No is pristine failure. Note
-0.32 the fourth
0.3652479 column for eac
1.5448524 0.3936643 No
case 1 13 stress state cases
1.0512599 0.4499021 No (each marked by a differently
-0.288333 0.3835307 colored block of
marks the cases where the shear stress exceeds the failure criter
1.5519825 0.4233633CaseNo2 14 1.0594085 0.4838438
would be expected withNo -0.256667
the word 0.4018134
yes (otherwise no is returned an
case
1.5596298 0.4529333 No 3 15 1.0681483 0.5176381
surface should No You may
be stable). -0.225
have to 0.4200962
move the plot or this
case
1.567792 0.4823654 No 4 16 box to see0.5512747
1.0774766 the values in Nothis column.
-0.193333 0.4383789
Failure
1.5764667 0.5116505 No envelope
17 1.0873905 0.5847434 No -0.161667 0.4566617
Tensile cutoff You can easily modify this sheet to add additional cases. Depend
1.5856511 0.5407797 No 18 1.097887 0.618034 No -0.13 0.4749445
input values the x and y axis may not be scaled the same and so
1.5953425 0.5697443 No 19 1.1089628
will plot as0.6511363
ellipses. You Nocan simply
-0.098333click 0.4932272
on, grab the corner and
1.6055379 0.5985353 No 20 1.1206148 0.6840403
plot until the Mohr circlesNo look-0.066667
like circles. 0.51151
H.D.Maher 9/12
1.6162343 0.6271439 No 21 1.1328391 0.7167359 No -0.035 0.5297927
1.6274283 0.6555615 No 22 1.1456323 0.7492132 No -0.003333 0.5480755
1.6391165 0.6837795 No 23 1.1589903 0.7814623 No 0.0283333 0.5663583
1.6512954 0.7117891 No 24 1.1729091 0.8134733 No 0.06 0.584641
1.6639614 0.739582 No 25 1.1873844 0.8452365 No 0.0916667 0.6029238
5 1.67711046 0.7671495 No 26 1.2024119 0.8767423 No 0.1233333 0.6212065
1.6907386 0.7944834 No 27 1.217987 0.907981 No 0.155 0.6394893
1.7048417 0.8215752 No 28 1.2341048 0.9389431 No 0.1866667 0.6577721
1.7194155 0.8484168 No 29 1.2507606 0.9696192 No 0.2183333 0.6760548
1.7344555 0.875 No 30 1.2679492 1 No 0.25 0.6943376
1.7499572 0.9013166 No 31 1.2856654 1.0300761 No 0.2816667 0.7126203
1.7659158 0.9273587 No 32 1.3039038 1.0598385 No 0.3133333 0.7309031
1.7823265 0.9531183 No 33 1.3226589 1.0892781 No 0.345 0.7491858
1.7991842 0.9785876 No 34 1.3419249 1.1183858 No 0.3766667 0.7674686
1.8164839 1.0037588 No 35 1.3616959 1.1471529 No 0.4083333 0.7857514
1.8342203 1.0286242 No 36 1.381966 1.1755705 No 0.44 0.8040341
1.8523879 1.0531763 No 37 1.402729 1.20363 No 0.4716667 0.8223169
1.8709812 1.0774076 No 38 1.4239785 1.231323 No 0.5033333 0.8405996
1.8899946 1.1013107 No 39 1.4457081 1.2586408 No 0.535 0.8588824
1.9094222 1.1248783 No 40 1.4679111 1.2855752 No 0.5666667 0.8771652
1.9292582 1.1481033 No 41 1.4905808 1.3121181 No 0.5983333 0.8954479
1.9494966 1.1709786 No 42 1.5137103 1.3382612 No 0.63 0.9137307
1.970131 1.1934971 No 43 1.5372926 1.3639967 No 0.6616667 0.9320134
1.9911553 1.2156521 No 44 1.5613204 1.3893167 No 0.6933333 0.9502962
2.0125631 1.2374369 No 45 1.5857864 1.4142136 No 0.725 0.9685789
2.0343479 1.2588447 No 46 1.6106833 1.4386796 No 0.7566667 0.9868617
2.0565029 1.279869 No 47 1.6360033 1.4627074 No 0.7883333 1.0051445
2.0790214 1.3005034 No 48 1.6617388 1.4862897 No 0.82 1.0234272
2.1018967 1.3207418 No 49 1.6878819 1.5094192 No 0.8516667 1.04171
2.1251217 1.3405778 No 50 1.7144248 1.5320889 No 0.8833333 1.0599927
2.1486893 1.3600054 No 51 1.7413592 1.5542919 No 0.915 1.0782755
2.1725924 1.3790188 No 52 1.768677 1.5760215 Yes 0.9466667 1.0965583
2.1968237 1.3976121 No 53 1.79637 1.597271 Yes 0.9783333 1.114841
2.2213758 1.4157797 No 54 1.8244295 1.618034 Yes 1.01 1.1331238
2.2462412 1.4335161 No 55 1.8528471 1.6383041 Yes 1.0416667 1.1514065
2.2714124 1.4508158 No 56 1.8816142 1.6580751 Yes 1.0733333 1.1696893
2.2968817 1.4676735 No 57 1.9107219 1.6773411 Yes 1.105 1.187972
2.3226413 1.4840842 No 58 1.9401615 1.6960962 Yes 1.1366667 1.2062548
2.3486834 1.5000428 No 59 1.9699239 1.7143346 Yes 1.1683333 1.2245376
2.375 1.5155445 No 60 2 1.7320508 Yes 1.2 1.2428203
2.4015832 1.5305845 No 61 2.0303808 1.7492394 Yes 1.2316667 1.2611031
2.4284248 1.5451583 No 62 2.0610569 1.7658952 Yes 1.2633333 1.2793858
2.4555166 1.5592614 No 63 2.092019 1.782013 Yes 1.295 1.2976686
2.4828505 1.5728896 No 64 2.1232577 1.7975881 Yes 1.3266667 1.3159514
2.510418 1.5860386 No 65 2.1547635 1.8126156 Yes 1.3583333 1.3342341
2.5382109 1.5987046 No 66 2.1865267 1.8270909 Yes 1.39 1.3525169
2.5662205 1.6108835 No 67 2.2185377 1.8410097 Yes 1.4216667 1.3707996
2.5944385 1.6225717 No 68 2.2507868 1.8543677 Yes 1.4533333 1.3890824
2.6228561 1.6337657 No 69 2.2832641 1.8671609 No 1.485 1.4073651
2.6514647 1.6444621 No 70 2.3159597 1.8793852 No 1.5166667 1.4256479
2.6802557 1.6546575 No 71 2.3488637 1.8910372 No 1.5483333 1.4439307
2.7092203 1.6643489 No 72 2.381966 1.902113 No 1.58 1.4622134
2.7383495 1.6735333 No 73 2.4152566 1.9126095 No 1.6116667 1.4804962
2.7676346 1.682208 No 74 2.4487253 1.9225234 No 1.6433333 1.4987789
2.7970667 1.6903702 No 75 2.4823619 1.9318517 No 1.675 1.5170617
2.8266367 1.6980175 No 76 2.5161562 1.9405915 No 1.7066667 1.5353445
2.8563357 1.7051476 No 77 2.5500979 1.9487401 No 1.7383333 1.5536272
2.8861545 1.7117583 No 78 2.5841766 1.9562952 No 1.77 1.57191
2.9160843 1.7178476 No 79 2.618382 1.9632544 No 1.8016667 1.5901927
2.9461157 1.7234136 No 80 2.6527036 1.9696155 No 1.8333333 1.6084755
2.9762397 1.7284546 No 81 2.6871311 1.9753767 No 1.865 1.6267583
3.0064471 1.7329691 No 82 2.7216538 1.9805361 No 1.8966667 1.645041
3.0367286 1.7369558 No 83 2.7562613 1.9850923 No 1.9283333 1.6633238
3.0670752 1.7404133 No 84 2.7909431 1.9890438 No 1.96 1.6816065
3.0974775 1.7433407 No 85 2.8256885 1.9923894 No 1.9916667 1.6998893
3.1279262 1.7457371 No 86 2.8604871 1.9951281 No 2.0233333 1.718172
3.1584121 1.7476017 No 87 2.8953281 1.9972591 No 2.055 1.7364548
3.1889259 1.7489339 No 88 2.930201 1.9987817 No 2.0866667 1.7547376
3.2194583 1.7497335 No 89 2.9650952 1.9996954 No 2.1183333 1.7730203
3.25 1.75 No 90 3 2 No 2.15 1.7913031
3.2805417 1.7497335 No 91 3.0349048 1.9996954 No 2.1816667 1.8095858
3.3110741 1.7489339 No 92 3.069799 1.9987817 No 2.2133333 1.8278686
3.3415879 1.7476017 No 93 3.1046719 1.9972591 No 2.245 1.8461514
3.3720738 1.7457371 No 94 3.1395129 1.9951281 No 2.2766667 1.8644341
3.4025225 1.7433407 No 95 3.1743115 1.9923894 No 2.3083333 1.8827169
3.4329248 1.7404133 No 96 3.2090569 1.9890438 No 2.34 1.9009996
3.4632714 1.7369558 No 97 3.2437387 1.9850923 No 2.3716667 1.9192824
3.4935529 1.7329691 No 98 3.2783462 1.9805361 No 2.4033333 1.9375651
3.5237603 1.7284546 No 99 3.3128689 1.9753767 No 2.435 1.9558479
3.5538843 1.7234136 No 100 3.3472964 1.9696155 No 2.4666667 1.9741307
3.5839157 1.7178476 No 101 3.381618 1.9632544 No 2.4983333 1.9924134
3.6138455 1.7117583 No 102 3.4158234 1.9562952 No 2.53 2.0106962
3.6436643 1.7051476 No 103 3.4499021 1.9487401 No 2.5616667 2.0289789
3.6733633 1.6980175 No 104 3.4838438 1.9405915 No 2.5933333 2.0472617
3.7029333 1.6903702 No 105 3.5176381 1.9318517 No 2.625 2.0655445
3.7323654 1.682208 No 106 3.5512747 1.9225234 No 2.6566667 2.0838272
3.7616505 1.6735333 No 107 3.5847434 1.9126095 No 2.6883333 2.10211
3.7907797 1.6643489 No 108 3.618034 1.902113 No 2.72 2.1203927
3.8197443 1.6546575 No 109 3.6511363 1.8910372 No 2.7516667 2.1386755
3.8485353 1.6444621 No 110 3.6840403 1.8793852 No 2.7833333 2.1569582
3.8771439 1.6337657 No 111 3.7167359 1.8671609 No 2.815 2.175241
3.9055615 1.6225717 No 112 3.7492132 1.8543677 No 2.8466667 2.1935238
3.9337795 1.6108835 No 113 3.7814623 1.8410097 No 2.8783333 2.2118065
3.9617891 1.5987046 No 114 3.8134733 1.8270909 No 2.91 2.2300893
3.989582 1.5860386 No 115 3.8452365 1.8126156 No 2.9416667 2.248372
4.0171495 1.5728896 No 116 3.8767423 1.7975881 No 2.9733333 2.2666548
4.0444834 1.5592614 No 117 3.907981 1.782013 No 3.005 2.2849376
4.0715752 1.5451583 No 118 3.9389431 1.7658952 No 3.0366667 2.3032203
4.0984168 1.5305845 No 119 3.9696192 1.7492394 No 3.0683333 2.3215031
4.125 1.5155445 No 120 4 1.7320508 No 3.1 2.3397858
4.1513166 1.5000428 No 121 4.0300761 1.7143346 No 3.1316667 2.3580686
4.1773587 1.4840842 No 122 4.0598385 1.6960962 No 3.1633333 2.3763514
4.2031183 1.4676735 No 123 4.0892781 1.6773411 No 3.195 2.3946341
4.2285876 1.4508158 No 124 4.1183858 1.6580751 No 3.2266667 2.4129169
4.2537588 1.4335161 No 125 4.1471529 1.6383041 No 3.2583333 2.4311996
4.2786242 1.4157797 No 126 4.1755705 1.618034 No 3.29 2.4494824
4.3031763 1.3976121 No 127 4.20363 1.597271 No 3.3216667 2.4677651
4.3274076 1.3790188 No 128 4.231323 1.5760215 No 3.3533333 2.4860479
4.3513107 1.3600054 No 129 4.2586408 1.5542919 No 3.385 2.5043307
4.3748783 1.3405778 No 130 4.2855752 1.5320889 No 3.4166667 2.5226134
4.3981033 1.3207418 No 131 4.3121181 1.5094192 No 3.4483333 2.5408962
4.4209786 1.3005034 No 132 4.3382612 1.4862897 No 3.48 2.5591789
4.4434971 1.279869 No 133 4.3639967 1.4627074 No 3.5116667 2.5774617
4.4656521 1.2588447 No 134 4.3893167 1.4386796 No 3.5433333 2.5957445
4.4874369 1.2374369 No 135 4.4142136 1.4142136 No 3.575 2.6140272
4.5088447 1.2156521 No 136 4.4386796 1.3893167 No 3.6066667 2.63231
4.529869 1.1934971 No 137 4.4627074 1.3639967 No 3.6383333 2.6505927
4.5505034 1.1709786 No 138 4.4862897 1.3382612 No 3.67 2.6688755
4.5707418 1.1481033 No 139 4.5094192 1.3121181 No 3.7016667 2.6871582
4.5905778 1.1248783 No 140 4.5320889 1.2855752 No 3.7333333 2.705441
4.6100054 1.1013107 No 141 4.5542919 1.2586408 No 3.765 2.7237238
4.6290188 1.0774076 No 142 4.5760215 1.231323 No 3.7966667 2.7420065
4.6476121 1.0531763 No 143 4.597271 1.20363 No 3.8283333 2.7602893
4.6657797 1.0286242 No 144 4.618034 1.1755705 No 3.86 2.778572
4.6835161 1.0037588 No 145 4.6383041 1.1471529 No 3.8916667 2.7968548
4.7008158 0.9785876 No 146 4.6580751 1.1183858 No 3.9233333 2.8151376
4.7176735 0.9531183 No 147 4.6773411 1.0892781 No 3.955 2.8334203
4.7340842 0.9273587 No 148 4.6960962 1.0598385 No 3.9866667 2.8517031
4.7500428 0.9013166 No 149 4.7143346 1.0300761 No 4.0183333 2.8699858
4.7655445 0.875 No 150 4.7320508 1 No 4.05 2.8882686
4.7805845 0.8484168 No 151 4.7492394 0.9696192 No 4.0816667 2.9065513
4.7951583 0.8215752 No 152 4.7658952 0.9389431 No 4.1133333 2.9248341
4.8092614 0.7944834 No 153 4.782013 0.907981 No 4.145 2.9431169
4.8228896 0.7671495 No 154 4.7975881 0.8767423 No 4.1766667 2.9613996
4.8360386 0.739582 No 155 4.8126156 0.8452365 No 4.2083333 2.9796824
4.8487046 0.7117891 No 156 4.8270909 0.8134733 No 4.24 2.9979651
4.8608835 0.6837795 No 157 4.8410097 0.7814623 No 4.2716667 3.0162479
4.8725717 0.6555615 No 158 4.8543677 0.7492132 No 4.3033333 3.0345307
4.8837657 0.6271439 No 159 4.8671609 0.7167359 No 4.335 3.0528134
4.8944621 0.5985353 No 160 4.8793852 0.6840403 No 4.3666667 3.0710962
4.9046575 0.5697443 No 161 4.8910372 0.6511363 No 4.3983333 3.0893789
4.9143489 0.5407797 No 162 4.902113 0.618034 No 4.43 3.1076617
4.9235333 0.5116505 No 163 4.9126095 0.5847434 No 4.4616667 3.1259445
4.932208 0.4823654 No 164 4.9225234 0.5512747 No 4.4933333 3.1442272
4.9403702 0.4529333 No 165 4.9318517 0.5176381 No 4.525 3.16251
4.9480175 0.4233633 No 166 4.9405915 0.4838438 No 4.5566667 3.1807927
4.9551476 0.3936643 No 167 4.9487401 0.4499021 No 4.5883333 3.1990755
4.9617583 0.3638455 No 168 4.9562952 0.4158234 No 4.62 3.2173582
4.9678476 0.3339157 No 169 4.9632544 0.381618 No 4.6516667 3.235641
4.9734136 0.3038843 No 170 4.9696155 0.3472964 No 4.6833333 3.2539238
4.9784546 0.2737603 No 171 4.9753767 0.3128689 No 4.715 3.2722065
4.9829691 0.2435529 No 172 4.9805361 0.2783462 No 4.7466667 3.2904893
4.9869558 0.2132714 No 173 4.9850923 0.2437387 No 4.7783333 3.308772
4.9904133 0.1829248 No 174 4.9890438 0.2090569 No 4.81 3.3270548
4.9933407 0.1525225 No 175 4.9923894 0.1743115 No 4.8416667 3.3453376
4.9957371 0.1220738 No 176 4.9951281 0.1395129 No 4.8733333 3.3636203
4.9976017 0.0915879 No 177 4.9972591 0.1046719 No 4.905 3.3819031
4.9989339 0.0610741 No 178 4.9987817 0.069799 No 4.9366667 3.4001858
4.9997335 0.0305417 No 179 4.9996954 0.0349048 No 4.9683333 3.4184686
5 2.14E-016 No 180 5 2.45E-016 No 5 3.4367513
nvelopenorma
max Tensile cut of

l
tractio
5
n -0.7
normal shear
traction traction
-0.7 0.0048618
-0.7 0.0097237
circles representing-0.74 stress0.0145855
as case 1 through case
-0.7 4 on the
0.0194473
are also plotted. Input values
he default values to -0.7
those you 0.0243091
s. Make sure that sigma 1 is 0.029171
-0.7
referring to the two-0.7
principal0.0340328
-0.7 0.0388946
-0.7 0.0437564
e evolution that leads to failure
ircles 'touches' the failure 0.0486183
-0.7
-0.7 sheet
d occur. In this particular 0.0534801
fourth column for each
-0.7 of the for
0.0583419
ently colored block -0.7
of cells).0.0632038
It
ceeds the failure criteria and slip
wise no is returned-0.7
and the0.0680656
slip
move the plot or this-0.7 0.0729274
explanation
-0.7 0.0777892
-0.7 0.0826511
itional cases. Depending on the
-0.7 0.0875129
aled the same and so the circles
n, grab the corner and-0.7resize0.0923747
the
-0.7 0.0972365
-0.7 0.1020984
-0.7 0.1069602
-0.7 0.111822
-0.7 0.1166838
-0.7 0.1215457
-0.7 0.1264075
-0.7 0.1312693
-0.7 0.1361312
-0.7 0.140993
-0.7 0.1458548